At The Waters Edge B&B

N7136 State Hwy 42
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
So sad there aren't more reviews because when I arrived Wednesday evening there were quite a few groups on the deck and at the fire pit. Anyway...this great little, cozy, comfortable B &B is a shining star in the lovely historic town of Algoma, WI. Themed rooms...I stayed in the music suite...are spacious, clean, feel like home and did I already say comfortable? Loved my bed almost as much as my own! Having coffee with Kari (the owner) and her critter friends while listening to the waves crashing makes for a great start to the day!
We stayed in the Northwoods Suite and it was so comfy and cute! We arrived really late (but had let them know) so when we got there, there was a note with our key & directions on how to get to our room (as well as time for breakfast in the morning). There was a private outdoor stairway to our cozy room, so we didn't feel like we were disturbing anyone with our late night arrival. We settled in, took showers, and fell asleep to the waves crashing on the shore right outside of our room. Woke up in the morning in time for the delicious breakfast that Kari had made. My partner and I knew that we'd enjoy this place when she walked out in a KISS shirt and worn jeans. :-) She served delicious Mexican Egg Casserole (the gentleman next to me had 2 full servings!) with sides of fresh blueberries (soooo good), sausage links, cantaloupe, and strawberries. Everything was so good and the Coffee was nice & black! I would have eaten more, but my stomach was already expanded as much as it would allow. Delightful conversation with Kari, as well as with the other guests (return visitors). And outside, along the shoreline - HAMMOCKS! And fire pits. :) This would be a great 4th of July destination or even just a long weekend. We really enjoyed ourselves and the hospitality was so wonderful. Next time we come this direction, We'll definitely stay here for longer than 1 night.

(920) 203-9584

Bed & Breakfast

Store is open now

Skaliwags

312 Clark St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
Good food but not over the top! I had the duck rolls for an appetizer, they were good, and vegetable ravioli, the cream sauce was a little heavy , along with two beers and the total was 40.40! Little steep for bar food and not a pretty place to eat in !
This place rocks! Chef Chris and his staff are extremely accommodating even on the busiest of nights. I am excited to go there on any occasion and have never had a bad meal!!! Definitely worth the trip to this dive bar/restaurant
Combines almost everything a person could love: amazing seafood, dive bar atmosphere, perfect old fashions, bad art and great service. Love this place

(920) 487-8092

American (New), Seafood, Cajun/Creole

Store is open now

Red’s Pub & Grill

N6318 State Hwy 42
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
LOVE the 2 for 1 sandwiches on Tuesdays. You have to try the deep fried white cheese curds. Good food, good atmosphere. Great views of Lake Michigan.
Great local spot great steak & steak sandwiches. Price reasonable and atmosphere awesome.
Great Food! Checken Sandwiches are delicious and 2-for-1 on Tuesdays.

(920) 487-5431

Pubs, American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Caffe Tlazo

607 4th St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
I really enjoyed my lunch here. The coffee was amazingly good! I had the Mediterranean wrap with chicken, apples, spinach, and raspberry vinaigrette. It was so good! There was a lot of room for seating. Even though they were very busy the service was very fast. I will definitely come back.
I love this coffee shop! I've been here many times with my coffee girl group. I usually get the Turtle frappe - it's divine. However, they have a new fall drink menu so I thought I'd try something new. I'm now addicted to the chunky chipmunk chai drink. It is unbelievably good.. and I don't usually care for chai. Now I'm obsessed. I've had breakfast and lunch here too. Their food is so yummy. For breakfast I had the chocolate filled crepes. The plate comes with scrambled eggs and a seasonal fruit bowl with some amazing kind of cinnamon cream on top. Delish. For lunch I usually get the California wrap - but I ask for it on gluten free bread. The bread is so amazing - I couldn't believe it was gluten free! It's even better when they do the panini press thing to it. Yum. You should go here. It's good for coffee, breakfast, lunch.. dinner too probably. Oh! They also have a case filled with desserts that look fantastic. I haven't tried any thus far. I did get a little cup of their hazelnut gelato once.. it tasted like Ferrero Rocher®. The owner is also really friendly!
Cute, clean and coffee was great! Breakfast was reasonably priced and was great. If yoy are in town, you need to stop by! Two thumbs up from Illinois!

(920) 487-7240

Sandwiches, Coffee & Tea

Store is open now

Koenig’s Bar

N9302 Elder Dr
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
We had our department Christmas party here. This place is known for their pizza. So I ordered the Koenig's special. A thin crust pizza with sausage made specially for Koenig's by a local meat market. It was also topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and loads of cheese. They can only bake a couple of pizzas at a time. There were several orders for pizza so I waited a quite a while for mine. It was worth the wait. It was a very good pizza. I think it could have used a little more seasoning, but that's my taste. I would order this pizza again.

(920) 487-2486

Bars

Store is open now

Algoma Pizza Bowl

401 2nd St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
I often wonder if the residents of Algoma realize what a gem of a place they have in the Algoma Pizza Bowl. The pizza is outstanding, superior to any that I've had in the Midwest outside of Chicago, and as good as many Chicago establishments. I can't emphasize enough how genuine of a compliment that is. When I take people here for the first time they are consistently blown away by the quality of these pies. Then there is the bar portion of Pizza Bowl, which by itself is a good place to tie one on. They don't have an extraordinary amount of beers, but they always have some good ones on tap, like a New Glarus brew or something similar. People play familiar stuff on the jukebox, and it's fun to order pitchers and sing along to some AC/DC. Then there is the bowling: Six lanes, manual scoring, smoking everywhere, pink and yellow neon shoes; it's the jam (to quote my friend Spencer H.). So there's your night all laid out for you. But whoa! you might say. CJ, seriously. Pizza, bowling, and beer all in one night may be undoubtedly fun, but must cost a fortune. Nope. Not here. I was just at APB with eight people, we ate, drank, and bowled, all for a grand total of $107! (107/8 = 13.375 *.20= 2.675. 13.375+2.675 = $16.42 per person) Ok, you say, fine. So you ate a modest amount of food, each had two beers, and bowled one game, whoop -fucking-eee. Wrong again, friend. That price included two pizzas (one large, one medium), two games of bowling, and five pitchers of beer. Also we weren't just drinking Miller Lite, these were pitchers of Blue Moon for $7 each. One more thing. Make sure you order Sauerkraut on your pizza. It sounds repulsive but it loses much of it's pungency while baking, and ends up being surprisingly delicious. Love you Pizza Bowl. Love you hard. Hopefully everyone in Algoma treats you with the reverence and respect you deserve.
I brought my wife here on a Wednesday evening for a snack. The place was virtually empty. One other person at the bar and a couple others who were just talking with the bartender. We ordered the Nachos Grande to share. We received our order in a reasonable amount of time. The cook brought them out to us. The nachos were served on a dinner platter. They were the red, white, and blue colored chips. The Nachos Grande was made with seasoned ground beef, fresh chopped onions, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes. It was topped with nacho cheese, sour cream, and shredded cheddar cheese. The jalapeños were served on the side as we requested. There was plenty for 2 people to share as a snack or appetizer. They were good, but a little salsa would have been nice. The price was decent at about $8.00. This is not a bad place to com for an evening snack.
When in town i go here...like almost live in here. I would have to say the pizza is the real deal. This is the kind of dump I grew up in. It's perfect just a dream. I mean you could really do worse. Algoma in general is a lil slice of heaven. The town's dead so maybe that description is truer than i meant. Back to the bowl, go here and have fun and listen to the guys talk about other guys in town.

(920) 487-2721

Pizza, Bowling

Store is open now

Southern Comfort Restaurant

70 Church St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
My group ate here on a Sat night which is mexi-fiesta night. The food is very simple and basic, seemed to be directly out of a can, however, i was perfectly happy with what i was served. Server was not highly experienced but very courteous and very prompt. The staff didn't miss a thong and ended up being very efficient. The dining room is a very simple country decor. Parking is abundant, prices are reasonable.
Drove up from Appleton to visit friends and had lunch here...the brisket. OMG. The brisket. So stinkin good. I had it with fries instead of the potato salad it usually comes with, and the fries were crispy and good, not greasy. The BBQ sauce is nice and sweet without being overpowering. Also...prices are reasonable! The two of us had a delicious lunch for less than $20.
We had breakfast there and it very good, the wait was not long at all and the waitstaff and owner are nice, would recommend this place to anyone. I wish they'd have more of a variety but it's a very very good place to eat

(920) 487-8145

American (Traditional), Southern

Store is open now

Steelhead Saloon

530 4th St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
Great little place in Algoma! Actually has seating for quite a few ! 4 of us had drinks, 2 appetizers and 4 lunches for under $75!!! They were slightly understaffed in the kitchen so it took as while to get our lunch but it was well worth the wait. Try their wings and their cheese curds! You won't be sorry you picked this place-- whether it's for a drink or 2 or lunch or both, you found a great place to support!! Don't understand why yelp reviews aren't better!!?
This place sucks! I have give it multiple attempts and the service is always terrible! Everyone working here hates there life and it's apparent! Food is very mediocre!
Decent bar. Neat layout, game room, overall appearance. DO NOT EAT HERE! Service is outrageous, slow is an understatement, food is mediocre at best. Walked in at 645 and sat quickly (of course it's empty), took 5 min to get menu, 5 more to order drinks, 15 min drinks to show up(not all drinks either), we ordered when final drinks arrived. The food took 40 minutes(wings, burger, chicken wrap an nachos) 1 hr and 20 min to get typical bar food(in a nearly empty seating section). Ordered 2nd round of drinks before the food arrived and was completely forgotten (as in they never arrived? ). Whoever owns or manages this place has a great bar but is missing out in a big way. I will never go back.

(920) 487-3899

Bars, Burgers, American (New)

Store is open now

Stadium Diner

205 Navarino St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
We tried it when it first opened. Wasn't very good but thought we would try again. More choices and seemed better than last time. They said they had a "lunch rush" and they were busy. Maybe busy for them but it wasn't busy to me, and I've been a waitress before. Anyway, one of the people we were with was in a rush and had to go. This isn't the place to go, they said it was going to take 20 minutes. Good thing she got hers to go, she had to leave and we didn't get our 2 sandwiches until 25 minutes later. Ridiculous. The service is terrible too. Might come here again if I get desperate. Not impressed overall though. Waitress never asked us how our meal was or came to check on us again. Not knowledgeable either, I asked about the "drink of the day" and nobody even knew what it was! So overall, mediocre food, terrible service and nothing special. We were there over an hour and we still never had anyone check on us or give us our bill. Rude.
Poor service and food was only "eh". After, I was talking with friends and they have had similar experiences here. There was live music which is attractive at a restaurant. The music was good but didn't make up for the other large downfalls. Waited a somewhat long time to get the food. It wasn't super long but longer than what I expect for how busy they were- or weren't. Waitress never checked back after getting our food and we were done eating for 20 minutes before we got our bill. This is my second time having the same experience so I won't be back.
Went there on a Sunday morning with my parents. I ordered the Denver omelet, dad ordered the breakfast quesadilla. Could not make half the items on the menu because they were out of cheese! IN WISCONSIN! I could maybe even see if they were crowded, but it was just us and one other table in there. On top of that, the waitress didn't seem to have a clue about the menu. Will not be back.

(920) 487-9788

American (Traditional), Comfort Food

Store is open now

Farm Market Kitchen

520 Parkway St
Algoma, 54201
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 487-9750

Store is open now