Get local results
Your Current location:
Enter your location to see results near to you.
Location you enter does not found in our records.
About Made In New York Pizza
Made In New York Pizza on Amsterdam Avenue brings classic New York-style pizza to Manhattan’s Upper West Side. Located at 421 Amsterdam Avenue, this neighborhood pizzeria serves traditional thin-crust slices, specialty square pizzas, and whole pies. Popular menu options include Spicy Pepperoni Square, Grandma Pizza, Margherita, and Sicilian-style pizza, along with garlic knots and other casual favorites.
Conveniently situated near West 80th Street, Central Park, and Riverside Park, Made In New York Pizza is a popular option for a quick slice, casual lunch, or dinner in the Upper West Side neighborhood. Whether you're looking for pizza by the slice, a whole pie to share, or convenient takeout and delivery, this Amsterdam Avenue pizza shop offers a classic NYC pizzeria experience.
Made In New York Pizza Menu
Explore dishes available on the restaurant's menu. Items may vary by location.
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
Tomato sauce, whole-milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
Cheese pizza topped with pepperoni.
Sausage Pie
Cheese pizza with sliced sweet Italian sausage.
Black Olive Pie
Cheese pizza topped with black olives.
Mushroom Pie
Cheese pizza with fresh mushrooms.
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
Tomato-and-cheese pizza with sausage and pepperoni.
Yo Paulie Pie
Pepperoni, hot cherry peppers and a drizzle of honey over classic cheese pizza.
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Mozzarella, Buffalo-style chicken and ranch drizzle.
BBQ Chicken Pie
Mozzarella and chicken with barbecue sauce.
White Pie
Four-cheese pizza finished with basil and extra-virgin olive oil.
Slices
Cheese Slice
Classic cheese pizza sold by the slice.
Pepperoni Slice
Cheese pizza slice topped with pepperoni.
Sausage Slice
Pizza slice topped with sausage.
Mushroom Slice
Mozzarella, tomatoes, pecorino, oregano and mushrooms.
Vodka Slice
Pizza slice with creamy tomato-vodka sauce and cheese.
Yo Paulie Slice
Signature Yo Paulie pizza sold by the slice; confirm toppings with the restaurant.
Street Fair Slice
Street Fair pizza sold by the slice; confirm toppings with the restaurant.
New Margherita Slice
Margherita-style pizza served by the slice.
Classic Margarita Slice
Classic Margherita-style pizza sold by the slice.
BBQ Chicken Slice
Chicken, red onions and barbecue sauce on a pizza slice.
Square Pies
Original Grandma Sqaure
Grandma-style square pizza with mozzarella, pecorino, tomatoes, garlic, basil and olive oil.
Pepperoni Grandma Sqaure
Grandma-style square pizza with pepperoni, mozzarella, tomatoes, garlic and basil.
Drunken Grandma Sqaure
Grandma-style square pizza with vodka sauce, mozzarella, pecorino and basil.
Vodka Roni Grandma Sqaure
Square grandma-style pizza with vodka sauce and pepperoni.
Spicy Pepperoni Sicilian Sqaure
Sicilian-style square pizza with spicy cupping pepperoni, mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Eggplant Sicilian Sqaure
Square pizza topped with eggplant, tomato sauce, mozzarella and basil.
White Sicilian Sqaure
Sicilian-style square pizza with a four-cheese blend, basil and olive oil.
Veggie Sicilian Sqaure
Square pizza with mozzarella, peppers, mushrooms, onions and tomato sauce.
Classic Sicilian Sqaure
Sicilian-style square pizza with marinara sauce, mozzarella, pecorino and oregano.
Upside Down Sicilian Sqaure
Square pizza layered with mozzarella, slow-cooked tomato sauce and pecorino.
Sides
Garlic Knots
Baked knots of pizza dough with garlic seasoning.
Pinwheel
Tortilla roll with jalapeño cream cheese, salsa, ham, pepperoni and olives.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce with croutons and Parmesan.
Cheese Calzone
Folded dough stuffed with cheese.
Water
Bottled Water
Bottled spring water.
smartwater
Bottled purified water.
vitaminwater
Flavored water beverage with added vitamins and electrolytes.
Other
Bee Dolce Honey
Honey offered as an add-on.
Parmigiana Cheese
Grated hard Italian cheese for seasoning.
Garlic Powder
Garlic seasoning add-on.
Oregano
Dried oregano seasoning.
Crushed Red Pepper
Crushed red pepper seasoning.
Ranch Dressing
Creamy ranch-style dipping sauce.
Marinara
Tomato-based dipping sauce.
Franks Red Hot Sauce
Hot sauce made with cayenne peppers.
BBQ Sauce
Sweet and tangy barbecue dipping sauce.
Hot Cherry Peppers
Spicy cherry peppers offered as an add-on.
Personal Pies
Vegan Mini Pie (Sauce + Basil)
Personal-size pizza with tomato sauce and basil, without cheese.
Cheese Mini Pie
Personal-size cheese pizza.
Pepperoni Mini Pie
Personal-size pepperoni pizza.
Mushroom Mini Pie
Personal-size mushroom pizza.
Sausage Mini Pie
Personal-size sausage pizza.
White Mini Pie
Personal-size white pizza.
Vodka Mini Pie
Personal-size pizza with vodka sauce.
Classic Margherita Mini Pie
Personal-size Margherita pizza.
White Spinach Mini Pie
Personal-size white pizza with spinach.
Yo Paulie Mini Pie
Personal-size version of the Yo Paulie specialty pizza.
Soda
Coca-Cola, Bottle
Bottled Coca-Cola soft drink.
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, Bottle
Bottled zero-sugar Coca-Cola.
Diet Coke, Bottle
Bottled Diet Coke.
Sprite, Bottle
Bottled lemon-lime soda.
Sprite Tropical
Tropical-flavored lemon-lime soda.
Fanta Orange, Bottle
Bottled orange soda.
Dr. Pepper Bottle
Bottled Dr Pepper soda.
Fanta Pineapple
Pineapple-flavored soda.
Ginger Ale Bottle
Bottled ginger ale.
Root Beer Bottle
Bottled root beer.
Glass
Mexican Coke, Glass
Coca-Cola in a glass bottle, made with cane sugar.
Mexican Sprite, Glass
Lemon-lime soda in a glass bottle.
Mexican Fanta Orange, Glass
Orange soda in a glass bottle.
Topo Chico Mineral Water
Sparkling mineral water.
Monster
Monster
Monster energy drink.
Monster Zero
Sugar-free Monster energy drink.
Menu items and availability may change. Contact the restaurant to confirm current offerings.
Made In New York Pizza Hours
Saturday
11:00 am - 1:00 am
Sunday
11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Monday
11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Tuesday
11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Wednesday
11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Thursday
11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Friday
11:00 am - 1:00 am
Made In New York Pizza Details
Phone number
Price
$10–$20
Cuisines
Pizza, Italian, American
Dining style
Casual Dining
Parking details
parking available
Payment options
Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Credit cards
Dress code
Smart Casual
Made In New York Pizza Facilities & Services
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Restroom
Explore Made In New York Pizza's Food & Drinks photos.
Made In New York Pizza location Details and Hours
Find Made In New York Pizza on the map
Last reviewed: October 2026
342 Votes
Obvio
- 3 E 28th St, New York, New York, 10016
- Thursday 5:00 pm - 2:00 am
- $10–$20
- Contemporary American, South American, Tapas / Small Plates
296 Votes
Brooklyn Dumpling Shop
- 453 E 78th St, New York, New York, 10075
- Thursday 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
- $10–$20
- Asian Fusion, Dim Sum
322 Votes
Brooklyn Dumpling Shop
- 245 W 46th Street, New York, New York, 10036
- Thursday 10:00 am - 9:00 pm
- $10–$20
- Asian Fusion, Dim Sum
791 Votes
Diner 24 NYC
- 283 3rd Ave, New York, New York, 10010
- Thursday 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
- $10–$20
- Burgers, Cocktail Bars, Breakfast & Brunch
346 Votes
Strip House Speakeasy
- 11 E 12th St, New York, New York, 10003
- $10–$20
- Steakhouse, Cocktail Bar, American
386 Votes
Shun Lee West
- 43 West 65th Street, New York, New York, 10023
- $10–$20
- Chinese, Asian
366 Votes
Laliko
- 80 Carmine St, New York, New York, 10014-4308
- Thursday 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- $10–$20
- Georgian
357 Votes
Daddies
- 450 Hudson St, New York, New York, 10014-3781
- $10–$20
- Pizzeria, Italian, Contemporary Italian