Sartori Food Corporation

404 Schwartz St
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
Trust me - Sartori's Bella Vitano has no rival so everyone should demand that their grocer offer Sartori cheeses.

(920) 892-6903

Store is open now

Wierl Wind

W8902 State Road 67
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
Haha I can't help but laugh when I think of this place. Some friends and I were camping at Kettle Moraine in nearby Campbellsport. We drove to another campsite to shower (you read that right), and drove passed the Wierl Wind. We thought it was a little store, so we stopped in to buy some beer. We walk in - not a store, it's a bar. Mind you, it's about 10am on a Saturday. After realizing it was a bar, we said hell with it, we can't be rude and walk out, so we sat at the bar and had a few. There were dice on the bar, and the bartender said they have a little "game" - I forget all of the combinations, but if you got 3, 4 or 5 of a kind, you won a certain "prize". One of us won a free sixpack - to drink there or TO GO! Conveniently, there were six of us, so we got another round free. Behind the bar, I saw a weird looking jar of...stuff. I asked what it was, and the bartender grabbed the jar and put it in front of me: PORK HOCKS. Being a suburban boy all my life, I had no idea what it was. My friends dared me to eat one. The bartender got some laughs out of us. I ate it, certainly wasn't delicious, but worth the $5 from my buddy! If you're in the area (read: middle of frickin' nowhere), stop in. They're good people.

(920) 526-3574

Store is open now

Nap’s Place

N7105 County Road C and J
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
5 stars for doing awesome at what it is. Local dive bar with great fried bar food. I walked in as a FIB at midnight last week and had an awesome time. Went with a bunch of hungry friends a couple years back and had a nice cheep dinner with cheep beers. Nothing fancy, but awesome in its own way.

(920) 892-6710

Dive Bars

Store is open now

Pizza Hut

1505 Eastern Ave,Pizza Hut #461
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
Our kids love Pizza Hut. We are visiting Elkhart lake for the week and they asked to get it. The quality of the pizza is great. Much better then the Pizza Hut close to our house in Chicago. Travis sent the kids animal crackers which made them so excited! The delivery was quick! Thank you.

(920) 893-8414

Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings

Store is open now

De O’malley’s Pizza Pub

417 E Mill St
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
This is my favorite place to get some pizza! This place gives great food. Fantastic pizza and great service! The waiters and waitresses are nice and always checking on you! We always come here and every time it has fantastic service! All the food is great, every one is so nice and loves customers. The price is worth the food! You need to check this place out!
Hey very unique restaurant full of very unique pizzas. There chip battered chicken strips are a great choice.
We found De O'malley's while visiting the Osthoff Hotel. We had the pizza which was great! Atmosphere is cozy and waitress friendly. The pizza crust was done perfectly. Good value for your money.

(920) 892-8485

Pizza

Store is open now

El Sombrero

1414 Eastern Ave
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
We love eating at El Sombrero! This restaurant had a slow start, but has improved to be one of our favorites. The avocado tostada is excellent.
Probably the worst Mexican food I've ever had. Enchiladas were sad... two tiny tortillas wrapped around dry, flavorless ground beef. The sauce was almost like ketchup and the tiny bits of cheese on top was disappointing. Will not be returning. Conjitos in Milwaukee is 10x better and 1/2 the price.
Delicious food, excellent prices and very nice staff. Yummy wine margaritas and beer available too. I work the front desk at the hotel less than a block away from El Sombrero and I usually recommend this restaurant to our guests first and they always come back to the hotel very happy. :)

(920) 893-0001

Mexican

Store is open now

Cozy Tavern

116 E Mill St
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
What's a great way to spend a 'let's venture out on an adventure' Saturday morning? A stop for Bloody Mary's at Cozy Tavern! Just happened to wander into the cute little town of Plymouth, WI this past Saturday and saw people wandering into the local tavern at 10 am. 10 am? Sure, why not, and are we ever glad we did! Amazing bloody Mary's, served with a snit (only $3.50!!!), and the nicest bartender I've experienced in a long time (Dawn was her name, I think). Reason why I love Wisconsin #423: Cozy Bar.

(920) 893-8966

Bars

Store is open now

Chester’s Drive-In

1504 Eastern Ave
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
Authentic drive in food. I like the teen burger, which is loaded with everything including bacon. I just love it because it's flavorful and fresh. My husband doesn't like it so much because they serve the hamburgers on chewy kaiser rolls, not in the usual soft hamburger rolls like at fast food restaurants. The onion rings are great and so are the fries. If you like root beer, theirs is made at the restaurant. They serve their root beer float comes in a frosty mug. This place is busy, busy, busy in the summer. CASH ONLY! Also, you should tip your car hop. :-)
Maybe it's a nostalgia thing, maybe it's a small town thing......maybe it's just because there are not a lot of options in Plymouth, but Chester's just wasn't good. It might be good for desserts or root beer floats, but there has to be dozens of better food options in Plymouth. Greasy, small burger patties, cold fries, and too many toppings made this a disastrous choice for dinner. If there isn't a better option in Plymouth, I'll have to make the journey into the big city of Sheboygan for my next meal up there.
Had a deluxe burger which was over loaded with toppings that the very thin burger taste was unrecognizable. The cheese curds were offensive to an self respecting wisconsinite, didn't finish half. Order a steak and cheese was good, excellent rolls. Strawberry and banana shake was good. Novelty of drive in their strongest sell point. Won't be a regular that is surely the truth

(920) 892-7722

Burgers

Store is open now

Wilderness Roadside Inn

N5575 State Rd 57
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
We stopped here for dinner this past weekend while camping at Road America and arrived a bit late. We showed up at 8:20 not knowing they closed at 9. Our host let us know we might not be able to order everything on the menu due to the time at night it was. Fortunately, we already knew what we were going to order, so she asked the kitchen if it was still possible to make the food we wanted, and they were able to! So we sat down, we got our drinks and soups very quickly.The chicken dumpling soup was very good (and hot). Shortly after our food came out. We both got the Roast turkey with mashed potatoes. It was a very generous portion of both, which neither of us could finish. Unfortunately, we had lots of leftovers and only a cooler to store it in. Our waitress was kind enough to saran wrap our leftover container so we could put it in our cooler without the food getting soaked! We finished eating and left right at 9. We were very pleased with the level of service we had, and the accommodating they did to take care of us shortly before they closed. We will be back again!
Great variety, delicious and very reasonable prices. I send many guests to The Roadside that stay at the hotel I work at and they always come back to the hotel with rave reviews! My personal favorite are the Gyros, yum yum yum!
I've been to the Roadside restaurant about 10 or 12 times. I have to say that for the most part this restaurant is pretty consistent with its service and quality of food. I wouldn't say that the food that I have had is exceptionally good or out of this world, but it's a decent meal and priced nicely.

(920) 892-4544

American (New)

Store is open now

PJ Campbells at The Depot

114 Depot Rd
Plymouth, 53073
Reviews:
Great food. I had a combo plate and my husband had the weiner scnitzel. It was so good. I never before had such tender meat. It was all served on glass plates with glass glasses. The waiter was very prompt and personable. We enjoyed having him as our waiter. We also got a complimentary desert for our 43rd anniversary that was to die for. Prices are high. Someplace you go for a special occasion.
Very good service. Great food. I would probably go there just for the soft pretzel and the apple dessert. Nice and casual relaxing atmosphere. I recommend it to anyone looking for a nice kid friendly place to eat with decent prices.
The food was very good. The service was pretty slow and my waitress wasn't very helpful. Had to go to the bar to request my bill since I was waiting so long. I would give it another chance because I was very satisfied with my meal, and hope I get better service.

(920) 893-8600

American (Traditional)

Store is open now