Nite Cap Inn

227 S 3rd St
Palmyra, 53156
Reviews:
My favorite fish fry joint. Nite Cap's potato pancakes are the yardstick by which all other potato pancakes are measured. I love the fish, and I'm always pleased with their tartar sauce. Standard bread and cole slaw come with meal, all you can eat for $10.75. It does seem the crowds are not quite as big as in the past, perhaps due to the economy. I also happen to know the owner is trying to sell. I hope the new owners, if there are any, know a good thing when they see it, and leave the fish fry as it is. Sometime I'll have to go on a different night. I see during the month of October, they will feature several German dishes on Saturday.
Bring on the potato pancakes!
A GEM. If you have gotten this far on Yelp, quit analyzing. Just GO. Ignore the few VERY old bad reviews. In summary: this unknowingly retro cool place is and has been in the family forever and produces DELICIOUS home cooked food. BELIEVE THE GOOD REVIEWS OF FRIDAY FISH FRY! And if you are really lucky on Thursday or Saturday, the German food is worth it! It might take awhile because Mom (I think her name is Susie) will cook to order. That might give you time to enjoy a drink at the fantastic Formica bar - a serious nod to design of the era. REALLY.

(262) 495-2659

American (Traditional), German

Store is open now

Kettle Hill Grill

109 W Main St
Palmyra, 53156
Reviews:
Great custard and delicious food!! If you have a flavor request, ask a few days ahead and the owner might make it! My personal favorite is the Coffee Heath Crunch! Definitely worth the stop just for the custard alone, but if you're looking for lunch or dinner they've got something for everyone!
The foods not the best its okay. I would rather go to the main street restaurant or subway or any other restaurants
Food is amazing! Frozen custard is great! The owners an staff are friendly and nice. I love the decorations of the Kettle Moraine woods/ up north feel. There isn't anything on the menu that isn't delicious. Large portions, lots of options for every eater in the family. Cozy and quaint, and you can eat outside on the patio area. I hope this restaurant stays for many more years to come. A much needed one for Palmyra.

(262) 495-4951

American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Subway

162 E Main St
Palmyra, 53156
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(262) 495-4311

Fast Food, Sandwiches

Store is open now

Hot Rod Bar -N- Grill

200 W Main St
Palmyra, 53156
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(262) 495-2000

Sports Bars, American (Traditional)

Store is open now