Nice little quick sandwich shop and certainly better than competitor 'fast-food' sandwich joints such as Subway. It's nice you fill out your own order, so there isn't much room for error, and there are a good number of toppings to choose from.
(5)
Samantha S.
Recluses, the timid, those studying to be a mime should rejoice! Cause you don't actually have to verbally say anything to place an order here. Your first time here may feel slightly overwhelming. I looked so lost by the sea of brown paper bags to pick from that someone actually came over to help me. But what you do is grab a bag, fill in the bubbles of what you what on your sandwich. Hand it to the cashier and voila a sandwich is in the bag a minute later. For the most part the additions that you can get to your sandwich are free. So you could potentially end up with a massive sandwich. Things like double cheese and avocado were extra. I would say it is a decent sandwich that they make here. Nothing that I would seek out but not a shop I wouldn't stop by again if I was hungry and craving a which.
(3)
Bridget S.
Best sandwich in Madison! The selection of sandwiches and toppings is pretty much endless here, and they always make your sandwich to-order, so it can take a while sometimes because it can be a long process just to pick what you want on your sandwich (let alone have them make it fresh!)....but the flavor is absolutely worth it!!! Great quality, fairly priced. Usually I go with medium-sized meals anywhere I eat, but the medium sandwich here is HUGE (hence the $8 price tag that comes along with it)! I usually go with the small unless I'm famished. I haven't had anything here that I didn't like, but if you're having trouble picking something out, the staff here is really helpful! I recommend the Grinder (Italian sub). I load mine up with: Caramelized onions Crispy onion strings Lettuce Tomato Hot pepper mix Olive salad Oregano Garlic Vinegar MmmmmMmMmmmmMmm!!
(5)
Christoph J.
I was really excited to try this place, but am sadly not very happy with my first visit. I saw an advertisement for their Bánh mì sub, and was expecting something pretty simple and delicious. But what they handed over was pretty terrible. The sub was only slightly warm, like they barely ran it through the little heating unit. Cold pulled-pork is never a very pleasant thing to eat. All the other ingredients just kind of fought each other. And the bread wasn't very good either. I didn't expect this to very closely replicate a great (authentic) Bánh mì sandwich, but this was a disaster. I was also frustrated with the price. I wasn't asked what size I wanted and the sandwich rang up at over $8, which is a crazy amount for a medium sub! The staff members working were pretty friendly, but not overly helpful or outgoing. When I said it was my first visit, they should have offered some suggestions maybe? They didn't even try to upsell me anything! I may go back and give them a second chance, but I just threw half of my first sandwich in the trash. Which wich? Not that one. Yuck.
this restaurant is really good. I always choose this over subway. food is really tasty, service is good. And very reasonable price.
(5)
Ally M.
I love sub sandwiches, so I was excited to try Which Wich. I do like that you can order what you want on a piece of paper, but I was a little disappointed for the hype that this place got. The sub was merely okay - nothing too different from the subs I've had before. It wasn't bad by any means, but it is smaller than subs from other places and also more expensive. I went here once and haven't been back since.
(3)
Owen R.
Quick service, quality food. I like the self serve system, clean and fast. Highly recommend.
(4)
Amanda B.
Absolutely love picking what I want on the bag. And sandwiches are delicious!!! And plenty of vegetarian!! will be coming back
(5)
Jim P.
Best sandwich down town hands down, perfectly toasted very consistent, awesome French bread, the variety is infinite. Great work, I am finally proud to eat sandwiches downtown again.
(5)
Allie L.
The sandwich filling options are good, but the bread is dry, crumbly, and tastes mass produced. With options like milio's and Jimmy john's so close by with much better bread, it's hard to justify paying so much for a sandwich here.
(3)
Pauline J.
Which Which is really high quality. They probably make the tastiest subs in town (I haven't had Erbert and Gerberts, so I can't say for certain). They definitely have a far better crab meat sub than Subway. The prices are a little higher than I would pay for the amount you get, like the other reviews say. I don't really get subs often enough to care, but if you frequent sub shops it might be enough to deter you. I would give Which Which a five star, but every time I eat here my stomach gets a litte upset. Every single time. It's really unfortunate, considering how tasty it is. My boyfriend has the same issue and he usually gets the tuna. Neither of us have tried anything other than fish, so maybe it's an issue with that. I wish they would fix whatever the problem is. They're so good I still end up getting a sub every other month or so and dealing with the upset stomach.
(4)
Adam R.
Which Wich is a chain I heard some good things about, so it intrigued me to find out they were opening a downtown Madison location! I went in to grab a quick lunch to go, and before I could even attempt to check in on Yelp (I couldn't either because it didn't have a page yet =/), I was happily greeted by an employee asking if i've ever been to a Which Wich before. I said no, and he gave me an overview of their ordering process. It was thoughtful of them to have an employee just to make sure people knew what they were doing at least during their first week of business! It certainly helped too, because Which Wich does things differently. There, you pick up a bag, and fill in a bunch of bubbles to describe what sub you'd like, including the toppings, sauces, the temperature of the sandwich, and size of sandwich. Then, you just give it to the cashier, and then they charge you. It's different, but I bet this system works better for the employees in the end, so I think it's fine. The sandwiches charge a flat rate for the most part: A small is $5.50, a medium is $8.25 and a large is $11.00 (I think). So, you'll notice that it's a bit pricier than say, Jimmy Johns or Subway up the road, but I think you're getting what you pay for here. I had a medium black bean patty sub with a ton of sauces and random veggies on it, and I can say that: I liked it a fair amount, it was filling, I didn't feel ripped off, and I didn't feel garbage after eating it. Given that I had no idea what I was doing the first time, I certainly could make a better sub the next time I go, without too many unnecessary things. One good thing about Which Wich is that you feel like you have more control over your sandwich than you do at the other sub places. It's easy to make your food vegetarian, vegan, gluten free, healthy, unhealthy (or "Epic", as some people call it), carnivore (They're known for a sub that has 5 different meats and 3 cheeses), etc. etc. Overall, I could see myself frequenting Which Wich on State occasionally. It's much better than any other sub place in the vicinity, and it even can hold a candle to some of State's other good lunch spots.
(4)
Jesse S.
Updating my review for Which Wich. Yes, the prices are too high. Yes, it takes too long to get your sandwich. (This has nothing to do with the staff, by the way. It is entirely due to the slowest toaster oven in the industry). No, this will never be a great sandwich. But the staff here really goes above and beyond what I'd expect from a restaurant at this price point, and I think that deserves an extra star. (Also, their gyro was unexpectedly awesome. Too bad it was only a monthly special.)
(4)
Michelle R.
Nice little quick sandwich shop and certainly better than competitor 'fast-food' sandwich joints such as Subway. It's nice you fill out your own order, so there isn't much room for error, and there are a good number of toppings to choose from.
Which Which is really high quality. They probably make the tastiest subs in town (I haven't had Erbert and Gerberts, so I can't say for certain). They definitely have a far better crab meat sub than Subway. The prices are a little higher than I would pay for the amount you get, like the other reviews say. I don't really get subs often enough to care, but if you frequent sub shops it might be enough to deter you. I would give Which Which a five star, but every time I eat here my stomach gets a litte upset. Every single time. It's really unfortunate, considering how tasty it is. My boyfriend has the same issue and he usually gets the tuna. Neither of us have tried anything other than fish, so maybe it's an issue with that. I wish they would fix whatever the problem is. They're so good I still end up getting a sub every other month or so and dealing with the upset stomach.
(4)
Adam R.
Which Wich is a chain I heard some good things about, so it intrigued me to find out they were opening a downtown Madison location! I went in to grab a quick lunch to go, and before I could even attempt to check in on Yelp (I couldn't either because it didn't have a page yet =/), I was happily greeted by an employee asking if i've ever been to a Which Wich before. I said no, and he gave me an overview of their ordering process. It was thoughtful of them to have an employee just to make sure people knew what they were doing at least during their first week of business! It certainly helped too, because Which Wich does things differently. There, you pick up a bag, and fill in a bunch of bubbles to describe what sub you'd like, including the toppings, sauces, the temperature of the sandwich, and size of sandwich. Then, you just give it to the cashier, and then they charge you. It's different, but I bet this system works better for the employees in the end, so I think it's fine. The sandwiches charge a flat rate for the most part: A small is $5.50, a medium is $8.25 and a large is $11.00 (I think). So, you'll notice that it's a bit pricier than say, Jimmy Johns or Subway up the road, but I think you're getting what you pay for here. I had a medium black bean patty sub with a ton of sauces and random veggies on it, and I can say that: I liked it a fair amount, it was filling, I didn't feel ripped off, and I didn't feel garbage after eating it. Given that I had no idea what I was doing the first time, I certainly could make a better sub the next time I go, without too many unnecessary things. One good thing about Which Wich is that you feel like you have more control over your sandwich than you do at the other sub places. It's easy to make your food vegetarian, vegan, gluten free, healthy, unhealthy (or "Epic", as some people call it), carnivore (They're known for a sub that has 5 different meats and 3 cheeses), etc. etc. Overall, I could see myself frequenting Which Wich on State occasionally. It's much better than any other sub place in the vicinity, and it even can hold a candle to some of State's other good lunch spots.
(4)
Jesse S.
Updating my review for Which Wich. Yes, the prices are too high. Yes, it takes too long to get your sandwich. (This has nothing to do with the staff, by the way. It is entirely due to the slowest toaster oven in the industry). No, this will never be a great sandwich. But the staff here really goes above and beyond what I'd expect from a restaurant at this price point, and I think that deserves an extra star. (Also, their gyro was unexpectedly awesome. Too bad it was only a monthly special.)
(4)
Sagar K.
this restaurant is really good. I always choose this over subway. food is really tasty, service is good. And very reasonable price.
(5)
Ally M.
I love sub sandwiches, so I was excited to try Which Wich. I do like that you can order what you want on a piece of paper, but I was a little disappointed for the hype that this place got. The sub was merely okay - nothing too different from the subs I've had before. It wasn't bad by any means, but it is smaller than subs from other places and also more expensive. I went here once and haven't been back since.
(3)
Owen R.
Quick service, quality food. I like the self serve system, clean and fast. Highly recommend.
(4)
Samantha S.
Recluses, the timid, those studying to be a mime should rejoice! Cause you don't actually have to verbally say anything to place an order here. Your first time here may feel slightly overwhelming. I looked so lost by the sea of brown paper bags to pick from that someone actually came over to help me. But what you do is grab a bag, fill in the bubbles of what you what on your sandwich. Hand it to the cashier and voila a sandwich is in the bag a minute later. For the most part the additions that you can get to your sandwich are free. So you could potentially end up with a massive sandwich. Things like double cheese and avocado were extra. I would say it is a decent sandwich that they make here. Nothing that I would seek out but not a shop I wouldn't stop by again if I was hungry and craving a which.
(3)
Amanda B.
Absolutely love picking what I want on the bag. And sandwiches are delicious!!! And plenty of vegetarian!! will be coming back
(5)
Jim P.
Best sandwich down town hands down, perfectly toasted very consistent, awesome French bread, the variety is infinite. Great work, I am finally proud to eat sandwiches downtown again.
(5)
Allie L.
The sandwich filling options are good, but the bread is dry, crumbly, and tastes mass produced. With options like milio's and Jimmy john's so close by with much better bread, it's hard to justify paying so much for a sandwich here.
(3)
Bridget S.
Best sandwich in Madison! The selection of sandwiches and toppings is pretty much endless here, and they always make your sandwich to-order, so it can take a while sometimes because it can be a long process just to pick what you want on your sandwich (let alone have them make it fresh!)....but the flavor is absolutely worth it!!! Great quality, fairly priced. Usually I go with medium-sized meals anywhere I eat, but the medium sandwich here is HUGE (hence the $8 price tag that comes along with it)! I usually go with the small unless I'm famished. I haven't had anything here that I didn't like, but if you're having trouble picking something out, the staff here is really helpful! I recommend the Grinder (Italian sub). I load mine up with: Caramelized onions Crispy onion strings Lettuce Tomato Hot pepper mix Olive salad Oregano Garlic Vinegar MmmmmMmMmmmmMmm!!
(5)
Christoph J.
I was really excited to try this place, but am sadly not very happy with my first visit. I saw an advertisement for their Bánh mì sub, and was expecting something pretty simple and delicious. But what they handed over was pretty terrible. The sub was only slightly warm, like they barely ran it through the little heating unit. Cold pulled-pork is never a very pleasant thing to eat. All the other ingredients just kind of fought each other. And the bread wasn't very good either. I didn't expect this to very closely replicate a great (authentic) Bánh mì sandwich, but this was a disaster. I was also frustrated with the price. I wasn't asked what size I wanted and the sandwich rang up at over $8, which is a crazy amount for a medium sub! The staff members working were pretty friendly, but not overly helpful or outgoing. When I said it was my first visit, they should have offered some suggestions maybe? They didn't even try to upsell me anything! I may go back and give them a second chance, but I just threw half of my first sandwich in the trash. Which wich? Not that one. Yuck.
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : No Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Bike Parking : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Outdoor Seating : No Has TV : Yes
Michelle R.
Nice little quick sandwich shop and certainly better than competitor 'fast-food' sandwich joints such as Subway. It's nice you fill out your own order, so there isn't much room for error, and there are a good number of toppings to choose from.
(5)Samantha S.
Recluses, the timid, those studying to be a mime should rejoice! Cause you don't actually have to verbally say anything to place an order here. Your first time here may feel slightly overwhelming. I looked so lost by the sea of brown paper bags to pick from that someone actually came over to help me. But what you do is grab a bag, fill in the bubbles of what you what on your sandwich. Hand it to the cashier and voila a sandwich is in the bag a minute later. For the most part the additions that you can get to your sandwich are free. So you could potentially end up with a massive sandwich. Things like double cheese and avocado were extra. I would say it is a decent sandwich that they make here. Nothing that I would seek out but not a shop I wouldn't stop by again if I was hungry and craving a which.
(3)Bridget S.
Best sandwich in Madison! The selection of sandwiches and toppings is pretty much endless here, and they always make your sandwich to-order, so it can take a while sometimes because it can be a long process just to pick what you want on your sandwich (let alone have them make it fresh!)....but the flavor is absolutely worth it!!! Great quality, fairly priced. Usually I go with medium-sized meals anywhere I eat, but the medium sandwich here is HUGE (hence the $8 price tag that comes along with it)! I usually go with the small unless I'm famished. I haven't had anything here that I didn't like, but if you're having trouble picking something out, the staff here is really helpful! I recommend the Grinder (Italian sub). I load mine up with: Caramelized onions Crispy onion strings Lettuce Tomato Hot pepper mix Olive salad Oregano Garlic Vinegar MmmmmMmMmmmmMmm!!
(5)Christoph J.
I was really excited to try this place, but am sadly not very happy with my first visit. I saw an advertisement for their Bánh mì sub, and was expecting something pretty simple and delicious. But what they handed over was pretty terrible. The sub was only slightly warm, like they barely ran it through the little heating unit. Cold pulled-pork is never a very pleasant thing to eat. All the other ingredients just kind of fought each other. And the bread wasn't very good either. I didn't expect this to very closely replicate a great (authentic) Bánh mì sandwich, but this was a disaster. I was also frustrated with the price. I wasn't asked what size I wanted and the sandwich rang up at over $8, which is a crazy amount for a medium sub! The staff members working were pretty friendly, but not overly helpful or outgoing. When I said it was my first visit, they should have offered some suggestions maybe? They didn't even try to upsell me anything! I may go back and give them a second chance, but I just threw half of my first sandwich in the trash. Which wich? Not that one. Yuck.
(2)Bernie C.
First time in a which witch and I was presently surprised! Efficient and interesting set up with reasonable prices. This chain had the banh mi as a special and it was way better than I expected it to be. I usually get mine from legitimate Vietnamese stores and I was expecting this one to be a huge let down, especially since it's a white-ish chain (racist? Maybe? Sorry. Not sure. Maybe if I have to ask it is.) yes the sandwich is a little different than the original and it's missing the pâté, but seriously, a solid variation. Definitely would come again
(4)Sagar K.
this restaurant is really good. I always choose this over subway. food is really tasty, service is good. And very reasonable price.
(5)Ally M.
I love sub sandwiches, so I was excited to try Which Wich. I do like that you can order what you want on a piece of paper, but I was a little disappointed for the hype that this place got. The sub was merely okay - nothing too different from the subs I've had before. It wasn't bad by any means, but it is smaller than subs from other places and also more expensive. I went here once and haven't been back since.
(3)Owen R.
Quick service, quality food. I like the self serve system, clean and fast. Highly recommend.
(4)Amanda B.
Absolutely love picking what I want on the bag. And sandwiches are delicious!!! And plenty of vegetarian!! will be coming back
(5)Jim P.
Best sandwich down town hands down, perfectly toasted very consistent, awesome French bread, the variety is infinite. Great work, I am finally proud to eat sandwiches downtown again.
(5)Allie L.
The sandwich filling options are good, but the bread is dry, crumbly, and tastes mass produced. With options like milio's and Jimmy john's so close by with much better bread, it's hard to justify paying so much for a sandwich here.
(3)Pauline J.
Which Which is really high quality. They probably make the tastiest subs in town (I haven't had Erbert and Gerberts, so I can't say for certain). They definitely have a far better crab meat sub than Subway. The prices are a little higher than I would pay for the amount you get, like the other reviews say. I don't really get subs often enough to care, but if you frequent sub shops it might be enough to deter you. I would give Which Which a five star, but every time I eat here my stomach gets a litte upset. Every single time. It's really unfortunate, considering how tasty it is. My boyfriend has the same issue and he usually gets the tuna. Neither of us have tried anything other than fish, so maybe it's an issue with that. I wish they would fix whatever the problem is. They're so good I still end up getting a sub every other month or so and dealing with the upset stomach.
(4)Adam R.
Which Wich is a chain I heard some good things about, so it intrigued me to find out they were opening a downtown Madison location! I went in to grab a quick lunch to go, and before I could even attempt to check in on Yelp (I couldn't either because it didn't have a page yet =/), I was happily greeted by an employee asking if i've ever been to a Which Wich before. I said no, and he gave me an overview of their ordering process. It was thoughtful of them to have an employee just to make sure people knew what they were doing at least during their first week of business! It certainly helped too, because Which Wich does things differently. There, you pick up a bag, and fill in a bunch of bubbles to describe what sub you'd like, including the toppings, sauces, the temperature of the sandwich, and size of sandwich. Then, you just give it to the cashier, and then they charge you. It's different, but I bet this system works better for the employees in the end, so I think it's fine. The sandwiches charge a flat rate for the most part: A small is $5.50, a medium is $8.25 and a large is $11.00 (I think). So, you'll notice that it's a bit pricier than say, Jimmy Johns or Subway up the road, but I think you're getting what you pay for here. I had a medium black bean patty sub with a ton of sauces and random veggies on it, and I can say that: I liked it a fair amount, it was filling, I didn't feel ripped off, and I didn't feel garbage after eating it. Given that I had no idea what I was doing the first time, I certainly could make a better sub the next time I go, without too many unnecessary things. One good thing about Which Wich is that you feel like you have more control over your sandwich than you do at the other sub places. It's easy to make your food vegetarian, vegan, gluten free, healthy, unhealthy (or "Epic", as some people call it), carnivore (They're known for a sub that has 5 different meats and 3 cheeses), etc. etc. Overall, I could see myself frequenting Which Wich on State occasionally. It's much better than any other sub place in the vicinity, and it even can hold a candle to some of State's other good lunch spots.
(4)Jesse S.
Updating my review for Which Wich. Yes, the prices are too high. Yes, it takes too long to get your sandwich. (This has nothing to do with the staff, by the way. It is entirely due to the slowest toaster oven in the industry). No, this will never be a great sandwich. But the staff here really goes above and beyond what I'd expect from a restaurant at this price point, and I think that deserves an extra star. (Also, their gyro was unexpectedly awesome. Too bad it was only a monthly special.)
(4)Michelle R.
Nice little quick sandwich shop and certainly better than competitor 'fast-food' sandwich joints such as Subway. It's nice you fill out your own order, so there isn't much room for error, and there are a good number of toppings to choose from.
(5)Bernie C.
First time in a which witch and I was presently surprised! Efficient and interesting set up with reasonable prices. This chain had the banh mi as a special and it was way better than I expected it to be. I usually get mine from legitimate Vietnamese stores and I was expecting this one to be a huge let down, especially since it's a white-ish chain (racist? Maybe? Sorry. Not sure. Maybe if I have to ask it is.) yes the sandwich is a little different than the original and it's missing the pâté, but seriously, a solid variation. Definitely would come again
(4)Pauline J.
Which Which is really high quality. They probably make the tastiest subs in town (I haven't had Erbert and Gerberts, so I can't say for certain). They definitely have a far better crab meat sub than Subway. The prices are a little higher than I would pay for the amount you get, like the other reviews say. I don't really get subs often enough to care, but if you frequent sub shops it might be enough to deter you. I would give Which Which a five star, but every time I eat here my stomach gets a litte upset. Every single time. It's really unfortunate, considering how tasty it is. My boyfriend has the same issue and he usually gets the tuna. Neither of us have tried anything other than fish, so maybe it's an issue with that. I wish they would fix whatever the problem is. They're so good I still end up getting a sub every other month or so and dealing with the upset stomach.
(4)Adam R.
Which Wich is a chain I heard some good things about, so it intrigued me to find out they were opening a downtown Madison location! I went in to grab a quick lunch to go, and before I could even attempt to check in on Yelp (I couldn't either because it didn't have a page yet =/), I was happily greeted by an employee asking if i've ever been to a Which Wich before. I said no, and he gave me an overview of their ordering process. It was thoughtful of them to have an employee just to make sure people knew what they were doing at least during their first week of business! It certainly helped too, because Which Wich does things differently. There, you pick up a bag, and fill in a bunch of bubbles to describe what sub you'd like, including the toppings, sauces, the temperature of the sandwich, and size of sandwich. Then, you just give it to the cashier, and then they charge you. It's different, but I bet this system works better for the employees in the end, so I think it's fine. The sandwiches charge a flat rate for the most part: A small is $5.50, a medium is $8.25 and a large is $11.00 (I think). So, you'll notice that it's a bit pricier than say, Jimmy Johns or Subway up the road, but I think you're getting what you pay for here. I had a medium black bean patty sub with a ton of sauces and random veggies on it, and I can say that: I liked it a fair amount, it was filling, I didn't feel ripped off, and I didn't feel garbage after eating it. Given that I had no idea what I was doing the first time, I certainly could make a better sub the next time I go, without too many unnecessary things. One good thing about Which Wich is that you feel like you have more control over your sandwich than you do at the other sub places. It's easy to make your food vegetarian, vegan, gluten free, healthy, unhealthy (or "Epic", as some people call it), carnivore (They're known for a sub that has 5 different meats and 3 cheeses), etc. etc. Overall, I could see myself frequenting Which Wich on State occasionally. It's much better than any other sub place in the vicinity, and it even can hold a candle to some of State's other good lunch spots.
(4)Jesse S.
Updating my review for Which Wich. Yes, the prices are too high. Yes, it takes too long to get your sandwich. (This has nothing to do with the staff, by the way. It is entirely due to the slowest toaster oven in the industry). No, this will never be a great sandwich. But the staff here really goes above and beyond what I'd expect from a restaurant at this price point, and I think that deserves an extra star. (Also, their gyro was unexpectedly awesome. Too bad it was only a monthly special.)
(4)Sagar K.
this restaurant is really good. I always choose this over subway. food is really tasty, service is good. And very reasonable price.
(5)Ally M.
I love sub sandwiches, so I was excited to try Which Wich. I do like that you can order what you want on a piece of paper, but I was a little disappointed for the hype that this place got. The sub was merely okay - nothing too different from the subs I've had before. It wasn't bad by any means, but it is smaller than subs from other places and also more expensive. I went here once and haven't been back since.
(3)Owen R.
Quick service, quality food. I like the self serve system, clean and fast. Highly recommend.
(4)Samantha S.
Recluses, the timid, those studying to be a mime should rejoice! Cause you don't actually have to verbally say anything to place an order here. Your first time here may feel slightly overwhelming. I looked so lost by the sea of brown paper bags to pick from that someone actually came over to help me. But what you do is grab a bag, fill in the bubbles of what you what on your sandwich. Hand it to the cashier and voila a sandwich is in the bag a minute later. For the most part the additions that you can get to your sandwich are free. So you could potentially end up with a massive sandwich. Things like double cheese and avocado were extra. I would say it is a decent sandwich that they make here. Nothing that I would seek out but not a shop I wouldn't stop by again if I was hungry and craving a which.
(3)Amanda B.
Absolutely love picking what I want on the bag. And sandwiches are delicious!!! And plenty of vegetarian!! will be coming back
(5)Jim P.
Best sandwich down town hands down, perfectly toasted very consistent, awesome French bread, the variety is infinite. Great work, I am finally proud to eat sandwiches downtown again.
(5)Allie L.
The sandwich filling options are good, but the bread is dry, crumbly, and tastes mass produced. With options like milio's and Jimmy john's so close by with much better bread, it's hard to justify paying so much for a sandwich here.
(3)Bridget S.
Best sandwich in Madison! The selection of sandwiches and toppings is pretty much endless here, and they always make your sandwich to-order, so it can take a while sometimes because it can be a long process just to pick what you want on your sandwich (let alone have them make it fresh!)....but the flavor is absolutely worth it!!! Great quality, fairly priced. Usually I go with medium-sized meals anywhere I eat, but the medium sandwich here is HUGE (hence the $8 price tag that comes along with it)! I usually go with the small unless I'm famished. I haven't had anything here that I didn't like, but if you're having trouble picking something out, the staff here is really helpful! I recommend the Grinder (Italian sub). I load mine up with: Caramelized onions Crispy onion strings Lettuce Tomato Hot pepper mix Olive salad Oregano Garlic Vinegar MmmmmMmMmmmmMmm!!
(5)Christoph J.
I was really excited to try this place, but am sadly not very happy with my first visit. I saw an advertisement for their Bánh mì sub, and was expecting something pretty simple and delicious. But what they handed over was pretty terrible. The sub was only slightly warm, like they barely ran it through the little heating unit. Cold pulled-pork is never a very pleasant thing to eat. All the other ingredients just kind of fought each other. And the bread wasn't very good either. I didn't expect this to very closely replicate a great (authentic) Bánh mì sandwich, but this was a disaster. I was also frustrated with the price. I wasn't asked what size I wanted and the sandwich rang up at over $8, which is a crazy amount for a medium sub! The staff members working were pretty friendly, but not overly helpful or outgoing. When I said it was my first visit, they should have offered some suggestions maybe? They didn't even try to upsell me anything! I may go back and give them a second chance, but I just threw half of my first sandwich in the trash. Which wich? Not that one. Yuck.
(2)