Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu

  • Menu

Healthy Meal suggestions for Potbelly Sandwich Shop

  • Menu

Visit below restaurant in Madison for healthy meals suggestion.

Visit below restaurant in Madison for healthy meals suggestion.

  • Lauren W.

    Went to Potbelly's looking for something less greasy in the mall. Even though they've plopped themselves in the 'more real restaurant' corner space of the food court, don't be fooled. It's mall food. Their menu layout is confusing and crowded, making it hard to know what I can order let alone their methods. I ordered a 'original' size sandwhich, their regular/medium, roast beef. I wanted the cheese, whatever came on it, and some avacado. The person at the front of the service line asked what we wanted, then immediately got distracted and started talking to another employee. It was loud and continually confusing. He asked if I wanted what came with it and I said yes. Turns out that just landed me paying extra for mushrooms, which make me sick, and greasy bacon. The next person was confused as to what I got, despite only being a foot from the first person. I then realized this was just a more confusing subway and this was the toppings guy. I repeated myself, confused what he wanted till I realized this, then was pretty done. After that we got to a third person where we had to repeat our order another time, find out we were paying extra for every topping, and $20 later (for two sandwiches and two drinks) we left. Frustrating. Never doing that again. As for flavor my roast beef was fatty greasy and pretty gross. The chicken was good. I'm sure someone would like the flavor, everything else was just so infuriating I never want to go back.

    (2)
  • Sherry L.

    As Janet K. mentioned, Potbelly is set at the far end of the West Towne mall at the edge of the food court, making the environment much less rowdy than the main seating area. It's convenient because you can enter from the parking lot or the food court, and with the outer door and the occasional breeze, it doesn't feel quite as claustrophobic. My mom and I both ordered a Skinny Pair, which is a "Skinny" sandwich + side of soup for $6.60 (quite a deal). My combination: a mushroom melt + spicy southwest veggie soup. The sandwich was perfectly toasted with fresh mushrooms - filling, but leaving just enough room for dessert (or a Butter Rum Mocha in my case). Not too much flair. Not too much oomph. The spicy southwest veggie soup reminded me of the corn chowder from the SF Soup Company back at home - creamy and chock-full of corn kernels with just a hint of spicy - so that was a definite plus for me. If you are a fan of super stuffed sandwiches drenched in sauces, this is probably not the sandwich place for you. On the other hand, if you are just looking for a hearty, wholesome meal, give this place a try. All in all, a great place to stop for lunch or a quick dinner. Potbelly me up! :9 PS. I've heard that the Potbelly oatmeal cookies are to-die-for, so I will be back to give them a try!

    (4)
  • Steve L.

    I've only had them deliver sandwiches to us for meetings, so I can't comment on the interior or ambiance of this location. However, if you're an office type that has to provide meals for working sessions over lunch, give Potbelly a try. Why? Their online ordering system is superb. It's absolutely intuitive, fast, and accurate. I've never had a single issue with their system. What's that? You say that "Joe from Accounting" is a picky eater? No problemo, my friend - Potbelly's system will not fail you. You select the base sandwich, and then customize it to your heart's content. It's foolproof. And they'll even write Joe's name on his specific sandwich, so there's no confusion. And perhaps the best part is the highly precise delivery time window - Potbelly has never once been late (or too early) with an order. If I select the "11:45am - 12:00pm" window, I'd bet my paycheck they'll be there at around 11:50am. Without fail. Oh, and the drivers are super friendly and helpful as well. I'm a fan of their farmhouse salad (no bacon, no cheese, add extra chicken), although the chicken is a bit "meh" at times. When I'm feeling indulgent (which is often, these days), you cannot go wrong with one of the hot sandwiches. The "wreck" is legendary. Have a larger group to feed? Get a party pack. It's painless, and it'll be devoured, guaranteed. The larger orders include all of the extras like condiments, plates, silverware, and so on. Given the choice between Paneras, Milios, Capriotti's, or Cosi, I'll take Potbelly every time. Potbelly = WIN Food = 3.75 stars Service = 4 stars Value = 3 stars MISC = 5 stars (great online ordering system; highly configurable, easy, and accurate!) Oh, and pssst - need a cookie fix? Here - try one of the Potbelly cookies. What's that? You're week in the knees? Good. First bite is free, then you'll have to buy the rest. Seriously - their cookies are TO DIE FOR. My insulin spiked just thinking about them. nomnomnomnom

    (4)
  • Jonathan B.

    Potbelly's is a good place for a quick bite. Their sandwiches are very reasonably priced and they are rather tasty. If you're in somewhat of a hurry and want something good, try Potbelly's!

    (3)
  • Kara J.

    Potbelly's is delicious! They are fast and put on whatever you like. The meatball sandwich is so good with hot peppers, cheese, sauce, etc. I could seriously eat that every day and be happy. For the size of the sub I was very happy with the price too! Only like 5 bucks for something that really filled me up. They also have smaller subs for even cheaper.

    (4)
  • Saira L.

    Is Potbellys the best sandwich you will ever eat? Not really. But they are really GOOD. Most sandwich chains don't have consistency or quality- Potbelly's has both. I have tried all three locations in Madison- and they are all good. Their sandwiches taste yummy. Their milkshakes are good. So are their soups. They are affordable. Overall Potbellys is pretty darn good. A good place for a quick lunch, or dinner. There Italian Sub by far is the best. No other Italian sub I have found to be half as good. Also their multigrain bread is yummier than their white, and better for you. And did.. I mention their Giardernera/ hot peppers... Heavenly. I always have a bottle at home.

    (4)

Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.

Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.

Map

Opening Hours

  • Mon :10:00 am - 9:00pm
  • Mon : 10:00 am - 9:00pm

Specialities

  • Takes Reservations : No
    Delivery : No
    Take-out : Yes
    Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
    Bike Parking : Yes
    Good for Kids : Yes
    Good for Groups : Yes
    Attire : Casual
    Outdoor Seating : No
    Has TV : No
    Caters : Yes

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Share with your social network

Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online

Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.

© 2024 Restaurant Listings. All rights reserved.