been here twice in the last week. so good! my wife just saw it on the map and we decided to stop in while we here i the area for a swim meet, pizza.... thin crust fresh sauce, great toppings. and the pies woh! sugar cream yum! second stop tacos with mozzarella cheeze, chips and salsa. wowl soo good. cheesecake.... nice sweet filling with gram cracker crust the service was nice. cant wait to stop back next time we are in town!
(5)
Doris M.
Bahahaha! Love the other reviews! Nothing much has changed, but I was impressed by the food.My waitress could've been a little more friendly; she acted like I was bothering her with my order.The other staff was more congenial. I loved this little place. The view of the lake was good from any seat in the house. I'd go again. Good food, good price.
(4)
Kate S.
Yes, the "regular" crowd are considered elderly but, don't let that stop you!! Pullman Bay is known for their pie - my favorite is Sugar Cream - DELICIOUS!! Also, they're known for their fried chicken - again, a delicious decision!!
(4)
Tiger J.
Went for 1 year Anniversary. I've read the other 2 reviews and yes the clientele are 100 years old but this place doesn't serve beer & I feel like that's why there aren't many 'Whippersnappers' that frequent Pullman. We had fried pickles for starters. They were good and weren't greasy. They were coated w/Panko bread crumbs and no grease in the serving bowl. Wife is from Moulton, a close small town& her Grandparents would take her here back in the day. Place is a bit small on the inside and the kitchen is even smaller. With that said, we weren't disappointed. I had a tenderloin, nothing special but it was filling. Fries were regular run of the mill. Wife had turkey club on a whole wheat toast...delicious. I enjoyed stealing bites from her plate. Fresh tomatoes, crisp bacon...wonderful. The view is wonderful as well. A beautiful view of Grand Lake St Marys, which was made by men who used no machinery, just pick axes, mules and elbow grease. Service was below par but the food was good and the view was wonderful. Can't wait to try breakfast. Make a trip to Pullman Bay, its worth it.
(4)
Pablo E.
Now this is a real Blue Hair delight. If you're reading this review, you'll be the youngest person in this restaurant by three decades. No joke, this place caters to the old and the older. The parking lot is always full of Buicks and Lincolns. The interior is right out of the early 1970s. Hell, I'll admit, my grandparents introduced me to this place back in the day. At the same time, though, it avoids the major blue hair weaknesses of bland food by having relatively innovative flavors in traditional American fare. Given the clientele, the food is reasonable and the portions sizable. The pie is amazing, and whole pies are sold to go (you'll want to know that after having a piece). Service is always great. The restaurant offers huge windows through the dining room with a nice lake view. And if the lake isn't your thing, check out the waitresses! The consistency of staff cuteness here is Guiness book-worthy, seriously. Definitely a bonus. Pullman Bay is everything you could want in a Blue Hair. If you're ever in Celina, check it out. I'll give you a couple warnings though: one, this is a small restaurant, so be prepared to wait. And two: leave the Obama and Che t-shirts at home. This is Mercer County, people, and you don't want to end up in jail, dead, or both.
(5)
Nathan L.
Ever wonder where to see a parking lot full of '70s and '80s Buicks - all white or tan - and everyone of them with LESS than 10,000 miles on it? Pullman Bay. Technically we could say anything we want about the average patrons of the Bay without any danger of offending any of them. They'll never find these reviews. My grandma thinks the Internet is a TV channel - and she could run circles around these geezers. The breakfast food is spot-on, though, which is why it is THE after church go-to in the greater Celina area. THERE WILL BE A CROWD ON SUNDAY MORNINGS. But that's only 'cause Pullmans bitch smacks next door neighbor Bob Evans right back to his corporate "farm." Every time I end up in Pullman Bay - especially now that I don't live in Celina anymore - I have to sit by the window and stare out across the lake. It can be so peaceful and serene. That is if Ethyl, Marilyn and Ester at the next table could keep the noise down a little...
(4)
Sandra T.
I have been visiting Celina Ohio since I was a little girl. We would always stop here and eat at least once during our visit. I always order their broasted chicken and am never disappointed. They also have the best homemade cream pies you will ever eat. This last time I ordered their coconut cream yummy.
(5)
Donna H.
Love the food at Pullman Bay but don't order too much. Save room for the wonderful dessert! Pies are outstanding and cake is memorable. We make it a point to come here when we are camping at Eldora Speedway. It makes for a nice break in the racing action.
(5)
Michelle R.
*Former employee review* This place is truly a classic. My grandparents ate here at my age, and now my nieces and nephews do. Support your local eatery! YOU MUST eat some of their pie! The women baking these pies come in every day specifically to make amazing pies. You may not ever see a higher meringue in your life. Experience shows here! The lemon meringue is just how you imagine it should be, and they rotate the flavors, even throwing in some experimental ones now and then. The pecan pie is also wonderful. Breakfast is always excellent, made on the griddle. Try the hashbrowns - can't go wrong! The decor is nothing to die over (haha,) and is very outdated, yet equally comforting when out-of-town for long periods of time. The staff is generally caring and attentive. --Leave a tip!! The wages in Celina are terrible and these people do work hard to keep you coming back. :)
(5)
Jacob G.
Excellent friendly service, delicious food and fantastic lemon meringue pie. Great little hometown place with good prices. Nice place to stop when traveling through St Mary's
(5)
Rachel P.
AMAZING ! We drive 15 mins to come here ! Pizza Light and the Burritos are fantastic ! Oh ! And the dessert !!! Perfectionnn ! Definitely recommend Pullman Bay & we will be back !
(5)
Lee M.
Good place. Nice location. The food was good. I don't think I would drive over 20 min to eat here but it was good. It's prob like 3 1/2 stars but I enjoyed it.
(4)
Chris R.
decor is not a plus, but if you like fried chicken (or broasted) you will love theirs! The pies are awesome too. I can't speak for the rest of the menu as I always get the chicken when I come! The view is also great and the severs are very friendly. Definitely one of my favorite places in Celina!
(4)
Brian H.
Whenever I'm back in Celina my parents usually drag me to dinner here. It's not bad by Celina standards but it's nothing spectacular either. The best part of eating at Pullman Bay is the dessert as they have some of the best pies. Depending on where you sit you can have some nice views of the toxic Grand Lake St. Mary's if you're into that sort of thing.
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : No Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch Parking : Private Lot Bike Parking : Yes Wheelchair Accessible : No Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Quiet Alcohol : No Outdoor Seating : No Wi-Fi : No Has TV : No Waiter Service : Yes Caters : Yes
Christopher S.
been here twice in the last week. so good! my wife just saw it on the map and we decided to stop in while we here i the area for a swim meet, pizza.... thin crust fresh sauce, great toppings. and the pies woh! sugar cream yum! second stop tacos with mozzarella cheeze, chips and salsa. wowl soo good. cheesecake.... nice sweet filling with gram cracker crust the service was nice. cant wait to stop back next time we are in town!
(5)Doris M.
Bahahaha! Love the other reviews! Nothing much has changed, but I was impressed by the food.My waitress could've been a little more friendly; she acted like I was bothering her with my order.The other staff was more congenial. I loved this little place. The view of the lake was good from any seat in the house. I'd go again. Good food, good price.
(4)Kate S.
Yes, the "regular" crowd are considered elderly but, don't let that stop you!! Pullman Bay is known for their pie - my favorite is Sugar Cream - DELICIOUS!! Also, they're known for their fried chicken - again, a delicious decision!!
(4)Tiger J.
Went for 1 year Anniversary. I've read the other 2 reviews and yes the clientele are 100 years old but this place doesn't serve beer & I feel like that's why there aren't many 'Whippersnappers' that frequent Pullman. We had fried pickles for starters. They were good and weren't greasy. They were coated w/Panko bread crumbs and no grease in the serving bowl. Wife is from Moulton, a close small town& her Grandparents would take her here back in the day. Place is a bit small on the inside and the kitchen is even smaller. With that said, we weren't disappointed. I had a tenderloin, nothing special but it was filling. Fries were regular run of the mill. Wife had turkey club on a whole wheat toast...delicious. I enjoyed stealing bites from her plate. Fresh tomatoes, crisp bacon...wonderful. The view is wonderful as well. A beautiful view of Grand Lake St Marys, which was made by men who used no machinery, just pick axes, mules and elbow grease. Service was below par but the food was good and the view was wonderful. Can't wait to try breakfast. Make a trip to Pullman Bay, its worth it.
(4)Pablo E.
Now this is a real Blue Hair delight. If you're reading this review, you'll be the youngest person in this restaurant by three decades. No joke, this place caters to the old and the older. The parking lot is always full of Buicks and Lincolns. The interior is right out of the early 1970s. Hell, I'll admit, my grandparents introduced me to this place back in the day. At the same time, though, it avoids the major blue hair weaknesses of bland food by having relatively innovative flavors in traditional American fare. Given the clientele, the food is reasonable and the portions sizable. The pie is amazing, and whole pies are sold to go (you'll want to know that after having a piece). Service is always great. The restaurant offers huge windows through the dining room with a nice lake view. And if the lake isn't your thing, check out the waitresses! The consistency of staff cuteness here is Guiness book-worthy, seriously. Definitely a bonus. Pullman Bay is everything you could want in a Blue Hair. If you're ever in Celina, check it out. I'll give you a couple warnings though: one, this is a small restaurant, so be prepared to wait. And two: leave the Obama and Che t-shirts at home. This is Mercer County, people, and you don't want to end up in jail, dead, or both.
(5)Nathan L.
Ever wonder where to see a parking lot full of '70s and '80s Buicks - all white or tan - and everyone of them with LESS than 10,000 miles on it? Pullman Bay. Technically we could say anything we want about the average patrons of the Bay without any danger of offending any of them. They'll never find these reviews. My grandma thinks the Internet is a TV channel - and she could run circles around these geezers. The breakfast food is spot-on, though, which is why it is THE after church go-to in the greater Celina area. THERE WILL BE A CROWD ON SUNDAY MORNINGS. But that's only 'cause Pullmans bitch smacks next door neighbor Bob Evans right back to his corporate "farm." Every time I end up in Pullman Bay - especially now that I don't live in Celina anymore - I have to sit by the window and stare out across the lake. It can be so peaceful and serene. That is if Ethyl, Marilyn and Ester at the next table could keep the noise down a little...
(4)Sandra T.
I have been visiting Celina Ohio since I was a little girl. We would always stop here and eat at least once during our visit. I always order their broasted chicken and am never disappointed. They also have the best homemade cream pies you will ever eat. This last time I ordered their coconut cream yummy.
(5)Donna H.
Love the food at Pullman Bay but don't order too much. Save room for the wonderful dessert! Pies are outstanding and cake is memorable. We make it a point to come here when we are camping at Eldora Speedway. It makes for a nice break in the racing action.
(5)Michelle R.
*Former employee review* This place is truly a classic. My grandparents ate here at my age, and now my nieces and nephews do. Support your local eatery! YOU MUST eat some of their pie! The women baking these pies come in every day specifically to make amazing pies. You may not ever see a higher meringue in your life. Experience shows here! The lemon meringue is just how you imagine it should be, and they rotate the flavors, even throwing in some experimental ones now and then. The pecan pie is also wonderful. Breakfast is always excellent, made on the griddle. Try the hashbrowns - can't go wrong! The decor is nothing to die over (haha,) and is very outdated, yet equally comforting when out-of-town for long periods of time. The staff is generally caring and attentive. --Leave a tip!! The wages in Celina are terrible and these people do work hard to keep you coming back. :)
(5)Jacob G.
Excellent friendly service, delicious food and fantastic lemon meringue pie. Great little hometown place with good prices. Nice place to stop when traveling through St Mary's
(5)Rachel P.
AMAZING ! We drive 15 mins to come here ! Pizza Light and the Burritos are fantastic ! Oh ! And the dessert !!! Perfectionnn ! Definitely recommend Pullman Bay & we will be back !
(5)Lee M.
Good place. Nice location. The food was good. I don't think I would drive over 20 min to eat here but it was good. It's prob like 3 1/2 stars but I enjoyed it.
(4)Chris R.
decor is not a plus, but if you like fried chicken (or broasted) you will love theirs! The pies are awesome too. I can't speak for the rest of the menu as I always get the chicken when I come! The view is also great and the severs are very friendly. Definitely one of my favorite places in Celina!
(4)Brian H.
Whenever I'm back in Celina my parents usually drag me to dinner here. It's not bad by Celina standards but it's nothing spectacular either. The best part of eating at Pullman Bay is the dessert as they have some of the best pies. Depending on where you sit you can have some nice views of the toxic Grand Lake St. Mary's if you're into that sort of thing.
(3)