On Sunday in the Arcadia Valley - you've no other choice. I'd say wait, go to Caledonia BBQ Company instead. Or, drive into Farmington. This used to be a great place and a great value but the portions keep getting smaller and the price went up. Ribs are good but not great. though some in our party liked them as much as Bandana's in St. Louis. Sweetie had a half portion which included 3, count 'em three asparagus spears which were good but seriously ..... 3? Our group decided since it's Baylee Jo's or Subway we'd do this place. Next time, I'll go on to Caledonia without hesitation. Groups? Service was woefully slow.
The food was all good. The cook was either very busy or needing some help because our meal took quite awhile, but it was worth it. Good baby back ribs, baked beans, cole slaw (homemade). My partner had the grilled tuna which was excellent. I never order seafood so far from the Coast, but can certainly recommend it here.
My wife and I came here after a day visiting the Shut ins and other local attractions. We came based on a previous Yelp review that rated it 5 stars. We were seated immediately upon arriving. Our waitress was friendly and provided excellent service. The food was very good. I ordered the barbecue combination plate (the Piggy plate?) it consisted of ribs, BBQ chicken and pulled pork. I also ordered the Big T for my side which was a stuffed baked potato that was exceptional. My wife ordered the catfish platter which was very tasty as well. I would also recommend the Parmesan side salad with the sweet house dressing. Great value overall with fast and friendly service!