We have been spending summers in Maine for 20 years. The simple lobster dinner at Holbrook's was by far the best I've ever had. My group also had the lobster quesadillas and several side dishes. The food was spectacular! The setting outside watching the harbor was perfect. Highly recommended!
Food is decent, just what you expect from picnic table dining on Orr's Island. A few important things to note: *Yelp lists 'beer and wine available'....not true. Just soda etc. We saw multiple parties BYOB. *We ate around 7:30 or so in mid August...the mosquitos were so bad I was dancing in my seat to keep them away. My host, Maine native, said he had only been there during the day, and the bugs were a non issue. We live in Vermont, we know bugs, but this swarm was oppressive and pretty much ruined any chance of staying on to enjoy the view of the water.
Just had dinner at Holbrooks Wharf. While it is not fancy, this is the place to go to get down and dirty with a lobster. It was the tenderest and most succulent lobster I had in a long time and I make it a point to have lobster at least once a day when I am in Maine. Been here for four days and this lobster was GOOD, served with delicious corn on the cob as well. Pete was kind enough to crack the lobster for me so that made life sooooo much easier since it is hard for me to do this anymore. My husband was not very hungry so he had the ginger carrot soup. Not so good. Tasted vinegary for some reason. He ended this meal with blueberry cobbler. It was so full of juicy blueberries and delicious pastry. Do not miss Holbrooks if you are near Brunswick, Curdy Beach area