Uncle Matty’s Eatery

142 Church St
New Windsor, 21776
Reviews:
Splendid!! A great find after a day of winery hopping. My wife and I started with the feta fries. I didn't think these would be a big deal, after all, it's fries with feta. They were fantastic! If I had one critique it would be that these weren't hand-cut, but honestly, who cares! Delicious. My wife had the Spinach pie with a side of asparagus and roasted potatoes. She was very pleased with the dish. I had a simple Gyro with house-made chips. It was outstanding. The Gyro was meaty and the tzatziki was fresh and delicious. The house-made chips are made to order!! They were still hot from the fryer! They have a decent selection of beers and wines. One small note and I hope the owners see this. It would be helpful if you had a printed beer list. Our waitress struggled to name all of the bottles on hand and she shouldn't have to do that. There should be a list. We were glad that we found this place and hope to return.
We had great food last time we went, so another trip was warranted. The quesadilla appetizer had a nice thin flour tortilla and plenty of melted cheese inside. Wife had Chicken Marsala with a side salad instead of vegetable of the day, eggplant, and starch of the day, rice. Portion size was huge and take home for tomorrow was necessary. I wanted the Atlee ribeye steak, but was told they were all out. My second choice was the Spinach Pie. That too was not available. So, my third choice was their signature hot dogs with French fries. I got the bacon wrapped dogs. I asked for fried onions, but there was a communications failure and the dogs came with raw onions. I asked that the onions be removed and didn't get fried onions in their place. The dogs were deep fried and the outside was nice and crispy. The bacon wrapping was a nice addition. The French fries were crispy outside with just the right amount of crunch with a nice inside. They were seasoned well. I would give them another five stars except for the unavailable dishes and the mess-up with the onions.
Great food, good bottled beer selection of various microbrews, and friendly staff. Definitely worth a return visit.

(410) 635-6777

Comfort Food, Cheesesteaks, American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Yellow Turtle Inn Bed & Breakfast

111 S Springdale Ave
New Windsor, 21776
Reviews:
Went to a wedding shower at this place it was filthy. the fans, windows and chairs crusted with dirt the host had to literally go there two hours early to clean before decorating not to mention the rudeness of the owner. Would not recommend this place at all!

(410) 635-3000

Hotels, Bed & Breakfast

Store is open now