Jimmy ‘ s Restaurant & Lounge

St Rd 13 South
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
Awesome steaks every night ! Homemade cooked to order Mexican food on Wednesdays with cooked to order chips and salsa too ! Stop and give it a try you wont be disappointed.

(574) 834-2801

Bars

Store is open now

Sheila’s Sweet Treats

511 S Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
Sheila's started serving Breakfast and Lunch this last year. What a great addition! Prior to Sheila's we would usually go to Maria's for breakfast. What I like about this place is it the type of place where everyone knows your name. Sheila is always there working and says "hi guys!" every time we come in. The food is tasty and has reasonable serving and lots of options. (Ask about the ice cream waffle!). I believe they also won the chili cookout in 2013. Outside of breakfast and lunch, their scooped ice cream is great too. My favorite is Birthday Cake in a waffle cone!

(574) 834-7550

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Breakfast & Brunch

Store is open now

Consegna & Coffee

611 S Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
Very nice a place for breakfast, service was a little slow. Food tasted great, atmosphere was awesome. Chai latte was excellent!
Very cute atmosphere just off HWY 13 in North Webster. Service was a little slow because it was very busy on a Sunday. Great lattes but temp was like warm. Food presentation and flavor was great, very filling and at a good price point. Definitely stop again.
This place is ... eccentric. It's like a garage sale plus cafe/coffeehouse. The floor is covered in shellacked magazines. The ceiling is decorated with daisies. The teacups, the tables and chairs, the light fixtures -- nothing really matches. Nor is it meant to. There's a secondhand store. China, clothes, random furniture, paperbacks from the '90s. The staff is super-friendly and the owner is clearly very passionate about what she does. It's a teeny-weeny town so I don't think there's a whole lot of competition. I mean, North Webster's only claims to fame are the Mermaid Festival and a giant shoe store in a palace. Oh, and a paddleboat. We got two cups of coffee and -- we thought -- a slice of cheesecake to share. What we ended up with was two cups of coffee and two oversized slices of cheesecake. I'm not sure if there was a miscommunication or if they just thought we really looked like we needed extra cheesecake. It WAS delicious -- some sort of brownie-toffee-cheesecake hybrid. Half of it is still in my fridge. The coffee was fresh and good and apparently is roasted by an Amish guy nearby. Named Vern or Marv or something. Their menu also includes homemade soup, salads, panini and other tasty-sounding food. I drive through North Webster approximately once every decade, so I can't say this is a regular stop, but I am pretty sure my mom will be back.

(574) 834-1954

Breakfast & Brunch, Cafes, Coffee & Tea

Store is open now

Aztecaz Mexican Grill

619 N Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
My favorite little mexican restaurant by far. Delicious food, great service. Never disappointed. Must get the chori queso dip everytime! The green salsa for the steak tacos is amazing. They have lots of variety for anyone who wants to try something new. Nothing is overly spicy so it's perfect for people who can't handle spicy foods. Took my grandmother and she loved it as well and that's saying a lot. Would definitely recommend to everyone!
I just went in for some take out. Service was so-so. Same with the food. Plastic utensils would have been helpful. Maybe a napkin. Asking questions resulted in very short answers, I'm sure I was bothering her. There was one other couple sitting at a table. Burrito was not what I expected, could be a regional thing. It was sloppy, not the kind you pick up and eat. Again, a fork would have been useful.
There are so many options for mexican food in the world, but I am thankful we have Aztecaz in our small town. VERY quick service (under 10 min) and the staff is friendly. They do not have their liquor license, so don't expect to get a margarita with dinner. Their food does not have a lot of spice, so if that is your thing, you may be a little disappointed. Good for families and young kids. We use them for take out quite a bit.

(574) 834-3600

Mexican

Store is open now

Lighthouse Cafe & Pizzeria

720 S Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
Really good Iced Tea. Can tell its brewed. Free wifi. Pizza is good and usually have specials.

(574) 834-2917

Pizza

Store is open now

Maria’s House of Pancakes

104 E Esterbrook Dr
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
This place looks like a regular diner, but one taste of the breakfast and you can tell they put their own spin on typical breakfast items. I love pancakes and I have to tell you, these were delicious. My food came out piping hot, which i love! I also had the Fiesta skillet (3 eggs, chorizo, onions, jalapeños, sourcream and salsa! Whew talking about flavorful! And they don't skimp on the portions. This was worth the 20 minute drive from the resort. I would give this a try for lunch or dinner.
Maria's is a good solid 4 star Yelp rating. The food is good. The service is good. The place is nice. You get a lot of food. Anyone that finishes there meal has to be totally over stuffed. Splitting any meal between two hungry adults is my suggestion.
Visiting the parents in Syracuse for a couple weeks. Went to Maria's for breakfast the other day and it was really good. Super fluffy huge omelettes! How do they get those omelettes so fluffy?! 5 egg omelettes- Huge portions! Delicious crispy hash browns. Two pancakes come with the omelettes. The pancakes were the only let down as they did not taste homemade but from a box mix. I'm picky about pancakes. Will definitely go back. Would likely get my omelette with the crispy hash browns and grits or fruit rather than the pancakes next time if they let you do that. Had left overs for a lunch later that day and even a little snack the next day! Our waitress was super attentive and provided us with excellent service. Wish I would have gotten her name as would like to give a shout out to her. (She was the gal with the stretched earlobes/earplugs. No judgement just wanted to give a description of our waitress as I recommend trying to sit in her section for excellent thorough service!)

(574) 834-4400

Breakfast & Brunch

Store is open now

Bourbon Street Pizza

643 N Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
Delicious pizza!!! Best local pizza option, by far.
Have eaten here on several occasions. My only complaint is that the service is a bit slow and clunky (empty drinks, apps coming out after pizzas). The food itself is very good. I would recommend the taco pizza or the BLT pizza. The place also has some cool local flavor to the decor that's worth checking out.
Not bad, but the sauce REALLY has too much oregano. We had to stop going there for that reason. :(

(574) 834-4444

Pizza, Italian

Store is open now

Subway

649 N Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
The worst subway ever. I mean ever! Their bread is always stale to the point it crumbles in your hands. Service is slow and the owners could care less if you are satisfied with the food or service.

(574) 834-5558

Sandwiches, Fast Food

Store is open now

North Webster Sunrise Deli

225 N Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(574) 834-3354

Bakeries, Coffee & Tea, Desserts

Store is open now

Happy Wok

621 N Main St
North Webster, 46555
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(574) 834-2990

Chinese

Store is open now