Brian J.

I've visited this place a half dozen times for lunch. I want to like it, but the food isn't all that great and there are two employees including the owner so the service is slow. The last two times I ordered food here (it's near where I work so convenient) I've ordered a buffalo chicken wrap (BCW) and was sorely disappointed. The first time I ate a BCW there it wasn't bad! The wrap was made with salad mix instead of iceberg lettuce, but no worries! It was tasty. The next time I asked for iceberg lettuce (not a fan of shredded carrots in my wrap) and it was great! Yes, I've had better BCWs, but this was a midrange B for a BCW. Then there were the last two times. Casey's is all about saving money (as any restaurant should be to a certain extent) but they tried to convince me that their "new" buffalo chicken wrap sauce was made with their chipotle sauce. A BCW is a cold wrap. The only warmth comes from the fried or grilled chicken not from the tortilla being put in a panini press. This was the way I got it the first two times and this is reflected on the menu. So now I have a chipotle wrap, completely hot sandwich from a panini press made with chipotle sauce. This is not a BCW. I asked if they could make it the old way on my first time back after the first chipotle wrap and they said, yes! .....NOPE. Same exact panini pressed tortilla with chipotle seasoning. Also, this thing looked like a bomb went off in a tortilla shell. Soggy, not well drained, hot to an extent, but relatively tasteless and without a hint of buffalo sauce as most people would define buffalo sauce. I gave them several chances, but I am finished with Casey's Custom Cafe.