Bartlett’s Gourmet Grill & Tavern

131 East Dunes Hwy
Beverly Shores, 46301
Bartlett's seems out of place for the area. It's near Michigan City but set aside by a couple of miles sweepingly in the woods. But the food quality, selection and service is all excellent! I'd expect this more in a large city not here! But that's a good thing: an oasis for those living or visiting nearby. That said you will get food from oysters to ahi to Reubens to Bahn Mi. Duck confit? They have it! The food is fresh so they will run out and you're out of luck. That's ok. More places should be like this! Highly recommended.
Have eaten there a few times with mixed feelings. Restaurant is smallish, located on a scenic stretch of US12 in Beverly Shores IN. It seems to be a popular stop for IL tourists that profligate into the area during the summer months. They can seat around 80-100 patrons inside, and also have outdoor patio style seating. It is a cramped, loud atmosphere, with a bar located on one side. The parking lot is also undersized with patrons having to leave their vehicles precariously parked out along the edge of the road (US12). Their menu has some high-brow items on it, a good number of which are grill related/prepared, including a grilled lettuce salad which is not the greatest. I'd heard various good things from coworkers who've eaten there before I stopped, and my first experience was a good one. Food was cooked right and flavorful. Subsequent visits, however, were disappointing. Overcooked burgers (burned actually), flavorless apple-fennel slaw, and a few other things I won't bore you with. Management is non-versed in personable customer service skills, if they have any at all. A "Hugh" is listed at the business' website as their contact. Hugh doesn't answer email, apparently. The place may be worth a try for you, idk. If you don't mind loud, cramped, crowded restaurants, with inconsistent meal quality then go for it. Prices are average for the area and serving size. Two stars.
Bartletts is on 12 not 20! One star for yelp in getting me lost!!!!!! Food was decent. I had to eat quick because the Mosquitos were swarming! Do not sit outside!

(219) 879-3081

American (Traditional)

Store is open now