Cheap, greasy wings that hit just the spot when you have a craving. I think you get a lot more wings in a single order to-go than by staying there. The spicy wings are just the right amount of spicy. By far, my favorite wing spot in Evanston. The burgers are decent as well.
(4)
Sasha R.
The waffle fries are amazing but the service ranges from rude as hell to indifferent. If I could send someone in to get my food for me, I'd be happy.
(2)
Stacey A.
Greatest. Buffalo. Chicken. Sandwich. Of. All. Time. It *might* burn your face off, though. If that's your thing, then you're good to go. If not....maybe don't order the hottest sauce they have.
(4)
Eric V.
Buff Joe's has been an ol' favorite ever since my high school days. The spicy wings have great flavor with a nice touch of heat. The cheddar chips are a must, along with a "gutbuster" 7Up to wash it all down. The dining room always has the strange scent of cleaning solution and the bathrooms kinda scare me, but the food is worth it. Don't forget, cash only!!
(4)
Jonathan K.
Suicide wings, w jalapenos if ur down with having flavor in ur food. cheddar chips are 100% cheddar cheese dumped on criss-cut fries. buffalo wings were good too. no frills, just wings and a place to eat them. and a tv.
(5)
David S.
From 2000-2004 I loved this place dearly ... since it was my only outlet for cheap wings while at Northwestern. I went often enough that I didn't have to tell them what I wanted most times (single suicide, fries and extra ranch) which was pretty nice. The wings aren't super meaty but the sauce is tangy (I really don't think any sauce below suicide is all that hot - one time they had a special XXX sauce that killed me before I could finish my wings though). The place itself is pretty grimey though - I felt like taking a shower every time I rolled out of there since every surface seems to have a few years worth of grease on it. Verdict: Great college place to grab cheap and relatively delicious wings, but the one time I've been back since made me a little sick.
(3)
Jacob K.
I used to love this place years ago unfortunately the quality has gone down drastically. The chicken is not so fresh and sometimes even has broken bones. The last time I went there the wings were warm (not hot) and the only way to make the wings hotter was adding pickled jalapenos. The prices are not great either... this place only survives because of the reputation it has and because there isn't much competition for good wings in the area.
(2)
Deez D.
I would give this place negative stars if I could. I had wings taste better from Costco. If you decide to sit way back by the window, you will smell rotten garbage while eating your meal. The only thing good about this place are the waffle fries. I didn't believe all the people who gave this place a bad rating but now I understand and hope that this will help others. People who gave this place a good rating should really get out more.
(1)
Joel F.
There is a deity in the chicken world and his name is Joe. Chickens line up to die at the hand of Joe to be blessedly cooked and eaten at this establishment. I know that I would if I were a chicken. The waffle fries rock, too :)
(5)
Grace L.
As my husband said it best, they are the best wings in Chicago, bar none. Yes, crave them, love them, and fill your arteries with them. Go get em wings.
(5)
Joshua D.
There is one major problem with Buffalo Joe's: Once you eat their wings, you will enter a world where suddenly all wings from anywhere else aren't as good. You will forever say, "these are no Buffalo Joes" Even the best of the best you might say,"Damn these are Great!!! But, they're no Buffalo Joe's.". So, if you simply want the best then do it...but don't say I didn't warn you.
(5)
Amy W.
Not a fan... I don't like their wings and there isn't much else to choose from. The Mexican potato is a decent alternative. Cash only, blah!
(2)
Peter M.
The wings here are culinary crack. Highly addictive, make you feel great at first, terrible for your health, you're willing to drive 30 min+ for them when the alternative might be 5 min away. After Hurricane Katrina they stopped serving wings because the Louisiana-based hot sauce couldn't be delivered. Jalapino soaked suicide wings aren't for everyone but the mild and hot are amazing. Celery and ranch on the side. I often sent a friend to pick up some of their wing sauce then cooked store bought chicken at home, healthier but just as excellent. Once my roomate and I went in and he ordered a "double pan" while I insisted we get a "double order." He was positively confused and sure enough they handed us a $55 double pan which is clearly for a Superbowl party of 8-12 people rather than the 24-wing double order that we should have had. Day 1) That night we probably took down in the aggregate 45 wings. The rest were covered and put into the fridge. Days 2-3) I ate about 12 a day and he might have had about 6. Day 4) We decide to put the last 30 wings or so into the garage (mid-winter Chicago) and, no joke, we would bring out a plate to eat some cold and warmed up. When finished they were just as good 4 days earlier. Day 5-7) Didn't want to live anymore. Considered digging my own grave. Possible long term liver damage. Now I'm in Beverly Hills land of the organic cooked in omega-3 oil "cheesesteak hoagie," and the best wings come from Papa John's. Maybe that's a good thing but I will one day make the pilgrimage back.
(5)
Sarah Beth B.
I dream of Buff Joe's. It's like, the most basic junk food ever, but I still get excited every.single.time. I eat here. I have heard there is a large menu, but I have never bothered with anything other than WINGS and CHEDDAR CHIPS. I guess if I had any criticism it would be they need bigger napkins? That's not a criticism, I guess, it's just a compliment on how saucy the wings are. Prepare to not do anything else for the rest of the night, because you will probably have heartburn and definitely be in a food coma.
(5)
Thu D.
When I moved to the city after graduating, my boyfriend and I searched high and low for wings as good as Buff Joe's and could not find a place that even came close. We would always get a double order of spicy wings and it is seriously heaven in a styrofoam container (my mouth is watering now just typing this). Luckily, I've returned to Evanston, so I can have the best wings whenever I want! The spicy wings are the way to go because they're spicy, but not so scorching hot that your tongue goes numb. Also, while I like this location fine, I think the Green Bay location is better because their wings are larger, so you get more bang for your buck. My only complaints are that they only serve ranch (blue cheese all the way!) and it is a cash-only establishment. However, that's nothing my own bottle of blue cheese dressing and an ATM can't fix, so Buff Joe's is okay in my book.
(5)
Stefanie B.
I haven't been to the actual restaurant in soo long so when I was in the area I had to come back to relive my high school memories coming here. Who doesn't love them some BJ's?! ;) The staff is so welcoming and fun as soon as you walk in and your order is ready in a matter of minutes. You can never go wrong here if you're in the mood for Buffalo Wings. Also the waffles fries tho...mmmm good eats for good prices. I'd get the double order of wings because the wings sizes are pretty anorexic and remember it's CASH ONLY! I hate the parking around this area tho
(4)
Catherine N.
WOW!! The wings here are truly delicious!! I met a few people at a party who told me that they would drive from downtown Chicago to Evanston, just for an order of Buffalo Joe's wings, and now I can see why. These wings are so simple and made to perfection!! They are the right amount of crispiness and the sauce is ON POINT! Plus, the portion size and price is not bad either. One order of wings is around $8 and you get like 10 wings!! DEAL! Tip: Get the normal waffle fries and not the one loaded with stuff - the WILL get soggy because it's drenched in canned nacho cheese sauce and and buffalo wing sauce. ALSO, if you want to place an order for a Super Bowl party... do that like 3 days in advance, this place gets so many orders that you won't get it if you order the night before!! - They are just THAT good.
(4)
Raheem L.
A good amount of food for a very good price. No complaints about the food, but the workers had a bit of attitude, they were very rude to some other customers that walked in after me and had a confusing order.
(4)
Matt A.
This place has the best wings ever!! I don't know what the captain puts in this sauce but it is AMAZING. I call him the Captain because he has been there for over 20 years running the ship. If you see him you will know. Now the only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because I have been bamboozled with a bad batch of wings but never when the Captain is there. One time my order got lost and the captain immediately gave me a new order free of charge. Granted I waited over 45 minutes but hey he's the captain and he acknowledged his mistake. In his defense, he was really busy. Double order mild("spicey" is extra sauce and hot is with jalapeños) with cheddar chips and a large ice water. Sometimes water is yellow. Watch for that.....I can still smell the sauce in my fingertips. Yum.
(4)
Kenny O.
Cheap, filling, and--best of all--tasty. After living in the Chicago area for several years now, this might be my favorite place for buffalo wings (the top contender being Duke of Perth in Chicago). While I was studying at NU, this was one of my most-frequented joints to hit up for late nights in the office. I don't think I've ever dined in, but the food's always been great even after a 20-minute walk home in the cold winter.
(5)
Adele n.
Yup. I did it. I ate the suicide wings for the first time in 10 years (go, u northwestern!) and it was as freaking delicious as I remembered. I am from upstate NY, homeland of the wing, and Buffalo Joes is the only Chicago wing that stacks up. Don't waste your time with any others! They could be even hotter, IMO, but these are about the hottest I've had out here. Vinegar-cayenne perfection.
(5)
Oliver W.
Pretty good wings, only choice you have is what level of spicyness you want. The restaurant is fairly dirty and greasy, which was a bit off-putting. But if you're ok taking a shower after eating here then you got the right idea.
(3)
Gspot H.
My First Real Date 1st month of Sophomore was up in here. The song "Blue Eye's" by The Who came on the radio. Went 2 see "Yamo" at ETHS afterwards on a double date; my X was the other Lady. I got the wings Mild. It was a good fun safe memorable out of site nite.
(5)
Kenneth L.
Yeah, I mean, it gets the job done. I had been advised by many Northwestern alum that Buff Joe's was the quintessential wing place - an institution for buffalo wings. To its credit, Buff Joe's is what it is and it doesn't mess around with that. But, little did I know, I was walking into a hole in the wall shack with an infinite amount of chicken wings already cooked and hanging out in the frying basket, awaiting my consumption. Don't get me wrong, fried chicken wings are fried chicken wings and I love fried chicken wings. It was pretty simple and pretty good, but not sure that it warrants the collegiate lore hype machine. Though, if I were still in college rocking a budget, I wouldn't be surprised to find myself here many a time.
(3)
Peter H.
Have been coming here for 13 plus years. Perfect overtime.
(5)
Mario G.
The wings and chips may have Crack like additives because I always Jones after them. I once saw a roach run across my table and yet has deterred me from eating here. Just start a mild sauce Iv, slap a mega gut no ice in my hand and I'm good. They're ranch sauce makes the pants tight! I want more...MORE!!!!!!!
(5)
Miss Kari P.
Every time I order wings they get smaller and smaller. I'm expecting just a pile of bones the next time I go in, which is unfortunate because I absolutely adore their suicide wings. It really doesn't matter, but every single worker inside is absolutely rude for no appropriate reason. Without fail. You're killin' me Buff Joes....
(2)
Steve A.
This is a good wings place, but they actually have a lot more, including hamburgers, hot dogs and even vegetarian sandwiches. Everything is cooked to order, so it's hot and fresh, and there is a nice enough dining area both in front and in back. Service is fast and efficient. Cash only.
Tangy, light sauce tossed on deep fried chicken wings. What's not to love? Waffle fries with heart attack cheese sauce is simple super thick rue cooked into some milk and minimal cheese. Ick.
(5)
Brian R.
I've been to Buffalo Joe's a few times now, and I'm just now writing a review. Of all the wing places I've been to, and I've been to a few, Buffalo Joe's is probably the best. I live out west (St. Charles/West Chicago/Geneva area), and I (usually) gladly make the 1 hour trip out to Evanston for Buff' Joe's. If Yelp ratings were all about food taste, I'd consider it a 5-star joint. Be warned! Buff' Joe's is cash only!
(4)
Travis L.
How in the name of Buffalo, New York can you call this place a good wing joint?! Honestly some of the worst wings I've had in a long while. I cannot understand how anyone can get past the dried shriveled up pieces of jerky Joe's tries to pass off as wings. I ordered the single which comes with about a dozen wings and after picking through the tough inedible chunks, I ate maybe 4-5 wings worth; wings=fail. Next, I except that I have a high tolerance for heat but the one thing I hate is when a place claims to have some high level of hotness that you can't fathom to handle and then when you take a bite it's nothing more than f'ing Tobasco; suicide sauce=fail. If anyone is paying attention @ Joe's, here are some pointers: Don't use frozen wings, it dries out the meat and ruins the taste, instead serve fewer higher quality wings (never frozen). Second, unless you're actually going to use exceptionally hot sauce don't call them suicide and finally, use fresh jalapeños instead of those crappy canned ones.
(1)
Christopher S.
This is by far the best wings I've ever had. I always order the single order of suicide wings and waffle fries. I would definitely recommend this place.
(5)
Jen C.
Old school- RC cola, cash only but they have an ATM machine- get the wings suicide style, celery and ranch- fast service~ wish the wings had more meat to them but the sauce is too good to complain. Waffle fries to balance the heat!
(4)
Mike A.
I'm not really sure what happened here. I used to come here all the time in high school and it was pretty much the best wings you could find on the planet. It was the first trip I'd make when coming back home from college. Wow have things changed. the wings are probably 3x smaller than they were back in the day and really dry. Prices also seemed to have doubled. 14.59 for a double order, man, the amount of overall meat on the bones wasn't even like a single order a few years ago. It was like the wings came from an unhatched chicken embryo. Someone came in an ran this place into the ground, it used to be a legitimate Chicago food landmark. Incredibly disappointed and feel cheated out of a lot of money, way to ruin their reputation. Should have read the reviews before coming back.
(1)
Spencer S.
I wish I can give this place 0 stars. I use to love it until I ordered a chicken tender dinner and they fed me raw chicken. When we went back the next day (we ordered the day before right before closing) the people there said "oh well, it wasn't on our shift, and no money back." So they fed me raw chicken and did nothing to fix it.
(1)
Ramena A.
I love my wings, and I thought if love buff joes (especially because of all the great things I heard about them). Unfortunately, I went there and the chicken didn't taste good, the sauce had a weird taste to it (not a normal wing flavor), and the cheesy fries had cold melted cheese on it. They only take cash, which is extremely inconvenient. It was an OK atmosphere, a little awkward to be honest. I just did not enjoy it.
(2)
Brandon B.
Best wings around. Wish it wasn't cash only and that they delivered. 5 star food, but 3 star convenience.
(4)
Crystal P.
The truth is, they are, what they say they are a wings and burger place in downtown Evanston and a wings and ribs place on Howard street Chicago. I have never been disappointed until this year. The girl on the register "flawless" as always, the ribs were like they took all the good stuff home and were serving the customer scraps. The 2 cooks in the back were so busy talking to each other that they literally didn't cook the food and there were about 4 people waiting and that number quickly built to a dozen since it was a Friday night. The girl asked them a couple times and they gave her a look that said "don't talk to us" Wings were good but no celery or sauce was on the order, they must be taking that home as well. Ive been coming here since they opened each of the resturants, I've recommended hundreds of people. This was a real let down.
(1)
Eugene W.
Buffalo Joe's is a great wings place. Their wings are delicious and if you a spicy-lover, this is the place to go. Their waffle fries are extremely tasty, though the cheese on the fries hardens and tastes kind of bad after a while. I would definitely go here over Buffalo Wild Wing's with a group of friends, because the atmosphere is nicer and the wings are just as good.
(4)
Mina P.
This visit was definitely 5 star worthy. I will forever be a fan of buffalo joe's but it's really a hit or miss here. Some days the wings are wimpy and dry and other days definitely the best on the planet. I love this place regardless because I've been eating here for almost 20 years. We can't have a gathering at home without a party pan of suicide from BJ's and you can't forget about the cheddar chips! CASH ONLY - there's an ATM inside ;)
(5)
Simon K.
People have probably written everything there is to write about this place. The wings are great. The waffle fries are great. Et cetera, et cetera... However, I'm about to drop some knowledge on anybody who is unfazed by how society views them. Bring a tupperware container full of white rice and make sure you have enough people to order the party platter. When you get a platter of suicide wings, a pool of butter, hot sauce and jalapenos ends up gathering at the bottom of the aluminum tray. If you take the rice (which the tupperware hopefully kept fairly warm) and mix it in with the sauce, you will experience Buff Joe's in a way you have never experienced before. For the ones who don't mind doing a little extra work, rip the meat off the last few chicken wings into smaller chunks to create a complete dish. This also works if you take the wings as take-out but nothing beats getting the wings right out of the fryer. So, do you dare take on the challenge? Hopefully I'll be seeing a few more people with tupperware the next time I go. I'll be sure to say hello.
(5)
Mike M.
First & LAST time I set foot in dis joint! I know joes due to occasionally a co-worker would bring in a tray of wings...So after a N/W game we decided to go to the joint... bad move...5 out of 6 staffr's are rude!!!!They don't give a s*** about u or your business, the place is filthy... if u gotta "go" take a risk and pee in the alley! The soda sucks! The bonelesss wings taste crappy and look like alien fingers! Don't get me wrong but the wings are good-not great!...Save yourself the horrible experience I went thru and GO to Jake Melnicks!- in downtown Chicago!!! JM undoubted-ly have the BEST WINGS IN Illinois!
(1)
Paul B.
We've been going to this hole in the wall wings joint for years and years. Look - the wings are amazing (I'm whimping out in my old age and can't do the hot or suicide wings anymore but the milds and mediums are still spectacular), the fries are good as is the chili but the help is obnoxious. They aren't even nice about telling you that it's cash only. The scene is that of a run down wings joint in a college town so I guess that fits. That being said we still come back.
(3)
Simplelife S.
So unprofessional!!! The employees at the register area stood and talked (inappropriately) amongst themselves using profanity while people waited for their orders to cook. At one point a guy came from the other side of the restaurant and participated in the conversation while he and the employee handled a bag with out washing their hands. At this point I watch closely and even asked that my food was not prepared by either of these women. I did finally ask for a manager who listened to my complaint as the two employees stood in ear shot but never looked as if they were even aware that they were doing something wrong. It had been years since I went to this Davis street location I usually use the Howard street one. Much better service. I was so disappointed in what I saw I called three people I knew while I was there and recommended to them NOT to use this place EVER!!!!! * WONT BE GOING BACK*
(1)
Marc G.
The more things change... the more they stay the same... mostly. Back in the day I would have had an order of Wings... suicide... a Cheddar Char Burger, Cheddar Char Chips and an RC Gut buster. That was in my NU days... but on a recent visit back to Evanston, we made a late night run to our old, favorite haunt. We went spicy with the Wings this time... and while they were good, they were not as good as we remembered... a little too fried and greasy, perhaps. Hmm... We skipped the Chips (waffle fries) but went for a Burger, too. That was even better than I remembered... So darn good... the juices from the meat soaked the cheese spread bun perfectly... mustard and ketchup... pickles, tomato and lettuce... Simple but stunningly delicious. I can still taste it. Mmmm!
(4)
Samuel M.
The only place i know of in the Chicago area that serves classic Buffalo Wings. What I mean by this: -Fried, but not battered -Equal parts drumettes/wings -BONE LEFT IN (as far as I'm concerned, "boneless wings" are both an oxymoron and something that only sociopaths eat) -Buttery yet spicy sauce that invariably leaves the eater messy The one place in which this place breaks from tradition is by serving the wings with ranch dressing rather than bleu cheese, but trust me, you won't miss it. I've only ever ordered one thing here: suicide wings with waffle chips. I see no reason to change this. 90% of the time, this is exceptional and well worth the havoc it inevitably wreaks on my gastrointestinal system. 10% of the time the food is pedestrian, for one reason or another (typically wings are too small, or are swimming in excessive sauce. However, this latter issue tends to arise with suicide more than with other styles because it necessitates the addition of extra sauce). In summation: If you are craving wings, do NOT be tempted by the cleaner exterior and large televisions and take your wing craving to BWW's down the street. It is mediocre. Buff Joe's is the real deal. PS As others have iterated, but which I must needs restate: CASH ONLY!! They have an ATM inside if you're desperate, though.
(4)
J K.
For me, a trip back to Evanston isn't complete without a visit to Buffalo Joe's. And they're open until midnight so even if my flight is delayed I'm able to get my junk food chicken fix. This place is CASH ONLY so plan accordingly - there's a Bank of America a block away and I think there's actually a small ATM in the restaurant but I'd assume it charges fees. My friends swear by the wings, but I always get the chicken tenders with mild sauce and extra ranch dressing - they're amazing. The food is so tasty that it's easy to overlook that the wings and tenders are always swimming in grease and the "cheese" on the buffalo chips (fries) is synthetic. Prices are reasonable, there's plenty of seating in the back, and even when the place is busy they seem to be able to cycle through orders quickly. A couple of things that might some day push Buffalo Joe's down into 4-star territory for me... 1) the wings seem to have gotten smaller over time - not a good trend 2) sometimes they don't have tenders - very disappointing since they're my favorite menu item 3) if you get food to go, they put fries in paper bags so you'll have nice, hot chicken but cold fries (I realize it's un-PC of me to enjoy the styrofoam containers they use for chicken, so I usually eat in the restaurant)
(5)
Arie W.
It would be an understatement to say I'm a huge fan of BJ's. My family gets a party platter for any type of get together, parties, Christmas, Thanksgiving (yes I said Thanksgiving). My favorite thing to order at BJ's are the suicide wings and cheese fries. I've noticed that in the past few years the wings were getting considerably smaller and smaller, but the last time I went, they were back to the normal size and just as great as ever. The way they make the cheese fries here is totally Chicago style. My other friends from out of town who I've brought here say that the cheese is way too cheddar-y and thick, but if I could eat it on everything, I absolutely would. I've also had the burger, brat, chili, and cookies and everything is delicious. The only bad thing about BJ's, if you don't eat it while it's hot, it loses it's appeal. The facilities are not the most pleasant, but it does the job. The bathroom is probably as clean as it possibly can get. They have TVs for customers to watch while eating. The seating area isn't too appealing, but when I get my wings, I don't care where I'm sitting. It's that good.
(5)
Kenneth M.
I have been going to Buffalo Joe's since 1992. I have traveled all over the world, had wings from all over the United States, including in Buffalo, and hands down Buffalo Joe's are the best wings I have ever had. I have had Buffalo Joe's at all my major birthday's, had my parents bring a double party pan 6 hours for my graduation from college. For those who have given a bad rating to Buffalo Joe's, they must have bad taste buds. Even if the service was poor, I would come back again and again for these wings. I see some of the reviews are for non wing related items. Get it straight, this is a WINGS PLACE. Although some of the staff may be rough around the edges, you come for the food. I have never had a bad experience at Buffalo Joe's in my life. When I need a comfort food a double order hot, with Buffalo Chips, and a gut buster R.C hit the spot. Ghetto Joe's on Howard on the hand is sub-par, and people may have been there. A fan since I was 12, and I will go until the day I die.
(5)
Melissa D.
So, I know they made the wings a little on the aneroxic side but they're SO GOOD. I love this place, I go here for the cheddar fries and wings ONLY, all the time. I seriously drive 45 minutes just to eat here. I know people's taste buds are different and they have different preferences but I adore this place to pieces. The sauce is delicious, and they do sell a huge jug of it (though it's a little pricey)... It's a hole in the wall place, but I don't know about everybody else, I go for the food, not to stare at teh walls and say, "Uh, the paint is peeling..." Buffalo Joe's, my go to place for wings when I'm really craving them!
(5)
Master B.
It is a sad day for me. i grew up eating these wings. i have even had wings from Anchor Bar in Buffalo where they were created, and buff joes sauce was better. but over the last few years i have been fighting an up hill battle defending this place. finally i ordered wings and had to write this. the wings have been getting progressively smaller as time goes by, but tonight i counted and i got a double order of wings and there was no meat what so ever on the wings. the largest wing was an inch and a quarter long and had only skin and tendons attached no meat. i understand the desire to make money and have high yield but how does the owner really expect people to keep coming back for chicken bones slathered in butter? my advice just see if you can buy the sauce in bulk and get your own wings, it has to be cheaper and a better meal... sorry buff joe's you lost a life long customer tonight.
(1)
alan q.
I've been hear a few times. I recently visited for the first time in at least 3-4 years. The only thing I've ever gotten are the suicide wings and waffle fries. Waffles fries are pretty standard...not much to judge here. The wings are pretty small. The suicide sauce isn't really that hot. It's hot but manageable. Man, I really remember the wings to be much better. It was ok, but all I was thinking while eating was, "what other places have better wings?" This is the definition of hole in the wall. I usually don't mind hole the wall places, but this time it got to me. The dining room smelled like a wet, dirty rag. The tables were greasy and is a type of place where you don't want to touch anything. I must say that I really don't need to go back to this place for another 3-4 years..or more.
(2)
D M.
Finger lickin good yummy-ness. That about sums it up.
(5)
Marion J.
This is more than 1 1/2 stars for me. We went for wings, I was cravings with, got take out, staff was not especially nice nor helpful. We got home wings were tiny and very dry. They felt old.. just not the juicy chicken wings I was craving. Not sure what went wrong. Both hubby and i did not like them. We did not finish them. We wont be back. Maybe they have better items or better days. They are cheap for wings.
(2)
Jon L.
best buffalo wings ever!!!
(5)
Khris L.
This place is a classic buffalo wing spot for anyone in the area. I even know people who would drive over an hour just to get some of the suicide wings from here. I want to start off by saying that their wings have gotten smaller and the prices have increased over the years. It's still worth it as the single order or their wings can fill you up easily. I love this place, but it's hard for me to give it higher than 3 stars because of the feeling you get when you eat in. The staff, for the most part, seem to not care about anything. The place is small and doesn't accomodate big groups. The tables are sticky, and so are the ketchup and mustard bottles...There are always people waiting outside to ask you for change and/or your leftovers. Aside from all those inconveniences, the food here is great and I suggest you try it out. Carry out might be a better idea than eating in.
(3)
Javi L.
Only had the wings so far but OH MY GAWWD! They are just super delicious... Price is fair for a single order (12pc) not to mention the unbelievable taste. I believe Buffalo Joes was nominated for best wings or something idk but I'd you are ever in the Evanston area you must stop and grab yourself some wings. Only had the spicy. Next up is the suicide.
(5)
Christine G.
I'd like to thank my homie Takala for winning a bet with me, of course I lost! I said I would buy her chicken dinner. This place was so good! Don't get it mixed up with BWWs. I did not get the wangs, she did but I tried it and it was oh so yummy. I had the chicken nachos which was bigger than my face but I ate it all because I was starving. I will be back!
(4)
Cecilia T.
Buffalo Joe's is without a doubt THE BEST flavored wings in Chicago. I've lived in the Chicago suburbs and in the city my whole life and have never found anything better than this local hotspot.The tangy vinegary secret sauce on their wings is totally standout and something you literally crave for over and over again. I trek out here just to get these wings and from this specific location. (their Howard Location is just so so.) They offer 3 levels of spiciness to choose from - Mild, Spicy, Suicide. I tend to go with Mild or Spicy because i can't handle a lot of spicy. "Suicide" wings used to be really really spicy (swimming in jalapenos) but from what i heard they are just "really spicy," nowadays as the sauce has changed over the years. The size of their wings is just a 1 star rating - unfortunetely they used to provide huge juicy wings but now they are getting dinkier every year.Whatever, the sauce makes up for it. Atmosphere is 1 star too - a total local hole the wall. Get take-out if you're a germaphobe but just know these wings taste best just out of the fryer. If you do carryout, eat the wings with Chinese rice! I know that sounds weird, but many asians i know eat the wings with rice at home and the tangy sauce pairs SOOO well with rice. Other food to get with your wings? - The Waffle Fries are crispy and very good. Recommend getting the cheese on the side if you don't want them to lather it on. - They used to serve Rolling Rock Beer which tasted SO gross with the wings. But i just went today and they are serving Berghoff Pilsner and Berghoff Dark Beer on tap - pairs very well with the wings and washes away the greasiness on your palate. -If you're not a winglover, i heard the burgers are very good here too. Have a Superbowl Party? Their Party Platters are the way to go! I've even seen them at Baby Showers =). CASH ONLY
(5)
Dane K.
TERRIBLE wings. I can't even BELIEVE people--anyone--would recommend them. They're TERRIBLE, disgusting. Some of you people who think they're great must be on some pretty heavy drugs. The sauce tastes like ketchup with a little hot sauce. It's very strange... And there's WAY too much sauce. It's like eating gobbly gook. They're the SMALLEST WINGS on earth!!! Don't take my word for it: I took pictures... One next to a quarter: THE QUARTER IS WIDER THAN THEIR FREAKING WINGS! (and it wasn't just this one wing, they were all that small). I posted them under the business pictures. How can a wing place find such small wings to serve? Are they aborted chickens, or chicks? Are they even chickens? Their spicy wings aren't even hot... then they have "suicide" wings where they're not really any hotter--they just douse them in more sauce--AND ADD GIARDINARE. how disgusting!!! (it might be good drunk food or something, but don't call them buffalo wings) THEY DON'T EVEN HAVE BLUE CHEESE!!! I suppose asking for carrots to go with celery (like you'd get in... Buffalo) would be totally out of the question if they're too cheap to even stock blue cheese! This place shouldn't be allowed to associate itself with wings OR Buffalo, let alone both. The staff wasn't very friendly... I was trying to read the menu and got rushed into ordering. Once we sat down, we overheard a group of people arguing on the other side of the eating area... not just arguing, but standing up shouting in each other faces, ready to punch arguing... the kind of thing where you debated if you should get up and leave, or get ready to dial 911. guess who it was? the staff. The *only* redeeming thing about this place was the waffle fries... they were pretty darn good. They weren't exactly cheap... An order of wings, waffle fries w/ cheese, and two drinks came out to be $17. I want my $17 back. Really. They were that bad. It was one of those meals where you sat and debated if you wanted to finish, or if you would just abort and go elsewhere... we ended up eating more later I'm pretty sure. I've had better wings at Applebee's. If you think the wings here are the best ever, you're really missing out.
(1)
Elizabeth T.
Went here a lot during my college days. Went back after 7 years because my fiance and I had Buffalo Joe's cravings. I have to admit: Wings & fries. VERY VERY GOOD. Price: VERY AFFORDABLE. That's about it. The place is SUPER DIRTY! Get take out but don't stay here.
(2)
Bruce B.
The best wings ever! I grew up with Buff Joes and nothing will be better than them. Get yourself a double order of suicide, buff chips with extra sauce, and a large RC. After you're done eating, you should probably run around the block to burn off the calories. Or, you will be in food coma because it's that good. Be prepared, they wings are not big. However, each one packs lots of taste. They service is always pretty quick. This location is far better than Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. If you like wings and fries (chips), there's none better in the Chicagoland area.
(5)
Sabrina B.
Wings ate delicious. Very greasy though. Wings are not big in size however. A single will be good for one person provides they are hungry.
(4)
Brian J.
What a bizarre place. So they call it "Buffalo" Joe's. That's offensive, in my opinion, being a native Buffalonian (I know you love the way that rolls off the tongue). If you're expecting real buffalo wings, this joint sucks. Period. Skimpy, nasty, sweet, weird wings without blue cheese. That's what comes to my mind now when I think of Buffalo Joe's. Upon entering the rude staff rushed me into ordering and looked at me like I was insane when I asked for blue cheese with my wings. This is when I knew we were in trouble, but we had read good reviews of the place so we figured it was worth a try. The order taking employee told me "they good, you should try them" so, with this ringing endorsement, Dane and I ordered a double order and some waffle fries. I think we ordered them mild but I can't remember because I'm still trying to wash the memory from my mind. Somewhere around this point, I saw the most offensive thing of all - giardiniera on top of a pile of the tiniest wings I've ever seen. Luckily, this monstrosity wasn't ours, but the next order to come out was. The first thing I noticed was the color and excessive quantity of sauce. They looked the color of spaghetti sauce and had were drowned in sauce. The waffle fries looked good (and they were, but deep fried toe jam would have tasted good compared to these wings). Upon arriving at our table, we took the plunge and tasted these tiny, tiny wings. They were so small that we actually had to take a break from eating to laugh about it. We compared the largest wing to a quarter and found the quarter to be wider (see photos uploaded by dane k.). The sauce was sweet and ketchupy. It was at this point when we decided we should consider cutting our losses, dumping the wings in the trash can and finding some real wings but the scary dining room entertainment was too interesting to abandon. I can't stress enough how tiny the wings were. Most of the drumettes, at the big end, were narrower than my thumbnail. Seriously. It was like they were actually pigeon wings. Maybe guinea hens. I'm not sure. Around this time a table started getting loud, every other word being an obscenity (*I* was uncomfortable and I have a mouth like a sailor -- and there were several families with children present). Next thing you know someone threw a tray onto the table and yelled "I told you I'd give you your f-ing money" and there was a verbal exchange that actually scared some people out of the restaurant. As it turns out, this was a table of employees on their break. Nice. I'm from Buffalo and admittedly a tough wing critic; however, these are without a doubt, no question about it, the worst attempt at wings I've EVER tasted. That's a pretty tough distinction to achieve because I've had some really nasty wings. These certainly take the cake. Calling this place "Buffalo Joe's" is false advertising. I hereby make a motion to rename it to "Joe's Ketchupy Pigeon Wing Emporioum" or something along those lines.
(1)
Ed E.
Buffalo Joe's used to be amazing. They fell off a lil but still have pretty good wings. Sometimes I'll go there and their wings are tiny and sometimes they're the way they used to be. I wish they were a little more consistent with their wings but still some of the better ones in the chicago-land area
(4)
Brian M.
Best wings in the area, I'd recommend sticking to hot or mild. Suicide isn't very good, just too much jalapeño not enough good flavor. The cheddar fries are fantastic waffle cut fried slathered in merkts cheese and some seasoning, dipped in their wonderful ranch they go great with some wings. The wing size here seems to vary from order to order but a single order is always plenty for me. Also the buffalo chicken sandwich is delicious here. It's a boneless breast pounded flat and breaded, it tastes like they make it in house, nice clean tasting breading and good fresh chicken breast. Make sure you add cheese on it to enjoy more of the merkts cheese. This is usually a place to grab take out during the lunch hours, the place isn't known for it's decor or seating. I recommend calling ahead when coming here or it can be a longer then average wait for take out places. They should definitely get rid of the cash only rule, I can't tell you how many times I got hit with ATM fees there because I have a real hard time accepting places with any kind of traffic wouldn't want a credit card machine.
(4)
Connie L.
Our first stop for dinner in Chicago was at Buffalo Joes. Our cousins who live in Chicago took us here and we were excited to try some good wings. We ordered the spicy wings with cheddar chips. The sauce was on! It had the right amount of kick and was sauceyyyy! The cheddar chips are waffle fries with melted cheese and they were a good compliment to the wings. Add some celery sticks and beer and the meal was spot on!
(4)
Ernesto R.
Not that impressed with the wings. They contain a ton of butter and the sauce is pretty standard. Also, the place is pretty dirty and should be kept more clean. I do not recommend this place as it might make you sick.
(2)
Jose B.
one day my girlfriend asked me if i liked wings, when i was done ridiculing her for such a ridiculous question (OF COURSE), she told me of this place. We went and for the money you spend you get an irresponsibly large amount of wings, also they have cool waffle fries and the wings themselves have a great taste, my only, and ONLY wish is that the wings were slightly bigger... maybe its better that theyre not or i would be 500lbs!!!!
(4)
Frank P.
I've been coming here for at least 10 years and still the best in Chicago land. Never had anything but wings and chips (fries). Nothing else compares especially the bigger wing chains. I like the medium with jalepenos on the side. I like spicy but like to taste the chicken as well. Place isn't too big and not quite as clean as you would like. But definitely a place I crave.
(4)
Pin Y.
As a Northwestern Alum, I miss this place so much!! You aren't an NU student if you don't go to Buffalo Joe's late a night. I want a Buffalo Joe's in LA! Please????
(4)
Sam W.
Been coming here since high school. Hands down the. Best wings I've ever had. Hidden secret, try the cookies at the counter if you have room after stuffing your face with wings. Oh yeah and the cheese fries!!
(5)
Lulu R.
I have been coming to buffalo Joes for a long time now. Sure, their wings have become much smaller. We can't do anything about it. On the bright side, their sauce hasn't changed one bit. The waffle fries are perfectly seasoned and piping hot and fresh. Back to these amazing wings. I am still proud of this place despite their ever shrinking wing size. Every time I have a friend from out of town, I take them here. The sauce makes it worth while. My friend loved the wings so much....i believe he moved here for them! (Maybe) The problem is the staff is on the rude side and they are really stingy on the ranch/ bleu Cheese. They do not take credit cards. The drinks (unless otherwise ordered) come heavily iced. The place is tiny and needs to desperately be remodeled and updated to 2009. The bathrooms are kinda clean. You would think I would give this place 3 stars considering the negatives I have for this place...right? WRONG. I love these wings so much that I will STILL, despite the negatives(which are pretty serious in most peoples books, give this place 4 stars. For 24 or so wings its $10 bucks For 15 its like $7 Try them....make the trip... you won't regret or forget the adventure you and your taste buds go on. word to the wise: Check out the waffle fries (omg, that rhymes hahahaha)
(4)
Justine L.
Good cheap food! Mild wings were surprisingly spicy and perfect. The single order had 10 wings! The burger was good as well- particularly enjoyed the bun.
(4)
daynia S.
I absolute love their classic version of buffalo wings. The chicken is not battered like Hooter's. The sauce is what makes the wings so yummy. The fresh cut waffle fries are excellent and always piping hot. Wings and fries ate made to order nothing sitting around under hot lamps. Celery sticks are always cold and crisp like they should be. I've been taking a drive out to evanston for at least 10 years since I discovered this spot. It's not healthy so I only go once or twice a year but it's always worth it. Recipe has never changed. The only minor complaint I have is some times that the wings are small in size.
(4)
Kat T.
I thought this place was alright. I did not feel like there was anything special about the place nor ws the selection of sauce very unique. Not a bad place.
(3)
Al D.
Merk's cheddar on an Italian Beef??? It's provolone unless I ask otherwise. Fail.
(3)
Joseph C.
STILL BAD!!! My name is Joe and I am from Buffalo and this place is misnamed. If you serve ranch with your wings you should not be allowed to use Buffalo in your name. Mid-West Joe's fried Chicken is the proper name. yuck
(1)
Tanya G.
I have had buffalo joe's since freshmen year of high school (9 years) and no wings have ever been able to top theirs. Personally I think that mild is the best! Its always a treat to go there with a friend and for them to taste exactly what I've been talking about :) Staff is always very friendly, always bustling with customers. ONLY tiny constructive criticism I have is that you have to be prepared to always have cash. They do not take credit/debit for payment and its always been like that. Seems like a very successful restaurant chain, really wish they would upgrade to this. Would make it a lot easier and convenient for customers versus running to an atm nearby...
(4)
Meinard C.
Buffalo Joe's is less of a restaurant and more of an establishment, dare I say it? A childhood friend. Sure we've had our rough patches and times when we haven't seen each other in ages. But it's always something you can depend on. I've been going to this place since I was in high school back when boy bands roamed the earth and gas was a dollar. The prices of the wings, like my waistline, have crept up since. Back then I could've taken on a single pan by myself, but nowadays I limit myself to a single order. I usually get 'suicide' (Which is hot with jalapenos. People swear it's a different sauce, but I think that's just the jalapeno pickle juice being mixed in), Waffle cut fries with cheddar sauce (OMGOMNOMNOMNOM) and regular a RC (no Coke or Pepsi here). I can't say I've had any other things on their menu. I know they exist and I keep telling myself "One day I'll have to try one of those." But that's like going to a strip club for their lunch specials; and like strip clubs, they only take cash. This place gets a solid 4 from me, and it gets awarded the mystical +1 of nostalgia; perhaps even a +2 but yelp doesn't let me do 6 stars.
(5)
Brian L.
I've been there about three times and truth be told, I'm afraid to go back. Each time the wings have progressively gotten smaller. I looked at my friend's plate and found one that was literally the size of a Jolly Rancher. If they start supplying larger/better quality I will definitely boost up their rating but as it stands now a solid 3. Their sauce is tangy. I love spicy with a bit of sweet. I wish they had a bit more to choose from like a standard New York Buffalo sauce though. I like them vinegary too!
(3)
Hoang L.
If you like your wings drowned in sauce, then you'll love Buff Joe's. But I cannot say this is the best wings, so I cannot give you 5-stars. Plus, I find it tough to justify the price of these wings. Don't get me wrong, I love eating here, but I think people hype it up too much. The wings are medium sized. The celery on the side is okay. Gets pretty crowded and kinda of annoying when you can't find a place to sit.
(4)
Chris B.
When I travel to Chicago, I always try and stop on by here. My friends in high school used to rant about coming here and filling up on wings. I come and I get the suicide wings and boy are they spicy! Fortunately they come with some ranch and celery to put my fire out! Sure as hell beats KFC and Popeye's for wings! Service could be a little more friendly.
(5)
Ben W.
I have been coming to Buff Joe's since 2006, and I must say that the quality of the wings and service is in rapid decline. The wings seem to be getting smaller and smaller(check out photos 11 and 12). Also the price is constantly on the rise. In 2006 the price was 8.99 for a double order, it went to 9.99, and is currently at the outrageous price of 12.99. Sadly Buff Joe's has lost over 75% of my business. GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER!!!!!!!!
(2)
Brandon R.
They're not the biggest wings. They're not the meatiest. But, without question, they're my favorite wings. That's Buff Joe's in a nutshell. Personally, I LOVE spicy wings. I want to sweat when I'm eating. I want nasal passages as clear as... something that's really clear. Sure, you've read people rave about the suicide wings here (their spicy sauce with a heaping pile of jalapenos on top). They're not too bad. But I'm hear to tell you about the variety that aren't even on the menu: XXX habanero. To this day, I have not found a better combination of heat and flavor. Much like the suicide variety, the XXX habanero wings come with a mountain of sliced jalapenos. About those jalapenos: they are EASILY the best jalapenos in the world. I don't know how much of that is due to the fact that they're slathered in buffalo sauce, but I could eat these suckers by the spoonful. I look at them in the same light as Superdawg's grilled onions: a simple addition to a meal that takes it to the next level. Two final things that must be mentioned: - The ranch. Insanely good. When it comes to ranch, I definitely lean towards the more 'liquidy' side. Especially for wings. Buff Joe's does not disappoint - just get extras though, because you'll want it. And if you go XXX habanero, you'll need it. - Cheddar chips, all day, every day. It's like the opposite of my ranch preference: I despise drippy, nacho cheese on fries. Buff's uses some actual melted down cheddar. The final product is about as good as it gets in the cheese fries world. And such a delicious world it is. Ignore the haters and make Buff Joe's your #1 priority next time you're in Evanston. Which hopefully won't be for a while because I have no clue what you do in Evanston besides eat at Buff's.
(5)
Drew D.
So, I've been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. That would mean that it's been about 15 years since I first tasted the succulent spiciness that is Buff Joe's sauce. I've introduced many people to this place, and never had I had anybody come out of here less than satisfied, which I think speaks to the quality of its food. I insist that everybody try the wings just once, even if they're not "wing people," just so they can have the experience. You'd be surprised how many of them are now "wing people" thanks to the gentle nudging! Every time I'm here, I tell myself I'm going to get something different...but when it comes down to it, I always have to go with my usual: single spicy, cheddar chips, and a mega size drink to wash it all down. Waiting for my food seems endless, and when I finally get to chomp down on my first wing, it's like tasting it for the first time all over again. There is a veritable explosion of spices in my mouth, and after the initial heat, the flavors come through like gangbusters. I tend to dislike wings that are hot for the sake of being hot. I find that they have little to no flavor once the heat passes, and for me, that sort of misses the point. The wings from Buff Joe's are fantastic for following up heat with flavor, and that to me is the hallmark of a good wing. Small wings? Perhaps, but I really don't care, because I've never left feeling any less than stuffed. And satisfied. It's the perfect prelude to sauntering over to the Lakefill and walking off some of the meal. :)
(5)
Gary M.
Service is what you would expect from a place like this. The wings are awesome..
(5)
Varun M.
So far I've had Buffalo Joe's food on take out twice and both times i was disappointed. I love wings, i'm addicted but bad wings well they are very disturbing. Growing up in Upstate NY (Rochester) I love to try wings wherever I go and Buffalo Joe's, you are heart breaking. At the end of the day the wings have a few key ingredients 1) The Sauce 2) Cooking Times 3) The actual wing quality used Buffalo Joe's fails on ALL THREE. First off the Sauce is not very spicy, it has a very vinegar based taste and doesn't taste like any good (or bad) buffalo sauce i've ever had. They are usually served very dry without much additional sauce. Looking at cooking times, they definitely over fry the all the wings. Good Buffalo Wings are crispy on the outside but pretty soft on the inside...unfortunately on both occasions i feel like i'm eating crispy chicken every time. Last the quality of the wing used, I have a strong feeling they aren't using fresh wings but the frozen ones you find at the super market. The wings they serve, the meat is very often stuck to the bone and you'll find the bone's break very often when you eat them. THIS IS A CLEAR SIGN that the wing is of low quality. I do like the fact that they are small and not like other places where a wing is larger than a drumstick but unfortunately they need a new supplier. They do have some good variety and I know they have made a good living because frankly, Chicago doesn't wings. Plus on a college campus, this is perfect food but with the BWW opened up around the corner I think Buffalo Joe's is going to be in for some tough competition.
(2)
Amy L.
Came here recently after going to the Great Lakes Naval Base. Mmmh, I was looking forward to some cheddar Chips and some suicide wings. And man, did I get my grub on. The suicide wings were good but I thought the mild taste pretty good too. Next time, it's milds all the way. It has the flavor without having the burning sensation when I potty. Sorry to be descriptive guys. You know you probably think the same thing when you eat hot stuff! DON"T LIE Note:**The wings seems to be a big bigger than the last time I visited Joe's.(Bigger than a quarter) All in all, a thumbs up to visit again.
(4)
Michelle L.
After an extremely disappointing "cheddar fries" experience somewhere else (note to all out there - if you call your dish "cheddar fries" or "cheddar chips" instead of cheese fries, this means that you need to use a real cheddar sauce vs. the generic bright yellow artificial imitation funky-tasting cheese sauce that the others use) I was seriously craving Joe's cheddar chips... ...And I was not disappointed! Not only is the cheddar sauce amazing and real, but the "chips" (fries) seem so fresh, and the skin is still on...they would be good just by themselves (not like I know from personal experience as I only get them with cheddar). As for the wings - they're good, the sauce is great, but I'm not a crazy wing fan. My husband loves them though, he's been eating here for so long and it's great when his wing craving coincides with my cheddar chip craving....
(4)
Frank L.
I'm sorry, but this place was just underwhelming. The two friends who took me to Buff' Joes made it seem like the wings were the best ever. I'm not a hater, but it just seemed to me that they took some chicken wings, threw them in a bowl of hot sauce and tossed it around. I kind of expected some of the seasoning cooked into the chicken. I suppose for the hot-wing lovers, this type of place is best, because you can ratchet up the heat if you like. Oh, and my girlfriend made the unfortunate mistake of ordering a baked potato. What they really meant was "microwave potato". Who goes to Joes? Long-time die hards who grew up on the stuff. People who want to choose the spicy to their hot wings Who avoids Joes? Folks who prefer wings with the flavor cooked into the chicken
(2)
Daniel A.
Great wings, great and fast service, all around-enjoyable. They don't take credit cards, though.
(4)
Dennis P.
The best wings in Illinois. Suicide is the only way! with the jalapenos... with their brand of ranch... my mouth is watering just talking about it...
(5)
Miriam B.
I've been going here since I was a little girl. Great wings, burgers, baked potatoes, cheese chips( waffle cut cheese fries) and awesome chardogs!.
(5)
Mike P.
This would be a 5-star, but for the complete lake of attention I received from the dude taking my order. It's partially my fault as I didn't have my order ready, this being my first visit. So the wing Nazi tuned me out. Anyway, the wings are superb. We had spicy and they were spicy, but not too spicy. Not the meatiest wings, but they give you a ton of them Celery and ranch came with. The cheddar chips great. That was the best fake cheddar cheese sauce I've ever had. I will relish the opportunity too have it sit in my colon for the next 6 months. Thanks, processed food stuffs! You should definitely check out this beautiful little dump. I can't wait to go back to try some sammiches on the menu, with a side of wings and maybe a processed cheddar cheese fry or too. Also, they have RC. My hillbilly soul rejoices.
(4)
Jeff H.
Look. This place is great if you know what you're getting: awesome wings and a lot of them. I love BW3's - my undergrad school had one across the street from our campus; in fact, I think I spent my 21st birthday there, or at least part of it. But BW3's costs a lot more, and whiile there is bigger sauce selection, sometimes you don't want to choose between 20 different flavors - you just want wings and a lot of them. The suicide wings ain't all that hot. They're basically medium-to-hot wings with canned jalapeños atop. I couldn't figure out why they were touted as suicide wings until the next day, where I spent 5 minutes in the bathroom wishing I was dead. But it was worth it. I might go back tomorrow just to show my colon who's boss. Don't come for the ambiance. Don't come for a business lunch. Don't bring your mom unless she can get down with some wings like whoa (and if she can, give her my number).
(4)
Simone T.
I'm from NY, and yes - Buffalo Joe's buffalo wings are the best I've ever eaten. Also the best cheese fries, hands down. GREAT owner AND staff. I love this place!
(5)
Jocelynne G.
I used to LOVE coming here when I was a kid, when it was packed and hyped. I took my friends here thinking it would still be awesome, but the service was downright bullshit. I was charged for tap water. The workers were on their cell phone when we walked in, and they served a few of THEIR FRIENDS before me when I placed my order much earlier. For the amount of food I got I can't believe how long it took. I've never been to such a filthy place. This is not even the city. The wings were good. But then I remember that when the worker was tossing them in the sauce, he wasn't wearing gloves and the sauce was getting all over his greasy unwashed finger which was IN the steel bowl! I also noticed there was a crusty residue in the steel sauce bowl, instead of texting on their cellphones when we walked in they should have taken the time to wash or rinse the nasty thing in the sink. God just... disgusting. And embarassing that I took my friends here. They were completely mortified. :|
(1)
Amy S.
I've heard from most locals Chicagoans that these are the best wings in town. I went, I ate and they were OK. Definitely not the best I've ever had, but not the worst. I think we ordered the hot and not the 911 (or whatever they were called) and I think the 911 are what people rave about. The hot were not hot and a little too vinegary for my palate. I need burn your mouth off HOT, not just a little hot. I'll go back again to try the 911 and I hope they don't disappoint.
(3)
Neal W.
It really doesn't get any better. Double order spicy w/ a side of chedder fries. Best wings in chicago. Sure it might take a minute to get your food but its well worth the wait.
(5)
Leonard S.
Got a gang of wings to go from here yesterday along w a hot dog and cheddar chips....I've never been inside buff joes before and still hadn't as I stayed in the car, but I've eaten these wings countless times before....I swear the wings were never this small before...some of them laughable but I couldn't stop eating them because of the sauce....I'll just get a burger or dog next time w sauce to go....I know a few Sunday chefs who can fry up some wings better than these while putting back a case...I can't believe that's the wings they served hahaha...the merkts cheddar is great!
(2)
Gary C.
Where do I begin?? I've had my fair share of wings and Buffalo Joe's definitely tops the list. I started off on the bottom of the spiciness chain and got the mild. Great flavor, but it was missing that kick. I moved on to hot and I knew I struck gold. Stronger flavor and much more heat. I stayed on this level for a while then built the courage to try suicide. I've never looked back. It's arguably the best wing sauce I've ever tried. The extra heat comes from the jalepeno slices, seeds and all. Not only does this place have great wings, their buffalo chips [seasoned] with cheese is to die for. Ask for some suicide sauce on top and you have some of the best fries in the land. Service is decent. Actually, better than average for this reason: they messed up an order [they gave me a single instead of a double order] but took my name down to give me a free order next time I ordered. No questions asked.
(5)
William W.
Came here with a group of friends last month after my last visit back in the college days. Unfortunately, the wings tasted a lot better back then when fast food was the only meal of choice I could afford. Don't get me wrong, they are still pretty darn good. They are just not at the level of "OMG let's go to BJ's!!!!!" good. We got a party tray of wings for a group of 6 people along with some buffalo chips (fries) and nachos. The flavor was definitely there but the wings' size was simply too small. We also got a small order of "suicide" flavor, thinking that they would be too hot for us. However, that did not impress too much either. Although the spiciness did sneak up on us and we were all sweating by the end of meals. I think I stopped at 20 something wings, which is equally depressing considering I inhaled 35 wings last time I visited. Now, my proudest moment of this visit was making pot of rice and brought a couple containers worth of it with us. Friends have always told us that rice surprisingly tastes good with the wing sauce so I decided that this would be the time to try it. And it did not disappoint!!! It sort of tastes like a Chinese dish of "sweet vinegar deep fried fish". So it certainly pleased the Asian side of me when the wings were just a-ok.
(3)
Elizabeth B.
My ex-boyfriend used to tell me all the time that I have a tiny mouth. I thought he was just flattering himself until my family dentist confirmed that I do indeed have a smaller-than-normal mouth. My tiny mouth is usually not much of a problem. However, it became an issue at Buffalo Joe's when I ordered the bacon cheese burger. I had to eat the grilled onions with a fork, take off most of the lettuce, all of the tomato, and pull out most of the top bun before I could take my first bite. When I did finally get to take my first bite, my burger was barely warm! I ordered the burger medium and it was well done. How exactly did they make my medium burger cold AND well done in less than 5 minutes? It defies the laws of physics. The fries were good but pretty cold. I didn't try my mate's wings, the burger made me lose my appetite for wings. We went to Buffalos Joe's for lunch because we are jobless and poor right now but, next time I will go to a different spot for lunch even if it costs a little more.
(1)
Joe T.
This place serves up some great hometown wings. Whenever we do a house party in Chicagoland we always get these puppies by the pound and bring em' home to serve to the masses. They're great nibbler wings and they have a Suicide flavor with a hot sauce and grilled jalapenos in it. This flavor and the BBQ are 2 of my favorites. When you dine in here - you buy based on the number of wings and the wings are bigger. When you order for a party - they are smaller nibbler wings and sold in aluminum trays by the pound. Either way if you are a Buffalo Wild WIngs fan and looking for another Wings joint in Chicagoland that hits the spot just as well - look no further and try Buff Joe's!
(3)
Darren F.
i been coming here off and on for many years.. it used to be better and more meat in them.. right now the wings is pretty tiny but it is still good.. love the waffle fries and love the burgers here! i dint really like eating inside there because it smells pretty horrible sometimes..
(3)
Joseluis L.
This is my first time ever giving a review. I just had to come and see what everyone else wrote and felt inclined to give my opinion. I was introduced to this place by a couple of friends and they told me these were the most amazing wings they have ever had. We went last friday night and I will start from the beginning... The man begging by the front door was an immediate turn off. Walking up to the cashier was another immediate turn off, she had a very bad attitude. Not only did she talk with a bad attitude but she also wore it on her face. She really acted like she didn't want to be there (I wouldn't want to be at such a filthy place either). Now this I blame on my friends since they did not tell me but they do no accept debit cards/credit cards. I haven't been to place in a long time that doesn't accept (it's 2012 and you still run a cash only place?)...oh well. Also, if they accepted credit cards I would have ordered so much more wings and beer (they were tiny). But I borrowed cash from my friends. I wasn't about to use their atm machine. I get it, you don't accept cards but the owner (I'm assuming he owns that atm machine) is more then happy to charge you that fee for using that machine he installed...nice. I ordered double suicide. I got my food fairly quickly so that was a plus. We then proceeded to sit down at the filthy tables. They have tvs to watch...too bad the one with the loudest volume for some reason was set to a channel with infomercials, huh? The wing sauce was good (it shouldn't be called suicide though, not that hot) but the wings themselves were soooo tiny, laughable tiny. I just pretended they were amazing for my friends benefit. They still were acting like the place was amazing. I didn't dare go to the bathrooms, I didn't want to know what they looked like but my girlfriend did. She came back in seconds after leaving and told me there was urine all over the seat and also that there was a nasty mess inside the toilet because that person didn't bother to flush.... We will not be going back. It's not worth it for great sauce on nasty wings, eaten on a nasty table, and our order being taken by someone with a nasty attitude. No thanks!
(1)
Shelden E.
mmm...yeah, these were good wings, and I did get quite a bit even for the single size version, but the dude worked at the register was such dick. I had ordered a Miller Lite beer when at the counter, but when I got to the register/tap they asked me again. So I changed my mind to the Leinenkugel's Winter ale--the exact same price--and the dude stood there saying, "It says Lite on your order." "Yeah my bad. I meant the Winter Ale. My bad." "It says Lite on the order." "Yyyyeah. I mean is that going to be a problem?" He just rung it up and took the cash. What a jerk. Like I said the wings were good, but I'd almost say they're just as good at Buffalo Wild Wings a few blocks away. Service is better there and more selections on stuff. Oh yeah. Also, the wet naps my friends and I got were all dry in their packaging. It was nice to walk out with the hands that weren't the cleanest.
(3)
Ernie C.
Buffalo Joe's is uneven. I love coming here, but sometimes I wish I just opted for Flattop or any other downtown Evanston eatery. 1. Wings have gotten smaller. 2. Stingy on the ranch/bleu cheese. 3. It is not worth the price. It costs me $12 for wings, fries and pop (me alone). 4. Don't ask for water, cashier is QUICK to tell you.. "We don't give no free water here" and charge you $1.50 for the cup. No lie. 5. Cheddar fries are still good. 6. Somedays food is hot, somedays food is warm. 7. Better than the Howard Street location.
(2)
Krupa U.
Buff Joe's is great! Every time I'm in chicago with friends, we always get a big order of buff joe's wings to pig out on at least one night we're there. I personally love the BBQ flavor, and I guess the Jalapeno would come in second. The wings are actually mini-wings, smaller than Buffalo Wild Wings, but we usually order the party pan for whatever party we're throwing so they are perfect little nibblers to go along w/ your beer or cocktail. Speaking of beer... they sell it! A limited selection mind you, but still, nice to know. Oh and major plus - it still tastes good the day after! Usually reheated wings end up getting dry and shriveled up, but Buff Joe's found a way to keep em tasting good for longer! I commend you, your Wingness!
(4)
Jason C.
When I get a craving for wings, there is only one place that can satisfy it: Buffalo Joe's. I will gladly drive 25 mins from my place to Evanston to get some of their wings because they are the best (in my opinion). You have to make sure you go to the Clark Street Buff Joe's and not the Howard one - I'll explain why later. My order never changes: Single order/suicide and cheddar chips, also served with celery and ranch dressing. If I'm feeling risky I'll also get a Diet Rite. The magic is all in the tangy house suicide sauce with jalapenos, but it's not spicy to the point that you can't enjoy the wings. The cheddar chips are waffle cut fries slathered in a layer of cheddar goodness. I went to the Howard location once thinking that they too would have cheddar chips - FAIL. This is why going to the Clark St location is a must. Reminder: They only accept cash so make sure you have some coin on you!
(5)
Grace B.
My trip back home was not complete until we went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston. By far one of the best wing spot ever. Double order mild w/ buffalo chips and a side of cheese please! You will not find a spot like this in LA. I've been a fan since '94. They keep it nice a simple.
(5)
harry b.
By far these are the best wings in the state, if not the country! Wheather you prefer BBQ, mild, spicy or 'suicide,' go all out and get a double order. If you don't finish them on your first try, they're great the next day. Note that the other locations are not as good as the Clak location. They will do in a pinch, but the extra few minutes in the car are well worth it!
(5)
Leo I.
Buffalo Joe's no more. When there is more bone than meat on the wings, you know it's time to accept that the legendary hole-in-the-wall has seen better days. I've been going to BJ's for quite a few years now. They had some of the best chicken wings I've ever tasted and definitely the best in the Chicagoland area. My last few visits were disappointing and last night's visit was the last straw. Whether it's the economic crisis or the fatigue that drives BJ's decline, decline it is. So long BJ.
(1)
Stephanie F.
Sh*t, man. I'm not even a wings fan but when I was taken here by a wing guru and experienced the melt-in-your-mouth quality of these babies, I felt it in my hips. The cheese fries are fantastic. MMmmmm........the wings are so good that the only descriptive words I can come up with are naughty interjections.
(5)
Jacob J.
Before Buffalo Wild Wings, this was my fix for wings in Chicago land. Suicide, thinking about it has me salivating. That's a ton of hot sauce lathered over wings and then a helping of sliced jalapenos over that. That sauce is great for dipping or just alone. You've got to really dig (vinegar) hot sauce to appreciate Joe's flavors. I can't remember the exact brand of hot sauce, might be Louisiana, they keep jugs of it in plain sight. A perfect order is a double order of wings, a basket of the waffle cut fries and a large drink. (That's large soda pop, not "drink") Tempt fate by getting a few friends together and ordering a full or half pan. That's a catering order of 50-100 wings. Extra wet, the extra better. Joe's however isn't consistent, at times you really love it and other times it's not how you remembered it. Note: during cold seasons it can be cold in the dining area, dress warm or you may have your jacket on while eating. There's something important to mention about payments, I believe it might be cash only, or charge only on orders over $20 +. You may like to inquire when placing phone orders. (This may have changed) Crowd is all Northwestern Univ peeps and locals. If you go late night expect to get harassed by street walkers. Not your usual kind either, they have refined tastes and may ask for more than just change, they need to eat too. (One time a guy asked me for change, I bought him some fries, he then tells me he would've rather had the money so he could get some Thai food!)
(4)
d a.
the bathroom is disgusting-reminds me of a prison from a bad tv movie but everything else is great. also the soda is supersized not the normal sizes so unless you're pat fitzgerald thirsty go smaller. great place, great service, food still reasonably priced and great mix of students, 5 year olds with dads, grownups and regulars. the fries are waffle and the cheese on the burgers is spread which is better. cash only and they're open very late. just excellent, but fix the bathroom-with all the little kids it should look better.
(5)
Ngoc H.
You don't know what wings are until you get a taste of Joe's. They come out right from the fryer and are topped with jalapenos if you get them suicide. I wold say some days the wings are better than others, some days juicy and huge, others skinny and disappointing, but you never know until you order. Their buffalo chips are to die for, crispy on the outside tender on the inside waffle fries that are tossed with a delicious seasoning blend. There's this seasoning on them which I can never guess whats in it. A lot of people like the cheddar on them but I would go without. They only take cash, but there's an ATM in there too if you want to be charged for the fee. Not the greatest place for a date but if you are craving wings with a couple friends, it's the place to be.
(4)
Taylor M.
Best drunken buffalo wings ever. Terrible for you, but that's not the point. They are incredible. Get the sauces mixed. Trust me.
(4)
Phil X.
"A single order of hot wings with a side of cheddar chips, extra cheese." I come here when I want buffalo wings...or when I want to negate any of my previous efforts at my local gym. I don't know too much about the rest of their menu. The hot wings here are tasty. I usually order 'em hot. If you order the "suicide" version, they take the "hot" and throw a bunch of peppers all over it. G'head and try it. Your colon will thank you. The wings themselves tend to be small sometimes. It's all about the sauce though. (That should be a bumper sticker) The BBQ wings are pretty good too. They're sweet, NOT hot. On the side, I always order cheddar chips with extra cheese. They are waffle-fries. The cheese is a melted sharp cheddar. You will either love the cheese...or you will hate it. I wash it down with grape pop.
(4)
Jeff H.
Hands-down the best wings I've ever had, and I've had them at about every place that is supposed have even passable wings. Perfectly fried, perfectly sauced. The best part is they don't bread them. Breading, in my humble opinion, is an amateur move. Breading is fine on chicken fingers, but it has no place on wings. The sauce...holy sh*t, the sauce. My theory is that BJ's sauce has three key ingredients - 1) Crack cocaine 2) Heroin 3) The tears, sweat ,or semen of some cosmic deity. Now, I see that some of the reviews bash BJ's for the wing size. I'll admit that these aren't great big, super meaty wings, but therein lies the genius. Ya see, I can say in all honesty that every place I've ever been where you get big, meaty wings, is that you usually just end up tasting the chicken which is usually low quality to begin with. When I eat wings I want a perfect wing-to-sauce ratio with the sauce having just the right consistency to cling to the wings. Buffalo Joe's has this ratio perfected. My friends and I have brought many, and I mean MANY people here to put it to the test and they've all loved it. In fact, out of all of our friends and acquaintances who've had BJ's only one of our buddies doesn't care for it, which isn't bad out of the large number of us who love it. I even know several people who - while claiming to be vegetarian - make an exception for these wings-from-above. Finally, to make your BJ's experience complete, get some waffle fries and a Gut RC and you have the makin's of a superbly unhealthy, but decadent meal. It's worth the drive from Chicago, I assure you.
(5)
Mr. C.
I'm not sure what has been happening here lately, but since I started coming here 3 years go the wings seem to be getting smaller and the employees ruder. Don't get me wrong they have one of the best buffalo sauces around, but my last visit was not a good one when I was taking one bite off each wing since they were so amazingly small. It's like they got their chicken wings from baby chicks that haven't fully developed yet, which made the entire recent experience kind of nauseating.
(3)
David T.
I've been a regular customer of Buffalo Joe's ever since I've moved to area in 2001, when I first heard they were the best wings in the city. They never disappointed ... until now. For some reason, my last five visits or so (I average about one visit per month, always driving more than 25 miles just to get my fix) the wings have been pretty sub par, almost bad in some cases. I would usually finish my single suicide order w/ waffle fries and crave more, but the wings have just been severely lacking lately. I can't put my finger on it, it might be the shrinking size of the wings, which were already pretty small to begin with. There's also been a few occasions where the pieces look deformed, neither looking like a traditional drumstick or wing, so I just throw them out. The sauce is still as good as ever, I just think they've somehow cut some costs and used a cheaper, less tasty wing now. I would usually recommend Joe's highly to any one who hasn't visited the place yet, but now I'm not so sure. Hopefully their act picks up again.
(3)
Abhist D.
I love Buffalo Joe's wings. I used to eat them a lot during high school and hadn't had them in quite a while. Well I lost a bet to a despicable Sox fan and had to pay up with Buff Joe's wings. Let's just say that this is one bet that I wouldn't mind losing over and over again! I mean...the wings are delicious! Heck, even my wife (who can't stand wings cuz she's never liked the tast) loved them. And I mean LOVED them. They're good. Service is what you'd expect from the joint, which means its quaint in its own way. Oh...and suicide wings are the way to go (and they are NOT THAT HOT!)
(5)
Bless P.
Outstanding and THE best chicken wings and fries I've ever tasted!!! Very casual and a long wait if there is a game scheduled.
(5)
Aimee C.
yes, yes and more yes! When I'm dying for some good old fashion buffalo wings, the trek to Buffalo Joe's is worth every painstaking moment. From their suicide sauce to their waffle fries, it's a treasure to devoured. Better than all the rest... Hot, saucy and delicious.. wings flying as elbows are up in the air. Don't try to talk to me, because I'm deep in sauce and can't be bothered. :) talk to you when my fingers are licked and the grin of complete satisfaction is plastered across my face. -- ps take a zantac.. the sauce will definitely get your tummy rumbling.
(4)
Albert C.
I love this place!! I've been going here for such a long time.. the single order is such a big portion and I always mixed bbq & suicide sauce!! Don't forget to get their buffalo chips aka waffle fries with the cheddar cheese! For $10.10 AMAZING!! Their cookies by the counter are amazing also! They're actually freshed baked daily but it looks old in the container
(4)
Janice L.
yumyumYUM. the suicide wings are the best, heaped on top with jalapeno peppers. the flavor is the best of all the wings i've ever had. also, i'm not a fan of breaded wings and here, it's naked, so perfect. one downside, sometimes some of the wings have absolutely no meat. i wish they fattened the chickens a little more, they're like anorexic! anyways, dip the wing into the ranch sauce, take a bite, aahh.. bliss (:
(4)
Precious B.
What can I say Buff Joe's never fails wings and fries all day!
(5)
Vanessa D.
I think this is one of those places that you can only truly appreciate if you've been coming here since you were in high school or college. Despite growing up in the area, I never set foot into this Buffalo Joe's until this year. I've been twice now. The spicy wings are good. And they have RC cola, which is always a pleasant surprise. However, I found the actual wings to be awfully small with not much meat. Additionally, their cheddar chips which I had high hopes for were soggy and gross both times. I had been assured that they typically were not like this... so, who knows. But, the place has character and they have a full menu of things I haven't yet tried, so I will definitely give them another chance.
(3)
Bridget M.
Quite yum. The wings are good, but are decidedly not truly spicy. They douse these guys in sauce which adds to the overall appeal. The cheese fries are a must do. Major props for the real cheddar cheese chunks accompanied by the jalapeno slices. The burgers are greasy and delicious; I'm not a big fan of the kinds of buns they use. Pretty good deal for what you spend. Just wish they'd invest in having a paper towel roll at the table a la Hooters and a credit card machine. Buyers beware, this is a cash only joint!
(4)
Eric M.
I'm giving them four stars within their genre, which is fast-food, with a heavy emphasis on wings. I went here for the first time last weekend. Not having been before, I don't know what size the wings were "back in the day," but I don't really give a damn about wing size when they just scoop a bunch up and don't count them. 20 small wings vs. 10 huge wings - who cares. If anything I like wings for the skin anyway, so more small ones usually means more skin, more deliciousness and more satisfaction! I thnik these are some of the best-tasting wings I've had. I do like blue cheese dressing better than ranch, but the wings themselves matter a whole lot more than the side sauce does. I don't live close, so I can't say I'll be a regular or anything, but I liked them well enough that I'll definitely be back, maybe even for a special trip now and then. I do have one complaint - the cheese fries were not up to par. The cheese congealed and became a gooey, cold mess way to fast. And the fries themselves weren't that great, either. Making good fries isn't rocket science and I think people let restaurants off easy too often for sub-par fries.
(4)
Demetrio P.
Went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston last night for the gazillionth time, and it never disappoints! Usually order a single order of suicide wings and waffle fries....hmmmm...just thinking about it is making me crave it again. Prices have risen over the years, but still budget friendly. I can't vouch for the other items on the menu, but why go to a buffalo wings place for anything other than, well, buffalo wings! Overall, good food, okay prices, and okay service.
(4)
eric l.
I don't know whether it was the hype, but the wings were just whatever. Ranch dressing was watered down. Also, their portions are measured in a weird way. They just eyeball the number. Number of freakn double order and the single order of wings were the same. Never get a double order, unless you don't know where to spend all your money and want to get overcharged. Service wasn't bad but neither good. GET CASH before or else get ready to pay an extra 3 bucks for the ATM fee (worst way to spend 3 bucks). I would say it is better than bw3 but not hooters.
(2)
Jason P.
Ok, so lets start this by saying I am a vegetarian reviewing a chicken wing place. For those of you that did not immediately stop reading, enjoy! Ok, this place has a pretty diverse menu outside of the chicken wings. The best part are the heart attack cheese fries, called chips. They will throw hot sauce on them and cover them with jalepenos as well to make heartburn heaven. They also have these giant cookies that are extremely awesome. The best part of being a vegetarian there is that you can go straight to the register and cut the line. My omnivore friends that actually wait in line say that the wings are fantastic as well. The only downside is that if you get water, I think it is something like 10 cents and they pack so much ice in there that you have to go get more every sip. Also, one recommendation is that you bring someone who smokes with you. It is the best way to interact with the greeters that stand outside (persons sans homes) as generally they will be satisfied with bumming a smoke off of your smoker friend. Trust me, it works everytime.
(4)
Paul d.
So after countless hours at the gym training for a 10 mile race and then finally getting to that wondrous day and reluctantly running it, what would any one in their right mind do? Feed your face with the most unhealthy food you can find, of course!. After a long debate between OCB (Old Country Buffet for you not in the know) and BJs, we ended up making the trek over to Evanston. I'm going to cut straight to the food; let me tell you, after ten grueling miles, you deserve any treat you get. This treat happened to be in the form of a double order of spicy wings, spicy cheddar fries, and a bacon cheddar burger. The wings are smaller than normal (about the same as BW3s size, if not smaller) but the crunchiness of the skin, lean meat and amazing sauce were in perfect unison. The spicy cheddar fries were good as well - waffle fries, cheddar (real cheddar btw, no gloppy manufactured cheese topping here), hot sauce and jalapenos on top. Bacon cheeseburger was standard except for the fact they again they used real cheddar - somewhat greasy but good nonetheless. Only thing I would change about this place are the napkins! How do you expect to eat wings, cheddar fries and a cheddarburger without half of it ending up on your face? Then they insult you with these dinky little napkins like the ones they used to give you in grade school. Next time I'm bringing a bib, a bottle of Purex and a hand towel! Tip: Leave the credit card at home, it's cash only here.
(4)
Paula B.
I had their special burger today for lunch and it was great! I've been there numerous times before and love their wings, their beef sandwiches, and their stuffed potatoes! Yummmm Their cookies are the best too! I think it's got good reasonable food. It's cash only though. There is an ATM there in the restaurant though if you need it.
(4)
Rob S.
This is probably the one spot I miss most since moving from the city out to the 'burbs. Buffalo Joe's defines buffalo chicken wings in my book. They are the benchmark, and few, if any can compare. Double order of Spicy, the waffled fries, and a Gut Lemonade are my standing order. I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's for over a decade, and there is na reason for this.
(5)
Giselle S.
I must be hard wired since my first taste in high school. The truly mouthwatering wing that bears your name makes one drool and dream for the delights. This place has been a neighborhood gem for many years. I would have to say that since the beginning weeks of football season there is nothing that can compare to a BJ and a beer! I know why the sexual innuendo (it's not my usual style:) ....b/c it is true, football season or not this place is the best. These wings rock. Single and Double orders or Single Party Tray or Double Party Tray. Suicide sauce on the side use to house whole jalapenos and now are chopped up and still so delicious. On my latest excursion to this place I placed the order over the phone thinking how the occasion called for an order that fits b/t Double order and Single party pan. My subconscious wanted the Single party pan for plenty of leftovers and to make sure no one was left without their fill. The practicality of it all was no need to spend more than what was needed. I ordered over the phone and was told it would be 10-15 minutes. By the time I picked up my order and pay (CASH ONLY) I ordered $50 worth of tantalizing wings. Pleasant surprise on my part. My subconscious won in the end and my longing for Joe's was satiated for the time being. :) Luckily, the gathering was a success, (I can not say the same for the Bears), and no leftovers to take home. Eat in and cafeteria style until you pay for your order and catch the game in the eatery on flat screen. Enjoy!
(5)
afro d.
i must be a gluten for punishment... i tried to go again hoping somethings have changed. but it had gotten worse. the wings were no bigger than a quarter. now the part it got worse is that its super dirty when i got there. a cart with dirty stuff in a bus tub in front of the reg. behind the counter it was filthy. not i went there about 11:30pm.. i learned my lesson. no more.
(1)
Angela H.
The hot I got was not quite hot enough. Should have gone with suicide. Their fluffy baked potato has had me craving baked potatoes with my wings ever since. It's sort of a divey place and mostly full of teenage boys and hard-working men. I was certainly a fish out of water, but acted like I belonged. Waffle fries looked amazing. I'll go back and give it another try. Didn't find anything to be dirty, and enjoyed my food.
(4)
Erin N.
Sans car, I don't get up to Evanston much anymore. But I had the pleasure of going there recently when my gf borrowed the car from her parents for the weekend. Like I mentioned earlier the wings have changed since back in my high school days (10+ years ago). But let me tell you this- I ate my single order of wings faster than I have ever eaten wings in my entire life. They were that good compared to the stuff that bars try to serve you in the city. They are a bit tinier than wings you'd get anywhere else, but I like that rather than the JUMBO wings that throw off the meat to sauce ratio and always seem kind of rubbery. I'm taking Buffalo Joe's down one star for their rude behavior towards my gf who brought a Papa John's pizza in. I was a paying customer (single order, RC, and spicy cheddar chips*) and she came to sit with me. On top of that, she also purchased a drink from them! She wasn't taking up space that could have been used by another patron- and it's not like her eating of her pizza would have caused BJ's to lose customers. They were just plain turdley to her. *not as good as I recall, but this might be due to the fact that by the time I got around to eating them my stomach was expanding from the rapid wing consumption.
(4)
Orack B.
When we started going to Buffalo Joe's back in the day we were so high on a number of different possible intoxicants that one would think we would not fully enjoy the experience. I am here to refute any such claims. We fucking loved it! Now 15 years later I still love it like I did back in my youth. The sauce is really what does it for me. I like the succulence of the sweetness followed by the bite of the heat. I always order suicide - although the heat varies from time to time and also depends on how many jalapenos you eat - I yearn for something hotter. This brings me to a Buffalo Joe's story circa '99 when I was offered habanero pepper wings. Now circa '99 me and my buddy were so high, and lovers of spice, that we said yes. What ensued was absolute hilarity. Each bite of wing rendered us delirious for ten minutes. We were in our own worlds, laughing uncontrollably between each bite. I believe capsaicin increases the effects of Jah Ganja at least tenfold. It was pure bliss! Now back to the food. Single suicide, sometimes a double if I feel extra large, cheddar chips and a gut RC. This is my definition of a fleeting paradise, consumed with such gusto it is almost a travesty. Big shouts to my man Dean behind the counter.
(4)
Peter R.
I had to run some errands in Evanston, and you know what that means!!! BUFFALO JOE'S all up in, and around my face!!! I stopped by the Chase ATM because this place only takes cash money. I strolled in with a Cheshire Cat grin on my face and ordered the single order spicy, and a smokehouse burger. I know, I know, I'm such a hippo, but I didn't eat lunch I swear!!! I validated my artery clogging meal by ordering a gut buster size Diet Rite, just to even things out. I plopped into one of the booths in the back, watched some ESPN on the big flat screen and waited for them to call my name. "Diego!" "Diego, single order with smokehouse burger!" If you know me, or if you look on the upper left of this review, you notice my name is not Diego. I always give them a fake name, just to keep things lively. I went back to my seat and got down to bizzzzness. Ah, the spicy delectable joy of these tender chicken morsels. The buffalo wings have that, "make your nose runny" heat on them...delicious. My smokehouse burger was very good, with the grilled onions, bacon, bbq sauce, and cheese, all coming together in splendid bliss. If you are ever in Evanston, and you love buffalo wings, you HAVE TO stop by. Buffalo Joe's is spicy chicken nirvana.
(5)
Kristin M.
I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but in my opionion the wings are too greasy and have way too much sauce on them. The sauce had a little too much sweetness to it and there were jalopenos in it, which is just not right... And I thought we had asked for blue cheese dressing, but it tasted like ranch-that's just not the way it should be! The cheesy fries, however, oh my! I was in heaven! I'd go back for that!
(3)
Nate C.
Its been years since I've been first introduced to this place and I have yet been disappointed. yum Yum! I love eating there while the food is nice and fresh. Then when I'm done with my spicy wings, I can always get an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie. The waffle cheese fries are yummy, the celery stix are yummy. Everything is just yummy. I guess you can say its one of my favorite wing joint.
(4)
Martha M.
Buff Joes is AWESOME. Let me give you a few pointers. 1. Call your order in ahead of time, otherwise you will most likely wait awhile. 2. They only take cash! There is an ATM but it charges you an obscene amount of money. 3. If you are gong with a few people and you all want the same sauce, get the double orders, instead of single orders. You'll save a few bucks. Maybe you could give the money you save to the bum who is always standing outside. 4. Have patience! Buff Jo's is always full of rude and obnoxious high schoolers and even ruder and more obnoxious Northwestern students. A word on the cheese fries. They are so so good! They have regular cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce and then they have the uber-amazing Spicy Cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce, buffalo sauce and jalapenos. delicious!!!
(4)
Kristen B.
Went here for the first time today and really enjoyed it! After running into a former Evanstonian yesterday who was appalled by the fact I still hadn't been here, we decided we should go. I was a little leery about it after reading some of the reviews thinking my friend was just guiding me to a place that was great during her high school days but had passed its glory days. I'm glad that I went against my better judgment. The wings were great, I can't say that they were the best I've ever had but definitely up there. Hubby and I shared a double order of spicy wings, cheddar chips (waffle fries smothered in cheese) and a side of spicy sauce for cheese fry dipping pleasure (this is also a great way to enjoy Buffalo Chips with Cheese at BWW.) The cheese was a little oddly sweet, but other than the meal was tasty. Nice meaty wings with a lot of sauce. We got 20 in our $10 double order. I will take away one star because things seemed to take a really long time. While not entirely their fault (U of Wisconsin's Lacrosse Team dropped in for lunch and another large group was there also) it did seem to frazzle them quite a bit and at one point a tub of raw chicken wings were dropped onto the floor. I will definitely go back for the wings and to try a "char dog."
(4)
Mike D.
I was quite excited to try out buffalo joes after many recommendations and drooling over it on yelp. I ordered the Spicy and BBQ thinking I'd try half and half. I was asked if I wanted a mix. Thinking that would get me my half and half situation, I agreed. What I got was delicious flavor heaven. The spicy and the sweet of the BBQ and hot sauce was an amazing combination. My only complaint is that their wings are definitely on the small side. However, the taste was great and it was a no frills process to get in, out and eating my wings.
(5)
Joe R.
This place hits the spot. come with a couple of friends and an appetite. the wings arent the biggest but the sauce really opens up the meat. they are well fried and are the ideal comfort food for a day of drinking or just to unwind after a long day. the suicide wings are the best and have a decent kick to them especially with the jalapeno's. service is good and nothing goes better with wings than dark beer. I look forward to hitting this place up when I can.
(4)
Doctor L.
As a Northwestern U. alum, absolutely nothing in this world makes me more nostalgic to head back to Evanston than Buff Joe's. As college students this is where we'd go whenever we got paid, whenever the dorm cafeteries were closed on Sunday nights, and/or whenever we got drunk and/or stoned. Or any combination of the above. Junk food connoisseurs know that grease is supposed to have its own FLAVOR, not just texture, and not just compliment other flavors. Perhaps no other restaurant in the world appreciates this more than Buffaloe Joe's. The wings are awesome, especially if you're having a party and buy them by the tray. I fondly recall multiple occassions when I saw fraternity pledges being sent there from as far away as Michigan and Missouri by their homesick Chicagoan brothers to pick up as many trays as could fit in their car. As other Yelpers have astutely pointed out, the genius behind Buff Joe's is that they appreciate spice while at the same time understanding that spice by itself is not a flavor. These wings have zest as well as heat. There's a huge difference between the two. The rich buttery flavor of the wings is only matched by the impeccable waffle-cut cheese fries. Again Buff Joe's has mastered capturing the rich greasy flavor of both the fry AND the processed cheese sauce to make this delicious side order a worthy meal in itself. As you'd expect, your ass WILL be on fire after dining here. Do not go to Buff Joe's on a date, before a date, or before any event where you will not have the opportunity to run to the bathroom every 5 minutes (ie: mid-term, final, movie, concert, orgy, etc.)
(5)
Michael M.
Even though this place can really cause havoc on your stomach with the spices it still is by far my favorite wing place in Evanston. My sales guys and I frequently will order this place for lunch, (Mild for Lunch) Don't want to kill the staff...LOL!!! Always get extra Ranch and there is never enough, and it is so good. Also try their baked potatoes they are surprisingly perfectly cooked ever time. All in all A+ in my book. - Greasy Spoon FYI, so don't expect anything fancy!
(5)
Alex Z.
I wish they served more different sauces, like that one big chain place to the southwest does. They are very good at what they do serve, though. I get spicy every time (or whatever the one in the middle is called). Single order is enough, and it comes with free celery (which is actually fresh!) and ranch dip. The texture of the chicken and the taste of the sauce are amazing. Hot dogs are meh, I heard the burgers were great but I've never gotten one. Beverage choices could be improved (RC is still in business!?!?), and not taking cards is a bit of an annoyance. Sometimes the people who take your order are condescending and mean, other times they are great. I like that poster in the waiting area that says "No bird soars too high if he soars with his own wings".
(4)
Kelsey M.
Let me tell you folks who didn't grow up in Evanston something, back in middle and high school, you could NOT have a classroom party without Buffalo Joe's. It just wasn't a party without. It's an Evanston institution, and rightly so. I am not normally a wings person, but these are DELICIOUS! So good. You are not a true Evanstonian if you haven't eaten here.
(4)
Candyce P.
I'm a huge wings fan. I've had them at most sports bars, of course at BW3 and my Dad grills some spectacular Portuguese wings. That being said, I'm picky about the way the wings are fried (or grilled) and the combination of spices used. Jason C. made plans for us to meet at Buffalo Joe's for lunch, with promises of the best wings. I was a bit skeptical, but excited to try them out. It's quite a casual setting: order at the counter, pick up you order when it's done. I got the single order of spicy wings, with cheddar fries and a Sprite. I also only order the "flat" pieces of the wing if I can, and they gladly obliged. (Some places give me the stank eye for requesting only flats). The wings are perfectly crispy, and the "single order" is huge! (I'd say about 12 wings? and for $6.something it's a steal!) The "spicy" sauce was just what I wanted as well - a deep flavor with a nice kick. The cheddar fries were good as well, but you have to eat them while it's still hot, or else the cheddar solidifies on your waffle fries. Which isn't such a bad thing either. :) Overall, HUGE fan. I'll definitely make the trip out to Evanston for these wings again and again. Note: They accept CASH ONLY, but there is an ATM in-house for those of us who never carry cash around.
(5)
Conrad Q.
I've been coming here since my early college years. I have never been disappointed by the wings. I always get suicide wings, cheddar chips and a gut buster RC. Celery has always been crisp when you dine in but never when you order for take out. They don't keep it separate with the wings. I noticed the wings might be getting smaller, but that could just be the economy.
(4)
Heather B.
If you want wings with taste as well as spice, this is the place for you! I like hot stuff, but I like it to taste like something other than just burning my tongue off!! I love this place despite the fact that it is in college kid central in Evanston. The staff rocks, and obviously love their jobs, because most of them have been there the entire 5 or longer years I have been going there. They even recognize us when we walk through the door!! Their sauce is to die for.... the mild is perfect spice with a bit of kick, spicy is hot and tasty, and suicide is.... well, topped with jalepenos, and makes my sinuses instantly clear. I can't do the suicide for long! For $35 you can buy a gallon of your favorite sauce and use at your discretion. I'm also a big fan of the broccoli cheese soup and buffalo tenders. The soup has the perfect amount of broccoli to cheese ratio, but can be a little greasy sometimes. The tenders are a great way to soak up that wonderful sauce and save some calories! (yeah, not really, but they are better than the wings in that respect) Everyone needs to try Buffalo Joe's if you like wings. You won't regret it!
(5)
Annie S.
LOVE BJ's!!!! I used to come here in high school and their wings, burgers and waffle fries are THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Melt in your mouth good. Dang, this place is so great. I love the suicide wings (very hot) and you have to order the fries (w/ cheese if you like that). The service is pretty fast and there's regular seating in the back. The place is a decent size and almost always I can find a table. Seriously, you have to try this place and get the wings!!!
(5)
James B.
Single order (or double if you a big boy) of spicy wings with some cheddar chips and a grape drink or rc and you will be good. best place for wings on this planet.
(5)
Justin G.
Best buffalo wings in the Chicagoland area (as it's in Evanston...) hands down. The atmosphere is super casual, with employees yelling out names as orders are completed. The wings are not as large as they were 10 years ago, when I started eating there, but they're an okay size. The sauce is what makes it great. Try the spicy, the mild is really very, very mild. The suicide is not as hot as most people seem to think, but the jalepenos on top seem to scare most people away. Good anytime, really. Even thinking about it makes me want to stop over there right now... Addendum: They only take cash. An annoyance, but it certainly doesn't ruin the experience.
(5)
Hilda E.
Love this place, been going for years. Although the wings are small at times...they are big other times. I don't really care about the size because the sauce is amazing....LITERALLY the best I ever had. Buffalo chips aka waffle fries are awesome...always freshly made. RC washes it all down fantastically. Missing 1 star because it is really dirty in that place. It wouldn't hurt to grab a rag and scrub it all down. Seriously. The decor is not bothersome but the dirt is a bit.
(4)
Joyce L.
You can feel your arteries clogging with each bite of a hot wing, but your taste buds will be in euphoria. This is by far, the best buffalo wing place I've ever eaten at, and I have eaten at many a wing place since I grew teeth. We LOVE this place and make it a point to stop by every time we're in Chicago. Why does Chicago have all the yummy food??? THEY ONLY TAKE CASH.
(5)
Madeline H.
Oh my god, junk food does not get any better than Buffalo Joes. I found Buff Joe's through a coworker who recommended I cure my hangover by walking over to this low-key Clark St. location for one of their oh so devilishly greasy burgers. My hangover was instantly cured. Upon returning to work my coworker told me "Now that you've tried the worst thing on the menu, you've got to go back and try what they're famous for: their chicken wings." Let me tell you, that burger was definitely delicious, but my coworker was right, you gotta go for the wings, I cannot express to you how good they are. My best friend and I got here at least once a month on Sunday afternoons to get our wings fix and it is always a delightful experience. Somehow the wings are both crispy and moist and the sauce is out of this world. Spicy is definitely the sauce to order and don't worry it isn't that hot (I am terrible at handling spice and I love it). If you're looking for something sweeter try mild, and if you're a big spice person you have the options of hot and suicide. Also make sure to order the buffalo chips and extra ranch and a gutbuster RC to quench your thirst. Hands down this place is my favorite place to eat in Evanston if not the whole north side, in fact I have to limit the number of times I allow myself to eat here because if I don't it would be an everyday event. The decor is nothing special but it totally fits the atmosphere of the joint. In fact, my friends and I have this theory that if a joint that sells burgers, hot dogs, or wings looks kind of dingy and crappy on the inside, then chances are you're gonna get a great meal and at Buff Joe's this is totally true. On any given day you'll find the place full of college students from both Northwestern and Loyola, families, and locals gathering for a good meal and whatever sporting event is on TV.
(5)
Nate L.
Not bad place for wings in my opinion. Their spicy wings with jalapenos on top... it really hit the spot. not too hot but it was perfectly balanced. Not a good place if you have a big group. Not enough tables for group of 10.
(4)
Douchee D.
I have a friend who is a Northwestern alumni, and it was her who brought me up to Evanston to visit Buffalo Joe's for the first time to try the best wings on the planet. They are without a doubt the best wings I have ever tasted. Now, correct me if I'm wrong ( actually don't ), but these wings don't taste like authentic buffalo style wings. There is a kind of mustardy zing to them, and they serve ranch dressing on the side as apposed to blue cheese dressing. These wings are on the wet side, which is messy and not good for first dates, but how are we kidding; if you're bringing your first date here you're a cheap or poor bastard. Actually, that sounded mean. It could be kind of cute, if it was presented the right way. Oh, just go for it! The waffle cut fries and cheese are addicting. I hope to God no one in my neighborhood starts doing their fries this way, or I'll be as big as a house by year's end. There are other interesting thing that I see going on on other people's trays, but I'm just there for the wings and waffle cut cheese fries.
(4)
Kate W.
I'm only commenting on the wings here... I grew up in Upstate NY, near Buffalo, and worked at a pizza place in high school that made buffalo wings. I know how they're made, and I know what makes them authentic... therefore I'm VERY picky when it comes to wings. This place gets 3 stars only because it's the closest I've come to decent wings in Chicago. They are far from good though. They deep fry the wings which is good, too many places don't. Their sauce is just ok though. Real Buffalo sauce is the easiest thing ever to make, it's just Frank's Red Hot and butter (adjust butter amounts for mild, medium or hot). The sauce here is obviously not authentic and has too much vinegar. They also need to make the wings bigger, the ones we got were pretty small. Lastly, what's with the ranch dipping sauce?! You have to serve blue cheese sauce with hot wings... it's the law.
(3)
B T.
Grat place. Only takes cash. Super busy. Love the cheese fries and suicide wings
(4)
Justin S.
So after a less than thrilling meal at Dixie kitchen I was still full. So off to this wing location that was being spoken of quite highly. I am hoping that what I was served was just off and not the normal fare they serve their customers. The buffalo sauce was lousy, too much vinegar, who knows but it seemed completely off that I couldn't even finish one wing. This place seems to be reserved in the college days, I'm drunk and hungry area. Lets face it after copious amounts of alcohol one will hardly notice nor care the off sauce in these wings.
(1)
Juan A.
the greatest of all time!! best wings, best cheddar chips, best ranch!! This place is so good youll forget the rest. many people might find there reason to complain because wings are small but you get enough to fill you up. Its all about flavor and texture and BJ's does it better than most. Whether you are a wing fan or a flavor fan buff joes is the way to go!
(5)
Charles W.
Wings were solid. Nothing great, nothing bad. However, they had lots of good 50 cent vending machines so I got my money's worth out of my pocket change! I ended up walking out of Buffalo Joe's with a glow-in-the-dark crucifix and a handful of sprees!
(3)
Sonesh S.
Suicide wings quite possibly are the best in the city. honestly, they are that good. I've been eating here for over 10 years now, and while their wings have gotten a bit smaller, the sauce is just as good, and the service still amazes me. The ambiance sucks. Take your food to go...its a terrible place to dine. If you do stay, get a beer. Oh, and get a party pan of celery and ranch...a great way to complement your meal
(5)
Lale S.
My mom worked in Evanston when I was a child, that is when I had my first experience at Buffalo Joes. I have gone there so much with friends and family since my teen years, the manager/owner there knows me by name. Buff Joes has the greatest wings I have ever had, not only does the wing itself rival other places, but the sauce is what puts them over the top!!! I could take a order of wings, cheddar chips and a mega gutbuster of RC anyday of the week! Ive even ordered trays from here for parties ive thrown! I highly recommend this place to anyone!
(5)
Chris T.
Hands down the best chicken wings on the planet.! There is a Mash episode where Peirce gets a hankering for some ribs from some rib joint and has them express mail the Mash 4077 a box of ribs. Well this is the kind of place where I would do that if I was stuck in a war zone halfway across the world. I graduated from Northwestern in 01 and still think about the amazing wings at Buffalo Joe's. I disagree with the comments about too much sauce. The sauce is the best part. Every time I go to Chicago I have to stop up in Evanston for their wings.
(5)
Sangorama s.
I can't imagine any wings being better than BJs. Most other wings taste like the frozen bag of wings you can get at Costco - they're not bad at all, just not all that impressive. We've been going to this place since for over 20 years now and we always get the mild. Don't get me wrong, we love spicy food, but you get the full flavor and enjoyment of the sauce with the mild. You can ask for spicy sauce on the side if you've got to have it. Not exactly sure what kind of freakish, butt burning death wish you have when you order suicide. You know that stuff has to come out of your body at the other end right? If you're not a wings guy then try the buffalo cheddar burger. It's dang good. Same sauce on a fat ole burger with kaukauna cheese spread (is that stuff real cheese?). The soft bun will soak up all the lovely burger juice and deteriorate before you finish so get lots of napkins. Prices are steadily rising and portions steadily getting smaller. There was a time a couple of years ago that the quality of the wings, the chicken itself, was pretty poor and everything was being overcooked and all dried out but they seem to have gotten past that lately. I have to eat here every visit to Chicago.
(5)
Johanna C.
Before having a Buffalo Joe's wing, I had no interest in ordering wings at a restaurant or having them at parties. I've had one here and there and never understood what the big deal was. A friend kept raving about how I would crave BuJoe's wings if I try them. Sadly, he was right! The sauce is really really tasty. You get a fair amount of meat on them. I like them soaked up in the sauce so the meat falls off the bone, which is usually the way you will get them in their busy hours. I went here late on a Friday night once (yay, they close at midnight on Friday and Saturday nights!) and the wings were on the crispier side. Not bad but different. A single order of wings will set you back about $7 and a double order about $11. That includes wings, celery and ranch dressing. The ranch tends to be more on the watery side but does the trick. The Buffalo Chips (waffle fries) are also very good, probably because they are waffle fries. The only other meal I've had here is the hot dogs on special. Don't get that. You may as well just make it at home. Just go to Hot Doug's if you want a hot dog! Bottom line - order the wings! Supposedly the burger is good as well but I can't get myself to order anything but the wings...
(4)
Neil A.
Maybe they would have gotten more stars if they were willing to sell me wings. Basically, whenever I have called, they aren't taking orders for pick-up until time X... Call back, still not taking orders... (and repeat). Maybe I should just eat there, but the place looks disgusting, and I like dirty pizzeria pizza - so maybe the wings are great - but I don't think I'll ever find out.
(1)
A.J. M.
What needs to be said? Wings are wings, and Joes has got em and does them very very well. Hell, they even have some beer on tap here. Oh, and try out the waffle fries some time. They're pretty awesome too.
(4)
Gigi L.
That's right, I'm giving it five stars, people. I only come here once a year. On my birthday, which is in May. In February I start marking the days off with a "x" with my black sharpie pen, as the anticipation builds. I can't come here more than that, because then I might be dead. Maybe not quite dead, but I KNOW my butt wouldn't fit through as many doorways. It is delicious though. Spicy as hell, well really as spicy as you want. Sometimes I like it when my head blows off. You get a really generous portion of tender, perfectly textured chicken pieces that melt in your mouth. And then it catches on fire. But then you dip into that blue cheese sauce. And then all is right with the world. Actually, your mouth is still burning, but you can drink milk to clear that right up. They have these amazing waffle fries that you can get with that Merkt's-type cheddar sauce on top. It isn't really saucey, it's more creamy and thick. On top of those hot golden potatoes, it actually is like a religious experience. I am coming back as a fry in my next life. The place is dingy and dirty, and everything is covered in a fine layer of grease. You come out stinking like a vat of oil where tremendously tasty things have been cooked for your eating pleasure. Good times.
(5)
Chris J.
Wow, totally going down hill. The wings are still great, but everything else is sub par. If this were a new business attempting to open up shop, it wouldn't stand a chance. They've been coasting on their reputation for at least a few years now. You would be well advised to wear blinders so as not to see the dirty conditions and just get to the wings, but you would never be able to place an order. Instead of a "welcome" or "how can I help you?", you get a surely look and silence. This has happened several times now, so it isn't a case of one server having a bad day. They finally repainted the "dining area" and got new tabletops, but its still in need of a fair amount of cleaning.
(1)
Conor M.
I've been going to Buff Joe's since I was in high school and honestly it used to be better. I love the wing sauce and the cheddar chips (caveat with those: eat them first because if you don't the cheese will solidify and it's a bit unappetizing) but the quality of the chicken has decreased significantly. But, hell they're still tasty and where else is there an RC machine?
(4)
Ira U.
What can I say? Greatest wings ever! Great Cheese Fries. I hear they have other food but I don't really see the point.
(5)
Edward H.
Lookout arteries, here they come! Even though it's been about a decade since my first visit to Joe's, I still remember my first suicide wings/gut buster combo - *and queue flashback* Buffalo Joe's quakes as a "HOLY CRAP! I can't feel my toungue!" echoes throughout the place followed by an "AHHHH" after a sip out of the gut buster (you'd think it's the sauce but it's actually the soda - maybe should be more aptly named the gut *builder*). The Evanston Joe's (not to be confused with the one on Howard) serves up the some of the best spicy buffalo wings around Chicago. The wings are complimented by great waffle fries and various char-broiled burgers. If you're feeling hungry, try and split one of their party trays with a friend or 3. They taste just as good reheated out of the oven. Use their suicide sauce with caution. I remember getting an order of waffle fries with suicide sauce and watching the sauce eat through the styrofoam container.
(4)
Paul A.
Anywhere I go, I always try the wings. Although I've had some great wings at a number of places, I always end up ranking Buffalo Joe's as one of the best I have ever had. They seem to have shrunk in size over the years, but I've noticed the same thing at a lot of other places too (in particular Buffalo Wild Wings - their wings look like they came off a sickly hamster). Regardless, a damn fine wing and exceptional sauce. You get ranch instead of blue cheese and I actually prefer that. I live downtown and I make the trek to Evanston for these babies almost once a month. The only con: cash only.
(5)
Hope Z.
I was severely disappointed. Maybe Im a wing snob. Maybe I expect more from my buffalo sauce than spice. I have heard so many rave reviews about this place and my fiance and I walked out thinking "eh" There was no flavor to the sauce. It was an oily mess. the "cheddar" on the "cheddar fries" was lacking in cheese taste. it was like yellowish paste. Its rare I pass up a cheese fry order. It ruined what would have been great waffle fries. The only redeeming quality of this place is the breading. I had the chicken tenders, and the breading was fantastic. But it certainly wasn't worth driving to Evanston over.
(3)
kelly c.
Yes! Don't waste your time on the other Joe's - this is the one that knows! Great wings and other sundries. I should probably warn that this isn't a high class place with quality ingredients - it's pretty low brow, but that's part of the charming novelty. For me, this Buffalo Joe's venue is well worth the hike up north.
(4)
Rob S.
I've been eating here since I first got my drivers license in 2004. Evanston was always the place to head to Friday nights and Buff Joes was the place to hit up for wings. Over the years though, I have found that the faces inside the place haven't changed, but the quality of the wing has. On my last visit, I felt like prices went up, my single order of suicide wings left me half full (in the past I would feel good after 1 single order), and the size of the wings are small compared to other wing establishments. I still like Buffalo Joes and will still eat there every once in a while out of nostalgia, but it would be nice if they invested in some meatier wings.
(3)
Amanda T.
My friends from Evanston and the other surrounding North Shore suburbs have been RAVING about Buffalo Joe's for who knows how long. So, naturally, I was more than excited to see what this place was all about. My anticipation grew once we got there after seeing reviews from nationally acclaimed critics posted all up and down the walls. When I took my first bite into the chicken wing, I wasn't impressed. It wasn't bad, but it was pretty much like buffalo wild wings, maybe it had a little more meat, but that's about it. The cheese on the baked potato I got was horrible!! It looked like it was made from concentrated powdered cheese mixed with water. Like the kind that comes with a box of mac and cheese, only worse. Even my high school served better cheese than that! Two of my other friends (who were also Buffalo Joe's virgins) agreed with me. The food is really cheap and the orders are huge, I'll give them that. But it really didn't do it for me. I tried my best to like Buffalo Joe's, but I couldn't. Sorry...
(2)
Esther Y.
BJ's has been a part of my life since my first visit to Evanston back in the day. Amazing. They are completely no nonsense here. Order your wings, see them toss it in your sauce, order your fries, pick it up, gorge. Of course, eating wings brings out two very distinct competitions to show that you can either eat like a real man (this applies to guys and girls). One competition is who can eat the hottest sauce. Not a good idea. Go for the middle. That way you can still enjoy the wing and you don't have to fill your stomach unnecessarily with your beverage. The second competition is who can eat the most wings. Again, unless there is money riding on it, you can pass. You will end up eating way too much and then hate yourself quietly as you lie in the fetal position.
(5)
Kristen L.
Double order of suicide? HELL YES. Buffalo Joe's has the only wings that I will ever crave. Sure the restaurant itself is a bit dated and it can be next to impossible to find seating on any given night, but damnit, are they worth it. The wings themselves are a bit on the smaller side, but they make up for it in how many they give you. The fat-ass in me always gets a double order with buffalo chips (the double order comes with anywhere between 20-25 wings). That paired with some fresh celery and ranch? Makes my mouth salivate just writing about it. On the way back home from a day at the Field Museum with the parentals, papa Lee decided he wanted to stop by and grab some to go. It's about a good 25-30 minute drive from Buff. Joe's to home, but good God they were still delicious (and not soggy) after we go home. The only painful spiciness I would ever put myself through.
(5)
Emily C.
Buffalo wings are one of my favorite foods. Quite the opposite of most connoisseurs, I am pretty tolerant to differences in size and flavor. I really haven't met any I didn't like for some reason or another, so naturally, I am inclined to be lenient on wing places. I see the benefits of Hooters, BW3, and likewise, I can speak to the appeal of Buffalo Joe's. You go in and order; the people behind the counter goof with you and give you a hard time in a funny way, which is bascially like spending time with my family and therefore makes me feel at home. They made fun of me for wearing a surf shop shirt in Chicago; haha...point taken. Anyhow, you wait for less than 10 minutes, then you get cardboard containers full of wings with ranch sauce (no bleu cheese, which is their weakest link, if you ask me), and celery. We also ordered the waffle cut cheese fries. The wings? Totally smothered in sauce. Some people on here seem to not like that, but I'm all for it. The hot sauce is a little garlicky and had just enough bite to kick me in the mouth a little without turning me into a Tums commercial. It was pretty darn good to dip celery in after the wings were gone. The ranch? A little thin, but okay. Again, kind of sad there's no bleu cheese but it had a nice flavor at least. The fries? Covered in some kind of bizarro processed cheese that I wanted so badly not to like because it was obviously fake...but failed. The stuff was delicious. It was sort of like EZ Cheez or Velveeta in that it should be gross but it's amazing. I'd go back.
(4)
Jon J.
They're the best wings that I've had in Chicago - meaty, properly saucey, and not too fried. Basically, they're perfect! The counter service can be terribly slow, though. But really, it's a divey, greasy, corner of any god's wing-filled heaven. What do you expect? As a funny anecdote, I saw a guy order a pint of ranch sauce here. That's it. NASTY!
(4)
TJ W.
Buffalo Joe's got some bangin' chicken wings! This used to be my spot in high school...I often made it a weekly ritual, until I found out that my metabolism isn't as great as it used to be. lol They have a few locations, but I prefer the drive to Evanston rather than going on Howard. Their mild and bbq wings are sick!!!!! If you're a chicken fanatic then Buffalo Joe's is the place!
(5)
Dan K.
Stopped in here a while back, because everyone said how authentic their Buffalo wings were. Being a wing snob from Buffalo, I had to check it out. Boy, did they stink. They were small little things, with a sauce that tasted nothing like true Buffalo chicken wings and they served friggin Ranch dressing! I'm sorry, but if you're going to claim to serve authentic Buffalo style chicken wings, you serve Blue Cheese not ranch dressing. Piss-poor in my book.
(1)
Chanita S.
I love this place. I don't care what anyone else thinks, but I've been going here since I was in high school--my Friday tradition. I wouldn't compare it to Popeye's because Popeye's isn't saucy fried chicken and they're not necessarily a wing place nor would I compare it to Hooter's because their breading is different. I love BJ's wings though because of their sauce and crispy wings. Their waffle fries are pretty amazing as well. Make sure to bring a bib because you will get sauce all over you which isn't really a bad thing here. The only downside is that they don't accept cash, but there is an ATM machine inside.
(5)
Joe H.
I'm giving BJ's a 4 star rating as an average of the 5 star place this place has been to me over the past 20 years and the 3 star place it was the other day when I stopped by. These wings are what I've always measured all buffalo wings I've ever eaten in my life. I LOVE THIS PLACE. But the other day, I didn't love it so much. The sauce had a weird ammonia kind of flavor and the cheese on my chips tasted like they put in more glue than normal. I also hate how expensive it has become. But I still love the place. The place hasn't changed at all! From the floors, tables, benches, bathrooms, and staff (GARY!!!!), it's the same. Kind of like an Evanston time capsule plus inflation.
(4)
Annie Y.
I haven't been to Buff Joe's in over 4 years, but I remember their wings being amazing - big, juicy, and cooked to perfection. I've heard since I left Chicago that they've gotten much smaller, so consider the four stars a rating for memories of times past.
(4)
Roxanne R.
Yu-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-ummmm!! Hands down best wings in Chicago. You get about 15 or so wings for a single order. The wing sizes are on the small side, just like I like it. I want to eat wings not drumsticks. The sauce is what makes the wings. It perfectly coats the wings and is fantastic. I always get a single order with waffles fries and cheese on the side. Waffle fries are solid. I recommend getting the cheese on the side. The cheese isn't liquidy nacho cheese, this cheese coagulates after a while and it's a nice compliment to the wings. Service is okay and the place isn't very tidy but this isn't fine dining, you come here because the wings are freaking delicious.
(5)
Amber J.
Am Huge Buffalo wings fan, could eat them everyday of the week. (And in college i pretty much did). However when i first drove by Buffalo Joe's with friends i was alittle apprehensive. It seemed a little hole -in-the wall-ish and there was a line out the door. When we actually got in there it was crowded as heck with literally no available seating. 2 of us lurked for a open table while the other person ordered. We finally got a 2 seater table though there were three of us. Then i embarked on of the greatest buffalo wing experiences of my life. The flavor, sigh...We ate wing and wings and more wings and thought we were all full we ate even more wings. I highly recommend - the only drawback is limited seating in the restauraunt. I will definetley be back.
(5)
Karen K.
It's always fun to come here for a late night dinner with friends. Unfortunately, I've noticed that their wings have gotten even smaller. There was barely any meat and what meat there was on the bones were very tough. The celery that came with our order was not washed well and I was so desperate to combat the saltiness of the wings with the celery that I ended up wiping the dirt off with the napkins.. but gross. The cheese fries were the only thing that made the meal yummy.
(2)
David P.
I like the suicide wings with the jalepeno peppers but its a bit of false advertising. The wings aren't over the top spicy but have a good flavor. From this place, I actually prefer the BBQ wings. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and tanginess. As someone from Buffalo, these wings rank pretty high in the Chicago-land area.
(4)
Shari F.
Buffalo Joe's in Evanston WILL NEVER AGAIN GET OUR BUSINESS! The manager is so unprofessional and the employees do not inform customers properly about pre-ordering, a horrible place. We have been going there for years and tried to pre-order for Super Bowl and the idiots told us for smaller orders to just come in. We drove in the blizzard and they wouldn't serve us, I will never go to a Buffalo Joe's again and will never recommend them to anyone.
(1)
Earlie C.
Wings are still the best in the city, but holy hell. We came in last night and came across the most ghetto, classless workers ever. First, the use of the word "fuck" was used around twenty times while I was waiting for my food. The vulgarity of staff had my brain hurting. Seriously, pull up your damn pants, act like a decent human, and possibly show me that your vocabulary consists of more than "fuck, shit, and motherfucker". My girlfriend ordered a polish. We both witnessed a female take a reject order (a polish that was sitting out in a basket when we first arrived - for how long?) back on the grill for about a minute and serve us that dog. Come on Buffalo Joe's... Just make sure you go when the owner is there. I'd question ever ordering food from this establishment again if he was not present.
(1)
Stacy H.
Suicide wings are soooo good.. I only like boneless wings but I make an exception for these. The waffle fries are good too. Can be a little salty but I just always have lots of water near by!!
(5)
Alana H.
Aside from the loud obnoxious and inappropriate conversation taking place by the staff. The chicken was amazing. The waffle fries were not as good as they were hyped up to be however the chicken makes the long drive and rude service worth it.
(4)
BforBulky B.
Just went! The buffalo wings are great. I'm not sure I'd trek all the way out there again for the wings, BUT I WOULD FOR THE COOKIES. And the ranch dip. If you're in this part of town, definitely stop by. If you're in Chicago, R.J. Grunts wings are delish.
(4)
Emma R.
If I could give this place no stars, I would. I have not been to this place since I was in high school. My family and I happen to be in the area and I had the bright idea of having wings. So down to Buffalo Joes we go. The girl in the front was the best part of experience here. Over All cleanliness of this place is just gross! They got one of our drinks wrong, my husband goes to the front to change it. The girls pours it, coughs in her hand and with that hand that she coughed in, grabs the lid puts it on the cup and hands it to my husband. Gross!!! I am surprised people eat here, and that this place has not been shut down because it's dirty.
(1)
Buttermilk P.
Very good wings. My wife and I try to grab a bite at Joe's whenever we are in Evanston. We normally order their wings with mild sauce and waffle cheese fries. They have three main levels of sauce which are all the same, mild, spicy and suicide. The difference is, the mild is only a coating of sauce, the spicy gives you a bit more and the suicide adds sliced jalapeno peppers. The sauce is really good, and since everything is made to order, the wings are usually hot and fresh. They don't give you very many fries, but the cheddar cheese sauce is also very good. In typical north side/north shore fashion, everything is overpriced and a la carte. We are used to Harold's, where chicken comes with fries, coleslaw and bread. That would cost an extra $50 here, and the prices you pay here would get you triple the amount of food at a south side establishment. However, it is a bit of a different take on wings, so we pay a visit every blue moon. Cash only.
(5)
Rene S.
Wings are really good (not as good as Franks for the Memories in Mundelein, but that is too far away). They are small but the portion size is huge so it is worth what you get. There are only three sauce levels: mild, spicy and suicide. I wanted medium and was directed by the woman who took my order that the spicy would be a good alternative. It was. So why only 4 stars if the wings are good? No credit cards, no delivery, and the cardinal sin for a wing joint .... NO BLUE CHEESE dressing! While I can cross the street to the Jewel and get some blue cheese dressing, no delivery is a big problem. They are going to lose a lot of business, including mine, by not offering delivery. On a nice summer evening in the summer, not a problem to walk the mile to get to the place. But if the weather is at all bad, I often order delivery so I don't have to go out if I'm running low on groceries. Too bad I can't order from here!
(4)
Lucy F.
Great wings!!!! Simply, Delicious, nice crunchy texture and the mild sauce is just great! Make sure you don't come on the weekend since the place is always so pack.
(4)
Kyle D.
Dear Evanston, you've got a serious impairment when it comes to evaluating wing joints. Not sure what's going on here. Buffalo Joe's is a 4 star wing joint? C'mon. Is this some kind of romantic/nostalgic thing? The result of underdeveloped undergrad taste buds? First, this place is f'ing D.I.R.T.Y. The dining area is dirty. So is the kitchen. Every time those kitchen doors opened we were smacked in the face with a nasty odor. And the wings suck. They go nuts with the corn starch. Corn starch has no place on wings. They damn sure don't need to look like they've been breaded in it. And the mild sauce is it sweet? WHY is it sweet? Call it sweet sauce, because it has no resemblance to a buffalo sauce. Fries were ok. Ranch was lame. Nothing redeeming about this place.
(1)
Emily P.
Suicide wings with cheddar fries are a must! (The burn in the bathroom later is worth it; trust me...haha sorry for the TMI)!
(4)
Eileen S.
Seriously good wings. I always get the buffalo wings with mild sauce and cheddar chips (waffles fries smothered in cheese sauce). Ranch is tasty as well. Sure its not the most beautiful place to eat, but that's not why I go. Beware: you will become addicted to these wings!
(5)
Sallie H.
The spicy wings were pretty good, I'm not a fan of wings so I can't really get excited about them. The one thing I can honestly say was terrible there was the cheese fries. I believe the cheese was made out of powder, idk it was just gross. I had to scrape the cheese off my fries because it was so disgusting. The cheese at 7-Eleven for the nachos are 10 times better than what Buffalo Joe's offered. The buffalo fries are very good, i wished they had real cheese to go with it :-(
(2)
Christine M.
Awful. Awful. Awful. Half way through our meal we found a long black hair melted in our cheese fries.
(1)
Will B.
Total collapse of the brand they built over the years. I've been going there for over 27 years. These days it is really bad. Watery teriyaki, under cooked fries, and the worst wings I've seen in a long time.
(1)
Brad S.
Going back to my days in high school, over 20 years ago, I've always been a big fan of the place. Went there for lunch on Friday with a friend from high school, trying to re-live the good old days. I was shocked at the quality of the wings themselves. They were so small and tiny. Wish I had taken a picture at the time to post on here. It also drives me crazy that they nickel and dime you for every little thing. Who charges for a cup of water?!?! They do. The reason they get 2 rather than 1 stars is the people were quite friendly, even offering up free samples of split pea soup, and the sauce itself was quite tasty. Hopefully it was just a bad batch of wings but have to say I was awfully disappointed in the place.
(2)
Gabriel S.
I've been coming to Buffalo Joes since the early 90s. The wings are still the best in the world in my opinion. The perfect blend of meat and crispy skin with absolutely amazing sauce.
(5)
Kevin C.
When I was an undergrad at NU I lived a few blocks away and would get the same order of wings and buffalo chips every couple of weeks. When I moved away, despite searching high and low, I could never find a wing place that matched the buff. So when I came back to Chicago for work, frequent pilgrimages to buff joes were a must. It still hits the spot every time.
(5)
Shalem A.
Buff Joes is an Evanston staple, and they offer the best wings in Evanston. This is not health food, but at least once a month I'll grab a single suicide for lunch. It is good for the soul. They also have awesome waffle fries and solid burgers, but if you're coming here for the first time, make sure you try the wings. The staff can be a little "sassy" at times, but it's part of their schtick, don't take it personally.
(4)
Randall K.
Not the cleanest place, but one of my top 5 places to eat. They have my favorite buffalo wings. In Buff-Joes language, I usually order a double suicide with cheddar chips and a gut-buster RC. What that really means is a double order of wings, spicy with jalapeños too. Waffle fries loaded with a creamy cheddar cheese sauce. A large Royal Crown soda. The wings come with little ranch cups and some celery. Mini napkins are on the table. The area is nice and close to northwestern university. It can have it's share of pan-handlers sometimes, but because of the area, they are usually non - aggressive. If someone asked me for my best wing place, it is definitely Buffalo Joes.
(5)
Lefai K.
The wings of the place is awesome! You won't find lots of flavors like you would at bw3, just mild, spicy, and suicide. The breading is not too much, but the crisp was perfect. =============================== And now my signature bathroom review! =============================== the place itself is kind of a hole in the wall. That being said, I didn't expect too much from it. And it's pretty much true. It's a place to take a leak, and then get the f out. So sit or squat? Squat... And flush the toilet by kicking the toilet handle down, because gawd knows what's touch that toilet handle
(4)
Alexander W.
Double Suicide, Mega RC. Perfection.
(5)
Jeff H.
Fun and cheap wings place for those that don't want that big chain down the street. #cheapeats
(4)
Faye D.
Oooh Buff Joes... My favorite place to eat in Evanston. The wangs are thee bomdiggidy and the cheese waffle fries. Mmm. Con: Kind of dirty and they don't accept cards. Oh well big whoop right? The best wings place for me so far.
(4)
Miles S.
Best wings I have had so far in the northern hemisphere. Great atmosphere and good people. Not a lot of flavors, but not needed. Great burgers and chicken. A must try .
(5)
Orlando H.
First thing I get walking in is a rude cashier. Went in 15 min before they closed and she was quick to say "we're closed we have nothing left". They should change their closing time to 1145 not midnight.
(1)
AJ M.
This place used to be my spot for wings. At one point I would even go as far to say the best wings I ever had. The sauce is amazing, wings so cripsy like none other. Although still pretty good it's not as good as it used to be. Prices have jumped alot over the years, I remember when a double order used to be around $9 now $14. The waffle fries are still a guilty pleasure that doesn't disappoint. They only take cash, well worth the occasional visit!!
(4)
Jamie H.
Came in today for lunch because I've heard the wings were amazing. I tried the mild and the hot; mild was awesome but the hot I wasn't too crazy about. Was a pretty standard hot sauce. You get a pretty decent price for the amount and because the mild was so good I plan to come back and try the suicide sauce the waffle cheese fries.
(4)
Gina T.
By far the best wings I've ever tried EVER. The only reason I give them four stars instead of five is because it looks dirty and smells. And even with all that going on ill still eat there. Other than that the wings are amazingly delicious. Very crispy. I got the mild wings and the sauce is sort of sweet but it's nothing less than scrumptious. The waffle fries are fresh and tasty. I'm a ranch lover. Ill have ranch with anything and buff joes ranch is the best ranch I've ever had. I wish they would clean up the place a bit. That's the only complaint I have.
(4)
Jane Y.
OH MY WORD. the wings here are DELICIOUS UGHAS;LDIFAH;SLDIFH i always crave these things and then GET SLAPPED IN THE FACE BY REALITY because... its a bit of a drive for me to get here but just thinking about these wonderful heavenly saucy tastey oh not so little wings goodness gracious and the CHEDDAR CHIPS screw diets and if ur gonna cheat might as well make it a WORTHY CHEAT COME TO BUFFALO JOESS!
(5)
Mark K.
This was Sweetie's favorite wing place in Chicago, so I had to stop by on the way through last week. Especially after she forbade me to stop at any BBQ places on the south side... Nice little college-town wing joint. Looks really small, but once you order you see there's a bigger room in back to eat. Service was efficient and friendly. Order sizes are big- I got a single and worried that it would be enough, but it was plenty. Nice meaty wings, good sauce (I got BBQ.) I got a side of celery, which was also good sized. Between a few veggies, lots of wings, and some RC, I was fully satisfied. Can't wait to go back.
(4)
Vealy C.
The wings were terrific, the service isn't that bad. The "ghetoness" of the place adds to the experience, but the bathrooms.. ohhh, they're always so dirty. My hands still feel dirty even after washing them.
(3)
Frank Y.
You are either a fan or a hater; there are no in-betweens when it comes to Buf Joes. I am a fan. When people complain, they tend to say that the wings are too small; but I love them. The sauce makes these wings. It is kind of sweet, thick, and has just enough spice. The wings, because, they are small, are crunchy on the outside and perfectly sauced. The ranch that Buf Joe's has is awesome! It is very easy to get addicted to these wings. When our sons come back to Evanston, one of the first things that they crave is Buffalo Joes. For a family of four, we get a double-order of spicy and a double-order of mild wings. The waffle fries are also yummy when you dip them in the ranch dressing. If you want a burger in Evanston, go to Edzo's. If, however, you want wings, nothing compares to Buf Joes.
(4)
Gautram W.
First and last time! I wonder did they fried the wings in oil or grease..... Horrible horrible horrible.... The burger as well was dipped in oil/ grease or whatever.....
(1)
Renya M.
The food here is amazing and the service isn't bad either except for this one douchebag who actually cooks and prepares the orders. I'm sorry that he feels his job is so difficult, bagging wings and taking people orders, really, I am. Id be miserable if I looked and acted anything like him too. This guy was rude to everyone in line though, do yourselves a favor and go to any other location if you care at all about servers doing even the absolute least in terms of being polite.
(2)
Rod D.
Still loving Buf Joes as the wife and I continue visit on a frequent basis. Remember to ask for well done if you like your wings crispy
(5)
Sharon C.
Everyone always raves abut Buff Joe's being the best wings in Evanson, but I honestly don't see it - I typically order the wings mild and they have this really funky aftertaste. The fries are soggy, and the burgers are literally dripping oil through the paper trays. I'll pass.
(2)
Z S.
So good. This is my guilty pleasure food. The wings are so good and saucy, while the burgers are enormous and very greasy. (The special Buff Joe's sauce mixed with mustard and ketchup is heaven.) All variations of the chips/fries are really crispy and flavorful. So while the food is a little unhealthy, you've got to treat yourself once in a while.
(4)
Don T.
Still after all these years, my favorite buffalo wings place in the Chicagoland area!
(5)
Cyril L.
Buffalo Joe's has some of the best wings. My first time was last month and they tasted really good. Make sure to get the sauce. For a low price, you can get a basket full of wings. It's worth the wait.
(4)
Meredith C.
My first impression was very poor. The girl taking my order was so incredibly rude, I immediately regretted my choice to eat here when there are literally 50 restaurants in this area. Rolled her eyes when asked questions, spoke barely above a mumble, when asked her to repeat herself she basically shouted at me. Really, really, rude first impression. She of course entered our order incorrectly. Wrong food came. However, the other members of the staff quickly fixed her mistake and we're exceptionally polite and cheerful. Food was really, really good. Best wings ever. Fries are great. All of the food was outstanding. Felt a little like we were eating out of our laps, maybe give some plates out with wings? When we left staff said goodbye, very polite. Made up for little miss sunshine that took our order. Try it out. Food is really amazing. Cash Only but there is an ATM. They do serve a few beers, also.
(3)
Michael G.
Simply the best. I made an hour round trip to get these wings. I usually do once every 3 weeks. I crave this place weekly. I wish I was skinny and could eat these wings every week. Standard order is Double Order Suicide (gotta have the jalapeños), cheddar chips (never get cheese on the side, the fries need to be covered in cheese!!!), and a bowl of cheddar broccoli (when you are waiting for your food ask for a sample If they already haven't offer it to you).
(5)
Nari L.
Love this place! Came here years ago with a friend when I was in college and I loved it! I recently came back here years later since the last time and I still loved it! The food is fast so you can come and eat here in a jiffy.
(5)
Jim K.
Been going here for more than 25 years. No change in order: Double order wings, Cheddar chips, and gutbuster lemonade. Why mess with perfection?
(5)
Tian Y.
Not really a picky wing-eater, and I'm good with their sauces. The wings are kind of small though compared to other places nearby, and I prefer the big and juicy ones with meat. Don't be surprised by poor customer service here.
(3)
Michael W.
You could not BELIEVE how much I love this place... To paraphrase... These wings are more full than Donald Trump at a Las Vegas strip buffet, with sauce sassier than Ellen DeGeneres, and so meaty they had to bring in a weatherman to evaluate it. Let me just be upfront and say that the wings are not boneless and are actually smaller than the average wing, but the upside of that is that the surface area to volume ratio on these wings is ri-DICK (any one of my AP Bio homies know what's up!!!), which makes for some outrageously saucy wings. Also, they give you celery sticks! Celery sticks are fantastic, it's literally portable water, but in solid form! I actually have a patent pending for a booze canteen that's made out of celery. The idea is that when you get a hangover after a heavy night of drinking, you can eat the canteen the next morning for a refreshing, fibrous jolt of hydration (hit me up if you're interested, but I already got a lot of investors lined up). Okay, one last thing. The one weird thing about it is that the urinals have ice in them. Ice! What is this, Soviet Russia*? I personally will not use any product with a molar mass less than or equal to 18, so this was especially problematic for me (sorry about your sink, Buff Joe's) *fun fact: In Soviet Russia, you were only allowed to buy water in ice form. In fact, the premise behind the "Cold War" was that the Soviets were trying to freeze the world's water supply (for that Russian +1 mobility buff in cold). That's why the United States detonated so many nuclear bombs back then, to keep the earth warm. Down with commies!
(5)
Donald S.
I love these wings (spicy. The barbecue don't count seeing as its only Sweet Baby Ray's), and I judge all other buffalo wings by these. They have beer on tap and consistently great wings whichever sauce you get (mild, spicy, suicide, or BBQ). Single, spicy, extra ranch & celery, with an order of the buffalo chips ( waffle fries...), and a Berghoff means your in buisness.
(5)
Jessica D.
My favorite food is spicy chicken and DING DING DING. Buffalo Joes has won the key to my heart and stomach. My mouth waters just thinking about it. I have pregnant cravings and I'm not even pregnant. If I were getting the death penalty, this would be my last meal. I can never stop myself from buying more than what can fit in my belly.
(5)
Marci G.
Sorry Joe, but I am done with Buffalo Joe's :( Sad to say. The last few years the wings have just gone way down hill and I just keep hoping the next time I go (once a year) the wings will be delish again, but sad to say they are not. I don't know why they changed the recipe, but they have not been the same for a long time now. I actually left there tonight and wondered if Joe was still alive, because I cannot imagine him being alive and him allowing his restaurant to go this far downhill. The worst part is........it is so filthy in there, I am shocked that the health dept has not come in and faulted them into cleaning the place up. So many bugs flying around in there, it's hard to eat your food. And the bathroom.....OH MY GOSH, GROSS! It was filthy last year when I went and this time.....horrible ( seriously, blood on the tiles!) I grew up on Buffalo Joe's. I have been eating there since the mid '80's. If you are around Joe, please put some money back into it and clean it up and get your food back up to the excellent tasty level it used to be in. Bye for now.
(1)
Asia C.
The BEST wings in the chicago area! I've been ordering wings from them for years! I always usually order a single order of suicide. Also, this location is the best. Coming in second is Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. is last. I can tell the difference in how each location prepares the wings.
(5)
Hersh A.
This place doesn't do much for me any more. Menu variety it's relatively good for what the place is. I mostly care for having wings here. I have been here a handful of times in the past. Back in the 90's I used to like their wings, especially the suicide kind but at some point something changed (I guess their recipe?) that the suicide wings have not been the same. They taste average at best. Also what I didn't like recently is that the order taking person said you get 12 wings in single order and we got our order we were shorted a few wings. When I asked about it, one of the persons behind the counter said that the wing amount is never exact but more like 10-12. Wtf? That's just dumb. I don't think I had such a problem in the past. I don't care for the cash only affect of it. Oh well, I don't desire to come here again anytime in the foreseeable future. There are better wings place out there.
(2)
James H.
I'm happy to see a lot of 4 and 5-star reviews for Buffalo Joe's. But it's pretty clear all of them are from people under 22 or who know so little about wings that they feel the need to make clear that these are bone-in wings (as if boneless wings are actually wings or should even be in the discussion of what makes a great wing). Anyhow, 10 or 15 years ago, I would have given Buffalo Joe's an emphatic 5 starts. It was unrivaled for the best wings in the Chicago area. But the wings keep getting smaller, the preparation keeps getting sloppier, and the restaurant keeps getting dirtier. They're not bad and I might go back if I lived in Evanston but my Buffalo Joe's days are done.
(2)
Danny M.
I live 30 minutes from this place and I will still make the drive here for their wings. They have the best mild and spicy wings I have ever eaten. The wings have gotten a lot smaller than they use to be, but it is still good. The sauce on the wing is perfect, not too spicy were it kills your taste buds. Get the wings with waffle fries and you will not be disappointed.
(5)
Heather K.
Love this place!! It's food that you get acquainted too while living here. Love the rib tips cause their bbq sauce is a little more on the sweeter side. And their wings...are nice and tangy!! Great combo with the ranch and celery sticks! Simple and easy option just to grab a bite to eat.
(5)
Jung K.
want spicy buffalo wings? look no further and stop by the Buffalo Joe's on Clark st. Order: single suicides with chips and a large drink. If suicides are too spicy, then get out. The regular spicy ones are good too.. They have their system on lock down. Order your food, pick up your food, pay in cash only, and go demolish those wings.
(5)
Scotty D.
I went here after a friend told me these were the best wings in the Chicago area. I love wings. I can confidently say these are the best wings in the Chicago area. 8 bucks for 10 wings is a great deal. The spicy sauce is great. Just enough heat. Even the mild my wife had was good. The wings are cooked perfectly, nice and crunchy. Even the ranch tastes better than other places. The waffle fries are great but I'd stay away from the cheese sauce. It was very salty and congealed quickly which ruined the fries. Wouldn't get them again. But if you want good wings, man this is the place.
(5)
Kristen D.
This place FAR surpasses any place like BDubs. The wings are HUGE, you get a lot of them with one order, and there is enough sauce on each wing to still have enough to lick off your fingers. (I feel like in all of my wing experiences, there is never enough sauce to go with the meat. NOT the case here!) They give you an order of celery and ranch with a wing order, which was one of my favorite things about this place. My only complaint is that it is HOT in this restaurant...but that could also be from the huge friers and grills up in the front of the restaurant.
(5)
Kevin S.
Great taste and good people. Best wings so far anywhere
(5)
Aldi J.
My go to wing place!!! Best buffalo sauce. Just get spicy or suicide please. Don't be weak and go mild. Growing up in nearby Skokie, my friends and I would head over here and pig out on the regular. I'm a bit disappointed though because the wings over time have gotten smaller... anyone else notice this? C'mon bring the bigger wings back. Sorry, this was the reason for my one star deduction. Some things never change though. When I arrive at a party and see a party pan, my mouth starts watering I know what I'm attacking first. Don't forget the awesome waffle fries!!
(4)
Ryne D.
I've been here many times before, but on my last trip to Northwestern this weekend to do an interview, the only thing on my mind was getting these wings. They have that much control over me. Ok, sure they're tiny, but they're damn tasty. And since a single order gets you around a dozen of these bad boys, you should be good with just that - even though I usually get double orders anyway. What puts this location over the other ones are their cheddar chips - waffle fries with Cheese Whiz-ish sauce dumped on top. So delicious, provided you finish them off before the cheese morphs back into its semi-solid state. Never had anything else from here - I'm good with my suicide wings, thanks.
(5)
Ed L.
My friends had nothing but great things to say about this place so i had to go check it out with them. Needless to say I left wanting to come back more and more often and thinking about the years wasted not coming here. My friends say that they raised the prices but a double order of wings and two orders of fries only cost about $20.02 with tax. Which isn't bad if you split it with someone. The waffle fries are crispy and tasty but to be honest next time i come here I'm getting a double order for myself. I love that they can mix sauces together and the spicy barbecue is the way to go in my opinion. The sauce makes my mouth water every time i think about it and adding jalapenos to the wings is icing to the cake. You will definitely be visited by me more than once in the coming month and if your in the Evanston neighborhood i would definitely consider checking them out.
(5)
Hannah P.
My mouth is watering waiting for our order. I worked out just so I can pig out today! Suicide Please.
(4)
Danny W.
A meal of a single order, cheddar chips and a mega-gut RC is now $13.65. What happened to you Buff Joe's? You used to be so beautiful.
(1)
Tom M.
My favorite spot to grab some wings. I take a detour into downtown Evanston or hit the one on Green Bay if I'm craving Rib Tips every so often to get my fix. When I lived in Evanston, this was a regular stop for me. Now that I'm farther away, my times between visits has lengthened which my doctor appreciates. I highly recommend!
(5)
Danny B.
In my opinion, these are the best wings in the world.... ** IF YOU ARE NOT A BONE-IN WING LOVER, THIS MAY NOT BE YOUR PLACE!!** But for the rest of us who have a wing obsession and could care less about the decor this place is highly recommended!!
(4)
Christine N.
Oh, Buff Joes. You are so conveniently located across the street from my college condo, tempting me everyday as I pass by to go to class, walk to downtown evanston, go visit a friend, walk to work... You haven't failed... Yet. I have this disgusting fear that one day I'll walk in, and it just won't be that good. Unfortunately, the wings have indeed gotten smaller since my first taste. But I must go on with the wonders of this wing. It's fried. It's not good for you. But oh... It's good. Something this good can't be THAT bad, can it? Ok fine. These chicken wings are not just fried. They are crispy. CRISPY, I tell you. Take a bite and CRUNCH! And then you get chicken. This is the disappointing part. I wish the chicken was more succulent inside, but it can't be when the wings are small. The sauce. Yum. We get spicy and it's the perfect amount of heat. Not a fan of the excess sauce on the bottom with the last few wings that are swimming in the sauce. And the celery sticks are usually warm. But I still am loyal to you, Buff Joes. I will always eat you because you are just that good. Also, the suicide wings are basically just the spicy flavor with jalapeños added. Skip the suicide. Take taste over heat. Word.
(4)
Elliott C.
attention buffalo joe's on clark street......please clean up that disgusting men bathroom and hire friendlier ppl to work there WHO VALUE CUSTOMER SERVICE. i can no longer take Lacresha and them attitude. First bad experience on November 3rd 2013 p.s. the wing are still the best!
(3)
Leonard P.
the chicken was delicious. I love coming here with friends and family. big fan of waffle fries and it hit's the spot when it comes to craving for chicken. the littel down side is how they don't accept card. Other than that, the food is fine and the atmostphere is pretty chill.
(4)
Ashley C.
We made the trip up here for the buffalo wings and because of the 4 stars on yelp. Disappointment to say the least. It started from the phone call to see what there hours were on the 4th of July. The girl picked up the phone and with attitude says, "the usual hours we're open." When had to ask what those were, she replied with the time after uttering an "uhhhh." That got me off to a really bad start. So we tried the buffalo wings (spicy), the burger, and the cheese fries. Cheese fries were average. The burger was average. The patty itself was good, but the toppings were average and didn't taste super fresh. The buffalo wings - average. I would have liked them crispier - the sauce was decent. Oh yes -and they had RC as their pop. As a diet coke/pepsi addict, this just did not quench my thirst on the blistering hot day. Average food + employees with attitude + drive to Evanston = not worth the trip.
(2)
Stephanie C.
Best wing place ever! My uncle had introduced me to this hole on the wall. It's not a super clean place. However the food is amazing. I love boned in wings and the flavors for the wings are perfectly seasoned. I love the mild wings the best. I cannot rave about this place enough..
(5)
Bethany A.
If you're looking for classic wings with classic sides, this place is the best. Their wings come out piping hot, lightly fried, and doused in just enough sauce. The sauce is tangy and spicy (or not, you have options) and it's seriously finger-licking good. I love munching on some celery sticks on the side and their waffle fries are pretty good as well. It's an awesome place to come with friends (order the party platter and dig in!). Yum, so glad that it's near campus.
(4)
Al D.
While I love the wings, cheddar burger with its creamy cheddar spread, plus the waffle fries, that's about it on the love for this Buffalo Joe's. I recently had some of their spicy chicken fingers, and they were nearly inedible. The chicken tasted spongy and off, and the breading was akin to rubber. Also on my last visit, I had their famous cheddar burger, but with grilled onions. Bad mistake. About 3/4 lb of undercooked, thick, white onions slid off the burger in a huge pool of grease; nasty. I think most of the five-star reviews are based on nostalgia. Buffalo Joe's is looking old, dirty and worn-out now. I'd maybe go here again for wings, but that's about it.
(3)
Derek D.
I have talked about merkts cheddar before and this place does it RIGHT! WINGS : Amazing every time with a good sauce to wing ratio. un-breaded as well - CRUCIAL. I love the vinegar and butter mild sauce. never had the guts to go hotter. Fries. Well done Buff Chips are the way to go. The cheese is best if you order 2 so you can dip Every fry with JUST enough of it. LOVE YOU BUFF JOES! d
(5)
Jeff W.
There's only one place I'll ever go for wings anymore and that's Buff Joe's. I grew up in Evanston and having been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. After college, I took a job that involved significant travel across the country. There is no place in the country like Buff Joe's. You'll see numerous awards on the walls from different cooking events they've won - their sauce just can't be beat. My favorite burger of all time is actually from Buff Joe's. It's called the Buffalo Cheddar Burger and has a grilled patty with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato, Merkt's cheddar, and then Buff Joe's wing sauce - whichever hotness you desire. It's AMAZING! No place has come close to replicating such an amazing creation. Some negatives are that they only take cash (not even debit card) and the place is located in downtown Evanston and parking is usually pretty difficult to find. While there are tables, there are very few so I suggest getting it to go and bringing it home.
(5)
Sevun H.
The wings and waffle fries were just as good as they were when I was a student and used to eat Buffalo Joes 4 days out of the week! The two girls who greeted me when I walked in were another story all together. They both had very nasty attitudes and seemed to be very unhappy with their jobs. One seemed much more interested in telling her co-worker about her previous nights Hennessy drinking exploits than providing anything remotely resembling customer service. Being eyeballed from head to toe by two immature, insecure, unprofessional employees is not welcome when I am spending my hard earned dollars on overpriced wings and fries. Will not be back. I will just cherish my memories of Buffalo Joes when the service was just as good as the food!
(2)
Mary M.
Always an Evanston favorite. I'm not a huge "chicken on the bone" kind of person, but this place brings wings to a whole new level. If you like spicy...even just a little bit, you have to get the hot or suicide wings. Cheddar chips are a must! Not to mention, the ranch dressing you get with the wings is hands down my favorite.
(5)
Viki N.
When you're feeling low, or lost in life, don't turn to Jesus, turn to Buffalo Joe's! (At least that's what I do.) I have been addicted to Buffalo Joe's for over 15 years. No matter how much I try to forget them, the taste of their wings keeps coming back up in my mind, and I am compelled to make the pilgrimage to Evanston once again. My personal drug of choice here is a single order of suicide wings, spicy cheddar chips, and 2 extra orders of celery and ranch. Nothing can make me happier, and nobody's wings come close to having as much flavor as Buffalo Joe's. (and I've tried, a lot, to find someone even half as good so I don't have to drive all the way up to Evanston again. But no such luck.) So, I recommend stuffing yourself full of wings, and then catching a movie at the movie theatre down the street, or at one of the film festivals they have at Northwestern. Happiness coming into every orifice!
(5)
Julia J.
I've only eaten take out of Buffalo Joes, and I wasn't the one who picked up the food, so I can't speak to the service or condition of the restaurant itself. The wings, though, were delicious- not the largest wings, but certainly not the smallest either. The sauce was really good. I was full from the smallest order. We also ordered the Spicy Cheddar Chips, which were messy and horrible for you, so they were pretty much one of the most delicious concoctions I've ever had.
(3)
Mike T.
Not impressed with this place at all... The wings are so so at best and the staff is always cranky. This is a good place for college kids that have a limited pallet, or are to drunk to know what they are eating is sub par.
(2)
Kareem A.
Place is a mess... ghetto service, thought they're gonna kick me in the face if I ordered one more thing. Their 'boneless wings' are basically chicken tenders refried just to be warm when served. The BBQ sauce is so average I wasn't sure why the place is so famous.. Maybe because it's by NU in the middle of downtown Evanston, who knows? Give them a try, you might have a different opinion.
(2)
Brian K.
FAMOUS FOR: - Buffalo Wings (8/10) Ah BJ's. My education in Buffalo Wings. Brings back great memories, because just about every party and get together in jr. high and high school (when hanging with my North Burbs friends) involved a double party platter of Suicide wings. It was also a much more innocent time where someone would mention BJ's, and instantly, everybody's ears would perk up, eyes would widen, a giggle would pursue, and then everyone was thinking the same thing...mmmm Buffalo Joe's. It also brings back 1 painful memory. They once had a limited time sauce called "XXX" which, after 4 wings, made me cry, drool, and drip from my nose. I downed an entire jug of Ocean Spray Ruby Red juice. It probably wasn't the best thing, but it was college and that was the only thing I had. Yeah...let's not do that again. THE WINGS The only way I ever have them is Suicide. It's not that spicy. Ok, I know this is coming from a Korean guy who's done a ghost chili wing challenge, but still... Put it this way, it's not anywhere near Mango Habanero at BW3 and not even as hot as Three Mile Island at Hooters. Not sure what else to compare it to. It comes with pickled jalapeno slices all over the top, but even those aren't that bad. I usually don't even break a sweat. They're very small wings, about than the length of a grown man's pinky. They're not battered, but do have a crispy skin (at least around the edges). It's drenched in a traditional buffalo type sauce, but it's their secret recipe. "Traditional" meaning that it's kinda like the Louisana hot sauce. You know, kinda salty, with a small kick. In my High School days, I couldn't get enough of these wings! I'd give them 5 stars everyday! Then now, in my post college days, these guys are hit 'n' miss, almost exactly 50/50. Sometimes I go, and I get my single order of suicide wings and fries, and they're just "pretty good." Sometimes I go, and all the lights go on and the choir sings and I'm basking in nostalgia and it just tastes so damn good! That's why I can only give it 8 stars, because it's not consistent. I've only been there maybe 5 times since college (I'd run outta fingers and toes trying to count between HS & College), so I don't know if I'm just changing or my mood affects the taste (although I don't recall ever being in any different moods), or what. It's just not consistent for me. ALL IN ALL I would never pass up an opportunity for BJ's. It's very rare that I'm ever in Evanston, so if we get the chance, it's always BJ's. Oh yeah...CASH ONLY! Even if you're buying hundreds of dollars of double party platters....It's CASH ONLY!
(4)
Matthew B.
Best buffalo wings on north shore and maybe in Chicago.
(5)
Amir L.
I've been going here for over 15 years and it's one of the staples that started my obsession with wings!! Gotta rock the cheddar chip all day with the gut RC !!
(5)
Nishan P.
Not everyone will love Buffalo Joe's. If you don't like sucking on bones, if you don't like the texture of skin, if you can't handle messy; Buffalo Joe's might not be for you. If these things don't bother you, you'll probably find Buffalo Joe's quite delightful. I know other reviewers have called Buffalo Joe's "filthy", "embarrassing" and "disgusting" but I have always been extremely satisfied. If you're not sure whether you would like Buffalo Joe's and need someone to try it out with, give me a holler. I am always up for Buffalo Joe's.
(4)
Luke S.
Their wings are good - close to real good. Their waffle fries are good - also close to real good. Their service is typically horrific and it's really expensive for what you get.
(3)
An P.
Famed and acclaimed, Buffalo Joe's is an anchor in Evanston and a primary contributor to the Northwestern freshman 15. You'll hear tales of its wonder and glory from all over but sometimes you just have to see it to believe it. I've made a few trips to Buffalo Joe's over the years and never counted it as a legendary wing....until now. On the latest edition of Get Yo Wing On, I waited in line and a brilliant idea came to my head, what if I ordered Buffalo Joe's wings extra well done?! Extra well done? Hell yes they made me a batch!!! The wait is comedic, you'll see people running off with their score with trays filled to the brim with wings, cheddar waffle fries, and the All-American celery with batches of ranch and bleu cheese. Lacking the glitz and glamour of fancier trappings, you'll find Buffalo Joe's with the charm of any greasy spoon you'll find across America sprinkled with a tinge of intoxicating wing aroma. The concept is simple: freshly cooked wings laced with some of the best wing sauces you'll find in the city. Wings come in mild, spicy, BBQ, and if they like you they'll make some spicy BBQ. More spice-addicted souls can try their suicide wings laced with jalapenos but your ears might be left blowing out billows of smoke! These wings are lilliputian in stature but what they lack in size they compensate with volume and honest to goodness flavor. I've always found the wing sauce exceptionally delicious with a little extra kick to leave your mouth watering but veritably, I find myself a texture freak. I love texture on my food so when I got my wings extra well done and brought it back to the table my eyes lit up. The first bite was the best bite as I finally figured out the puzzle and unlocked the greatness of Buffalo Joe's at last. Extra well done means extra tasty crispy to the beat of my drum. You're going to find yourself wanting to come back for another visit to this Evanston wingery, and you just have to figure out what wing is best for you, but don't let me be the judge - take a bite out that for yourself!
(5)
Albert M.
Omg! Just left this place with two of my friends, absolutely disgusting! Decor was a mess, a hooters demolished! Just weird! I wouldn't recommend this place to my worst enemy!
(1)
Robert G.
Obsessed. I love the fact that a restaurant can do business the same way for 20 years and still have a huge fan base. Want a coke or diet coke? Too bad. We only have RC Cola. Want to pay with plastic? Sorry, cash only. Obviously, Buffalo Joe's is doing something right, because they continue to crank out amazing, delicious, greasy, fantastic food. The house made sauces were incredible. Mild sauce was just the perfect amount of heat with that signature Buffalo buttery-ness. I had the chicken tenders: cooked PERFECTLY! Crisp and crunchy on the outside, juicy and tender on the inside. Waffle cut fries and a Diet Rite rounded out the meal. My friends tried out some of the various chicken sandwiches, which looked phenomenal (and the general consensus was that they were). This is most definitely an Evanston institution, and you would be remiss if you didn't stop by when in town.
(4)
Gaby C.
Maybe its just me, but i've eaten here 5 times in two weeks. The wings are the best ever!!! I love love love the wings here. The sauces (hot or mild) are just right, not too spicy not to sweet not too tangy, just riight. They have a few locations in Evanston, but I like the one on Clark.
(5)
Jennifer E.
Oh my chicken wing goodness! I got the double order of hot wings plus waffle fries and it was sooooo good and sooooo cheap. I wish I live closer to one of the locations! Dear Buffalo Joe's owner - please open more locations in Chicago (preferably in the Lincoln Square neighborhood)
(5)
Phill C.
Oh boy, what else can I say other than "double sui with waffle cheese fries please". Back in the good old days, me and my highschool buddies would all pitch in for a double suicide party pan with lots of ranch. Just thinking about the food makes my mouth water as I type. The roughest part is standing to the side, waiting for your order. Just watching them make the wings, while you stand there is pure torture. They have such unique and of course delicious wings. Deep fried crispy in what looks like no batter or breading at all, then swirled around in large bowl containing a combination of buttery hot sauce. Crispy but not crunchy chicken wings with a unique butter hot sauce... and I always get the suicide loaded with jalapenos. One of my favorite places for wings.
(4)
Fletcher G.
I hate to be a nay sayer but Buffalo Joes didn't hold up to all of the "glorious" reviews. You end up paying a bit more then Buffalo Wild Wings prices but far less then Buffalo Wild Wings quality. I was extremely disappointed in this place!
(2)
AJ K.
I can't say anything here that hasn't already been said. I just want to lend my enthusiastic support. Been going here 12 years, from high school to having them cater my best friend's baby shower. I love it here.
(5)
Jonathan C.
Just take your $25 that you would spend on wing fest..... come here..... buy a huge tray of wings and enjoy. I personally will only order Suicide. Yup call me crazy, but extra hot sauce with Jalepenos on top and then more hot sauce just makes me happy. But I want something more than wings and celery says the imaginary voice in my belly. So I shut him up with some cheese smothered waffle fries. Well even though its 9am and I'm not hungry... I really want some now.
(5)
Adam K.
Another local haunt I have been frequenting since before I could legally drink and had to resort to getting loaded on drinking the hookah water at the hookah bar down the street. I think all the negative reviews from long time patrons are telling in that they mention all the good things about this place in great detail but then say the bad in one sentence. And then they go on to say that they will be back. Sure this place is flawed, hell, this place may not be the best for wings anymore, but it is an institution. A buffalo university. When you graduate from it, you will cast aside the wing stop Pizza Hut wings with a scornful smirk and declare, "I HAVE EATEN AT BUFF JOES! THESE ARE NOT WINGS!" I always have and always will get: Double order of Suicide - Spicy, what can I say other than I got a party platter of the spicy wing awesomeness once for the superbowl, one of my idiot friends liked it so much he decided to drink the concentrated hot spicy suicide wing sauce that had congealed jalapenos in it, and then had a fiery colon for 3 days. Do not attempt to drink a full cup of the sauce. But do get the suicide and Double order of BBQ - Oh man, so sweet and delish, these really compliment the spicy, and because of my Indian upbringing, I am partial to the spicy but these will always hold a special place in my heart, cuz they are loaded with cholesterol and will probably be either removed by a robot doctor or kill me. Waffle Fries w Cheddar - another artery bomb, but so good in so many ways, there is not enough room on the internet to describe my love for these particular waffle cheese fries. Just try them. They also have beer which is a newer thing, I have not gotten any here. They have a pretty large seating area in the back with TV's so you can watch whatever games are going on, the ordering process is a bit apprehensive as you have to explain and re explain what you want to the surly, young, often but not always african american youngsters who look upon you with disdain. Then after about 20 minutes, you give CASH ONLY to the fat white dude manning the register with very little patience for small talk. Just go here. The experience outweighs the negative feelings you get when your cardiac surgeon looks up at you from the top of his glasses.
(4)
Jason S.
Buffalo Joe's is pretty crappy. I ordered a single order of wings with spicy wing sauce and waffle fries. My sister ordered a chili cheese dog. Our beverage consisted of RC Cola (on tap). The wings must come from dead baby chicks because they contained almost no meat. The sauce wasn't bad, but the comparable sauce from Buffalo Wild Wings or Hooters tastes better. That being said, I can't find any fault with the fries. They were delicious. The pop however was a travesty, as they did not offer free refills. That is borderline un-American (or at they least cheap as hell). The chili cheese dog appeared to contain Kraft singles for the cheese and the chili had beans (gross). A friend had the charburger with bacon, cheese and wing sauce. It was pretty good, but make sure to ask for spicy sauce instead of mild. Overall, I didn't want to kill myself after eating at Buffalo Joe's, but I certainly can't recommend the place.
(2)
Matt A.
giving this place anything less than 5 stars is a joke, seriously. if you want a big chunk of chicken or some hormone feed bird with giant wings goto wingstop or some other joke of a place. Chicken wings are supposed to be small - i.e. NOT have a 1lb of meat on them. This is the perfect wing and the suicide is the only way to go. i've tried them all - bw3, wingstop, wingshack whatever - NOTHING compared to Buffalo joes. worth the trip to e-Town all day.
(5)
Art V.
As I've enjoyed dining at this establishment for years, it pains me to post this negative review. Buff Joes has long offered tournament-quality buffalo wings despite (1) questionable sanitation practices, (2) aloof employees, and (3) a dynamic pricing scheme. Generally, the men's bathroom is under-equipped and shockingly dirty. More often than not, the paper towel dispenser is empty and the only urinal is jammed to the brim with ice. That door handle has enough grease on it to keep a 1000 ships' engines humming along nicely. Things aren't much better in the kitchen where latex gloves are treated like commas in a David Foster Wallace piece: used occasionally but only when damn well justified. Regarding the employees, I've long suspected that the ability to appear utterly disengaged while conversing with customers is a prerequisite to getting hired. It also helps if you can act as if there is literally no task you would enjoy less than mixing pre-cooked wings in a metallic bowl full of buffalo sauce. As a rule, I'm hesitant to generalize and disparage the entire crew. The cashier is usually pretty pleasant and I've actually had some appropriate interactions with the ladies up front of late. However, given the frequency with which I've experienced sub-par customer service over the years, I'd be entirely remiss not to mention this issue in a review. Although I rarely deviate from my standard order (a single basket of spicy wings, extra ranch, and a mega-gut RC Cola), the price I pay each time tends to wildly fluctuate. The value of wings must be inexplicably linked to some mysterious economic indicator. I forked over $12.01 for my standard order last night. While this price actually appears pretty competitive with that of similar outfits (i.e. Buffalo Wild Wings), it's far removed from the less than ten dollars the restaurant charged just a few years back. Despite the above, I happily made the not-insubstantial trek to Evanston to feast on Buffalo Joe's delicious wings for years. Up until quite recently, the restaurant had some of the best wings in Chicagoland. The chicken was always perfectly cooked: crisp on the outside, juicy on the inside. The sauce was and still is, "to die for." However, my last two visits have been underwhelming. The employees seem to be overcooking the chicken these days. Additionally, the wings are now embarrassingly small. I'm comfortable wagering that they are at least 50% tinier than their counterparts at Buffalo Wild Wings and Gators. While I will likely return to Buff Joes within the next month out of habit, I can promise you I won't be thrilled about it. Patronizing this establishment is like watching a washed-up, former all-star at the plate; evidence of greatness lingers, but he's still probably going to strike out.
(1)
Leo S.
Pretty good wing place, but the wings,themselves, are tiny. The suicide sauce is good, but it's not that spicy. It's more acidic than anything else because of the preserved jalapeños. The waffle fries was delicious. The burgers were also not bad. Everything is also reasonably priced, but they only accept cash which I dislike a lot.
(4)
Courtney W.
This place is good for one thing, wings. You'll have to order a lot though, more than you think you need, because there isn't much on these bones. The sauces are pretty tasty too but the classic is pretty hot for me. There isn't much to the inside of this place and the service isn't the best but that's not what they're known for anyways. I don't go to Northwestern but from friends, I understand that this place is a staple. They put plenty of sauce on these bad boys though so you won't have to order extra. The wings come with celery too and plenty of blue cheese and ranch sauce. I can see why this place is so famous and as a foodie, I understand the hype. I just hope this place never plays too much into, no frills and good wings is what this place does best.
(4)
Cecil S.
The most delicious wings I've had in a long time, definitely beats B-dubs hands down. Go here with an appetite, try their spicy wings. Includes some celery and ranch as well, in case things get too hot! Looks like they only had Miller or Bud Light on tap, eat-in area is kind of small/cramped with local Northwestern students.
(4)
Kim D.
i like your bbq wings and your merkts cheddar waffle fries. they r so good. cash only and dont you forget it.
(4)
Jay N.
I've been here several times and parking can be found on Benson Avenue to the west near the el. I went again last Saturday before the Ohio State game and was surprised to see that it wasn't that busy. As soon as you walk in, you put in your order and once it's ready, they'll put it on a tray (or in a sack if it's to-go) and you'll get your receipt. You pay after you get your food. There's a decent amount of seats in the back but it can get a little crowded. It's pretty limited in decor with framed posters about food or hot peppers. There's 1 tv in the back. The wings come in 4 flavors - mild, spicy, suicide, and bbq. I usually go with the spicy as it has the right amount of kick. They add on the celery sticks and ranch sauce with the order. I really like their waffle fries here. The wing sizes are decent again. They were pretty small for a while and now seem to be a good combination of meaty, crispness, and sauce flavor retention. There are only really 2 order sizes - single and double order. I usually get the double order as I can munch on some and then save some for later. Next sizes up are party trays for 8 or 15 people. Overall, it was a very good experience to come back here again.
(4)
Sebastian Y.
Warning: The tiny wings at Buff Joe's are extremely addictive. Another Warning: Cheddar chips are waffle fries with way too much cheddar cheese lopped on top. Last Warning: The Suicide sauce is hot. 4 stars for the wings. 2 stars for the cheddar chips. I'll give Buff Joe's a 4.
(4)
Sonia B.
If you are looking for some amazing wings, Buffalo Joes is the place to go! I've been going to Buffalo Joes for 15 years and I can still say that they, hands down, have the best wings in the Chicago-land area. Their sauce is definitely what makes the wings and it doesn't taste like only tobasco...like most other establishments. Mild, spicy or suicide are the levels of heat and you can order a single order, double order or a party pan if you're really hungry! I love to pair their wings with the buffalo chips or cheddar chips and a gutbuster (medium) lemonade or pop. Yes, pop...not soda! :) I like my wings a little crispy, so I order mine well done. Buffalo Joes is definitely a comfort food and I probably go once a week! :) They have many other items on the menu, but I can't say I have EVER tried anything else there. It just seems wrong. However, it is great that they have other options...which look yummy...in case you are with people who don't like wings. Although, I have NEVER met a person who doesn't LOVE Buffalo Joes! Even people who don't like wings end up loving Buffalo Joes! Buffalo Joes has a couple of locations, but the one in Evanston is the best. It does get crowded, especially when Northwestern has a game - but seats open up pretty quickly on a normal night. The only downside of the place is that it is cash only. So, make sure you come prepared. Your belly will definitely leave happy! :)
(5)
Julie K.
I'm 5 months pregnant and I've been craving wings. We live in Chicago on division, tons of bars and they sell wings too, but nothing compared to Buffalo Joes. Not the cleanest place but it is definitely worth the trip to Evanston for their wings. It truly is finger lickin good.
(5)
Patrick S.
Probably the closest yet I have come to what I would imagine they intended buffalo wings to be. Buff Joes has to be on my top...3 of wings destinations. I was intro-ed to said wings several years ago in my high school years. I still feel like Im cutting class when I sit down to eat over there. So anywho..why I am writing a review now? Because I have never attempted to tackle a party platter in one sitting....till now. I speak of the $40 platter thats supposed to serve 8-12 people I believe? I have no idea what possessed my friends and I (yes! grammar skills) to attempt to tackle such a feat. Let me just clarify I speak of 4 people for this platter of glory. This stint of gluttony was the brain child of pure spontaneity and opportunity. 4 people, $40...how could you go wrong?? About 45minutes later..me and my partner in crime inhaled about low-mid 30s each. The 2 others wimped out and had about 10-15 each. A late comer came into the equation contributing another 10-15. In the conclusion of this session of man v food..... Food came out victorious...there was about 12 wings left. Think about that for a sec..that is a massive amount of wings! And let me tell you..grease, and spice.......youre just asking for it. A dastardly duo of disaster; definitely! They device a fiendish evac. Regardless of what is left on the plate after any gluttony bout...trust me, FOOD ALWAYS COME OUT ON TOP.
(5)
Eileen Z.
My favorite wings in Chicagoland. I've been hitting up this Clark location since high school. When I'm out of town, I dream of these wings. IT'S THE WING SAUCE. It's different from any other wing sauce I've had. BE PREPARED FOR GREASE. Buff Joe's wings swim in it and it's delicious. I love the suicide wings which are tossed with jalapenos, but I actually enjoy ordering the mild sauce more often because you can really taste the sauce. I find most people like to order the spicy, which isn't all that spicy to begin with. That's the three degrees of hot: suicide, spicy, and mild. No extras, just as simple as that. 12 years ago I may have given them 5 stars. But if I had to complain about anything about Buff Joe's it would be their wings have gotten much smaller over the years and that they only have a small coating of the sauce over the wings... much less than they used to. But I've found that this is the way I like ordering: - a double order mild with extra wing sauce (this already comes with ranch and celery) - buff chips (waffle fries) with cheese - large RC or grape soda The cheese they use with the buff chips seems to be a hit or miss with people I know since it's more of a cheez whiz type of cheese, but it goes beautifully with all the greasy goodness of the wings AND I LOVE IT. Even their ranch doesn't seem like a ranch I could just go buy at the grocery store. In fact, you can purchase pints of both their ranch sauce and special Buff Joe's wing sauce by themselves. This is nice for your at-home cooking experiments. In the past you were able to order the jugs, but they have put a stop to that. I haven't tried much else on their menu. The burgers are nothing special aside from the Buff Joe's sauce, but the buns they use suck and fall apart easily. The corn on the cob and broccoli cheddar soup are pretty good, too. But the only thing I keep running back for are the wings. Buff Joe's is cash only, but they finally put in an ATM a few years ago so if you forget to grab cash ahead of time it won't be a problem. The place is small and gets pretty packed, especially on nights and weekends since it's only a hop skip and a jump away from the Northwestern University campus. This is one of those hole-in-the-wall kinda gems. I've always wished they'd expand past Evanston, but the owner has said he never plans on it. Oh well. It's worth the trip anyway.
(4)
J J.
I used to travel for business quite a bit. I've been to basically 3/4 of the U.S. and my modus operandi was basically to hit up a wing joint anytime I could. After going to Buff Joes since I was a teen and experiencing the best wings you could only be disappointed going anywhere else which is exactly what happened to me. There is no comparison. Buff Joes hands down has the best sauce. If they put it in a cup I would drink it through a straw. And when there was not enough wing sauce to suck up through the straw I would tip the cup over and tap the bottom until every drop of sauce made it's way out of the cup. The same applies to their ranch dressing. It perfectly compliments their wing sauce. I can't say much about any of their other food as I've only eaten wings and celery here. The ONLY thing I can complain about is the size of their wings as I'm absolutely positive that they are smaller than they used to be. I'm not going crazy. Someone please agree with me. Don't bother wasting your time going anywhere else if you've experienced Buff Joes. You'll only be disappointed.
(5)
David C.
Some wings are really good, some are even incredible. Buff Joes is heaven. Yes, they raised their prices a lot. Yes, their wings are slightly smaller. Yes, they are more inconsistent than normal wings places. But really, you can't top that sauce and those waffle fries. I would probably be willing to get in the ring with Floyd Mayweather and get knocked in 10 seconds just to have a double order of suicide with some waffle fries and a large RC Cola. If you go to Buffalo Wild Wings, I can't speak to your taste buds (they are obviously very unrefined). I did really like Wings Over, but they are definitely a different type of wing, basically chicken fingers with sauce. Overall, best restaurant in Evanston bar none. James, who usually works the cashier, is the man, and some of my best college memories are at Buff Joes. I've never tried crack, but i'm assuming it tastes something like buff joes wings (and its probably healthier).
(5)
Frank A.
Party pans! Haven't had B.J.'s in a year! Still hasn't changed. Still the best. Eaten til cardiac arrest! - Haha. I made a rhyme! See the Party Pan pix! They'll make you want some!
(5)
Mikhail D.
I've been coming to Buff Joes since I was 8 year old. FIRST OFF: Yes, this is down right unhealthy, greasy, fattening food. But sober or not, I always leave this place completely satisfied and it's my first meal everytime I come home. And you're a sinner if you're not getting cheddar chips!
(5)
Mark T.
Go figure, I go to a restaurant that specializes in wings...and I order a burger. What is wrong with me?? A group of friends invited me out on a weekday to hang out, and they suggested this place. I didn't feel like chicken that night (wait a minute, wasn't that a jingle from a commercial from the 1980s?) so I ended up getting a Cheddar Char burger off the menu. The burger itself tasted pretty standard, nothing spectacular. However, the waffle fried were de-lish. Maybe I should have just had a single order of fries...that would have been an adequate meal. Beware, this place takes cash only; luckily I had exactly $7 in my wallet to pay for my meal. Overall, the place serves pretty good food for a pretty cheap price. You can't ask for anything more. My dinner companions all ordered the wings and loved them. I did take a look at their plates and noticed the small size of them; eventually when I come back to actually try their wings I'd have to make a note to get a double order.
(3)
Ted C.
Small. That's what comes to mind now when I came here on a recent visit. BuJoe's used to be a staple of my adolescence. Splitting a party pan of 'Suicide' where it was so hot it looked like my friends and I had spent the day at the pool. A huge cup 'Gutbuster' size lemonade to wash it down and a tray of celery and ranch-you know for the healthy part of the meal. The wings now are small-just so tiny that it made me want to cry a little over the now former memories of big wings/drummettes that used to be the calling card here along with the 'Suicide' sauce which was so hot but now seems a little tame by comparison-maybe my taste buds are dying off in my old age but I think they are just using a weaker hot sauce. RIP Buffalo Joe, you're not what you used to be. I'll miss you.
(2)
Eugene M.
In 1996 or so, when I was in that most miserable of summers between 7th and 8th grade, I attended Sports Camp in Wilmette, IL. (Sports Camp is camp for children who are so bad at sports that it doesn't even matter which one they try to play on any given day.) At sports camp, I had a counselor named Dave, and Dave happened to be A Very Cool Guy because when our troop slept over at his house, we could play Waverace 64 until 4 AM and then watch Faces of Death. Having that kind of night makes you feel pretty cool yourself. Anyway, while at Dave's house that fateful night, I saw huge container that I thought was reserved for things like laundry detergent or motor oil, and the label on it read "Buffalo Joe's Suicide." Having just watched a bunch of Faces of Death, I didn't even want to think of what that stuff was, but Dave assured me that it was just wing sauce. A lot of wing sauce. At that time, I'd never even had a buffalo wing, but I'll always remember that huge plastic vat. Flash forward 8 years. I'm at Buffalo Joe's for the first time, face-to-face with one of those vats, the memories rushing back at me. I'd only had buffalo wings a few times, and I didn't particularly care for them. Nevertheless, my buddies swore by this place and what the hell else are you going to do on a Tuesday in your first summer with a driver's license? Double order of spicy barbecue wings, cheddar chips, and a Gutbuster root beer. I had seen the face of God. The wings were perfectly crispy, and the sauce was buttery, delicious goo. The cheddar chips, a perfect complement with their tangy sharp cheddar melted until it just barely retains some texture. Words don't really serve that sublime moment. I just knew that I found my calling. Flash forward another 10 years. I don't even like wings. I think they mostly suck. I don't eat much "unhealthy" food. But if I'm in Chicago, or even Milwaukee or Indiana or Iowa City or wherever, I go to Buffalo Joe's. Consistency has taken a dip, yes, but...BuJo's is not just "my" place. BuJo's is America. The huddled, poor, teeming masses yearning to eat wings, waiting in line for their taste of suicide or double mild or even a burger. Young kids, old dudes, foreigners, whoever, They're all here. They're all waiting for wings. BuffJoe's has opened its doors.
(5)
Stephen C.
This place is a Northwestern institution, or so I'm told. The decor hasn't changed in 20 or so years and the owner is the same. It feels like a generic place from the early 80s -- clean but utilitarian -- though the flat screen TVs help. Long counter in the front to order and pick up food and then tables in the next room. The wings were tasty -- messy but that's what buffalo wings should be. We got hot but I heard the suicide are not too bad either so I'm hoping to get those next time. People swear also by the cheese fries but the cheese was so processed that i found them a little gross. But the wings. Yum!
(4)
Lisa H.
I have been coming here for a couple of years now. This place is a little old, have nasty employees, filthy bathrooms, and sometimes smell. Their tables are always dirty and sticky, it seems like they never would wipe them down. But the chicken wings are one of the best wings I have ever eaten. They may be small, but you get a lot with one order. The spicy or suicide sauce drenched on these wings are to die for!! It also comes with celery and ranch (always need an extra one because they give you so little). Get the waffles fries to compliment your order and you'll be all set for a delicious meal.
(5)
Nichole F.
I consider wings one of my very favorite foods so the first time I had wings at Buffalo Joe's, I was a very happy girl! Their wings are among the best that I have ever had. The waffle fries are great too!
(5)
Bobby C.
Best wings I've had hands down. Get a single of spicy wings (or suicide if you want them to double the sauce and drown in jalepenos) and a side of buffalo cheddar chips with a mega RC cola and prepare to get your face messy! The sauce is just absolutely criminal. Second to none. I've heard the burgers and sandwiches are great too but the wings are so good I've never gone astray. Is usually pretty busy and cash only. If you are ordering on Sunday during football season call your order in to avoid the wait. Got a lot of friends and family in Evanston so I'm in town every couple of months. I always try to get to Buff Joe's when I'm in town and you should too!
(5)
Eric V.
Best Wings in the entire world!!!! Single Suicide w/ Cheddar Chip and a mega RC has been my order since 1998. Eric Vawda
(5)
Cathy B.
wings = MUST GET SUICIDE IF YOU CAN HANDLE IT. DELICIOUS SAUCINESS. CHEESE WAFFLE FRIES = BEST THING EVERRRRRRR! Cheese waffles fries is more awesome than the Wings. Haven't tried anything besides the wings and cheese fries, but once you try the cheese fries, you don't need to try anything else. PERIOD. The people behind the counter look scary and intimidating but don't be fooled, they're actually kinda nice....
(4)
justin m.
I really dont get it - almost to the point of loosing sleep. I can easily look past the dismal service, 30 min wait (for wings), crappy napkins & flat soda - I don't expect anything different. However, the wings (aka fried bones w/ skin and hot sauce) were horrible! I've had frog legs... hell frog arms with more meat! But all is not lost. The sauce was simply amazing, all I want is some chicken to accompany it. Hopefully they will see this and the other reviews of skimpy wings and step their game up.
(2)
Tim S.
Here's how I look at wings: it starts with the sauce, but it ends with the meat. Their sauces are pretty legit; I went spicy and bbq in my first go around. Both were great. My biggest complaint was the level of meatiness they have on their wings. I think I saw an earlier review that referenced 'dead baby chicks', and - while a bit too descriptive - you get the point. You eat these wings to transport their sauce. The sauce is good, but it's not to the point where I don't want get full in the process. To their credit, they give you a TON of these tiny wings, so it's not like you get a half dozen or a dozen in an order. You get a ton in the order. This get's them to three stars. Their fries would have gotten them another half star if Yelp would allow it.
(3)
Danielle J.
Yummy wings & great customer service! I get wings here from time to time and had an issue with my last order. Dean was so nice, friendly and helpful and he rectified the problem for me. The sauce is addictive. I always get mild becuz I'm not a lover of all things spicy, but the have a twinge of heat which is fine for me. Will definitely be back soon!
(5)
Susan F.
I love wings, I really do. I'll try any flavor, from sweet to spicy. I'll try them bone-in, boneless, stripped, naked, whatevs, I'm down. An afternoon in Evanston called from some Buff Jo action. I had actually never heard of the place, but I felt that wings were the perfect cure to my hangover, and a cure for just any old regular day anyways. But, I ended up getting a tuna sandwich, while my friends got a big order of wings I could suck off of. I'm actually glad I got the 'wich...I'll tell you why: #1. The service was awful. They didn't even know what a tuna salad sandwich was (and it's been on their menu for what I can assume is for YEARS). I had to repeat myself several times, and even while they were making my sandwich, half of them didn't even know it was on the menu. That being said, it was very fresh and didn't taste fattening at all. Win! #2. Now, for the wings. I have never seen so much wing grease at the bottom of a plate in my entire life. No other wings I've had have been like this, I was kind of shocked. They were good and all...but not the best. They tasted like they had butter in them... Their prices were really fair, but I just could NOT get over that freakin grease. It was a major turn off. I really don't think I'll return here again much to my friend's dismay.
(2)
Pascal M.
Small, tiny, puny, miniscule, wimpy, scrawny, baby lookin' wings. Huge, immense, big, lip smacking good flavor wings. My office raved about this place. After an early appointment, I told them I would pick up some grub for everyone. We had a feast. The wings are delicious and the experience inside the place is cool too. I spent my wait lookin at all the interesting charm on the walls. Which I love doing at places like this. it almost tells a story about the establishment and acts as a reassuring testamonial for what your about to put in your mouth. I hear the burgers are great too.. Looking forward to going back for my office soon. Shoot, maybe tomorrow!
(4)
Amy L.
Why people rave about this place? The chicken wings are legendarily small and they do not take credit cards!!!
(3)
Richard L.
The only thing okay here is the sauce... But I don't like that it's a little sweet. You can also buy it by itself. The restaurant is grimey, the wings are tiny; it's not worth it. Doesn't live up to the hype. The cookies were actually pretty good. Large Oatmeal Chocolate Chip for 0.85$.
(1)
April P.
Yep, they're still here, doing the damn thing, still being a foodie landmark, the quest and one of the greats to have for Superbowl, NBA finals, and just a regular chicken run on a Saturday night. Even though they are smothered with their special sauce, they are still retain their crispy exterior, even after a half hour car ride home. Score! Love their bbq, not too sweet, not too savory. Their hot sauce is just right amount of heat for the rookies who can't take it. Can't comment on their suicide wings, but for the brave, I heard they're pretty outstanding. Open late, parking plenty even on the weekends. Fast service, as well. A half order of wings will run you about $7.
(5)
Jeanie P.
2.5 stars hm maybe it was the hype, but buffalo joe's is just okay. I tried the single order spicy wings and cheddar waffle fries, and it was just alright. Honestly nothing mindblowing. The aroma is amazing, but the actual taste is nothing to write home about. Wings are swimming in grease fyi (like a pool at the bottom of my white styrofoam to go box). I didn't really like the fake taste of the cheddar--- i'm very skeptical this is real cheese? It had like the weirdest texture after it cooled down a little bit. And I LOVE cheese but I had to scrape this stuff off and wished I had ordered regular fries instead. It tasted almost sweet. Definitely would not get that again. I also didn't think the ranch was tangy enough-- too much on the sweet side. And like a lot of the reviews say, the wings are really small... which I didn't think would bother me but it is definitely an aspect that could be improved. So props to them for being a hole in the wall place with tons of loyal customers and able to thrive blocks away from a BWW. But personally, just not very impressed.
(3)
Jaclyn Y.
The wings are small, but the sauce is soooo good. I like how the wings are crispy. The waffle fries are excellent with cheese!!! YUM. Can't wait to come back here.
(5)
Eric G.
Do not eat their food. You will become addicted and then I will have to wait in line behind you. Cash only. Mild is a friendly hot. This place is worth a ride up on the purple line.
(5)
Doug F.
Been going here for 15 years. All you need to know is get the Wings with Suicide sauce. If you like it even hotter ask for Double Suicide sauce. If you like it it mild, the wings won't taste as good without the suicide sauce. The suicide sauce not only adds heat but adds lots of flavor. The wings are so tasty, you eat one and before you know it, you have enough bones in front of you to fill a museum. Its the classic hot sauce , deep fried wings with side of celery and blue cheese. Expect it to be a messy. Grab plenty of napkins. If you have 4 or more (big) people in your party, get the "Pan" (around $40). Serving sizes are good. They give nice portions. Located in the trendy, rich, hip, college town (Northwestern University) of Evanston. Great neighborhood. The inside is a basic chair and tables, nothing fancy. A little greasy feeling because of the open kitchen with exposed fryers. Next door is a church that always attract pan handlers outside. Just be aware. Street parking. Bottom line is the WIngs. They're so good, I just keep coming back for the last 15 years. Enjoy and keep a glass of milk nearby to kill the fire!
(5)
Daphne L.
An Evanston staple. I've been coming here since high-school and it's still one of my favorite places for wings. The wings are spicy, like they should be, not breaded and deep fried, like they shoulnd't be. The waffle fries with cheese..lord have mercy! So good, so very bad for you, you must have them. The people that work there are great: friendly, get down to business and get the food out to the customers. Can't ask for more than that.
(4)
Stacy S.
Wings? Yes please! I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's since high school and this is by far the best wings I've ever had! B Dubs comes close, but it doesn't quite nail it the way Buffalo Joe's does. Now, I can only speak for the (mild or spicy) wings and the waffle fries, because those are the only two things I've had on the menu..with the RC, of course. Seriously, looking for good wings? Buff Joes is it.
(5)
Dan H.
Buffalo Joes is awesome. I have been going here since before I was ever born. My mother told me that when she was pregnant with me this was the place that she craved. I can see why, freshly cooked wings are slathered with a traditional buffalo wing sauce. you can order your wings mild, hot or suicide. When you order them suicide they come covered in pickled jalapeno peppers and buffalo wings sauce. It's awesome, until the next day if you know what i am saying. You must order the Cheddar Chips. They are seasoned waffle fries covered in cheese sauce. I could eat an entire party tray of these with out ever blinking an eye. I love them. You need to eat them there though, they don't travel well. I've also had the pleasure of eating a burger here, the burger was large and tasty. It is cooked in front of you on an actual grill that gives it a nice char. Go to buffalo joes, don't wear white and remember to tip the homeless guy out front.
(5)
Billy M.
Buffalo Joe's is my second favorite wing place in the world behind Bird's Nest. I have frequented this location for many years and they have never dissapointed. I also love their waffle cheese fries. This place has amazing food and a great tradition. If you are in downtown Evanston i highly recommend that yoiu stop and order a few dozen hot wings with cheddar waffle fries.
(5)
Derik P.
My favorite Buffalo wings place hands down. I've been here for the past 4 years. I have to say one thing though, the wings aren't as good as before but it still great. If you like spicy 1. Get suicide 2. Spicy buffalo chip (Waffle fries top with cheddar cheese and Jalapenos) Drools 3. Don't get mild. It sucks in my opinion 4. TIP THE HOMELESS GUY OUTSIDE. 8 OUT OF 10 TIMES I'M THERE I ALWAYS SEE HIM. Every year it's getting worst and worst. Smaller wings and more expensive. Still the best sauce ever for the wings but I'm looking somewhere else for better wings now.
(4)
Colin D.
The first time I had wings, it was at Buffalo Joe's. That set the standard at the time, and nothing since has compared. I think three things set Buffalo Joe's apart: the sauce (the buffalo and barbecue are both top-notch), the texture (tend to be a bit more well done than most, which makes the skin taste great), and the size (as the pictures show, sometimes they can be REALLY tiny. However, I like wings a little on the small side so you get some sauce and skin in each bite). The Clark St location is specifically my favorite - not all of the others offer the (excellent) waffle fries. Get 'em suicide style (buffalo sauce, jalapenos, and cheese), and make sure to bring your Lipitor.
(5)
Ju L.
So, wings: The sauce is delicious and oilier than most other buffalo sauces, but the "suicide" sauce, their most intense, is NOT spicy-- I've had wings with no spiciness designation at all that were hotter than these (case in point: Dixie Kitchen's Jamaican jerk wings). Maybe they only call it "suicide" because they're served under a heap of pickled jalapeno? If that is the case, I feel cheated. And holy heck these wings are small. Even Merle's menu, next to THEIR wings, says outright, "Friends don't let friends eat tiny wings at Buffalo Joe's" or something like that. I also don't love that they give you ranch dressing instead of bleu cheese. The staff is amusingly irreverent, prices are not as low as might be expected ($13 for a double order; wings at Merle's or Dixie Kitchen are significantly cheaper for a comparable amount), and shady characters hover outside and occasionally need to be made to leave by the staff, who return immediately to looking indifferent. This is a convenient and casual place to get something to munch on without dealing with a real restaurant, so I'll probably find myself back here sometime in the future. But I won't be too enthused.
(2)
Sandra Y.
I've been going here for nearly 10 years so it brings back so many memories the second I walk into the place :) I always order double suicide wings with blue cheese dressing, broccoli cheddar soup, cheddar fries, & a bacon cheddar burger. Everything is always soooo good! Speaking of which, I think I need to make a stop here soon.
(5)
Sarah F.
WINGS! yum! Buff Joe's serves wings done right. The chips (waffle fries) are delicious! Be sure to call early if you want to order some for a football weekend and/or the Superbowl. Also fun for an alum to reminisce about the old days at NU. :)
(5)
Scott C.
The wings here are the best in the country. The wings I got were nice size with lots of meat on them too, I stuck with the mild because the flavor is fantastic and theyr spicy enough for me. The "Buffalo Chips" are really good quality waffle cut french fries and the smallest drink is large enough to do the job.
(5)
Jon W.
The last time I was there an employee was vomiting in the patron area while her friends recorded the events on their phones and uploaded through social media. The guy who appears to be the owner or manager (fat guy, mustache) acted as though this were normal. I am never going back.
(1)
EdanEdan T.
Great sauces and fast service. BUT why are the chicken wings the size of my thumb? I felt like i was eating fried skin with a bone in it but without barely any meat. Luckily they give you more than a dozen of these mini wings...but still, i was hungry right afterwards. I dont even know any other chicken wing places that have wings this small...its as if they took baby chicken's for the meat. So weak. Def not going back.
(2)
Sara L.
Me and my bf came here based off of Yelp reviews and both of us left extremely disappointed. First off, the place smelled like a bathroom. I tried to not think about it but honestly, the smell threw any appetite I had out the window. If you REALLY want to try this place, order it for take-out. The wings were REALLY small, I'm talking, microscopic. I feel sorry for the quails that they are taking these wings off from because they're so small and cute...and their lives aren't worth taking for sub-par wings! I gave it two stars because the sauce was good. If they had meatier wings to couple with the sauce, the wings would be a lot better. We also shared cheddar chips (waffle fries) which were also not very good. The cheddar cheese that is used on the fries was gritty and thick. I'm a huge cheese person but found this kind to be really unappetizing and left over half of the fries untouched. If you like the thick and gritty cheese (my bf said it reminded him of the cheese used at Weiner Circle), then by all means, this is your place. Otherwise, I'd stick to the plain waffle fries. Overall, I've been to plenty of other places for wings that are significantly better than this place. I didn't really understand all of these 5 star reviews but looking at the dates for most of these, it seems as if this place has gone down-hill since 2009. Perhaps there was a change in management? Either way, I don't think I will ever come back here. I'd rather go to Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)
Gabriel C.
I have been going here ever since highschool and it is still my all time favorite place for wings. Wings are one of my favorite types of foods so there are times I stop by here multiple times a week. There are some times that the wings are small in size, but I go there so much that it usually balances out lol.
(5)
Jill M.
Well...this is sad for me because I have been a Buffalo Joe's fan for a long time (10 years or more), but I won't be going back after having a bad experience three times in a row now. 1. The employees have been consistently rude and occasionally down-right mean. Maybe they are all underpaid and treated poorly. I don't know. But, whatever it is....who wants to go out and be treated rudely just for ordering food? I don't get it. 2. The restaurant is a greasy, unclean mess. Yes...that is what you might expect at a fast-food place, but it is disgusting now. The floor is so greasy that you might slip and fall in the grease. The bathrooms are so disgusting that I watched multiple people go into the bathrooms only to come out immediately and say they'd have to go somewhere else. Seriously, the restaurant should close down for however long it takes and CLEAN UP. Maybe get new bathrooms and floors. It's surprising they have passed the health inspections. 3. The wings just aren't that good anymore. I feel like a traitor just saying that, but ti's true. They are tiny, expensive and the meat is all dried out. Not good. My waffle fries were fine. So, please, Buffalo Joe's...clean up the restaurant, hire new people that are trained in being pleasant and bring back the wings that were the best in the country!
(1)
Rae D.
Best wings in the city! Although I love me some hot wings, I prefer ordering the mild here as they have a great buttery taste to them. The cheddar chips are so good! Who wouldn't love waffle fries with cheddar cheese spread all over them?
(5)
Keith H.
You cannot afford not to go eat here. Why are you still reading reviews. Get your shoes on and go. Now!
(5)
Aurore L.
Joe was behind the counter. (well - I don't really know. But with his pony tail, his long side burns and his cap, he DID look like a Joe. And not the G.I. kind) He took my order with nonchalance, and I waited, wondering with a bit of disbelief what I was doing there, and if I was indeed in the heart of sleek, posh, suburban Evanston. Or if I had landed in hell's waiting room for hormone-driven high school students. They were EVERYWHERE. And hungry. And scary with their hands and chin dripping with wing sauce. Ok, I am exaggerating a bit. BJ's is not for whimpers. The normal order is 12 wings. What you get is more like 18, so be prepared. They are on the smaller side though. Therefore manageable. Cheese fries, a pop and game on!!! Probably not a destination in itself - it's really sorta shabby looking - but if you are on a wing quest...well....why not?!??
(3)
Richard H.
I've only been here one time -- and boy did this place make a bad impression! It was unclean and smelly. There was a layer of smelly grime on the table and ketchup blobs dried on the wall. The food is not god-awful -- but the odor and scuz are killer. In all fairness, I did not try the wings. Perhaps, I should consider carry out from here sometime, since others really seem to like it. If you want some greasy comfort food, I'd recommend skipping this place and walking a couple blocks to Edzo's.
(1)
Ben A.
1 Single order Buffalo Wings with spicy sauce, and mixed with XXX Sauce. The XXX Sauce is so good it works well when blended with other sauces. It's the strongest they have, and its not on the menu. Try it if you like spicy. Its not too bad.
(4)
Cassie S.
Messy. Greasy. Delicious. Not sure how else to describe these wings. Are they the spiciest wings you can find? No. But they are flavorful which, to me, makes up for that! I'd much rather eat a tasty (but not as spicy) wing over one that's so spicy that you can't taste anything but heat anyday! And I enjoy the pickled jalapeno that comes with the "suicide" wings. They can be hit or miss with the size/meatiness of the wings, but I think that's the case pretty much everywhere. Fries are good too. Especially with the cheese :) Not somewhere I can eat at often, but a wonderful treat!
(4)
Alex N.
Best wings on the planet
(5)
Brandon B.
I went back this weekend. Maybe they had a bad batch before or something, but the quality is back! Still kind of pricey, though.
(4)
Igor U.
still my favorite wings place. Get the cheese fries on the side.
(5)
Crystal L.
BJs is my #1 choice of preference for chicken wings. It beats Hooters, BW3s, and Wing Stop. Their spicy wing sauce is so unique like a mix of hot n cheddar?? I'm not really sure what the ingredients are but it's amazing to say the least. I usually order to suicide which is their spiciest sauce with jalapenos on top! It's great for those who love their wings hot hot hot. To balance the hotness from the wings I also get an order of their buffalo chips (aka french fries) with cheddar. Cheddar is a crucial part because its absolutely amazing here. My boyfriend isn't as into spicy as I am so he usually gets the buffalo chicken sandwich and it's just perfect for him.
(5)
James F.
One of my new found favorite places for wings. Good wings are HARD to come by, but Joe's suits the bill. They're fried fresh and mixed with just the right amount of buttery, fiery sauce. I was in town for a visit for 4 days and ate at Joe's 3 times for lunch! Yes ... it's THAT good.
(5)
Jaz P.
This fast food place has zero ambience but it's well worth the trip because their wings are my favorite - the standard by which I judge all other wings by. When I go to other wing restaurants and I'm supposed to choose from a variety of types, I always ask for the ones that taste most like Buffalo Joe's.
(5)
Jesse C.
Damn fine wings, friendly staff and lots of seating. A little dirty.
(4)
Jerry B.
The wings are very tasty as well as the beautifully seasoned fries. I can't handle the spicy ones though. They never skimp on the sauce & I should give them 3.5 stars, but I bumped it up to 4 because there was a BW3 ad on their yelp site & it's good to support local businesses like them. I wish that they would go into the 20th Century and get a credit card machine & help me get more credit card rewards... Also, the place could use a bit of tidying up & it sometimes smells like dirty diapers in there & I did not see any little ones frolicking... or maybe it could be the Depends.
(4)
J F.
Pretty small wings, but they are crispy. The sauces are not really all that hot, but taste great. Suicide wings really not that hot, jalapenos are kinda of a weird touch. Overall not a bad place to get wings, I would agree probably best in the local area.
(3)
Paul C.
I went here with Anita because she had read that BJs had the best wings in Chicago, and if there's one thing I love it's wings. Boy where we both disappointed. The wings are small and pretty bland. I've been served better chicken wings on airplanes. This place can't even hold a candle to BW3s. It's cheap though, and everyone is friendly. Definitely not worth the trip, but if you're nearby and want a cheap bite, you probably won't be too upset. Just don't expect greatness. Thanks for nothing Anita.
(2)
KING J.
I remember these wings to be damn good! Havent been back since like 1998, I better go back soon and confirm this!
(5)
MooMoo L.
My favorite wings place. Deep fried, buttery, saucy. For some odd reason, wings at this place taste a lot better than its branch at Greenbay Rd.
(5)
Dave Y.
grease grease grease! you can feel the grease on your face when you walk in here. if you have acne, you'll probably breakout just being here. but their buffalo wings are the best i've had anywhere. get the suicide sauce
(5)
C.S. C.
this has been a 5 star for me from high school to even just a couple of years back. here are my 2 reasons why the stars keep on falling off. 1. size of the wings: in the past year or so, the wings have been insultingly tiny. often times, i trek from far away to eat these once beloved wings hoping that i will leave satisfied. however, these days, after my visit, i am left to wonder...where are they buying these tiny wings? are these off the rejected chickens that don't make the cut for tysons or perdue? when i start to think that they are getting these tiny wings from possible deformed/malnutritioned chickens, i get sick. i mean, capt. buff joe, do you really have to get the worst of the worst sized chicken wings when your competitors are still selling good sized wings? 2. price - this is correlated with the size of the wings. i cannot believe capt. buff joe can go to sleep at night knowing that he is robbing people's money by charging so much for these small wings. come on dude. i know wing prices have gone up nationally. so i know that prices will go up. but other places like bw3's, bars, and restaurants are not selling cheap a** wings. at least their prices matches the size. it saddens me to think after spending so much money, time and memories here that bj's is becoming like this. what doesn't help is when people are still paying the money to get such low quality product. i guess that's why capt. buff joe can afford that boxter that sits out in the back. don't get me wrong, the sauce is still the best in chicagoland. also, when the chips are cooked perfectly, they melt like butter. however, the continued lack of quality wings with soaring prices is forcing me not to make the drive to evanston and find other alternatives around here.
(3)
A. R.
As stated by other reviewers, the wings at Buff Joe's are neither large nor overly spicy. However the modest-sized wings don't have too much fat on them, so invariably you still get a good amount of chicken in your order. If you have the capacity to eat spicy foods I would recommend the suicide sauce. Although this sauce won't lead to your imminent demise, it will continue to build heat if you lay off the blue cheese dressing and fries as you bask in the glory of these wings. And if you're like me, you'll eat the jalapenos that come in the sauce to ensure that the meal is as spicy as possible. I also had the cheddar chips based on the strong reviews of other Buff Joe's visitors. The fries were good but I was hoping that they would come in a pool of molten cheese. Unfortunately that wasn't the case, and that was perhaps the greatest let down of this meal.
(4)
Lenna O.
BuJo's!! now that's some, "finger licking good" stuff. Their buffalo wings are so tasty. The sauce just hits every taste bud in your mouth. There is just something distinct about it that differs from other places. And what better way to compliment the wings than with some of their waffle fries? great with some cheddar cheese drizzled over or just some ketchup - yum. I've also had their cream of broccoli soup, which is one of my favorite soups, and it was indeed good. Haven't had in a while because i don't live nearby, but definitely a place to stop at if you are in the downtown area of Evanston and want a quick bite to eat. Or if you are just craving some of their food and wanna make the trip! Sure beats having mcdonald's or something.
(5)
トモ T.
The BEST buffalo wings! I've tried the famous wing places in Buffalo NY, but I still like Buffalo Joe's wings the best. If I visit Evanston for any reason, I will always stop by Buffalo Joe's, even if I am not hungry.
(5)
James C.
My first experience was probably back in the year 2000. I remember their wings to be about twice the size as they are today with a little more of a spicy kick than the sweet plain buttery taste that you get today. Today, a group of my friends decided to hit this place up and try to kill a double party platter. We had 6 really big guys and 5 small girls so we didn't think we'd have a problem but to my surprise, we couldn't do it. After having a bunch, the wings become tasteless and the meat starts to taste like old chicken (I still have a weird taste in my mouth as I'm typing this). Anyway, I don't really want to waste my time writing a review on this place cause after reading some of the good reviews that other people wrote, I'm starting to think that I don't know what good wings taste like... I'd like to end by saying that I will no longer be recommending their wings. The prices almost doubled but their wings are half the size and they taste like the chickens were dead and rotting for a while. Will I be going back for their wings? Probably not in my sober state... but maybe after I smoke a couple blunts and a j on the way there... and then another j in front of the door... and maybe one in the bathroom right before my order comes out... otherwise, I think I'm done with this place forever. Sorry Buffalo Joe's... but you disappoint me and I will not be giving you any more of my hard earned money. And for all of you guys that gave this place a good rating... I don't know what to say to you guys. Either my expectation for buffalo wing's are way too high or you're easily impressed. 4/5 stars? Really? Insane.
(2)
John L.
back when i was in highschool and in college i would have given this place 5 stars no question. but alas... good things don't always last. the size of the wings have gotten much smaller and so has the quality. i would always get a party or a double party pan and split it amongst my friends.... good times. the sauce that they use is still good so if you go... i would recommend you getting individual servings so the wings aren't as soggy. i still love their cheddar chips. still 4 stars because i haven't really found a better wings place than this.
(4)
David L.
Suicide sauce....when I concentrate and remember how good it tastes...after 15 seconds I start to salivate. Those that have had it as often as I do will understand. For the light eaters, single order, for the real players double order with waffle fries and wash it down with an RC Cola... I know, right? RC Cola...awesome... Also, try a party pan for your next weekend party. but careful with the sauce in the car as one speed bump could mean a lingering smell for weeks...
(5)
Chris R.
Overcooked, bland sauce, no blue cheese. My wife and I went here to satisfy a Buffalo craving, but were disappointed. I'm not complaining; we paid $15 and got $15 worth of fast food, but it's not worth a return visit. I'm not from upstate New York, so I don't have the "only Buffalo has real wings" mentality. However, I've eaten a lot of wings in a lot of places. There are a lot of good places in upstate New York and elsewhere for that matter. Buffalo Joe's in Evanston is not one of those places. Flavor and quality are their downfall. The food we had was overcooked. The wings and chicken sandwich we ordered both spent too much time in the deep fryer, making them dry and tough. Judging by the size and shape of the wings and the breaded chicken breast, they were standard-issue frozen foodservice items. That might be ok in a fast food restaurant, but for a place that bills itself as a wing joint, it doesn't cut it. The wing sauce left much to be desired. It didn't pack much flavor in general terms, and had almost no peppery spice even though I ordered "hot". Even accounting for personal differences in palate and how spicy one likes their food, I still don't think their hot sauce has much flavor. The complete lack of a spicy kick is what makes me say this. If there were a little bit of heat I could say that it might just be a matter of perception, but there just wasn't any. In my experience, many Midwesterners don't enjoy truly spicy food, so what they called "hot" sauce at Buffalo Joe's might be perfectly acceptable locally. If you want true hot wing sauce with a tabasco-style or red-hot sauce base, you'll have to look elsewhere. (Full disclosure: I'm a midwesterner myself. I just happen to have spent a lot of time in other places and have noticed that "spicy" on a midwestern menu isn't as spicy as in other regions.) The wings were disappointing for what should've been a simple dish (wings + sauce = good eating, but not here). The sandwich started out with bad ingredients, and was not executed well. A gooey yellow ballpark-nacho-style cheese sauce was so thick on the sandwich that it overwhelmed any other flavor that might have been there. The cheese sauce wasn't necessary to begin with, and it became a case of too much of a bad thing. Finally, they only offer ranch dressing, and no blue cheese. A Buffalo native would have a stroke about this, and I personally think ranch dressing on wings is an abomination. It's not traditional, and its bland flavor does not complement the sauce's spice as well as blue cheese's pungent tang. The preference is personal, but Buffalo Joe's should at least offer the traditional alternative alongside ranch.
(1)
steph n.
I don't care how good they say the wings are in Buffalo, NY. Chicago's Buffalo Wings at Buffalo Joe's is THE king of the BUFFALO WING. I went here during the night of the SUPERBOWL and man was line packed! I couldn't even imagine how many chickens had to lose their wings to serve THAT many people! Then that made me wonder, where the heck did all those chickens go? Anyways, the wings here are served piping hot, nice and crispy, and coated with their TOP SECRET WING SAUCE. I believe it is a mixture of butter, vinegar, hot sauce, and ???? I can't even guess what the other ingredients are because I tried countless times to mimic it at home to no avail. I just wished this place served white rice. Do you know how much better these wings taste when eaten with rice? I even went scouring for asian restaurants around Buff Joes to order some rice, but I started panicking when I couldn't find any in the vicinity. It is the perfect combination...like PB AND J, like ham and cheese, like cake and ice cream.
(5)
Adam P.
I'm an NU student, but I'm from Buffalo, NY, home of the chicken wing. And Goddammit, it's all we've got. Having jockeyed a few deep fryers in my high school days, I like to think I know my wings. Buff Joe's has some of the best I've ever eaten, and BY FAR the best I've encountered in Chicago -- they're directly comparable to Duff's in Buffalo, which some would argue is the best chicken wing joint on Earth. Buff Joe's is the only place I've encountered in Chicago that understands that nothing but crispy frying and simple sauce can make great wings. And the rest of the stuff on their menu is pretty good too. My favorite thing is their grilled chicken sandwich, with hot sauce of course. They have excellent waffle fries and huge usually-solid burgers. I avoid the cheeseburgers -- they use some kind of cheddar spread instead of real cheese. The Char Dog is a hybrid of Ted's on Niagara Falls Boulevard in Kenmore NY with Chicago-style toppings. Yum. This is one of my favorite takeout places in Evanston. I just wish they were open even later on the weekends and that they had delivery. But open 'til 12am 7 nights a week ain't bad.
(5)
Patrick W.
I've been eating here for 13 years (since I could drive my little tushy to Evanston). I participated in a Buffalo Joe's wing eating contest in high school against offensive and defensive lineman from my school (3rd prize!). I wrote an essay about it for an english class final during my sophomore year in college. (Teacher's probable reaction: "Why is this yankee in my English class at Louisiana State University writing a final exam essay about hot wings from a place in Illinois? A+ by the way!") I ran two orange (partly yellow, partly red) lights recently to get here one night before they closed. Needless to say, I have history with Buffalo Joe's. The wings are every bit as good as they were when I first started going here. My last visit was the first in several years, but the order rolled off my tongue like it had only been since lunchtime... "Full order of suicide and a side of buffalo chips"... it was like a song. The chips are actually waffle fries, which really more restaurants should have. Suicide wings are the hottest they offer, it's basically the hot sauce but sliced jalapeno peppers are strewn about on top of your wings. My mouth is officially watering as I write this.
(5)
Michael G.
Three flavors: mild, spicy, suicide. I've tried all three. The suicide are basically the same as the spicy with a few jalapenos thrown in. Honestly, this place is overrated. Like one recent reviewer said, the wing sauce is pretty run-of-the-mill, nothing amazing. If you're in this neighborhood, you're better off going to Great Sea or even Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)
Ryan N.
My friends and I have been going to Buff Joe's for awhile now and there are some that love it ands some that don't. Single order of suicide , Gutbuster RC, and Cheeder Chips is our order. The other stuff on the menu is ok I've tried some other things but nothing beats that wings. The Suicide sauce is not as hot as people say its more of a great flavor than a spicyness which is the reason I love it. Great atmosphere and we usually enjoy giving fake names to the people who take your order.
(5)
Roger W.
Terrific wings. So so so flavorful. That is some magical sauce. The cheddar chips are mouthwatering. Haven't been there in a while...need to go back!
(5)
Alex K.
Buff joe's; cheddar chips + suicide wings beats all A friend of my roomate's lived in Louisiana, and would come to visit about once a year. He arrived around 10PM (after flying himself here in a cessna) and asked, before anything else (except a bathroom break) to go to this place. He claimed to crave it constantly. He would go there a few times in a 2 or 3-day stay. I totally understand. despite the negatives in other reviews (mostly valid on some level), you don't see anyone proposing better alternatives. The sauce and overall taste beat other places pretty handily. People giving bad ratings are usually wistful for days gone by... totally fair, but this is still the place to go for wings.
(5)
Brian S.
I've been coming here for awhile. Their prices have gone up a lot which sucks but I've always loved buff joes. i wouldn't listen to people saying this is a huge disappointment but i will say they are very very hit or miss. Sometimes you will get small wings and sometimes bigger ones and sometimes they were taste like crap or be awesome. The staff can be ok but the ladies who take the orders can be pretty rude especially if you can't understand them because then they just won't take your order. I have started migrating to the Greenbay location because their wings are a lot more consistent then this one. The only other place that really even compares around chicago is wings around the world but otherwise i'd settle for buff joes anytime.
(4)
John S.
I used to frequent BJ's ALL the time from '97 - '03 and their wings were GREAT. After 2003, we moved into the northwest suburbs and never had a chance to come often. Well, the past two times I've been there have been AWFUL! The wings are the smallest I've ever seen and taste like burnt/old oil was used in frying them. They're so terrible I still cringe from my experience yesterday. The worst part is I have been recommending them for years! Never again. Unless something extraordinary happens.
(1)
John G.
"Buff Joe's" has the best wings in Chicago, and maybe the entire world. I have brought friends from Buffalo, NY to try these wings and they all agree they are awesome. The secret is consistency. The same guys who worked here when I was in high school are still proudly manning the deep fryer. Sure, they don't flip the sauce bowl quite as fast as they used to, but they have plenty of that special ingredient that makes magic everytime: love.
(5)
Stephanie C.
i don't even live in chicago anymore, but dammit, i crave buffalo joe's wing's on a regular basis. sadly, i now live in LA, the land of mediocre (at best) wings. sigh... here it is, an ode to buffalo joe's: oh buffalo joe's, with your perfectly friend wings (not soggy, not dry, but crisp on the outside, juicy on inside) and wonderful sauce (not runny, and not too "fake" and thick - juuuust the right consistency). and don't even get me started on the cheddar fries. what is in that cheese sauce??? whatever it is, i'm totally addicted. my only beefs are the following: a) you don't serve blue cheese - what is up with that? thankfully, i can always stop at the ralph's around the corner to pick up a jar and sneak it into your restaurant. yes, i'm that crazy. and b) your "suicide" doesn't deserve the name. loading the wings with canned jalepeno slices does not constitute another level of heat. the actual sauce could stand to have a lot more kick. regardless of these minor flaws, i love you anyway, buffalo joe's, and miss you more than you can imagine!
(5)
Dee W.
Good cheap option for wings - don't try anything else - try the suicide sauce - it's a for sure spicy mouthwatering temptation. If you really want something else - go for the cheese fries - those are pretty good, too. Make sure that you go in a group - have one person stand outside waiting for the food and another person to go scope out a table!
(4)
Gil N.
Awesome wings. So-so service. The place varies from being a dump on some nights to pretty decent on others. But it's a Buffalo Joe's, what do you expect? Good wings, right?
(4)
Jonathan H.
Simply the best wings in the city. Period.
(5)
Irene J.
if you love wings and haven't tried BJ's, what are you waiting for?! i finally had some BJ's for the first time in 10 years, and it was delicious. we ordered suicide, spicy, and BBQ. the suicide sauce was addicting. i love their ranch sauce--get extra! they also have great buffalo waffle chips. cheddar chips and spicy cheddar chips are good, too. i have to say, though, i'm a bit disappointed with the price. back in the day, you could order an entire party platter for $20. it's now, sadly, double the price. BJ wings are a must have. be ready with cash (you know a place is good when they can survive on a cash-only policy), napkins, and water/milk. ;] yum!
(4)
Ramon R.
There was a time when I went to this place daily. Then I started getting repulsed by the sloppy appearance of the restaurant, the filthy containers and the fact that so many people here seem intent on gaining 50 pounds (though they're already at at least 250). Go here if you want to get fat and be afraid of catching something. The food is actually enjoyable, but only as long as you don't think about the likelihood that roaches and mice are running all around it.
(1)
Greg M.
Not much more to say other than the best Buffalo Wings I have ever tasted. Although not the biggest, but they taste incredible. The place itself is kind of scummy, but their wings are top notch. It's all I've been eating from here for years and they have never disappointed.
(5)
tina V.
Single order of spicy wings. Cheddar chips. Gutbuster RC (OK, or a regular one with less ice). My order four+ years ago, my order now. The perfect meal when you're in search of something crispy, fried and delicious. Also good for pre-game, game, post-game, picnics, parties and more.
(4)
Peggy K.
the wings taste way better than buffalo wild wings,, in my humble thought. Upon reading other reviews mentioning too much sauce, however, I admitted its true the sauce is flooded..but again, given that I always tend to credit those who dare to be different....Me have to say that this place has sold me yummy wings in prices that never worry my wallet. However, I wont recommend eating in after 9 pm since there was wierd smell inside. Cleaning time? maybe
(3)
Pete D.
A sunday night tradition while i was at northwestern. Mild, hot or suicide?? love the bbq as well.....there are times when it gets crowded, but this is definitely the place to go. Great option for parties as well...can't beat a few trays of wings! yum!
(5)
Bernard M.
Buffalo Joe's wings are simply the best wings in the world. A couple of my friends explored the globe trying to find a superior recipe. They even went to the home of the original Buffalo wings in Buffalo, NY and could not find an equal. Their sauce is addictive. We use to think that they drugged the sauce in high school and when my group of friends went away from college one of the first things we missed was Buffalo Joe's wings. Definitely get the mild because you get the full taste of their national award winning recipe (not just for wings! all foods!). Also their burgers get local rave reviews in a city that knows burgers... I love how they spread a thick paste of cheddar on the buns! Their buffalo fries, soups, and chicken sandwiches all kick ass. One downside is that since my high school days (15+ years ago) their wings and party pans have gotten smaller.
(5)
joanne y.
yay for buffalo sauce covered fingers!!! oh, and you have to try their cheese waffles (fries). this is the perfect place to go before or after watching a movie at the century 12 movie theater. you can always park at the parking garage for free or cheap (i forgot) and get it validated at the theater. this place has a hole in the wall charm to it with sticky tables and everything!
(5)
Matt B.
I don't know why people have such a passion for this place. I found the wings to be mostly bone & gristle - certainly less meat than BW3s for instance. I'm not sure what advantage this place has over BW3s, and I'm not one to talk up a chain. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here.
(3)
Nhu N.
you have to go here regularly to know that buff joes is amazing some days and eh ok others.. the last 2 times i've had it, it's been on point. HAVE TO get the cheddar chips they are simply divinnnnnnneeeee. Worth going to. not the cleanest place but they bumped it up with a plasma in the back
(3)
Alan R.
Without a doubt the best wings in Chicago. They have mild, spicy and suicide. The suicide wings are only the spicy with jalapenos on them. An orange sauce and then deep fried to perfection, I miss my Joe's! When I lived in Evanston, I probably came here about once per week. If you don't like wings, they also have loaded baked potatoes, awesome chili, cheap but amazing burgers, and dogs and chicken sandwiches. Definitely a better fast food option than the national chains.
(5)
Shimi L.
This place was a dissapointment. We got the suicide spicy which was hardly spicy, even with the jalapenos. The sauce was gummy and congealed. It was quite disgusting and I don't recommend entering this establishment.
(1)
Rayid G.
xxx suicide sauce...mmmmmmm
(4)
Max S.
Oh man how I miss Buff Joe's. Those wings/fries are soooo good. Heart attack inducing but worth it.
(5)
Zach W.
The reason I couldn't go any higher with my rating was because it would be suicide, just like the wings! Suicide wings will be the death of you - guarantee it! My buddy takes me here every time we head north to golf. The first outing he warned us all about the suicide wings, but nobody listened. Let's just say we weren't right for a couple days.
(3)
Michael S.
Simply the best wings I've ever had. I usually get a single order of mild, a side of buffalo chips (crosscut fries), and a large RC Cola. If I'm feeling fiesty i'll get a hot order (my buddies always go suicide, but i like tasting my wings). I'm a hungry guy most of the time, and single order can be a beast to finish. especially with fries. if you go for fries, i recommend asking for a second cup of ranch (ranch and celery come standard with the wings). If you do this right as they put the first ranch and celery on tray, they don't charge you. if you wait and make the checkout guy ask for one, he tacks it on the bill (at least in my experience). runs just over 10 bucks for the best dinner you'll have in long time. some reviews mention the wing size getting smaller. i've been going with my friends about once every few months for 5 years now and it may be slightly smaller every now and then, i just think its the batch, ya know? still so good, and i've actually had days where we got huuuuge wings. i wish i didn't write this review, i kinda wanna go now....
(5)
Melissa M.
Despite being dubious in terms of health and cleanliness, the wings here really are good. Unfortunately that is a testament to the rich spicy sauce rather than the meat, which is a little on the dry lower-quality side. Sides are pretty good, I enjoy their fries. The atmosphere leaves much to be desired...because well, it's a dive, but a dive with good wing sauce.
(2)
Ron S.
as good as it gets when it comes to getting wings in Illinois.
(5)
Jacko J.
Food is ok. Buffalo Wild Wings and Wings Over Evanston are much better. The reason I'm posting is to complain about the ladies behind the counter. It was a slow lunch onTues. Maybe 2 tables and about 6 ladies "working" behind the counter. It took them15 minutes to make my hotdog and fries. I had to endure them cursing and talking about all sorts of crap that customers shouldn't hear while waiting for food. I'm traveling so I need a receipt for work. I get to the car and realize the hens didn't give me one. I go back and the lady looks at me like I'm crazy. No apology, she simply grabs a piece of paper and asks me what I ordered so she can scribble it down. Hey Mr Buffalo Joe if you don't have a computer printing out receipts how do you know these charming ladies aren't pocketing every other sale? And why do you need so many of them when you're so slow? Maybe you should go on Kitchen Nightmares?
(2)
a w.
Their buffalo wings are definitely not the best, but when you add a good amount of suicide sauce, they'll become the best!! Its a nice restraunt, a very cheap eat, and a good place to come with a bunch of friends to enjoy good food in a casual setting!
(3)
Ben S.
Most overated Wing place I have ever visited. At best these wings are better than average, and the size of the wings are incredibly dissapointing. Chicago does not do wings right- been living here for two years and yet to find anywhere that comes close to Buffalo or Pennsylvania inspired Wing places.
(2)
Kat W.
This is a great joint for lunch/takeout wings and other fast food. Their wings are pretty good, but not the best I have had in Chicagoland; Mullen's on Clark has the best ones in my opinion. Having said that, the price is good, the food is good, and they serve pretty fast.
(4)
calvin n.
This place never dissapoints except for the sanitation ( hey its not Buffalo Joes if its clean) I've known this place and gone here for years just wished it was still the old price of 3.75 for a single I believe??? but one time which is still stuck in my head was that the person who took my order was picking his teeth with his finger which was absolutly gross in my opinion I kept a close eye on him to make sure he didnt touch my food. Service is meh... ok not to bad accept one guy gave me attitude for asking for extra sauce... great place though I take most of my new friends here.
(4)
steve c.
Good tiny suicide wings. Best? Not so much. Double order, waffle fries and large drink. (Dont ask but don't get the cheese for the fries) Always gave a different fake name. Comes with celery and for a double order its like $8 now.
(5)
PJ K.
Dingy neighborhood joint; pretty much a rite of passage for anyone who went to NU or ETHS. A full menu of fast-food favorites, but I don't come here often enough (like maybe once a year) to be tempted away from ordering wings, which are made to order and a cut above what's available in most bars. Berghoff beer on tap, too. A fun stop for cheap eats in Evanston.
(4)
James B.
Worth a special visit; as good as advertised.
(5)
Nelson S.
My friend dragged me from the west suburbs all the way up to Evanston to try these so called "Best Wings Ever" (and he is allergic to chicken by the way). One, I was happy that I wasn't driving so take me wherever and two, I'm not sure if they were the "Best Wings Ever" but they were pretty darn tasty. I'm not sure if I have yet found the best wings ever but this does place high on my list. I thought the wings were quite small in size, like I would use it as a toothpick but you did get plenty of them. If I remember correctly, they also serve waffle fries! I love waffle fries, more place should serve waffle fries! If I did live in the area of this restaurant, I would most likely come here more often.
(4)
Jenny M.
What's up with the sinking quality here? In the last month we've eaten there twice and both were ICK. Rotten celery, hairy wings, small wings, inconsistent saucing. We've done our share of damage at this joint over a bunch of years living in Evanston and never been as grossed out by last week's order taker picking at her hair and cleaning her nails while she was taking orders - and opening food containers on the line. Too bad, but they are no longer the only great wings on the block.
(2)
Jesster A.
Agree with the general concensus: not THE best wings - but pretty "d" good and the best in the general area. The Cheddar waffle fries are good too. Bring a roll of "thirsty" paper towels (just kidding, kind of...) Perhaps it's just our germaphobic culture rubbing off on me (I try to avoid most forms of paranoia) - but for some reason here (and other places as well) I enjoy the food more if I DON'T watch them prepare it...
(4)
Josh L.
I've been going to BJ's since I was in high school (about 15 years). The quality of the chicken seems to have gone down a little bit since then, but they still have the best buffalo wings I've ever tried - by far. I'm sure they'll give me a heart attack one day, but I can't stop paying them a visit every once in a while. It's a great place to eat with friends. I like to order my wings spicy with suicide sauce on the side (having the suicide sauce on the chicken sometimes overwhelms the taste a little too much).
(5)
Ted W.
This place is awesome. Has one of the best wings in the chicago area. Always have sports games on. There fries are pretty good to.
(5)
M. C.
Good wings, AMAZING cheddar fries! Dirty but good for a bite or for high school kids.
(4)
Constantine H.
My favorite place to get wings. I prefer it over all the popular wing joints including BW3, Timothy O'Tooles, Gators, etc. We order from here for any party or sporting event and any guest that's never had it before always asks where we get them from. Something about the sauce will keep me coming back for the rest of my life.
(5)
r j.
Is it me or does it seem that the suicide wings lost a heat level or two? Don't get me wrong the wings are still good but not as good as from what I remember. They have gotten a lot smaller over the years and the prices have gone up. The cheddar fries and gut buster R.C do bring back a lot of memories. Still an alright place to go to for wings.
(3)
Christina B.
Perhaps my most favorite place to eat! Why can't they open a Buffalo Joe's in San Francisco? I practically lived here during my high school years, and every time I go back to Chicago I have to get an order of suicide wings to tide me through until the next visit.
(5)
Eli R.
I get buffalo wings everywhere and these are the best I've ever had. It's kind of pricey unless you share (which I do not when it comes to wings). The buffalo chips are like waffled fries and are pretty good. A gutbuster RC should do the trick. Order extra ranch. Sometimes the kitchen smells a little funny, which can be disturbing. The wings really are great, though. The choices are mild, spicy, and suicide, but none are really that spicy. It's more about the great taste than hotness. Can also get crowded around lunchtime.
(4)
Nick B.
Best buffalo wings around. Make sure to try their suicide wings, you won't regret it.
(4)
Jaclyn C.
I don't know if I'd go with "Best buffalo wings ever" but they're good. And there's a wide-range of other options too.
(3)
J H.
I'm giving it 5 stars simply because there is no competition in the area for wings. The sauce is fantastic but its basically liquid butter with hot sauce and vinegar. The hot wings are fantastic as it provides an excellent kick to balance out the buttery sauce. Spicy barbecue is one of my favorite as it is sweet and hot--the best combo. Suicide is hot and it really fills the void after couple drinks. For the best deal, just get a platter or half platter and split it with buddies and don't forget the pitcher of beer to wash it down.
(5)
Mark P.
The perfect meal- double spicy, buffalo chips, and gutbuster RC. Love the spicy, buttery wings and waffle-cut fries. Avoid the Howard one, and stick to the downtown Evanston location.
(5)
Stephanie M.
I was smart and came here with 3 of my guy friends. We got this huge foil pan of wings and a smaller pan of celery and blue cheese. It is so much fun to eat wings slathered with sauce and get messy. Yea, I even dropped some sauce onto my shirt. I looked like a slob.
(3)
Yousuf K.
Always have great wings. However always received poor customer service. Only reason they aren't getting 5 stars. Also they don't take credit card. We are in the 21st century. I can go to a street vendor in Morocco and he will still take card!
(4)
Daria D.
I had the buffalo chicken sandwich. It was okay, the chicken tasted a little like it was fried in old oil but perfectly crispy so I can't complain that much.
(3)
Gabe H.
Some of the best, if not THE best wings I've ever had! I had a single order, mild, with jalapeño peppers on top. It was the perfect amount of sweet, buttery, and spiciness. Also, I highly recommend the waffle fries and a side of ranch. To describe it in one word: DELICIOUS. **Quick Tip! They only accept cash, but have an ATM just in case**
(5)
Sara R.
These were the worst "buffalo" wings I have ever had. I ordered the mild wings, and was immediately discouraged by the terrible smell. I took one bite of one wing and that was enough for me to know I did not want to eat any more. The fries were cold, flavorless, and soggy. The only thing saving them was the Merkts cheese. I will not be going back.
Ah, Buffalo Joe's! From being a regular in high school '92-96 (ufck I'm old!) to visiting just once in a blue moon these days...it's been a love affair from day one. At Joe's you WILL: - Eat too much - Finger the real cheddar (and not nacho "cheese" bullish) that didn't take to your waffle fries into your gob (British for mouth you uncultured twit) - Stop at an ATM first or have some cash on ya, ya lout! - Piss on ice cubes in a graffiti riddled bathroom (if you're a guy...God knows what women deal with here?!?) - Overpay ($8) for an order of wings...but not really because your fat ayeuss (mine too) *should* be splitting this artery clogging 1,400 calorie estimated meal - See Bulls' Steve Kerr spitting image brother proprietor of the place on occasion - Leave happy Joe's wings are excellent...they are a bit small relative to most but Steve Kerr says it's because the other guys have hormoned up preternatural chickens. Perhaps... Get suicide, ya wuss...it's not as hot as it sounds...just a mixture of two sauces and some wussified pickled 'peños on top. Buttery, sour, piquant delicious...THIS is the original aficionado wing of a North sider or suburbanite! I'd give the nod on wing quality and taste slightly...JUST slightly...to Bird's Nest...but Joe's is like your first girlfriend....you NEVER FORGET. Eat at Joe's, maggot!
(4)
Chun M.
During a visit to nearby Northwestern U, the admissions counselor joked about never going hungry as an undergrad because he lived above Buffalo Joe's. That was as good a recommendation as I've heard before. Never passing up an opportunity for college town eats, we headed over there for lunch after our campus tour. Street parking is readily available on this side street. You walk in, order at the register and wait to be called to pick up your food. The grilled chicken sandwich was moist & tasty. The chicken tenders were a little over cooked, but still good, as were the waffle fries. The namesake wings were disappointing though. Even though the texture and taste were good, the wingettes are so small, they looked like they came from downtown pigeons. A decent amount of about 13-14 per order, but the meat on them were pretty scrawny. You might have to get a double order if you're hungry. Reminds me of my college buddy who could stick a wing in his mouth, swish it around and spit out a clean bone. That talent ranks up there with tying a cherry stem into a knot. Wings are good for silly bar tricks to impress your buddies, but not enough for a meal.
(3)
Minh-An C.
Immediately walking into the store, my friends and I lowkey regret entering this place and started fearing for our lives. It was our first time in Evanston and we were unfamiliar with the neighborhood. The workers in Buffalo all looked intimidating and seemed to be staring us down. I timidly placed our double order of chicken wings and was curious if I could pick two sauce for the wings. The waiter replied to my question by a roll of her eyes and I was a bit lost..so I asked to clarify "yes I can pick two sauces or no I can't?" and she roughly answered no. So I settled for the BBQ flavored wings with an order of waffle fries. It came out to less than $20 and enough to feed 3 people. CASH ONLY. The food came out fairly fast and we quickly dug in. After the first bite, all my regrets of coming into this store went away and I was in chicken wing heaven. The wings were perfectly crispy and a right portion of meat on each wing. The double order came with carrots and celery. And the waffle fries were yummy, too! Cheap metered parking across the street and around the neighborhood. Walking distance to Northwestern campus.
(4)
Kevin T.
I've eaten here so many times, but only now getting around to reviewing it. I love the wings here, but they can be very inconsistent. Sometimes your double order feels like a 1.5 order, sometimes the chicken they serve you is really dry, sometimes it's soggy. However, they get it right more times than they get it wrong. And when they get it right, it's pure bliss. Some major downsides are that it's cash only and the service can be really bad sometimes. The people taking your order seem to prioritize chit chatting with each other over taking your order. There's an ATM inside the place where you can withdraw money, but of course there are fees for doing so. The eating area also never feels "clean enough".
(4)
Jeannie A.
I've heard great things about this place. After waiting about 20 minutes to get my order, that I had to remind them about, I sat down to a stack of wings the size of my pinky finger. Having great sauce is the only thing that kept me from complaining about my experience here. The sauce would be considered one of the best, if it was applied to wings of actual substance, with meat on them. After eating a double order of wings, I leave still starving and just annoyed that I wasted an hour of my life there. Not to mention the staff is rude, and when asking for a refill they looked at me with a death stare and charged me $1.50. The best bet would be buying their sauce and going elsewhere.
(2)
Leslie S.
wings are OK I guess- its the atmosphere I hate- just plain dirty- I expected a chorus ine to perform a dance on the table. Dirty floors, dirty tables, greasy dirty walls- yum
(2)
Cindy C.
Addictive wings.. One star taken off for lack of consistency of the sauce on the wing. Sometimes there isn't enough sauce and sometime, they're drenched in them. My mother in law loves these wings and that is a great compliment.
(4)
Naty K.
This place was ONCE at it's prime (somewhat of a prime), and is rapidly going down hill. The Evanston location is extremely dirty! Feels like a 2 AM movie scene when you're in the middle of nowhere, in some weird diner/restaurant. Yes, that's the feel I get when i'm in this place. The employee's are certainly missing more than half of the customer service skills needed to fulfill a customer service/ restaurant job. This place needs to be renovated into like, a McDonald's or something more useful. The wings are tiny, skimpy, and unless drenched in sauce, tasteless. The cheese sauce can be overwhelmingly gritty, and you can literally taste the artificial additives which makes me gag at the thought! This place does have 2 things going for it, which is... 1: The hot sauce (Which is EXTREMELY unappealing when I see it come out of that plastic jug that's probably been sitting on the shelf for God knows how long) but still tasty if you don't think about it, LOL. 2: The oatmeal cookies are yummy! Wish they were bigger. Overall, this place has def lost it's touch and is certainly NOT a Chicago staple! I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone, given the exception of a college student looking for a quick bite. TO WINGSTOP WE GO!:)
(1)
Priam D.
This was a cult place in high school, and I still come here every time I'm back in town. I know that we're all biased in favor of the restaurants with which we grew up, but these are the best buffalo wings I've ever had. I also love the cheddar fries.
(5)
Dan C.
The ultimate late night junk food! I always get the single order suicide wings.. and sometimes the waffle fries with cheese. For these places usually I call in ahead, but I do enjoy walking in, sitting on one of the stools, and taking in the local vibe. It is cash only, so plan ahead. The suicide wings are sort of a misnomer to me. It's great, but it's not thai "kill you" spicy. It's very sweet and tickles, and it leaves a very small heat after eating a few wings. I may be wrong, but I think it's primarily vinegar and butter based. The jalapenos do not hurt at all, so don't be afraid of suicide level. Waffle fries are amazing, and the cheese just adds that little bit of "I shouldn't eat this but it tastes so good!" My only possible complaint would be the small chicken wings, but if I think about it the wings allow you to enjoy the sauce more, which is primarily one of the reasons I frequent this place over others. Conclusion: for chicken wings, go to Buffalo Joe's. For fried chicken, go to Chicken Shack!
(5)
Timothy A.
Employees here are about as ghetto as can be. Rude as hell and talk to you like trash. Some serious customer service classes are needed here. Employees just don't care about the concept of serving and don't understand that the customer comes first. They practically threw my food at me when it was done. Hell I wouldn't put it past them spitting in my food if I complained about something seeing the type of people that work there. Below low quality, sub human treatment. Dogs get better service. Can't say much for the food since it was generic and as low quality as a hole in the wall can be. Chicken wings were bland, frozen and tasteless deep fried matter.
(1)
Brian N.
I don't understand throes of you who praise Buffalo joes. This isn't even food. Seriously the wings are TERRIBLE. I got a burger once and it had cheese spread on it in place of a slice. The food makes my stomach turn. They dump salt on the fried like there's no tomorrow and the people who work there are delinquents. They're rude as fuck EVERY time I've gone there (which is about 4-5 until I officially wrote this dump off) People saying "oh buff joes is great" must either be on a masculinity overcompensation quest OR just incapable of tasting anything.
(1)
B L.
Sometimes way too small. Service is horrible. Always getting more expensive. But it doesn't matter because it's still my favorite place to get wings.
(5)
JaeMin K.
Would probably be a really good place for wings if their sauce wasn't so sour and the chickens they use aren't so scrawny. We got the spicy and suicide sauce, but the sauce was more sour than spicy. It was so overwhelming that I eventually had to blot in a napkin before eating it. Suicide is essentially spicy sauce with jalapeños. If you prefer the sour taste of buffalo sauce though, it is the place for you! Their single portion is very generous--around 12 wings for $8. Make sure you bring cash because this place is cash only!!
(3)
Hannah H.
About a 2-2.5: Buffalo Joe's is an NU institution; this place is opened late, and they are known for their buffalo wings and chips (waffle fries). I usually get the Suicide Wings, extra well-done, with a side of cheddar chips. The sauce is more tangy and saucy, rather than spicy (there are slices of jalapenos on top to give it that 'kick'). There is a consistency problem with the size of the wings, as the size has decreased tremendously; in addition, the taste of the wings can alternate being saucy and tangy or tasting like ammonia (!!!). Make sure you request for fresh chips (waffle fries), as when it gets cold, you can't appreciate the thick powdery cheese sauce that comes on top (it's thick, creamy, and salty; this can also fluctuate in being a little less thick)! I love that they have RC Cola, which is quite refreshing. The tables are sticky, and the place is not the most clean and sanitary-friendly (the bathroom is another whole mess :O Also, keep in mind that they only accept cash. +Cheddar Chips +Suicide Wings (extra well-done) +cash only +sticky tables T___T +metered parking
(3)
Chrissy S.
If you're a wing lover buff joes is definitely the go to spot in the area. I've been coming here for over ten years and it's always delicious. I've noticed recently they've changed their sauce from a spicy buffalo to a more spicy BBQ type deal, but it's still really good. Another thing they've changed is their portions, which are pretty small now for what you're paying. They also have the best homemade oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. I always stock up on these before I leave, they're addicting.
(4)
Haley K.
Buff joes is like a treasure sent from heaven in a messy paper container. Voices go silent as wings are munched to the bone and other-worldly Merkts cheddar dressed on perfectly crunchy waffle fries are devoured. Take time to appreciate their strange wall hangings and paint color choice. Cash only makes you feel like you're in a drug deal for the best stuff out there.
(5)
Park R.
This place has delicious wings! Suicide is not that spicy, but hits the spot. They are very small, indeed, but they give you plenty of them. And that small size (and dusting with spices before frying) means you get even-doneness and lots of crispy skin relative to the small but toothsome and well-cooked amount of meat. Much better compared with pumped-up frankenwings, or boneless fakes. The waffle fries (buffalo chips) are delectable served with real cheddar -- yes, it's grainy, that's how it's supposed to be. It is called a pub spread, and the cheddar flavor is also great if you get it on one of their nicely charred, but always too greasy burgers. Always a good place for a perfect brat with mustard and grilled onions, and a beer for under $10! That is unusual in etown. The staff here does often fight with each other, and can be a little surly, but that is part of the charm. If you are nice and respectful of these powerful keepers of the wings, then they always treat you well. Maybe they don't really deserve 5 stars. But I must fight the haters. Sure, it gets better and worse over the years... I been coming here since the early 90's, and having eaten here about 100X it has never been bad, and always a fun time and a fair deal. Go Joe's!
(5)
Joani O.
This was the place to go growing up, and friends from out of town always wanted to eat here as well. Recently, not so much. Their quality has gone DOWN. The buffalo wings, which they're known for, are now tiny with hardly any meat on them. Very disappointing. (I also like Bleu cheese dip and both carrots and celery on the side; Buffalo Joe's only serves ranch and celery.) My daughter ordered a burger and not only was it burnt, but it was much more bun than burger. They also use the sharp cheddar Merkdt cheese which is clumpy and has a far too pungent taste for a kid. What's wrong with regular sliced cheese? Their waffle fries are good, but those alone aren't worth the trip here anymore. There are other items on the menu, yet I always came for the wings!!
(2)
Jay B.
-One of my favorite wing spots since highschool -wings are made to order and apun right in front of you -seats about 25 people comfortably with standing area tables in the front -cheddar waffle fries are a must, they are on the sweeter side -wings are a b
(5)
Rye M.
Bo Jo's is so ferda. I managed to get a few of my bots to make the long drive down here and it was so worth it. They didn't believe snee when I said it was better than bdubs. The staff is foyntastic but if you can get over the service the food is so worth it. I'm so happy the koozie king blessed me with the knowledge of this joint.
(5)
Ushna A.
I came here to eat with my Philippino friend who recommended this place. When we walked in the joint the black workers here had bad attitudes and were being rude. We placed an order , after receiving our wings it seemed cold. My Philippino friend Leo went up to the counter and told them the situation they rolled there eyes. He called them out on there behavior and the black girl looked over at another black girl behind the counter and stated aren't there people use to eating cold dogs ,( as in the pet animal). I'm totally appalled! I'm telling everyone about this in the Filipino community ...
(1)
Anish A.
Ghetto and rude! Once you walk in your greeted with rudeness. I'll stick to Buffalo Wild Wings and wing stop. The black people working here are extremely rude are not friendly. I over heard them talking about a gay male white customer who ordered his food just before I did. Once the customer left they started, mocking his mannerisms and joking about his alternative life style. I don't appreciate prejudice people. I canceled my order and walked out.
(1)
Eric B.
I love wings and Buffalo Joe's does it right! Some people see the small wing as a negative, on the contrary, i LOVE the smaller wings for the flavor they bring. The sauces are fantastic and their hottest sauce is perfect for me. Can't wait to go back!
(5)
Paco L.
Great food. The buffalo cheese chips are the absolute best. Come here at least one a week.
(5)
Eva S.
Buff Joe's.... always works their magic. When someone mentions it, the response is usually: "omg Buff Joe's, it's SO good let's go there NOW!" said quickly, almost panicky in one breath. Or followed by: "I need Buff Joe's, why'd you have to mention it, we need to go NOW!" When someone mentions your favorite type of food, you have a mini anxiety attack when your mouth waters and you need dem wings... That's kinda what happens... no matter what time of day. I always get a single order of Suicide Wings (topped with jalapenos) with a side of waffle fries ("Buffalo Chips" $1.89). Your order will come with celery and ranch, and a wetwipe (which you will certainly need). Sometimes I'll wash everything down with an RC. Their wings are freshly fried, then tossed in tangy sauce. A single order is $7.99 and you better bring cash because it's CASH only... but they have a generic ATM right inside the restaurant in case you forget. They also serve beer and these little oatmeal chocolate chip cookies in a huge tub by the cashier, which look heavenly, but I never have room for dessert. Also, they have a "XXX" sauce which is a spicy habenero-type darker red sauce... which I have only requested on the side as a sample because I heard eating an order with that sauce is brutal for your tastebuds. Try it on the side first to see if you'll like it because once you start it's so spicy it hurts. So maybe I have an unhealthy relationship with this place. But if wings were ever going inside my stomach, they better be from here. When friends visit from out of town, I'll take them to Buff Joe's and with a serious face, say: "These are the best wings in Chicago." (Deep dish pizza will be tomorrow night...) I only go to the Clark location, although there are two others on Green Bay and Howard. After I have gone and out-done myself again in the form of massive wing consumption, I say I've reached my Buff Joe's quota, forever. But of course I end up coming back the following month or so. This stuff is on par with being one of my last meals on urf. Heaven on urf...earth.
(5)
Leonel H.
This establishment has gone from a 90'S SENSATION to a ghetto establishment the culture isn't there anymore. The customer service is a joke I had a complaint with the bonanza special I brought it to their attention staff did not show any sympoyhy. Also since when was it o k to sell drugs in a restaurant. Literally there was a drug deal going on in there when I sat down and ate my food. The quality of the meat chicken ribs whatever is digesting. Whoever is the current owner of this establishment shame on u.
(1)
Anthony P.
I go to buff Joe's with my buddies all the time. I seem to be the only one who finds the wings to be just ok. The wings are somewhat small, and they are a little too crispy and dry. Also, the sauce they put on the wings is a little bland and lacks a distinct taste. Buffalo Joe's also does not have the greatest variety of sauces, with only three different variations. The interior is also not the cleanest place on earth. If you want better wings and better variety, I would head over to wings over Evanston just a couple blocks away.
(3)
Jonathan N.
Having had the opportunity to eat at some of the best wing joints in the US, I was sorely disappointed in the food, cleanliness, customer service, and overall first impression of Buffalo Joes. The wings were soggy, swimming in a gag-inducing mild sauce, and fatty. I am so used to grilled, crispy/charred, or at least baked crisp and not soggy wings. Mother Pluckers throughout Texas is a good example of awesome wings. Spending a few days shadowing that Texas institution might serve the ownership of Buffalo Joes well. I doubt if I will ever go back to BJs again. Regardless of the reviews, it's prima facie evidence that the fans and locals have limited experience in what a good wing tastes like.
(1)
Karen C.
Holy deliciousness! Went out looking initially for a good burger to take home. After discovering one place was closed, my friend suggested grabbing something from here. We went all out. Split some spicy wings and cheese fries. And then had a sandwich each. The wings. So good! I cannot say enough good things about them. Cheese fries...eh. The cheese wasn't what I was expecting. But the fries themselves, yes! We both decided the sandwiches were good. But honestly it's all about the wings! I cannot wait to go back.
(5)
Shawn J.
Could EASILY be the best wings in Chicago if they stopped using anorexic chickens...the wings barely have any meat on them! Their sauce is the best I've ever tasted, though. Also, they only accept cash. It's 2015. Other establishments accept electronic payment and these dudes can't get a credit card reader. One last complaint, they charge 50 cents for a teaspoon of ranch if you want extra.
(3)
Lauren G.
Best.wings.ever. Order them spicy with a side of buffalo chips and an RC. I mean it's the best combo for some reason or another. Sometimes it can be a real hit or miss but regardless it's delicious. What I mean is just sometimes it's not as good(when they skimp on the sauce hmph) and sometimes it's really on point. Like any place really. CASH ONLY. 12.00 for everything. The order comes with like 10-12 wings. The buffalo chips are seasoned so well. I recommend eating there the wings and fries can get soggy taking it to go not as good but still good. The sauce is like crack I swear idk what they put in it but it makes you want more! O_o! The wings itself are little with a good amount of meat. If you're not a fan of little wings and more for the bigger sized I would say still try but you may be disappointed.
(5)
Andrew Z.
My friends took me here since I was visiting them. They asked me what I was in the mood for and I replied "something with protein". I think mounds of chicken qualify. I don't usually get buffalo flavor wings at places like Buffalo Wild Wings - usually I opt for some variation of "savory" (spicy garlic, parmesan garlic, garlic fries... I really like garlic, ok?) but I ordered the Mild wings here and really liked them. I don't know how they make the sauce, but it's seemed to be more savory and less vinegary than the ones I've had. So if you're like me, and usually don't like buffalo wings, I would still suggest trying this place out. Good stuff, Buff Joe's.
(4)
Albert M.
BEST BUFFALO WINGS IN AMERICA! HANDS DOWN, NO QUESTIONS ASKED!! Chicago is a city rich and immersed in history from the water tower to Mrs. O'Leary, the Cubs/Sox/Bears/Bulls, the Daly's. This city is also known as the city of broad shoulders which I directly attribute to the fact that it is freezing, so you gotta eat a lot and that's why Chicago is a city so rich and immersed in incredible food....deep dish pizza, hot dogs, italian beef, popcorn, and so on. But my favorite place in all of Chicago is a hole in the wall buffalo wing place where spicy perfection lies. It's the one place I MUST go whenever I am in town, no ifs, ands or buts. It's called Buffalo Joes, or to the locals Buff Joe's. It is cash only. It is run by employees just as angry as the Wiener Circle a few miles south. I argue the employees of Wiener Circle work during the day at Buff Joe's and the night at the Circle of Wiener. This place has burgers, hot dogs, italian beef, but you come for the wings, the celery and the ranch. I am pretty sure that this place has been open 40+ years and my father in law was the first to order a burger. The wings are giant and so meaty. The wings are cooked perfectly. The sauce is buttery and perfect. Get the suicide...its just their normal hot wings with jalapenos. Get the cheese fries! Get a large RC! PERFECTION!Wings, cheese fries, and RC with extra ranch and celery from Buff Joe's is on my short list for finals meals if I was on death row. SPRINT, DO NOT RUN, DO NOT WALK!!!!!!
(5)
Marikit R.
Best chicken wings in town! I'm a girl who can handle her spice, so suicide (which is basically spicy with jalapeños on top) order for me! Whether you got the single or double order, there's a complimentary of celery with the order! The waffle fries are good too! The ranch they give you is pretty small, so I ask for two extra ranch and they charge a quarter each. The cookies are amazing too! Might not look like it because its in a sketchy non transparent container, that looks like it hasn't been cleaned, but trust me, the oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are a must! The only bad thing of this place, to me at least, is the cheddar cheese. It's tastes, old? Maybe I got a bad batch but I know I won't ever get the cheese on my fries again.
(4)
Jenn E.
I'm sad to say that this place really failed to meet my expectations. Came here with high expectations given the Yelp reviews but was really disappointed. Service was fast and pleasant enough and I didn't get any raw chicken but it was really not great. I got spicy wings (sorry Yelp fans, suicide is just too much for me) and waited while they freshly prepared them and then took them home where I ate them immediately. Unfortunately, in the very short walk home, the sauce seemed to separate and i was left with an oily goo in the bottom of the container and some wings that were basically dry. Aside from the texture, the sauce was ok but it was really oily which was pretty gross to me. The wings themselves were also pretty sad. The meat was sparse and tough and at times was too tough for me to chew through without some serious effort. I would have preferred way less but more meaty wings. Towards the end I was swirling the wings in sauce in hopes that it might make it all better but honestly no matter what I tried my wings were pretty tasteless, sauce was oily and I agree with others, there is a really weird after taste. Also, they only have ranch! Cash only. I want to say I'll try it again, but honestly, it won't be for a very long time, if ever.
(1)
Victoria S.
This place serves the best diggitey-darn wings I have ever figgitey figgety fricken tried. Despite having to pay with cash (always got sacks) this place really tickles my taste buds and goes great with other types of bud. You really need to get down and dirty but it's a great messy first date! The wings are so succulent they should have a novel written about them. I am writing that novel. Check back in a few days, for now let me provide you with a single excerpt. "I would never, could never, forget that moment. It has been burned into my memory by the unrelenting flaming heat of Buffalo Joe's sauce. The crunchy flesh of wild, possibly free range FDA organic, chicken fell of the bone like an avalanche of meat crashing down Mt. Everest and onto the head of unsuspecting Victor Sunkelson, the first man I killed."
(5)
Richard Y.
One of my previous favs has unfortunately gone downhill. 'Had lunch here with a friend today. The wings are good but the size and crispness have declined, as has the order accuracy. I ordered a chix salad sandwich and received a grilled chix breast sandwich-- huh? And cash only? In the 21st century? Luckily I had cash on me. Buff j s used to have an edge on food and service but has, IMHO, lost it.
(3)
Feb S.
Taste: 3.5 Location: 4 Cleanliness: 3.5 Ambience: 3 Value: 3.5 Service: 3 OVERALL = 3.5 * Out of a 5-point scale I got the Suicide Wings and Spicy Cheddar Waffle Fries (they call them Chips). The taste was pretty good, but for Suicide Wings, I expected something much spicier but was let down instead. Overall it still can't beat Buffalo Wild Wings flavors. I'd still recommend this though for anyone looking for Wings in downtown Evanston.
(4)
Dee S.
How does this place get great reviews? Haha, I guess you have to be from Evanston to get it. The wings are amazing...IF you like extremely tiny, super greasy pigeon wings with stomach acid for sauce these will be right up your alley! The fries OH EM GEE the fries were so good, the best cardboard I've ever had! The ketchup was so good and fresh too..this place just really knows how to give you violent diarrhea.. What a clean establishment this is might I add, it looks like its cleaned on a daily basis, I love the giant stain right where the overhead menu used to be..
(1)
Shajan K.
I haven't been here in years and I remembered why I stopped going...CASH ONLY policy! Otherwise, the wings are great, especially suicide style! Soaked in sauce and jalapenos? Can't ever go wrong with that! Cheese fries can use a little work.
(4)
Ian S.
So I've been getting BJ's (Buffalo Joe's) for a long time but only at this location. If you want the better wings and fries, this location is IT! Can't say much for the other ones but they were meh. So onto the review, if you love spicy wings, you have to get suicide wings. If you're like me, a double order is more than enough. It comes with jalapeños on the wings and the sauce is awesomesauce! If you dine in, they serve beer too! Don't forget to order suicide cheddar chips with your meal. It's waffle fries smothered in awesome cheddar and suicide sauce! Ok now this review is making me crave BJ's. I'll make a stop this week. Ahhhhhhh! P.S. If you make buffalo chicken dip, try substituting franks red hot with the suicide sauce. You can order some on the side and trust me, you won't regret it! It's always a hit and perfect for watching Da Bears game.
(5)
Gabe H.
Some of the best, if not THE best wings I've ever had! I had a single order, mild, with jalapeño peppers on top. It was the perfect amount of sweet, buttery, and spiciness. Also, I highly recommend the waffle fries and a side of ranch. To describe it in one word: DELICIOUS. **Quick Tip! They only accept cash, but have an ATM just in case**
(5)
Sara R.
These were the worst "buffalo" wings I have ever had. I ordered the mild wings, and was immediately discouraged by the terrible smell. I took one bite of one wing and that was enough for me to know I did not want to eat any more. The fries were cold, flavorless, and soggy. The only thing saving them was the Merkts cheese. I will not be going back.
(1)
Alex A.
Ah, Buffalo Joe's! From being a regular in high school '92-96 (ufck I'm old!) to visiting just once in a blue moon these days...it's been a love affair from day one. At Joe's you WILL: - Eat too much - Finger the real cheddar (and not nacho "cheese" bullish) that didn't take to your waffle fries into your gob (British for mouth you uncultured twit) - Stop at an ATM first or have some cash on ya, ya lout! - Piss on ice cubes in a graffiti riddled bathroom (if you're a guy...God knows what women deal with here?!?) - Overpay ($8) for an order of wings...but not really because your fat ayeuss (mine too) *should* be splitting this artery clogging 1,400 calorie estimated meal - See Bulls' Steve Kerr spitting image brother proprietor of the place on occasion - Leave happy Joe's wings are excellent...they are a bit small relative to most but Steve Kerr says it's because the other guys have hormoned up preternatural chickens. Perhaps... Get suicide, ya wuss...it's not as hot as it sounds...just a mixture of two sauces and some wussified pickled 'peños on top. Buttery, sour, piquant delicious...THIS is the original aficionado wing of a North sider or suburbanite! I'd give the nod on wing quality and taste slightly...JUST slightly...to Bird's Nest...but Joe's is like your first girlfriend....you NEVER FORGET. Eat at Joe's, maggot!
(4)
Chun M.
During a visit to nearby Northwestern U, the admissions counselor joked about never going hungry as an undergrad because he lived above Buffalo Joe's. That was as good a recommendation as I've heard before. Never passing up an opportunity for college town eats, we headed over there for lunch after our campus tour. Street parking is readily available on this side street. You walk in, order at the register and wait to be called to pick up your food. The grilled chicken sandwich was moist & tasty. The chicken tenders were a little over cooked, but still good, as were the waffle fries. The namesake wings were disappointing though. Even though the texture and taste were good, the wingettes are so small, they looked like they came from downtown pigeons. A decent amount of about 13-14 per order, but the meat on them were pretty scrawny. You might have to get a double order if you're hungry. Reminds me of my college buddy who could stick a wing in his mouth, swish it around and spit out a clean bone. That talent ranks up there with tying a cherry stem into a knot. Wings are good for silly bar tricks to impress your buddies, but not enough for a meal.
(3)
Minh-An C.
Immediately walking into the store, my friends and I lowkey regret entering this place and started fearing for our lives. It was our first time in Evanston and we were unfamiliar with the neighborhood. The workers in Buffalo all looked intimidating and seemed to be staring us down. I timidly placed our double order of chicken wings and was curious if I could pick two sauce for the wings. The waiter replied to my question by a roll of her eyes and I was a bit lost..so I asked to clarify "yes I can pick two sauces or no I can't?" and she roughly answered no. So I settled for the BBQ flavored wings with an order of waffle fries. It came out to less than $20 and enough to feed 3 people. CASH ONLY. The food came out fairly fast and we quickly dug in. After the first bite, all my regrets of coming into this store went away and I was in chicken wing heaven. The wings were perfectly crispy and a right portion of meat on each wing. The double order came with carrots and celery. And the waffle fries were yummy, too! Cheap metered parking across the street and around the neighborhood. Walking distance to Northwestern campus.
(4)
Kevin T.
I've eaten here so many times, but only now getting around to reviewing it. I love the wings here, but they can be very inconsistent. Sometimes your double order feels like a 1.5 order, sometimes the chicken they serve you is really dry, sometimes it's soggy. However, they get it right more times than they get it wrong. And when they get it right, it's pure bliss. Some major downsides are that it's cash only and the service can be really bad sometimes. The people taking your order seem to prioritize chit chatting with each other over taking your order. There's an ATM inside the place where you can withdraw money, but of course there are fees for doing so. The eating area also never feels "clean enough".
(4)
Jeannie A.
I've heard great things about this place. After waiting about 20 minutes to get my order, that I had to remind them about, I sat down to a stack of wings the size of my pinky finger. Having great sauce is the only thing that kept me from complaining about my experience here. The sauce would be considered one of the best, if it was applied to wings of actual substance, with meat on them. After eating a double order of wings, I leave still starving and just annoyed that I wasted an hour of my life there. Not to mention the staff is rude, and when asking for a refill they looked at me with a death stare and charged me $1.50. The best bet would be buying their sauce and going elsewhere.
(2)
Leslie S.
wings are OK I guess- its the atmosphere I hate- just plain dirty- I expected a chorus ine to perform a dance on the table. Dirty floors, dirty tables, greasy dirty walls- yum
(2)
Cindy C.
Addictive wings.. One star taken off for lack of consistency of the sauce on the wing. Sometimes there isn't enough sauce and sometime, they're drenched in them. My mother in law loves these wings and that is a great compliment.
(4)
Naty K.
This place was ONCE at it's prime (somewhat of a prime), and is rapidly going down hill. The Evanston location is extremely dirty! Feels like a 2 AM movie scene when you're in the middle of nowhere, in some weird diner/restaurant. Yes, that's the feel I get when i'm in this place. The employee's are certainly missing more than half of the customer service skills needed to fulfill a customer service/ restaurant job. This place needs to be renovated into like, a McDonald's or something more useful. The wings are tiny, skimpy, and unless drenched in sauce, tasteless. The cheese sauce can be overwhelmingly gritty, and you can literally taste the artificial additives which makes me gag at the thought! This place does have 2 things going for it, which is... 1: The hot sauce (Which is EXTREMELY unappealing when I see it come out of that plastic jug that's probably been sitting on the shelf for God knows how long) but still tasty if you don't think about it, LOL. 2: The oatmeal cookies are yummy! Wish they were bigger. Overall, this place has def lost it's touch and is certainly NOT a Chicago staple! I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone, given the exception of a college student looking for a quick bite. TO WINGSTOP WE GO!:)
(1)
Priam D.
This was a cult place in high school, and I still come here every time I'm back in town. I know that we're all biased in favor of the restaurants with which we grew up, but these are the best buffalo wings I've ever had. I also love the cheddar fries.
(5)
Dan C.
The ultimate late night junk food! I always get the single order suicide wings.. and sometimes the waffle fries with cheese. For these places usually I call in ahead, but I do enjoy walking in, sitting on one of the stools, and taking in the local vibe. It is cash only, so plan ahead. The suicide wings are sort of a misnomer to me. It's great, but it's not thai "kill you" spicy. It's very sweet and tickles, and it leaves a very small heat after eating a few wings. I may be wrong, but I think it's primarily vinegar and butter based. The jalapenos do not hurt at all, so don't be afraid of suicide level. Waffle fries are amazing, and the cheese just adds that little bit of "I shouldn't eat this but it tastes so good!" My only possible complaint would be the small chicken wings, but if I think about it the wings allow you to enjoy the sauce more, which is primarily one of the reasons I frequent this place over others. Conclusion: for chicken wings, go to Buffalo Joe's. For fried chicken, go to Chicken Shack!
(5)
Timothy A.
Employees here are about as ghetto as can be. Rude as hell and talk to you like trash. Some serious customer service classes are needed here. Employees just don't care about the concept of serving and don't understand that the customer comes first. They practically threw my food at me when it was done. Hell I wouldn't put it past them spitting in my food if I complained about something seeing the type of people that work there. Below low quality, sub human treatment. Dogs get better service. Can't say much for the food since it was generic and as low quality as a hole in the wall can be. Chicken wings were bland, frozen and tasteless deep fried matter.
(1)
Brian N.
I don't understand throes of you who praise Buffalo joes. This isn't even food. Seriously the wings are TERRIBLE. I got a burger once and it had cheese spread on it in place of a slice. The food makes my stomach turn. They dump salt on the fried like there's no tomorrow and the people who work there are delinquents. They're rude as fuck EVERY time I've gone there (which is about 4-5 until I officially wrote this dump off) People saying "oh buff joes is great" must either be on a masculinity overcompensation quest OR just incapable of tasting anything.
(1)
B L.
Sometimes way too small. Service is horrible. Always getting more expensive. But it doesn't matter because it's still my favorite place to get wings.
(5)
JaeMin K.
Would probably be a really good place for wings if their sauce wasn't so sour and the chickens they use aren't so scrawny. We got the spicy and suicide sauce, but the sauce was more sour than spicy. It was so overwhelming that I eventually had to blot in a napkin before eating it. Suicide is essentially spicy sauce with jalapeños. If you prefer the sour taste of buffalo sauce though, it is the place for you! Their single portion is very generous--around 12 wings for $8. Make sure you bring cash because this place is cash only!!
(3)
Hannah H.
About a 2-2.5: Buffalo Joe's is an NU institution; this place is opened late, and they are known for their buffalo wings and chips (waffle fries). I usually get the Suicide Wings, extra well-done, with a side of cheddar chips. The sauce is more tangy and saucy, rather than spicy (there are slices of jalapenos on top to give it that 'kick'). There is a consistency problem with the size of the wings, as the size has decreased tremendously; in addition, the taste of the wings can alternate being saucy and tangy or tasting like ammonia (!!!). Make sure you request for fresh chips (waffle fries), as when it gets cold, you can't appreciate the thick powdery cheese sauce that comes on top (it's thick, creamy, and salty; this can also fluctuate in being a little less thick)! I love that they have RC Cola, which is quite refreshing. The tables are sticky, and the place is not the most clean and sanitary-friendly (the bathroom is another whole mess :O Also, keep in mind that they only accept cash. +Cheddar Chips +Suicide Wings (extra well-done) +cash only +sticky tables T___T +metered parking
(3)
Chrissy S.
If you're a wing lover buff joes is definitely the go to spot in the area. I've been coming here for over ten years and it's always delicious. I've noticed recently they've changed their sauce from a spicy buffalo to a more spicy BBQ type deal, but it's still really good. Another thing they've changed is their portions, which are pretty small now for what you're paying. They also have the best homemade oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. I always stock up on these before I leave, they're addicting.
(4)
Haley K.
Buff joes is like a treasure sent from heaven in a messy paper container. Voices go silent as wings are munched to the bone and other-worldly Merkts cheddar dressed on perfectly crunchy waffle fries are devoured. Take time to appreciate their strange wall hangings and paint color choice. Cash only makes you feel like you're in a drug deal for the best stuff out there.
(5)
Park R.
This place has delicious wings! Suicide is not that spicy, but hits the spot. They are very small, indeed, but they give you plenty of them. And that small size (and dusting with spices before frying) means you get even-doneness and lots of crispy skin relative to the small but toothsome and well-cooked amount of meat. Much better compared with pumped-up frankenwings, or boneless fakes. The waffle fries (buffalo chips) are delectable served with real cheddar -- yes, it's grainy, that's how it's supposed to be. It is called a pub spread, and the cheddar flavor is also great if you get it on one of their nicely charred, but always too greasy burgers. Always a good place for a perfect brat with mustard and grilled onions, and a beer for under $10! That is unusual in etown. The staff here does often fight with each other, and can be a little surly, but that is part of the charm. If you are nice and respectful of these powerful keepers of the wings, then they always treat you well. Maybe they don't really deserve 5 stars. But I must fight the haters. Sure, it gets better and worse over the years... I been coming here since the early 90's, and having eaten here about 100X it has never been bad, and always a fun time and a fair deal. Go Joe's!
(5)
Joani O.
This was the place to go growing up, and friends from out of town always wanted to eat here as well. Recently, not so much. Their quality has gone DOWN. The buffalo wings, which they're known for, are now tiny with hardly any meat on them. Very disappointing. (I also like Bleu cheese dip and both carrots and celery on the side; Buffalo Joe's only serves ranch and celery.) My daughter ordered a burger and not only was it burnt, but it was much more bun than burger. They also use the sharp cheddar Merkdt cheese which is clumpy and has a far too pungent taste for a kid. What's wrong with regular sliced cheese? Their waffle fries are good, but those alone aren't worth the trip here anymore. There are other items on the menu, yet I always came for the wings!!
(2)
Jay B.
-One of my favorite wing spots since highschool -wings are made to order and apun right in front of you -seats about 25 people comfortably with standing area tables in the front -cheddar waffle fries are a must, they are on the sweeter side -wings are a b
(5)
Rye M.
Bo Jo's is so ferda. I managed to get a few of my bots to make the long drive down here and it was so worth it. They didn't believe snee when I said it was better than bdubs. The staff is foyntastic but if you can get over the service the food is so worth it. I'm so happy the koozie king blessed me with the knowledge of this joint.
(5)
Ushna A.
I came here to eat with my Philippino friend who recommended this place. When we walked in the joint the black workers here had bad attitudes and were being rude. We placed an order , after receiving our wings it seemed cold. My Philippino friend Leo went up to the counter and told them the situation they rolled there eyes. He called them out on there behavior and the black girl looked over at another black girl behind the counter and stated aren't there people use to eating cold dogs ,( as in the pet animal). I'm totally appalled! I'm telling everyone about this in the Filipino community ...
(1)
Anish A.
Ghetto and rude! Once you walk in your greeted with rudeness. I'll stick to Buffalo Wild Wings and wing stop. The black people working here are extremely rude are not friendly. I over heard them talking about a gay male white customer who ordered his food just before I did. Once the customer left they started, mocking his mannerisms and joking about his alternative life style. I don't appreciate prejudice people. I canceled my order and walked out.
(1)
Eric B.
I love wings and Buffalo Joe's does it right! Some people see the small wing as a negative, on the contrary, i LOVE the smaller wings for the flavor they bring. The sauces are fantastic and their hottest sauce is perfect for me. Can't wait to go back!
(5)
Paco L.
Great food. The buffalo cheese chips are the absolute best. Come here at least one a week.
(5)
Eva S.
Buff Joe's.... always works their magic. When someone mentions it, the response is usually: "omg Buff Joe's, it's SO good let's go there NOW!" said quickly, almost panicky in one breath. Or followed by: "I need Buff Joe's, why'd you have to mention it, we need to go NOW!" When someone mentions your favorite type of food, you have a mini anxiety attack when your mouth waters and you need dem wings... That's kinda what happens... no matter what time of day. I always get a single order of Suicide Wings (topped with jalapenos) with a side of waffle fries ("Buffalo Chips" $1.89). Your order will come with celery and ranch, and a wetwipe (which you will certainly need). Sometimes I'll wash everything down with an RC. Their wings are freshly fried, then tossed in tangy sauce. A single order is $7.99 and you better bring cash because it's CASH only... but they have a generic ATM right inside the restaurant in case you forget. They also serve beer and these little oatmeal chocolate chip cookies in a huge tub by the cashier, which look heavenly, but I never have room for dessert. Also, they have a "XXX" sauce which is a spicy habenero-type darker red sauce... which I have only requested on the side as a sample because I heard eating an order with that sauce is brutal for your tastebuds. Try it on the side first to see if you'll like it because once you start it's so spicy it hurts. So maybe I have an unhealthy relationship with this place. But if wings were ever going inside my stomach, they better be from here. When friends visit from out of town, I'll take them to Buff Joe's and with a serious face, say: "These are the best wings in Chicago." (Deep dish pizza will be tomorrow night...) I only go to the Clark location, although there are two others on Green Bay and Howard. After I have gone and out-done myself again in the form of massive wing consumption, I say I've reached my Buff Joe's quota, forever. But of course I end up coming back the following month or so. This stuff is on par with being one of my last meals on urf. Heaven on urf...earth.
(5)
Leonel H.
This establishment has gone from a 90'S SENSATION to a ghetto establishment the culture isn't there anymore. The customer service is a joke I had a complaint with the bonanza special I brought it to their attention staff did not show any sympoyhy. Also since when was it o k to sell drugs in a restaurant. Literally there was a drug deal going on in there when I sat down and ate my food. The quality of the meat chicken ribs whatever is digesting. Whoever is the current owner of this establishment shame on u.
(1)
Anthony P.
I go to buff Joe's with my buddies all the time. I seem to be the only one who finds the wings to be just ok. The wings are somewhat small, and they are a little too crispy and dry. Also, the sauce they put on the wings is a little bland and lacks a distinct taste. Buffalo Joe's also does not have the greatest variety of sauces, with only three different variations. The interior is also not the cleanest place on earth. If you want better wings and better variety, I would head over to wings over Evanston just a couple blocks away.
(3)
Jonathan N.
Having had the opportunity to eat at some of the best wing joints in the US, I was sorely disappointed in the food, cleanliness, customer service, and overall first impression of Buffalo Joes. The wings were soggy, swimming in a gag-inducing mild sauce, and fatty. I am so used to grilled, crispy/charred, or at least baked crisp and not soggy wings. Mother Pluckers throughout Texas is a good example of awesome wings. Spending a few days shadowing that Texas institution might serve the ownership of Buffalo Joes well. I doubt if I will ever go back to BJs again. Regardless of the reviews, it's prima facie evidence that the fans and locals have limited experience in what a good wing tastes like.
(1)
Karen C.
Holy deliciousness! Went out looking initially for a good burger to take home. After discovering one place was closed, my friend suggested grabbing something from here. We went all out. Split some spicy wings and cheese fries. And then had a sandwich each. The wings. So good! I cannot say enough good things about them. Cheese fries...eh. The cheese wasn't what I was expecting. But the fries themselves, yes! We both decided the sandwiches were good. But honestly it's all about the wings! I cannot wait to go back.
(5)
Shawn J.
Could EASILY be the best wings in Chicago if they stopped using anorexic chickens...the wings barely have any meat on them! Their sauce is the best I've ever tasted, though. Also, they only accept cash. It's 2015. Other establishments accept electronic payment and these dudes can't get a credit card reader. One last complaint, they charge 50 cents for a teaspoon of ranch if you want extra.
(3)
Lauren G.
Best.wings.ever. Order them spicy with a side of buffalo chips and an RC. I mean it's the best combo for some reason or another. Sometimes it can be a real hit or miss but regardless it's delicious. What I mean is just sometimes it's not as good(when they skimp on the sauce hmph) and sometimes it's really on point. Like any place really. CASH ONLY. 12.00 for everything. The order comes with like 10-12 wings. The buffalo chips are seasoned so well. I recommend eating there the wings and fries can get soggy taking it to go not as good but still good. The sauce is like crack I swear idk what they put in it but it makes you want more! O_o! The wings itself are little with a good amount of meat. If you're not a fan of little wings and more for the bigger sized I would say still try but you may be disappointed.
(5)
Albert M.
BEST BUFFALO WINGS IN AMERICA! HANDS DOWN, NO QUESTIONS ASKED!! Chicago is a city rich and immersed in history from the water tower to Mrs. O'Leary, the Cubs/Sox/Bears/Bulls, the Daly's. This city is also known as the city of broad shoulders which I directly attribute to the fact that it is freezing, so you gotta eat a lot and that's why Chicago is a city so rich and immersed in incredible food....deep dish pizza, hot dogs, italian beef, popcorn, and so on. But my favorite place in all of Chicago is a hole in the wall buffalo wing place where spicy perfection lies. It's the one place I MUST go whenever I am in town, no ifs, ands or buts. It's called Buffalo Joes, or to the locals Buff Joe's. It is cash only. It is run by employees just as angry as the Wiener Circle a few miles south. I argue the employees of Wiener Circle work during the day at Buff Joe's and the night at the Circle of Wiener. This place has burgers, hot dogs, italian beef, but you come for the wings, the celery and the ranch. I am pretty sure that this place has been open 40+ years and my father in law was the first to order a burger. The wings are giant and so meaty. The wings are cooked perfectly. The sauce is buttery and perfect. Get the suicide...its just their normal hot wings with jalapenos. Get the cheese fries! Get a large RC! PERFECTION!Wings, cheese fries, and RC with extra ranch and celery from Buff Joe's is on my short list for finals meals if I was on death row. SPRINT, DO NOT RUN, DO NOT WALK!!!!!!
(5)
Marikit R.
Best chicken wings in town! I'm a girl who can handle her spice, so suicide (which is basically spicy with jalapeños on top) order for me! Whether you got the single or double order, there's a complimentary of celery with the order! The waffle fries are good too! The ranch they give you is pretty small, so I ask for two extra ranch and they charge a quarter each. The cookies are amazing too! Might not look like it because its in a sketchy non transparent container, that looks like it hasn't been cleaned, but trust me, the oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are a must! The only bad thing of this place, to me at least, is the cheddar cheese. It's tastes, old? Maybe I got a bad batch but I know I won't ever get the cheese on my fries again.
(4)
Jenn E.
I'm sad to say that this place really failed to meet my expectations. Came here with high expectations given the Yelp reviews but was really disappointed. Service was fast and pleasant enough and I didn't get any raw chicken but it was really not great. I got spicy wings (sorry Yelp fans, suicide is just too much for me) and waited while they freshly prepared them and then took them home where I ate them immediately. Unfortunately, in the very short walk home, the sauce seemed to separate and i was left with an oily goo in the bottom of the container and some wings that were basically dry. Aside from the texture, the sauce was ok but it was really oily which was pretty gross to me. The wings themselves were also pretty sad. The meat was sparse and tough and at times was too tough for me to chew through without some serious effort. I would have preferred way less but more meaty wings. Towards the end I was swirling the wings in sauce in hopes that it might make it all better but honestly no matter what I tried my wings were pretty tasteless, sauce was oily and I agree with others, there is a really weird after taste. Also, they only have ranch! Cash only. I want to say I'll try it again, but honestly, it won't be for a very long time, if ever.
(1)
Victoria S.
This place serves the best diggitey-darn wings I have ever figgitey figgety fricken tried. Despite having to pay with cash (always got sacks) this place really tickles my taste buds and goes great with other types of bud. You really need to get down and dirty but it's a great messy first date! The wings are so succulent they should have a novel written about them. I am writing that novel. Check back in a few days, for now let me provide you with a single excerpt. "I would never, could never, forget that moment. It has been burned into my memory by the unrelenting flaming heat of Buffalo Joe's sauce. The crunchy flesh of wild, possibly free range FDA organic, chicken fell of the bone like an avalanche of meat crashing down Mt. Everest and onto the head of unsuspecting Victor Sunkelson, the first man I killed."
(5)
Richard Y.
One of my previous favs has unfortunately gone downhill. 'Had lunch here with a friend today. The wings are good but the size and crispness have declined, as has the order accuracy. I ordered a chix salad sandwich and received a grilled chix breast sandwich-- huh? And cash only? In the 21st century? Luckily I had cash on me. Buff j s used to have an edge on food and service but has, IMHO, lost it.
(3)
Feb S.
Taste: 3.5 Location: 4 Cleanliness: 3.5 Ambience: 3 Value: 3.5 Service: 3 OVERALL = 3.5 * Out of a 5-point scale I got the Suicide Wings and Spicy Cheddar Waffle Fries (they call them Chips). The taste was pretty good, but for Suicide Wings, I expected something much spicier but was let down instead. Overall it still can't beat Buffalo Wild Wings flavors. I'd still recommend this though for anyone looking for Wings in downtown Evanston.
(4)
Dee S.
How does this place get great reviews? Haha, I guess you have to be from Evanston to get it. The wings are amazing...IF you like extremely tiny, super greasy pigeon wings with stomach acid for sauce these will be right up your alley! The fries OH EM GEE the fries were so good, the best cardboard I've ever had! The ketchup was so good and fresh too..this place just really knows how to give you violent diarrhea.. What a clean establishment this is might I add, it looks like its cleaned on a daily basis, I love the giant stain right where the overhead menu used to be..
(1)
Shajan K.
I haven't been here in years and I remembered why I stopped going...CASH ONLY policy! Otherwise, the wings are great, especially suicide style! Soaked in sauce and jalapenos? Can't ever go wrong with that! Cheese fries can use a little work.
(4)
Ian S.
So I've been getting BJ's (Buffalo Joe's) for a long time but only at this location. If you want the better wings and fries, this location is IT! Can't say much for the other ones but they were meh. So onto the review, if you love spicy wings, you have to get suicide wings. If you're like me, a double order is more than enough. It comes with jalapeños on the wings and the sauce is awesomesauce! If you dine in, they serve beer too! Don't forget to order suicide cheddar chips with your meal. It's waffle fries smothered in awesome cheddar and suicide sauce! Ok now this review is making me crave BJ's. I'll make a stop this week. Ahhhhhhh! P.S. If you make buffalo chicken dip, try substituting franks red hot with the suicide sauce. You can order some on the side and trust me, you won't regret it! It's always a hit and perfect for watching Da Bears game.
(5)
Yousuf K.
Always have great wings. However always received poor customer service. Only reason they aren't getting 5 stars. Also they don't take credit card. We are in the 21st century. I can go to a street vendor in Morocco and he will still take card!
(4)
Daria D.
I had the buffalo chicken sandwich. It was okay, the chicken tasted a little like it was fried in old oil but perfectly crispy so I can't complain that much.
(3)
Andrew Z.
My friends took me here since I was visiting them. They asked me what I was in the mood for and I replied "something with protein". I think mounds of chicken qualify. I don't usually get buffalo flavor wings at places like Buffalo Wild Wings - usually I opt for some variation of "savory" (spicy garlic, parmesan garlic, garlic fries... I really like garlic, ok?) but I ordered the Mild wings here and really liked them. I don't know how they make the sauce, but it's seemed to be more savory and less vinegary than the ones I've had. So if you're like me, and usually don't like buffalo wings, I would still suggest trying this place out. Good stuff, Buff Joe's.
I dream of Buff Joe's. It's like, the most basic junk food ever, but I still get excited every.single.time. I eat here. I have heard there is a large menu, but I have never bothered with anything other than WINGS and CHEDDAR CHIPS. I guess if I had any criticism it would be they need bigger napkins? That's not a criticism, I guess, it's just a compliment on how saucy the wings are. Prepare to not do anything else for the rest of the night, because you will probably have heartburn and definitely be in a food coma.
(5)
Thu D.
When I moved to the city after graduating, my boyfriend and I searched high and low for wings as good as Buff Joe's and could not find a place that even came close. We would always get a double order of spicy wings and it is seriously heaven in a styrofoam container (my mouth is watering now just typing this). Luckily, I've returned to Evanston, so I can have the best wings whenever I want! The spicy wings are the way to go because they're spicy, but not so scorching hot that your tongue goes numb. Also, while I like this location fine, I think the Green Bay location is better because their wings are larger, so you get more bang for your buck. My only complaints are that they only serve ranch (blue cheese all the way!) and it is a cash-only establishment. However, that's nothing my own bottle of blue cheese dressing and an ATM can't fix, so Buff Joe's is okay in my book.
(5)
Stefanie B.
I haven't been to the actual restaurant in soo long so when I was in the area I had to come back to relive my high school memories coming here. Who doesn't love them some BJ's?! ;) The staff is so welcoming and fun as soon as you walk in and your order is ready in a matter of minutes. You can never go wrong here if you're in the mood for Buffalo Wings. Also the waffles fries tho...mmmm good eats for good prices. I'd get the double order of wings because the wings sizes are pretty anorexic and remember it's CASH ONLY! I hate the parking around this area tho
(4)
Catherine N.
WOW!! The wings here are truly delicious!! I met a few people at a party who told me that they would drive from downtown Chicago to Evanston, just for an order of Buffalo Joe's wings, and now I can see why. These wings are so simple and made to perfection!! They are the right amount of crispiness and the sauce is ON POINT! Plus, the portion size and price is not bad either. One order of wings is around $8 and you get like 10 wings!! DEAL! Tip: Get the normal waffle fries and not the one loaded with stuff - the WILL get soggy because it's drenched in canned nacho cheese sauce and and buffalo wing sauce. ALSO, if you want to place an order for a Super Bowl party... do that like 3 days in advance, this place gets so many orders that you won't get it if you order the night before!! - They are just THAT good.
(4)
Raheem L.
A good amount of food for a very good price. No complaints about the food, but the workers had a bit of attitude, they were very rude to some other customers that walked in after me and had a confusing order.
(4)
Matt A.
This place has the best wings ever!! I don't know what the captain puts in this sauce but it is AMAZING. I call him the Captain because he has been there for over 20 years running the ship. If you see him you will know. Now the only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because I have been bamboozled with a bad batch of wings but never when the Captain is there. One time my order got lost and the captain immediately gave me a new order free of charge. Granted I waited over 45 minutes but hey he's the captain and he acknowledged his mistake. In his defense, he was really busy. Double order mild("spicey" is extra sauce and hot is with jalapeños) with cheddar chips and a large ice water. Sometimes water is yellow. Watch for that.....I can still smell the sauce in my fingertips. Yum.
(4)
Kenny O.
Cheap, filling, and--best of all--tasty. After living in the Chicago area for several years now, this might be my favorite place for buffalo wings (the top contender being Duke of Perth in Chicago). While I was studying at NU, this was one of my most-frequented joints to hit up for late nights in the office. I don't think I've ever dined in, but the food's always been great even after a 20-minute walk home in the cold winter.
(5)
Adele n.
Yup. I did it. I ate the suicide wings for the first time in 10 years (go, u northwestern!) and it was as freaking delicious as I remembered. I am from upstate NY, homeland of the wing, and Buffalo Joes is the only Chicago wing that stacks up. Don't waste your time with any others! They could be even hotter, IMO, but these are about the hottest I've had out here. Vinegar-cayenne perfection.
(5)
Oliver W.
Pretty good wings, only choice you have is what level of spicyness you want. The restaurant is fairly dirty and greasy, which was a bit off-putting. But if you're ok taking a shower after eating here then you got the right idea.
(3)
Gspot H.
My First Real Date 1st month of Sophomore was up in here. The song "Blue Eye's" by The Who came on the radio. Went 2 see "Yamo" at ETHS afterwards on a double date; my X was the other Lady. I got the wings Mild. It was a good fun safe memorable out of site nite.
(5)
Kenneth L.
Yeah, I mean, it gets the job done. I had been advised by many Northwestern alum that Buff Joe's was the quintessential wing place - an institution for buffalo wings. To its credit, Buff Joe's is what it is and it doesn't mess around with that. But, little did I know, I was walking into a hole in the wall shack with an infinite amount of chicken wings already cooked and hanging out in the frying basket, awaiting my consumption. Don't get me wrong, fried chicken wings are fried chicken wings and I love fried chicken wings. It was pretty simple and pretty good, but not sure that it warrants the collegiate lore hype machine. Though, if I were still in college rocking a budget, I wouldn't be surprised to find myself here many a time.
(3)
Peter H.
Have been coming here for 13 plus years. Perfect overtime.
(5)
Mario G.
The wings and chips may have Crack like additives because I always Jones after them. I once saw a roach run across my table and yet has deterred me from eating here. Just start a mild sauce Iv, slap a mega gut no ice in my hand and I'm good. They're ranch sauce makes the pants tight! I want more...MORE!!!!!!!
(5)
Miss Kari P.
Every time I order wings they get smaller and smaller. I'm expecting just a pile of bones the next time I go in, which is unfortunate because I absolutely adore their suicide wings. It really doesn't matter, but every single worker inside is absolutely rude for no appropriate reason. Without fail. You're killin' me Buff Joes....
(2)
Steve A.
This is a good wings place, but they actually have a lot more, including hamburgers, hot dogs and even vegetarian sandwiches. Everything is cooked to order, so it's hot and fresh, and there is a nice enough dining area both in front and in back. Service is fast and efficient. Cash only.
Tangy, light sauce tossed on deep fried chicken wings. What's not to love? Waffle fries with heart attack cheese sauce is simple super thick rue cooked into some milk and minimal cheese. Ick.
(5)
Travis L.
How in the name of Buffalo, New York can you call this place a good wing joint?! Honestly some of the worst wings I've had in a long while. I cannot understand how anyone can get past the dried shriveled up pieces of jerky Joe's tries to pass off as wings. I ordered the single which comes with about a dozen wings and after picking through the tough inedible chunks, I ate maybe 4-5 wings worth; wings=fail. Next, I except that I have a high tolerance for heat but the one thing I hate is when a place claims to have some high level of hotness that you can't fathom to handle and then when you take a bite it's nothing more than f'ing Tobasco; suicide sauce=fail. If anyone is paying attention @ Joe's, here are some pointers: Don't use frozen wings, it dries out the meat and ruins the taste, instead serve fewer higher quality wings (never frozen). Second, unless you're actually going to use exceptionally hot sauce don't call them suicide and finally, use fresh jalapeños instead of those crappy canned ones.
(1)
Christopher S.
This is by far the best wings I've ever had. I always order the single order of suicide wings and waffle fries. I would definitely recommend this place.
(5)
Jen C.
Old school- RC cola, cash only but they have an ATM machine- get the wings suicide style, celery and ranch- fast service~ wish the wings had more meat to them but the sauce is too good to complain. Waffle fries to balance the heat!
(4)
Mike A.
I'm not really sure what happened here. I used to come here all the time in high school and it was pretty much the best wings you could find on the planet. It was the first trip I'd make when coming back home from college. Wow have things changed. the wings are probably 3x smaller than they were back in the day and really dry. Prices also seemed to have doubled. 14.59 for a double order, man, the amount of overall meat on the bones wasn't even like a single order a few years ago. It was like the wings came from an unhatched chicken embryo. Someone came in an ran this place into the ground, it used to be a legitimate Chicago food landmark. Incredibly disappointed and feel cheated out of a lot of money, way to ruin their reputation. Should have read the reviews before coming back.
(1)
Spencer S.
I wish I can give this place 0 stars. I use to love it until I ordered a chicken tender dinner and they fed me raw chicken. When we went back the next day (we ordered the day before right before closing) the people there said "oh well, it wasn't on our shift, and no money back." So they fed me raw chicken and did nothing to fix it.
(1)
Ramena A.
I love my wings, and I thought if love buff joes (especially because of all the great things I heard about them). Unfortunately, I went there and the chicken didn't taste good, the sauce had a weird taste to it (not a normal wing flavor), and the cheesy fries had cold melted cheese on it. They only take cash, which is extremely inconvenient. It was an OK atmosphere, a little awkward to be honest. I just did not enjoy it.
(2)
Brandon B.
Best wings around. Wish it wasn't cash only and that they delivered. 5 star food, but 3 star convenience.
(4)
Crystal P.
The truth is, they are, what they say they are a wings and burger place in downtown Evanston and a wings and ribs place on Howard street Chicago. I have never been disappointed until this year. The girl on the register "flawless" as always, the ribs were like they took all the good stuff home and were serving the customer scraps. The 2 cooks in the back were so busy talking to each other that they literally didn't cook the food and there were about 4 people waiting and that number quickly built to a dozen since it was a Friday night. The girl asked them a couple times and they gave her a look that said "don't talk to us" Wings were good but no celery or sauce was on the order, they must be taking that home as well. Ive been coming here since they opened each of the resturants, I've recommended hundreds of people. This was a real let down.
(1)
Eugene W.
Buffalo Joe's is a great wings place. Their wings are delicious and if you a spicy-lover, this is the place to go. Their waffle fries are extremely tasty, though the cheese on the fries hardens and tastes kind of bad after a while. I would definitely go here over Buffalo Wild Wing's with a group of friends, because the atmosphere is nicer and the wings are just as good.
(4)
Mina P.
This visit was definitely 5 star worthy. I will forever be a fan of buffalo joe's but it's really a hit or miss here. Some days the wings are wimpy and dry and other days definitely the best on the planet. I love this place regardless because I've been eating here for almost 20 years. We can't have a gathering at home without a party pan of suicide from BJ's and you can't forget about the cheddar chips! CASH ONLY - there's an ATM inside ;)
(5)
Simon K.
People have probably written everything there is to write about this place. The wings are great. The waffle fries are great. Et cetera, et cetera... However, I'm about to drop some knowledge on anybody who is unfazed by how society views them. Bring a tupperware container full of white rice and make sure you have enough people to order the party platter. When you get a platter of suicide wings, a pool of butter, hot sauce and jalapenos ends up gathering at the bottom of the aluminum tray. If you take the rice (which the tupperware hopefully kept fairly warm) and mix it in with the sauce, you will experience Buff Joe's in a way you have never experienced before. For the ones who don't mind doing a little extra work, rip the meat off the last few chicken wings into smaller chunks to create a complete dish. This also works if you take the wings as take-out but nothing beats getting the wings right out of the fryer. So, do you dare take on the challenge? Hopefully I'll be seeing a few more people with tupperware the next time I go. I'll be sure to say hello.
(5)
Mike M.
First & LAST time I set foot in dis joint! I know joes due to occasionally a co-worker would bring in a tray of wings...So after a N/W game we decided to go to the joint... bad move...5 out of 6 staffr's are rude!!!!They don't give a s*** about u or your business, the place is filthy... if u gotta "go" take a risk and pee in the alley! The soda sucks! The bonelesss wings taste crappy and look like alien fingers! Don't get me wrong but the wings are good-not great!...Save yourself the horrible experience I went thru and GO to Jake Melnicks!- in downtown Chicago!!! JM undoubted-ly have the BEST WINGS IN Illinois!
(1)
Brian R.
I've been to Buffalo Joe's a few times now, and I'm just now writing a review. Of all the wing places I've been to, and I've been to a few, Buffalo Joe's is probably the best. I live out west (St. Charles/West Chicago/Geneva area), and I (usually) gladly make the 1 hour trip out to Evanston for Buff' Joe's. If Yelp ratings were all about food taste, I'd consider it a 5-star joint. Be warned! Buff' Joe's is cash only!
(4)
Paul B.
We've been going to this hole in the wall wings joint for years and years. Look - the wings are amazing (I'm whimping out in my old age and can't do the hot or suicide wings anymore but the milds and mediums are still spectacular), the fries are good as is the chili but the help is obnoxious. They aren't even nice about telling you that it's cash only. The scene is that of a run down wings joint in a college town so I guess that fits. That being said we still come back.
(3)
Simplelife S.
So unprofessional!!! The employees at the register area stood and talked (inappropriately) amongst themselves using profanity while people waited for their orders to cook. At one point a guy came from the other side of the restaurant and participated in the conversation while he and the employee handled a bag with out washing their hands. At this point I watch closely and even asked that my food was not prepared by either of these women. I did finally ask for a manager who listened to my complaint as the two employees stood in ear shot but never looked as if they were even aware that they were doing something wrong. It had been years since I went to this Davis street location I usually use the Howard street one. Much better service. I was so disappointed in what I saw I called three people I knew while I was there and recommended to them NOT to use this place EVER!!!!! * WONT BE GOING BACK*
(1)
Marc G.
The more things change... the more they stay the same... mostly. Back in the day I would have had an order of Wings... suicide... a Cheddar Char Burger, Cheddar Char Chips and an RC Gut buster. That was in my NU days... but on a recent visit back to Evanston, we made a late night run to our old, favorite haunt. We went spicy with the Wings this time... and while they were good, they were not as good as we remembered... a little too fried and greasy, perhaps. Hmm... We skipped the Chips (waffle fries) but went for a Burger, too. That was even better than I remembered... So darn good... the juices from the meat soaked the cheese spread bun perfectly... mustard and ketchup... pickles, tomato and lettuce... Simple but stunningly delicious. I can still taste it. Mmmm!
(4)
Samuel M.
The only place i know of in the Chicago area that serves classic Buffalo Wings. What I mean by this: -Fried, but not battered -Equal parts drumettes/wings -BONE LEFT IN (as far as I'm concerned, "boneless wings" are both an oxymoron and something that only sociopaths eat) -Buttery yet spicy sauce that invariably leaves the eater messy The one place in which this place breaks from tradition is by serving the wings with ranch dressing rather than bleu cheese, but trust me, you won't miss it. I've only ever ordered one thing here: suicide wings with waffle chips. I see no reason to change this. 90% of the time, this is exceptional and well worth the havoc it inevitably wreaks on my gastrointestinal system. 10% of the time the food is pedestrian, for one reason or another (typically wings are too small, or are swimming in excessive sauce. However, this latter issue tends to arise with suicide more than with other styles because it necessitates the addition of extra sauce). In summation: If you are craving wings, do NOT be tempted by the cleaner exterior and large televisions and take your wing craving to BWW's down the street. It is mediocre. Buff Joe's is the real deal. PS As others have iterated, but which I must needs restate: CASH ONLY!! They have an ATM inside if you're desperate, though.
(4)
J K.
For me, a trip back to Evanston isn't complete without a visit to Buffalo Joe's. And they're open until midnight so even if my flight is delayed I'm able to get my junk food chicken fix. This place is CASH ONLY so plan accordingly - there's a Bank of America a block away and I think there's actually a small ATM in the restaurant but I'd assume it charges fees. My friends swear by the wings, but I always get the chicken tenders with mild sauce and extra ranch dressing - they're amazing. The food is so tasty that it's easy to overlook that the wings and tenders are always swimming in grease and the "cheese" on the buffalo chips (fries) is synthetic. Prices are reasonable, there's plenty of seating in the back, and even when the place is busy they seem to be able to cycle through orders quickly. A couple of things that might some day push Buffalo Joe's down into 4-star territory for me... 1) the wings seem to have gotten smaller over time - not a good trend 2) sometimes they don't have tenders - very disappointing since they're my favorite menu item 3) if you get food to go, they put fries in paper bags so you'll have nice, hot chicken but cold fries (I realize it's un-PC of me to enjoy the styrofoam containers they use for chicken, so I usually eat in the restaurant)
(5)
Arie W.
It would be an understatement to say I'm a huge fan of BJ's. My family gets a party platter for any type of get together, parties, Christmas, Thanksgiving (yes I said Thanksgiving). My favorite thing to order at BJ's are the suicide wings and cheese fries. I've noticed that in the past few years the wings were getting considerably smaller and smaller, but the last time I went, they were back to the normal size and just as great as ever. The way they make the cheese fries here is totally Chicago style. My other friends from out of town who I've brought here say that the cheese is way too cheddar-y and thick, but if I could eat it on everything, I absolutely would. I've also had the burger, brat, chili, and cookies and everything is delicious. The only bad thing about BJ's, if you don't eat it while it's hot, it loses it's appeal. The facilities are not the most pleasant, but it does the job. The bathroom is probably as clean as it possibly can get. They have TVs for customers to watch while eating. The seating area isn't too appealing, but when I get my wings, I don't care where I'm sitting. It's that good.
(5)
Kenneth M.
I have been going to Buffalo Joe's since 1992. I have traveled all over the world, had wings from all over the United States, including in Buffalo, and hands down Buffalo Joe's are the best wings I have ever had. I have had Buffalo Joe's at all my major birthday's, had my parents bring a double party pan 6 hours for my graduation from college. For those who have given a bad rating to Buffalo Joe's, they must have bad taste buds. Even if the service was poor, I would come back again and again for these wings. I see some of the reviews are for non wing related items. Get it straight, this is a WINGS PLACE. Although some of the staff may be rough around the edges, you come for the food. I have never had a bad experience at Buffalo Joe's in my life. When I need a comfort food a double order hot, with Buffalo Chips, and a gut buster R.C hit the spot. Ghetto Joe's on Howard on the hand is sub-par, and people may have been there. A fan since I was 12, and I will go until the day I die.
(5)
Melissa D.
So, I know they made the wings a little on the aneroxic side but they're SO GOOD. I love this place, I go here for the cheddar fries and wings ONLY, all the time. I seriously drive 45 minutes just to eat here. I know people's taste buds are different and they have different preferences but I adore this place to pieces. The sauce is delicious, and they do sell a huge jug of it (though it's a little pricey)... It's a hole in the wall place, but I don't know about everybody else, I go for the food, not to stare at teh walls and say, "Uh, the paint is peeling..." Buffalo Joe's, my go to place for wings when I'm really craving them!
(5)
Master B.
It is a sad day for me. i grew up eating these wings. i have even had wings from Anchor Bar in Buffalo where they were created, and buff joes sauce was better. but over the last few years i have been fighting an up hill battle defending this place. finally i ordered wings and had to write this. the wings have been getting progressively smaller as time goes by, but tonight i counted and i got a double order of wings and there was no meat what so ever on the wings. the largest wing was an inch and a quarter long and had only skin and tendons attached no meat. i understand the desire to make money and have high yield but how does the owner really expect people to keep coming back for chicken bones slathered in butter? my advice just see if you can buy the sauce in bulk and get your own wings, it has to be cheaper and a better meal... sorry buff joe's you lost a life long customer tonight.
(1)
alan q.
I've been hear a few times. I recently visited for the first time in at least 3-4 years. The only thing I've ever gotten are the suicide wings and waffle fries. Waffles fries are pretty standard...not much to judge here. The wings are pretty small. The suicide sauce isn't really that hot. It's hot but manageable. Man, I really remember the wings to be much better. It was ok, but all I was thinking while eating was, "what other places have better wings?" This is the definition of hole in the wall. I usually don't mind hole the wall places, but this time it got to me. The dining room smelled like a wet, dirty rag. The tables were greasy and is a type of place where you don't want to touch anything. I must say that I really don't need to go back to this place for another 3-4 years..or more.
(2)
D M.
Finger lickin good yummy-ness. That about sums it up.
(5)
Marion J.
This is more than 1 1/2 stars for me. We went for wings, I was cravings with, got take out, staff was not especially nice nor helpful. We got home wings were tiny and very dry. They felt old.. just not the juicy chicken wings I was craving. Not sure what went wrong. Both hubby and i did not like them. We did not finish them. We wont be back. Maybe they have better items or better days. They are cheap for wings.
(2)
Jon L.
best buffalo wings ever!!!
(5)
Khris L.
This place is a classic buffalo wing spot for anyone in the area. I even know people who would drive over an hour just to get some of the suicide wings from here. I want to start off by saying that their wings have gotten smaller and the prices have increased over the years. It's still worth it as the single order or their wings can fill you up easily. I love this place, but it's hard for me to give it higher than 3 stars because of the feeling you get when you eat in. The staff, for the most part, seem to not care about anything. The place is small and doesn't accomodate big groups. The tables are sticky, and so are the ketchup and mustard bottles...There are always people waiting outside to ask you for change and/or your leftovers. Aside from all those inconveniences, the food here is great and I suggest you try it out. Carry out might be a better idea than eating in.
(3)
Javi L.
Only had the wings so far but OH MY GAWWD! They are just super delicious... Price is fair for a single order (12pc) not to mention the unbelievable taste. I believe Buffalo Joes was nominated for best wings or something idk but I'd you are ever in the Evanston area you must stop and grab yourself some wings. Only had the spicy. Next up is the suicide.
(5)
Christine G.
I'd like to thank my homie Takala for winning a bet with me, of course I lost! I said I would buy her chicken dinner. This place was so good! Don't get it mixed up with BWWs. I did not get the wangs, she did but I tried it and it was oh so yummy. I had the chicken nachos which was bigger than my face but I ate it all because I was starving. I will be back!
(4)
Dane K.
TERRIBLE wings. I can't even BELIEVE people--anyone--would recommend them. They're TERRIBLE, disgusting. Some of you people who think they're great must be on some pretty heavy drugs. The sauce tastes like ketchup with a little hot sauce. It's very strange... And there's WAY too much sauce. It's like eating gobbly gook. They're the SMALLEST WINGS on earth!!! Don't take my word for it: I took pictures... One next to a quarter: THE QUARTER IS WIDER THAN THEIR FREAKING WINGS! (and it wasn't just this one wing, they were all that small). I posted them under the business pictures. How can a wing place find such small wings to serve? Are they aborted chickens, or chicks? Are they even chickens? Their spicy wings aren't even hot... then they have "suicide" wings where they're not really any hotter--they just douse them in more sauce--AND ADD GIARDINARE. how disgusting!!! (it might be good drunk food or something, but don't call them buffalo wings) THEY DON'T EVEN HAVE BLUE CHEESE!!! I suppose asking for carrots to go with celery (like you'd get in... Buffalo) would be totally out of the question if they're too cheap to even stock blue cheese! This place shouldn't be allowed to associate itself with wings OR Buffalo, let alone both. The staff wasn't very friendly... I was trying to read the menu and got rushed into ordering. Once we sat down, we overheard a group of people arguing on the other side of the eating area... not just arguing, but standing up shouting in each other faces, ready to punch arguing... the kind of thing where you debated if you should get up and leave, or get ready to dial 911. guess who it was? the staff. The *only* redeeming thing about this place was the waffle fries... they were pretty darn good. They weren't exactly cheap... An order of wings, waffle fries w/ cheese, and two drinks came out to be $17. I want my $17 back. Really. They were that bad. It was one of those meals where you sat and debated if you wanted to finish, or if you would just abort and go elsewhere... we ended up eating more later I'm pretty sure. I've had better wings at Applebee's. If you think the wings here are the best ever, you're really missing out.
(1)
Elizabeth T.
Went here a lot during my college days. Went back after 7 years because my fiance and I had Buffalo Joe's cravings. I have to admit: Wings & fries. VERY VERY GOOD. Price: VERY AFFORDABLE. That's about it. The place is SUPER DIRTY! Get take out but don't stay here.
(2)
Brian J.
What a bizarre place. So they call it "Buffalo" Joe's. That's offensive, in my opinion, being a native Buffalonian (I know you love the way that rolls off the tongue). If you're expecting real buffalo wings, this joint sucks. Period. Skimpy, nasty, sweet, weird wings without blue cheese. That's what comes to my mind now when I think of Buffalo Joe's. Upon entering the rude staff rushed me into ordering and looked at me like I was insane when I asked for blue cheese with my wings. This is when I knew we were in trouble, but we had read good reviews of the place so we figured it was worth a try. The order taking employee told me "they good, you should try them" so, with this ringing endorsement, Dane and I ordered a double order and some waffle fries. I think we ordered them mild but I can't remember because I'm still trying to wash the memory from my mind. Somewhere around this point, I saw the most offensive thing of all - giardiniera on top of a pile of the tiniest wings I've ever seen. Luckily, this monstrosity wasn't ours, but the next order to come out was. The first thing I noticed was the color and excessive quantity of sauce. They looked the color of spaghetti sauce and had were drowned in sauce. The waffle fries looked good (and they were, but deep fried toe jam would have tasted good compared to these wings). Upon arriving at our table, we took the plunge and tasted these tiny, tiny wings. They were so small that we actually had to take a break from eating to laugh about it. We compared the largest wing to a quarter and found the quarter to be wider (see photos uploaded by dane k.). The sauce was sweet and ketchupy. It was at this point when we decided we should consider cutting our losses, dumping the wings in the trash can and finding some real wings but the scary dining room entertainment was too interesting to abandon. I can't stress enough how tiny the wings were. Most of the drumettes, at the big end, were narrower than my thumbnail. Seriously. It was like they were actually pigeon wings. Maybe guinea hens. I'm not sure. Around this time a table started getting loud, every other word being an obscenity (*I* was uncomfortable and I have a mouth like a sailor -- and there were several families with children present). Next thing you know someone threw a tray onto the table and yelled "I told you I'd give you your f-ing money" and there was a verbal exchange that actually scared some people out of the restaurant. As it turns out, this was a table of employees on their break. Nice. I'm from Buffalo and admittedly a tough wing critic; however, these are without a doubt, no question about it, the worst attempt at wings I've EVER tasted. That's a pretty tough distinction to achieve because I've had some really nasty wings. These certainly take the cake. Calling this place "Buffalo Joe's" is false advertising. I hereby make a motion to rename it to "Joe's Ketchupy Pigeon Wing Emporioum" or something along those lines.
(1)
Cecilia T.
Buffalo Joe's is without a doubt THE BEST flavored wings in Chicago. I've lived in the Chicago suburbs and in the city my whole life and have never found anything better than this local hotspot.The tangy vinegary secret sauce on their wings is totally standout and something you literally crave for over and over again. I trek out here just to get these wings and from this specific location. (their Howard Location is just so so.) They offer 3 levels of spiciness to choose from - Mild, Spicy, Suicide. I tend to go with Mild or Spicy because i can't handle a lot of spicy. "Suicide" wings used to be really really spicy (swimming in jalapenos) but from what i heard they are just "really spicy," nowadays as the sauce has changed over the years. The size of their wings is just a 1 star rating - unfortunetely they used to provide huge juicy wings but now they are getting dinkier every year.Whatever, the sauce makes up for it. Atmosphere is 1 star too - a total local hole the wall. Get take-out if you're a germaphobe but just know these wings taste best just out of the fryer. If you do carryout, eat the wings with Chinese rice! I know that sounds weird, but many asians i know eat the wings with rice at home and the tangy sauce pairs SOOO well with rice. Other food to get with your wings? - The Waffle Fries are crispy and very good. Recommend getting the cheese on the side if you don't want them to lather it on. - They used to serve Rolling Rock Beer which tasted SO gross with the wings. But i just went today and they are serving Berghoff Pilsner and Berghoff Dark Beer on tap - pairs very well with the wings and washes away the greasiness on your palate. -If you're not a winglover, i heard the burgers are very good here too. Have a Superbowl Party? Their Party Platters are the way to go! I've even seen them at Baby Showers =). CASH ONLY
(5)
Brian M.
Best wings in the area, I'd recommend sticking to hot or mild. Suicide isn't very good, just too much jalapeño not enough good flavor. The cheddar fries are fantastic waffle cut fried slathered in merkts cheese and some seasoning, dipped in their wonderful ranch they go great with some wings. The wing size here seems to vary from order to order but a single order is always plenty for me. Also the buffalo chicken sandwich is delicious here. It's a boneless breast pounded flat and breaded, it tastes like they make it in house, nice clean tasting breading and good fresh chicken breast. Make sure you add cheese on it to enjoy more of the merkts cheese. This is usually a place to grab take out during the lunch hours, the place isn't known for it's decor or seating. I recommend calling ahead when coming here or it can be a longer then average wait for take out places. They should definitely get rid of the cash only rule, I can't tell you how many times I got hit with ATM fees there because I have a real hard time accepting places with any kind of traffic wouldn't want a credit card machine.
(4)
Connie L.
Our first stop for dinner in Chicago was at Buffalo Joes. Our cousins who live in Chicago took us here and we were excited to try some good wings. We ordered the spicy wings with cheddar chips. The sauce was on! It had the right amount of kick and was sauceyyyy! The cheddar chips are waffle fries with melted cheese and they were a good compliment to the wings. Add some celery sticks and beer and the meal was spot on!
(4)
Ernesto R.
Not that impressed with the wings. They contain a ton of butter and the sauce is pretty standard. Also, the place is pretty dirty and should be kept more clean. I do not recommend this place as it might make you sick.
(2)
Jose B.
one day my girlfriend asked me if i liked wings, when i was done ridiculing her for such a ridiculous question (OF COURSE), she told me of this place. We went and for the money you spend you get an irresponsibly large amount of wings, also they have cool waffle fries and the wings themselves have a great taste, my only, and ONLY wish is that the wings were slightly bigger... maybe its better that theyre not or i would be 500lbs!!!!
(4)
Lulu R.
I have been coming to buffalo Joes for a long time now. Sure, their wings have become much smaller. We can't do anything about it. On the bright side, their sauce hasn't changed one bit. The waffle fries are perfectly seasoned and piping hot and fresh. Back to these amazing wings. I am still proud of this place despite their ever shrinking wing size. Every time I have a friend from out of town, I take them here. The sauce makes it worth while. My friend loved the wings so much....i believe he moved here for them! (Maybe) The problem is the staff is on the rude side and they are really stingy on the ranch/ bleu Cheese. They do not take credit cards. The drinks (unless otherwise ordered) come heavily iced. The place is tiny and needs to desperately be remodeled and updated to 2009. The bathrooms are kinda clean. You would think I would give this place 3 stars considering the negatives I have for this place...right? WRONG. I love these wings so much that I will STILL, despite the negatives(which are pretty serious in most peoples books, give this place 4 stars. For 24 or so wings its $10 bucks For 15 its like $7 Try them....make the trip... you won't regret or forget the adventure you and your taste buds go on. word to the wise: Check out the waffle fries (omg, that rhymes hahahaha)
(4)
Justine L.
Good cheap food! Mild wings were surprisingly spicy and perfect. The single order had 10 wings! The burger was good as well- particularly enjoyed the bun.
(4)
daynia S.
I absolute love their classic version of buffalo wings. The chicken is not battered like Hooter's. The sauce is what makes the wings so yummy. The fresh cut waffle fries are excellent and always piping hot. Wings and fries ate made to order nothing sitting around under hot lamps. Celery sticks are always cold and crisp like they should be. I've been taking a drive out to evanston for at least 10 years since I discovered this spot. It's not healthy so I only go once or twice a year but it's always worth it. Recipe has never changed. The only minor complaint I have is some times that the wings are small in size.
(4)
Kat T.
I thought this place was alright. I did not feel like there was anything special about the place nor ws the selection of sauce very unique. Not a bad place.
(3)
Al D.
Merk's cheddar on an Italian Beef??? It's provolone unless I ask otherwise. Fail.
(3)
Meinard C.
Buffalo Joe's is less of a restaurant and more of an establishment, dare I say it? A childhood friend. Sure we've had our rough patches and times when we haven't seen each other in ages. But it's always something you can depend on. I've been going to this place since I was in high school back when boy bands roamed the earth and gas was a dollar. The prices of the wings, like my waistline, have crept up since. Back then I could've taken on a single pan by myself, but nowadays I limit myself to a single order. I usually get 'suicide' (Which is hot with jalapenos. People swear it's a different sauce, but I think that's just the jalapeno pickle juice being mixed in), Waffle cut fries with cheddar sauce (OMGOMNOMNOMNOM) and regular a RC (no Coke or Pepsi here). I can't say I've had any other things on their menu. I know they exist and I keep telling myself "One day I'll have to try one of those." But that's like going to a strip club for their lunch specials; and like strip clubs, they only take cash. This place gets a solid 4 from me, and it gets awarded the mystical +1 of nostalgia; perhaps even a +2 but yelp doesn't let me do 6 stars.
(5)
Brian L.
I've been there about three times and truth be told, I'm afraid to go back. Each time the wings have progressively gotten smaller. I looked at my friend's plate and found one that was literally the size of a Jolly Rancher. If they start supplying larger/better quality I will definitely boost up their rating but as it stands now a solid 3. Their sauce is tangy. I love spicy with a bit of sweet. I wish they had a bit more to choose from like a standard New York Buffalo sauce though. I like them vinegary too!
(3)
Hoang L.
If you like your wings drowned in sauce, then you'll love Buff Joe's. But I cannot say this is the best wings, so I cannot give you 5-stars. Plus, I find it tough to justify the price of these wings. Don't get me wrong, I love eating here, but I think people hype it up too much. The wings are medium sized. The celery on the side is okay. Gets pretty crowded and kinda of annoying when you can't find a place to sit.
(4)
Chris B.
When I travel to Chicago, I always try and stop on by here. My friends in high school used to rant about coming here and filling up on wings. I come and I get the suicide wings and boy are they spicy! Fortunately they come with some ranch and celery to put my fire out! Sure as hell beats KFC and Popeye's for wings! Service could be a little more friendly.
(5)
Brandon R.
They're not the biggest wings. They're not the meatiest. But, without question, they're my favorite wings. That's Buff Joe's in a nutshell. Personally, I LOVE spicy wings. I want to sweat when I'm eating. I want nasal passages as clear as... something that's really clear. Sure, you've read people rave about the suicide wings here (their spicy sauce with a heaping pile of jalapenos on top). They're not too bad. But I'm hear to tell you about the variety that aren't even on the menu: XXX habanero. To this day, I have not found a better combination of heat and flavor. Much like the suicide variety, the XXX habanero wings come with a mountain of sliced jalapenos. About those jalapenos: they are EASILY the best jalapenos in the world. I don't know how much of that is due to the fact that they're slathered in buffalo sauce, but I could eat these suckers by the spoonful. I look at them in the same light as Superdawg's grilled onions: a simple addition to a meal that takes it to the next level. Two final things that must be mentioned: - The ranch. Insanely good. When it comes to ranch, I definitely lean towards the more 'liquidy' side. Especially for wings. Buff Joe's does not disappoint - just get extras though, because you'll want it. And if you go XXX habanero, you'll need it. - Cheddar chips, all day, every day. It's like the opposite of my ranch preference: I despise drippy, nacho cheese on fries. Buff's uses some actual melted down cheddar. The final product is about as good as it gets in the cheese fries world. And such a delicious world it is. Ignore the haters and make Buff Joe's your #1 priority next time you're in Evanston. Which hopefully won't be for a while because I have no clue what you do in Evanston besides eat at Buff's.
(5)
Drew D.
So, I've been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. That would mean that it's been about 15 years since I first tasted the succulent spiciness that is Buff Joe's sauce. I've introduced many people to this place, and never had I had anybody come out of here less than satisfied, which I think speaks to the quality of its food. I insist that everybody try the wings just once, even if they're not "wing people," just so they can have the experience. You'd be surprised how many of them are now "wing people" thanks to the gentle nudging! Every time I'm here, I tell myself I'm going to get something different...but when it comes down to it, I always have to go with my usual: single spicy, cheddar chips, and a mega size drink to wash it all down. Waiting for my food seems endless, and when I finally get to chomp down on my first wing, it's like tasting it for the first time all over again. There is a veritable explosion of spices in my mouth, and after the initial heat, the flavors come through like gangbusters. I tend to dislike wings that are hot for the sake of being hot. I find that they have little to no flavor once the heat passes, and for me, that sort of misses the point. The wings from Buff Joe's are fantastic for following up heat with flavor, and that to me is the hallmark of a good wing. Small wings? Perhaps, but I really don't care, because I've never left feeling any less than stuffed. And satisfied. It's the perfect prelude to sauntering over to the Lakefill and walking off some of the meal. :)
(5)
Gary M.
Service is what you would expect from a place like this. The wings are awesome..
(5)
Joseph C.
STILL BAD!!! My name is Joe and I am from Buffalo and this place is misnamed. If you serve ranch with your wings you should not be allowed to use Buffalo in your name. Mid-West Joe's fried Chicken is the proper name. yuck
(1)
Varun M.
So far I've had Buffalo Joe's food on take out twice and both times i was disappointed. I love wings, i'm addicted but bad wings well they are very disturbing. Growing up in Upstate NY (Rochester) I love to try wings wherever I go and Buffalo Joe's, you are heart breaking. At the end of the day the wings have a few key ingredients 1) The Sauce 2) Cooking Times 3) The actual wing quality used Buffalo Joe's fails on ALL THREE. First off the Sauce is not very spicy, it has a very vinegar based taste and doesn't taste like any good (or bad) buffalo sauce i've ever had. They are usually served very dry without much additional sauce. Looking at cooking times, they definitely over fry the all the wings. Good Buffalo Wings are crispy on the outside but pretty soft on the inside...unfortunately on both occasions i feel like i'm eating crispy chicken every time. Last the quality of the wing used, I have a strong feeling they aren't using fresh wings but the frozen ones you find at the super market. The wings they serve, the meat is very often stuck to the bone and you'll find the bone's break very often when you eat them. THIS IS A CLEAR SIGN that the wing is of low quality. I do like the fact that they are small and not like other places where a wing is larger than a drumstick but unfortunately they need a new supplier. They do have some good variety and I know they have made a good living because frankly, Chicago doesn't wings. Plus on a college campus, this is perfect food but with the BWW opened up around the corner I think Buffalo Joe's is going to be in for some tough competition.
(2)
Amy L.
Came here recently after going to the Great Lakes Naval Base. Mmmh, I was looking forward to some cheddar Chips and some suicide wings. And man, did I get my grub on. The suicide wings were good but I thought the mild taste pretty good too. Next time, it's milds all the way. It has the flavor without having the burning sensation when I potty. Sorry to be descriptive guys. You know you probably think the same thing when you eat hot stuff! DON"T LIE Note:**The wings seems to be a big bigger than the last time I visited Joe's.(Bigger than a quarter) All in all, a thumbs up to visit again.
(4)
Michelle L.
After an extremely disappointing "cheddar fries" experience somewhere else (note to all out there - if you call your dish "cheddar fries" or "cheddar chips" instead of cheese fries, this means that you need to use a real cheddar sauce vs. the generic bright yellow artificial imitation funky-tasting cheese sauce that the others use) I was seriously craving Joe's cheddar chips... ...And I was not disappointed! Not only is the cheddar sauce amazing and real, but the "chips" (fries) seem so fresh, and the skin is still on...they would be good just by themselves (not like I know from personal experience as I only get them with cheddar). As for the wings - they're good, the sauce is great, but I'm not a crazy wing fan. My husband loves them though, he's been eating here for so long and it's great when his wing craving coincides with my cheddar chip craving....
(4)
Frank L.
I'm sorry, but this place was just underwhelming. The two friends who took me to Buff' Joes made it seem like the wings were the best ever. I'm not a hater, but it just seemed to me that they took some chicken wings, threw them in a bowl of hot sauce and tossed it around. I kind of expected some of the seasoning cooked into the chicken. I suppose for the hot-wing lovers, this type of place is best, because you can ratchet up the heat if you like. Oh, and my girlfriend made the unfortunate mistake of ordering a baked potato. What they really meant was "microwave potato". Who goes to Joes? Long-time die hards who grew up on the stuff. People who want to choose the spicy to their hot wings Who avoids Joes? Folks who prefer wings with the flavor cooked into the chicken
(2)
Daniel A.
Great wings, great and fast service, all around-enjoyable. They don't take credit cards, though.
(4)
Dennis P.
The best wings in Illinois. Suicide is the only way! with the jalapenos... with their brand of ranch... my mouth is watering just talking about it...
(5)
Miriam B.
I've been going here since I was a little girl. Great wings, burgers, baked potatoes, cheese chips( waffle cut cheese fries) and awesome chardogs!.
(5)
Mike P.
This would be a 5-star, but for the complete lake of attention I received from the dude taking my order. It's partially my fault as I didn't have my order ready, this being my first visit. So the wing Nazi tuned me out. Anyway, the wings are superb. We had spicy and they were spicy, but not too spicy. Not the meatiest wings, but they give you a ton of them Celery and ranch came with. The cheddar chips great. That was the best fake cheddar cheese sauce I've ever had. I will relish the opportunity too have it sit in my colon for the next 6 months. Thanks, processed food stuffs! You should definitely check out this beautiful little dump. I can't wait to go back to try some sammiches on the menu, with a side of wings and maybe a processed cheddar cheese fry or too. Also, they have RC. My hillbilly soul rejoices.
(4)
Jeff H.
Look. This place is great if you know what you're getting: awesome wings and a lot of them. I love BW3's - my undergrad school had one across the street from our campus; in fact, I think I spent my 21st birthday there, or at least part of it. But BW3's costs a lot more, and whiile there is bigger sauce selection, sometimes you don't want to choose between 20 different flavors - you just want wings and a lot of them. The suicide wings ain't all that hot. They're basically medium-to-hot wings with canned jalapeños atop. I couldn't figure out why they were touted as suicide wings until the next day, where I spent 5 minutes in the bathroom wishing I was dead. But it was worth it. I might go back tomorrow just to show my colon who's boss. Don't come for the ambiance. Don't come for a business lunch. Don't bring your mom unless she can get down with some wings like whoa (and if she can, give her my number).
(4)
Simone T.
I'm from NY, and yes - Buffalo Joe's buffalo wings are the best I've ever eaten. Also the best cheese fries, hands down. GREAT owner AND staff. I love this place!
(5)
Tanya G.
I have had buffalo joe's since freshmen year of high school (9 years) and no wings have ever been able to top theirs. Personally I think that mild is the best! Its always a treat to go there with a friend and for them to taste exactly what I've been talking about :) Staff is always very friendly, always bustling with customers. ONLY tiny constructive criticism I have is that you have to be prepared to always have cash. They do not take credit/debit for payment and its always been like that. Seems like a very successful restaurant chain, really wish they would upgrade to this. Would make it a lot easier and convenient for customers versus running to an atm nearby...
(4)
Jocelynne G.
I used to LOVE coming here when I was a kid, when it was packed and hyped. I took my friends here thinking it would still be awesome, but the service was downright bullshit. I was charged for tap water. The workers were on their cell phone when we walked in, and they served a few of THEIR FRIENDS before me when I placed my order much earlier. For the amount of food I got I can't believe how long it took. I've never been to such a filthy place. This is not even the city. The wings were good. But then I remember that when the worker was tossing them in the sauce, he wasn't wearing gloves and the sauce was getting all over his greasy unwashed finger which was IN the steel bowl! I also noticed there was a crusty residue in the steel sauce bowl, instead of texting on their cellphones when we walked in they should have taken the time to wash or rinse the nasty thing in the sink. God just... disgusting. And embarassing that I took my friends here. They were completely mortified. :|
(1)
Amy S.
I've heard from most locals Chicagoans that these are the best wings in town. I went, I ate and they were OK. Definitely not the best I've ever had, but not the worst. I think we ordered the hot and not the 911 (or whatever they were called) and I think the 911 are what people rave about. The hot were not hot and a little too vinegary for my palate. I need burn your mouth off HOT, not just a little hot. I'll go back again to try the 911 and I hope they don't disappoint.
(3)
Neal W.
It really doesn't get any better. Double order spicy w/ a side of chedder fries. Best wings in chicago. Sure it might take a minute to get your food but its well worth the wait.
(5)
Leonard S.
Got a gang of wings to go from here yesterday along w a hot dog and cheddar chips....I've never been inside buff joes before and still hadn't as I stayed in the car, but I've eaten these wings countless times before....I swear the wings were never this small before...some of them laughable but I couldn't stop eating them because of the sauce....I'll just get a burger or dog next time w sauce to go....I know a few Sunday chefs who can fry up some wings better than these while putting back a case...I can't believe that's the wings they served hahaha...the merkts cheddar is great!
(2)
Gary C.
Where do I begin?? I've had my fair share of wings and Buffalo Joe's definitely tops the list. I started off on the bottom of the spiciness chain and got the mild. Great flavor, but it was missing that kick. I moved on to hot and I knew I struck gold. Stronger flavor and much more heat. I stayed on this level for a while then built the courage to try suicide. I've never looked back. It's arguably the best wing sauce I've ever tried. The extra heat comes from the jalepeno slices, seeds and all. Not only does this place have great wings, their buffalo chips [seasoned] with cheese is to die for. Ask for some suicide sauce on top and you have some of the best fries in the land. Service is decent. Actually, better than average for this reason: they messed up an order [they gave me a single instead of a double order] but took my name down to give me a free order next time I ordered. No questions asked.
(5)
Ben W.
I have been coming to Buff Joe's since 2006, and I must say that the quality of the wings and service is in rapid decline. The wings seem to be getting smaller and smaller(check out photos 11 and 12). Also the price is constantly on the rise. In 2006 the price was 8.99 for a double order, it went to 9.99, and is currently at the outrageous price of 12.99. Sadly Buff Joe's has lost over 75% of my business. GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER!!!!!!!!
(2)
William W.
Came here with a group of friends last month after my last visit back in the college days. Unfortunately, the wings tasted a lot better back then when fast food was the only meal of choice I could afford. Don't get me wrong, they are still pretty darn good. They are just not at the level of "OMG let's go to BJ's!!!!!" good. We got a party tray of wings for a group of 6 people along with some buffalo chips (fries) and nachos. The flavor was definitely there but the wings' size was simply too small. We also got a small order of "suicide" flavor, thinking that they would be too hot for us. However, that did not impress too much either. Although the spiciness did sneak up on us and we were all sweating by the end of meals. I think I stopped at 20 something wings, which is equally depressing considering I inhaled 35 wings last time I visited. Now, my proudest moment of this visit was making pot of rice and brought a couple containers worth of it with us. Friends have always told us that rice surprisingly tastes good with the wing sauce so I decided that this would be the time to try it. And it did not disappoint!!! It sort of tastes like a Chinese dish of "sweet vinegar deep fried fish". So it certainly pleased the Asian side of me when the wings were just a-ok.
(3)
Elizabeth B.
My ex-boyfriend used to tell me all the time that I have a tiny mouth. I thought he was just flattering himself until my family dentist confirmed that I do indeed have a smaller-than-normal mouth. My tiny mouth is usually not much of a problem. However, it became an issue at Buffalo Joe's when I ordered the bacon cheese burger. I had to eat the grilled onions with a fork, take off most of the lettuce, all of the tomato, and pull out most of the top bun before I could take my first bite. When I did finally get to take my first bite, my burger was barely warm! I ordered the burger medium and it was well done. How exactly did they make my medium burger cold AND well done in less than 5 minutes? It defies the laws of physics. The fries were good but pretty cold. I didn't try my mate's wings, the burger made me lose my appetite for wings. We went to Buffalos Joe's for lunch because we are jobless and poor right now but, next time I will go to a different spot for lunch even if it costs a little more.
(1)
Joseluis L.
This is my first time ever giving a review. I just had to come and see what everyone else wrote and felt inclined to give my opinion. I was introduced to this place by a couple of friends and they told me these were the most amazing wings they have ever had. We went last friday night and I will start from the beginning... The man begging by the front door was an immediate turn off. Walking up to the cashier was another immediate turn off, she had a very bad attitude. Not only did she talk with a bad attitude but she also wore it on her face. She really acted like she didn't want to be there (I wouldn't want to be at such a filthy place either). Now this I blame on my friends since they did not tell me but they do no accept debit cards/credit cards. I haven't been to place in a long time that doesn't accept (it's 2012 and you still run a cash only place?)...oh well. Also, if they accepted credit cards I would have ordered so much more wings and beer (they were tiny). But I borrowed cash from my friends. I wasn't about to use their atm machine. I get it, you don't accept cards but the owner (I'm assuming he owns that atm machine) is more then happy to charge you that fee for using that machine he installed...nice. I ordered double suicide. I got my food fairly quickly so that was a plus. We then proceeded to sit down at the filthy tables. They have tvs to watch...too bad the one with the loudest volume for some reason was set to a channel with infomercials, huh? The wing sauce was good (it shouldn't be called suicide though, not that hot) but the wings themselves were soooo tiny, laughable tiny. I just pretended they were amazing for my friends benefit. They still were acting like the place was amazing. I didn't dare go to the bathrooms, I didn't want to know what they looked like but my girlfriend did. She came back in seconds after leaving and told me there was urine all over the seat and also that there was a nasty mess inside the toilet because that person didn't bother to flush.... We will not be going back. It's not worth it for great sauce on nasty wings, eaten on a nasty table, and our order being taken by someone with a nasty attitude. No thanks!
(1)
Shelden E.
mmm...yeah, these were good wings, and I did get quite a bit even for the single size version, but the dude worked at the register was such dick. I had ordered a Miller Lite beer when at the counter, but when I got to the register/tap they asked me again. So I changed my mind to the Leinenkugel's Winter ale--the exact same price--and the dude stood there saying, "It says Lite on your order." "Yeah my bad. I meant the Winter Ale. My bad." "It says Lite on the order." "Yyyyeah. I mean is that going to be a problem?" He just rung it up and took the cash. What a jerk. Like I said the wings were good, but I'd almost say they're just as good at Buffalo Wild Wings a few blocks away. Service is better there and more selections on stuff. Oh yeah. Also, the wet naps my friends and I got were all dry in their packaging. It was nice to walk out with the hands that weren't the cleanest.
(3)
Ernie C.
Buffalo Joe's is uneven. I love coming here, but sometimes I wish I just opted for Flattop or any other downtown Evanston eatery. 1. Wings have gotten smaller. 2. Stingy on the ranch/bleu cheese. 3. It is not worth the price. It costs me $12 for wings, fries and pop (me alone). 4. Don't ask for water, cashier is QUICK to tell you.. "We don't give no free water here" and charge you $1.50 for the cup. No lie. 5. Cheddar fries are still good. 6. Somedays food is hot, somedays food is warm. 7. Better than the Howard Street location.
(2)
Joe T.
This place serves up some great hometown wings. Whenever we do a house party in Chicagoland we always get these puppies by the pound and bring em' home to serve to the masses. They're great nibbler wings and they have a Suicide flavor with a hot sauce and grilled jalapenos in it. This flavor and the BBQ are 2 of my favorites. When you dine in here - you buy based on the number of wings and the wings are bigger. When you order for a party - they are smaller nibbler wings and sold in aluminum trays by the pound. Either way if you are a Buffalo Wild WIngs fan and looking for another Wings joint in Chicagoland that hits the spot just as well - look no further and try Buff Joe's!
(3)
Darren F.
i been coming here off and on for many years.. it used to be better and more meat in them.. right now the wings is pretty tiny but it is still good.. love the waffle fries and love the burgers here! i dint really like eating inside there because it smells pretty horrible sometimes..
(3)
Krupa U.
Buff Joe's is great! Every time I'm in chicago with friends, we always get a big order of buff joe's wings to pig out on at least one night we're there. I personally love the BBQ flavor, and I guess the Jalapeno would come in second. The wings are actually mini-wings, smaller than Buffalo Wild Wings, but we usually order the party pan for whatever party we're throwing so they are perfect little nibblers to go along w/ your beer or cocktail. Speaking of beer... they sell it! A limited selection mind you, but still, nice to know. Oh and major plus - it still tastes good the day after! Usually reheated wings end up getting dry and shriveled up, but Buff Joe's found a way to keep em tasting good for longer! I commend you, your Wingness!
(4)
Jason C.
When I get a craving for wings, there is only one place that can satisfy it: Buffalo Joe's. I will gladly drive 25 mins from my place to Evanston to get some of their wings because they are the best (in my opinion). You have to make sure you go to the Clark Street Buff Joe's and not the Howard one - I'll explain why later. My order never changes: Single order/suicide and cheddar chips, also served with celery and ranch dressing. If I'm feeling risky I'll also get a Diet Rite. The magic is all in the tangy house suicide sauce with jalapenos, but it's not spicy to the point that you can't enjoy the wings. The cheddar chips are waffle cut fries slathered in a layer of cheddar goodness. I went to the Howard location once thinking that they too would have cheddar chips - FAIL. This is why going to the Clark St location is a must. Reminder: They only accept cash so make sure you have some coin on you!
(5)
Grace B.
My trip back home was not complete until we went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston. By far one of the best wing spot ever. Double order mild w/ buffalo chips and a side of cheese please! You will not find a spot like this in LA. I've been a fan since '94. They keep it nice a simple.
(5)
harry b.
By far these are the best wings in the state, if not the country! Wheather you prefer BBQ, mild, spicy or 'suicide,' go all out and get a double order. If you don't finish them on your first try, they're great the next day. Note that the other locations are not as good as the Clak location. They will do in a pinch, but the extra few minutes in the car are well worth it!
(5)
Leo I.
Buffalo Joe's no more. When there is more bone than meat on the wings, you know it's time to accept that the legendary hole-in-the-wall has seen better days. I've been going to BJ's for quite a few years now. They had some of the best chicken wings I've ever tasted and definitely the best in the Chicagoland area. My last few visits were disappointing and last night's visit was the last straw. Whether it's the economic crisis or the fatigue that drives BJ's decline, decline it is. So long BJ.
(1)
Stephanie F.
Sh*t, man. I'm not even a wings fan but when I was taken here by a wing guru and experienced the melt-in-your-mouth quality of these babies, I felt it in my hips. The cheese fries are fantastic. MMmmmm........the wings are so good that the only descriptive words I can come up with are naughty interjections.
(5)
Frank P.
I've been coming here for at least 10 years and still the best in Chicago land. Never had anything but wings and chips (fries). Nothing else compares especially the bigger wing chains. I like the medium with jalepenos on the side. I like spicy but like to taste the chicken as well. Place isn't too big and not quite as clean as you would like. But definitely a place I crave.
(4)
Pin Y.
As a Northwestern Alum, I miss this place so much!! You aren't an NU student if you don't go to Buffalo Joe's late a night. I want a Buffalo Joe's in LA! Please????
(4)
Sam W.
Been coming here since high school. Hands down the. Best wings I've ever had. Hidden secret, try the cookies at the counter if you have room after stuffing your face with wings. Oh yeah and the cheese fries!!
(5)
Jacob J.
Before Buffalo Wild Wings, this was my fix for wings in Chicago land. Suicide, thinking about it has me salivating. That's a ton of hot sauce lathered over wings and then a helping of sliced jalapenos over that. That sauce is great for dipping or just alone. You've got to really dig (vinegar) hot sauce to appreciate Joe's flavors. I can't remember the exact brand of hot sauce, might be Louisiana, they keep jugs of it in plain sight. A perfect order is a double order of wings, a basket of the waffle cut fries and a large drink. (That's large soda pop, not "drink") Tempt fate by getting a few friends together and ordering a full or half pan. That's a catering order of 50-100 wings. Extra wet, the extra better. Joe's however isn't consistent, at times you really love it and other times it's not how you remembered it. Note: during cold seasons it can be cold in the dining area, dress warm or you may have your jacket on while eating. There's something important to mention about payments, I believe it might be cash only, or charge only on orders over $20 +. You may like to inquire when placing phone orders. (This may have changed) Crowd is all Northwestern Univ peeps and locals. If you go late night expect to get harassed by street walkers. Not your usual kind either, they have refined tastes and may ask for more than just change, they need to eat too. (One time a guy asked me for change, I bought him some fries, he then tells me he would've rather had the money so he could get some Thai food!)
(4)
d a.
the bathroom is disgusting-reminds me of a prison from a bad tv movie but everything else is great. also the soda is supersized not the normal sizes so unless you're pat fitzgerald thirsty go smaller. great place, great service, food still reasonably priced and great mix of students, 5 year olds with dads, grownups and regulars. the fries are waffle and the cheese on the burgers is spread which is better. cash only and they're open very late. just excellent, but fix the bathroom-with all the little kids it should look better.
(5)
Ngoc H.
You don't know what wings are until you get a taste of Joe's. They come out right from the fryer and are topped with jalapenos if you get them suicide. I wold say some days the wings are better than others, some days juicy and huge, others skinny and disappointing, but you never know until you order. Their buffalo chips are to die for, crispy on the outside tender on the inside waffle fries that are tossed with a delicious seasoning blend. There's this seasoning on them which I can never guess whats in it. A lot of people like the cheddar on them but I would go without. They only take cash, but there's an ATM in there too if you want to be charged for the fee. Not the greatest place for a date but if you are craving wings with a couple friends, it's the place to be.
(4)
Phil X.
"A single order of hot wings with a side of cheddar chips, extra cheese." I come here when I want buffalo wings...or when I want to negate any of my previous efforts at my local gym. I don't know too much about the rest of their menu. The hot wings here are tasty. I usually order 'em hot. If you order the "suicide" version, they take the "hot" and throw a bunch of peppers all over it. G'head and try it. Your colon will thank you. The wings themselves tend to be small sometimes. It's all about the sauce though. (That should be a bumper sticker) The BBQ wings are pretty good too. They're sweet, NOT hot. On the side, I always order cheddar chips with extra cheese. They are waffle-fries. The cheese is a melted sharp cheddar. You will either love the cheese...or you will hate it. I wash it down with grape pop.
(4)
Jeff H.
Hands-down the best wings I've ever had, and I've had them at about every place that is supposed have even passable wings. Perfectly fried, perfectly sauced. The best part is they don't bread them. Breading, in my humble opinion, is an amateur move. Breading is fine on chicken fingers, but it has no place on wings. The sauce...holy sh*t, the sauce. My theory is that BJ's sauce has three key ingredients - 1) Crack cocaine 2) Heroin 3) The tears, sweat ,or semen of some cosmic deity. Now, I see that some of the reviews bash BJ's for the wing size. I'll admit that these aren't great big, super meaty wings, but therein lies the genius. Ya see, I can say in all honesty that every place I've ever been where you get big, meaty wings, is that you usually just end up tasting the chicken which is usually low quality to begin with. When I eat wings I want a perfect wing-to-sauce ratio with the sauce having just the right consistency to cling to the wings. Buffalo Joe's has this ratio perfected. My friends and I have brought many, and I mean MANY people here to put it to the test and they've all loved it. In fact, out of all of our friends and acquaintances who've had BJ's only one of our buddies doesn't care for it, which isn't bad out of the large number of us who love it. I even know several people who - while claiming to be vegetarian - make an exception for these wings-from-above. Finally, to make your BJ's experience complete, get some waffle fries and a Gut RC and you have the makin's of a superbly unhealthy, but decadent meal. It's worth the drive from Chicago, I assure you.
(5)
Mr. C.
I'm not sure what has been happening here lately, but since I started coming here 3 years go the wings seem to be getting smaller and the employees ruder. Don't get me wrong they have one of the best buffalo sauces around, but my last visit was not a good one when I was taking one bite off each wing since they were so amazingly small. It's like they got their chicken wings from baby chicks that haven't fully developed yet, which made the entire recent experience kind of nauseating.
(3)
David T.
I've been a regular customer of Buffalo Joe's ever since I've moved to area in 2001, when I first heard they were the best wings in the city. They never disappointed ... until now. For some reason, my last five visits or so (I average about one visit per month, always driving more than 25 miles just to get my fix) the wings have been pretty sub par, almost bad in some cases. I would usually finish my single suicide order w/ waffle fries and crave more, but the wings have just been severely lacking lately. I can't put my finger on it, it might be the shrinking size of the wings, which were already pretty small to begin with. There's also been a few occasions where the pieces look deformed, neither looking like a traditional drumstick or wing, so I just throw them out. The sauce is still as good as ever, I just think they've somehow cut some costs and used a cheaper, less tasty wing now. I would usually recommend Joe's highly to any one who hasn't visited the place yet, but now I'm not so sure. Hopefully their act picks up again.
(3)
Abhist D.
I love Buffalo Joe's wings. I used to eat them a lot during high school and hadn't had them in quite a while. Well I lost a bet to a despicable Sox fan and had to pay up with Buff Joe's wings. Let's just say that this is one bet that I wouldn't mind losing over and over again! I mean...the wings are delicious! Heck, even my wife (who can't stand wings cuz she's never liked the tast) loved them. And I mean LOVED them. They're good. Service is what you'd expect from the joint, which means its quaint in its own way. Oh...and suicide wings are the way to go (and they are NOT THAT HOT!)
(5)
Bless P.
Outstanding and THE best chicken wings and fries I've ever tasted!!! Very casual and a long wait if there is a game scheduled.
(5)
Aimee C.
yes, yes and more yes! When I'm dying for some good old fashion buffalo wings, the trek to Buffalo Joe's is worth every painstaking moment. From their suicide sauce to their waffle fries, it's a treasure to devoured. Better than all the rest... Hot, saucy and delicious.. wings flying as elbows are up in the air. Don't try to talk to me, because I'm deep in sauce and can't be bothered. :) talk to you when my fingers are licked and the grin of complete satisfaction is plastered across my face. -- ps take a zantac.. the sauce will definitely get your tummy rumbling.
(4)
Albert C.
I love this place!! I've been going here for such a long time.. the single order is such a big portion and I always mixed bbq & suicide sauce!! Don't forget to get their buffalo chips aka waffle fries with the cheddar cheese! For $10.10 AMAZING!! Their cookies by the counter are amazing also! They're actually freshed baked daily but it looks old in the container
(4)
Janice L.
yumyumYUM. the suicide wings are the best, heaped on top with jalapeno peppers. the flavor is the best of all the wings i've ever had. also, i'm not a fan of breaded wings and here, it's naked, so perfect. one downside, sometimes some of the wings have absolutely no meat. i wish they fattened the chickens a little more, they're like anorexic! anyways, dip the wing into the ranch sauce, take a bite, aahh.. bliss (:
(4)
Precious B.
What can I say Buff Joe's never fails wings and fries all day!
(5)
Bruce B.
The best wings ever! I grew up with Buff Joes and nothing will be better than them. Get yourself a double order of suicide, buff chips with extra sauce, and a large RC. After you're done eating, you should probably run around the block to burn off the calories. Or, you will be in food coma because it's that good. Be prepared, they wings are not big. However, each one packs lots of taste. They service is always pretty quick. This location is far better than Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. If you like wings and fries (chips), there's none better in the Chicagoland area.
(5)
Sabrina B.
Wings ate delicious. Very greasy though. Wings are not big in size however. A single will be good for one person provides they are hungry.
(4)
Vanessa D.
I think this is one of those places that you can only truly appreciate if you've been coming here since you were in high school or college. Despite growing up in the area, I never set foot into this Buffalo Joe's until this year. I've been twice now. The spicy wings are good. And they have RC cola, which is always a pleasant surprise. However, I found the actual wings to be awfully small with not much meat. Additionally, their cheddar chips which I had high hopes for were soggy and gross both times. I had been assured that they typically were not like this... so, who knows. But, the place has character and they have a full menu of things I haven't yet tried, so I will definitely give them another chance.
(3)
Bridget M.
Quite yum. The wings are good, but are decidedly not truly spicy. They douse these guys in sauce which adds to the overall appeal. The cheese fries are a must do. Major props for the real cheddar cheese chunks accompanied by the jalapeno slices. The burgers are greasy and delicious; I'm not a big fan of the kinds of buns they use. Pretty good deal for what you spend. Just wish they'd invest in having a paper towel roll at the table a la Hooters and a credit card machine. Buyers beware, this is a cash only joint!
(4)
Eric M.
I'm giving them four stars within their genre, which is fast-food, with a heavy emphasis on wings. I went here for the first time last weekend. Not having been before, I don't know what size the wings were "back in the day," but I don't really give a damn about wing size when they just scoop a bunch up and don't count them. 20 small wings vs. 10 huge wings - who cares. If anything I like wings for the skin anyway, so more small ones usually means more skin, more deliciousness and more satisfaction! I thnik these are some of the best-tasting wings I've had. I do like blue cheese dressing better than ranch, but the wings themselves matter a whole lot more than the side sauce does. I don't live close, so I can't say I'll be a regular or anything, but I liked them well enough that I'll definitely be back, maybe even for a special trip now and then. I do have one complaint - the cheese fries were not up to par. The cheese congealed and became a gooey, cold mess way to fast. And the fries themselves weren't that great, either. Making good fries isn't rocket science and I think people let restaurants off easy too often for sub-par fries.
(4)
Alexander W.
Double Suicide, Mega RC. Perfection.
(5)
Jeff H.
Fun and cheap wings place for those that don't want that big chain down the street. #cheapeats
(4)
Faye D.
Oooh Buff Joes... My favorite place to eat in Evanston. The wangs are thee bomdiggidy and the cheese waffle fries. Mmm. Con: Kind of dirty and they don't accept cards. Oh well big whoop right? The best wings place for me so far.
(4)
Miles S.
Best wings I have had so far in the northern hemisphere. Great atmosphere and good people. Not a lot of flavors, but not needed. Great burgers and chicken. A must try .
(5)
Orlando H.
First thing I get walking in is a rude cashier. Went in 15 min before they closed and she was quick to say "we're closed we have nothing left". They should change their closing time to 1145 not midnight.
(1)
AJ M.
This place used to be my spot for wings. At one point I would even go as far to say the best wings I ever had. The sauce is amazing, wings so cripsy like none other. Although still pretty good it's not as good as it used to be. Prices have jumped alot over the years, I remember when a double order used to be around $9 now $14. The waffle fries are still a guilty pleasure that doesn't disappoint. They only take cash, well worth the occasional visit!!
(4)
Jamie H.
Came in today for lunch because I've heard the wings were amazing. I tried the mild and the hot; mild was awesome but the hot I wasn't too crazy about. Was a pretty standard hot sauce. You get a pretty decent price for the amount and because the mild was so good I plan to come back and try the suicide sauce the waffle cheese fries.
(4)
Gina T.
By far the best wings I've ever tried EVER. The only reason I give them four stars instead of five is because it looks dirty and smells. And even with all that going on ill still eat there. Other than that the wings are amazingly delicious. Very crispy. I got the mild wings and the sauce is sort of sweet but it's nothing less than scrumptious. The waffle fries are fresh and tasty. I'm a ranch lover. Ill have ranch with anything and buff joes ranch is the best ranch I've ever had. I wish they would clean up the place a bit. That's the only complaint I have.
(4)
Jane Y.
OH MY WORD. the wings here are DELICIOUS UGHAS;LDIFAH;SLDIFH i always crave these things and then GET SLAPPED IN THE FACE BY REALITY because... its a bit of a drive for me to get here but just thinking about these wonderful heavenly saucy tastey oh not so little wings goodness gracious and the CHEDDAR CHIPS screw diets and if ur gonna cheat might as well make it a WORTHY CHEAT COME TO BUFFALO JOESS!
(5)
Mark K.
This was Sweetie's favorite wing place in Chicago, so I had to stop by on the way through last week. Especially after she forbade me to stop at any BBQ places on the south side... Nice little college-town wing joint. Looks really small, but once you order you see there's a bigger room in back to eat. Service was efficient and friendly. Order sizes are big- I got a single and worried that it would be enough, but it was plenty. Nice meaty wings, good sauce (I got BBQ.) I got a side of celery, which was also good sized. Between a few veggies, lots of wings, and some RC, I was fully satisfied. Can't wait to go back.
(4)
Vealy C.
The wings were terrific, the service isn't that bad. The "ghetoness" of the place adds to the experience, but the bathrooms.. ohhh, they're always so dirty. My hands still feel dirty even after washing them.
(3)
Frank Y.
You are either a fan or a hater; there are no in-betweens when it comes to Buf Joes. I am a fan. When people complain, they tend to say that the wings are too small; but I love them. The sauce makes these wings. It is kind of sweet, thick, and has just enough spice. The wings, because, they are small, are crunchy on the outside and perfectly sauced. The ranch that Buf Joe's has is awesome! It is very easy to get addicted to these wings. When our sons come back to Evanston, one of the first things that they crave is Buffalo Joes. For a family of four, we get a double-order of spicy and a double-order of mild wings. The waffle fries are also yummy when you dip them in the ranch dressing. If you want a burger in Evanston, go to Edzo's. If, however, you want wings, nothing compares to Buf Joes.
(4)
Gautram W.
First and last time! I wonder did they fried the wings in oil or grease..... Horrible horrible horrible.... The burger as well was dipped in oil/ grease or whatever.....
(1)
Renya M.
The food here is amazing and the service isn't bad either except for this one douchebag who actually cooks and prepares the orders. I'm sorry that he feels his job is so difficult, bagging wings and taking people orders, really, I am. Id be miserable if I looked and acted anything like him too. This guy was rude to everyone in line though, do yourselves a favor and go to any other location if you care at all about servers doing even the absolute least in terms of being polite.
(2)
Rod D.
Still loving Buf Joes as the wife and I continue visit on a frequent basis. Remember to ask for well done if you like your wings crispy
(5)
Sharon C.
Everyone always raves abut Buff Joe's being the best wings in Evanson, but I honestly don't see it - I typically order the wings mild and they have this really funky aftertaste. The fries are soggy, and the burgers are literally dripping oil through the paper trays. I'll pass.
(2)
Z S.
So good. This is my guilty pleasure food. The wings are so good and saucy, while the burgers are enormous and very greasy. (The special Buff Joe's sauce mixed with mustard and ketchup is heaven.) All variations of the chips/fries are really crispy and flavorful. So while the food is a little unhealthy, you've got to treat yourself once in a while.
(4)
Don T.
Still after all these years, my favorite buffalo wings place in the Chicagoland area!
(5)
Cyril L.
Buffalo Joe's has some of the best wings. My first time was last month and they tasted really good. Make sure to get the sauce. For a low price, you can get a basket full of wings. It's worth the wait.
(4)
Meredith C.
My first impression was very poor. The girl taking my order was so incredibly rude, I immediately regretted my choice to eat here when there are literally 50 restaurants in this area. Rolled her eyes when asked questions, spoke barely above a mumble, when asked her to repeat herself she basically shouted at me. Really, really, rude first impression. She of course entered our order incorrectly. Wrong food came. However, the other members of the staff quickly fixed her mistake and we're exceptionally polite and cheerful. Food was really, really good. Best wings ever. Fries are great. All of the food was outstanding. Felt a little like we were eating out of our laps, maybe give some plates out with wings? When we left staff said goodbye, very polite. Made up for little miss sunshine that took our order. Try it out. Food is really amazing. Cash Only but there is an ATM. They do serve a few beers, also.
(3)
Michael G.
Simply the best. I made an hour round trip to get these wings. I usually do once every 3 weeks. I crave this place weekly. I wish I was skinny and could eat these wings every week. Standard order is Double Order Suicide (gotta have the jalapeños), cheddar chips (never get cheese on the side, the fries need to be covered in cheese!!!), and a bowl of cheddar broccoli (when you are waiting for your food ask for a sample If they already haven't offer it to you).
(5)
Nari L.
Love this place! Came here years ago with a friend when I was in college and I loved it! I recently came back here years later since the last time and I still loved it! The food is fast so you can come and eat here in a jiffy.
(5)
Jim K.
Been going here for more than 25 years. No change in order: Double order wings, Cheddar chips, and gutbuster lemonade. Why mess with perfection?
(5)
Michael W.
You could not BELIEVE how much I love this place... To paraphrase... These wings are more full than Donald Trump at a Las Vegas strip buffet, with sauce sassier than Ellen DeGeneres, and so meaty they had to bring in a weatherman to evaluate it. Let me just be upfront and say that the wings are not boneless and are actually smaller than the average wing, but the upside of that is that the surface area to volume ratio on these wings is ri-DICK (any one of my AP Bio homies know what's up!!!), which makes for some outrageously saucy wings. Also, they give you celery sticks! Celery sticks are fantastic, it's literally portable water, but in solid form! I actually have a patent pending for a booze canteen that's made out of celery. The idea is that when you get a hangover after a heavy night of drinking, you can eat the canteen the next morning for a refreshing, fibrous jolt of hydration (hit me up if you're interested, but I already got a lot of investors lined up). Okay, one last thing. The one weird thing about it is that the urinals have ice in them. Ice! What is this, Soviet Russia*? I personally will not use any product with a molar mass less than or equal to 18, so this was especially problematic for me (sorry about your sink, Buff Joe's) *fun fact: In Soviet Russia, you were only allowed to buy water in ice form. In fact, the premise behind the "Cold War" was that the Soviets were trying to freeze the world's water supply (for that Russian +1 mobility buff in cold). That's why the United States detonated so many nuclear bombs back then, to keep the earth warm. Down with commies!
(5)
Donald S.
I love these wings (spicy. The barbecue don't count seeing as its only Sweet Baby Ray's), and I judge all other buffalo wings by these. They have beer on tap and consistently great wings whichever sauce you get (mild, spicy, suicide, or BBQ). Single, spicy, extra ranch & celery, with an order of the buffalo chips ( waffle fries...), and a Berghoff means your in buisness.
(5)
Jessica D.
My favorite food is spicy chicken and DING DING DING. Buffalo Joes has won the key to my heart and stomach. My mouth waters just thinking about it. I have pregnant cravings and I'm not even pregnant. If I were getting the death penalty, this would be my last meal. I can never stop myself from buying more than what can fit in my belly.
(5)
Marci G.
Sorry Joe, but I am done with Buffalo Joe's :( Sad to say. The last few years the wings have just gone way down hill and I just keep hoping the next time I go (once a year) the wings will be delish again, but sad to say they are not. I don't know why they changed the recipe, but they have not been the same for a long time now. I actually left there tonight and wondered if Joe was still alive, because I cannot imagine him being alive and him allowing his restaurant to go this far downhill. The worst part is........it is so filthy in there, I am shocked that the health dept has not come in and faulted them into cleaning the place up. So many bugs flying around in there, it's hard to eat your food. And the bathroom.....OH MY GOSH, GROSS! It was filthy last year when I went and this time.....horrible ( seriously, blood on the tiles!) I grew up on Buffalo Joe's. I have been eating there since the mid '80's. If you are around Joe, please put some money back into it and clean it up and get your food back up to the excellent tasty level it used to be in. Bye for now.
(1)
Tian Y.
Not really a picky wing-eater, and I'm good with their sauces. The wings are kind of small though compared to other places nearby, and I prefer the big and juicy ones with meat. Don't be surprised by poor customer service here.
(3)
Kristen L.
Double order of suicide? HELL YES. Buffalo Joe's has the only wings that I will ever crave. Sure the restaurant itself is a bit dated and it can be next to impossible to find seating on any given night, but damnit, are they worth it. The wings themselves are a bit on the smaller side, but they make up for it in how many they give you. The fat-ass in me always gets a double order with buffalo chips (the double order comes with anywhere between 20-25 wings). That paired with some fresh celery and ranch? Makes my mouth salivate just writing about it. On the way back home from a day at the Field Museum with the parentals, papa Lee decided he wanted to stop by and grab some to go. It's about a good 25-30 minute drive from Buff. Joe's to home, but good God they were still delicious (and not soggy) after we go home. The only painful spiciness I would ever put myself through.
(5)
Joe H.
I'm giving BJ's a 4 star rating as an average of the 5 star place this place has been to me over the past 20 years and the 3 star place it was the other day when I stopped by. These wings are what I've always measured all buffalo wings I've ever eaten in my life. I LOVE THIS PLACE. But the other day, I didn't love it so much. The sauce had a weird ammonia kind of flavor and the cheese on my chips tasted like they put in more glue than normal. I also hate how expensive it has become. But I still love the place. The place hasn't changed at all! From the floors, tables, benches, bathrooms, and staff (GARY!!!!), it's the same. Kind of like an Evanston time capsule plus inflation.
(4)
Roxanne R.
Yu-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-ummmm!! Hands down best wings in Chicago. You get about 15 or so wings for a single order. The wing sizes are on the small side, just like I like it. I want to eat wings not drumsticks. The sauce is what makes the wings. It perfectly coats the wings and is fantastic. I always get a single order with waffles fries and cheese on the side. Waffle fries are solid. I recommend getting the cheese on the side. The cheese isn't liquidy nacho cheese, this cheese coagulates after a while and it's a nice compliment to the wings. Service is okay and the place isn't very tidy but this isn't fine dining, you come here because the wings are freaking delicious.
(5)
Karen K.
It's always fun to come here for a late night dinner with friends. Unfortunately, I've noticed that their wings have gotten even smaller. There was barely any meat and what meat there was on the bones were very tough. The celery that came with our order was not washed well and I was so desperate to combat the saltiness of the wings with the celery that I ended up wiping the dirt off with the napkins.. but gross. The cheese fries were the only thing that made the meal yummy.
(2)
Earlie C.
Wings are still the best in the city, but holy hell. We came in last night and came across the most ghetto, classless workers ever. First, the use of the word "fuck" was used around twenty times while I was waiting for my food. The vulgarity of staff had my brain hurting. Seriously, pull up your damn pants, act like a decent human, and possibly show me that your vocabulary consists of more than "fuck, shit, and motherfucker". My girlfriend ordered a polish. We both witnessed a female take a reject order (a polish that was sitting out in a basket when we first arrived - for how long?) back on the grill for about a minute and serve us that dog. Come on Buffalo Joe's... Just make sure you go when the owner is there. I'd question ever ordering food from this establishment again if he was not present.
(1)
Stacy H.
Suicide wings are soooo good.. I only like boneless wings but I make an exception for these. The waffle fries are good too. Can be a little salty but I just always have lots of water near by!!
(5)
Alana H.
Aside from the loud obnoxious and inappropriate conversation taking place by the staff. The chicken was amazing. The waffle fries were not as good as they were hyped up to be however the chicken makes the long drive and rude service worth it.
(4)
BforBulky B.
Just went! The buffalo wings are great. I'm not sure I'd trek all the way out there again for the wings, BUT I WOULD FOR THE COOKIES. And the ranch dip. If you're in this part of town, definitely stop by. If you're in Chicago, R.J. Grunts wings are delish.
(4)
Emma R.
If I could give this place no stars, I would. I have not been to this place since I was in high school. My family and I happen to be in the area and I had the bright idea of having wings. So down to Buffalo Joes we go. The girl in the front was the best part of experience here. Over All cleanliness of this place is just gross! They got one of our drinks wrong, my husband goes to the front to change it. The girls pours it, coughs in her hand and with that hand that she coughed in, grabs the lid puts it on the cup and hands it to my husband. Gross!!! I am surprised people eat here, and that this place has not been shut down because it's dirty.
(1)
Buttermilk P.
Very good wings. My wife and I try to grab a bite at Joe's whenever we are in Evanston. We normally order their wings with mild sauce and waffle cheese fries. They have three main levels of sauce which are all the same, mild, spicy and suicide. The difference is, the mild is only a coating of sauce, the spicy gives you a bit more and the suicide adds sliced jalapeno peppers. The sauce is really good, and since everything is made to order, the wings are usually hot and fresh. They don't give you very many fries, but the cheddar cheese sauce is also very good. In typical north side/north shore fashion, everything is overpriced and a la carte. We are used to Harold's, where chicken comes with fries, coleslaw and bread. That would cost an extra $50 here, and the prices you pay here would get you triple the amount of food at a south side establishment. However, it is a bit of a different take on wings, so we pay a visit every blue moon. Cash only.
(5)
Shari F.
Buffalo Joe's in Evanston WILL NEVER AGAIN GET OUR BUSINESS! The manager is so unprofessional and the employees do not inform customers properly about pre-ordering, a horrible place. We have been going there for years and tried to pre-order for Super Bowl and the idiots told us for smaller orders to just come in. We drove in the blizzard and they wouldn't serve us, I will never go to a Buffalo Joe's again and will never recommend them to anyone.
(1)
Rene S.
Wings are really good (not as good as Franks for the Memories in Mundelein, but that is too far away). They are small but the portion size is huge so it is worth what you get. There are only three sauce levels: mild, spicy and suicide. I wanted medium and was directed by the woman who took my order that the spicy would be a good alternative. It was. So why only 4 stars if the wings are good? No credit cards, no delivery, and the cardinal sin for a wing joint .... NO BLUE CHEESE dressing! While I can cross the street to the Jewel and get some blue cheese dressing, no delivery is a big problem. They are going to lose a lot of business, including mine, by not offering delivery. On a nice summer evening in the summer, not a problem to walk the mile to get to the place. But if the weather is at all bad, I often order delivery so I don't have to go out if I'm running low on groceries. Too bad I can't order from here!
(4)
Lucy F.
Great wings!!!! Simply, Delicious, nice crunchy texture and the mild sauce is just great! Make sure you don't come on the weekend since the place is always so pack.
(4)
Kyle D.
Dear Evanston, you've got a serious impairment when it comes to evaluating wing joints. Not sure what's going on here. Buffalo Joe's is a 4 star wing joint? C'mon. Is this some kind of romantic/nostalgic thing? The result of underdeveloped undergrad taste buds? First, this place is f'ing D.I.R.T.Y. The dining area is dirty. So is the kitchen. Every time those kitchen doors opened we were smacked in the face with a nasty odor. And the wings suck. They go nuts with the corn starch. Corn starch has no place on wings. They damn sure don't need to look like they've been breaded in it. And the mild sauce is it sweet? WHY is it sweet? Call it sweet sauce, because it has no resemblance to a buffalo sauce. Fries were ok. Ranch was lame. Nothing redeeming about this place.
(1)
Emily P.
Suicide wings with cheddar fries are a must! (The burn in the bathroom later is worth it; trust me...haha sorry for the TMI)!
(4)
Eileen S.
Seriously good wings. I always get the buffalo wings with mild sauce and cheddar chips (waffles fries smothered in cheese sauce). Ranch is tasty as well. Sure its not the most beautiful place to eat, but that's not why I go. Beware: you will become addicted to these wings!
(5)
Sallie H.
The spicy wings were pretty good, I'm not a fan of wings so I can't really get excited about them. The one thing I can honestly say was terrible there was the cheese fries. I believe the cheese was made out of powder, idk it was just gross. I had to scrape the cheese off my fries because it was so disgusting. The cheese at 7-Eleven for the nachos are 10 times better than what Buffalo Joe's offered. The buffalo fries are very good, i wished they had real cheese to go with it :-(
(2)
Christine M.
Awful. Awful. Awful. Half way through our meal we found a long black hair melted in our cheese fries.
(1)
Will B.
Total collapse of the brand they built over the years. I've been going there for over 27 years. These days it is really bad. Watery teriyaki, under cooked fries, and the worst wings I've seen in a long time.
(1)
Brad S.
Going back to my days in high school, over 20 years ago, I've always been a big fan of the place. Went there for lunch on Friday with a friend from high school, trying to re-live the good old days. I was shocked at the quality of the wings themselves. They were so small and tiny. Wish I had taken a picture at the time to post on here. It also drives me crazy that they nickel and dime you for every little thing. Who charges for a cup of water?!?! They do. The reason they get 2 rather than 1 stars is the people were quite friendly, even offering up free samples of split pea soup, and the sauce itself was quite tasty. Hopefully it was just a bad batch of wings but have to say I was awfully disappointed in the place.
(2)
Gabriel S.
I've been coming to Buffalo Joes since the early 90s. The wings are still the best in the world in my opinion. The perfect blend of meat and crispy skin with absolutely amazing sauce.
(5)
Kevin C.
When I was an undergrad at NU I lived a few blocks away and would get the same order of wings and buffalo chips every couple of weeks. When I moved away, despite searching high and low, I could never find a wing place that matched the buff. So when I came back to Chicago for work, frequent pilgrimages to buff joes were a must. It still hits the spot every time.
(5)
Shalem A.
Buff Joes is an Evanston staple, and they offer the best wings in Evanston. This is not health food, but at least once a month I'll grab a single suicide for lunch. It is good for the soul. They also have awesome waffle fries and solid burgers, but if you're coming here for the first time, make sure you try the wings. The staff can be a little "sassy" at times, but it's part of their schtick, don't take it personally.
(4)
Randall K.
Not the cleanest place, but one of my top 5 places to eat. They have my favorite buffalo wings. In Buff-Joes language, I usually order a double suicide with cheddar chips and a gut-buster RC. What that really means is a double order of wings, spicy with jalapeños too. Waffle fries loaded with a creamy cheddar cheese sauce. A large Royal Crown soda. The wings come with little ranch cups and some celery. Mini napkins are on the table. The area is nice and close to northwestern university. It can have it's share of pan-handlers sometimes, but because of the area, they are usually non - aggressive. If someone asked me for my best wing place, it is definitely Buffalo Joes.
(5)
Lefai K.
The wings of the place is awesome! You won't find lots of flavors like you would at bw3, just mild, spicy, and suicide. The breading is not too much, but the crisp was perfect. =============================== And now my signature bathroom review! =============================== the place itself is kind of a hole in the wall. That being said, I didn't expect too much from it. And it's pretty much true. It's a place to take a leak, and then get the f out. So sit or squat? Squat... And flush the toilet by kicking the toilet handle down, because gawd knows what's touch that toilet handle
(4)
Asia C.
The BEST wings in the chicago area! I've been ordering wings from them for years! I always usually order a single order of suicide. Also, this location is the best. Coming in second is Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. is last. I can tell the difference in how each location prepares the wings.
(5)
Hersh A.
This place doesn't do much for me any more. Menu variety it's relatively good for what the place is. I mostly care for having wings here. I have been here a handful of times in the past. Back in the 90's I used to like their wings, especially the suicide kind but at some point something changed (I guess their recipe?) that the suicide wings have not been the same. They taste average at best. Also what I didn't like recently is that the order taking person said you get 12 wings in single order and we got our order we were shorted a few wings. When I asked about it, one of the persons behind the counter said that the wing amount is never exact but more like 10-12. Wtf? That's just dumb. I don't think I had such a problem in the past. I don't care for the cash only affect of it. Oh well, I don't desire to come here again anytime in the foreseeable future. There are better wings place out there.
(2)
James H.
I'm happy to see a lot of 4 and 5-star reviews for Buffalo Joe's. But it's pretty clear all of them are from people under 22 or who know so little about wings that they feel the need to make clear that these are bone-in wings (as if boneless wings are actually wings or should even be in the discussion of what makes a great wing). Anyhow, 10 or 15 years ago, I would have given Buffalo Joe's an emphatic 5 starts. It was unrivaled for the best wings in the Chicago area. But the wings keep getting smaller, the preparation keeps getting sloppier, and the restaurant keeps getting dirtier. They're not bad and I might go back if I lived in Evanston but my Buffalo Joe's days are done.
(2)
Danny M.
I live 30 minutes from this place and I will still make the drive here for their wings. They have the best mild and spicy wings I have ever eaten. The wings have gotten a lot smaller than they use to be, but it is still good. The sauce on the wing is perfect, not too spicy were it kills your taste buds. Get the wings with waffle fries and you will not be disappointed.
(5)
Heather K.
Love this place!! It's food that you get acquainted too while living here. Love the rib tips cause their bbq sauce is a little more on the sweeter side. And their wings...are nice and tangy!! Great combo with the ranch and celery sticks! Simple and easy option just to grab a bite to eat.
(5)
Jung K.
want spicy buffalo wings? look no further and stop by the Buffalo Joe's on Clark st. Order: single suicides with chips and a large drink. If suicides are too spicy, then get out. The regular spicy ones are good too.. They have their system on lock down. Order your food, pick up your food, pay in cash only, and go demolish those wings.
(5)
Scotty D.
I went here after a friend told me these were the best wings in the Chicago area. I love wings. I can confidently say these are the best wings in the Chicago area. 8 bucks for 10 wings is a great deal. The spicy sauce is great. Just enough heat. Even the mild my wife had was good. The wings are cooked perfectly, nice and crunchy. Even the ranch tastes better than other places. The waffle fries are great but I'd stay away from the cheese sauce. It was very salty and congealed quickly which ruined the fries. Wouldn't get them again. But if you want good wings, man this is the place.
(5)
Kristen D.
This place FAR surpasses any place like BDubs. The wings are HUGE, you get a lot of them with one order, and there is enough sauce on each wing to still have enough to lick off your fingers. (I feel like in all of my wing experiences, there is never enough sauce to go with the meat. NOT the case here!) They give you an order of celery and ranch with a wing order, which was one of my favorite things about this place. My only complaint is that it is HOT in this restaurant...but that could also be from the huge friers and grills up in the front of the restaurant.
(5)
Kevin S.
Great taste and good people. Best wings so far anywhere
(5)
Aldi J.
My go to wing place!!! Best buffalo sauce. Just get spicy or suicide please. Don't be weak and go mild. Growing up in nearby Skokie, my friends and I would head over here and pig out on the regular. I'm a bit disappointed though because the wings over time have gotten smaller... anyone else notice this? C'mon bring the bigger wings back. Sorry, this was the reason for my one star deduction. Some things never change though. When I arrive at a party and see a party pan, my mouth starts watering I know what I'm attacking first. Don't forget the awesome waffle fries!!
(4)
Ryne D.
I've been here many times before, but on my last trip to Northwestern this weekend to do an interview, the only thing on my mind was getting these wings. They have that much control over me. Ok, sure they're tiny, but they're damn tasty. And since a single order gets you around a dozen of these bad boys, you should be good with just that - even though I usually get double orders anyway. What puts this location over the other ones are their cheddar chips - waffle fries with Cheese Whiz-ish sauce dumped on top. So delicious, provided you finish them off before the cheese morphs back into its semi-solid state. Never had anything else from here - I'm good with my suicide wings, thanks.
(5)
Ed L.
My friends had nothing but great things to say about this place so i had to go check it out with them. Needless to say I left wanting to come back more and more often and thinking about the years wasted not coming here. My friends say that they raised the prices but a double order of wings and two orders of fries only cost about $20.02 with tax. Which isn't bad if you split it with someone. The waffle fries are crispy and tasty but to be honest next time i come here I'm getting a double order for myself. I love that they can mix sauces together and the spicy barbecue is the way to go in my opinion. The sauce makes my mouth water every time i think about it and adding jalapenos to the wings is icing to the cake. You will definitely be visited by me more than once in the coming month and if your in the Evanston neighborhood i would definitely consider checking them out.
(5)
Hannah P.
My mouth is watering waiting for our order. I worked out just so I can pig out today! Suicide Please.
(4)
Danny W.
A meal of a single order, cheddar chips and a mega-gut RC is now $13.65. What happened to you Buff Joe's? You used to be so beautiful.
(1)
Tom M.
My favorite spot to grab some wings. I take a detour into downtown Evanston or hit the one on Green Bay if I'm craving Rib Tips every so often to get my fix. When I lived in Evanston, this was a regular stop for me. Now that I'm farther away, my times between visits has lengthened which my doctor appreciates. I highly recommend!
(5)
Danny B.
In my opinion, these are the best wings in the world.... ** IF YOU ARE NOT A BONE-IN WING LOVER, THIS MAY NOT BE YOUR PLACE!!** But for the rest of us who have a wing obsession and could care less about the decor this place is highly recommended!!
(4)
Christine N.
Oh, Buff Joes. You are so conveniently located across the street from my college condo, tempting me everyday as I pass by to go to class, walk to downtown evanston, go visit a friend, walk to work... You haven't failed... Yet. I have this disgusting fear that one day I'll walk in, and it just won't be that good. Unfortunately, the wings have indeed gotten smaller since my first taste. But I must go on with the wonders of this wing. It's fried. It's not good for you. But oh... It's good. Something this good can't be THAT bad, can it? Ok fine. These chicken wings are not just fried. They are crispy. CRISPY, I tell you. Take a bite and CRUNCH! And then you get chicken. This is the disappointing part. I wish the chicken was more succulent inside, but it can't be when the wings are small. The sauce. Yum. We get spicy and it's the perfect amount of heat. Not a fan of the excess sauce on the bottom with the last few wings that are swimming in the sauce. And the celery sticks are usually warm. But I still am loyal to you, Buff Joes. I will always eat you because you are just that good. Also, the suicide wings are basically just the spicy flavor with jalapeños added. Skip the suicide. Take taste over heat. Word.
(4)
Elliott C.
attention buffalo joe's on clark street......please clean up that disgusting men bathroom and hire friendlier ppl to work there WHO VALUE CUSTOMER SERVICE. i can no longer take Lacresha and them attitude. First bad experience on November 3rd 2013 p.s. the wing are still the best!
(3)
Leonard P.
the chicken was delicious. I love coming here with friends and family. big fan of waffle fries and it hit's the spot when it comes to craving for chicken. the littel down side is how they don't accept card. Other than that, the food is fine and the atmostphere is pretty chill.
(4)
Ashley C.
We made the trip up here for the buffalo wings and because of the 4 stars on yelp. Disappointment to say the least. It started from the phone call to see what there hours were on the 4th of July. The girl picked up the phone and with attitude says, "the usual hours we're open." When had to ask what those were, she replied with the time after uttering an "uhhhh." That got me off to a really bad start. So we tried the buffalo wings (spicy), the burger, and the cheese fries. Cheese fries were average. The burger was average. The patty itself was good, but the toppings were average and didn't taste super fresh. The buffalo wings - average. I would have liked them crispier - the sauce was decent. Oh yes -and they had RC as their pop. As a diet coke/pepsi addict, this just did not quench my thirst on the blistering hot day. Average food + employees with attitude + drive to Evanston = not worth the trip.
(2)
Stephanie C.
Best wing place ever! My uncle had introduced me to this hole on the wall. It's not a super clean place. However the food is amazing. I love boned in wings and the flavors for the wings are perfectly seasoned. I love the mild wings the best. I cannot rave about this place enough..
(5)
Bethany A.
If you're looking for classic wings with classic sides, this place is the best. Their wings come out piping hot, lightly fried, and doused in just enough sauce. The sauce is tangy and spicy (or not, you have options) and it's seriously finger-licking good. I love munching on some celery sticks on the side and their waffle fries are pretty good as well. It's an awesome place to come with friends (order the party platter and dig in!). Yum, so glad that it's near campus.
(4)
Al D.
While I love the wings, cheddar burger with its creamy cheddar spread, plus the waffle fries, that's about it on the love for this Buffalo Joe's. I recently had some of their spicy chicken fingers, and they were nearly inedible. The chicken tasted spongy and off, and the breading was akin to rubber. Also on my last visit, I had their famous cheddar burger, but with grilled onions. Bad mistake. About 3/4 lb of undercooked, thick, white onions slid off the burger in a huge pool of grease; nasty. I think most of the five-star reviews are based on nostalgia. Buffalo Joe's is looking old, dirty and worn-out now. I'd maybe go here again for wings, but that's about it.
(3)
Derek D.
I have talked about merkts cheddar before and this place does it RIGHT! WINGS : Amazing every time with a good sauce to wing ratio. un-breaded as well - CRUCIAL. I love the vinegar and butter mild sauce. never had the guts to go hotter. Fries. Well done Buff Chips are the way to go. The cheese is best if you order 2 so you can dip Every fry with JUST enough of it. LOVE YOU BUFF JOES! d
(5)
Jeff W.
There's only one place I'll ever go for wings anymore and that's Buff Joe's. I grew up in Evanston and having been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. After college, I took a job that involved significant travel across the country. There is no place in the country like Buff Joe's. You'll see numerous awards on the walls from different cooking events they've won - their sauce just can't be beat. My favorite burger of all time is actually from Buff Joe's. It's called the Buffalo Cheddar Burger and has a grilled patty with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato, Merkt's cheddar, and then Buff Joe's wing sauce - whichever hotness you desire. It's AMAZING! No place has come close to replicating such an amazing creation. Some negatives are that they only take cash (not even debit card) and the place is located in downtown Evanston and parking is usually pretty difficult to find. While there are tables, there are very few so I suggest getting it to go and bringing it home.
(5)
Sevun H.
The wings and waffle fries were just as good as they were when I was a student and used to eat Buffalo Joes 4 days out of the week! The two girls who greeted me when I walked in were another story all together. They both had very nasty attitudes and seemed to be very unhappy with their jobs. One seemed much more interested in telling her co-worker about her previous nights Hennessy drinking exploits than providing anything remotely resembling customer service. Being eyeballed from head to toe by two immature, insecure, unprofessional employees is not welcome when I am spending my hard earned dollars on overpriced wings and fries. Will not be back. I will just cherish my memories of Buffalo Joes when the service was just as good as the food!
(2)
Mary M.
Always an Evanston favorite. I'm not a huge "chicken on the bone" kind of person, but this place brings wings to a whole new level. If you like spicy...even just a little bit, you have to get the hot or suicide wings. Cheddar chips are a must! Not to mention, the ranch dressing you get with the wings is hands down my favorite.
(5)
Viki N.
When you're feeling low, or lost in life, don't turn to Jesus, turn to Buffalo Joe's! (At least that's what I do.) I have been addicted to Buffalo Joe's for over 15 years. No matter how much I try to forget them, the taste of their wings keeps coming back up in my mind, and I am compelled to make the pilgrimage to Evanston once again. My personal drug of choice here is a single order of suicide wings, spicy cheddar chips, and 2 extra orders of celery and ranch. Nothing can make me happier, and nobody's wings come close to having as much flavor as Buffalo Joe's. (and I've tried, a lot, to find someone even half as good so I don't have to drive all the way up to Evanston again. But no such luck.) So, I recommend stuffing yourself full of wings, and then catching a movie at the movie theatre down the street, or at one of the film festivals they have at Northwestern. Happiness coming into every orifice!
(5)
Julia J.
I've only eaten take out of Buffalo Joes, and I wasn't the one who picked up the food, so I can't speak to the service or condition of the restaurant itself. The wings, though, were delicious- not the largest wings, but certainly not the smallest either. The sauce was really good. I was full from the smallest order. We also ordered the Spicy Cheddar Chips, which were messy and horrible for you, so they were pretty much one of the most delicious concoctions I've ever had.
(3)
Mike T.
Not impressed with this place at all... The wings are so so at best and the staff is always cranky. This is a good place for college kids that have a limited pallet, or are to drunk to know what they are eating is sub par.
(2)
Kareem A.
Place is a mess... ghetto service, thought they're gonna kick me in the face if I ordered one more thing. Their 'boneless wings' are basically chicken tenders refried just to be warm when served. The BBQ sauce is so average I wasn't sure why the place is so famous.. Maybe because it's by NU in the middle of downtown Evanston, who knows? Give them a try, you might have a different opinion.
(2)
Brian K.
FAMOUS FOR: - Buffalo Wings (8/10) Ah BJ's. My education in Buffalo Wings. Brings back great memories, because just about every party and get together in jr. high and high school (when hanging with my North Burbs friends) involved a double party platter of Suicide wings. It was also a much more innocent time where someone would mention BJ's, and instantly, everybody's ears would perk up, eyes would widen, a giggle would pursue, and then everyone was thinking the same thing...mmmm Buffalo Joe's. It also brings back 1 painful memory. They once had a limited time sauce called "XXX" which, after 4 wings, made me cry, drool, and drip from my nose. I downed an entire jug of Ocean Spray Ruby Red juice. It probably wasn't the best thing, but it was college and that was the only thing I had. Yeah...let's not do that again. THE WINGS The only way I ever have them is Suicide. It's not that spicy. Ok, I know this is coming from a Korean guy who's done a ghost chili wing challenge, but still... Put it this way, it's not anywhere near Mango Habanero at BW3 and not even as hot as Three Mile Island at Hooters. Not sure what else to compare it to. It comes with pickled jalapeno slices all over the top, but even those aren't that bad. I usually don't even break a sweat. They're very small wings, about than the length of a grown man's pinky. They're not battered, but do have a crispy skin (at least around the edges). It's drenched in a traditional buffalo type sauce, but it's their secret recipe. "Traditional" meaning that it's kinda like the Louisana hot sauce. You know, kinda salty, with a small kick. In my High School days, I couldn't get enough of these wings! I'd give them 5 stars everyday! Then now, in my post college days, these guys are hit 'n' miss, almost exactly 50/50. Sometimes I go, and I get my single order of suicide wings and fries, and they're just "pretty good." Sometimes I go, and all the lights go on and the choir sings and I'm basking in nostalgia and it just tastes so damn good! That's why I can only give it 8 stars, because it's not consistent. I've only been there maybe 5 times since college (I'd run outta fingers and toes trying to count between HS & College), so I don't know if I'm just changing or my mood affects the taste (although I don't recall ever being in any different moods), or what. It's just not consistent for me. ALL IN ALL I would never pass up an opportunity for BJ's. It's very rare that I'm ever in Evanston, so if we get the chance, it's always BJ's. Oh yeah...CASH ONLY! Even if you're buying hundreds of dollars of double party platters....It's CASH ONLY!
(4)
Matthew B.
Best buffalo wings on north shore and maybe in Chicago.
(5)
Amir L.
I've been going here for over 15 years and it's one of the staples that started my obsession with wings!! Gotta rock the cheddar chip all day with the gut RC !!
(5)
Nishan P.
Not everyone will love Buffalo Joe's. If you don't like sucking on bones, if you don't like the texture of skin, if you can't handle messy; Buffalo Joe's might not be for you. If these things don't bother you, you'll probably find Buffalo Joe's quite delightful. I know other reviewers have called Buffalo Joe's "filthy", "embarrassing" and "disgusting" but I have always been extremely satisfied. If you're not sure whether you would like Buffalo Joe's and need someone to try it out with, give me a holler. I am always up for Buffalo Joe's.
(4)
Luke S.
Their wings are good - close to real good. Their waffle fries are good - also close to real good. Their service is typically horrific and it's really expensive for what you get.
(3)
An P.
Famed and acclaimed, Buffalo Joe's is an anchor in Evanston and a primary contributor to the Northwestern freshman 15. You'll hear tales of its wonder and glory from all over but sometimes you just have to see it to believe it. I've made a few trips to Buffalo Joe's over the years and never counted it as a legendary wing....until now. On the latest edition of Get Yo Wing On, I waited in line and a brilliant idea came to my head, what if I ordered Buffalo Joe's wings extra well done?! Extra well done? Hell yes they made me a batch!!! The wait is comedic, you'll see people running off with their score with trays filled to the brim with wings, cheddar waffle fries, and the All-American celery with batches of ranch and bleu cheese. Lacking the glitz and glamour of fancier trappings, you'll find Buffalo Joe's with the charm of any greasy spoon you'll find across America sprinkled with a tinge of intoxicating wing aroma. The concept is simple: freshly cooked wings laced with some of the best wing sauces you'll find in the city. Wings come in mild, spicy, BBQ, and if they like you they'll make some spicy BBQ. More spice-addicted souls can try their suicide wings laced with jalapenos but your ears might be left blowing out billows of smoke! These wings are lilliputian in stature but what they lack in size they compensate with volume and honest to goodness flavor. I've always found the wing sauce exceptionally delicious with a little extra kick to leave your mouth watering but veritably, I find myself a texture freak. I love texture on my food so when I got my wings extra well done and brought it back to the table my eyes lit up. The first bite was the best bite as I finally figured out the puzzle and unlocked the greatness of Buffalo Joe's at last. Extra well done means extra tasty crispy to the beat of my drum. You're going to find yourself wanting to come back for another visit to this Evanston wingery, and you just have to figure out what wing is best for you, but don't let me be the judge - take a bite out that for yourself!
(5)
Albert M.
Omg! Just left this place with two of my friends, absolutely disgusting! Decor was a mess, a hooters demolished! Just weird! I wouldn't recommend this place to my worst enemy!
(1)
Robert G.
Obsessed. I love the fact that a restaurant can do business the same way for 20 years and still have a huge fan base. Want a coke or diet coke? Too bad. We only have RC Cola. Want to pay with plastic? Sorry, cash only. Obviously, Buffalo Joe's is doing something right, because they continue to crank out amazing, delicious, greasy, fantastic food. The house made sauces were incredible. Mild sauce was just the perfect amount of heat with that signature Buffalo buttery-ness. I had the chicken tenders: cooked PERFECTLY! Crisp and crunchy on the outside, juicy and tender on the inside. Waffle cut fries and a Diet Rite rounded out the meal. My friends tried out some of the various chicken sandwiches, which looked phenomenal (and the general consensus was that they were). This is most definitely an Evanston institution, and you would be remiss if you didn't stop by when in town.
(4)
Gaby C.
Maybe its just me, but i've eaten here 5 times in two weeks. The wings are the best ever!!! I love love love the wings here. The sauces (hot or mild) are just right, not too spicy not to sweet not too tangy, just riight. They have a few locations in Evanston, but I like the one on Clark.
(5)
Jennifer E.
Oh my chicken wing goodness! I got the double order of hot wings plus waffle fries and it was sooooo good and sooooo cheap. I wish I live closer to one of the locations! Dear Buffalo Joe's owner - please open more locations in Chicago (preferably in the Lincoln Square neighborhood)
(5)
Phill C.
Oh boy, what else can I say other than "double sui with waffle cheese fries please". Back in the good old days, me and my highschool buddies would all pitch in for a double suicide party pan with lots of ranch. Just thinking about the food makes my mouth water as I type. The roughest part is standing to the side, waiting for your order. Just watching them make the wings, while you stand there is pure torture. They have such unique and of course delicious wings. Deep fried crispy in what looks like no batter or breading at all, then swirled around in large bowl containing a combination of buttery hot sauce. Crispy but not crunchy chicken wings with a unique butter hot sauce... and I always get the suicide loaded with jalapenos. One of my favorite places for wings.
(4)
Fletcher G.
I hate to be a nay sayer but Buffalo Joes didn't hold up to all of the "glorious" reviews. You end up paying a bit more then Buffalo Wild Wings prices but far less then Buffalo Wild Wings quality. I was extremely disappointed in this place!
(2)
Adam K.
Another local haunt I have been frequenting since before I could legally drink and had to resort to getting loaded on drinking the hookah water at the hookah bar down the street. I think all the negative reviews from long time patrons are telling in that they mention all the good things about this place in great detail but then say the bad in one sentence. And then they go on to say that they will be back. Sure this place is flawed, hell, this place may not be the best for wings anymore, but it is an institution. A buffalo university. When you graduate from it, you will cast aside the wing stop Pizza Hut wings with a scornful smirk and declare, "I HAVE EATEN AT BUFF JOES! THESE ARE NOT WINGS!" I always have and always will get: Double order of Suicide - Spicy, what can I say other than I got a party platter of the spicy wing awesomeness once for the superbowl, one of my idiot friends liked it so much he decided to drink the concentrated hot spicy suicide wing sauce that had congealed jalapenos in it, and then had a fiery colon for 3 days. Do not attempt to drink a full cup of the sauce. But do get the suicide and Double order of BBQ - Oh man, so sweet and delish, these really compliment the spicy, and because of my Indian upbringing, I am partial to the spicy but these will always hold a special place in my heart, cuz they are loaded with cholesterol and will probably be either removed by a robot doctor or kill me. Waffle Fries w Cheddar - another artery bomb, but so good in so many ways, there is not enough room on the internet to describe my love for these particular waffle cheese fries. Just try them. They also have beer which is a newer thing, I have not gotten any here. They have a pretty large seating area in the back with TV's so you can watch whatever games are going on, the ordering process is a bit apprehensive as you have to explain and re explain what you want to the surly, young, often but not always african american youngsters who look upon you with disdain. Then after about 20 minutes, you give CASH ONLY to the fat white dude manning the register with very little patience for small talk. Just go here. The experience outweighs the negative feelings you get when your cardiac surgeon looks up at you from the top of his glasses.
(4)
Jason S.
Buffalo Joe's is pretty crappy. I ordered a single order of wings with spicy wing sauce and waffle fries. My sister ordered a chili cheese dog. Our beverage consisted of RC Cola (on tap). The wings must come from dead baby chicks because they contained almost no meat. The sauce wasn't bad, but the comparable sauce from Buffalo Wild Wings or Hooters tastes better. That being said, I can't find any fault with the fries. They were delicious. The pop however was a travesty, as they did not offer free refills. That is borderline un-American (or at they least cheap as hell). The chili cheese dog appeared to contain Kraft singles for the cheese and the chili had beans (gross). A friend had the charburger with bacon, cheese and wing sauce. It was pretty good, but make sure to ask for spicy sauce instead of mild. Overall, I didn't want to kill myself after eating at Buffalo Joe's, but I certainly can't recommend the place.
(2)
Matt A.
giving this place anything less than 5 stars is a joke, seriously. if you want a big chunk of chicken or some hormone feed bird with giant wings goto wingstop or some other joke of a place. Chicken wings are supposed to be small - i.e. NOT have a 1lb of meat on them. This is the perfect wing and the suicide is the only way to go. i've tried them all - bw3, wingstop, wingshack whatever - NOTHING compared to Buffalo joes. worth the trip to e-Town all day.
(5)
Art V.
As I've enjoyed dining at this establishment for years, it pains me to post this negative review. Buff Joes has long offered tournament-quality buffalo wings despite (1) questionable sanitation practices, (2) aloof employees, and (3) a dynamic pricing scheme. Generally, the men's bathroom is under-equipped and shockingly dirty. More often than not, the paper towel dispenser is empty and the only urinal is jammed to the brim with ice. That door handle has enough grease on it to keep a 1000 ships' engines humming along nicely. Things aren't much better in the kitchen where latex gloves are treated like commas in a David Foster Wallace piece: used occasionally but only when damn well justified. Regarding the employees, I've long suspected that the ability to appear utterly disengaged while conversing with customers is a prerequisite to getting hired. It also helps if you can act as if there is literally no task you would enjoy less than mixing pre-cooked wings in a metallic bowl full of buffalo sauce. As a rule, I'm hesitant to generalize and disparage the entire crew. The cashier is usually pretty pleasant and I've actually had some appropriate interactions with the ladies up front of late. However, given the frequency with which I've experienced sub-par customer service over the years, I'd be entirely remiss not to mention this issue in a review. Although I rarely deviate from my standard order (a single basket of spicy wings, extra ranch, and a mega-gut RC Cola), the price I pay each time tends to wildly fluctuate. The value of wings must be inexplicably linked to some mysterious economic indicator. I forked over $12.01 for my standard order last night. While this price actually appears pretty competitive with that of similar outfits (i.e. Buffalo Wild Wings), it's far removed from the less than ten dollars the restaurant charged just a few years back. Despite the above, I happily made the not-insubstantial trek to Evanston to feast on Buffalo Joe's delicious wings for years. Up until quite recently, the restaurant had some of the best wings in Chicagoland. The chicken was always perfectly cooked: crisp on the outside, juicy on the inside. The sauce was and still is, "to die for." However, my last two visits have been underwhelming. The employees seem to be overcooking the chicken these days. Additionally, the wings are now embarrassingly small. I'm comfortable wagering that they are at least 50% tinier than their counterparts at Buffalo Wild Wings and Gators. While I will likely return to Buff Joes within the next month out of habit, I can promise you I won't be thrilled about it. Patronizing this establishment is like watching a washed-up, former all-star at the plate; evidence of greatness lingers, but he's still probably going to strike out.
(1)
Leo S.
Pretty good wing place, but the wings,themselves, are tiny. The suicide sauce is good, but it's not that spicy. It's more acidic than anything else because of the preserved jalapeños. The waffle fries was delicious. The burgers were also not bad. Everything is also reasonably priced, but they only accept cash which I dislike a lot.
(4)
Courtney W.
This place is good for one thing, wings. You'll have to order a lot though, more than you think you need, because there isn't much on these bones. The sauces are pretty tasty too but the classic is pretty hot for me. There isn't much to the inside of this place and the service isn't the best but that's not what they're known for anyways. I don't go to Northwestern but from friends, I understand that this place is a staple. They put plenty of sauce on these bad boys though so you won't have to order extra. The wings come with celery too and plenty of blue cheese and ranch sauce. I can see why this place is so famous and as a foodie, I understand the hype. I just hope this place never plays too much into, no frills and good wings is what this place does best.
(4)
Cecil S.
The most delicious wings I've had in a long time, definitely beats B-dubs hands down. Go here with an appetite, try their spicy wings. Includes some celery and ranch as well, in case things get too hot! Looks like they only had Miller or Bud Light on tap, eat-in area is kind of small/cramped with local Northwestern students.
(4)
Kim D.
i like your bbq wings and your merkts cheddar waffle fries. they r so good. cash only and dont you forget it.
(4)
Jay N.
I've been here several times and parking can be found on Benson Avenue to the west near the el. I went again last Saturday before the Ohio State game and was surprised to see that it wasn't that busy. As soon as you walk in, you put in your order and once it's ready, they'll put it on a tray (or in a sack if it's to-go) and you'll get your receipt. You pay after you get your food. There's a decent amount of seats in the back but it can get a little crowded. It's pretty limited in decor with framed posters about food or hot peppers. There's 1 tv in the back. The wings come in 4 flavors - mild, spicy, suicide, and bbq. I usually go with the spicy as it has the right amount of kick. They add on the celery sticks and ranch sauce with the order. I really like their waffle fries here. The wing sizes are decent again. They were pretty small for a while and now seem to be a good combination of meaty, crispness, and sauce flavor retention. There are only really 2 order sizes - single and double order. I usually get the double order as I can munch on some and then save some for later. Next sizes up are party trays for 8 or 15 people. Overall, it was a very good experience to come back here again.
(4)
Sebastian Y.
Warning: The tiny wings at Buff Joe's are extremely addictive. Another Warning: Cheddar chips are waffle fries with way too much cheddar cheese lopped on top. Last Warning: The Suicide sauce is hot. 4 stars for the wings. 2 stars for the cheddar chips. I'll give Buff Joe's a 4.
(4)
Sonia B.
If you are looking for some amazing wings, Buffalo Joes is the place to go! I've been going to Buffalo Joes for 15 years and I can still say that they, hands down, have the best wings in the Chicago-land area. Their sauce is definitely what makes the wings and it doesn't taste like only tobasco...like most other establishments. Mild, spicy or suicide are the levels of heat and you can order a single order, double order or a party pan if you're really hungry! I love to pair their wings with the buffalo chips or cheddar chips and a gutbuster (medium) lemonade or pop. Yes, pop...not soda! :) I like my wings a little crispy, so I order mine well done. Buffalo Joes is definitely a comfort food and I probably go once a week! :) They have many other items on the menu, but I can't say I have EVER tried anything else there. It just seems wrong. However, it is great that they have other options...which look yummy...in case you are with people who don't like wings. Although, I have NEVER met a person who doesn't LOVE Buffalo Joes! Even people who don't like wings end up loving Buffalo Joes! Buffalo Joes has a couple of locations, but the one in Evanston is the best. It does get crowded, especially when Northwestern has a game - but seats open up pretty quickly on a normal night. The only downside of the place is that it is cash only. So, make sure you come prepared. Your belly will definitely leave happy! :)
(5)
Julie K.
I'm 5 months pregnant and I've been craving wings. We live in Chicago on division, tons of bars and they sell wings too, but nothing compared to Buffalo Joes. Not the cleanest place but it is definitely worth the trip to Evanston for their wings. It truly is finger lickin good.
(5)
Eileen Z.
My favorite wings in Chicagoland. I've been hitting up this Clark location since high school. When I'm out of town, I dream of these wings. IT'S THE WING SAUCE. It's different from any other wing sauce I've had. BE PREPARED FOR GREASE. Buff Joe's wings swim in it and it's delicious. I love the suicide wings which are tossed with jalapenos, but I actually enjoy ordering the mild sauce more often because you can really taste the sauce. I find most people like to order the spicy, which isn't all that spicy to begin with. That's the three degrees of hot: suicide, spicy, and mild. No extras, just as simple as that. 12 years ago I may have given them 5 stars. But if I had to complain about anything about Buff Joe's it would be their wings have gotten much smaller over the years and that they only have a small coating of the sauce over the wings... much less than they used to. But I've found that this is the way I like ordering: - a double order mild with extra wing sauce (this already comes with ranch and celery) - buff chips (waffle fries) with cheese - large RC or grape soda The cheese they use with the buff chips seems to be a hit or miss with people I know since it's more of a cheez whiz type of cheese, but it goes beautifully with all the greasy goodness of the wings AND I LOVE IT. Even their ranch doesn't seem like a ranch I could just go buy at the grocery store. In fact, you can purchase pints of both their ranch sauce and special Buff Joe's wing sauce by themselves. This is nice for your at-home cooking experiments. In the past you were able to order the jugs, but they have put a stop to that. I haven't tried much else on their menu. The burgers are nothing special aside from the Buff Joe's sauce, but the buns they use suck and fall apart easily. The corn on the cob and broccoli cheddar soup are pretty good, too. But the only thing I keep running back for are the wings. Buff Joe's is cash only, but they finally put in an ATM a few years ago so if you forget to grab cash ahead of time it won't be a problem. The place is small and gets pretty packed, especially on nights and weekends since it's only a hop skip and a jump away from the Northwestern University campus. This is one of those hole-in-the-wall kinda gems. I've always wished they'd expand past Evanston, but the owner has said he never plans on it. Oh well. It's worth the trip anyway.
(4)
J J.
I used to travel for business quite a bit. I've been to basically 3/4 of the U.S. and my modus operandi was basically to hit up a wing joint anytime I could. After going to Buff Joes since I was a teen and experiencing the best wings you could only be disappointed going anywhere else which is exactly what happened to me. There is no comparison. Buff Joes hands down has the best sauce. If they put it in a cup I would drink it through a straw. And when there was not enough wing sauce to suck up through the straw I would tip the cup over and tap the bottom until every drop of sauce made it's way out of the cup. The same applies to their ranch dressing. It perfectly compliments their wing sauce. I can't say much about any of their other food as I've only eaten wings and celery here. The ONLY thing I can complain about is the size of their wings as I'm absolutely positive that they are smaller than they used to be. I'm not going crazy. Someone please agree with me. Don't bother wasting your time going anywhere else if you've experienced Buff Joes. You'll only be disappointed.
(5)
Patrick S.
Probably the closest yet I have come to what I would imagine they intended buffalo wings to be. Buff Joes has to be on my top...3 of wings destinations. I was intro-ed to said wings several years ago in my high school years. I still feel like Im cutting class when I sit down to eat over there. So anywho..why I am writing a review now? Because I have never attempted to tackle a party platter in one sitting....till now. I speak of the $40 platter thats supposed to serve 8-12 people I believe? I have no idea what possessed my friends and I (yes! grammar skills) to attempt to tackle such a feat. Let me just clarify I speak of 4 people for this platter of glory. This stint of gluttony was the brain child of pure spontaneity and opportunity. 4 people, $40...how could you go wrong?? About 45minutes later..me and my partner in crime inhaled about low-mid 30s each. The 2 others wimped out and had about 10-15 each. A late comer came into the equation contributing another 10-15. In the conclusion of this session of man v food..... Food came out victorious...there was about 12 wings left. Think about that for a sec..that is a massive amount of wings! And let me tell you..grease, and spice.......youre just asking for it. A dastardly duo of disaster; definitely! They device a fiendish evac. Regardless of what is left on the plate after any gluttony bout...trust me, FOOD ALWAYS COME OUT ON TOP.
(5)
David C.
Some wings are really good, some are even incredible. Buff Joes is heaven. Yes, they raised their prices a lot. Yes, their wings are slightly smaller. Yes, they are more inconsistent than normal wings places. But really, you can't top that sauce and those waffle fries. I would probably be willing to get in the ring with Floyd Mayweather and get knocked in 10 seconds just to have a double order of suicide with some waffle fries and a large RC Cola. If you go to Buffalo Wild Wings, I can't speak to your taste buds (they are obviously very unrefined). I did really like Wings Over, but they are definitely a different type of wing, basically chicken fingers with sauce. Overall, best restaurant in Evanston bar none. James, who usually works the cashier, is the man, and some of my best college memories are at Buff Joes. I've never tried crack, but i'm assuming it tastes something like buff joes wings (and its probably healthier).
(5)
Frank A.
Party pans! Haven't had B.J.'s in a year! Still hasn't changed. Still the best. Eaten til cardiac arrest! - Haha. I made a rhyme! See the Party Pan pix! They'll make you want some!
(5)
Mikhail D.
I've been coming to Buff Joes since I was 8 year old. FIRST OFF: Yes, this is down right unhealthy, greasy, fattening food. But sober or not, I always leave this place completely satisfied and it's my first meal everytime I come home. And you're a sinner if you're not getting cheddar chips!
(5)
Eugene M.
In 1996 or so, when I was in that most miserable of summers between 7th and 8th grade, I attended Sports Camp in Wilmette, IL. (Sports Camp is camp for children who are so bad at sports that it doesn't even matter which one they try to play on any given day.) At sports camp, I had a counselor named Dave, and Dave happened to be A Very Cool Guy because when our troop slept over at his house, we could play Waverace 64 until 4 AM and then watch Faces of Death. Having that kind of night makes you feel pretty cool yourself. Anyway, while at Dave's house that fateful night, I saw huge container that I thought was reserved for things like laundry detergent or motor oil, and the label on it read "Buffalo Joe's Suicide." Having just watched a bunch of Faces of Death, I didn't even want to think of what that stuff was, but Dave assured me that it was just wing sauce. A lot of wing sauce. At that time, I'd never even had a buffalo wing, but I'll always remember that huge plastic vat. Flash forward 8 years. I'm at Buffalo Joe's for the first time, face-to-face with one of those vats, the memories rushing back at me. I'd only had buffalo wings a few times, and I didn't particularly care for them. Nevertheless, my buddies swore by this place and what the hell else are you going to do on a Tuesday in your first summer with a driver's license? Double order of spicy barbecue wings, cheddar chips, and a Gutbuster root beer. I had seen the face of God. The wings were perfectly crispy, and the sauce was buttery, delicious goo. The cheddar chips, a perfect complement with their tangy sharp cheddar melted until it just barely retains some texture. Words don't really serve that sublime moment. I just knew that I found my calling. Flash forward another 10 years. I don't even like wings. I think they mostly suck. I don't eat much "unhealthy" food. But if I'm in Chicago, or even Milwaukee or Indiana or Iowa City or wherever, I go to Buffalo Joe's. Consistency has taken a dip, yes, but...BuJo's is not just "my" place. BuJo's is America. The huddled, poor, teeming masses yearning to eat wings, waiting in line for their taste of suicide or double mild or even a burger. Young kids, old dudes, foreigners, whoever, They're all here. They're all waiting for wings. BuffJoe's has opened its doors.
(5)
Stephen C.
This place is a Northwestern institution, or so I'm told. The decor hasn't changed in 20 or so years and the owner is the same. It feels like a generic place from the early 80s -- clean but utilitarian -- though the flat screen TVs help. Long counter in the front to order and pick up food and then tables in the next room. The wings were tasty -- messy but that's what buffalo wings should be. We got hot but I heard the suicide are not too bad either so I'm hoping to get those next time. People swear also by the cheese fries but the cheese was so processed that i found them a little gross. But the wings. Yum!
(4)
Lisa H.
I have been coming here for a couple of years now. This place is a little old, have nasty employees, filthy bathrooms, and sometimes smell. Their tables are always dirty and sticky, it seems like they never would wipe them down. But the chicken wings are one of the best wings I have ever eaten. They may be small, but you get a lot with one order. The spicy or suicide sauce drenched on these wings are to die for!! It also comes with celery and ranch (always need an extra one because they give you so little). Get the waffles fries to compliment your order and you'll be all set for a delicious meal.
(5)
Mark T.
Go figure, I go to a restaurant that specializes in wings...and I order a burger. What is wrong with me?? A group of friends invited me out on a weekday to hang out, and they suggested this place. I didn't feel like chicken that night (wait a minute, wasn't that a jingle from a commercial from the 1980s?) so I ended up getting a Cheddar Char burger off the menu. The burger itself tasted pretty standard, nothing spectacular. However, the waffle fried were de-lish. Maybe I should have just had a single order of fries...that would have been an adequate meal. Beware, this place takes cash only; luckily I had exactly $7 in my wallet to pay for my meal. Overall, the place serves pretty good food for a pretty cheap price. You can't ask for anything more. My dinner companions all ordered the wings and loved them. I did take a look at their plates and noticed the small size of them; eventually when I come back to actually try their wings I'd have to make a note to get a double order.
(3)
Ted C.
Small. That's what comes to mind now when I came here on a recent visit. BuJoe's used to be a staple of my adolescence. Splitting a party pan of 'Suicide' where it was so hot it looked like my friends and I had spent the day at the pool. A huge cup 'Gutbuster' size lemonade to wash it down and a tray of celery and ranch-you know for the healthy part of the meal. The wings now are small-just so tiny that it made me want to cry a little over the now former memories of big wings/drummettes that used to be the calling card here along with the 'Suicide' sauce which was so hot but now seems a little tame by comparison-maybe my taste buds are dying off in my old age but I think they are just using a weaker hot sauce. RIP Buffalo Joe, you're not what you used to be. I'll miss you.
(2)
AJ K.
I can't say anything here that hasn't already been said. I just want to lend my enthusiastic support. Been going here 12 years, from high school to having them cater my best friend's baby shower. I love it here.
(5)
Jonathan C.
Just take your $25 that you would spend on wing fest..... come here..... buy a huge tray of wings and enjoy. I personally will only order Suicide. Yup call me crazy, but extra hot sauce with Jalepenos on top and then more hot sauce just makes me happy. But I want something more than wings and celery says the imaginary voice in my belly. So I shut him up with some cheese smothered waffle fries. Well even though its 9am and I'm not hungry... I really want some now.
(5)
Nichole F.
I consider wings one of my very favorite foods so the first time I had wings at Buffalo Joe's, I was a very happy girl! Their wings are among the best that I have ever had. The waffle fries are great too!
(5)
Bobby C.
Best wings I've had hands down. Get a single of spicy wings (or suicide if you want them to double the sauce and drown in jalepenos) and a side of buffalo cheddar chips with a mega RC cola and prepare to get your face messy! The sauce is just absolutely criminal. Second to none. I've heard the burgers and sandwiches are great too but the wings are so good I've never gone astray. Is usually pretty busy and cash only. If you are ordering on Sunday during football season call your order in to avoid the wait. Got a lot of friends and family in Evanston so I'm in town every couple of months. I always try to get to Buff Joe's when I'm in town and you should too!
(5)
Eric V.
Best Wings in the entire world!!!! Single Suicide w/ Cheddar Chip and a mega RC has been my order since 1998. Eric Vawda
(5)
Cathy B.
wings = MUST GET SUICIDE IF YOU CAN HANDLE IT. DELICIOUS SAUCINESS. CHEESE WAFFLE FRIES = BEST THING EVERRRRRRR! Cheese waffles fries is more awesome than the Wings. Haven't tried anything besides the wings and cheese fries, but once you try the cheese fries, you don't need to try anything else. PERIOD. The people behind the counter look scary and intimidating but don't be fooled, they're actually kinda nice....
(4)
justin m.
I really dont get it - almost to the point of loosing sleep. I can easily look past the dismal service, 30 min wait (for wings), crappy napkins & flat soda - I don't expect anything different. However, the wings (aka fried bones w/ skin and hot sauce) were horrible! I've had frog legs... hell frog arms with more meat! But all is not lost. The sauce was simply amazing, all I want is some chicken to accompany it. Hopefully they will see this and the other reviews of skimpy wings and step their game up.
(2)
Tim S.
Here's how I look at wings: it starts with the sauce, but it ends with the meat. Their sauces are pretty legit; I went spicy and bbq in my first go around. Both were great. My biggest complaint was the level of meatiness they have on their wings. I think I saw an earlier review that referenced 'dead baby chicks', and - while a bit too descriptive - you get the point. You eat these wings to transport their sauce. The sauce is good, but it's not to the point where I don't want get full in the process. To their credit, they give you a TON of these tiny wings, so it's not like you get a half dozen or a dozen in an order. You get a ton in the order. This get's them to three stars. Their fries would have gotten them another half star if Yelp would allow it.
(3)
Danielle J.
Yummy wings & great customer service! I get wings here from time to time and had an issue with my last order. Dean was so nice, friendly and helpful and he rectified the problem for me. The sauce is addictive. I always get mild becuz I'm not a lover of all things spicy, but the have a twinge of heat which is fine for me. Will definitely be back soon!
(5)
Susan F.
I love wings, I really do. I'll try any flavor, from sweet to spicy. I'll try them bone-in, boneless, stripped, naked, whatevs, I'm down. An afternoon in Evanston called from some Buff Jo action. I had actually never heard of the place, but I felt that wings were the perfect cure to my hangover, and a cure for just any old regular day anyways. But, I ended up getting a tuna sandwich, while my friends got a big order of wings I could suck off of. I'm actually glad I got the 'wich...I'll tell you why: #1. The service was awful. They didn't even know what a tuna salad sandwich was (and it's been on their menu for what I can assume is for YEARS). I had to repeat myself several times, and even while they were making my sandwich, half of them didn't even know it was on the menu. That being said, it was very fresh and didn't taste fattening at all. Win! #2. Now, for the wings. I have never seen so much wing grease at the bottom of a plate in my entire life. No other wings I've had have been like this, I was kind of shocked. They were good and all...but not the best. They tasted like they had butter in them... Their prices were really fair, but I just could NOT get over that freakin grease. It was a major turn off. I really don't think I'll return here again much to my friend's dismay.
(2)
Pascal M.
Small, tiny, puny, miniscule, wimpy, scrawny, baby lookin' wings. Huge, immense, big, lip smacking good flavor wings. My office raved about this place. After an early appointment, I told them I would pick up some grub for everyone. We had a feast. The wings are delicious and the experience inside the place is cool too. I spent my wait lookin at all the interesting charm on the walls. Which I love doing at places like this. it almost tells a story about the establishment and acts as a reassuring testamonial for what your about to put in your mouth. I hear the burgers are great too.. Looking forward to going back for my office soon. Shoot, maybe tomorrow!
(4)
Amy L.
Why people rave about this place? The chicken wings are legendarily small and they do not take credit cards!!!
(3)
Richard L.
The only thing okay here is the sauce... But I don't like that it's a little sweet. You can also buy it by itself. The restaurant is grimey, the wings are tiny; it's not worth it. Doesn't live up to the hype. The cookies were actually pretty good. Large Oatmeal Chocolate Chip for 0.85$.
(1)
April P.
Yep, they're still here, doing the damn thing, still being a foodie landmark, the quest and one of the greats to have for Superbowl, NBA finals, and just a regular chicken run on a Saturday night. Even though they are smothered with their special sauce, they are still retain their crispy exterior, even after a half hour car ride home. Score! Love their bbq, not too sweet, not too savory. Their hot sauce is just right amount of heat for the rookies who can't take it. Can't comment on their suicide wings, but for the brave, I heard they're pretty outstanding. Open late, parking plenty even on the weekends. Fast service, as well. A half order of wings will run you about $7.
(5)
Jeanie P.
2.5 stars hm maybe it was the hype, but buffalo joe's is just okay. I tried the single order spicy wings and cheddar waffle fries, and it was just alright. Honestly nothing mindblowing. The aroma is amazing, but the actual taste is nothing to write home about. Wings are swimming in grease fyi (like a pool at the bottom of my white styrofoam to go box). I didn't really like the fake taste of the cheddar--- i'm very skeptical this is real cheese? It had like the weirdest texture after it cooled down a little bit. And I LOVE cheese but I had to scrape this stuff off and wished I had ordered regular fries instead. It tasted almost sweet. Definitely would not get that again. I also didn't think the ranch was tangy enough-- too much on the sweet side. And like a lot of the reviews say, the wings are really small... which I didn't think would bother me but it is definitely an aspect that could be improved. So props to them for being a hole in the wall place with tons of loyal customers and able to thrive blocks away from a BWW. But personally, just not very impressed.
(3)
Jaclyn Y.
The wings are small, but the sauce is soooo good. I like how the wings are crispy. The waffle fries are excellent with cheese!!! YUM. Can't wait to come back here.
(5)
Eric G.
Do not eat their food. You will become addicted and then I will have to wait in line behind you. Cash only. Mild is a friendly hot. This place is worth a ride up on the purple line.
(5)
Doug F.
Been going here for 15 years. All you need to know is get the Wings with Suicide sauce. If you like it even hotter ask for Double Suicide sauce. If you like it it mild, the wings won't taste as good without the suicide sauce. The suicide sauce not only adds heat but adds lots of flavor. The wings are so tasty, you eat one and before you know it, you have enough bones in front of you to fill a museum. Its the classic hot sauce , deep fried wings with side of celery and blue cheese. Expect it to be a messy. Grab plenty of napkins. If you have 4 or more (big) people in your party, get the "Pan" (around $40). Serving sizes are good. They give nice portions. Located in the trendy, rich, hip, college town (Northwestern University) of Evanston. Great neighborhood. The inside is a basic chair and tables, nothing fancy. A little greasy feeling because of the open kitchen with exposed fryers. Next door is a church that always attract pan handlers outside. Just be aware. Street parking. Bottom line is the WIngs. They're so good, I just keep coming back for the last 15 years. Enjoy and keep a glass of milk nearby to kill the fire!
(5)
Daphne L.
An Evanston staple. I've been coming here since high-school and it's still one of my favorite places for wings. The wings are spicy, like they should be, not breaded and deep fried, like they shoulnd't be. The waffle fries with cheese..lord have mercy! So good, so very bad for you, you must have them. The people that work there are great: friendly, get down to business and get the food out to the customers. Can't ask for more than that.
(4)
Stacy S.
Wings? Yes please! I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's since high school and this is by far the best wings I've ever had! B Dubs comes close, but it doesn't quite nail it the way Buffalo Joe's does. Now, I can only speak for the (mild or spicy) wings and the waffle fries, because those are the only two things I've had on the menu..with the RC, of course. Seriously, looking for good wings? Buff Joes is it.
(5)
Dan H.
Buffalo Joes is awesome. I have been going here since before I was ever born. My mother told me that when she was pregnant with me this was the place that she craved. I can see why, freshly cooked wings are slathered with a traditional buffalo wing sauce. you can order your wings mild, hot or suicide. When you order them suicide they come covered in pickled jalapeno peppers and buffalo wings sauce. It's awesome, until the next day if you know what i am saying. You must order the Cheddar Chips. They are seasoned waffle fries covered in cheese sauce. I could eat an entire party tray of these with out ever blinking an eye. I love them. You need to eat them there though, they don't travel well. I've also had the pleasure of eating a burger here, the burger was large and tasty. It is cooked in front of you on an actual grill that gives it a nice char. Go to buffalo joes, don't wear white and remember to tip the homeless guy out front.
(5)
Billy M.
Buffalo Joe's is my second favorite wing place in the world behind Bird's Nest. I have frequented this location for many years and they have never dissapointed. I also love their waffle cheese fries. This place has amazing food and a great tradition. If you are in downtown Evanston i highly recommend that yoiu stop and order a few dozen hot wings with cheddar waffle fries.
(5)
Derik P.
My favorite Buffalo wings place hands down. I've been here for the past 4 years. I have to say one thing though, the wings aren't as good as before but it still great. If you like spicy 1. Get suicide 2. Spicy buffalo chip (Waffle fries top with cheddar cheese and Jalapenos) Drools 3. Don't get mild. It sucks in my opinion 4. TIP THE HOMELESS GUY OUTSIDE. 8 OUT OF 10 TIMES I'M THERE I ALWAYS SEE HIM. Every year it's getting worst and worst. Smaller wings and more expensive. Still the best sauce ever for the wings but I'm looking somewhere else for better wings now.
(4)
Ju L.
So, wings: The sauce is delicious and oilier than most other buffalo sauces, but the "suicide" sauce, their most intense, is NOT spicy-- I've had wings with no spiciness designation at all that were hotter than these (case in point: Dixie Kitchen's Jamaican jerk wings). Maybe they only call it "suicide" because they're served under a heap of pickled jalapeno? If that is the case, I feel cheated. And holy heck these wings are small. Even Merle's menu, next to THEIR wings, says outright, "Friends don't let friends eat tiny wings at Buffalo Joe's" or something like that. I also don't love that they give you ranch dressing instead of bleu cheese. The staff is amusingly irreverent, prices are not as low as might be expected ($13 for a double order; wings at Merle's or Dixie Kitchen are significantly cheaper for a comparable amount), and shady characters hover outside and occasionally need to be made to leave by the staff, who return immediately to looking indifferent. This is a convenient and casual place to get something to munch on without dealing with a real restaurant, so I'll probably find myself back here sometime in the future. But I won't be too enthused.
(2)
Sandra Y.
I've been going here for nearly 10 years so it brings back so many memories the second I walk into the place :) I always order double suicide wings with blue cheese dressing, broccoli cheddar soup, cheddar fries, & a bacon cheddar burger. Everything is always soooo good! Speaking of which, I think I need to make a stop here soon.
(5)
Sarah F.
WINGS! yum! Buff Joe's serves wings done right. The chips (waffle fries) are delicious! Be sure to call early if you want to order some for a football weekend and/or the Superbowl. Also fun for an alum to reminisce about the old days at NU. :)
(5)
Scott C.
The wings here are the best in the country. The wings I got were nice size with lots of meat on them too, I stuck with the mild because the flavor is fantastic and theyr spicy enough for me. The "Buffalo Chips" are really good quality waffle cut french fries and the smallest drink is large enough to do the job.
(5)
Jon W.
The last time I was there an employee was vomiting in the patron area while her friends recorded the events on their phones and uploaded through social media. The guy who appears to be the owner or manager (fat guy, mustache) acted as though this were normal. I am never going back.
(1)
EdanEdan T.
Great sauces and fast service. BUT why are the chicken wings the size of my thumb? I felt like i was eating fried skin with a bone in it but without barely any meat. Luckily they give you more than a dozen of these mini wings...but still, i was hungry right afterwards. I dont even know any other chicken wing places that have wings this small...its as if they took baby chicken's for the meat. So weak. Def not going back.
(2)
Colin D.
The first time I had wings, it was at Buffalo Joe's. That set the standard at the time, and nothing since has compared. I think three things set Buffalo Joe's apart: the sauce (the buffalo and barbecue are both top-notch), the texture (tend to be a bit more well done than most, which makes the skin taste great), and the size (as the pictures show, sometimes they can be REALLY tiny. However, I like wings a little on the small side so you get some sauce and skin in each bite). The Clark St location is specifically my favorite - not all of the others offer the (excellent) waffle fries. Get 'em suicide style (buffalo sauce, jalapenos, and cheese), and make sure to bring your Lipitor.
(5)
Sara L.
Me and my bf came here based off of Yelp reviews and both of us left extremely disappointed. First off, the place smelled like a bathroom. I tried to not think about it but honestly, the smell threw any appetite I had out the window. If you REALLY want to try this place, order it for take-out. The wings were REALLY small, I'm talking, microscopic. I feel sorry for the quails that they are taking these wings off from because they're so small and cute...and their lives aren't worth taking for sub-par wings! I gave it two stars because the sauce was good. If they had meatier wings to couple with the sauce, the wings would be a lot better. We also shared cheddar chips (waffle fries) which were also not very good. The cheddar cheese that is used on the fries was gritty and thick. I'm a huge cheese person but found this kind to be really unappetizing and left over half of the fries untouched. If you like the thick and gritty cheese (my bf said it reminded him of the cheese used at Weiner Circle), then by all means, this is your place. Otherwise, I'd stick to the plain waffle fries. Overall, I've been to plenty of other places for wings that are significantly better than this place. I didn't really understand all of these 5 star reviews but looking at the dates for most of these, it seems as if this place has gone down-hill since 2009. Perhaps there was a change in management? Either way, I don't think I will ever come back here. I'd rather go to Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)
Gabriel C.
I have been going here ever since highschool and it is still my all time favorite place for wings. Wings are one of my favorite types of foods so there are times I stop by here multiple times a week. There are some times that the wings are small in size, but I go there so much that it usually balances out lol.
(5)
Jill M.
Well...this is sad for me because I have been a Buffalo Joe's fan for a long time (10 years or more), but I won't be going back after having a bad experience three times in a row now. 1. The employees have been consistently rude and occasionally down-right mean. Maybe they are all underpaid and treated poorly. I don't know. But, whatever it is....who wants to go out and be treated rudely just for ordering food? I don't get it. 2. The restaurant is a greasy, unclean mess. Yes...that is what you might expect at a fast-food place, but it is disgusting now. The floor is so greasy that you might slip and fall in the grease. The bathrooms are so disgusting that I watched multiple people go into the bathrooms only to come out immediately and say they'd have to go somewhere else. Seriously, the restaurant should close down for however long it takes and CLEAN UP. Maybe get new bathrooms and floors. It's surprising they have passed the health inspections. 3. The wings just aren't that good anymore. I feel like a traitor just saying that, but ti's true. They are tiny, expensive and the meat is all dried out. Not good. My waffle fries were fine. So, please, Buffalo Joe's...clean up the restaurant, hire new people that are trained in being pleasant and bring back the wings that were the best in the country!
(1)
Rae D.
Best wings in the city! Although I love me some hot wings, I prefer ordering the mild here as they have a great buttery taste to them. The cheddar chips are so good! Who wouldn't love waffle fries with cheddar cheese spread all over them?
(5)
Keith H.
You cannot afford not to go eat here. Why are you still reading reviews. Get your shoes on and go. Now!
(5)
Aurore L.
Joe was behind the counter. (well - I don't really know. But with his pony tail, his long side burns and his cap, he DID look like a Joe. And not the G.I. kind) He took my order with nonchalance, and I waited, wondering with a bit of disbelief what I was doing there, and if I was indeed in the heart of sleek, posh, suburban Evanston. Or if I had landed in hell's waiting room for hormone-driven high school students. They were EVERYWHERE. And hungry. And scary with their hands and chin dripping with wing sauce. Ok, I am exaggerating a bit. BJ's is not for whimpers. The normal order is 12 wings. What you get is more like 18, so be prepared. They are on the smaller side though. Therefore manageable. Cheese fries, a pop and game on!!! Probably not a destination in itself - it's really sorta shabby looking - but if you are on a wing quest...well....why not?!??
(3)
Richard H.
I've only been here one time -- and boy did this place make a bad impression! It was unclean and smelly. There was a layer of smelly grime on the table and ketchup blobs dried on the wall. The food is not god-awful -- but the odor and scuz are killer. In all fairness, I did not try the wings. Perhaps, I should consider carry out from here sometime, since others really seem to like it. If you want some greasy comfort food, I'd recommend skipping this place and walking a couple blocks to Edzo's.
(1)
Ben A.
1 Single order Buffalo Wings with spicy sauce, and mixed with XXX Sauce. The XXX Sauce is so good it works well when blended with other sauces. It's the strongest they have, and its not on the menu. Try it if you like spicy. Its not too bad.
(4)
Cassie S.
Messy. Greasy. Delicious. Not sure how else to describe these wings. Are they the spiciest wings you can find? No. But they are flavorful which, to me, makes up for that! I'd much rather eat a tasty (but not as spicy) wing over one that's so spicy that you can't taste anything but heat anyday! And I enjoy the pickled jalapeno that comes with the "suicide" wings. They can be hit or miss with the size/meatiness of the wings, but I think that's the case pretty much everywhere. Fries are good too. Especially with the cheese :) Not somewhere I can eat at often, but a wonderful treat!
(4)
Alex N.
Best wings on the planet
(5)
Brandon B.
I went back this weekend. Maybe they had a bad batch before or something, but the quality is back! Still kind of pricey, though.
(4)
Igor U.
still my favorite wings place. Get the cheese fries on the side.
(5)
Crystal L.
BJs is my #1 choice of preference for chicken wings. It beats Hooters, BW3s, and Wing Stop. Their spicy wing sauce is so unique like a mix of hot n cheddar?? I'm not really sure what the ingredients are but it's amazing to say the least. I usually order to suicide which is their spiciest sauce with jalapenos on top! It's great for those who love their wings hot hot hot. To balance the hotness from the wings I also get an order of their buffalo chips (aka french fries) with cheddar. Cheddar is a crucial part because its absolutely amazing here. My boyfriend isn't as into spicy as I am so he usually gets the buffalo chicken sandwich and it's just perfect for him.
(5)
James F.
One of my new found favorite places for wings. Good wings are HARD to come by, but Joe's suits the bill. They're fried fresh and mixed with just the right amount of buttery, fiery sauce. I was in town for a visit for 4 days and ate at Joe's 3 times for lunch! Yes ... it's THAT good.
(5)
Jaz P.
This fast food place has zero ambience but it's well worth the trip because their wings are my favorite - the standard by which I judge all other wings by. When I go to other wing restaurants and I'm supposed to choose from a variety of types, I always ask for the ones that taste most like Buffalo Joe's.
(5)
Jesse C.
Damn fine wings, friendly staff and lots of seating. A little dirty.
(4)
Jerry B.
The wings are very tasty as well as the beautifully seasoned fries. I can't handle the spicy ones though. They never skimp on the sauce & I should give them 3.5 stars, but I bumped it up to 4 because there was a BW3 ad on their yelp site & it's good to support local businesses like them. I wish that they would go into the 20th Century and get a credit card machine & help me get more credit card rewards... Also, the place could use a bit of tidying up & it sometimes smells like dirty diapers in there & I did not see any little ones frolicking... or maybe it could be the Depends.
(4)
J F.
Pretty small wings, but they are crispy. The sauces are not really all that hot, but taste great. Suicide wings really not that hot, jalapenos are kinda of a weird touch. Overall not a bad place to get wings, I would agree probably best in the local area.
(3)
Paul C.
I went here with Anita because she had read that BJs had the best wings in Chicago, and if there's one thing I love it's wings. Boy where we both disappointed. The wings are small and pretty bland. I've been served better chicken wings on airplanes. This place can't even hold a candle to BW3s. It's cheap though, and everyone is friendly. Definitely not worth the trip, but if you're nearby and want a cheap bite, you probably won't be too upset. Just don't expect greatness. Thanks for nothing Anita.
(2)
KING J.
I remember these wings to be damn good! Havent been back since like 1998, I better go back soon and confirm this!
(5)
MooMoo L.
My favorite wings place. Deep fried, buttery, saucy. For some odd reason, wings at this place taste a lot better than its branch at Greenbay Rd.
(5)
Dave Y.
grease grease grease! you can feel the grease on your face when you walk in here. if you have acne, you'll probably breakout just being here. but their buffalo wings are the best i've had anywhere. get the suicide sauce
(5)
C.S. C.
this has been a 5 star for me from high school to even just a couple of years back. here are my 2 reasons why the stars keep on falling off. 1. size of the wings: in the past year or so, the wings have been insultingly tiny. often times, i trek from far away to eat these once beloved wings hoping that i will leave satisfied. however, these days, after my visit, i am left to wonder...where are they buying these tiny wings? are these off the rejected chickens that don't make the cut for tysons or perdue? when i start to think that they are getting these tiny wings from possible deformed/malnutritioned chickens, i get sick. i mean, capt. buff joe, do you really have to get the worst of the worst sized chicken wings when your competitors are still selling good sized wings? 2. price - this is correlated with the size of the wings. i cannot believe capt. buff joe can go to sleep at night knowing that he is robbing people's money by charging so much for these small wings. come on dude. i know wing prices have gone up nationally. so i know that prices will go up. but other places like bw3's, bars, and restaurants are not selling cheap a** wings. at least their prices matches the size. it saddens me to think after spending so much money, time and memories here that bj's is becoming like this. what doesn't help is when people are still paying the money to get such low quality product. i guess that's why capt. buff joe can afford that boxter that sits out in the back. don't get me wrong, the sauce is still the best in chicagoland. also, when the chips are cooked perfectly, they melt like butter. however, the continued lack of quality wings with soaring prices is forcing me not to make the drive to evanston and find other alternatives around here.
(3)
A. R.
As stated by other reviewers, the wings at Buff Joe's are neither large nor overly spicy. However the modest-sized wings don't have too much fat on them, so invariably you still get a good amount of chicken in your order. If you have the capacity to eat spicy foods I would recommend the suicide sauce. Although this sauce won't lead to your imminent demise, it will continue to build heat if you lay off the blue cheese dressing and fries as you bask in the glory of these wings. And if you're like me, you'll eat the jalapenos that come in the sauce to ensure that the meal is as spicy as possible. I also had the cheddar chips based on the strong reviews of other Buff Joe's visitors. The fries were good but I was hoping that they would come in a pool of molten cheese. Unfortunately that wasn't the case, and that was perhaps the greatest let down of this meal.
(4)
Lenna O.
BuJo's!! now that's some, "finger licking good" stuff. Their buffalo wings are so tasty. The sauce just hits every taste bud in your mouth. There is just something distinct about it that differs from other places. And what better way to compliment the wings than with some of their waffle fries? great with some cheddar cheese drizzled over or just some ketchup - yum. I've also had their cream of broccoli soup, which is one of my favorite soups, and it was indeed good. Haven't had in a while because i don't live nearby, but definitely a place to stop at if you are in the downtown area of Evanston and want a quick bite to eat. Or if you are just craving some of their food and wanna make the trip! Sure beats having mcdonald's or something.
(5)
トモ T.
The BEST buffalo wings! I've tried the famous wing places in Buffalo NY, but I still like Buffalo Joe's wings the best. If I visit Evanston for any reason, I will always stop by Buffalo Joe's, even if I am not hungry.
(5)
James C.
My first experience was probably back in the year 2000. I remember their wings to be about twice the size as they are today with a little more of a spicy kick than the sweet plain buttery taste that you get today. Today, a group of my friends decided to hit this place up and try to kill a double party platter. We had 6 really big guys and 5 small girls so we didn't think we'd have a problem but to my surprise, we couldn't do it. After having a bunch, the wings become tasteless and the meat starts to taste like old chicken (I still have a weird taste in my mouth as I'm typing this). Anyway, I don't really want to waste my time writing a review on this place cause after reading some of the good reviews that other people wrote, I'm starting to think that I don't know what good wings taste like... I'd like to end by saying that I will no longer be recommending their wings. The prices almost doubled but their wings are half the size and they taste like the chickens were dead and rotting for a while. Will I be going back for their wings? Probably not in my sober state... but maybe after I smoke a couple blunts and a j on the way there... and then another j in front of the door... and maybe one in the bathroom right before my order comes out... otherwise, I think I'm done with this place forever. Sorry Buffalo Joe's... but you disappoint me and I will not be giving you any more of my hard earned money. And for all of you guys that gave this place a good rating... I don't know what to say to you guys. Either my expectation for buffalo wing's are way too high or you're easily impressed. 4/5 stars? Really? Insane.
(2)
John L.
back when i was in highschool and in college i would have given this place 5 stars no question. but alas... good things don't always last. the size of the wings have gotten much smaller and so has the quality. i would always get a party or a double party pan and split it amongst my friends.... good times. the sauce that they use is still good so if you go... i would recommend you getting individual servings so the wings aren't as soggy. i still love their cheddar chips. still 4 stars because i haven't really found a better wings place than this.
(4)
David L.
Suicide sauce....when I concentrate and remember how good it tastes...after 15 seconds I start to salivate. Those that have had it as often as I do will understand. For the light eaters, single order, for the real players double order with waffle fries and wash it down with an RC Cola... I know, right? RC Cola...awesome... Also, try a party pan for your next weekend party. but careful with the sauce in the car as one speed bump could mean a lingering smell for weeks...
(5)
Chris R.
Overcooked, bland sauce, no blue cheese. My wife and I went here to satisfy a Buffalo craving, but were disappointed. I'm not complaining; we paid $15 and got $15 worth of fast food, but it's not worth a return visit. I'm not from upstate New York, so I don't have the "only Buffalo has real wings" mentality. However, I've eaten a lot of wings in a lot of places. There are a lot of good places in upstate New York and elsewhere for that matter. Buffalo Joe's in Evanston is not one of those places. Flavor and quality are their downfall. The food we had was overcooked. The wings and chicken sandwich we ordered both spent too much time in the deep fryer, making them dry and tough. Judging by the size and shape of the wings and the breaded chicken breast, they were standard-issue frozen foodservice items. That might be ok in a fast food restaurant, but for a place that bills itself as a wing joint, it doesn't cut it. The wing sauce left much to be desired. It didn't pack much flavor in general terms, and had almost no peppery spice even though I ordered "hot". Even accounting for personal differences in palate and how spicy one likes their food, I still don't think their hot sauce has much flavor. The complete lack of a spicy kick is what makes me say this. If there were a little bit of heat I could say that it might just be a matter of perception, but there just wasn't any. In my experience, many Midwesterners don't enjoy truly spicy food, so what they called "hot" sauce at Buffalo Joe's might be perfectly acceptable locally. If you want true hot wing sauce with a tabasco-style or red-hot sauce base, you'll have to look elsewhere. (Full disclosure: I'm a midwesterner myself. I just happen to have spent a lot of time in other places and have noticed that "spicy" on a midwestern menu isn't as spicy as in other regions.) The wings were disappointing for what should've been a simple dish (wings + sauce = good eating, but not here). The sandwich started out with bad ingredients, and was not executed well. A gooey yellow ballpark-nacho-style cheese sauce was so thick on the sandwich that it overwhelmed any other flavor that might have been there. The cheese sauce wasn't necessary to begin with, and it became a case of too much of a bad thing. Finally, they only offer ranch dressing, and no blue cheese. A Buffalo native would have a stroke about this, and I personally think ranch dressing on wings is an abomination. It's not traditional, and its bland flavor does not complement the sauce's spice as well as blue cheese's pungent tang. The preference is personal, but Buffalo Joe's should at least offer the traditional alternative alongside ranch.
(1)
steph n.
I don't care how good they say the wings are in Buffalo, NY. Chicago's Buffalo Wings at Buffalo Joe's is THE king of the BUFFALO WING. I went here during the night of the SUPERBOWL and man was line packed! I couldn't even imagine how many chickens had to lose their wings to serve THAT many people! Then that made me wonder, where the heck did all those chickens go? Anyways, the wings here are served piping hot, nice and crispy, and coated with their TOP SECRET WING SAUCE. I believe it is a mixture of butter, vinegar, hot sauce, and ???? I can't even guess what the other ingredients are because I tried countless times to mimic it at home to no avail. I just wished this place served white rice. Do you know how much better these wings taste when eaten with rice? I even went scouring for asian restaurants around Buff Joes to order some rice, but I started panicking when I couldn't find any in the vicinity. It is the perfect combination...like PB AND J, like ham and cheese, like cake and ice cream.
(5)
Adam P.
I'm an NU student, but I'm from Buffalo, NY, home of the chicken wing. And Goddammit, it's all we've got. Having jockeyed a few deep fryers in my high school days, I like to think I know my wings. Buff Joe's has some of the best I've ever eaten, and BY FAR the best I've encountered in Chicago -- they're directly comparable to Duff's in Buffalo, which some would argue is the best chicken wing joint on Earth. Buff Joe's is the only place I've encountered in Chicago that understands that nothing but crispy frying and simple sauce can make great wings. And the rest of the stuff on their menu is pretty good too. My favorite thing is their grilled chicken sandwich, with hot sauce of course. They have excellent waffle fries and huge usually-solid burgers. I avoid the cheeseburgers -- they use some kind of cheddar spread instead of real cheese. The Char Dog is a hybrid of Ted's on Niagara Falls Boulevard in Kenmore NY with Chicago-style toppings. Yum. This is one of my favorite takeout places in Evanston. I just wish they were open even later on the weekends and that they had delivery. But open 'til 12am 7 nights a week ain't bad.
(5)
Patrick W.
I've been eating here for 13 years (since I could drive my little tushy to Evanston). I participated in a Buffalo Joe's wing eating contest in high school against offensive and defensive lineman from my school (3rd prize!). I wrote an essay about it for an english class final during my sophomore year in college. (Teacher's probable reaction: "Why is this yankee in my English class at Louisiana State University writing a final exam essay about hot wings from a place in Illinois? A+ by the way!") I ran two orange (partly yellow, partly red) lights recently to get here one night before they closed. Needless to say, I have history with Buffalo Joe's. The wings are every bit as good as they were when I first started going here. My last visit was the first in several years, but the order rolled off my tongue like it had only been since lunchtime... "Full order of suicide and a side of buffalo chips"... it was like a song. The chips are actually waffle fries, which really more restaurants should have. Suicide wings are the hottest they offer, it's basically the hot sauce but sliced jalapeno peppers are strewn about on top of your wings. My mouth is officially watering as I write this.
(5)
Michael G.
Three flavors: mild, spicy, suicide. I've tried all three. The suicide are basically the same as the spicy with a few jalapenos thrown in. Honestly, this place is overrated. Like one recent reviewer said, the wing sauce is pretty run-of-the-mill, nothing amazing. If you're in this neighborhood, you're better off going to Great Sea or even Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)
Ryan N.
My friends and I have been going to Buff Joe's for awhile now and there are some that love it ands some that don't. Single order of suicide , Gutbuster RC, and Cheeder Chips is our order. The other stuff on the menu is ok I've tried some other things but nothing beats that wings. The Suicide sauce is not as hot as people say its more of a great flavor than a spicyness which is the reason I love it. Great atmosphere and we usually enjoy giving fake names to the people who take your order.
(5)
Roger W.
Terrific wings. So so so flavorful. That is some magical sauce. The cheddar chips are mouthwatering. Haven't been there in a while...need to go back!
(5)
Alex K.
Buff joe's; cheddar chips + suicide wings beats all A friend of my roomate's lived in Louisiana, and would come to visit about once a year. He arrived around 10PM (after flying himself here in a cessna) and asked, before anything else (except a bathroom break) to go to this place. He claimed to crave it constantly. He would go there a few times in a 2 or 3-day stay. I totally understand. despite the negatives in other reviews (mostly valid on some level), you don't see anyone proposing better alternatives. The sauce and overall taste beat other places pretty handily. People giving bad ratings are usually wistful for days gone by... totally fair, but this is still the place to go for wings.
(5)
Brian S.
I've been coming here for awhile. Their prices have gone up a lot which sucks but I've always loved buff joes. i wouldn't listen to people saying this is a huge disappointment but i will say they are very very hit or miss. Sometimes you will get small wings and sometimes bigger ones and sometimes they were taste like crap or be awesome. The staff can be ok but the ladies who take the orders can be pretty rude especially if you can't understand them because then they just won't take your order. I have started migrating to the Greenbay location because their wings are a lot more consistent then this one. The only other place that really even compares around chicago is wings around the world but otherwise i'd settle for buff joes anytime.
(4)
John S.
I used to frequent BJ's ALL the time from '97 - '03 and their wings were GREAT. After 2003, we moved into the northwest suburbs and never had a chance to come often. Well, the past two times I've been there have been AWFUL! The wings are the smallest I've ever seen and taste like burnt/old oil was used in frying them. They're so terrible I still cringe from my experience yesterday. The worst part is I have been recommending them for years! Never again. Unless something extraordinary happens.
(1)
John G.
"Buff Joe's" has the best wings in Chicago, and maybe the entire world. I have brought friends from Buffalo, NY to try these wings and they all agree they are awesome. The secret is consistency. The same guys who worked here when I was in high school are still proudly manning the deep fryer. Sure, they don't flip the sauce bowl quite as fast as they used to, but they have plenty of that special ingredient that makes magic everytime: love.
(5)
Stephanie C.
i don't even live in chicago anymore, but dammit, i crave buffalo joe's wing's on a regular basis. sadly, i now live in LA, the land of mediocre (at best) wings. sigh... here it is, an ode to buffalo joe's: oh buffalo joe's, with your perfectly friend wings (not soggy, not dry, but crisp on the outside, juicy on inside) and wonderful sauce (not runny, and not too "fake" and thick - juuuust the right consistency). and don't even get me started on the cheddar fries. what is in that cheese sauce??? whatever it is, i'm totally addicted. my only beefs are the following: a) you don't serve blue cheese - what is up with that? thankfully, i can always stop at the ralph's around the corner to pick up a jar and sneak it into your restaurant. yes, i'm that crazy. and b) your "suicide" doesn't deserve the name. loading the wings with canned jalepeno slices does not constitute another level of heat. the actual sauce could stand to have a lot more kick. regardless of these minor flaws, i love you anyway, buffalo joe's, and miss you more than you can imagine!
(5)
Dee W.
Good cheap option for wings - don't try anything else - try the suicide sauce - it's a for sure spicy mouthwatering temptation. If you really want something else - go for the cheese fries - those are pretty good, too. Make sure that you go in a group - have one person stand outside waiting for the food and another person to go scope out a table!
(4)
Gil N.
Awesome wings. So-so service. The place varies from being a dump on some nights to pretty decent on others. But it's a Buffalo Joe's, what do you expect? Good wings, right?
(4)
Jonathan H.
Simply the best wings in the city. Period.
(5)
Irene J.
if you love wings and haven't tried BJ's, what are you waiting for?! i finally had some BJ's for the first time in 10 years, and it was delicious. we ordered suicide, spicy, and BBQ. the suicide sauce was addicting. i love their ranch sauce--get extra! they also have great buffalo waffle chips. cheddar chips and spicy cheddar chips are good, too. i have to say, though, i'm a bit disappointed with the price. back in the day, you could order an entire party platter for $20. it's now, sadly, double the price. BJ wings are a must have. be ready with cash (you know a place is good when they can survive on a cash-only policy), napkins, and water/milk. ;] yum!
(4)
Ramon R.
There was a time when I went to this place daily. Then I started getting repulsed by the sloppy appearance of the restaurant, the filthy containers and the fact that so many people here seem intent on gaining 50 pounds (though they're already at at least 250). Go here if you want to get fat and be afraid of catching something. The food is actually enjoyable, but only as long as you don't think about the likelihood that roaches and mice are running all around it.
(1)
Greg M.
Not much more to say other than the best Buffalo Wings I have ever tasted. Although not the biggest, but they taste incredible. The place itself is kind of scummy, but their wings are top notch. It's all I've been eating from here for years and they have never disappointed.
(5)
tina V.
Single order of spicy wings. Cheddar chips. Gutbuster RC (OK, or a regular one with less ice). My order four+ years ago, my order now. The perfect meal when you're in search of something crispy, fried and delicious. Also good for pre-game, game, post-game, picnics, parties and more.
(4)
Bernard M.
Buffalo Joe's wings are simply the best wings in the world. A couple of my friends explored the globe trying to find a superior recipe. They even went to the home of the original Buffalo wings in Buffalo, NY and could not find an equal. Their sauce is addictive. We use to think that they drugged the sauce in high school and when my group of friends went away from college one of the first things we missed was Buffalo Joe's wings. Definitely get the mild because you get the full taste of their national award winning recipe (not just for wings! all foods!). Also their burgers get local rave reviews in a city that knows burgers... I love how they spread a thick paste of cheddar on the buns! Their buffalo fries, soups, and chicken sandwiches all kick ass. One downside is that since my high school days (15+ years ago) their wings and party pans have gotten smaller.
(5)
joanne y.
yay for buffalo sauce covered fingers!!! oh, and you have to try their cheese waffles (fries). this is the perfect place to go before or after watching a movie at the century 12 movie theater. you can always park at the parking garage for free or cheap (i forgot) and get it validated at the theater. this place has a hole in the wall charm to it with sticky tables and everything!
(5)
Matt B.
I don't know why people have such a passion for this place. I found the wings to be mostly bone & gristle - certainly less meat than BW3s for instance. I'm not sure what advantage this place has over BW3s, and I'm not one to talk up a chain. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here.
(3)
Nhu N.
you have to go here regularly to know that buff joes is amazing some days and eh ok others.. the last 2 times i've had it, it's been on point. HAVE TO get the cheddar chips they are simply divinnnnnnneeeee. Worth going to. not the cleanest place but they bumped it up with a plasma in the back
(3)
Alan R.
Without a doubt the best wings in Chicago. They have mild, spicy and suicide. The suicide wings are only the spicy with jalapenos on them. An orange sauce and then deep fried to perfection, I miss my Joe's! When I lived in Evanston, I probably came here about once per week. If you don't like wings, they also have loaded baked potatoes, awesome chili, cheap but amazing burgers, and dogs and chicken sandwiches. Definitely a better fast food option than the national chains.
(5)
Shimi L.
This place was a dissapointment. We got the suicide spicy which was hardly spicy, even with the jalapenos. The sauce was gummy and congealed. It was quite disgusting and I don't recommend entering this establishment.
(1)
Rayid G.
xxx suicide sauce...mmmmmmm
(4)
Max S.
Oh man how I miss Buff Joe's. Those wings/fries are soooo good. Heart attack inducing but worth it.
(5)
Peggy K.
the wings taste way better than buffalo wild wings,, in my humble thought. Upon reading other reviews mentioning too much sauce, however, I admitted its true the sauce is flooded..but again, given that I always tend to credit those who dare to be different....Me have to say that this place has sold me yummy wings in prices that never worry my wallet. However, I wont recommend eating in after 9 pm since there was wierd smell inside. Cleaning time? maybe
(3)
Pete D.
A sunday night tradition while i was at northwestern. Mild, hot or suicide?? love the bbq as well.....there are times when it gets crowded, but this is definitely the place to go. Great option for parties as well...can't beat a few trays of wings! yum!
(5)
Zach W.
The reason I couldn't go any higher with my rating was because it would be suicide, just like the wings! Suicide wings will be the death of you - guarantee it! My buddy takes me here every time we head north to golf. The first outing he warned us all about the suicide wings, but nobody listened. Let's just say we weren't right for a couple days.
(3)
Michael S.
Simply the best wings I've ever had. I usually get a single order of mild, a side of buffalo chips (crosscut fries), and a large RC Cola. If I'm feeling fiesty i'll get a hot order (my buddies always go suicide, but i like tasting my wings). I'm a hungry guy most of the time, and single order can be a beast to finish. especially with fries. if you go for fries, i recommend asking for a second cup of ranch (ranch and celery come standard with the wings). If you do this right as they put the first ranch and celery on tray, they don't charge you. if you wait and make the checkout guy ask for one, he tacks it on the bill (at least in my experience). runs just over 10 bucks for the best dinner you'll have in long time. some reviews mention the wing size getting smaller. i've been going with my friends about once every few months for 5 years now and it may be slightly smaller every now and then, i just think its the batch, ya know? still so good, and i've actually had days where we got huuuuge wings. i wish i didn't write this review, i kinda wanna go now....
(5)
Melissa M.
Despite being dubious in terms of health and cleanliness, the wings here really are good. Unfortunately that is a testament to the rich spicy sauce rather than the meat, which is a little on the dry lower-quality side. Sides are pretty good, I enjoy their fries. The atmosphere leaves much to be desired...because well, it's a dive, but a dive with good wing sauce.
(2)
Ron S.
as good as it gets when it comes to getting wings in Illinois.
(5)
Jacko J.
Food is ok. Buffalo Wild Wings and Wings Over Evanston are much better. The reason I'm posting is to complain about the ladies behind the counter. It was a slow lunch onTues. Maybe 2 tables and about 6 ladies "working" behind the counter. It took them15 minutes to make my hotdog and fries. I had to endure them cursing and talking about all sorts of crap that customers shouldn't hear while waiting for food. I'm traveling so I need a receipt for work. I get to the car and realize the hens didn't give me one. I go back and the lady looks at me like I'm crazy. No apology, she simply grabs a piece of paper and asks me what I ordered so she can scribble it down. Hey Mr Buffalo Joe if you don't have a computer printing out receipts how do you know these charming ladies aren't pocketing every other sale? And why do you need so many of them when you're so slow? Maybe you should go on Kitchen Nightmares?
(2)
a w.
Their buffalo wings are definitely not the best, but when you add a good amount of suicide sauce, they'll become the best!! Its a nice restraunt, a very cheap eat, and a good place to come with a bunch of friends to enjoy good food in a casual setting!
(3)
Ben S.
Most overated Wing place I have ever visited. At best these wings are better than average, and the size of the wings are incredibly dissapointing. Chicago does not do wings right- been living here for two years and yet to find anywhere that comes close to Buffalo or Pennsylvania inspired Wing places.
(2)
Kat W.
This is a great joint for lunch/takeout wings and other fast food. Their wings are pretty good, but not the best I have had in Chicagoland; Mullen's on Clark has the best ones in my opinion. Having said that, the price is good, the food is good, and they serve pretty fast.
(4)
calvin n.
This place never dissapoints except for the sanitation ( hey its not Buffalo Joes if its clean) I've known this place and gone here for years just wished it was still the old price of 3.75 for a single I believe??? but one time which is still stuck in my head was that the person who took my order was picking his teeth with his finger which was absolutly gross in my opinion I kept a close eye on him to make sure he didnt touch my food. Service is meh... ok not to bad accept one guy gave me attitude for asking for extra sauce... great place though I take most of my new friends here.
(4)
steve c.
Good tiny suicide wings. Best? Not so much. Double order, waffle fries and large drink. (Dont ask but don't get the cheese for the fries) Always gave a different fake name. Comes with celery and for a double order its like $8 now.
(5)
PJ K.
Dingy neighborhood joint; pretty much a rite of passage for anyone who went to NU or ETHS. A full menu of fast-food favorites, but I don't come here often enough (like maybe once a year) to be tempted away from ordering wings, which are made to order and a cut above what's available in most bars. Berghoff beer on tap, too. A fun stop for cheap eats in Evanston.
(4)
James B.
Worth a special visit; as good as advertised.
(5)
Nelson S.
My friend dragged me from the west suburbs all the way up to Evanston to try these so called "Best Wings Ever" (and he is allergic to chicken by the way). One, I was happy that I wasn't driving so take me wherever and two, I'm not sure if they were the "Best Wings Ever" but they were pretty darn tasty. I'm not sure if I have yet found the best wings ever but this does place high on my list. I thought the wings were quite small in size, like I would use it as a toothpick but you did get plenty of them. If I remember correctly, they also serve waffle fries! I love waffle fries, more place should serve waffle fries! If I did live in the area of this restaurant, I would most likely come here more often.
(4)
Jenny M.
What's up with the sinking quality here? In the last month we've eaten there twice and both were ICK. Rotten celery, hairy wings, small wings, inconsistent saucing. We've done our share of damage at this joint over a bunch of years living in Evanston and never been as grossed out by last week's order taker picking at her hair and cleaning her nails while she was taking orders - and opening food containers on the line. Too bad, but they are no longer the only great wings on the block.
(2)
Jesster A.
Agree with the general concensus: not THE best wings - but pretty "d" good and the best in the general area. The Cheddar waffle fries are good too. Bring a roll of "thirsty" paper towels (just kidding, kind of...) Perhaps it's just our germaphobic culture rubbing off on me (I try to avoid most forms of paranoia) - but for some reason here (and other places as well) I enjoy the food more if I DON'T watch them prepare it...
(4)
Josh L.
I've been going to BJ's since I was in high school (about 15 years). The quality of the chicken seems to have gone down a little bit since then, but they still have the best buffalo wings I've ever tried - by far. I'm sure they'll give me a heart attack one day, but I can't stop paying them a visit every once in a while. It's a great place to eat with friends. I like to order my wings spicy with suicide sauce on the side (having the suicide sauce on the chicken sometimes overwhelms the taste a little too much).
(5)
Ted W.
This place is awesome. Has one of the best wings in the chicago area. Always have sports games on. There fries are pretty good to.
(5)
M. C.
Good wings, AMAZING cheddar fries! Dirty but good for a bite or for high school kids.
(4)
Constantine H.
My favorite place to get wings. I prefer it over all the popular wing joints including BW3, Timothy O'Tooles, Gators, etc. We order from here for any party or sporting event and any guest that's never had it before always asks where we get them from. Something about the sauce will keep me coming back for the rest of my life.
(5)
r j.
Is it me or does it seem that the suicide wings lost a heat level or two? Don't get me wrong the wings are still good but not as good as from what I remember. They have gotten a lot smaller over the years and the prices have gone up. The cheddar fries and gut buster R.C do bring back a lot of memories. Still an alright place to go to for wings.
(3)
Christina B.
Perhaps my most favorite place to eat! Why can't they open a Buffalo Joe's in San Francisco? I practically lived here during my high school years, and every time I go back to Chicago I have to get an order of suicide wings to tide me through until the next visit.
(5)
Eli R.
I get buffalo wings everywhere and these are the best I've ever had. It's kind of pricey unless you share (which I do not when it comes to wings). The buffalo chips are like waffled fries and are pretty good. A gutbuster RC should do the trick. Order extra ranch. Sometimes the kitchen smells a little funny, which can be disturbing. The wings really are great, though. The choices are mild, spicy, and suicide, but none are really that spicy. It's more about the great taste than hotness. Can also get crowded around lunchtime.
(4)
Nick B.
Best buffalo wings around. Make sure to try their suicide wings, you won't regret it.
(4)
Jaclyn C.
I don't know if I'd go with "Best buffalo wings ever" but they're good. And there's a wide-range of other options too.
(3)
J H.
I'm giving it 5 stars simply because there is no competition in the area for wings. The sauce is fantastic but its basically liquid butter with hot sauce and vinegar. The hot wings are fantastic as it provides an excellent kick to balance out the buttery sauce. Spicy barbecue is one of my favorite as it is sweet and hot--the best combo. Suicide is hot and it really fills the void after couple drinks. For the best deal, just get a platter or half platter and split it with buddies and don't forget the pitcher of beer to wash it down.
(5)
Mark P.
The perfect meal- double spicy, buffalo chips, and gutbuster RC. Love the spicy, buttery wings and waffle-cut fries. Avoid the Howard one, and stick to the downtown Evanston location.
(5)
Stephanie M.
I was smart and came here with 3 of my guy friends. We got this huge foil pan of wings and a smaller pan of celery and blue cheese. It is so much fun to eat wings slathered with sauce and get messy. Yea, I even dropped some sauce onto my shirt. I looked like a slob.
(3)
Demetrio P.
Went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston last night for the gazillionth time, and it never disappoints! Usually order a single order of suicide wings and waffle fries....hmmmm...just thinking about it is making me crave it again. Prices have risen over the years, but still budget friendly. I can't vouch for the other items on the menu, but why go to a buffalo wings place for anything other than, well, buffalo wings! Overall, good food, okay prices, and okay service.
(4)
eric l.
I don't know whether it was the hype, but the wings were just whatever. Ranch dressing was watered down. Also, their portions are measured in a weird way. They just eyeball the number. Number of freakn double order and the single order of wings were the same. Never get a double order, unless you don't know where to spend all your money and want to get overcharged. Service wasn't bad but neither good. GET CASH before or else get ready to pay an extra 3 bucks for the ATM fee (worst way to spend 3 bucks). I would say it is better than bw3 but not hooters.
(2)
Taylor M.
Best drunken buffalo wings ever. Terrible for you, but that's not the point. They are incredible. Get the sauces mixed. Trust me.
(4)
Jason P.
Ok, so lets start this by saying I am a vegetarian reviewing a chicken wing place. For those of you that did not immediately stop reading, enjoy! Ok, this place has a pretty diverse menu outside of the chicken wings. The best part are the heart attack cheese fries, called chips. They will throw hot sauce on them and cover them with jalepenos as well to make heartburn heaven. They also have these giant cookies that are extremely awesome. The best part of being a vegetarian there is that you can go straight to the register and cut the line. My omnivore friends that actually wait in line say that the wings are fantastic as well. The only downside is that if you get water, I think it is something like 10 cents and they pack so much ice in there that you have to go get more every sip. Also, one recommendation is that you bring someone who smokes with you. It is the best way to interact with the greeters that stand outside (persons sans homes) as generally they will be satisfied with bumming a smoke off of your smoker friend. Trust me, it works everytime.
(4)
Paul d.
So after countless hours at the gym training for a 10 mile race and then finally getting to that wondrous day and reluctantly running it, what would any one in their right mind do? Feed your face with the most unhealthy food you can find, of course!. After a long debate between OCB (Old Country Buffet for you not in the know) and BJs, we ended up making the trek over to Evanston. I'm going to cut straight to the food; let me tell you, after ten grueling miles, you deserve any treat you get. This treat happened to be in the form of a double order of spicy wings, spicy cheddar fries, and a bacon cheddar burger. The wings are smaller than normal (about the same as BW3s size, if not smaller) but the crunchiness of the skin, lean meat and amazing sauce were in perfect unison. The spicy cheddar fries were good as well - waffle fries, cheddar (real cheddar btw, no gloppy manufactured cheese topping here), hot sauce and jalapenos on top. Bacon cheeseburger was standard except for the fact they again they used real cheddar - somewhat greasy but good nonetheless. Only thing I would change about this place are the napkins! How do you expect to eat wings, cheddar fries and a cheddarburger without half of it ending up on your face? Then they insult you with these dinky little napkins like the ones they used to give you in grade school. Next time I'm bringing a bib, a bottle of Purex and a hand towel! Tip: Leave the credit card at home, it's cash only here.
(4)
Giselle S.
I must be hard wired since my first taste in high school. The truly mouthwatering wing that bears your name makes one drool and dream for the delights. This place has been a neighborhood gem for many years. I would have to say that since the beginning weeks of football season there is nothing that can compare to a BJ and a beer! I know why the sexual innuendo (it's not my usual style:) ....b/c it is true, football season or not this place is the best. These wings rock. Single and Double orders or Single Party Tray or Double Party Tray. Suicide sauce on the side use to house whole jalapenos and now are chopped up and still so delicious. On my latest excursion to this place I placed the order over the phone thinking how the occasion called for an order that fits b/t Double order and Single party pan. My subconscious wanted the Single party pan for plenty of leftovers and to make sure no one was left without their fill. The practicality of it all was no need to spend more than what was needed. I ordered over the phone and was told it would be 10-15 minutes. By the time I picked up my order and pay (CASH ONLY) I ordered $50 worth of tantalizing wings. Pleasant surprise on my part. My subconscious won in the end and my longing for Joe's was satiated for the time being. :) Luckily, the gathering was a success, (I can not say the same for the Bears), and no leftovers to take home. Eat in and cafeteria style until you pay for your order and catch the game in the eatery on flat screen. Enjoy!
(5)
afro d.
i must be a gluten for punishment... i tried to go again hoping somethings have changed. but it had gotten worse. the wings were no bigger than a quarter. now the part it got worse is that its super dirty when i got there. a cart with dirty stuff in a bus tub in front of the reg. behind the counter it was filthy. not i went there about 11:30pm.. i learned my lesson. no more.
(1)
Angela H.
The hot I got was not quite hot enough. Should have gone with suicide. Their fluffy baked potato has had me craving baked potatoes with my wings ever since. It's sort of a divey place and mostly full of teenage boys and hard-working men. I was certainly a fish out of water, but acted like I belonged. Waffle fries looked amazing. I'll go back and give it another try. Didn't find anything to be dirty, and enjoyed my food.
(4)
Erin N.
Sans car, I don't get up to Evanston much anymore. But I had the pleasure of going there recently when my gf borrowed the car from her parents for the weekend. Like I mentioned earlier the wings have changed since back in my high school days (10+ years ago). But let me tell you this- I ate my single order of wings faster than I have ever eaten wings in my entire life. They were that good compared to the stuff that bars try to serve you in the city. They are a bit tinier than wings you'd get anywhere else, but I like that rather than the JUMBO wings that throw off the meat to sauce ratio and always seem kind of rubbery. I'm taking Buffalo Joe's down one star for their rude behavior towards my gf who brought a Papa John's pizza in. I was a paying customer (single order, RC, and spicy cheddar chips*) and she came to sit with me. On top of that, she also purchased a drink from them! She wasn't taking up space that could have been used by another patron- and it's not like her eating of her pizza would have caused BJ's to lose customers. They were just plain turdley to her. *not as good as I recall, but this might be due to the fact that by the time I got around to eating them my stomach was expanding from the rapid wing consumption.
(4)
Paula B.
I had their special burger today for lunch and it was great! I've been there numerous times before and love their wings, their beef sandwiches, and their stuffed potatoes! Yummmm Their cookies are the best too! I think it's got good reasonable food. It's cash only though. There is an ATM there in the restaurant though if you need it.
(4)
Rob S.
This is probably the one spot I miss most since moving from the city out to the 'burbs. Buffalo Joe's defines buffalo chicken wings in my book. They are the benchmark, and few, if any can compare. Double order of Spicy, the waffled fries, and a Gut Lemonade are my standing order. I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's for over a decade, and there is na reason for this.
(5)
Orack B.
When we started going to Buffalo Joe's back in the day we were so high on a number of different possible intoxicants that one would think we would not fully enjoy the experience. I am here to refute any such claims. We fucking loved it! Now 15 years later I still love it like I did back in my youth. The sauce is really what does it for me. I like the succulence of the sweetness followed by the bite of the heat. I always order suicide - although the heat varies from time to time and also depends on how many jalapenos you eat - I yearn for something hotter. This brings me to a Buffalo Joe's story circa '99 when I was offered habanero pepper wings. Now circa '99 me and my buddy were so high, and lovers of spice, that we said yes. What ensued was absolute hilarity. Each bite of wing rendered us delirious for ten minutes. We were in our own worlds, laughing uncontrollably between each bite. I believe capsaicin increases the effects of Jah Ganja at least tenfold. It was pure bliss! Now back to the food. Single suicide, sometimes a double if I feel extra large, cheddar chips and a gut RC. This is my definition of a fleeting paradise, consumed with such gusto it is almost a travesty. Big shouts to my man Dean behind the counter.
(4)
Peter R.
I had to run some errands in Evanston, and you know what that means!!! BUFFALO JOE'S all up in, and around my face!!! I stopped by the Chase ATM because this place only takes cash money. I strolled in with a Cheshire Cat grin on my face and ordered the single order spicy, and a smokehouse burger. I know, I know, I'm such a hippo, but I didn't eat lunch I swear!!! I validated my artery clogging meal by ordering a gut buster size Diet Rite, just to even things out. I plopped into one of the booths in the back, watched some ESPN on the big flat screen and waited for them to call my name. "Diego!" "Diego, single order with smokehouse burger!" If you know me, or if you look on the upper left of this review, you notice my name is not Diego. I always give them a fake name, just to keep things lively. I went back to my seat and got down to bizzzzness. Ah, the spicy delectable joy of these tender chicken morsels. The buffalo wings have that, "make your nose runny" heat on them...delicious. My smokehouse burger was very good, with the grilled onions, bacon, bbq sauce, and cheese, all coming together in splendid bliss. If you are ever in Evanston, and you love buffalo wings, you HAVE TO stop by. Buffalo Joe's is spicy chicken nirvana.
(5)
Kristin M.
I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but in my opionion the wings are too greasy and have way too much sauce on them. The sauce had a little too much sweetness to it and there were jalopenos in it, which is just not right... And I thought we had asked for blue cheese dressing, but it tasted like ranch-that's just not the way it should be! The cheesy fries, however, oh my! I was in heaven! I'd go back for that!
(3)
Martha M.
Buff Joes is AWESOME. Let me give you a few pointers. 1. Call your order in ahead of time, otherwise you will most likely wait awhile. 2. They only take cash! There is an ATM but it charges you an obscene amount of money. 3. If you are gong with a few people and you all want the same sauce, get the double orders, instead of single orders. You'll save a few bucks. Maybe you could give the money you save to the bum who is always standing outside. 4. Have patience! Buff Jo's is always full of rude and obnoxious high schoolers and even ruder and more obnoxious Northwestern students. A word on the cheese fries. They are so so good! They have regular cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce and then they have the uber-amazing Spicy Cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce, buffalo sauce and jalapenos. delicious!!!
(4)
Kristen B.
Went here for the first time today and really enjoyed it! After running into a former Evanstonian yesterday who was appalled by the fact I still hadn't been here, we decided we should go. I was a little leery about it after reading some of the reviews thinking my friend was just guiding me to a place that was great during her high school days but had passed its glory days. I'm glad that I went against my better judgment. The wings were great, I can't say that they were the best I've ever had but definitely up there. Hubby and I shared a double order of spicy wings, cheddar chips (waffle fries smothered in cheese) and a side of spicy sauce for cheese fry dipping pleasure (this is also a great way to enjoy Buffalo Chips with Cheese at BWW.) The cheese was a little oddly sweet, but other than the meal was tasty. Nice meaty wings with a lot of sauce. We got 20 in our $10 double order. I will take away one star because things seemed to take a really long time. While not entirely their fault (U of Wisconsin's Lacrosse Team dropped in for lunch and another large group was there also) it did seem to frazzle them quite a bit and at one point a tub of raw chicken wings were dropped onto the floor. I will definitely go back for the wings and to try a "char dog."
(4)
Mike D.
I was quite excited to try out buffalo joes after many recommendations and drooling over it on yelp. I ordered the Spicy and BBQ thinking I'd try half and half. I was asked if I wanted a mix. Thinking that would get me my half and half situation, I agreed. What I got was delicious flavor heaven. The spicy and the sweet of the BBQ and hot sauce was an amazing combination. My only complaint is that their wings are definitely on the small side. However, the taste was great and it was a no frills process to get in, out and eating my wings.
(5)
Doctor L.
As a Northwestern U. alum, absolutely nothing in this world makes me more nostalgic to head back to Evanston than Buff Joe's. As college students this is where we'd go whenever we got paid, whenever the dorm cafeteries were closed on Sunday nights, and/or whenever we got drunk and/or stoned. Or any combination of the above. Junk food connoisseurs know that grease is supposed to have its own FLAVOR, not just texture, and not just compliment other flavors. Perhaps no other restaurant in the world appreciates this more than Buffaloe Joe's. The wings are awesome, especially if you're having a party and buy them by the tray. I fondly recall multiple occassions when I saw fraternity pledges being sent there from as far away as Michigan and Missouri by their homesick Chicagoan brothers to pick up as many trays as could fit in their car. As other Yelpers have astutely pointed out, the genius behind Buff Joe's is that they appreciate spice while at the same time understanding that spice by itself is not a flavor. These wings have zest as well as heat. There's a huge difference between the two. The rich buttery flavor of the wings is only matched by the impeccable waffle-cut cheese fries. Again Buff Joe's has mastered capturing the rich greasy flavor of both the fry AND the processed cheese sauce to make this delicious side order a worthy meal in itself. As you'd expect, your ass WILL be on fire after dining here. Do not go to Buff Joe's on a date, before a date, or before any event where you will not have the opportunity to run to the bathroom every 5 minutes (ie: mid-term, final, movie, concert, orgy, etc.)
(5)
Michael M.
Even though this place can really cause havoc on your stomach with the spices it still is by far my favorite wing place in Evanston. My sales guys and I frequently will order this place for lunch, (Mild for Lunch) Don't want to kill the staff...LOL!!! Always get extra Ranch and there is never enough, and it is so good. Also try their baked potatoes they are surprisingly perfectly cooked ever time. All in all A+ in my book. - Greasy Spoon FYI, so don't expect anything fancy!
(5)
Alex Z.
I wish they served more different sauces, like that one big chain place to the southwest does. They are very good at what they do serve, though. I get spicy every time (or whatever the one in the middle is called). Single order is enough, and it comes with free celery (which is actually fresh!) and ranch dip. The texture of the chicken and the taste of the sauce are amazing. Hot dogs are meh, I heard the burgers were great but I've never gotten one. Beverage choices could be improved (RC is still in business!?!?), and not taking cards is a bit of an annoyance. Sometimes the people who take your order are condescending and mean, other times they are great. I like that poster in the waiting area that says "No bird soars too high if he soars with his own wings".
(4)
Kelsey M.
Let me tell you folks who didn't grow up in Evanston something, back in middle and high school, you could NOT have a classroom party without Buffalo Joe's. It just wasn't a party without. It's an Evanston institution, and rightly so. I am not normally a wings person, but these are DELICIOUS! So good. You are not a true Evanstonian if you haven't eaten here.
(4)
Joe R.
This place hits the spot. come with a couple of friends and an appetite. the wings arent the biggest but the sauce really opens up the meat. they are well fried and are the ideal comfort food for a day of drinking or just to unwind after a long day. the suicide wings are the best and have a decent kick to them especially with the jalapeno's. service is good and nothing goes better with wings than dark beer. I look forward to hitting this place up when I can.
(4)
Nate C.
Its been years since I've been first introduced to this place and I have yet been disappointed. yum Yum! I love eating there while the food is nice and fresh. Then when I'm done with my spicy wings, I can always get an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie. The waffle cheese fries are yummy, the celery stix are yummy. Everything is just yummy. I guess you can say its one of my favorite wing joint.
(4)
Ed E.
Buffalo Joe's used to be amazing. They fell off a lil but still have pretty good wings. Sometimes I'll go there and their wings are tiny and sometimes they're the way they used to be. I wish they were a little more consistent with their wings but still some of the better ones in the chicago-land area
(4)
Candyce P.
I'm a huge wings fan. I've had them at most sports bars, of course at BW3 and my Dad grills some spectacular Portuguese wings. That being said, I'm picky about the way the wings are fried (or grilled) and the combination of spices used. Jason C. made plans for us to meet at Buffalo Joe's for lunch, with promises of the best wings. I was a bit skeptical, but excited to try them out. It's quite a casual setting: order at the counter, pick up you order when it's done. I got the single order of spicy wings, with cheddar fries and a Sprite. I also only order the "flat" pieces of the wing if I can, and they gladly obliged. (Some places give me the stank eye for requesting only flats). The wings are perfectly crispy, and the "single order" is huge! (I'd say about 12 wings? and for $6.something it's a steal!) The "spicy" sauce was just what I wanted as well - a deep flavor with a nice kick. The cheddar fries were good as well, but you have to eat them while it's still hot, or else the cheddar solidifies on your waffle fries. Which isn't such a bad thing either. :) Overall, HUGE fan. I'll definitely make the trip out to Evanston for these wings again and again. Note: They accept CASH ONLY, but there is an ATM in-house for those of us who never carry cash around.
(5)
Conrad Q.
I've been coming here since my early college years. I have never been disappointed by the wings. I always get suicide wings, cheddar chips and a gut buster RC. Celery has always been crisp when you dine in but never when you order for take out. They don't keep it separate with the wings. I noticed the wings might be getting smaller, but that could just be the economy.
(4)
Heather B.
If you want wings with taste as well as spice, this is the place for you! I like hot stuff, but I like it to taste like something other than just burning my tongue off!! I love this place despite the fact that it is in college kid central in Evanston. The staff rocks, and obviously love their jobs, because most of them have been there the entire 5 or longer years I have been going there. They even recognize us when we walk through the door!! Their sauce is to die for.... the mild is perfect spice with a bit of kick, spicy is hot and tasty, and suicide is.... well, topped with jalepenos, and makes my sinuses instantly clear. I can't do the suicide for long! For $35 you can buy a gallon of your favorite sauce and use at your discretion. I'm also a big fan of the broccoli cheese soup and buffalo tenders. The soup has the perfect amount of broccoli to cheese ratio, but can be a little greasy sometimes. The tenders are a great way to soak up that wonderful sauce and save some calories! (yeah, not really, but they are better than the wings in that respect) Everyone needs to try Buffalo Joe's if you like wings. You won't regret it!
(5)
Annie S.
LOVE BJ's!!!! I used to come here in high school and their wings, burgers and waffle fries are THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Melt in your mouth good. Dang, this place is so great. I love the suicide wings (very hot) and you have to order the fries (w/ cheese if you like that). The service is pretty fast and there's regular seating in the back. The place is a decent size and almost always I can find a table. Seriously, you have to try this place and get the wings!!!
(5)
James B.
Single order (or double if you a big boy) of spicy wings with some cheddar chips and a grape drink or rc and you will be good. best place for wings on this planet.
(5)
Justin G.
Best buffalo wings in the Chicagoland area (as it's in Evanston...) hands down. The atmosphere is super casual, with employees yelling out names as orders are completed. The wings are not as large as they were 10 years ago, when I started eating there, but they're an okay size. The sauce is what makes it great. Try the spicy, the mild is really very, very mild. The suicide is not as hot as most people seem to think, but the jalepenos on top seem to scare most people away. Good anytime, really. Even thinking about it makes me want to stop over there right now... Addendum: They only take cash. An annoyance, but it certainly doesn't ruin the experience.
(5)
Hilda E.
Love this place, been going for years. Although the wings are small at times...they are big other times. I don't really care about the size because the sauce is amazing....LITERALLY the best I ever had. Buffalo chips aka waffle fries are awesome...always freshly made. RC washes it all down fantastically. Missing 1 star because it is really dirty in that place. It wouldn't hurt to grab a rag and scrub it all down. Seriously. The decor is not bothersome but the dirt is a bit.
(4)
Joyce L.
You can feel your arteries clogging with each bite of a hot wing, but your taste buds will be in euphoria. This is by far, the best buffalo wing place I've ever eaten at, and I have eaten at many a wing place since I grew teeth. We LOVE this place and make it a point to stop by every time we're in Chicago. Why does Chicago have all the yummy food??? THEY ONLY TAKE CASH.
(5)
Madeline H.
Oh my god, junk food does not get any better than Buffalo Joes. I found Buff Joe's through a coworker who recommended I cure my hangover by walking over to this low-key Clark St. location for one of their oh so devilishly greasy burgers. My hangover was instantly cured. Upon returning to work my coworker told me "Now that you've tried the worst thing on the menu, you've got to go back and try what they're famous for: their chicken wings." Let me tell you, that burger was definitely delicious, but my coworker was right, you gotta go for the wings, I cannot express to you how good they are. My best friend and I got here at least once a month on Sunday afternoons to get our wings fix and it is always a delightful experience. Somehow the wings are both crispy and moist and the sauce is out of this world. Spicy is definitely the sauce to order and don't worry it isn't that hot (I am terrible at handling spice and I love it). If you're looking for something sweeter try mild, and if you're a big spice person you have the options of hot and suicide. Also make sure to order the buffalo chips and extra ranch and a gutbuster RC to quench your thirst. Hands down this place is my favorite place to eat in Evanston if not the whole north side, in fact I have to limit the number of times I allow myself to eat here because if I don't it would be an everyday event. The decor is nothing special but it totally fits the atmosphere of the joint. In fact, my friends and I have this theory that if a joint that sells burgers, hot dogs, or wings looks kind of dingy and crappy on the inside, then chances are you're gonna get a great meal and at Buff Joe's this is totally true. On any given day you'll find the place full of college students from both Northwestern and Loyola, families, and locals gathering for a good meal and whatever sporting event is on TV.
(5)
Nate L.
Not bad place for wings in my opinion. Their spicy wings with jalapenos on top... it really hit the spot. not too hot but it was perfectly balanced. Not a good place if you have a big group. Not enough tables for group of 10.
(4)
Douchee D.
I have a friend who is a Northwestern alumni, and it was her who brought me up to Evanston to visit Buffalo Joe's for the first time to try the best wings on the planet. They are without a doubt the best wings I have ever tasted. Now, correct me if I'm wrong ( actually don't ), but these wings don't taste like authentic buffalo style wings. There is a kind of mustardy zing to them, and they serve ranch dressing on the side as apposed to blue cheese dressing. These wings are on the wet side, which is messy and not good for first dates, but how are we kidding; if you're bringing your first date here you're a cheap or poor bastard. Actually, that sounded mean. It could be kind of cute, if it was presented the right way. Oh, just go for it! The waffle cut fries and cheese are addicting. I hope to God no one in my neighborhood starts doing their fries this way, or I'll be as big as a house by year's end. There are other interesting thing that I see going on on other people's trays, but I'm just there for the wings and waffle cut cheese fries.
(4)
Kate W.
I'm only commenting on the wings here... I grew up in Upstate NY, near Buffalo, and worked at a pizza place in high school that made buffalo wings. I know how they're made, and I know what makes them authentic... therefore I'm VERY picky when it comes to wings. This place gets 3 stars only because it's the closest I've come to decent wings in Chicago. They are far from good though. They deep fry the wings which is good, too many places don't. Their sauce is just ok though. Real Buffalo sauce is the easiest thing ever to make, it's just Frank's Red Hot and butter (adjust butter amounts for mild, medium or hot). The sauce here is obviously not authentic and has too much vinegar. They also need to make the wings bigger, the ones we got were pretty small. Lastly, what's with the ranch dipping sauce?! You have to serve blue cheese sauce with hot wings... it's the law.
(3)
B T.
Grat place. Only takes cash. Super busy. Love the cheese fries and suicide wings
(4)
Justin S.
So after a less than thrilling meal at Dixie kitchen I was still full. So off to this wing location that was being spoken of quite highly. I am hoping that what I was served was just off and not the normal fare they serve their customers. The buffalo sauce was lousy, too much vinegar, who knows but it seemed completely off that I couldn't even finish one wing. This place seems to be reserved in the college days, I'm drunk and hungry area. Lets face it after copious amounts of alcohol one will hardly notice nor care the off sauce in these wings.
(1)
Juan A.
the greatest of all time!! best wings, best cheddar chips, best ranch!! This place is so good youll forget the rest. many people might find there reason to complain because wings are small but you get enough to fill you up. Its all about flavor and texture and BJ's does it better than most. Whether you are a wing fan or a flavor fan buff joes is the way to go!
(5)
Charles W.
Wings were solid. Nothing great, nothing bad. However, they had lots of good 50 cent vending machines so I got my money's worth out of my pocket change! I ended up walking out of Buffalo Joe's with a glow-in-the-dark crucifix and a handful of sprees!
(3)
Sonesh S.
Suicide wings quite possibly are the best in the city. honestly, they are that good. I've been eating here for over 10 years now, and while their wings have gotten a bit smaller, the sauce is just as good, and the service still amazes me. The ambiance sucks. Take your food to go...its a terrible place to dine. If you do stay, get a beer. Oh, and get a party pan of celery and ranch...a great way to complement your meal
(5)
Lale S.
My mom worked in Evanston when I was a child, that is when I had my first experience at Buffalo Joes. I have gone there so much with friends and family since my teen years, the manager/owner there knows me by name. Buff Joes has the greatest wings I have ever had, not only does the wing itself rival other places, but the sauce is what puts them over the top!!! I could take a order of wings, cheddar chips and a mega gutbuster of RC anyday of the week! Ive even ordered trays from here for parties ive thrown! I highly recommend this place to anyone!
(5)
Chris T.
Hands down the best chicken wings on the planet.! There is a Mash episode where Peirce gets a hankering for some ribs from some rib joint and has them express mail the Mash 4077 a box of ribs. Well this is the kind of place where I would do that if I was stuck in a war zone halfway across the world. I graduated from Northwestern in 01 and still think about the amazing wings at Buffalo Joe's. I disagree with the comments about too much sauce. The sauce is the best part. Every time I go to Chicago I have to stop up in Evanston for their wings.
(5)
Sangorama s.
I can't imagine any wings being better than BJs. Most other wings taste like the frozen bag of wings you can get at Costco - they're not bad at all, just not all that impressive. We've been going to this place since for over 20 years now and we always get the mild. Don't get me wrong, we love spicy food, but you get the full flavor and enjoyment of the sauce with the mild. You can ask for spicy sauce on the side if you've got to have it. Not exactly sure what kind of freakish, butt burning death wish you have when you order suicide. You know that stuff has to come out of your body at the other end right? If you're not a wings guy then try the buffalo cheddar burger. It's dang good. Same sauce on a fat ole burger with kaukauna cheese spread (is that stuff real cheese?). The soft bun will soak up all the lovely burger juice and deteriorate before you finish so get lots of napkins. Prices are steadily rising and portions steadily getting smaller. There was a time a couple of years ago that the quality of the wings, the chicken itself, was pretty poor and everything was being overcooked and all dried out but they seem to have gotten past that lately. I have to eat here every visit to Chicago.
(5)
Johanna C.
Before having a Buffalo Joe's wing, I had no interest in ordering wings at a restaurant or having them at parties. I've had one here and there and never understood what the big deal was. A friend kept raving about how I would crave BuJoe's wings if I try them. Sadly, he was right! The sauce is really really tasty. You get a fair amount of meat on them. I like them soaked up in the sauce so the meat falls off the bone, which is usually the way you will get them in their busy hours. I went here late on a Friday night once (yay, they close at midnight on Friday and Saturday nights!) and the wings were on the crispier side. Not bad but different. A single order of wings will set you back about $7 and a double order about $11. That includes wings, celery and ranch dressing. The ranch tends to be more on the watery side but does the trick. The Buffalo Chips (waffle fries) are also very good, probably because they are waffle fries. The only other meal I've had here is the hot dogs on special. Don't get that. You may as well just make it at home. Just go to Hot Doug's if you want a hot dog! Bottom line - order the wings! Supposedly the burger is good as well but I can't get myself to order anything but the wings...
(4)
Neil A.
Maybe they would have gotten more stars if they were willing to sell me wings. Basically, whenever I have called, they aren't taking orders for pick-up until time X... Call back, still not taking orders... (and repeat). Maybe I should just eat there, but the place looks disgusting, and I like dirty pizzeria pizza - so maybe the wings are great - but I don't think I'll ever find out.
(1)
A.J. M.
What needs to be said? Wings are wings, and Joes has got em and does them very very well. Hell, they even have some beer on tap here. Oh, and try out the waffle fries some time. They're pretty awesome too.
(4)
Gigi L.
That's right, I'm giving it five stars, people. I only come here once a year. On my birthday, which is in May. In February I start marking the days off with a "x" with my black sharpie pen, as the anticipation builds. I can't come here more than that, because then I might be dead. Maybe not quite dead, but I KNOW my butt wouldn't fit through as many doorways. It is delicious though. Spicy as hell, well really as spicy as you want. Sometimes I like it when my head blows off. You get a really generous portion of tender, perfectly textured chicken pieces that melt in your mouth. And then it catches on fire. But then you dip into that blue cheese sauce. And then all is right with the world. Actually, your mouth is still burning, but you can drink milk to clear that right up. They have these amazing waffle fries that you can get with that Merkt's-type cheddar sauce on top. It isn't really saucey, it's more creamy and thick. On top of those hot golden potatoes, it actually is like a religious experience. I am coming back as a fry in my next life. The place is dingy and dirty, and everything is covered in a fine layer of grease. You come out stinking like a vat of oil where tremendously tasty things have been cooked for your eating pleasure. Good times.
(5)
Chris J.
Wow, totally going down hill. The wings are still great, but everything else is sub par. If this were a new business attempting to open up shop, it wouldn't stand a chance. They've been coasting on their reputation for at least a few years now. You would be well advised to wear blinders so as not to see the dirty conditions and just get to the wings, but you would never be able to place an order. Instead of a "welcome" or "how can I help you?", you get a surely look and silence. This has happened several times now, so it isn't a case of one server having a bad day. They finally repainted the "dining area" and got new tabletops, but its still in need of a fair amount of cleaning.
(1)
Conor M.
I've been going to Buff Joe's since I was in high school and honestly it used to be better. I love the wing sauce and the cheddar chips (caveat with those: eat them first because if you don't the cheese will solidify and it's a bit unappetizing) but the quality of the chicken has decreased significantly. But, hell they're still tasty and where else is there an RC machine?
(4)
Ira U.
What can I say? Greatest wings ever! Great Cheese Fries. I hear they have other food but I don't really see the point.
(5)
Edward H.
Lookout arteries, here they come! Even though it's been about a decade since my first visit to Joe's, I still remember my first suicide wings/gut buster combo - *and queue flashback* Buffalo Joe's quakes as a "HOLY CRAP! I can't feel my toungue!" echoes throughout the place followed by an "AHHHH" after a sip out of the gut buster (you'd think it's the sauce but it's actually the soda - maybe should be more aptly named the gut *builder*). The Evanston Joe's (not to be confused with the one on Howard) serves up the some of the best spicy buffalo wings around Chicago. The wings are complimented by great waffle fries and various char-broiled burgers. If you're feeling hungry, try and split one of their party trays with a friend or 3. They taste just as good reheated out of the oven. Use their suicide sauce with caution. I remember getting an order of waffle fries with suicide sauce and watching the sauce eat through the styrofoam container.
(4)
Paul A.
Anywhere I go, I always try the wings. Although I've had some great wings at a number of places, I always end up ranking Buffalo Joe's as one of the best I have ever had. They seem to have shrunk in size over the years, but I've noticed the same thing at a lot of other places too (in particular Buffalo Wild Wings - their wings look like they came off a sickly hamster). Regardless, a damn fine wing and exceptional sauce. You get ranch instead of blue cheese and I actually prefer that. I live downtown and I make the trek to Evanston for these babies almost once a month. The only con: cash only.
(5)
Hope Z.
I was severely disappointed. Maybe Im a wing snob. Maybe I expect more from my buffalo sauce than spice. I have heard so many rave reviews about this place and my fiance and I walked out thinking "eh" There was no flavor to the sauce. It was an oily mess. the "cheddar" on the "cheddar fries" was lacking in cheese taste. it was like yellowish paste. Its rare I pass up a cheese fry order. It ruined what would have been great waffle fries. The only redeeming quality of this place is the breading. I had the chicken tenders, and the breading was fantastic. But it certainly wasn't worth driving to Evanston over.
(3)
kelly c.
Yes! Don't waste your time on the other Joe's - this is the one that knows! Great wings and other sundries. I should probably warn that this isn't a high class place with quality ingredients - it's pretty low brow, but that's part of the charming novelty. For me, this Buffalo Joe's venue is well worth the hike up north.
(4)
Rob S.
I've been eating here since I first got my drivers license in 2004. Evanston was always the place to head to Friday nights and Buff Joes was the place to hit up for wings. Over the years though, I have found that the faces inside the place haven't changed, but the quality of the wing has. On my last visit, I felt like prices went up, my single order of suicide wings left me half full (in the past I would feel good after 1 single order), and the size of the wings are small compared to other wing establishments. I still like Buffalo Joes and will still eat there every once in a while out of nostalgia, but it would be nice if they invested in some meatier wings.
(3)
Amanda T.
My friends from Evanston and the other surrounding North Shore suburbs have been RAVING about Buffalo Joe's for who knows how long. So, naturally, I was more than excited to see what this place was all about. My anticipation grew once we got there after seeing reviews from nationally acclaimed critics posted all up and down the walls. When I took my first bite into the chicken wing, I wasn't impressed. It wasn't bad, but it was pretty much like buffalo wild wings, maybe it had a little more meat, but that's about it. The cheese on the baked potato I got was horrible!! It looked like it was made from concentrated powdered cheese mixed with water. Like the kind that comes with a box of mac and cheese, only worse. Even my high school served better cheese than that! Two of my other friends (who were also Buffalo Joe's virgins) agreed with me. The food is really cheap and the orders are huge, I'll give them that. But it really didn't do it for me. I tried my best to like Buffalo Joe's, but I couldn't. Sorry...
(2)
Esther Y.
BJ's has been a part of my life since my first visit to Evanston back in the day. Amazing. They are completely no nonsense here. Order your wings, see them toss it in your sauce, order your fries, pick it up, gorge. Of course, eating wings brings out two very distinct competitions to show that you can either eat like a real man (this applies to guys and girls). One competition is who can eat the hottest sauce. Not a good idea. Go for the middle. That way you can still enjoy the wing and you don't have to fill your stomach unnecessarily with your beverage. The second competition is who can eat the most wings. Again, unless there is money riding on it, you can pass. You will end up eating way too much and then hate yourself quietly as you lie in the fetal position.
(5)
Emily C.
Buffalo wings are one of my favorite foods. Quite the opposite of most connoisseurs, I am pretty tolerant to differences in size and flavor. I really haven't met any I didn't like for some reason or another, so naturally, I am inclined to be lenient on wing places. I see the benefits of Hooters, BW3, and likewise, I can speak to the appeal of Buffalo Joe's. You go in and order; the people behind the counter goof with you and give you a hard time in a funny way, which is bascially like spending time with my family and therefore makes me feel at home. They made fun of me for wearing a surf shop shirt in Chicago; haha...point taken. Anyhow, you wait for less than 10 minutes, then you get cardboard containers full of wings with ranch sauce (no bleu cheese, which is their weakest link, if you ask me), and celery. We also ordered the waffle cut cheese fries. The wings? Totally smothered in sauce. Some people on here seem to not like that, but I'm all for it. The hot sauce is a little garlicky and had just enough bite to kick me in the mouth a little without turning me into a Tums commercial. It was pretty darn good to dip celery in after the wings were gone. The ranch? A little thin, but okay. Again, kind of sad there's no bleu cheese but it had a nice flavor at least. The fries? Covered in some kind of bizarro processed cheese that I wanted so badly not to like because it was obviously fake...but failed. The stuff was delicious. It was sort of like EZ Cheez or Velveeta in that it should be gross but it's amazing. I'd go back.
(4)
Jon J.
They're the best wings that I've had in Chicago - meaty, properly saucey, and not too fried. Basically, they're perfect! The counter service can be terribly slow, though. But really, it's a divey, greasy, corner of any god's wing-filled heaven. What do you expect? As a funny anecdote, I saw a guy order a pint of ranch sauce here. That's it. NASTY!
(4)
TJ W.
Buffalo Joe's got some bangin' chicken wings! This used to be my spot in high school...I often made it a weekly ritual, until I found out that my metabolism isn't as great as it used to be. lol They have a few locations, but I prefer the drive to Evanston rather than going on Howard. Their mild and bbq wings are sick!!!!! If you're a chicken fanatic then Buffalo Joe's is the place!
(5)
Dan K.
Stopped in here a while back, because everyone said how authentic their Buffalo wings were. Being a wing snob from Buffalo, I had to check it out. Boy, did they stink. They were small little things, with a sauce that tasted nothing like true Buffalo chicken wings and they served friggin Ranch dressing! I'm sorry, but if you're going to claim to serve authentic Buffalo style chicken wings, you serve Blue Cheese not ranch dressing. Piss-poor in my book.
(1)
Chanita S.
I love this place. I don't care what anyone else thinks, but I've been going here since I was in high school--my Friday tradition. I wouldn't compare it to Popeye's because Popeye's isn't saucy fried chicken and they're not necessarily a wing place nor would I compare it to Hooter's because their breading is different. I love BJ's wings though because of their sauce and crispy wings. Their waffle fries are pretty amazing as well. Make sure to bring a bib because you will get sauce all over you which isn't really a bad thing here. The only downside is that they don't accept cash, but there is an ATM machine inside.
(5)
Annie Y.
I haven't been to Buff Joe's in over 4 years, but I remember their wings being amazing - big, juicy, and cooked to perfection. I've heard since I left Chicago that they've gotten much smaller, so consider the four stars a rating for memories of times past.
(4)
Amber J.
Am Huge Buffalo wings fan, could eat them everyday of the week. (And in college i pretty much did). However when i first drove by Buffalo Joe's with friends i was alittle apprehensive. It seemed a little hole -in-the wall-ish and there was a line out the door. When we actually got in there it was crowded as heck with literally no available seating. 2 of us lurked for a open table while the other person ordered. We finally got a 2 seater table though there were three of us. Then i embarked on of the greatest buffalo wing experiences of my life. The flavor, sigh...We ate wing and wings and more wings and thought we were all full we ate even more wings. I highly recommend - the only drawback is limited seating in the restauraunt. I will definetley be back.
(5)
David P.
I like the suicide wings with the jalepeno peppers but its a bit of false advertising. The wings aren't over the top spicy but have a good flavor. From this place, I actually prefer the BBQ wings. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and tanginess. As someone from Buffalo, these wings rank pretty high in the Chicago-land area.
(4)
Swapna P.
Cheap, greasy wings that hit just the spot when you have a craving. I think you get a lot more wings in a single order to-go than by staying there. The spicy wings are just the right amount of spicy. By far, my favorite wing spot in Evanston. The burgers are decent as well.
(4)
Sasha R.
The waffle fries are amazing but the service ranges from rude as hell to indifferent. If I could send someone in to get my food for me, I'd be happy.
(2)
Stacey A.
Greatest. Buffalo. Chicken. Sandwich. Of. All. Time. It *might* burn your face off, though. If that's your thing, then you're good to go. If not....maybe don't order the hottest sauce they have.
(4)
Eric V.
Buff Joe's has been an ol' favorite ever since my high school days. The spicy wings have great flavor with a nice touch of heat. The cheddar chips are a must, along with a "gutbuster" 7Up to wash it all down. The dining room always has the strange scent of cleaning solution and the bathrooms kinda scare me, but the food is worth it. Don't forget, cash only!!
(4)
Jonathan K.
Suicide wings, w jalapenos if ur down with having flavor in ur food. cheddar chips are 100% cheddar cheese dumped on criss-cut fries. buffalo wings were good too. no frills, just wings and a place to eat them. and a tv.
(5)
David S.
From 2000-2004 I loved this place dearly ... since it was my only outlet for cheap wings while at Northwestern. I went often enough that I didn't have to tell them what I wanted most times (single suicide, fries and extra ranch) which was pretty nice. The wings aren't super meaty but the sauce is tangy (I really don't think any sauce below suicide is all that hot - one time they had a special XXX sauce that killed me before I could finish my wings though). The place itself is pretty grimey though - I felt like taking a shower every time I rolled out of there since every surface seems to have a few years worth of grease on it. Verdict: Great college place to grab cheap and relatively delicious wings, but the one time I've been back since made me a little sick.
(3)
Jacob K.
I used to love this place years ago unfortunately the quality has gone down drastically. The chicken is not so fresh and sometimes even has broken bones. The last time I went there the wings were warm (not hot) and the only way to make the wings hotter was adding pickled jalapenos. The prices are not great either... this place only survives because of the reputation it has and because there isn't much competition for good wings in the area.
(2)
Deez D.
I would give this place negative stars if I could. I had wings taste better from Costco. If you decide to sit way back by the window, you will smell rotten garbage while eating your meal. The only thing good about this place are the waffle fries. I didn't believe all the people who gave this place a bad rating but now I understand and hope that this will help others. People who gave this place a good rating should really get out more.
(1)
Joel F.
There is a deity in the chicken world and his name is Joe. Chickens line up to die at the hand of Joe to be blessedly cooked and eaten at this establishment. I know that I would if I were a chicken. The waffle fries rock, too :)
(5)
Grace L.
As my husband said it best, they are the best wings in Chicago, bar none. Yes, crave them, love them, and fill your arteries with them. Go get em wings.
(5)
Joshua D.
There is one major problem with Buffalo Joe's: Once you eat their wings, you will enter a world where suddenly all wings from anywhere else aren't as good. You will forever say, "these are no Buffalo Joes" Even the best of the best you might say,"Damn these are Great!!! But, they're no Buffalo Joe's.". So, if you simply want the best then do it...but don't say I didn't warn you.
(5)
Amy W.
Not a fan... I don't like their wings and there isn't much else to choose from. The Mexican potato is a decent alternative. Cash only, blah!
(2)
Peter M.
The wings here are culinary crack. Highly addictive, make you feel great at first, terrible for your health, you're willing to drive 30 min+ for them when the alternative might be 5 min away. After Hurricane Katrina they stopped serving wings because the Louisiana-based hot sauce couldn't be delivered. Jalapino soaked suicide wings aren't for everyone but the mild and hot are amazing. Celery and ranch on the side. I often sent a friend to pick up some of their wing sauce then cooked store bought chicken at home, healthier but just as excellent. Once my roomate and I went in and he ordered a "double pan" while I insisted we get a "double order." He was positively confused and sure enough they handed us a $55 double pan which is clearly for a Superbowl party of 8-12 people rather than the 24-wing double order that we should have had. Day 1) That night we probably took down in the aggregate 45 wings. The rest were covered and put into the fridge. Days 2-3) I ate about 12 a day and he might have had about 6. Day 4) We decide to put the last 30 wings or so into the garage (mid-winter Chicago) and, no joke, we would bring out a plate to eat some cold and warmed up. When finished they were just as good 4 days earlier. Day 5-7) Didn't want to live anymore. Considered digging my own grave. Possible long term liver damage. Now I'm in Beverly Hills land of the organic cooked in omega-3 oil "cheesesteak hoagie," and the best wings come from Papa John's. Maybe that's a good thing but I will one day make the pilgrimage back.
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : No Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : No Good For : Lunch, Dinner Parking : Street Bike Parking : Yes Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : Beer & Wine Only Outdoor Seating : No Wi-Fi : No Has TV : Yes Waiter Service : No Drive-Thru : No Caters : Yes
Swapna P.
Cheap, greasy wings that hit just the spot when you have a craving. I think you get a lot more wings in a single order to-go than by staying there. The spicy wings are just the right amount of spicy. By far, my favorite wing spot in Evanston. The burgers are decent as well.
(4)Sasha R.
The waffle fries are amazing but the service ranges from rude as hell to indifferent. If I could send someone in to get my food for me, I'd be happy.
(2)Stacey A.
Greatest. Buffalo. Chicken. Sandwich. Of. All. Time. It *might* burn your face off, though. If that's your thing, then you're good to go. If not....maybe don't order the hottest sauce they have.
(4)Eric V.
Buff Joe's has been an ol' favorite ever since my high school days. The spicy wings have great flavor with a nice touch of heat. The cheddar chips are a must, along with a "gutbuster" 7Up to wash it all down. The dining room always has the strange scent of cleaning solution and the bathrooms kinda scare me, but the food is worth it. Don't forget, cash only!!
(4)Jonathan K.
Suicide wings, w jalapenos if ur down with having flavor in ur food. cheddar chips are 100% cheddar cheese dumped on criss-cut fries. buffalo wings were good too. no frills, just wings and a place to eat them. and a tv.
(5)David S.
From 2000-2004 I loved this place dearly ... since it was my only outlet for cheap wings while at Northwestern. I went often enough that I didn't have to tell them what I wanted most times (single suicide, fries and extra ranch) which was pretty nice. The wings aren't super meaty but the sauce is tangy (I really don't think any sauce below suicide is all that hot - one time they had a special XXX sauce that killed me before I could finish my wings though). The place itself is pretty grimey though - I felt like taking a shower every time I rolled out of there since every surface seems to have a few years worth of grease on it. Verdict: Great college place to grab cheap and relatively delicious wings, but the one time I've been back since made me a little sick.
(3)Jacob K.
I used to love this place years ago unfortunately the quality has gone down drastically. The chicken is not so fresh and sometimes even has broken bones. The last time I went there the wings were warm (not hot) and the only way to make the wings hotter was adding pickled jalapenos. The prices are not great either... this place only survives because of the reputation it has and because there isn't much competition for good wings in the area.
(2)Deez D.
I would give this place negative stars if I could. I had wings taste better from Costco. If you decide to sit way back by the window, you will smell rotten garbage while eating your meal. The only thing good about this place are the waffle fries. I didn't believe all the people who gave this place a bad rating but now I understand and hope that this will help others. People who gave this place a good rating should really get out more.
(1)Joel F.
There is a deity in the chicken world and his name is Joe. Chickens line up to die at the hand of Joe to be blessedly cooked and eaten at this establishment. I know that I would if I were a chicken. The waffle fries rock, too :)
(5)Grace L.
As my husband said it best, they are the best wings in Chicago, bar none. Yes, crave them, love them, and fill your arteries with them. Go get em wings.
(5)Joshua D.
There is one major problem with Buffalo Joe's: Once you eat their wings, you will enter a world where suddenly all wings from anywhere else aren't as good. You will forever say, "these are no Buffalo Joes" Even the best of the best you might say,"Damn these are Great!!! But, they're no Buffalo Joe's.". So, if you simply want the best then do it...but don't say I didn't warn you.
(5)Amy W.
Not a fan... I don't like their wings and there isn't much else to choose from. The Mexican potato is a decent alternative. Cash only, blah!
(2)Peter M.
The wings here are culinary crack. Highly addictive, make you feel great at first, terrible for your health, you're willing to drive 30 min+ for them when the alternative might be 5 min away. After Hurricane Katrina they stopped serving wings because the Louisiana-based hot sauce couldn't be delivered. Jalapino soaked suicide wings aren't for everyone but the mild and hot are amazing. Celery and ranch on the side. I often sent a friend to pick up some of their wing sauce then cooked store bought chicken at home, healthier but just as excellent. Once my roomate and I went in and he ordered a "double pan" while I insisted we get a "double order." He was positively confused and sure enough they handed us a $55 double pan which is clearly for a Superbowl party of 8-12 people rather than the 24-wing double order that we should have had. Day 1) That night we probably took down in the aggregate 45 wings. The rest were covered and put into the fridge. Days 2-3) I ate about 12 a day and he might have had about 6. Day 4) We decide to put the last 30 wings or so into the garage (mid-winter Chicago) and, no joke, we would bring out a plate to eat some cold and warmed up. When finished they were just as good 4 days earlier. Day 5-7) Didn't want to live anymore. Considered digging my own grave. Possible long term liver damage. Now I'm in Beverly Hills land of the organic cooked in omega-3 oil "cheesesteak hoagie," and the best wings come from Papa John's. Maybe that's a good thing but I will one day make the pilgrimage back.
(5)Sarah Beth B.
I dream of Buff Joe's. It's like, the most basic junk food ever, but I still get excited every.single.time. I eat here. I have heard there is a large menu, but I have never bothered with anything other than WINGS and CHEDDAR CHIPS. I guess if I had any criticism it would be they need bigger napkins? That's not a criticism, I guess, it's just a compliment on how saucy the wings are. Prepare to not do anything else for the rest of the night, because you will probably have heartburn and definitely be in a food coma.
(5)Thu D.
When I moved to the city after graduating, my boyfriend and I searched high and low for wings as good as Buff Joe's and could not find a place that even came close. We would always get a double order of spicy wings and it is seriously heaven in a styrofoam container (my mouth is watering now just typing this). Luckily, I've returned to Evanston, so I can have the best wings whenever I want! The spicy wings are the way to go because they're spicy, but not so scorching hot that your tongue goes numb. Also, while I like this location fine, I think the Green Bay location is better because their wings are larger, so you get more bang for your buck. My only complaints are that they only serve ranch (blue cheese all the way!) and it is a cash-only establishment. However, that's nothing my own bottle of blue cheese dressing and an ATM can't fix, so Buff Joe's is okay in my book.
(5)Stefanie B.
I haven't been to the actual restaurant in soo long so when I was in the area I had to come back to relive my high school memories coming here. Who doesn't love them some BJ's?! ;) The staff is so welcoming and fun as soon as you walk in and your order is ready in a matter of minutes. You can never go wrong here if you're in the mood for Buffalo Wings. Also the waffles fries tho...mmmm good eats for good prices. I'd get the double order of wings because the wings sizes are pretty anorexic and remember it's CASH ONLY! I hate the parking around this area tho
(4)Catherine N.
WOW!! The wings here are truly delicious!! I met a few people at a party who told me that they would drive from downtown Chicago to Evanston, just for an order of Buffalo Joe's wings, and now I can see why. These wings are so simple and made to perfection!! They are the right amount of crispiness and the sauce is ON POINT! Plus, the portion size and price is not bad either. One order of wings is around $8 and you get like 10 wings!! DEAL! Tip: Get the normal waffle fries and not the one loaded with stuff - the WILL get soggy because it's drenched in canned nacho cheese sauce and and buffalo wing sauce. ALSO, if you want to place an order for a Super Bowl party... do that like 3 days in advance, this place gets so many orders that you won't get it if you order the night before!! - They are just THAT good.
(4)Raheem L.
A good amount of food for a very good price. No complaints about the food, but the workers had a bit of attitude, they were very rude to some other customers that walked in after me and had a confusing order.
(4)Matt A.
This place has the best wings ever!! I don't know what the captain puts in this sauce but it is AMAZING. I call him the Captain because he has been there for over 20 years running the ship. If you see him you will know. Now the only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because I have been bamboozled with a bad batch of wings but never when the Captain is there. One time my order got lost and the captain immediately gave me a new order free of charge. Granted I waited over 45 minutes but hey he's the captain and he acknowledged his mistake. In his defense, he was really busy. Double order mild("spicey" is extra sauce and hot is with jalapeños) with cheddar chips and a large ice water. Sometimes water is yellow. Watch for that.....I can still smell the sauce in my fingertips. Yum.
(4)Kenny O.
Cheap, filling, and--best of all--tasty. After living in the Chicago area for several years now, this might be my favorite place for buffalo wings (the top contender being Duke of Perth in Chicago). While I was studying at NU, this was one of my most-frequented joints to hit up for late nights in the office. I don't think I've ever dined in, but the food's always been great even after a 20-minute walk home in the cold winter.
(5)Adele n.
Yup. I did it. I ate the suicide wings for the first time in 10 years (go, u northwestern!) and it was as freaking delicious as I remembered. I am from upstate NY, homeland of the wing, and Buffalo Joes is the only Chicago wing that stacks up. Don't waste your time with any others! They could be even hotter, IMO, but these are about the hottest I've had out here. Vinegar-cayenne perfection.
(5)Oliver W.
Pretty good wings, only choice you have is what level of spicyness you want. The restaurant is fairly dirty and greasy, which was a bit off-putting. But if you're ok taking a shower after eating here then you got the right idea.
(3)Gspot H.
My First Real Date 1st month of Sophomore was up in here. The song "Blue Eye's" by The Who came on the radio. Went 2 see "Yamo" at ETHS afterwards on a double date; my X was the other Lady. I got the wings Mild. It was a good fun safe memorable out of site nite.
(5)Kenneth L.
Yeah, I mean, it gets the job done. I had been advised by many Northwestern alum that Buff Joe's was the quintessential wing place - an institution for buffalo wings. To its credit, Buff Joe's is what it is and it doesn't mess around with that. But, little did I know, I was walking into a hole in the wall shack with an infinite amount of chicken wings already cooked and hanging out in the frying basket, awaiting my consumption. Don't get me wrong, fried chicken wings are fried chicken wings and I love fried chicken wings. It was pretty simple and pretty good, but not sure that it warrants the collegiate lore hype machine. Though, if I were still in college rocking a budget, I wouldn't be surprised to find myself here many a time.
(3)Peter H.
Have been coming here for 13 plus years. Perfect overtime.
(5)Mario G.
The wings and chips may have Crack like additives because I always Jones after them. I once saw a roach run across my table and yet has deterred me from eating here. Just start a mild sauce Iv, slap a mega gut no ice in my hand and I'm good. They're ranch sauce makes the pants tight! I want more...MORE!!!!!!!
(5)Miss Kari P.
Every time I order wings they get smaller and smaller. I'm expecting just a pile of bones the next time I go in, which is unfortunate because I absolutely adore their suicide wings. It really doesn't matter, but every single worker inside is absolutely rude for no appropriate reason. Without fail. You're killin' me Buff Joes....
(2)Steve A.
This is a good wings place, but they actually have a lot more, including hamburgers, hot dogs and even vegetarian sandwiches. Everything is cooked to order, so it's hot and fresh, and there is a nice enough dining area both in front and in back. Service is fast and efficient. Cash only.
(4)Andy S.
Finally made it to Buffalo Joe's as lots of people had always said to go there. Décor seemed like a neat hole-in-the-wallish type of place but that had been around for a while. From there it generally seemed to go downhill for me. The pricing structure seems funky to me - they have single orders, which, when I asked how many come in an order the guy said 10-12. 10-12? These are wings, not M&M's. Why is there a range of wings you get in an order? Then, if you get a double order (for which there is a slight price break of lets say $1.50) you can only get one sauce for the entire double order. If you want two different sauces you have to buy single orders of each, even though you get the same number in the end (though who can be sure with this range of wings you could apparently get?). The one thing that was nice was they offered a free sample of chicken gumbo while we waited (which isn't a big deal but a nice small touch). We got the BBQ sauce and mild sauce. BBQ was pretty good but the mild was very underwhelming IMO. There was actually a fairly strong taste of butter with the mild sauce that I didn't find very good. Furthermore, I felt like the wings were pretty small. Would have expected them to be bigger. Not a great first experience with Buff Joe's. Maybe will give it another shot. Maybe.
(2)Sarah T.
Tangy, light sauce tossed on deep fried chicken wings. What's not to love? Waffle fries with heart attack cheese sauce is simple super thick rue cooked into some milk and minimal cheese. Ick.
(5)Brian R.
I've been to Buffalo Joe's a few times now, and I'm just now writing a review. Of all the wing places I've been to, and I've been to a few, Buffalo Joe's is probably the best. I live out west (St. Charles/West Chicago/Geneva area), and I (usually) gladly make the 1 hour trip out to Evanston for Buff' Joe's. If Yelp ratings were all about food taste, I'd consider it a 5-star joint. Be warned! Buff' Joe's is cash only!
(4)Travis L.
How in the name of Buffalo, New York can you call this place a good wing joint?! Honestly some of the worst wings I've had in a long while. I cannot understand how anyone can get past the dried shriveled up pieces of jerky Joe's tries to pass off as wings. I ordered the single which comes with about a dozen wings and after picking through the tough inedible chunks, I ate maybe 4-5 wings worth; wings=fail. Next, I except that I have a high tolerance for heat but the one thing I hate is when a place claims to have some high level of hotness that you can't fathom to handle and then when you take a bite it's nothing more than f'ing Tobasco; suicide sauce=fail. If anyone is paying attention @ Joe's, here are some pointers: Don't use frozen wings, it dries out the meat and ruins the taste, instead serve fewer higher quality wings (never frozen). Second, unless you're actually going to use exceptionally hot sauce don't call them suicide and finally, use fresh jalapeños instead of those crappy canned ones.
(1)Christopher S.
This is by far the best wings I've ever had. I always order the single order of suicide wings and waffle fries. I would definitely recommend this place.
(5)Jen C.
Old school- RC cola, cash only but they have an ATM machine- get the wings suicide style, celery and ranch- fast service~ wish the wings had more meat to them but the sauce is too good to complain. Waffle fries to balance the heat!
(4)Mike A.
I'm not really sure what happened here. I used to come here all the time in high school and it was pretty much the best wings you could find on the planet. It was the first trip I'd make when coming back home from college. Wow have things changed. the wings are probably 3x smaller than they were back in the day and really dry. Prices also seemed to have doubled. 14.59 for a double order, man, the amount of overall meat on the bones wasn't even like a single order a few years ago. It was like the wings came from an unhatched chicken embryo. Someone came in an ran this place into the ground, it used to be a legitimate Chicago food landmark. Incredibly disappointed and feel cheated out of a lot of money, way to ruin their reputation. Should have read the reviews before coming back.
(1)Spencer S.
I wish I can give this place 0 stars. I use to love it until I ordered a chicken tender dinner and they fed me raw chicken. When we went back the next day (we ordered the day before right before closing) the people there said "oh well, it wasn't on our shift, and no money back." So they fed me raw chicken and did nothing to fix it.
(1)Ramena A.
I love my wings, and I thought if love buff joes (especially because of all the great things I heard about them). Unfortunately, I went there and the chicken didn't taste good, the sauce had a weird taste to it (not a normal wing flavor), and the cheesy fries had cold melted cheese on it. They only take cash, which is extremely inconvenient. It was an OK atmosphere, a little awkward to be honest. I just did not enjoy it.
(2)Brandon B.
Best wings around. Wish it wasn't cash only and that they delivered. 5 star food, but 3 star convenience.
(4)Crystal P.
The truth is, they are, what they say they are a wings and burger place in downtown Evanston and a wings and ribs place on Howard street Chicago. I have never been disappointed until this year. The girl on the register "flawless" as always, the ribs were like they took all the good stuff home and were serving the customer scraps. The 2 cooks in the back were so busy talking to each other that they literally didn't cook the food and there were about 4 people waiting and that number quickly built to a dozen since it was a Friday night. The girl asked them a couple times and they gave her a look that said "don't talk to us" Wings were good but no celery or sauce was on the order, they must be taking that home as well. Ive been coming here since they opened each of the resturants, I've recommended hundreds of people. This was a real let down.
(1)Eugene W.
Buffalo Joe's is a great wings place. Their wings are delicious and if you a spicy-lover, this is the place to go. Their waffle fries are extremely tasty, though the cheese on the fries hardens and tastes kind of bad after a while. I would definitely go here over Buffalo Wild Wing's with a group of friends, because the atmosphere is nicer and the wings are just as good.
(4)Mina P.
This visit was definitely 5 star worthy. I will forever be a fan of buffalo joe's but it's really a hit or miss here. Some days the wings are wimpy and dry and other days definitely the best on the planet. I love this place regardless because I've been eating here for almost 20 years. We can't have a gathering at home without a party pan of suicide from BJ's and you can't forget about the cheddar chips! CASH ONLY - there's an ATM inside ;)
(5)Simon K.
People have probably written everything there is to write about this place. The wings are great. The waffle fries are great. Et cetera, et cetera... However, I'm about to drop some knowledge on anybody who is unfazed by how society views them. Bring a tupperware container full of white rice and make sure you have enough people to order the party platter. When you get a platter of suicide wings, a pool of butter, hot sauce and jalapenos ends up gathering at the bottom of the aluminum tray. If you take the rice (which the tupperware hopefully kept fairly warm) and mix it in with the sauce, you will experience Buff Joe's in a way you have never experienced before. For the ones who don't mind doing a little extra work, rip the meat off the last few chicken wings into smaller chunks to create a complete dish. This also works if you take the wings as take-out but nothing beats getting the wings right out of the fryer. So, do you dare take on the challenge? Hopefully I'll be seeing a few more people with tupperware the next time I go. I'll be sure to say hello.
(5)Mike M.
First & LAST time I set foot in dis joint! I know joes due to occasionally a co-worker would bring in a tray of wings...So after a N/W game we decided to go to the joint... bad move...5 out of 6 staffr's are rude!!!!They don't give a s*** about u or your business, the place is filthy... if u gotta "go" take a risk and pee in the alley! The soda sucks! The bonelesss wings taste crappy and look like alien fingers! Don't get me wrong but the wings are good-not great!...Save yourself the horrible experience I went thru and GO to Jake Melnicks!- in downtown Chicago!!! JM undoubted-ly have the BEST WINGS IN Illinois!
(1)Paul B.
We've been going to this hole in the wall wings joint for years and years. Look - the wings are amazing (I'm whimping out in my old age and can't do the hot or suicide wings anymore but the milds and mediums are still spectacular), the fries are good as is the chili but the help is obnoxious. They aren't even nice about telling you that it's cash only. The scene is that of a run down wings joint in a college town so I guess that fits. That being said we still come back.
(3)Simplelife S.
So unprofessional!!! The employees at the register area stood and talked (inappropriately) amongst themselves using profanity while people waited for their orders to cook. At one point a guy came from the other side of the restaurant and participated in the conversation while he and the employee handled a bag with out washing their hands. At this point I watch closely and even asked that my food was not prepared by either of these women. I did finally ask for a manager who listened to my complaint as the two employees stood in ear shot but never looked as if they were even aware that they were doing something wrong. It had been years since I went to this Davis street location I usually use the Howard street one. Much better service. I was so disappointed in what I saw I called three people I knew while I was there and recommended to them NOT to use this place EVER!!!!! * WONT BE GOING BACK*
(1)Marc G.
The more things change... the more they stay the same... mostly. Back in the day I would have had an order of Wings... suicide... a Cheddar Char Burger, Cheddar Char Chips and an RC Gut buster. That was in my NU days... but on a recent visit back to Evanston, we made a late night run to our old, favorite haunt. We went spicy with the Wings this time... and while they were good, they were not as good as we remembered... a little too fried and greasy, perhaps. Hmm... We skipped the Chips (waffle fries) but went for a Burger, too. That was even better than I remembered... So darn good... the juices from the meat soaked the cheese spread bun perfectly... mustard and ketchup... pickles, tomato and lettuce... Simple but stunningly delicious. I can still taste it. Mmmm!
(4)Samuel M.
The only place i know of in the Chicago area that serves classic Buffalo Wings. What I mean by this: -Fried, but not battered -Equal parts drumettes/wings -BONE LEFT IN (as far as I'm concerned, "boneless wings" are both an oxymoron and something that only sociopaths eat) -Buttery yet spicy sauce that invariably leaves the eater messy The one place in which this place breaks from tradition is by serving the wings with ranch dressing rather than bleu cheese, but trust me, you won't miss it. I've only ever ordered one thing here: suicide wings with waffle chips. I see no reason to change this. 90% of the time, this is exceptional and well worth the havoc it inevitably wreaks on my gastrointestinal system. 10% of the time the food is pedestrian, for one reason or another (typically wings are too small, or are swimming in excessive sauce. However, this latter issue tends to arise with suicide more than with other styles because it necessitates the addition of extra sauce). In summation: If you are craving wings, do NOT be tempted by the cleaner exterior and large televisions and take your wing craving to BWW's down the street. It is mediocre. Buff Joe's is the real deal. PS As others have iterated, but which I must needs restate: CASH ONLY!! They have an ATM inside if you're desperate, though.
(4)J K.
For me, a trip back to Evanston isn't complete without a visit to Buffalo Joe's. And they're open until midnight so even if my flight is delayed I'm able to get my junk food chicken fix. This place is CASH ONLY so plan accordingly - there's a Bank of America a block away and I think there's actually a small ATM in the restaurant but I'd assume it charges fees. My friends swear by the wings, but I always get the chicken tenders with mild sauce and extra ranch dressing - they're amazing. The food is so tasty that it's easy to overlook that the wings and tenders are always swimming in grease and the "cheese" on the buffalo chips (fries) is synthetic. Prices are reasonable, there's plenty of seating in the back, and even when the place is busy they seem to be able to cycle through orders quickly. A couple of things that might some day push Buffalo Joe's down into 4-star territory for me... 1) the wings seem to have gotten smaller over time - not a good trend 2) sometimes they don't have tenders - very disappointing since they're my favorite menu item 3) if you get food to go, they put fries in paper bags so you'll have nice, hot chicken but cold fries (I realize it's un-PC of me to enjoy the styrofoam containers they use for chicken, so I usually eat in the restaurant)
(5)Arie W.
It would be an understatement to say I'm a huge fan of BJ's. My family gets a party platter for any type of get together, parties, Christmas, Thanksgiving (yes I said Thanksgiving). My favorite thing to order at BJ's are the suicide wings and cheese fries. I've noticed that in the past few years the wings were getting considerably smaller and smaller, but the last time I went, they were back to the normal size and just as great as ever. The way they make the cheese fries here is totally Chicago style. My other friends from out of town who I've brought here say that the cheese is way too cheddar-y and thick, but if I could eat it on everything, I absolutely would. I've also had the burger, brat, chili, and cookies and everything is delicious. The only bad thing about BJ's, if you don't eat it while it's hot, it loses it's appeal. The facilities are not the most pleasant, but it does the job. The bathroom is probably as clean as it possibly can get. They have TVs for customers to watch while eating. The seating area isn't too appealing, but when I get my wings, I don't care where I'm sitting. It's that good.
(5)Kenneth M.
I have been going to Buffalo Joe's since 1992. I have traveled all over the world, had wings from all over the United States, including in Buffalo, and hands down Buffalo Joe's are the best wings I have ever had. I have had Buffalo Joe's at all my major birthday's, had my parents bring a double party pan 6 hours for my graduation from college. For those who have given a bad rating to Buffalo Joe's, they must have bad taste buds. Even if the service was poor, I would come back again and again for these wings. I see some of the reviews are for non wing related items. Get it straight, this is a WINGS PLACE. Although some of the staff may be rough around the edges, you come for the food. I have never had a bad experience at Buffalo Joe's in my life. When I need a comfort food a double order hot, with Buffalo Chips, and a gut buster R.C hit the spot. Ghetto Joe's on Howard on the hand is sub-par, and people may have been there. A fan since I was 12, and I will go until the day I die.
(5)Melissa D.
So, I know they made the wings a little on the aneroxic side but they're SO GOOD. I love this place, I go here for the cheddar fries and wings ONLY, all the time. I seriously drive 45 minutes just to eat here. I know people's taste buds are different and they have different preferences but I adore this place to pieces. The sauce is delicious, and they do sell a huge jug of it (though it's a little pricey)... It's a hole in the wall place, but I don't know about everybody else, I go for the food, not to stare at teh walls and say, "Uh, the paint is peeling..." Buffalo Joe's, my go to place for wings when I'm really craving them!
(5)Master B.
It is a sad day for me. i grew up eating these wings. i have even had wings from Anchor Bar in Buffalo where they were created, and buff joes sauce was better. but over the last few years i have been fighting an up hill battle defending this place. finally i ordered wings and had to write this. the wings have been getting progressively smaller as time goes by, but tonight i counted and i got a double order of wings and there was no meat what so ever on the wings. the largest wing was an inch and a quarter long and had only skin and tendons attached no meat. i understand the desire to make money and have high yield but how does the owner really expect people to keep coming back for chicken bones slathered in butter? my advice just see if you can buy the sauce in bulk and get your own wings, it has to be cheaper and a better meal... sorry buff joe's you lost a life long customer tonight.
(1)alan q.
I've been hear a few times. I recently visited for the first time in at least 3-4 years. The only thing I've ever gotten are the suicide wings and waffle fries. Waffles fries are pretty standard...not much to judge here. The wings are pretty small. The suicide sauce isn't really that hot. It's hot but manageable. Man, I really remember the wings to be much better. It was ok, but all I was thinking while eating was, "what other places have better wings?" This is the definition of hole in the wall. I usually don't mind hole the wall places, but this time it got to me. The dining room smelled like a wet, dirty rag. The tables were greasy and is a type of place where you don't want to touch anything. I must say that I really don't need to go back to this place for another 3-4 years..or more.
(2)D M.
Finger lickin good yummy-ness. That about sums it up.
(5)Marion J.
This is more than 1 1/2 stars for me. We went for wings, I was cravings with, got take out, staff was not especially nice nor helpful. We got home wings were tiny and very dry. They felt old.. just not the juicy chicken wings I was craving. Not sure what went wrong. Both hubby and i did not like them. We did not finish them. We wont be back. Maybe they have better items or better days. They are cheap for wings.
(2)Jon L.
best buffalo wings ever!!!
(5)Khris L.
This place is a classic buffalo wing spot for anyone in the area. I even know people who would drive over an hour just to get some of the suicide wings from here. I want to start off by saying that their wings have gotten smaller and the prices have increased over the years. It's still worth it as the single order or their wings can fill you up easily. I love this place, but it's hard for me to give it higher than 3 stars because of the feeling you get when you eat in. The staff, for the most part, seem to not care about anything. The place is small and doesn't accomodate big groups. The tables are sticky, and so are the ketchup and mustard bottles...There are always people waiting outside to ask you for change and/or your leftovers. Aside from all those inconveniences, the food here is great and I suggest you try it out. Carry out might be a better idea than eating in.
(3)Javi L.
Only had the wings so far but OH MY GAWWD! They are just super delicious... Price is fair for a single order (12pc) not to mention the unbelievable taste. I believe Buffalo Joes was nominated for best wings or something idk but I'd you are ever in the Evanston area you must stop and grab yourself some wings. Only had the spicy. Next up is the suicide.
(5)Christine G.
I'd like to thank my homie Takala for winning a bet with me, of course I lost! I said I would buy her chicken dinner. This place was so good! Don't get it mixed up with BWWs. I did not get the wangs, she did but I tried it and it was oh so yummy. I had the chicken nachos which was bigger than my face but I ate it all because I was starving. I will be back!
(4)Cecilia T.
Buffalo Joe's is without a doubt THE BEST flavored wings in Chicago. I've lived in the Chicago suburbs and in the city my whole life and have never found anything better than this local hotspot.The tangy vinegary secret sauce on their wings is totally standout and something you literally crave for over and over again. I trek out here just to get these wings and from this specific location. (their Howard Location is just so so.) They offer 3 levels of spiciness to choose from - Mild, Spicy, Suicide. I tend to go with Mild or Spicy because i can't handle a lot of spicy. "Suicide" wings used to be really really spicy (swimming in jalapenos) but from what i heard they are just "really spicy," nowadays as the sauce has changed over the years. The size of their wings is just a 1 star rating - unfortunetely they used to provide huge juicy wings but now they are getting dinkier every year.Whatever, the sauce makes up for it. Atmosphere is 1 star too - a total local hole the wall. Get take-out if you're a germaphobe but just know these wings taste best just out of the fryer. If you do carryout, eat the wings with Chinese rice! I know that sounds weird, but many asians i know eat the wings with rice at home and the tangy sauce pairs SOOO well with rice. Other food to get with your wings? - The Waffle Fries are crispy and very good. Recommend getting the cheese on the side if you don't want them to lather it on. - They used to serve Rolling Rock Beer which tasted SO gross with the wings. But i just went today and they are serving Berghoff Pilsner and Berghoff Dark Beer on tap - pairs very well with the wings and washes away the greasiness on your palate. -If you're not a winglover, i heard the burgers are very good here too. Have a Superbowl Party? Their Party Platters are the way to go! I've even seen them at Baby Showers =). CASH ONLY
(5)Dane K.
TERRIBLE wings. I can't even BELIEVE people--anyone--would recommend them. They're TERRIBLE, disgusting. Some of you people who think they're great must be on some pretty heavy drugs. The sauce tastes like ketchup with a little hot sauce. It's very strange... And there's WAY too much sauce. It's like eating gobbly gook. They're the SMALLEST WINGS on earth!!! Don't take my word for it: I took pictures... One next to a quarter: THE QUARTER IS WIDER THAN THEIR FREAKING WINGS! (and it wasn't just this one wing, they were all that small). I posted them under the business pictures. How can a wing place find such small wings to serve? Are they aborted chickens, or chicks? Are they even chickens? Their spicy wings aren't even hot... then they have "suicide" wings where they're not really any hotter--they just douse them in more sauce--AND ADD GIARDINARE. how disgusting!!! (it might be good drunk food or something, but don't call them buffalo wings) THEY DON'T EVEN HAVE BLUE CHEESE!!! I suppose asking for carrots to go with celery (like you'd get in... Buffalo) would be totally out of the question if they're too cheap to even stock blue cheese! This place shouldn't be allowed to associate itself with wings OR Buffalo, let alone both. The staff wasn't very friendly... I was trying to read the menu and got rushed into ordering. Once we sat down, we overheard a group of people arguing on the other side of the eating area... not just arguing, but standing up shouting in each other faces, ready to punch arguing... the kind of thing where you debated if you should get up and leave, or get ready to dial 911. guess who it was? the staff. The *only* redeeming thing about this place was the waffle fries... they were pretty darn good. They weren't exactly cheap... An order of wings, waffle fries w/ cheese, and two drinks came out to be $17. I want my $17 back. Really. They were that bad. It was one of those meals where you sat and debated if you wanted to finish, or if you would just abort and go elsewhere... we ended up eating more later I'm pretty sure. I've had better wings at Applebee's. If you think the wings here are the best ever, you're really missing out.
(1)Elizabeth T.
Went here a lot during my college days. Went back after 7 years because my fiance and I had Buffalo Joe's cravings. I have to admit: Wings & fries. VERY VERY GOOD. Price: VERY AFFORDABLE. That's about it. The place is SUPER DIRTY! Get take out but don't stay here.
(2)Bruce B.
The best wings ever! I grew up with Buff Joes and nothing will be better than them. Get yourself a double order of suicide, buff chips with extra sauce, and a large RC. After you're done eating, you should probably run around the block to burn off the calories. Or, you will be in food coma because it's that good. Be prepared, they wings are not big. However, each one packs lots of taste. They service is always pretty quick. This location is far better than Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. If you like wings and fries (chips), there's none better in the Chicagoland area.
(5)Sabrina B.
Wings ate delicious. Very greasy though. Wings are not big in size however. A single will be good for one person provides they are hungry.
(4)Brian J.
What a bizarre place. So they call it "Buffalo" Joe's. That's offensive, in my opinion, being a native Buffalonian (I know you love the way that rolls off the tongue). If you're expecting real buffalo wings, this joint sucks. Period. Skimpy, nasty, sweet, weird wings without blue cheese. That's what comes to my mind now when I think of Buffalo Joe's. Upon entering the rude staff rushed me into ordering and looked at me like I was insane when I asked for blue cheese with my wings. This is when I knew we were in trouble, but we had read good reviews of the place so we figured it was worth a try. The order taking employee told me "they good, you should try them" so, with this ringing endorsement, Dane and I ordered a double order and some waffle fries. I think we ordered them mild but I can't remember because I'm still trying to wash the memory from my mind. Somewhere around this point, I saw the most offensive thing of all - giardiniera on top of a pile of the tiniest wings I've ever seen. Luckily, this monstrosity wasn't ours, but the next order to come out was. The first thing I noticed was the color and excessive quantity of sauce. They looked the color of spaghetti sauce and had were drowned in sauce. The waffle fries looked good (and they were, but deep fried toe jam would have tasted good compared to these wings). Upon arriving at our table, we took the plunge and tasted these tiny, tiny wings. They were so small that we actually had to take a break from eating to laugh about it. We compared the largest wing to a quarter and found the quarter to be wider (see photos uploaded by dane k.). The sauce was sweet and ketchupy. It was at this point when we decided we should consider cutting our losses, dumping the wings in the trash can and finding some real wings but the scary dining room entertainment was too interesting to abandon. I can't stress enough how tiny the wings were. Most of the drumettes, at the big end, were narrower than my thumbnail. Seriously. It was like they were actually pigeon wings. Maybe guinea hens. I'm not sure. Around this time a table started getting loud, every other word being an obscenity (*I* was uncomfortable and I have a mouth like a sailor -- and there were several families with children present). Next thing you know someone threw a tray onto the table and yelled "I told you I'd give you your f-ing money" and there was a verbal exchange that actually scared some people out of the restaurant. As it turns out, this was a table of employees on their break. Nice. I'm from Buffalo and admittedly a tough wing critic; however, these are without a doubt, no question about it, the worst attempt at wings I've EVER tasted. That's a pretty tough distinction to achieve because I've had some really nasty wings. These certainly take the cake. Calling this place "Buffalo Joe's" is false advertising. I hereby make a motion to rename it to "Joe's Ketchupy Pigeon Wing Emporioum" or something along those lines.
(1)Ed E.
Buffalo Joe's used to be amazing. They fell off a lil but still have pretty good wings. Sometimes I'll go there and their wings are tiny and sometimes they're the way they used to be. I wish they were a little more consistent with their wings but still some of the better ones in the chicago-land area
(4)Brian M.
Best wings in the area, I'd recommend sticking to hot or mild. Suicide isn't very good, just too much jalapeño not enough good flavor. The cheddar fries are fantastic waffle cut fried slathered in merkts cheese and some seasoning, dipped in their wonderful ranch they go great with some wings. The wing size here seems to vary from order to order but a single order is always plenty for me. Also the buffalo chicken sandwich is delicious here. It's a boneless breast pounded flat and breaded, it tastes like they make it in house, nice clean tasting breading and good fresh chicken breast. Make sure you add cheese on it to enjoy more of the merkts cheese. This is usually a place to grab take out during the lunch hours, the place isn't known for it's decor or seating. I recommend calling ahead when coming here or it can be a longer then average wait for take out places. They should definitely get rid of the cash only rule, I can't tell you how many times I got hit with ATM fees there because I have a real hard time accepting places with any kind of traffic wouldn't want a credit card machine.
(4)Connie L.
Our first stop for dinner in Chicago was at Buffalo Joes. Our cousins who live in Chicago took us here and we were excited to try some good wings. We ordered the spicy wings with cheddar chips. The sauce was on! It had the right amount of kick and was sauceyyyy! The cheddar chips are waffle fries with melted cheese and they were a good compliment to the wings. Add some celery sticks and beer and the meal was spot on!
(4)Ernesto R.
Not that impressed with the wings. They contain a ton of butter and the sauce is pretty standard. Also, the place is pretty dirty and should be kept more clean. I do not recommend this place as it might make you sick.
(2)Jose B.
one day my girlfriend asked me if i liked wings, when i was done ridiculing her for such a ridiculous question (OF COURSE), she told me of this place. We went and for the money you spend you get an irresponsibly large amount of wings, also they have cool waffle fries and the wings themselves have a great taste, my only, and ONLY wish is that the wings were slightly bigger... maybe its better that theyre not or i would be 500lbs!!!!
(4)Frank P.
I've been coming here for at least 10 years and still the best in Chicago land. Never had anything but wings and chips (fries). Nothing else compares especially the bigger wing chains. I like the medium with jalepenos on the side. I like spicy but like to taste the chicken as well. Place isn't too big and not quite as clean as you would like. But definitely a place I crave.
(4)Pin Y.
As a Northwestern Alum, I miss this place so much!! You aren't an NU student if you don't go to Buffalo Joe's late a night. I want a Buffalo Joe's in LA! Please????
(4)Sam W.
Been coming here since high school. Hands down the. Best wings I've ever had. Hidden secret, try the cookies at the counter if you have room after stuffing your face with wings. Oh yeah and the cheese fries!!
(5)Lulu R.
I have been coming to buffalo Joes for a long time now. Sure, their wings have become much smaller. We can't do anything about it. On the bright side, their sauce hasn't changed one bit. The waffle fries are perfectly seasoned and piping hot and fresh. Back to these amazing wings. I am still proud of this place despite their ever shrinking wing size. Every time I have a friend from out of town, I take them here. The sauce makes it worth while. My friend loved the wings so much....i believe he moved here for them! (Maybe) The problem is the staff is on the rude side and they are really stingy on the ranch/ bleu Cheese. They do not take credit cards. The drinks (unless otherwise ordered) come heavily iced. The place is tiny and needs to desperately be remodeled and updated to 2009. The bathrooms are kinda clean. You would think I would give this place 3 stars considering the negatives I have for this place...right? WRONG. I love these wings so much that I will STILL, despite the negatives(which are pretty serious in most peoples books, give this place 4 stars. For 24 or so wings its $10 bucks For 15 its like $7 Try them....make the trip... you won't regret or forget the adventure you and your taste buds go on. word to the wise: Check out the waffle fries (omg, that rhymes hahahaha)
(4)Justine L.
Good cheap food! Mild wings were surprisingly spicy and perfect. The single order had 10 wings! The burger was good as well- particularly enjoyed the bun.
(4)daynia S.
I absolute love their classic version of buffalo wings. The chicken is not battered like Hooter's. The sauce is what makes the wings so yummy. The fresh cut waffle fries are excellent and always piping hot. Wings and fries ate made to order nothing sitting around under hot lamps. Celery sticks are always cold and crisp like they should be. I've been taking a drive out to evanston for at least 10 years since I discovered this spot. It's not healthy so I only go once or twice a year but it's always worth it. Recipe has never changed. The only minor complaint I have is some times that the wings are small in size.
(4)Kat T.
I thought this place was alright. I did not feel like there was anything special about the place nor ws the selection of sauce very unique. Not a bad place.
(3)Al D.
Merk's cheddar on an Italian Beef??? It's provolone unless I ask otherwise. Fail.
(3)Joseph C.
STILL BAD!!! My name is Joe and I am from Buffalo and this place is misnamed. If you serve ranch with your wings you should not be allowed to use Buffalo in your name. Mid-West Joe's fried Chicken is the proper name. yuck
(1)Tanya G.
I have had buffalo joe's since freshmen year of high school (9 years) and no wings have ever been able to top theirs. Personally I think that mild is the best! Its always a treat to go there with a friend and for them to taste exactly what I've been talking about :) Staff is always very friendly, always bustling with customers. ONLY tiny constructive criticism I have is that you have to be prepared to always have cash. They do not take credit/debit for payment and its always been like that. Seems like a very successful restaurant chain, really wish they would upgrade to this. Would make it a lot easier and convenient for customers versus running to an atm nearby...
(4)Meinard C.
Buffalo Joe's is less of a restaurant and more of an establishment, dare I say it? A childhood friend. Sure we've had our rough patches and times when we haven't seen each other in ages. But it's always something you can depend on. I've been going to this place since I was in high school back when boy bands roamed the earth and gas was a dollar. The prices of the wings, like my waistline, have crept up since. Back then I could've taken on a single pan by myself, but nowadays I limit myself to a single order. I usually get 'suicide' (Which is hot with jalapenos. People swear it's a different sauce, but I think that's just the jalapeno pickle juice being mixed in), Waffle cut fries with cheddar sauce (OMGOMNOMNOMNOM) and regular a RC (no Coke or Pepsi here). I can't say I've had any other things on their menu. I know they exist and I keep telling myself "One day I'll have to try one of those." But that's like going to a strip club for their lunch specials; and like strip clubs, they only take cash. This place gets a solid 4 from me, and it gets awarded the mystical +1 of nostalgia; perhaps even a +2 but yelp doesn't let me do 6 stars.
(5)Brian L.
I've been there about three times and truth be told, I'm afraid to go back. Each time the wings have progressively gotten smaller. I looked at my friend's plate and found one that was literally the size of a Jolly Rancher. If they start supplying larger/better quality I will definitely boost up their rating but as it stands now a solid 3. Their sauce is tangy. I love spicy with a bit of sweet. I wish they had a bit more to choose from like a standard New York Buffalo sauce though. I like them vinegary too!
(3)Hoang L.
If you like your wings drowned in sauce, then you'll love Buff Joe's. But I cannot say this is the best wings, so I cannot give you 5-stars. Plus, I find it tough to justify the price of these wings. Don't get me wrong, I love eating here, but I think people hype it up too much. The wings are medium sized. The celery on the side is okay. Gets pretty crowded and kinda of annoying when you can't find a place to sit.
(4)Chris B.
When I travel to Chicago, I always try and stop on by here. My friends in high school used to rant about coming here and filling up on wings. I come and I get the suicide wings and boy are they spicy! Fortunately they come with some ranch and celery to put my fire out! Sure as hell beats KFC and Popeye's for wings! Service could be a little more friendly.
(5)Ben W.
I have been coming to Buff Joe's since 2006, and I must say that the quality of the wings and service is in rapid decline. The wings seem to be getting smaller and smaller(check out photos 11 and 12). Also the price is constantly on the rise. In 2006 the price was 8.99 for a double order, it went to 9.99, and is currently at the outrageous price of 12.99. Sadly Buff Joe's has lost over 75% of my business. GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER!!!!!!!!
(2)Brandon R.
They're not the biggest wings. They're not the meatiest. But, without question, they're my favorite wings. That's Buff Joe's in a nutshell. Personally, I LOVE spicy wings. I want to sweat when I'm eating. I want nasal passages as clear as... something that's really clear. Sure, you've read people rave about the suicide wings here (their spicy sauce with a heaping pile of jalapenos on top). They're not too bad. But I'm hear to tell you about the variety that aren't even on the menu: XXX habanero. To this day, I have not found a better combination of heat and flavor. Much like the suicide variety, the XXX habanero wings come with a mountain of sliced jalapenos. About those jalapenos: they are EASILY the best jalapenos in the world. I don't know how much of that is due to the fact that they're slathered in buffalo sauce, but I could eat these suckers by the spoonful. I look at them in the same light as Superdawg's grilled onions: a simple addition to a meal that takes it to the next level. Two final things that must be mentioned: - The ranch. Insanely good. When it comes to ranch, I definitely lean towards the more 'liquidy' side. Especially for wings. Buff Joe's does not disappoint - just get extras though, because you'll want it. And if you go XXX habanero, you'll need it. - Cheddar chips, all day, every day. It's like the opposite of my ranch preference: I despise drippy, nacho cheese on fries. Buff's uses some actual melted down cheddar. The final product is about as good as it gets in the cheese fries world. And such a delicious world it is. Ignore the haters and make Buff Joe's your #1 priority next time you're in Evanston. Which hopefully won't be for a while because I have no clue what you do in Evanston besides eat at Buff's.
(5)Drew D.
So, I've been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. That would mean that it's been about 15 years since I first tasted the succulent spiciness that is Buff Joe's sauce. I've introduced many people to this place, and never had I had anybody come out of here less than satisfied, which I think speaks to the quality of its food. I insist that everybody try the wings just once, even if they're not "wing people," just so they can have the experience. You'd be surprised how many of them are now "wing people" thanks to the gentle nudging! Every time I'm here, I tell myself I'm going to get something different...but when it comes down to it, I always have to go with my usual: single spicy, cheddar chips, and a mega size drink to wash it all down. Waiting for my food seems endless, and when I finally get to chomp down on my first wing, it's like tasting it for the first time all over again. There is a veritable explosion of spices in my mouth, and after the initial heat, the flavors come through like gangbusters. I tend to dislike wings that are hot for the sake of being hot. I find that they have little to no flavor once the heat passes, and for me, that sort of misses the point. The wings from Buff Joe's are fantastic for following up heat with flavor, and that to me is the hallmark of a good wing. Small wings? Perhaps, but I really don't care, because I've never left feeling any less than stuffed. And satisfied. It's the perfect prelude to sauntering over to the Lakefill and walking off some of the meal. :)
(5)Gary M.
Service is what you would expect from a place like this. The wings are awesome..
(5)Varun M.
So far I've had Buffalo Joe's food on take out twice and both times i was disappointed. I love wings, i'm addicted but bad wings well they are very disturbing. Growing up in Upstate NY (Rochester) I love to try wings wherever I go and Buffalo Joe's, you are heart breaking. At the end of the day the wings have a few key ingredients 1) The Sauce 2) Cooking Times 3) The actual wing quality used Buffalo Joe's fails on ALL THREE. First off the Sauce is not very spicy, it has a very vinegar based taste and doesn't taste like any good (or bad) buffalo sauce i've ever had. They are usually served very dry without much additional sauce. Looking at cooking times, they definitely over fry the all the wings. Good Buffalo Wings are crispy on the outside but pretty soft on the inside...unfortunately on both occasions i feel like i'm eating crispy chicken every time. Last the quality of the wing used, I have a strong feeling they aren't using fresh wings but the frozen ones you find at the super market. The wings they serve, the meat is very often stuck to the bone and you'll find the bone's break very often when you eat them. THIS IS A CLEAR SIGN that the wing is of low quality. I do like the fact that they are small and not like other places where a wing is larger than a drumstick but unfortunately they need a new supplier. They do have some good variety and I know they have made a good living because frankly, Chicago doesn't wings. Plus on a college campus, this is perfect food but with the BWW opened up around the corner I think Buffalo Joe's is going to be in for some tough competition.
(2)Amy L.
Came here recently after going to the Great Lakes Naval Base. Mmmh, I was looking forward to some cheddar Chips and some suicide wings. And man, did I get my grub on. The suicide wings were good but I thought the mild taste pretty good too. Next time, it's milds all the way. It has the flavor without having the burning sensation when I potty. Sorry to be descriptive guys. You know you probably think the same thing when you eat hot stuff! DON"T LIE Note:**The wings seems to be a big bigger than the last time I visited Joe's.(Bigger than a quarter) All in all, a thumbs up to visit again.
(4)Michelle L.
After an extremely disappointing "cheddar fries" experience somewhere else (note to all out there - if you call your dish "cheddar fries" or "cheddar chips" instead of cheese fries, this means that you need to use a real cheddar sauce vs. the generic bright yellow artificial imitation funky-tasting cheese sauce that the others use) I was seriously craving Joe's cheddar chips... ...And I was not disappointed! Not only is the cheddar sauce amazing and real, but the "chips" (fries) seem so fresh, and the skin is still on...they would be good just by themselves (not like I know from personal experience as I only get them with cheddar). As for the wings - they're good, the sauce is great, but I'm not a crazy wing fan. My husband loves them though, he's been eating here for so long and it's great when his wing craving coincides with my cheddar chip craving....
(4)Frank L.
I'm sorry, but this place was just underwhelming. The two friends who took me to Buff' Joes made it seem like the wings were the best ever. I'm not a hater, but it just seemed to me that they took some chicken wings, threw them in a bowl of hot sauce and tossed it around. I kind of expected some of the seasoning cooked into the chicken. I suppose for the hot-wing lovers, this type of place is best, because you can ratchet up the heat if you like. Oh, and my girlfriend made the unfortunate mistake of ordering a baked potato. What they really meant was "microwave potato". Who goes to Joes? Long-time die hards who grew up on the stuff. People who want to choose the spicy to their hot wings Who avoids Joes? Folks who prefer wings with the flavor cooked into the chicken
(2)Daniel A.
Great wings, great and fast service, all around-enjoyable. They don't take credit cards, though.
(4)Dennis P.
The best wings in Illinois. Suicide is the only way! with the jalapenos... with their brand of ranch... my mouth is watering just talking about it...
(5)Miriam B.
I've been going here since I was a little girl. Great wings, burgers, baked potatoes, cheese chips( waffle cut cheese fries) and awesome chardogs!.
(5)Mike P.
This would be a 5-star, but for the complete lake of attention I received from the dude taking my order. It's partially my fault as I didn't have my order ready, this being my first visit. So the wing Nazi tuned me out. Anyway, the wings are superb. We had spicy and they were spicy, but not too spicy. Not the meatiest wings, but they give you a ton of them Celery and ranch came with. The cheddar chips great. That was the best fake cheddar cheese sauce I've ever had. I will relish the opportunity too have it sit in my colon for the next 6 months. Thanks, processed food stuffs! You should definitely check out this beautiful little dump. I can't wait to go back to try some sammiches on the menu, with a side of wings and maybe a processed cheddar cheese fry or too. Also, they have RC. My hillbilly soul rejoices.
(4)Jeff H.
Look. This place is great if you know what you're getting: awesome wings and a lot of them. I love BW3's - my undergrad school had one across the street from our campus; in fact, I think I spent my 21st birthday there, or at least part of it. But BW3's costs a lot more, and whiile there is bigger sauce selection, sometimes you don't want to choose between 20 different flavors - you just want wings and a lot of them. The suicide wings ain't all that hot. They're basically medium-to-hot wings with canned jalapeños atop. I couldn't figure out why they were touted as suicide wings until the next day, where I spent 5 minutes in the bathroom wishing I was dead. But it was worth it. I might go back tomorrow just to show my colon who's boss. Don't come for the ambiance. Don't come for a business lunch. Don't bring your mom unless she can get down with some wings like whoa (and if she can, give her my number).
(4)Simone T.
I'm from NY, and yes - Buffalo Joe's buffalo wings are the best I've ever eaten. Also the best cheese fries, hands down. GREAT owner AND staff. I love this place!
(5)Jocelynne G.
I used to LOVE coming here when I was a kid, when it was packed and hyped. I took my friends here thinking it would still be awesome, but the service was downright bullshit. I was charged for tap water. The workers were on their cell phone when we walked in, and they served a few of THEIR FRIENDS before me when I placed my order much earlier. For the amount of food I got I can't believe how long it took. I've never been to such a filthy place. This is not even the city. The wings were good. But then I remember that when the worker was tossing them in the sauce, he wasn't wearing gloves and the sauce was getting all over his greasy unwashed finger which was IN the steel bowl! I also noticed there was a crusty residue in the steel sauce bowl, instead of texting on their cellphones when we walked in they should have taken the time to wash or rinse the nasty thing in the sink. God just... disgusting. And embarassing that I took my friends here. They were completely mortified. :|
(1)Amy S.
I've heard from most locals Chicagoans that these are the best wings in town. I went, I ate and they were OK. Definitely not the best I've ever had, but not the worst. I think we ordered the hot and not the 911 (or whatever they were called) and I think the 911 are what people rave about. The hot were not hot and a little too vinegary for my palate. I need burn your mouth off HOT, not just a little hot. I'll go back again to try the 911 and I hope they don't disappoint.
(3)Neal W.
It really doesn't get any better. Double order spicy w/ a side of chedder fries. Best wings in chicago. Sure it might take a minute to get your food but its well worth the wait.
(5)Leonard S.
Got a gang of wings to go from here yesterday along w a hot dog and cheddar chips....I've never been inside buff joes before and still hadn't as I stayed in the car, but I've eaten these wings countless times before....I swear the wings were never this small before...some of them laughable but I couldn't stop eating them because of the sauce....I'll just get a burger or dog next time w sauce to go....I know a few Sunday chefs who can fry up some wings better than these while putting back a case...I can't believe that's the wings they served hahaha...the merkts cheddar is great!
(2)Gary C.
Where do I begin?? I've had my fair share of wings and Buffalo Joe's definitely tops the list. I started off on the bottom of the spiciness chain and got the mild. Great flavor, but it was missing that kick. I moved on to hot and I knew I struck gold. Stronger flavor and much more heat. I stayed on this level for a while then built the courage to try suicide. I've never looked back. It's arguably the best wing sauce I've ever tried. The extra heat comes from the jalepeno slices, seeds and all. Not only does this place have great wings, their buffalo chips [seasoned] with cheese is to die for. Ask for some suicide sauce on top and you have some of the best fries in the land. Service is decent. Actually, better than average for this reason: they messed up an order [they gave me a single instead of a double order] but took my name down to give me a free order next time I ordered. No questions asked.
(5)William W.
Came here with a group of friends last month after my last visit back in the college days. Unfortunately, the wings tasted a lot better back then when fast food was the only meal of choice I could afford. Don't get me wrong, they are still pretty darn good. They are just not at the level of "OMG let's go to BJ's!!!!!" good. We got a party tray of wings for a group of 6 people along with some buffalo chips (fries) and nachos. The flavor was definitely there but the wings' size was simply too small. We also got a small order of "suicide" flavor, thinking that they would be too hot for us. However, that did not impress too much either. Although the spiciness did sneak up on us and we were all sweating by the end of meals. I think I stopped at 20 something wings, which is equally depressing considering I inhaled 35 wings last time I visited. Now, my proudest moment of this visit was making pot of rice and brought a couple containers worth of it with us. Friends have always told us that rice surprisingly tastes good with the wing sauce so I decided that this would be the time to try it. And it did not disappoint!!! It sort of tastes like a Chinese dish of "sweet vinegar deep fried fish". So it certainly pleased the Asian side of me when the wings were just a-ok.
(3)Elizabeth B.
My ex-boyfriend used to tell me all the time that I have a tiny mouth. I thought he was just flattering himself until my family dentist confirmed that I do indeed have a smaller-than-normal mouth. My tiny mouth is usually not much of a problem. However, it became an issue at Buffalo Joe's when I ordered the bacon cheese burger. I had to eat the grilled onions with a fork, take off most of the lettuce, all of the tomato, and pull out most of the top bun before I could take my first bite. When I did finally get to take my first bite, my burger was barely warm! I ordered the burger medium and it was well done. How exactly did they make my medium burger cold AND well done in less than 5 minutes? It defies the laws of physics. The fries were good but pretty cold. I didn't try my mate's wings, the burger made me lose my appetite for wings. We went to Buffalos Joe's for lunch because we are jobless and poor right now but, next time I will go to a different spot for lunch even if it costs a little more.
(1)Joe T.
This place serves up some great hometown wings. Whenever we do a house party in Chicagoland we always get these puppies by the pound and bring em' home to serve to the masses. They're great nibbler wings and they have a Suicide flavor with a hot sauce and grilled jalapenos in it. This flavor and the BBQ are 2 of my favorites. When you dine in here - you buy based on the number of wings and the wings are bigger. When you order for a party - they are smaller nibbler wings and sold in aluminum trays by the pound. Either way if you are a Buffalo Wild WIngs fan and looking for another Wings joint in Chicagoland that hits the spot just as well - look no further and try Buff Joe's!
(3)Darren F.
i been coming here off and on for many years.. it used to be better and more meat in them.. right now the wings is pretty tiny but it is still good.. love the waffle fries and love the burgers here! i dint really like eating inside there because it smells pretty horrible sometimes..
(3)Joseluis L.
This is my first time ever giving a review. I just had to come and see what everyone else wrote and felt inclined to give my opinion. I was introduced to this place by a couple of friends and they told me these were the most amazing wings they have ever had. We went last friday night and I will start from the beginning... The man begging by the front door was an immediate turn off. Walking up to the cashier was another immediate turn off, she had a very bad attitude. Not only did she talk with a bad attitude but she also wore it on her face. She really acted like she didn't want to be there (I wouldn't want to be at such a filthy place either). Now this I blame on my friends since they did not tell me but they do no accept debit cards/credit cards. I haven't been to place in a long time that doesn't accept (it's 2012 and you still run a cash only place?)...oh well. Also, if they accepted credit cards I would have ordered so much more wings and beer (they were tiny). But I borrowed cash from my friends. I wasn't about to use their atm machine. I get it, you don't accept cards but the owner (I'm assuming he owns that atm machine) is more then happy to charge you that fee for using that machine he installed...nice. I ordered double suicide. I got my food fairly quickly so that was a plus. We then proceeded to sit down at the filthy tables. They have tvs to watch...too bad the one with the loudest volume for some reason was set to a channel with infomercials, huh? The wing sauce was good (it shouldn't be called suicide though, not that hot) but the wings themselves were soooo tiny, laughable tiny. I just pretended they were amazing for my friends benefit. They still were acting like the place was amazing. I didn't dare go to the bathrooms, I didn't want to know what they looked like but my girlfriend did. She came back in seconds after leaving and told me there was urine all over the seat and also that there was a nasty mess inside the toilet because that person didn't bother to flush.... We will not be going back. It's not worth it for great sauce on nasty wings, eaten on a nasty table, and our order being taken by someone with a nasty attitude. No thanks!
(1)Shelden E.
mmm...yeah, these were good wings, and I did get quite a bit even for the single size version, but the dude worked at the register was such dick. I had ordered a Miller Lite beer when at the counter, but when I got to the register/tap they asked me again. So I changed my mind to the Leinenkugel's Winter ale--the exact same price--and the dude stood there saying, "It says Lite on your order." "Yeah my bad. I meant the Winter Ale. My bad." "It says Lite on the order." "Yyyyeah. I mean is that going to be a problem?" He just rung it up and took the cash. What a jerk. Like I said the wings were good, but I'd almost say they're just as good at Buffalo Wild Wings a few blocks away. Service is better there and more selections on stuff. Oh yeah. Also, the wet naps my friends and I got were all dry in their packaging. It was nice to walk out with the hands that weren't the cleanest.
(3)Ernie C.
Buffalo Joe's is uneven. I love coming here, but sometimes I wish I just opted for Flattop or any other downtown Evanston eatery. 1. Wings have gotten smaller. 2. Stingy on the ranch/bleu cheese. 3. It is not worth the price. It costs me $12 for wings, fries and pop (me alone). 4. Don't ask for water, cashier is QUICK to tell you.. "We don't give no free water here" and charge you $1.50 for the cup. No lie. 5. Cheddar fries are still good. 6. Somedays food is hot, somedays food is warm. 7. Better than the Howard Street location.
(2)Krupa U.
Buff Joe's is great! Every time I'm in chicago with friends, we always get a big order of buff joe's wings to pig out on at least one night we're there. I personally love the BBQ flavor, and I guess the Jalapeno would come in second. The wings are actually mini-wings, smaller than Buffalo Wild Wings, but we usually order the party pan for whatever party we're throwing so they are perfect little nibblers to go along w/ your beer or cocktail. Speaking of beer... they sell it! A limited selection mind you, but still, nice to know. Oh and major plus - it still tastes good the day after! Usually reheated wings end up getting dry and shriveled up, but Buff Joe's found a way to keep em tasting good for longer! I commend you, your Wingness!
(4)Jason C.
When I get a craving for wings, there is only one place that can satisfy it: Buffalo Joe's. I will gladly drive 25 mins from my place to Evanston to get some of their wings because they are the best (in my opinion). You have to make sure you go to the Clark Street Buff Joe's and not the Howard one - I'll explain why later. My order never changes: Single order/suicide and cheddar chips, also served with celery and ranch dressing. If I'm feeling risky I'll also get a Diet Rite. The magic is all in the tangy house suicide sauce with jalapenos, but it's not spicy to the point that you can't enjoy the wings. The cheddar chips are waffle cut fries slathered in a layer of cheddar goodness. I went to the Howard location once thinking that they too would have cheddar chips - FAIL. This is why going to the Clark St location is a must. Reminder: They only accept cash so make sure you have some coin on you!
(5)Grace B.
My trip back home was not complete until we went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston. By far one of the best wing spot ever. Double order mild w/ buffalo chips and a side of cheese please! You will not find a spot like this in LA. I've been a fan since '94. They keep it nice a simple.
(5)harry b.
By far these are the best wings in the state, if not the country! Wheather you prefer BBQ, mild, spicy or 'suicide,' go all out and get a double order. If you don't finish them on your first try, they're great the next day. Note that the other locations are not as good as the Clak location. They will do in a pinch, but the extra few minutes in the car are well worth it!
(5)Leo I.
Buffalo Joe's no more. When there is more bone than meat on the wings, you know it's time to accept that the legendary hole-in-the-wall has seen better days. I've been going to BJ's for quite a few years now. They had some of the best chicken wings I've ever tasted and definitely the best in the Chicagoland area. My last few visits were disappointing and last night's visit was the last straw. Whether it's the economic crisis or the fatigue that drives BJ's decline, decline it is. So long BJ.
(1)Stephanie F.
Sh*t, man. I'm not even a wings fan but when I was taken here by a wing guru and experienced the melt-in-your-mouth quality of these babies, I felt it in my hips. The cheese fries are fantastic. MMmmmm........the wings are so good that the only descriptive words I can come up with are naughty interjections.
(5)Jacob J.
Before Buffalo Wild Wings, this was my fix for wings in Chicago land. Suicide, thinking about it has me salivating. That's a ton of hot sauce lathered over wings and then a helping of sliced jalapenos over that. That sauce is great for dipping or just alone. You've got to really dig (vinegar) hot sauce to appreciate Joe's flavors. I can't remember the exact brand of hot sauce, might be Louisiana, they keep jugs of it in plain sight. A perfect order is a double order of wings, a basket of the waffle cut fries and a large drink. (That's large soda pop, not "drink") Tempt fate by getting a few friends together and ordering a full or half pan. That's a catering order of 50-100 wings. Extra wet, the extra better. Joe's however isn't consistent, at times you really love it and other times it's not how you remembered it. Note: during cold seasons it can be cold in the dining area, dress warm or you may have your jacket on while eating. There's something important to mention about payments, I believe it might be cash only, or charge only on orders over $20 +. You may like to inquire when placing phone orders. (This may have changed) Crowd is all Northwestern Univ peeps and locals. If you go late night expect to get harassed by street walkers. Not your usual kind either, they have refined tastes and may ask for more than just change, they need to eat too. (One time a guy asked me for change, I bought him some fries, he then tells me he would've rather had the money so he could get some Thai food!)
(4)d a.
the bathroom is disgusting-reminds me of a prison from a bad tv movie but everything else is great. also the soda is supersized not the normal sizes so unless you're pat fitzgerald thirsty go smaller. great place, great service, food still reasonably priced and great mix of students, 5 year olds with dads, grownups and regulars. the fries are waffle and the cheese on the burgers is spread which is better. cash only and they're open very late. just excellent, but fix the bathroom-with all the little kids it should look better.
(5)Ngoc H.
You don't know what wings are until you get a taste of Joe's. They come out right from the fryer and are topped with jalapenos if you get them suicide. I wold say some days the wings are better than others, some days juicy and huge, others skinny and disappointing, but you never know until you order. Their buffalo chips are to die for, crispy on the outside tender on the inside waffle fries that are tossed with a delicious seasoning blend. There's this seasoning on them which I can never guess whats in it. A lot of people like the cheddar on them but I would go without. They only take cash, but there's an ATM in there too if you want to be charged for the fee. Not the greatest place for a date but if you are craving wings with a couple friends, it's the place to be.
(4)Taylor M.
Best drunken buffalo wings ever. Terrible for you, but that's not the point. They are incredible. Get the sauces mixed. Trust me.
(4)Phil X.
"A single order of hot wings with a side of cheddar chips, extra cheese." I come here when I want buffalo wings...or when I want to negate any of my previous efforts at my local gym. I don't know too much about the rest of their menu. The hot wings here are tasty. I usually order 'em hot. If you order the "suicide" version, they take the "hot" and throw a bunch of peppers all over it. G'head and try it. Your colon will thank you. The wings themselves tend to be small sometimes. It's all about the sauce though. (That should be a bumper sticker) The BBQ wings are pretty good too. They're sweet, NOT hot. On the side, I always order cheddar chips with extra cheese. They are waffle-fries. The cheese is a melted sharp cheddar. You will either love the cheese...or you will hate it. I wash it down with grape pop.
(4)Jeff H.
Hands-down the best wings I've ever had, and I've had them at about every place that is supposed have even passable wings. Perfectly fried, perfectly sauced. The best part is they don't bread them. Breading, in my humble opinion, is an amateur move. Breading is fine on chicken fingers, but it has no place on wings. The sauce...holy sh*t, the sauce. My theory is that BJ's sauce has three key ingredients - 1) Crack cocaine 2) Heroin 3) The tears, sweat ,or semen of some cosmic deity. Now, I see that some of the reviews bash BJ's for the wing size. I'll admit that these aren't great big, super meaty wings, but therein lies the genius. Ya see, I can say in all honesty that every place I've ever been where you get big, meaty wings, is that you usually just end up tasting the chicken which is usually low quality to begin with. When I eat wings I want a perfect wing-to-sauce ratio with the sauce having just the right consistency to cling to the wings. Buffalo Joe's has this ratio perfected. My friends and I have brought many, and I mean MANY people here to put it to the test and they've all loved it. In fact, out of all of our friends and acquaintances who've had BJ's only one of our buddies doesn't care for it, which isn't bad out of the large number of us who love it. I even know several people who - while claiming to be vegetarian - make an exception for these wings-from-above. Finally, to make your BJ's experience complete, get some waffle fries and a Gut RC and you have the makin's of a superbly unhealthy, but decadent meal. It's worth the drive from Chicago, I assure you.
(5)Mr. C.
I'm not sure what has been happening here lately, but since I started coming here 3 years go the wings seem to be getting smaller and the employees ruder. Don't get me wrong they have one of the best buffalo sauces around, but my last visit was not a good one when I was taking one bite off each wing since they were so amazingly small. It's like they got their chicken wings from baby chicks that haven't fully developed yet, which made the entire recent experience kind of nauseating.
(3)David T.
I've been a regular customer of Buffalo Joe's ever since I've moved to area in 2001, when I first heard they were the best wings in the city. They never disappointed ... until now. For some reason, my last five visits or so (I average about one visit per month, always driving more than 25 miles just to get my fix) the wings have been pretty sub par, almost bad in some cases. I would usually finish my single suicide order w/ waffle fries and crave more, but the wings have just been severely lacking lately. I can't put my finger on it, it might be the shrinking size of the wings, which were already pretty small to begin with. There's also been a few occasions where the pieces look deformed, neither looking like a traditional drumstick or wing, so I just throw them out. The sauce is still as good as ever, I just think they've somehow cut some costs and used a cheaper, less tasty wing now. I would usually recommend Joe's highly to any one who hasn't visited the place yet, but now I'm not so sure. Hopefully their act picks up again.
(3)Abhist D.
I love Buffalo Joe's wings. I used to eat them a lot during high school and hadn't had them in quite a while. Well I lost a bet to a despicable Sox fan and had to pay up with Buff Joe's wings. Let's just say that this is one bet that I wouldn't mind losing over and over again! I mean...the wings are delicious! Heck, even my wife (who can't stand wings cuz she's never liked the tast) loved them. And I mean LOVED them. They're good. Service is what you'd expect from the joint, which means its quaint in its own way. Oh...and suicide wings are the way to go (and they are NOT THAT HOT!)
(5)Bless P.
Outstanding and THE best chicken wings and fries I've ever tasted!!! Very casual and a long wait if there is a game scheduled.
(5)Aimee C.
yes, yes and more yes! When I'm dying for some good old fashion buffalo wings, the trek to Buffalo Joe's is worth every painstaking moment. From their suicide sauce to their waffle fries, it's a treasure to devoured. Better than all the rest... Hot, saucy and delicious.. wings flying as elbows are up in the air. Don't try to talk to me, because I'm deep in sauce and can't be bothered. :) talk to you when my fingers are licked and the grin of complete satisfaction is plastered across my face. -- ps take a zantac.. the sauce will definitely get your tummy rumbling.
(4)Albert C.
I love this place!! I've been going here for such a long time.. the single order is such a big portion and I always mixed bbq & suicide sauce!! Don't forget to get their buffalo chips aka waffle fries with the cheddar cheese! For $10.10 AMAZING!! Their cookies by the counter are amazing also! They're actually freshed baked daily but it looks old in the container
(4)Janice L.
yumyumYUM. the suicide wings are the best, heaped on top with jalapeno peppers. the flavor is the best of all the wings i've ever had. also, i'm not a fan of breaded wings and here, it's naked, so perfect. one downside, sometimes some of the wings have absolutely no meat. i wish they fattened the chickens a little more, they're like anorexic! anyways, dip the wing into the ranch sauce, take a bite, aahh.. bliss (:
(4)Precious B.
What can I say Buff Joe's never fails wings and fries all day!
(5)Vanessa D.
I think this is one of those places that you can only truly appreciate if you've been coming here since you were in high school or college. Despite growing up in the area, I never set foot into this Buffalo Joe's until this year. I've been twice now. The spicy wings are good. And they have RC cola, which is always a pleasant surprise. However, I found the actual wings to be awfully small with not much meat. Additionally, their cheddar chips which I had high hopes for were soggy and gross both times. I had been assured that they typically were not like this... so, who knows. But, the place has character and they have a full menu of things I haven't yet tried, so I will definitely give them another chance.
(3)Bridget M.
Quite yum. The wings are good, but are decidedly not truly spicy. They douse these guys in sauce which adds to the overall appeal. The cheese fries are a must do. Major props for the real cheddar cheese chunks accompanied by the jalapeno slices. The burgers are greasy and delicious; I'm not a big fan of the kinds of buns they use. Pretty good deal for what you spend. Just wish they'd invest in having a paper towel roll at the table a la Hooters and a credit card machine. Buyers beware, this is a cash only joint!
(4)Eric M.
I'm giving them four stars within their genre, which is fast-food, with a heavy emphasis on wings. I went here for the first time last weekend. Not having been before, I don't know what size the wings were "back in the day," but I don't really give a damn about wing size when they just scoop a bunch up and don't count them. 20 small wings vs. 10 huge wings - who cares. If anything I like wings for the skin anyway, so more small ones usually means more skin, more deliciousness and more satisfaction! I thnik these are some of the best-tasting wings I've had. I do like blue cheese dressing better than ranch, but the wings themselves matter a whole lot more than the side sauce does. I don't live close, so I can't say I'll be a regular or anything, but I liked them well enough that I'll definitely be back, maybe even for a special trip now and then. I do have one complaint - the cheese fries were not up to par. The cheese congealed and became a gooey, cold mess way to fast. And the fries themselves weren't that great, either. Making good fries isn't rocket science and I think people let restaurants off easy too often for sub-par fries.
(4)Demetrio P.
Went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston last night for the gazillionth time, and it never disappoints! Usually order a single order of suicide wings and waffle fries....hmmmm...just thinking about it is making me crave it again. Prices have risen over the years, but still budget friendly. I can't vouch for the other items on the menu, but why go to a buffalo wings place for anything other than, well, buffalo wings! Overall, good food, okay prices, and okay service.
(4)eric l.
I don't know whether it was the hype, but the wings were just whatever. Ranch dressing was watered down. Also, their portions are measured in a weird way. They just eyeball the number. Number of freakn double order and the single order of wings were the same. Never get a double order, unless you don't know where to spend all your money and want to get overcharged. Service wasn't bad but neither good. GET CASH before or else get ready to pay an extra 3 bucks for the ATM fee (worst way to spend 3 bucks). I would say it is better than bw3 but not hooters.
(2)Jason P.
Ok, so lets start this by saying I am a vegetarian reviewing a chicken wing place. For those of you that did not immediately stop reading, enjoy! Ok, this place has a pretty diverse menu outside of the chicken wings. The best part are the heart attack cheese fries, called chips. They will throw hot sauce on them and cover them with jalepenos as well to make heartburn heaven. They also have these giant cookies that are extremely awesome. The best part of being a vegetarian there is that you can go straight to the register and cut the line. My omnivore friends that actually wait in line say that the wings are fantastic as well. The only downside is that if you get water, I think it is something like 10 cents and they pack so much ice in there that you have to go get more every sip. Also, one recommendation is that you bring someone who smokes with you. It is the best way to interact with the greeters that stand outside (persons sans homes) as generally they will be satisfied with bumming a smoke off of your smoker friend. Trust me, it works everytime.
(4)Paul d.
So after countless hours at the gym training for a 10 mile race and then finally getting to that wondrous day and reluctantly running it, what would any one in their right mind do? Feed your face with the most unhealthy food you can find, of course!. After a long debate between OCB (Old Country Buffet for you not in the know) and BJs, we ended up making the trek over to Evanston. I'm going to cut straight to the food; let me tell you, after ten grueling miles, you deserve any treat you get. This treat happened to be in the form of a double order of spicy wings, spicy cheddar fries, and a bacon cheddar burger. The wings are smaller than normal (about the same as BW3s size, if not smaller) but the crunchiness of the skin, lean meat and amazing sauce were in perfect unison. The spicy cheddar fries were good as well - waffle fries, cheddar (real cheddar btw, no gloppy manufactured cheese topping here), hot sauce and jalapenos on top. Bacon cheeseburger was standard except for the fact they again they used real cheddar - somewhat greasy but good nonetheless. Only thing I would change about this place are the napkins! How do you expect to eat wings, cheddar fries and a cheddarburger without half of it ending up on your face? Then they insult you with these dinky little napkins like the ones they used to give you in grade school. Next time I'm bringing a bib, a bottle of Purex and a hand towel! Tip: Leave the credit card at home, it's cash only here.
(4)Paula B.
I had their special burger today for lunch and it was great! I've been there numerous times before and love their wings, their beef sandwiches, and their stuffed potatoes! Yummmm Their cookies are the best too! I think it's got good reasonable food. It's cash only though. There is an ATM there in the restaurant though if you need it.
(4)Rob S.
This is probably the one spot I miss most since moving from the city out to the 'burbs. Buffalo Joe's defines buffalo chicken wings in my book. They are the benchmark, and few, if any can compare. Double order of Spicy, the waffled fries, and a Gut Lemonade are my standing order. I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's for over a decade, and there is na reason for this.
(5)Giselle S.
I must be hard wired since my first taste in high school. The truly mouthwatering wing that bears your name makes one drool and dream for the delights. This place has been a neighborhood gem for many years. I would have to say that since the beginning weeks of football season there is nothing that can compare to a BJ and a beer! I know why the sexual innuendo (it's not my usual style:) ....b/c it is true, football season or not this place is the best. These wings rock. Single and Double orders or Single Party Tray or Double Party Tray. Suicide sauce on the side use to house whole jalapenos and now are chopped up and still so delicious. On my latest excursion to this place I placed the order over the phone thinking how the occasion called for an order that fits b/t Double order and Single party pan. My subconscious wanted the Single party pan for plenty of leftovers and to make sure no one was left without their fill. The practicality of it all was no need to spend more than what was needed. I ordered over the phone and was told it would be 10-15 minutes. By the time I picked up my order and pay (CASH ONLY) I ordered $50 worth of tantalizing wings. Pleasant surprise on my part. My subconscious won in the end and my longing for Joe's was satiated for the time being. :) Luckily, the gathering was a success, (I can not say the same for the Bears), and no leftovers to take home. Eat in and cafeteria style until you pay for your order and catch the game in the eatery on flat screen. Enjoy!
(5)afro d.
i must be a gluten for punishment... i tried to go again hoping somethings have changed. but it had gotten worse. the wings were no bigger than a quarter. now the part it got worse is that its super dirty when i got there. a cart with dirty stuff in a bus tub in front of the reg. behind the counter it was filthy. not i went there about 11:30pm.. i learned my lesson. no more.
(1)Angela H.
The hot I got was not quite hot enough. Should have gone with suicide. Their fluffy baked potato has had me craving baked potatoes with my wings ever since. It's sort of a divey place and mostly full of teenage boys and hard-working men. I was certainly a fish out of water, but acted like I belonged. Waffle fries looked amazing. I'll go back and give it another try. Didn't find anything to be dirty, and enjoyed my food.
(4)Erin N.
Sans car, I don't get up to Evanston much anymore. But I had the pleasure of going there recently when my gf borrowed the car from her parents for the weekend. Like I mentioned earlier the wings have changed since back in my high school days (10+ years ago). But let me tell you this- I ate my single order of wings faster than I have ever eaten wings in my entire life. They were that good compared to the stuff that bars try to serve you in the city. They are a bit tinier than wings you'd get anywhere else, but I like that rather than the JUMBO wings that throw off the meat to sauce ratio and always seem kind of rubbery. I'm taking Buffalo Joe's down one star for their rude behavior towards my gf who brought a Papa John's pizza in. I was a paying customer (single order, RC, and spicy cheddar chips*) and she came to sit with me. On top of that, she also purchased a drink from them! She wasn't taking up space that could have been used by another patron- and it's not like her eating of her pizza would have caused BJ's to lose customers. They were just plain turdley to her. *not as good as I recall, but this might be due to the fact that by the time I got around to eating them my stomach was expanding from the rapid wing consumption.
(4)Orack B.
When we started going to Buffalo Joe's back in the day we were so high on a number of different possible intoxicants that one would think we would not fully enjoy the experience. I am here to refute any such claims. We fucking loved it! Now 15 years later I still love it like I did back in my youth. The sauce is really what does it for me. I like the succulence of the sweetness followed by the bite of the heat. I always order suicide - although the heat varies from time to time and also depends on how many jalapenos you eat - I yearn for something hotter. This brings me to a Buffalo Joe's story circa '99 when I was offered habanero pepper wings. Now circa '99 me and my buddy were so high, and lovers of spice, that we said yes. What ensued was absolute hilarity. Each bite of wing rendered us delirious for ten minutes. We were in our own worlds, laughing uncontrollably between each bite. I believe capsaicin increases the effects of Jah Ganja at least tenfold. It was pure bliss! Now back to the food. Single suicide, sometimes a double if I feel extra large, cheddar chips and a gut RC. This is my definition of a fleeting paradise, consumed with such gusto it is almost a travesty. Big shouts to my man Dean behind the counter.
(4)Peter R.
I had to run some errands in Evanston, and you know what that means!!! BUFFALO JOE'S all up in, and around my face!!! I stopped by the Chase ATM because this place only takes cash money. I strolled in with a Cheshire Cat grin on my face and ordered the single order spicy, and a smokehouse burger. I know, I know, I'm such a hippo, but I didn't eat lunch I swear!!! I validated my artery clogging meal by ordering a gut buster size Diet Rite, just to even things out. I plopped into one of the booths in the back, watched some ESPN on the big flat screen and waited for them to call my name. "Diego!" "Diego, single order with smokehouse burger!" If you know me, or if you look on the upper left of this review, you notice my name is not Diego. I always give them a fake name, just to keep things lively. I went back to my seat and got down to bizzzzness. Ah, the spicy delectable joy of these tender chicken morsels. The buffalo wings have that, "make your nose runny" heat on them...delicious. My smokehouse burger was very good, with the grilled onions, bacon, bbq sauce, and cheese, all coming together in splendid bliss. If you are ever in Evanston, and you love buffalo wings, you HAVE TO stop by. Buffalo Joe's is spicy chicken nirvana.
(5)Kristin M.
I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but in my opionion the wings are too greasy and have way too much sauce on them. The sauce had a little too much sweetness to it and there were jalopenos in it, which is just not right... And I thought we had asked for blue cheese dressing, but it tasted like ranch-that's just not the way it should be! The cheesy fries, however, oh my! I was in heaven! I'd go back for that!
(3)Nate C.
Its been years since I've been first introduced to this place and I have yet been disappointed. yum Yum! I love eating there while the food is nice and fresh. Then when I'm done with my spicy wings, I can always get an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie. The waffle cheese fries are yummy, the celery stix are yummy. Everything is just yummy. I guess you can say its one of my favorite wing joint.
(4)Martha M.
Buff Joes is AWESOME. Let me give you a few pointers. 1. Call your order in ahead of time, otherwise you will most likely wait awhile. 2. They only take cash! There is an ATM but it charges you an obscene amount of money. 3. If you are gong with a few people and you all want the same sauce, get the double orders, instead of single orders. You'll save a few bucks. Maybe you could give the money you save to the bum who is always standing outside. 4. Have patience! Buff Jo's is always full of rude and obnoxious high schoolers and even ruder and more obnoxious Northwestern students. A word on the cheese fries. They are so so good! They have regular cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce and then they have the uber-amazing Spicy Cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce, buffalo sauce and jalapenos. delicious!!!
(4)Kristen B.
Went here for the first time today and really enjoyed it! After running into a former Evanstonian yesterday who was appalled by the fact I still hadn't been here, we decided we should go. I was a little leery about it after reading some of the reviews thinking my friend was just guiding me to a place that was great during her high school days but had passed its glory days. I'm glad that I went against my better judgment. The wings were great, I can't say that they were the best I've ever had but definitely up there. Hubby and I shared a double order of spicy wings, cheddar chips (waffle fries smothered in cheese) and a side of spicy sauce for cheese fry dipping pleasure (this is also a great way to enjoy Buffalo Chips with Cheese at BWW.) The cheese was a little oddly sweet, but other than the meal was tasty. Nice meaty wings with a lot of sauce. We got 20 in our $10 double order. I will take away one star because things seemed to take a really long time. While not entirely their fault (U of Wisconsin's Lacrosse Team dropped in for lunch and another large group was there also) it did seem to frazzle them quite a bit and at one point a tub of raw chicken wings were dropped onto the floor. I will definitely go back for the wings and to try a "char dog."
(4)Mike D.
I was quite excited to try out buffalo joes after many recommendations and drooling over it on yelp. I ordered the Spicy and BBQ thinking I'd try half and half. I was asked if I wanted a mix. Thinking that would get me my half and half situation, I agreed. What I got was delicious flavor heaven. The spicy and the sweet of the BBQ and hot sauce was an amazing combination. My only complaint is that their wings are definitely on the small side. However, the taste was great and it was a no frills process to get in, out and eating my wings.
(5)Joe R.
This place hits the spot. come with a couple of friends and an appetite. the wings arent the biggest but the sauce really opens up the meat. they are well fried and are the ideal comfort food for a day of drinking or just to unwind after a long day. the suicide wings are the best and have a decent kick to them especially with the jalapeno's. service is good and nothing goes better with wings than dark beer. I look forward to hitting this place up when I can.
(4)Doctor L.
As a Northwestern U. alum, absolutely nothing in this world makes me more nostalgic to head back to Evanston than Buff Joe's. As college students this is where we'd go whenever we got paid, whenever the dorm cafeteries were closed on Sunday nights, and/or whenever we got drunk and/or stoned. Or any combination of the above. Junk food connoisseurs know that grease is supposed to have its own FLAVOR, not just texture, and not just compliment other flavors. Perhaps no other restaurant in the world appreciates this more than Buffaloe Joe's. The wings are awesome, especially if you're having a party and buy them by the tray. I fondly recall multiple occassions when I saw fraternity pledges being sent there from as far away as Michigan and Missouri by their homesick Chicagoan brothers to pick up as many trays as could fit in their car. As other Yelpers have astutely pointed out, the genius behind Buff Joe's is that they appreciate spice while at the same time understanding that spice by itself is not a flavor. These wings have zest as well as heat. There's a huge difference between the two. The rich buttery flavor of the wings is only matched by the impeccable waffle-cut cheese fries. Again Buff Joe's has mastered capturing the rich greasy flavor of both the fry AND the processed cheese sauce to make this delicious side order a worthy meal in itself. As you'd expect, your ass WILL be on fire after dining here. Do not go to Buff Joe's on a date, before a date, or before any event where you will not have the opportunity to run to the bathroom every 5 minutes (ie: mid-term, final, movie, concert, orgy, etc.)
(5)Michael M.
Even though this place can really cause havoc on your stomach with the spices it still is by far my favorite wing place in Evanston. My sales guys and I frequently will order this place for lunch, (Mild for Lunch) Don't want to kill the staff...LOL!!! Always get extra Ranch and there is never enough, and it is so good. Also try their baked potatoes they are surprisingly perfectly cooked ever time. All in all A+ in my book. - Greasy Spoon FYI, so don't expect anything fancy!
(5)Alex Z.
I wish they served more different sauces, like that one big chain place to the southwest does. They are very good at what they do serve, though. I get spicy every time (or whatever the one in the middle is called). Single order is enough, and it comes with free celery (which is actually fresh!) and ranch dip. The texture of the chicken and the taste of the sauce are amazing. Hot dogs are meh, I heard the burgers were great but I've never gotten one. Beverage choices could be improved (RC is still in business!?!?), and not taking cards is a bit of an annoyance. Sometimes the people who take your order are condescending and mean, other times they are great. I like that poster in the waiting area that says "No bird soars too high if he soars with his own wings".
(4)Kelsey M.
Let me tell you folks who didn't grow up in Evanston something, back in middle and high school, you could NOT have a classroom party without Buffalo Joe's. It just wasn't a party without. It's an Evanston institution, and rightly so. I am not normally a wings person, but these are DELICIOUS! So good. You are not a true Evanstonian if you haven't eaten here.
(4)Candyce P.
I'm a huge wings fan. I've had them at most sports bars, of course at BW3 and my Dad grills some spectacular Portuguese wings. That being said, I'm picky about the way the wings are fried (or grilled) and the combination of spices used. Jason C. made plans for us to meet at Buffalo Joe's for lunch, with promises of the best wings. I was a bit skeptical, but excited to try them out. It's quite a casual setting: order at the counter, pick up you order when it's done. I got the single order of spicy wings, with cheddar fries and a Sprite. I also only order the "flat" pieces of the wing if I can, and they gladly obliged. (Some places give me the stank eye for requesting only flats). The wings are perfectly crispy, and the "single order" is huge! (I'd say about 12 wings? and for $6.something it's a steal!) The "spicy" sauce was just what I wanted as well - a deep flavor with a nice kick. The cheddar fries were good as well, but you have to eat them while it's still hot, or else the cheddar solidifies on your waffle fries. Which isn't such a bad thing either. :) Overall, HUGE fan. I'll definitely make the trip out to Evanston for these wings again and again. Note: They accept CASH ONLY, but there is an ATM in-house for those of us who never carry cash around.
(5)Conrad Q.
I've been coming here since my early college years. I have never been disappointed by the wings. I always get suicide wings, cheddar chips and a gut buster RC. Celery has always been crisp when you dine in but never when you order for take out. They don't keep it separate with the wings. I noticed the wings might be getting smaller, but that could just be the economy.
(4)Heather B.
If you want wings with taste as well as spice, this is the place for you! I like hot stuff, but I like it to taste like something other than just burning my tongue off!! I love this place despite the fact that it is in college kid central in Evanston. The staff rocks, and obviously love their jobs, because most of them have been there the entire 5 or longer years I have been going there. They even recognize us when we walk through the door!! Their sauce is to die for.... the mild is perfect spice with a bit of kick, spicy is hot and tasty, and suicide is.... well, topped with jalepenos, and makes my sinuses instantly clear. I can't do the suicide for long! For $35 you can buy a gallon of your favorite sauce and use at your discretion. I'm also a big fan of the broccoli cheese soup and buffalo tenders. The soup has the perfect amount of broccoli to cheese ratio, but can be a little greasy sometimes. The tenders are a great way to soak up that wonderful sauce and save some calories! (yeah, not really, but they are better than the wings in that respect) Everyone needs to try Buffalo Joe's if you like wings. You won't regret it!
(5)Annie S.
LOVE BJ's!!!! I used to come here in high school and their wings, burgers and waffle fries are THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Melt in your mouth good. Dang, this place is so great. I love the suicide wings (very hot) and you have to order the fries (w/ cheese if you like that). The service is pretty fast and there's regular seating in the back. The place is a decent size and almost always I can find a table. Seriously, you have to try this place and get the wings!!!
(5)James B.
Single order (or double if you a big boy) of spicy wings with some cheddar chips and a grape drink or rc and you will be good. best place for wings on this planet.
(5)Justin G.
Best buffalo wings in the Chicagoland area (as it's in Evanston...) hands down. The atmosphere is super casual, with employees yelling out names as orders are completed. The wings are not as large as they were 10 years ago, when I started eating there, but they're an okay size. The sauce is what makes it great. Try the spicy, the mild is really very, very mild. The suicide is not as hot as most people seem to think, but the jalepenos on top seem to scare most people away. Good anytime, really. Even thinking about it makes me want to stop over there right now... Addendum: They only take cash. An annoyance, but it certainly doesn't ruin the experience.
(5)Hilda E.
Love this place, been going for years. Although the wings are small at times...they are big other times. I don't really care about the size because the sauce is amazing....LITERALLY the best I ever had. Buffalo chips aka waffle fries are awesome...always freshly made. RC washes it all down fantastically. Missing 1 star because it is really dirty in that place. It wouldn't hurt to grab a rag and scrub it all down. Seriously. The decor is not bothersome but the dirt is a bit.
(4)Joyce L.
You can feel your arteries clogging with each bite of a hot wing, but your taste buds will be in euphoria. This is by far, the best buffalo wing place I've ever eaten at, and I have eaten at many a wing place since I grew teeth. We LOVE this place and make it a point to stop by every time we're in Chicago. Why does Chicago have all the yummy food??? THEY ONLY TAKE CASH.
(5)Madeline H.
Oh my god, junk food does not get any better than Buffalo Joes. I found Buff Joe's through a coworker who recommended I cure my hangover by walking over to this low-key Clark St. location for one of their oh so devilishly greasy burgers. My hangover was instantly cured. Upon returning to work my coworker told me "Now that you've tried the worst thing on the menu, you've got to go back and try what they're famous for: their chicken wings." Let me tell you, that burger was definitely delicious, but my coworker was right, you gotta go for the wings, I cannot express to you how good they are. My best friend and I got here at least once a month on Sunday afternoons to get our wings fix and it is always a delightful experience. Somehow the wings are both crispy and moist and the sauce is out of this world. Spicy is definitely the sauce to order and don't worry it isn't that hot (I am terrible at handling spice and I love it). If you're looking for something sweeter try mild, and if you're a big spice person you have the options of hot and suicide. Also make sure to order the buffalo chips and extra ranch and a gutbuster RC to quench your thirst. Hands down this place is my favorite place to eat in Evanston if not the whole north side, in fact I have to limit the number of times I allow myself to eat here because if I don't it would be an everyday event. The decor is nothing special but it totally fits the atmosphere of the joint. In fact, my friends and I have this theory that if a joint that sells burgers, hot dogs, or wings looks kind of dingy and crappy on the inside, then chances are you're gonna get a great meal and at Buff Joe's this is totally true. On any given day you'll find the place full of college students from both Northwestern and Loyola, families, and locals gathering for a good meal and whatever sporting event is on TV.
(5)Nate L.
Not bad place for wings in my opinion. Their spicy wings with jalapenos on top... it really hit the spot. not too hot but it was perfectly balanced. Not a good place if you have a big group. Not enough tables for group of 10.
(4)Douchee D.
I have a friend who is a Northwestern alumni, and it was her who brought me up to Evanston to visit Buffalo Joe's for the first time to try the best wings on the planet. They are without a doubt the best wings I have ever tasted. Now, correct me if I'm wrong ( actually don't ), but these wings don't taste like authentic buffalo style wings. There is a kind of mustardy zing to them, and they serve ranch dressing on the side as apposed to blue cheese dressing. These wings are on the wet side, which is messy and not good for first dates, but how are we kidding; if you're bringing your first date here you're a cheap or poor bastard. Actually, that sounded mean. It could be kind of cute, if it was presented the right way. Oh, just go for it! The waffle cut fries and cheese are addicting. I hope to God no one in my neighborhood starts doing their fries this way, or I'll be as big as a house by year's end. There are other interesting thing that I see going on on other people's trays, but I'm just there for the wings and waffle cut cheese fries.
(4)Kate W.
I'm only commenting on the wings here... I grew up in Upstate NY, near Buffalo, and worked at a pizza place in high school that made buffalo wings. I know how they're made, and I know what makes them authentic... therefore I'm VERY picky when it comes to wings. This place gets 3 stars only because it's the closest I've come to decent wings in Chicago. They are far from good though. They deep fry the wings which is good, too many places don't. Their sauce is just ok though. Real Buffalo sauce is the easiest thing ever to make, it's just Frank's Red Hot and butter (adjust butter amounts for mild, medium or hot). The sauce here is obviously not authentic and has too much vinegar. They also need to make the wings bigger, the ones we got were pretty small. Lastly, what's with the ranch dipping sauce?! You have to serve blue cheese sauce with hot wings... it's the law.
(3)B T.
Grat place. Only takes cash. Super busy. Love the cheese fries and suicide wings
(4)Justin S.
So after a less than thrilling meal at Dixie kitchen I was still full. So off to this wing location that was being spoken of quite highly. I am hoping that what I was served was just off and not the normal fare they serve their customers. The buffalo sauce was lousy, too much vinegar, who knows but it seemed completely off that I couldn't even finish one wing. This place seems to be reserved in the college days, I'm drunk and hungry area. Lets face it after copious amounts of alcohol one will hardly notice nor care the off sauce in these wings.
(1)Juan A.
the greatest of all time!! best wings, best cheddar chips, best ranch!! This place is so good youll forget the rest. many people might find there reason to complain because wings are small but you get enough to fill you up. Its all about flavor and texture and BJ's does it better than most. Whether you are a wing fan or a flavor fan buff joes is the way to go!
(5)Charles W.
Wings were solid. Nothing great, nothing bad. However, they had lots of good 50 cent vending machines so I got my money's worth out of my pocket change! I ended up walking out of Buffalo Joe's with a glow-in-the-dark crucifix and a handful of sprees!
(3)Sonesh S.
Suicide wings quite possibly are the best in the city. honestly, they are that good. I've been eating here for over 10 years now, and while their wings have gotten a bit smaller, the sauce is just as good, and the service still amazes me. The ambiance sucks. Take your food to go...its a terrible place to dine. If you do stay, get a beer. Oh, and get a party pan of celery and ranch...a great way to complement your meal
(5)Lale S.
My mom worked in Evanston when I was a child, that is when I had my first experience at Buffalo Joes. I have gone there so much with friends and family since my teen years, the manager/owner there knows me by name. Buff Joes has the greatest wings I have ever had, not only does the wing itself rival other places, but the sauce is what puts them over the top!!! I could take a order of wings, cheddar chips and a mega gutbuster of RC anyday of the week! Ive even ordered trays from here for parties ive thrown! I highly recommend this place to anyone!
(5)Chris T.
Hands down the best chicken wings on the planet.! There is a Mash episode where Peirce gets a hankering for some ribs from some rib joint and has them express mail the Mash 4077 a box of ribs. Well this is the kind of place where I would do that if I was stuck in a war zone halfway across the world. I graduated from Northwestern in 01 and still think about the amazing wings at Buffalo Joe's. I disagree with the comments about too much sauce. The sauce is the best part. Every time I go to Chicago I have to stop up in Evanston for their wings.
(5)Sangorama s.
I can't imagine any wings being better than BJs. Most other wings taste like the frozen bag of wings you can get at Costco - they're not bad at all, just not all that impressive. We've been going to this place since for over 20 years now and we always get the mild. Don't get me wrong, we love spicy food, but you get the full flavor and enjoyment of the sauce with the mild. You can ask for spicy sauce on the side if you've got to have it. Not exactly sure what kind of freakish, butt burning death wish you have when you order suicide. You know that stuff has to come out of your body at the other end right? If you're not a wings guy then try the buffalo cheddar burger. It's dang good. Same sauce on a fat ole burger with kaukauna cheese spread (is that stuff real cheese?). The soft bun will soak up all the lovely burger juice and deteriorate before you finish so get lots of napkins. Prices are steadily rising and portions steadily getting smaller. There was a time a couple of years ago that the quality of the wings, the chicken itself, was pretty poor and everything was being overcooked and all dried out but they seem to have gotten past that lately. I have to eat here every visit to Chicago.
(5)Johanna C.
Before having a Buffalo Joe's wing, I had no interest in ordering wings at a restaurant or having them at parties. I've had one here and there and never understood what the big deal was. A friend kept raving about how I would crave BuJoe's wings if I try them. Sadly, he was right! The sauce is really really tasty. You get a fair amount of meat on them. I like them soaked up in the sauce so the meat falls off the bone, which is usually the way you will get them in their busy hours. I went here late on a Friday night once (yay, they close at midnight on Friday and Saturday nights!) and the wings were on the crispier side. Not bad but different. A single order of wings will set you back about $7 and a double order about $11. That includes wings, celery and ranch dressing. The ranch tends to be more on the watery side but does the trick. The Buffalo Chips (waffle fries) are also very good, probably because they are waffle fries. The only other meal I've had here is the hot dogs on special. Don't get that. You may as well just make it at home. Just go to Hot Doug's if you want a hot dog! Bottom line - order the wings! Supposedly the burger is good as well but I can't get myself to order anything but the wings...
(4)Neil A.
Maybe they would have gotten more stars if they were willing to sell me wings. Basically, whenever I have called, they aren't taking orders for pick-up until time X... Call back, still not taking orders... (and repeat). Maybe I should just eat there, but the place looks disgusting, and I like dirty pizzeria pizza - so maybe the wings are great - but I don't think I'll ever find out.
(1)A.J. M.
What needs to be said? Wings are wings, and Joes has got em and does them very very well. Hell, they even have some beer on tap here. Oh, and try out the waffle fries some time. They're pretty awesome too.
(4)Gigi L.
That's right, I'm giving it five stars, people. I only come here once a year. On my birthday, which is in May. In February I start marking the days off with a "x" with my black sharpie pen, as the anticipation builds. I can't come here more than that, because then I might be dead. Maybe not quite dead, but I KNOW my butt wouldn't fit through as many doorways. It is delicious though. Spicy as hell, well really as spicy as you want. Sometimes I like it when my head blows off. You get a really generous portion of tender, perfectly textured chicken pieces that melt in your mouth. And then it catches on fire. But then you dip into that blue cheese sauce. And then all is right with the world. Actually, your mouth is still burning, but you can drink milk to clear that right up. They have these amazing waffle fries that you can get with that Merkt's-type cheddar sauce on top. It isn't really saucey, it's more creamy and thick. On top of those hot golden potatoes, it actually is like a religious experience. I am coming back as a fry in my next life. The place is dingy and dirty, and everything is covered in a fine layer of grease. You come out stinking like a vat of oil where tremendously tasty things have been cooked for your eating pleasure. Good times.
(5)Chris J.
Wow, totally going down hill. The wings are still great, but everything else is sub par. If this were a new business attempting to open up shop, it wouldn't stand a chance. They've been coasting on their reputation for at least a few years now. You would be well advised to wear blinders so as not to see the dirty conditions and just get to the wings, but you would never be able to place an order. Instead of a "welcome" or "how can I help you?", you get a surely look and silence. This has happened several times now, so it isn't a case of one server having a bad day. They finally repainted the "dining area" and got new tabletops, but its still in need of a fair amount of cleaning.
(1)Conor M.
I've been going to Buff Joe's since I was in high school and honestly it used to be better. I love the wing sauce and the cheddar chips (caveat with those: eat them first because if you don't the cheese will solidify and it's a bit unappetizing) but the quality of the chicken has decreased significantly. But, hell they're still tasty and where else is there an RC machine?
(4)Ira U.
What can I say? Greatest wings ever! Great Cheese Fries. I hear they have other food but I don't really see the point.
(5)Edward H.
Lookout arteries, here they come! Even though it's been about a decade since my first visit to Joe's, I still remember my first suicide wings/gut buster combo - *and queue flashback* Buffalo Joe's quakes as a "HOLY CRAP! I can't feel my toungue!" echoes throughout the place followed by an "AHHHH" after a sip out of the gut buster (you'd think it's the sauce but it's actually the soda - maybe should be more aptly named the gut *builder*). The Evanston Joe's (not to be confused with the one on Howard) serves up the some of the best spicy buffalo wings around Chicago. The wings are complimented by great waffle fries and various char-broiled burgers. If you're feeling hungry, try and split one of their party trays with a friend or 3. They taste just as good reheated out of the oven. Use their suicide sauce with caution. I remember getting an order of waffle fries with suicide sauce and watching the sauce eat through the styrofoam container.
(4)Paul A.
Anywhere I go, I always try the wings. Although I've had some great wings at a number of places, I always end up ranking Buffalo Joe's as one of the best I have ever had. They seem to have shrunk in size over the years, but I've noticed the same thing at a lot of other places too (in particular Buffalo Wild Wings - their wings look like they came off a sickly hamster). Regardless, a damn fine wing and exceptional sauce. You get ranch instead of blue cheese and I actually prefer that. I live downtown and I make the trek to Evanston for these babies almost once a month. The only con: cash only.
(5)Hope Z.
I was severely disappointed. Maybe Im a wing snob. Maybe I expect more from my buffalo sauce than spice. I have heard so many rave reviews about this place and my fiance and I walked out thinking "eh" There was no flavor to the sauce. It was an oily mess. the "cheddar" on the "cheddar fries" was lacking in cheese taste. it was like yellowish paste. Its rare I pass up a cheese fry order. It ruined what would have been great waffle fries. The only redeeming quality of this place is the breading. I had the chicken tenders, and the breading was fantastic. But it certainly wasn't worth driving to Evanston over.
(3)kelly c.
Yes! Don't waste your time on the other Joe's - this is the one that knows! Great wings and other sundries. I should probably warn that this isn't a high class place with quality ingredients - it's pretty low brow, but that's part of the charming novelty. For me, this Buffalo Joe's venue is well worth the hike up north.
(4)Rob S.
I've been eating here since I first got my drivers license in 2004. Evanston was always the place to head to Friday nights and Buff Joes was the place to hit up for wings. Over the years though, I have found that the faces inside the place haven't changed, but the quality of the wing has. On my last visit, I felt like prices went up, my single order of suicide wings left me half full (in the past I would feel good after 1 single order), and the size of the wings are small compared to other wing establishments. I still like Buffalo Joes and will still eat there every once in a while out of nostalgia, but it would be nice if they invested in some meatier wings.
(3)Amanda T.
My friends from Evanston and the other surrounding North Shore suburbs have been RAVING about Buffalo Joe's for who knows how long. So, naturally, I was more than excited to see what this place was all about. My anticipation grew once we got there after seeing reviews from nationally acclaimed critics posted all up and down the walls. When I took my first bite into the chicken wing, I wasn't impressed. It wasn't bad, but it was pretty much like buffalo wild wings, maybe it had a little more meat, but that's about it. The cheese on the baked potato I got was horrible!! It looked like it was made from concentrated powdered cheese mixed with water. Like the kind that comes with a box of mac and cheese, only worse. Even my high school served better cheese than that! Two of my other friends (who were also Buffalo Joe's virgins) agreed with me. The food is really cheap and the orders are huge, I'll give them that. But it really didn't do it for me. I tried my best to like Buffalo Joe's, but I couldn't. Sorry...
(2)Esther Y.
BJ's has been a part of my life since my first visit to Evanston back in the day. Amazing. They are completely no nonsense here. Order your wings, see them toss it in your sauce, order your fries, pick it up, gorge. Of course, eating wings brings out two very distinct competitions to show that you can either eat like a real man (this applies to guys and girls). One competition is who can eat the hottest sauce. Not a good idea. Go for the middle. That way you can still enjoy the wing and you don't have to fill your stomach unnecessarily with your beverage. The second competition is who can eat the most wings. Again, unless there is money riding on it, you can pass. You will end up eating way too much and then hate yourself quietly as you lie in the fetal position.
(5)Kristen L.
Double order of suicide? HELL YES. Buffalo Joe's has the only wings that I will ever crave. Sure the restaurant itself is a bit dated and it can be next to impossible to find seating on any given night, but damnit, are they worth it. The wings themselves are a bit on the smaller side, but they make up for it in how many they give you. The fat-ass in me always gets a double order with buffalo chips (the double order comes with anywhere between 20-25 wings). That paired with some fresh celery and ranch? Makes my mouth salivate just writing about it. On the way back home from a day at the Field Museum with the parentals, papa Lee decided he wanted to stop by and grab some to go. It's about a good 25-30 minute drive from Buff. Joe's to home, but good God they were still delicious (and not soggy) after we go home. The only painful spiciness I would ever put myself through.
(5)Emily C.
Buffalo wings are one of my favorite foods. Quite the opposite of most connoisseurs, I am pretty tolerant to differences in size and flavor. I really haven't met any I didn't like for some reason or another, so naturally, I am inclined to be lenient on wing places. I see the benefits of Hooters, BW3, and likewise, I can speak to the appeal of Buffalo Joe's. You go in and order; the people behind the counter goof with you and give you a hard time in a funny way, which is bascially like spending time with my family and therefore makes me feel at home. They made fun of me for wearing a surf shop shirt in Chicago; haha...point taken. Anyhow, you wait for less than 10 minutes, then you get cardboard containers full of wings with ranch sauce (no bleu cheese, which is their weakest link, if you ask me), and celery. We also ordered the waffle cut cheese fries. The wings? Totally smothered in sauce. Some people on here seem to not like that, but I'm all for it. The hot sauce is a little garlicky and had just enough bite to kick me in the mouth a little without turning me into a Tums commercial. It was pretty darn good to dip celery in after the wings were gone. The ranch? A little thin, but okay. Again, kind of sad there's no bleu cheese but it had a nice flavor at least. The fries? Covered in some kind of bizarro processed cheese that I wanted so badly not to like because it was obviously fake...but failed. The stuff was delicious. It was sort of like EZ Cheez or Velveeta in that it should be gross but it's amazing. I'd go back.
(4)Jon J.
They're the best wings that I've had in Chicago - meaty, properly saucey, and not too fried. Basically, they're perfect! The counter service can be terribly slow, though. But really, it's a divey, greasy, corner of any god's wing-filled heaven. What do you expect? As a funny anecdote, I saw a guy order a pint of ranch sauce here. That's it. NASTY!
(4)TJ W.
Buffalo Joe's got some bangin' chicken wings! This used to be my spot in high school...I often made it a weekly ritual, until I found out that my metabolism isn't as great as it used to be. lol They have a few locations, but I prefer the drive to Evanston rather than going on Howard. Their mild and bbq wings are sick!!!!! If you're a chicken fanatic then Buffalo Joe's is the place!
(5)Dan K.
Stopped in here a while back, because everyone said how authentic their Buffalo wings were. Being a wing snob from Buffalo, I had to check it out. Boy, did they stink. They were small little things, with a sauce that tasted nothing like true Buffalo chicken wings and they served friggin Ranch dressing! I'm sorry, but if you're going to claim to serve authentic Buffalo style chicken wings, you serve Blue Cheese not ranch dressing. Piss-poor in my book.
(1)Chanita S.
I love this place. I don't care what anyone else thinks, but I've been going here since I was in high school--my Friday tradition. I wouldn't compare it to Popeye's because Popeye's isn't saucy fried chicken and they're not necessarily a wing place nor would I compare it to Hooter's because their breading is different. I love BJ's wings though because of their sauce and crispy wings. Their waffle fries are pretty amazing as well. Make sure to bring a bib because you will get sauce all over you which isn't really a bad thing here. The only downside is that they don't accept cash, but there is an ATM machine inside.
(5)Joe H.
I'm giving BJ's a 4 star rating as an average of the 5 star place this place has been to me over the past 20 years and the 3 star place it was the other day when I stopped by. These wings are what I've always measured all buffalo wings I've ever eaten in my life. I LOVE THIS PLACE. But the other day, I didn't love it so much. The sauce had a weird ammonia kind of flavor and the cheese on my chips tasted like they put in more glue than normal. I also hate how expensive it has become. But I still love the place. The place hasn't changed at all! From the floors, tables, benches, bathrooms, and staff (GARY!!!!), it's the same. Kind of like an Evanston time capsule plus inflation.
(4)Annie Y.
I haven't been to Buff Joe's in over 4 years, but I remember their wings being amazing - big, juicy, and cooked to perfection. I've heard since I left Chicago that they've gotten much smaller, so consider the four stars a rating for memories of times past.
(4)Roxanne R.
Yu-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-ummmm!! Hands down best wings in Chicago. You get about 15 or so wings for a single order. The wing sizes are on the small side, just like I like it. I want to eat wings not drumsticks. The sauce is what makes the wings. It perfectly coats the wings and is fantastic. I always get a single order with waffles fries and cheese on the side. Waffle fries are solid. I recommend getting the cheese on the side. The cheese isn't liquidy nacho cheese, this cheese coagulates after a while and it's a nice compliment to the wings. Service is okay and the place isn't very tidy but this isn't fine dining, you come here because the wings are freaking delicious.
(5)Amber J.
Am Huge Buffalo wings fan, could eat them everyday of the week. (And in college i pretty much did). However when i first drove by Buffalo Joe's with friends i was alittle apprehensive. It seemed a little hole -in-the wall-ish and there was a line out the door. When we actually got in there it was crowded as heck with literally no available seating. 2 of us lurked for a open table while the other person ordered. We finally got a 2 seater table though there were three of us. Then i embarked on of the greatest buffalo wing experiences of my life. The flavor, sigh...We ate wing and wings and more wings and thought we were all full we ate even more wings. I highly recommend - the only drawback is limited seating in the restauraunt. I will definetley be back.
(5)Karen K.
It's always fun to come here for a late night dinner with friends. Unfortunately, I've noticed that their wings have gotten even smaller. There was barely any meat and what meat there was on the bones were very tough. The celery that came with our order was not washed well and I was so desperate to combat the saltiness of the wings with the celery that I ended up wiping the dirt off with the napkins.. but gross. The cheese fries were the only thing that made the meal yummy.
(2)David P.
I like the suicide wings with the jalepeno peppers but its a bit of false advertising. The wings aren't over the top spicy but have a good flavor. From this place, I actually prefer the BBQ wings. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and tanginess. As someone from Buffalo, these wings rank pretty high in the Chicago-land area.
(4)Shari F.
Buffalo Joe's in Evanston WILL NEVER AGAIN GET OUR BUSINESS! The manager is so unprofessional and the employees do not inform customers properly about pre-ordering, a horrible place. We have been going there for years and tried to pre-order for Super Bowl and the idiots told us for smaller orders to just come in. We drove in the blizzard and they wouldn't serve us, I will never go to a Buffalo Joe's again and will never recommend them to anyone.
(1)Earlie C.
Wings are still the best in the city, but holy hell. We came in last night and came across the most ghetto, classless workers ever. First, the use of the word "fuck" was used around twenty times while I was waiting for my food. The vulgarity of staff had my brain hurting. Seriously, pull up your damn pants, act like a decent human, and possibly show me that your vocabulary consists of more than "fuck, shit, and motherfucker". My girlfriend ordered a polish. We both witnessed a female take a reject order (a polish that was sitting out in a basket when we first arrived - for how long?) back on the grill for about a minute and serve us that dog. Come on Buffalo Joe's... Just make sure you go when the owner is there. I'd question ever ordering food from this establishment again if he was not present.
(1)Stacy H.
Suicide wings are soooo good.. I only like boneless wings but I make an exception for these. The waffle fries are good too. Can be a little salty but I just always have lots of water near by!!
(5)Alana H.
Aside from the loud obnoxious and inappropriate conversation taking place by the staff. The chicken was amazing. The waffle fries were not as good as they were hyped up to be however the chicken makes the long drive and rude service worth it.
(4)BforBulky B.
Just went! The buffalo wings are great. I'm not sure I'd trek all the way out there again for the wings, BUT I WOULD FOR THE COOKIES. And the ranch dip. If you're in this part of town, definitely stop by. If you're in Chicago, R.J. Grunts wings are delish.
(4)Emma R.
If I could give this place no stars, I would. I have not been to this place since I was in high school. My family and I happen to be in the area and I had the bright idea of having wings. So down to Buffalo Joes we go. The girl in the front was the best part of experience here. Over All cleanliness of this place is just gross! They got one of our drinks wrong, my husband goes to the front to change it. The girls pours it, coughs in her hand and with that hand that she coughed in, grabs the lid puts it on the cup and hands it to my husband. Gross!!! I am surprised people eat here, and that this place has not been shut down because it's dirty.
(1)Buttermilk P.
Very good wings. My wife and I try to grab a bite at Joe's whenever we are in Evanston. We normally order their wings with mild sauce and waffle cheese fries. They have three main levels of sauce which are all the same, mild, spicy and suicide. The difference is, the mild is only a coating of sauce, the spicy gives you a bit more and the suicide adds sliced jalapeno peppers. The sauce is really good, and since everything is made to order, the wings are usually hot and fresh. They don't give you very many fries, but the cheddar cheese sauce is also very good. In typical north side/north shore fashion, everything is overpriced and a la carte. We are used to Harold's, where chicken comes with fries, coleslaw and bread. That would cost an extra $50 here, and the prices you pay here would get you triple the amount of food at a south side establishment. However, it is a bit of a different take on wings, so we pay a visit every blue moon. Cash only.
(5)Rene S.
Wings are really good (not as good as Franks for the Memories in Mundelein, but that is too far away). They are small but the portion size is huge so it is worth what you get. There are only three sauce levels: mild, spicy and suicide. I wanted medium and was directed by the woman who took my order that the spicy would be a good alternative. It was. So why only 4 stars if the wings are good? No credit cards, no delivery, and the cardinal sin for a wing joint .... NO BLUE CHEESE dressing! While I can cross the street to the Jewel and get some blue cheese dressing, no delivery is a big problem. They are going to lose a lot of business, including mine, by not offering delivery. On a nice summer evening in the summer, not a problem to walk the mile to get to the place. But if the weather is at all bad, I often order delivery so I don't have to go out if I'm running low on groceries. Too bad I can't order from here!
(4)Lucy F.
Great wings!!!! Simply, Delicious, nice crunchy texture and the mild sauce is just great! Make sure you don't come on the weekend since the place is always so pack.
(4)Kyle D.
Dear Evanston, you've got a serious impairment when it comes to evaluating wing joints. Not sure what's going on here. Buffalo Joe's is a 4 star wing joint? C'mon. Is this some kind of romantic/nostalgic thing? The result of underdeveloped undergrad taste buds? First, this place is f'ing D.I.R.T.Y. The dining area is dirty. So is the kitchen. Every time those kitchen doors opened we were smacked in the face with a nasty odor. And the wings suck. They go nuts with the corn starch. Corn starch has no place on wings. They damn sure don't need to look like they've been breaded in it. And the mild sauce is it sweet? WHY is it sweet? Call it sweet sauce, because it has no resemblance to a buffalo sauce. Fries were ok. Ranch was lame. Nothing redeeming about this place.
(1)Emily P.
Suicide wings with cheddar fries are a must! (The burn in the bathroom later is worth it; trust me...haha sorry for the TMI)!
(4)Eileen S.
Seriously good wings. I always get the buffalo wings with mild sauce and cheddar chips (waffles fries smothered in cheese sauce). Ranch is tasty as well. Sure its not the most beautiful place to eat, but that's not why I go. Beware: you will become addicted to these wings!
(5)Sallie H.
The spicy wings were pretty good, I'm not a fan of wings so I can't really get excited about them. The one thing I can honestly say was terrible there was the cheese fries. I believe the cheese was made out of powder, idk it was just gross. I had to scrape the cheese off my fries because it was so disgusting. The cheese at 7-Eleven for the nachos are 10 times better than what Buffalo Joe's offered. The buffalo fries are very good, i wished they had real cheese to go with it :-(
(2)Christine M.
Awful. Awful. Awful. Half way through our meal we found a long black hair melted in our cheese fries.
(1)Will B.
Total collapse of the brand they built over the years. I've been going there for over 27 years. These days it is really bad. Watery teriyaki, under cooked fries, and the worst wings I've seen in a long time.
(1)Brad S.
Going back to my days in high school, over 20 years ago, I've always been a big fan of the place. Went there for lunch on Friday with a friend from high school, trying to re-live the good old days. I was shocked at the quality of the wings themselves. They were so small and tiny. Wish I had taken a picture at the time to post on here. It also drives me crazy that they nickel and dime you for every little thing. Who charges for a cup of water?!?! They do. The reason they get 2 rather than 1 stars is the people were quite friendly, even offering up free samples of split pea soup, and the sauce itself was quite tasty. Hopefully it was just a bad batch of wings but have to say I was awfully disappointed in the place.
(2)Gabriel S.
I've been coming to Buffalo Joes since the early 90s. The wings are still the best in the world in my opinion. The perfect blend of meat and crispy skin with absolutely amazing sauce.
(5)Kevin C.
When I was an undergrad at NU I lived a few blocks away and would get the same order of wings and buffalo chips every couple of weeks. When I moved away, despite searching high and low, I could never find a wing place that matched the buff. So when I came back to Chicago for work, frequent pilgrimages to buff joes were a must. It still hits the spot every time.
(5)Shalem A.
Buff Joes is an Evanston staple, and they offer the best wings in Evanston. This is not health food, but at least once a month I'll grab a single suicide for lunch. It is good for the soul. They also have awesome waffle fries and solid burgers, but if you're coming here for the first time, make sure you try the wings. The staff can be a little "sassy" at times, but it's part of their schtick, don't take it personally.
(4)Randall K.
Not the cleanest place, but one of my top 5 places to eat. They have my favorite buffalo wings. In Buff-Joes language, I usually order a double suicide with cheddar chips and a gut-buster RC. What that really means is a double order of wings, spicy with jalapeños too. Waffle fries loaded with a creamy cheddar cheese sauce. A large Royal Crown soda. The wings come with little ranch cups and some celery. Mini napkins are on the table. The area is nice and close to northwestern university. It can have it's share of pan-handlers sometimes, but because of the area, they are usually non - aggressive. If someone asked me for my best wing place, it is definitely Buffalo Joes.
(5)Lefai K.
The wings of the place is awesome! You won't find lots of flavors like you would at bw3, just mild, spicy, and suicide. The breading is not too much, but the crisp was perfect. =============================== And now my signature bathroom review! =============================== the place itself is kind of a hole in the wall. That being said, I didn't expect too much from it. And it's pretty much true. It's a place to take a leak, and then get the f out. So sit or squat? Squat... And flush the toilet by kicking the toilet handle down, because gawd knows what's touch that toilet handle
(4)Alexander W.
Double Suicide, Mega RC. Perfection.
(5)Jeff H.
Fun and cheap wings place for those that don't want that big chain down the street. #cheapeats
(4)Faye D.
Oooh Buff Joes... My favorite place to eat in Evanston. The wangs are thee bomdiggidy and the cheese waffle fries. Mmm. Con: Kind of dirty and they don't accept cards. Oh well big whoop right? The best wings place for me so far.
(4)Miles S.
Best wings I have had so far in the northern hemisphere. Great atmosphere and good people. Not a lot of flavors, but not needed. Great burgers and chicken. A must try .
(5)Orlando H.
First thing I get walking in is a rude cashier. Went in 15 min before they closed and she was quick to say "we're closed we have nothing left". They should change their closing time to 1145 not midnight.
(1)AJ M.
This place used to be my spot for wings. At one point I would even go as far to say the best wings I ever had. The sauce is amazing, wings so cripsy like none other. Although still pretty good it's not as good as it used to be. Prices have jumped alot over the years, I remember when a double order used to be around $9 now $14. The waffle fries are still a guilty pleasure that doesn't disappoint. They only take cash, well worth the occasional visit!!
(4)Jamie H.
Came in today for lunch because I've heard the wings were amazing. I tried the mild and the hot; mild was awesome but the hot I wasn't too crazy about. Was a pretty standard hot sauce. You get a pretty decent price for the amount and because the mild was so good I plan to come back and try the suicide sauce the waffle cheese fries.
(4)Gina T.
By far the best wings I've ever tried EVER. The only reason I give them four stars instead of five is because it looks dirty and smells. And even with all that going on ill still eat there. Other than that the wings are amazingly delicious. Very crispy. I got the mild wings and the sauce is sort of sweet but it's nothing less than scrumptious. The waffle fries are fresh and tasty. I'm a ranch lover. Ill have ranch with anything and buff joes ranch is the best ranch I've ever had. I wish they would clean up the place a bit. That's the only complaint I have.
(4)Jane Y.
OH MY WORD. the wings here are DELICIOUS UGHAS;LDIFAH;SLDIFH i always crave these things and then GET SLAPPED IN THE FACE BY REALITY because... its a bit of a drive for me to get here but just thinking about these wonderful heavenly saucy tastey oh not so little wings goodness gracious and the CHEDDAR CHIPS screw diets and if ur gonna cheat might as well make it a WORTHY CHEAT COME TO BUFFALO JOESS!
(5)Mark K.
This was Sweetie's favorite wing place in Chicago, so I had to stop by on the way through last week. Especially after she forbade me to stop at any BBQ places on the south side... Nice little college-town wing joint. Looks really small, but once you order you see there's a bigger room in back to eat. Service was efficient and friendly. Order sizes are big- I got a single and worried that it would be enough, but it was plenty. Nice meaty wings, good sauce (I got BBQ.) I got a side of celery, which was also good sized. Between a few veggies, lots of wings, and some RC, I was fully satisfied. Can't wait to go back.
(4)Vealy C.
The wings were terrific, the service isn't that bad. The "ghetoness" of the place adds to the experience, but the bathrooms.. ohhh, they're always so dirty. My hands still feel dirty even after washing them.
(3)Frank Y.
You are either a fan or a hater; there are no in-betweens when it comes to Buf Joes. I am a fan. When people complain, they tend to say that the wings are too small; but I love them. The sauce makes these wings. It is kind of sweet, thick, and has just enough spice. The wings, because, they are small, are crunchy on the outside and perfectly sauced. The ranch that Buf Joe's has is awesome! It is very easy to get addicted to these wings. When our sons come back to Evanston, one of the first things that they crave is Buffalo Joes. For a family of four, we get a double-order of spicy and a double-order of mild wings. The waffle fries are also yummy when you dip them in the ranch dressing. If you want a burger in Evanston, go to Edzo's. If, however, you want wings, nothing compares to Buf Joes.
(4)Gautram W.
First and last time! I wonder did they fried the wings in oil or grease..... Horrible horrible horrible.... The burger as well was dipped in oil/ grease or whatever.....
(1)Renya M.
The food here is amazing and the service isn't bad either except for this one douchebag who actually cooks and prepares the orders. I'm sorry that he feels his job is so difficult, bagging wings and taking people orders, really, I am. Id be miserable if I looked and acted anything like him too. This guy was rude to everyone in line though, do yourselves a favor and go to any other location if you care at all about servers doing even the absolute least in terms of being polite.
(2)Rod D.
Still loving Buf Joes as the wife and I continue visit on a frequent basis. Remember to ask for well done if you like your wings crispy
(5)Sharon C.
Everyone always raves abut Buff Joe's being the best wings in Evanson, but I honestly don't see it - I typically order the wings mild and they have this really funky aftertaste. The fries are soggy, and the burgers are literally dripping oil through the paper trays. I'll pass.
(2)Z S.
So good. This is my guilty pleasure food. The wings are so good and saucy, while the burgers are enormous and very greasy. (The special Buff Joe's sauce mixed with mustard and ketchup is heaven.) All variations of the chips/fries are really crispy and flavorful. So while the food is a little unhealthy, you've got to treat yourself once in a while.
(4)Don T.
Still after all these years, my favorite buffalo wings place in the Chicagoland area!
(5)Cyril L.
Buffalo Joe's has some of the best wings. My first time was last month and they tasted really good. Make sure to get the sauce. For a low price, you can get a basket full of wings. It's worth the wait.
(4)Meredith C.
My first impression was very poor. The girl taking my order was so incredibly rude, I immediately regretted my choice to eat here when there are literally 50 restaurants in this area. Rolled her eyes when asked questions, spoke barely above a mumble, when asked her to repeat herself she basically shouted at me. Really, really, rude first impression. She of course entered our order incorrectly. Wrong food came. However, the other members of the staff quickly fixed her mistake and we're exceptionally polite and cheerful. Food was really, really good. Best wings ever. Fries are great. All of the food was outstanding. Felt a little like we were eating out of our laps, maybe give some plates out with wings? When we left staff said goodbye, very polite. Made up for little miss sunshine that took our order. Try it out. Food is really amazing. Cash Only but there is an ATM. They do serve a few beers, also.
(3)Michael G.
Simply the best. I made an hour round trip to get these wings. I usually do once every 3 weeks. I crave this place weekly. I wish I was skinny and could eat these wings every week. Standard order is Double Order Suicide (gotta have the jalapeños), cheddar chips (never get cheese on the side, the fries need to be covered in cheese!!!), and a bowl of cheddar broccoli (when you are waiting for your food ask for a sample If they already haven't offer it to you).
(5)Nari L.
Love this place! Came here years ago with a friend when I was in college and I loved it! I recently came back here years later since the last time and I still loved it! The food is fast so you can come and eat here in a jiffy.
(5)Jim K.
Been going here for more than 25 years. No change in order: Double order wings, Cheddar chips, and gutbuster lemonade. Why mess with perfection?
(5)Tian Y.
Not really a picky wing-eater, and I'm good with their sauces. The wings are kind of small though compared to other places nearby, and I prefer the big and juicy ones with meat. Don't be surprised by poor customer service here.
(3)Michael W.
You could not BELIEVE how much I love this place... To paraphrase... These wings are more full than Donald Trump at a Las Vegas strip buffet, with sauce sassier than Ellen DeGeneres, and so meaty they had to bring in a weatherman to evaluate it. Let me just be upfront and say that the wings are not boneless and are actually smaller than the average wing, but the upside of that is that the surface area to volume ratio on these wings is ri-DICK (any one of my AP Bio homies know what's up!!!), which makes for some outrageously saucy wings. Also, they give you celery sticks! Celery sticks are fantastic, it's literally portable water, but in solid form! I actually have a patent pending for a booze canteen that's made out of celery. The idea is that when you get a hangover after a heavy night of drinking, you can eat the canteen the next morning for a refreshing, fibrous jolt of hydration (hit me up if you're interested, but I already got a lot of investors lined up). Okay, one last thing. The one weird thing about it is that the urinals have ice in them. Ice! What is this, Soviet Russia*? I personally will not use any product with a molar mass less than or equal to 18, so this was especially problematic for me (sorry about your sink, Buff Joe's) *fun fact: In Soviet Russia, you were only allowed to buy water in ice form. In fact, the premise behind the "Cold War" was that the Soviets were trying to freeze the world's water supply (for that Russian +1 mobility buff in cold). That's why the United States detonated so many nuclear bombs back then, to keep the earth warm. Down with commies!
(5)Donald S.
I love these wings (spicy. The barbecue don't count seeing as its only Sweet Baby Ray's), and I judge all other buffalo wings by these. They have beer on tap and consistently great wings whichever sauce you get (mild, spicy, suicide, or BBQ). Single, spicy, extra ranch & celery, with an order of the buffalo chips ( waffle fries...), and a Berghoff means your in buisness.
(5)Jessica D.
My favorite food is spicy chicken and DING DING DING. Buffalo Joes has won the key to my heart and stomach. My mouth waters just thinking about it. I have pregnant cravings and I'm not even pregnant. If I were getting the death penalty, this would be my last meal. I can never stop myself from buying more than what can fit in my belly.
(5)Marci G.
Sorry Joe, but I am done with Buffalo Joe's :( Sad to say. The last few years the wings have just gone way down hill and I just keep hoping the next time I go (once a year) the wings will be delish again, but sad to say they are not. I don't know why they changed the recipe, but they have not been the same for a long time now. I actually left there tonight and wondered if Joe was still alive, because I cannot imagine him being alive and him allowing his restaurant to go this far downhill. The worst part is........it is so filthy in there, I am shocked that the health dept has not come in and faulted them into cleaning the place up. So many bugs flying around in there, it's hard to eat your food. And the bathroom.....OH MY GOSH, GROSS! It was filthy last year when I went and this time.....horrible ( seriously, blood on the tiles!) I grew up on Buffalo Joe's. I have been eating there since the mid '80's. If you are around Joe, please put some money back into it and clean it up and get your food back up to the excellent tasty level it used to be in. Bye for now.
(1)Asia C.
The BEST wings in the chicago area! I've been ordering wings from them for years! I always usually order a single order of suicide. Also, this location is the best. Coming in second is Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. is last. I can tell the difference in how each location prepares the wings.
(5)Hersh A.
This place doesn't do much for me any more. Menu variety it's relatively good for what the place is. I mostly care for having wings here. I have been here a handful of times in the past. Back in the 90's I used to like their wings, especially the suicide kind but at some point something changed (I guess their recipe?) that the suicide wings have not been the same. They taste average at best. Also what I didn't like recently is that the order taking person said you get 12 wings in single order and we got our order we were shorted a few wings. When I asked about it, one of the persons behind the counter said that the wing amount is never exact but more like 10-12. Wtf? That's just dumb. I don't think I had such a problem in the past. I don't care for the cash only affect of it. Oh well, I don't desire to come here again anytime in the foreseeable future. There are better wings place out there.
(2)James H.
I'm happy to see a lot of 4 and 5-star reviews for Buffalo Joe's. But it's pretty clear all of them are from people under 22 or who know so little about wings that they feel the need to make clear that these are bone-in wings (as if boneless wings are actually wings or should even be in the discussion of what makes a great wing). Anyhow, 10 or 15 years ago, I would have given Buffalo Joe's an emphatic 5 starts. It was unrivaled for the best wings in the Chicago area. But the wings keep getting smaller, the preparation keeps getting sloppier, and the restaurant keeps getting dirtier. They're not bad and I might go back if I lived in Evanston but my Buffalo Joe's days are done.
(2)Danny M.
I live 30 minutes from this place and I will still make the drive here for their wings. They have the best mild and spicy wings I have ever eaten. The wings have gotten a lot smaller than they use to be, but it is still good. The sauce on the wing is perfect, not too spicy were it kills your taste buds. Get the wings with waffle fries and you will not be disappointed.
(5)Heather K.
Love this place!! It's food that you get acquainted too while living here. Love the rib tips cause their bbq sauce is a little more on the sweeter side. And their wings...are nice and tangy!! Great combo with the ranch and celery sticks! Simple and easy option just to grab a bite to eat.
(5)Jung K.
want spicy buffalo wings? look no further and stop by the Buffalo Joe's on Clark st. Order: single suicides with chips and a large drink. If suicides are too spicy, then get out. The regular spicy ones are good too.. They have their system on lock down. Order your food, pick up your food, pay in cash only, and go demolish those wings.
(5)Scotty D.
I went here after a friend told me these were the best wings in the Chicago area. I love wings. I can confidently say these are the best wings in the Chicago area. 8 bucks for 10 wings is a great deal. The spicy sauce is great. Just enough heat. Even the mild my wife had was good. The wings are cooked perfectly, nice and crunchy. Even the ranch tastes better than other places. The waffle fries are great but I'd stay away from the cheese sauce. It was very salty and congealed quickly which ruined the fries. Wouldn't get them again. But if you want good wings, man this is the place.
(5)Kristen D.
This place FAR surpasses any place like BDubs. The wings are HUGE, you get a lot of them with one order, and there is enough sauce on each wing to still have enough to lick off your fingers. (I feel like in all of my wing experiences, there is never enough sauce to go with the meat. NOT the case here!) They give you an order of celery and ranch with a wing order, which was one of my favorite things about this place. My only complaint is that it is HOT in this restaurant...but that could also be from the huge friers and grills up in the front of the restaurant.
(5)Kevin S.
Great taste and good people. Best wings so far anywhere
(5)Aldi J.
My go to wing place!!! Best buffalo sauce. Just get spicy or suicide please. Don't be weak and go mild. Growing up in nearby Skokie, my friends and I would head over here and pig out on the regular. I'm a bit disappointed though because the wings over time have gotten smaller... anyone else notice this? C'mon bring the bigger wings back. Sorry, this was the reason for my one star deduction. Some things never change though. When I arrive at a party and see a party pan, my mouth starts watering I know what I'm attacking first. Don't forget the awesome waffle fries!!
(4)Ryne D.
I've been here many times before, but on my last trip to Northwestern this weekend to do an interview, the only thing on my mind was getting these wings. They have that much control over me. Ok, sure they're tiny, but they're damn tasty. And since a single order gets you around a dozen of these bad boys, you should be good with just that - even though I usually get double orders anyway. What puts this location over the other ones are their cheddar chips - waffle fries with Cheese Whiz-ish sauce dumped on top. So delicious, provided you finish them off before the cheese morphs back into its semi-solid state. Never had anything else from here - I'm good with my suicide wings, thanks.
(5)Ed L.
My friends had nothing but great things to say about this place so i had to go check it out with them. Needless to say I left wanting to come back more and more often and thinking about the years wasted not coming here. My friends say that they raised the prices but a double order of wings and two orders of fries only cost about $20.02 with tax. Which isn't bad if you split it with someone. The waffle fries are crispy and tasty but to be honest next time i come here I'm getting a double order for myself. I love that they can mix sauces together and the spicy barbecue is the way to go in my opinion. The sauce makes my mouth water every time i think about it and adding jalapenos to the wings is icing to the cake. You will definitely be visited by me more than once in the coming month and if your in the Evanston neighborhood i would definitely consider checking them out.
(5)Hannah P.
My mouth is watering waiting for our order. I worked out just so I can pig out today! Suicide Please.
(4)Danny W.
A meal of a single order, cheddar chips and a mega-gut RC is now $13.65. What happened to you Buff Joe's? You used to be so beautiful.
(1)Tom M.
My favorite spot to grab some wings. I take a detour into downtown Evanston or hit the one on Green Bay if I'm craving Rib Tips every so often to get my fix. When I lived in Evanston, this was a regular stop for me. Now that I'm farther away, my times between visits has lengthened which my doctor appreciates. I highly recommend!
(5)Danny B.
In my opinion, these are the best wings in the world.... ** IF YOU ARE NOT A BONE-IN WING LOVER, THIS MAY NOT BE YOUR PLACE!!** But for the rest of us who have a wing obsession and could care less about the decor this place is highly recommended!!
(4)Christine N.
Oh, Buff Joes. You are so conveniently located across the street from my college condo, tempting me everyday as I pass by to go to class, walk to downtown evanston, go visit a friend, walk to work... You haven't failed... Yet. I have this disgusting fear that one day I'll walk in, and it just won't be that good. Unfortunately, the wings have indeed gotten smaller since my first taste. But I must go on with the wonders of this wing. It's fried. It's not good for you. But oh... It's good. Something this good can't be THAT bad, can it? Ok fine. These chicken wings are not just fried. They are crispy. CRISPY, I tell you. Take a bite and CRUNCH! And then you get chicken. This is the disappointing part. I wish the chicken was more succulent inside, but it can't be when the wings are small. The sauce. Yum. We get spicy and it's the perfect amount of heat. Not a fan of the excess sauce on the bottom with the last few wings that are swimming in the sauce. And the celery sticks are usually warm. But I still am loyal to you, Buff Joes. I will always eat you because you are just that good. Also, the suicide wings are basically just the spicy flavor with jalapeños added. Skip the suicide. Take taste over heat. Word.
(4)Elliott C.
attention buffalo joe's on clark street......please clean up that disgusting men bathroom and hire friendlier ppl to work there WHO VALUE CUSTOMER SERVICE. i can no longer take Lacresha and them attitude. First bad experience on November 3rd 2013 p.s. the wing are still the best!
(3)Leonard P.
the chicken was delicious. I love coming here with friends and family. big fan of waffle fries and it hit's the spot when it comes to craving for chicken. the littel down side is how they don't accept card. Other than that, the food is fine and the atmostphere is pretty chill.
(4)Ashley C.
We made the trip up here for the buffalo wings and because of the 4 stars on yelp. Disappointment to say the least. It started from the phone call to see what there hours were on the 4th of July. The girl picked up the phone and with attitude says, "the usual hours we're open." When had to ask what those were, she replied with the time after uttering an "uhhhh." That got me off to a really bad start. So we tried the buffalo wings (spicy), the burger, and the cheese fries. Cheese fries were average. The burger was average. The patty itself was good, but the toppings were average and didn't taste super fresh. The buffalo wings - average. I would have liked them crispier - the sauce was decent. Oh yes -and they had RC as their pop. As a diet coke/pepsi addict, this just did not quench my thirst on the blistering hot day. Average food + employees with attitude + drive to Evanston = not worth the trip.
(2)Stephanie C.
Best wing place ever! My uncle had introduced me to this hole on the wall. It's not a super clean place. However the food is amazing. I love boned in wings and the flavors for the wings are perfectly seasoned. I love the mild wings the best. I cannot rave about this place enough..
(5)Bethany A.
If you're looking for classic wings with classic sides, this place is the best. Their wings come out piping hot, lightly fried, and doused in just enough sauce. The sauce is tangy and spicy (or not, you have options) and it's seriously finger-licking good. I love munching on some celery sticks on the side and their waffle fries are pretty good as well. It's an awesome place to come with friends (order the party platter and dig in!). Yum, so glad that it's near campus.
(4)Al D.
While I love the wings, cheddar burger with its creamy cheddar spread, plus the waffle fries, that's about it on the love for this Buffalo Joe's. I recently had some of their spicy chicken fingers, and they were nearly inedible. The chicken tasted spongy and off, and the breading was akin to rubber. Also on my last visit, I had their famous cheddar burger, but with grilled onions. Bad mistake. About 3/4 lb of undercooked, thick, white onions slid off the burger in a huge pool of grease; nasty. I think most of the five-star reviews are based on nostalgia. Buffalo Joe's is looking old, dirty and worn-out now. I'd maybe go here again for wings, but that's about it.
(3)Derek D.
I have talked about merkts cheddar before and this place does it RIGHT! WINGS : Amazing every time with a good sauce to wing ratio. un-breaded as well - CRUCIAL. I love the vinegar and butter mild sauce. never had the guts to go hotter. Fries. Well done Buff Chips are the way to go. The cheese is best if you order 2 so you can dip Every fry with JUST enough of it. LOVE YOU BUFF JOES! d
(5)Jeff W.
There's only one place I'll ever go for wings anymore and that's Buff Joe's. I grew up in Evanston and having been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. After college, I took a job that involved significant travel across the country. There is no place in the country like Buff Joe's. You'll see numerous awards on the walls from different cooking events they've won - their sauce just can't be beat. My favorite burger of all time is actually from Buff Joe's. It's called the Buffalo Cheddar Burger and has a grilled patty with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato, Merkt's cheddar, and then Buff Joe's wing sauce - whichever hotness you desire. It's AMAZING! No place has come close to replicating such an amazing creation. Some negatives are that they only take cash (not even debit card) and the place is located in downtown Evanston and parking is usually pretty difficult to find. While there are tables, there are very few so I suggest getting it to go and bringing it home.
(5)Sevun H.
The wings and waffle fries were just as good as they were when I was a student and used to eat Buffalo Joes 4 days out of the week! The two girls who greeted me when I walked in were another story all together. They both had very nasty attitudes and seemed to be very unhappy with their jobs. One seemed much more interested in telling her co-worker about her previous nights Hennessy drinking exploits than providing anything remotely resembling customer service. Being eyeballed from head to toe by two immature, insecure, unprofessional employees is not welcome when I am spending my hard earned dollars on overpriced wings and fries. Will not be back. I will just cherish my memories of Buffalo Joes when the service was just as good as the food!
(2)Mary M.
Always an Evanston favorite. I'm not a huge "chicken on the bone" kind of person, but this place brings wings to a whole new level. If you like spicy...even just a little bit, you have to get the hot or suicide wings. Cheddar chips are a must! Not to mention, the ranch dressing you get with the wings is hands down my favorite.
(5)Viki N.
When you're feeling low, or lost in life, don't turn to Jesus, turn to Buffalo Joe's! (At least that's what I do.) I have been addicted to Buffalo Joe's for over 15 years. No matter how much I try to forget them, the taste of their wings keeps coming back up in my mind, and I am compelled to make the pilgrimage to Evanston once again. My personal drug of choice here is a single order of suicide wings, spicy cheddar chips, and 2 extra orders of celery and ranch. Nothing can make me happier, and nobody's wings come close to having as much flavor as Buffalo Joe's. (and I've tried, a lot, to find someone even half as good so I don't have to drive all the way up to Evanston again. But no such luck.) So, I recommend stuffing yourself full of wings, and then catching a movie at the movie theatre down the street, or at one of the film festivals they have at Northwestern. Happiness coming into every orifice!
(5)Julia J.
I've only eaten take out of Buffalo Joes, and I wasn't the one who picked up the food, so I can't speak to the service or condition of the restaurant itself. The wings, though, were delicious- not the largest wings, but certainly not the smallest either. The sauce was really good. I was full from the smallest order. We also ordered the Spicy Cheddar Chips, which were messy and horrible for you, so they were pretty much one of the most delicious concoctions I've ever had.
(3)Mike T.
Not impressed with this place at all... The wings are so so at best and the staff is always cranky. This is a good place for college kids that have a limited pallet, or are to drunk to know what they are eating is sub par.
(2)Kareem A.
Place is a mess... ghetto service, thought they're gonna kick me in the face if I ordered one more thing. Their 'boneless wings' are basically chicken tenders refried just to be warm when served. The BBQ sauce is so average I wasn't sure why the place is so famous.. Maybe because it's by NU in the middle of downtown Evanston, who knows? Give them a try, you might have a different opinion.
(2)Brian K.
FAMOUS FOR: - Buffalo Wings (8/10) Ah BJ's. My education in Buffalo Wings. Brings back great memories, because just about every party and get together in jr. high and high school (when hanging with my North Burbs friends) involved a double party platter of Suicide wings. It was also a much more innocent time where someone would mention BJ's, and instantly, everybody's ears would perk up, eyes would widen, a giggle would pursue, and then everyone was thinking the same thing...mmmm Buffalo Joe's. It also brings back 1 painful memory. They once had a limited time sauce called "XXX" which, after 4 wings, made me cry, drool, and drip from my nose. I downed an entire jug of Ocean Spray Ruby Red juice. It probably wasn't the best thing, but it was college and that was the only thing I had. Yeah...let's not do that again. THE WINGS The only way I ever have them is Suicide. It's not that spicy. Ok, I know this is coming from a Korean guy who's done a ghost chili wing challenge, but still... Put it this way, it's not anywhere near Mango Habanero at BW3 and not even as hot as Three Mile Island at Hooters. Not sure what else to compare it to. It comes with pickled jalapeno slices all over the top, but even those aren't that bad. I usually don't even break a sweat. They're very small wings, about than the length of a grown man's pinky. They're not battered, but do have a crispy skin (at least around the edges). It's drenched in a traditional buffalo type sauce, but it's their secret recipe. "Traditional" meaning that it's kinda like the Louisana hot sauce. You know, kinda salty, with a small kick. In my High School days, I couldn't get enough of these wings! I'd give them 5 stars everyday! Then now, in my post college days, these guys are hit 'n' miss, almost exactly 50/50. Sometimes I go, and I get my single order of suicide wings and fries, and they're just "pretty good." Sometimes I go, and all the lights go on and the choir sings and I'm basking in nostalgia and it just tastes so damn good! That's why I can only give it 8 stars, because it's not consistent. I've only been there maybe 5 times since college (I'd run outta fingers and toes trying to count between HS & College), so I don't know if I'm just changing or my mood affects the taste (although I don't recall ever being in any different moods), or what. It's just not consistent for me. ALL IN ALL I would never pass up an opportunity for BJ's. It's very rare that I'm ever in Evanston, so if we get the chance, it's always BJ's. Oh yeah...CASH ONLY! Even if you're buying hundreds of dollars of double party platters....It's CASH ONLY!
(4)Matthew B.
Best buffalo wings on north shore and maybe in Chicago.
(5)Amir L.
I've been going here for over 15 years and it's one of the staples that started my obsession with wings!! Gotta rock the cheddar chip all day with the gut RC !!
(5)Nishan P.
Not everyone will love Buffalo Joe's. If you don't like sucking on bones, if you don't like the texture of skin, if you can't handle messy; Buffalo Joe's might not be for you. If these things don't bother you, you'll probably find Buffalo Joe's quite delightful. I know other reviewers have called Buffalo Joe's "filthy", "embarrassing" and "disgusting" but I have always been extremely satisfied. If you're not sure whether you would like Buffalo Joe's and need someone to try it out with, give me a holler. I am always up for Buffalo Joe's.
(4)Luke S.
Their wings are good - close to real good. Their waffle fries are good - also close to real good. Their service is typically horrific and it's really expensive for what you get.
(3)An P.
Famed and acclaimed, Buffalo Joe's is an anchor in Evanston and a primary contributor to the Northwestern freshman 15. You'll hear tales of its wonder and glory from all over but sometimes you just have to see it to believe it. I've made a few trips to Buffalo Joe's over the years and never counted it as a legendary wing....until now. On the latest edition of Get Yo Wing On, I waited in line and a brilliant idea came to my head, what if I ordered Buffalo Joe's wings extra well done?! Extra well done? Hell yes they made me a batch!!! The wait is comedic, you'll see people running off with their score with trays filled to the brim with wings, cheddar waffle fries, and the All-American celery with batches of ranch and bleu cheese. Lacking the glitz and glamour of fancier trappings, you'll find Buffalo Joe's with the charm of any greasy spoon you'll find across America sprinkled with a tinge of intoxicating wing aroma. The concept is simple: freshly cooked wings laced with some of the best wing sauces you'll find in the city. Wings come in mild, spicy, BBQ, and if they like you they'll make some spicy BBQ. More spice-addicted souls can try their suicide wings laced with jalapenos but your ears might be left blowing out billows of smoke! These wings are lilliputian in stature but what they lack in size they compensate with volume and honest to goodness flavor. I've always found the wing sauce exceptionally delicious with a little extra kick to leave your mouth watering but veritably, I find myself a texture freak. I love texture on my food so when I got my wings extra well done and brought it back to the table my eyes lit up. The first bite was the best bite as I finally figured out the puzzle and unlocked the greatness of Buffalo Joe's at last. Extra well done means extra tasty crispy to the beat of my drum. You're going to find yourself wanting to come back for another visit to this Evanston wingery, and you just have to figure out what wing is best for you, but don't let me be the judge - take a bite out that for yourself!
(5)Albert M.
Omg! Just left this place with two of my friends, absolutely disgusting! Decor was a mess, a hooters demolished! Just weird! I wouldn't recommend this place to my worst enemy!
(1)Robert G.
Obsessed. I love the fact that a restaurant can do business the same way for 20 years and still have a huge fan base. Want a coke or diet coke? Too bad. We only have RC Cola. Want to pay with plastic? Sorry, cash only. Obviously, Buffalo Joe's is doing something right, because they continue to crank out amazing, delicious, greasy, fantastic food. The house made sauces were incredible. Mild sauce was just the perfect amount of heat with that signature Buffalo buttery-ness. I had the chicken tenders: cooked PERFECTLY! Crisp and crunchy on the outside, juicy and tender on the inside. Waffle cut fries and a Diet Rite rounded out the meal. My friends tried out some of the various chicken sandwiches, which looked phenomenal (and the general consensus was that they were). This is most definitely an Evanston institution, and you would be remiss if you didn't stop by when in town.
(4)Gaby C.
Maybe its just me, but i've eaten here 5 times in two weeks. The wings are the best ever!!! I love love love the wings here. The sauces (hot or mild) are just right, not too spicy not to sweet not too tangy, just riight. They have a few locations in Evanston, but I like the one on Clark.
(5)Jennifer E.
Oh my chicken wing goodness! I got the double order of hot wings plus waffle fries and it was sooooo good and sooooo cheap. I wish I live closer to one of the locations! Dear Buffalo Joe's owner - please open more locations in Chicago (preferably in the Lincoln Square neighborhood)
(5)Phill C.
Oh boy, what else can I say other than "double sui with waffle cheese fries please". Back in the good old days, me and my highschool buddies would all pitch in for a double suicide party pan with lots of ranch. Just thinking about the food makes my mouth water as I type. The roughest part is standing to the side, waiting for your order. Just watching them make the wings, while you stand there is pure torture. They have such unique and of course delicious wings. Deep fried crispy in what looks like no batter or breading at all, then swirled around in large bowl containing a combination of buttery hot sauce. Crispy but not crunchy chicken wings with a unique butter hot sauce... and I always get the suicide loaded with jalapenos. One of my favorite places for wings.
(4)Fletcher G.
I hate to be a nay sayer but Buffalo Joes didn't hold up to all of the "glorious" reviews. You end up paying a bit more then Buffalo Wild Wings prices but far less then Buffalo Wild Wings quality. I was extremely disappointed in this place!
(2)AJ K.
I can't say anything here that hasn't already been said. I just want to lend my enthusiastic support. Been going here 12 years, from high school to having them cater my best friend's baby shower. I love it here.
(5)Jonathan C.
Just take your $25 that you would spend on wing fest..... come here..... buy a huge tray of wings and enjoy. I personally will only order Suicide. Yup call me crazy, but extra hot sauce with Jalepenos on top and then more hot sauce just makes me happy. But I want something more than wings and celery says the imaginary voice in my belly. So I shut him up with some cheese smothered waffle fries. Well even though its 9am and I'm not hungry... I really want some now.
(5)Adam K.
Another local haunt I have been frequenting since before I could legally drink and had to resort to getting loaded on drinking the hookah water at the hookah bar down the street. I think all the negative reviews from long time patrons are telling in that they mention all the good things about this place in great detail but then say the bad in one sentence. And then they go on to say that they will be back. Sure this place is flawed, hell, this place may not be the best for wings anymore, but it is an institution. A buffalo university. When you graduate from it, you will cast aside the wing stop Pizza Hut wings with a scornful smirk and declare, "I HAVE EATEN AT BUFF JOES! THESE ARE NOT WINGS!" I always have and always will get: Double order of Suicide - Spicy, what can I say other than I got a party platter of the spicy wing awesomeness once for the superbowl, one of my idiot friends liked it so much he decided to drink the concentrated hot spicy suicide wing sauce that had congealed jalapenos in it, and then had a fiery colon for 3 days. Do not attempt to drink a full cup of the sauce. But do get the suicide and Double order of BBQ - Oh man, so sweet and delish, these really compliment the spicy, and because of my Indian upbringing, I am partial to the spicy but these will always hold a special place in my heart, cuz they are loaded with cholesterol and will probably be either removed by a robot doctor or kill me. Waffle Fries w Cheddar - another artery bomb, but so good in so many ways, there is not enough room on the internet to describe my love for these particular waffle cheese fries. Just try them. They also have beer which is a newer thing, I have not gotten any here. They have a pretty large seating area in the back with TV's so you can watch whatever games are going on, the ordering process is a bit apprehensive as you have to explain and re explain what you want to the surly, young, often but not always african american youngsters who look upon you with disdain. Then after about 20 minutes, you give CASH ONLY to the fat white dude manning the register with very little patience for small talk. Just go here. The experience outweighs the negative feelings you get when your cardiac surgeon looks up at you from the top of his glasses.
(4)Jason S.
Buffalo Joe's is pretty crappy. I ordered a single order of wings with spicy wing sauce and waffle fries. My sister ordered a chili cheese dog. Our beverage consisted of RC Cola (on tap). The wings must come from dead baby chicks because they contained almost no meat. The sauce wasn't bad, but the comparable sauce from Buffalo Wild Wings or Hooters tastes better. That being said, I can't find any fault with the fries. They were delicious. The pop however was a travesty, as they did not offer free refills. That is borderline un-American (or at they least cheap as hell). The chili cheese dog appeared to contain Kraft singles for the cheese and the chili had beans (gross). A friend had the charburger with bacon, cheese and wing sauce. It was pretty good, but make sure to ask for spicy sauce instead of mild. Overall, I didn't want to kill myself after eating at Buffalo Joe's, but I certainly can't recommend the place.
(2)Matt A.
giving this place anything less than 5 stars is a joke, seriously. if you want a big chunk of chicken or some hormone feed bird with giant wings goto wingstop or some other joke of a place. Chicken wings are supposed to be small - i.e. NOT have a 1lb of meat on them. This is the perfect wing and the suicide is the only way to go. i've tried them all - bw3, wingstop, wingshack whatever - NOTHING compared to Buffalo joes. worth the trip to e-Town all day.
(5)Art V.
As I've enjoyed dining at this establishment for years, it pains me to post this negative review. Buff Joes has long offered tournament-quality buffalo wings despite (1) questionable sanitation practices, (2) aloof employees, and (3) a dynamic pricing scheme. Generally, the men's bathroom is under-equipped and shockingly dirty. More often than not, the paper towel dispenser is empty and the only urinal is jammed to the brim with ice. That door handle has enough grease on it to keep a 1000 ships' engines humming along nicely. Things aren't much better in the kitchen where latex gloves are treated like commas in a David Foster Wallace piece: used occasionally but only when damn well justified. Regarding the employees, I've long suspected that the ability to appear utterly disengaged while conversing with customers is a prerequisite to getting hired. It also helps if you can act as if there is literally no task you would enjoy less than mixing pre-cooked wings in a metallic bowl full of buffalo sauce. As a rule, I'm hesitant to generalize and disparage the entire crew. The cashier is usually pretty pleasant and I've actually had some appropriate interactions with the ladies up front of late. However, given the frequency with which I've experienced sub-par customer service over the years, I'd be entirely remiss not to mention this issue in a review. Although I rarely deviate from my standard order (a single basket of spicy wings, extra ranch, and a mega-gut RC Cola), the price I pay each time tends to wildly fluctuate. The value of wings must be inexplicably linked to some mysterious economic indicator. I forked over $12.01 for my standard order last night. While this price actually appears pretty competitive with that of similar outfits (i.e. Buffalo Wild Wings), it's far removed from the less than ten dollars the restaurant charged just a few years back. Despite the above, I happily made the not-insubstantial trek to Evanston to feast on Buffalo Joe's delicious wings for years. Up until quite recently, the restaurant had some of the best wings in Chicagoland. The chicken was always perfectly cooked: crisp on the outside, juicy on the inside. The sauce was and still is, "to die for." However, my last two visits have been underwhelming. The employees seem to be overcooking the chicken these days. Additionally, the wings are now embarrassingly small. I'm comfortable wagering that they are at least 50% tinier than their counterparts at Buffalo Wild Wings and Gators. While I will likely return to Buff Joes within the next month out of habit, I can promise you I won't be thrilled about it. Patronizing this establishment is like watching a washed-up, former all-star at the plate; evidence of greatness lingers, but he's still probably going to strike out.
(1)Leo S.
Pretty good wing place, but the wings,themselves, are tiny. The suicide sauce is good, but it's not that spicy. It's more acidic than anything else because of the preserved jalapeños. The waffle fries was delicious. The burgers were also not bad. Everything is also reasonably priced, but they only accept cash which I dislike a lot.
(4)Courtney W.
This place is good for one thing, wings. You'll have to order a lot though, more than you think you need, because there isn't much on these bones. The sauces are pretty tasty too but the classic is pretty hot for me. There isn't much to the inside of this place and the service isn't the best but that's not what they're known for anyways. I don't go to Northwestern but from friends, I understand that this place is a staple. They put plenty of sauce on these bad boys though so you won't have to order extra. The wings come with celery too and plenty of blue cheese and ranch sauce. I can see why this place is so famous and as a foodie, I understand the hype. I just hope this place never plays too much into, no frills and good wings is what this place does best.
(4)Cecil S.
The most delicious wings I've had in a long time, definitely beats B-dubs hands down. Go here with an appetite, try their spicy wings. Includes some celery and ranch as well, in case things get too hot! Looks like they only had Miller or Bud Light on tap, eat-in area is kind of small/cramped with local Northwestern students.
(4)Kim D.
i like your bbq wings and your merkts cheddar waffle fries. they r so good. cash only and dont you forget it.
(4)Jay N.
I've been here several times and parking can be found on Benson Avenue to the west near the el. I went again last Saturday before the Ohio State game and was surprised to see that it wasn't that busy. As soon as you walk in, you put in your order and once it's ready, they'll put it on a tray (or in a sack if it's to-go) and you'll get your receipt. You pay after you get your food. There's a decent amount of seats in the back but it can get a little crowded. It's pretty limited in decor with framed posters about food or hot peppers. There's 1 tv in the back. The wings come in 4 flavors - mild, spicy, suicide, and bbq. I usually go with the spicy as it has the right amount of kick. They add on the celery sticks and ranch sauce with the order. I really like their waffle fries here. The wing sizes are decent again. They were pretty small for a while and now seem to be a good combination of meaty, crispness, and sauce flavor retention. There are only really 2 order sizes - single and double order. I usually get the double order as I can munch on some and then save some for later. Next sizes up are party trays for 8 or 15 people. Overall, it was a very good experience to come back here again.
(4)Sebastian Y.
Warning: The tiny wings at Buff Joe's are extremely addictive. Another Warning: Cheddar chips are waffle fries with way too much cheddar cheese lopped on top. Last Warning: The Suicide sauce is hot. 4 stars for the wings. 2 stars for the cheddar chips. I'll give Buff Joe's a 4.
(4)Sonia B.
If you are looking for some amazing wings, Buffalo Joes is the place to go! I've been going to Buffalo Joes for 15 years and I can still say that they, hands down, have the best wings in the Chicago-land area. Their sauce is definitely what makes the wings and it doesn't taste like only tobasco...like most other establishments. Mild, spicy or suicide are the levels of heat and you can order a single order, double order or a party pan if you're really hungry! I love to pair their wings with the buffalo chips or cheddar chips and a gutbuster (medium) lemonade or pop. Yes, pop...not soda! :) I like my wings a little crispy, so I order mine well done. Buffalo Joes is definitely a comfort food and I probably go once a week! :) They have many other items on the menu, but I can't say I have EVER tried anything else there. It just seems wrong. However, it is great that they have other options...which look yummy...in case you are with people who don't like wings. Although, I have NEVER met a person who doesn't LOVE Buffalo Joes! Even people who don't like wings end up loving Buffalo Joes! Buffalo Joes has a couple of locations, but the one in Evanston is the best. It does get crowded, especially when Northwestern has a game - but seats open up pretty quickly on a normal night. The only downside of the place is that it is cash only. So, make sure you come prepared. Your belly will definitely leave happy! :)
(5)Julie K.
I'm 5 months pregnant and I've been craving wings. We live in Chicago on division, tons of bars and they sell wings too, but nothing compared to Buffalo Joes. Not the cleanest place but it is definitely worth the trip to Evanston for their wings. It truly is finger lickin good.
(5)Patrick S.
Probably the closest yet I have come to what I would imagine they intended buffalo wings to be. Buff Joes has to be on my top...3 of wings destinations. I was intro-ed to said wings several years ago in my high school years. I still feel like Im cutting class when I sit down to eat over there. So anywho..why I am writing a review now? Because I have never attempted to tackle a party platter in one sitting....till now. I speak of the $40 platter thats supposed to serve 8-12 people I believe? I have no idea what possessed my friends and I (yes! grammar skills) to attempt to tackle such a feat. Let me just clarify I speak of 4 people for this platter of glory. This stint of gluttony was the brain child of pure spontaneity and opportunity. 4 people, $40...how could you go wrong?? About 45minutes later..me and my partner in crime inhaled about low-mid 30s each. The 2 others wimped out and had about 10-15 each. A late comer came into the equation contributing another 10-15. In the conclusion of this session of man v food..... Food came out victorious...there was about 12 wings left. Think about that for a sec..that is a massive amount of wings! And let me tell you..grease, and spice.......youre just asking for it. A dastardly duo of disaster; definitely! They device a fiendish evac. Regardless of what is left on the plate after any gluttony bout...trust me, FOOD ALWAYS COME OUT ON TOP.
(5)Eileen Z.
My favorite wings in Chicagoland. I've been hitting up this Clark location since high school. When I'm out of town, I dream of these wings. IT'S THE WING SAUCE. It's different from any other wing sauce I've had. BE PREPARED FOR GREASE. Buff Joe's wings swim in it and it's delicious. I love the suicide wings which are tossed with jalapenos, but I actually enjoy ordering the mild sauce more often because you can really taste the sauce. I find most people like to order the spicy, which isn't all that spicy to begin with. That's the three degrees of hot: suicide, spicy, and mild. No extras, just as simple as that. 12 years ago I may have given them 5 stars. But if I had to complain about anything about Buff Joe's it would be their wings have gotten much smaller over the years and that they only have a small coating of the sauce over the wings... much less than they used to. But I've found that this is the way I like ordering: - a double order mild with extra wing sauce (this already comes with ranch and celery) - buff chips (waffle fries) with cheese - large RC or grape soda The cheese they use with the buff chips seems to be a hit or miss with people I know since it's more of a cheez whiz type of cheese, but it goes beautifully with all the greasy goodness of the wings AND I LOVE IT. Even their ranch doesn't seem like a ranch I could just go buy at the grocery store. In fact, you can purchase pints of both their ranch sauce and special Buff Joe's wing sauce by themselves. This is nice for your at-home cooking experiments. In the past you were able to order the jugs, but they have put a stop to that. I haven't tried much else on their menu. The burgers are nothing special aside from the Buff Joe's sauce, but the buns they use suck and fall apart easily. The corn on the cob and broccoli cheddar soup are pretty good, too. But the only thing I keep running back for are the wings. Buff Joe's is cash only, but they finally put in an ATM a few years ago so if you forget to grab cash ahead of time it won't be a problem. The place is small and gets pretty packed, especially on nights and weekends since it's only a hop skip and a jump away from the Northwestern University campus. This is one of those hole-in-the-wall kinda gems. I've always wished they'd expand past Evanston, but the owner has said he never plans on it. Oh well. It's worth the trip anyway.
(4)J J.
I used to travel for business quite a bit. I've been to basically 3/4 of the U.S. and my modus operandi was basically to hit up a wing joint anytime I could. After going to Buff Joes since I was a teen and experiencing the best wings you could only be disappointed going anywhere else which is exactly what happened to me. There is no comparison. Buff Joes hands down has the best sauce. If they put it in a cup I would drink it through a straw. And when there was not enough wing sauce to suck up through the straw I would tip the cup over and tap the bottom until every drop of sauce made it's way out of the cup. The same applies to their ranch dressing. It perfectly compliments their wing sauce. I can't say much about any of their other food as I've only eaten wings and celery here. The ONLY thing I can complain about is the size of their wings as I'm absolutely positive that they are smaller than they used to be. I'm not going crazy. Someone please agree with me. Don't bother wasting your time going anywhere else if you've experienced Buff Joes. You'll only be disappointed.
(5)David C.
Some wings are really good, some are even incredible. Buff Joes is heaven. Yes, they raised their prices a lot. Yes, their wings are slightly smaller. Yes, they are more inconsistent than normal wings places. But really, you can't top that sauce and those waffle fries. I would probably be willing to get in the ring with Floyd Mayweather and get knocked in 10 seconds just to have a double order of suicide with some waffle fries and a large RC Cola. If you go to Buffalo Wild Wings, I can't speak to your taste buds (they are obviously very unrefined). I did really like Wings Over, but they are definitely a different type of wing, basically chicken fingers with sauce. Overall, best restaurant in Evanston bar none. James, who usually works the cashier, is the man, and some of my best college memories are at Buff Joes. I've never tried crack, but i'm assuming it tastes something like buff joes wings (and its probably healthier).
(5)Frank A.
Party pans! Haven't had B.J.'s in a year! Still hasn't changed. Still the best. Eaten til cardiac arrest! - Haha. I made a rhyme! See the Party Pan pix! They'll make you want some!
(5)Mikhail D.
I've been coming to Buff Joes since I was 8 year old. FIRST OFF: Yes, this is down right unhealthy, greasy, fattening food. But sober or not, I always leave this place completely satisfied and it's my first meal everytime I come home. And you're a sinner if you're not getting cheddar chips!
(5)Mark T.
Go figure, I go to a restaurant that specializes in wings...and I order a burger. What is wrong with me?? A group of friends invited me out on a weekday to hang out, and they suggested this place. I didn't feel like chicken that night (wait a minute, wasn't that a jingle from a commercial from the 1980s?) so I ended up getting a Cheddar Char burger off the menu. The burger itself tasted pretty standard, nothing spectacular. However, the waffle fried were de-lish. Maybe I should have just had a single order of fries...that would have been an adequate meal. Beware, this place takes cash only; luckily I had exactly $7 in my wallet to pay for my meal. Overall, the place serves pretty good food for a pretty cheap price. You can't ask for anything more. My dinner companions all ordered the wings and loved them. I did take a look at their plates and noticed the small size of them; eventually when I come back to actually try their wings I'd have to make a note to get a double order.
(3)Ted C.
Small. That's what comes to mind now when I came here on a recent visit. BuJoe's used to be a staple of my adolescence. Splitting a party pan of 'Suicide' where it was so hot it looked like my friends and I had spent the day at the pool. A huge cup 'Gutbuster' size lemonade to wash it down and a tray of celery and ranch-you know for the healthy part of the meal. The wings now are small-just so tiny that it made me want to cry a little over the now former memories of big wings/drummettes that used to be the calling card here along with the 'Suicide' sauce which was so hot but now seems a little tame by comparison-maybe my taste buds are dying off in my old age but I think they are just using a weaker hot sauce. RIP Buffalo Joe, you're not what you used to be. I'll miss you.
(2)Eugene M.
In 1996 or so, when I was in that most miserable of summers between 7th and 8th grade, I attended Sports Camp in Wilmette, IL. (Sports Camp is camp for children who are so bad at sports that it doesn't even matter which one they try to play on any given day.) At sports camp, I had a counselor named Dave, and Dave happened to be A Very Cool Guy because when our troop slept over at his house, we could play Waverace 64 until 4 AM and then watch Faces of Death. Having that kind of night makes you feel pretty cool yourself. Anyway, while at Dave's house that fateful night, I saw huge container that I thought was reserved for things like laundry detergent or motor oil, and the label on it read "Buffalo Joe's Suicide." Having just watched a bunch of Faces of Death, I didn't even want to think of what that stuff was, but Dave assured me that it was just wing sauce. A lot of wing sauce. At that time, I'd never even had a buffalo wing, but I'll always remember that huge plastic vat. Flash forward 8 years. I'm at Buffalo Joe's for the first time, face-to-face with one of those vats, the memories rushing back at me. I'd only had buffalo wings a few times, and I didn't particularly care for them. Nevertheless, my buddies swore by this place and what the hell else are you going to do on a Tuesday in your first summer with a driver's license? Double order of spicy barbecue wings, cheddar chips, and a Gutbuster root beer. I had seen the face of God. The wings were perfectly crispy, and the sauce was buttery, delicious goo. The cheddar chips, a perfect complement with their tangy sharp cheddar melted until it just barely retains some texture. Words don't really serve that sublime moment. I just knew that I found my calling. Flash forward another 10 years. I don't even like wings. I think they mostly suck. I don't eat much "unhealthy" food. But if I'm in Chicago, or even Milwaukee or Indiana or Iowa City or wherever, I go to Buffalo Joe's. Consistency has taken a dip, yes, but...BuJo's is not just "my" place. BuJo's is America. The huddled, poor, teeming masses yearning to eat wings, waiting in line for their taste of suicide or double mild or even a burger. Young kids, old dudes, foreigners, whoever, They're all here. They're all waiting for wings. BuffJoe's has opened its doors.
(5)Stephen C.
This place is a Northwestern institution, or so I'm told. The decor hasn't changed in 20 or so years and the owner is the same. It feels like a generic place from the early 80s -- clean but utilitarian -- though the flat screen TVs help. Long counter in the front to order and pick up food and then tables in the next room. The wings were tasty -- messy but that's what buffalo wings should be. We got hot but I heard the suicide are not too bad either so I'm hoping to get those next time. People swear also by the cheese fries but the cheese was so processed that i found them a little gross. But the wings. Yum!
(4)Lisa H.
I have been coming here for a couple of years now. This place is a little old, have nasty employees, filthy bathrooms, and sometimes smell. Their tables are always dirty and sticky, it seems like they never would wipe them down. But the chicken wings are one of the best wings I have ever eaten. They may be small, but you get a lot with one order. The spicy or suicide sauce drenched on these wings are to die for!! It also comes with celery and ranch (always need an extra one because they give you so little). Get the waffles fries to compliment your order and you'll be all set for a delicious meal.
(5)Nichole F.
I consider wings one of my very favorite foods so the first time I had wings at Buffalo Joe's, I was a very happy girl! Their wings are among the best that I have ever had. The waffle fries are great too!
(5)Bobby C.
Best wings I've had hands down. Get a single of spicy wings (or suicide if you want them to double the sauce and drown in jalepenos) and a side of buffalo cheddar chips with a mega RC cola and prepare to get your face messy! The sauce is just absolutely criminal. Second to none. I've heard the burgers and sandwiches are great too but the wings are so good I've never gone astray. Is usually pretty busy and cash only. If you are ordering on Sunday during football season call your order in to avoid the wait. Got a lot of friends and family in Evanston so I'm in town every couple of months. I always try to get to Buff Joe's when I'm in town and you should too!
(5)Eric V.
Best Wings in the entire world!!!! Single Suicide w/ Cheddar Chip and a mega RC has been my order since 1998. Eric Vawda
(5)Cathy B.
wings = MUST GET SUICIDE IF YOU CAN HANDLE IT. DELICIOUS SAUCINESS. CHEESE WAFFLE FRIES = BEST THING EVERRRRRRR! Cheese waffles fries is more awesome than the Wings. Haven't tried anything besides the wings and cheese fries, but once you try the cheese fries, you don't need to try anything else. PERIOD. The people behind the counter look scary and intimidating but don't be fooled, they're actually kinda nice....
(4)justin m.
I really dont get it - almost to the point of loosing sleep. I can easily look past the dismal service, 30 min wait (for wings), crappy napkins & flat soda - I don't expect anything different. However, the wings (aka fried bones w/ skin and hot sauce) were horrible! I've had frog legs... hell frog arms with more meat! But all is not lost. The sauce was simply amazing, all I want is some chicken to accompany it. Hopefully they will see this and the other reviews of skimpy wings and step their game up.
(2)Tim S.
Here's how I look at wings: it starts with the sauce, but it ends with the meat. Their sauces are pretty legit; I went spicy and bbq in my first go around. Both were great. My biggest complaint was the level of meatiness they have on their wings. I think I saw an earlier review that referenced 'dead baby chicks', and - while a bit too descriptive - you get the point. You eat these wings to transport their sauce. The sauce is good, but it's not to the point where I don't want get full in the process. To their credit, they give you a TON of these tiny wings, so it's not like you get a half dozen or a dozen in an order. You get a ton in the order. This get's them to three stars. Their fries would have gotten them another half star if Yelp would allow it.
(3)Danielle J.
Yummy wings & great customer service! I get wings here from time to time and had an issue with my last order. Dean was so nice, friendly and helpful and he rectified the problem for me. The sauce is addictive. I always get mild becuz I'm not a lover of all things spicy, but the have a twinge of heat which is fine for me. Will definitely be back soon!
(5)Susan F.
I love wings, I really do. I'll try any flavor, from sweet to spicy. I'll try them bone-in, boneless, stripped, naked, whatevs, I'm down. An afternoon in Evanston called from some Buff Jo action. I had actually never heard of the place, but I felt that wings were the perfect cure to my hangover, and a cure for just any old regular day anyways. But, I ended up getting a tuna sandwich, while my friends got a big order of wings I could suck off of. I'm actually glad I got the 'wich...I'll tell you why: #1. The service was awful. They didn't even know what a tuna salad sandwich was (and it's been on their menu for what I can assume is for YEARS). I had to repeat myself several times, and even while they were making my sandwich, half of them didn't even know it was on the menu. That being said, it was very fresh and didn't taste fattening at all. Win! #2. Now, for the wings. I have never seen so much wing grease at the bottom of a plate in my entire life. No other wings I've had have been like this, I was kind of shocked. They were good and all...but not the best. They tasted like they had butter in them... Their prices were really fair, but I just could NOT get over that freakin grease. It was a major turn off. I really don't think I'll return here again much to my friend's dismay.
(2)Pascal M.
Small, tiny, puny, miniscule, wimpy, scrawny, baby lookin' wings. Huge, immense, big, lip smacking good flavor wings. My office raved about this place. After an early appointment, I told them I would pick up some grub for everyone. We had a feast. The wings are delicious and the experience inside the place is cool too. I spent my wait lookin at all the interesting charm on the walls. Which I love doing at places like this. it almost tells a story about the establishment and acts as a reassuring testamonial for what your about to put in your mouth. I hear the burgers are great too.. Looking forward to going back for my office soon. Shoot, maybe tomorrow!
(4)Amy L.
Why people rave about this place? The chicken wings are legendarily small and they do not take credit cards!!!
(3)Richard L.
The only thing okay here is the sauce... But I don't like that it's a little sweet. You can also buy it by itself. The restaurant is grimey, the wings are tiny; it's not worth it. Doesn't live up to the hype. The cookies were actually pretty good. Large Oatmeal Chocolate Chip for 0.85$.
(1)April P.
Yep, they're still here, doing the damn thing, still being a foodie landmark, the quest and one of the greats to have for Superbowl, NBA finals, and just a regular chicken run on a Saturday night. Even though they are smothered with their special sauce, they are still retain their crispy exterior, even after a half hour car ride home. Score! Love their bbq, not too sweet, not too savory. Their hot sauce is just right amount of heat for the rookies who can't take it. Can't comment on their suicide wings, but for the brave, I heard they're pretty outstanding. Open late, parking plenty even on the weekends. Fast service, as well. A half order of wings will run you about $7.
(5)Jeanie P.
2.5 stars hm maybe it was the hype, but buffalo joe's is just okay. I tried the single order spicy wings and cheddar waffle fries, and it was just alright. Honestly nothing mindblowing. The aroma is amazing, but the actual taste is nothing to write home about. Wings are swimming in grease fyi (like a pool at the bottom of my white styrofoam to go box). I didn't really like the fake taste of the cheddar--- i'm very skeptical this is real cheese? It had like the weirdest texture after it cooled down a little bit. And I LOVE cheese but I had to scrape this stuff off and wished I had ordered regular fries instead. It tasted almost sweet. Definitely would not get that again. I also didn't think the ranch was tangy enough-- too much on the sweet side. And like a lot of the reviews say, the wings are really small... which I didn't think would bother me but it is definitely an aspect that could be improved. So props to them for being a hole in the wall place with tons of loyal customers and able to thrive blocks away from a BWW. But personally, just not very impressed.
(3)Jaclyn Y.
The wings are small, but the sauce is soooo good. I like how the wings are crispy. The waffle fries are excellent with cheese!!! YUM. Can't wait to come back here.
(5)Eric G.
Do not eat their food. You will become addicted and then I will have to wait in line behind you. Cash only. Mild is a friendly hot. This place is worth a ride up on the purple line.
(5)Doug F.
Been going here for 15 years. All you need to know is get the Wings with Suicide sauce. If you like it even hotter ask for Double Suicide sauce. If you like it it mild, the wings won't taste as good without the suicide sauce. The suicide sauce not only adds heat but adds lots of flavor. The wings are so tasty, you eat one and before you know it, you have enough bones in front of you to fill a museum. Its the classic hot sauce , deep fried wings with side of celery and blue cheese. Expect it to be a messy. Grab plenty of napkins. If you have 4 or more (big) people in your party, get the "Pan" (around $40). Serving sizes are good. They give nice portions. Located in the trendy, rich, hip, college town (Northwestern University) of Evanston. Great neighborhood. The inside is a basic chair and tables, nothing fancy. A little greasy feeling because of the open kitchen with exposed fryers. Next door is a church that always attract pan handlers outside. Just be aware. Street parking. Bottom line is the WIngs. They're so good, I just keep coming back for the last 15 years. Enjoy and keep a glass of milk nearby to kill the fire!
(5)Daphne L.
An Evanston staple. I've been coming here since high-school and it's still one of my favorite places for wings. The wings are spicy, like they should be, not breaded and deep fried, like they shoulnd't be. The waffle fries with cheese..lord have mercy! So good, so very bad for you, you must have them. The people that work there are great: friendly, get down to business and get the food out to the customers. Can't ask for more than that.
(4)Stacy S.
Wings? Yes please! I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's since high school and this is by far the best wings I've ever had! B Dubs comes close, but it doesn't quite nail it the way Buffalo Joe's does. Now, I can only speak for the (mild or spicy) wings and the waffle fries, because those are the only two things I've had on the menu..with the RC, of course. Seriously, looking for good wings? Buff Joes is it.
(5)Dan H.
Buffalo Joes is awesome. I have been going here since before I was ever born. My mother told me that when she was pregnant with me this was the place that she craved. I can see why, freshly cooked wings are slathered with a traditional buffalo wing sauce. you can order your wings mild, hot or suicide. When you order them suicide they come covered in pickled jalapeno peppers and buffalo wings sauce. It's awesome, until the next day if you know what i am saying. You must order the Cheddar Chips. They are seasoned waffle fries covered in cheese sauce. I could eat an entire party tray of these with out ever blinking an eye. I love them. You need to eat them there though, they don't travel well. I've also had the pleasure of eating a burger here, the burger was large and tasty. It is cooked in front of you on an actual grill that gives it a nice char. Go to buffalo joes, don't wear white and remember to tip the homeless guy out front.
(5)Billy M.
Buffalo Joe's is my second favorite wing place in the world behind Bird's Nest. I have frequented this location for many years and they have never dissapointed. I also love their waffle cheese fries. This place has amazing food and a great tradition. If you are in downtown Evanston i highly recommend that yoiu stop and order a few dozen hot wings with cheddar waffle fries.
(5)Derik P.
My favorite Buffalo wings place hands down. I've been here for the past 4 years. I have to say one thing though, the wings aren't as good as before but it still great. If you like spicy 1. Get suicide 2. Spicy buffalo chip (Waffle fries top with cheddar cheese and Jalapenos) Drools 3. Don't get mild. It sucks in my opinion 4. TIP THE HOMELESS GUY OUTSIDE. 8 OUT OF 10 TIMES I'M THERE I ALWAYS SEE HIM. Every year it's getting worst and worst. Smaller wings and more expensive. Still the best sauce ever for the wings but I'm looking somewhere else for better wings now.
(4)Colin D.
The first time I had wings, it was at Buffalo Joe's. That set the standard at the time, and nothing since has compared. I think three things set Buffalo Joe's apart: the sauce (the buffalo and barbecue are both top-notch), the texture (tend to be a bit more well done than most, which makes the skin taste great), and the size (as the pictures show, sometimes they can be REALLY tiny. However, I like wings a little on the small side so you get some sauce and skin in each bite). The Clark St location is specifically my favorite - not all of the others offer the (excellent) waffle fries. Get 'em suicide style (buffalo sauce, jalapenos, and cheese), and make sure to bring your Lipitor.
(5)Ju L.
So, wings: The sauce is delicious and oilier than most other buffalo sauces, but the "suicide" sauce, their most intense, is NOT spicy-- I've had wings with no spiciness designation at all that were hotter than these (case in point: Dixie Kitchen's Jamaican jerk wings). Maybe they only call it "suicide" because they're served under a heap of pickled jalapeno? If that is the case, I feel cheated. And holy heck these wings are small. Even Merle's menu, next to THEIR wings, says outright, "Friends don't let friends eat tiny wings at Buffalo Joe's" or something like that. I also don't love that they give you ranch dressing instead of bleu cheese. The staff is amusingly irreverent, prices are not as low as might be expected ($13 for a double order; wings at Merle's or Dixie Kitchen are significantly cheaper for a comparable amount), and shady characters hover outside and occasionally need to be made to leave by the staff, who return immediately to looking indifferent. This is a convenient and casual place to get something to munch on without dealing with a real restaurant, so I'll probably find myself back here sometime in the future. But I won't be too enthused.
(2)Sandra Y.
I've been going here for nearly 10 years so it brings back so many memories the second I walk into the place :) I always order double suicide wings with blue cheese dressing, broccoli cheddar soup, cheddar fries, & a bacon cheddar burger. Everything is always soooo good! Speaking of which, I think I need to make a stop here soon.
(5)Sarah F.
WINGS! yum! Buff Joe's serves wings done right. The chips (waffle fries) are delicious! Be sure to call early if you want to order some for a football weekend and/or the Superbowl. Also fun for an alum to reminisce about the old days at NU. :)
(5)Scott C.
The wings here are the best in the country. The wings I got were nice size with lots of meat on them too, I stuck with the mild because the flavor is fantastic and theyr spicy enough for me. The "Buffalo Chips" are really good quality waffle cut french fries and the smallest drink is large enough to do the job.
(5)Jon W.
The last time I was there an employee was vomiting in the patron area while her friends recorded the events on their phones and uploaded through social media. The guy who appears to be the owner or manager (fat guy, mustache) acted as though this were normal. I am never going back.
(1)EdanEdan T.
Great sauces and fast service. BUT why are the chicken wings the size of my thumb? I felt like i was eating fried skin with a bone in it but without barely any meat. Luckily they give you more than a dozen of these mini wings...but still, i was hungry right afterwards. I dont even know any other chicken wing places that have wings this small...its as if they took baby chicken's for the meat. So weak. Def not going back.
(2)Sara L.
Me and my bf came here based off of Yelp reviews and both of us left extremely disappointed. First off, the place smelled like a bathroom. I tried to not think about it but honestly, the smell threw any appetite I had out the window. If you REALLY want to try this place, order it for take-out. The wings were REALLY small, I'm talking, microscopic. I feel sorry for the quails that they are taking these wings off from because they're so small and cute...and their lives aren't worth taking for sub-par wings! I gave it two stars because the sauce was good. If they had meatier wings to couple with the sauce, the wings would be a lot better. We also shared cheddar chips (waffle fries) which were also not very good. The cheddar cheese that is used on the fries was gritty and thick. I'm a huge cheese person but found this kind to be really unappetizing and left over half of the fries untouched. If you like the thick and gritty cheese (my bf said it reminded him of the cheese used at Weiner Circle), then by all means, this is your place. Otherwise, I'd stick to the plain waffle fries. Overall, I've been to plenty of other places for wings that are significantly better than this place. I didn't really understand all of these 5 star reviews but looking at the dates for most of these, it seems as if this place has gone down-hill since 2009. Perhaps there was a change in management? Either way, I don't think I will ever come back here. I'd rather go to Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)Gabriel C.
I have been going here ever since highschool and it is still my all time favorite place for wings. Wings are one of my favorite types of foods so there are times I stop by here multiple times a week. There are some times that the wings are small in size, but I go there so much that it usually balances out lol.
(5)Jill M.
Well...this is sad for me because I have been a Buffalo Joe's fan for a long time (10 years or more), but I won't be going back after having a bad experience three times in a row now. 1. The employees have been consistently rude and occasionally down-right mean. Maybe they are all underpaid and treated poorly. I don't know. But, whatever it is....who wants to go out and be treated rudely just for ordering food? I don't get it. 2. The restaurant is a greasy, unclean mess. Yes...that is what you might expect at a fast-food place, but it is disgusting now. The floor is so greasy that you might slip and fall in the grease. The bathrooms are so disgusting that I watched multiple people go into the bathrooms only to come out immediately and say they'd have to go somewhere else. Seriously, the restaurant should close down for however long it takes and CLEAN UP. Maybe get new bathrooms and floors. It's surprising they have passed the health inspections. 3. The wings just aren't that good anymore. I feel like a traitor just saying that, but ti's true. They are tiny, expensive and the meat is all dried out. Not good. My waffle fries were fine. So, please, Buffalo Joe's...clean up the restaurant, hire new people that are trained in being pleasant and bring back the wings that were the best in the country!
(1)Rae D.
Best wings in the city! Although I love me some hot wings, I prefer ordering the mild here as they have a great buttery taste to them. The cheddar chips are so good! Who wouldn't love waffle fries with cheddar cheese spread all over them?
(5)Keith H.
You cannot afford not to go eat here. Why are you still reading reviews. Get your shoes on and go. Now!
(5)Aurore L.
Joe was behind the counter. (well - I don't really know. But with his pony tail, his long side burns and his cap, he DID look like a Joe. And not the G.I. kind) He took my order with nonchalance, and I waited, wondering with a bit of disbelief what I was doing there, and if I was indeed in the heart of sleek, posh, suburban Evanston. Or if I had landed in hell's waiting room for hormone-driven high school students. They were EVERYWHERE. And hungry. And scary with their hands and chin dripping with wing sauce. Ok, I am exaggerating a bit. BJ's is not for whimpers. The normal order is 12 wings. What you get is more like 18, so be prepared. They are on the smaller side though. Therefore manageable. Cheese fries, a pop and game on!!! Probably not a destination in itself - it's really sorta shabby looking - but if you are on a wing quest...well....why not?!??
(3)Richard H.
I've only been here one time -- and boy did this place make a bad impression! It was unclean and smelly. There was a layer of smelly grime on the table and ketchup blobs dried on the wall. The food is not god-awful -- but the odor and scuz are killer. In all fairness, I did not try the wings. Perhaps, I should consider carry out from here sometime, since others really seem to like it. If you want some greasy comfort food, I'd recommend skipping this place and walking a couple blocks to Edzo's.
(1)Ben A.
1 Single order Buffalo Wings with spicy sauce, and mixed with XXX Sauce. The XXX Sauce is so good it works well when blended with other sauces. It's the strongest they have, and its not on the menu. Try it if you like spicy. Its not too bad.
(4)Cassie S.
Messy. Greasy. Delicious. Not sure how else to describe these wings. Are they the spiciest wings you can find? No. But they are flavorful which, to me, makes up for that! I'd much rather eat a tasty (but not as spicy) wing over one that's so spicy that you can't taste anything but heat anyday! And I enjoy the pickled jalapeno that comes with the "suicide" wings. They can be hit or miss with the size/meatiness of the wings, but I think that's the case pretty much everywhere. Fries are good too. Especially with the cheese :) Not somewhere I can eat at often, but a wonderful treat!
(4)Alex N.
Best wings on the planet
(5)Brandon B.
I went back this weekend. Maybe they had a bad batch before or something, but the quality is back! Still kind of pricey, though.
(4)Igor U.
still my favorite wings place. Get the cheese fries on the side.
(5)Crystal L.
BJs is my #1 choice of preference for chicken wings. It beats Hooters, BW3s, and Wing Stop. Their spicy wing sauce is so unique like a mix of hot n cheddar?? I'm not really sure what the ingredients are but it's amazing to say the least. I usually order to suicide which is their spiciest sauce with jalapenos on top! It's great for those who love their wings hot hot hot. To balance the hotness from the wings I also get an order of their buffalo chips (aka french fries) with cheddar. Cheddar is a crucial part because its absolutely amazing here. My boyfriend isn't as into spicy as I am so he usually gets the buffalo chicken sandwich and it's just perfect for him.
(5)James F.
One of my new found favorite places for wings. Good wings are HARD to come by, but Joe's suits the bill. They're fried fresh and mixed with just the right amount of buttery, fiery sauce. I was in town for a visit for 4 days and ate at Joe's 3 times for lunch! Yes ... it's THAT good.
(5)Jaz P.
This fast food place has zero ambience but it's well worth the trip because their wings are my favorite - the standard by which I judge all other wings by. When I go to other wing restaurants and I'm supposed to choose from a variety of types, I always ask for the ones that taste most like Buffalo Joe's.
(5)Jesse C.
Damn fine wings, friendly staff and lots of seating. A little dirty.
(4)Jerry B.
The wings are very tasty as well as the beautifully seasoned fries. I can't handle the spicy ones though. They never skimp on the sauce & I should give them 3.5 stars, but I bumped it up to 4 because there was a BW3 ad on their yelp site & it's good to support local businesses like them. I wish that they would go into the 20th Century and get a credit card machine & help me get more credit card rewards... Also, the place could use a bit of tidying up & it sometimes smells like dirty diapers in there & I did not see any little ones frolicking... or maybe it could be the Depends.
(4)J F.
Pretty small wings, but they are crispy. The sauces are not really all that hot, but taste great. Suicide wings really not that hot, jalapenos are kinda of a weird touch. Overall not a bad place to get wings, I would agree probably best in the local area.
(3)Paul C.
I went here with Anita because she had read that BJs had the best wings in Chicago, and if there's one thing I love it's wings. Boy where we both disappointed. The wings are small and pretty bland. I've been served better chicken wings on airplanes. This place can't even hold a candle to BW3s. It's cheap though, and everyone is friendly. Definitely not worth the trip, but if you're nearby and want a cheap bite, you probably won't be too upset. Just don't expect greatness. Thanks for nothing Anita.
(2)KING J.
I remember these wings to be damn good! Havent been back since like 1998, I better go back soon and confirm this!
(5)MooMoo L.
My favorite wings place. Deep fried, buttery, saucy. For some odd reason, wings at this place taste a lot better than its branch at Greenbay Rd.
(5)Dave Y.
grease grease grease! you can feel the grease on your face when you walk in here. if you have acne, you'll probably breakout just being here. but their buffalo wings are the best i've had anywhere. get the suicide sauce
(5)C.S. C.
this has been a 5 star for me from high school to even just a couple of years back. here are my 2 reasons why the stars keep on falling off. 1. size of the wings: in the past year or so, the wings have been insultingly tiny. often times, i trek from far away to eat these once beloved wings hoping that i will leave satisfied. however, these days, after my visit, i am left to wonder...where are they buying these tiny wings? are these off the rejected chickens that don't make the cut for tysons or perdue? when i start to think that they are getting these tiny wings from possible deformed/malnutritioned chickens, i get sick. i mean, capt. buff joe, do you really have to get the worst of the worst sized chicken wings when your competitors are still selling good sized wings? 2. price - this is correlated with the size of the wings. i cannot believe capt. buff joe can go to sleep at night knowing that he is robbing people's money by charging so much for these small wings. come on dude. i know wing prices have gone up nationally. so i know that prices will go up. but other places like bw3's, bars, and restaurants are not selling cheap a** wings. at least their prices matches the size. it saddens me to think after spending so much money, time and memories here that bj's is becoming like this. what doesn't help is when people are still paying the money to get such low quality product. i guess that's why capt. buff joe can afford that boxter that sits out in the back. don't get me wrong, the sauce is still the best in chicagoland. also, when the chips are cooked perfectly, they melt like butter. however, the continued lack of quality wings with soaring prices is forcing me not to make the drive to evanston and find other alternatives around here.
(3)A. R.
As stated by other reviewers, the wings at Buff Joe's are neither large nor overly spicy. However the modest-sized wings don't have too much fat on them, so invariably you still get a good amount of chicken in your order. If you have the capacity to eat spicy foods I would recommend the suicide sauce. Although this sauce won't lead to your imminent demise, it will continue to build heat if you lay off the blue cheese dressing and fries as you bask in the glory of these wings. And if you're like me, you'll eat the jalapenos that come in the sauce to ensure that the meal is as spicy as possible. I also had the cheddar chips based on the strong reviews of other Buff Joe's visitors. The fries were good but I was hoping that they would come in a pool of molten cheese. Unfortunately that wasn't the case, and that was perhaps the greatest let down of this meal.
(4)Lenna O.
BuJo's!! now that's some, "finger licking good" stuff. Their buffalo wings are so tasty. The sauce just hits every taste bud in your mouth. There is just something distinct about it that differs from other places. And what better way to compliment the wings than with some of their waffle fries? great with some cheddar cheese drizzled over or just some ketchup - yum. I've also had their cream of broccoli soup, which is one of my favorite soups, and it was indeed good. Haven't had in a while because i don't live nearby, but definitely a place to stop at if you are in the downtown area of Evanston and want a quick bite to eat. Or if you are just craving some of their food and wanna make the trip! Sure beats having mcdonald's or something.
(5)トモ T.
The BEST buffalo wings! I've tried the famous wing places in Buffalo NY, but I still like Buffalo Joe's wings the best. If I visit Evanston for any reason, I will always stop by Buffalo Joe's, even if I am not hungry.
(5)James C.
My first experience was probably back in the year 2000. I remember their wings to be about twice the size as they are today with a little more of a spicy kick than the sweet plain buttery taste that you get today. Today, a group of my friends decided to hit this place up and try to kill a double party platter. We had 6 really big guys and 5 small girls so we didn't think we'd have a problem but to my surprise, we couldn't do it. After having a bunch, the wings become tasteless and the meat starts to taste like old chicken (I still have a weird taste in my mouth as I'm typing this). Anyway, I don't really want to waste my time writing a review on this place cause after reading some of the good reviews that other people wrote, I'm starting to think that I don't know what good wings taste like... I'd like to end by saying that I will no longer be recommending their wings. The prices almost doubled but their wings are half the size and they taste like the chickens were dead and rotting for a while. Will I be going back for their wings? Probably not in my sober state... but maybe after I smoke a couple blunts and a j on the way there... and then another j in front of the door... and maybe one in the bathroom right before my order comes out... otherwise, I think I'm done with this place forever. Sorry Buffalo Joe's... but you disappoint me and I will not be giving you any more of my hard earned money. And for all of you guys that gave this place a good rating... I don't know what to say to you guys. Either my expectation for buffalo wing's are way too high or you're easily impressed. 4/5 stars? Really? Insane.
(2)John L.
back when i was in highschool and in college i would have given this place 5 stars no question. but alas... good things don't always last. the size of the wings have gotten much smaller and so has the quality. i would always get a party or a double party pan and split it amongst my friends.... good times. the sauce that they use is still good so if you go... i would recommend you getting individual servings so the wings aren't as soggy. i still love their cheddar chips. still 4 stars because i haven't really found a better wings place than this.
(4)David L.
Suicide sauce....when I concentrate and remember how good it tastes...after 15 seconds I start to salivate. Those that have had it as often as I do will understand. For the light eaters, single order, for the real players double order with waffle fries and wash it down with an RC Cola... I know, right? RC Cola...awesome... Also, try a party pan for your next weekend party. but careful with the sauce in the car as one speed bump could mean a lingering smell for weeks...
(5)Chris R.
Overcooked, bland sauce, no blue cheese. My wife and I went here to satisfy a Buffalo craving, but were disappointed. I'm not complaining; we paid $15 and got $15 worth of fast food, but it's not worth a return visit. I'm not from upstate New York, so I don't have the "only Buffalo has real wings" mentality. However, I've eaten a lot of wings in a lot of places. There are a lot of good places in upstate New York and elsewhere for that matter. Buffalo Joe's in Evanston is not one of those places. Flavor and quality are their downfall. The food we had was overcooked. The wings and chicken sandwich we ordered both spent too much time in the deep fryer, making them dry and tough. Judging by the size and shape of the wings and the breaded chicken breast, they were standard-issue frozen foodservice items. That might be ok in a fast food restaurant, but for a place that bills itself as a wing joint, it doesn't cut it. The wing sauce left much to be desired. It didn't pack much flavor in general terms, and had almost no peppery spice even though I ordered "hot". Even accounting for personal differences in palate and how spicy one likes their food, I still don't think their hot sauce has much flavor. The complete lack of a spicy kick is what makes me say this. If there were a little bit of heat I could say that it might just be a matter of perception, but there just wasn't any. In my experience, many Midwesterners don't enjoy truly spicy food, so what they called "hot" sauce at Buffalo Joe's might be perfectly acceptable locally. If you want true hot wing sauce with a tabasco-style or red-hot sauce base, you'll have to look elsewhere. (Full disclosure: I'm a midwesterner myself. I just happen to have spent a lot of time in other places and have noticed that "spicy" on a midwestern menu isn't as spicy as in other regions.) The wings were disappointing for what should've been a simple dish (wings + sauce = good eating, but not here). The sandwich started out with bad ingredients, and was not executed well. A gooey yellow ballpark-nacho-style cheese sauce was so thick on the sandwich that it overwhelmed any other flavor that might have been there. The cheese sauce wasn't necessary to begin with, and it became a case of too much of a bad thing. Finally, they only offer ranch dressing, and no blue cheese. A Buffalo native would have a stroke about this, and I personally think ranch dressing on wings is an abomination. It's not traditional, and its bland flavor does not complement the sauce's spice as well as blue cheese's pungent tang. The preference is personal, but Buffalo Joe's should at least offer the traditional alternative alongside ranch.
(1)steph n.
I don't care how good they say the wings are in Buffalo, NY. Chicago's Buffalo Wings at Buffalo Joe's is THE king of the BUFFALO WING. I went here during the night of the SUPERBOWL and man was line packed! I couldn't even imagine how many chickens had to lose their wings to serve THAT many people! Then that made me wonder, where the heck did all those chickens go? Anyways, the wings here are served piping hot, nice and crispy, and coated with their TOP SECRET WING SAUCE. I believe it is a mixture of butter, vinegar, hot sauce, and ???? I can't even guess what the other ingredients are because I tried countless times to mimic it at home to no avail. I just wished this place served white rice. Do you know how much better these wings taste when eaten with rice? I even went scouring for asian restaurants around Buff Joes to order some rice, but I started panicking when I couldn't find any in the vicinity. It is the perfect combination...like PB AND J, like ham and cheese, like cake and ice cream.
(5)Adam P.
I'm an NU student, but I'm from Buffalo, NY, home of the chicken wing. And Goddammit, it's all we've got. Having jockeyed a few deep fryers in my high school days, I like to think I know my wings. Buff Joe's has some of the best I've ever eaten, and BY FAR the best I've encountered in Chicago -- they're directly comparable to Duff's in Buffalo, which some would argue is the best chicken wing joint on Earth. Buff Joe's is the only place I've encountered in Chicago that understands that nothing but crispy frying and simple sauce can make great wings. And the rest of the stuff on their menu is pretty good too. My favorite thing is their grilled chicken sandwich, with hot sauce of course. They have excellent waffle fries and huge usually-solid burgers. I avoid the cheeseburgers -- they use some kind of cheddar spread instead of real cheese. The Char Dog is a hybrid of Ted's on Niagara Falls Boulevard in Kenmore NY with Chicago-style toppings. Yum. This is one of my favorite takeout places in Evanston. I just wish they were open even later on the weekends and that they had delivery. But open 'til 12am 7 nights a week ain't bad.
(5)Patrick W.
I've been eating here for 13 years (since I could drive my little tushy to Evanston). I participated in a Buffalo Joe's wing eating contest in high school against offensive and defensive lineman from my school (3rd prize!). I wrote an essay about it for an english class final during my sophomore year in college. (Teacher's probable reaction: "Why is this yankee in my English class at Louisiana State University writing a final exam essay about hot wings from a place in Illinois? A+ by the way!") I ran two orange (partly yellow, partly red) lights recently to get here one night before they closed. Needless to say, I have history with Buffalo Joe's. The wings are every bit as good as they were when I first started going here. My last visit was the first in several years, but the order rolled off my tongue like it had only been since lunchtime... "Full order of suicide and a side of buffalo chips"... it was like a song. The chips are actually waffle fries, which really more restaurants should have. Suicide wings are the hottest they offer, it's basically the hot sauce but sliced jalapeno peppers are strewn about on top of your wings. My mouth is officially watering as I write this.
(5)Michael G.
Three flavors: mild, spicy, suicide. I've tried all three. The suicide are basically the same as the spicy with a few jalapenos thrown in. Honestly, this place is overrated. Like one recent reviewer said, the wing sauce is pretty run-of-the-mill, nothing amazing. If you're in this neighborhood, you're better off going to Great Sea or even Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)Ryan N.
My friends and I have been going to Buff Joe's for awhile now and there are some that love it ands some that don't. Single order of suicide , Gutbuster RC, and Cheeder Chips is our order. The other stuff on the menu is ok I've tried some other things but nothing beats that wings. The Suicide sauce is not as hot as people say its more of a great flavor than a spicyness which is the reason I love it. Great atmosphere and we usually enjoy giving fake names to the people who take your order.
(5)Roger W.
Terrific wings. So so so flavorful. That is some magical sauce. The cheddar chips are mouthwatering. Haven't been there in a while...need to go back!
(5)Alex K.
Buff joe's; cheddar chips + suicide wings beats all A friend of my roomate's lived in Louisiana, and would come to visit about once a year. He arrived around 10PM (after flying himself here in a cessna) and asked, before anything else (except a bathroom break) to go to this place. He claimed to crave it constantly. He would go there a few times in a 2 or 3-day stay. I totally understand. despite the negatives in other reviews (mostly valid on some level), you don't see anyone proposing better alternatives. The sauce and overall taste beat other places pretty handily. People giving bad ratings are usually wistful for days gone by... totally fair, but this is still the place to go for wings.
(5)Brian S.
I've been coming here for awhile. Their prices have gone up a lot which sucks but I've always loved buff joes. i wouldn't listen to people saying this is a huge disappointment but i will say they are very very hit or miss. Sometimes you will get small wings and sometimes bigger ones and sometimes they were taste like crap or be awesome. The staff can be ok but the ladies who take the orders can be pretty rude especially if you can't understand them because then they just won't take your order. I have started migrating to the Greenbay location because their wings are a lot more consistent then this one. The only other place that really even compares around chicago is wings around the world but otherwise i'd settle for buff joes anytime.
(4)John S.
I used to frequent BJ's ALL the time from '97 - '03 and their wings were GREAT. After 2003, we moved into the northwest suburbs and never had a chance to come often. Well, the past two times I've been there have been AWFUL! The wings are the smallest I've ever seen and taste like burnt/old oil was used in frying them. They're so terrible I still cringe from my experience yesterday. The worst part is I have been recommending them for years! Never again. Unless something extraordinary happens.
(1)John G.
"Buff Joe's" has the best wings in Chicago, and maybe the entire world. I have brought friends from Buffalo, NY to try these wings and they all agree they are awesome. The secret is consistency. The same guys who worked here when I was in high school are still proudly manning the deep fryer. Sure, they don't flip the sauce bowl quite as fast as they used to, but they have plenty of that special ingredient that makes magic everytime: love.
(5)Stephanie C.
i don't even live in chicago anymore, but dammit, i crave buffalo joe's wing's on a regular basis. sadly, i now live in LA, the land of mediocre (at best) wings. sigh... here it is, an ode to buffalo joe's: oh buffalo joe's, with your perfectly friend wings (not soggy, not dry, but crisp on the outside, juicy on inside) and wonderful sauce (not runny, and not too "fake" and thick - juuuust the right consistency). and don't even get me started on the cheddar fries. what is in that cheese sauce??? whatever it is, i'm totally addicted. my only beefs are the following: a) you don't serve blue cheese - what is up with that? thankfully, i can always stop at the ralph's around the corner to pick up a jar and sneak it into your restaurant. yes, i'm that crazy. and b) your "suicide" doesn't deserve the name. loading the wings with canned jalepeno slices does not constitute another level of heat. the actual sauce could stand to have a lot more kick. regardless of these minor flaws, i love you anyway, buffalo joe's, and miss you more than you can imagine!
(5)Dee W.
Good cheap option for wings - don't try anything else - try the suicide sauce - it's a for sure spicy mouthwatering temptation. If you really want something else - go for the cheese fries - those are pretty good, too. Make sure that you go in a group - have one person stand outside waiting for the food and another person to go scope out a table!
(4)Gil N.
Awesome wings. So-so service. The place varies from being a dump on some nights to pretty decent on others. But it's a Buffalo Joe's, what do you expect? Good wings, right?
(4)Jonathan H.
Simply the best wings in the city. Period.
(5)Irene J.
if you love wings and haven't tried BJ's, what are you waiting for?! i finally had some BJ's for the first time in 10 years, and it was delicious. we ordered suicide, spicy, and BBQ. the suicide sauce was addicting. i love their ranch sauce--get extra! they also have great buffalo waffle chips. cheddar chips and spicy cheddar chips are good, too. i have to say, though, i'm a bit disappointed with the price. back in the day, you could order an entire party platter for $20. it's now, sadly, double the price. BJ wings are a must have. be ready with cash (you know a place is good when they can survive on a cash-only policy), napkins, and water/milk. ;] yum!
(4)Ramon R.
There was a time when I went to this place daily. Then I started getting repulsed by the sloppy appearance of the restaurant, the filthy containers and the fact that so many people here seem intent on gaining 50 pounds (though they're already at at least 250). Go here if you want to get fat and be afraid of catching something. The food is actually enjoyable, but only as long as you don't think about the likelihood that roaches and mice are running all around it.
(1)Greg M.
Not much more to say other than the best Buffalo Wings I have ever tasted. Although not the biggest, but they taste incredible. The place itself is kind of scummy, but their wings are top notch. It's all I've been eating from here for years and they have never disappointed.
(5)tina V.
Single order of spicy wings. Cheddar chips. Gutbuster RC (OK, or a regular one with less ice). My order four+ years ago, my order now. The perfect meal when you're in search of something crispy, fried and delicious. Also good for pre-game, game, post-game, picnics, parties and more.
(4)Peggy K.
the wings taste way better than buffalo wild wings,, in my humble thought. Upon reading other reviews mentioning too much sauce, however, I admitted its true the sauce is flooded..but again, given that I always tend to credit those who dare to be different....Me have to say that this place has sold me yummy wings in prices that never worry my wallet. However, I wont recommend eating in after 9 pm since there was wierd smell inside. Cleaning time? maybe
(3)Pete D.
A sunday night tradition while i was at northwestern. Mild, hot or suicide?? love the bbq as well.....there are times when it gets crowded, but this is definitely the place to go. Great option for parties as well...can't beat a few trays of wings! yum!
(5)Bernard M.
Buffalo Joe's wings are simply the best wings in the world. A couple of my friends explored the globe trying to find a superior recipe. They even went to the home of the original Buffalo wings in Buffalo, NY and could not find an equal. Their sauce is addictive. We use to think that they drugged the sauce in high school and when my group of friends went away from college one of the first things we missed was Buffalo Joe's wings. Definitely get the mild because you get the full taste of their national award winning recipe (not just for wings! all foods!). Also their burgers get local rave reviews in a city that knows burgers... I love how they spread a thick paste of cheddar on the buns! Their buffalo fries, soups, and chicken sandwiches all kick ass. One downside is that since my high school days (15+ years ago) their wings and party pans have gotten smaller.
(5)joanne y.
yay for buffalo sauce covered fingers!!! oh, and you have to try their cheese waffles (fries). this is the perfect place to go before or after watching a movie at the century 12 movie theater. you can always park at the parking garage for free or cheap (i forgot) and get it validated at the theater. this place has a hole in the wall charm to it with sticky tables and everything!
(5)Matt B.
I don't know why people have such a passion for this place. I found the wings to be mostly bone & gristle - certainly less meat than BW3s for instance. I'm not sure what advantage this place has over BW3s, and I'm not one to talk up a chain. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here.
(3)Nhu N.
you have to go here regularly to know that buff joes is amazing some days and eh ok others.. the last 2 times i've had it, it's been on point. HAVE TO get the cheddar chips they are simply divinnnnnnneeeee. Worth going to. not the cleanest place but they bumped it up with a plasma in the back
(3)Alan R.
Without a doubt the best wings in Chicago. They have mild, spicy and suicide. The suicide wings are only the spicy with jalapenos on them. An orange sauce and then deep fried to perfection, I miss my Joe's! When I lived in Evanston, I probably came here about once per week. If you don't like wings, they also have loaded baked potatoes, awesome chili, cheap but amazing burgers, and dogs and chicken sandwiches. Definitely a better fast food option than the national chains.
(5)Shimi L.
This place was a dissapointment. We got the suicide spicy which was hardly spicy, even with the jalapenos. The sauce was gummy and congealed. It was quite disgusting and I don't recommend entering this establishment.
(1)Rayid G.
xxx suicide sauce...mmmmmmm
(4)Max S.
Oh man how I miss Buff Joe's. Those wings/fries are soooo good. Heart attack inducing but worth it.
(5)Zach W.
The reason I couldn't go any higher with my rating was because it would be suicide, just like the wings! Suicide wings will be the death of you - guarantee it! My buddy takes me here every time we head north to golf. The first outing he warned us all about the suicide wings, but nobody listened. Let's just say we weren't right for a couple days.
(3)Michael S.
Simply the best wings I've ever had. I usually get a single order of mild, a side of buffalo chips (crosscut fries), and a large RC Cola. If I'm feeling fiesty i'll get a hot order (my buddies always go suicide, but i like tasting my wings). I'm a hungry guy most of the time, and single order can be a beast to finish. especially with fries. if you go for fries, i recommend asking for a second cup of ranch (ranch and celery come standard with the wings). If you do this right as they put the first ranch and celery on tray, they don't charge you. if you wait and make the checkout guy ask for one, he tacks it on the bill (at least in my experience). runs just over 10 bucks for the best dinner you'll have in long time. some reviews mention the wing size getting smaller. i've been going with my friends about once every few months for 5 years now and it may be slightly smaller every now and then, i just think its the batch, ya know? still so good, and i've actually had days where we got huuuuge wings. i wish i didn't write this review, i kinda wanna go now....
(5)Melissa M.
Despite being dubious in terms of health and cleanliness, the wings here really are good. Unfortunately that is a testament to the rich spicy sauce rather than the meat, which is a little on the dry lower-quality side. Sides are pretty good, I enjoy their fries. The atmosphere leaves much to be desired...because well, it's a dive, but a dive with good wing sauce.
(2)Ron S.
as good as it gets when it comes to getting wings in Illinois.
(5)Jacko J.
Food is ok. Buffalo Wild Wings and Wings Over Evanston are much better. The reason I'm posting is to complain about the ladies behind the counter. It was a slow lunch onTues. Maybe 2 tables and about 6 ladies "working" behind the counter. It took them15 minutes to make my hotdog and fries. I had to endure them cursing and talking about all sorts of crap that customers shouldn't hear while waiting for food. I'm traveling so I need a receipt for work. I get to the car and realize the hens didn't give me one. I go back and the lady looks at me like I'm crazy. No apology, she simply grabs a piece of paper and asks me what I ordered so she can scribble it down. Hey Mr Buffalo Joe if you don't have a computer printing out receipts how do you know these charming ladies aren't pocketing every other sale? And why do you need so many of them when you're so slow? Maybe you should go on Kitchen Nightmares?
(2)a w.
Their buffalo wings are definitely not the best, but when you add a good amount of suicide sauce, they'll become the best!! Its a nice restraunt, a very cheap eat, and a good place to come with a bunch of friends to enjoy good food in a casual setting!
(3)Ben S.
Most overated Wing place I have ever visited. At best these wings are better than average, and the size of the wings are incredibly dissapointing. Chicago does not do wings right- been living here for two years and yet to find anywhere that comes close to Buffalo or Pennsylvania inspired Wing places.
(2)Kat W.
This is a great joint for lunch/takeout wings and other fast food. Their wings are pretty good, but not the best I have had in Chicagoland; Mullen's on Clark has the best ones in my opinion. Having said that, the price is good, the food is good, and they serve pretty fast.
(4)calvin n.
This place never dissapoints except for the sanitation ( hey its not Buffalo Joes if its clean) I've known this place and gone here for years just wished it was still the old price of 3.75 for a single I believe??? but one time which is still stuck in my head was that the person who took my order was picking his teeth with his finger which was absolutly gross in my opinion I kept a close eye on him to make sure he didnt touch my food. Service is meh... ok not to bad accept one guy gave me attitude for asking for extra sauce... great place though I take most of my new friends here.
(4)steve c.
Good tiny suicide wings. Best? Not so much. Double order, waffle fries and large drink. (Dont ask but don't get the cheese for the fries) Always gave a different fake name. Comes with celery and for a double order its like $8 now.
(5)PJ K.
Dingy neighborhood joint; pretty much a rite of passage for anyone who went to NU or ETHS. A full menu of fast-food favorites, but I don't come here often enough (like maybe once a year) to be tempted away from ordering wings, which are made to order and a cut above what's available in most bars. Berghoff beer on tap, too. A fun stop for cheap eats in Evanston.
(4)James B.
Worth a special visit; as good as advertised.
(5)Nelson S.
My friend dragged me from the west suburbs all the way up to Evanston to try these so called "Best Wings Ever" (and he is allergic to chicken by the way). One, I was happy that I wasn't driving so take me wherever and two, I'm not sure if they were the "Best Wings Ever" but they were pretty darn tasty. I'm not sure if I have yet found the best wings ever but this does place high on my list. I thought the wings were quite small in size, like I would use it as a toothpick but you did get plenty of them. If I remember correctly, they also serve waffle fries! I love waffle fries, more place should serve waffle fries! If I did live in the area of this restaurant, I would most likely come here more often.
(4)Jenny M.
What's up with the sinking quality here? In the last month we've eaten there twice and both were ICK. Rotten celery, hairy wings, small wings, inconsistent saucing. We've done our share of damage at this joint over a bunch of years living in Evanston and never been as grossed out by last week's order taker picking at her hair and cleaning her nails while she was taking orders - and opening food containers on the line. Too bad, but they are no longer the only great wings on the block.
(2)Jesster A.
Agree with the general concensus: not THE best wings - but pretty "d" good and the best in the general area. The Cheddar waffle fries are good too. Bring a roll of "thirsty" paper towels (just kidding, kind of...) Perhaps it's just our germaphobic culture rubbing off on me (I try to avoid most forms of paranoia) - but for some reason here (and other places as well) I enjoy the food more if I DON'T watch them prepare it...
(4)Josh L.
I've been going to BJ's since I was in high school (about 15 years). The quality of the chicken seems to have gone down a little bit since then, but they still have the best buffalo wings I've ever tried - by far. I'm sure they'll give me a heart attack one day, but I can't stop paying them a visit every once in a while. It's a great place to eat with friends. I like to order my wings spicy with suicide sauce on the side (having the suicide sauce on the chicken sometimes overwhelms the taste a little too much).
(5)Ted W.
This place is awesome. Has one of the best wings in the chicago area. Always have sports games on. There fries are pretty good to.
(5)M. C.
Good wings, AMAZING cheddar fries! Dirty but good for a bite or for high school kids.
(4)Constantine H.
My favorite place to get wings. I prefer it over all the popular wing joints including BW3, Timothy O'Tooles, Gators, etc. We order from here for any party or sporting event and any guest that's never had it before always asks where we get them from. Something about the sauce will keep me coming back for the rest of my life.
(5)r j.
Is it me or does it seem that the suicide wings lost a heat level or two? Don't get me wrong the wings are still good but not as good as from what I remember. They have gotten a lot smaller over the years and the prices have gone up. The cheddar fries and gut buster R.C do bring back a lot of memories. Still an alright place to go to for wings.
(3)Christina B.
Perhaps my most favorite place to eat! Why can't they open a Buffalo Joe's in San Francisco? I practically lived here during my high school years, and every time I go back to Chicago I have to get an order of suicide wings to tide me through until the next visit.
(5)Eli R.
I get buffalo wings everywhere and these are the best I've ever had. It's kind of pricey unless you share (which I do not when it comes to wings). The buffalo chips are like waffled fries and are pretty good. A gutbuster RC should do the trick. Order extra ranch. Sometimes the kitchen smells a little funny, which can be disturbing. The wings really are great, though. The choices are mild, spicy, and suicide, but none are really that spicy. It's more about the great taste than hotness. Can also get crowded around lunchtime.
(4)Nick B.
Best buffalo wings around. Make sure to try their suicide wings, you won't regret it.
(4)Jaclyn C.
I don't know if I'd go with "Best buffalo wings ever" but they're good. And there's a wide-range of other options too.
(3)J H.
I'm giving it 5 stars simply because there is no competition in the area for wings. The sauce is fantastic but its basically liquid butter with hot sauce and vinegar. The hot wings are fantastic as it provides an excellent kick to balance out the buttery sauce. Spicy barbecue is one of my favorite as it is sweet and hot--the best combo. Suicide is hot and it really fills the void after couple drinks. For the best deal, just get a platter or half platter and split it with buddies and don't forget the pitcher of beer to wash it down.
(5)Mark P.
The perfect meal- double spicy, buffalo chips, and gutbuster RC. Love the spicy, buttery wings and waffle-cut fries. Avoid the Howard one, and stick to the downtown Evanston location.
(5)Stephanie M.
I was smart and came here with 3 of my guy friends. We got this huge foil pan of wings and a smaller pan of celery and blue cheese. It is so much fun to eat wings slathered with sauce and get messy. Yea, I even dropped some sauce onto my shirt. I looked like a slob.
(3)Yousuf K.
Always have great wings. However always received poor customer service. Only reason they aren't getting 5 stars. Also they don't take credit card. We are in the 21st century. I can go to a street vendor in Morocco and he will still take card!
(4)Daria D.
I had the buffalo chicken sandwich. It was okay, the chicken tasted a little like it was fried in old oil but perfectly crispy so I can't complain that much.
(3)Gabe H.
Some of the best, if not THE best wings I've ever had! I had a single order, mild, with jalapeño peppers on top. It was the perfect amount of sweet, buttery, and spiciness. Also, I highly recommend the waffle fries and a side of ranch. To describe it in one word: DELICIOUS. **Quick Tip! They only accept cash, but have an ATM just in case**
(5)Sara R.
These were the worst "buffalo" wings I have ever had. I ordered the mild wings, and was immediately discouraged by the terrible smell. I took one bite of one wing and that was enough for me to know I did not want to eat any more. The fries were cold, flavorless, and soggy. The only thing saving them was the Merkts cheese. I will not be going back.
(1)Lynn C.
I was craving a cheeseburger today so we popped into this place while walking and looking for a place to eat, it's a divey little place but sometimes those are the best. I think the guy on the grill was possibly the owner, he offered me a sample of his chili while I was waiting and it was absolutely delicious and I'm a picky chili eater. I ordered a bacon cheddar cheeseburger with sautéed onions, pickles and tomatoes cooked medium, it was cooked perfectly and the accompaniments were very fresh. they were very busy for lunch and I noticed most people ordering wings and waffle fries. Next time I find myself in Evenston I will try the wings.
(4)Alex A.
Ah, Buffalo Joe's! From being a regular in high school '92-96 (ufck I'm old!) to visiting just once in a blue moon these days...it's been a love affair from day one. At Joe's you WILL: - Eat too much - Finger the real cheddar (and not nacho "cheese" bullish) that didn't take to your waffle fries into your gob (British for mouth you uncultured twit) - Stop at an ATM first or have some cash on ya, ya lout! - Piss on ice cubes in a graffiti riddled bathroom (if you're a guy...God knows what women deal with here?!?) - Overpay ($8) for an order of wings...but not really because your fat ayeuss (mine too) *should* be splitting this artery clogging 1,400 calorie estimated meal - See Bulls' Steve Kerr spitting image brother proprietor of the place on occasion - Leave happy Joe's wings are excellent...they are a bit small relative to most but Steve Kerr says it's because the other guys have hormoned up preternatural chickens. Perhaps... Get suicide, ya wuss...it's not as hot as it sounds...just a mixture of two sauces and some wussified pickled 'peños on top. Buttery, sour, piquant delicious...THIS is the original aficionado wing of a North sider or suburbanite! I'd give the nod on wing quality and taste slightly...JUST slightly...to Bird's Nest...but Joe's is like your first girlfriend....you NEVER FORGET. Eat at Joe's, maggot!
(4)Chun M.
During a visit to nearby Northwestern U, the admissions counselor joked about never going hungry as an undergrad because he lived above Buffalo Joe's. That was as good a recommendation as I've heard before. Never passing up an opportunity for college town eats, we headed over there for lunch after our campus tour. Street parking is readily available on this side street. You walk in, order at the register and wait to be called to pick up your food. The grilled chicken sandwich was moist & tasty. The chicken tenders were a little over cooked, but still good, as were the waffle fries. The namesake wings were disappointing though. Even though the texture and taste were good, the wingettes are so small, they looked like they came from downtown pigeons. A decent amount of about 13-14 per order, but the meat on them were pretty scrawny. You might have to get a double order if you're hungry. Reminds me of my college buddy who could stick a wing in his mouth, swish it around and spit out a clean bone. That talent ranks up there with tying a cherry stem into a knot. Wings are good for silly bar tricks to impress your buddies, but not enough for a meal.
(3)Minh-An C.
Immediately walking into the store, my friends and I lowkey regret entering this place and started fearing for our lives. It was our first time in Evanston and we were unfamiliar with the neighborhood. The workers in Buffalo all looked intimidating and seemed to be staring us down. I timidly placed our double order of chicken wings and was curious if I could pick two sauce for the wings. The waiter replied to my question by a roll of her eyes and I was a bit lost..so I asked to clarify "yes I can pick two sauces or no I can't?" and she roughly answered no. So I settled for the BBQ flavored wings with an order of waffle fries. It came out to less than $20 and enough to feed 3 people. CASH ONLY. The food came out fairly fast and we quickly dug in. After the first bite, all my regrets of coming into this store went away and I was in chicken wing heaven. The wings were perfectly crispy and a right portion of meat on each wing. The double order came with carrots and celery. And the waffle fries were yummy, too! Cheap metered parking across the street and around the neighborhood. Walking distance to Northwestern campus.
(4)Kevin T.
I've eaten here so many times, but only now getting around to reviewing it. I love the wings here, but they can be very inconsistent. Sometimes your double order feels like a 1.5 order, sometimes the chicken they serve you is really dry, sometimes it's soggy. However, they get it right more times than they get it wrong. And when they get it right, it's pure bliss. Some major downsides are that it's cash only and the service can be really bad sometimes. The people taking your order seem to prioritize chit chatting with each other over taking your order. There's an ATM inside the place where you can withdraw money, but of course there are fees for doing so. The eating area also never feels "clean enough".
(4)Jeannie A.
I've heard great things about this place. After waiting about 20 minutes to get my order, that I had to remind them about, I sat down to a stack of wings the size of my pinky finger. Having great sauce is the only thing that kept me from complaining about my experience here. The sauce would be considered one of the best, if it was applied to wings of actual substance, with meat on them. After eating a double order of wings, I leave still starving and just annoyed that I wasted an hour of my life there. Not to mention the staff is rude, and when asking for a refill they looked at me with a death stare and charged me $1.50. The best bet would be buying their sauce and going elsewhere.
(2)Leslie S.
wings are OK I guess- its the atmosphere I hate- just plain dirty- I expected a chorus ine to perform a dance on the table. Dirty floors, dirty tables, greasy dirty walls- yum
(2)Cindy C.
Addictive wings.. One star taken off for lack of consistency of the sauce on the wing. Sometimes there isn't enough sauce and sometime, they're drenched in them. My mother in law loves these wings and that is a great compliment.
(4)Naty K.
This place was ONCE at it's prime (somewhat of a prime), and is rapidly going down hill. The Evanston location is extremely dirty! Feels like a 2 AM movie scene when you're in the middle of nowhere, in some weird diner/restaurant. Yes, that's the feel I get when i'm in this place. The employee's are certainly missing more than half of the customer service skills needed to fulfill a customer service/ restaurant job. This place needs to be renovated into like, a McDonald's or something more useful. The wings are tiny, skimpy, and unless drenched in sauce, tasteless. The cheese sauce can be overwhelmingly gritty, and you can literally taste the artificial additives which makes me gag at the thought! This place does have 2 things going for it, which is... 1: The hot sauce (Which is EXTREMELY unappealing when I see it come out of that plastic jug that's probably been sitting on the shelf for God knows how long) but still tasty if you don't think about it, LOL. 2: The oatmeal cookies are yummy! Wish they were bigger. Overall, this place has def lost it's touch and is certainly NOT a Chicago staple! I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone, given the exception of a college student looking for a quick bite. TO WINGSTOP WE GO!:)
(1)Priam D.
This was a cult place in high school, and I still come here every time I'm back in town. I know that we're all biased in favor of the restaurants with which we grew up, but these are the best buffalo wings I've ever had. I also love the cheddar fries.
(5)Dan C.
The ultimate late night junk food! I always get the single order suicide wings.. and sometimes the waffle fries with cheese. For these places usually I call in ahead, but I do enjoy walking in, sitting on one of the stools, and taking in the local vibe. It is cash only, so plan ahead. The suicide wings are sort of a misnomer to me. It's great, but it's not thai "kill you" spicy. It's very sweet and tickles, and it leaves a very small heat after eating a few wings. I may be wrong, but I think it's primarily vinegar and butter based. The jalapenos do not hurt at all, so don't be afraid of suicide level. Waffle fries are amazing, and the cheese just adds that little bit of "I shouldn't eat this but it tastes so good!" My only possible complaint would be the small chicken wings, but if I think about it the wings allow you to enjoy the sauce more, which is primarily one of the reasons I frequent this place over others. Conclusion: for chicken wings, go to Buffalo Joe's. For fried chicken, go to Chicken Shack!
(5)Timothy A.
Employees here are about as ghetto as can be. Rude as hell and talk to you like trash. Some serious customer service classes are needed here. Employees just don't care about the concept of serving and don't understand that the customer comes first. They practically threw my food at me when it was done. Hell I wouldn't put it past them spitting in my food if I complained about something seeing the type of people that work there. Below low quality, sub human treatment. Dogs get better service. Can't say much for the food since it was generic and as low quality as a hole in the wall can be. Chicken wings were bland, frozen and tasteless deep fried matter.
(1)Brian N.
I don't understand throes of you who praise Buffalo joes. This isn't even food. Seriously the wings are TERRIBLE. I got a burger once and it had cheese spread on it in place of a slice. The food makes my stomach turn. They dump salt on the fried like there's no tomorrow and the people who work there are delinquents. They're rude as fuck EVERY time I've gone there (which is about 4-5 until I officially wrote this dump off) People saying "oh buff joes is great" must either be on a masculinity overcompensation quest OR just incapable of tasting anything.
(1)B L.
Sometimes way too small. Service is horrible. Always getting more expensive. But it doesn't matter because it's still my favorite place to get wings.
(5)JaeMin K.
Would probably be a really good place for wings if their sauce wasn't so sour and the chickens they use aren't so scrawny. We got the spicy and suicide sauce, but the sauce was more sour than spicy. It was so overwhelming that I eventually had to blot in a napkin before eating it. Suicide is essentially spicy sauce with jalapeños. If you prefer the sour taste of buffalo sauce though, it is the place for you! Their single portion is very generous--around 12 wings for $8. Make sure you bring cash because this place is cash only!!
(3)Hannah H.
About a 2-2.5: Buffalo Joe's is an NU institution; this place is opened late, and they are known for their buffalo wings and chips (waffle fries). I usually get the Suicide Wings, extra well-done, with a side of cheddar chips. The sauce is more tangy and saucy, rather than spicy (there are slices of jalapenos on top to give it that 'kick'). There is a consistency problem with the size of the wings, as the size has decreased tremendously; in addition, the taste of the wings can alternate being saucy and tangy or tasting like ammonia (!!!). Make sure you request for fresh chips (waffle fries), as when it gets cold, you can't appreciate the thick powdery cheese sauce that comes on top (it's thick, creamy, and salty; this can also fluctuate in being a little less thick)! I love that they have RC Cola, which is quite refreshing. The tables are sticky, and the place is not the most clean and sanitary-friendly (the bathroom is another whole mess :O Also, keep in mind that they only accept cash. +Cheddar Chips +Suicide Wings (extra well-done) +cash only +sticky tables T___T +metered parking
(3)Chrissy S.
If you're a wing lover buff joes is definitely the go to spot in the area. I've been coming here for over ten years and it's always delicious. I've noticed recently they've changed their sauce from a spicy buffalo to a more spicy BBQ type deal, but it's still really good. Another thing they've changed is their portions, which are pretty small now for what you're paying. They also have the best homemade oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. I always stock up on these before I leave, they're addicting.
(4)Haley K.
Buff joes is like a treasure sent from heaven in a messy paper container. Voices go silent as wings are munched to the bone and other-worldly Merkts cheddar dressed on perfectly crunchy waffle fries are devoured. Take time to appreciate their strange wall hangings and paint color choice. Cash only makes you feel like you're in a drug deal for the best stuff out there.
(5)Park R.
This place has delicious wings! Suicide is not that spicy, but hits the spot. They are very small, indeed, but they give you plenty of them. And that small size (and dusting with spices before frying) means you get even-doneness and lots of crispy skin relative to the small but toothsome and well-cooked amount of meat. Much better compared with pumped-up frankenwings, or boneless fakes. The waffle fries (buffalo chips) are delectable served with real cheddar -- yes, it's grainy, that's how it's supposed to be. It is called a pub spread, and the cheddar flavor is also great if you get it on one of their nicely charred, but always too greasy burgers. Always a good place for a perfect brat with mustard and grilled onions, and a beer for under $10! That is unusual in etown. The staff here does often fight with each other, and can be a little surly, but that is part of the charm. If you are nice and respectful of these powerful keepers of the wings, then they always treat you well. Maybe they don't really deserve 5 stars. But I must fight the haters. Sure, it gets better and worse over the years... I been coming here since the early 90's, and having eaten here about 100X it has never been bad, and always a fun time and a fair deal. Go Joe's!
(5)Joani O.
This was the place to go growing up, and friends from out of town always wanted to eat here as well. Recently, not so much. Their quality has gone DOWN. The buffalo wings, which they're known for, are now tiny with hardly any meat on them. Very disappointing. (I also like Bleu cheese dip and both carrots and celery on the side; Buffalo Joe's only serves ranch and celery.) My daughter ordered a burger and not only was it burnt, but it was much more bun than burger. They also use the sharp cheddar Merkdt cheese which is clumpy and has a far too pungent taste for a kid. What's wrong with regular sliced cheese? Their waffle fries are good, but those alone aren't worth the trip here anymore. There are other items on the menu, yet I always came for the wings!!
(2)Jay B.
-One of my favorite wing spots since highschool -wings are made to order and apun right in front of you -seats about 25 people comfortably with standing area tables in the front -cheddar waffle fries are a must, they are on the sweeter side -wings are a b
(5)Rye M.
Bo Jo's is so ferda. I managed to get a few of my bots to make the long drive down here and it was so worth it. They didn't believe snee when I said it was better than bdubs. The staff is foyntastic but if you can get over the service the food is so worth it. I'm so happy the koozie king blessed me with the knowledge of this joint.
(5)Ushna A.
I came here to eat with my Philippino friend who recommended this place. When we walked in the joint the black workers here had bad attitudes and were being rude. We placed an order , after receiving our wings it seemed cold. My Philippino friend Leo went up to the counter and told them the situation they rolled there eyes. He called them out on there behavior and the black girl looked over at another black girl behind the counter and stated aren't there people use to eating cold dogs ,( as in the pet animal). I'm totally appalled! I'm telling everyone about this in the Filipino community ...
(1)Anish A.
Ghetto and rude! Once you walk in your greeted with rudeness. I'll stick to Buffalo Wild Wings and wing stop. The black people working here are extremely rude are not friendly. I over heard them talking about a gay male white customer who ordered his food just before I did. Once the customer left they started, mocking his mannerisms and joking about his alternative life style. I don't appreciate prejudice people. I canceled my order and walked out.
(1)Eric B.
I love wings and Buffalo Joe's does it right! Some people see the small wing as a negative, on the contrary, i LOVE the smaller wings for the flavor they bring. The sauces are fantastic and their hottest sauce is perfect for me. Can't wait to go back!
(5)Paco L.
Great food. The buffalo cheese chips are the absolute best. Come here at least one a week.
(5)Eva S.
Buff Joe's.... always works their magic. When someone mentions it, the response is usually: "omg Buff Joe's, it's SO good let's go there NOW!" said quickly, almost panicky in one breath. Or followed by: "I need Buff Joe's, why'd you have to mention it, we need to go NOW!" When someone mentions your favorite type of food, you have a mini anxiety attack when your mouth waters and you need dem wings... That's kinda what happens... no matter what time of day. I always get a single order of Suicide Wings (topped with jalapenos) with a side of waffle fries ("Buffalo Chips" $1.89). Your order will come with celery and ranch, and a wetwipe (which you will certainly need). Sometimes I'll wash everything down with an RC. Their wings are freshly fried, then tossed in tangy sauce. A single order is $7.99 and you better bring cash because it's CASH only... but they have a generic ATM right inside the restaurant in case you forget. They also serve beer and these little oatmeal chocolate chip cookies in a huge tub by the cashier, which look heavenly, but I never have room for dessert. Also, they have a "XXX" sauce which is a spicy habenero-type darker red sauce... which I have only requested on the side as a sample because I heard eating an order with that sauce is brutal for your tastebuds. Try it on the side first to see if you'll like it because once you start it's so spicy it hurts. So maybe I have an unhealthy relationship with this place. But if wings were ever going inside my stomach, they better be from here. When friends visit from out of town, I'll take them to Buff Joe's and with a serious face, say: "These are the best wings in Chicago." (Deep dish pizza will be tomorrow night...) I only go to the Clark location, although there are two others on Green Bay and Howard. After I have gone and out-done myself again in the form of massive wing consumption, I say I've reached my Buff Joe's quota, forever. But of course I end up coming back the following month or so. This stuff is on par with being one of my last meals on urf. Heaven on urf...earth.
(5)Leonel H.
This establishment has gone from a 90'S SENSATION to a ghetto establishment the culture isn't there anymore. The customer service is a joke I had a complaint with the bonanza special I brought it to their attention staff did not show any sympoyhy. Also since when was it o k to sell drugs in a restaurant. Literally there was a drug deal going on in there when I sat down and ate my food. The quality of the meat chicken ribs whatever is digesting. Whoever is the current owner of this establishment shame on u.
(1)Anthony P.
I go to buff Joe's with my buddies all the time. I seem to be the only one who finds the wings to be just ok. The wings are somewhat small, and they are a little too crispy and dry. Also, the sauce they put on the wings is a little bland and lacks a distinct taste. Buffalo Joe's also does not have the greatest variety of sauces, with only three different variations. The interior is also not the cleanest place on earth. If you want better wings and better variety, I would head over to wings over Evanston just a couple blocks away.
(3)Jonathan N.
Having had the opportunity to eat at some of the best wing joints in the US, I was sorely disappointed in the food, cleanliness, customer service, and overall first impression of Buffalo Joes. The wings were soggy, swimming in a gag-inducing mild sauce, and fatty. I am so used to grilled, crispy/charred, or at least baked crisp and not soggy wings. Mother Pluckers throughout Texas is a good example of awesome wings. Spending a few days shadowing that Texas institution might serve the ownership of Buffalo Joes well. I doubt if I will ever go back to BJs again. Regardless of the reviews, it's prima facie evidence that the fans and locals have limited experience in what a good wing tastes like.
(1)Karen C.
Holy deliciousness! Went out looking initially for a good burger to take home. After discovering one place was closed, my friend suggested grabbing something from here. We went all out. Split some spicy wings and cheese fries. And then had a sandwich each. The wings. So good! I cannot say enough good things about them. Cheese fries...eh. The cheese wasn't what I was expecting. But the fries themselves, yes! We both decided the sandwiches were good. But honestly it's all about the wings! I cannot wait to go back.
(5)Shawn J.
Could EASILY be the best wings in Chicago if they stopped using anorexic chickens...the wings barely have any meat on them! Their sauce is the best I've ever tasted, though. Also, they only accept cash. It's 2015. Other establishments accept electronic payment and these dudes can't get a credit card reader. One last complaint, they charge 50 cents for a teaspoon of ranch if you want extra.
(3)Lauren G.
Best.wings.ever. Order them spicy with a side of buffalo chips and an RC. I mean it's the best combo for some reason or another. Sometimes it can be a real hit or miss but regardless it's delicious. What I mean is just sometimes it's not as good(when they skimp on the sauce hmph) and sometimes it's really on point. Like any place really. CASH ONLY. 12.00 for everything. The order comes with like 10-12 wings. The buffalo chips are seasoned so well. I recommend eating there the wings and fries can get soggy taking it to go not as good but still good. The sauce is like crack I swear idk what they put in it but it makes you want more! O_o! The wings itself are little with a good amount of meat. If you're not a fan of little wings and more for the bigger sized I would say still try but you may be disappointed.
(5)Andrew Z.
My friends took me here since I was visiting them. They asked me what I was in the mood for and I replied "something with protein". I think mounds of chicken qualify. I don't usually get buffalo flavor wings at places like Buffalo Wild Wings - usually I opt for some variation of "savory" (spicy garlic, parmesan garlic, garlic fries... I really like garlic, ok?) but I ordered the Mild wings here and really liked them. I don't know how they make the sauce, but it's seemed to be more savory and less vinegary than the ones I've had. So if you're like me, and usually don't like buffalo wings, I would still suggest trying this place out. Good stuff, Buff Joe's.
(4)Albert M.
BEST BUFFALO WINGS IN AMERICA! HANDS DOWN, NO QUESTIONS ASKED!! Chicago is a city rich and immersed in history from the water tower to Mrs. O'Leary, the Cubs/Sox/Bears/Bulls, the Daly's. This city is also known as the city of broad shoulders which I directly attribute to the fact that it is freezing, so you gotta eat a lot and that's why Chicago is a city so rich and immersed in incredible food....deep dish pizza, hot dogs, italian beef, popcorn, and so on. But my favorite place in all of Chicago is a hole in the wall buffalo wing place where spicy perfection lies. It's the one place I MUST go whenever I am in town, no ifs, ands or buts. It's called Buffalo Joes, or to the locals Buff Joe's. It is cash only. It is run by employees just as angry as the Wiener Circle a few miles south. I argue the employees of Wiener Circle work during the day at Buff Joe's and the night at the Circle of Wiener. This place has burgers, hot dogs, italian beef, but you come for the wings, the celery and the ranch. I am pretty sure that this place has been open 40+ years and my father in law was the first to order a burger. The wings are giant and so meaty. The wings are cooked perfectly. The sauce is buttery and perfect. Get the suicide...its just their normal hot wings with jalapenos. Get the cheese fries! Get a large RC! PERFECTION!Wings, cheese fries, and RC with extra ranch and celery from Buff Joe's is on my short list for finals meals if I was on death row. SPRINT, DO NOT RUN, DO NOT WALK!!!!!!
(5)Marikit R.
Best chicken wings in town! I'm a girl who can handle her spice, so suicide (which is basically spicy with jalapeños on top) order for me! Whether you got the single or double order, there's a complimentary of celery with the order! The waffle fries are good too! The ranch they give you is pretty small, so I ask for two extra ranch and they charge a quarter each. The cookies are amazing too! Might not look like it because its in a sketchy non transparent container, that looks like it hasn't been cleaned, but trust me, the oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are a must! The only bad thing of this place, to me at least, is the cheddar cheese. It's tastes, old? Maybe I got a bad batch but I know I won't ever get the cheese on my fries again.
(4)Jenn E.
I'm sad to say that this place really failed to meet my expectations. Came here with high expectations given the Yelp reviews but was really disappointed. Service was fast and pleasant enough and I didn't get any raw chicken but it was really not great. I got spicy wings (sorry Yelp fans, suicide is just too much for me) and waited while they freshly prepared them and then took them home where I ate them immediately. Unfortunately, in the very short walk home, the sauce seemed to separate and i was left with an oily goo in the bottom of the container and some wings that were basically dry. Aside from the texture, the sauce was ok but it was really oily which was pretty gross to me. The wings themselves were also pretty sad. The meat was sparse and tough and at times was too tough for me to chew through without some serious effort. I would have preferred way less but more meaty wings. Towards the end I was swirling the wings in sauce in hopes that it might make it all better but honestly no matter what I tried my wings were pretty tasteless, sauce was oily and I agree with others, there is a really weird after taste. Also, they only have ranch! Cash only. I want to say I'll try it again, but honestly, it won't be for a very long time, if ever.
(1)Victoria S.
This place serves the best diggitey-darn wings I have ever figgitey figgety fricken tried. Despite having to pay with cash (always got sacks) this place really tickles my taste buds and goes great with other types of bud. You really need to get down and dirty but it's a great messy first date! The wings are so succulent they should have a novel written about them. I am writing that novel. Check back in a few days, for now let me provide you with a single excerpt. "I would never, could never, forget that moment. It has been burned into my memory by the unrelenting flaming heat of Buffalo Joe's sauce. The crunchy flesh of wild, possibly free range FDA organic, chicken fell of the bone like an avalanche of meat crashing down Mt. Everest and onto the head of unsuspecting Victor Sunkelson, the first man I killed."
(5)Richard Y.
One of my previous favs has unfortunately gone downhill. 'Had lunch here with a friend today. The wings are good but the size and crispness have declined, as has the order accuracy. I ordered a chix salad sandwich and received a grilled chix breast sandwich-- huh? And cash only? In the 21st century? Luckily I had cash on me. Buff j s used to have an edge on food and service but has, IMHO, lost it.
(3)Feb S.
Taste: 3.5 Location: 4 Cleanliness: 3.5 Ambience: 3 Value: 3.5 Service: 3 OVERALL = 3.5 * Out of a 5-point scale I got the Suicide Wings and Spicy Cheddar Waffle Fries (they call them Chips). The taste was pretty good, but for Suicide Wings, I expected something much spicier but was let down instead. Overall it still can't beat Buffalo Wild Wings flavors. I'd still recommend this though for anyone looking for Wings in downtown Evanston.
(4)Dee S.
How does this place get great reviews? Haha, I guess you have to be from Evanston to get it. The wings are amazing...IF you like extremely tiny, super greasy pigeon wings with stomach acid for sauce these will be right up your alley! The fries OH EM GEE the fries were so good, the best cardboard I've ever had! The ketchup was so good and fresh too..this place just really knows how to give you violent diarrhea.. What a clean establishment this is might I add, it looks like its cleaned on a daily basis, I love the giant stain right where the overhead menu used to be..
(1)Shajan K.
I haven't been here in years and I remembered why I stopped going...CASH ONLY policy! Otherwise, the wings are great, especially suicide style! Soaked in sauce and jalapenos? Can't ever go wrong with that! Cheese fries can use a little work.
(4)Ian S.
So I've been getting BJ's (Buffalo Joe's) for a long time but only at this location. If you want the better wings and fries, this location is IT! Can't say much for the other ones but they were meh. So onto the review, if you love spicy wings, you have to get suicide wings. If you're like me, a double order is more than enough. It comes with jalapeños on the wings and the sauce is awesomesauce! If you dine in, they serve beer too! Don't forget to order suicide cheddar chips with your meal. It's waffle fries smothered in awesome cheddar and suicide sauce! Ok now this review is making me crave BJ's. I'll make a stop this week. Ahhhhhhh! P.S. If you make buffalo chicken dip, try substituting franks red hot with the suicide sauce. You can order some on the side and trust me, you won't regret it! It's always a hit and perfect for watching Da Bears game.
(5)Gabe H.
Some of the best, if not THE best wings I've ever had! I had a single order, mild, with jalapeño peppers on top. It was the perfect amount of sweet, buttery, and spiciness. Also, I highly recommend the waffle fries and a side of ranch. To describe it in one word: DELICIOUS. **Quick Tip! They only accept cash, but have an ATM just in case**
(5)Sara R.
These were the worst "buffalo" wings I have ever had. I ordered the mild wings, and was immediately discouraged by the terrible smell. I took one bite of one wing and that was enough for me to know I did not want to eat any more. The fries were cold, flavorless, and soggy. The only thing saving them was the Merkts cheese. I will not be going back.
(1)Alex A.
Ah, Buffalo Joe's! From being a regular in high school '92-96 (ufck I'm old!) to visiting just once in a blue moon these days...it's been a love affair from day one. At Joe's you WILL: - Eat too much - Finger the real cheddar (and not nacho "cheese" bullish) that didn't take to your waffle fries into your gob (British for mouth you uncultured twit) - Stop at an ATM first or have some cash on ya, ya lout! - Piss on ice cubes in a graffiti riddled bathroom (if you're a guy...God knows what women deal with here?!?) - Overpay ($8) for an order of wings...but not really because your fat ayeuss (mine too) *should* be splitting this artery clogging 1,400 calorie estimated meal - See Bulls' Steve Kerr spitting image brother proprietor of the place on occasion - Leave happy Joe's wings are excellent...they are a bit small relative to most but Steve Kerr says it's because the other guys have hormoned up preternatural chickens. Perhaps... Get suicide, ya wuss...it's not as hot as it sounds...just a mixture of two sauces and some wussified pickled 'peños on top. Buttery, sour, piquant delicious...THIS is the original aficionado wing of a North sider or suburbanite! I'd give the nod on wing quality and taste slightly...JUST slightly...to Bird's Nest...but Joe's is like your first girlfriend....you NEVER FORGET. Eat at Joe's, maggot!
(4)Chun M.
During a visit to nearby Northwestern U, the admissions counselor joked about never going hungry as an undergrad because he lived above Buffalo Joe's. That was as good a recommendation as I've heard before. Never passing up an opportunity for college town eats, we headed over there for lunch after our campus tour. Street parking is readily available on this side street. You walk in, order at the register and wait to be called to pick up your food. The grilled chicken sandwich was moist & tasty. The chicken tenders were a little over cooked, but still good, as were the waffle fries. The namesake wings were disappointing though. Even though the texture and taste were good, the wingettes are so small, they looked like they came from downtown pigeons. A decent amount of about 13-14 per order, but the meat on them were pretty scrawny. You might have to get a double order if you're hungry. Reminds me of my college buddy who could stick a wing in his mouth, swish it around and spit out a clean bone. That talent ranks up there with tying a cherry stem into a knot. Wings are good for silly bar tricks to impress your buddies, but not enough for a meal.
(3)Minh-An C.
Immediately walking into the store, my friends and I lowkey regret entering this place and started fearing for our lives. It was our first time in Evanston and we were unfamiliar with the neighborhood. The workers in Buffalo all looked intimidating and seemed to be staring us down. I timidly placed our double order of chicken wings and was curious if I could pick two sauce for the wings. The waiter replied to my question by a roll of her eyes and I was a bit lost..so I asked to clarify "yes I can pick two sauces or no I can't?" and she roughly answered no. So I settled for the BBQ flavored wings with an order of waffle fries. It came out to less than $20 and enough to feed 3 people. CASH ONLY. The food came out fairly fast and we quickly dug in. After the first bite, all my regrets of coming into this store went away and I was in chicken wing heaven. The wings were perfectly crispy and a right portion of meat on each wing. The double order came with carrots and celery. And the waffle fries were yummy, too! Cheap metered parking across the street and around the neighborhood. Walking distance to Northwestern campus.
(4)Kevin T.
I've eaten here so many times, but only now getting around to reviewing it. I love the wings here, but they can be very inconsistent. Sometimes your double order feels like a 1.5 order, sometimes the chicken they serve you is really dry, sometimes it's soggy. However, they get it right more times than they get it wrong. And when they get it right, it's pure bliss. Some major downsides are that it's cash only and the service can be really bad sometimes. The people taking your order seem to prioritize chit chatting with each other over taking your order. There's an ATM inside the place where you can withdraw money, but of course there are fees for doing so. The eating area also never feels "clean enough".
(4)Jeannie A.
I've heard great things about this place. After waiting about 20 minutes to get my order, that I had to remind them about, I sat down to a stack of wings the size of my pinky finger. Having great sauce is the only thing that kept me from complaining about my experience here. The sauce would be considered one of the best, if it was applied to wings of actual substance, with meat on them. After eating a double order of wings, I leave still starving and just annoyed that I wasted an hour of my life there. Not to mention the staff is rude, and when asking for a refill they looked at me with a death stare and charged me $1.50. The best bet would be buying their sauce and going elsewhere.
(2)Leslie S.
wings are OK I guess- its the atmosphere I hate- just plain dirty- I expected a chorus ine to perform a dance on the table. Dirty floors, dirty tables, greasy dirty walls- yum
(2)Cindy C.
Addictive wings.. One star taken off for lack of consistency of the sauce on the wing. Sometimes there isn't enough sauce and sometime, they're drenched in them. My mother in law loves these wings and that is a great compliment.
(4)Naty K.
This place was ONCE at it's prime (somewhat of a prime), and is rapidly going down hill. The Evanston location is extremely dirty! Feels like a 2 AM movie scene when you're in the middle of nowhere, in some weird diner/restaurant. Yes, that's the feel I get when i'm in this place. The employee's are certainly missing more than half of the customer service skills needed to fulfill a customer service/ restaurant job. This place needs to be renovated into like, a McDonald's or something more useful. The wings are tiny, skimpy, and unless drenched in sauce, tasteless. The cheese sauce can be overwhelmingly gritty, and you can literally taste the artificial additives which makes me gag at the thought! This place does have 2 things going for it, which is... 1: The hot sauce (Which is EXTREMELY unappealing when I see it come out of that plastic jug that's probably been sitting on the shelf for God knows how long) but still tasty if you don't think about it, LOL. 2: The oatmeal cookies are yummy! Wish they were bigger. Overall, this place has def lost it's touch and is certainly NOT a Chicago staple! I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone, given the exception of a college student looking for a quick bite. TO WINGSTOP WE GO!:)
(1)Priam D.
This was a cult place in high school, and I still come here every time I'm back in town. I know that we're all biased in favor of the restaurants with which we grew up, but these are the best buffalo wings I've ever had. I also love the cheddar fries.
(5)Dan C.
The ultimate late night junk food! I always get the single order suicide wings.. and sometimes the waffle fries with cheese. For these places usually I call in ahead, but I do enjoy walking in, sitting on one of the stools, and taking in the local vibe. It is cash only, so plan ahead. The suicide wings are sort of a misnomer to me. It's great, but it's not thai "kill you" spicy. It's very sweet and tickles, and it leaves a very small heat after eating a few wings. I may be wrong, but I think it's primarily vinegar and butter based. The jalapenos do not hurt at all, so don't be afraid of suicide level. Waffle fries are amazing, and the cheese just adds that little bit of "I shouldn't eat this but it tastes so good!" My only possible complaint would be the small chicken wings, but if I think about it the wings allow you to enjoy the sauce more, which is primarily one of the reasons I frequent this place over others. Conclusion: for chicken wings, go to Buffalo Joe's. For fried chicken, go to Chicken Shack!
(5)Timothy A.
Employees here are about as ghetto as can be. Rude as hell and talk to you like trash. Some serious customer service classes are needed here. Employees just don't care about the concept of serving and don't understand that the customer comes first. They practically threw my food at me when it was done. Hell I wouldn't put it past them spitting in my food if I complained about something seeing the type of people that work there. Below low quality, sub human treatment. Dogs get better service. Can't say much for the food since it was generic and as low quality as a hole in the wall can be. Chicken wings were bland, frozen and tasteless deep fried matter.
(1)Brian N.
I don't understand throes of you who praise Buffalo joes. This isn't even food. Seriously the wings are TERRIBLE. I got a burger once and it had cheese spread on it in place of a slice. The food makes my stomach turn. They dump salt on the fried like there's no tomorrow and the people who work there are delinquents. They're rude as fuck EVERY time I've gone there (which is about 4-5 until I officially wrote this dump off) People saying "oh buff joes is great" must either be on a masculinity overcompensation quest OR just incapable of tasting anything.
(1)B L.
Sometimes way too small. Service is horrible. Always getting more expensive. But it doesn't matter because it's still my favorite place to get wings.
(5)JaeMin K.
Would probably be a really good place for wings if their sauce wasn't so sour and the chickens they use aren't so scrawny. We got the spicy and suicide sauce, but the sauce was more sour than spicy. It was so overwhelming that I eventually had to blot in a napkin before eating it. Suicide is essentially spicy sauce with jalapeños. If you prefer the sour taste of buffalo sauce though, it is the place for you! Their single portion is very generous--around 12 wings for $8. Make sure you bring cash because this place is cash only!!
(3)Hannah H.
About a 2-2.5: Buffalo Joe's is an NU institution; this place is opened late, and they are known for their buffalo wings and chips (waffle fries). I usually get the Suicide Wings, extra well-done, with a side of cheddar chips. The sauce is more tangy and saucy, rather than spicy (there are slices of jalapenos on top to give it that 'kick'). There is a consistency problem with the size of the wings, as the size has decreased tremendously; in addition, the taste of the wings can alternate being saucy and tangy or tasting like ammonia (!!!). Make sure you request for fresh chips (waffle fries), as when it gets cold, you can't appreciate the thick powdery cheese sauce that comes on top (it's thick, creamy, and salty; this can also fluctuate in being a little less thick)! I love that they have RC Cola, which is quite refreshing. The tables are sticky, and the place is not the most clean and sanitary-friendly (the bathroom is another whole mess :O Also, keep in mind that they only accept cash. +Cheddar Chips +Suicide Wings (extra well-done) +cash only +sticky tables T___T +metered parking
(3)Chrissy S.
If you're a wing lover buff joes is definitely the go to spot in the area. I've been coming here for over ten years and it's always delicious. I've noticed recently they've changed their sauce from a spicy buffalo to a more spicy BBQ type deal, but it's still really good. Another thing they've changed is their portions, which are pretty small now for what you're paying. They also have the best homemade oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. I always stock up on these before I leave, they're addicting.
(4)Haley K.
Buff joes is like a treasure sent from heaven in a messy paper container. Voices go silent as wings are munched to the bone and other-worldly Merkts cheddar dressed on perfectly crunchy waffle fries are devoured. Take time to appreciate their strange wall hangings and paint color choice. Cash only makes you feel like you're in a drug deal for the best stuff out there.
(5)Park R.
This place has delicious wings! Suicide is not that spicy, but hits the spot. They are very small, indeed, but they give you plenty of them. And that small size (and dusting with spices before frying) means you get even-doneness and lots of crispy skin relative to the small but toothsome and well-cooked amount of meat. Much better compared with pumped-up frankenwings, or boneless fakes. The waffle fries (buffalo chips) are delectable served with real cheddar -- yes, it's grainy, that's how it's supposed to be. It is called a pub spread, and the cheddar flavor is also great if you get it on one of their nicely charred, but always too greasy burgers. Always a good place for a perfect brat with mustard and grilled onions, and a beer for under $10! That is unusual in etown. The staff here does often fight with each other, and can be a little surly, but that is part of the charm. If you are nice and respectful of these powerful keepers of the wings, then they always treat you well. Maybe they don't really deserve 5 stars. But I must fight the haters. Sure, it gets better and worse over the years... I been coming here since the early 90's, and having eaten here about 100X it has never been bad, and always a fun time and a fair deal. Go Joe's!
(5)Joani O.
This was the place to go growing up, and friends from out of town always wanted to eat here as well. Recently, not so much. Their quality has gone DOWN. The buffalo wings, which they're known for, are now tiny with hardly any meat on them. Very disappointing. (I also like Bleu cheese dip and both carrots and celery on the side; Buffalo Joe's only serves ranch and celery.) My daughter ordered a burger and not only was it burnt, but it was much more bun than burger. They also use the sharp cheddar Merkdt cheese which is clumpy and has a far too pungent taste for a kid. What's wrong with regular sliced cheese? Their waffle fries are good, but those alone aren't worth the trip here anymore. There are other items on the menu, yet I always came for the wings!!
(2)Jay B.
-One of my favorite wing spots since highschool -wings are made to order and apun right in front of you -seats about 25 people comfortably with standing area tables in the front -cheddar waffle fries are a must, they are on the sweeter side -wings are a b
(5)Rye M.
Bo Jo's is so ferda. I managed to get a few of my bots to make the long drive down here and it was so worth it. They didn't believe snee when I said it was better than bdubs. The staff is foyntastic but if you can get over the service the food is so worth it. I'm so happy the koozie king blessed me with the knowledge of this joint.
(5)Ushna A.
I came here to eat with my Philippino friend who recommended this place. When we walked in the joint the black workers here had bad attitudes and were being rude. We placed an order , after receiving our wings it seemed cold. My Philippino friend Leo went up to the counter and told them the situation they rolled there eyes. He called them out on there behavior and the black girl looked over at another black girl behind the counter and stated aren't there people use to eating cold dogs ,( as in the pet animal). I'm totally appalled! I'm telling everyone about this in the Filipino community ...
(1)Anish A.
Ghetto and rude! Once you walk in your greeted with rudeness. I'll stick to Buffalo Wild Wings and wing stop. The black people working here are extremely rude are not friendly. I over heard them talking about a gay male white customer who ordered his food just before I did. Once the customer left they started, mocking his mannerisms and joking about his alternative life style. I don't appreciate prejudice people. I canceled my order and walked out.
(1)Eric B.
I love wings and Buffalo Joe's does it right! Some people see the small wing as a negative, on the contrary, i LOVE the smaller wings for the flavor they bring. The sauces are fantastic and their hottest sauce is perfect for me. Can't wait to go back!
(5)Paco L.
Great food. The buffalo cheese chips are the absolute best. Come here at least one a week.
(5)Eva S.
Buff Joe's.... always works their magic. When someone mentions it, the response is usually: "omg Buff Joe's, it's SO good let's go there NOW!" said quickly, almost panicky in one breath. Or followed by: "I need Buff Joe's, why'd you have to mention it, we need to go NOW!" When someone mentions your favorite type of food, you have a mini anxiety attack when your mouth waters and you need dem wings... That's kinda what happens... no matter what time of day. I always get a single order of Suicide Wings (topped with jalapenos) with a side of waffle fries ("Buffalo Chips" $1.89). Your order will come with celery and ranch, and a wetwipe (which you will certainly need). Sometimes I'll wash everything down with an RC. Their wings are freshly fried, then tossed in tangy sauce. A single order is $7.99 and you better bring cash because it's CASH only... but they have a generic ATM right inside the restaurant in case you forget. They also serve beer and these little oatmeal chocolate chip cookies in a huge tub by the cashier, which look heavenly, but I never have room for dessert. Also, they have a "XXX" sauce which is a spicy habenero-type darker red sauce... which I have only requested on the side as a sample because I heard eating an order with that sauce is brutal for your tastebuds. Try it on the side first to see if you'll like it because once you start it's so spicy it hurts. So maybe I have an unhealthy relationship with this place. But if wings were ever going inside my stomach, they better be from here. When friends visit from out of town, I'll take them to Buff Joe's and with a serious face, say: "These are the best wings in Chicago." (Deep dish pizza will be tomorrow night...) I only go to the Clark location, although there are two others on Green Bay and Howard. After I have gone and out-done myself again in the form of massive wing consumption, I say I've reached my Buff Joe's quota, forever. But of course I end up coming back the following month or so. This stuff is on par with being one of my last meals on urf. Heaven on urf...earth.
(5)Leonel H.
This establishment has gone from a 90'S SENSATION to a ghetto establishment the culture isn't there anymore. The customer service is a joke I had a complaint with the bonanza special I brought it to their attention staff did not show any sympoyhy. Also since when was it o k to sell drugs in a restaurant. Literally there was a drug deal going on in there when I sat down and ate my food. The quality of the meat chicken ribs whatever is digesting. Whoever is the current owner of this establishment shame on u.
(1)Anthony P.
I go to buff Joe's with my buddies all the time. I seem to be the only one who finds the wings to be just ok. The wings are somewhat small, and they are a little too crispy and dry. Also, the sauce they put on the wings is a little bland and lacks a distinct taste. Buffalo Joe's also does not have the greatest variety of sauces, with only three different variations. The interior is also not the cleanest place on earth. If you want better wings and better variety, I would head over to wings over Evanston just a couple blocks away.
(3)Jonathan N.
Having had the opportunity to eat at some of the best wing joints in the US, I was sorely disappointed in the food, cleanliness, customer service, and overall first impression of Buffalo Joes. The wings were soggy, swimming in a gag-inducing mild sauce, and fatty. I am so used to grilled, crispy/charred, or at least baked crisp and not soggy wings. Mother Pluckers throughout Texas is a good example of awesome wings. Spending a few days shadowing that Texas institution might serve the ownership of Buffalo Joes well. I doubt if I will ever go back to BJs again. Regardless of the reviews, it's prima facie evidence that the fans and locals have limited experience in what a good wing tastes like.
(1)Karen C.
Holy deliciousness! Went out looking initially for a good burger to take home. After discovering one place was closed, my friend suggested grabbing something from here. We went all out. Split some spicy wings and cheese fries. And then had a sandwich each. The wings. So good! I cannot say enough good things about them. Cheese fries...eh. The cheese wasn't what I was expecting. But the fries themselves, yes! We both decided the sandwiches were good. But honestly it's all about the wings! I cannot wait to go back.
(5)Shawn J.
Could EASILY be the best wings in Chicago if they stopped using anorexic chickens...the wings barely have any meat on them! Their sauce is the best I've ever tasted, though. Also, they only accept cash. It's 2015. Other establishments accept electronic payment and these dudes can't get a credit card reader. One last complaint, they charge 50 cents for a teaspoon of ranch if you want extra.
(3)Lauren G.
Best.wings.ever. Order them spicy with a side of buffalo chips and an RC. I mean it's the best combo for some reason or another. Sometimes it can be a real hit or miss but regardless it's delicious. What I mean is just sometimes it's not as good(when they skimp on the sauce hmph) and sometimes it's really on point. Like any place really. CASH ONLY. 12.00 for everything. The order comes with like 10-12 wings. The buffalo chips are seasoned so well. I recommend eating there the wings and fries can get soggy taking it to go not as good but still good. The sauce is like crack I swear idk what they put in it but it makes you want more! O_o! The wings itself are little with a good amount of meat. If you're not a fan of little wings and more for the bigger sized I would say still try but you may be disappointed.
(5)Albert M.
BEST BUFFALO WINGS IN AMERICA! HANDS DOWN, NO QUESTIONS ASKED!! Chicago is a city rich and immersed in history from the water tower to Mrs. O'Leary, the Cubs/Sox/Bears/Bulls, the Daly's. This city is also known as the city of broad shoulders which I directly attribute to the fact that it is freezing, so you gotta eat a lot and that's why Chicago is a city so rich and immersed in incredible food....deep dish pizza, hot dogs, italian beef, popcorn, and so on. But my favorite place in all of Chicago is a hole in the wall buffalo wing place where spicy perfection lies. It's the one place I MUST go whenever I am in town, no ifs, ands or buts. It's called Buffalo Joes, or to the locals Buff Joe's. It is cash only. It is run by employees just as angry as the Wiener Circle a few miles south. I argue the employees of Wiener Circle work during the day at Buff Joe's and the night at the Circle of Wiener. This place has burgers, hot dogs, italian beef, but you come for the wings, the celery and the ranch. I am pretty sure that this place has been open 40+ years and my father in law was the first to order a burger. The wings are giant and so meaty. The wings are cooked perfectly. The sauce is buttery and perfect. Get the suicide...its just their normal hot wings with jalapenos. Get the cheese fries! Get a large RC! PERFECTION!Wings, cheese fries, and RC with extra ranch and celery from Buff Joe's is on my short list for finals meals if I was on death row. SPRINT, DO NOT RUN, DO NOT WALK!!!!!!
(5)Marikit R.
Best chicken wings in town! I'm a girl who can handle her spice, so suicide (which is basically spicy with jalapeños on top) order for me! Whether you got the single or double order, there's a complimentary of celery with the order! The waffle fries are good too! The ranch they give you is pretty small, so I ask for two extra ranch and they charge a quarter each. The cookies are amazing too! Might not look like it because its in a sketchy non transparent container, that looks like it hasn't been cleaned, but trust me, the oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are a must! The only bad thing of this place, to me at least, is the cheddar cheese. It's tastes, old? Maybe I got a bad batch but I know I won't ever get the cheese on my fries again.
(4)Jenn E.
I'm sad to say that this place really failed to meet my expectations. Came here with high expectations given the Yelp reviews but was really disappointed. Service was fast and pleasant enough and I didn't get any raw chicken but it was really not great. I got spicy wings (sorry Yelp fans, suicide is just too much for me) and waited while they freshly prepared them and then took them home where I ate them immediately. Unfortunately, in the very short walk home, the sauce seemed to separate and i was left with an oily goo in the bottom of the container and some wings that were basically dry. Aside from the texture, the sauce was ok but it was really oily which was pretty gross to me. The wings themselves were also pretty sad. The meat was sparse and tough and at times was too tough for me to chew through without some serious effort. I would have preferred way less but more meaty wings. Towards the end I was swirling the wings in sauce in hopes that it might make it all better but honestly no matter what I tried my wings were pretty tasteless, sauce was oily and I agree with others, there is a really weird after taste. Also, they only have ranch! Cash only. I want to say I'll try it again, but honestly, it won't be for a very long time, if ever.
(1)Victoria S.
This place serves the best diggitey-darn wings I have ever figgitey figgety fricken tried. Despite having to pay with cash (always got sacks) this place really tickles my taste buds and goes great with other types of bud. You really need to get down and dirty but it's a great messy first date! The wings are so succulent they should have a novel written about them. I am writing that novel. Check back in a few days, for now let me provide you with a single excerpt. "I would never, could never, forget that moment. It has been burned into my memory by the unrelenting flaming heat of Buffalo Joe's sauce. The crunchy flesh of wild, possibly free range FDA organic, chicken fell of the bone like an avalanche of meat crashing down Mt. Everest and onto the head of unsuspecting Victor Sunkelson, the first man I killed."
(5)Richard Y.
One of my previous favs has unfortunately gone downhill. 'Had lunch here with a friend today. The wings are good but the size and crispness have declined, as has the order accuracy. I ordered a chix salad sandwich and received a grilled chix breast sandwich-- huh? And cash only? In the 21st century? Luckily I had cash on me. Buff j s used to have an edge on food and service but has, IMHO, lost it.
(3)Feb S.
Taste: 3.5 Location: 4 Cleanliness: 3.5 Ambience: 3 Value: 3.5 Service: 3 OVERALL = 3.5 * Out of a 5-point scale I got the Suicide Wings and Spicy Cheddar Waffle Fries (they call them Chips). The taste was pretty good, but for Suicide Wings, I expected something much spicier but was let down instead. Overall it still can't beat Buffalo Wild Wings flavors. I'd still recommend this though for anyone looking for Wings in downtown Evanston.
(4)Dee S.
How does this place get great reviews? Haha, I guess you have to be from Evanston to get it. The wings are amazing...IF you like extremely tiny, super greasy pigeon wings with stomach acid for sauce these will be right up your alley! The fries OH EM GEE the fries were so good, the best cardboard I've ever had! The ketchup was so good and fresh too..this place just really knows how to give you violent diarrhea.. What a clean establishment this is might I add, it looks like its cleaned on a daily basis, I love the giant stain right where the overhead menu used to be..
(1)Shajan K.
I haven't been here in years and I remembered why I stopped going...CASH ONLY policy! Otherwise, the wings are great, especially suicide style! Soaked in sauce and jalapenos? Can't ever go wrong with that! Cheese fries can use a little work.
(4)Ian S.
So I've been getting BJ's (Buffalo Joe's) for a long time but only at this location. If you want the better wings and fries, this location is IT! Can't say much for the other ones but they were meh. So onto the review, if you love spicy wings, you have to get suicide wings. If you're like me, a double order is more than enough. It comes with jalapeños on the wings and the sauce is awesomesauce! If you dine in, they serve beer too! Don't forget to order suicide cheddar chips with your meal. It's waffle fries smothered in awesome cheddar and suicide sauce! Ok now this review is making me crave BJ's. I'll make a stop this week. Ahhhhhhh! P.S. If you make buffalo chicken dip, try substituting franks red hot with the suicide sauce. You can order some on the side and trust me, you won't regret it! It's always a hit and perfect for watching Da Bears game.
(5)Yousuf K.
Always have great wings. However always received poor customer service. Only reason they aren't getting 5 stars. Also they don't take credit card. We are in the 21st century. I can go to a street vendor in Morocco and he will still take card!
(4)Daria D.
I had the buffalo chicken sandwich. It was okay, the chicken tasted a little like it was fried in old oil but perfectly crispy so I can't complain that much.
(3)Andrew Z.
My friends took me here since I was visiting them. They asked me what I was in the mood for and I replied "something with protein". I think mounds of chicken qualify. I don't usually get buffalo flavor wings at places like Buffalo Wild Wings - usually I opt for some variation of "savory" (spicy garlic, parmesan garlic, garlic fries... I really like garlic, ok?) but I ordered the Mild wings here and really liked them. I don't know how they make the sauce, but it's seemed to be more savory and less vinegary than the ones I've had. So if you're like me, and usually don't like buffalo wings, I would still suggest trying this place out. Good stuff, Buff Joe's.
(4)Lynn C.
I was craving a cheeseburger today so we popped into this place while walking and looking for a place to eat, it's a divey little place but sometimes those are the best. I think the guy on the grill was possibly the owner, he offered me a sample of his chili while I was waiting and it was absolutely delicious and I'm a picky chili eater. I ordered a bacon cheddar cheeseburger with sautéed onions, pickles and tomatoes cooked medium, it was cooked perfectly and the accompaniments were very fresh. they were very busy for lunch and I noticed most people ordering wings and waffle fries. Next time I find myself in Evenston I will try the wings.
(4)Sarah Beth B.
I dream of Buff Joe's. It's like, the most basic junk food ever, but I still get excited every.single.time. I eat here. I have heard there is a large menu, but I have never bothered with anything other than WINGS and CHEDDAR CHIPS. I guess if I had any criticism it would be they need bigger napkins? That's not a criticism, I guess, it's just a compliment on how saucy the wings are. Prepare to not do anything else for the rest of the night, because you will probably have heartburn and definitely be in a food coma.
(5)Thu D.
When I moved to the city after graduating, my boyfriend and I searched high and low for wings as good as Buff Joe's and could not find a place that even came close. We would always get a double order of spicy wings and it is seriously heaven in a styrofoam container (my mouth is watering now just typing this). Luckily, I've returned to Evanston, so I can have the best wings whenever I want! The spicy wings are the way to go because they're spicy, but not so scorching hot that your tongue goes numb. Also, while I like this location fine, I think the Green Bay location is better because their wings are larger, so you get more bang for your buck. My only complaints are that they only serve ranch (blue cheese all the way!) and it is a cash-only establishment. However, that's nothing my own bottle of blue cheese dressing and an ATM can't fix, so Buff Joe's is okay in my book.
(5)Stefanie B.
I haven't been to the actual restaurant in soo long so when I was in the area I had to come back to relive my high school memories coming here. Who doesn't love them some BJ's?! ;) The staff is so welcoming and fun as soon as you walk in and your order is ready in a matter of minutes. You can never go wrong here if you're in the mood for Buffalo Wings. Also the waffles fries tho...mmmm good eats for good prices. I'd get the double order of wings because the wings sizes are pretty anorexic and remember it's CASH ONLY! I hate the parking around this area tho
(4)Catherine N.
WOW!! The wings here are truly delicious!! I met a few people at a party who told me that they would drive from downtown Chicago to Evanston, just for an order of Buffalo Joe's wings, and now I can see why. These wings are so simple and made to perfection!! They are the right amount of crispiness and the sauce is ON POINT! Plus, the portion size and price is not bad either. One order of wings is around $8 and you get like 10 wings!! DEAL! Tip: Get the normal waffle fries and not the one loaded with stuff - the WILL get soggy because it's drenched in canned nacho cheese sauce and and buffalo wing sauce. ALSO, if you want to place an order for a Super Bowl party... do that like 3 days in advance, this place gets so many orders that you won't get it if you order the night before!! - They are just THAT good.
(4)Raheem L.
A good amount of food for a very good price. No complaints about the food, but the workers had a bit of attitude, they were very rude to some other customers that walked in after me and had a confusing order.
(4)Matt A.
This place has the best wings ever!! I don't know what the captain puts in this sauce but it is AMAZING. I call him the Captain because he has been there for over 20 years running the ship. If you see him you will know. Now the only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because I have been bamboozled with a bad batch of wings but never when the Captain is there. One time my order got lost and the captain immediately gave me a new order free of charge. Granted I waited over 45 minutes but hey he's the captain and he acknowledged his mistake. In his defense, he was really busy. Double order mild("spicey" is extra sauce and hot is with jalapeños) with cheddar chips and a large ice water. Sometimes water is yellow. Watch for that.....I can still smell the sauce in my fingertips. Yum.
(4)Kenny O.
Cheap, filling, and--best of all--tasty. After living in the Chicago area for several years now, this might be my favorite place for buffalo wings (the top contender being Duke of Perth in Chicago). While I was studying at NU, this was one of my most-frequented joints to hit up for late nights in the office. I don't think I've ever dined in, but the food's always been great even after a 20-minute walk home in the cold winter.
(5)Adele n.
Yup. I did it. I ate the suicide wings for the first time in 10 years (go, u northwestern!) and it was as freaking delicious as I remembered. I am from upstate NY, homeland of the wing, and Buffalo Joes is the only Chicago wing that stacks up. Don't waste your time with any others! They could be even hotter, IMO, but these are about the hottest I've had out here. Vinegar-cayenne perfection.
(5)Oliver W.
Pretty good wings, only choice you have is what level of spicyness you want. The restaurant is fairly dirty and greasy, which was a bit off-putting. But if you're ok taking a shower after eating here then you got the right idea.
(3)Gspot H.
My First Real Date 1st month of Sophomore was up in here. The song "Blue Eye's" by The Who came on the radio. Went 2 see "Yamo" at ETHS afterwards on a double date; my X was the other Lady. I got the wings Mild. It was a good fun safe memorable out of site nite.
(5)Kenneth L.
Yeah, I mean, it gets the job done. I had been advised by many Northwestern alum that Buff Joe's was the quintessential wing place - an institution for buffalo wings. To its credit, Buff Joe's is what it is and it doesn't mess around with that. But, little did I know, I was walking into a hole in the wall shack with an infinite amount of chicken wings already cooked and hanging out in the frying basket, awaiting my consumption. Don't get me wrong, fried chicken wings are fried chicken wings and I love fried chicken wings. It was pretty simple and pretty good, but not sure that it warrants the collegiate lore hype machine. Though, if I were still in college rocking a budget, I wouldn't be surprised to find myself here many a time.
(3)Peter H.
Have been coming here for 13 plus years. Perfect overtime.
(5)Mario G.
The wings and chips may have Crack like additives because I always Jones after them. I once saw a roach run across my table and yet has deterred me from eating here. Just start a mild sauce Iv, slap a mega gut no ice in my hand and I'm good. They're ranch sauce makes the pants tight! I want more...MORE!!!!!!!
(5)Miss Kari P.
Every time I order wings they get smaller and smaller. I'm expecting just a pile of bones the next time I go in, which is unfortunate because I absolutely adore their suicide wings. It really doesn't matter, but every single worker inside is absolutely rude for no appropriate reason. Without fail. You're killin' me Buff Joes....
(2)Steve A.
This is a good wings place, but they actually have a lot more, including hamburgers, hot dogs and even vegetarian sandwiches. Everything is cooked to order, so it's hot and fresh, and there is a nice enough dining area both in front and in back. Service is fast and efficient. Cash only.
(4)Andy S.
Finally made it to Buffalo Joe's as lots of people had always said to go there. Décor seemed like a neat hole-in-the-wallish type of place but that had been around for a while. From there it generally seemed to go downhill for me. The pricing structure seems funky to me - they have single orders, which, when I asked how many come in an order the guy said 10-12. 10-12? These are wings, not M&M's. Why is there a range of wings you get in an order? Then, if you get a double order (for which there is a slight price break of lets say $1.50) you can only get one sauce for the entire double order. If you want two different sauces you have to buy single orders of each, even though you get the same number in the end (though who can be sure with this range of wings you could apparently get?). The one thing that was nice was they offered a free sample of chicken gumbo while we waited (which isn't a big deal but a nice small touch). We got the BBQ sauce and mild sauce. BBQ was pretty good but the mild was very underwhelming IMO. There was actually a fairly strong taste of butter with the mild sauce that I didn't find very good. Furthermore, I felt like the wings were pretty small. Would have expected them to be bigger. Not a great first experience with Buff Joe's. Maybe will give it another shot. Maybe.
(2)Sarah T.
Tangy, light sauce tossed on deep fried chicken wings. What's not to love? Waffle fries with heart attack cheese sauce is simple super thick rue cooked into some milk and minimal cheese. Ick.
(5)Travis L.
How in the name of Buffalo, New York can you call this place a good wing joint?! Honestly some of the worst wings I've had in a long while. I cannot understand how anyone can get past the dried shriveled up pieces of jerky Joe's tries to pass off as wings. I ordered the single which comes with about a dozen wings and after picking through the tough inedible chunks, I ate maybe 4-5 wings worth; wings=fail. Next, I except that I have a high tolerance for heat but the one thing I hate is when a place claims to have some high level of hotness that you can't fathom to handle and then when you take a bite it's nothing more than f'ing Tobasco; suicide sauce=fail. If anyone is paying attention @ Joe's, here are some pointers: Don't use frozen wings, it dries out the meat and ruins the taste, instead serve fewer higher quality wings (never frozen). Second, unless you're actually going to use exceptionally hot sauce don't call them suicide and finally, use fresh jalapeños instead of those crappy canned ones.
(1)Christopher S.
This is by far the best wings I've ever had. I always order the single order of suicide wings and waffle fries. I would definitely recommend this place.
(5)Jen C.
Old school- RC cola, cash only but they have an ATM machine- get the wings suicide style, celery and ranch- fast service~ wish the wings had more meat to them but the sauce is too good to complain. Waffle fries to balance the heat!
(4)Mike A.
I'm not really sure what happened here. I used to come here all the time in high school and it was pretty much the best wings you could find on the planet. It was the first trip I'd make when coming back home from college. Wow have things changed. the wings are probably 3x smaller than they were back in the day and really dry. Prices also seemed to have doubled. 14.59 for a double order, man, the amount of overall meat on the bones wasn't even like a single order a few years ago. It was like the wings came from an unhatched chicken embryo. Someone came in an ran this place into the ground, it used to be a legitimate Chicago food landmark. Incredibly disappointed and feel cheated out of a lot of money, way to ruin their reputation. Should have read the reviews before coming back.
(1)Spencer S.
I wish I can give this place 0 stars. I use to love it until I ordered a chicken tender dinner and they fed me raw chicken. When we went back the next day (we ordered the day before right before closing) the people there said "oh well, it wasn't on our shift, and no money back." So they fed me raw chicken and did nothing to fix it.
(1)Ramena A.
I love my wings, and I thought if love buff joes (especially because of all the great things I heard about them). Unfortunately, I went there and the chicken didn't taste good, the sauce had a weird taste to it (not a normal wing flavor), and the cheesy fries had cold melted cheese on it. They only take cash, which is extremely inconvenient. It was an OK atmosphere, a little awkward to be honest. I just did not enjoy it.
(2)Brandon B.
Best wings around. Wish it wasn't cash only and that they delivered. 5 star food, but 3 star convenience.
(4)Crystal P.
The truth is, they are, what they say they are a wings and burger place in downtown Evanston and a wings and ribs place on Howard street Chicago. I have never been disappointed until this year. The girl on the register "flawless" as always, the ribs were like they took all the good stuff home and were serving the customer scraps. The 2 cooks in the back were so busy talking to each other that they literally didn't cook the food and there were about 4 people waiting and that number quickly built to a dozen since it was a Friday night. The girl asked them a couple times and they gave her a look that said "don't talk to us" Wings were good but no celery or sauce was on the order, they must be taking that home as well. Ive been coming here since they opened each of the resturants, I've recommended hundreds of people. This was a real let down.
(1)Eugene W.
Buffalo Joe's is a great wings place. Their wings are delicious and if you a spicy-lover, this is the place to go. Their waffle fries are extremely tasty, though the cheese on the fries hardens and tastes kind of bad after a while. I would definitely go here over Buffalo Wild Wing's with a group of friends, because the atmosphere is nicer and the wings are just as good.
(4)Mina P.
This visit was definitely 5 star worthy. I will forever be a fan of buffalo joe's but it's really a hit or miss here. Some days the wings are wimpy and dry and other days definitely the best on the planet. I love this place regardless because I've been eating here for almost 20 years. We can't have a gathering at home without a party pan of suicide from BJ's and you can't forget about the cheddar chips! CASH ONLY - there's an ATM inside ;)
(5)Simon K.
People have probably written everything there is to write about this place. The wings are great. The waffle fries are great. Et cetera, et cetera... However, I'm about to drop some knowledge on anybody who is unfazed by how society views them. Bring a tupperware container full of white rice and make sure you have enough people to order the party platter. When you get a platter of suicide wings, a pool of butter, hot sauce and jalapenos ends up gathering at the bottom of the aluminum tray. If you take the rice (which the tupperware hopefully kept fairly warm) and mix it in with the sauce, you will experience Buff Joe's in a way you have never experienced before. For the ones who don't mind doing a little extra work, rip the meat off the last few chicken wings into smaller chunks to create a complete dish. This also works if you take the wings as take-out but nothing beats getting the wings right out of the fryer. So, do you dare take on the challenge? Hopefully I'll be seeing a few more people with tupperware the next time I go. I'll be sure to say hello.
(5)Mike M.
First & LAST time I set foot in dis joint! I know joes due to occasionally a co-worker would bring in a tray of wings...So after a N/W game we decided to go to the joint... bad move...5 out of 6 staffr's are rude!!!!They don't give a s*** about u or your business, the place is filthy... if u gotta "go" take a risk and pee in the alley! The soda sucks! The bonelesss wings taste crappy and look like alien fingers! Don't get me wrong but the wings are good-not great!...Save yourself the horrible experience I went thru and GO to Jake Melnicks!- in downtown Chicago!!! JM undoubted-ly have the BEST WINGS IN Illinois!
(1)Brian R.
I've been to Buffalo Joe's a few times now, and I'm just now writing a review. Of all the wing places I've been to, and I've been to a few, Buffalo Joe's is probably the best. I live out west (St. Charles/West Chicago/Geneva area), and I (usually) gladly make the 1 hour trip out to Evanston for Buff' Joe's. If Yelp ratings were all about food taste, I'd consider it a 5-star joint. Be warned! Buff' Joe's is cash only!
(4)Paul B.
We've been going to this hole in the wall wings joint for years and years. Look - the wings are amazing (I'm whimping out in my old age and can't do the hot or suicide wings anymore but the milds and mediums are still spectacular), the fries are good as is the chili but the help is obnoxious. They aren't even nice about telling you that it's cash only. The scene is that of a run down wings joint in a college town so I guess that fits. That being said we still come back.
(3)Simplelife S.
So unprofessional!!! The employees at the register area stood and talked (inappropriately) amongst themselves using profanity while people waited for their orders to cook. At one point a guy came from the other side of the restaurant and participated in the conversation while he and the employee handled a bag with out washing their hands. At this point I watch closely and even asked that my food was not prepared by either of these women. I did finally ask for a manager who listened to my complaint as the two employees stood in ear shot but never looked as if they were even aware that they were doing something wrong. It had been years since I went to this Davis street location I usually use the Howard street one. Much better service. I was so disappointed in what I saw I called three people I knew while I was there and recommended to them NOT to use this place EVER!!!!! * WONT BE GOING BACK*
(1)Marc G.
The more things change... the more they stay the same... mostly. Back in the day I would have had an order of Wings... suicide... a Cheddar Char Burger, Cheddar Char Chips and an RC Gut buster. That was in my NU days... but on a recent visit back to Evanston, we made a late night run to our old, favorite haunt. We went spicy with the Wings this time... and while they were good, they were not as good as we remembered... a little too fried and greasy, perhaps. Hmm... We skipped the Chips (waffle fries) but went for a Burger, too. That was even better than I remembered... So darn good... the juices from the meat soaked the cheese spread bun perfectly... mustard and ketchup... pickles, tomato and lettuce... Simple but stunningly delicious. I can still taste it. Mmmm!
(4)Samuel M.
The only place i know of in the Chicago area that serves classic Buffalo Wings. What I mean by this: -Fried, but not battered -Equal parts drumettes/wings -BONE LEFT IN (as far as I'm concerned, "boneless wings" are both an oxymoron and something that only sociopaths eat) -Buttery yet spicy sauce that invariably leaves the eater messy The one place in which this place breaks from tradition is by serving the wings with ranch dressing rather than bleu cheese, but trust me, you won't miss it. I've only ever ordered one thing here: suicide wings with waffle chips. I see no reason to change this. 90% of the time, this is exceptional and well worth the havoc it inevitably wreaks on my gastrointestinal system. 10% of the time the food is pedestrian, for one reason or another (typically wings are too small, or are swimming in excessive sauce. However, this latter issue tends to arise with suicide more than with other styles because it necessitates the addition of extra sauce). In summation: If you are craving wings, do NOT be tempted by the cleaner exterior and large televisions and take your wing craving to BWW's down the street. It is mediocre. Buff Joe's is the real deal. PS As others have iterated, but which I must needs restate: CASH ONLY!! They have an ATM inside if you're desperate, though.
(4)J K.
For me, a trip back to Evanston isn't complete without a visit to Buffalo Joe's. And they're open until midnight so even if my flight is delayed I'm able to get my junk food chicken fix. This place is CASH ONLY so plan accordingly - there's a Bank of America a block away and I think there's actually a small ATM in the restaurant but I'd assume it charges fees. My friends swear by the wings, but I always get the chicken tenders with mild sauce and extra ranch dressing - they're amazing. The food is so tasty that it's easy to overlook that the wings and tenders are always swimming in grease and the "cheese" on the buffalo chips (fries) is synthetic. Prices are reasonable, there's plenty of seating in the back, and even when the place is busy they seem to be able to cycle through orders quickly. A couple of things that might some day push Buffalo Joe's down into 4-star territory for me... 1) the wings seem to have gotten smaller over time - not a good trend 2) sometimes they don't have tenders - very disappointing since they're my favorite menu item 3) if you get food to go, they put fries in paper bags so you'll have nice, hot chicken but cold fries (I realize it's un-PC of me to enjoy the styrofoam containers they use for chicken, so I usually eat in the restaurant)
(5)Arie W.
It would be an understatement to say I'm a huge fan of BJ's. My family gets a party platter for any type of get together, parties, Christmas, Thanksgiving (yes I said Thanksgiving). My favorite thing to order at BJ's are the suicide wings and cheese fries. I've noticed that in the past few years the wings were getting considerably smaller and smaller, but the last time I went, they were back to the normal size and just as great as ever. The way they make the cheese fries here is totally Chicago style. My other friends from out of town who I've brought here say that the cheese is way too cheddar-y and thick, but if I could eat it on everything, I absolutely would. I've also had the burger, brat, chili, and cookies and everything is delicious. The only bad thing about BJ's, if you don't eat it while it's hot, it loses it's appeal. The facilities are not the most pleasant, but it does the job. The bathroom is probably as clean as it possibly can get. They have TVs for customers to watch while eating. The seating area isn't too appealing, but when I get my wings, I don't care where I'm sitting. It's that good.
(5)Kenneth M.
I have been going to Buffalo Joe's since 1992. I have traveled all over the world, had wings from all over the United States, including in Buffalo, and hands down Buffalo Joe's are the best wings I have ever had. I have had Buffalo Joe's at all my major birthday's, had my parents bring a double party pan 6 hours for my graduation from college. For those who have given a bad rating to Buffalo Joe's, they must have bad taste buds. Even if the service was poor, I would come back again and again for these wings. I see some of the reviews are for non wing related items. Get it straight, this is a WINGS PLACE. Although some of the staff may be rough around the edges, you come for the food. I have never had a bad experience at Buffalo Joe's in my life. When I need a comfort food a double order hot, with Buffalo Chips, and a gut buster R.C hit the spot. Ghetto Joe's on Howard on the hand is sub-par, and people may have been there. A fan since I was 12, and I will go until the day I die.
(5)Melissa D.
So, I know they made the wings a little on the aneroxic side but they're SO GOOD. I love this place, I go here for the cheddar fries and wings ONLY, all the time. I seriously drive 45 minutes just to eat here. I know people's taste buds are different and they have different preferences but I adore this place to pieces. The sauce is delicious, and they do sell a huge jug of it (though it's a little pricey)... It's a hole in the wall place, but I don't know about everybody else, I go for the food, not to stare at teh walls and say, "Uh, the paint is peeling..." Buffalo Joe's, my go to place for wings when I'm really craving them!
(5)Master B.
It is a sad day for me. i grew up eating these wings. i have even had wings from Anchor Bar in Buffalo where they were created, and buff joes sauce was better. but over the last few years i have been fighting an up hill battle defending this place. finally i ordered wings and had to write this. the wings have been getting progressively smaller as time goes by, but tonight i counted and i got a double order of wings and there was no meat what so ever on the wings. the largest wing was an inch and a quarter long and had only skin and tendons attached no meat. i understand the desire to make money and have high yield but how does the owner really expect people to keep coming back for chicken bones slathered in butter? my advice just see if you can buy the sauce in bulk and get your own wings, it has to be cheaper and a better meal... sorry buff joe's you lost a life long customer tonight.
(1)alan q.
I've been hear a few times. I recently visited for the first time in at least 3-4 years. The only thing I've ever gotten are the suicide wings and waffle fries. Waffles fries are pretty standard...not much to judge here. The wings are pretty small. The suicide sauce isn't really that hot. It's hot but manageable. Man, I really remember the wings to be much better. It was ok, but all I was thinking while eating was, "what other places have better wings?" This is the definition of hole in the wall. I usually don't mind hole the wall places, but this time it got to me. The dining room smelled like a wet, dirty rag. The tables were greasy and is a type of place where you don't want to touch anything. I must say that I really don't need to go back to this place for another 3-4 years..or more.
(2)D M.
Finger lickin good yummy-ness. That about sums it up.
(5)Marion J.
This is more than 1 1/2 stars for me. We went for wings, I was cravings with, got take out, staff was not especially nice nor helpful. We got home wings were tiny and very dry. They felt old.. just not the juicy chicken wings I was craving. Not sure what went wrong. Both hubby and i did not like them. We did not finish them. We wont be back. Maybe they have better items or better days. They are cheap for wings.
(2)Jon L.
best buffalo wings ever!!!
(5)Khris L.
This place is a classic buffalo wing spot for anyone in the area. I even know people who would drive over an hour just to get some of the suicide wings from here. I want to start off by saying that their wings have gotten smaller and the prices have increased over the years. It's still worth it as the single order or their wings can fill you up easily. I love this place, but it's hard for me to give it higher than 3 stars because of the feeling you get when you eat in. The staff, for the most part, seem to not care about anything. The place is small and doesn't accomodate big groups. The tables are sticky, and so are the ketchup and mustard bottles...There are always people waiting outside to ask you for change and/or your leftovers. Aside from all those inconveniences, the food here is great and I suggest you try it out. Carry out might be a better idea than eating in.
(3)Javi L.
Only had the wings so far but OH MY GAWWD! They are just super delicious... Price is fair for a single order (12pc) not to mention the unbelievable taste. I believe Buffalo Joes was nominated for best wings or something idk but I'd you are ever in the Evanston area you must stop and grab yourself some wings. Only had the spicy. Next up is the suicide.
(5)Christine G.
I'd like to thank my homie Takala for winning a bet with me, of course I lost! I said I would buy her chicken dinner. This place was so good! Don't get it mixed up with BWWs. I did not get the wangs, she did but I tried it and it was oh so yummy. I had the chicken nachos which was bigger than my face but I ate it all because I was starving. I will be back!
(4)Dane K.
TERRIBLE wings. I can't even BELIEVE people--anyone--would recommend them. They're TERRIBLE, disgusting. Some of you people who think they're great must be on some pretty heavy drugs. The sauce tastes like ketchup with a little hot sauce. It's very strange... And there's WAY too much sauce. It's like eating gobbly gook. They're the SMALLEST WINGS on earth!!! Don't take my word for it: I took pictures... One next to a quarter: THE QUARTER IS WIDER THAN THEIR FREAKING WINGS! (and it wasn't just this one wing, they were all that small). I posted them under the business pictures. How can a wing place find such small wings to serve? Are they aborted chickens, or chicks? Are they even chickens? Their spicy wings aren't even hot... then they have "suicide" wings where they're not really any hotter--they just douse them in more sauce--AND ADD GIARDINARE. how disgusting!!! (it might be good drunk food or something, but don't call them buffalo wings) THEY DON'T EVEN HAVE BLUE CHEESE!!! I suppose asking for carrots to go with celery (like you'd get in... Buffalo) would be totally out of the question if they're too cheap to even stock blue cheese! This place shouldn't be allowed to associate itself with wings OR Buffalo, let alone both. The staff wasn't very friendly... I was trying to read the menu and got rushed into ordering. Once we sat down, we overheard a group of people arguing on the other side of the eating area... not just arguing, but standing up shouting in each other faces, ready to punch arguing... the kind of thing where you debated if you should get up and leave, or get ready to dial 911. guess who it was? the staff. The *only* redeeming thing about this place was the waffle fries... they were pretty darn good. They weren't exactly cheap... An order of wings, waffle fries w/ cheese, and two drinks came out to be $17. I want my $17 back. Really. They were that bad. It was one of those meals where you sat and debated if you wanted to finish, or if you would just abort and go elsewhere... we ended up eating more later I'm pretty sure. I've had better wings at Applebee's. If you think the wings here are the best ever, you're really missing out.
(1)Elizabeth T.
Went here a lot during my college days. Went back after 7 years because my fiance and I had Buffalo Joe's cravings. I have to admit: Wings & fries. VERY VERY GOOD. Price: VERY AFFORDABLE. That's about it. The place is SUPER DIRTY! Get take out but don't stay here.
(2)Brian J.
What a bizarre place. So they call it "Buffalo" Joe's. That's offensive, in my opinion, being a native Buffalonian (I know you love the way that rolls off the tongue). If you're expecting real buffalo wings, this joint sucks. Period. Skimpy, nasty, sweet, weird wings without blue cheese. That's what comes to my mind now when I think of Buffalo Joe's. Upon entering the rude staff rushed me into ordering and looked at me like I was insane when I asked for blue cheese with my wings. This is when I knew we were in trouble, but we had read good reviews of the place so we figured it was worth a try. The order taking employee told me "they good, you should try them" so, with this ringing endorsement, Dane and I ordered a double order and some waffle fries. I think we ordered them mild but I can't remember because I'm still trying to wash the memory from my mind. Somewhere around this point, I saw the most offensive thing of all - giardiniera on top of a pile of the tiniest wings I've ever seen. Luckily, this monstrosity wasn't ours, but the next order to come out was. The first thing I noticed was the color and excessive quantity of sauce. They looked the color of spaghetti sauce and had were drowned in sauce. The waffle fries looked good (and they were, but deep fried toe jam would have tasted good compared to these wings). Upon arriving at our table, we took the plunge and tasted these tiny, tiny wings. They were so small that we actually had to take a break from eating to laugh about it. We compared the largest wing to a quarter and found the quarter to be wider (see photos uploaded by dane k.). The sauce was sweet and ketchupy. It was at this point when we decided we should consider cutting our losses, dumping the wings in the trash can and finding some real wings but the scary dining room entertainment was too interesting to abandon. I can't stress enough how tiny the wings were. Most of the drumettes, at the big end, were narrower than my thumbnail. Seriously. It was like they were actually pigeon wings. Maybe guinea hens. I'm not sure. Around this time a table started getting loud, every other word being an obscenity (*I* was uncomfortable and I have a mouth like a sailor -- and there were several families with children present). Next thing you know someone threw a tray onto the table and yelled "I told you I'd give you your f-ing money" and there was a verbal exchange that actually scared some people out of the restaurant. As it turns out, this was a table of employees on their break. Nice. I'm from Buffalo and admittedly a tough wing critic; however, these are without a doubt, no question about it, the worst attempt at wings I've EVER tasted. That's a pretty tough distinction to achieve because I've had some really nasty wings. These certainly take the cake. Calling this place "Buffalo Joe's" is false advertising. I hereby make a motion to rename it to "Joe's Ketchupy Pigeon Wing Emporioum" or something along those lines.
(1)Cecilia T.
Buffalo Joe's is without a doubt THE BEST flavored wings in Chicago. I've lived in the Chicago suburbs and in the city my whole life and have never found anything better than this local hotspot.The tangy vinegary secret sauce on their wings is totally standout and something you literally crave for over and over again. I trek out here just to get these wings and from this specific location. (their Howard Location is just so so.) They offer 3 levels of spiciness to choose from - Mild, Spicy, Suicide. I tend to go with Mild or Spicy because i can't handle a lot of spicy. "Suicide" wings used to be really really spicy (swimming in jalapenos) but from what i heard they are just "really spicy," nowadays as the sauce has changed over the years. The size of their wings is just a 1 star rating - unfortunetely they used to provide huge juicy wings but now they are getting dinkier every year.Whatever, the sauce makes up for it. Atmosphere is 1 star too - a total local hole the wall. Get take-out if you're a germaphobe but just know these wings taste best just out of the fryer. If you do carryout, eat the wings with Chinese rice! I know that sounds weird, but many asians i know eat the wings with rice at home and the tangy sauce pairs SOOO well with rice. Other food to get with your wings? - The Waffle Fries are crispy and very good. Recommend getting the cheese on the side if you don't want them to lather it on. - They used to serve Rolling Rock Beer which tasted SO gross with the wings. But i just went today and they are serving Berghoff Pilsner and Berghoff Dark Beer on tap - pairs very well with the wings and washes away the greasiness on your palate. -If you're not a winglover, i heard the burgers are very good here too. Have a Superbowl Party? Their Party Platters are the way to go! I've even seen them at Baby Showers =). CASH ONLY
(5)Brian M.
Best wings in the area, I'd recommend sticking to hot or mild. Suicide isn't very good, just too much jalapeño not enough good flavor. The cheddar fries are fantastic waffle cut fried slathered in merkts cheese and some seasoning, dipped in their wonderful ranch they go great with some wings. The wing size here seems to vary from order to order but a single order is always plenty for me. Also the buffalo chicken sandwich is delicious here. It's a boneless breast pounded flat and breaded, it tastes like they make it in house, nice clean tasting breading and good fresh chicken breast. Make sure you add cheese on it to enjoy more of the merkts cheese. This is usually a place to grab take out during the lunch hours, the place isn't known for it's decor or seating. I recommend calling ahead when coming here or it can be a longer then average wait for take out places. They should definitely get rid of the cash only rule, I can't tell you how many times I got hit with ATM fees there because I have a real hard time accepting places with any kind of traffic wouldn't want a credit card machine.
(4)Connie L.
Our first stop for dinner in Chicago was at Buffalo Joes. Our cousins who live in Chicago took us here and we were excited to try some good wings. We ordered the spicy wings with cheddar chips. The sauce was on! It had the right amount of kick and was sauceyyyy! The cheddar chips are waffle fries with melted cheese and they were a good compliment to the wings. Add some celery sticks and beer and the meal was spot on!
(4)Ernesto R.
Not that impressed with the wings. They contain a ton of butter and the sauce is pretty standard. Also, the place is pretty dirty and should be kept more clean. I do not recommend this place as it might make you sick.
(2)Jose B.
one day my girlfriend asked me if i liked wings, when i was done ridiculing her for such a ridiculous question (OF COURSE), she told me of this place. We went and for the money you spend you get an irresponsibly large amount of wings, also they have cool waffle fries and the wings themselves have a great taste, my only, and ONLY wish is that the wings were slightly bigger... maybe its better that theyre not or i would be 500lbs!!!!
(4)Lulu R.
I have been coming to buffalo Joes for a long time now. Sure, their wings have become much smaller. We can't do anything about it. On the bright side, their sauce hasn't changed one bit. The waffle fries are perfectly seasoned and piping hot and fresh. Back to these amazing wings. I am still proud of this place despite their ever shrinking wing size. Every time I have a friend from out of town, I take them here. The sauce makes it worth while. My friend loved the wings so much....i believe he moved here for them! (Maybe) The problem is the staff is on the rude side and they are really stingy on the ranch/ bleu Cheese. They do not take credit cards. The drinks (unless otherwise ordered) come heavily iced. The place is tiny and needs to desperately be remodeled and updated to 2009. The bathrooms are kinda clean. You would think I would give this place 3 stars considering the negatives I have for this place...right? WRONG. I love these wings so much that I will STILL, despite the negatives(which are pretty serious in most peoples books, give this place 4 stars. For 24 or so wings its $10 bucks For 15 its like $7 Try them....make the trip... you won't regret or forget the adventure you and your taste buds go on. word to the wise: Check out the waffle fries (omg, that rhymes hahahaha)
(4)Justine L.
Good cheap food! Mild wings were surprisingly spicy and perfect. The single order had 10 wings! The burger was good as well- particularly enjoyed the bun.
(4)daynia S.
I absolute love their classic version of buffalo wings. The chicken is not battered like Hooter's. The sauce is what makes the wings so yummy. The fresh cut waffle fries are excellent and always piping hot. Wings and fries ate made to order nothing sitting around under hot lamps. Celery sticks are always cold and crisp like they should be. I've been taking a drive out to evanston for at least 10 years since I discovered this spot. It's not healthy so I only go once or twice a year but it's always worth it. Recipe has never changed. The only minor complaint I have is some times that the wings are small in size.
(4)Kat T.
I thought this place was alright. I did not feel like there was anything special about the place nor ws the selection of sauce very unique. Not a bad place.
(3)Al D.
Merk's cheddar on an Italian Beef??? It's provolone unless I ask otherwise. Fail.
(3)Meinard C.
Buffalo Joe's is less of a restaurant and more of an establishment, dare I say it? A childhood friend. Sure we've had our rough patches and times when we haven't seen each other in ages. But it's always something you can depend on. I've been going to this place since I was in high school back when boy bands roamed the earth and gas was a dollar. The prices of the wings, like my waistline, have crept up since. Back then I could've taken on a single pan by myself, but nowadays I limit myself to a single order. I usually get 'suicide' (Which is hot with jalapenos. People swear it's a different sauce, but I think that's just the jalapeno pickle juice being mixed in), Waffle cut fries with cheddar sauce (OMGOMNOMNOMNOM) and regular a RC (no Coke or Pepsi here). I can't say I've had any other things on their menu. I know they exist and I keep telling myself "One day I'll have to try one of those." But that's like going to a strip club for their lunch specials; and like strip clubs, they only take cash. This place gets a solid 4 from me, and it gets awarded the mystical +1 of nostalgia; perhaps even a +2 but yelp doesn't let me do 6 stars.
(5)Brian L.
I've been there about three times and truth be told, I'm afraid to go back. Each time the wings have progressively gotten smaller. I looked at my friend's plate and found one that was literally the size of a Jolly Rancher. If they start supplying larger/better quality I will definitely boost up their rating but as it stands now a solid 3. Their sauce is tangy. I love spicy with a bit of sweet. I wish they had a bit more to choose from like a standard New York Buffalo sauce though. I like them vinegary too!
(3)Hoang L.
If you like your wings drowned in sauce, then you'll love Buff Joe's. But I cannot say this is the best wings, so I cannot give you 5-stars. Plus, I find it tough to justify the price of these wings. Don't get me wrong, I love eating here, but I think people hype it up too much. The wings are medium sized. The celery on the side is okay. Gets pretty crowded and kinda of annoying when you can't find a place to sit.
(4)Chris B.
When I travel to Chicago, I always try and stop on by here. My friends in high school used to rant about coming here and filling up on wings. I come and I get the suicide wings and boy are they spicy! Fortunately they come with some ranch and celery to put my fire out! Sure as hell beats KFC and Popeye's for wings! Service could be a little more friendly.
(5)Brandon R.
They're not the biggest wings. They're not the meatiest. But, without question, they're my favorite wings. That's Buff Joe's in a nutshell. Personally, I LOVE spicy wings. I want to sweat when I'm eating. I want nasal passages as clear as... something that's really clear. Sure, you've read people rave about the suicide wings here (their spicy sauce with a heaping pile of jalapenos on top). They're not too bad. But I'm hear to tell you about the variety that aren't even on the menu: XXX habanero. To this day, I have not found a better combination of heat and flavor. Much like the suicide variety, the XXX habanero wings come with a mountain of sliced jalapenos. About those jalapenos: they are EASILY the best jalapenos in the world. I don't know how much of that is due to the fact that they're slathered in buffalo sauce, but I could eat these suckers by the spoonful. I look at them in the same light as Superdawg's grilled onions: a simple addition to a meal that takes it to the next level. Two final things that must be mentioned: - The ranch. Insanely good. When it comes to ranch, I definitely lean towards the more 'liquidy' side. Especially for wings. Buff Joe's does not disappoint - just get extras though, because you'll want it. And if you go XXX habanero, you'll need it. - Cheddar chips, all day, every day. It's like the opposite of my ranch preference: I despise drippy, nacho cheese on fries. Buff's uses some actual melted down cheddar. The final product is about as good as it gets in the cheese fries world. And such a delicious world it is. Ignore the haters and make Buff Joe's your #1 priority next time you're in Evanston. Which hopefully won't be for a while because I have no clue what you do in Evanston besides eat at Buff's.
(5)Drew D.
So, I've been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. That would mean that it's been about 15 years since I first tasted the succulent spiciness that is Buff Joe's sauce. I've introduced many people to this place, and never had I had anybody come out of here less than satisfied, which I think speaks to the quality of its food. I insist that everybody try the wings just once, even if they're not "wing people," just so they can have the experience. You'd be surprised how many of them are now "wing people" thanks to the gentle nudging! Every time I'm here, I tell myself I'm going to get something different...but when it comes down to it, I always have to go with my usual: single spicy, cheddar chips, and a mega size drink to wash it all down. Waiting for my food seems endless, and when I finally get to chomp down on my first wing, it's like tasting it for the first time all over again. There is a veritable explosion of spices in my mouth, and after the initial heat, the flavors come through like gangbusters. I tend to dislike wings that are hot for the sake of being hot. I find that they have little to no flavor once the heat passes, and for me, that sort of misses the point. The wings from Buff Joe's are fantastic for following up heat with flavor, and that to me is the hallmark of a good wing. Small wings? Perhaps, but I really don't care, because I've never left feeling any less than stuffed. And satisfied. It's the perfect prelude to sauntering over to the Lakefill and walking off some of the meal. :)
(5)Gary M.
Service is what you would expect from a place like this. The wings are awesome..
(5)Joseph C.
STILL BAD!!! My name is Joe and I am from Buffalo and this place is misnamed. If you serve ranch with your wings you should not be allowed to use Buffalo in your name. Mid-West Joe's fried Chicken is the proper name. yuck
(1)Varun M.
So far I've had Buffalo Joe's food on take out twice and both times i was disappointed. I love wings, i'm addicted but bad wings well they are very disturbing. Growing up in Upstate NY (Rochester) I love to try wings wherever I go and Buffalo Joe's, you are heart breaking. At the end of the day the wings have a few key ingredients 1) The Sauce 2) Cooking Times 3) The actual wing quality used Buffalo Joe's fails on ALL THREE. First off the Sauce is not very spicy, it has a very vinegar based taste and doesn't taste like any good (or bad) buffalo sauce i've ever had. They are usually served very dry without much additional sauce. Looking at cooking times, they definitely over fry the all the wings. Good Buffalo Wings are crispy on the outside but pretty soft on the inside...unfortunately on both occasions i feel like i'm eating crispy chicken every time. Last the quality of the wing used, I have a strong feeling they aren't using fresh wings but the frozen ones you find at the super market. The wings they serve, the meat is very often stuck to the bone and you'll find the bone's break very often when you eat them. THIS IS A CLEAR SIGN that the wing is of low quality. I do like the fact that they are small and not like other places where a wing is larger than a drumstick but unfortunately they need a new supplier. They do have some good variety and I know they have made a good living because frankly, Chicago doesn't wings. Plus on a college campus, this is perfect food but with the BWW opened up around the corner I think Buffalo Joe's is going to be in for some tough competition.
(2)Amy L.
Came here recently after going to the Great Lakes Naval Base. Mmmh, I was looking forward to some cheddar Chips and some suicide wings. And man, did I get my grub on. The suicide wings were good but I thought the mild taste pretty good too. Next time, it's milds all the way. It has the flavor without having the burning sensation when I potty. Sorry to be descriptive guys. You know you probably think the same thing when you eat hot stuff! DON"T LIE Note:**The wings seems to be a big bigger than the last time I visited Joe's.(Bigger than a quarter) All in all, a thumbs up to visit again.
(4)Michelle L.
After an extremely disappointing "cheddar fries" experience somewhere else (note to all out there - if you call your dish "cheddar fries" or "cheddar chips" instead of cheese fries, this means that you need to use a real cheddar sauce vs. the generic bright yellow artificial imitation funky-tasting cheese sauce that the others use) I was seriously craving Joe's cheddar chips... ...And I was not disappointed! Not only is the cheddar sauce amazing and real, but the "chips" (fries) seem so fresh, and the skin is still on...they would be good just by themselves (not like I know from personal experience as I only get them with cheddar). As for the wings - they're good, the sauce is great, but I'm not a crazy wing fan. My husband loves them though, he's been eating here for so long and it's great when his wing craving coincides with my cheddar chip craving....
(4)Frank L.
I'm sorry, but this place was just underwhelming. The two friends who took me to Buff' Joes made it seem like the wings were the best ever. I'm not a hater, but it just seemed to me that they took some chicken wings, threw them in a bowl of hot sauce and tossed it around. I kind of expected some of the seasoning cooked into the chicken. I suppose for the hot-wing lovers, this type of place is best, because you can ratchet up the heat if you like. Oh, and my girlfriend made the unfortunate mistake of ordering a baked potato. What they really meant was "microwave potato". Who goes to Joes? Long-time die hards who grew up on the stuff. People who want to choose the spicy to their hot wings Who avoids Joes? Folks who prefer wings with the flavor cooked into the chicken
(2)Daniel A.
Great wings, great and fast service, all around-enjoyable. They don't take credit cards, though.
(4)Dennis P.
The best wings in Illinois. Suicide is the only way! with the jalapenos... with their brand of ranch... my mouth is watering just talking about it...
(5)Miriam B.
I've been going here since I was a little girl. Great wings, burgers, baked potatoes, cheese chips( waffle cut cheese fries) and awesome chardogs!.
(5)Mike P.
This would be a 5-star, but for the complete lake of attention I received from the dude taking my order. It's partially my fault as I didn't have my order ready, this being my first visit. So the wing Nazi tuned me out. Anyway, the wings are superb. We had spicy and they were spicy, but not too spicy. Not the meatiest wings, but they give you a ton of them Celery and ranch came with. The cheddar chips great. That was the best fake cheddar cheese sauce I've ever had. I will relish the opportunity too have it sit in my colon for the next 6 months. Thanks, processed food stuffs! You should definitely check out this beautiful little dump. I can't wait to go back to try some sammiches on the menu, with a side of wings and maybe a processed cheddar cheese fry or too. Also, they have RC. My hillbilly soul rejoices.
(4)Jeff H.
Look. This place is great if you know what you're getting: awesome wings and a lot of them. I love BW3's - my undergrad school had one across the street from our campus; in fact, I think I spent my 21st birthday there, or at least part of it. But BW3's costs a lot more, and whiile there is bigger sauce selection, sometimes you don't want to choose between 20 different flavors - you just want wings and a lot of them. The suicide wings ain't all that hot. They're basically medium-to-hot wings with canned jalapeños atop. I couldn't figure out why they were touted as suicide wings until the next day, where I spent 5 minutes in the bathroom wishing I was dead. But it was worth it. I might go back tomorrow just to show my colon who's boss. Don't come for the ambiance. Don't come for a business lunch. Don't bring your mom unless she can get down with some wings like whoa (and if she can, give her my number).
(4)Simone T.
I'm from NY, and yes - Buffalo Joe's buffalo wings are the best I've ever eaten. Also the best cheese fries, hands down. GREAT owner AND staff. I love this place!
(5)Tanya G.
I have had buffalo joe's since freshmen year of high school (9 years) and no wings have ever been able to top theirs. Personally I think that mild is the best! Its always a treat to go there with a friend and for them to taste exactly what I've been talking about :) Staff is always very friendly, always bustling with customers. ONLY tiny constructive criticism I have is that you have to be prepared to always have cash. They do not take credit/debit for payment and its always been like that. Seems like a very successful restaurant chain, really wish they would upgrade to this. Would make it a lot easier and convenient for customers versus running to an atm nearby...
(4)Jocelynne G.
I used to LOVE coming here when I was a kid, when it was packed and hyped. I took my friends here thinking it would still be awesome, but the service was downright bullshit. I was charged for tap water. The workers were on their cell phone when we walked in, and they served a few of THEIR FRIENDS before me when I placed my order much earlier. For the amount of food I got I can't believe how long it took. I've never been to such a filthy place. This is not even the city. The wings were good. But then I remember that when the worker was tossing them in the sauce, he wasn't wearing gloves and the sauce was getting all over his greasy unwashed finger which was IN the steel bowl! I also noticed there was a crusty residue in the steel sauce bowl, instead of texting on their cellphones when we walked in they should have taken the time to wash or rinse the nasty thing in the sink. God just... disgusting. And embarassing that I took my friends here. They were completely mortified. :|
(1)Amy S.
I've heard from most locals Chicagoans that these are the best wings in town. I went, I ate and they were OK. Definitely not the best I've ever had, but not the worst. I think we ordered the hot and not the 911 (or whatever they were called) and I think the 911 are what people rave about. The hot were not hot and a little too vinegary for my palate. I need burn your mouth off HOT, not just a little hot. I'll go back again to try the 911 and I hope they don't disappoint.
(3)Neal W.
It really doesn't get any better. Double order spicy w/ a side of chedder fries. Best wings in chicago. Sure it might take a minute to get your food but its well worth the wait.
(5)Leonard S.
Got a gang of wings to go from here yesterday along w a hot dog and cheddar chips....I've never been inside buff joes before and still hadn't as I stayed in the car, but I've eaten these wings countless times before....I swear the wings were never this small before...some of them laughable but I couldn't stop eating them because of the sauce....I'll just get a burger or dog next time w sauce to go....I know a few Sunday chefs who can fry up some wings better than these while putting back a case...I can't believe that's the wings they served hahaha...the merkts cheddar is great!
(2)Gary C.
Where do I begin?? I've had my fair share of wings and Buffalo Joe's definitely tops the list. I started off on the bottom of the spiciness chain and got the mild. Great flavor, but it was missing that kick. I moved on to hot and I knew I struck gold. Stronger flavor and much more heat. I stayed on this level for a while then built the courage to try suicide. I've never looked back. It's arguably the best wing sauce I've ever tried. The extra heat comes from the jalepeno slices, seeds and all. Not only does this place have great wings, their buffalo chips [seasoned] with cheese is to die for. Ask for some suicide sauce on top and you have some of the best fries in the land. Service is decent. Actually, better than average for this reason: they messed up an order [they gave me a single instead of a double order] but took my name down to give me a free order next time I ordered. No questions asked.
(5)Ben W.
I have been coming to Buff Joe's since 2006, and I must say that the quality of the wings and service is in rapid decline. The wings seem to be getting smaller and smaller(check out photos 11 and 12). Also the price is constantly on the rise. In 2006 the price was 8.99 for a double order, it went to 9.99, and is currently at the outrageous price of 12.99. Sadly Buff Joe's has lost over 75% of my business. GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER!!!!!!!!
(2)William W.
Came here with a group of friends last month after my last visit back in the college days. Unfortunately, the wings tasted a lot better back then when fast food was the only meal of choice I could afford. Don't get me wrong, they are still pretty darn good. They are just not at the level of "OMG let's go to BJ's!!!!!" good. We got a party tray of wings for a group of 6 people along with some buffalo chips (fries) and nachos. The flavor was definitely there but the wings' size was simply too small. We also got a small order of "suicide" flavor, thinking that they would be too hot for us. However, that did not impress too much either. Although the spiciness did sneak up on us and we were all sweating by the end of meals. I think I stopped at 20 something wings, which is equally depressing considering I inhaled 35 wings last time I visited. Now, my proudest moment of this visit was making pot of rice and brought a couple containers worth of it with us. Friends have always told us that rice surprisingly tastes good with the wing sauce so I decided that this would be the time to try it. And it did not disappoint!!! It sort of tastes like a Chinese dish of "sweet vinegar deep fried fish". So it certainly pleased the Asian side of me when the wings were just a-ok.
(3)Elizabeth B.
My ex-boyfriend used to tell me all the time that I have a tiny mouth. I thought he was just flattering himself until my family dentist confirmed that I do indeed have a smaller-than-normal mouth. My tiny mouth is usually not much of a problem. However, it became an issue at Buffalo Joe's when I ordered the bacon cheese burger. I had to eat the grilled onions with a fork, take off most of the lettuce, all of the tomato, and pull out most of the top bun before I could take my first bite. When I did finally get to take my first bite, my burger was barely warm! I ordered the burger medium and it was well done. How exactly did they make my medium burger cold AND well done in less than 5 minutes? It defies the laws of physics. The fries were good but pretty cold. I didn't try my mate's wings, the burger made me lose my appetite for wings. We went to Buffalos Joe's for lunch because we are jobless and poor right now but, next time I will go to a different spot for lunch even if it costs a little more.
(1)Joseluis L.
This is my first time ever giving a review. I just had to come and see what everyone else wrote and felt inclined to give my opinion. I was introduced to this place by a couple of friends and they told me these were the most amazing wings they have ever had. We went last friday night and I will start from the beginning... The man begging by the front door was an immediate turn off. Walking up to the cashier was another immediate turn off, she had a very bad attitude. Not only did she talk with a bad attitude but she also wore it on her face. She really acted like she didn't want to be there (I wouldn't want to be at such a filthy place either). Now this I blame on my friends since they did not tell me but they do no accept debit cards/credit cards. I haven't been to place in a long time that doesn't accept (it's 2012 and you still run a cash only place?)...oh well. Also, if they accepted credit cards I would have ordered so much more wings and beer (they were tiny). But I borrowed cash from my friends. I wasn't about to use their atm machine. I get it, you don't accept cards but the owner (I'm assuming he owns that atm machine) is more then happy to charge you that fee for using that machine he installed...nice. I ordered double suicide. I got my food fairly quickly so that was a plus. We then proceeded to sit down at the filthy tables. They have tvs to watch...too bad the one with the loudest volume for some reason was set to a channel with infomercials, huh? The wing sauce was good (it shouldn't be called suicide though, not that hot) but the wings themselves were soooo tiny, laughable tiny. I just pretended they were amazing for my friends benefit. They still were acting like the place was amazing. I didn't dare go to the bathrooms, I didn't want to know what they looked like but my girlfriend did. She came back in seconds after leaving and told me there was urine all over the seat and also that there was a nasty mess inside the toilet because that person didn't bother to flush.... We will not be going back. It's not worth it for great sauce on nasty wings, eaten on a nasty table, and our order being taken by someone with a nasty attitude. No thanks!
(1)Shelden E.
mmm...yeah, these were good wings, and I did get quite a bit even for the single size version, but the dude worked at the register was such dick. I had ordered a Miller Lite beer when at the counter, but when I got to the register/tap they asked me again. So I changed my mind to the Leinenkugel's Winter ale--the exact same price--and the dude stood there saying, "It says Lite on your order." "Yeah my bad. I meant the Winter Ale. My bad." "It says Lite on the order." "Yyyyeah. I mean is that going to be a problem?" He just rung it up and took the cash. What a jerk. Like I said the wings were good, but I'd almost say they're just as good at Buffalo Wild Wings a few blocks away. Service is better there and more selections on stuff. Oh yeah. Also, the wet naps my friends and I got were all dry in their packaging. It was nice to walk out with the hands that weren't the cleanest.
(3)Ernie C.
Buffalo Joe's is uneven. I love coming here, but sometimes I wish I just opted for Flattop or any other downtown Evanston eatery. 1. Wings have gotten smaller. 2. Stingy on the ranch/bleu cheese. 3. It is not worth the price. It costs me $12 for wings, fries and pop (me alone). 4. Don't ask for water, cashier is QUICK to tell you.. "We don't give no free water here" and charge you $1.50 for the cup. No lie. 5. Cheddar fries are still good. 6. Somedays food is hot, somedays food is warm. 7. Better than the Howard Street location.
(2)Joe T.
This place serves up some great hometown wings. Whenever we do a house party in Chicagoland we always get these puppies by the pound and bring em' home to serve to the masses. They're great nibbler wings and they have a Suicide flavor with a hot sauce and grilled jalapenos in it. This flavor and the BBQ are 2 of my favorites. When you dine in here - you buy based on the number of wings and the wings are bigger. When you order for a party - they are smaller nibbler wings and sold in aluminum trays by the pound. Either way if you are a Buffalo Wild WIngs fan and looking for another Wings joint in Chicagoland that hits the spot just as well - look no further and try Buff Joe's!
(3)Darren F.
i been coming here off and on for many years.. it used to be better and more meat in them.. right now the wings is pretty tiny but it is still good.. love the waffle fries and love the burgers here! i dint really like eating inside there because it smells pretty horrible sometimes..
(3)Krupa U.
Buff Joe's is great! Every time I'm in chicago with friends, we always get a big order of buff joe's wings to pig out on at least one night we're there. I personally love the BBQ flavor, and I guess the Jalapeno would come in second. The wings are actually mini-wings, smaller than Buffalo Wild Wings, but we usually order the party pan for whatever party we're throwing so they are perfect little nibblers to go along w/ your beer or cocktail. Speaking of beer... they sell it! A limited selection mind you, but still, nice to know. Oh and major plus - it still tastes good the day after! Usually reheated wings end up getting dry and shriveled up, but Buff Joe's found a way to keep em tasting good for longer! I commend you, your Wingness!
(4)Jason C.
When I get a craving for wings, there is only one place that can satisfy it: Buffalo Joe's. I will gladly drive 25 mins from my place to Evanston to get some of their wings because they are the best (in my opinion). You have to make sure you go to the Clark Street Buff Joe's and not the Howard one - I'll explain why later. My order never changes: Single order/suicide and cheddar chips, also served with celery and ranch dressing. If I'm feeling risky I'll also get a Diet Rite. The magic is all in the tangy house suicide sauce with jalapenos, but it's not spicy to the point that you can't enjoy the wings. The cheddar chips are waffle cut fries slathered in a layer of cheddar goodness. I went to the Howard location once thinking that they too would have cheddar chips - FAIL. This is why going to the Clark St location is a must. Reminder: They only accept cash so make sure you have some coin on you!
(5)Grace B.
My trip back home was not complete until we went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston. By far one of the best wing spot ever. Double order mild w/ buffalo chips and a side of cheese please! You will not find a spot like this in LA. I've been a fan since '94. They keep it nice a simple.
(5)harry b.
By far these are the best wings in the state, if not the country! Wheather you prefer BBQ, mild, spicy or 'suicide,' go all out and get a double order. If you don't finish them on your first try, they're great the next day. Note that the other locations are not as good as the Clak location. They will do in a pinch, but the extra few minutes in the car are well worth it!
(5)Leo I.
Buffalo Joe's no more. When there is more bone than meat on the wings, you know it's time to accept that the legendary hole-in-the-wall has seen better days. I've been going to BJ's for quite a few years now. They had some of the best chicken wings I've ever tasted and definitely the best in the Chicagoland area. My last few visits were disappointing and last night's visit was the last straw. Whether it's the economic crisis or the fatigue that drives BJ's decline, decline it is. So long BJ.
(1)Stephanie F.
Sh*t, man. I'm not even a wings fan but when I was taken here by a wing guru and experienced the melt-in-your-mouth quality of these babies, I felt it in my hips. The cheese fries are fantastic. MMmmmm........the wings are so good that the only descriptive words I can come up with are naughty interjections.
(5)Frank P.
I've been coming here for at least 10 years and still the best in Chicago land. Never had anything but wings and chips (fries). Nothing else compares especially the bigger wing chains. I like the medium with jalepenos on the side. I like spicy but like to taste the chicken as well. Place isn't too big and not quite as clean as you would like. But definitely a place I crave.
(4)Pin Y.
As a Northwestern Alum, I miss this place so much!! You aren't an NU student if you don't go to Buffalo Joe's late a night. I want a Buffalo Joe's in LA! Please????
(4)Sam W.
Been coming here since high school. Hands down the. Best wings I've ever had. Hidden secret, try the cookies at the counter if you have room after stuffing your face with wings. Oh yeah and the cheese fries!!
(5)Jacob J.
Before Buffalo Wild Wings, this was my fix for wings in Chicago land. Suicide, thinking about it has me salivating. That's a ton of hot sauce lathered over wings and then a helping of sliced jalapenos over that. That sauce is great for dipping or just alone. You've got to really dig (vinegar) hot sauce to appreciate Joe's flavors. I can't remember the exact brand of hot sauce, might be Louisiana, they keep jugs of it in plain sight. A perfect order is a double order of wings, a basket of the waffle cut fries and a large drink. (That's large soda pop, not "drink") Tempt fate by getting a few friends together and ordering a full or half pan. That's a catering order of 50-100 wings. Extra wet, the extra better. Joe's however isn't consistent, at times you really love it and other times it's not how you remembered it. Note: during cold seasons it can be cold in the dining area, dress warm or you may have your jacket on while eating. There's something important to mention about payments, I believe it might be cash only, or charge only on orders over $20 +. You may like to inquire when placing phone orders. (This may have changed) Crowd is all Northwestern Univ peeps and locals. If you go late night expect to get harassed by street walkers. Not your usual kind either, they have refined tastes and may ask for more than just change, they need to eat too. (One time a guy asked me for change, I bought him some fries, he then tells me he would've rather had the money so he could get some Thai food!)
(4)d a.
the bathroom is disgusting-reminds me of a prison from a bad tv movie but everything else is great. also the soda is supersized not the normal sizes so unless you're pat fitzgerald thirsty go smaller. great place, great service, food still reasonably priced and great mix of students, 5 year olds with dads, grownups and regulars. the fries are waffle and the cheese on the burgers is spread which is better. cash only and they're open very late. just excellent, but fix the bathroom-with all the little kids it should look better.
(5)Ngoc H.
You don't know what wings are until you get a taste of Joe's. They come out right from the fryer and are topped with jalapenos if you get them suicide. I wold say some days the wings are better than others, some days juicy and huge, others skinny and disappointing, but you never know until you order. Their buffalo chips are to die for, crispy on the outside tender on the inside waffle fries that are tossed with a delicious seasoning blend. There's this seasoning on them which I can never guess whats in it. A lot of people like the cheddar on them but I would go without. They only take cash, but there's an ATM in there too if you want to be charged for the fee. Not the greatest place for a date but if you are craving wings with a couple friends, it's the place to be.
(4)Phil X.
"A single order of hot wings with a side of cheddar chips, extra cheese." I come here when I want buffalo wings...or when I want to negate any of my previous efforts at my local gym. I don't know too much about the rest of their menu. The hot wings here are tasty. I usually order 'em hot. If you order the "suicide" version, they take the "hot" and throw a bunch of peppers all over it. G'head and try it. Your colon will thank you. The wings themselves tend to be small sometimes. It's all about the sauce though. (That should be a bumper sticker) The BBQ wings are pretty good too. They're sweet, NOT hot. On the side, I always order cheddar chips with extra cheese. They are waffle-fries. The cheese is a melted sharp cheddar. You will either love the cheese...or you will hate it. I wash it down with grape pop.
(4)Jeff H.
Hands-down the best wings I've ever had, and I've had them at about every place that is supposed have even passable wings. Perfectly fried, perfectly sauced. The best part is they don't bread them. Breading, in my humble opinion, is an amateur move. Breading is fine on chicken fingers, but it has no place on wings. The sauce...holy sh*t, the sauce. My theory is that BJ's sauce has three key ingredients - 1) Crack cocaine 2) Heroin 3) The tears, sweat ,or semen of some cosmic deity. Now, I see that some of the reviews bash BJ's for the wing size. I'll admit that these aren't great big, super meaty wings, but therein lies the genius. Ya see, I can say in all honesty that every place I've ever been where you get big, meaty wings, is that you usually just end up tasting the chicken which is usually low quality to begin with. When I eat wings I want a perfect wing-to-sauce ratio with the sauce having just the right consistency to cling to the wings. Buffalo Joe's has this ratio perfected. My friends and I have brought many, and I mean MANY people here to put it to the test and they've all loved it. In fact, out of all of our friends and acquaintances who've had BJ's only one of our buddies doesn't care for it, which isn't bad out of the large number of us who love it. I even know several people who - while claiming to be vegetarian - make an exception for these wings-from-above. Finally, to make your BJ's experience complete, get some waffle fries and a Gut RC and you have the makin's of a superbly unhealthy, but decadent meal. It's worth the drive from Chicago, I assure you.
(5)Mr. C.
I'm not sure what has been happening here lately, but since I started coming here 3 years go the wings seem to be getting smaller and the employees ruder. Don't get me wrong they have one of the best buffalo sauces around, but my last visit was not a good one when I was taking one bite off each wing since they were so amazingly small. It's like they got their chicken wings from baby chicks that haven't fully developed yet, which made the entire recent experience kind of nauseating.
(3)David T.
I've been a regular customer of Buffalo Joe's ever since I've moved to area in 2001, when I first heard they were the best wings in the city. They never disappointed ... until now. For some reason, my last five visits or so (I average about one visit per month, always driving more than 25 miles just to get my fix) the wings have been pretty sub par, almost bad in some cases. I would usually finish my single suicide order w/ waffle fries and crave more, but the wings have just been severely lacking lately. I can't put my finger on it, it might be the shrinking size of the wings, which were already pretty small to begin with. There's also been a few occasions where the pieces look deformed, neither looking like a traditional drumstick or wing, so I just throw them out. The sauce is still as good as ever, I just think they've somehow cut some costs and used a cheaper, less tasty wing now. I would usually recommend Joe's highly to any one who hasn't visited the place yet, but now I'm not so sure. Hopefully their act picks up again.
(3)Abhist D.
I love Buffalo Joe's wings. I used to eat them a lot during high school and hadn't had them in quite a while. Well I lost a bet to a despicable Sox fan and had to pay up with Buff Joe's wings. Let's just say that this is one bet that I wouldn't mind losing over and over again! I mean...the wings are delicious! Heck, even my wife (who can't stand wings cuz she's never liked the tast) loved them. And I mean LOVED them. They're good. Service is what you'd expect from the joint, which means its quaint in its own way. Oh...and suicide wings are the way to go (and they are NOT THAT HOT!)
(5)Bless P.
Outstanding and THE best chicken wings and fries I've ever tasted!!! Very casual and a long wait if there is a game scheduled.
(5)Aimee C.
yes, yes and more yes! When I'm dying for some good old fashion buffalo wings, the trek to Buffalo Joe's is worth every painstaking moment. From their suicide sauce to their waffle fries, it's a treasure to devoured. Better than all the rest... Hot, saucy and delicious.. wings flying as elbows are up in the air. Don't try to talk to me, because I'm deep in sauce and can't be bothered. :) talk to you when my fingers are licked and the grin of complete satisfaction is plastered across my face. -- ps take a zantac.. the sauce will definitely get your tummy rumbling.
(4)Albert C.
I love this place!! I've been going here for such a long time.. the single order is such a big portion and I always mixed bbq & suicide sauce!! Don't forget to get their buffalo chips aka waffle fries with the cheddar cheese! For $10.10 AMAZING!! Their cookies by the counter are amazing also! They're actually freshed baked daily but it looks old in the container
(4)Janice L.
yumyumYUM. the suicide wings are the best, heaped on top with jalapeno peppers. the flavor is the best of all the wings i've ever had. also, i'm not a fan of breaded wings and here, it's naked, so perfect. one downside, sometimes some of the wings have absolutely no meat. i wish they fattened the chickens a little more, they're like anorexic! anyways, dip the wing into the ranch sauce, take a bite, aahh.. bliss (:
(4)Precious B.
What can I say Buff Joe's never fails wings and fries all day!
(5)Bruce B.
The best wings ever! I grew up with Buff Joes and nothing will be better than them. Get yourself a double order of suicide, buff chips with extra sauce, and a large RC. After you're done eating, you should probably run around the block to burn off the calories. Or, you will be in food coma because it's that good. Be prepared, they wings are not big. However, each one packs lots of taste. They service is always pretty quick. This location is far better than Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. If you like wings and fries (chips), there's none better in the Chicagoland area.
(5)Sabrina B.
Wings ate delicious. Very greasy though. Wings are not big in size however. A single will be good for one person provides they are hungry.
(4)Vanessa D.
I think this is one of those places that you can only truly appreciate if you've been coming here since you were in high school or college. Despite growing up in the area, I never set foot into this Buffalo Joe's until this year. I've been twice now. The spicy wings are good. And they have RC cola, which is always a pleasant surprise. However, I found the actual wings to be awfully small with not much meat. Additionally, their cheddar chips which I had high hopes for were soggy and gross both times. I had been assured that they typically were not like this... so, who knows. But, the place has character and they have a full menu of things I haven't yet tried, so I will definitely give them another chance.
(3)Bridget M.
Quite yum. The wings are good, but are decidedly not truly spicy. They douse these guys in sauce which adds to the overall appeal. The cheese fries are a must do. Major props for the real cheddar cheese chunks accompanied by the jalapeno slices. The burgers are greasy and delicious; I'm not a big fan of the kinds of buns they use. Pretty good deal for what you spend. Just wish they'd invest in having a paper towel roll at the table a la Hooters and a credit card machine. Buyers beware, this is a cash only joint!
(4)Eric M.
I'm giving them four stars within their genre, which is fast-food, with a heavy emphasis on wings. I went here for the first time last weekend. Not having been before, I don't know what size the wings were "back in the day," but I don't really give a damn about wing size when they just scoop a bunch up and don't count them. 20 small wings vs. 10 huge wings - who cares. If anything I like wings for the skin anyway, so more small ones usually means more skin, more deliciousness and more satisfaction! I thnik these are some of the best-tasting wings I've had. I do like blue cheese dressing better than ranch, but the wings themselves matter a whole lot more than the side sauce does. I don't live close, so I can't say I'll be a regular or anything, but I liked them well enough that I'll definitely be back, maybe even for a special trip now and then. I do have one complaint - the cheese fries were not up to par. The cheese congealed and became a gooey, cold mess way to fast. And the fries themselves weren't that great, either. Making good fries isn't rocket science and I think people let restaurants off easy too often for sub-par fries.
(4)Alexander W.
Double Suicide, Mega RC. Perfection.
(5)Jeff H.
Fun and cheap wings place for those that don't want that big chain down the street. #cheapeats
(4)Faye D.
Oooh Buff Joes... My favorite place to eat in Evanston. The wangs are thee bomdiggidy and the cheese waffle fries. Mmm. Con: Kind of dirty and they don't accept cards. Oh well big whoop right? The best wings place for me so far.
(4)Miles S.
Best wings I have had so far in the northern hemisphere. Great atmosphere and good people. Not a lot of flavors, but not needed. Great burgers and chicken. A must try .
(5)Orlando H.
First thing I get walking in is a rude cashier. Went in 15 min before they closed and she was quick to say "we're closed we have nothing left". They should change their closing time to 1145 not midnight.
(1)AJ M.
This place used to be my spot for wings. At one point I would even go as far to say the best wings I ever had. The sauce is amazing, wings so cripsy like none other. Although still pretty good it's not as good as it used to be. Prices have jumped alot over the years, I remember when a double order used to be around $9 now $14. The waffle fries are still a guilty pleasure that doesn't disappoint. They only take cash, well worth the occasional visit!!
(4)Jamie H.
Came in today for lunch because I've heard the wings were amazing. I tried the mild and the hot; mild was awesome but the hot I wasn't too crazy about. Was a pretty standard hot sauce. You get a pretty decent price for the amount and because the mild was so good I plan to come back and try the suicide sauce the waffle cheese fries.
(4)Gina T.
By far the best wings I've ever tried EVER. The only reason I give them four stars instead of five is because it looks dirty and smells. And even with all that going on ill still eat there. Other than that the wings are amazingly delicious. Very crispy. I got the mild wings and the sauce is sort of sweet but it's nothing less than scrumptious. The waffle fries are fresh and tasty. I'm a ranch lover. Ill have ranch with anything and buff joes ranch is the best ranch I've ever had. I wish they would clean up the place a bit. That's the only complaint I have.
(4)Jane Y.
OH MY WORD. the wings here are DELICIOUS UGHAS;LDIFAH;SLDIFH i always crave these things and then GET SLAPPED IN THE FACE BY REALITY because... its a bit of a drive for me to get here but just thinking about these wonderful heavenly saucy tastey oh not so little wings goodness gracious and the CHEDDAR CHIPS screw diets and if ur gonna cheat might as well make it a WORTHY CHEAT COME TO BUFFALO JOESS!
(5)Mark K.
This was Sweetie's favorite wing place in Chicago, so I had to stop by on the way through last week. Especially after she forbade me to stop at any BBQ places on the south side... Nice little college-town wing joint. Looks really small, but once you order you see there's a bigger room in back to eat. Service was efficient and friendly. Order sizes are big- I got a single and worried that it would be enough, but it was plenty. Nice meaty wings, good sauce (I got BBQ.) I got a side of celery, which was also good sized. Between a few veggies, lots of wings, and some RC, I was fully satisfied. Can't wait to go back.
(4)Vealy C.
The wings were terrific, the service isn't that bad. The "ghetoness" of the place adds to the experience, but the bathrooms.. ohhh, they're always so dirty. My hands still feel dirty even after washing them.
(3)Frank Y.
You are either a fan or a hater; there are no in-betweens when it comes to Buf Joes. I am a fan. When people complain, they tend to say that the wings are too small; but I love them. The sauce makes these wings. It is kind of sweet, thick, and has just enough spice. The wings, because, they are small, are crunchy on the outside and perfectly sauced. The ranch that Buf Joe's has is awesome! It is very easy to get addicted to these wings. When our sons come back to Evanston, one of the first things that they crave is Buffalo Joes. For a family of four, we get a double-order of spicy and a double-order of mild wings. The waffle fries are also yummy when you dip them in the ranch dressing. If you want a burger in Evanston, go to Edzo's. If, however, you want wings, nothing compares to Buf Joes.
(4)Gautram W.
First and last time! I wonder did they fried the wings in oil or grease..... Horrible horrible horrible.... The burger as well was dipped in oil/ grease or whatever.....
(1)Renya M.
The food here is amazing and the service isn't bad either except for this one douchebag who actually cooks and prepares the orders. I'm sorry that he feels his job is so difficult, bagging wings and taking people orders, really, I am. Id be miserable if I looked and acted anything like him too. This guy was rude to everyone in line though, do yourselves a favor and go to any other location if you care at all about servers doing even the absolute least in terms of being polite.
(2)Rod D.
Still loving Buf Joes as the wife and I continue visit on a frequent basis. Remember to ask for well done if you like your wings crispy
(5)Sharon C.
Everyone always raves abut Buff Joe's being the best wings in Evanson, but I honestly don't see it - I typically order the wings mild and they have this really funky aftertaste. The fries are soggy, and the burgers are literally dripping oil through the paper trays. I'll pass.
(2)Z S.
So good. This is my guilty pleasure food. The wings are so good and saucy, while the burgers are enormous and very greasy. (The special Buff Joe's sauce mixed with mustard and ketchup is heaven.) All variations of the chips/fries are really crispy and flavorful. So while the food is a little unhealthy, you've got to treat yourself once in a while.
(4)Don T.
Still after all these years, my favorite buffalo wings place in the Chicagoland area!
(5)Cyril L.
Buffalo Joe's has some of the best wings. My first time was last month and they tasted really good. Make sure to get the sauce. For a low price, you can get a basket full of wings. It's worth the wait.
(4)Meredith C.
My first impression was very poor. The girl taking my order was so incredibly rude, I immediately regretted my choice to eat here when there are literally 50 restaurants in this area. Rolled her eyes when asked questions, spoke barely above a mumble, when asked her to repeat herself she basically shouted at me. Really, really, rude first impression. She of course entered our order incorrectly. Wrong food came. However, the other members of the staff quickly fixed her mistake and we're exceptionally polite and cheerful. Food was really, really good. Best wings ever. Fries are great. All of the food was outstanding. Felt a little like we were eating out of our laps, maybe give some plates out with wings? When we left staff said goodbye, very polite. Made up for little miss sunshine that took our order. Try it out. Food is really amazing. Cash Only but there is an ATM. They do serve a few beers, also.
(3)Michael G.
Simply the best. I made an hour round trip to get these wings. I usually do once every 3 weeks. I crave this place weekly. I wish I was skinny and could eat these wings every week. Standard order is Double Order Suicide (gotta have the jalapeños), cheddar chips (never get cheese on the side, the fries need to be covered in cheese!!!), and a bowl of cheddar broccoli (when you are waiting for your food ask for a sample If they already haven't offer it to you).
(5)Nari L.
Love this place! Came here years ago with a friend when I was in college and I loved it! I recently came back here years later since the last time and I still loved it! The food is fast so you can come and eat here in a jiffy.
(5)Jim K.
Been going here for more than 25 years. No change in order: Double order wings, Cheddar chips, and gutbuster lemonade. Why mess with perfection?
(5)Michael W.
You could not BELIEVE how much I love this place... To paraphrase... These wings are more full than Donald Trump at a Las Vegas strip buffet, with sauce sassier than Ellen DeGeneres, and so meaty they had to bring in a weatherman to evaluate it. Let me just be upfront and say that the wings are not boneless and are actually smaller than the average wing, but the upside of that is that the surface area to volume ratio on these wings is ri-DICK (any one of my AP Bio homies know what's up!!!), which makes for some outrageously saucy wings. Also, they give you celery sticks! Celery sticks are fantastic, it's literally portable water, but in solid form! I actually have a patent pending for a booze canteen that's made out of celery. The idea is that when you get a hangover after a heavy night of drinking, you can eat the canteen the next morning for a refreshing, fibrous jolt of hydration (hit me up if you're interested, but I already got a lot of investors lined up). Okay, one last thing. The one weird thing about it is that the urinals have ice in them. Ice! What is this, Soviet Russia*? I personally will not use any product with a molar mass less than or equal to 18, so this was especially problematic for me (sorry about your sink, Buff Joe's) *fun fact: In Soviet Russia, you were only allowed to buy water in ice form. In fact, the premise behind the "Cold War" was that the Soviets were trying to freeze the world's water supply (for that Russian +1 mobility buff in cold). That's why the United States detonated so many nuclear bombs back then, to keep the earth warm. Down with commies!
(5)Donald S.
I love these wings (spicy. The barbecue don't count seeing as its only Sweet Baby Ray's), and I judge all other buffalo wings by these. They have beer on tap and consistently great wings whichever sauce you get (mild, spicy, suicide, or BBQ). Single, spicy, extra ranch & celery, with an order of the buffalo chips ( waffle fries...), and a Berghoff means your in buisness.
(5)Jessica D.
My favorite food is spicy chicken and DING DING DING. Buffalo Joes has won the key to my heart and stomach. My mouth waters just thinking about it. I have pregnant cravings and I'm not even pregnant. If I were getting the death penalty, this would be my last meal. I can never stop myself from buying more than what can fit in my belly.
(5)Marci G.
Sorry Joe, but I am done with Buffalo Joe's :( Sad to say. The last few years the wings have just gone way down hill and I just keep hoping the next time I go (once a year) the wings will be delish again, but sad to say they are not. I don't know why they changed the recipe, but they have not been the same for a long time now. I actually left there tonight and wondered if Joe was still alive, because I cannot imagine him being alive and him allowing his restaurant to go this far downhill. The worst part is........it is so filthy in there, I am shocked that the health dept has not come in and faulted them into cleaning the place up. So many bugs flying around in there, it's hard to eat your food. And the bathroom.....OH MY GOSH, GROSS! It was filthy last year when I went and this time.....horrible ( seriously, blood on the tiles!) I grew up on Buffalo Joe's. I have been eating there since the mid '80's. If you are around Joe, please put some money back into it and clean it up and get your food back up to the excellent tasty level it used to be in. Bye for now.
(1)Tian Y.
Not really a picky wing-eater, and I'm good with their sauces. The wings are kind of small though compared to other places nearby, and I prefer the big and juicy ones with meat. Don't be surprised by poor customer service here.
(3)Kristen L.
Double order of suicide? HELL YES. Buffalo Joe's has the only wings that I will ever crave. Sure the restaurant itself is a bit dated and it can be next to impossible to find seating on any given night, but damnit, are they worth it. The wings themselves are a bit on the smaller side, but they make up for it in how many they give you. The fat-ass in me always gets a double order with buffalo chips (the double order comes with anywhere between 20-25 wings). That paired with some fresh celery and ranch? Makes my mouth salivate just writing about it. On the way back home from a day at the Field Museum with the parentals, papa Lee decided he wanted to stop by and grab some to go. It's about a good 25-30 minute drive from Buff. Joe's to home, but good God they were still delicious (and not soggy) after we go home. The only painful spiciness I would ever put myself through.
(5)Joe H.
I'm giving BJ's a 4 star rating as an average of the 5 star place this place has been to me over the past 20 years and the 3 star place it was the other day when I stopped by. These wings are what I've always measured all buffalo wings I've ever eaten in my life. I LOVE THIS PLACE. But the other day, I didn't love it so much. The sauce had a weird ammonia kind of flavor and the cheese on my chips tasted like they put in more glue than normal. I also hate how expensive it has become. But I still love the place. The place hasn't changed at all! From the floors, tables, benches, bathrooms, and staff (GARY!!!!), it's the same. Kind of like an Evanston time capsule plus inflation.
(4)Roxanne R.
Yu-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-u-ummmm!! Hands down best wings in Chicago. You get about 15 or so wings for a single order. The wing sizes are on the small side, just like I like it. I want to eat wings not drumsticks. The sauce is what makes the wings. It perfectly coats the wings and is fantastic. I always get a single order with waffles fries and cheese on the side. Waffle fries are solid. I recommend getting the cheese on the side. The cheese isn't liquidy nacho cheese, this cheese coagulates after a while and it's a nice compliment to the wings. Service is okay and the place isn't very tidy but this isn't fine dining, you come here because the wings are freaking delicious.
(5)Karen K.
It's always fun to come here for a late night dinner with friends. Unfortunately, I've noticed that their wings have gotten even smaller. There was barely any meat and what meat there was on the bones were very tough. The celery that came with our order was not washed well and I was so desperate to combat the saltiness of the wings with the celery that I ended up wiping the dirt off with the napkins.. but gross. The cheese fries were the only thing that made the meal yummy.
(2)Earlie C.
Wings are still the best in the city, but holy hell. We came in last night and came across the most ghetto, classless workers ever. First, the use of the word "fuck" was used around twenty times while I was waiting for my food. The vulgarity of staff had my brain hurting. Seriously, pull up your damn pants, act like a decent human, and possibly show me that your vocabulary consists of more than "fuck, shit, and motherfucker". My girlfriend ordered a polish. We both witnessed a female take a reject order (a polish that was sitting out in a basket when we first arrived - for how long?) back on the grill for about a minute and serve us that dog. Come on Buffalo Joe's... Just make sure you go when the owner is there. I'd question ever ordering food from this establishment again if he was not present.
(1)Stacy H.
Suicide wings are soooo good.. I only like boneless wings but I make an exception for these. The waffle fries are good too. Can be a little salty but I just always have lots of water near by!!
(5)Alana H.
Aside from the loud obnoxious and inappropriate conversation taking place by the staff. The chicken was amazing. The waffle fries were not as good as they were hyped up to be however the chicken makes the long drive and rude service worth it.
(4)BforBulky B.
Just went! The buffalo wings are great. I'm not sure I'd trek all the way out there again for the wings, BUT I WOULD FOR THE COOKIES. And the ranch dip. If you're in this part of town, definitely stop by. If you're in Chicago, R.J. Grunts wings are delish.
(4)Emma R.
If I could give this place no stars, I would. I have not been to this place since I was in high school. My family and I happen to be in the area and I had the bright idea of having wings. So down to Buffalo Joes we go. The girl in the front was the best part of experience here. Over All cleanliness of this place is just gross! They got one of our drinks wrong, my husband goes to the front to change it. The girls pours it, coughs in her hand and with that hand that she coughed in, grabs the lid puts it on the cup and hands it to my husband. Gross!!! I am surprised people eat here, and that this place has not been shut down because it's dirty.
(1)Buttermilk P.
Very good wings. My wife and I try to grab a bite at Joe's whenever we are in Evanston. We normally order their wings with mild sauce and waffle cheese fries. They have three main levels of sauce which are all the same, mild, spicy and suicide. The difference is, the mild is only a coating of sauce, the spicy gives you a bit more and the suicide adds sliced jalapeno peppers. The sauce is really good, and since everything is made to order, the wings are usually hot and fresh. They don't give you very many fries, but the cheddar cheese sauce is also very good. In typical north side/north shore fashion, everything is overpriced and a la carte. We are used to Harold's, where chicken comes with fries, coleslaw and bread. That would cost an extra $50 here, and the prices you pay here would get you triple the amount of food at a south side establishment. However, it is a bit of a different take on wings, so we pay a visit every blue moon. Cash only.
(5)Shari F.
Buffalo Joe's in Evanston WILL NEVER AGAIN GET OUR BUSINESS! The manager is so unprofessional and the employees do not inform customers properly about pre-ordering, a horrible place. We have been going there for years and tried to pre-order for Super Bowl and the idiots told us for smaller orders to just come in. We drove in the blizzard and they wouldn't serve us, I will never go to a Buffalo Joe's again and will never recommend them to anyone.
(1)Rene S.
Wings are really good (not as good as Franks for the Memories in Mundelein, but that is too far away). They are small but the portion size is huge so it is worth what you get. There are only three sauce levels: mild, spicy and suicide. I wanted medium and was directed by the woman who took my order that the spicy would be a good alternative. It was. So why only 4 stars if the wings are good? No credit cards, no delivery, and the cardinal sin for a wing joint .... NO BLUE CHEESE dressing! While I can cross the street to the Jewel and get some blue cheese dressing, no delivery is a big problem. They are going to lose a lot of business, including mine, by not offering delivery. On a nice summer evening in the summer, not a problem to walk the mile to get to the place. But if the weather is at all bad, I often order delivery so I don't have to go out if I'm running low on groceries. Too bad I can't order from here!
(4)Lucy F.
Great wings!!!! Simply, Delicious, nice crunchy texture and the mild sauce is just great! Make sure you don't come on the weekend since the place is always so pack.
(4)Kyle D.
Dear Evanston, you've got a serious impairment when it comes to evaluating wing joints. Not sure what's going on here. Buffalo Joe's is a 4 star wing joint? C'mon. Is this some kind of romantic/nostalgic thing? The result of underdeveloped undergrad taste buds? First, this place is f'ing D.I.R.T.Y. The dining area is dirty. So is the kitchen. Every time those kitchen doors opened we were smacked in the face with a nasty odor. And the wings suck. They go nuts with the corn starch. Corn starch has no place on wings. They damn sure don't need to look like they've been breaded in it. And the mild sauce is it sweet? WHY is it sweet? Call it sweet sauce, because it has no resemblance to a buffalo sauce. Fries were ok. Ranch was lame. Nothing redeeming about this place.
(1)Emily P.
Suicide wings with cheddar fries are a must! (The burn in the bathroom later is worth it; trust me...haha sorry for the TMI)!
(4)Eileen S.
Seriously good wings. I always get the buffalo wings with mild sauce and cheddar chips (waffles fries smothered in cheese sauce). Ranch is tasty as well. Sure its not the most beautiful place to eat, but that's not why I go. Beware: you will become addicted to these wings!
(5)Sallie H.
The spicy wings were pretty good, I'm not a fan of wings so I can't really get excited about them. The one thing I can honestly say was terrible there was the cheese fries. I believe the cheese was made out of powder, idk it was just gross. I had to scrape the cheese off my fries because it was so disgusting. The cheese at 7-Eleven for the nachos are 10 times better than what Buffalo Joe's offered. The buffalo fries are very good, i wished they had real cheese to go with it :-(
(2)Christine M.
Awful. Awful. Awful. Half way through our meal we found a long black hair melted in our cheese fries.
(1)Will B.
Total collapse of the brand they built over the years. I've been going there for over 27 years. These days it is really bad. Watery teriyaki, under cooked fries, and the worst wings I've seen in a long time.
(1)Brad S.
Going back to my days in high school, over 20 years ago, I've always been a big fan of the place. Went there for lunch on Friday with a friend from high school, trying to re-live the good old days. I was shocked at the quality of the wings themselves. They were so small and tiny. Wish I had taken a picture at the time to post on here. It also drives me crazy that they nickel and dime you for every little thing. Who charges for a cup of water?!?! They do. The reason they get 2 rather than 1 stars is the people were quite friendly, even offering up free samples of split pea soup, and the sauce itself was quite tasty. Hopefully it was just a bad batch of wings but have to say I was awfully disappointed in the place.
(2)Gabriel S.
I've been coming to Buffalo Joes since the early 90s. The wings are still the best in the world in my opinion. The perfect blend of meat and crispy skin with absolutely amazing sauce.
(5)Kevin C.
When I was an undergrad at NU I lived a few blocks away and would get the same order of wings and buffalo chips every couple of weeks. When I moved away, despite searching high and low, I could never find a wing place that matched the buff. So when I came back to Chicago for work, frequent pilgrimages to buff joes were a must. It still hits the spot every time.
(5)Shalem A.
Buff Joes is an Evanston staple, and they offer the best wings in Evanston. This is not health food, but at least once a month I'll grab a single suicide for lunch. It is good for the soul. They also have awesome waffle fries and solid burgers, but if you're coming here for the first time, make sure you try the wings. The staff can be a little "sassy" at times, but it's part of their schtick, don't take it personally.
(4)Randall K.
Not the cleanest place, but one of my top 5 places to eat. They have my favorite buffalo wings. In Buff-Joes language, I usually order a double suicide with cheddar chips and a gut-buster RC. What that really means is a double order of wings, spicy with jalapeños too. Waffle fries loaded with a creamy cheddar cheese sauce. A large Royal Crown soda. The wings come with little ranch cups and some celery. Mini napkins are on the table. The area is nice and close to northwestern university. It can have it's share of pan-handlers sometimes, but because of the area, they are usually non - aggressive. If someone asked me for my best wing place, it is definitely Buffalo Joes.
(5)Lefai K.
The wings of the place is awesome! You won't find lots of flavors like you would at bw3, just mild, spicy, and suicide. The breading is not too much, but the crisp was perfect. =============================== And now my signature bathroom review! =============================== the place itself is kind of a hole in the wall. That being said, I didn't expect too much from it. And it's pretty much true. It's a place to take a leak, and then get the f out. So sit or squat? Squat... And flush the toilet by kicking the toilet handle down, because gawd knows what's touch that toilet handle
(4)Asia C.
The BEST wings in the chicago area! I've been ordering wings from them for years! I always usually order a single order of suicide. Also, this location is the best. Coming in second is Green Bay Rd. and Howard St. is last. I can tell the difference in how each location prepares the wings.
(5)Hersh A.
This place doesn't do much for me any more. Menu variety it's relatively good for what the place is. I mostly care for having wings here. I have been here a handful of times in the past. Back in the 90's I used to like their wings, especially the suicide kind but at some point something changed (I guess their recipe?) that the suicide wings have not been the same. They taste average at best. Also what I didn't like recently is that the order taking person said you get 12 wings in single order and we got our order we were shorted a few wings. When I asked about it, one of the persons behind the counter said that the wing amount is never exact but more like 10-12. Wtf? That's just dumb. I don't think I had such a problem in the past. I don't care for the cash only affect of it. Oh well, I don't desire to come here again anytime in the foreseeable future. There are better wings place out there.
(2)James H.
I'm happy to see a lot of 4 and 5-star reviews for Buffalo Joe's. But it's pretty clear all of them are from people under 22 or who know so little about wings that they feel the need to make clear that these are bone-in wings (as if boneless wings are actually wings or should even be in the discussion of what makes a great wing). Anyhow, 10 or 15 years ago, I would have given Buffalo Joe's an emphatic 5 starts. It was unrivaled for the best wings in the Chicago area. But the wings keep getting smaller, the preparation keeps getting sloppier, and the restaurant keeps getting dirtier. They're not bad and I might go back if I lived in Evanston but my Buffalo Joe's days are done.
(2)Danny M.
I live 30 minutes from this place and I will still make the drive here for their wings. They have the best mild and spicy wings I have ever eaten. The wings have gotten a lot smaller than they use to be, but it is still good. The sauce on the wing is perfect, not too spicy were it kills your taste buds. Get the wings with waffle fries and you will not be disappointed.
(5)Heather K.
Love this place!! It's food that you get acquainted too while living here. Love the rib tips cause their bbq sauce is a little more on the sweeter side. And their wings...are nice and tangy!! Great combo with the ranch and celery sticks! Simple and easy option just to grab a bite to eat.
(5)Jung K.
want spicy buffalo wings? look no further and stop by the Buffalo Joe's on Clark st. Order: single suicides with chips and a large drink. If suicides are too spicy, then get out. The regular spicy ones are good too.. They have their system on lock down. Order your food, pick up your food, pay in cash only, and go demolish those wings.
(5)Scotty D.
I went here after a friend told me these were the best wings in the Chicago area. I love wings. I can confidently say these are the best wings in the Chicago area. 8 bucks for 10 wings is a great deal. The spicy sauce is great. Just enough heat. Even the mild my wife had was good. The wings are cooked perfectly, nice and crunchy. Even the ranch tastes better than other places. The waffle fries are great but I'd stay away from the cheese sauce. It was very salty and congealed quickly which ruined the fries. Wouldn't get them again. But if you want good wings, man this is the place.
(5)Kristen D.
This place FAR surpasses any place like BDubs. The wings are HUGE, you get a lot of them with one order, and there is enough sauce on each wing to still have enough to lick off your fingers. (I feel like in all of my wing experiences, there is never enough sauce to go with the meat. NOT the case here!) They give you an order of celery and ranch with a wing order, which was one of my favorite things about this place. My only complaint is that it is HOT in this restaurant...but that could also be from the huge friers and grills up in the front of the restaurant.
(5)Kevin S.
Great taste and good people. Best wings so far anywhere
(5)Aldi J.
My go to wing place!!! Best buffalo sauce. Just get spicy or suicide please. Don't be weak and go mild. Growing up in nearby Skokie, my friends and I would head over here and pig out on the regular. I'm a bit disappointed though because the wings over time have gotten smaller... anyone else notice this? C'mon bring the bigger wings back. Sorry, this was the reason for my one star deduction. Some things never change though. When I arrive at a party and see a party pan, my mouth starts watering I know what I'm attacking first. Don't forget the awesome waffle fries!!
(4)Ryne D.
I've been here many times before, but on my last trip to Northwestern this weekend to do an interview, the only thing on my mind was getting these wings. They have that much control over me. Ok, sure they're tiny, but they're damn tasty. And since a single order gets you around a dozen of these bad boys, you should be good with just that - even though I usually get double orders anyway. What puts this location over the other ones are their cheddar chips - waffle fries with Cheese Whiz-ish sauce dumped on top. So delicious, provided you finish them off before the cheese morphs back into its semi-solid state. Never had anything else from here - I'm good with my suicide wings, thanks.
(5)Ed L.
My friends had nothing but great things to say about this place so i had to go check it out with them. Needless to say I left wanting to come back more and more often and thinking about the years wasted not coming here. My friends say that they raised the prices but a double order of wings and two orders of fries only cost about $20.02 with tax. Which isn't bad if you split it with someone. The waffle fries are crispy and tasty but to be honest next time i come here I'm getting a double order for myself. I love that they can mix sauces together and the spicy barbecue is the way to go in my opinion. The sauce makes my mouth water every time i think about it and adding jalapenos to the wings is icing to the cake. You will definitely be visited by me more than once in the coming month and if your in the Evanston neighborhood i would definitely consider checking them out.
(5)Hannah P.
My mouth is watering waiting for our order. I worked out just so I can pig out today! Suicide Please.
(4)Danny W.
A meal of a single order, cheddar chips and a mega-gut RC is now $13.65. What happened to you Buff Joe's? You used to be so beautiful.
(1)Tom M.
My favorite spot to grab some wings. I take a detour into downtown Evanston or hit the one on Green Bay if I'm craving Rib Tips every so often to get my fix. When I lived in Evanston, this was a regular stop for me. Now that I'm farther away, my times between visits has lengthened which my doctor appreciates. I highly recommend!
(5)Danny B.
In my opinion, these are the best wings in the world.... ** IF YOU ARE NOT A BONE-IN WING LOVER, THIS MAY NOT BE YOUR PLACE!!** But for the rest of us who have a wing obsession and could care less about the decor this place is highly recommended!!
(4)Christine N.
Oh, Buff Joes. You are so conveniently located across the street from my college condo, tempting me everyday as I pass by to go to class, walk to downtown evanston, go visit a friend, walk to work... You haven't failed... Yet. I have this disgusting fear that one day I'll walk in, and it just won't be that good. Unfortunately, the wings have indeed gotten smaller since my first taste. But I must go on with the wonders of this wing. It's fried. It's not good for you. But oh... It's good. Something this good can't be THAT bad, can it? Ok fine. These chicken wings are not just fried. They are crispy. CRISPY, I tell you. Take a bite and CRUNCH! And then you get chicken. This is the disappointing part. I wish the chicken was more succulent inside, but it can't be when the wings are small. The sauce. Yum. We get spicy and it's the perfect amount of heat. Not a fan of the excess sauce on the bottom with the last few wings that are swimming in the sauce. And the celery sticks are usually warm. But I still am loyal to you, Buff Joes. I will always eat you because you are just that good. Also, the suicide wings are basically just the spicy flavor with jalapeños added. Skip the suicide. Take taste over heat. Word.
(4)Elliott C.
attention buffalo joe's on clark street......please clean up that disgusting men bathroom and hire friendlier ppl to work there WHO VALUE CUSTOMER SERVICE. i can no longer take Lacresha and them attitude. First bad experience on November 3rd 2013 p.s. the wing are still the best!
(3)Leonard P.
the chicken was delicious. I love coming here with friends and family. big fan of waffle fries and it hit's the spot when it comes to craving for chicken. the littel down side is how they don't accept card. Other than that, the food is fine and the atmostphere is pretty chill.
(4)Ashley C.
We made the trip up here for the buffalo wings and because of the 4 stars on yelp. Disappointment to say the least. It started from the phone call to see what there hours were on the 4th of July. The girl picked up the phone and with attitude says, "the usual hours we're open." When had to ask what those were, she replied with the time after uttering an "uhhhh." That got me off to a really bad start. So we tried the buffalo wings (spicy), the burger, and the cheese fries. Cheese fries were average. The burger was average. The patty itself was good, but the toppings were average and didn't taste super fresh. The buffalo wings - average. I would have liked them crispier - the sauce was decent. Oh yes -and they had RC as their pop. As a diet coke/pepsi addict, this just did not quench my thirst on the blistering hot day. Average food + employees with attitude + drive to Evanston = not worth the trip.
(2)Stephanie C.
Best wing place ever! My uncle had introduced me to this hole on the wall. It's not a super clean place. However the food is amazing. I love boned in wings and the flavors for the wings are perfectly seasoned. I love the mild wings the best. I cannot rave about this place enough..
(5)Bethany A.
If you're looking for classic wings with classic sides, this place is the best. Their wings come out piping hot, lightly fried, and doused in just enough sauce. The sauce is tangy and spicy (or not, you have options) and it's seriously finger-licking good. I love munching on some celery sticks on the side and their waffle fries are pretty good as well. It's an awesome place to come with friends (order the party platter and dig in!). Yum, so glad that it's near campus.
(4)Al D.
While I love the wings, cheddar burger with its creamy cheddar spread, plus the waffle fries, that's about it on the love for this Buffalo Joe's. I recently had some of their spicy chicken fingers, and they were nearly inedible. The chicken tasted spongy and off, and the breading was akin to rubber. Also on my last visit, I had their famous cheddar burger, but with grilled onions. Bad mistake. About 3/4 lb of undercooked, thick, white onions slid off the burger in a huge pool of grease; nasty. I think most of the five-star reviews are based on nostalgia. Buffalo Joe's is looking old, dirty and worn-out now. I'd maybe go here again for wings, but that's about it.
(3)Derek D.
I have talked about merkts cheddar before and this place does it RIGHT! WINGS : Amazing every time with a good sauce to wing ratio. un-breaded as well - CRUCIAL. I love the vinegar and butter mild sauce. never had the guts to go hotter. Fries. Well done Buff Chips are the way to go. The cheese is best if you order 2 so you can dip Every fry with JUST enough of it. LOVE YOU BUFF JOES! d
(5)Jeff W.
There's only one place I'll ever go for wings anymore and that's Buff Joe's. I grew up in Evanston and having been coming to Buff Joe's since I was in high school. After college, I took a job that involved significant travel across the country. There is no place in the country like Buff Joe's. You'll see numerous awards on the walls from different cooking events they've won - their sauce just can't be beat. My favorite burger of all time is actually from Buff Joe's. It's called the Buffalo Cheddar Burger and has a grilled patty with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato, Merkt's cheddar, and then Buff Joe's wing sauce - whichever hotness you desire. It's AMAZING! No place has come close to replicating such an amazing creation. Some negatives are that they only take cash (not even debit card) and the place is located in downtown Evanston and parking is usually pretty difficult to find. While there are tables, there are very few so I suggest getting it to go and bringing it home.
(5)Sevun H.
The wings and waffle fries were just as good as they were when I was a student and used to eat Buffalo Joes 4 days out of the week! The two girls who greeted me when I walked in were another story all together. They both had very nasty attitudes and seemed to be very unhappy with their jobs. One seemed much more interested in telling her co-worker about her previous nights Hennessy drinking exploits than providing anything remotely resembling customer service. Being eyeballed from head to toe by two immature, insecure, unprofessional employees is not welcome when I am spending my hard earned dollars on overpriced wings and fries. Will not be back. I will just cherish my memories of Buffalo Joes when the service was just as good as the food!
(2)Mary M.
Always an Evanston favorite. I'm not a huge "chicken on the bone" kind of person, but this place brings wings to a whole new level. If you like spicy...even just a little bit, you have to get the hot or suicide wings. Cheddar chips are a must! Not to mention, the ranch dressing you get with the wings is hands down my favorite.
(5)Viki N.
When you're feeling low, or lost in life, don't turn to Jesus, turn to Buffalo Joe's! (At least that's what I do.) I have been addicted to Buffalo Joe's for over 15 years. No matter how much I try to forget them, the taste of their wings keeps coming back up in my mind, and I am compelled to make the pilgrimage to Evanston once again. My personal drug of choice here is a single order of suicide wings, spicy cheddar chips, and 2 extra orders of celery and ranch. Nothing can make me happier, and nobody's wings come close to having as much flavor as Buffalo Joe's. (and I've tried, a lot, to find someone even half as good so I don't have to drive all the way up to Evanston again. But no such luck.) So, I recommend stuffing yourself full of wings, and then catching a movie at the movie theatre down the street, or at one of the film festivals they have at Northwestern. Happiness coming into every orifice!
(5)Julia J.
I've only eaten take out of Buffalo Joes, and I wasn't the one who picked up the food, so I can't speak to the service or condition of the restaurant itself. The wings, though, were delicious- not the largest wings, but certainly not the smallest either. The sauce was really good. I was full from the smallest order. We also ordered the Spicy Cheddar Chips, which were messy and horrible for you, so they were pretty much one of the most delicious concoctions I've ever had.
(3)Mike T.
Not impressed with this place at all... The wings are so so at best and the staff is always cranky. This is a good place for college kids that have a limited pallet, or are to drunk to know what they are eating is sub par.
(2)Kareem A.
Place is a mess... ghetto service, thought they're gonna kick me in the face if I ordered one more thing. Their 'boneless wings' are basically chicken tenders refried just to be warm when served. The BBQ sauce is so average I wasn't sure why the place is so famous.. Maybe because it's by NU in the middle of downtown Evanston, who knows? Give them a try, you might have a different opinion.
(2)Brian K.
FAMOUS FOR: - Buffalo Wings (8/10) Ah BJ's. My education in Buffalo Wings. Brings back great memories, because just about every party and get together in jr. high and high school (when hanging with my North Burbs friends) involved a double party platter of Suicide wings. It was also a much more innocent time where someone would mention BJ's, and instantly, everybody's ears would perk up, eyes would widen, a giggle would pursue, and then everyone was thinking the same thing...mmmm Buffalo Joe's. It also brings back 1 painful memory. They once had a limited time sauce called "XXX" which, after 4 wings, made me cry, drool, and drip from my nose. I downed an entire jug of Ocean Spray Ruby Red juice. It probably wasn't the best thing, but it was college and that was the only thing I had. Yeah...let's not do that again. THE WINGS The only way I ever have them is Suicide. It's not that spicy. Ok, I know this is coming from a Korean guy who's done a ghost chili wing challenge, but still... Put it this way, it's not anywhere near Mango Habanero at BW3 and not even as hot as Three Mile Island at Hooters. Not sure what else to compare it to. It comes with pickled jalapeno slices all over the top, but even those aren't that bad. I usually don't even break a sweat. They're very small wings, about than the length of a grown man's pinky. They're not battered, but do have a crispy skin (at least around the edges). It's drenched in a traditional buffalo type sauce, but it's their secret recipe. "Traditional" meaning that it's kinda like the Louisana hot sauce. You know, kinda salty, with a small kick. In my High School days, I couldn't get enough of these wings! I'd give them 5 stars everyday! Then now, in my post college days, these guys are hit 'n' miss, almost exactly 50/50. Sometimes I go, and I get my single order of suicide wings and fries, and they're just "pretty good." Sometimes I go, and all the lights go on and the choir sings and I'm basking in nostalgia and it just tastes so damn good! That's why I can only give it 8 stars, because it's not consistent. I've only been there maybe 5 times since college (I'd run outta fingers and toes trying to count between HS & College), so I don't know if I'm just changing or my mood affects the taste (although I don't recall ever being in any different moods), or what. It's just not consistent for me. ALL IN ALL I would never pass up an opportunity for BJ's. It's very rare that I'm ever in Evanston, so if we get the chance, it's always BJ's. Oh yeah...CASH ONLY! Even if you're buying hundreds of dollars of double party platters....It's CASH ONLY!
(4)Matthew B.
Best buffalo wings on north shore and maybe in Chicago.
(5)Amir L.
I've been going here for over 15 years and it's one of the staples that started my obsession with wings!! Gotta rock the cheddar chip all day with the gut RC !!
(5)Nishan P.
Not everyone will love Buffalo Joe's. If you don't like sucking on bones, if you don't like the texture of skin, if you can't handle messy; Buffalo Joe's might not be for you. If these things don't bother you, you'll probably find Buffalo Joe's quite delightful. I know other reviewers have called Buffalo Joe's "filthy", "embarrassing" and "disgusting" but I have always been extremely satisfied. If you're not sure whether you would like Buffalo Joe's and need someone to try it out with, give me a holler. I am always up for Buffalo Joe's.
(4)Luke S.
Their wings are good - close to real good. Their waffle fries are good - also close to real good. Their service is typically horrific and it's really expensive for what you get.
(3)An P.
Famed and acclaimed, Buffalo Joe's is an anchor in Evanston and a primary contributor to the Northwestern freshman 15. You'll hear tales of its wonder and glory from all over but sometimes you just have to see it to believe it. I've made a few trips to Buffalo Joe's over the years and never counted it as a legendary wing....until now. On the latest edition of Get Yo Wing On, I waited in line and a brilliant idea came to my head, what if I ordered Buffalo Joe's wings extra well done?! Extra well done? Hell yes they made me a batch!!! The wait is comedic, you'll see people running off with their score with trays filled to the brim with wings, cheddar waffle fries, and the All-American celery with batches of ranch and bleu cheese. Lacking the glitz and glamour of fancier trappings, you'll find Buffalo Joe's with the charm of any greasy spoon you'll find across America sprinkled with a tinge of intoxicating wing aroma. The concept is simple: freshly cooked wings laced with some of the best wing sauces you'll find in the city. Wings come in mild, spicy, BBQ, and if they like you they'll make some spicy BBQ. More spice-addicted souls can try their suicide wings laced with jalapenos but your ears might be left blowing out billows of smoke! These wings are lilliputian in stature but what they lack in size they compensate with volume and honest to goodness flavor. I've always found the wing sauce exceptionally delicious with a little extra kick to leave your mouth watering but veritably, I find myself a texture freak. I love texture on my food so when I got my wings extra well done and brought it back to the table my eyes lit up. The first bite was the best bite as I finally figured out the puzzle and unlocked the greatness of Buffalo Joe's at last. Extra well done means extra tasty crispy to the beat of my drum. You're going to find yourself wanting to come back for another visit to this Evanston wingery, and you just have to figure out what wing is best for you, but don't let me be the judge - take a bite out that for yourself!
(5)Albert M.
Omg! Just left this place with two of my friends, absolutely disgusting! Decor was a mess, a hooters demolished! Just weird! I wouldn't recommend this place to my worst enemy!
(1)Robert G.
Obsessed. I love the fact that a restaurant can do business the same way for 20 years and still have a huge fan base. Want a coke or diet coke? Too bad. We only have RC Cola. Want to pay with plastic? Sorry, cash only. Obviously, Buffalo Joe's is doing something right, because they continue to crank out amazing, delicious, greasy, fantastic food. The house made sauces were incredible. Mild sauce was just the perfect amount of heat with that signature Buffalo buttery-ness. I had the chicken tenders: cooked PERFECTLY! Crisp and crunchy on the outside, juicy and tender on the inside. Waffle cut fries and a Diet Rite rounded out the meal. My friends tried out some of the various chicken sandwiches, which looked phenomenal (and the general consensus was that they were). This is most definitely an Evanston institution, and you would be remiss if you didn't stop by when in town.
(4)Gaby C.
Maybe its just me, but i've eaten here 5 times in two weeks. The wings are the best ever!!! I love love love the wings here. The sauces (hot or mild) are just right, not too spicy not to sweet not too tangy, just riight. They have a few locations in Evanston, but I like the one on Clark.
(5)Jennifer E.
Oh my chicken wing goodness! I got the double order of hot wings plus waffle fries and it was sooooo good and sooooo cheap. I wish I live closer to one of the locations! Dear Buffalo Joe's owner - please open more locations in Chicago (preferably in the Lincoln Square neighborhood)
(5)Phill C.
Oh boy, what else can I say other than "double sui with waffle cheese fries please". Back in the good old days, me and my highschool buddies would all pitch in for a double suicide party pan with lots of ranch. Just thinking about the food makes my mouth water as I type. The roughest part is standing to the side, waiting for your order. Just watching them make the wings, while you stand there is pure torture. They have such unique and of course delicious wings. Deep fried crispy in what looks like no batter or breading at all, then swirled around in large bowl containing a combination of buttery hot sauce. Crispy but not crunchy chicken wings with a unique butter hot sauce... and I always get the suicide loaded with jalapenos. One of my favorite places for wings.
(4)Fletcher G.
I hate to be a nay sayer but Buffalo Joes didn't hold up to all of the "glorious" reviews. You end up paying a bit more then Buffalo Wild Wings prices but far less then Buffalo Wild Wings quality. I was extremely disappointed in this place!
(2)Adam K.
Another local haunt I have been frequenting since before I could legally drink and had to resort to getting loaded on drinking the hookah water at the hookah bar down the street. I think all the negative reviews from long time patrons are telling in that they mention all the good things about this place in great detail but then say the bad in one sentence. And then they go on to say that they will be back. Sure this place is flawed, hell, this place may not be the best for wings anymore, but it is an institution. A buffalo university. When you graduate from it, you will cast aside the wing stop Pizza Hut wings with a scornful smirk and declare, "I HAVE EATEN AT BUFF JOES! THESE ARE NOT WINGS!" I always have and always will get: Double order of Suicide - Spicy, what can I say other than I got a party platter of the spicy wing awesomeness once for the superbowl, one of my idiot friends liked it so much he decided to drink the concentrated hot spicy suicide wing sauce that had congealed jalapenos in it, and then had a fiery colon for 3 days. Do not attempt to drink a full cup of the sauce. But do get the suicide and Double order of BBQ - Oh man, so sweet and delish, these really compliment the spicy, and because of my Indian upbringing, I am partial to the spicy but these will always hold a special place in my heart, cuz they are loaded with cholesterol and will probably be either removed by a robot doctor or kill me. Waffle Fries w Cheddar - another artery bomb, but so good in so many ways, there is not enough room on the internet to describe my love for these particular waffle cheese fries. Just try them. They also have beer which is a newer thing, I have not gotten any here. They have a pretty large seating area in the back with TV's so you can watch whatever games are going on, the ordering process is a bit apprehensive as you have to explain and re explain what you want to the surly, young, often but not always african american youngsters who look upon you with disdain. Then after about 20 minutes, you give CASH ONLY to the fat white dude manning the register with very little patience for small talk. Just go here. The experience outweighs the negative feelings you get when your cardiac surgeon looks up at you from the top of his glasses.
(4)Jason S.
Buffalo Joe's is pretty crappy. I ordered a single order of wings with spicy wing sauce and waffle fries. My sister ordered a chili cheese dog. Our beverage consisted of RC Cola (on tap). The wings must come from dead baby chicks because they contained almost no meat. The sauce wasn't bad, but the comparable sauce from Buffalo Wild Wings or Hooters tastes better. That being said, I can't find any fault with the fries. They were delicious. The pop however was a travesty, as they did not offer free refills. That is borderline un-American (or at they least cheap as hell). The chili cheese dog appeared to contain Kraft singles for the cheese and the chili had beans (gross). A friend had the charburger with bacon, cheese and wing sauce. It was pretty good, but make sure to ask for spicy sauce instead of mild. Overall, I didn't want to kill myself after eating at Buffalo Joe's, but I certainly can't recommend the place.
(2)Matt A.
giving this place anything less than 5 stars is a joke, seriously. if you want a big chunk of chicken or some hormone feed bird with giant wings goto wingstop or some other joke of a place. Chicken wings are supposed to be small - i.e. NOT have a 1lb of meat on them. This is the perfect wing and the suicide is the only way to go. i've tried them all - bw3, wingstop, wingshack whatever - NOTHING compared to Buffalo joes. worth the trip to e-Town all day.
(5)Art V.
As I've enjoyed dining at this establishment for years, it pains me to post this negative review. Buff Joes has long offered tournament-quality buffalo wings despite (1) questionable sanitation practices, (2) aloof employees, and (3) a dynamic pricing scheme. Generally, the men's bathroom is under-equipped and shockingly dirty. More often than not, the paper towel dispenser is empty and the only urinal is jammed to the brim with ice. That door handle has enough grease on it to keep a 1000 ships' engines humming along nicely. Things aren't much better in the kitchen where latex gloves are treated like commas in a David Foster Wallace piece: used occasionally but only when damn well justified. Regarding the employees, I've long suspected that the ability to appear utterly disengaged while conversing with customers is a prerequisite to getting hired. It also helps if you can act as if there is literally no task you would enjoy less than mixing pre-cooked wings in a metallic bowl full of buffalo sauce. As a rule, I'm hesitant to generalize and disparage the entire crew. The cashier is usually pretty pleasant and I've actually had some appropriate interactions with the ladies up front of late. However, given the frequency with which I've experienced sub-par customer service over the years, I'd be entirely remiss not to mention this issue in a review. Although I rarely deviate from my standard order (a single basket of spicy wings, extra ranch, and a mega-gut RC Cola), the price I pay each time tends to wildly fluctuate. The value of wings must be inexplicably linked to some mysterious economic indicator. I forked over $12.01 for my standard order last night. While this price actually appears pretty competitive with that of similar outfits (i.e. Buffalo Wild Wings), it's far removed from the less than ten dollars the restaurant charged just a few years back. Despite the above, I happily made the not-insubstantial trek to Evanston to feast on Buffalo Joe's delicious wings for years. Up until quite recently, the restaurant had some of the best wings in Chicagoland. The chicken was always perfectly cooked: crisp on the outside, juicy on the inside. The sauce was and still is, "to die for." However, my last two visits have been underwhelming. The employees seem to be overcooking the chicken these days. Additionally, the wings are now embarrassingly small. I'm comfortable wagering that they are at least 50% tinier than their counterparts at Buffalo Wild Wings and Gators. While I will likely return to Buff Joes within the next month out of habit, I can promise you I won't be thrilled about it. Patronizing this establishment is like watching a washed-up, former all-star at the plate; evidence of greatness lingers, but he's still probably going to strike out.
(1)Leo S.
Pretty good wing place, but the wings,themselves, are tiny. The suicide sauce is good, but it's not that spicy. It's more acidic than anything else because of the preserved jalapeños. The waffle fries was delicious. The burgers were also not bad. Everything is also reasonably priced, but they only accept cash which I dislike a lot.
(4)Courtney W.
This place is good for one thing, wings. You'll have to order a lot though, more than you think you need, because there isn't much on these bones. The sauces are pretty tasty too but the classic is pretty hot for me. There isn't much to the inside of this place and the service isn't the best but that's not what they're known for anyways. I don't go to Northwestern but from friends, I understand that this place is a staple. They put plenty of sauce on these bad boys though so you won't have to order extra. The wings come with celery too and plenty of blue cheese and ranch sauce. I can see why this place is so famous and as a foodie, I understand the hype. I just hope this place never plays too much into, no frills and good wings is what this place does best.
(4)Cecil S.
The most delicious wings I've had in a long time, definitely beats B-dubs hands down. Go here with an appetite, try their spicy wings. Includes some celery and ranch as well, in case things get too hot! Looks like they only had Miller or Bud Light on tap, eat-in area is kind of small/cramped with local Northwestern students.
(4)Kim D.
i like your bbq wings and your merkts cheddar waffle fries. they r so good. cash only and dont you forget it.
(4)Jay N.
I've been here several times and parking can be found on Benson Avenue to the west near the el. I went again last Saturday before the Ohio State game and was surprised to see that it wasn't that busy. As soon as you walk in, you put in your order and once it's ready, they'll put it on a tray (or in a sack if it's to-go) and you'll get your receipt. You pay after you get your food. There's a decent amount of seats in the back but it can get a little crowded. It's pretty limited in decor with framed posters about food or hot peppers. There's 1 tv in the back. The wings come in 4 flavors - mild, spicy, suicide, and bbq. I usually go with the spicy as it has the right amount of kick. They add on the celery sticks and ranch sauce with the order. I really like their waffle fries here. The wing sizes are decent again. They were pretty small for a while and now seem to be a good combination of meaty, crispness, and sauce flavor retention. There are only really 2 order sizes - single and double order. I usually get the double order as I can munch on some and then save some for later. Next sizes up are party trays for 8 or 15 people. Overall, it was a very good experience to come back here again.
(4)Sebastian Y.
Warning: The tiny wings at Buff Joe's are extremely addictive. Another Warning: Cheddar chips are waffle fries with way too much cheddar cheese lopped on top. Last Warning: The Suicide sauce is hot. 4 stars for the wings. 2 stars for the cheddar chips. I'll give Buff Joe's a 4.
(4)Sonia B.
If you are looking for some amazing wings, Buffalo Joes is the place to go! I've been going to Buffalo Joes for 15 years and I can still say that they, hands down, have the best wings in the Chicago-land area. Their sauce is definitely what makes the wings and it doesn't taste like only tobasco...like most other establishments. Mild, spicy or suicide are the levels of heat and you can order a single order, double order or a party pan if you're really hungry! I love to pair their wings with the buffalo chips or cheddar chips and a gutbuster (medium) lemonade or pop. Yes, pop...not soda! :) I like my wings a little crispy, so I order mine well done. Buffalo Joes is definitely a comfort food and I probably go once a week! :) They have many other items on the menu, but I can't say I have EVER tried anything else there. It just seems wrong. However, it is great that they have other options...which look yummy...in case you are with people who don't like wings. Although, I have NEVER met a person who doesn't LOVE Buffalo Joes! Even people who don't like wings end up loving Buffalo Joes! Buffalo Joes has a couple of locations, but the one in Evanston is the best. It does get crowded, especially when Northwestern has a game - but seats open up pretty quickly on a normal night. The only downside of the place is that it is cash only. So, make sure you come prepared. Your belly will definitely leave happy! :)
(5)Julie K.
I'm 5 months pregnant and I've been craving wings. We live in Chicago on division, tons of bars and they sell wings too, but nothing compared to Buffalo Joes. Not the cleanest place but it is definitely worth the trip to Evanston for their wings. It truly is finger lickin good.
(5)Eileen Z.
My favorite wings in Chicagoland. I've been hitting up this Clark location since high school. When I'm out of town, I dream of these wings. IT'S THE WING SAUCE. It's different from any other wing sauce I've had. BE PREPARED FOR GREASE. Buff Joe's wings swim in it and it's delicious. I love the suicide wings which are tossed with jalapenos, but I actually enjoy ordering the mild sauce more often because you can really taste the sauce. I find most people like to order the spicy, which isn't all that spicy to begin with. That's the three degrees of hot: suicide, spicy, and mild. No extras, just as simple as that. 12 years ago I may have given them 5 stars. But if I had to complain about anything about Buff Joe's it would be their wings have gotten much smaller over the years and that they only have a small coating of the sauce over the wings... much less than they used to. But I've found that this is the way I like ordering: - a double order mild with extra wing sauce (this already comes with ranch and celery) - buff chips (waffle fries) with cheese - large RC or grape soda The cheese they use with the buff chips seems to be a hit or miss with people I know since it's more of a cheez whiz type of cheese, but it goes beautifully with all the greasy goodness of the wings AND I LOVE IT. Even their ranch doesn't seem like a ranch I could just go buy at the grocery store. In fact, you can purchase pints of both their ranch sauce and special Buff Joe's wing sauce by themselves. This is nice for your at-home cooking experiments. In the past you were able to order the jugs, but they have put a stop to that. I haven't tried much else on their menu. The burgers are nothing special aside from the Buff Joe's sauce, but the buns they use suck and fall apart easily. The corn on the cob and broccoli cheddar soup are pretty good, too. But the only thing I keep running back for are the wings. Buff Joe's is cash only, but they finally put in an ATM a few years ago so if you forget to grab cash ahead of time it won't be a problem. The place is small and gets pretty packed, especially on nights and weekends since it's only a hop skip and a jump away from the Northwestern University campus. This is one of those hole-in-the-wall kinda gems. I've always wished they'd expand past Evanston, but the owner has said he never plans on it. Oh well. It's worth the trip anyway.
(4)J J.
I used to travel for business quite a bit. I've been to basically 3/4 of the U.S. and my modus operandi was basically to hit up a wing joint anytime I could. After going to Buff Joes since I was a teen and experiencing the best wings you could only be disappointed going anywhere else which is exactly what happened to me. There is no comparison. Buff Joes hands down has the best sauce. If they put it in a cup I would drink it through a straw. And when there was not enough wing sauce to suck up through the straw I would tip the cup over and tap the bottom until every drop of sauce made it's way out of the cup. The same applies to their ranch dressing. It perfectly compliments their wing sauce. I can't say much about any of their other food as I've only eaten wings and celery here. The ONLY thing I can complain about is the size of their wings as I'm absolutely positive that they are smaller than they used to be. I'm not going crazy. Someone please agree with me. Don't bother wasting your time going anywhere else if you've experienced Buff Joes. You'll only be disappointed.
(5)Patrick S.
Probably the closest yet I have come to what I would imagine they intended buffalo wings to be. Buff Joes has to be on my top...3 of wings destinations. I was intro-ed to said wings several years ago in my high school years. I still feel like Im cutting class when I sit down to eat over there. So anywho..why I am writing a review now? Because I have never attempted to tackle a party platter in one sitting....till now. I speak of the $40 platter thats supposed to serve 8-12 people I believe? I have no idea what possessed my friends and I (yes! grammar skills) to attempt to tackle such a feat. Let me just clarify I speak of 4 people for this platter of glory. This stint of gluttony was the brain child of pure spontaneity and opportunity. 4 people, $40...how could you go wrong?? About 45minutes later..me and my partner in crime inhaled about low-mid 30s each. The 2 others wimped out and had about 10-15 each. A late comer came into the equation contributing another 10-15. In the conclusion of this session of man v food..... Food came out victorious...there was about 12 wings left. Think about that for a sec..that is a massive amount of wings! And let me tell you..grease, and spice.......youre just asking for it. A dastardly duo of disaster; definitely! They device a fiendish evac. Regardless of what is left on the plate after any gluttony bout...trust me, FOOD ALWAYS COME OUT ON TOP.
(5)David C.
Some wings are really good, some are even incredible. Buff Joes is heaven. Yes, they raised their prices a lot. Yes, their wings are slightly smaller. Yes, they are more inconsistent than normal wings places. But really, you can't top that sauce and those waffle fries. I would probably be willing to get in the ring with Floyd Mayweather and get knocked in 10 seconds just to have a double order of suicide with some waffle fries and a large RC Cola. If you go to Buffalo Wild Wings, I can't speak to your taste buds (they are obviously very unrefined). I did really like Wings Over, but they are definitely a different type of wing, basically chicken fingers with sauce. Overall, best restaurant in Evanston bar none. James, who usually works the cashier, is the man, and some of my best college memories are at Buff Joes. I've never tried crack, but i'm assuming it tastes something like buff joes wings (and its probably healthier).
(5)Frank A.
Party pans! Haven't had B.J.'s in a year! Still hasn't changed. Still the best. Eaten til cardiac arrest! - Haha. I made a rhyme! See the Party Pan pix! They'll make you want some!
(5)Mikhail D.
I've been coming to Buff Joes since I was 8 year old. FIRST OFF: Yes, this is down right unhealthy, greasy, fattening food. But sober or not, I always leave this place completely satisfied and it's my first meal everytime I come home. And you're a sinner if you're not getting cheddar chips!
(5)Eugene M.
In 1996 or so, when I was in that most miserable of summers between 7th and 8th grade, I attended Sports Camp in Wilmette, IL. (Sports Camp is camp for children who are so bad at sports that it doesn't even matter which one they try to play on any given day.) At sports camp, I had a counselor named Dave, and Dave happened to be A Very Cool Guy because when our troop slept over at his house, we could play Waverace 64 until 4 AM and then watch Faces of Death. Having that kind of night makes you feel pretty cool yourself. Anyway, while at Dave's house that fateful night, I saw huge container that I thought was reserved for things like laundry detergent or motor oil, and the label on it read "Buffalo Joe's Suicide." Having just watched a bunch of Faces of Death, I didn't even want to think of what that stuff was, but Dave assured me that it was just wing sauce. A lot of wing sauce. At that time, I'd never even had a buffalo wing, but I'll always remember that huge plastic vat. Flash forward 8 years. I'm at Buffalo Joe's for the first time, face-to-face with one of those vats, the memories rushing back at me. I'd only had buffalo wings a few times, and I didn't particularly care for them. Nevertheless, my buddies swore by this place and what the hell else are you going to do on a Tuesday in your first summer with a driver's license? Double order of spicy barbecue wings, cheddar chips, and a Gutbuster root beer. I had seen the face of God. The wings were perfectly crispy, and the sauce was buttery, delicious goo. The cheddar chips, a perfect complement with their tangy sharp cheddar melted until it just barely retains some texture. Words don't really serve that sublime moment. I just knew that I found my calling. Flash forward another 10 years. I don't even like wings. I think they mostly suck. I don't eat much "unhealthy" food. But if I'm in Chicago, or even Milwaukee or Indiana or Iowa City or wherever, I go to Buffalo Joe's. Consistency has taken a dip, yes, but...BuJo's is not just "my" place. BuJo's is America. The huddled, poor, teeming masses yearning to eat wings, waiting in line for their taste of suicide or double mild or even a burger. Young kids, old dudes, foreigners, whoever, They're all here. They're all waiting for wings. BuffJoe's has opened its doors.
(5)Stephen C.
This place is a Northwestern institution, or so I'm told. The decor hasn't changed in 20 or so years and the owner is the same. It feels like a generic place from the early 80s -- clean but utilitarian -- though the flat screen TVs help. Long counter in the front to order and pick up food and then tables in the next room. The wings were tasty -- messy but that's what buffalo wings should be. We got hot but I heard the suicide are not too bad either so I'm hoping to get those next time. People swear also by the cheese fries but the cheese was so processed that i found them a little gross. But the wings. Yum!
(4)Lisa H.
I have been coming here for a couple of years now. This place is a little old, have nasty employees, filthy bathrooms, and sometimes smell. Their tables are always dirty and sticky, it seems like they never would wipe them down. But the chicken wings are one of the best wings I have ever eaten. They may be small, but you get a lot with one order. The spicy or suicide sauce drenched on these wings are to die for!! It also comes with celery and ranch (always need an extra one because they give you so little). Get the waffles fries to compliment your order and you'll be all set for a delicious meal.
(5)Mark T.
Go figure, I go to a restaurant that specializes in wings...and I order a burger. What is wrong with me?? A group of friends invited me out on a weekday to hang out, and they suggested this place. I didn't feel like chicken that night (wait a minute, wasn't that a jingle from a commercial from the 1980s?) so I ended up getting a Cheddar Char burger off the menu. The burger itself tasted pretty standard, nothing spectacular. However, the waffle fried were de-lish. Maybe I should have just had a single order of fries...that would have been an adequate meal. Beware, this place takes cash only; luckily I had exactly $7 in my wallet to pay for my meal. Overall, the place serves pretty good food for a pretty cheap price. You can't ask for anything more. My dinner companions all ordered the wings and loved them. I did take a look at their plates and noticed the small size of them; eventually when I come back to actually try their wings I'd have to make a note to get a double order.
(3)Ted C.
Small. That's what comes to mind now when I came here on a recent visit. BuJoe's used to be a staple of my adolescence. Splitting a party pan of 'Suicide' where it was so hot it looked like my friends and I had spent the day at the pool. A huge cup 'Gutbuster' size lemonade to wash it down and a tray of celery and ranch-you know for the healthy part of the meal. The wings now are small-just so tiny that it made me want to cry a little over the now former memories of big wings/drummettes that used to be the calling card here along with the 'Suicide' sauce which was so hot but now seems a little tame by comparison-maybe my taste buds are dying off in my old age but I think they are just using a weaker hot sauce. RIP Buffalo Joe, you're not what you used to be. I'll miss you.
(2)AJ K.
I can't say anything here that hasn't already been said. I just want to lend my enthusiastic support. Been going here 12 years, from high school to having them cater my best friend's baby shower. I love it here.
(5)Jonathan C.
Just take your $25 that you would spend on wing fest..... come here..... buy a huge tray of wings and enjoy. I personally will only order Suicide. Yup call me crazy, but extra hot sauce with Jalepenos on top and then more hot sauce just makes me happy. But I want something more than wings and celery says the imaginary voice in my belly. So I shut him up with some cheese smothered waffle fries. Well even though its 9am and I'm not hungry... I really want some now.
(5)Nichole F.
I consider wings one of my very favorite foods so the first time I had wings at Buffalo Joe's, I was a very happy girl! Their wings are among the best that I have ever had. The waffle fries are great too!
(5)Bobby C.
Best wings I've had hands down. Get a single of spicy wings (or suicide if you want them to double the sauce and drown in jalepenos) and a side of buffalo cheddar chips with a mega RC cola and prepare to get your face messy! The sauce is just absolutely criminal. Second to none. I've heard the burgers and sandwiches are great too but the wings are so good I've never gone astray. Is usually pretty busy and cash only. If you are ordering on Sunday during football season call your order in to avoid the wait. Got a lot of friends and family in Evanston so I'm in town every couple of months. I always try to get to Buff Joe's when I'm in town and you should too!
(5)Eric V.
Best Wings in the entire world!!!! Single Suicide w/ Cheddar Chip and a mega RC has been my order since 1998. Eric Vawda
(5)Cathy B.
wings = MUST GET SUICIDE IF YOU CAN HANDLE IT. DELICIOUS SAUCINESS. CHEESE WAFFLE FRIES = BEST THING EVERRRRRRR! Cheese waffles fries is more awesome than the Wings. Haven't tried anything besides the wings and cheese fries, but once you try the cheese fries, you don't need to try anything else. PERIOD. The people behind the counter look scary and intimidating but don't be fooled, they're actually kinda nice....
(4)justin m.
I really dont get it - almost to the point of loosing sleep. I can easily look past the dismal service, 30 min wait (for wings), crappy napkins & flat soda - I don't expect anything different. However, the wings (aka fried bones w/ skin and hot sauce) were horrible! I've had frog legs... hell frog arms with more meat! But all is not lost. The sauce was simply amazing, all I want is some chicken to accompany it. Hopefully they will see this and the other reviews of skimpy wings and step their game up.
(2)Tim S.
Here's how I look at wings: it starts with the sauce, but it ends with the meat. Their sauces are pretty legit; I went spicy and bbq in my first go around. Both were great. My biggest complaint was the level of meatiness they have on their wings. I think I saw an earlier review that referenced 'dead baby chicks', and - while a bit too descriptive - you get the point. You eat these wings to transport their sauce. The sauce is good, but it's not to the point where I don't want get full in the process. To their credit, they give you a TON of these tiny wings, so it's not like you get a half dozen or a dozen in an order. You get a ton in the order. This get's them to three stars. Their fries would have gotten them another half star if Yelp would allow it.
(3)Danielle J.
Yummy wings & great customer service! I get wings here from time to time and had an issue with my last order. Dean was so nice, friendly and helpful and he rectified the problem for me. The sauce is addictive. I always get mild becuz I'm not a lover of all things spicy, but the have a twinge of heat which is fine for me. Will definitely be back soon!
(5)Susan F.
I love wings, I really do. I'll try any flavor, from sweet to spicy. I'll try them bone-in, boneless, stripped, naked, whatevs, I'm down. An afternoon in Evanston called from some Buff Jo action. I had actually never heard of the place, but I felt that wings were the perfect cure to my hangover, and a cure for just any old regular day anyways. But, I ended up getting a tuna sandwich, while my friends got a big order of wings I could suck off of. I'm actually glad I got the 'wich...I'll tell you why: #1. The service was awful. They didn't even know what a tuna salad sandwich was (and it's been on their menu for what I can assume is for YEARS). I had to repeat myself several times, and even while they were making my sandwich, half of them didn't even know it was on the menu. That being said, it was very fresh and didn't taste fattening at all. Win! #2. Now, for the wings. I have never seen so much wing grease at the bottom of a plate in my entire life. No other wings I've had have been like this, I was kind of shocked. They were good and all...but not the best. They tasted like they had butter in them... Their prices were really fair, but I just could NOT get over that freakin grease. It was a major turn off. I really don't think I'll return here again much to my friend's dismay.
(2)Pascal M.
Small, tiny, puny, miniscule, wimpy, scrawny, baby lookin' wings. Huge, immense, big, lip smacking good flavor wings. My office raved about this place. After an early appointment, I told them I would pick up some grub for everyone. We had a feast. The wings are delicious and the experience inside the place is cool too. I spent my wait lookin at all the interesting charm on the walls. Which I love doing at places like this. it almost tells a story about the establishment and acts as a reassuring testamonial for what your about to put in your mouth. I hear the burgers are great too.. Looking forward to going back for my office soon. Shoot, maybe tomorrow!
(4)Amy L.
Why people rave about this place? The chicken wings are legendarily small and they do not take credit cards!!!
(3)Richard L.
The only thing okay here is the sauce... But I don't like that it's a little sweet. You can also buy it by itself. The restaurant is grimey, the wings are tiny; it's not worth it. Doesn't live up to the hype. The cookies were actually pretty good. Large Oatmeal Chocolate Chip for 0.85$.
(1)April P.
Yep, they're still here, doing the damn thing, still being a foodie landmark, the quest and one of the greats to have for Superbowl, NBA finals, and just a regular chicken run on a Saturday night. Even though they are smothered with their special sauce, they are still retain their crispy exterior, even after a half hour car ride home. Score! Love their bbq, not too sweet, not too savory. Their hot sauce is just right amount of heat for the rookies who can't take it. Can't comment on their suicide wings, but for the brave, I heard they're pretty outstanding. Open late, parking plenty even on the weekends. Fast service, as well. A half order of wings will run you about $7.
(5)Jeanie P.
2.5 stars hm maybe it was the hype, but buffalo joe's is just okay. I tried the single order spicy wings and cheddar waffle fries, and it was just alright. Honestly nothing mindblowing. The aroma is amazing, but the actual taste is nothing to write home about. Wings are swimming in grease fyi (like a pool at the bottom of my white styrofoam to go box). I didn't really like the fake taste of the cheddar--- i'm very skeptical this is real cheese? It had like the weirdest texture after it cooled down a little bit. And I LOVE cheese but I had to scrape this stuff off and wished I had ordered regular fries instead. It tasted almost sweet. Definitely would not get that again. I also didn't think the ranch was tangy enough-- too much on the sweet side. And like a lot of the reviews say, the wings are really small... which I didn't think would bother me but it is definitely an aspect that could be improved. So props to them for being a hole in the wall place with tons of loyal customers and able to thrive blocks away from a BWW. But personally, just not very impressed.
(3)Jaclyn Y.
The wings are small, but the sauce is soooo good. I like how the wings are crispy. The waffle fries are excellent with cheese!!! YUM. Can't wait to come back here.
(5)Eric G.
Do not eat their food. You will become addicted and then I will have to wait in line behind you. Cash only. Mild is a friendly hot. This place is worth a ride up on the purple line.
(5)Doug F.
Been going here for 15 years. All you need to know is get the Wings with Suicide sauce. If you like it even hotter ask for Double Suicide sauce. If you like it it mild, the wings won't taste as good without the suicide sauce. The suicide sauce not only adds heat but adds lots of flavor. The wings are so tasty, you eat one and before you know it, you have enough bones in front of you to fill a museum. Its the classic hot sauce , deep fried wings with side of celery and blue cheese. Expect it to be a messy. Grab plenty of napkins. If you have 4 or more (big) people in your party, get the "Pan" (around $40). Serving sizes are good. They give nice portions. Located in the trendy, rich, hip, college town (Northwestern University) of Evanston. Great neighborhood. The inside is a basic chair and tables, nothing fancy. A little greasy feeling because of the open kitchen with exposed fryers. Next door is a church that always attract pan handlers outside. Just be aware. Street parking. Bottom line is the WIngs. They're so good, I just keep coming back for the last 15 years. Enjoy and keep a glass of milk nearby to kill the fire!
(5)Daphne L.
An Evanston staple. I've been coming here since high-school and it's still one of my favorite places for wings. The wings are spicy, like they should be, not breaded and deep fried, like they shoulnd't be. The waffle fries with cheese..lord have mercy! So good, so very bad for you, you must have them. The people that work there are great: friendly, get down to business and get the food out to the customers. Can't ask for more than that.
(4)Stacy S.
Wings? Yes please! I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's since high school and this is by far the best wings I've ever had! B Dubs comes close, but it doesn't quite nail it the way Buffalo Joe's does. Now, I can only speak for the (mild or spicy) wings and the waffle fries, because those are the only two things I've had on the menu..with the RC, of course. Seriously, looking for good wings? Buff Joes is it.
(5)Dan H.
Buffalo Joes is awesome. I have been going here since before I was ever born. My mother told me that when she was pregnant with me this was the place that she craved. I can see why, freshly cooked wings are slathered with a traditional buffalo wing sauce. you can order your wings mild, hot or suicide. When you order them suicide they come covered in pickled jalapeno peppers and buffalo wings sauce. It's awesome, until the next day if you know what i am saying. You must order the Cheddar Chips. They are seasoned waffle fries covered in cheese sauce. I could eat an entire party tray of these with out ever blinking an eye. I love them. You need to eat them there though, they don't travel well. I've also had the pleasure of eating a burger here, the burger was large and tasty. It is cooked in front of you on an actual grill that gives it a nice char. Go to buffalo joes, don't wear white and remember to tip the homeless guy out front.
(5)Billy M.
Buffalo Joe's is my second favorite wing place in the world behind Bird's Nest. I have frequented this location for many years and they have never dissapointed. I also love their waffle cheese fries. This place has amazing food and a great tradition. If you are in downtown Evanston i highly recommend that yoiu stop and order a few dozen hot wings with cheddar waffle fries.
(5)Derik P.
My favorite Buffalo wings place hands down. I've been here for the past 4 years. I have to say one thing though, the wings aren't as good as before but it still great. If you like spicy 1. Get suicide 2. Spicy buffalo chip (Waffle fries top with cheddar cheese and Jalapenos) Drools 3. Don't get mild. It sucks in my opinion 4. TIP THE HOMELESS GUY OUTSIDE. 8 OUT OF 10 TIMES I'M THERE I ALWAYS SEE HIM. Every year it's getting worst and worst. Smaller wings and more expensive. Still the best sauce ever for the wings but I'm looking somewhere else for better wings now.
(4)Ju L.
So, wings: The sauce is delicious and oilier than most other buffalo sauces, but the "suicide" sauce, their most intense, is NOT spicy-- I've had wings with no spiciness designation at all that were hotter than these (case in point: Dixie Kitchen's Jamaican jerk wings). Maybe they only call it "suicide" because they're served under a heap of pickled jalapeno? If that is the case, I feel cheated. And holy heck these wings are small. Even Merle's menu, next to THEIR wings, says outright, "Friends don't let friends eat tiny wings at Buffalo Joe's" or something like that. I also don't love that they give you ranch dressing instead of bleu cheese. The staff is amusingly irreverent, prices are not as low as might be expected ($13 for a double order; wings at Merle's or Dixie Kitchen are significantly cheaper for a comparable amount), and shady characters hover outside and occasionally need to be made to leave by the staff, who return immediately to looking indifferent. This is a convenient and casual place to get something to munch on without dealing with a real restaurant, so I'll probably find myself back here sometime in the future. But I won't be too enthused.
(2)Sandra Y.
I've been going here for nearly 10 years so it brings back so many memories the second I walk into the place :) I always order double suicide wings with blue cheese dressing, broccoli cheddar soup, cheddar fries, & a bacon cheddar burger. Everything is always soooo good! Speaking of which, I think I need to make a stop here soon.
(5)Sarah F.
WINGS! yum! Buff Joe's serves wings done right. The chips (waffle fries) are delicious! Be sure to call early if you want to order some for a football weekend and/or the Superbowl. Also fun for an alum to reminisce about the old days at NU. :)
(5)Scott C.
The wings here are the best in the country. The wings I got were nice size with lots of meat on them too, I stuck with the mild because the flavor is fantastic and theyr spicy enough for me. The "Buffalo Chips" are really good quality waffle cut french fries and the smallest drink is large enough to do the job.
(5)Jon W.
The last time I was there an employee was vomiting in the patron area while her friends recorded the events on their phones and uploaded through social media. The guy who appears to be the owner or manager (fat guy, mustache) acted as though this were normal. I am never going back.
(1)EdanEdan T.
Great sauces and fast service. BUT why are the chicken wings the size of my thumb? I felt like i was eating fried skin with a bone in it but without barely any meat. Luckily they give you more than a dozen of these mini wings...but still, i was hungry right afterwards. I dont even know any other chicken wing places that have wings this small...its as if they took baby chicken's for the meat. So weak. Def not going back.
(2)Colin D.
The first time I had wings, it was at Buffalo Joe's. That set the standard at the time, and nothing since has compared. I think three things set Buffalo Joe's apart: the sauce (the buffalo and barbecue are both top-notch), the texture (tend to be a bit more well done than most, which makes the skin taste great), and the size (as the pictures show, sometimes they can be REALLY tiny. However, I like wings a little on the small side so you get some sauce and skin in each bite). The Clark St location is specifically my favorite - not all of the others offer the (excellent) waffle fries. Get 'em suicide style (buffalo sauce, jalapenos, and cheese), and make sure to bring your Lipitor.
(5)Sara L.
Me and my bf came here based off of Yelp reviews and both of us left extremely disappointed. First off, the place smelled like a bathroom. I tried to not think about it but honestly, the smell threw any appetite I had out the window. If you REALLY want to try this place, order it for take-out. The wings were REALLY small, I'm talking, microscopic. I feel sorry for the quails that they are taking these wings off from because they're so small and cute...and their lives aren't worth taking for sub-par wings! I gave it two stars because the sauce was good. If they had meatier wings to couple with the sauce, the wings would be a lot better. We also shared cheddar chips (waffle fries) which were also not very good. The cheddar cheese that is used on the fries was gritty and thick. I'm a huge cheese person but found this kind to be really unappetizing and left over half of the fries untouched. If you like the thick and gritty cheese (my bf said it reminded him of the cheese used at Weiner Circle), then by all means, this is your place. Otherwise, I'd stick to the plain waffle fries. Overall, I've been to plenty of other places for wings that are significantly better than this place. I didn't really understand all of these 5 star reviews but looking at the dates for most of these, it seems as if this place has gone down-hill since 2009. Perhaps there was a change in management? Either way, I don't think I will ever come back here. I'd rather go to Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)Gabriel C.
I have been going here ever since highschool and it is still my all time favorite place for wings. Wings are one of my favorite types of foods so there are times I stop by here multiple times a week. There are some times that the wings are small in size, but I go there so much that it usually balances out lol.
(5)Jill M.
Well...this is sad for me because I have been a Buffalo Joe's fan for a long time (10 years or more), but I won't be going back after having a bad experience three times in a row now. 1. The employees have been consistently rude and occasionally down-right mean. Maybe they are all underpaid and treated poorly. I don't know. But, whatever it is....who wants to go out and be treated rudely just for ordering food? I don't get it. 2. The restaurant is a greasy, unclean mess. Yes...that is what you might expect at a fast-food place, but it is disgusting now. The floor is so greasy that you might slip and fall in the grease. The bathrooms are so disgusting that I watched multiple people go into the bathrooms only to come out immediately and say they'd have to go somewhere else. Seriously, the restaurant should close down for however long it takes and CLEAN UP. Maybe get new bathrooms and floors. It's surprising they have passed the health inspections. 3. The wings just aren't that good anymore. I feel like a traitor just saying that, but ti's true. They are tiny, expensive and the meat is all dried out. Not good. My waffle fries were fine. So, please, Buffalo Joe's...clean up the restaurant, hire new people that are trained in being pleasant and bring back the wings that were the best in the country!
(1)Rae D.
Best wings in the city! Although I love me some hot wings, I prefer ordering the mild here as they have a great buttery taste to them. The cheddar chips are so good! Who wouldn't love waffle fries with cheddar cheese spread all over them?
(5)Keith H.
You cannot afford not to go eat here. Why are you still reading reviews. Get your shoes on and go. Now!
(5)Aurore L.
Joe was behind the counter. (well - I don't really know. But with his pony tail, his long side burns and his cap, he DID look like a Joe. And not the G.I. kind) He took my order with nonchalance, and I waited, wondering with a bit of disbelief what I was doing there, and if I was indeed in the heart of sleek, posh, suburban Evanston. Or if I had landed in hell's waiting room for hormone-driven high school students. They were EVERYWHERE. And hungry. And scary with their hands and chin dripping with wing sauce. Ok, I am exaggerating a bit. BJ's is not for whimpers. The normal order is 12 wings. What you get is more like 18, so be prepared. They are on the smaller side though. Therefore manageable. Cheese fries, a pop and game on!!! Probably not a destination in itself - it's really sorta shabby looking - but if you are on a wing quest...well....why not?!??
(3)Richard H.
I've only been here one time -- and boy did this place make a bad impression! It was unclean and smelly. There was a layer of smelly grime on the table and ketchup blobs dried on the wall. The food is not god-awful -- but the odor and scuz are killer. In all fairness, I did not try the wings. Perhaps, I should consider carry out from here sometime, since others really seem to like it. If you want some greasy comfort food, I'd recommend skipping this place and walking a couple blocks to Edzo's.
(1)Ben A.
1 Single order Buffalo Wings with spicy sauce, and mixed with XXX Sauce. The XXX Sauce is so good it works well when blended with other sauces. It's the strongest they have, and its not on the menu. Try it if you like spicy. Its not too bad.
(4)Cassie S.
Messy. Greasy. Delicious. Not sure how else to describe these wings. Are they the spiciest wings you can find? No. But they are flavorful which, to me, makes up for that! I'd much rather eat a tasty (but not as spicy) wing over one that's so spicy that you can't taste anything but heat anyday! And I enjoy the pickled jalapeno that comes with the "suicide" wings. They can be hit or miss with the size/meatiness of the wings, but I think that's the case pretty much everywhere. Fries are good too. Especially with the cheese :) Not somewhere I can eat at often, but a wonderful treat!
(4)Alex N.
Best wings on the planet
(5)Brandon B.
I went back this weekend. Maybe they had a bad batch before or something, but the quality is back! Still kind of pricey, though.
(4)Igor U.
still my favorite wings place. Get the cheese fries on the side.
(5)Crystal L.
BJs is my #1 choice of preference for chicken wings. It beats Hooters, BW3s, and Wing Stop. Their spicy wing sauce is so unique like a mix of hot n cheddar?? I'm not really sure what the ingredients are but it's amazing to say the least. I usually order to suicide which is their spiciest sauce with jalapenos on top! It's great for those who love their wings hot hot hot. To balance the hotness from the wings I also get an order of their buffalo chips (aka french fries) with cheddar. Cheddar is a crucial part because its absolutely amazing here. My boyfriend isn't as into spicy as I am so he usually gets the buffalo chicken sandwich and it's just perfect for him.
(5)James F.
One of my new found favorite places for wings. Good wings are HARD to come by, but Joe's suits the bill. They're fried fresh and mixed with just the right amount of buttery, fiery sauce. I was in town for a visit for 4 days and ate at Joe's 3 times for lunch! Yes ... it's THAT good.
(5)Jaz P.
This fast food place has zero ambience but it's well worth the trip because their wings are my favorite - the standard by which I judge all other wings by. When I go to other wing restaurants and I'm supposed to choose from a variety of types, I always ask for the ones that taste most like Buffalo Joe's.
(5)Jesse C.
Damn fine wings, friendly staff and lots of seating. A little dirty.
(4)Jerry B.
The wings are very tasty as well as the beautifully seasoned fries. I can't handle the spicy ones though. They never skimp on the sauce & I should give them 3.5 stars, but I bumped it up to 4 because there was a BW3 ad on their yelp site & it's good to support local businesses like them. I wish that they would go into the 20th Century and get a credit card machine & help me get more credit card rewards... Also, the place could use a bit of tidying up & it sometimes smells like dirty diapers in there & I did not see any little ones frolicking... or maybe it could be the Depends.
(4)J F.
Pretty small wings, but they are crispy. The sauces are not really all that hot, but taste great. Suicide wings really not that hot, jalapenos are kinda of a weird touch. Overall not a bad place to get wings, I would agree probably best in the local area.
(3)Paul C.
I went here with Anita because she had read that BJs had the best wings in Chicago, and if there's one thing I love it's wings. Boy where we both disappointed. The wings are small and pretty bland. I've been served better chicken wings on airplanes. This place can't even hold a candle to BW3s. It's cheap though, and everyone is friendly. Definitely not worth the trip, but if you're nearby and want a cheap bite, you probably won't be too upset. Just don't expect greatness. Thanks for nothing Anita.
(2)KING J.
I remember these wings to be damn good! Havent been back since like 1998, I better go back soon and confirm this!
(5)MooMoo L.
My favorite wings place. Deep fried, buttery, saucy. For some odd reason, wings at this place taste a lot better than its branch at Greenbay Rd.
(5)Dave Y.
grease grease grease! you can feel the grease on your face when you walk in here. if you have acne, you'll probably breakout just being here. but their buffalo wings are the best i've had anywhere. get the suicide sauce
(5)C.S. C.
this has been a 5 star for me from high school to even just a couple of years back. here are my 2 reasons why the stars keep on falling off. 1. size of the wings: in the past year or so, the wings have been insultingly tiny. often times, i trek from far away to eat these once beloved wings hoping that i will leave satisfied. however, these days, after my visit, i am left to wonder...where are they buying these tiny wings? are these off the rejected chickens that don't make the cut for tysons or perdue? when i start to think that they are getting these tiny wings from possible deformed/malnutritioned chickens, i get sick. i mean, capt. buff joe, do you really have to get the worst of the worst sized chicken wings when your competitors are still selling good sized wings? 2. price - this is correlated with the size of the wings. i cannot believe capt. buff joe can go to sleep at night knowing that he is robbing people's money by charging so much for these small wings. come on dude. i know wing prices have gone up nationally. so i know that prices will go up. but other places like bw3's, bars, and restaurants are not selling cheap a** wings. at least their prices matches the size. it saddens me to think after spending so much money, time and memories here that bj's is becoming like this. what doesn't help is when people are still paying the money to get such low quality product. i guess that's why capt. buff joe can afford that boxter that sits out in the back. don't get me wrong, the sauce is still the best in chicagoland. also, when the chips are cooked perfectly, they melt like butter. however, the continued lack of quality wings with soaring prices is forcing me not to make the drive to evanston and find other alternatives around here.
(3)A. R.
As stated by other reviewers, the wings at Buff Joe's are neither large nor overly spicy. However the modest-sized wings don't have too much fat on them, so invariably you still get a good amount of chicken in your order. If you have the capacity to eat spicy foods I would recommend the suicide sauce. Although this sauce won't lead to your imminent demise, it will continue to build heat if you lay off the blue cheese dressing and fries as you bask in the glory of these wings. And if you're like me, you'll eat the jalapenos that come in the sauce to ensure that the meal is as spicy as possible. I also had the cheddar chips based on the strong reviews of other Buff Joe's visitors. The fries were good but I was hoping that they would come in a pool of molten cheese. Unfortunately that wasn't the case, and that was perhaps the greatest let down of this meal.
(4)Lenna O.
BuJo's!! now that's some, "finger licking good" stuff. Their buffalo wings are so tasty. The sauce just hits every taste bud in your mouth. There is just something distinct about it that differs from other places. And what better way to compliment the wings than with some of their waffle fries? great with some cheddar cheese drizzled over or just some ketchup - yum. I've also had their cream of broccoli soup, which is one of my favorite soups, and it was indeed good. Haven't had in a while because i don't live nearby, but definitely a place to stop at if you are in the downtown area of Evanston and want a quick bite to eat. Or if you are just craving some of their food and wanna make the trip! Sure beats having mcdonald's or something.
(5)トモ T.
The BEST buffalo wings! I've tried the famous wing places in Buffalo NY, but I still like Buffalo Joe's wings the best. If I visit Evanston for any reason, I will always stop by Buffalo Joe's, even if I am not hungry.
(5)James C.
My first experience was probably back in the year 2000. I remember their wings to be about twice the size as they are today with a little more of a spicy kick than the sweet plain buttery taste that you get today. Today, a group of my friends decided to hit this place up and try to kill a double party platter. We had 6 really big guys and 5 small girls so we didn't think we'd have a problem but to my surprise, we couldn't do it. After having a bunch, the wings become tasteless and the meat starts to taste like old chicken (I still have a weird taste in my mouth as I'm typing this). Anyway, I don't really want to waste my time writing a review on this place cause after reading some of the good reviews that other people wrote, I'm starting to think that I don't know what good wings taste like... I'd like to end by saying that I will no longer be recommending their wings. The prices almost doubled but their wings are half the size and they taste like the chickens were dead and rotting for a while. Will I be going back for their wings? Probably not in my sober state... but maybe after I smoke a couple blunts and a j on the way there... and then another j in front of the door... and maybe one in the bathroom right before my order comes out... otherwise, I think I'm done with this place forever. Sorry Buffalo Joe's... but you disappoint me and I will not be giving you any more of my hard earned money. And for all of you guys that gave this place a good rating... I don't know what to say to you guys. Either my expectation for buffalo wing's are way too high or you're easily impressed. 4/5 stars? Really? Insane.
(2)John L.
back when i was in highschool and in college i would have given this place 5 stars no question. but alas... good things don't always last. the size of the wings have gotten much smaller and so has the quality. i would always get a party or a double party pan and split it amongst my friends.... good times. the sauce that they use is still good so if you go... i would recommend you getting individual servings so the wings aren't as soggy. i still love their cheddar chips. still 4 stars because i haven't really found a better wings place than this.
(4)David L.
Suicide sauce....when I concentrate and remember how good it tastes...after 15 seconds I start to salivate. Those that have had it as often as I do will understand. For the light eaters, single order, for the real players double order with waffle fries and wash it down with an RC Cola... I know, right? RC Cola...awesome... Also, try a party pan for your next weekend party. but careful with the sauce in the car as one speed bump could mean a lingering smell for weeks...
(5)Chris R.
Overcooked, bland sauce, no blue cheese. My wife and I went here to satisfy a Buffalo craving, but were disappointed. I'm not complaining; we paid $15 and got $15 worth of fast food, but it's not worth a return visit. I'm not from upstate New York, so I don't have the "only Buffalo has real wings" mentality. However, I've eaten a lot of wings in a lot of places. There are a lot of good places in upstate New York and elsewhere for that matter. Buffalo Joe's in Evanston is not one of those places. Flavor and quality are their downfall. The food we had was overcooked. The wings and chicken sandwich we ordered both spent too much time in the deep fryer, making them dry and tough. Judging by the size and shape of the wings and the breaded chicken breast, they were standard-issue frozen foodservice items. That might be ok in a fast food restaurant, but for a place that bills itself as a wing joint, it doesn't cut it. The wing sauce left much to be desired. It didn't pack much flavor in general terms, and had almost no peppery spice even though I ordered "hot". Even accounting for personal differences in palate and how spicy one likes their food, I still don't think their hot sauce has much flavor. The complete lack of a spicy kick is what makes me say this. If there were a little bit of heat I could say that it might just be a matter of perception, but there just wasn't any. In my experience, many Midwesterners don't enjoy truly spicy food, so what they called "hot" sauce at Buffalo Joe's might be perfectly acceptable locally. If you want true hot wing sauce with a tabasco-style or red-hot sauce base, you'll have to look elsewhere. (Full disclosure: I'm a midwesterner myself. I just happen to have spent a lot of time in other places and have noticed that "spicy" on a midwestern menu isn't as spicy as in other regions.) The wings were disappointing for what should've been a simple dish (wings + sauce = good eating, but not here). The sandwich started out with bad ingredients, and was not executed well. A gooey yellow ballpark-nacho-style cheese sauce was so thick on the sandwich that it overwhelmed any other flavor that might have been there. The cheese sauce wasn't necessary to begin with, and it became a case of too much of a bad thing. Finally, they only offer ranch dressing, and no blue cheese. A Buffalo native would have a stroke about this, and I personally think ranch dressing on wings is an abomination. It's not traditional, and its bland flavor does not complement the sauce's spice as well as blue cheese's pungent tang. The preference is personal, but Buffalo Joe's should at least offer the traditional alternative alongside ranch.
(1)steph n.
I don't care how good they say the wings are in Buffalo, NY. Chicago's Buffalo Wings at Buffalo Joe's is THE king of the BUFFALO WING. I went here during the night of the SUPERBOWL and man was line packed! I couldn't even imagine how many chickens had to lose their wings to serve THAT many people! Then that made me wonder, where the heck did all those chickens go? Anyways, the wings here are served piping hot, nice and crispy, and coated with their TOP SECRET WING SAUCE. I believe it is a mixture of butter, vinegar, hot sauce, and ???? I can't even guess what the other ingredients are because I tried countless times to mimic it at home to no avail. I just wished this place served white rice. Do you know how much better these wings taste when eaten with rice? I even went scouring for asian restaurants around Buff Joes to order some rice, but I started panicking when I couldn't find any in the vicinity. It is the perfect combination...like PB AND J, like ham and cheese, like cake and ice cream.
(5)Adam P.
I'm an NU student, but I'm from Buffalo, NY, home of the chicken wing. And Goddammit, it's all we've got. Having jockeyed a few deep fryers in my high school days, I like to think I know my wings. Buff Joe's has some of the best I've ever eaten, and BY FAR the best I've encountered in Chicago -- they're directly comparable to Duff's in Buffalo, which some would argue is the best chicken wing joint on Earth. Buff Joe's is the only place I've encountered in Chicago that understands that nothing but crispy frying and simple sauce can make great wings. And the rest of the stuff on their menu is pretty good too. My favorite thing is their grilled chicken sandwich, with hot sauce of course. They have excellent waffle fries and huge usually-solid burgers. I avoid the cheeseburgers -- they use some kind of cheddar spread instead of real cheese. The Char Dog is a hybrid of Ted's on Niagara Falls Boulevard in Kenmore NY with Chicago-style toppings. Yum. This is one of my favorite takeout places in Evanston. I just wish they were open even later on the weekends and that they had delivery. But open 'til 12am 7 nights a week ain't bad.
(5)Patrick W.
I've been eating here for 13 years (since I could drive my little tushy to Evanston). I participated in a Buffalo Joe's wing eating contest in high school against offensive and defensive lineman from my school (3rd prize!). I wrote an essay about it for an english class final during my sophomore year in college. (Teacher's probable reaction: "Why is this yankee in my English class at Louisiana State University writing a final exam essay about hot wings from a place in Illinois? A+ by the way!") I ran two orange (partly yellow, partly red) lights recently to get here one night before they closed. Needless to say, I have history with Buffalo Joe's. The wings are every bit as good as they were when I first started going here. My last visit was the first in several years, but the order rolled off my tongue like it had only been since lunchtime... "Full order of suicide and a side of buffalo chips"... it was like a song. The chips are actually waffle fries, which really more restaurants should have. Suicide wings are the hottest they offer, it's basically the hot sauce but sliced jalapeno peppers are strewn about on top of your wings. My mouth is officially watering as I write this.
(5)Michael G.
Three flavors: mild, spicy, suicide. I've tried all three. The suicide are basically the same as the spicy with a few jalapenos thrown in. Honestly, this place is overrated. Like one recent reviewer said, the wing sauce is pretty run-of-the-mill, nothing amazing. If you're in this neighborhood, you're better off going to Great Sea or even Buffalo Wild Wings.
(2)Ryan N.
My friends and I have been going to Buff Joe's for awhile now and there are some that love it ands some that don't. Single order of suicide , Gutbuster RC, and Cheeder Chips is our order. The other stuff on the menu is ok I've tried some other things but nothing beats that wings. The Suicide sauce is not as hot as people say its more of a great flavor than a spicyness which is the reason I love it. Great atmosphere and we usually enjoy giving fake names to the people who take your order.
(5)Roger W.
Terrific wings. So so so flavorful. That is some magical sauce. The cheddar chips are mouthwatering. Haven't been there in a while...need to go back!
(5)Alex K.
Buff joe's; cheddar chips + suicide wings beats all A friend of my roomate's lived in Louisiana, and would come to visit about once a year. He arrived around 10PM (after flying himself here in a cessna) and asked, before anything else (except a bathroom break) to go to this place. He claimed to crave it constantly. He would go there a few times in a 2 or 3-day stay. I totally understand. despite the negatives in other reviews (mostly valid on some level), you don't see anyone proposing better alternatives. The sauce and overall taste beat other places pretty handily. People giving bad ratings are usually wistful for days gone by... totally fair, but this is still the place to go for wings.
(5)Brian S.
I've been coming here for awhile. Their prices have gone up a lot which sucks but I've always loved buff joes. i wouldn't listen to people saying this is a huge disappointment but i will say they are very very hit or miss. Sometimes you will get small wings and sometimes bigger ones and sometimes they were taste like crap or be awesome. The staff can be ok but the ladies who take the orders can be pretty rude especially if you can't understand them because then they just won't take your order. I have started migrating to the Greenbay location because their wings are a lot more consistent then this one. The only other place that really even compares around chicago is wings around the world but otherwise i'd settle for buff joes anytime.
(4)John S.
I used to frequent BJ's ALL the time from '97 - '03 and their wings were GREAT. After 2003, we moved into the northwest suburbs and never had a chance to come often. Well, the past two times I've been there have been AWFUL! The wings are the smallest I've ever seen and taste like burnt/old oil was used in frying them. They're so terrible I still cringe from my experience yesterday. The worst part is I have been recommending them for years! Never again. Unless something extraordinary happens.
(1)John G.
"Buff Joe's" has the best wings in Chicago, and maybe the entire world. I have brought friends from Buffalo, NY to try these wings and they all agree they are awesome. The secret is consistency. The same guys who worked here when I was in high school are still proudly manning the deep fryer. Sure, they don't flip the sauce bowl quite as fast as they used to, but they have plenty of that special ingredient that makes magic everytime: love.
(5)Stephanie C.
i don't even live in chicago anymore, but dammit, i crave buffalo joe's wing's on a regular basis. sadly, i now live in LA, the land of mediocre (at best) wings. sigh... here it is, an ode to buffalo joe's: oh buffalo joe's, with your perfectly friend wings (not soggy, not dry, but crisp on the outside, juicy on inside) and wonderful sauce (not runny, and not too "fake" and thick - juuuust the right consistency). and don't even get me started on the cheddar fries. what is in that cheese sauce??? whatever it is, i'm totally addicted. my only beefs are the following: a) you don't serve blue cheese - what is up with that? thankfully, i can always stop at the ralph's around the corner to pick up a jar and sneak it into your restaurant. yes, i'm that crazy. and b) your "suicide" doesn't deserve the name. loading the wings with canned jalepeno slices does not constitute another level of heat. the actual sauce could stand to have a lot more kick. regardless of these minor flaws, i love you anyway, buffalo joe's, and miss you more than you can imagine!
(5)Dee W.
Good cheap option for wings - don't try anything else - try the suicide sauce - it's a for sure spicy mouthwatering temptation. If you really want something else - go for the cheese fries - those are pretty good, too. Make sure that you go in a group - have one person stand outside waiting for the food and another person to go scope out a table!
(4)Gil N.
Awesome wings. So-so service. The place varies from being a dump on some nights to pretty decent on others. But it's a Buffalo Joe's, what do you expect? Good wings, right?
(4)Jonathan H.
Simply the best wings in the city. Period.
(5)Irene J.
if you love wings and haven't tried BJ's, what are you waiting for?! i finally had some BJ's for the first time in 10 years, and it was delicious. we ordered suicide, spicy, and BBQ. the suicide sauce was addicting. i love their ranch sauce--get extra! they also have great buffalo waffle chips. cheddar chips and spicy cheddar chips are good, too. i have to say, though, i'm a bit disappointed with the price. back in the day, you could order an entire party platter for $20. it's now, sadly, double the price. BJ wings are a must have. be ready with cash (you know a place is good when they can survive on a cash-only policy), napkins, and water/milk. ;] yum!
(4)Ramon R.
There was a time when I went to this place daily. Then I started getting repulsed by the sloppy appearance of the restaurant, the filthy containers and the fact that so many people here seem intent on gaining 50 pounds (though they're already at at least 250). Go here if you want to get fat and be afraid of catching something. The food is actually enjoyable, but only as long as you don't think about the likelihood that roaches and mice are running all around it.
(1)Greg M.
Not much more to say other than the best Buffalo Wings I have ever tasted. Although not the biggest, but they taste incredible. The place itself is kind of scummy, but their wings are top notch. It's all I've been eating from here for years and they have never disappointed.
(5)tina V.
Single order of spicy wings. Cheddar chips. Gutbuster RC (OK, or a regular one with less ice). My order four+ years ago, my order now. The perfect meal when you're in search of something crispy, fried and delicious. Also good for pre-game, game, post-game, picnics, parties and more.
(4)Bernard M.
Buffalo Joe's wings are simply the best wings in the world. A couple of my friends explored the globe trying to find a superior recipe. They even went to the home of the original Buffalo wings in Buffalo, NY and could not find an equal. Their sauce is addictive. We use to think that they drugged the sauce in high school and when my group of friends went away from college one of the first things we missed was Buffalo Joe's wings. Definitely get the mild because you get the full taste of their national award winning recipe (not just for wings! all foods!). Also their burgers get local rave reviews in a city that knows burgers... I love how they spread a thick paste of cheddar on the buns! Their buffalo fries, soups, and chicken sandwiches all kick ass. One downside is that since my high school days (15+ years ago) their wings and party pans have gotten smaller.
(5)joanne y.
yay for buffalo sauce covered fingers!!! oh, and you have to try their cheese waffles (fries). this is the perfect place to go before or after watching a movie at the century 12 movie theater. you can always park at the parking garage for free or cheap (i forgot) and get it validated at the theater. this place has a hole in the wall charm to it with sticky tables and everything!
(5)Matt B.
I don't know why people have such a passion for this place. I found the wings to be mostly bone & gristle - certainly less meat than BW3s for instance. I'm not sure what advantage this place has over BW3s, and I'm not one to talk up a chain. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here.
(3)Nhu N.
you have to go here regularly to know that buff joes is amazing some days and eh ok others.. the last 2 times i've had it, it's been on point. HAVE TO get the cheddar chips they are simply divinnnnnnneeeee. Worth going to. not the cleanest place but they bumped it up with a plasma in the back
(3)Alan R.
Without a doubt the best wings in Chicago. They have mild, spicy and suicide. The suicide wings are only the spicy with jalapenos on them. An orange sauce and then deep fried to perfection, I miss my Joe's! When I lived in Evanston, I probably came here about once per week. If you don't like wings, they also have loaded baked potatoes, awesome chili, cheap but amazing burgers, and dogs and chicken sandwiches. Definitely a better fast food option than the national chains.
(5)Shimi L.
This place was a dissapointment. We got the suicide spicy which was hardly spicy, even with the jalapenos. The sauce was gummy and congealed. It was quite disgusting and I don't recommend entering this establishment.
(1)Rayid G.
xxx suicide sauce...mmmmmmm
(4)Max S.
Oh man how I miss Buff Joe's. Those wings/fries are soooo good. Heart attack inducing but worth it.
(5)Peggy K.
the wings taste way better than buffalo wild wings,, in my humble thought. Upon reading other reviews mentioning too much sauce, however, I admitted its true the sauce is flooded..but again, given that I always tend to credit those who dare to be different....Me have to say that this place has sold me yummy wings in prices that never worry my wallet. However, I wont recommend eating in after 9 pm since there was wierd smell inside. Cleaning time? maybe
(3)Pete D.
A sunday night tradition while i was at northwestern. Mild, hot or suicide?? love the bbq as well.....there are times when it gets crowded, but this is definitely the place to go. Great option for parties as well...can't beat a few trays of wings! yum!
(5)Zach W.
The reason I couldn't go any higher with my rating was because it would be suicide, just like the wings! Suicide wings will be the death of you - guarantee it! My buddy takes me here every time we head north to golf. The first outing he warned us all about the suicide wings, but nobody listened. Let's just say we weren't right for a couple days.
(3)Michael S.
Simply the best wings I've ever had. I usually get a single order of mild, a side of buffalo chips (crosscut fries), and a large RC Cola. If I'm feeling fiesty i'll get a hot order (my buddies always go suicide, but i like tasting my wings). I'm a hungry guy most of the time, and single order can be a beast to finish. especially with fries. if you go for fries, i recommend asking for a second cup of ranch (ranch and celery come standard with the wings). If you do this right as they put the first ranch and celery on tray, they don't charge you. if you wait and make the checkout guy ask for one, he tacks it on the bill (at least in my experience). runs just over 10 bucks for the best dinner you'll have in long time. some reviews mention the wing size getting smaller. i've been going with my friends about once every few months for 5 years now and it may be slightly smaller every now and then, i just think its the batch, ya know? still so good, and i've actually had days where we got huuuuge wings. i wish i didn't write this review, i kinda wanna go now....
(5)Melissa M.
Despite being dubious in terms of health and cleanliness, the wings here really are good. Unfortunately that is a testament to the rich spicy sauce rather than the meat, which is a little on the dry lower-quality side. Sides are pretty good, I enjoy their fries. The atmosphere leaves much to be desired...because well, it's a dive, but a dive with good wing sauce.
(2)Ron S.
as good as it gets when it comes to getting wings in Illinois.
(5)Jacko J.
Food is ok. Buffalo Wild Wings and Wings Over Evanston are much better. The reason I'm posting is to complain about the ladies behind the counter. It was a slow lunch onTues. Maybe 2 tables and about 6 ladies "working" behind the counter. It took them15 minutes to make my hotdog and fries. I had to endure them cursing and talking about all sorts of crap that customers shouldn't hear while waiting for food. I'm traveling so I need a receipt for work. I get to the car and realize the hens didn't give me one. I go back and the lady looks at me like I'm crazy. No apology, she simply grabs a piece of paper and asks me what I ordered so she can scribble it down. Hey Mr Buffalo Joe if you don't have a computer printing out receipts how do you know these charming ladies aren't pocketing every other sale? And why do you need so many of them when you're so slow? Maybe you should go on Kitchen Nightmares?
(2)a w.
Their buffalo wings are definitely not the best, but when you add a good amount of suicide sauce, they'll become the best!! Its a nice restraunt, a very cheap eat, and a good place to come with a bunch of friends to enjoy good food in a casual setting!
(3)Ben S.
Most overated Wing place I have ever visited. At best these wings are better than average, and the size of the wings are incredibly dissapointing. Chicago does not do wings right- been living here for two years and yet to find anywhere that comes close to Buffalo or Pennsylvania inspired Wing places.
(2)Kat W.
This is a great joint for lunch/takeout wings and other fast food. Their wings are pretty good, but not the best I have had in Chicagoland; Mullen's on Clark has the best ones in my opinion. Having said that, the price is good, the food is good, and they serve pretty fast.
(4)calvin n.
This place never dissapoints except for the sanitation ( hey its not Buffalo Joes if its clean) I've known this place and gone here for years just wished it was still the old price of 3.75 for a single I believe??? but one time which is still stuck in my head was that the person who took my order was picking his teeth with his finger which was absolutly gross in my opinion I kept a close eye on him to make sure he didnt touch my food. Service is meh... ok not to bad accept one guy gave me attitude for asking for extra sauce... great place though I take most of my new friends here.
(4)steve c.
Good tiny suicide wings. Best? Not so much. Double order, waffle fries and large drink. (Dont ask but don't get the cheese for the fries) Always gave a different fake name. Comes with celery and for a double order its like $8 now.
(5)PJ K.
Dingy neighborhood joint; pretty much a rite of passage for anyone who went to NU or ETHS. A full menu of fast-food favorites, but I don't come here often enough (like maybe once a year) to be tempted away from ordering wings, which are made to order and a cut above what's available in most bars. Berghoff beer on tap, too. A fun stop for cheap eats in Evanston.
(4)James B.
Worth a special visit; as good as advertised.
(5)Nelson S.
My friend dragged me from the west suburbs all the way up to Evanston to try these so called "Best Wings Ever" (and he is allergic to chicken by the way). One, I was happy that I wasn't driving so take me wherever and two, I'm not sure if they were the "Best Wings Ever" but they were pretty darn tasty. I'm not sure if I have yet found the best wings ever but this does place high on my list. I thought the wings were quite small in size, like I would use it as a toothpick but you did get plenty of them. If I remember correctly, they also serve waffle fries! I love waffle fries, more place should serve waffle fries! If I did live in the area of this restaurant, I would most likely come here more often.
(4)Jenny M.
What's up with the sinking quality here? In the last month we've eaten there twice and both were ICK. Rotten celery, hairy wings, small wings, inconsistent saucing. We've done our share of damage at this joint over a bunch of years living in Evanston and never been as grossed out by last week's order taker picking at her hair and cleaning her nails while she was taking orders - and opening food containers on the line. Too bad, but they are no longer the only great wings on the block.
(2)Jesster A.
Agree with the general concensus: not THE best wings - but pretty "d" good and the best in the general area. The Cheddar waffle fries are good too. Bring a roll of "thirsty" paper towels (just kidding, kind of...) Perhaps it's just our germaphobic culture rubbing off on me (I try to avoid most forms of paranoia) - but for some reason here (and other places as well) I enjoy the food more if I DON'T watch them prepare it...
(4)Josh L.
I've been going to BJ's since I was in high school (about 15 years). The quality of the chicken seems to have gone down a little bit since then, but they still have the best buffalo wings I've ever tried - by far. I'm sure they'll give me a heart attack one day, but I can't stop paying them a visit every once in a while. It's a great place to eat with friends. I like to order my wings spicy with suicide sauce on the side (having the suicide sauce on the chicken sometimes overwhelms the taste a little too much).
(5)Ted W.
This place is awesome. Has one of the best wings in the chicago area. Always have sports games on. There fries are pretty good to.
(5)M. C.
Good wings, AMAZING cheddar fries! Dirty but good for a bite or for high school kids.
(4)Constantine H.
My favorite place to get wings. I prefer it over all the popular wing joints including BW3, Timothy O'Tooles, Gators, etc. We order from here for any party or sporting event and any guest that's never had it before always asks where we get them from. Something about the sauce will keep me coming back for the rest of my life.
(5)r j.
Is it me or does it seem that the suicide wings lost a heat level or two? Don't get me wrong the wings are still good but not as good as from what I remember. They have gotten a lot smaller over the years and the prices have gone up. The cheddar fries and gut buster R.C do bring back a lot of memories. Still an alright place to go to for wings.
(3)Christina B.
Perhaps my most favorite place to eat! Why can't they open a Buffalo Joe's in San Francisco? I practically lived here during my high school years, and every time I go back to Chicago I have to get an order of suicide wings to tide me through until the next visit.
(5)Eli R.
I get buffalo wings everywhere and these are the best I've ever had. It's kind of pricey unless you share (which I do not when it comes to wings). The buffalo chips are like waffled fries and are pretty good. A gutbuster RC should do the trick. Order extra ranch. Sometimes the kitchen smells a little funny, which can be disturbing. The wings really are great, though. The choices are mild, spicy, and suicide, but none are really that spicy. It's more about the great taste than hotness. Can also get crowded around lunchtime.
(4)Nick B.
Best buffalo wings around. Make sure to try their suicide wings, you won't regret it.
(4)Jaclyn C.
I don't know if I'd go with "Best buffalo wings ever" but they're good. And there's a wide-range of other options too.
(3)J H.
I'm giving it 5 stars simply because there is no competition in the area for wings. The sauce is fantastic but its basically liquid butter with hot sauce and vinegar. The hot wings are fantastic as it provides an excellent kick to balance out the buttery sauce. Spicy barbecue is one of my favorite as it is sweet and hot--the best combo. Suicide is hot and it really fills the void after couple drinks. For the best deal, just get a platter or half platter and split it with buddies and don't forget the pitcher of beer to wash it down.
(5)Mark P.
The perfect meal- double spicy, buffalo chips, and gutbuster RC. Love the spicy, buttery wings and waffle-cut fries. Avoid the Howard one, and stick to the downtown Evanston location.
(5)Stephanie M.
I was smart and came here with 3 of my guy friends. We got this huge foil pan of wings and a smaller pan of celery and blue cheese. It is so much fun to eat wings slathered with sauce and get messy. Yea, I even dropped some sauce onto my shirt. I looked like a slob.
(3)Demetrio P.
Went to Buffalo Joes in Evanston last night for the gazillionth time, and it never disappoints! Usually order a single order of suicide wings and waffle fries....hmmmm...just thinking about it is making me crave it again. Prices have risen over the years, but still budget friendly. I can't vouch for the other items on the menu, but why go to a buffalo wings place for anything other than, well, buffalo wings! Overall, good food, okay prices, and okay service.
(4)eric l.
I don't know whether it was the hype, but the wings were just whatever. Ranch dressing was watered down. Also, their portions are measured in a weird way. They just eyeball the number. Number of freakn double order and the single order of wings were the same. Never get a double order, unless you don't know where to spend all your money and want to get overcharged. Service wasn't bad but neither good. GET CASH before or else get ready to pay an extra 3 bucks for the ATM fee (worst way to spend 3 bucks). I would say it is better than bw3 but not hooters.
(2)Taylor M.
Best drunken buffalo wings ever. Terrible for you, but that's not the point. They are incredible. Get the sauces mixed. Trust me.
(4)Jason P.
Ok, so lets start this by saying I am a vegetarian reviewing a chicken wing place. For those of you that did not immediately stop reading, enjoy! Ok, this place has a pretty diverse menu outside of the chicken wings. The best part are the heart attack cheese fries, called chips. They will throw hot sauce on them and cover them with jalepenos as well to make heartburn heaven. They also have these giant cookies that are extremely awesome. The best part of being a vegetarian there is that you can go straight to the register and cut the line. My omnivore friends that actually wait in line say that the wings are fantastic as well. The only downside is that if you get water, I think it is something like 10 cents and they pack so much ice in there that you have to go get more every sip. Also, one recommendation is that you bring someone who smokes with you. It is the best way to interact with the greeters that stand outside (persons sans homes) as generally they will be satisfied with bumming a smoke off of your smoker friend. Trust me, it works everytime.
(4)Paul d.
So after countless hours at the gym training for a 10 mile race and then finally getting to that wondrous day and reluctantly running it, what would any one in their right mind do? Feed your face with the most unhealthy food you can find, of course!. After a long debate between OCB (Old Country Buffet for you not in the know) and BJs, we ended up making the trek over to Evanston. I'm going to cut straight to the food; let me tell you, after ten grueling miles, you deserve any treat you get. This treat happened to be in the form of a double order of spicy wings, spicy cheddar fries, and a bacon cheddar burger. The wings are smaller than normal (about the same as BW3s size, if not smaller) but the crunchiness of the skin, lean meat and amazing sauce were in perfect unison. The spicy cheddar fries were good as well - waffle fries, cheddar (real cheddar btw, no gloppy manufactured cheese topping here), hot sauce and jalapenos on top. Bacon cheeseburger was standard except for the fact they again they used real cheddar - somewhat greasy but good nonetheless. Only thing I would change about this place are the napkins! How do you expect to eat wings, cheddar fries and a cheddarburger without half of it ending up on your face? Then they insult you with these dinky little napkins like the ones they used to give you in grade school. Next time I'm bringing a bib, a bottle of Purex and a hand towel! Tip: Leave the credit card at home, it's cash only here.
(4)Giselle S.
I must be hard wired since my first taste in high school. The truly mouthwatering wing that bears your name makes one drool and dream for the delights. This place has been a neighborhood gem for many years. I would have to say that since the beginning weeks of football season there is nothing that can compare to a BJ and a beer! I know why the sexual innuendo (it's not my usual style:) ....b/c it is true, football season or not this place is the best. These wings rock. Single and Double orders or Single Party Tray or Double Party Tray. Suicide sauce on the side use to house whole jalapenos and now are chopped up and still so delicious. On my latest excursion to this place I placed the order over the phone thinking how the occasion called for an order that fits b/t Double order and Single party pan. My subconscious wanted the Single party pan for plenty of leftovers and to make sure no one was left without their fill. The practicality of it all was no need to spend more than what was needed. I ordered over the phone and was told it would be 10-15 minutes. By the time I picked up my order and pay (CASH ONLY) I ordered $50 worth of tantalizing wings. Pleasant surprise on my part. My subconscious won in the end and my longing for Joe's was satiated for the time being. :) Luckily, the gathering was a success, (I can not say the same for the Bears), and no leftovers to take home. Eat in and cafeteria style until you pay for your order and catch the game in the eatery on flat screen. Enjoy!
(5)afro d.
i must be a gluten for punishment... i tried to go again hoping somethings have changed. but it had gotten worse. the wings were no bigger than a quarter. now the part it got worse is that its super dirty when i got there. a cart with dirty stuff in a bus tub in front of the reg. behind the counter it was filthy. not i went there about 11:30pm.. i learned my lesson. no more.
(1)Angela H.
The hot I got was not quite hot enough. Should have gone with suicide. Their fluffy baked potato has had me craving baked potatoes with my wings ever since. It's sort of a divey place and mostly full of teenage boys and hard-working men. I was certainly a fish out of water, but acted like I belonged. Waffle fries looked amazing. I'll go back and give it another try. Didn't find anything to be dirty, and enjoyed my food.
(4)Erin N.
Sans car, I don't get up to Evanston much anymore. But I had the pleasure of going there recently when my gf borrowed the car from her parents for the weekend. Like I mentioned earlier the wings have changed since back in my high school days (10+ years ago). But let me tell you this- I ate my single order of wings faster than I have ever eaten wings in my entire life. They were that good compared to the stuff that bars try to serve you in the city. They are a bit tinier than wings you'd get anywhere else, but I like that rather than the JUMBO wings that throw off the meat to sauce ratio and always seem kind of rubbery. I'm taking Buffalo Joe's down one star for their rude behavior towards my gf who brought a Papa John's pizza in. I was a paying customer (single order, RC, and spicy cheddar chips*) and she came to sit with me. On top of that, she also purchased a drink from them! She wasn't taking up space that could have been used by another patron- and it's not like her eating of her pizza would have caused BJ's to lose customers. They were just plain turdley to her. *not as good as I recall, but this might be due to the fact that by the time I got around to eating them my stomach was expanding from the rapid wing consumption.
(4)Paula B.
I had their special burger today for lunch and it was great! I've been there numerous times before and love their wings, their beef sandwiches, and their stuffed potatoes! Yummmm Their cookies are the best too! I think it's got good reasonable food. It's cash only though. There is an ATM there in the restaurant though if you need it.
(4)Rob S.
This is probably the one spot I miss most since moving from the city out to the 'burbs. Buffalo Joe's defines buffalo chicken wings in my book. They are the benchmark, and few, if any can compare. Double order of Spicy, the waffled fries, and a Gut Lemonade are my standing order. I've been coming to Buffalo Joe's for over a decade, and there is na reason for this.
(5)Orack B.
When we started going to Buffalo Joe's back in the day we were so high on a number of different possible intoxicants that one would think we would not fully enjoy the experience. I am here to refute any such claims. We fucking loved it! Now 15 years later I still love it like I did back in my youth. The sauce is really what does it for me. I like the succulence of the sweetness followed by the bite of the heat. I always order suicide - although the heat varies from time to time and also depends on how many jalapenos you eat - I yearn for something hotter. This brings me to a Buffalo Joe's story circa '99 when I was offered habanero pepper wings. Now circa '99 me and my buddy were so high, and lovers of spice, that we said yes. What ensued was absolute hilarity. Each bite of wing rendered us delirious for ten minutes. We were in our own worlds, laughing uncontrollably between each bite. I believe capsaicin increases the effects of Jah Ganja at least tenfold. It was pure bliss! Now back to the food. Single suicide, sometimes a double if I feel extra large, cheddar chips and a gut RC. This is my definition of a fleeting paradise, consumed with such gusto it is almost a travesty. Big shouts to my man Dean behind the counter.
(4)Peter R.
I had to run some errands in Evanston, and you know what that means!!! BUFFALO JOE'S all up in, and around my face!!! I stopped by the Chase ATM because this place only takes cash money. I strolled in with a Cheshire Cat grin on my face and ordered the single order spicy, and a smokehouse burger. I know, I know, I'm such a hippo, but I didn't eat lunch I swear!!! I validated my artery clogging meal by ordering a gut buster size Diet Rite, just to even things out. I plopped into one of the booths in the back, watched some ESPN on the big flat screen and waited for them to call my name. "Diego!" "Diego, single order with smokehouse burger!" If you know me, or if you look on the upper left of this review, you notice my name is not Diego. I always give them a fake name, just to keep things lively. I went back to my seat and got down to bizzzzness. Ah, the spicy delectable joy of these tender chicken morsels. The buffalo wings have that, "make your nose runny" heat on them...delicious. My smokehouse burger was very good, with the grilled onions, bacon, bbq sauce, and cheese, all coming together in splendid bliss. If you are ever in Evanston, and you love buffalo wings, you HAVE TO stop by. Buffalo Joe's is spicy chicken nirvana.
(5)Kristin M.
I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but in my opionion the wings are too greasy and have way too much sauce on them. The sauce had a little too much sweetness to it and there were jalopenos in it, which is just not right... And I thought we had asked for blue cheese dressing, but it tasted like ranch-that's just not the way it should be! The cheesy fries, however, oh my! I was in heaven! I'd go back for that!
(3)Martha M.
Buff Joes is AWESOME. Let me give you a few pointers. 1. Call your order in ahead of time, otherwise you will most likely wait awhile. 2. They only take cash! There is an ATM but it charges you an obscene amount of money. 3. If you are gong with a few people and you all want the same sauce, get the double orders, instead of single orders. You'll save a few bucks. Maybe you could give the money you save to the bum who is always standing outside. 4. Have patience! Buff Jo's is always full of rude and obnoxious high schoolers and even ruder and more obnoxious Northwestern students. A word on the cheese fries. They are so so good! They have regular cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce and then they have the uber-amazing Spicy Cheddar chips - waffle fries w/cheese sauce, buffalo sauce and jalapenos. delicious!!!
(4)Kristen B.
Went here for the first time today and really enjoyed it! After running into a former Evanstonian yesterday who was appalled by the fact I still hadn't been here, we decided we should go. I was a little leery about it after reading some of the reviews thinking my friend was just guiding me to a place that was great during her high school days but had passed its glory days. I'm glad that I went against my better judgment. The wings were great, I can't say that they were the best I've ever had but definitely up there. Hubby and I shared a double order of spicy wings, cheddar chips (waffle fries smothered in cheese) and a side of spicy sauce for cheese fry dipping pleasure (this is also a great way to enjoy Buffalo Chips with Cheese at BWW.) The cheese was a little oddly sweet, but other than the meal was tasty. Nice meaty wings with a lot of sauce. We got 20 in our $10 double order. I will take away one star because things seemed to take a really long time. While not entirely their fault (U of Wisconsin's Lacrosse Team dropped in for lunch and another large group was there also) it did seem to frazzle them quite a bit and at one point a tub of raw chicken wings were dropped onto the floor. I will definitely go back for the wings and to try a "char dog."
(4)Mike D.
I was quite excited to try out buffalo joes after many recommendations and drooling over it on yelp. I ordered the Spicy and BBQ thinking I'd try half and half. I was asked if I wanted a mix. Thinking that would get me my half and half situation, I agreed. What I got was delicious flavor heaven. The spicy and the sweet of the BBQ and hot sauce was an amazing combination. My only complaint is that their wings are definitely on the small side. However, the taste was great and it was a no frills process to get in, out and eating my wings.
(5)Doctor L.
As a Northwestern U. alum, absolutely nothing in this world makes me more nostalgic to head back to Evanston than Buff Joe's. As college students this is where we'd go whenever we got paid, whenever the dorm cafeteries were closed on Sunday nights, and/or whenever we got drunk and/or stoned. Or any combination of the above. Junk food connoisseurs know that grease is supposed to have its own FLAVOR, not just texture, and not just compliment other flavors. Perhaps no other restaurant in the world appreciates this more than Buffaloe Joe's. The wings are awesome, especially if you're having a party and buy them by the tray. I fondly recall multiple occassions when I saw fraternity pledges being sent there from as far away as Michigan and Missouri by their homesick Chicagoan brothers to pick up as many trays as could fit in their car. As other Yelpers have astutely pointed out, the genius behind Buff Joe's is that they appreciate spice while at the same time understanding that spice by itself is not a flavor. These wings have zest as well as heat. There's a huge difference between the two. The rich buttery flavor of the wings is only matched by the impeccable waffle-cut cheese fries. Again Buff Joe's has mastered capturing the rich greasy flavor of both the fry AND the processed cheese sauce to make this delicious side order a worthy meal in itself. As you'd expect, your ass WILL be on fire after dining here. Do not go to Buff Joe's on a date, before a date, or before any event where you will not have the opportunity to run to the bathroom every 5 minutes (ie: mid-term, final, movie, concert, orgy, etc.)
(5)Michael M.
Even though this place can really cause havoc on your stomach with the spices it still is by far my favorite wing place in Evanston. My sales guys and I frequently will order this place for lunch, (Mild for Lunch) Don't want to kill the staff...LOL!!! Always get extra Ranch and there is never enough, and it is so good. Also try their baked potatoes they are surprisingly perfectly cooked ever time. All in all A+ in my book. - Greasy Spoon FYI, so don't expect anything fancy!
(5)Alex Z.
I wish they served more different sauces, like that one big chain place to the southwest does. They are very good at what they do serve, though. I get spicy every time (or whatever the one in the middle is called). Single order is enough, and it comes with free celery (which is actually fresh!) and ranch dip. The texture of the chicken and the taste of the sauce are amazing. Hot dogs are meh, I heard the burgers were great but I've never gotten one. Beverage choices could be improved (RC is still in business!?!?), and not taking cards is a bit of an annoyance. Sometimes the people who take your order are condescending and mean, other times they are great. I like that poster in the waiting area that says "No bird soars too high if he soars with his own wings".
(4)Kelsey M.
Let me tell you folks who didn't grow up in Evanston something, back in middle and high school, you could NOT have a classroom party without Buffalo Joe's. It just wasn't a party without. It's an Evanston institution, and rightly so. I am not normally a wings person, but these are DELICIOUS! So good. You are not a true Evanstonian if you haven't eaten here.
(4)Joe R.
This place hits the spot. come with a couple of friends and an appetite. the wings arent the biggest but the sauce really opens up the meat. they are well fried and are the ideal comfort food for a day of drinking or just to unwind after a long day. the suicide wings are the best and have a decent kick to them especially with the jalapeno's. service is good and nothing goes better with wings than dark beer. I look forward to hitting this place up when I can.
(4)Nate C.
Its been years since I've been first introduced to this place and I have yet been disappointed. yum Yum! I love eating there while the food is nice and fresh. Then when I'm done with my spicy wings, I can always get an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie. The waffle cheese fries are yummy, the celery stix are yummy. Everything is just yummy. I guess you can say its one of my favorite wing joint.
(4)Ed E.
Buffalo Joe's used to be amazing. They fell off a lil but still have pretty good wings. Sometimes I'll go there and their wings are tiny and sometimes they're the way they used to be. I wish they were a little more consistent with their wings but still some of the better ones in the chicago-land area
(4)Candyce P.
I'm a huge wings fan. I've had them at most sports bars, of course at BW3 and my Dad grills some spectacular Portuguese wings. That being said, I'm picky about the way the wings are fried (or grilled) and the combination of spices used. Jason C. made plans for us to meet at Buffalo Joe's for lunch, with promises of the best wings. I was a bit skeptical, but excited to try them out. It's quite a casual setting: order at the counter, pick up you order when it's done. I got the single order of spicy wings, with cheddar fries and a Sprite. I also only order the "flat" pieces of the wing if I can, and they gladly obliged. (Some places give me the stank eye for requesting only flats). The wings are perfectly crispy, and the "single order" is huge! (I'd say about 12 wings? and for $6.something it's a steal!) The "spicy" sauce was just what I wanted as well - a deep flavor with a nice kick. The cheddar fries were good as well, but you have to eat them while it's still hot, or else the cheddar solidifies on your waffle fries. Which isn't such a bad thing either. :) Overall, HUGE fan. I'll definitely make the trip out to Evanston for these wings again and again. Note: They accept CASH ONLY, but there is an ATM in-house for those of us who never carry cash around.
(5)Conrad Q.
I've been coming here since my early college years. I have never been disappointed by the wings. I always get suicide wings, cheddar chips and a gut buster RC. Celery has always been crisp when you dine in but never when you order for take out. They don't keep it separate with the wings. I noticed the wings might be getting smaller, but that could just be the economy.
(4)Heather B.
If you want wings with taste as well as spice, this is the place for you! I like hot stuff, but I like it to taste like something other than just burning my tongue off!! I love this place despite the fact that it is in college kid central in Evanston. The staff rocks, and obviously love their jobs, because most of them have been there the entire 5 or longer years I have been going there. They even recognize us when we walk through the door!! Their sauce is to die for.... the mild is perfect spice with a bit of kick, spicy is hot and tasty, and suicide is.... well, topped with jalepenos, and makes my sinuses instantly clear. I can't do the suicide for long! For $35 you can buy a gallon of your favorite sauce and use at your discretion. I'm also a big fan of the broccoli cheese soup and buffalo tenders. The soup has the perfect amount of broccoli to cheese ratio, but can be a little greasy sometimes. The tenders are a great way to soak up that wonderful sauce and save some calories! (yeah, not really, but they are better than the wings in that respect) Everyone needs to try Buffalo Joe's if you like wings. You won't regret it!
(5)Annie S.
LOVE BJ's!!!! I used to come here in high school and their wings, burgers and waffle fries are THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Melt in your mouth good. Dang, this place is so great. I love the suicide wings (very hot) and you have to order the fries (w/ cheese if you like that). The service is pretty fast and there's regular seating in the back. The place is a decent size and almost always I can find a table. Seriously, you have to try this place and get the wings!!!
(5)James B.
Single order (or double if you a big boy) of spicy wings with some cheddar chips and a grape drink or rc and you will be good. best place for wings on this planet.
(5)Justin G.
Best buffalo wings in the Chicagoland area (as it's in Evanston...) hands down. The atmosphere is super casual, with employees yelling out names as orders are completed. The wings are not as large as they were 10 years ago, when I started eating there, but they're an okay size. The sauce is what makes it great. Try the spicy, the mild is really very, very mild. The suicide is not as hot as most people seem to think, but the jalepenos on top seem to scare most people away. Good anytime, really. Even thinking about it makes me want to stop over there right now... Addendum: They only take cash. An annoyance, but it certainly doesn't ruin the experience.
(5)Hilda E.
Love this place, been going for years. Although the wings are small at times...they are big other times. I don't really care about the size because the sauce is amazing....LITERALLY the best I ever had. Buffalo chips aka waffle fries are awesome...always freshly made. RC washes it all down fantastically. Missing 1 star because it is really dirty in that place. It wouldn't hurt to grab a rag and scrub it all down. Seriously. The decor is not bothersome but the dirt is a bit.
(4)Joyce L.
You can feel your arteries clogging with each bite of a hot wing, but your taste buds will be in euphoria. This is by far, the best buffalo wing place I've ever eaten at, and I have eaten at many a wing place since I grew teeth. We LOVE this place and make it a point to stop by every time we're in Chicago. Why does Chicago have all the yummy food??? THEY ONLY TAKE CASH.
(5)Madeline H.
Oh my god, junk food does not get any better than Buffalo Joes. I found Buff Joe's through a coworker who recommended I cure my hangover by walking over to this low-key Clark St. location for one of their oh so devilishly greasy burgers. My hangover was instantly cured. Upon returning to work my coworker told me "Now that you've tried the worst thing on the menu, you've got to go back and try what they're famous for: their chicken wings." Let me tell you, that burger was definitely delicious, but my coworker was right, you gotta go for the wings, I cannot express to you how good they are. My best friend and I got here at least once a month on Sunday afternoons to get our wings fix and it is always a delightful experience. Somehow the wings are both crispy and moist and the sauce is out of this world. Spicy is definitely the sauce to order and don't worry it isn't that hot (I am terrible at handling spice and I love it). If you're looking for something sweeter try mild, and if you're a big spice person you have the options of hot and suicide. Also make sure to order the buffalo chips and extra ranch and a gutbuster RC to quench your thirst. Hands down this place is my favorite place to eat in Evanston if not the whole north side, in fact I have to limit the number of times I allow myself to eat here because if I don't it would be an everyday event. The decor is nothing special but it totally fits the atmosphere of the joint. In fact, my friends and I have this theory that if a joint that sells burgers, hot dogs, or wings looks kind of dingy and crappy on the inside, then chances are you're gonna get a great meal and at Buff Joe's this is totally true. On any given day you'll find the place full of college students from both Northwestern and Loyola, families, and locals gathering for a good meal and whatever sporting event is on TV.
(5)Nate L.
Not bad place for wings in my opinion. Their spicy wings with jalapenos on top... it really hit the spot. not too hot but it was perfectly balanced. Not a good place if you have a big group. Not enough tables for group of 10.
(4)Douchee D.
I have a friend who is a Northwestern alumni, and it was her who brought me up to Evanston to visit Buffalo Joe's for the first time to try the best wings on the planet. They are without a doubt the best wings I have ever tasted. Now, correct me if I'm wrong ( actually don't ), but these wings don't taste like authentic buffalo style wings. There is a kind of mustardy zing to them, and they serve ranch dressing on the side as apposed to blue cheese dressing. These wings are on the wet side, which is messy and not good for first dates, but how are we kidding; if you're bringing your first date here you're a cheap or poor bastard. Actually, that sounded mean. It could be kind of cute, if it was presented the right way. Oh, just go for it! The waffle cut fries and cheese are addicting. I hope to God no one in my neighborhood starts doing their fries this way, or I'll be as big as a house by year's end. There are other interesting thing that I see going on on other people's trays, but I'm just there for the wings and waffle cut cheese fries.
(4)Kate W.
I'm only commenting on the wings here... I grew up in Upstate NY, near Buffalo, and worked at a pizza place in high school that made buffalo wings. I know how they're made, and I know what makes them authentic... therefore I'm VERY picky when it comes to wings. This place gets 3 stars only because it's the closest I've come to decent wings in Chicago. They are far from good though. They deep fry the wings which is good, too many places don't. Their sauce is just ok though. Real Buffalo sauce is the easiest thing ever to make, it's just Frank's Red Hot and butter (adjust butter amounts for mild, medium or hot). The sauce here is obviously not authentic and has too much vinegar. They also need to make the wings bigger, the ones we got were pretty small. Lastly, what's with the ranch dipping sauce?! You have to serve blue cheese sauce with hot wings... it's the law.
(3)B T.
Grat place. Only takes cash. Super busy. Love the cheese fries and suicide wings
(4)Justin S.
So after a less than thrilling meal at Dixie kitchen I was still full. So off to this wing location that was being spoken of quite highly. I am hoping that what I was served was just off and not the normal fare they serve their customers. The buffalo sauce was lousy, too much vinegar, who knows but it seemed completely off that I couldn't even finish one wing. This place seems to be reserved in the college days, I'm drunk and hungry area. Lets face it after copious amounts of alcohol one will hardly notice nor care the off sauce in these wings.
(1)Juan A.
the greatest of all time!! best wings, best cheddar chips, best ranch!! This place is so good youll forget the rest. many people might find there reason to complain because wings are small but you get enough to fill you up. Its all about flavor and texture and BJ's does it better than most. Whether you are a wing fan or a flavor fan buff joes is the way to go!
(5)Charles W.
Wings were solid. Nothing great, nothing bad. However, they had lots of good 50 cent vending machines so I got my money's worth out of my pocket change! I ended up walking out of Buffalo Joe's with a glow-in-the-dark crucifix and a handful of sprees!
(3)Sonesh S.
Suicide wings quite possibly are the best in the city. honestly, they are that good. I've been eating here for over 10 years now, and while their wings have gotten a bit smaller, the sauce is just as good, and the service still amazes me. The ambiance sucks. Take your food to go...its a terrible place to dine. If you do stay, get a beer. Oh, and get a party pan of celery and ranch...a great way to complement your meal
(5)Lale S.
My mom worked in Evanston when I was a child, that is when I had my first experience at Buffalo Joes. I have gone there so much with friends and family since my teen years, the manager/owner there knows me by name. Buff Joes has the greatest wings I have ever had, not only does the wing itself rival other places, but the sauce is what puts them over the top!!! I could take a order of wings, cheddar chips and a mega gutbuster of RC anyday of the week! Ive even ordered trays from here for parties ive thrown! I highly recommend this place to anyone!
(5)Chris T.
Hands down the best chicken wings on the planet.! There is a Mash episode where Peirce gets a hankering for some ribs from some rib joint and has them express mail the Mash 4077 a box of ribs. Well this is the kind of place where I would do that if I was stuck in a war zone halfway across the world. I graduated from Northwestern in 01 and still think about the amazing wings at Buffalo Joe's. I disagree with the comments about too much sauce. The sauce is the best part. Every time I go to Chicago I have to stop up in Evanston for their wings.
(5)Sangorama s.
I can't imagine any wings being better than BJs. Most other wings taste like the frozen bag of wings you can get at Costco - they're not bad at all, just not all that impressive. We've been going to this place since for over 20 years now and we always get the mild. Don't get me wrong, we love spicy food, but you get the full flavor and enjoyment of the sauce with the mild. You can ask for spicy sauce on the side if you've got to have it. Not exactly sure what kind of freakish, butt burning death wish you have when you order suicide. You know that stuff has to come out of your body at the other end right? If you're not a wings guy then try the buffalo cheddar burger. It's dang good. Same sauce on a fat ole burger with kaukauna cheese spread (is that stuff real cheese?). The soft bun will soak up all the lovely burger juice and deteriorate before you finish so get lots of napkins. Prices are steadily rising and portions steadily getting smaller. There was a time a couple of years ago that the quality of the wings, the chicken itself, was pretty poor and everything was being overcooked and all dried out but they seem to have gotten past that lately. I have to eat here every visit to Chicago.
(5)Johanna C.
Before having a Buffalo Joe's wing, I had no interest in ordering wings at a restaurant or having them at parties. I've had one here and there and never understood what the big deal was. A friend kept raving about how I would crave BuJoe's wings if I try them. Sadly, he was right! The sauce is really really tasty. You get a fair amount of meat on them. I like them soaked up in the sauce so the meat falls off the bone, which is usually the way you will get them in their busy hours. I went here late on a Friday night once (yay, they close at midnight on Friday and Saturday nights!) and the wings were on the crispier side. Not bad but different. A single order of wings will set you back about $7 and a double order about $11. That includes wings, celery and ranch dressing. The ranch tends to be more on the watery side but does the trick. The Buffalo Chips (waffle fries) are also very good, probably because they are waffle fries. The only other meal I've had here is the hot dogs on special. Don't get that. You may as well just make it at home. Just go to Hot Doug's if you want a hot dog! Bottom line - order the wings! Supposedly the burger is good as well but I can't get myself to order anything but the wings...
(4)Neil A.
Maybe they would have gotten more stars if they were willing to sell me wings. Basically, whenever I have called, they aren't taking orders for pick-up until time X... Call back, still not taking orders... (and repeat). Maybe I should just eat there, but the place looks disgusting, and I like dirty pizzeria pizza - so maybe the wings are great - but I don't think I'll ever find out.
(1)A.J. M.
What needs to be said? Wings are wings, and Joes has got em and does them very very well. Hell, they even have some beer on tap here. Oh, and try out the waffle fries some time. They're pretty awesome too.
(4)Gigi L.
That's right, I'm giving it five stars, people. I only come here once a year. On my birthday, which is in May. In February I start marking the days off with a "x" with my black sharpie pen, as the anticipation builds. I can't come here more than that, because then I might be dead. Maybe not quite dead, but I KNOW my butt wouldn't fit through as many doorways. It is delicious though. Spicy as hell, well really as spicy as you want. Sometimes I like it when my head blows off. You get a really generous portion of tender, perfectly textured chicken pieces that melt in your mouth. And then it catches on fire. But then you dip into that blue cheese sauce. And then all is right with the world. Actually, your mouth is still burning, but you can drink milk to clear that right up. They have these amazing waffle fries that you can get with that Merkt's-type cheddar sauce on top. It isn't really saucey, it's more creamy and thick. On top of those hot golden potatoes, it actually is like a religious experience. I am coming back as a fry in my next life. The place is dingy and dirty, and everything is covered in a fine layer of grease. You come out stinking like a vat of oil where tremendously tasty things have been cooked for your eating pleasure. Good times.
(5)Chris J.
Wow, totally going down hill. The wings are still great, but everything else is sub par. If this were a new business attempting to open up shop, it wouldn't stand a chance. They've been coasting on their reputation for at least a few years now. You would be well advised to wear blinders so as not to see the dirty conditions and just get to the wings, but you would never be able to place an order. Instead of a "welcome" or "how can I help you?", you get a surely look and silence. This has happened several times now, so it isn't a case of one server having a bad day. They finally repainted the "dining area" and got new tabletops, but its still in need of a fair amount of cleaning.
(1)Conor M.
I've been going to Buff Joe's since I was in high school and honestly it used to be better. I love the wing sauce and the cheddar chips (caveat with those: eat them first because if you don't the cheese will solidify and it's a bit unappetizing) but the quality of the chicken has decreased significantly. But, hell they're still tasty and where else is there an RC machine?
(4)Ira U.
What can I say? Greatest wings ever! Great Cheese Fries. I hear they have other food but I don't really see the point.
(5)Edward H.
Lookout arteries, here they come! Even though it's been about a decade since my first visit to Joe's, I still remember my first suicide wings/gut buster combo - *and queue flashback* Buffalo Joe's quakes as a "HOLY CRAP! I can't feel my toungue!" echoes throughout the place followed by an "AHHHH" after a sip out of the gut buster (you'd think it's the sauce but it's actually the soda - maybe should be more aptly named the gut *builder*). The Evanston Joe's (not to be confused with the one on Howard) serves up the some of the best spicy buffalo wings around Chicago. The wings are complimented by great waffle fries and various char-broiled burgers. If you're feeling hungry, try and split one of their party trays with a friend or 3. They taste just as good reheated out of the oven. Use their suicide sauce with caution. I remember getting an order of waffle fries with suicide sauce and watching the sauce eat through the styrofoam container.
(4)Paul A.
Anywhere I go, I always try the wings. Although I've had some great wings at a number of places, I always end up ranking Buffalo Joe's as one of the best I have ever had. They seem to have shrunk in size over the years, but I've noticed the same thing at a lot of other places too (in particular Buffalo Wild Wings - their wings look like they came off a sickly hamster). Regardless, a damn fine wing and exceptional sauce. You get ranch instead of blue cheese and I actually prefer that. I live downtown and I make the trek to Evanston for these babies almost once a month. The only con: cash only.
(5)Hope Z.
I was severely disappointed. Maybe Im a wing snob. Maybe I expect more from my buffalo sauce than spice. I have heard so many rave reviews about this place and my fiance and I walked out thinking "eh" There was no flavor to the sauce. It was an oily mess. the "cheddar" on the "cheddar fries" was lacking in cheese taste. it was like yellowish paste. Its rare I pass up a cheese fry order. It ruined what would have been great waffle fries. The only redeeming quality of this place is the breading. I had the chicken tenders, and the breading was fantastic. But it certainly wasn't worth driving to Evanston over.
(3)kelly c.
Yes! Don't waste your time on the other Joe's - this is the one that knows! Great wings and other sundries. I should probably warn that this isn't a high class place with quality ingredients - it's pretty low brow, but that's part of the charming novelty. For me, this Buffalo Joe's venue is well worth the hike up north.
(4)Rob S.
I've been eating here since I first got my drivers license in 2004. Evanston was always the place to head to Friday nights and Buff Joes was the place to hit up for wings. Over the years though, I have found that the faces inside the place haven't changed, but the quality of the wing has. On my last visit, I felt like prices went up, my single order of suicide wings left me half full (in the past I would feel good after 1 single order), and the size of the wings are small compared to other wing establishments. I still like Buffalo Joes and will still eat there every once in a while out of nostalgia, but it would be nice if they invested in some meatier wings.
(3)Amanda T.
My friends from Evanston and the other surrounding North Shore suburbs have been RAVING about Buffalo Joe's for who knows how long. So, naturally, I was more than excited to see what this place was all about. My anticipation grew once we got there after seeing reviews from nationally acclaimed critics posted all up and down the walls. When I took my first bite into the chicken wing, I wasn't impressed. It wasn't bad, but it was pretty much like buffalo wild wings, maybe it had a little more meat, but that's about it. The cheese on the baked potato I got was horrible!! It looked like it was made from concentrated powdered cheese mixed with water. Like the kind that comes with a box of mac and cheese, only worse. Even my high school served better cheese than that! Two of my other friends (who were also Buffalo Joe's virgins) agreed with me. The food is really cheap and the orders are huge, I'll give them that. But it really didn't do it for me. I tried my best to like Buffalo Joe's, but I couldn't. Sorry...
(2)Esther Y.
BJ's has been a part of my life since my first visit to Evanston back in the day. Amazing. They are completely no nonsense here. Order your wings, see them toss it in your sauce, order your fries, pick it up, gorge. Of course, eating wings brings out two very distinct competitions to show that you can either eat like a real man (this applies to guys and girls). One competition is who can eat the hottest sauce. Not a good idea. Go for the middle. That way you can still enjoy the wing and you don't have to fill your stomach unnecessarily with your beverage. The second competition is who can eat the most wings. Again, unless there is money riding on it, you can pass. You will end up eating way too much and then hate yourself quietly as you lie in the fetal position.
(5)Emily C.
Buffalo wings are one of my favorite foods. Quite the opposite of most connoisseurs, I am pretty tolerant to differences in size and flavor. I really haven't met any I didn't like for some reason or another, so naturally, I am inclined to be lenient on wing places. I see the benefits of Hooters, BW3, and likewise, I can speak to the appeal of Buffalo Joe's. You go in and order; the people behind the counter goof with you and give you a hard time in a funny way, which is bascially like spending time with my family and therefore makes me feel at home. They made fun of me for wearing a surf shop shirt in Chicago; haha...point taken. Anyhow, you wait for less than 10 minutes, then you get cardboard containers full of wings with ranch sauce (no bleu cheese, which is their weakest link, if you ask me), and celery. We also ordered the waffle cut cheese fries. The wings? Totally smothered in sauce. Some people on here seem to not like that, but I'm all for it. The hot sauce is a little garlicky and had just enough bite to kick me in the mouth a little without turning me into a Tums commercial. It was pretty darn good to dip celery in after the wings were gone. The ranch? A little thin, but okay. Again, kind of sad there's no bleu cheese but it had a nice flavor at least. The fries? Covered in some kind of bizarro processed cheese that I wanted so badly not to like because it was obviously fake...but failed. The stuff was delicious. It was sort of like EZ Cheez or Velveeta in that it should be gross but it's amazing. I'd go back.
(4)Jon J.
They're the best wings that I've had in Chicago - meaty, properly saucey, and not too fried. Basically, they're perfect! The counter service can be terribly slow, though. But really, it's a divey, greasy, corner of any god's wing-filled heaven. What do you expect? As a funny anecdote, I saw a guy order a pint of ranch sauce here. That's it. NASTY!
(4)TJ W.
Buffalo Joe's got some bangin' chicken wings! This used to be my spot in high school...I often made it a weekly ritual, until I found out that my metabolism isn't as great as it used to be. lol They have a few locations, but I prefer the drive to Evanston rather than going on Howard. Their mild and bbq wings are sick!!!!! If you're a chicken fanatic then Buffalo Joe's is the place!
(5)Dan K.
Stopped in here a while back, because everyone said how authentic their Buffalo wings were. Being a wing snob from Buffalo, I had to check it out. Boy, did they stink. They were small little things, with a sauce that tasted nothing like true Buffalo chicken wings and they served friggin Ranch dressing! I'm sorry, but if you're going to claim to serve authentic Buffalo style chicken wings, you serve Blue Cheese not ranch dressing. Piss-poor in my book.
(1)Chanita S.
I love this place. I don't care what anyone else thinks, but I've been going here since I was in high school--my Friday tradition. I wouldn't compare it to Popeye's because Popeye's isn't saucy fried chicken and they're not necessarily a wing place nor would I compare it to Hooter's because their breading is different. I love BJ's wings though because of their sauce and crispy wings. Their waffle fries are pretty amazing as well. Make sure to bring a bib because you will get sauce all over you which isn't really a bad thing here. The only downside is that they don't accept cash, but there is an ATM machine inside.
(5)Annie Y.
I haven't been to Buff Joe's in over 4 years, but I remember their wings being amazing - big, juicy, and cooked to perfection. I've heard since I left Chicago that they've gotten much smaller, so consider the four stars a rating for memories of times past.
(4)Amber J.
Am Huge Buffalo wings fan, could eat them everyday of the week. (And in college i pretty much did). However when i first drove by Buffalo Joe's with friends i was alittle apprehensive. It seemed a little hole -in-the wall-ish and there was a line out the door. When we actually got in there it was crowded as heck with literally no available seating. 2 of us lurked for a open table while the other person ordered. We finally got a 2 seater table though there were three of us. Then i embarked on of the greatest buffalo wing experiences of my life. The flavor, sigh...We ate wing and wings and more wings and thought we were all full we ate even more wings. I highly recommend - the only drawback is limited seating in the restauraunt. I will definetley be back.
(5)David P.
I like the suicide wings with the jalepeno peppers but its a bit of false advertising. The wings aren't over the top spicy but have a good flavor. From this place, I actually prefer the BBQ wings. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and tanginess. As someone from Buffalo, these wings rank pretty high in the Chicago-land area.
(4)Swapna P.
Cheap, greasy wings that hit just the spot when you have a craving. I think you get a lot more wings in a single order to-go than by staying there. The spicy wings are just the right amount of spicy. By far, my favorite wing spot in Evanston. The burgers are decent as well.
(4)Sasha R.
The waffle fries are amazing but the service ranges from rude as hell to indifferent. If I could send someone in to get my food for me, I'd be happy.
(2)Stacey A.
Greatest. Buffalo. Chicken. Sandwich. Of. All. Time. It *might* burn your face off, though. If that's your thing, then you're good to go. If not....maybe don't order the hottest sauce they have.
(4)Eric V.
Buff Joe's has been an ol' favorite ever since my high school days. The spicy wings have great flavor with a nice touch of heat. The cheddar chips are a must, along with a "gutbuster" 7Up to wash it all down. The dining room always has the strange scent of cleaning solution and the bathrooms kinda scare me, but the food is worth it. Don't forget, cash only!!
(4)Jonathan K.
Suicide wings, w jalapenos if ur down with having flavor in ur food. cheddar chips are 100% cheddar cheese dumped on criss-cut fries. buffalo wings were good too. no frills, just wings and a place to eat them. and a tv.
(5)David S.
From 2000-2004 I loved this place dearly ... since it was my only outlet for cheap wings while at Northwestern. I went often enough that I didn't have to tell them what I wanted most times (single suicide, fries and extra ranch) which was pretty nice. The wings aren't super meaty but the sauce is tangy (I really don't think any sauce below suicide is all that hot - one time they had a special XXX sauce that killed me before I could finish my wings though). The place itself is pretty grimey though - I felt like taking a shower every time I rolled out of there since every surface seems to have a few years worth of grease on it. Verdict: Great college place to grab cheap and relatively delicious wings, but the one time I've been back since made me a little sick.
(3)Jacob K.
I used to love this place years ago unfortunately the quality has gone down drastically. The chicken is not so fresh and sometimes even has broken bones. The last time I went there the wings were warm (not hot) and the only way to make the wings hotter was adding pickled jalapenos. The prices are not great either... this place only survives because of the reputation it has and because there isn't much competition for good wings in the area.
(2)Deez D.
I would give this place negative stars if I could. I had wings taste better from Costco. If you decide to sit way back by the window, you will smell rotten garbage while eating your meal. The only thing good about this place are the waffle fries. I didn't believe all the people who gave this place a bad rating but now I understand and hope that this will help others. People who gave this place a good rating should really get out more.
(1)Joel F.
There is a deity in the chicken world and his name is Joe. Chickens line up to die at the hand of Joe to be blessedly cooked and eaten at this establishment. I know that I would if I were a chicken. The waffle fries rock, too :)
(5)Grace L.
As my husband said it best, they are the best wings in Chicago, bar none. Yes, crave them, love them, and fill your arteries with them. Go get em wings.
(5)Joshua D.
There is one major problem with Buffalo Joe's: Once you eat their wings, you will enter a world where suddenly all wings from anywhere else aren't as good. You will forever say, "these are no Buffalo Joes" Even the best of the best you might say,"Damn these are Great!!! But, they're no Buffalo Joe's.". So, if you simply want the best then do it...but don't say I didn't warn you.
(5)Amy W.
Not a fan... I don't like their wings and there isn't much else to choose from. The Mexican potato is a decent alternative. Cash only, blah!
(2)Peter M.
The wings here are culinary crack. Highly addictive, make you feel great at first, terrible for your health, you're willing to drive 30 min+ for them when the alternative might be 5 min away. After Hurricane Katrina they stopped serving wings because the Louisiana-based hot sauce couldn't be delivered. Jalapino soaked suicide wings aren't for everyone but the mild and hot are amazing. Celery and ranch on the side. I often sent a friend to pick up some of their wing sauce then cooked store bought chicken at home, healthier but just as excellent. Once my roomate and I went in and he ordered a "double pan" while I insisted we get a "double order." He was positively confused and sure enough they handed us a $55 double pan which is clearly for a Superbowl party of 8-12 people rather than the 24-wing double order that we should have had. Day 1) That night we probably took down in the aggregate 45 wings. The rest were covered and put into the fridge. Days 2-3) I ate about 12 a day and he might have had about 6. Day 4) We decide to put the last 30 wings or so into the garage (mid-winter Chicago) and, no joke, we would bring out a plate to eat some cold and warmed up. When finished they were just as good 4 days earlier. Day 5-7) Didn't want to live anymore. Considered digging my own grave. Possible long term liver damage. Now I'm in Beverly Hills land of the organic cooked in omega-3 oil "cheesesteak hoagie," and the best wings come from Papa John's. Maybe that's a good thing but I will one day make the pilgrimage back.
(5)