Super surprised this place only has three stars. Their pizza is by far the best pizza I have had around the Orlando area. My boyfriend and I always order on Tuesdays because they have a buy one "14 pizza get one free. Their cheese is absolutely amazing and it's always so fresh.
(5)
Thomas E.
Ordered a medium pizza with extra cheese for delivery to my hotel room (Double Tree). It was delivered exactly when they said and it was hot and ready to eat. My favorite style of Pizza is NY style but in my experience many places who advertise NY style is far from it. Brooklyn Pizza is the real deal. If your favorite, like mine, is NY style look no other place in Orlando this is the best you will find.
(5)
Monica S.
So sad I just moved away from this place. Best pizza in Orlando. Wings are good, too. But do not pass up this place for pizza if you are in the area. So cheesy. So delicious. My mouth is watering just thinking about it.
(5)
Curtis B.
Ordered here for lunch for the second time, first time I ordered was a thin crust pizza, soggy and not a lot of flavor now the second time I ordered the veal parmesan it came dry no flavor just a little bit of sauce. I just ripped up the menu and will never eat there again, flavorful food is what I'm looking for if I wanted Stouffer's quality I will go to Publix to the frozen section
(1)
Lenore F.
I dashed in here before work today and got a cheese slice and a Bianca slice to go. The service is super quick and the menu is vast. I've got to say, the pizza is decent, but I think to give more than three stars I'll have to try the slices when they are fresh and not reheated. I will say, though, that the Bianca pizza has generous dollops of seasoned ricotta on it, and that always makes me happy.
(3)
Seth M.
Despite the yelp email to the contrary... Orlando is a desert for pizza. Brooklyn pizza is as decent a slice as I have come across since I have been here. A great place for a lunch slice. Whole pies are even better if you are with a group and have the time Staff is very friendly. They will actually get to know your name!
(3)
Chris M.
If you like poor service, hair in your food, 9 wings for the price of 10, a ridiculously long wait and just not getting your entire order, than you will LOVE Brooklyn Pizza. Their pizza is not too bad, but it is hardly worth the price you pay for it. Their wings were fairly tasteless, but were fresh. Two problems, the basic skill of counting eludes the cook but he did make up for that by adding hair. Thanks! The service over the phone wouldn't fly at the DMV, and instead of acknowledging a couple of honest mistakes and working to resolve them, the 'gentleman' I reached via phone was too high or just generally did not care to do anything about it. I will say the delivery driver was polite on the bright side. Overall, the restaurant business is thankfully competitive so places like this one will eventually find their rightful place in court for bankruptcy. My recommendation, if you want the pizza you expected from this place call Broadway. I have been going there for years but decided to try this place because their prices seemed similar and they were much closer. Oops. I look forward to seeing a for rent sign in your window soon Brooklyn Pizza! :) -Chris
(1)
Samantha M.
We love their Crazy Tuesday special for $14... Great value, great pizza! We love their pizza by the slice and having a seat inside. They even have Cheerwine, my favorite soda! Great NY taste!
(5)
Aaron B.
Still my go to place for pizza at least once a week, usually for lunch to get a slice or two or special ( 2 cheese slices + drink $4.95 ) Damn good and very nice people. Bad reviews are from tourists it seems that are usually the cardboard pizzahut crowd.
(4)
Ayanna C.
I'm not from Orlando but every time I come down to visit my brother I just have to make a point to get me a couple of slices of pizza, I'm never disappointed cause where I'm from it's very hard to find authentic or half descent Brooklyn style pizza.
(4)
Dream B.
I live in an apartment complex and they are always leaving signs on the door so I decided to try it one day. I ordered buffalo wings which were delicious. They followed directions on how I wanted the sauce, the wings were nice and crisp and didnt have that "blubbery" texture that wings at major chains like Domino's has. Authenitc ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Here is the bad part: I ordered a Chicken Aldredo pizza and while the flavours were there the actual pizza itself was hard and tough to bite it was like eating beef jerky. Another gripe I had with the pizza is that they carelessly toss GIGANTIC rings of onions all over the pizza. Under the cheese, over the cheese, and interwined throughout. I am a grown woman and I was disgusted with the size of onions tossed on the pizza my 6 year old nephew almost went ballistic! Onions are fine but should be chopped finely not tossed on a hard bed of dough masquerading as a pizza.
(2)
Alicia D.
Average/good Pizza....Very dirty restaurant, all the food is super greasy though...and Why would you not accept a credit card over the phone??? Thankfully the pizza place across the street does!
(1)
Karalee M.
I have been a customer of Brooklyn Pizza forever and last night I ordered a meatball and chicken parmesan sub. I end up getting a meatball pizza and chicken parmesan sub.When I place the order I asked if they had whole wheat subs. They replied no so I said ok. When the driver arrived I told him I did not order a pizza, I did not even know they had meatball pizzas. He told me if I kept the order it would be 30% off my next order and he was going to call in also, When I called Tyler the person who took my order answered and when I was placeing my order he was talking and carrying on with other people. When I told him the order was incorrect an and the driver told me I could get 30% off my next order he told me the driver doesn't decide how much!! Way to go Tyler you have lost a customer over 10%. I called back to speak to a manager and I did not recognize Tyler's voice when he answered and he told nme he was the manager so when I started explaining the problem and mentiioned his name then he tells me he is Tyler, during this time another fake manager grabs the phone and tells me he's Armando. What a really professional guy. He says to me what do you want lady? I explained and he told me to be quiet. You might have been busy last night but if I have anything to do with it that won't continue.
(1)
Mad G.
We were staying near the airport for one night and needed a quick meal. After reading some of the reviews we found on Yelp and other sites, we decided on a pizza from Brooklyn Pizza. They were running a special on 16 inch, 1 topping pizzas, so we ordered one. The total was $11.50 including tax and we picked it up. This was very greasy pizza (it actually dripped from the sides), but the crust was good. The sauce was average. I would choose another place if I had to choose again.
(2)
Justin W.
Very cheap and authentic NY style pizza. When you go in, the staff are all relocated New Yorkers who are very proud of their "pies"! It's the type of dive that you pick up from and not dine in though since the place is loud and a bit disheveled.
(5)
Gareth Q.
Meat Lover's with Salami instead of Bacon. Eat it there! Anyway, having been in NYC 14yrs, this is the only place so far I know that's close to NYC style pizza.
(3)
John L.
Other reviewer described it well, it really is a hole in the wall, the place is filthy and service is really bad. Don't understand why people say this place is good.
(2)
Cassandra W.
I can't believe that there are people who love this place! I have tried it twice. I really didn't want to go back after the first time, but I gave the place the benefit of the doubt, thinking perhaps they'd just had a bad day. Nope! The crust is so thin it's pitiful, and they are unbelievably stingy with the tomato sauce. At first I thought they'd forgotten the sauce, but you lift up the cheese and you see a microscopic smear of it there. If paper-thin crust and tiny sauce smears make you think "Mmm mmm good!", then this is the place for you! If this is NY-style pizza, they can keep it up in NY, and I'll be sure not to eat any pizza if I go to NY.
(1)
Sergio P.
I have been eating here for over 15 years, mostly take out. I have eaten inside exactly 3 times. It has always been consistently great! Staff is "Brooklyn Friendly" if you're not from New York or Jersey, you won't understand....LMFAO. Lets just say, they make you feel at home. Just a little slice of Brooklyn in my neighborhood.......Than you guys for great service and food throughout the years! Keep up the GREAT work!
(5)
Nate B.
It's hard to screw up pizza, and these guys do NOT screw it up. It's good. The slices are huge. The prices are reasonable. The taste is... well, it's the taste of pizza. It's exactly what you'd expect from a divey Brooklyn pizza joint. I'll be back to stuff my face, and that's no joke. Oh yeah, the cookies are amazing. Eat one.
(4)
Jeff O.
Yelp is advising me to update my review on Brooklyn Pizza. I think it's very timely, as I visited this pizzeria today and a few things have changed since my last review. The slices are still great. The people are nice. The decor is the same. The prices however went up yesterday, and I think it's across the board. The 2 cheese slice/soda combo is now $5.50. Still a good deal, until you add a topping to the slices. Somehow my combo was $7.19 today, and it wasn't a mistake. Apparently if you add a topping to the slices, it nullifies the combo deal and you end up paying a la carte. I think this is BS, and the owner needs to fix this or he's gonna hear complaints six ways to sunset. I still enjoy going here, but I may have to give up toppings for the basic 2-cheese slice deal. :/
(4)
Rob W.
This is typical strip shopping center NY style pizza. They use electric ovens, so they can't get a very crispy crust. A little light on the sauce and heavy on the cheese, so its a bit greasy. Not bad, but not memorable.
(2)
Lauren K.
I am currently staying at the Hilton Garden Inn, waiting to leave in the morning on my honeymoon. I am very hungry and very sad. We ordered some food from Brooklyn Pizza around 7 p.m. Called back around 8 to follow up, since they quoted 30-45 minutes, and after being put on hold for a while, they said the driver had just left and it would be 10 minutes. 45 minutes later, we called again and no one answered. We called AGAIN and were told that someone called to cancel our order a little while before. Very unprofessional... it took the guy on the phone 15 minutes to get our initial order, between us having to repeat our room number five times to having to find the address to getting put on hold. And now we will wait for another delivery. Thanks for the memories, Brooklyn!
(1)
Janene H.
I've never actually been inside the restaurant but always get the food delivered. The pizza is good but my co-workers and I are really fans of the wraps. The turkey wrap is a good bet and the calzones are very large. My favorite item has to be the cannoli. I have tried to find the best cannolis in Orlando and Brooklyn Pizza's are it.
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : Yes Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Lunch, Dinner Parking : Private Lot Bike Parking : No Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : No Outdoor Seating : No Wi-Fi : Free Has TV : Yes Waiter Service : No
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
Shantal H.
Super surprised this place only has three stars. Their pizza is by far the best pizza I have had around the Orlando area. My boyfriend and I always order on Tuesdays because they have a buy one "14 pizza get one free. Their cheese is absolutely amazing and it's always so fresh.
(5)Thomas E.
Ordered a medium pizza with extra cheese for delivery to my hotel room (Double Tree). It was delivered exactly when they said and it was hot and ready to eat. My favorite style of Pizza is NY style but in my experience many places who advertise NY style is far from it. Brooklyn Pizza is the real deal. If your favorite, like mine, is NY style look no other place in Orlando this is the best you will find.
(5)Monica S.
So sad I just moved away from this place. Best pizza in Orlando. Wings are good, too. But do not pass up this place for pizza if you are in the area. So cheesy. So delicious. My mouth is watering just thinking about it.
(5)Curtis B.
Ordered here for lunch for the second time, first time I ordered was a thin crust pizza, soggy and not a lot of flavor now the second time I ordered the veal parmesan it came dry no flavor just a little bit of sauce. I just ripped up the menu and will never eat there again, flavorful food is what I'm looking for if I wanted Stouffer's quality I will go to Publix to the frozen section
(1)Lenore F.
I dashed in here before work today and got a cheese slice and a Bianca slice to go. The service is super quick and the menu is vast. I've got to say, the pizza is decent, but I think to give more than three stars I'll have to try the slices when they are fresh and not reheated. I will say, though, that the Bianca pizza has generous dollops of seasoned ricotta on it, and that always makes me happy.
(3)Seth M.
Despite the yelp email to the contrary... Orlando is a desert for pizza. Brooklyn pizza is as decent a slice as I have come across since I have been here. A great place for a lunch slice. Whole pies are even better if you are with a group and have the time Staff is very friendly. They will actually get to know your name!
(3)Chris M.
If you like poor service, hair in your food, 9 wings for the price of 10, a ridiculously long wait and just not getting your entire order, than you will LOVE Brooklyn Pizza. Their pizza is not too bad, but it is hardly worth the price you pay for it. Their wings were fairly tasteless, but were fresh. Two problems, the basic skill of counting eludes the cook but he did make up for that by adding hair. Thanks! The service over the phone wouldn't fly at the DMV, and instead of acknowledging a couple of honest mistakes and working to resolve them, the 'gentleman' I reached via phone was too high or just generally did not care to do anything about it. I will say the delivery driver was polite on the bright side. Overall, the restaurant business is thankfully competitive so places like this one will eventually find their rightful place in court for bankruptcy. My recommendation, if you want the pizza you expected from this place call Broadway. I have been going there for years but decided to try this place because their prices seemed similar and they were much closer. Oops. I look forward to seeing a for rent sign in your window soon Brooklyn Pizza! :) -Chris
(1)Samantha M.
We love their Crazy Tuesday special for $14... Great value, great pizza! We love their pizza by the slice and having a seat inside. They even have Cheerwine, my favorite soda! Great NY taste!
(5)Aaron B.
Still my go to place for pizza at least once a week, usually for lunch to get a slice or two or special ( 2 cheese slices + drink $4.95 ) Damn good and very nice people. Bad reviews are from tourists it seems that are usually the cardboard pizzahut crowd.
(4)Ayanna C.
I'm not from Orlando but every time I come down to visit my brother I just have to make a point to get me a couple of slices of pizza, I'm never disappointed cause where I'm from it's very hard to find authentic or half descent Brooklyn style pizza.
(4)Dream B.
I live in an apartment complex and they are always leaving signs on the door so I decided to try it one day. I ordered buffalo wings which were delicious. They followed directions on how I wanted the sauce, the wings were nice and crisp and didnt have that "blubbery" texture that wings at major chains like Domino's has. Authenitc ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Here is the bad part: I ordered a Chicken Aldredo pizza and while the flavours were there the actual pizza itself was hard and tough to bite it was like eating beef jerky. Another gripe I had with the pizza is that they carelessly toss GIGANTIC rings of onions all over the pizza. Under the cheese, over the cheese, and interwined throughout. I am a grown woman and I was disgusted with the size of onions tossed on the pizza my 6 year old nephew almost went ballistic! Onions are fine but should be chopped finely not tossed on a hard bed of dough masquerading as a pizza.
(2)Alicia D.
Average/good Pizza....Very dirty restaurant, all the food is super greasy though...and Why would you not accept a credit card over the phone??? Thankfully the pizza place across the street does!
(1)Karalee M.
I have been a customer of Brooklyn Pizza forever and last night I ordered a meatball and chicken parmesan sub. I end up getting a meatball pizza and chicken parmesan sub.When I place the order I asked if they had whole wheat subs. They replied no so I said ok. When the driver arrived I told him I did not order a pizza, I did not even know they had meatball pizzas. He told me if I kept the order it would be 30% off my next order and he was going to call in also, When I called Tyler the person who took my order answered and when I was placeing my order he was talking and carrying on with other people. When I told him the order was incorrect an and the driver told me I could get 30% off my next order he told me the driver doesn't decide how much!! Way to go Tyler you have lost a customer over 10%. I called back to speak to a manager and I did not recognize Tyler's voice when he answered and he told nme he was the manager so when I started explaining the problem and mentiioned his name then he tells me he is Tyler, during this time another fake manager grabs the phone and tells me he's Armando. What a really professional guy. He says to me what do you want lady? I explained and he told me to be quiet. You might have been busy last night but if I have anything to do with it that won't continue.
(1)Mad G.
We were staying near the airport for one night and needed a quick meal. After reading some of the reviews we found on Yelp and other sites, we decided on a pizza from Brooklyn Pizza. They were running a special on 16 inch, 1 topping pizzas, so we ordered one. The total was $11.50 including tax and we picked it up. This was very greasy pizza (it actually dripped from the sides), but the crust was good. The sauce was average. I would choose another place if I had to choose again.
(2)Justin W.
Very cheap and authentic NY style pizza. When you go in, the staff are all relocated New Yorkers who are very proud of their "pies"! It's the type of dive that you pick up from and not dine in though since the place is loud and a bit disheveled.
(5)Gareth Q.
Meat Lover's with Salami instead of Bacon. Eat it there! Anyway, having been in NYC 14yrs, this is the only place so far I know that's close to NYC style pizza.
(3)John L.
Other reviewer described it well, it really is a hole in the wall, the place is filthy and service is really bad. Don't understand why people say this place is good.
(2)Cassandra W.
I can't believe that there are people who love this place! I have tried it twice. I really didn't want to go back after the first time, but I gave the place the benefit of the doubt, thinking perhaps they'd just had a bad day. Nope! The crust is so thin it's pitiful, and they are unbelievably stingy with the tomato sauce. At first I thought they'd forgotten the sauce, but you lift up the cheese and you see a microscopic smear of it there. If paper-thin crust and tiny sauce smears make you think "Mmm mmm good!", then this is the place for you! If this is NY-style pizza, they can keep it up in NY, and I'll be sure not to eat any pizza if I go to NY.
(1)Sergio P.
I have been eating here for over 15 years, mostly take out. I have eaten inside exactly 3 times. It has always been consistently great! Staff is "Brooklyn Friendly" if you're not from New York or Jersey, you won't understand....LMFAO. Lets just say, they make you feel at home. Just a little slice of Brooklyn in my neighborhood.......Than you guys for great service and food throughout the years! Keep up the GREAT work!
(5)Nate B.
It's hard to screw up pizza, and these guys do NOT screw it up. It's good. The slices are huge. The prices are reasonable. The taste is... well, it's the taste of pizza. It's exactly what you'd expect from a divey Brooklyn pizza joint. I'll be back to stuff my face, and that's no joke. Oh yeah, the cookies are amazing. Eat one.
(4)Jeff O.
Yelp is advising me to update my review on Brooklyn Pizza. I think it's very timely, as I visited this pizzeria today and a few things have changed since my last review. The slices are still great. The people are nice. The decor is the same. The prices however went up yesterday, and I think it's across the board. The 2 cheese slice/soda combo is now $5.50. Still a good deal, until you add a topping to the slices. Somehow my combo was $7.19 today, and it wasn't a mistake. Apparently if you add a topping to the slices, it nullifies the combo deal and you end up paying a la carte. I think this is BS, and the owner needs to fix this or he's gonna hear complaints six ways to sunset. I still enjoy going here, but I may have to give up toppings for the basic 2-cheese slice deal. :/
(4)Rob W.
This is typical strip shopping center NY style pizza. They use electric ovens, so they can't get a very crispy crust. A little light on the sauce and heavy on the cheese, so its a bit greasy. Not bad, but not memorable.
(2)Lauren K.
I am currently staying at the Hilton Garden Inn, waiting to leave in the morning on my honeymoon. I am very hungry and very sad. We ordered some food from Brooklyn Pizza around 7 p.m. Called back around 8 to follow up, since they quoted 30-45 minutes, and after being put on hold for a while, they said the driver had just left and it would be 10 minutes. 45 minutes later, we called again and no one answered. We called AGAIN and were told that someone called to cancel our order a little while before. Very unprofessional... it took the guy on the phone 15 minutes to get our initial order, between us having to repeat our room number five times to having to find the address to getting put on hold. And now we will wait for another delivery. Thanks for the memories, Brooklyn!
(1)Janene H.
I've never actually been inside the restaurant but always get the food delivered. The pizza is good but my co-workers and I are really fans of the wraps. The turkey wrap is a good bet and the calzones are very large. My favorite item has to be the cannoli. I have tried to find the best cannolis in Orlando and Brooklyn Pizza's are it.
(4)