This place is always hit or miss.... Most of the time it's miss, depending on certain factors like time of day. Walked in and there was a total of two old, mangy looking slices. This was at 4PM. I once came when they opened and they had special pies with chicken and other toppings fresh. This time they asked me what I wanted and said they would make to order. Quoted me at 7 minutes..... Took WAY longer than 7 minutes. Were the only people there. Sucks to be misquoted especially when you are the only customers there. Only way I'll come back is if I'm doing laundry at 11AM and there has to be fresh baked pizza since that's when they open.
(2)
Mandy N.
We ordered this for delivery our first night in NY staying at the Winn Manor. We got a great family deal for $17.99 (a large pizza, baked ziti, garlic bread and a salad). Was more than enough to feed a family of 4. Delivery was on time and food was nice and hot. Everything tasted fantastic!
(5)
Lawrence F.
This place has to be the worst pizzeria I've ever been to. I called them up on new years eve over two hours before they were set to close. There was nobody in the restaurant. They got the order wrong and I had to wait an additional half hour the pizza was cold when I got it home. The garlic knots that I ordered was just dough. There was no garlic taste to it. To top it off, they're probably the most expensive pizzeria in Pine Bush and by far the worst food. I'll never go there again
(1)
Nicole M.
If I could give zero stars I would. DO NOT ORDER PIZZA FROM HERE! Called in two large pizzas 1 with extra onion other ham & olive. They say 25 mins. I know they're usually late so I went to get gas first, shop up about 35 mins later, counter girl tells me another 7. Fine I wait, turns into 17, because they just started making it when I got there. I get home and open my boxes, and first off there NOT EVEN CIRCLES, and there were about 6 pieces of olive. I call to speak to a manager and they tell me he's not available, no wonder because the department of labor should check this place out. Every single employee had to be under 16. I did not see a single adult in site, and I'm 23 so that's saying a lot. If the pizza makers hadn't been so preoccupied with their cars in the parking lot maybe I would have had a better experience. Eating here is contributing to child labor law violations, and a complete waste of $40.
(1)
Puma S.
I ordered a large pie from this pizzeria with half meatballs and half sausage, peppers, and onions. I also ordered mozzarella sticks. I patiently waited the 30 minutes they quoted me and walked in to pay. As I was standing there, another guy came in and started talking to the guy behind the counter who was making pizzas. They basically were discussing how much marijuana they were going to smoke when he got off. I don't have anything against weed, but maybe the pizza maker should slow down on it so he can start getting orders right. I received my overpriced pizza and mozzarella sticks and went back to my car to eat it (I like eating in my car, I don't know why). The mozzarella sticks were bland and cold. The cheese wasn't melty at all. The pizza was cold, not melty, and they forgot the peppers and onions. I still gave two stars because the sauce actually tasted decent and the crust wasn't half bad. I only wish it was hot and what I ordered. They did charge me for the missing toppings. No I did not go back to complain. I complain in the form of never going back.
(2)
Sally M.
We were here unannounced with a group of 25, starving after a long hike, and they provided excellent service - polite, timely, and very tasty wings and pizza. The waiter was attentive and catered all our needs. All ingredients on the pizza were fresh. Big plus
(5)
Shanna C.
DONT ORDER FROM HERE!!! BE WARNED!!! we decided to give this business another chance after getting a message from the "new" owner who reassured me that we would get better business and ordered a simple pizza and wings. We were told its would be 45mins to a hour. Over a hour later I had a missed call that you ran out of wings. When I called the guy didn't even answer the phone with the proper response and only said hello. Then I told him what was going on and his only response was we're busy. I asked to speak with a manager and heard him ask 3 people for who he should give me to and finally got another gentleman on the phone who basically brushed me off and told me that I should see how busy they are and maybe I would understand. He did not offer anything for inconvenience or even a real apology. To be honest i will never order from you again and I will make sure to let everyone I know how we were treated and the type of service we received. 2 hours later.... Still no pizza Just had the pizza arrive and it's the wrong thing and cold!!!! Tried to text the "owner who reached out to me" and he gave a fake number
(1)
Eric R.
Boy, I used to love this place but it's going downhill fast. It took us an hour and fifteen minutes to get our food. It was truly unbelievable. No explanation why. Food wasn't bad, but it's definitely slipping into the typical New York bland restaurant experience where you're treated as cattle as opposed to feeling like guests. No bread provided, boring salad, etc. Second bad experience in a row. Won't be brining our friends back here again. Much rather drive to New Paltz.
(2)
Gianni S.
Not good. Service was incredibly slow. 12 mins for waitress to get order. Only 3 tables with customers. She was nice but very clueless. We ordered 3 plates all finger food. No napkins no utensils nothing. Food isn't very good either. Pizza for me was not good. Wrap came out just shy of cold. Not going back.
(2)
Marci S.
The pizza was decent, but like other reviewers have stated the service is horrible. We were seated with NOT ONE other person in the restaurant, yet two other tables who came in after us got their food first. It took over an hour to get two pizzas and a small side salad. The server never came back to refill drinks or apologize for how long we waited. Won't be back.
(2)
Peter D.
Pizza is good. Service is slow. Rest of the menu is mediocre. If you want a decent slice, this is the place to go. As for the rest of the menu, meh. Salad was wilted. Fried calamari was a bit too greasy. Prices are reasonable.
(2)
Elison C.
I must say this: their food tastes great, if it's what you actually ordered. They mess up orders constantly and to top it all off they make you wait twice as long for your food. This place used to be great years ago but they have been on a slow decline since then. Today was the last straw for me. I called ahead of time to make my order that was only supposed to take 20min. I arrived 30min after I placed the order and it was still not ready (I was driving from Middletown). I waited in the booth next to the counter for another 30min. When I voiced my frustration they said that they would take $5 off my next order! $5!?! It was like a slap in the face. Oh, and my order was wrong....This restaurant has become complacent. They've been there for so long that they think they are impervious to going out of business. What the owners will unfortunately find out is: as their willingness to serve diminishes so will their business!
(1)
Shari A.
We ordered pizza and wings for take out. Person on phone very friendly. Wings were pretty good. I like them crispy and they were on the money. They weren't pigeon sized either! Pizza could have had more mushrooms-perhaps try fresh ones??? It was good pizza though!
(4)
Jeremy H.
The service was the WORST SERVICE I HAVE EVER HAD!!! Every one was mean, the had us wait for ever, over charged us TWICE, yelled at us, and asked up not to come back! I WISH I could changed this to a 0 star DO NOT COME HERE! The waiter and staff was off the chain!
(1)
Steward P.
Pleasantly surprised with how much I liked this place. We were in town for the night with no idea where to get food. We saw this place in a strip mall and weren't sure we'd like it, but man-o-man it was good. I got some pasta dish with broccolli, sausage and garlic. Man it was GOOD! Decent selection of beers, reasonable prices. If this place was near us we'd go often.
(4)
Len M.
I have been eating here forever it seems, now that I live in AZ I still make it a point to stop by for something to eat. Its usually always good but not great, never bad though so that is a big thing. The place has not changed a bit in all these years. I got some tortellini alfredo and a salad, it was very good. Will return next year to give them my business.
(4)
Conrad S.
Ok, I'm a downstate NYC pizza snob, there, I said it...this must be made abundantly clear that I generally look at any "pizza" beyond the five boroughs as being a triangular drawing on cardboard with crayons - so any pizza establishment outside my geographical comfort zone will already be stared at with a jaundice eye of condescension. So while recently barnstorming the wine regions of the Hudson Valley & developing a hankering for some red sauce & cheese after an afternoon of vino, I "yelped" my way into Antonia's and just have to cut to the chase and say I was quite surprised & pleased for what it was. My companion had 2 slices of veggie pizza that were chock full of vegetables & had a nice eye appeal while I went the full Monty with 2 slices of regular (a decent & tasty effort overall) & a chicken parm hero (competently made with crusty, toasted bread, copious amounts of a decent industrial mozzarella & lots of chopped chicken cutlet) - tasty offerings overall, comfy environs & a friendly and efficient waitstaff...in NYC would be a 6-7 but a solid 9 for upstate, and from me, that's a rave!
(4)
Jessica S.
LOVE IT!! Fantastic pizza!!
(5)
Brian H.
Food is excellent, service casual yet attentive. A great place for family dining. (An ocasional issue is loud families). Excellent Penne Ala Vodka and Chicken Ala Antonio proof this is much more than a pizza place. Visiting relatives ask that we go here, rather than to more expensive Italian restaurant. Expansion coming soon!
Keith A.
This place is always hit or miss.... Most of the time it's miss, depending on certain factors like time of day. Walked in and there was a total of two old, mangy looking slices. This was at 4PM. I once came when they opened and they had special pies with chicken and other toppings fresh. This time they asked me what I wanted and said they would make to order. Quoted me at 7 minutes..... Took WAY longer than 7 minutes. Were the only people there. Sucks to be misquoted especially when you are the only customers there. Only way I'll come back is if I'm doing laundry at 11AM and there has to be fresh baked pizza since that's when they open.
(2)Mandy N.
We ordered this for delivery our first night in NY staying at the Winn Manor. We got a great family deal for $17.99 (a large pizza, baked ziti, garlic bread and a salad). Was more than enough to feed a family of 4. Delivery was on time and food was nice and hot. Everything tasted fantastic!
(5)Lawrence F.
This place has to be the worst pizzeria I've ever been to. I called them up on new years eve over two hours before they were set to close. There was nobody in the restaurant. They got the order wrong and I had to wait an additional half hour the pizza was cold when I got it home. The garlic knots that I ordered was just dough. There was no garlic taste to it. To top it off, they're probably the most expensive pizzeria in Pine Bush and by far the worst food. I'll never go there again
(1)Nicole M.
If I could give zero stars I would. DO NOT ORDER PIZZA FROM HERE! Called in two large pizzas 1 with extra onion other ham & olive. They say 25 mins. I know they're usually late so I went to get gas first, shop up about 35 mins later, counter girl tells me another 7. Fine I wait, turns into 17, because they just started making it when I got there. I get home and open my boxes, and first off there NOT EVEN CIRCLES, and there were about 6 pieces of olive. I call to speak to a manager and they tell me he's not available, no wonder because the department of labor should check this place out. Every single employee had to be under 16. I did not see a single adult in site, and I'm 23 so that's saying a lot. If the pizza makers hadn't been so preoccupied with their cars in the parking lot maybe I would have had a better experience. Eating here is contributing to child labor law violations, and a complete waste of $40.
(1)Puma S.
I ordered a large pie from this pizzeria with half meatballs and half sausage, peppers, and onions. I also ordered mozzarella sticks. I patiently waited the 30 minutes they quoted me and walked in to pay. As I was standing there, another guy came in and started talking to the guy behind the counter who was making pizzas. They basically were discussing how much marijuana they were going to smoke when he got off. I don't have anything against weed, but maybe the pizza maker should slow down on it so he can start getting orders right. I received my overpriced pizza and mozzarella sticks and went back to my car to eat it (I like eating in my car, I don't know why). The mozzarella sticks were bland and cold. The cheese wasn't melty at all. The pizza was cold, not melty, and they forgot the peppers and onions. I still gave two stars because the sauce actually tasted decent and the crust wasn't half bad. I only wish it was hot and what I ordered. They did charge me for the missing toppings. No I did not go back to complain. I complain in the form of never going back.
(2)Sally M.
We were here unannounced with a group of 25, starving after a long hike, and they provided excellent service - polite, timely, and very tasty wings and pizza. The waiter was attentive and catered all our needs. All ingredients on the pizza were fresh. Big plus
(5)Shanna C.
DONT ORDER FROM HERE!!! BE WARNED!!! we decided to give this business another chance after getting a message from the "new" owner who reassured me that we would get better business and ordered a simple pizza and wings. We were told its would be 45mins to a hour. Over a hour later I had a missed call that you ran out of wings. When I called the guy didn't even answer the phone with the proper response and only said hello. Then I told him what was going on and his only response was we're busy. I asked to speak with a manager and heard him ask 3 people for who he should give me to and finally got another gentleman on the phone who basically brushed me off and told me that I should see how busy they are and maybe I would understand. He did not offer anything for inconvenience or even a real apology. To be honest i will never order from you again and I will make sure to let everyone I know how we were treated and the type of service we received. 2 hours later.... Still no pizza Just had the pizza arrive and it's the wrong thing and cold!!!! Tried to text the "owner who reached out to me" and he gave a fake number
(1)Eric R.
Boy, I used to love this place but it's going downhill fast. It took us an hour and fifteen minutes to get our food. It was truly unbelievable. No explanation why. Food wasn't bad, but it's definitely slipping into the typical New York bland restaurant experience where you're treated as cattle as opposed to feeling like guests. No bread provided, boring salad, etc. Second bad experience in a row. Won't be brining our friends back here again. Much rather drive to New Paltz.
(2)Gianni S.
Not good. Service was incredibly slow. 12 mins for waitress to get order. Only 3 tables with customers. She was nice but very clueless. We ordered 3 plates all finger food. No napkins no utensils nothing. Food isn't very good either. Pizza for me was not good. Wrap came out just shy of cold. Not going back.
(2)Marci S.
The pizza was decent, but like other reviewers have stated the service is horrible. We were seated with NOT ONE other person in the restaurant, yet two other tables who came in after us got their food first. It took over an hour to get two pizzas and a small side salad. The server never came back to refill drinks or apologize for how long we waited. Won't be back.
(2)Peter D.
Pizza is good. Service is slow. Rest of the menu is mediocre. If you want a decent slice, this is the place to go. As for the rest of the menu, meh. Salad was wilted. Fried calamari was a bit too greasy. Prices are reasonable.
(2)Elison C.
I must say this: their food tastes great, if it's what you actually ordered. They mess up orders constantly and to top it all off they make you wait twice as long for your food. This place used to be great years ago but they have been on a slow decline since then. Today was the last straw for me. I called ahead of time to make my order that was only supposed to take 20min. I arrived 30min after I placed the order and it was still not ready (I was driving from Middletown). I waited in the booth next to the counter for another 30min. When I voiced my frustration they said that they would take $5 off my next order! $5!?! It was like a slap in the face. Oh, and my order was wrong....This restaurant has become complacent. They've been there for so long that they think they are impervious to going out of business. What the owners will unfortunately find out is: as their willingness to serve diminishes so will their business!
(1)Shari A.
We ordered pizza and wings for take out. Person on phone very friendly. Wings were pretty good. I like them crispy and they were on the money. They weren't pigeon sized either! Pizza could have had more mushrooms-perhaps try fresh ones??? It was good pizza though!
(4)Jeremy H.
The service was the WORST SERVICE I HAVE EVER HAD!!! Every one was mean, the had us wait for ever, over charged us TWICE, yelled at us, and asked up not to come back! I WISH I could changed this to a 0 star DO NOT COME HERE! The waiter and staff was off the chain!
(1)Steward P.
Pleasantly surprised with how much I liked this place. We were in town for the night with no idea where to get food. We saw this place in a strip mall and weren't sure we'd like it, but man-o-man it was good. I got some pasta dish with broccolli, sausage and garlic. Man it was GOOD! Decent selection of beers, reasonable prices. If this place was near us we'd go often.
(4)Len M.
I have been eating here forever it seems, now that I live in AZ I still make it a point to stop by for something to eat. Its usually always good but not great, never bad though so that is a big thing. The place has not changed a bit in all these years. I got some tortellini alfredo and a salad, it was very good. Will return next year to give them my business.
(4)Conrad S.
Ok, I'm a downstate NYC pizza snob, there, I said it...this must be made abundantly clear that I generally look at any "pizza" beyond the five boroughs as being a triangular drawing on cardboard with crayons - so any pizza establishment outside my geographical comfort zone will already be stared at with a jaundice eye of condescension. So while recently barnstorming the wine regions of the Hudson Valley & developing a hankering for some red sauce & cheese after an afternoon of vino, I "yelped" my way into Antonia's and just have to cut to the chase and say I was quite surprised & pleased for what it was. My companion had 2 slices of veggie pizza that were chock full of vegetables & had a nice eye appeal while I went the full Monty with 2 slices of regular (a decent & tasty effort overall) & a chicken parm hero (competently made with crusty, toasted bread, copious amounts of a decent industrial mozzarella & lots of chopped chicken cutlet) - tasty offerings overall, comfy environs & a friendly and efficient waitstaff...in NYC would be a 6-7 but a solid 9 for upstate, and from me, that's a rave!
(4)Jessica S.
LOVE IT!! Fantastic pizza!!
(5)Brian H.
Food is excellent, service casual yet attentive. A great place for family dining. (An ocasional issue is loud families). Excellent Penne Ala Vodka and Chicken Ala Antonio proof this is much more than a pizza place. Visiting relatives ask that we go here, rather than to more expensive Italian restaurant. Expansion coming soon!
(4)