Valentino’s Pizza

55 River Rd
Ogallala, 69153
Reviews:
Run away! Run away quickly! For your own sake! Do not eat here! How does a place like this exist? If anyone has seen restaurant impossible, this place is the worst of the worst. First things first, they have pizza. Not fresh pizza, but pizza. It was cold, sitting on the hot heater thingy. At best I'd call it "room temperature". Food is supposed to be hot at a buffet if it's hot food. And cold if it's cold food! Supposedly they change it fast based on other reviews, but what the hell? This is like the dirtiest looking country bumpkin shack I have ever seen. I don't mean that as an insult to country folk, but I mean that as an insult to any concept of following any concept of food safety. I don't think they even pay attention to the food they are making - they have labels, but the food does not match. They have cheese pizza labeled (important for you know, vegetarians), but put other pizzas there. Do they have any idea what would happen if someone was allergic to pepperoni which they put there instead? How are you going to tell the difference if all you can see on top is a layer of cheese? Sure I can eat meat, it doesn't bother me, but I could see people not being happy with the result here. If you're not going to make another of (pizza labeled on the buffet), leave it empty. At least you know what's there. Also, we went at like 630, and there were a grand total of 3 groups there. Not exactly a vote of confidence for a decent sized town, is it? Nobody should eat here, and the health inspectors would shut this place down in 5 seconds if they saw the stuff I saw when I unfortunately happened to eat here. Are you supposed to put out 2-3 day old labeled bulk food? Doesn't exactly sound like quality to me. At least it wasn't bulk mayonnaise or I would have walked out the door. I took a pepto just to make sure that I didn't get food poisoning. I feel really sorry for the cute married girl who is the cashier, because I don't know if there are other jobs available in a region like this. Yes they have lasagna, pizza, salad, etc. No it doesn't look anything like the picture. If the picture is way too good to be true, that should give you an idea of what this place is like on the inside. If you value your stomach, do not ever eat here. Starve if you must. Are other valentino's this bad? I have no idea. This is the only one I've ever been to. So maybe it's an exception?
The best pizza between Denver and Lincoln!
We were traveling I-80 eastbound after a stay in the southwest, we'd had magnificent Mexican food during our time there and had a hanker'in for pasta. The navi came up with Valentino's. We called for directions and to be sure they were indeed an Italian place. They said they are a pizza buffet plus pasta on the menu. They're right by the interstate, we dropped by at about 7:30 pm & were seated by a sweet hostess. Indeed they had a pizza buffet, with pasta, lasagna, multiple sauce choices, plus salad & dessert bar all for $9.25. That's what we chose, my wife loved the marinara sauce she had pasta, I chose the hearty meat sauce with rotini, we both had salads (ice berg lettuce). They have a unique cherry dessert pizza for cherry lovers, I had two pieces. For sure, it ain't Lidia's Italy, but it's good food served by nice people (the manager or owner stopped by to see how things were) in a clean place.

(308) 284-3603

Pizza

Store is open now

Pizza Hut

516 E 1st St
Ogallala, 69153
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(308) 284-6006

Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings

Store is open now