The Hideaway Tavern

23601 84th St
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
The Hideaway, is a little bit off the beaten path (as the name might suggest). When you pull up it looks like a private residence, but there is a small yard sign by the driveway. Only once you pull around back and see the Old Style sign - Does it feels more like a place that is open to the public. The bartender/cook was friendly. She made a delicious cheeseburger. She said the tomato on my burger was grown in her garden, it really enhanced the burger. Whatever you order, get it with the chip fries they are very tasty. This place is hard to find but worth the search.
This place is awesome. I'm from the Chicago suburbs and was looking for a good dive bar that is still good. This place is it. The bartender is an older lady with a fun bitchy attitude that whistles beautifully while she cooks. Food is great for bar food. Exactly what I was looking for. I will return. I'd like to see this place on a night when it's packed!
What a funky little place! I got the bacon ranch chicken sandwich and it was rad. Service was great, the decor was gnarly and unique. I felt like I was at my grandma's house in 1975, and i was born in 1983. Whatever you do get the "chip fries" as a side for your sandwich.

(262) 843-3014

Bars, American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Subway

24406 75th St
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
This location is great...the owner is amazing...for example...we stopped in here one morning for breakfast and our daughter was not very happy. The owner nicely gave our little girl a cookie to make her happy...crying adverted...thanks owner at Subway. The breakfast here is delicious. For 3 dollars we can get an egg white, ham and cheese sandwich on flat bread. The flat bread is our new find at Subway. We really like it. We were getting our breakfast sandwiches on the muffin and one day stumbled on to the flat bread. Sorry muffin we are never coming back to you. Oh yeah and we got free coffee too with our breakfast...I have no idea how long that promotion will run but it was a nice surprise. So when you are driving through Paddock Lake, make sure you stop in for breakfast. Lunch is also good too...one can never go wrong with a Subway sandwich. Plus you can stop at the lake and enjoy your Subway meal there too!!!

(262) 843-3325

Sandwiches, Fast Food

Store is open now

Sieberts Pub

8403 Antioch Rd
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
One word....WOW!!! Only downside of this little gem is that the restaurant is not that big & has a very small dining room......but......it was worth the wait!!! Something for everyone....even the most finickest palate. Wonderful vegetarian options. Their portobello sandwich is to die for!!!! I cannot wait to go back!!! Their baked French onion soup and monkey fries are A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!! The service is as fantastic as the food they serve!! This may be one of my new favorite restaurants. We will definitely go back!!
Loved, loved, loved the Reuben! The corned beef was shredded rather than poor quality slices that you get everywhere else. Our server was fantastic! I will drive out of my way to come here again!
Nice little place. Charming old house turned bar and restaurant over 100 years ago. If your in the area choices are limited so this place is a local stand out. We were at the ski resort near by and stopped for dinner and drinks. Had the pulled pork sandwich and corn-beef egg rolls. Was better than average and lets face it there isn't many choices. I would highly recommend if near by.

(262) 843-4621

American (New), Pubs

Store is open now

Hill Country Market

7510 288th Ave
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
What a cute place! I was in a hurry and just stopped in the see what it was all about. You can have lunch, sandwiches, soups, etc.... and different kinds of coffee too. Even some desserts. Great selection of local food goods for sale (and some non-local), beer, wine and a few craft items. Can't wait to go back when I have time to eat and when the weather is nicer. Very cute place.
I stop in frequently to grab a bite to eat. They offer a great sandwich called the BLEU MOON. It's definitely worth trying. The staff is super friendly and always willing to help! Great place to stop and grab lunch or do done quick grocery shopping!
I love this place. Their panini's are great and their salads are good too. They make the best citrus salad dressing; the store carries nice selection of organic and healthy options.

(262) 537-4867

Specialty Food

Store is open now

75th Street Inn

26229 75th St
Salem, 53143
Reviews:
Come here for lunch several times a month. Occasionally for a Friday evening fish fry. I've never had a meal I could complain about. The main reason I'm doing this review is that the place is far better than 3.5 stars. It's good pub grub and a fish fry if you're in the mood for something informal. 5 star restaurant, probably not, but with the way yelp ratings go, 3.5 stars is an insult. Good fish fry, good hamburgers, and a pleasant informal atmosphere at a decent price. You dont need to dress up to eat here is the only negative I can think of /sarcasm.
Our "go to" place when we make a run for the border to watch a Packer's game! Great service and great food - especially the burgers and potato soup. Several items on the menu that we can't get at any of the other restaurants/bars we frequent. We've never had a bad meal here. Outside deck is now pet friendly, so bring your pooch if the weather permits!
Well, I went here two days in a row and the service and food was awesome both days! A little chilly in the back booths, but then it is winter in Wisconsin. Love the Blue cheese burger and the Salmon salad......awesome!

(262) 843-1505

Bars, American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Luisa’s Pizza

6806 317th Ave
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
We recently ordered a pizza from Luisa's on one of their 1/2 price pizza nights (which are Tuesdays and Wednesdays, but you have to pay cash). The pizza was FANTASTIC!! I was so happy that the pizza I remembered was back! I've always liked their pepperoni too - large, very thin slices and the way they place it on the pizza (kinda half under the cheese) makes it MUCH LESS greasy. We did pick it up, and the pick up process is slightly more organized than it use to be (there is a separate counter and register for pickup) - but since it's not clearly marked, you do have some people walking in and just standing around, which can cause some confusion (but honestly, there are a lot of idiots who just love to walk into a restaurant, barely get in the door and STAND THERE, causing a foot traffic jam). The staff was friendly and the pizza was delicious! Yay!
A little divey...I ordered the pasta..it was very much like a high school cafeteria meal. Not one thing impressed me. Pass.
We waited a long time for our pizza. I was able to drink 3 beers by the time it came out. Pizza was alright but not anything to brag about. Little to no sauce - bland flavor and seemed like it could use some seasoning. Crust was crispy and cheese was not greasy although I think it was overcooked just a smidge. The cheese was darker and almost to the point of being rubbery. The building itself is definitely a dive and could use some re-modeling.

(262) 537-4795

Pizza, Italian, American (Traditional)

Store is open now

La Cabana Mexican Restaurant

24231 75th St
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
Being an out of towner, we decided to make the trip from IL. Glad I did.! The atmosphere is cozy and staff is very welcoming. I had the shredded beef chimichanga dinner which was our waitress suggestion. No disappointment there. Large frozen margarita, was large and tasty.! Overall very pleasant experience, not too bad on the wallet either.
The food was ok, but nothing special. Our waitress was very unprofessional and rude. The only spectacular thing about this place was the murals on the ceiling and tables.
This restaurants vegetarian menu looks great. I ordered veggie chimichanga meal, which the menu stated came filled with a short list of veggies including, broccoli and carrots. When I received my meal all that was in my burritos was greasy bell peppers and onions. I was pretty bummed.

(262) 843-2681

Mexican

Store is open now

The Marina

28836 Silver Lake Rd
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
Had heard good things about this place so I finally tried it. BOO! We decided to sit at the bar which had virtually no one in it....the dining room was not overly busy either. the bartenders seemed more interested eating their snacks. we ordered our drinks and I asked for a menu.....HINT: when a menu is closed it means the person is ready to order.....I had to actually ask them to put my order in after they had walked by me several times.....I ordered a chicken fajita salad and it took 45 minutes for it to get to me....the bartenders used excuses like "I've checked but there's nothing else I can do" and " you have to remember, they have all those tables in there"., it wasn't THAT busy "in there"!!! If it were me I would have gone to a mgr and had my meal comped or at the very least offered me a drink on the house....I mean really 45 minutes for a friggin salad.....UNACCEPTABLE.....my first time there was my last time there! The bartenders can blame their lack of any tip on their kitchen and their lack of knowledge on how to give good service!
Good grub ( pizza,burgers and wings). Thursdays are specials on domestic beer($1.50 ea.) and wings (I forget the price). Pizza is solid. The enire place has a fantastic view of beautiful Silver Lake. Located on South side of lake. My review is somewhat relative to what is available in this area and because of the lake. It is worth checking out. Formerly Crossroads... some guy from Chicago bought it and is much improved.
I would give this place two or three stars if it were not in such a great location. The food is ok, service hit or miss and pricing average, but the view of Silver Lake is awesome. We are able to dock our boat for free while eating which is nice. All of the tables on the patio are only a few feet from the water. If your bringing kids definitely sit outside as inside is more or less a bar. If the kids get restless they can walk onto the docks to see fish swimming around etc., but be close enough for you to keep an eye on them. One of the most entertaining aspects of sitting outside is watching people launch and retrive their boats. Their is a decent size drop off so it is rare to get through a meal without witnessing someone having problems.

(262) 889-8465

American (New), Chicken Wings, Pizza

Store is open now

Tenuta’s Pizza Pasta Catering

25240 75th St
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
XL thin crust x-sauce cheese pizza made for a wonderful lenten meal. Well done!
It has almost been 3 years since we tried the pizza here and I was sure we would never go back. But a few factors were in place for us to give it a try and a re-review! First, this location is under new management but still the same family. I am sure that there is a good story here. I have heard a few rumors but I am not going to pass on word of mouth facts. Secondly, they have coupons in the Happenings magazine. Bonus!!! So we were hungry one night and wanted food fast without cooking or driving too far to get it. When I came across the coupons. There was a coupon for a four piece fried chicken dinner for 5 bucks and a coupon for a large pizza with two toppings for 5 bucks. I figured if I was going to try them again, at least it wasn't going to cost me a lot of money. I must say that the pizza is a completely different pizza then the pizza we got years ago. The fried chicken was also really good too. I am giving the food four stars based on the new management and for the coupons. If it was not for the coupons, I am sure I would not be tempted to eat here. The coupons make the food worth it. I also must say that everything was ready in 20 minutes...that was really fast. The food was also nice and hot by the time I got it home. So if you see a coupon in the Happenings, then give them a try if you have had a bad experience in the past.
My husband and I ordered a family dinner of spaghetti with meatballs with bread and salad for take out and it was terrible! The pasta was so over cooked it was mushy. The sauce was so bland it had no flavor whatsoever. The meatballs tasted like they bought generic frozen meatballs and warmed them up. The bread was cheap rolls slightly warmed up and the salad was super simple with watery salad dressing. Terrible! Olive Garden is better than this place for "Italian".

(262) 843-4687

Pizza, Italian

Store is open now

Lucky Chen

7353 256th Ave
Salem, 53168
Reviews:
While a five star might be pushing it, the food at lunch was very good. Small intimate space, carry out must be their bread and butter... or rather egg rolls and soy sauce. Quick food, good prices.
Convenient and fast. Not the best Chinese takeout ever, but pretty good none the less
This place is one of our quick dinner options. We like the spicy shredded beef ( it is not shredded, weird), pot stickers, and the mifun noodles extra veggies. Egg rolls taste frozen, and are pretty bland.

(262) 843-2388

Chinese

Store is open now