Subway

W 9195 County Rd Cs
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
On the way up to the Dells to drop off a kid at camp (long story). I found myself starving but with nothing around besides twigs and berries, I thought I was doomed. Then out of the woods, I came across the... finest, nicest, cleanest, freshest, friendliest, tastiest Subway in the world... The end.

(608) 635-2999

Sandwiches, Fast Food

Store is open now

Owl’s Nest

617 E North St
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
Food is good, service is fine. Came here after the maple sryup festival. its an old restaurant for sure.
Went here on a Tuesday night, and we had the entire dining room to ourselves. The food was decent for the price. Service was friendly but a little slow considering the place was empty.
So I just moved to the sleepy town of Poynette, and all the old duffers at the local golf course said I needed to try this place. I'm left with just a "ho-hum" feeling of satisfaction. We visited this fine establishment on a Sunday morning at 9 am. As we walked in, we were greeted by a clean bar area. It hadn't been updated since Nixon was in office, but it was clean. As you walk through the bar, you'll find the eating area. This area is large, and not overly inviting. It reminds me of a church sanctuary full of tables, not pews and the senior crowd, the parishioners. As one looks around, you can't help but wonder if Metamucil is on draught here. We sat down, and waited, and then waited some more. Finally the menus showed up. it was breakfast and the choices are vast and cheap. The omlettes are named after various owls in the wild. Snow, Horned, and other random owls are what you order. Too bad the Service Owl hadn't flown to work today as there was only one poor girl to work the room full of staving folks. The food, when it finally showed up, was really good. I had the Horned Owl, which was an omlette of ham, cheese, veggies and other stuff I can't recall. I also had American fries and toast. I can't recall what my date had, but she couldn't finish her meal the portions were so large. I guess when it comes down to it, you go to a restaurant to eat. And eat we did. The food was great. Our bill for two meals and one drink was under $14.00. McDonalds would have been about the same price and then I would have needed the plunger Owl later in the AM. What sucked is the two hours it took to have a meal from enter to exit. Too long to wait, even if the food is great.

(608) 635-2298

Seafood

Store is open now

Spanky’s Cafe

221 N US Highway 51 Ste C
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
This is very good pizza. And I like pizza. I really like pizza and I take my pizza seriously. We've ordered it a couple times and it was very good both times. It's not great pizza but it is very good. We will continue to order Spanky's pizza. Their sausage is excellent. The pepperoni had flavor. The mushrooms were fresh (not canned). There is plenty of cheese and the sauce is good. Delivery has been on time both times. Very courteous staff. All around good experience. My ONLY gripe would be that they did not inform me of a delivery charge. I live about 9 miles out of town and that trip incurs a delivery charge. Spanky's should inform customers of this charge.

(608) 635-3988

Pizza

Store is open now

Hooker’s Resort

W9370 County Road V
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
Went there over the weekend. Most of us ordered The Special which was amazing. You have to pay extra for a side which sucks. The fires were hot and crispy and we love how they have a ranch in a bottle per table. They should have a couple menus made so it is much easier to read.
I've been here a handful of times and it was okay, but this place is terrible now. It's a grill your own food place, but I don't go out to dinner to cook for myself. On Fridays they have fish fry. Don't come here expecting baked or broiled, everything is deep fried. Hope you can remember everything because they don't have menus. The meal starts with warm, stale bread sticks. The French dressing for the salad is fluorescent red. The corn that came with the meal was soggy, wet, and obviously frozen. In Wisconsin in the summer, there is no excuse for using frozen over fresh corn. French fries were limp, soggy, and undercooked. Bluegill and walleye were good, but nothing special. After I ate, I found out that there were several side dishes that I would have liked to had with meal. Too bad I couldn't read about them because this restaurant doesn't have menus.
Not great, in need of major upgrade. We went there on a Fri night to celebrate my husband's 35th birthday. I made a reservation for 5 over a week in advance and we still had to wait over a half hour for our table in the bar. The dining room was very dark, bad lighting and when the sun sets it creates a blinding light in some seats. The waitress seemed annoyed because we had 3 teens with many questions and because I asked for a birthday cake with candle for hubby which they could not do!!! The salad was iceberg lettuce, very plain and bland. The grill your own steak is somewhat fun but hot.... And for $21per person it is expensive when you're the one cooking it. Mushrooms and onions cost 8.95 for a very small cup. We had to order 3 of these and had to wait extra long because the waitress didn't ask us if we wanted them during our original order for our steaks. I also had to ask for baked potatoes for my family because the bin was empty when we went to the grill. The table had a cheap paper coverage and no real napkins or nice silverware. It seemed very cheap for a not so cheap dinner. Spent $150 for 5 people.

(608) 635-7867

Hotels, Restaurants

Store is open now

The Nest

N5095 Hemlock St Frnt Frnt
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(608) 635-7220

Store is open now

McDonald’s

N3240 County Road J
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(608) 635-2655

Burgers, Fast Food

Store is open now

Inn-Cognito

532 N US Highway 51
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(608) 635-4834

Pizza

Store is open now

Merchants Walk Restaurant & Lounge

213 N Main St
Poynette, 53955
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(608) 635-8181

Restaurants

Store is open now