Schwarz’s Supper Club

W1688 Sheboygan Rd
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
Don't ask ?s. Just go. Best steak I have had this side of the Mississippi in quite sometime. Right up there w the stage stop and anything else you can find. They have a different way of ordering but it all works out in the end. It was so busy !!! And this was a sun at 530pm. But we only waited about half hour 4 our food / table. I will definitely be back !!! Great grasshoppers too !!!
The boyfriend and I drove for an hour to meet a friend here, and it was definitely worth it! This place is waaaay out in the sticks, so you won't ever just stumble across it, but they were reasonably busy even on a Wednesday night. The ordering/seating process is a tiny bit strange -- you check in with the host on arrival, get menus, and sit in the bar area. You actually order while there, and are only seated in the dining room when salads and the relish tray are on the table. A little odd, but it seemed to work for them. Shrimp cocktail in the bar was good, though the little plastic cup of cocktail sauce could have been served a little more nicely. The salad and relish tray are straight out of, hmmm, 1975? Salad was nothing special, but the boyfriend enjoyed the relish tray. Steaks were all around fabulous. Honestly, I can't remember the last time I had such a great steak in a restaurant. My filet was amazing, as was the boyfriend's porterhouse (with leftovers the next day just as good). However, they were uniformly kind of under the requested temperature -- not quite enough that we'd send them back, but if you're afraid of rare meat, maybe this isn't the place for you. Overall, it was a great meal. Next time I'm in the mood for a drive and a steak, I'll be back at Schwarz's!
Our first experience at a "supper club" ... Really liked Schwarz's flow, appetizers and drinks in the bar area, then called to your table for salads and dinner - never standing around waiting for a table. The food was delicious, service was good and staff were very hospitable.

(920) 894-3598

American (New), Seafood, Steakhouses

Store is open now

South Town Family Restaurant

1305 Milwaukee Dr
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
What you would imagine a small town diner should be! Good portions at a reasonable price.

(920) 898-4941

Restaurants

Store is open now

Campbell’s 7 Corners Bar & Restaurant

W505 Fur Farm Rd
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 898-4702

Store is open now

Mt Glass Bar & Grill

2122 Wisconsin Ave
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 898-9030

Store is open now

Tri City Lodge Local 1260

2116 Wisconsin Ave
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 827-2022

Store is open now

Subway

2305 Calumet Dr
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 898-1344

Fast Food, Sandwiches

Store is open now

Village Inn Pizza Family Restaurant

1706 Wisconsin Ave
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 898-4045

Pizza

Store is open now

T-Bones Tap

2001 Calumet Dr
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 898-5600

Restaurants

Store is open now

Altona Supper Club

2306 Calumet Dr
New Holstein, 53061
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(920) 898-5255

Seafood, Steakhouses

Store is open now