Tilly’s Too Tavern

5071 Wash
Butte Des Morts, 54927
Reviews:
I arrived via boat one summer afternoon. My first time here. I thought I was a Wisconsinite before I walked in, then the reality check hit me. Best darn taxidermic duck wall I've seen in a while. Or ever. Drinks were stiff. A meat raffle ensued. Cheers and laughter. I stumbled out a better person.

(920) 582-7626

Store is open now

Jimmie’s White House Inn

5776 Main St
Butte Des Morts, 54927
Reviews:
Sense of history and vintage atmosphere. Check. Brandy Old Fashions. Check. Chicken Wellington. Check. In Wisconsin. Check. I'd go back fo' sho'.
This is by far the best restaurant in the area. I happened upon it because a friend said that they make a good steak. I got the char ribbed ribeye. The food was outstanding. The service was maybe a little so-so as they seem to hire a lot of young people who aren't very experienced, but overall a very nice job. The interior decor includes some civil war memorabilia. Now I'll admit that I'm not a fan of the rebel flag on the front sign, but they do present it in a historical perspective, so I'm willing to look the other way.
We stopped by over the 4th-of-July weekend as part of our ongoing quest to hit up as many excellent Wisconsin supper clubs as we possibly could. Jimmie's is a bit off the beaten path, but well worth the short side trip (or longer and more scenic alternate route). I went with the tenderloin, and my wife had the crab-stuffed haddock. Both of us were very impressed with the food and the attentive servers, and we enjoyed old-fashioneds and manhattans that not only tasted great but were priced such that we seriously considered staying in their parking lot over the weekend :-) Special mention about the potato pancakes, which to our surprise and delight were stuffed with cheese and were oh so savory. Pleasant suprises await you at Jimmie's.

(920) 582-7211

Seafood, Steakhouses, Supper Clubs

Store is open now