4. Restaurants

Hoagie Haven

242 Nassau St, Princeton, NJ, 08542
  • (609) 921-7723
  • Store is closed

Hoagie Haven Menu

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant blood pressure menu details.

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant cholesterol menu details.

  • Daniel E.

    The best food princeton has! Its just incredible! Any person who walks into Hoagie Haven will come out with their mouth watering, ready to eat their delicious hoagie on the few benches out in front of the "college food shops". You can't just get half a sandwich, because that would only give you half a sandwich, and no one would want that! It is also not recommended that anyone whose watching their cholesterol should walk in (Heartstop is one of their best sandwiches) anybody who is anybody who happens to be in Princeton at lunch needs to stop by and try any of their incredible subs.

    (5)

  • Zach S.

    Best place on earth. I grew up in the area and I've eaten a Number 1 with everything on it (sometimes a Number 3 with everything) more times than you could possibly imagine. Interspersing these number 3's and 1's were many a cheeseburger, cheesesteak and sanchez. Forget that 'footlong' horseshit you can get something that's at least two feet long here for around $5. It's better than whatever sandwich place you go to. Except maybe Georges.

    (5)

  • Megan C.

    Mmmmm Late Night Bliss!! Plenty of Grease to go around! Cheese steaks will fill you up and keep you smiling! Date Rating: 10 (This is a little piece of History you can't miss it) Pick up Scale: 10 (If you like Princetonians) Strong Suggestions: Remember many have come before you, and many will come after you... Hoagie Haven is a Legend!

    (4)

  • Patrick G.

    Whole bacon cheesesteak with raw onions and peppers is the best sub. Love this place and have been eating here for years, if you go at lunch time or late night expect to stand in line but it's ALWAYS worth the wait. The only reason I'm not giving them 5 stars is because they don't take credit cards.

    (4)

  • Chris T.

    That Hoagie Haven is consistently Princeton's top-rated restaurant on Yelp is more indicative of Princeton's limited dining scene than Hoagie Haven's quality. This local favorite offers large servings of (fairly standard) affordable and greasy "dining truck" sandwiches (sans the truck). Unsurprisingly, the quality of ingredients is on par with the low prices; still, I am a fan of Hoagie Haven's late hours, speedy service, and soft and chewy Italian rolls.

    (3)

  • Lorr P.

    This is a famous subs place. Get the bacon cheese steak with onions. There can be horrible lines at lunchtime. Years ago we used to go there from work during lunch - we'd call and place our order across the street on the pay phone, so we could cut in line and get our pick-up order.

    (5)

  • Ana K.

    Hoagie Haven is incredible for so many reasons: you cannot get these sandwiches anywhere else, it's quick and ridiculously cheap, and the food is absolutely mouthwatering. I typically go with the Sanchez - a italian hoagie with chicken fingers, fries, mozzarella sticks, cheese, and famed Sanchez sauce. The sauce is the best part. While I assumed it would be gross (just consider how much is in this whopping sandwich), I one day caved and tried it - best decision ever.

    (5)

  • John L.

    Only been there once or twice -- very good food for what is, admittedly, a hole in the wall. Chili is delicious and murky. Hoagies are authentic and tasty. That being said, there are many that equal or surpass these flavors if you're willing to travel 10 or 20 minutes. Think Bossio's in Lawrenceville on 206, for example. If you're eating here, enjoy the idea of where you are and what you're doing, because in my opinion, the food itself is not what this place is really about -- it's the experience of enjoying something that so many others have.

    (5)

  • Ale X.

    Was driving thru Princeton and glanced over to see this place. Had to stop, i was hungry. Small place with lots of drinks in coolers, and a bunch of dudes behind the counter. No messin around for them, they put together a hoagie faster then i could blink. The ingredients were fresh, crisp and cool. Lots of food for the price, i got a huge #1 and a coke. It was GOOD.

    (4)

  • Amanda F.

    It might have been the bread, or some other kind of magical ingredient (it was really great bread though!) but they somehow made the cheese hoagie I shared with a vegetarian worth my while. WOW, that was good bread.

    (4)

  • Jimmy L.

    While visiting NY, my friend and i made a trip to Princeton and the destination was Hoagie Haven, not the university. I didnt believe the hype, but i went along with it. I had the chicken parm, and was an instant believer. That thing was the best chicken sandwhich i've ever eaten! Hot and crispy, i can still taste it. Im jealous of you guys in NJ.

    (5)

  • Danny S.

    One sandwich was about the size of my arm. Cheap eats, especially good to cure late night, I'm drunk and I need some greasy food craving. The chicken parm was pretty good, the extra dirty sanchez (hehe) is probably my favorite. Chicken cutlet, mozzarela sticks and fries in a hoagie with 'sanchez' sauce (mayo, ketchup and something else), what's not to like?? Just make sure you hit the treadmill the next day.

    (4)

  • Heather T.

    A Princeton mainstay. Go to hoagie haven for great sandwiches at good prices. And it's always a plus that the staff is friendly.

    (5)

  • Nick D.

    fuck yeaaaaaaaa....hoagie heartattack

    (5)

  • Jimmy O.

    Two words: great food. superb sandwiches and quick service, great price.

    (5)

  • Daniela J.

    cant live without, cant do it, wont do it. (mike singletary) i never met anybody who did not like hoagie haven. their staff is hilarious and if u go at night time u get to listen to house music greek style and watch kosta dance ;)

    (5)

  • Oliver L.

    Perfect for late-night dining on the cheap. No seating except for some benches outside, but that's part of the charm. If you wear your Hoagie Haven t-shirt there, I think they give you a discount on a soda (or something).

    (5)

  • Brian J.

    Hoagie Haven is a Princeton institution. Whenever I wear my orange and black Haven teeshirt smiling people come up and start nostaglic converstations. In California. THIS is where cheesesteaks come from. (Everyone seems to think they have something to do with Philladelphia. Uh, people? In Philladelphia, they but CHEEZ WHIZ on their cheesesteaks. Cheez Whiz is a bad joke. It is not cheese. I mean ok, do whatever you want but yuck!) As far as I'm concerned, Hoagie Haven's pizza cheesesteak is the Reference Cheesesteak, against which all others are measured. Extra hot peppers please!

    (5)

  • Chris H.

    This is a great place to get your fill of mouth-watering greasy goodness, at a super cheap price. The employees here have great personality - gruff, but in a nice way that says "Hurry the fuck up and order" but also "You gonna enjoy what I cook up for you. I'm gonna give you a treat." I love the outdoor bench seating; just watch out for the accumulated grease pools underneath.

    (4)

  • Nathan L.

    You need to go here and get a sub. They are a classic sub shop, almost enough to call them old school submarine sandwiches! But they are very good and whenever we would go here for lunch there was typically a line but it moves fast.

    (5)

  • Richard P.

    Amazing. If you buy a full length cold cut sub, eat half (just right for lunch), and stick the other half in your work fridge, you are talking $3 healthy meals. I don't think I could assemble the ingredients for that amount of money. Great value and fast, tasty, fresh food.

    (5)

  • Courtney M.

    another one of my hometown staples! many a 7th period class at PHS was missed so a group of us could go get delicious sandwiches. cheese steak with everything is the only way to go! if you're brave, add bacon :) i said not good for groups (if you plan on eating there) because all they have is 2 little ledges along the front windows. get it to go!

    (5)

  • P C.

    The cheesesteak, though just frozen and put on the grill, is pretty good. The people who work there are nice and friendly too. It gets a little sketchy late at night when the after-bar crowd goes there, but not that bad, especially if you go there in a group. Sadly the cold sandwiches are not so great--nothing compares to fresh-sliced deli meat. However, the hot sandwiches are perfect drunk food. I hear the Phat Lady is delish--will get that next time I go!

    (3)

  • Brian G.

    This is one of my favorite places in the entire world! Hoagie Haven creates what I would argue are the best sandwiches in the world. The combination of a Sanchez and an Arizona Ice Tea Arnold Palmer is a match made in haven. My craving for Hoagie Haven will never be satiated. This is hands down the best place to eat in Princeton. The price is great, and make sure you take note of the grease underneath the benches outside.

    (5)

  • Mason L.

    By far the best food in Princeton for the money, and one of the top five places even if money is not a consideration. Cheesesteak+egg+mayo is delicious!

    (5)

  • Atiya H.

    I did a search for Hoagie Haven because I thought I would be the 1st person to review it. I see there are many people that know this hometown favorite. Great prices, great food and great memories. Enough said!

    (5)

  • KC L.

    This place is pretty good. Came down to this place since I was a kid. First the Cheese Steak then the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak. I haven't eaten here for a while but would not hesitate to come back. The meat is not as good as Pat's down in Phil but it does taste a lot better. I heard the owner had sold this place. Good luck to him.

    (4)

  • Amy J.

    It may take a few sammies here to dial your usual, since there is so much to choose from at ridiculous prices. The order over the counter service is in your face interactively making your food while you choose your seasonings in a bewildering array of signs, smells, sounds and slurps. I winged it with the cheesesteak: plain (they salt and pepper the paper-thin steaks while cooking) with hot peppers and shredded lettuce and it was heavenly. $3.80. And they carry Manhattan Special Espresso soda.

    (5)

  • Jenna H.

    When it comes to grease, it gets no better than Haven. While all the traditional sandwiches are great (chicken parm, chicken cheesesteak, etc) the holy grail are the BUFFALO FRIES. Just typing the words induces a Pavlovian response. A hand-held heart attack, these crisp tasty delights come drenched in blue cheese & hot sauce. It was love at first bite senior year of high school, & these fries became my primary food group for the rest of my Princeton days. I haven't found a fry as satisfying since... (& not for lack of effort on my part)

    (4)

  • J. P. K.

    Good, fast, AND cheap (very few things in life can claim all three attributes!). My favorite combo is the mushroom cheesesteak with a bottle of Stewart's root beer. The only hassle is finding parking.

    (5)

  • jimmy d.

    i feel like i'm taking crazy pills! hoagie haven is CRAP FOOD. i think the average age of the reviewers is like 17 and 1/2. there is some good food in princeton. this rat trap doesn't make ANY of it. order a cheese steak and they make it with steak-ums (it's like the particle board of "beef"). don't people who eat out keep ANY kind of standards? i guess if it's 1:58 am and you're too stoned to drive to a diner, or just not old enough, you can fill the void. i got two words for this den of dysentery..., "yeah, NO"!

    (1)

  • Victor L.

    Before coming to Princeton to attend a summer camp years ago, I had no idea what a hoagie was. Upstate New York doesn't have hoagies. The gang would walk around wondering what we could do since we couldn't drink. But we could eat. And eat we did. We were initiated with Wawa, possibly the greatest convenience store ever. And as we walked down Nassau, from Talbots to timbucktu, we saw Hoagie Haven. Its just a joint. Literally. You feel like you should be a pudgy balding Carl-type from Aqua Teen with a wifebeater that's too small and mustard stains that have been there too long, chomping away here and discussing how your 1985 cutlass supreme would have more market value than your friend's 1988 tercel wagon. That's right, the Tercel is comin' back. Plain and simple, their cheesesteak with cooked onions is unbeatable, its just nasty good, I remember forcing myself to eat two to keep the memory/taste/moment alive. The bread is so delicious, when the juice melts into it its redonculous, because its not flaky but it softens like an icy heart melting at the end of the Brave Little Toaster. Its like, oh its so soft I think I can fit another one I CAN BOOM SHAKALAKA OH god I'm too full. And then you go down the road to Thomas Sweets to eat some ice cream to distract your stomach from the tender beef that is making its way down there.

    (5)

  • Brooke Y.

    My Princetonian husband has many tales of the Haven from late nights in the E-Quad. When we were there for Reunions in 2002, the line around the block told the whole story. I've had many a meal from the Haven and have never been disappointed. Apparently the prices haven't changed since the late '80's. We stop in every visit we make to town.

    (5)

  • samantha k. s.

    If you're looking for a real world soupnazi experience, get in line. This is the real deal. Sitting here in Seattle and contemplating an upcoming trip east, this, among other delights, is on my mind. Mine? Simple. Tuna with pepperocini an lettuce, italian dressing. salt. pepper. stop me, i feel faint. the bread, you can not begin to imagine if you've not been, well, precisely there. fries oh my god. eggplant parm hoagie. though the line is long you'd do well to stand aside and watch the flow before stepping in. The pace is beyond swift, and the ordering is precise. you will want to grab all the necessary sides, drinks, whatever, napkins so you can just hunker down on the stoop or jet over to the campus for a little picnic. your belly will be oh so happy. you will go back tomorrow even in the face of *hoagies? again?* protests from the uninitiated.

    (5)

  • Chris C.

    Best late-night eatery within walking distance of Princeton campus. I recommend the Fat Lady (cheese steak with fries, mozzarella sticks and hot sauce) or the Heart Stop (bacon cheese steak with eggs). The sandwiches are enormous and you can't beat the prices.

    (5)

  • sam j.

    really good sandwiches and burgers for the price. i have managed to feed 4 friends for under $15, with each friend being satisfied, happy, and full (they all got addicted to hoagie haven as well and started requesting we eat there again). the food tastes great and the line move fast. it is also easy to order over the phone and just go pick your order up, speeding the process up even further. you get to watch them make your food so you can ask them to make adjustments you want, and everything is made to order. the "half" hoagie is plenty of food for an average eater (or even 2 meals for some of us). some of my favorites are hot pastrami, eggplant parm, tuna, cheeseburger, cheesesteak, and chicken cheesesteak. there is no seating but there is usually some place to sit outside so you get the benefit of people watching while enjoying great, inexpensive food. this gets little tough in winter when many people try to cram at the window counters inside, so i would recommend just doing takeout if the weather is not nice.

    (4)

  • Kavi m.

    ridiculously good sandwich.went there to get heart stop and phat lady. awesome sandwiches. must visit place. enough greasy but you can't get the real taste without too much fat.

    (5)

  • Sarah B.

    hoagie haven is bomb! i love the chicken parm sandwich, but the best thing about haven is the experience. you just gotta try it.. don't let the department of health get you down!

    (4)

  • Thomas J.

    The mecca of all that is sandwich sacred, Hoagie Haven is a treasure. My favorite place to eat by far in Princeton (now that Da's Thai left), Haven is suitable for all meals of the day. My favorite used to be the bacon and cheese omelette, but recently I've been ordering the Heartstop (cheesesteak, bacon + eggs) with gyro sauce, a little mayo, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, ketchup and salt/pepper. If I'm feeling extra fatty I'll also throw in a buffalo cheese fries order. I recommend trying all the special sandwiches. Within walking distance from the University and a few blocks from Prospect Street, Haven is usually pretty busy during meal hours and impossible during Reunions. You must go to this establishment even if you happen to be a vegetarian or shun greasy food. If you truly are all that is man, plunk down 15 GDubs and order a full Big Kat plus cheesesteak. Do it. You won't...

    (5)

  • Jason D.

    Nothing is open. Man, I'm hungry. Why don't any food joints in Lawrenceville stay open late? There's Crystal Diner, but... nah... OK, yes, I'll drive to Hoagie Haven. What do you want? Seriously, no, I'm not ordering a turkey sub for you. You have two choices. A Sanchez or a Chicken Parm. Choose. Choose. Now. Sanchez? YES. I knew it. I'm getting the parm. No, I'm not letting them put tomatoes on it. You want extra sauce on the Sanchez? Cool. OK. No, I think the liquor store over there is closed by now. There are still beers in the fridge. I'll be back in a few.

    (4)

  • Jane S.

    I'm not sure when this place actually closes, as they are always open (and PACKED) after the bars let out at 2am. Fast, cheap and delicious are the ways best to describe Hoagie Haven, especially if you're here with the after 2am crowd. Definitely nothing wrong with this place, highly recommended!

    (5)

  • Jenny C.

    They had me at fried mac n cheese wedges! I am a Rutgers girl and there for a big fan of the grease trucks so when I was in the Princeton area and saw HH I knew I needed to try it. I believe I had the Fat Lady complete with cheese steak mozzarella sticks and fries. (RU's Fat Koko) Yum! I wouldn't say it was better, but I was definitely satisfied! The fried mac n cheese wedges are what makes them different and will bring me back.

    (5)

  • Priyanka T.

    I personally love Hoagie Haven. It is perfectly located, in the middle of downtown Princeton. Their gyros are amazing and service is exceptional. It is a quick and easy place to get excellent food!

    (5)

  • Caroline M.

    When I go to Haven (not Hoagie Haven, not "the Haven," but just Haven), I get the chicken parm. Or the pizza cheesesteak. Or if I can't decide, I get both. Fun fact: the Bloch (a chicken parm with bacon and eggs) is named after one of my friends, who repeatedly ordered it so often that they dedicated it to him. The dude's name is Sam Loch, he was an '06 grad of Princeton's heavyweight rowing squad, and the nickname came from his refrigerator-like build. Now you can impress people at parties with that knowledge.

    (5)

  • Julie B.

    My food was a let-down. After friends of mine expressed their love for Hoagie Haven's tuna sub, so I decided to try it for myself (I love tuna subs). It was nothing more than mayo and dark-meat canned tuna, and it was greasy... which perplexed me... because at no point in time during my ordering did I ask them to put grease on my sandwich, just lettuce and onion. Wasn't a fan of the turkey sub I ordered recently either, the meat slices were on the slimey side. I do have to admit that the price wasn't all that bad, but I can get way better tuna subs at Wawa for even cheaper. Who knows... maybe their other stuff is better. it was better than my college's subs, which is why if I could give it 2.5 stars, I would.

    (2)

  • W J.

    Hoagie Haven is legendary. I've been eating here for the past 25 years and it's still the same: inexpensive hoagies that fill you up. I am a Hoagie Haven traditionalist, don't order the 'fat' sandwiches that Rutgers students forced on everybody. The traditional HH menu involves all the cold subs plus the cheesesteaks. Stick to those and you'll be alright. My personal favorite is a whole cheesesteak with everything plus ketchup and mayo. Don't expect too much, it will not be the greatest sandwich you've ever had, but the place has been there forever, and it's fast, and easy on your wallet. Here's to another 25 years.

    (4)

  • Jo N.

    6 words and you're happy: #1 with everything on it... If you need variety, you can't go wrong with the chicken parm or cheesesteak. It'll be a sad sad day in Princeton when the health inspectors finally close this place down.

    (4)

  • Heider T.

    I thought subway had it made, until I tried a sandwich in this place, huge place, gorgeous location and the servers are fast as well. The food is fresh, oh my God the sandwiches are huge! You can also have them half and trust me it'd be good enough for you. It's a very popular spot, so if you ever go to Princeton again, make sure to have a meal at Hoagie Heaven!

    (4)

  • lmno p.

    I remember being in love with the cheesesteaks when I first moved here. Now the shine has worn off but we still take out from here once in a while. The food is good but can't be good for you! It's an institution though and I love their t-shirts! I bought one for my brother who lives in Seattle and he gets compliments on it out there!

    (3)

  • Tiff C.

    Came here while visiting princeton with my family. My dad ordered the cheese steak & my sister ordered the hot pastrami. I had the cheese fries with mushrooms. The small sandwiches are HUGE & DELICIOUS!. The cheese fries were a little on the greasy side but still tasty with some hot sauce! I will def come again on my visits to princeton :)

    (5)

  • Juliana S.

    I love you Hoagie Haven! Your eggplant parm hoagie has and will always continue to be my favorite. Please, move to Philly and make my diet more complete(ly unhealthy)!

    (5)

  • Johnny C.

    great food and a historic background, if you ever go to princeton be sure to stop by. the sandwiches come in so many varieties and are complimented so well with great bread. the late hours are also great to fulfill that late night hunger.

    (5)

  • Arthur O.

    I probably have nothing new to add to the legend that is Haven. Nonetheless, armed with a notebook - not to mention a Yelp tab locked on Firefox - ten working fingers, and the memory of having Haven twice in one day, I am compelled. Folks like to talk about "late night eating" or "drunken meal" but what about breakfast? Lunch? Dinner? And those precious in-between meal snacks? Whenever I visit Princeton - one of my friends intent on self-improvement by self-torture still lives with his parents - I try to average at least 2 Haven visits per day. Princeton being 53.8 miles from my apartment, clearly, I've been trying to replicate the texture and the taste of Haven at home. Surely, it's impossible - especially when I've no clue as to where I can get them thinly sliced frozen pieces of pink meat that turns gray when cooked - but as we all know, hobbies are important.

    (5)

  • ed f.

    Food is okay but people worked there are impatient and not very friendly. If you want to come up with all the fancy names, you better give your first-time customers some time to figure them out. BOdy bag? What the heck is that?

    (1)

  • Robert C.

    Although the lines can get long around lunch and dinner, Hoagie Haven is well worth the wait. Hands down the best sandwiches in the Princeton area. All the ingredients are fresh and taste delicious. They have both hot and cold hoagies that will fill up your stomach without emptying your wallet! Prices are amazing for hoagies, especially for being in Princeton. A "half" hoagie (which is still about 10 inches) is between 3-4 dollars for most items, with a "whole" being a couple dollars more. If you are in Princeton, this is a place definitely worth checking out. If you go at peak hours thought (lunch and dinner) I HIGHLY suggest calling ahead so your order will be there waiting for you, so you don't have to wait in line. Their whole menu is on their website.

    (4)

  • TX B.

    ~$7 for a giant hoagie, with the works. Don't forget the peppers!

    (4)

  • Ben w.

    Five stars - nuff said.

    (5)

  • Smith F.

    A landmark within a landmark, Princeton's own Hoagie Haven is just that... a haven of hoagie happiness, and a source of alliterations. The story goes that Hoagie Haven was repetitively failing the state health code inspection year after year, though with no known complaints from customers. Finally, a few years ago, the state buckled down and forced them to clean up or close shop. So they closed shop. It was only a temporary closing for a month or two, though it seemed like an eternity. In that time they cleaned house, and no doubt scraped off all of the carcinogenic additives that were stuck to the walls from the past years of cooking greasy burgers and cheese steaks. This is undoubtedly a mixed blessing. While we all can dine there without worry of disease or cancer, I will openly admit that on a psychological level, the hoagies don't taste quiet as good. Oh who am I kidding?! They are still awesome!! Note, though you can take this hoagies off to the Princeton battlefield, or back home for later consumption, the fluidity of some of the ingredients will prevent the bread from retaining the structure integrity to hold it's components adequately. Hence my recommendation to consume the sandwich immediately. The location is ideal for pleasant walks in and around Princeton. They carry a full selection of bottled soft drinks including a wide array of Arizona teas, Snapple beverages, and a fine root bear selection. The menu is simple and direct with variations on all the major grease grill choices - burgers, dogs, hot and cold hoagies, fries, etc. A final note to newbies to the establishment. The staff has a great deal of history with the establishment and are an integral part of the dining experience. Though you aren't going to be ordering from the Hoagie Nazi, it is best that you are not debating your choices while they are trying to take your order, as the line will be long and they are ready to make your meal. SO MOVE IT OR LOSE IT!

    (5)

  • Karina M.

    There are probably three or four famous spots in Princeton: the campus itself, the battlefield, Einstein's house, and last but most definately not least-- Hoagie Haven. I have two words for you: Buffalo Fries. They are heavenly (my mouth is actually watering right now). I usually go for the Italian sub, or the fries, but the hoagies are definately worth a try. If you're feeling adventurous get a Phat Lady, but please be sure to be starving when you get it because otherwise you wont come out (or finish it...) alive. The staff is super friendly and fun, if you go there on a regular basis you get to know them pretty well. Ordering by phone before getting there is a good idea, because usually there is a long line.

    (5)

  • Lynn C.

    I grew up in Princeton and Hoagie Haven was the place to gather late Friday nights with the gang and scarf down cheese steaks that were out of this world. My folks still live there, so I get back frequently and every time I do, I stop by the Haven, order one of those cheese steaks loaded with fried onions, lettuce, tomatoes and more and am instantly transported right back to high school right from the first bite. Hoagie Haven is virtually an institution in Princeton, and the lines still from out the door for their amazing food. Wish they'd open an outpost in Santa Fe....

    (5)

  • di z.

    four. pretty damn delicious.

    (4)

  • Julie E.

    Chicken parm from Hoagie Haven. A masterpiece of massive, greasy proportions. My nostalgia prompts my taste buds to crave your goodness. For once in the rare occurrence of restaurants, Hoagie Haven's name appropriately reflects it's cuisine.

    (5)

  • Sasha K.

    If you absolutely must eat Hoagie, this place is FOR YOU! Near cult following by the Princeton High School crowd and other Hoagie Haven junkies. While you are there, grab a few Hoagie Haven t-shirts as presents! LG- XLG-XXLG Cash only.

    (5)

  • Kim S.

    Best thing about this Princeton establishment is the price. Wait times can be long, with no seating. If you are looking for a Philly cheesesteak and can't get to Philly, they do make a killer sandwich.

    (3)

  • Evan S.

    So divine: Let me lay it on the line, they have two on the vine. Not only are Jon Fernandez's devastating good looks, political cunning, and long, luxurious hippie hair owed entirely to this fine establishment, but students have been known to spend thousands of dollars at "the haven" during their Princeton careers, settle bets with hoagies, and even push old women out of the way to get an order in before closing. I have personally enjoyed the haven (#24, hot pastrami) as a delicious dinner, lovely lunch, and part of a complete breakfast. Their selection of drinks is vast, their drink prices are competitive, and many students claim the haven is better after a few drinks anwyay. While students, eating clubs, administrators (you know who I mean...), and even entire prison camp-like residential colleges come and go, the haven is a beloved and time-tested Princeton establishment.

    (5)

  • Eugene H.

    One of the best hoagie places in Princeton. This place has been around for quite a while and although it's pretty much a hole in the wall, what you get for what you pay is excellent.

    (4)

  • Tony W.

    A 'must-do' if you are hungry for something real and satisfying, especially late at night. Hoagie Haven is a bit of a hole in the wall, but you really can't go wrong here with anything you choose. You can probably tell how popular this place is by the lines that are usually out the door, but if that isn't a hint, try the cheesesteak. Definitely as good as you will find anywhere outside of Philly (and better than most places in Philly too). Hoagie Haven is my favorite sandwich place in Princeton - hands down.

    (5)

  • Chris S.

    Hoagie haven is grease truck heaven. I get a fat lady with ketchup and hot sauce every time I go there - Cheesesteak with fries and mozzarella sticks. So tasty. It's open late. Although they don't take credit cards, there is an atm in the store that will let you take out cash for a small fee ($1?). There's a wall with tons of pictures of people wearing hoagie haven tshirts at random places all over the world - great wall, afghanistan, etc. Bottom line - this place is awesome. Go here. Please. For your own sake.

    (5)

  • rachel d.

    Quite a few options for the vegetarian... The eggplant Parm is fantastic, as well as the cheese omelet. And there is your standard tuna and egg. They have rice pudding and tiramisu which I cant wait to try.

    (4)

  • T W.

    Been eating at Hoagie Haven for over 10 years. I go because they are open late, inexpensive, convenient, and consistent. However, they use lower-quality meats and cheeses (think bulk generic grade), and even worse, the bread sucks, white, mass produced, and tasteless (no excuse for bad hoagie bread in NJ). Not even close to the best hoagie I ever had, there are a half dozen places in Princeton you will get a better sandwich. But not for the price, and not late at night. Awesome atmosphere and they don't care if you are baked. And that's why I love Hoagie Haven.

    (4)

  • Jeffrey J.

    The hoagies at Hoagie Haven are the best!! You don't have to travel to Philly for the perfect hoagie when you have this awesome place in Princeton, NJ. The hoagie roll they use for their hoagies and hot sandwiches are amazing. It is so soft & the texture is perfect. It's all about the roll and Hoagie Haven is right on the mark. They are also very generous with the amount of meat and toppings they put into their sandwiches. Their hoagies are not for the faint at heart, so be prepared to have your cholesterol checked before you visit this place. This is the best sandwich shop in Princeton and probably in NJ. They have a huge menu of hoagie subs and hot subs similar to the ones you will see in the grease trucks at Rutgers University. These "grease" hoagies are also popular at Hoagie Haven. The lines are long, so be prepared to wait but they also close late if your looking for a midnight snack. My favorite hoagies are their classic italian hoagie and they have the BEST eggplant parmesan hoagie as well.

    (5)

  • yaagul D.

    hoagie haven is a delite I been living in Princeton for 20 yes and I loved hello: juggalos& juggalettes there food especially #15 &16 presently now they are not as good has when they had the orig anal crew (the guys with the cool mustaches) but despite the loss I still love hogie haven because they really have the best hogaies I ever had any were in this planet no exaggeration also they are economic , friendly this place is the pride of Princeton and when late hungry and drunk what best than hoagie haven. P.a. Don't go to gorges they are not has good look juggalos & juggaletes hoagie haven is not a miss is the best yummy...!

    (4)

  • Joe S.

    Hoagie Haven Full cheese steak with hot sauce, honey mustard, fries, and onions please. And if its a very cold night, order the Chili with a buttered roll. I remember this time I was in NYC at a bar, drinking it up, talkin to the ladies, and suddenly in my drunken state I uttered "If only there was a hoagie haven here". Shocked and intrigued this lovely woman to my right turned toward me, eyes wide open with flaring excitement..."you know hoagie haven!?!". And thats when I knew that my special hoagie place was not MY special hoagie place, but a gift to all of us. Call it what you will but hoagie haven will always hold a special place in my arteries.

    (5)

  • N J.

    Really good cheesesteaks. Half was the perfect size for me, whole is way too big. The long line goes by fairly quickly even during lunchtime due to their fast workers. Too bad I won't be visiting Princeton again any time soon.

    (4)

  • Amy F.

    Amazing cheesesteaks! Got the "phat lady" and shared with my brother. It's not good for your heart, but who cares? Tastes awesome. Most likely to see a line here. Cheap, fast, and greasy--perfect for a fatty like me!

    (5)

  • Tony G.

    YUM Simply the best hoagie, hero, sub, whatever you want to term it--I cant wait for reunions--Chicken Parm @ 2AM

    (5)

  • Ross R.

    I have a hard time knocking it any points. The food is satisfying. Yeah, I don't feel like it's the healthiest, but the price is right. Service is great. I like the full size cheesesteak and the western omelet, and I don't feel like I need to stray from these. I think I've tried some of the more exotic combinations, but haven't felt very good by the end of the meal--my fault, as my eyes were bigger than my stomach. All in all, a great spot. Usually open late (e.g., I typically stop by between 10pm and 2am on a weeknight), but they are sometimes closed randomly. The wait is longer than I want, so calling ahead with an order is my m.o.

    (5)

  • Kristen R.

    I get the chicken parm sub with lettuce, mayo, and bbq sauce. Don't knock it till you try it... this place is inappropriately delicious.

    (5)

  • Joe B.

    If you're visiting Princeton then don't miss Hoagie Haven! Awesome food and great staff.

    (5)

  • Jeff E.

    I don't get it. People swear by this place, but i think it's because any food tastes good when you are drunk and hungry. It is open late and is right beside the Ivy Inn. I think the sandwiches from the Wawa are better.

    (2)

  • Rob J.

    Haven is the best because they have awesome bread which comes fresh (supposedly) everyday from the Italian people's bakery in trenton, they have passed the state sanitation test for 6 years running now, and they store cooked bacon in a huge pile underneath the griddle, the cooks regularly pick their butts before cooking your food. That last part was a joke. Sorta. As a Princetonian, i offer some Haven Tips: - As a general rule of thumb, the cold hoagies are better at haven and the hot ones are better at georges -Nonetheless Haven "Serves the best Hamburgers on Earth or Anyplace else" - The #1 is legendary (italian). Preferable with everything, hot peppers, oil and vinegar, and mayo - The #3 is the poor man's # 1 - Trust them on the salt, pepper ketchup and the spices thing - grilled chicken sandwich is mad underated - Cheese steaks are awesome, especially with bacon and egg - the (Dirty) Sanchez is bomb, but be sure to ask for extra Sanchez Sauce, or hot sauce, its dry without it - The heartstop is nasty, im sorry. - Veal parm dinner no one seems to notice is on the menu hooks it up with breaded veal and pasta for like 5 bucks. - Cheddar fries come with cheese sauce whereas cheese fries are made with real american.

    (5)

  • Neil J.

    It's good for their unique sandwich combinations (the Body Bag and Phat Lady are pretty good), but they're just your neighborhood greasy sandwich in a bag shop. Take it for what it is, and enjoy it.

    (4)

  • Samuel R.

    Been going here forever. Doesn't get any better than the extra dirty sanchez or a greasy bacon cheesesteak.

    (5)

  • Karma B.

    Everything everyone else says is true. It's great.

    (5)

  • George L.

    Over. Rated. The food is pure garbage.

    (1)

  • Peggy C.

    This place is a staple for younger people. Typical fried food. Burger, Fries, Onion Rings. Hoagies. They also serve Spaghetti, fried chicken My son says "Get the Phat Lady! That's the best!:.

    (3)

  • John L.

    west coast just can't do hoagies like the east... actually they don't even call them hoagies. i had the capicola, ham, salami, provolone and the philly steak. both were excellent. i've had the real philly steaks in philly and this one can hold its own (although i like the ones in philly better). you can't really eat inside so we stood outside chomping away. unfortunately... i won't ever be in the princeton area anytime soon... maybe never. i'll just pray that my son or daughter goes to princeton.

    (4)

  • Derek C.

    There is a sign near the fryers that says "Best hamburgers in the world". It's the truth. Salt pepper ketchup? Yes please!

    (5)

  • Emily W.

    The best hoagie place I know of. I grew up eating this stuff and go every time I'm back in Princeton. Number 6 please!!!

    (5)

  • R C.

    I randomly ran into this during my time at Princeton and sure enough I was hooked! It definitely is a hole in the wall joint that sticks out like a soar thumb on Nassau Street but it's worth it! I usually had the omelet hoagie for $3 but I also liked the BLTs and pepper steak options. This place is ALWAYS opened for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and midnight snack. The cashiers were also very friendly and welcoming to newcomers. Two thumbs up for Hoagie Haven!

    (5)

  • Cara N.

    Some friends and I went here on a Sunday afternoon, and we were unimpressed, to say the least. The hoagies just weren't good! The prices are low - how much can you expect to pay for a hoagie though? I'm wondering how this place got all of these high ratings, but I have to think back to when I was in college, and anything that wasn't cafeteria food tasted pretty good. Seriously, you'd be better off going to Wawa for a hoagie.

    (1)

  • Carrie E.

    There's not much I can say that hasn't already been said, but I just couldn't call myself a Yelper if I didn't chime in with my deep feelings of love and admiration for Hoagie Haven. The food there is so good that once my husband and I drove from our place in Brooklyn to Princeton just for a Hoagie Haven sandwich, gobbled it up by the fountain and then turned right around and went home. Now that's love.

    (5)

  • Vihar D.

    SIMPLY AWESOME! Nothing more, nothing less. PS: for someone with not so great appetite, opt for half size.

    (5)

  • Dkrejser S.

    Heavenly hoagies! My mouth watering as I was reading my first review. This place continues to rock!

    (5)

  • Geoff Y.

    I'm reading the reviews and would never have imagined that the cheesesteaks were actually that good. When I went, I had the sausage and pepper sub (ironic, given this place's name) and it was pretty good. It might sound redundant to say this, but the food was hot since it was straight off the grill (I've had stuff that wasn't hot straight off the grill). The peppers were sweet (almost suspiciously so). The only thing I have against the place is that there's nowhere to sit except a solitary bench outside, which is tough when it gets cold out. Other than that, it's a good sub shop.

    (4)

  • Sean P.

    This is hands down one of the best Hoagie places that I know of. That said, not every single one of the sandwiches they have there are tops, but all of them are at least decent. There are two distinct Hoagie Haven experiences: Drunk or Sober One must experience the drunken comaraderie that occurs around 2AM on Thursday and Saturday nights. Princeton students, residents, and others file in, yelling on top of each other to get a nice hot sandwich in the early hours of the morning. The sober experience parallels in excellence. Most anything on their specials menu is great (except unforunately the Shrimp Po-Boy, the first few bites are great but it quickly gets extremely dry and bland). Sauces, greasy meats, and bread and combined in a wonderful unison that makes you want more (and feel oh so guilty after having pigged on an entire sandwich).

    (4)

  • David B.

    I used to go here all the time, until the help changed. The food is good, but the help is not polite and , disrespectful. They think they are the only place around. The place needs to find a way to maintain a crowd better.

    (2)

  • Amit K.

    This place is crazy - for $5 you walk away with an all-you-can-eat sized hoagie, stuffed to the core with various combinations of toppings and sauces. Always packed with students, but the line moves quickly with the staffs assembly-line approach. Our go-to place, when we want a food fix past 11 pm.

    (4)

  • Ted D.

    The one, the only. Awesomest big sandwiches I know, anywhere, period. I've never figured out what kind of crack they put in these things, but in the course of any given trip back to Princeton I'm inexorably drawn there just about every day. And even with price increases over the years, everything still manages to be ridiculously cheap here. The classic Italian-style hoagies and parm sandwiches are the real deal. Big omelet sandwiches? Hell yes. Any menu item with a number on it is old school and top notch. Get lettuce, tomato, onions, and hot peppers on just about any sandwich - the hot peppers are totally key. In recent years they've added some flashy drunkfood sandwich options to compete with the Rutgers grease trucks and cater to the neanderthal bro in all of us. Giant piles of fries and mozz sticks and eggs and bacon and whatever on top of a normal sandwich, with names like Heart Stop, Body Bag, and Sanchez (get it 'Dirty' for extra sauce, huh huh huh do you get it brah??). Forget about this garbage, you don't need an arterial grease injection to reach true Haven enlightenment. Keep it classy, Princeton.

    (5)

  • Max S.

    Monster sized subs. Had the chicken parm, it was great. Could use less lettuce but was spiced great otherwise.

    (4)

  • Pearl O.

    he thought it tasted better than pat's steaks. i, personally, wouldnt go as far as to say THAT, but it was pretty good for outside of philly. we were driving through the princeton area and he insisted that we take a little detour to stop here. despite our having eaten a very large breakfast not even 2 hours earlier, we still managed to house a $7 whole cheese steak* that's wider than the width of my lap between the two of us. the line was nearly out the door in this small dine out** joint because each sub is made to order, spending a few minutes in their large toaster oven to melt cheesy goodness onto the flavored steak meat. but it's well worth it. *veggie toppings included **outdoor benches

    (4)

  • Mantri P.

    The best late night eatery around. Sanchez--Extra Dirty , you cannot go wrong with that order. The bread is good, the chicken is delicious. The sanchez sauce is amazing. TRY IT!

    (5)

  • Atilla B.

    Cheap, quick and fun to eat. If you get one of the specials, it's like eating 3-4 sandwiches all crammed into one. Add hot sauce to that! Enough said...

    (4)

  • Alexis F.

    My family always gets the cheesesteak with everything, but I love the fat lady and heart stoppers !

    (5)

  • Hartej S.

    I've been visiting Hoagie Haven since I went to high school at West Windsor Plainsboro South. Years later I'm still addicted to the place. Although I miss the Bengali guys that used to make my food without any gloves on, this place is the greatest. I wish the current staff spoke better english and were better at taking orders. I am a huge fan of the fat cats, and make SURE you get the buffalo cheese fries. I can't even imagine how much more ridiculous Hoagie Havens business would be if Princeton had more night life. Hoagie Haven loyalist for life!

    (4)

  • Hanne V.

    If I want to sum up this place in one line, I would call it a premium Subway: it feels a bit more authentic, but the sandwiches are just as greasy and fast-foody as a typical Subway. The place claims to be Italian, but listing "Eggplant Parmigiana" on your menu hardly makes it Italian. Forget crispy ciabatta or French baguettes, light toppings, delicate cheeses or cured hams. Instead think huge (who can possibly eat a whole bread?) soggy breads, stuffed with melted low-quality cheese, tons of sauce and greasy meat. Would I come here again: sure! But lets be honest, only because I want to satisfy a cheap and fat fast food craving, not because of refined food.

    (3)

  • Robyn H.

    Yeah.... it really is THAT GOOD!!!!!! I agree with all the rave reviews below mine. Grew up going to Hoagie Haven, although NOT SO OFTEN because I had parents that actually COOKED DINNER every night. LOL Once I was old enough to eat whatever I wanted, I went there a lot more often than I care to admit!!!! Definitely one of the best.

    (4)

  • Doris W.

    After reading about fat sandwiches, I was excited to find that I could get one without having to drive up to Rutgers. I was also excited to find out at you can get a 1/2 hoagie instead of a whole. I think I would have died. It is located off a happening street in Princeton. So it's definitely a typical college joint. A lot selections and unfortunately cash-only for people who don't usually carry cash. There is an on-site ATM, so no worries there. So deciding which hoagie to get, I ended up getting the Sanchez. I did not get it extra dirty since it looked like the guy poured a lot of sauce. It was a nice night so I sat outside to eat. It is definitely messy so I was lucky enough to only get a drop of sauce on my shirt. How was it? I thought it was ok. I mean it's really just a bunch of fried food stuffed into bread with cheese and sauce. I could also be that I don't eat food like this so my stomach just wasn't having it. At one point, I got tired of chewing so I ate each ingredient individually. The chicken fingers were nice and crispy. The mozarella sticks were actually really bad by itself. Barely fried crisp with the cheese having the texture of fake chicken nuggets. The fries were just fries. I'm glad to have tried it but now I know it is definitely not my type of hoagie. I would be willing to try something else.

    (3)

  • S E.

    I've been a regular for decades. Great value for delciously greasy hot sandwiches. The eggplant parm is the best I've ever had.

    (5)

  • Ross M.

    Don't for an entire morning....wait until 3pm....then go in and order a whole SANCHEZ--extra dirty of course. Don't forget to grab an Arnold Palmer from the fridge. Enjoy.

    (5)

  • David C.

    Excellent place to come for a quick bite if you're in the downtown Princeton area. It's cash only, and there isn't any seating, but the food is good and cheap. For me, a good hoagie/sub shop must have good bread, and that's what hoagie haven has. Lightly toasted, airy, and flavorful. It provides an excellent base for whatever goes in it. The cheesesteak with fried egg is a classic for me. If not that, the gyro/souvlaki is always good as are pretty much anything on the hot side of the menu. The cold cuts are decent, but nothing special. Service is quick and generally friendly. For fast eats in Princeton, especially during late night, Hoagie Haven can't be beat.

    (4)

  • Matt B.

    Great place to get a sandwich. Not for the health conscious. Many of the special sandwiches have names that deal with health problems (the Heart Stop, the Body Bag, and the Block just to name a few). The bread they use is outstanding and they are not stingy with the sauces. I made a special stop with some friends when driving down route 1 and they all agreed that it was the best sandwich they ever had. If you go late night, be aware that the grill will be turned off exactly at closing time (no matter how long you have been there) but they will make cold sandwiches until the line is gone.

    (5)

  • Ryan L.

    Huge hoagies with a cult following. I've always had great food here.

    (4)

  • Mark D.

    Tips: You can add cheese, eggs, and/or bacon to any of your sandwiches for a few extra charge, so take full advantage of that. Stay away from cold sandwiches as the hot ones are much much better. Good items: I get lettuce, tomato, onion, ketchup, mayonnaise, salt & pepper on most of my sandwiches. All of these are hot sandwiches: Western Omelette - ham and green pepper omelette. My favorite. I always ask for cheese. Sausage Omelette - sausage omelette. Also good if you prefer sausage over ham and green peppers. I always ask for cheese. Sanchez - the sauce is a sour sauce, which I dislike. I never get the sanchez sauce. This is chicken cutlet with fries and mozarella sticks. Heartstop - If you're going to get a cheese steak, and want eggs & bacon on it, might as well get a heartstop. Fried Flouder - it's fried fish. Pretty good though they could give more fish pieces. Meatballs - Takes quite awhile before it gets soggy, so eat it on the spot for the best taste. Sides: Hash Browns - 3 pieces for $2. They are so good. I always get it with a sandwich so that I can stick it in for even better taste. Stay away from The Bloch (gets soggy way too fast and really nasty when that happens), Cheese fries (it's just white cheese on top of fries, so it's not the expected kind of cheese you'd find on nachos), Pastrami (It's okay, but I find the other sandwiches much better), and the Phat Lady (I just don't really like their fries and mozerella sticks enough to get this over other choices).

    (4)

  • Irene H.

    I will always have a soft spot for Hoagie Haven. I lived in the area when I was much younger and my parent regularly took us here. I have no idea what they used to order, but whatever it was, it was good. I visited recently and went with the bacon omelet with cheese. I shared a half with my friend because we had more eating planned for the day. Still good, still greasy, and still very crowded. I love a good sandwich!

    (4)

  • Tim B.

    Get the wake up call. You will not be disappointed.

    (5)

  • Ken S.

    The only place in Princeton that stays open past midnight. Used to come here during late night study groups pretty often. The guys working here are fast and furious, not to mention very friendly. They offer some of the highest calorie foods too, but worth trying at least once. The Phat Lady and Heartstopper are classics, and so is the grilled eggplant.

    (4)

  • Valerie V.

    Oh Hoagie Haven how I miss you! My HH meal of choice is the Pizza Cheese Steak Hoagie with all the fixings...mmmm! If only they delivered to California! HH is a staple in Princeton. It would not be the same without it.

    (5)

  • Ben C.

    The real deal. Packed full of students and others - food cooked quickly and to order. Nothing under the heat lamps here. You know you want the heart stop sandwich. Go ahead. Order it. It will make you smile. You can diet tomorrow.

    (5)

  • Alex R.

    While driving through NJ my dad wanted to stop at one of the many memories he had from college. Staying up late studing and dropping by here in the late hours of the night to grab one of the best hoagie's ever. These things are what my dad would say "exquisite". The bread is awesome and the amount of food you get for the low price is fantastic. I love how they have pictures hanging on the wall next to the register of people wearing their Hoagie Haven T-Shirts from all over the world. It made me want to buy one, and I did. So now I have this awesome orange Hoagie Haven shirt that is the colors of the school it represents, Princeton. I ordered the Pizza Steak Hoagie because it was my dads favorite and my sister got the meatball one. I am not a fan of meatball sandwitches, but when I tried hers, it was really really really great. I absolutely loved mine, I ate half of a whole one with my dad and I kept thinking I wanted more, but when I got up to go order another, the line was out the door and we needed to get back on the road. This place has a spot in my dads heart and I have to say this place is so good it is now apart of me too. Maybe it runs in the blood, but I have to say I can not wait to come back here. Maybe I should try and get accepted to Princeton? haha in my dreams.....

    (5)

  • Sadie R.

    I've been coming here for nearly 25 years. Yes, really. Today I ate a #1 with everything. When I was 16, I lived on grilled cheese Hoagies (they weren't yet on the menu, but I ate one every sunday after church - yes, church). When I stopped being vegetarian one night at midnight, I ate a whole roast beef hoagie by the fountain with my skater buddies. In college, I got into the weird realm of cheesesteaks, and all the crazy heart stopping variants that fellow Cloister Inn folks invented. Since then, every visit home, reunions, holidays, involves several haven visits. I'm still a huge fan of a #1 with everything - except mayo. I won't turn down bites of a hot pastrami or a bacon cheesteak, but my 6 foot husband is more likely to burn that off.

    (5)

  • Craig G.

    I love this place... It's right down the street from Westminster Choir College so when I was a student there, this was the closest place to get lunch outside the school. It's a great place to hang out and the cheesesteaks are out of this world. Any time I go to Princeton I plan on eating here!

    (5)

  • Andrew M.

    Huge greasy sandwiches full of succulent meat. Really wacky combinations with creative names. A must-try at Princeton.

    (5)

  • Jessica C.

    Call and order ahead on weekend nights after 8. Walking past the line and just grabbing your food will elicit a feeling that tastes as delicious as the sandwich you will consume.

    (3)

  • Alex F.

    Hoagie Haven is a Princeton institution. Cheap, delicious, fast, and greasy food. Whether it's noon and you're sober or midnight and you're drunk Hoagie Haven is delicious. I highly recommend the cheese fries (or buffalo cheese fries, buffalo fries, or honey mustard cheese fries) or any of the fat sandwiches. George's next door usually does better hot sandwiches though (better quality chicken at least), so if you are going during the day it might be worth checking George's out instead. Otherwise they have the same owners and make basically the same food.

    (5)

  • Rebekah S.

    If you're an eater and I'm an eater, then you'll love this place like I love this place! Been going here since high school, and although my metabolism may be slowing, the taste buds are still the same (okay, probably a bit more refined, but I digress!). It's cheap, it's greasy, it's good and you get a LOT of hoagie towards your hunger!! It's great for 16 year olds, 26 year olds and 36 year olds. I'll tell you if I love this place when I hit 46, but I think I'll still fondly remember the days I can eat a whole chicken parm hoagie and still have room for fries, dinner and then some. Now I'll stick with a whole hoagie as a "once in a while" treat... Gotsta keep the tubby from getting too chubby! Definitely go... the cheesesteak and the chicken parm are my particular favorites!

    (4)

  • Olivia S.

    Italian people's bread and an extra dirty Sanchez. Enough said.

    (5)

  • Susan L.

    After hearing raves about this place, I decided to give it a try. I was not impressed. On the plus side, the hoagie I ordered was quite tasty (the sanchez) and the prices are very reasonable. Downright cheap for the size of the hoagie. On the down side, the place was really filthy. Ok, I know it's a dive, but I've been in cleaner dives. Also on the down side is that they don't accept credit or debit cards at all. Cash only. I won't be rushing back there.

    (2)

  • Te R.

    first, i do not like sandwiches or something of that sort. but i love hoagie haven. when i was walking there, i was like... hmmm how good a hoagie could get. i got there and ordered cheese steak and bacon sandwich. they grilled the cheese steak, bacon, and bread separately, so everything was crispy and tasty. hmmmmm my friends got chicken parm and cheese steak with buffalo chicken. they were very pleased. i just moved here for grad school and would totally come here a lot.

    (5)

  • Conway Y.

    Honestly, I think that if anyone opened a store anywhere in the world where they deep-fry their food as much as Haven does, you'd have a pretty popular fanbase. I'm proud (or should I say not proud) to say that I've had every one of their "named" sandwiches like the Dirty Sanchez, Bloch, Big Cat, etc. Sure, what's not to love? Its the epitome of a glutton's paradise... deep fried, steak-filled, cheese-layered, eggy 15 inch hoagies that can't be eaten more than two days in a row because they'll cause a heart attack. Sure, it's intensely satisfying.in a way that McDonalds or Burger King tries to emulate, that greasy zone where the brain shuts down. It's very much like a drug, in that respect. I think that this place could serve worms if they were sufficiently fried and layered in cheese. I have no doubt that people would flock to it, wait in lines, and rate it highly on sites like Yelp. The only reason I don't rate it lower is because.. well, it's good stuff, in a I'm-going-to-regret-this-later, primeval way that satisfies our carnivore roots. For under $10, you can't get a better experience at any other fast food joint. But now that I've had all of their best, I usually skip over Haven to some other place in Princeton like George's Roasters next door or the Soupman. Go once, go twice, but don't go after that.

    (3)

  • Ceci S.

    I am from the Princeton area and all of my friends are for some reason obsessed with this place. And it's really not bad, though not spectacular either. It is basically just a grease truck indoor-style. They do have the typical "fat" sandwiches and it is cheaply priced as well. Other than that it's just another sub place. If grease truck food is your style, then go there and you will be happy. They are good for their target consumer base, which are college students.

    (3)

  • J D.

    Nope, it's just not all that. If you are starving, really drunk, broke, or any combination of the above, I'm sure Hoagie Haven is fantastic. Stagger in, scream a number, hand over $10, and get about 3 pounts worth of sandwich, most of which you will wind up wearing while you gobble down your food on a park bench outside. I can also easily imagine the nostalgia I would build around this place if it was part of my college experience. But, if you aren't from the area, or are picky about food, or are (occasionally) sober, you will probably be like me and leave very underwhelmed. It's all Subway-grade ingredients on cheap white bread with fried food on the side -- might as well eat fast food instead. No way Hoagie Haven should pop up as one of the top restaurants in Princeton!

    (3)

  • Micah M.

    I have no idea why people like Hoagie Haven. Maybe it has something to do with school spirit or hometown nostalgia. Maybe they're too wasted to taste the food. Anyway, Hoagie Haven is just a grungy dive with sandwiches that never fail to make my stomach hurt. But I guess you don't have many options in Princeton...

    (1)

  • Greg Y.

    Sandwiches are cheap, gigantic, filling, and just plain delicious. Who wouldn't want to eat a sandwich stuffed with mozzarella sticks and/or french fries? Classic hoagies: Phat Lady, Sanchez (order it extra dirty). Mexicali is quite good if you're feeling a little more adventerous. Not exactly diet food, but otherwise HH is the place to grab some of the best grub in the area.

    (5)

  • Adam S.

    This place saved my ass on a late week day night. Flew in to LGA and made the drive to Princeton. Got in to town around 11:30 and not a thing was open except Starbucks?!? I hadn't eaten since breakfast and I was hangry. Then I drive by the shining window of Hoagie Haven, see a large crowd of people inside, and know I'm home. 5 minutes later I'm walking out with a delicious Italian hoagie, and a couple bags of chips. 10 minutes after that I'm at my hotel eating and deciding it's a damn good hoagie.

    (5)

  • Charles C.

    i grew up going to the wwp school district. this was the place to go after drinking with friends. although they aren't quite the same as they used to be. i'll still make pit stops to this place when ever i come back. the best sandwich here is the #16 bacon cheese steak (cause its a classic). a newer creation called the heart stop (basically #16 plus egg) is also recommended.

    (4)

  • Amanda S.

    Ohhh Hoagie Haven .. you sure are special. Mmmmm. To be honest .. this place is pretty darn gross. Inside could be MUCH more cleaner and appealing. The people working are not very nice. There is also usually a line that moves slow, especially late night. However .. this is a local hot spot. It is just plain old good. And they are open SUPER LATE. If you can handle waiting in the gross line for a few minuets .. give this one a try. The line inside wont seem so gross anymore. 5 stars for the HH.

    (5)

  • John M.

    Whenever I am in town i always make it a point to stop in for a cheese steak, their bread is delicious and i am always pleased with this place. If your ever in town its totally worth the trip

    (5)

  • Andy Y.

    The sandwich there is amazing! I love Heart Stop the most! But I think people should just try every sandwich if you can!

    (5)

  • Kimarie C.

    OK...I want to be honest and give a helpful review. I LOVE HH! But---if you want a 5 star experience there are a few things you need to do: 1. BRING CASH! 2. Don't go there for a sandwich you can get any any other subshop, that's not what they do best! 3. Go for one of the HH crazy concoction subs, but read what is on it. Customize yours. (Ex: I get the Wake Up Call without Pork Roll[never been a fan]and ketchup instead of hot sauce) 4. Don't be afraid of the queue, they know how to get you out the door quickly. Pick out your beverage while you are waiting, as they have quite an impressive selection! 5. You can step to the side after giving your order, maybe even pay at the register, but don't wander far, as you will be asked what condiments you would like on your sub. 6. Enjoy an out of the ordinary taste treat...we are not talking gourmet food by any stretch, but this is THE place for late night, cheap eats. That's the niche they have carved, and they do it best. Where else in Princeton are you going to get fried eggs with your bacon cheesesteak/burger? It's a taste like no other, and if it is for you, you will be craving it at least once a month! So, please don't go and order a chicken, eggplant or meatball parm, and then give the place 3 stars because it didn't live up to the hype. The other subs are all edible and very worth the money (A whole 12" Eggplant Parm for $6?? C'mon!) ***If you don't get the first sub choice right, come back one more time and try something different!!***

    (5)

  • Vikash S.

    There's a reason Haven is considered the best not only by locals. This place never fails to disappoint. Excellent value and taste, the bread is light and fluffy, and their sandwiches are king. The fried macaroni wedges are delicious, crispy on the outside and gooey and rich on the inside. Pretty sure the macaroni is craft mac and cheese, but it's a home run. My personal fav sandwiches: eggplant parm with hot peppers, and the phat lady with fried eggs instead of steak. This sandwich (phat lady) is HUGE -comes standard with french fries and mozzarella sticks, and the sanchez sauce pulls it all together. Get a whole if you're starving, or get a whole anyways and save half for later! Simply delicious.

    (5)

  • Aaron J.

    A Hoagie Haven bacon cheese steak at 2am on a drunken Friday or Saturday night is one of life's greatest triumphs... Not to be missed. There's a reason why this place is legendary.

    (5)

  • Greg D.

    I was in a touring band a while back and every time we were in the area we were at Hoagie Haven. Though I was vegetarian at the time, it was still amazing. I would always get the #12 with the cheese on the grill. Of course they didn't like this request because it's got to be a pain in the ass. But when there's a line of 6 guys requesting the same thing they would always give in. It was basically fried cheese, nice and crispy and super unhealthy. The eggplant parm was good too. Hoagie Haven was our East Coast Mecca. I miss it dearly.

    (5)

  • Vick J.

    if you like Triumph..if you like their beer...if you enjoi their Saturday night band....then you have to end your night with Hoagie Haven.... Perfect greasy food to put you too bed!!!

    (4)

  • Charles H.

    A true Princeton institution. Anyone who has visited Princeton remembers this place long before any other restaurant in town. Haven has changed somewhat over the years. The extended menu on the left side is a relatively new addition that added some sandwiches similar to the Rutgers Grease Trucks. I don't personally care for those and the related indigestion, so I would advise first time visitors to head straight for the number 14 (cheesesteak). It's prepared differently from the Philly-style shredded/chopped steak so it doesn't fall apart between bites. Get it with lettuce-tomato-onion, ketchup and mayo. Add a rice pudding from the fridge on the left. Also try the western omelet, bacon cheesesteak, number 1 Italian, chicken cheesesteak, cheese fries, hot pastrami, American-Provolone cheese hoagie (wtih honey mustard), and chicken salad hoagie with bacon.

    (5)

  • Janelle M.

    Hoagie Haven rocks. Sure it's a greasy college joint, but that's part of the experience. You're a little tipsy and you're hungry and you know you're going to HH to get a huge sandwich for like $5. Sweet. Veggie options are limited to the Cheese Hoagie and the Eggplant Parm, but the menu has a ton of options for everyone else. Go there, you won't be disappointed. Cash only, but ATM in store.

    (4)

  • Todd O.

    i've heard a lot of good things about this place before moving to the princeton area; even my foodie phone apps were telling me to check this place out. this definitely is a hole-in-the-wall...and NOT for those that are on any sort of diet. i look at the old school menus and see something that stands out: the "body bag": an italian hoagie + provolone cheese steak + hash browns + eggs + hot sauce. i don't know who thought of such a mix, but one would definitely die happy after eating this. i'll be back to try the other things on the menu...just remember to bring cash because they won't accept your credit cards.

    (4)

  • Joanna K.

    *Cash only* Hoagie Haven is an institution in Princeton. The sandwiches are HUGE so be forewarned - a half size is plenty for most. My two favorite items are their buffalo fries (french fries coated in hot sauce and the most delicious mild blue cheese sauce) and their cheesesteak. Pro-tip: order double meat on the cheesesteak. Just do it.

    (5)

  • Tom L.

    definitely cheap and filling, I can see how this is a big hit with the younger crowd. I got the number 1 (provolone, ham, capicola, salami) and it was pretty good. however, some things stuck out. for peppers, they use jalapeno instead of the typical italian hot peppers which I did not like too much. while they don't exactly skimp on the meat, the slices are too thick. It reminds me of what you would get in the supermarket instead of the deli. lastly, there is usually a decent wait at all hours of the day, usually hordes of high schoolers. overall, not a bad place and would definitely come back, but for now, Tastee Sub in Edison is still my top spot in NJ for a sandwich

    (3)

  • Ravi D.

    Great sub, definitely not an often place to eat, but a bang for the buck!

    (4)

  • Damian S.

    I worked down the road from this place.....it's good, not great.If you want a relatively cheap cheesesteak (think steak'um) then this place is for you...

    (3)

  • Kevin P.

    Cheap. But hey, you get what you pay for. Over-processed cold cuts, greasy fried food, nasty lettuce, boring bread. Did I mention it's cheap? There are plenty of better places in town, unless you're on a tight budget.

    (2)

  • Samik S.

    I give this place a 4 because it's fun. It's that guilty pleasure that everyone has. Incredibly unhealthy, but so savory and good. Making that trip out to Princeton late night, just to fulfill that Hoagie Haven craving - it's fun. These might not be the absolute best fat sandwiches out there (I prefer Ewing's Fat Shack), but it all comes together to make a good experience. Attempting to interact with the workers, asking for 'spices' instead of just oregano or whatever that concoction is, saying you want your sandwich extra dirty, and then biting into that saucy masterpiece. It's all awesome.

    (4)

  • Nyomi L.

    I wanted to *love* this place, because I think anyone daring enough to put mozzarella sticks in a sub deserves all the love I can give him... but, I couldn't. What should've turned out to be spectacular (in theory anyways) turned out to be mediocre. What should've been fourth of july in my mouth was just another sub, albeit one that's probably shortening my life by a good 5 years. I'll come back, if only to try the other wacky combinations... but as for loving... I'll probably hang on to my heart.

    (3)

  • Pooja K.

    Im a simpleton- i just get the plain boring turkey sub-- but with their fresh ingredients, the bread always tastes like its just out of the oven and thier spring lettuce.. just makes my day :) Dont expect a subway variety of veggies, but whatever they have is alwyas fresh! I live in jersey city now and no one makes hoagies like our little princeton hoagie haven! FIVE STARS! PS_ their chicken cheesesteak is awesome as well!!!

    (5)

  • Geoff c.

    Soo gooood. I always stop by hoagie haven when I'm passing by Princeton. Considering I'll soon be working in the Princeton area, I should probably stop that, lest I self-induce coronary artery disease within a year. The heart stop and phat lady are my go-to, as well as tons of loyal HH'ers. I haven't tried the body bag yet, though it looks/sounds equally awesome and myocardial infarct-inducing. They also have a great selection of drinks, ranging from your regular soft drinks to lesser popular varieties of Stewarts, and the most recent interesting drink I saw... hemp iced tea? Haven't tried that one. If you're new, bear right when you get in. Order at the counter on the right. Get out of the way and wait for your sandwich. Pay on the left where the cashier is. Then go outside and sit on the benches and enjoy. Also take notice that the ground around the benches outside is noticeably darker. That's from all the greasiness of all the many people who have sat where you are sitting. Eating greased-delicious hoagies.

    (5)

  • Steve A.

    It's like the grease trucks in New Brunswick, minus the grease, plus an actual restaurant to be in. Minus some of the attitude, plus the ability to add your own toppings. Great price, great food too. Interesting drink selection too, like Mexican Coke. I have a lot more hoagies to try here.

    (4)

  • Siyi F.

    Greased out fare for high school and college kids. that's perfectly fine, but they don't even do it that well. George's next door is so much better. And the food trucks I had in college did it so much better too. I ate here quite a bit because it was close and it was cheap, but once I discovered George's buffalo chicken cheesesteak I never went back (and same owners, I think). I feel like people eat here just because it's a Princeton institution and because of their grease truck type sandwiches. But they just don't make them quite right, you know?

    (2)

  • Judy S.

    WHY IS THIS NOT FIVE STARS?! No words can describe Hoagie Haven. Even thinking it makes me shed happy, happy tears of joy. The hoagies are not for the faint-hearted. I'm a small, Asian girl and many have told me one cannot finish a full hoagie on the first try. This would've been true if I wasn't starving. So tip: Go when you are starving. But once you start, you just can't stop. It is ridiculously good. I'm a firm believer of the Heartstop. The first time I met him -- my heart did indeed stop. Your virgin bite is something you'll remember for the rest of your life. The first half comes easy. Once you reach the second half, it only becomes all the more savory. And at the end, you could only wish for more. Five minutes later, you'll feel so full and satiated. It's a pretty fulfilling rollercoaster experience. All the haters that gave this place four stars did not have one of Hoagie Haven's signature hoagies. It's impossible to not fall in love with this place. Best in the country! FLY HERE TO HAVE A HOAGIE HAVEN HOAGIE. It's dirt cheap and it's so good it can't be real... but it is. Going to get a Heartstop when I get back to campus for sure.

    (5)

  • Tom M.

    I attended a screening of Race to Nowhere in Princeton on 11/17/10. I looked on Yelp for a dinner spot and by far the best and most rated place is Hoagie Haven. For those who have not been, there is no seating so I had to eat my hoagie in my car. I didn't mind because it was so good. I ordered the Shrimp Po Boy which does not really follow the precise New Orleans po boy method. No Yelp reviews mentioned it but I was intrigued. It is on their hot items menu and the description on the website reads: "Lettuce, Tomatoes, Tartar Sauce & Hot Sauce." I watched as it was assembled. The guy put on the fried shrimp and tartar sauce. Then he asked me if I wanted hot sauce, lettuce and tomato. Why do they ask? Of course I want hot sauce on it! I watched as he proceeded to squirt a ton of hot sauce onto the sandwich. Concerned, and wishing I had said, "just a little" I proceeded to my car and dinner. What a great hoagie! I ordered a half size. The whole is huge. The bread for the half is perfect. It surrounded the contents of the Po Boy like a glove. Barely anything spilled out. And it was really thin. Some hoagie places give you this dense bread. Not here. The lettuce was perfect. It was in very thin strips, almost as if it was cut for coleslaw. I shouldn't have worried about the hot sauce. It mixed with the tartar sauce to be the perfect dressing for the fried shrimp. If I am anywhere near Princeton again I will return to Hoagie Heaven for a Shrimp Po Boy.

    (5)

  • Franklin A.

    Heavenly! I know that Philly is known the world over for their cheesesteaks, but Hoagie Haven truly cannot be beat. This place is a MUST for anyone visiting the Lawrenceville/Princeton area! The sandwiches are to die for from the regular cheesesteak to one of their hot or cold signature sandwiches. I've been eating here for the past 20+ years. Every time I am in the area I have to make my pilgrimage here and have a cheesesteak...no ifs, ands, or buts about it. Very affordable...but get there either a little bit before lunch or a little after lunch because the line gets LONG (and often out the door).

    (5)

  • Dan M.

    Finally got to try the infamous hoagie haven in Princeton NJ. When is walked into the place I couldn't stop studying the crazy and insane menu. Its one long list of massive subs stuffed with anything everything you could think of. I went with the extra dirty Sanchez. Which is chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, fried eggs and some random sauces. My buddy went with the heart attack which is chicken fingers, loads and loads of bacon and a bunch of eggs. The sandwiches are huge and def have a shot at killing someone but you just have to give this place a shot at least once.

    (4)

  • Annamarie T.

    Deliciousness!!!!!! The only way to describe this place!! Some of the best cheese fries ever, in addition to one of the best cheese steaks ever! All the food is so great, and such great prices!!!! There is no going wrong with Hoagie Haven.

    (5)

  • Lily P.

    Great prices..sandwiches huge subs for $4 and tshirts for $15 that are reversible and have writing and are pretty witty. The place is cash and has a old fashion register which is amusing to watch them operate. Its fun to figure out what the differen subs are since they have philly cheese steaks with eggs & bacon, cheesesticks with fries and chicken tenders in some sandwiches, and others are def things you want to just say you have tried. I got a turkey sandwich the first time i was here and though it was huge..the turkey wasn't the best. It reminded me of cheap bulk turkey that had been frozen and then thawed out...ehh..I def think its better for the warm food.

    (3)

  • Jinhee L.

    Went here for lunch because I was around.. and it was the worst experience I've ever had at a food place. One particular employee that had "helped" me that day was the most rude and careless person I've ever had to deal with..He was so lazy and in such a rush to get me out of there (there was no line whatsoever, I was the only one in the store at the time). While he was in the process of still putting my sandwich together, I had asked him if those were pickles, but he literally ignored me, wrapped up my sandwich as if I was already done, and said "its too late". Oh, and the food? Nothing special. Just huge sandwiches full of random crap. Or maybe I didn't enjoy it as much after having a huge argument with the employee. I have no tolerance for terrible service like that. Never going here again.

    (1)

  • Anya S.

    Well, no heaven, but is open late at night and the price is right. I think this is a solid choice, considering your options for late night snack in Princeton. They offer about 20 different hoagies and some extras like hashbrowns or french fries. Typical selection of chips and sodas. The staff was friendly, I had the roast beef hoagie, which was all right, but nothing to rave about. Nothing melted in my mouth and I didn't want another one but it satisfied the midnight-after -the -movie -craving.

    (3)

  • Landon C.

    Worst Cheesesteak ever!! Added with bad service and Hoagie Haven was Hoagie Hell!!!

    (1)

  • Andrew J.

    This place is terrible. I'll start with the food. The sandwiches here are nothing special. In fact they are made of low quality ingredients, probably frozen stuff bought from a distributor. Pretty much any neighborhood pizza shop has what they have and therefore can make the sandwiches they sell. Remember that kid in elementary school who would take his chips and his cookies and put them on his ham and cheese sandwich? Yeah that's pretty much the creativity of the sandwiches they offer. The place is nothing special and there is no where to sit and eat the sandwiches you just spent way too much money for. Also the guys working the counter are rude and cannot wait to get you out the door. They also couldn't be bothered to explain what is on the sandwiches. And when my friend asked them to name some of the popular sandwiches they sell one of the guys named a few on the menu, and then called her a lesbian in Spanish, which got a laugh from his buddies. Guess what? I've worked in restaurants my entire life, I know how to curse in Spanish. But you know what? I was more offended by the food. Some people think it's a plus this place is open late but I think every hour this place is open is terrible. Besides I'm from Philly and I can get a decent hoagie anytime of the day.

    (1)

  • Alex S.

    I've eaten here a handful of times, starting when I was a kid that didn't know any better. After my latest visit, I've decided I'm not coming back here, even though everything went fine. I feel liberated, much like the time I had the epiphany that after every time I ate at Denny's I felt like killing myself. I don't need Denny's in my life, and I can surely do without Hoagie Haven. The service is awful, very pushy, not willing to answer questions if you don't know what you want or what's decent. A part of me kind of likes that they ask you to get out of line if you don't know what you want, but the sandwiches are stacked with ingredients that don't seem to make sense so I can sympathize with people that are paying $9 for a sandwich and want to have an idea about what they're getting. The ingredients are terrible, anything but fresh. I'm sure there are a lot of prepared foods that come in boxes and sauces out of the can. As for the menu, most of the sandwiches make no sense. The fat sandwich, I contend, is less than the sum of its parts. Mozzerella sticks are always solid by definition, french fries - why not, I can dig a cheesesteak. Now, Hoagie Haven uses low qualities of each of those ingredients, and I don't think their is any interplay of these ingredients inside a sandwich. They have some other sandwiches, such as the shrimp poboy, but the ingredients are disappointing and I'm pretty sure it made me sick. Come to think of it, I always feel sick after eating a sandwich here. With all my options in Princeton, I really don't need more experiences at Hoagie Haven in my life.

    (1)

  • Martin B.

    Arriving in quaint Princeton, I needed something to sate my appetite. A quick check on Yelp suggested that this place was top dog for getting some grub at 11AM. I found parking pretty easily (I imagine that's a whole 'nother story when students are back at Princeton), and moseyed on into Hoagie Haven. The store itself is pretty nondescript and even a bit grungy, but make no mistake: there are some great sandwiches here. I got the half-foot cheesesteak and I enjoyed every bit of it. If you're hungry though, I strongly recommend getting the foot-long. The meat is very high quality with no unchewable bits, but they don't pack it on in. If you need cheap, filling and quality sandwiches then you should look no further than Hoagie Haven!

    (4)

  • Kate Y.

    Yesterday was one of THOSE days. You know, the ones where you just have to eat that one particular thing that you believe will make you the happiest being on earth (well, for that one day anyway). If you don't have it, you will just keep thinking about it...over and over and over again. And then once you get it set into your head, you can't wait to get your hands on it. Well, I had to wait for an hour and a half because of my commute, but it was so worth the wait. What does it for me? The Western Omelette Hoagie sandwich from Hoagie Haven. So it's just an egg sandwich. But it's a damn good one. The omelette is tasty and made just right (not runny), served on warm toasted bread. I get mine with honey mustard or mayo with onions and hot peppers. Every time I get it, I tell myself that I will only eat half of it - but of course, that never works out. I'm looking forward to one of those days again.

    (4)

  • Cordaryl C.

    I LOVE this place!!! Every time my wife and I come in town to visit the in-laws we go here before we go see the family lol. Get the Phat Lady. So delicious!!! Tip: Cash only

    (5)

  • Lisa K.

    If you're a boy from NJ trying to convince a girl from NYC to date you, you should probably bring her here and order a Sanchez. Wait, does that only work on classy girls like me? Princeton was the first stop on a recent full-day adventure designed to convince me that NJ is not a wasteland devoid of intelligent life. I mentioned how hungry I was after surviving an hour on NJTransit, and Jersey steered his car directly to Hoagie Haven. The man is smart, what can I say. The place is tiny, divey, cheap and awesome. It was pretty crowded, but the line moved quickly. Jersey got the aforementioned Sanchez ($5.50), which he ended up sharing me with (again, smart man). I was pretty lame and got a chicken salad hoagie ($3.50!!), but let me tell you it was damn good. And I'm a girl who knows her chicken salad. We also got the most adorable fried macaroni and cheese triangles. I don't even care if they took five years off my life, I still dream about them sometimes. I feel the same way about the Sanchez. Whose idea was it to put chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, french fries and cheese on a sandwich? Because I want to marry them. Right now. I just want to curl up next to their ordering counter and hang out forever. That's not stalkerish, right?

    (4)

  • Lala A.

    I always feel weird giving places like this four stars, because I've also given fine dining restaurants four stars. I rate the place for what it is... a dive of a sandwich shop... and it's one of the best around. Every time I'm near Princeton I will stop here and then go to the bent spoon afterwards for ice cream. Cash only. Order on the right side of the restaurant and then get the hell out of the way. Pick up and pay on the left.

    (4)

  • Jarrod S.

    If you're trying to be healthy or dieting, stay away! If you're seeking a decadent mid-day moment of grease and glory, step up, my friend, step up. This place is quirky. It definitely gives the sense of somewhere that takes a few visits to "master." They've been making these sandwiches for a long time, so there a lot of options and "insider" secrets. This is the sort of place that has a lot of regulars. Personally, for my own health and safety, I've limited myself to one visit a week, but I always try to make the best of it. Most recently, I tried the "Sanchez." It's a hoagie loaded with french fries, fried mozzarella sticks, a fried breaded chicken cutlet and Sanchez sauce, which is like a blend of chicken finger sauce and buffalo sauce. It was pretty tasty, but actually a little bland. It just tasted like fried stuff. One of my coworkers got the Heart Stopper, which is a cheese steak loaded with fried eggs. This looked fantastic and would be a great combo breakfast/lunch meal if you're having a busy day. Don't leave Princeton without getting down here and smearing a little grease on your phase. This place is a winner. Cash only! But they have an ATM.

    (4)

  • Alex Z.

    Fantastic hoagies. Princeton alumni come every year to relive their college late night runs to hoagie haven.

    (5)

  • Alex T.

    Love this place. This is my go-to joint whenever I'm in town. Love their selection of sandwiches, burgers, drinks...u name it! Only complaint I have is that the quality of the food can be somewhat inconsistent, but really can't complain with their relatively inexpensive prices - especially in a lavish place like Princeton!

    (4)

  • g c.

    Awesome hoagie selection! Will need a big workout either prior or after consuming one:) Great value for your money though.

    (4)

  • David K.

    If you're looking for gigantic greasy sandwiches for not much money Hoagie Haven is as good as it gets, a Princeton landmark.

    (5)

  • Lisa J.

    Decent sandwich for the price. Okay service. Pro-tip: if you ask for lots of any topping, you'll get charged for it, so just look out for that. All in all, pretty good.

    (3)

  • Dylan D.

    This is a must go if you are in Princeton... This place is a college kids heaven! AWESOME Hoagies! The price is great, the service is fast, and all of the food is GREAT! My favorite sandwich here is the Phat Lady: cheese steak, mozzarella sticks, french fries, and any toppings you want. If you don't want this, go with the classic, the cheese steak! This is not a typical restaurant, its a get your hoagie and leave type of place... no seating, but there are plenty of places to take your hoagie to eat... Its right in the center of Princeton!

    (5)

  • Jay I.

    I think this place is a little bit (really,....really a little bit) overhyped because of the scarce options Princeton has got. Nonethelesss, this little joint has really good sub/hoagie/sandwiches to offer. My favorites were western omelet hoagie with buffalo fries (fries with buffalo sauce and ranch sauce). They have other options too. If you visit Princeton (Since you should know this place if you live around the area) and wanna have some quick bite, this is the place to go.

    (4)

  • Jessica J.

    Love hoagie haven. The guys working behind the counter are always super nice (usually a comical argument ensues over whether or not I can handle the hot peppers - which are a must on any sandwich I get there). It can get really crowded at times, but its popularity is well earned. Definitely try it if you're looking for a cheap alternative in Princeton.

    (5)

  • Vince N.

    This place don't mess around! If full, thick, HEARTY sandwiches are what you crave, then you've come to the right place. I ordered the "Body Bag" sandwich and let me tell ya, it certainly didn't pull any punches. The hoagie was toasted to perfection and the megaton of ingredients and all the delicious grease delivered a heavy roundhouse to my taste buds. I should mention that I ordered the half size, and it was more than enough to satisfy. In addition to the sandwich, I also ordered a side of Buffalo Fries. I was somewhat disappointed in the fries as it was simply bulk fries topped with hot sauce and ranch. Considering the effort that they placed into the sandwiches, I'd like to see the same done with the fries. The service is no-nonsense and efficient, and given the size of the sandwich, the price is certainly reasonable. One final note is that while I rate this place a 4, from what I've heard from students, the sandwiches taste that much better after a night of drinking. As such, it's safe to say the rating under those circumstances would be an easy 5. Take that for what it's worth ;)

    (4)

  • Justin T.

    This place was not like what people had cracked it up to be. I can't begin to name the number of things that were wrong, but here is a short list: There isn't seating, so don't plan on enjoying your meal as soon as you get it; (2) they don't accept cards. Luckily, I had cash, because if I wouldn't have, I would have been pissed to have to withdraw from the ATM that's situated at the entrance; (3) they were trying so hard to get me out of there that they didn't put anything on my sandwich. All in all, the sandwiches that my partner and I got were okay. Still nothing to talk about, and certainly nothing to go back for.

    (1)

  • Harry H.

    $5 footlong my @$$ I dropped $11.50 at the Haven for a substantial amount of sustenance for the two of us. Said nutrition (or lack thereof) came in the form of a half eggplant parm, a turkey hoagie (I bought into the moniker only when inside the joint), and (8) mac 'n' cheese wedges. The folks were no-nonsense, efficient but a bit distant, just the way you want it at a place of this breed. We took our purchases (along with a free can of soda compliments of the FourSquare newbie special) over to the standing area by the door, monitoring the high turnover inside and the action along Nassau St. Ultimately, tasty creations at a good value; not something I could scarf down daily, but certainly a good recommendation at whatever hour you're craving a sangvich.

    (4)

  • Matt K.

    Don't go expecting gourmet. What it is however, is pure and simple college food - large quantities, overbearing flavors, ambiance sometimes resembling a frat house. Yet, these are not bad things. I had a cheesesteak. A massive, massive cheesesteak. It was quite good, and quite filling. If you have the foresight to take it home and cut it up, you have lunch for the next day. Most of the time, your stomach will overwhelm the self-control needed for that.

    (4)

  • Brad N.

    My wife and I always get the same thing: a whole eggplant parmigiana. We split it in half and she usually can't finish her half. They batter and deep-fry the eggplant. Be sure to eat it immediately or else you'll have a soggy mess. Also God's gift to mankind: deep-fried mac and cheese wedges. Just order it and thank me later.

    (4)

  • Jason C.

    2.5* Prices are pretty good. Most subs are ~4/7 for half/whole. Variety of hot/cold items. Fast service. Absolutely nothing special about the place. Great for quick, cheap eats if you are in the area; not worth a mention if you are more than 15 minutes away.

    (3)

  • Yoon S.

    Dear Hoagie Haven, How I miss your chicken parm, sausage omelet, and pizza cheese steak hoagies. Life was so much simpler back then. Thanks for the memories...and the calories! Love, Y Keywords: Whole Chicken Parm, Pizza Cheese Steak, Princeton, NJ, Nassau Street, Awesome, Saltpeppaketchup, Saltpepporegano

    (5)

  • Percy N.

    Used to go here almost every weekend when I lived in Princeton. Simple greasy meaty burger goodness.

    (4)

  • Jaeshin S.

    Other than the fact that I get stomachache every time I eat their sandwiches, this is a good place to go in Princeton. Pretty decent in price. Try the chicken parm. It's as good as it gets.

    (4)

  • Lucy C.

    Hoagie Haven is a must-try place in Princeton. Everyone raves about their specialty sandwiches: fat lady, dirty sanchez, extra dirty sanchez, etc. While I've tried all of these and acknowledge that they're good, I wish they had healthier options. I guess being so greasy, with sandwiches like the "heart stopper", is their allure. Many other "unhealthy" places also offer low-calorie options so why can't hoagie haven do the same? I know they have cold deli subs but I'd like to see some healthy hot sandwiches. The best thing about this place though, are their low prices and serving time. Also, the sandwich guys are super nice.

    (3)

  • Emily P.

    The best drunk food on earth. Half phat lady, no mayo.

    (5)

  • Tim A.

    They have the best sandwiches here by far! It is great if you're looking for something delicious. My favorite sandwich is the Dirty Sanchez! Whenever I'm in the area I go to this place. The only thing is that it's cash only but they do have an ATM inside the store plus you can't really eat in the store because it's so small. Other than that, their sandwiches are amazing!

    (4)

  • Tom R.

    Great takeout spot. They are masters of what they make. Sanchez is highly recommended.

    (5)

  • Dave M.

    THE best steak sub yet. the steak with everything with an egg is the best.... but don't be cheap with your veggies hoagie haven

    (4)

  • Wayne L.

    If I were to pick my last meal, it'd be from Hogie Haven. My first memory of Hogie Haven is from when I was 8 years old and my dad would order a Chicken Parm hogie on the way home from piano lessons in Princeton. Now 20 years later, though I no longer live in the Princeton area, I still eat at Hogie Haven every time I get the chance. This past Christmas I was home visiting family for a week and I think I had Hogie Haven 3 of the 5 nights I was home. Some of the Hogies on the must have list: Cheesesteak Bacon Cheesesteak Pizza Cheesesteak Peppersteak -- Not on the menu anymore, but it's sweet peppers with your cheesesteak Chicken Parm -- If you're up for waiting for the chicken to deep fry Western Omlet -- A new one for me. Omlet in a hogie. Worth trying. In fact, if you take a close look at my profile pic, you'll see I'm wearing a Hogie Haven t-shirt in it. That's how much I love this place.

    (5)

  • Daniel C.

    Great hoagies. Try their specials like the "Sanchez" or "Wake-up Call".

    (4)

  • Sascha F.

    It's a greasy sandwich place. Check that. It's THE greasy sandwich place. I'm completely biased in that I went to Princeton and my formative Haven experiences were spent largely intoxicated. Simply perfect food at 1:59am (they close at 2). If it were possible to give bonus points for being optimal drunk food, I'd give them to the Haven.. I still live in the area and still have the opportunity to have a nostalgic hoagie every now and then. Even sober they're great. They're not haute cuisine. They're great crappy sandwiches, if that makes sense. In my 15 years of Havening I've only had about a half dozen things on the menu. First of all, contrary to some other reviewers opinions, if you're getting a cold sandwich you're wasting your time. Because I'm old, I've been thoroughly scared of the new offerings (Sanchez, etc.). Cheesesteak, Pizza cheesesteak, Bacon cheesesteak, Hot pastrami, Chicken parm and the omelet subs. That's it. For 15 years on and off a greasy hole in the wall has had me happily coming back for one of six sandwiches. I think that's telling enough. Just get everything on whatever you order if you're new. There is a good natured soup nazi vibe in that the other customers'll get pissed if you don't keep the line moving. Rightfully so. The hot gooey goodness of any of the hot subs will totally disintegrate the bread in about 5 minutes. Time is of the essence. If you want a fancy, expensive sandwich (and I have no problem with that) there are about a dozen places in town you can go. If you want satisfying gullet filling greasyness, Hoagie Haven is the only game in town.

    (5)

  • Cedric L.

    I am from the west coast, and I went to that place because it was highly recommended to me by a friend. This friend was used to come to that place a lot and she told me that I must go to Hoagie Haven if I had a chance to go Princeton. So that was what I did today. I have to say she was completely right when she told me that she had the better cheese streak she never had before there. If you look carefully on the right of the boutique, you will see a poster that said that they served the best sandwich on earth! Yeah this is a simple as that! The place is not very large. They don't have any seating options but who care? In fact who would like to have a sandwich inside, especially when the weather is nice? They provide half or a whole cheese steak hot sandwiches (among a long list of others - hot or cold - that I can't comment about because I haven't tried those). The whole cheese steak is definitely a lot of stuff to eat. Much heavier (and even larger) than the 5$ foot long that you can find at Subway. (I know there is no comparison between a fast food and a local place - but that was the only comparison that came into my mind.) So you should go for the whole only if you are very hungry! Once you order your cheese steak you can choose the kind of toppings that you want: tomatoes, lettuce, pickles..., there is no limitation on what you would like to add as soon as they offer it!. Prices are also very low. 3.9$ for half and 6.9 for the whole cheese steak. Please note that they don't take credit card. Last but not least, they've got the oldest cash register I haven't seen before. Very original touch to that place. Bottom line, if I can, I will probably come back and try another cheese steak variation they provide on their menu...

    (4)

  • Brad F.

    Look, you're not coming here for gourmet cuisine. You're coming here for greasy and delicious sandwiches after a night of drinking or the morning after for some hangover medicine. Back when I was studying at the University, I probably came here at least twice a week and my health surely suffered for it, but it was so worth it. I always thought they should have extended their hours of business until at least 3 AM, since all the parties on Prospect would be wrapping up and drunk kiddies would be looking for some friggin' grub. The place is a little like the Soup Nazi of Seinfeld fame. You want to be quick with your order or you will be pressured into deciding, since there will surely be a line of hungry patrons behind you waiting their turn. The Sanchez is a recent addition - they didn't have it when I was in school - but if you're willing to brave the artery-hardening sandwich, you must try it. Get it Extra Dirty. I know you like it that way.

    (5)

  • Victor S.

    Why go to Grease Trucks when you can come here. I have never had these types of non cold cut sandwiches before and could honestly say I am fan. The sandwich combos are pretty good but pretty unhealthy. After I was done I got the same uneasy feeling after finishing a hot pocket. I did not find the prices to be too much considering how much you were getting.

    (4)

  • A.R. C.

    Ate here during a one day visit of Princeton University and seeing that it was so highly rated on yelp. The full sandwiches are huge! My wife got a half chicken parm hoagie and I got a full chicken cheese steak. They were both good but we both agreed the chicken parm was much better. The place looks decent and was full of college kids. The only downside would be that there is no searing available. Prices were reasonable.

    (4)

  • Dorothy W.

    Everyone's always talking about this place so I decided to finally try it. I was expecting to be bedazzled by a sub, but ended up being disappointed by a mediocre cheesesteak. I don't get why this place is so hyped up. I mean, i'll try another sub next time (perhaps one of the more famous ones) but I'm not a fan so far. Maybe it's a Jersey thing...

    (3)

  • Les V.

    Really surprised. This place is famous and gets great reviews. Either it has slipped or some people haven't ever had a great Italian Hoagie. Would not go here again. Ordered a #1. Provolone Cheese, Capicola, Ham, Salami. Not much meat (reminded me of the amount that Subway and Quiznos use.) Provolone was weak and not full flavored. They used cheap capicola and salami. Sorry to write such a negative review but I was REALLY looking forward to a real Italian Hoagie.

    (1)

  • Vanni M.

    I love this place. It's one of those places you just HAVE to try at least once if you're visiting Princeton. Order one of their specials! the fat lady, heartstop, bodybag... Okay but in all honesty, the food is super good. There's usually a line, but they're super speedy. They have a huge selection of drinks (if that makes a difference). Also I think there's a special that if you check-in on foursquare you get a free drink. OH, and if you buy a shirt and take a picture of yourself wearing it in front of a famous landmark, I think you get a free sub or something. Free something? Look to the left of the cash register, there's a whole wall of people who took pictures :)

    (5)

  • Alan N.

    Growing up near Princeton was a huge plus for me. I got to eat Chuck's wings, halo pub, and hoagie haven of course. Here's a few reasons why HH gets 4 stars instead of 5. One, you should only come here for cheesesteaks, everyone knows that, if you order a tuna sub or something, you've come to the wrong place (go to Tastee Sub instead). Two, HH is best eaten after the bar (the Ivy is next door), when everything tastes better. However this is also when it is most crowded. Three, the cheesesteaks are simply better at other places. They don't chop the meat here and there is no whiz. Although, HH gets four stars because of its rep. Everyone knows this is the only place you can get a decent cheesesteak in princeton. Maybe the only place near/on campus that will even serve a cheesesteak now that I think about it. If you are in princeton, I would get a whole cheesesteak with L,T,O, and a little mayo and ketchup. It's only like $6. The bread is really good and soaks up all the grease. Also, on friday night over thanksgiving break when i went a girl went in and ordered this, "Can i have fries with a disgusting amount of mayo on it? like don't stop putting it on til I say stop". Needless to say there was a 1 to 1 ratio of mayo to fries. it was def gross.

    (4)

  • Michael E.

    Hoagie Haven may be the perfect dining experience. There are no pretenses, just an honest and delicious sandwich. I have been going to the Haven for about 25 years and in all that time I have yet to be disappointed. Then menu is varied and full of fantastic combinations. I tend to the tuna or #1, but when the occasion warrants, the omelet hoagie can serve to replenish even the weariest of souls. For me the way to enjoy their offerings is go at an off hour, when the lines are not too long, then take the short walk to the Woodrow Wilson building on the Princeton campus and sit at the fountain for some people watching and face stuffing. I truly treasure the one to one relationship between patron and sandwich constructor. The junior constructors are overseen by a tough but fair overlord, whose charter is to keep the purity and proper proportions of each creation to the Haven's time-honored standards. There is nothing like a place with good food and a staff that is dedicated to serving a great product.

    (5)

  • Myrtle T.

    Greasy junk. Honestly, you take two bites of a "Fat Lady" or a "Sanchez" and you're done with it. Their buffalo fries are good though... hence two stars.

    (2)

  • Jeff H.

    Cheap, quick, hateful, greasy, goodness. Perfect hangover cure when you only have 4 bucks in your pocket. The only problem is that I am not in college anymore and I just prefer a better sandwich. People were lined around the corner for one special, which was a pile of mozzarella sticks on a roll, covered in hot sauce and topped with a cheese steak. I opted for the plain cheese steak which was still damn good.

    (3)

  • Daria C.

    I will be a Haven devotee until the day I die. Rest assured that, unless you are 6'6 or a professional athlete, you'll be fine getting the "half" sized sub as opposed to the "whole". I normally order a half cheese sub with LTO, mayo, oil/ vinegar, hot peppers, and extra pickles. The pickles here are the BEST: they're thick-cut and just add so much to the sandwich. One day they were out of them and it literally ruined my day. True story. They also make killer cheese fries. Be sure to ask for extra ketchup on them, and if you want them to layer the cheese throughout the fries, ask for it "Eleonore style". Mentally prepared your order while you're in line (or before approaching the counter if there's no line), since you'll be expected to machine-gun it out once they're ready for you. This place gets VERY crowded around mealtime, but the staff are very efficient and speedy so you probably won't wait a terribly long time. Be aware that Hoagies takes cash only- they used to take checks but I don't think they do anymore. There's an ATM near the door, and if it's broken there are a few nearby banks and a health food store across the road that have them.

    (5)

  • Jennifer S.

    Whenever you step into this Haven, expect a line. The price is right for young Princetonians and it shows. It's places like this that make living in/visiting college towns a treat (you'd never find prices like this in DC--even though we are abundant with colleges/universities!) I am personally a fan of the chicken cheesesteak with provolone on whole wheat as well as the eggs with provolone, peppers and onions on whole wheat. Tip: I don't think that whole wheat is listed on the wall as a bread option, but if you ask for it they get it from the back. If you can bear the wait, give this little sandwich shop a try!

    (5)

  • Joseph B.

    3.5 Stars Absoultely love the Haven. Great sandwhiches for an even better price. You really cant beat it for lunch or dinner and absoultely wonderful as a late night stop. Service is quick and always perfect!

    (3)

  • Vi V.

    With prices as good as these, how could they not deserve 5 stars? the large is a whole freakin' italian loaf and cost, what...$6.50? it really is a big ass sandwich (almost 2 feet long)and to some, that could be enough food for one day. Why so cheap? Beats me. Princetonians are typically old-moneyed so its really unnecessary, in my opinion. Chicken parm's the good one but i'd always get #9 cos i am crazy about tuna sandwiches. And they really do pile on the tuna. Chicken steak's only ok though and i wouldn't recommend it especially when there are other terrific-sounding sandwiches around such as The Sanchez (chicken cutlet with mozzarella sticks and fries in special Sanchez sauce), which could be made extra dirty on request. At first,i was intimidated by the people here. They are the no-nonsense type who just want to assemble your sandwich quick and get the line moving. but they turned out to be quite courteous. And to help fight off the winter blues, they also have a soup and stew of the say, for $1.50 and $2 respectively. the food here might not be mind blowing (good nonetheless), but the prices are.

    (5)

  • Alexis T.

    Amazing sandwiches. Amazing prices. Extremely quick. And delicious.

    (5)

  • Henry Y.

    Some 25 years ago when I was just a budding geek, the precursor ritual to an all-nighter at the E-Quad was to pick up a monster hoagie built to be nibbled on till morning. Hoagie Haven could probably lay claim to a chunk of every engineering degree awarded at Princeton! No visit back here has ever gone hoagie-less, and yesterday was no exception. I had the large pizza cheese steak, damn the cholesterol, of which half was wolfed down in minutes and the other half took me dang near the rest of the day to finish. Their half ($3.80) is the same size as a large at any mortal sub shop, while their large ($6.50) is the equivalent of a party sub or fence post.

    (5)

  • Iggy F.

    You can feed an entire village of indigenous people with one large hoagie. I would stop at this place every time I'm in the area and you should too.

    (5)

  • Paul L.

    I was born within 100 feet of Hoagie Haven's door. That may add no credibility to what I am about to say, but please understand that this part of the world is close to my heart. I will try to keep this short. I was a very loyal Hoagie Haven customer until George's opened up 2 doors down. Simply put, I think that George's has better food and better ambiance. Hoagie Haven's food is still good, but doesn't compare with George's. Additionally, Haven sometimes feels like a tourist trap (avoid it at all cost during Reunions). Haven is still a great establishment and I hope it never goes away, but for my money, George's the better spot.

    (4)

  • Brendan T.

    Still average, although the mac n cheese bites are as good as people say. The steak and cheese is average at best.

    (3)

  • Sarah L.

    The dirty sanchez tastes amazing. You can get it "extra dirty" which means it comes with extra sauce. I'm not sure what goes into the sauce but it's amazing. They make your sandwich in front of you so you see what goes in it. You can customize it however you'd like. Downside: they do not accept credit cards.

    (5)

  • Jason A.

    One of the best sandwich shops I've been to on the East Coast. Heard it was great from some locals (I just moved to town) and it did not disappoint. They were fast, reasonably priced, and the food was delicious. I got a half bacon cheese steak and mozzarella sticks and everything was awesome. You can get insane combinations (they will literally put anything you want on a roll) which only made me want to go back more.

    (5)

  • Nikhil S.

    This place is a Princeton classic. One of my go-to places when I am crazing a fat sandwich in the Princeton area. My recommendation: The Dirty Sanchez..... Extra Dirty! Give it a shot - right in the heart of Princeton.

    (4)

  • Patrick S.

    Disclaimer: I feel that anyone who would give this establishment less than four stars is a bad human being. Perhaps these individuals are accomplished researchers or teachers who have helped thousands. Perhaps they are all-star athletes who have represented our fine nation on international fields of competition. None of that matters. Hoagie Haven is a godsend, and disbelievers should be round up and expulsed from New Jersey. But alas, I'm joking. There's quite a bit not to like about Haven, if you're so inclined. The food couldn't possibly be greasier, and the menu is strictly limited to food that seems designed to induce heart failure. Most of the food, if not consumed within the first ten minutes, will biodegrade into a substance resembling that maleficent ooze in Ghostbusters 2... and yet true beauty of Haven is it's apparent unflinching ignorance of these shortcomings. This Princeton staple, which has been in business for at least the entirety of my quarter-century existence, is essentially a stationary "grease truck" of the like found encircles Rutgers or UPenn. In addition to the standard sandwich fare, Hoagie Haven offers up such culinary abominations as "the fat lady" (which, for anyone who's curious, is a cheesesteak with mozzarella sticks and french fries packed in alongside the meat). This type of food is clearly designed for the hung-over ivy leaguer or metabolically berserk teenager, and they deliver on all fronts. Sure, the food is bad for you. Sure, you'll probably pass out after the final bite and wake up the can. Yet the food is delicious: you'll be hard to pressed to find a better cheese steak, even in Flipadelphia, and the Chicken Fingers are truly delicious. Hoagie Haven gets five stars from me because it perfectly accomplishes what it's clearly designed for. This is not fine dining - in fact - it's the opposite. Hoagie Haven represents the pinnacle of scuzzy Jersey grub, and, like The Record Exchange, is a mandatory stop for visitors of Princeton. Just don't tell you doctor you stopped in.

    (5)

  • Shantanu D.

    I dont get it. This is the kind of place that I should love. That I want to love. And I just dont. The bread is sub par. The meats used are poor quality. The ratios are not well thought out. The sandwiches themselves are not novel. I was eating them at grease trucks 20 years ago. The grease trucks in New Brunswick did a better job. Guessing they still do. I've been there enough times that its not a case of "I went there on a bad day". The staff is quite nice but it seems they are happy to remain busy based on hype and not the quality of their product. Maybe it was better historically.

    (2)

  • Brian L.

    First, cash only. Second, if you've been in/around Princeton, you know that this place is expensive. But this (along with George's Roasters) is not expensive. You should order by number here. They'll get the base (size, meats), then you tell them what you want on there (right away if cold, if they have to prepare, wait around). I particularly like their chicken parm ($4.50 half/$7.90/whole), roast beef ($3.90/$6.90), pizza steak (good, but greasy[$4.30/$7.70]) hoagies. That's all I get here (french fries are pretty good) and I am satisfied. I am going to emphasize quantity over quality. It tastes really good, but don't be surprised after you're finished you just don't feel right. It goes away, but you have to weigh between the pros and cons (tastes so good, tummy hurts).

    (4)

  • Maynard G.

    Hey, pretty good. Not bad. I went here a few times just because it was fast and convenient, and I finally figured out that you can have the man put lots of free stuff on your hero, or hoagie, what they call it around here.

    (4)

  • Mike P.

    One of the best sub shops in NJ, although i regret eating a full sub for health reasons the juice is worth the squeeze since they taste so good. If you've never gone make sure you try one of their specialty sandwich. I always get the heartstop and by the name of there items you can see why i say i regret eating it for health reason, but its so damn good!. The fat lady is also pretty good too if you dont like egg on your sandwich, If you in the Princeton area its almost always worth the trip.

    (5)

  • Matt S.

    I can only vouch for the chicken parm. But it is solid. Would have gone here a lot more if I got better grades in high school.

    (5)

  • Jared C.

    The hype is not hype. Hoagie Haven is for real, churning out simple sandwiches that focus on their core ingredients and do not try to be fancy. At lunchtime on the Saturday of spring break, the place was still full of students and other locals, ordering and moving aside so as not to block the flow. The place has a working man's feel to it, but there is an order in motion here that might take a return visit or two to fully grasp. I felt as if I was in the way more than once, holding up the line and therefore coming between men and their hoagies. A friend and I decided to pick two and split them for a little variety. We were surprised by the sheer size of each beast. almost two feet in length, a tremendous value for the price. The hot pastrami ($6.90, large) was stuffed full of delicious strips of meat. I found it a little strange that he asked if I wanted mayonnaise, but the sandwich was eventually delivered with a beautiful and biting mustard that complimented the pastrami perfectly. The breads were fresh and delivered from nearby Italian Peoples Bakery, thrown into their over for good measure to make sure everything was toasty. More toppings confusion ensued with the chicken parmesan ($7.90, large), which somehow ended up with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Those were easily removed though and the delicious crispy fried chicken and sharp cheese shined. The sauce was used sparingly, and I think anymore would have completed disentigrated the bread before we could eat it. I would have loved to have asked for some more on the side though, as it was one of the best parts.

    (4)

  • AG D.

    Princeton landmark fails with their rude and uneducated Mexican worker's stupidity . As soon as we walked in, Mexican workers started talking to each other and laughing , we ignored just ordering our food. But it got worse when they call us "hey putos". Instantly kills the joy of visiting great Princeton university.. This place is a joke!!! When we address their rudeness by saying It wasnt very nice, they continue laughed, shocking other customers including students from Princeton University. The management should consider this right away, which i doubt if the owner is Mexican, he will probably just jaugh along with them.. So Sad! lol

    (1)

  • Steven C.

    There's nothing I can say that can express my feelings towards this place, other than to look at the large number of positive reviews that follow below mine. I would gladly trade the Rutgers Grease Trucks for Hoagie Heaven. I would even go as far as to say the cheesesteaks at Hoagie Heaven are some of the best I've ever had, even better than famous cheesesteak places like Pat and Gino's in Philly. Nothing beats the quality of food you get at such a low price.

    (5)

  • Stephen F.

    There's a cheap and questionably sanitary sandwich shop in every college town. And they are mostly the same -- but Hoagie Haven is MINE. So, five stars. New this year: The Wake-Up Call. For $12, you get 18 inches of cheesesteak, eggs, bacon, hash browns, porkroll, and saltpeppereganoketchup you can stomach.

    (5)

  • Kaylen H.

    Having grown up in Princeton and gone to middle and high school only two blocks from Hoagie Haven, there is no way that I can't give this place 5 stars! Every time I go home, this is a must visit for me. If you are a student, whether in Princeton, West Windsor, Plainsboro, Montgomery, or the surrounding areas and you haven't been here, you've been wasting your time! There is no possibly way to describe just how delicious and lovingly crafted these sandwiches are. Don't mess around next time you're hungry, and get over to Haven ASAP.

    (5)

  • Nina V.

    The Phat Lady makes me drool.

    (5)

  • Rich W.

    This place is a princeton landmark! Cool place to get a great sandwich!Not the cleanest place, Try not to look around to much when you are waiting in line.:) some tips- Don't go there and order a sandwich you normally would, try a phat lady or a sanchez. Extra dirty means extra hot sauce. Grab a seat outside on one of the curbside benches.. If you are 20 something and looking to get late night food, this is it.

    (5)

  • Danan R.

    In desperate need of a cardiac-arrest-inducing midnight snack in Princeton? Look no further than Hoagie Haven. Okay, I admit that I actually wanted to grab a breakfast sandwich for tomorrow but that doesn't change the fact that: a) they are open until LATE b)the hoagies are overstuffed and HUGE c)um, where else can you get a huge sandwich for under $4 on campus? My bacon, egg, and cheese was only $3.50, and I was kinda hungry and feeling adventurous so I decided to grab a chicken salad platter. It wasn't that bad, surprisingly! Actually, it was pretty good and not heavy at all (enough mayo to make it creamy without overdoing it), and came served on a bed of lettuce with tomato slices. I know, I know...salad isn't their forte but now you all are aware that there are some less health-hazardous but still cheap, good options here. Okay, lesson learned. It's back to the body bag next visit. It came to $10 for the salad, my sandwich, and a BLT (friend's). Cash only! Staff here are good-natured flirts, for sure, and remember the faces of regulars (and even ex-regulars...guilty as charged).

    (4)

  • Jeff D.

    Hoagie Haven definitely deserves a shout out. The grease trucks in New Brunswick will always be my destination for fat sandwiches, yet Hoagie Haven isn't shy about loading their sandwiches up. (Take the next morning off from work. Trust me). Reasonable prices: yes Crowded: yes Delicious sandwiches and worth a trip: Hell yes

    (4)

  • Simon L.

    The name Hoagie Haven makes me think of a nice little mom and pop operation run by middle-americans but that's not what this is. You walk in and you are surprised to see an Indian guy working the register and some Spanish guys making your sandwich. It's more fast food than mom and pop. With that said: They make great sandwiches and that's all that matters. We ate half of the chicken parm with egg and bacon and it was a monster of a sandwich. I saw people walking out of there with the whole sandwiches and I feared for their heart. But for $7 or so, you get a nice cutlet and cheese and a fried egg and bacon. The sauce was a little light but no complaints. If I'm hungry and on a budget, I've got no hesitation going to Hoagie Haven.

    (4)

  • Al G.

    I'm 6'2", athletic, work out daily, and eat a LOT. If I can drop $4 on HALF a fish sandwich and be stuffed, they're doing something right. The food is excellent for the price range. (absurdly cheap) Also, the hype is the culture. The place has been there since before my parents were born, and it's special to us local folks. If you don't want a greasy, insanely filling sandwich, don't go here. It's no 5-star restaurant, but it is tasty. Unless you are sharing, only order a half sandwich. Mistake #1 made by all out-of-area customers. Bottom Line: Awesome, dirt cheap sandwiches I can grab and they never disappoint.

    (5)

  • Veronica D.

    For any kind of American fare sandwich, this is the best place in town.

    (4)

  • Michael W.

    I LOVE HOAGIES. Even if it will kill me. Give me a Sanchez please, extra dirty.

    (5)

  • Lyn L.

    I stopped by this place last week on a visit to the Princeton area after having found it on Yelp. Let me tell you, it's quite a popular place, and not just with the college students across the street. School hadn't even started yet, so I can imagine this place gets very crowded. I ordered a #14 (cheese steak) with everything and asked for sauteed onions instead of raw onions. The meat is just two thin slices of steak, rather than the usual chopped or shredded steak. The cheese is melted right on top of the meat. Then it is all folded into the sandwich on top of the mayo, lettuce, tomatoes and onions. The bread is toasted and has a nice crunch to it and the middle is soft and fluffy. I got a half size and that was plenty for lunch. The place is cash only and everything is to go as there are no seats inside. The guy who made my sandwich was not very friendly at all. In fact he seemed liked he didn't want to be there. Other than that the sandwich tasted great.

    (4)

  • Adani C.

    5/5 no doubt! Best Hoagie I had so far.

    (5)

  • Celeste M.

    What can I not say about Hoagie Haven? Being a calorie-conscious adult, I don't know how we didn't gain 50 pounds drinking and eating at Hoagie Haven back in college, but I wouldn't change a thing. It's a definite for anytime I'm in Princeton for Reunions or stopping by. I love the chicken parm (with lettuce and tomato, cause why not?). I've found the newer more experimental sandwiches fun and interesting, but not as homey as my beloved chicken parm. I will love Hoagie Haven forever.

    (5)

  • Candice T.

    The pastrami was apparently quite a tatty hoagie" according to my sister. I am vegetarian, and my on,y option was the egg salad. It would nave been nice to have other options. Even subway has vegan options now. That said, the entire party I was with was thoroughly satisfied.

    (4)

  • Neil P.

    Sir Sandwich knew what he was doing! Think of HH as the better Subway or Quiznos and you will certainly not be disappointed. Had the buffalo chicken and the mexican.. Great solid flavor and definitely filled me up. (Better than the grease pit I went to for dinner in Princeton)

    (4)

  • Aditya M.

    I had the chicken parm, and my taste buds were in eternal bliss for about 5 or 6 minutes. Best hoagie ive had in years. Im definitely a fan! ill be hitting this place up for lunch every day now. The only sucky part is they take cash only, so have about a 10 dollar bill handy you might find yourself tipping them the price of the sandwich its so good!!!

    (4)

  • Alex S.

    This place had some awesome sandwiches. I was forced into the state of NJ for a wedding, and this was the best part about the state. I actually thought NJ was pretty nice from what i saw. Either way, Hoagie Haven is awesome and I hope I get another chance to go to NJ so I can eat 47 sandwiches.

    (4)

  • Justin F.

    OK lets be honest about Hoagie Haven - the food here is not that great. I'm not saying I don't love the place or haven't spent countless drunken nights attempting to get a bacon cheesesteak, I'm just saying that the cheesesteaks are greasy and they aren't that great tasting when sober. One year my parents even got me a gift certificate there. Hoagie Haven does have some good traits - its extremely cheap, fast and there is parking across the street. Its open until 4 AM and you can sit outside on the benches when the sun is out. I was a big fan of their bacon cheesesteaks, chicken parm and their burgers. They even added some of the fat sandwiches that the Rutgers trucks made famous. All in all a great place to go for late night food.

    (3)

  • Caro D.

    Hoagie Haven is a great little sandwich shop. The food is far from healthy, but it's consistent which is more than I can say for a lot of food places in Princeton. When you go there, you know what you are getting every time. The guys that work there, as well as the owners, are super friendly even when the line is out the door which happens a lot.

    (5)

  • Rad B.

    I've been going here since high school and to keep it short and sweet, you can pretty much count on a fairly solid sandwich here. After experiencing the grease trucks for four years, I realized this place was a bit overhyped. Nonetheless if you dont want to get stuck in a stuffy place in princeton, go to Hoagie Haven. Here, I've tried: - variety of cold hoagies - pretty solid. just tell them to add less sauce if you dont want it soggy. - chicken parm - I normally dont like chicken parm but I liked this one! - sanchez - heart attack in a sandwich? yes please. - shrimp po boy - my least favorite - fries - solid. Bottomline: fairly cheap, solid sandwiches..what more can you expect?

    (3)

  • Chris D.

    This place caught my eye while i was biking down from new Brunswick on a nice day. I had about 8 bucks in my bike shorts and was able to get a large cheese steak with everything on it and a drink. Ate it on the street in the sun with a bunch of other ppl around Mowing down on there tasty sandwiches. passed out for about 15 min after i finished eating and biked back home. This place is defiantly worth stopping in if you want a deliciously greasy sandwich.. it reminded me of the grease trucks at Rutgers but the sandwich was much bigger and definitely hit the spot.

    (5)

  • Lizz K.

    First time I came here and shared the Bloch (Chicken Parm w/Bacon & Eggs) with a friend, I thought, "So what, it's just a chicken parm sammich!". Chicken is not up there on my list of preferred meats. Coming here a second time I was less enthused, even more so since I just ate a Fat Elvis from the Rutgers Truck 20 minutes prior. 4 of us shared a whole Heart Stop (Cheesesteak w/Bacon & Eggs) just to taste in our already comatosed state. Now THAT'S A F!%$ING sandwich! Before I knew it, I was hungry for more and wished that I had gotten my own sandwich instead of being a team player and sharing one! Fellow Yelpers, this place is definitely worth the visit if you're in the area. Lucky for me I have friends who will organize a road trip just to eat fatty sandwiches.

    (4)

  • T S.

    Hoagie Haven is one of those places that I crave, and am usually underwhelmed when I finally get it. I never partake in the specialty named hoagies because they are all way too complicated and heart clogging for my taste, nor do I get anything other than hoagies and fries. In my first few trips to the Haven, I had a special order that I wanted. Nothing on the menu, but nothing complicated either. Just 3 different kinds of meat and the usual onion tomato and mayo. Every time I went and asked for said sandwich the workers always gave me a hard time. Yes I'm a girl and i want this sandwich, and YES i'm gonna pay for it , and really I'm only asking for things that you have right in front of you, so stop giving me this look as if I've asked you to go next door and put some lo mein on it. So if you are looking for any kind of friendly or cordial service, go somewhere else. Tired of dealing with this shame-based ordering, I switched to the cheesesteak, which is pretty good but doesnt have enough meat in it for my taste; I don't like it when a hoagie is mostly bread. The fries are good, but make sure you ask for salt, and lots of it. The fries don't come salted, and that can be a rude and sad awakening once you've gotten to your chowdown spot and discover your naked fries. If there's anything I've learned though, it's that adding french fries to any sandwich is a WIN. The drink selection is impressive though. And remember, cash only.

    (3)

  • Jacques C.

    This is a great place to get a cheap, but gexcellent sandwich. The pizza cheese steak was my choice and was more than adequate, in fact very good. It can be a little wild with respect to lines, and I was lucky to hit between peak times. All in all, great for a heavy lunch, but plan on a nap afterward. Well worth the visit for samwich fans. There is relatively little in the way of seating, except a few park benches just outside. Cash ONLY.

    (4)

  • Mark K.

    Just got to Princeton & I'm starving. Read great reviews & saw the menu, I'm excited. So I go to order the Sanchez. Dirty, dirty Sanchez. It's just ok. Tasted good, but i wouldn't order it again. Maybe i would try some other hoagie. People probably like this place cause their aren't many choices out here in bumblefuk, Princeton. It's beautiful out here, though. Very colonial. Mansions & estates.

    (3)

  • Melmoth K.

    Obviously a favorite place of some of the many people who live nearby, but this place is absolutely nothing to go out of your way for if you are looking for a sandwich. If you're looking to experience what Princeton students experience, then OK, take your turn at Hoagie Haven. Its really just your basic Jersey sandwich shop, including the strong food odor that sticks to your clothes even after just a few minutes inside. They make huge cheap subs, just like lots of other similar places around here. They use Italian Peoples' bread, just like lots of other similar places around here. The fillings are pretty much like they are at lots of other similar places around here. They offer a selection of small and medium-sized bags of chips, and bottled drinks, just like lots of other similar places around here.

    (2)

  • Renee M.

    Hoagie Haven is amazing. Absolutely delicious. I don't care if i feel like I'm going to have a heart attack after i devour one of their amazingly greasy cheese steaks. So worth it for my arteries to become completely clogged. Pretty much every time I've come here I've gotten a cheesesteak, and I haven't had a better one, even in Philly. Everything is mad cheap too- perfect for my broke ass. I love the old cash register too!! I rep these place hard with my sweet black and orange Hoagie Haven tshirt..

    (5)

  • Francis Reiner B.

    They're sandwiches are quite impressive. Similar to the grease trucks at Rutgers, they have "fat"-style sandwiches. The last sandwich I had was the Sanchez (Chicken Cutlet, American Cheese, Mozzarella Sticks & Fries w/Sanchez Sauce). The only downside, is similar to how the grease trucks were at Rutgers, there's not really much seating, so when you come as a group, be ready to eat outside. Hopefully, not on a cold day.

    (5)

  • Adrian A.

    American alchemy: one loaf italian bread, split lengthwise. Greasy meat, bacon, cheese. Cook on Philosopher's Stone, 5-10 minutes. Top bread with lettuce, honey mustard, onions, black pepper. Insert meats. Consume. Die happy.

    (5)

  • Hrishikesh J.

    This is a famous shop in Princeton. The (really greasy) hoagies can hit the spot after a night out. The eggplant parm is a decent vegetarian option. But the service can be bad (and sometimes rude). And beware of long lines (which owe to the popularity of this place).

    (2)

  • Chris P.

    This place is perfect for a late night I don't care about being healthy kind of mood. Reasonable prices and extremely good fatting food! The heart stop is my personal favorite but it's really hard to go wrong!

    (4)

  • Connie S.

    My family and I made a pit stop to Jersey to get a tour of Princeton (a relative's alma mater) and had to try this place. And yes, it lives up to the hype!! The store is very small with no seating. You order, they make it, you take it and eat it. We ordered the cheesesteak, meatball, tuna, and pastrami. The sandwiches were GINORMOUS!! I tried a bite of each and yummmmm-ooooo. My favorites was the cheesesteak. And I've tried a few cheesesteaks in my few years living in Philly. But who knew I would find THE BEST CHEESESTEAK in JERSEY!! We ended up sitting on a random bench on the sidewalk while we consumed our delicious sandwiches. I will be back Hoagie Haven!!

    (5)

  • Fiona L.

    You may be surprised, but the buffalo chicken sandwich without the buffalo sauce (only hot sauce and a dash of mayo) is my FAVORITE sandwich here! Living by Princeton my entire life, I always heard great things about Hoagie Haven, but I never checked it out until 5-6 years ago. Instead of ordering one of those famous FAT sandwiches, my friend and I ordered the buffalo chicken hoagie sandwich to share. From then on, that was my go-to sandwich! Recently, I came here and tried out the fried shrimp and pizza cheese steak subs, and they were okay! I'm not sure if it was just that time, but the fried shrimp seemed a little overcooked (deep fried too long). Also, the shrimps were very puny. The pizza steak tasted good, but it wasn't especially satisfying. Plus, my entire sub kind of collapsed and fell apart making the eating rather messy. Next time, I'm probably going to stick with my usual favorite. Or try one of those fat sandwiches! Btw, the prices of the subs are extremely affordable! I usually get a half unless I'm sharing it with a friend then I would get the whole. CASH ONLY! (Though they do have an ATM in their shop.)

    (4)

  • Joseph W.

    Today was my first experience at Hoagie Haven, and possibly my last. In my opinion, the sandwich I bought (Po Boy) was good. For the price, you get a good amount of food (it beats Subway by far). The taste was nothing to get excited about but it was still good, especially for a late night craving. However, my experience with the staff was extremely unpleasant; the employee making my sandwich was just flat out rude. I asked to speak with the manager, because I felt like the employee was being disrespectful. While I was asking for the manager, another employee said "he's trying to get his food for free". It seems like customer service is not a high priority to Hoagie Haven since they express no discretion.

    (2)

  • Mike B.

    as a lifelong resident of Brooklyn and Queens, I'm loathe to even use the word "hoagie" but for once I'll concede to the local vernacular. Hoagie Haven's menu is full of options - cold, hot, fried, grilled - you name it. Italian, Greek, and Mexican flavors are well represented here. throw it all on a big-ass hero roll and eat it you fat FUC! I tried the Phat Lady - cheesesteak, fries, mozzarella sticks, hot sauce, and ketchup - at a half size because even those are pretty hefty. REKT in about 3 minutes, but it was delicious and cheap. healthy? hell no! filling and tasty? hell yes! yes, it's similar to the infamous Grease Trucks, but an actual shop. maybe 4 or 5 seats, so be ready to stand while you eat or be disgusting and eat in your car in a dark parking lot, hiding your shame. my pants will hate me for it, but I would totally go again.

    (4)

  • Allie O.

    No! What is happening?! Hoagie Haven is a rip off of the grease trucks in New Brunswick which caters to the late night totally drunk population pouring out of the Ivy or other bars and parties in need of a 1,400 calorie sandwich for whatever reason. No. I've had fat sandwiches at Hoagie Haven and....just like when I had them at the grease trucks...they were terrible. The sandwiches are awful, what is wrong with everyone?! It's not like "oh it's super bad for you but it tastes amazing" cause no. It doesn't. Yuck. Their cold sandwiches are nothing to write home about (unless you're from Princeton and for some reason you miss hoagie haven and then you write home about it.) I would rather go to one of the zillion plus infinity delis around here (because this is NEW JERSEY) and get a cold sub from there. They don't make me call it a hoagie either because this is not South Jersey, it's Central Jersey. Also, it's way too bright in there. Please turn down the lights so that when I stand in your mile long line to get a sandwich (said me never again) my eyes don't have to adjust to the difference of being outside (where it's definitely dark).

    (3)

  • Marla O.

    Was looking forward to a great hoagie because of all the good reviews. This is a decent sub sandwich shop, but NOT a hoagie shop. Big difference if you know the real thing. Don't bother with a cheesesteak, it wouldn't be good even if it was called a hot beef sandwich. I am sorry to say, I've had better sandwiches from Subway. The sandwiches are definitely large, so if you do find one you like, you will have enough for two or three people. This one was so far off, my faith in Yelp is wavering.

    (1)

  • Tava E.

    Good hoagies but bad service especially when the employees cannot get the order right. The owner proceeded to tell me that I didn't know how to order right. Sorry that we came here for a big order that required making more than one hoagie at a time. Maybe as the owner you should help your employees communicate with your customers when they don't understand your order.

    (2)

  • Rebecca P.

    If you're on a diet or at all health conscious don't bother reading any of these reviews. Just don't. However, if you're into eating like a fat kid, do proceed. Know that there are certain rules to be followed here: 1. Bring cash 2. Do not bother ordering a cold sandwich 3. Since you've already blown your diet for the day, get a fat sandwich. Sanchez is your amigo. How fresh are the ingredients? Lord knows. Does it even matter anyway since everything is fried to a delicious crisp anyway? The inside of this place offers little in the way of seating (a couple seats at a counter facing the window) and is probably wouldn't pass the white glove test. Whatever - the direct antithesis of "fine dining" means cheaper prices and therefore more money in your pocket to accelerate your trip to the grave. In related news, I ran about five miles this morning to offset my half Sanchez lunch. I'm now dialing up my doctor for a Lipitor prescription and a preemptive pacemaker order.

    (4)

  • Priya S.

    SANCHEZZZ. That's all I gotta say. Oh, with extra Sanchez sauce of course. They're huge so split with someone! Besides that sandwich, I've had the chicken parm, buffalo chicken, and the one with chicken tacos in it. Yes I said chicken tacos. The sauce for the chicken parm was not flavorful at all so I definitely would not get that again. The buffalo chicken tastes weird. The chicken itself was great but either they didn't put enough buffalo sauce or their buffalo sauce didn't have that pizzazz. The chicken taco sandwich was great though! Who would've thought you could stuff little chicken tacos into a sandwich?! Great prices, quick service.

    (4)

  • Caroline B.

    Hoagie Haven is absolutely up to the hype it receives. I have many fond memories of those sandwiches from growing up in Princeton and finally took Mike tonight to experience the magic found within an Italian Peoples' Bakery Italian bread. TIPS: 1. Good luck finding seats--you will probably want to take your hoagie to go, but it makes perfect picnic food, so you will enjoy it nonetheless. 2. A whole sandwich=an entire baguette overflowing with goodness. Unless you're starving, you may want a 1/2. Tonight I barely made a dent in my 1/2 tuna hoagie and was comfortably full. The portions are huge. 3. Realize that this silly, little take-out hoagie place is unforgettable and that you will be rhapsodizing about it even years later. I would be embarrassed that I enjoyed my tuna hoagie as much as I did tonight but this is Hoagie Haven we're talking about. I played it safe but the menu includes more creative options too ("Fat" sandwiches, pita sandwiches, etc.) ENJOY!

    (5)

  • Anthony J.

    I only tried this place once. As a longtime customer of George's, I couldn't help always seeing the crowds of people at Hoagie Haven. So I wanted to see what all the fuss was about. Unfortunately, I still don't know what all the fuss is about. The sandwich was pretty big, but the turkey meat tasted old, like it was just starting to go bad but wasn't quite there yet. At least it was cheap. After that, i really never had a reason to go back, especially with George's right next door.

    (2)

  • Ching C.

    These hoagie sandwiches are BIG! I can barely finish half a sandwich and that's saying a lot because I can usually crush a chipotle chicken bowl (no beans) - no problem. I first discovered Hoagie Haven while visiting my friend in Princeton a couple years back and was recently acquainted again with the sandwich shop when I was visiting New Jersey. There is a great variety on the menu but I usually go for their hot items. I've tried the The Phat Lady which I heard was a popular sandwich. Never have I had a sandwich with mozzarella sticks and french fries - mind blown! I am a big fan of the Wake Up Call, which is a cheese steak sandwich with Eggs, Hash Browns and bacon (everything I like in a breakfast sandwich)! I was in heaven! It was only $6.25 for half a sandwich - a delicious and filling sandwich at a great price. It kept me stuffed the rest of the night and I was in an instant food coma afterwards. I wish they had a location in DC or New York!

    (4)

  • Karen C.

    As a native of Princeton Junction, I've been coming here for decades. The hole in the wall hoagie shop is delicious, creative, and not pricey! They have delicious ingredients, and I've never had a bad experience. There are many choices, including fat sandwiches, which are 10x better than the Grease Trucks up in New Brunswick at Rutgers. I went to Rutgers, and every time I came home, my friends back on campus would beg me to bring back Hoagie Haven's fat sandwiches because Grease Trucks' are unworthy!! MUST TRY THE BUFFALO FRIES. Basically, the hot and cold sandwiches are great, and there are always good drinks and chips choices. As a hole in the wall, don't expect seating, it's a simple take away place (with a ledge inside if you want to stand and eat).

    (5)

  • Kyla W.

    This place is really good. The service is great and so are the sandwiches. When someone say hoagie haven all I can think of is yummmmmmmyyyy food. Great place for lunch!

    (5)

  • Kathryn A.

    This is the saddest sandwich I've ever seen. I got a large cheesesteak and there was literally four slices of minute made meat. Two on each half. I should of taken a picture to show how much of a disgrace this sandwich is. Don't even bother here and go to a pizza shop instead to get your money's worth

    (1)

  • Jamie M.

    Not sure why all the good reviews. My first (and last) impression of this place is that it is your typical college grease pit of which I attribute the good reviews to the late nite drunk crowd or the hung-over crowd. The place is dirty, inside and out, and needs some TLC so that I don't want to sanitize my hands at every little thing I touch in there. At the age of 36, I no longer feel this is any place I want to go. We ordered a cheesesteak and a pork roll egg and cheese breakfast sandwich. The cheesesteak had VERY little meat on it... very disappointing. I went to college in the Philly area so I know a good cheesesteak when I see it; this is not it! The porkroll egg and cheese sandwich was more substantial; two thin slices of porkroll, two eggs, and two slices of cheese. Somehow they managed to make this the most greasy breakfast sandwich I have ever had. All around disappointing.... I will not be going back.

    (2)

  • April B.

    I grew up in Princeton, and this is the hoagie sandwich place all the locals and cool PU students go to. Great eatz. My middle sissy always went for the roast beef hoagie (full please). However, once I had it, I HAD to have it, their Philly Cheese steak (full hoagie, yes please.) During the day, the lines aren't so bad. Late at night, it will take some time. As a PDS alumna, every reunion we attend, we both feature HH hoagies as snack food and need to drive by for a fix. Parking is impossible, but drop a buddy off while one of you orders for the crew. Years ago, if memory serves me, Princeton University honored the man who owns the place. Might not have given him an honorary degree. Then again, maybe they did. Greek blue collar folks, he nearly wept over the honor. Whilst at PDS, a new faculty did the hoagie run while we were rehearsing for the Winter Musical. We gave him our money and written orders. He went somewhere else which went out of business, "Because the lines were shorter." Of course they were. Locally owned, great hoagies. Idiots who give this place a neggie review just want attention. This is a hole in the wall venue. Clean, but no sit down. It is ALL to go. Those sliced cold cuts were cut today, maybe the last few hours because they do a land office business.

    (5)

  • Dan S.

    *Disappointing visit this last time, told the guys I came in from Seattle and had to stop and have a hoagie and got he "who cares" response meaning, no response *My Phat Lady's chicken had small bones through out it, ruined the sandwich *I feel like they have steady clientele and really don't care much for service, must be nice. Kinda a soup nazi approach but not quite that bad but you catch my drift

    (2)

  • Paul Y.

    Hoagie Haven is a standard, run-of-the-mill, young-adult serving, really greasy, sandwich place. There's not too much they can do wrong- whats objectionable about chicken fingers and mozzerella sticks? Their portions are fairly big, but I will contend, not even that cheap. However, Hoagie Haven is one of those places that I think many people low-key dislike, but get sucked into believing it is awesome and enthusiastically saying so, simply because everyone else claims to love it. I know that this might be slightly controversial, and people definitely do love Hoagie Haven, but it is slightly overrated. If you do not find nauseatingly greasy food delicious, then Hoagie Haven is not for you. One thing that Hoagie Haven does have going for it is being open until fairly late.

    (3)

  • Jessie H.

    I came here for lunch and got the #1 cold sub (ham, salami, cheese), there was another meat but I can't remember. It was basically an Italian sandwich. First of all I asked for a half sandwich because their sandwiches are huge; however the guy still gave me a large sub. Since I was in a rush I just took the large sandwich which was around $7.50. I got mayo and onions on my sandwich since I don't like vegetables. The bread is super fresh. Overall the sandwich tasted average. The large sandwich can def feed two people and you'll feel satisfied. If I come back I'd like to try another sandwich like the buffalo cheesesteak, maybe there will be more flavor. There are a few stool window seats here but no bathroom. CASH ONLY

    (3)

  • Alex W.

    Ah, the infamous Hoagie Haven! Growing up in Princeton, this little takeout spot was a landmark for nearly everyone, but especially students. During my high school days, I ate at Haven almost every day, with a rotating set of options so in reviewing these different meals, I will know that one outstanding meal is not a fluke. As an outsider, you might not think to eat at Haven unless it has been suggested by a local, but you will be glad you did afterward. The inside is not at all fancy, yet has remained a type of nostalgic classic setup, although there have been some recent additions that make it feel more modern such as a TV and the techno music that has been known to echo through the speakers at night. Set in a nice college town that usually shuts down fairly early with the exception of a couple bars (after midnight it is more common to see police cars than regular cars), it is relieving to know that Haven stays open pretty late. In fact, they do not have a set closing time but rather go with how busy they tend to be night-by-night, with their website even listing "Late" as their closing time. Being in Jersey, you know that the hoagies are destined to be good and sure enough they don't disappoint. The sandwiches tend to be packed, requiring a bread that will hold it all. This bread, from the Italian Peoples Bakery in Trenton, works perfectly for Haven's sandwiches. The menu is endless, with options such as the Phat Lady, Sanchez, and Heart Stop among others offering a gut busting combination meal all inside the sandwich. More on those later. Additionally, you can have them throw pretty much anything you can think of together if they have the ingredients. Maybe you can even get your own sandwich created if your combo works! Just bring some cash as they don't take credit cards, though there is an ATM machine if needed. Given my numerous visits I will provide a breakdown on a number of their menu items. One thing to note is that, while using the same bread for each hoagie, I may give different ratings on the bread based on how they impact (or work for) that particular sandwich. Let's start out with a simple cheeseburger. The burger is not all that big (maybe 6 ounces) and is one of the few menu items that comes with a bit more bun than meat. Nevertheless, this burger is pretty good though I would not mind a little more meat to it. Unfortunately, my phone broke right before I could snap a picture of this so you will just have to imagine it. I got mine with minimal condiments, just a bit of ketchup which while I often avoid ketchup on burgers works well for Haven. Meat: 6 Bread: 6.5 Cheese: 6 Condiments: 7.5 Overall: 7 The first dish I ever ordered at Haven was a turkey sub and I have to tell you, it is pretty good. Sure, it is a simple item to make but I always love it. The bread is great and that is always a key to the sandwich. I usually get mine with lettuce, onions and oil & vinger, but thew on some salt and pepper as well as tomatoes this time. Simple sandwich and no toppings overpowering the other. Meat: 8 Bread: 8.5 Condiments: 8.5 Overall: 8 Phat Lady: Today I ordered one of my favorites at Hoagie Haven. Similar to the Fat Sandwiches at Rutgers, the Phat Lady stuffs mozzarella sticks and fries inside the hoagie along with a cheesesteak. It also comes with your choice of ketchup, hot sauce, sanchez sauce, or whatever combination of sauce you could think of. Personally, I went with hot sauce and a touch of sanchez today. Although it may sound disgusting to some, everyone who tries the sandwich tends to love it. While not a fan of Haven's cheesesteak by itself, the combination in the Phat Lady is delicious. The sauce prevents it from being too dry and while the taste is not quite as good as the similar Sanchez, which replaces the cheesesteak with chicken cutlet, the Phat Lady is not as oversized and allows for better bite-sized pieces. All in all a terrificsandwich, and one of my recommendations. Bread: 9 Sauces: 8 Cheesesteak: 4.5 Fries/Mozz Sticks: 7 Overall: 10 In my high school days, I followed a rotation of frequently eaten sandwiches, one of them being the chicken parm. This sandwich features a nicely fried piece of chicken along with a think layer of marinara sauce that proves it is indeed a chicken parm while not overwhelming the sandwich with it. A few slices of cheese then get melted on top of the sandwich to create a really great hoagie. Chicken: 8.5 Bread: 8 Marinara: 8 Cheese: 7 Overall: 8

    (5)

  • Brian B.

    The Haven was our late-night sanctuary during our college days, always the perfect bookend to a night of revelry. To the uninitiated, it would seems to just be a normal sandwich shop, but there's just something about the controlled chaos housed within, mixed with some sort of griddle magic that makes the Haven one of the greatest sandwich shops in the world. The menu is huge, but if you want my advice, stick to the hot sandwiches, like the chicken parm, or the bacon omelet cheesesteak. The line moves quick, and the service is just one notch more forgiving than the Soup Nazi, so know what you want before you step up to the counter. You always want the salpepperegano. The bread is fantastic. What's housed within can only be described as the closest thing I'll ever have to religion. The toppings are piled on liberally, and the meat is informed by the layers of seasoning that have caked their griddles and fryers for decades. The Haven is so good, that I once took a 6-hour detour during a road trip just to have a chicken parm and cheese fries. It's the first place I head when I pay a visit to my old stomping grounds. And when I bite into a sandwich from one of those perfectly-serviceable shops you can find just about anywhere, I always find myself pining for my first love.

    (5)

  • Misha T.

    I came in furiously hung over and the Phat Lady saw that, sang, and ended it. It's a disturbing mix of cheesesteak, fries, and mozzarella sticks with ketchup and hot sauce. It tastes like it sounds like and the regular size will be enough for you.I really can't imagine eating a large one.

    (4)

  • Natavia H.

    Hoagie Haven is more like Hoagie Hell. It's not the long lines or poor service or cramped space that bother me; it's the fact that the food is absolutely disgusting. My first time here I got a turkey and swiss sub. The turkey meat was definitely not what I'm used to. It was sliced way too thick and had an almost slimy mouth feel. Definitely not appetizing. I ended up picking off the turkey, and the mayo, cheese, lettuce and onion sammy I was left with was not half bad. Against my better judgement, I tried them once again, this time opting for a cheese steak with provolone and grilled onions. I think the provolone turned out to be white American, and the sandwich was beyond greasy, even for a cheese steak. I'm still disappointed in myself for eating it. I get that they are catering to a college crowd who are pulled in by the affordable prices (I didn't see any sandwiches over $10), and crazy sandwich combos a la Rutgers grease trucks, but it just didn't do it for me. As a ritual, my boyfriend insists on stopping here for a bite before Princeton games, and because I love him, I always oblige. I would do anything for love, but eating at Hoagie Haven again?- no m'am, I won't do that. Sorry boo.

    (1)

  • David L.

    It's been too long since I've had one. Sanchez on a full roll, slight sanchez sauce, extra ketchup, some lettuce and onions. When you go, get the mac and cheese squares. Fun and easy and really really good. Can't finish one anymore. So sad when the stomach shrinks when something as good as this is available. Would give it 5 stars, but the bread isn't quite as good anymore. And you forgot bacon on my bacon cheesesteak!

    (4)

  • Charles B.

    Best chicken parm ! I come here every week at least 2 times . My Work is in the area ,great place recommend it to everyone !

    (5)

  • Angela Y.

    Food: OUTTA THIS HEART ATTACK, ARTERY CLOGGING WORLD! **recommend Sanchez, Phat Lady, and Heart Attack--got some mozzarella sticks, got some meat, got some cheese, got some french fries...all sorts of goodness. And Don't forget to try their tangy spicy sauce, goes awesome on almost everything! First off, I hail from out of state and have eaten a few sandwiches in my life time, and this one is pretty up there on my fatty-delicious list. I try to convince my friend to drive me there every time I visit Jersey. Second, best tip I got for the folks that are looking to score grub--come at odd hours! There's a line during all major eating times and since the place is so small, it becomes an awkward snaking maneuver game with other hungry, sweaty beasts--better not tempt them. Where Hoagie Haven loses points is in the small cramped space that offers no friendly place to sit and enjoy the goods. There's NO seating at all except for a bench outside (which is nice for people watching), but there's only a tiny bar table with no chairs so you must stand to eat. If you're coming from afar, most of their signature hoagies run $5 for half and $10ish for the full thing. You can get it cut in quarters to share or just down the whole thing yourself. If you live near Princeton, it's a short stroll through to the place so I'd definitely take it home to enjoy with a beer and something on TV.

    (4)

  • Tom M.

    Don't serve breakfast if your not going to open before 9 am. Food is cheap but you get what you pay for. Way too greasy. And the owners do not seem friendly in any way. I'll pass on this place for now on.

    (2)

  • Steve E.

    Moved to Princeton in 1974 and used to ride my bike "uptown" to this joint when I started PHS in 1978! Used to go regularly throughout HS till I graduated in 83!

    (5)

  • Julia D.

    This place is only 15 minutes away from my house and I cannot be more grateful for this short commute. The long lines that go out of the shop are worth it. The fat sandwiches leave you in awe and possible food heaven, although you'll probably be in a food coma afterwards and go to the bathroom shortly after you finish your food. If you're on a diet, don't even think about coming here. When you come to Hoagie Haven, you know your waistline is going to be in trouble, but that's okay, because you'll remember how amazing that fat sandwich was.Their signature Dirty Sanchez hits the spot. Personally my favorite is their Mac Daddy. I have a huge appetite but I cannot even finish half of one order. I can't imagine eating a whole, but it's good to order if you're sharing.They have a wide selection of beverages both familiar and some extremely obscure. I try to buy a new unfamiliar bottle each time I go. Decent price and exceptional food. How can you go wrong?

    (5)

  • Nan R.

    half is enough！I am serious!!

    (4)

  • Angel C.

    Location sucks, no atm/credit card but they do have an atm machine....food: I had the phat lady, it was surprisingly good. My fried had the big daddy, he said it was really good too. Look are deceivin

    (4)

  • Mister K.

    Nothing to write home about. Me and my dad was in the Princeton area, and got a sandwich here. After seeing the 4 star on yelp, I was expecting a nice sandwich shop. What we got is the run of mill sandwich places, that are dime a dozen in New Jersey. Nothing is special about this place. The sandwiches were edible, and they had options, which is why this place get 1 star. The second star is for using real cheese for the cheese fries, instead of the cheese wiz. However, with a reputation like Hoagie Haven, I expected far more I guess. Almost No seating area, its a takeout place primarily. Don't expect much. If you are coming here so you can say you had a sandwich from this place, go ahead. But if you want a good sandwich, go somewhere else.

    (2)

  • Leas C.

    Went there around 4ish to get two subs. I got there and was first in line at the order counter. 5 guys just standing there and nobody came up to take my order right away. They did at some point then started to make it. The first one was the mac daddy and the guy let me put extra toppings on it like lettuce and tomatoes and onions. The second one wad the phat lady and when I asked for lettuce tomatoes and onion on it the guy yelled at me and said I was changing the sandwich from the way it should be. The food was good but the people who work there are rude.

    (2)

  • Jason G.

    Hoagie Haven has an outstanding reputation in the area. Finally decided to see what all the buzz is about. Holy. Overrated. Batman. Where do I even start? Place is kind of dingy. But, hey, some of the best holes-in-the-wall are nothing to look at. In retrospect, that should have been the warning shot. So...the cold cuts. Pre-sliced, sitting in a case. When did they cut them? An hour ago? This morning? Last night? Or did they buy pre-sliced?? No question that cold cuts on a good sub should be sliced fresh to order. Then, with those pre-sliced cold cuts, at least put a respectable amount on the bread. No exaggeration, one layer of ham, one capicola, one cheese. It's all bread and lettuce. Same thing with the turkey sub. Even worse was the tuna. My 3-year-old wouldn't eat it because of the overwhelming celery flavor. I got past that, but not the sour taste underneath it. Bread was stale on this one too. My daughter got 3 scoops of ice cream for dessert as an apology. The Rutgers-style "fat" sandwiches, loaded with fries and mozzarella sticks, seemed to be popular with the rest of the customers, maybe that's what you are supposed to eat here. I don't know, but I won't return...EVER... to find out. $15 life lesson.

    (1)

  • Catherina D.

    You come here for the unique hoagie creations the shop thinks up. The Phat lady is my go-to whenever I'm in Princeton and want lunch. The shop has little to no seating other than across the window sill and a couple stools. Thankfully there are plenty of benches up and down the street, or you can go relax near the fountain next to the university.

    (4)

  • Jericho C.

    The quintessential college "fat-sandwich" joint that every campus needs. Dirty Sanchez, extra dirty. Order, (CASH ONLY!), wait, eat, and then experience delightful remorse, knowing that your past week's gym efforts have been obliterated.

    (4)

  • Daniel B.

    It's "Haven" not "Heaven". And in fact, there is no food that will put you on the fast road to hell quicker than one of the signature hoagies from this Princeton institution. Let's say this first: the sandwiches here are disgusting. They are disgusting in lots of ways. It's disgusting how much fat and how many carbs can be squeezed into such a tasty package for a relatively paltry sum. It's disgusting to consider that some human beings will contemplate consuming an entire hoagie on their own (even a half hoagie is more than enough for any mortal). The ingredients they use are pretty disgusting too. But there is no escaping that when you take a lot of fried greasy things, slide them in the nest of a well-baked roll, and put them in your mouth, it will make all of the pleasure sensors in your brain explode with joy. Still, what they call a cheesesteak is a sad sad commentary on the form. The mozzarella sticks are kind of bland and lacking flavor. And worse, the fries have a dry and crumbly interior texture. Luckily, the good folks behind the line at Hoagie Haven are more than willing to help you build the sandwich of your dreams. I've still been triangulating mine. It involves some subset of their tastier ingredients which include: chicken cutlet, hash browns, mac and cheese wedges, pork roll, eggs, bacon, cheese and sanchez sauce. You can still do a lot of damage with those. My next visit will be a modified Sanchez, switching out the mozzarella sticks in favor of the mac & cheese wedges, and substituting hash browns for the fries. Brain chemistry is a pretty powerful thing. Even though I know that the food at Hoagie Haven will kill me, and that the quality of their ingredients isn't terribly high, I spend almost every day craving one of their phantasmagorical sandwiches. And every time I walk or drive past their storefront, it's an act of Herculean willpower not to stop in for a snack.

    (4)

  • Love Z.

    Let's keep this brief. Hoagie Haven is a landmark at Princeton University. Chicken parm and cheesesteaks are out of this world. Crazy french fry and sandwich concoctions await you. Lots of chips and drinks, too. And it's all yours at student prices. Just don't expect the line to be short. Ever.

    (5)

  • Chris F.

    The perfect 1am drunk food. Be warned, the hoagie are diet busters. The Sanchez and Body Bag are great, a half sandwich always hits the spot. The secret to their great sandwiches is the bread. That and all the fried stuff they throw on it. Next time you stumble out of the Ivy, or crave something greasy after downing a few at Triumph, give this place a try. It won't disappoint.

    (4)

  • Kevin H.

    Hoagie Haven is the best thing about the city of Princeton. Yes, even better than the all of the discoveries and humanitarian achievements of Princeton alumni. For where else can one pick anything on the menu, find it delicious, plentiful and at a price more consistent with an earlier era? Enjoy

    (5)

  • Chad N.

    I started coming here as a youngster around 1995, which was an 8 mile bike ride from West Windsor. Fast forward 19 years and I am still coming here. It was the best back then, and even with 200+ meals under my increasingly larger belt, it is still the best. I wish they would get rid of the tv screens, the blue t-shirt, and the newer menu items (Sanchez, fat sandwiches, chicken tacos on cheesesteaks). I just dont get the appeal in effectively diluting the perfect roll/meat combo with mozzarella sticks or fries. When it comes to the classic cheesesteak, I have yet to find a place that does it better (including Filthadelphia). Order a #16 w/ fried onions, hot sauce, ketchup, hot peppers. Find a bench outside or some steps to sit and eat. Repeat tomorrow with the #18.

    (5)

  • Connie W.

    After a brutal sunny day at a music festival, my Jersey friends took a detour to come here, just because me and my other friend have never been. It was 1AM on a Saturday and when we arrived, it was still as lively as ever. My friend was cold and hungry. I was alright. She got the heart stop. Just looking at it gave me a heart attack. But oh my god, it was delicious. I don't care how much calories it had or how it would bring me one step closer to obesity. It was delicious and that's all that mattered. This would seriously be the perfect late night snack (or meal)

    (4)

  • Martin L.

    Parking is near impossible, but that's not really the fault of this business. One of the few sub stores in Princeton. I ordered a sub and watched them make it. The pan of shredded lettuce was all brown. I figured the guy would rake off the brown lettuce from the top to expose fresh lettuce, but no, the entire pan was brown lettuce and it went right on the sandwich. That will be my last trip there. My girlfriend had previously gotten sick from one of their sandwiches.

    (1)

  • Jeff S.

    The greatest drunk food in the history of mankind. I cannot vouch for the cleanliness, but it is oh so delicious.

    (5)

  • Shilpa P.

    Grew up on Hoagie Haven, if you live in the area, you can't not love it. I always get the veggie. It is super loaded with all the cheeses, they never skimp on the veggies. Just the right amount of o&v. I have had some of the other sandwiches and they are great too but this is my favorite! Whenever I am back in the jerz, I find my way back to HH!

    (5)

  • Kevin W.

    Hoagie Haven is a Princeton institution, but more out of a poverty of better choices than because of genuinely good grub. It's open late, and perfect after a long night on the street - but it's pricey, and not particularly memorable. The Sanchez is a standby, but quite honestly, somewhat overwhelming ... your lifespan probably takes a two week hit for each one you eat. The Greek gyro is a cheaper option, and surprisingly good. Near the front counter, they sell some questionable edible gel that ostensibly makes you happier (through 'endorphin release'). So sketchy, but novel enough that I might try it next time I drop by.

    (3)

  • Cristin s.

    Fav fav sandwich spot! A classic amongst locals. Perk included: Hot Princeton guys getting there grub on

    (5)

  • Sarah S.

    Definitively a must if you're passing through Princeton and looking for a cheap, but good meal. Amazing sandwiches. They'll keep you full for hours and possibly put you into a food coma as well. We learned the calling ahead tip and were able to head to the front of the huge line that generally never goes away at this place, grab our sandwiches and head home in a matter of minutes. *Always call ahead to avoid the long line and bring cash*

    (5)

  • Beth H.

    SO here is the deal with Hoagie Haven. If you grew up in Princeton [and no, I do not mean you just went to school here for four short years], you understand that Hoagie Haven is nothing glamorous. It is not a "gourmet" sub shop, nor does it claim to be. If you are coming here expecting a perfectly manicured, pristine sandwich to be handed to you on a silver platter with cloth napkins, it ain't gonna happen. Hoagie Haven is the place to go for fast, cheap, greasy, and tasty food. Anything you get there will be delicious and filling. Once you go here a few times, you'll be hooked, and other sandwich places just won't do it anymore.

    (4)

  • Luke M.

    Are you kidding me? It's so weird that there still exist sandwich shops that are remarkably better than the rest. This is one of those. My top choice is the chicken pachanga, his deputy is the buffalo chicken cheesesteak. Word to the wise: the wait in the order line tends to be long. If you're a pro, you'll call in your order 10 minutes before you get there.

    (5)

  • C E.

    Better philly cheesesteak than anywhere in philly! The bacon cheesesteak tops all. My last meal would be a hoagie haven sandwich.

    (5)

  • Andrew N.

    Delicious! Definitely recommend this place. After a long bike ride, I enjoyed a very pleasant surprise at then end of my trip. This place should be renamed to Hoagie Heaven because I felt like I was in heaven after this meal.

    (4)

  • Preston E.

    The sandwiches are terrible and not good compared to jersey mikes and hoagie shop in Lawrence perhaps they should explore other businesses and I'm sure they will see how to improve

    (1)

  • Thomas N.

    I went here and had the worst and most ride service I have ever experienced. Most of the people were okay but the kid trying to take my order and the cashier were horrible. Food was average, nothing special and too greasy.

    (1)

  • Pauly D.

    The Wake Up call sandwich is outstanding its breakfast and lunch all in one. The only thing that this establishment is missing a Man Vs Food Challenge with a wall of fame for Princeton to be put on the map!

    (5)

  • Anthony I.

    After a long day, we stopped here before hitting our hotel, it was around midnight and it was jammed. We really didn't examine the menu and just ordered a cheese steak. It was very good, nothing magical or creative but just a solid cheese steak, not like a philly cheese steak, but it hit the spot.

    (3)

  • Ravi P.

    The Dirty Sanchez is delicious, and a heart attack waiting to happen (mozzarella sticks, French fries, and chicken cutlet all in a hoagie with 'Sanchez sauce'). It's so good I never order anything else, so my review is pretty limited. Hoagie Haven is often busy (especially during the college semester, later at night), so service can be strained. It also has very limited seating. But it's all worth it for that Sanchez Sauce.

    (5)

  • Christian S.

    Hoagie Haven certainly is a Princeton institution like many of my fellow yelpers have stated. Even though it seems as if this place just caters to one particular customer, everyone at some point finds himself or herself dining at Hoagie Haven. During the early to mid 90's, before I became a resident of Mercer County later that decade, I would leave the hustle and bustle of NYC behind for the tranquility of West Windsor and Princeton Junction for the summer. There were less than a handful of things to do for the youngsters at the time, but the one thing everyone did was some how bring their high, underage, or legally drunk ass to Nassau Street to dine at then two late night eateries, PJ's Pancake House or Hoagie Haven. Hoagie Haven took care of my belly many of nights; drunk, sober, or just plain ole hungry after work. There was nothing like grabbing a sandwich and finding a seat on the benches, the curb, to enjoy that sandwich in the crisp summer air. My favorite was always the Chicken Parm no cheese, no sauce. Uh? Yeah... Fried Chicken cutlet with lettuce, tomato, and mayo is on the menu. Naturally you have to at least order a cheesesteak once in awhile. Once I put aside my no pork rule from my misguided youth, I introduced myself to the bacon cheesesteak. Other than the staff and a few additions to the menu, the place has not changed much. The steak-umm meat cheesesteaks are decent. They probably won't receive any cheesesteak awards but they will satisfy your hunger, and get the job done. FYI...they are still a little cheap with the meat in my opinion. I had a cold hoagie twice. It was good once, but eh eh the very next time. Lack of consistency yeah, but they have proven that they can make a good sandwich. I just refuse to relive the negative experience again. I have certainly eaten less from Hoagie Haven as of late because I am getting older, but I suggest that everyone at least tries it and those of you that haven't had it in awhile grab yourself In the words of Randy Moss... Straight Cash Homie

    (3)

  • Christin K.

    Seems to be a Princeton town staple, but very disappointing nonetheless. The "hoagies" should be called sandwiches, since they offer very little meat, and the restaurant should be called Subway. What a shame, since its in the perfect geographic location - in NJ and just a stone's throw from Phili. That locale normally produces hoagies you can write home about: Several, paper thin meat and cheese or steak slices, packed into the roll with a ration of 3:1, content to bread. Good thing the rolls are delicious, since they completely outweigh the sandwich content.

    (2)

  • Andre P.

    I'd give it a 3 based on the sandwich I had, but due to it's incredibly cheap price and fanatical raving from patrons, I'm giving it four stars. I had the #1 and while it had cheap baloney on it, it was pretty good. Very huge, even the "half" which was the size of a large hoagie anywhere else. I heard the hot sandwiches are real good.

    (4)

  • Mark C.

    If there's one cuisine I haven't been able to find in the Bay Area, it's a "totally unhealthy, but so delicious" hoagie like those served at Hoagie Haven. During school, I had a love-hate relationship with the Phat Lady -- a cheese steak sandwich with mozzarella sticks and french fries. I loved how the layers of meat and fried goods blended in my mouth, but hated how it made my heart and arteries cry out in pain. That didn't stop me from eating this wonderful creation far more often than I should have. The bread -- vessel of goodness -- is a plain Italian white loaf. It's not bad, but I think there is some opportunity for improvement. I hope I can one day enjoy a Phat Lady on a loaf seasoned in garlic and covered in Asiago cheese. They also do build-to-order sandwiches. Once, I was craving hot dogs. When I walked into Hoagie Haven, I decided I didn't just want a plain old hotdog, but one with french fries, mozzarella sticks, and chicken nuggets. It was delicious! Since I graduated, it seems like they have done some culinary experiments and have discovered deep frying chunks of Mac n' Cheese. During a recent visit, I tried the Mac Daddy - a Bacon Cheeseburger with deep fried Mac n' Cheese wedges, french fries, and honey mustard. Let's just say the Phat Lady now has some serious competition for my favorite artery-clogging hoagie!

    (4)

  • Salva A.

    Not a fancy place, but perfect for a college town, especially since it's open late! There isn't seating indoors, but there are benches outside. Their sandwiches are savory, greasy, and delicious!!! The Phat Lady and (extra) Dirty Sanchez hoagies are my two favorites! They also have a wide selection of drinks. Don't come here if you're not in the mood for heavy, junk food. I always come back here when I visit Princeton.

    (5)

  • Tyler C.

    I always get the Dirty Sanchez. Delicious combo of mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders and French fries. Not sure what is in the Sanchez sauce, but it works well on several of their sandwiches. Their full sized hoagies are big, so come hungry.

    (4)

  • Lonnie S.

    Today March 19th, 2015 from 12:50 pm to 1:13 pm I was stuck in my pickup behind an illegally parked delivery truck in front of Hoagie Haven. Out of concern for my own safety and that of the delivery workers I stayed put until I could safely pull away. Their parking was illegal and very aggravating. They saw me in my truck, too.

    (1)

  • Emre Y.

    First time visiring Hoagie Haven. I got Sanchez and it was delicious and cheap. Half is enough to full. Do not forget to bring cash, they don't accept any card. There is only space for four people so you will probably get to go

    (4)

  • Rachel C.

    If you're in the mood to eat a gut bomb of a sandwich, this is the place. You can get greasy hoagies with fries, mozz sticks, cheesesteak, burger patties, eggs, bacon, hash browns, you name it.

    (4)

  • Alex H.

    Amazing staple of Princeton for the most "hit the spot" like, acid refluxing inducing junk food!

    (5)

  • Wilson C.

    FACT: Jared from Subway would not be able to do what he did, if he was born in Princeton, NJ and was introduced to Hoagie Haven. And it's a good thing he wasn't because he wouldn't be Jared from Subway, but rather Just Jared. Their subs are the real deal. They are truly footlongs-actually, no even longer and contain just about anything you want or could think of. Eggs, bacon, hash browns, cheese-steak, french fries, mozzarella sticks, roast beef, pastrami, chicken cutlet- pick your poison. I got the "Big Cat", which is a pretty accurate depiction of what I'd look like after eating one, a big cat a/k/a Garfield. 4 Bacon cheeseburgers (without the patty) and 4 eggs packed into a long ass sub, topped off with BBQ sauce and don't forget the lettuce and tomatoes, because those are good for you. Needless to say, after finishing the whole sub, it was pretty dam delicious. It also induced a pretty good nap. You don't come here for a quality sub but rather a fast, greasy, tasty sub that will fill you up good. It's a shame I don't live near the area and that I only came across this super sub shop because my friend was driving around his neighborhood. I've also yet to find a similar place in NYC/Brooklyn but my heart and nutritionist thank me for it. Don't be afraid to walk in and order a sub. They also have "normal" cold cut subs and sandwiches as well for those who choose to ride the safe road but trust me, you don't want to do that. Overall, Hoagie Haven is good old grub that will leave you and your tummy happy.

    (4)

  • Julia N.

    Hoagie Haven is always my go-to when I want to indulge. Get an extra dirty Sanchez. You won't regret it.

    (5)

  • Awani D.

    I've had the sanchez, phat lady, and el mexicano in the past...THE best fat sandwiches...can't think of a thing they could improve on. Worth the fat.

    (5)

  • Kwame D.

    Wow. What a sandwich! This place rivals Ike's in the Castro district in San Francisco with the crazy ingredient combos and melt-in-your-mouth bread -- except it's cheaper and decidedly more spacious. I opted for the "Mac Daddy," and thanks to other Yelpers, only ordered the half size. Just enough to leave me full without feeling disgusting! Yeah. This place isn't for you if you're counting points, watching your waist or minding your calories. But DAMN it's a nice indulgence. Next time I'm in Princeton, I'll definitely be back.

    (4)

  • Aneesh S.

    If you visit Princeton (and aren't a vegetarian) you MUST visit Hoagie Haven. Definitely recommend the chicken parm, bloch (chicken parm+bacon+eggs), and sanchez (chicken+fries+ mozzarella sticks). Lots of creative sandwiches. VERY long lines at night. Very worth it.

    (5)

  • Ninja M.

    First time here and I figure I try it given the awesome reviews. 1 foot long sub for 7.50. Great deal. Interior doesn't have a lot of space for seating. I ordered number 1 cold sub. Not sure if it was coincidence, but my stomach wasn't happy after I had 6 inches of the sub. Sub was good though.

    (3)

  • Carol S.

    Went for the first time today with a friend who loves this place. Service was quick, the employees were semi-friendly. Not that they were mean, but they didn't seem very happy to be serving despite my efforts to have a short happy dialogue (when it wasn't busy). No place to sit and eat inside the haven, and no restroom for patrons. There's a long bench-like table that runs along the window if you want to stand and eat there. Friend and I split a Phat Lady for $10, which I'd say totalled about 15" long. I didn't know what to choose because none of the "famous hoagies" had a description except the new "Body Bag". The Phat Lady had mozzarella sticks, french fries, cheesesteak, lettuce, peppers, onion, and hot sauce and Sanchez sauce. Wrapped it up and took it to the park to eat. Smelled SOOOO good I was dying and practically petting the hoagie that was in the passenger seat. Compared to Rutgers University Grease Trucks / Fat Sandwiches, I'd say Hoagie Haven beats it. It's probably thanks to the Sanchez sauce though. The hoagie was definitely thick and because it had so many different foods smushed together, you can't really appreciate each thing. But maybe that's not the point! I guess that's the awesome part. You just position your teeth onto the hoagie and slowly bite down through every layer, and chew it together in your mouth appreciating the fact that your American tongue will love anything that is this bad for you. I was well-full after my share of half the Phat Lady. I actually didn't feel like throwing up afterwards, nor the need to walk around and digest it, but maybe cause it was "only half". Or maybe because I'm a glutton that's used this terrible stomach abuse. My advice would be to make sure to get enough Sanchez sauce in your hoagie. That brings in flavor and doesn't make the hoagie feel altogether "too mushed up" to eat by giving it a good kick. I'll be back whenever I'm in the area! But won't be traveling down to Princeton just for Hoagie Haven.

    (4)

  • Chelsie L.

    Awwww The famous Hoagie Haven. Finally we meet! This place is like the grease trucks @ RU but in brick and mortar format. Greasy sandwiches full of deep fried stuff that will satisfy your drunk cravings. I got the dirty sanchez. Thought it was a little bland but I can definitely see the appeal. If you're looking for a hearty snack, thus place definitely gives you bang for your buck.

    (3)

  • Vinayak B.

    Amazing hoagies! Pretty inexpensive as well. This landmark sub shop in Princeton is a must visit. If you don't like any of their many signature hoagies (we recommend the Sanchez, the body bag and the phat lady), you can get a custom one done the way you want it. Don't forget to take a free lipitor from the pill box by the retro cash register haha just kidding ;)

    (5)

  • Will M.

    Ok, I am floridian, an extensive traveler and this is my "number 1" sandwich place. Amazing sammies, and a great price! A must visit if you ever find yourself in Princeton, NJ. CASH ONLY.

    (5)

  • Willy S.

    This place has decent sandwiches at an affordable price. The staff was friendly and responsive. If you want to indulge, try a sandwich from this place. One inconvenience is that they don't take credit card. Overall, good sandwiches at a reasonable price.

    (3)

  • Emma M.

    After a football game, we decided to try this classic dive famous for its hoagies and grilled sandwiches. Quite an extensive menu! They also carry drinks, chips, candy, and Tastykake baked products. My eggplant parmigiana half-sandwich consisted of a generous roll (about a foot long) laden with tons of deep-fried eggplant and tomato sauce, then grilled with a huge helping of cheese, and stuffed with fillings of your choice. I got onions. I really wanted to like this sandwich. Unfortunately, it was bland and needed a little kick...spice...something! In contrast, the Sanchez, with chicken, a spicy sauce, cheese, fries, and mozzarella sticks really hit the spot. So too, my order of french fries, which were super yummy, and for me the highlight. Low prices and very generously sized subs are no doubt part of the reason for this business' popularity. The line was long and intimidating, but moved very quickly.

    (3)

  • Amy G.

    Hoagie haven is a legacy in the town of Princeton. It's timeless style is only matched by the creativity of their unique sandwiches. Aside from the creative choices, their traditional hoagies are impeccable and tastefully crafted. Get the buffalo chicken cheese steak, you will not be disappointed! My second favorite would be turkey, lettuce, tomatoes and Mayo. You should also add some buffalo cheese fries to your order! Enjoy (-:

    (5)

  • Angelica A.

    I really don't know what the hype is about Hoagie Haven. Went in for a late night bite with some friends and was very disappointed. We ordered a foot long buffalo chicken hoagie. They used whole fried chicken tenders which wasn't what I was expecting-- I thought we'd get some kind of unbreaded chicken either shredded or chopped-- but that was alright. The bread to chicken ratio was very off. There was entirely too much bread and maybe three chicken tenders. The person who made our hoagie also slathered on entirely too much ranch and not enough buffalo sauce so it was like eating a ranch soaked piece of bread. The only saving grace for this place was that the service was speedy and the servers very friendly. If you're in the Princeton area and need a hoagie just go to Wawa.

    (2)

  • Ben H.

    I've grown up around princeton and this spot is a regular for my friends and I. We can always count on delicious fattening sandwiches that should not be in existence because they could be considered a major health hazard. I've never been disappointed with the essentials (dirty sanchez, mexicana, mac daddy, body bag) and will continue to return! It's also open super late so it's great for weekend hangouts in princeton!

    (5)

  • William S.

    Used to be great back in the day. Now a bunch of disrespectful goons and BROWN lettuce!!

    (2)

  • LJ R.

    Hoagie Haven...Yeah the world definitely needs more places like Hoagie Haven. Keep feeding the minds of the #1 rated school in the nation Princeton University colleges.usnews.rankings… If I can't go to Princeton I might as well eat like I go there. I don't remember how I came across this place via the Yelp app or TV Food Maps but all I know is that I am glad I did. So what does one order at Hoagie Haven!? A hoagie of course, honestly at the time I didn't know what it was or what to order but I wanted to try something good and not just anything I could get elsewhere. Looking around, listening to what others were ordering, looking at menus, what to order what to order and lo and behold, yeah I just used "lo and behold" but I don't think it was correctly used IDK, a sign stood out above the counter and I decided to try it yelp.com/biz_photos/hoag… forget about just trying one I had to go for both since they were conveniently placed next to each other, smart they just outsmarted me. How do you choose one? One order of the Adam Bomb and one order of The Wake Up Call for me. yelp.com/biz_photos/hoag… Lets finally talk about the food it to pure junk food/drunk food at least the two I ordered and they were delicious unhealthy for you. The Adam Bomb was something it had a hotdog, fries, mac and cheese wedges, chili, hot peppers, and cheese and hot sauce. The Wake Up Call was another something it had cheese steak, eggs, bacon, hash browns. Both were funky combinations and both were pretty good. I don't know if they were regular items since I didn't see them on the menu. Like the Adam Bomb the better of the two. It wasn't gourmet, fusion, or anything like that kind of amazing but amazing for what it was. I'd never had a place do this before other than what I'd do at a potluck and throw everything together and eat it. Friendly and fast service. Small pickup shop. Parking meters up in front. It's like what Jared from Subway ate before he lost all that weight and switched to Subway.

    (4)

  • Paula B.

    I don't get the hype. I found the hoagie to be dry and flavorless. I'd prefer a Subway.

    (2)

  • Kat W.

    When your team at work creates an event called Fat Friday, Hoagie Haven is the best place to fill your craving of that bucket of fatty, oily, but disgustingly delicious sandwich. You can get a sandwich of every fatty kind out there. My regular is the eggplant parmesan, so not the most fatty one out there, but definitely satisfying the craving of never having to eat anything for the next few days. Bread is fluffy and crispy. Make sure to eat the hoagie there and then, because it'll end up soaking a lot of the sauce. I've had the omelet sandwich before too, pretty good as well. Either way, they can make it whatever you like--as long as it's fat. Key to making the sandwich the way you like it is to be sure to watch who is making your sandwich. They will be asking you if you want the vegetables. The sandwich makers all have similar traits, so I sometimes gets confused and then I'm never really sure. Have never found a better place to celebrate any kind of Fat Friday. Because it's gotta be fat. Cash only.

    (3)

  • John B. L.

    Huge subs. Recommended by several locals, we got some for the road. They were Great! Lots of choices; sure to be something that you shouldn't eat, but makes you happy!

    (4)

  • Amy D.

    Found this place on yelp while on a road trip and was a worthwhile stop. Between the four of us we tried the Sanchez, Chicken Parm, Chicken Pachanga, and the Middle Finger. Seems as if the Sanchez is very popular and it sure was good (especially the sauce!). The Chicken Parm was really messy (AND yummy), and given there isn't seating in this place other than a few benches outside, as long as you have a handful of napkins you'll be fine. The other two were both specials and very unique. The hot sauce on the Pachango was perfect. We shared some Mac 'n Cheese bites which were basically Kraft Mac 'n Cheese fried up nice and good. Didn't hate it. :) I was pretty impressed with the quick service and surprisingly, the selection of canned and bottles drinks - very unique sodas, teas, etc. Overall, we're all very happy with our decision to stop here on the way through Princeton - quite the gem.

    (4)

  • Daniel L.

    Get "the Block." It'll come out as a block later too. Chicken Parm, Bacon and fried eggs. Yum. Add some peppers (black, and sweet) with some salt. Oh and some ketchup and you're good to go. Which size should you get? Half if you are sober. Full if you are drunk. (No, they are not 6" and footlongs, you morons) Either way, whichever size you get, be prepared to feast and die in agony. Full of regret and prayers will be lifted to god in the bathroom stalls. This is only place available as a late night option here in Princeton. Cash only homies.

    (4)

  • Ed U.

    I wonder if the denizens of Princeton are miffed that Yelp's highest rated "restaurant" in their fair city is this unadorned sandwich shop with a steady stream of undergrads ordering their submarine sammies to transport back to their dorm rooms. I had been curious about the place on my last two business trips here but never found the opportunity to go until now. I ordered half of a cold hoagie, the Provolone Cheese, Pressed Ham and Salami (see photos). What did I think? It was exactly what I wanted. Speedy service. Dirt cheap at just $3.50. Sloppy with all the fixings piling out. What I didn't expect - and I believe this is the clincher for people - is the soft, fresh Italian torpedo roll that housed all the ingredients. It doesn't look like the bread is baked on the premises, but it sure tastes like it. The sliced meats are definitely a cut above the machine-processed cold cuts Subway appears to use, and the oil and vinegar doesn't have a rancid after-taste. Besides, I walked in and out in less than four minutes. FOOD - 4 stars...the secret is in the roll, everything else falls into place AMBIANCE - 3 stars...not sure what to say except the makers wear plastic gloves SERVICE - 4 stars...not much for chit-chat, turnover is their goal TOTAL - 4 stars...hey, if I was a Princeton undergrad in the middle of finals and out of Chex Mix and beer, this is where I'd go, too

    (4)

  • Stephanie D.

    Late night, drunk-food. It's not clean, its not pretty. It IS a monmouth amount of food, a ton of calories, and sinfully, fatteningly, delicious. My husband has gotten the bodybag and the heart stop, both of which he struggle to fully ingest. Id highly recommend it here if you're drunk and famished.

    (3)

  • Lele E.

    I'm eating a cheese steak from here now. It's okay. Initially I walked in and there was a group of people. I asked them if they were in line and they said no. So I walked around and approached the front. No one greeted me or said hello so I figured they were just busy cooking Finally after inching closer someone kindly asked what I wanted to order. I requested the small cheese steak. I went to the cashier and he kindly asked if I wanted anything else. It was an okay experience, I just expected more bc of the reviews. The cheese steak was okay, the best part about it was the bread. The meat looks like steakumms. I'd go back here to try other food but my first experience was just okay. :/ Update....I'm not going back there :/

    (3)

  • Holly C.

    Cash only. Cheap, good subs and sandwiches. No one I know of has ever been disappointed.

    (5)

  • Ophelia S.

    I grew up eating lunch regularly at this joint, and watched it evolve from a tiny greasy disgustingly delicious sub shop into a almost upstanding still amazing (with less grease) hole in the wall. It's still got the best subs around Jersey though! I recommend every single sub and bacon cheese fries (real cheese melted on fries if you're okay with that). You can make your own subs or choose one of their many varieties and creations. I really enjoy their chicken parm, veal parm, or meatball parmigiana subs (12" hell yes). And they have a secret stash of home made rice pudding in their fridges to the front left - a delicious lightly sugared dessert. The place is always crawling with Princeton university college and high school kids and the lines get ridiculously long during lunch and dinner rush hours - but it's worth the wait in line. The place is a tiny one room shop, with snacks and drinks lining the walls, and people always crowding in groupies. The staffs super nice too and one time I forgot cash and their ATM machine wasn't processing my credit card, so they took my phone number and let me take the food anyways until I could get back to them with the money. Good affordable food, great staff, and if you like it as much as me - buy a hoagie haven tshirt! Haha... I got one that's bright orange! :)

    (5)

  • Christopher S.

    Heard so much talk about this place being a great post bar food spot when I moved to area. Place was the definition of a health code violation the second we walked in and confirmed when the guy handling cash touched food without gloves. Food itself was bland, place is only in business because there's nowhere else like it in area. Won't return, disgusting.

    (2)

  • Michael P.

    When in Princeton, you got to go to Hoagie Haven. I get the Sanchez and I am never disappointed.

    (4)

  • Neil A.

    Hoagie Haven was recommended to me as a place to try when I first visited Princeton. This was 10 years ago during my early 20's. It reminded me of a very similar group of trucks located in New Brunswick which I will not name but many local college kids are most likely familiar with. In terms of its strengths, the price point of Hoagie Haven and variety of foods definitely appeals to the college crowd within Princeton. It is very affordable and catered to my 20 year old palette. One couldn't argue with a cheese steak with fries, mozzarella sticks and marinara sauce for $5. It was priced so accordingly I could easily buy and eat two and not worry about breaking the wallet. 10 years later, their food still tastes the same. But sadly the way my body handles it has. Service is spotty. There are times the music is so loud (mostly techno) one can question oneself if the servers heard your order properly. The language of the servers can be of question at times. I understand its language that can be tolerated for a back of house kitchen environment, but unfortunately their kitchen is exposed and you can hear pretty much everything. One normally has to ignore it or take it with a grain of salt. Overall, one mostly goes here for cheap and affordable college food that satisfies their hunger. It is cash only and there an ATM in the corner (if you don't mind the ATM and bank fees associated with its use). As a result during the school year, don't expect there to be a short line unless you come at off peak hours since it is one of the very few places students can get a full stomach at an affordable price.

    (2)

  • Max M.

    One of my favorite parts about Princeton. Creative, delicious, reasonably priced hoagies with an extremely loyal following. The only two downsides is that there is usually a line and they only take cash. Despite that, I still think they're the best. I love the Sanchez, but you really can't go wrong here.

    (5)

  • Fred K.

    Went with the dirty Sanchez. If you're looking for a greasy sub that'll prepare you for nap, then you've found one! Everything tasted real good, the chicks fingers, mozz sticks, and Sanchez sauce were solid. Fries were just ok nothing special. but looks like I'll be going to the gym for an extra hour today... After my mandatory nap that is.

    (4)

  • Mary G.

    This is the only place I know of to ever get hoagies! My friends and I drove 40 minutes last night just for some hoagies. I usually get one of 2 things: tuna salad hoagie or philly cheesesteak. It still remains good the next day, and the next! Only issue, cash only!

    (4)

  • Eva S.

    Obviously, you don't come here for quality food. Very good tasting unhealthy food. I got the body bag. There are a lot of surprises inside the sandwich. Very meaty. Too bad it was messy to hold because it has too much stuff on it. Overall, the taste is good. Very fast service and low price.

    (5)

  • Steve C.

    Awesome sandwich shop! Try the phat lady, you won't be disappointed! Prices are good and the service is quick. Eat and then take a walk through downtown Princeton. It's definitely worth the wait.

    (4)

  • Kyle M.

    I grew up near Princeton, and I've been here a few times over the years (most recently last night). When I was in high school, I wanted to like this place just because there was pressure to conform and say that I liked it. Specifically from girls that I was attracted to at the time -- they all loved Hoagie Haven in Princeton, and in fact, they liked walking down Nassau Street in general as a way to pass time on the weekends. It is just such a nice place to be a healthy, upper-middle class, well-educated white person. Now that I am older and have experienced hundreds of similar places to eat in the New York Metro area, I can safely say that Hoagie Haven is overrated. The fact is, Hoagie Haven enjoys a cushy, opportune location devoid of any natural competitors in a 20-mile radius. It is a college-demographic food joint in a town that is too rich for college-demographic food joints -- thus, it attracts annoying adolescents from all over who are enamored by the Princeton mystique. I've had good sandwiches from here before, but my Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak last night reminded me of a school lunch: passionless shredded iceberg lettuce, manufactured-looking slices of tomato, and rubbery chicken patties that, when combined, were only satisfying because I was somewhat drunk. ...and last night, my friend ordered a Cheese Steak, but in his borderline autistic awkwardness, he somehow walked out ten minutes later complaining that they never made his sandwich. I think someone who came in after him just grabbed his sandwich, paid for it, and left. The guys behind the counter didn't notice or do anything. Why would they? I like to imagine that the person who stole his order was an Asian chick -- moderately good-looking, maybe. At least that way I could sort of relate to just standing there while someone took my food... sort of.

    (3)

  • Alice S.

    My benchmark deli sandwich is a turkey sub, and out of all the places I've had one from, Hoagie Haven does a pretty great job. I've never ordered their hot subs/grease truck style items before. The "line" for ordering does get a bit confusing/muddled at times, and also it's cash only.

    (4)

  • Elisa H.

    We stood in line for about 15 minutes and it was so worth the wait! A gentleman behind us recommended that we split a couple of sandwiches, so we did! I ordered the Mac Daddy (beef, cheese, fries, hot sauce, and mac n cheese) and the Phat Lady (steak, cheese, fries, mozzarella sticks and ketchup.) My friend ordered the Sanchez (chicken was great but little bland compared to the other sandwiches. She also ordered the Shrimp po boy hoagie, which i didn't get to try because we were so full after the second sandwich! She didn't get to try my Phat Lady but yes, it was all that! definitely don't recommend eating here on a regular basis unless you are college age (which I'm not!) and/or are an athlete who can burn off the calories efficiently. Oh, and like most places in downtown Princeton, they only take cash!!

    (5)

  • Ted W.

    The food here is pretty good. It's also very cheap. Cash only. Be aware the service is usually annoying - the guys behind the counter like to joke around when they don't have your order right. It's not too bad though. The fact that this place is open so late is also a plus. Recommended. (Please work on your service...)

    (4)

  • Mike N.

    Hoagie Haven is the king of all sandwiches. I've traveled far and wide, and I've never found a sandwich that compares to any place in the area. The key to all of the sandwiches is the bread - it's light and fluffy stuff that crisps up just enough with a light toasting, but gives a satisfactorily spongey give with each bite. It soaks up the flavors and seasonings of the sandwiches and can withstand whatever you decide to get on your sandwich. And boy, can you get some things on your sandwich here. The usual staples are all here - cheesesteaks, chicken and eggplant parm, cold deli sandwiches - but the real joys come from what you can get on your sandwich. Mayo, hot sauce, Sanchez sauce? Check. Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, hot peppers, pickles? Check. Salt, pepper, oregano? Check. Those are all the standard things you would expect from any sandwich place. Hoagie Haven lets you put things like cheesesteak, chicken fingers and mozzarella sticks on a sandwich. Feel like chicken tacos inside of your cheesesteak? They'll do it. Hoagie Haven is not for those who are looking to be health conscious. There are a few items on the menu which could be considered healthy, I suppose, but the real reason to come here is to get some delicious, greasy stuff that will satisfy your craving, especially after a long night out at the Ivy. I've been coming here for over a decade, and every time I come back, I always remember why. Hoagie Haven is a staple of Princeton, and deserves to be known as the king of sandwiches.

    (5)

  • Sarang K.

    The only reason it gets 3 stars over 2 is that it is the only place around that is open past midnight. I don't deny that I thoroughly enjoy every single morsel of food that comes out of this place. With that said, it is because I have to be supremely hungry or in a particular mood to get my a-double over there to get a hoagie. Conclusion? Over rated but still good. The guys that work there are a flirt, and that just makes it fun. Not worth a 5+ mile drive unless you're buying in bulk. Then there's gas.

    (3)

  • Lily T.

    Maybe I ordered the wrong thing. Maybe I had such high expectations. Maybe I am too spoiled from eating exceptionally good food in NYC. I thought the sandwich was just okay. I got the chicken parm sub. The chicken was fried to crispy and it had a good amount of tomatoe sauce and parm cheese in it. I thought the bread was too soggy and thin for me. Just ok...slightly disappointed And the place was very small, dirty and smelled funky and greasy

    (3)

  • Sirfaraz P.

    Been eating here since '05. Always enjoyed it, been watching the prices go up but I guess that's standard. I don't eat much meat so always stick with the number 12. I remember the days when a whole used to be 4.25. They've added a bunch of new things to the menu but I say stay with the classics.

    (5)

  • Claudia B.

    This place is good. We usually get small subs (which are actually very big subs) and we eat them on the benches outside. The only thing I would recommend is that they clean the sidewalk area under the benches. It looks like there is 20 years worth of oil and food build up under those benches. The ground is actually slippery from it! Eww.

    (5)

Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.

Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.

Map

Opening Hours

  • Mon :8:30 am - 1:00pm

Specialities

  • Takes Reservations : No
    Delivery : No
    Take-out : Yes
    Accepts Credit Cards : No
    Good For : Lunch
    Parking : Street
    Bike Parking : Yes
    Wheelchair Accessible : No
    Good for Kids : Yes
    Good for Groups : Yes
    Attire : Casual
    Ambience : Casual
    Noise Level : Average
    Alcohol : No
    Outdoor Seating : No
    Wi-Fi : No
    Has TV : No
    Waiter Service : No
    Caters : No

Hoagie Haven

Share with your social network

WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES

Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online

Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.

© 2024 Restaurant Listings. All rights reserved.