Not sure if the name changed but this place is now the Irish Setter Pub. It's the classic Irish-American pub style but for PI, it was the best best food I had. It's a cute time capsule of locals and the decor seems inspired by their police force and those giant red dogs. They have the full range of Irish, Tex-Mex (seems that nachos, taco salad, etc are a staple of Irish pubs), and American food. There isn't a ton of selection but they have a good range of burgers, sandwiches, wraps, entrees, and apps. I had the nachos twice and they were the good kind with real cheese, olives, tomatoes, jalepenos, etc. They also come in full and half sizes in case you want something else. Also the fried pickles are phenomenal!! Prices are reasonable and beer is cheap for those over 21!
Good food, good prices, nice relaxed atmosphere. Good with just a couple or for a group. Friendly wait staff. I like the specials posted on the road sign, they always entice me to come try it out!