Old Salty’s

2560 Hoopers Island Rd
Fishing Creek, 21634
Great seafood place. The menu bit look boring but everything is so much more than expected. The main seafood - either fried or broiled - are cooked to perfection. All the sides are great especially the baked pineapple. The homemade rolls and desserts just add to the dining experience. This is must stop if you are in Hoopers Island!!
Honestly, nothing special about this place. The food is decent but nothing great. It appears to be the only restaurant in the area and greatly benefits from the lack of competition. The decor is abysmal and badly needs to be updated. (Minus 1 star) The soft shell crab sandwich came out on two pieces of white bread..un-toasted. The food is a 3. The pricing is reasonable.
This is by far the best seafood place i've been that serves true MARYLAND crabs, crab cakes, especially the best Baked Pineapple i have ever tasted. The broiled crab cake was so delicious. It was all crab meat, no filler...sooooo meaty! My other favorite is the fried soft shell crabs :) it was fresh and crunchy, fried to perfection.. The sides were delicious. My favorite was definitely the baked pineapple. It is making my mouth water just writing about it...so make sure you order that!!! The atmosphere was awesome, the servers were nice and pleasant. we even met the owner and he was really nice and welcoming!!! Lastly, the view of the chesapeake with pretty :) This place is definitely worth the 2 hr drive from DC! Can't wait to go back.

(410) 397-3752


Store is open now