J’s Dairy Inn

207 W Union St
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
Sometimes reviews need to be updated. Things change in four years. It's true; J's seems to be a bit cleaner and friendlier than in years past. Perhaps it's under new ownership? I don't have the inside scoop on every local business like some Yelpers do. Anyway, I have to give a major shout-out to the hot wings... well, drumsticks to be more accurate. They were so crunchy on the outside and the grease was minimal. I was happy I branched out for once in 25 years. The JoJo's are still JoJoriffic.
J's is an institution Liberty. Every town should be so lucky to have a place like this. J Boy! Jo Jo fries, pizza burgers, slushies, any kind of ice cream you dream up, if you're headed home from Brookville Lake, J's is the place to stop.
The owner has reached out to me to apologize and find out the details of what happened so he can make it right. He stated he was going to use this as an "educational opportunity" and I hope he does because boy, do they need it! I will continue to get my "J's fix" whenever I'm in town! BTW, if you go you MUST get their Vanilla Diet- very tasty!

(765) 458-5812

American (Traditional), Burgers, Chicken Wings

Store is open now

Ainsley’s Cafe & Harbor Bar

15179 Old State Rd 101
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
Great view of the lake when you sit out on the multi tiered deck. The menu is very American. My husband and I both ordered grilled fish with roasted potatoes and the fresh veg of the day hoping for lighter fare. What we got was delicious, but anything but light. The fish wasn't flame grilled. The potatoes had been deep fried. All was covered in buttery grease. Again, very good, but not what we'd expected. The staff was plentiful, so it was odd that we weren't even greeted for a while upon entering and then sat at our table for another while before our server claimed us as her table. In the end, we were well taken care of, though.
Greek salad was great, seafood fettuccine was delicious, onion straws were good. Huge portions, so you may want to share! Great view and atmosphere!
The Chop Chop Salad (salmon salad) was delicious! It came with a fluffy breadstick. The service was great and the view is wonderful.

(765) 458-7474

American (New)

Store is open now

Ainsley’s Cafe

15179 Old State Rd 101
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
Ainsley's Cafe is a great place to enjoy a meal if you're in the Brookville area. The restaurant has great outdoor seating with views of the marina and a decent menu variety. Each year we go to Whitewater Memorial State Park and rent out a group of cabins, Ainsley's is the restaurant of choice in the area when we don't feel like grilling. I went twice this past weekend, the first time I had the wings, which were ok (breaded is not my thing- but I didn't ask) and the second time I had the Yachtsman (re: bacon cheeseburger) which was great. Others in the group had ribs, seafood parm, and cajun chicken, which all looked pretty good. The prices are a little steep, but the quality and service are definitely deserving of an above average star rating. There were about ten servers on the Saturday I went (during the Indy 500) and they were all really cute and helpful. The view is amazing from pretty much anywhere in the building as well as outside. I've always had a positive experience at Ainsley's and would recommend it to anyone in the area. Check out their website for more info on when they're open because I'm pretty sure they're a seasonal restaurant.
I think most folks go here for the view, which is nice, but the food is pretty good. It's a pretty standard American-fare menu. The spinach salad was really good, and the wings were tasty, though the "hot" was...not. Service was good, though I think we got lucky with the young lady who waited on us. My drink was never empty (a nice touch on a hot day on the deck).
Great setting, but you never know which restaurant you are visiting -there is the good fresh restaurant and the stale blah restaurant. Servers nice. Last spinach salad - the spinach was terrible and the dressing was rancid. Over the years, quality not consistent.

(765) 458-7474

American (New)

Store is open now

El Reparo Mexican Restaurant

103 W High St
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
As far as I know, this is one of two El Reparo restaurants, the other being in Brookville. I was surprised at 1 p.m. to be the only customer in the place. Later, a few other people arrived. The lunch menu seemed very much like El Rodeo, down to the Speedy Gonzalez and the #3 Enchilada with rice and beans that I often order. The chips weren't very good--the usual cook-them-once-reheat them-many-times kind of chips. The accompanying salsa was good. I know that they don't have time to cook the chips in individual batches but it would certainly taste much, much better. The enchilada came with ground beef--I forgot to specify the filling--and the sauce was good. I'd almost think it was the same kind that El Rodeo and so many others use. The rice was particularly tasty and the beans were good. The price wasn't bad, especially considering the lack of customers. You'd think that they'd have to charge more to keep it open for lunch. They had two tvs mounted high on the walls, so I would imagine that they have a great after-work crowd and during sports events. The décor was amusing with little cactus figures on the partitions and paintings on the walls to remind you of Mexico.
My husband and I ordered take out and they messed the order up. Gave us something we didn't order and we didn't get stuff we did.
Top notch. Worth the drive from Richmond. Great fresh food, great service, great atmosphere.

(765) 458-1520

Mexican

Store is open now

Liberty Bell Restaurant

216 S Main St
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
The broasted chicken is the best chicken I have every had. All you can eat for $9.99 on Saturday night. I will defiantly be back.
Liberty Bell has a large dining area and an even larger menu. They offer pressure fried chicken, Mexican, Italian, steaks, burgers, breakfast and more. Unfortunately, the focus is on quantity, not quality. Everything our party ordered was just okay. The sirloin tips were tough and had an off taste. The cube steak was actually a JTM-type meat patty covered in gravy. The kids spaghetti was way overcooked and swimming in water. Speaking of water, it rained hard during our visit and the dining room had leaks everywhere. According to our server, the water pouring out of the ceiling is a normal occurrence, though there were some new leaks this storm. The aforementioned server did a pretty good job. There were a couple of others that seemed really spaced out and scatterbrained; glad we didn't get one of them. In the end, this place is one of the few choices in the area, so if we lived here, we'd probably go back eventually.
Had a great breakfast here! Great pancakes, omelets and country fried steak. Staff was very friendly and took great care if us. We will be back for sure!

(765) 458-6115

Restaurants

Store is open now

Brookville Resort Property Owners Assoc

2288 W Old 101 Rd
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(765) 458-5353

Store is open now

Grandma Cookie’s Sugarshack

9 W Union St
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(765) 458-7500

Store is open now

Carriage Lamp Bed & Breakfast

308 W Union St
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(765) 458-6100

Bed & Breakfast

Store is open now

Sagamore Resort

15179 Old State Road 101
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(765) 458-7431

Boating

Store is open now

Pizza King

201 N Main St
Liberty, 47353
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(765) 458-5775

Pizza

Store is open now