Taco Bell

1152 Indianapolis Rd
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
The nicest customer service. I wouldn't really say anything about it but I was just stunned at how nice the employees were. Impressive.

(765) 653-2061

Mexican, Tex-Mex, Fast Food

Store is open now

Papa John’s Pizza

1205 S Bloomington St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Excellent pizza consistent quality. Always have weekly specials to get a great deals. Staff are courteous and accurate with your order. Store is clean and bright

(765) 655-2292

Pizza

Store is open now

Moores Bar & Restaurant

17 S Indiana St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
The one thing I will miss about my girlfriend going to school in this town! after long nights of studying we would go here and enjoy good beer and amazing "hand food" get the pot roast sandwich! OH. MY!
It's your average neighborhood bar. I had the pork tenderloin sandwich. It really hit the spot.
Favorite small town bar! This is by far the best cheeseburger around! Great place to meet up with friends or even just drop in for a quick after work beverage. Service is always great!

(765) 653-9939

Restaurants

Store is open now

Anthony’s New York Style Pizzeria

306 E Washington St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Anthony's returns to Greencastle after a few year hiatus. It has great pizzas but please don't stop there. It also has great pastas,salads and calzones. The pizza is served by the slice or course you can order a whole one. But one slice is big enough for most. Also highly recommend the garlic rolls
This place just opened up and I can already tell you I am a big fan. Went in for lunch and the place was packed. Good sign! My family and I ordered pizza by the slice with some breadsticks and took a seat. Within 7 minutes they had our pizza ready. Piping hot and smelling great! HUGE slices of pizza I may add. I had their Sicilian Supreme. WOW! Incredible flavor! Everything about it was solid. Their sauce is so tasty. I tried a few bites of my son's sausage pizza slice and found it to be mouth watering good. I am beyond impressed. Will be back to try their pasta and calzones soon.
Very good NY style pizza. Long overdue in Greencastle. Solid, fast, reliable. Good calzones, and sandwiches. Glad to have Anthonys in the food desert of Greencastle.

(765) 653-4300

Pizza, Food Delivery Services, Caterers

Store is open now

Chief’s

5 W Franklin St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Yum! Great food and great service!!! Manager stopped by to make sure everything was too our liking. Very sweet staff all around. Food was gooooooood!! I highly recommend the catfish and crab florentine. Hubby ordered the shrimp alfredo and was equally impressed. Definitely worth a stop in!
I'm not sure what all of the hype is about. This location has been a few different businesses over the years; most recently Chiefs restaurant and before that 'Anthony's Pizzeria,' which I liked much better. The décor is supposed to have a 'Cajun,' feel, but it really comes up short IMO and is borderline tacky. They don't have much to offer their vegetarian customers, which is the main reason I've only dined here 2 or 3 times. Salads are mediocre (but how do you screw up a salad) and the dill pickle soup was 'ok.' Menu is a decent size with variety. Prices are reasonable as well. Place has been (nearly) completely empty during my visits, with only one waitress-but waitress is very nice. Review has been updated to 3/5 starts because the owner contacted me personally about my review; expressing his concern. Good to know that Chief's really appreciates customer feedback.
The most unique restaurant in Greencastle. Fun atmosphere and staff. You just never know what the daily special will be, but rest assured it will be yummy. If you are there on Pickle Soup day, dive right in and enjoy. Unfortunately, Chiefs is closed. Sad day in Greencastle

(765) 301-4135

American (Traditional), Cajun/Creole

Store is open now

Mama Nunz’s

800 Main St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Can't go wrong here! Very good food - home cooking and great service! Come by and chat with Nunzio the owner.
It really IS in a strange location--kind of behind the Beefcake place, in what appears at first glance to be a vacant lot; after we spotted it we had to circle around to get into the parking area. The food we had wasn't out of this world, but overall, it was very tasty. The mozzarella sticks seemed to be the standard frozen kind, but the marinara served with them was extremely good and garlicky. The pasta Alfredo with chicken was non-gloppy, and the chicken grilled but not cooked to shoe leather, which was a nice touch, and sometimes hard to manage in a restaurant setting. I'd definitely like to come back to try some of their other menu items.
A great restaurant in Greencastle. A little hard to find but worth it. Also a different menu than most of the other places in town. It has the normal steaks and stuff but great pasta and Italian food. if you're looking for a different place to eat make sure you give it a try

(765) 653-8402

Pizza, Italian, Steakhouses

Store is open now

Dairy Castle

801 Indianapolis Rd
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Small, quaint locally owned and operated establishment that offers good ice cream, finger foods, and even some hot items as well. Decent burrito too. My favorite is the caramel and butterscotch malt! WOW! So good! The youthful feel of the place is nice, as the staff usually consists of high school aged kids. They have never gotten my order wrong and I have been here dozens of times. They are hard working and that is something you don't see out of the youth of today!
We loved this place. Until today. I got an itemized receipt because it seems that although I order the same thing for my kids all the time, it seem to pay different prices. This happened a lot last year as well... I figure 'teens behind the counter' kind of thing. Today I saw that this place actually charges .75 cents ... for sprinkles!! Like 50 sprinkles could fit on a medium cone, right!? That's .75 cents worth?? Talk about a rip off. I think we'll stick to buying ice cream and a JAR of sprinkles ourselves if that's the price I'm paying.
Huge selection! Can't go wrong with this small-town gem! Reasonably priced.

(765) 653-9222

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Store is open now

Monical’s Pizza Restaurant

29 Putnam Plz
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
We ordered the barbecue chicken flatbread pizza. Super awesome! Quick friendly service and fresh salad and pizza!
The pizza is always good and I love the breadsticks! Plus, the owners are very supportive of the community. Best pizza in town!
Great thin crust and very good pan pizza .Great experience all around .

(765) 301-4404

Italian, Pizza

Store is open now

Almost Home Restaurant

17 W Franklin St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Lovely restaurant in downtown Greencastle - it's nice to have a local place on the square. My son loved the big burger. We all loved the soft and warm dinner rolls and pecan butter. I tried the crab cakes - good for Indiana. :) The ambiance is wonderful. I love having a glass of Indiana's Oliver Winery Soft Red with dinner. Service is always pleasant. A great place for this little town!
Great ambience... Wonderful recipes, fresh ingredients... The carrot soup was outstanding, specials of the day yummy and affordable, service excellent and friendly... Thanks for a delicious lunch Paul&Jacki, Traveling from San Luis Obispo, CA
Totally quality of food has degraded. Prices have gone up and experience is nothing great any more.

(765) 653-5788

American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Charlie’s Chill & Grill

424 S Bloomington St
Greencastle, 46135
Reviews:
Now that Beefcake Burgers has infused their taste to Charlie's, it gets a major upgrade! Fresh angus beef, hand dipped milkshakes, and an amazing staff! The trifecta of taste, atmosphere, friendliness! Beef On!
Cheap fast food in a restaurant like atmosphere. We ordered the chicken nuggets, chicken wrap, smothered fries, smothered hot dog, and a pulled pork sandwich. The kitchen is open so you can see them grilling and deep frying. Just don't look back there. Everything was very very average but for $10, you can't really complain too much. Since we already didn't feel like fat asses, we got a vanilla cone & vanilla Oreo Shake. Both good. Until we found 2 short hairs in the Oreo Shake. Now we can complain. F-ing disgusting. Weeks later and I'm still holding back vomit.
We have eaten there twice now. The coney sauce tasted burnt both times, maybe the bottom of the pan sauce? The service was just below average. Seemed almost like it was a hassle to take our order. Nothing special about the food.

(765) 301-9142

American (New)

Store is open now