Yesterday’s Drive-In

709 Oak St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-8741

American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Dimaggio’s Pizza

100 April Ave
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
Beth W.. I'm gonna start by saying you are a freaking idiot and clearly don't know anything about pizza. Dimaggios has been around for 40 years. The crust is not pre made or frozen. The dough is made fresh everyday then rolled out to order. It is a harder type crust because it's Sicilian brink oven pizza and it is suppose to be like that! Unlike your terrible chain college pizza you are used to eating every topping on a DiMaggio pizza is fresh with the exception of few toppings. Again they have been around and doing extremely well for 40 years so I'm sure they have the temperature of their ovens down pat. So before you bash something on yelp you should get your facts straight. Enjoy your dominos and pizza hut pizza!
I've never had DiMaggio's but heard it was good. I guess maybe I'm spoiled from living in a college town, because I thought it was pretty gross. The crust was like cardboard--zero bubbles like you get with a hand tossed crust. It was kind of like frozen pizza crust and was perfectly round, so I'm betting they buy it pre-made. The sauce is bright red and way too sweet. This was several steps away from ever being tomatoes--there was none of the flavor or spices you normally get in pizza sauce. The mushrooms were straight out of a can. Ew. The thing that bugged me most and prevented me from eating more than my two original small pieces was the fact that they put chunks of raw bacon on top of the pizza before cooking it. It was still WAY too squishy to eat. And I don't think they are cooking the pizzas in a high temp pizza oven. They just didn't have the right texture or caramelization. On a good note, there was a ton of cheese. And the sweet tea was good. My brother-in-law was hoping for a beer with his pizza but only soda and tea are served here. We ordered an Italian salad and had to search for the meat and cheese in it. The salads did have sliced radishes, which is nice, and the blue cheese dressing was really good. I wouldn't come back here.
One of the best pizza joints in all of Illinois. I consider myself a bit of a pizza connoisseur, and this place will forever be in my top 3. For starters, the place is ran by two Italian brothers, so the authenticity is there. The signature crust is hand tossed, which comes out to be twice as thick as a St. Louis style pizza. They do offer thick crust and deep dish, but if you want the real experience, go traditional. The pizza is very filling and I've never heard of anyone not enjoying it. If you don't want pizza, they have a wide selection of pasta, sandwiches, and salads.

(618) 382-8912

Pizza

Store is open now

Tequila’s Mexican Restaurant 2

1616 W Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 384-4037

Mexican

Store is open now

McDonalds

1300 W Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-8054

Burgers

Store is open now

Dannys Pool Room

119 E Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-9987

Store is open now

Gottzz’s

105 E Cherry St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-5715

American (Traditional), Bars

Store is open now

The Coffee Shop

1012 W Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-8225

Coffee & Tea

Store is open now

Ginny’s Place

1216 E Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-3099

Diners

Store is open now

Dairy Queen

910 W Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-2536

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Store is open now

Casey’s Carry-Out Pizza

1320 W Main St
Carmi, 62821
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(618) 382-4670

Pizza

Store is open now