Thornton Merc

4856 S Hwy 191
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
Best burgers, fries, onion rings, and milkshakes ever. All homemade and made in front of you in a greasy little dive. The building is super old and a bit rundown, but it's not dirty. This hole in the wall had been around for almost 75 years. My dad has been taking me in for burgers for my whole life. The people you see in there (if you see any at all) are farmers and older locals who grew up going there to buy a candy bar and a pop. Eating in there is like taking a bite out of history.

(208) 356-6649

American (Traditional)

Store is open now

Domino’s Pizza

155 W Main St
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
This was, by far, the best pizza experience of all time. Let me explain via metaphor. The person who answered the phone was like the hot, melty cheese on top of a fresh, glorious pizza, just out of the oven. I do not remember the young lad's name so we'll call him Cory, after the beloved protagonist of my favorite childhood show - Boy Meets World. Cory was warm and inviting, and made me feel very comfortable, the way mozzarella makes you feel like you have found that thing you've been missing since your college sweetheart walked out on you when you take that first bite. When I hung up with Cory, as he had assisted me in providing the carry-out and delivery specials of the evening, I began to place my order via the world wide web. The structure of the site was designed as would a beautiful, flaky pizza crust. While hard at first glance, the site was also gentle and soft as it guided me through placing my order. Lastly, when my pie was delivered by a young man, whose name I also don't remember so I will dub him Alaric, he was robust, lively, and hearty. Alaric was very excited and pleased to be delivering my beautiful dinner with origins of the Mediterranean. Alaric was as vivacious and inspired as the deep red sauce that lies on the crust of all great pizzas. To conclude, as individual experiences, Cory, the website, and Alaric would each have made my night, but as golden crusts are always better with rich sauce and gooey cheese, all experiences added up to baked, flaky perfection. Thank you Domino's Pizza of Rexburg, for doing it again and again.
I was very impressed! I ordered online like I normally do and when I asked for double or triple, they literally gave me double and triple! The delivery was quick and the pizza was fresh and hot! Wonderful job guys, I will definitely order here again!
Best pizza in town!! Every time we come to rexburg that's our pizza place to eat!! Great, great place!! Good prices and good quality!!

(208) 356-9555

Pizza, Chicken Wings, Sandwiches

Store is open now

Papa Murphy’s

64 N 2nd E
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
Papa Murphy's is my favorite pizza chain hands down. The money they save by having you make it at home makes for better quality ingredients and pizzas. Their menu is great. They have extremely unique pizzas. Everyone seems to love the Chicago style pizza, and its always been one of my favorites. Very meaty and hearty. Their deLite thin crust pizzas are what we usually get though. REALLY really good pizzas. The chicken bacon artichoke thin crust pizza will change your life.
My husband and I waited no longer than 10 minutes on a very busy night, and the guy at the end of the pizza building station told us we could pick out any 2-liter soda free of charge for the wait. We were very surprised because the wait wasn't that long. We love their pizza and we are always impressed with their customer service and products. Best pizza in town.
For a chain, Papa Murphy's is up there with quality inexpensive pizza. If you have never been, they make the pizza fresh in front of you and you take it home to bake it. It's a great way to have the freshest pizza possible without paying for delivery. Think about it, last time you ordered pizza it was probably at least 10 minutes before you were able to get to your door and eat it. They have all sorts of toppings and pre-selected combos. I really enjoy their stuffed pizza. It's similar to a calzone, and they aren't stingy with the meat/toppings. Also, for those trying to stay close to a diet, they have what's called deLite pizza. It's made on a very thin, light crust, and honestly, it's become my favorite way to have it. (I'm a thin crust man). Prices are reasonable, and if you were splitting with friends, it makes for a cheap evening. You can always go to Little Cesar's, but about 20 minutes after cooking, those pizzas lose a lot of freshness.

(208) 356-8900

Pizza

Store is open now

G’s Dairy Delights

600 Handcart Ln
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
Love me some G's dairy. This has Reeds Dairy ice cream which is the best ice cream I've ever had and I've been eating ice cream for at least 20 years... maybe even 21. They have several different types of ice cream. I recommend "Mom's Recipe". You have to go there to find out what that actually includes. They also sell other Dairy products i.e. cheese, milk etc. I wouldn't recommend buying milk or cheese here because it is way over priced. The staff is very friendly. The ice cream is a little pricy as well, but well worth the best ice cream you will ever taste.
Reed's Dairy ice cream was freaking oh so creamy delicious heaven! The service to me and my group was really good. The little blonde girl was friendly and very helpful. The other girl there didn't do much to help the customers. She just kind of did her own thing. Kinda lame for everyone else there. I recommend the Reed's Dairy raw milk and the ice cream. So what are you doing? Get off your duff and head on over there today!
Would rather get Ben n jerrys for the price. Also the fact that their dairy and shelf items are rotten and old more often than not is a red flag for me.

(208) 359-5443

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Store is open now

Kiwi Loco

Hemming Village,160 W 2nd S, Ste 106
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
I was visiting my sister and her husband and they took me here. The atmosphere was fun and playful and the place was clean for being so busy. There was about a million different flavors (strawberry lemonade, carmel green apple, and pistachio were some of the flavors I tried) and pretty much any topping you could think of (my favorite was a cinnamon sauce, Samoa Girl Scout cookies, and white mini chocolate chips). You pay by weight so you only have yourself to blame if it's "pricey." I found it to be reasonable. My sister thinks it's a great place to "date watch" with her husband. I would totally go back here again and again if I could. Until next time, Kiwi Loco!
They're ice cream is delicious. But, I didn't go by here for four months and my frequent buyer points all disappeared. Don't know what happened but I had thought I racked up enough for some free ice cream. All well, there's always Broulims.
Not really amazing enough to warrant a 5-star rating. I feel that it's marketing strategies have definitely been successful in generating a lot of hype around the place, leading it to be overrated by the students here. Its just your run of the mill frozen yogurt joint, and they are successful in offering good flavors, toppings, and a tasty treat.

(208) 356-5494

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Store is open now

Jimmy John’s

109 S. 2nd W.
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
Hands down the fastest food joint in Rexburg. This place will blow you away with their delivery service.
These guys always make me the most delicious sandwiches! I honestly order at least once a week. Go with the roast beef!! Delivery drivers are always fast and very friendly!
POSITIVES: the bread is delicious. The sandwich was ok overall. NEGATIVES: it was pricey for a simple sub. They charge a lot to add bacon and avocado spread, and didn't even put very much on. They took a while delivering it to my work, saying next time I should mention the name of the business, which in fact, I did before giving the address. Didn't they used to deliver for free? Kind of a bummer that they charge now, since that was the reason I had it delivered to my work.

(208) 656-0556

Sandwiches

Store is open now

Blister’s BBQ

15 N 12th W
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
I absolutely love blisters! My roommate are in almost a few times a week and we always see tons of regulars! The staff are fun and friendly and very quick! I would suggest getting the Cuban if you've never had one before! The meat is all fresh, sauce is unique and kickin' and the prices are way better than the hickory's. Not to mention the portion sizes are awesome!
I really wanted to try the brisket sandwich from here, because I was missing the juicy, delicious taste of brisket. Sadly, they shred their brisket and toss it in BBQ sauce. It was okay, but I was just expecting an actual slice of brisket. My husband got the Tri-Tip sandwich which came with cheese, and it was pretty good dipped in ranch. The sandwiches would have been so much better if they used higher quality buns. Their buns taste really cheap. The fries were really good though!
The meat was so sour that it was not edible. I can't believe this place has such a high review.

(208) 356-3965

Barbeque, Southern

Store is open now

Costa Vida - Fresh Mexican grill

485 N 2nd St,Ste 108
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
Good food with strong taste and fresh ingredients which does drive some higher cost.
Unfortunately, they changed the raspberry chicken recipe, so they lost a star in my book. The other star is because they're not always consistent. Sometimes the rice & beans are still hard. Or they give crap portions. Other than that though they are pretty decent.
Decent. You can get a solid meal if you don't mind spending $$ a moderate price for what is economy food. It felt cold and corporate, and had pop music blasting outside. Didn't really enjoy my meal. Eat and run.

(208) 356-7733

Mexican

Store is open now

Big Jud’s

411 W 7800 S
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
Its a cool place, the food is a bit greasy but what do you expect its a hamburger joint, its kind of a hole in the wall place, we were trying to find it for the first time and we drove right by it. Maybe I'm biased but I like small business that are doing a good service. I recommend if your in rexburg to stop by and try it. Get the 2 pound burger I
Super fun place to go with a group of buddies or on a date. The big jud burger is just something everyone has to get at least once, maybe twice. The food was pretty good. I think my ice-cream they used for my shake was a little freezer burnt though. Good burgers but my experience with their shakes was not so great.
Best burger place in Rexburg!! Good food friendly staff when it gets busy it gets a little crowded and noisey but over all good place. Wish it wasn't so far outside of town would go there a lot more often then what I do. Prices are good for what you get.

(208) 359-2833

Burgers, American (Traditional)

Store is open now

The Cocoa Bean Cupcake Cafe

20 College Ave
Rexburg, 83440
Reviews:
It's reallllyyyy sugar-y.
So far so good. All I had was a grasshopper cake pop (I'm a lightweight) but it was awesome! Looking forward to going back and trying more! My husband got a red velvet shake (that's their red velvet cake mixed into reed's dairy ice cream and blended up into a milkshake) and loved it.
My favorite is the Ultimate Brownie, but I honestly haven't had a bad one. Their ice cream is also super yummy.

(208) 359-9493

Desserts

Store is open now