Search Your Favourite Restaurants.

Name: Paia Fish Market
Address: 100 Baldwin Ave,Ste A, Paia, HI, 96779
Telephone: (808) 579-8030
Price range: Under $11
Rating: 4.12

Paia Fish Market

100 Baldwin Ave,Ste A, Paia, HI, 96779

(808) 579-8030
Store is closed

Paia Fish Market Menu

Burgers

Kid?s Burger 110g

Kid?s Cheeseburger 120g

Bacon Cheddar Burger 125g

Bacon Double Cheeseburger 250g

Big Buford® 230g

Bacon Buford® 255g

Bacon Swiss Buford® 250g

1/4 LB. Champ® 205g

1/4 LB. Champ® with Cheese 225g

1/4 LB. Bacon Cheese Champ® 235g

1/2 LB. Double Champ® 280g

1/2 LB. Double Champ® with Cheese 300g

Checkerburger® 170g

Checkerburger® with Cheese 179g

Cheese Double Cheese 190g

Chili Cheeseburger 135g

Double Chili Cheeseburger 180g

Double Decker 215g

Rallyburger® 170g

Rallyburger® with Cheese 179g

Smokehouse Buford® 265g

Triple Cheeseburger 250g

Healthy Meal suggestions for

Burgers

Kid?s Burger 110g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 28, Sodium (s): 570, Saturated Fat (ms) : 6, Calories: 280, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

Kid?s Cheeseburger 120g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 29, Sodium (s): 730, Saturated Fat (ms) : 8, Calories: 320, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

Bacon Cheddar Burger 125g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 29, Sodium (s): 730, Saturated Fat (ms) : 9, Calories: 370, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

Bacon Double Cheeseburger 250g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 32, Sodium (s): 1340, Saturated Fat (ms) : 20, Calories: 650, Sugar (ms): 6 ]

Big Buford® 230g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 31, Sodium (s): 1090, Saturated Fat (ms) : 18, Calories: 570, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Bacon Buford® 255g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 31, Sodium (s): 1510, Saturated Fat (ms) : 21, Calories: 680, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Bacon Swiss Buford® 250g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 28, Sodium (s): 1310, Saturated Fat (ms) : 21, Calories: 660, Sugar (ms): 4 ]

1/4 LB. Champ® 205g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 32, Sodium (s): 810, Saturated Fat (ms) : 12, Calories: 490, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

1/4 LB. Champ® with Cheese 225g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 33, Sodium (s): 930, Saturated Fat (ms) : 18, Calories: 580, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

1/4 LB. Bacon Cheese Champ® 235g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 35, Sodium (s): 1230, Saturated Fat (ms) : 18, Calories: 630, Sugar (ms): 4 ]

1/2 LB. Double Champ® 280g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 30, Sodium (s): 1030, Saturated Fat (ms) : 25, Calories: 740, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

1/2 LB. Double Champ® with Cheese 300g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 34, Sodium (s): 1360, Saturated Fat (ms) : 28, Calories: 790, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

Checkerburger® 170g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 32, Sodium (s): 680, Saturated Fat (ms) : 8, Calories: 390, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Checkerburger® with Cheese 179g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 33, Sodium (s): 810, Saturated Fat (ms) : 12, Calories: 420, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Cheese Double Cheese 190g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 31, Sodium (s): 1140, Saturated Fat (ms) : 17, Calories: 510, Sugar (ms): 4 ]

Chili Cheeseburger 135g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 30, Sodium (s): 620, Saturated Fat (ms) : 8, Calories: 320, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

Double Chili Cheeseburger 180g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 30, Sodium (s): 760, Saturated Fat (ms) : 14, Calories: 460, Sugar (ms): 3 ]

Double Decker 215g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 31, Sodium (s): 720, Saturated Fat (ms) : 13, Calories: 480, Sugar (ms): 4 ]

Rallyburger® 170g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 32, Sodium (s): 680, Saturated Fat (ms) : 8, Calories: 390, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Rallyburger® with Cheese 179g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 33, Sodium (s): 810, Saturated Fat (ms) : 12, Calories: 420, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Triple Cheeseburger 250g [ Carbohydrates (ms): 33, Sodium (s): 1450, Saturated Fat (ms) : 23, Calories: 690, Sugar (ms): 5 ]

Healthy Meal suggestions for CheckersRally

Burgers

Smokehouse Buford® 265g [ Sodium (s): 1610, Calories: 650, Sugar (ms): 15 ]

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant cholesterol menu details.

Write An Anonymous Review

Mimi N.

Rating based on experience/service not food: I'm sure this place is good...was very excited to try it... Came at 11, told "5-10 mins we will open wer'e running late".. Ok no prob (it's hawaiian time right?), our flight isn't until 3 anyways... 11:10 came back, "oh 5 more mins" ok no prob, still excited for food! 11:20 came back walked in w menu ready to order, "oh uh another 15 mins"... Hmmmm... Ok so I called earlier at 10:30 to check if you are open(not knowing they open at 11)... me - "hi are you open today?" someone answers - "oh ya come by were open!" ok cool... Not too mention we came 2 days earlier and they were closed for remodel. Nonetheless we ate at Mexican place next door cuz we didn't have another 30 mins to spare after waiting 30 mins past opening time. Sad guess it wasn't meant to be... Maybe they should keep their front door closed n not answer the phone next time when they're not ready to open...
(1)
Corey S.

So good I went there thrice in one week! You can get a plate of ahi sashimi for $15, as fresh and good as it gets! This is much cheaper than I've ever seen such a meal elsewhere. Mahi Mahi fish and chips was also excellent. Meat was perfect. Given the chance to go back to Maui, this will be my first stop for food!
(5)
Sara F.

This is a real casual place for a quick bit before heading to the beach & it's really delicious! Just tried it once on a recent trip & I couldn't get over how fresh & delicious the fish burger was! I had the ono burger, it was grilled perfectly & covered lightly with tarter, cheese & tomato. It was SO delicious! The side of slaw was great too, very fresh. I wish I was there now!
(5)
Keith K.

Best fish tacos ever! If you're staying in Kaanapali it's still worth the drive. Place can get very busy with very limited seating - so if you're going for lunch avoid the 12-1 hour.
(5)
Alexandra A.

The fish (mahi mahi) & chips are good. The bread-ing is light so the dish isn't heavy. The portions are a pretty decent size so you won't leave hungry. The only issue is the cafeteria like seating - it's a little hard for larger groups.
(3)
Monkiboi B.

Get the Ono or Mahi Burger and some fresh maui onion rings. Done. Fish is spot on here. I always say I am gonna try the fish tacos, but the Ono burger is just so damned good.
(4)
Sally T.

After eating at over-priced toursity places, the boyfriend and i decided to drive somewhere and find a more "local" place and ended up here and boy aren't we glad we did!!! the food was fresh and delish and not dressed up at all. call me nuts but when i am hungry, just give me the food without the flowers and plating fru-frus. for lunch my boyfriend had their special; the obama burger. it was a piece of grilled ono with avacado and wasabi dressing...he loved it so much he wanted 2nds but decided he shouldn't over stuff himself. i ordered the fish taco meal and it wasn't because i was hungry, i really did think it was delish, so i inhaled it. let's just say we went back for dinner after coming back from Haleakala and my fish and chips and his mahi burger was just as delish.
(5)
Mike V.

holy crap was this place good. I had the Obama buger (huge Mahi Mahi burger with a wasabi mayo that was eye-watering-ly good). The fish platters are also really insane. I loved the Ono. This place is simple, delicious, huge portions of fish cooked perfectly. Not to be missed.
(5)
Lulu L.

5 stars for the ono burger!!! drove from Wailia to Paia on a recommendation from a friend, specifically to try the ono burger, it was really great, juicy, packed with flavor, didnt even need fries to satisfy me! worth the trip! try it with the Lion hot sauce on the table, for me , it went from really great to amazing!
(5)
Billy V.

Great find, thanks to Yelp! Cool little place, nothing fancy but good food at good prices! Share a big table with other diners & bus your own dishes when you're done...would eat here again.
(4)
Kenn P.

Fish Tacos! Yes Fish Tacos are very good, loved them and would have loved them even more if I had Guacamole to put on them. However, they were delicious and I would go back again and again until I tried everything on their menu...twice!
(4)
Amar P.

Honestly, this was one of my favorite meals of my trip in Hawaii. I dragged my family here after wanting fish and seeing that we were near this place that had good Yelp reviews AND was recommended in our guide book. They have all different kinds of fish and many different ways of cooking them, and you can get whatever. The standard fishes are mahi mahi and ono (wahoo), but they also have a list of currently fresh fish with descriptions of the texture and flavor of each, that you can choose to substitute into any of the entrees, which is great. For my meal I picked the opah (moonfish - this was off the fresh fish list) cajun burger with fries. Man, it was so good. Super tender, cajun spices were right on, tartar sauce in just the right amount. I was super happy. And the fries were crisp and tasty, and they had local beers as well, of which I tried the Maui coconut porter... not bad. My brother had the ono burger, which I tried some of, but I liked the moonfish way better than the wahoo... way more tender. I bet the mahi mahi would be pretty good as well. To be honest, I'd really like to be able to try one of the fried entrees or the seafood pasta, but alas... oh, and someone else's tacos looked really good too. But yeah, go here. For sure. Super yum. A++.
(5)
Jean H.

SEAFOOD PASTA = SOOOOO GOOD. (~$17) During a recent trip to Maui with friends, my boyfriend and his family had gone to Paia Fish Market, and he brought back some leftover seafood pasta which he thought I might like to try b/c I love my scallops. I was pretty full that night from Zippy's, so I saved it for the next day's lunch. I was a little skeptical because leftover+reheated seafood does NOT appeal to me. But, once we threw it in the microwave, OH MY GOD.. it smelled sooooo good (and tasted even better). All of our friends were jealous as I quickly scarfed down the pasta. Our friends ended up making the drive to Paia for the seafood pasta. 5/6 of them ordered the seafood pasta, the last 1 got plate of ginormous calamari. Keep in mind this was mere days after swearing up and down they'd never go near the road to Hana ever again. As for my boyfriend and I, we also made a large detour to Paia on our way to the airport to get one last seafood pasta meal. It was definitely as droolworthy as the first time around. Creamy sauce (but not too heavy), scallops, clams, capers, shrimp, oodles and oodles of noodles :) Delicious!
(5)
David C.

Excellent food! My favorite fish place on maui. Great fish plates and sandwiches. Love the town of Paia also. Small but charming. The walls and tables are decorated with gyutaku (japanese fish prints) done by the owner's husband.
(4)
LL A.

Outstanding fish tacos!!!!
(5)
Michael K.

This place is a local institution, offering an extensive menu of fresh-caught fish prepared four different ways, plus shellfish, chicken, burgers, pasta, and salads. You cannot go wrong here if you like seafood. A popular choice here is a "fish burger", a generous ahi tuna fillet chargrilled, and topped with homemade coleslaw, tomato, cheese, and tartar sauce on a bun ($8.50). Service is casual, done by placing your order at the self-service counter and taking a seat at one of the communal picnic tables inside until your name is called a few minutes later. The only thing seriously wrong with this place is that the line of customers is usually out the door at peak meal times, and you can't get in!
(4)
Ed U.

As the last point of commercial note on the tourist-infested road to Hana, Pa'ia is a funky little hamlet with its share of motel-type art galleries, hemp shops, and eateries. Considering that there is no place to eat on the way or even in Hana over fifty miles away, by all means, stop at the Pa'ia Fish Market right at the central intersection of the Hana Highway and Baldwin. It's a wooden, tavern-looking place with loads of tables and benches, but it is definitely crowded. No mystery as the fish is really fresh tasting. My friend ordered the Fish Tacos with home fries and dirty rice, and the fish tasted like it was cooked right after it was caught. It seems steep at $12 but the portion is pretty hefty. I had the $10.95 Calamari and Chips, and the squid pieces were nice and tender and lightly breaded and fried. You can get free refills on your soda, though be careful...it's a long road to Hana and maybe one pit stop available for a restroom. FOOD - 4 stars...fresh from the sea AMBIENCE - 2.5 stars...like a big woodsy bar with lots of people elbowing you for the malt vinegar and tartar sauce...if you see six inches open on a bench, grab it SERVICE - 3 stars...made fresh to order so sit a spell when there's a crowd TOTAL - 4 stars...last stop before Hana...stop if you know what's good for ya
(4)
michelle m.

I ordered Seafood pasta (too soggy), fish plate and mahi fish and chips (overcooked). Staff unfriendly. Wouldn't come back.
(1)
Mike L.

Visited the Paia Fish Market on my way to the airport. The place was packed at 6:30 PM. I was with my toddlers and this place is definitely not young children since seating is picnic style. I ordered the Seafood Pasta and it was OK, but nothing special. The dish was very creamy and it had a lot of seafood. I also ordered the onion rings and I must say, sweet Maui onions make the best onion rings.
(3)
Steve N.

We stopped in here on a recommendation of a co-worker. I grew up around So CA fish tacos so I was expecting to be disappointed since I rarely find what I consider to be true fish tacos. I saw they put cheese on their fish tacos and was ready to take a star away from there based on that, until I took my first bite. First, the tacos are huge and tasty, and so fresh. Counter service was friendly, and the family style seating made for some extra conversation with the folks next to us. They had the fish and chips and showed us a cross section - all fish with a thin, crisp coating. Very generous portions of fish. One fish and chip plate would be enough for two people, in my opinion. It was a busy Saturday for lunch, but we got in, got an order in, found a table, and were delighted. We're going back again here for sure. We've been disappointed by the other fish tacos we've had in Maui so far, except for here. This place is a keeper.
(4)
Nicholas S.

Had a layover on Maui for 3 hours, and specifically rented a car just to have dinner here. I lived on Maui for awhile and a Ono fish burger after surfing all day is my kind of heaven. Delicious fish, my mouth is watering just writing about it. Place gets busy and is small. Tables are shared so be nice and bus your dishes. Aloha
(5)
Cooking B.

I am a chef, and I have eaten all over the world. THIS place by far makes the MOST delicious piece of Mahi Mahi that I have ever tasted. You get a huge piece of fish that is not only long but thick. You can not buy a piece of fish this size anywhere on the island for the price they charge for an entire salad with the fish included. The absolute moistest piece of fish I have ever had. If you want a delicious meal, go there. I am salivating thinking of my meal and can not wait to go back again someday. This place needs more notoriety, but then it would just be too touristy, already the wait is 20 mins for lunch alone. GREAT JOB
(5)
Dave L.

This was the last meal we were to enjoy on Maui last week and I thought it was THE BEST! I love dives, and this was a clean and classy one. People complain about the family seating and picnic style tables,,,,,, get a life! It's supposed to be fun and lively, it works! If you want something fancy,,,,,,,,,,,,, go someplace fancy,,,,,,, sheesh! Wifeypie had the Fish and Chips, the kidlet had a Veggie Quesadilla with Cajun Rice and i had the Obama Burger (blackened Ono) with Red Skinned Potatoes. The wife's fish and chips were crispy and delish. Vegegirl's Quesadilla was just what the doctor ordered and my sammich was utterly fantastic! Blackened and perfectly charred yet raw on the inside, on a large soft bun atop of coleslaw and dressed with a wasabi butter. It was the best fish sandwich I have ever had,,,,,,,,,,, EVER! It also was beyond generous. The red skinned potatoes were also A+++. The person taking our order was swift, knowledgeable and extremely pleasant. The prices,,,,,, I wish they had places in L.A. that could compare, there aren't! And for Hawaii, the prices were ridiculously cheap! Granted we did not try close to everything they had to offer but hands down, what we got was stellar. Thank you Paia Fish Market! Mahalo! Dave
(5)
Voice Of The People S.

YUM!!!!!!!!! got 2 fish tacos which turned out to be a ton of food. huge delicious fish tacos on top of a bed of coleslaw with your choice of sides. i got french fries but in retrospect (and next time) should have tried half potatoes half fries or maybe rice because those potatoes looked so good too. we also got some calamari which was great. its very loud here and picnic bench style eating which is kinda fun but if you're looking for something more intimate this is not the place.
(5)
Robin R.

Had lunch in the Paia location and really enjoyed it. What a busy place. So happy to hear they are opening later this year in historic Lahaina across from the Banyan Tree.
(5)
Lan L.

Came here for lunch after ziplining at North Shore. This is on the list of a lot of tourist magazines and other things that list off places to visit in Maui. It was my 3rd time to Maui and my first visit to Paia. It's not as big as I thought and I was hoping for poke of some kind but I guess I didn't look ahead. We got the fish platters. I ordered the daily platter with salmon and bf got the ono platter. We shared the coconut shrimp. The platter portions were huge. It took an effort to finish. My salmon platter seemed to be overly buttered. I wish I could say the butteryness was from the salmon but it was actual butter. The coconut shrimp was ok. Seemed like it was from one of those defrosted packages. I would pass on it. Overall, seems more like a tourist trap and not a good local spot to have a nice lunch.
(3)
Isaac H.

We dined here for lunch on our recent trip to maui after several recommendation and where not disappointed! The fish plate lunch was well flavored, delicious! My mahi burger was a little on the bland side and left me wishing I had ordered the fish plate instead but was not bad by any means. The fries where great and cole slaw was good. Price was very reasonable for Maui and the fish was fresh and juicy. It got busy very quickly so plan ahead if you want to eat here!
(4)
Alfred Y.

There are two locations, one in Paia, and one in Kihei. On a busy Saturday afternoon you'll have to share a table with others. Ordered the Ono burger with a side of fries, but both were at best mediocre. I'd like to think coming here would be a transformational experience, but the burger was really simple and the fries stale. It tasted like was somebody starting out buying lower quality ingredients in bulk, putting together the least amount of ingredients, and then hastedly adding Ono. The fries has to be ordered separately, but came in sparingly. If I ever come back, I'll have to try to redeem this first visit.
(3)
Chris L.

This place gets popular on the weekends. We arrived famished from our road back from Hana. This place seems like the perfect spot to grab some fish for dinner. Located in the heart of Paia it's easily walkable from the parking lot. Parking is very difficult to find. We had to walk about a block and a half from the parking lot to get here. Be sure to get a table or a spot on the many picnic style tables before you order. If you came with someone else make sure to spot a table otherwise, you'll have to walk back and eat in the car like we did! The Mahi fish and chips were delicious but not the best fish for fish and chips. My wife and i have grown accustomed to a softer and less firm fish. The batter was nice and crunchy and held up well. Not so well for dunking. The 4-5 sticks were cut into 3 inch thick rectangular squares. I ordered the fish plate. The fish plate is your choice of fish from the list of the catch of the day. It's a large portion for the 23 / 24 bucks that it costs. The whiteboard usually has mahi mahi, opa, or ono on the list as they're common fishes that they fish. I picked the ono cooked cajun style. The entree comes with a side: The ono was lightly seasoned and soft. Be sure to stop by when one is in Kihei.
(4)
Jay T.

Although this restaurant is pretty busy, food is fairly fast. It's also open seating and although tables are limited, most customers are not there to "hang out" and chitchat which makes finding a table easy. They are popular seafood and fish tacos were highly recommended; although I've had better, my other half really liked it. Their food are also pricey, a small fish taco costs 12.99 and sides are from 3.50-4 bucks. There is no bathroom inside the restaurant but there is are public restrooms available. Parking is limited in this are, there is an open lot next to the shell station BUT PLEASE PLEASE do not leave your belongings in the car; we were walking back to our car and this suspicious (homeless) man was looking inside cars with something to bust the car door handles. Break-ins are very common in Maui especially in tourists hot spots; rental cars are very easy to distinguish due to the blue sticker located on the driver side.
(3)
Beachy B.

This place is pretty average. Nothing here really "wowed" me. It's lunch bench style where you order at the front and get the food yourself. The quality is okay, but again, nothing that impressed me. I had the chicken salad. The people I came with had the fish sandwich, fish and chips, fish pasta, and the red snapper plate. I got pictures of just a few items. I'll probably skip this spot the next time I visit.
(3)
Zhailah G.

The fish tacos are amazing!!!! Served on a bed of coleslaw with chips (French fries) which were addicting. I had a cheese quesadilla which was yummy too.
(5)
Linda X.

Solid restaurant in Paia! You order at the counter and pick up your food when they call your number. There was a line when we went for dinner on a Friday night but it went by quickly. You can sit down at one of the many benches inside. Took about 20 minutes total before we got our food. Ordered the fish and chips ($15 for dinner) and Ono burger ($10). For the fish and chips, I was expecting the fish to be really fried/heavy but it was actually more like breaded which I really liked. The tartar sauce was so tasty! The Ono burger was great also. Definitely recommend this place if you are in Paia!
(4)
Michele G.

OMG... Maui's hidden secret! The best Seafood here. This is the first restaurant in Maui that I was 100% pleased. Great food, taste fresh, seasoned perfectly, quick service, friendly staff, clean restaurant, reasonable prices. This is a place that everyone must try. I came with a party of 7.. The Ono burger was so delicious. So this is how it works. You buy your food at the counter.. find a.seating area.. then listen for your number.. it took us 4 minutes to get our food from the time it was ordered. Everyone was pleased! No complaints.. one word- total perfection. P.s sorry yelp folks for not posting a picture. . Food was too delicious lol.. I almost swallowed it whole..
(5)
Niclas C.

Visiting the Maui north side without eating at Paia Fish market, is like going to Maui without snorkeling. Their Ono burger is famous, but ask for one less hard grilled, as ono's tend to be a bit dry. Or, ask for a mahi or ahi burger instead, medium rare or medium. Then you'll be able to enjoy the fish to its fullest. The place is always crowded, but turnover is quick so you'll be able to get a seat in time you get the food. The place tends to be a bit hot and hasn't got the best scenery, placed at a corner of the main intersection in Paia. But you're here for the food, right? You can get a better mahi-burger at Ma'alaea General Store, but this one is nearly as good.
(3)
Julianna M.

Great food! Thanks to Yelp, we were led to this place while wandering Paia. We ordered the Ono fish burger and the fish tacos. These were generous helpings and totally worth it. Definitely worth a stop!
(4)
TianChee S.

This place serves fresh fish and it's relatively close by the airport if you are looking for a nearby, quick, but delicious meal! Ordered the fried calamari as my appetizer and it was pretty good. No complaints with it and would order it again if I'm here. My main meal was the Opah fish plate which was really good. Very fresh and perfectly cooked. Overcooking fish is a huge turnoff and they thankfully cooked it perfectly. My sides were rice and mashed potatoes. It was really hearty and filling. Wouldn't mind ordering it again.
(4)
Janelle F.

Seared sashimi was very good. You should split up and have someone order and the other stalk people for their seats. Just a tip.
(4)
Nory B.

Love the community style seating--very European! Love that you order and pay at the counter and then go get your own food--no slow service! Good fish sandwich, great blackened ahi sashimi, crunchy hot French fries. Definitely will be back!
(4)
Linda N.

This is the #1 spot to go if you're strolling around Paia or coming out from the Haleakala bike ride (like myself). We got there exactly at 1050am, sat ourselves down, and waited until 11am to order from the cashier. My bf and I ordered fried calamari, fried fish plate, and one fish taco a la carte. This came out to $36. O_o I will admit the fish is really fresh here. I really enjoyed the calamari.. It was the perfect batter to squid ratio and seasoned so tasty. The tartar sauce starts to smell vinegar-y towards the end of your meal. The one fish taco I ordered was loaded with greens, chopped tomatoes, and fish. It was a good $5 well spent. As pricey as it is, I might go back to try their seafood pasta. It looked Damn good.
(5)
Sasha R.

Tourists will often tell you there is no good food on Maui.....they just don't know where to go, ask the locals! This great spot we found on recommendation. Located on the main street of Paia amongst a bunch of local shops, restaurants and gelateries, the restaurant is small with wooden tables, giving it an authentic beachy feeling. The have a white board near the register listing the fresh fish they are offering for the day. After you decide what type of fish to enjoy, you choose how you want it prepared. They offer Cajun style, sauteed in butter, wine and garlic, grilled, etc. You can also get fish tacos, fish and chips, fish burgers, etc. The fish is quality and fresh, you can absolutely taste it. The fries aren't the best, the red potatoes are better. I highly recommend Mahi Mahi fish and chips - seasoned to perfection, this was the best order of fish and chips I have ever tried. If you want great seafood for a reasonable price, this is the place!
(4)
Kirsten C.

My son loved the chicken quesadilla. Calamari & chips barely mediocre and the fish tacos just ok. Insane amount of fries. Fun environment. Overpriced.
(3)
Adam T.

A must visit if in the area. We are talking about some serious portions here. I recommend forgoing the side dishes of rice, beans, etc. They are just filler that you won't be needing. The tacos are huge and more than enough to have a fulfilling lunch. If you want to stretch your money you could easily split a plate with rice and beans or take half of that bad boy to-go. Stay away from the onion rings. Nothing special and way too much batter. Go for the catch of the day.
(4)
Josh G.

We just happened to be in the area and hungry and tried this place out. ...the best fresh fish and potatoes. Can't wait to come back here. Highly recommend eating here
(5)
Angel W.

This place was packed and I can see why! They had shared seating and it was full but turned over quickly. The fish tacos were great! We also shared the Ono burger which was amazing! My son got the fish and chips and says they were good, but not the best he's ever had. My husband got the fish tacos and says that it was better than the fish tacos at Coconut's. Daughter and other son and I think Coconut's were the best. But these were more traditional style. And they were great! We will definitely go back. The city of Paia is adorable and I wish we had more time there. (Note, they add a service charge of 15% for parties of 6 or more, even though it is a "walk up to the counter and pay, then they call your number and you pick up your food" establishment. She asked if it was ok if she added this charge.)
(5)
Laura I.

We stopped by Paia fish market on our way to the airport. My husband and I both ordered fish tacos, 1 blackened and 1 cajun. Having tried both, I would recommend cajun all the way.The blackened was bland. Looking around it looks like we missed out by not ordering the fish burger. I think it's what they are known for and it looked amazing on our neighbors plate! They don't offer anything raw, so don't come looking for a poke bowl like I did :). There is also a location in Kihei (near Wailea) if that is more convenient for your trip.
(3)
William H.

Never had a bad meal there. Everything exceptional. Portions are big, sometimes too big (like the pasta), and everything very fresh and always grilled to perfection
(5)
Jonathan B.

Last stop in Maui before heading home. Another recommendation from a friend. Parking is a bit difficult to find so be prepared to look. We ended up parking in a paid lot...$1 for the first 30 minutes. It was just a few minute walk to the restaurant. The place is pretty cool...you walk up to order the food and they call your number. There are tables but if busy I can see where it would be hard to find one. Their menu is pretty simple...staple local Hawaiian food. Fish is fresh every day! I tried their dinner plate...blackened Mahi. You can pick from a variety of fish and cook it in a few ways. Definitely the best fish I had while in Maui. Cooked perfectly and the potatoes/rice were a perfect mix. If you are flying out or into Maui make sure you stop and try the food at Paia Fish Market. You won't be disappointed!
(5)
Leslie G.

They do have a couple of options for vegetarians. I was star.ving, and went with a little something called the vegetarian quesadilla or something like that. It had cheese, beans, rice, lettuce, pico de gallo all inside. It was more like a weird burrito than a quesadilla. I didn't really like it. I was so starving that when it first came, I was like hell yes this thing is gigantic!!! But, it's one of those things that after you aren't starving anymore and you think back on it, you're like - gross. A better vegetarian option, in my humble opinion, would be just bean tacos. Their tacos looked great, swap the fish out for some beans, and you're stoked. Onion rings were nothing special. I saw some reviews complaining about snooty service, but the service we had was friendly and great. No complaints there. Expect to spend $10-15/person, not including drinks.
(3)
Jade R.

Ok, so we have to give Paia Fish market 5 stars because their fish is really fresh and their service is outstanding. It's a friendly, welcoming ambiance, just bustling with activity and fish lovers camaraderie. It's almost like you cannot walk past without going in. Great music! The super cook staff makes every order personal, even though they are working at light speed. Eating with others at long tables is fun. It's a great place for people watching, too, as the eclectic crowd hangs in Paia and especially this restaurant. We just love this place!
(5)
Hue O.

There is nothing more delicious then fresh grilled ahi served with local greens!
(4)
Lynette D.

Loved every bite. Got there just ahead of the crowd, which was lucky because there isn't much seating. Shared a table with a local and got to hear some good stories. Delicious Maui fish and chips. Hubby said fish tacos were good but not great. The taco plate was messy and they were kind of hard to eat. Didn't help that we are on the way back from Hana and were ready for a nap. However, we would go again!
(4)
Kristin W.

My BFF and I flew to Maui from Kaua'i for a couple of hours to hang out. Someone in a nearby shop suggested we eat at Paia Fish Market for lunch and raved about the slaw. So my BFF and I arrive and are overwhelmed by the appearance of the menu and almost walked out. It was the busiest, wordiest menu in life and it was either walk out or just choose the fish and chips, so I got the fish and chips and he got the shrimp and chips. I would have liked to eat something other than mahi mahi, but it happened. Aside from the menu the food was okay. Fish (mahi) seemed fresh and tender. Fries okay. The slaw I didn't like, sadly, because apparently it was supposed to be to die for. The flavor was good, but I like slaw that's chopped up fine and these were huge chunks of cabbage. Service was so-so. No one really greeted us when we walked up to the ordering counter. They just kind of stared at us staring at the menu. The market itself is not that big and it was super busy, but seating opens up fairly quickly, so don't let that deter you. It is 100% a tourist spot and prices are as such. For two lunches and drinks I paid almost $40, so just be aware of the prices.
(3)
Str8sixfan ..

Awesome seafood at a reasonable price. They move you fast like a Chipotle, meaning you stand in line thinking where am I going to sit? But by the time you order and get your food something frees up. Fantastic proportions, can't go wrong here!
(4)
Carol K.

Always busy, always fresh, always delicious. Can't say I have explored the menu much because I am stuck on the fish burger. That huge slab of fresh _____ is on a bun with all the trims. Said trims enhance the fish beautifully. I've tried the Mahi mahi, ono and opa. All are expertly prepared. Keep me away from the onion rings, too too good.
(4)
Elfira d.

Had the mahi blacken Cajun style lunch plate, large portion and delicious. The rice taste bland to me. The seating arrangement is cafeteria style. The place itself was small so it was a bit over crowded when we went there. Over all I think the place was ok, just average. A bit expensive for a lunch plate.
(3)
Emily R.

On the hunt for the best lunch options we attempted a food crawl to try as many places as we could. My fella and I arrived here just before the lunch rush and we ordered the Ono burger to share. The fish was fresh and well-cooked and we both enjoyed it quite a bit. I'd likely ask for the burger without cheese next time, but it's a solid choice. We were tempted to order another meal but the portions were generous and decided to save our next food adventure. Greet little spot in Paia.
(4)
Francesca C.

This place is wayyyyyy overrated. Born and raised in Hawaii so I know what I'm talking about here. Fish was good, but nothing I can't make at home. Place is insanely packed and very dirty. So busy and understaffed that they have no time to clean the place! Nothing special at all. Also prices are quite high for what you get IMO
(2)
Julie D.

One of my favorite places to eat at when I come to Maui!! Always fresh and delicious!!
(5)
Kirk S.

The Paia Fish Market is a fine lunch spot, but don't expect to be blown away. The Paia Fish Market is a small lunch-ish place in Paia with communal tables. It's perpetually crowded, so be prepared to fight your way through a crowd for food. This is unquestionably the kinda place you go after wandering around Maui, so there isn't a dress code to speak of. The food here is good, but not nearly as mind-blowing as some might imply. The fish itself is of superb quality, as might be expected, and their Cajun preparation of the fish is tasty and healthy. Unfortunately, their fries and fish burger were both a bit run-of-the-mill, though I'm honestly not a huge fan of either. Their Cajun rice, like the fish, was a much better choice of a side. I'd say this place is a solid choice for lunch, but not much beyond that.
(4)
Loren B.

This place is well worth checking out if you like seafood at all. I had the best fish and chips I think i've ever had here. The seafood pasta was pretty good as well, its spendy but they don't skimp on big meaty chunks of fish. The place was packed to the gills both times we went but the shared tables turn around quickly so its not a big deal.
(5)
Ting L.

First time we drove by on a Friday night, the line was super long out the door and we also couldn't find parking. Second time we came by earlier for lunch right when they opened. Even then, it was really hard to find parking. We had to wait around in the municipal lot for someone to leave. I'd say overall it's a bit tough to find parking in Paia. We got the ono burger, grilled mahi mahi with fries and sashimi. Overall the fish is fresh, but it's not worth the hype or the price. A solid lunch spot, but I don't think I'd be waiting in line to eat here. The ono burger was interesting since I've never had ono before, but personally think it's a bit bland. The mahi mahi was fresh and tasty. The sashimi was really fresh, but I would recommend against ordering it here. They didn't cut against the grain of the fish and the sashimi ended up very chewy in texture instead of buttery and soft.
(3)
Keith L.

This was our second time here. Basic seafood prepared to perfection! I recommend the Ono Burger, fish tacos and onion rings. If you do no mind ordering at the counter and community style seating than this is a must stop. Only 15 mins from the airport.
(4)
Sarah W.

A friend who used to live in Maui recommended this place for our trip here in May, so we decided to try it since we were in the area. We liked the setup, the atmosphere was very casual, and the wait to order and get food wasn't long at all. Customers were in and out pretty quickly. This is the perfect place to get a good meal if you want to allocate more time for sightseeing and just want some fresh seafood quick. We tried the fish taco and fish and chips, both were fresh and delicious. It was a bit pricey for a casual food place, but for the good quality of seafood it was worth it.
(4)
David D.

My wife and I were killing time in Paia before heading back to airport and decided on the Fish Market for dinner. It was outstanding. I had the blackened mahi burger and Cajun rice. Wife had a mahi fish quesadilla which I thought was weird at first but it was freaking delicious. Next time we visit we are making a full day in Paia and maybe eat here twice!
(5)
Logie Z.

I'm an island girl and I know good fresh fish. That, they have. You can also tell when the fish of the day changes daily. Check. Your choice of grilled, battered or cajun was cooked to order and very nicely executed. What I didn't like was the parbroiled cajun rice. I know it's easy to make from a box, but at least offer steamed white or brown rice, unless you no kea about locals. Coleslaw could have a little more flavor other than mayonaisse...please! The french fries were a from a frozen source, it got pretty soggy fast! My little cutie pie liked the Seafood Chowder. For $5 it came in a good sized bowl, not a cup. The counter girl had an obvious sign on her forehead that read "I'd rather be surfing". At least put on a fake smile for sizeable tips so you can work less and surf more. All in all, it was just okay. Their fresh fish is so good, I just wish the side dishes complemented it better.
(3)
Laurel S.

Delicious, laid back, huge portions, pricey though...
(5)
Jessica S.

Best fish tacos ever. Seriously... they're amazing. Also, their coleslaw is pretty great, as well. And I can't stand coleslaw. Basically this place can do no wrong.
(5)
Tanya L.

If this is not your first stop in Maui for food I hope it's number two! This place has great food no doubt about it. Do not order the Mahi because that's what everyone else orders. Order tuna to be seared on the grill and WATCH them do it. Trust me.... all tourist get the Mahi. get what the locals eat. They have Mexican coke bottle and there is plenty of picnic style seating. I ordered the burger and although I'm not a fan for tarter sauce or slaw or whatever it is they have on it, but I wanted to try it as is. It was great. The best times to hit this spot are before lunch rush and my favorite time, between 3 and 5. They are open til around 9:30 and locals told me it's pretty slow around closing time. The lines move quickly. We also ordered the seafood pasta which was great as well. All in all, this is THE place for fish in paia.
(5)
Sheila B.

Awesome.fresh.fish , not fancy, long line but so worth it. Three adults and a toddler dinner = $50.. The line is long, but the people behind the counter are making some delicious fish tacos, mahi mahi and great eats. The place us busy in the center of Paia. parking is hard, but once you get your teeth in your fish you will be happy you came and waited. It's a small business with a lot of foot traffic, menu is mostly what you would expect per the name. The fish Ttco plate was great, the Cajun rice and coleslaw to boot were also great. This is about 10min from the airport and on the way to and from Hana. Must stop here next time..
(5)
Julie M.

Visited the town of Paia and spent an afternoon at the amazing beach...we strolled into the FIsh Market and the line was near the door so the wait was about 20 minutes.Staff was unavailable to bus the tables so we put away the dirty dishes of the prior customers and cleaned the table after sitting and waiting for staff( we noticed others had to do the same and we needed the space to eat!) Ordered fish tacos and noticed the tortillas were cold and hard around the edges with a lot of shredded lettuce. After the first bite I had to check to see what I was eating so after pushing off the lettuce I discovered mushy, smallish chopped fish (really just scraps that should not have been served to customers as edible!)Well, the cole slaw was tasty. I did notice other customers had fish plates which looked good. I can't recommend the fish tacos at all as the quality was poor. I am from So Cal where tacos are really amazing!
(2)
Alley C.

Best
(5)
Danielle F.

This is the kind of food you would expect the eat on a beach somewhere with the sand between your toes. Eating this food in that environment would make it amazing. Otherwise, it's just ok. It's like eating in a fish shack without the water. There are some things I liked-- the food was fresh and made to order. No food sitting around here. Fish was definitely tender but my tacos were really bland and the fish and chips were super salty.. And I love salt! Food isn't overly greasy either which is good but overall this food isn't really very memorable. It's the food you want to eat when you want fish and you want it quickly and relatively cheaply.
(3)
Sandy N.

I really had high expectations for this place after all the reviews from here! I ordered their fish taco w/c was prepared girlled. Sound healthy enough. I asked for my fish to be cooked medium, but when I got my fish taco the fish was over over cooked to my liking. The sides were good, thier rice was full of flavor and their potatoes were good as well. The BF ordered fish and chips. I liked his dish better. The fish was really tender and flaky inside and crunchy outside. It wasn't that good that I wanted to return to this place again while on vacay. Perhaps another time I'll give this place try. the price was great and so was the service.
(3)
Uland W.

Following my fellow yelpers to try this place. After a fun bike ride down the volcanic crater, this place was still bustling with patrons. Ordered the fish tacos cajun style and the famous or infamous ono burger. As I wait patiently the smell of fried fish and fries engulfs this small corner diner. A cool breeze from the double wide door, helps with the radiant heat from the hot stove. The beach tables bring customers close and one tends to slouch. If you decide to sit next to you friend, lover, or family. Be prepared to stare awkwardly at your neighbor while munching away on your food. Maybe I'm spoiled with food being that I am from California, the place were food meets taste buds; the food in my opinion was just so-so. Yes, I agree the fish was fresh, but the taste of it was just okay to my standards especially if you are planning to paying $12 a plate. Stop by my neck of the woods, and I 'll show you some good Mexican cuisine.
(2)
Maria W.

Our absolute favorite meal during our vacation in Maui. Perfect end to the day after doing the road to Hana. Very casual place with perfectly cooked fish dishes. It's community seating and quite crowded, but seats open quickly and you'll have a good time chatting with table-mates. Great wine and beer selection, too. Try the Ono!
(5)
Francis B.

Chowder, pasta, fish and chips
(5)
Daniel K.

The OPAH burger was amazing!
(5)
Tom R.

Was I not suppose to order the fish and chips??? Well I did and they burned the hell out of it...I would of went back up there and ask for a different plate but it was too packed. They say great place to sit with the locals and meet new people but realistically there's too many people in too small of a space. Thanks to the bench seating I sat next to a foreigner who smelled like B.O....BTW good luck finding parking!! My wife on the other hand loved her fish tacos AND my wife also has her own yelp account, she can give it a 5 star rating like everyone else for all I care.
(2)
Melissa D.

Completely overrated. The food was so bland. Absolutely no flavor. I have no idea what all the hype was about. I couldn't even eat more than one bite of my food, it was that bad. I ordered the cajun-style opah and it was just terrible. I poured salt, pepper, vinegar, ketchup, tiger sauce, and lemon on it in a pathetic and unsuccessful attempt to make the food have some semblance of flavor. My family members didn't even want to eat their food either. What a disappointment. I will never ever come back.
(1)
Peter K.

Grilled mahi burger and calamari are excellent and the people are very friendly. One of my favorite places to visit in maui. The calamari is thick and lightly breaded, with a ton of flavor. The mahi burger is the best fish sandwich I've ever had. Also like the original sugar based cokes in glass bottles. Lines are long but worth it!
(4)
Jacob L.

You have got to try the salmon burger. It is so good. Wished I had a chance to go back the second time before we left.
(5)
Lily Y.

After our trip to Hana, we stopped by this place for dinner. My friends and I were starving! I ordered the maui fish'n'chips. It was a large order. The fries were just regular skinny fries, nothing too special. The fish was tasty! It was lightly breaded big meaty chunks of fish. It was really yummy! :) The popular dishes here were the fish plates, and the fish burgers. Downside: -long wait to order especially when busy -bench table seating, may be hard to get a table for a large group -cramped, crowded The meal was very satisfying. However, I can't say that it was worth the wait. Definitely a nice place to stop for dinner and hang out with friends.
(4)
Mick W.

Good service but the food quality is lacking. Both our fish dishes were tough, chewy and bland. The cole slaw was not up to par. The rice was not so nice either. Could only stomach to eat half my dish as I was starving. Same with my wife's dish. Portions we large and the beer selection was good. I'd try them again some time later to re evaluate the taste just to be sure we didn't catch them on an off night.
(1)
Kate G.

RIDICULOUSLY GINORMOUS AMOUNTS OF FOOD. I made the mistake of ordering two fish tacos. One would have been more than enough. Not only is each taco OVERFLOWING with fish, lettuce, and salsa, but it comes with coleslaw and a bed of potatoes, rice, or a half-half potato and rice combination. If this were a Man v. Food challenge, food definitely won. Boyfriend and I particularly liked the rice pilaf - it was almost like a dry Spanish rice. As for the tacos, they were tasty. Hard to eat, but tasty. Tip: It gets CROWDED, so make friends and share your bench!
(4)
Richard B.

Not bad, but a lil over-priced. My wife and I stopped by here on the recommendation from my boss. We came in after our five hour tour on "The Drive to Hana" and we were starved! The prices seemed steep for the items, but we'd heard good things (the boss). We split the Mahi Mahi fish and chips plate. It was about $13 for three pieces of fish, some French fries and some coleslaw... It was very good. the fish was flaky and soft. The breading was crunchy. It was everything you'd expect in 'fish and chips'. The place was packed, so finding a seat for the two of us was a bit of challenge, but doable. Overall, it's a bit steep for the price (like many of the hills on the way to Hana), but definitely worth it.
(4)
Ann A.

This is the place to go in Paia! It's extremely casual with picnic table seating and extremely busy as are all good restaurants on this island. My friend and I waited in line for about 30 minutes to get in for lunch. I had a Caesar salad topped with ono and my friend had a mahi burger. Both were excellent. My friend is a local who lunches there regularly. Next time I visit, I'll be back.
(4)
Taylor K.

After reading the review about this place on Yelp, we decided to give it a try when we visited Piia. It's a very casual place. There are about 6 long tables with benches that you share with others. Sort of cafeteria style. You go up to the cashier and order food. There is no waiter service which means you have to go pick up your food when your number gets called. I ordered the Ono (aka wahoo) burger and my hubby ordered the fish and chips. The burger was all right but his fish and chips were the Bomb!!! They were crispy on the outside and plenty of fish inside and it wasn't greasy at all! You can order sides with your meal. I got the rice and it was pretty yummy but nothing spectacular though. This place is a must visit if you are in Paii especially if you are in a mood for great Fish and Chips.
(5)
Tina D.

This is a good casual place for lunch when you are stopping through Paia on your way to wherever you are going. Their menu is up on the board when you walk in and you order at the back counter. They advertise their fish of the day and any specials as well. I ordered the Mahi fish and chips. The Mahi was super fresh and came out hot and yummy. The fries were really good too, or maybe I was just really hungry. They were thin and crispy. Almost the way burger king fries used to be before everything became horribly bad at fast food restaurants... sad. The service was great, you pretty much walk up and get your food when they call your number and you dispose of your garbage when you leave. I didn't even mind the picnic table style seating. I'm not sure why everyone is so anti-social these days and doesn't want to share a table. We are all ohana afterall, right?
(4)
James S.

Loved this place. The fish tacos were the best I ever had...and I'm from So Cal so I sorta know a good fish taco. It was worth the drive, and the village of Paia has lots of great stores to browse after your meal.
(5)
Hugh J.

How do you spell tourist trap: Paia Fish Market. I ate A LOT of good food on Maui. This was my last meal before heading back to reality, aka the mainland. Worst mistake of ALL TIME. After my boyfriend hyped this place up, I expected to be blown away. Instead I was blown away how such a terrible restaurant has such good reviews. Then I noticed that EVERYONE in there was a tourist. The couple sitting next to me proves my point. One person ordered fish, the other fries only. The fries only person said: "This is exactly what I was looking for. These are the best fries I've ever had." Did you get too high? There must be good pot because who the h*** gets excited about eating a plate of sucky fries in Maui??? Those were some of the worst fries I've ever had. My blackened mahi should have come with a free beer on the side to wash down all the salt. My boyfriend's SEARED ahi was cooked medium well and bland. Fresh fish--questionable. Cajun rice??? What the?? It's Hawaii, give me mac salad & white rice!! Where's the Poke? They call it a fish market, puh-leeze. I was going to order fish tacos but they had cheese on them--cheese on fish tacos?? Sacrilege!! They really like to season everything with dill, ummm no one I know with any taste buds goes nuts for dill. No Thai chili sauce, only tartar sauce. No Aloha Maid or Hawaiian Sun juices--but they got Vitamin Water & Orangina, FAIL. I'm gonna say it cause I'm Hapa: for Haole's that love Haole food. Overpriced, lame food for people who love all their food seasoned with dill.
(1)
James B.

UHHH -- Here is the breakdown 1. Coconut's Fish cafe: Filet of ono done in a style of your choice, rice and cold slaw: $12 2. Paia Fish Market: Same thing, $24. So if you're out for a casual, community seating, dining experience in a loud place for 2, and have 60 bucks to drop for 2 including sodas, just head on down. At the fish market, fish quite overcooked, cajun rice was soaked in some type of juices, I don't think cajun food is actually cooked like that. Also, someone comes around and reminds you to bus your own dishes. We would have done it anyway, but that was hilarious.
(1)
Sam B.

We tried the Ono Burger and it was excellent. Looking inside the kitchen, I saw them filleting their own fish. You can tell they use fresh fish and it translates in the flavor of the dish. Good place to stop on the Hana road.
(5)
Phil H.

My favorite place on Maui. The fish tacos and the Obama burger (Ono) were awesome. My wife got a cheeseless veggie quesadilla and even that was super.
(5)
Shannon T.

As advised by Yelpers, I got the fish tacos while my family got fish and chips and a chicken sandwich. We just came from a bike ride from Haleakala, so our hungry stomachs might be a little biased, but everybody loved the food. You could really taste the fresh ingredients. The food was hot and comfortable. The fish n' chips were crunchy with crisp fries. My tacos weren't soggy and held together well. The food is plain and simple, but it tastes so much better because of it. I really like the decorating and ambiance. The only thing I didn't like was the fact that there is only one bathroom for customers.
(4)
Alex B.

Long line, decent food. Fresh fish, but overpriced. I guess it's worth a try... maybe once. Definitely overpriced.
(3)
Rick C.

The absolute best fish and chips I have ever had. And although insanely busy the service was still fast an very friendly. Keep up the good work !!!!
(5)
Marc P.

This place is a regular stop for my wife and I when we visit Maui. This isn't your fancy restaurant, but the food is tasty. Can get crowded, but moves pretty quickly. Bench seating, so be ready to potentially eat next to other patrons. The Mahi burger is my preferred choice.
(4)
Amary N.

This is based on the fish taco which I thought it was just average and didn't taste fresh. There are better fish tacos out there. The line is chaotic, the place is noisy and the tables were pretty messy. I have to clean the table before I set my food. I wouldn't come back! Good luck finding a table.
(2)
Kiki H.

Pretty good fish tacos, but I thought they were dry. Fish was very fresh though. Also not a fan of the double tortilla deal. Wish they had more fries with the tacos instead of coleslaw (ew). Even though these tacos were featured on The Best Thing I Ever Ate, they definitely were not the best thing I've ever ate....
(3)
Brenda S.

Best meal in Maui. Fish tacos were divine and the fish and chips my boyfriend ate were the best of all time!
(5)
Kim l.

One of the top 3 restaurants in Maui. Husband loved his Obama burger (special ingredient wasabi!) and I loved my chicken sandwich (preggo so couldn't indulge in as much seafood as I wanted to). If you aren't preggo I highly recommend getting their fish burgers. I had a little bit and it was bursting with flavor, cooked to perfection. My chicken sandwich was juice and was super flavorful too. Put in your order, pay and grab a seat. Get your food and enjoy!
(5)
Bree M.

Kinda disappointed in the fish taco's here at the fish market. We had walked by here several times and finally decided to go in. We sat on the edge of a table with a big family and quickly made acquantices. When the food arrived, we were happy with the presentation but I really felt the flavors were missing. After a few bites, I wasn't into it anymore and moved onto the rest. The only thing I found happiness in was the potatoes. Thankfully we had 2 beers, which I guess made up for it. Being a fish market, I would hope we caught them on an off day and usually their fish tacos aren't so bland and flavorless. Will definitely "try again" but I'm not rushing back to do so. :(
(2)
Kelly L.

My husband and I spent 10 days on two islands and this was probably the best food we had the entire trip! I had the fish tacos and hubby had the catch of the day burger - both were superb. I am picky about fish tacos and these did not disappoint! Loved that they double up on the tortillas so the tacos don't fall apart as easily. Reasonable prices. I deducted a star for the seating situation -- very crowded, communal style tables. We had to hover for a seat and there really wasn't much room to stand. Would absolutely still recommend it and will go back if we are in Maui again!
(4)
J S.

Fun place but stick to the simple fare such as a fish sandwich. I ordered the opa fish lunch plate and my sister had the mahi mahi lunch plate. Both were around $21 and not worth it. Both were overcooked and dry. Our friend had the calamari and he said it was 7 out of 10 but don't expect any tiny whole ones.
(3)
Big K.

Based on the food alone..5 stars.. I enjoyed the fish more than the fish I had at Roy's .. But it does get crowded so can be a bit cramped. I suggest the Obama.
(5)
Steven G.

Smelled so good. Kind of expensive but the food is good. Service was good and food was served with real dishes and silverware. Fresh and hot fish for fish and chips with cole slaw. Food was good and the tarter sauce was the best. Fresh and the best. Free refills. No parking area, must park on the street.
(4)
Valerie C.

The menu features a smattering of fried foods which is good, because that's exactly how I like my seafood. The group and I came in for lunch and was not in the least bit surprised at how long the line was and how crowded and noisy the dining area was. So instead of fighting our fellow tourists for a coveted spot, we ordered our food to go and enjoyed lunch on a nearby beach over a few beers. Paia Fish Market is a definitely stop while in Maui. It has a great selection of fish, salads, and probably the best french fries on the island!
(4)
Jake V.

Mahi Mahi fish was very flavorful and the potatoes were good also. Didn't like the seafood chowder not creamy enough. The wait was long and the bench sitting seemed awkward. The prices were ok at least not over the top like some other places in Hawaii.
(3)
Rosemary O.

This was the best meal we had while in Maui. I would recommend the fish and chips, they were delicious.
(5)
Michael F.

This place had the making of an amazing little spot. It was small, simple and packed. We were referred to stop here on our way to the airport by a bartender. He advised to stop and get the fish tacos, we were very excited for them. Overall they were average, we were underwhelmed. The tacos seemed bland even with the toppings. The meal was huge and the Cajun rice was good. Overall our experience was average. I read a lot of good reviews about this place and would be willing to try it again. The fish and chips looked great and would be my next choice.
(3)
Tom S.

Great island fare meets Mexican simplicity. We had a fish sandwich, fajitas, the Ono dinner plate and the ahi sashimi. The good was very good! The Ono on the dinner plate was a bit over cooked but still good. The fish was all VERY fresh! We will be back...
(5)
Jcee K.

These were the best fish tacos I have EVER had. You really don't need to bother ordering anything else when you come here. It's always busy so you know this place is good.
(5)
Leann B.

The ketchup Nazi needs to learn who pays the bills. He called us down in front of everyone in the restaurant when we borrowed ketchup from the next table. "Only one ketchup per table" is the rule and he intends to enforce it even if he has to embarrasses the perpetrator. Additionally, the fish tacos were bland and the fish and chips were nearly burned. I'd avoid for today. We must have caught them on a bad day. We've been here before and normally the food is pretty good. Today, neither the service nor the food was good.
(1)
Nathan S.

We absolutely love this place and always stop here for lunch when in Paia. Don't expect a restaurant with linens and your own space. All the tables are picnic benches, where you may find yourself next to others. Love the atmosphere. Great fun to visit if others are feeling friendly, but sometimes they just want to eat. =( The sandwiches we've have always been gut-filling wonderful. I've never had the salads, but my daughters say they are the bomb. The fish tacos rock too! I m a little disturbed by one of the reviews that says the fish is from Costco. I haven't heard this nor seen it, so I can't address that. Always expect a line, but if it's your first time - the line gives you a chance to consider the menu and make difficult choices. Great place for lunch and then on to other things. Definitely a must-stop when our family's near Paia.
(4)
Tanya N.

This was my first stop once I arrived in Maui since it was only about 10 minutes away from the airport and recommended by a friend. Seating is first come first served basis and you order & pay at the counter so my suggestion is that if you're there with someone else, grab a seat when you see one available and order for your friend. The lunch plate was pretty pricey at about $18 each. I had charbroiled ono fish with cajun rice and coleslaw. The fish was huge, moist and flavourful. The rice had a bit of spice to it but my preference would be a spicier. Overall, it hit the spot after a 5 hour flight.
(4)
Ashley G.

Opa burger. 17840947 stars. I swear I actually gasped in pleasure when I bit into this... for like the first 3 bites. I don't do fish sandwiches, but this rocked my world. I can't find anything this fresh and delish back in Orange County, and it makes me sad on a daily basis.
(5)
Rachel S.

Out of this world delicious. When we arrived here the place was packed and there was a line out the door. That indicated to me that it's gotta be good. The restaurant is in essence a fast fish joint where guests sit at long tables and benches to chow down. Finding a place to sit was a hassle, but eventually someone cleared their place and left. The food was awesome. I had the grilled mahi, which was cooked to perfection, and my hubby had the blackned ono, which was also phenomenal. They make their own tartar sauce in house and it definitely shows. The french fries were some of the best I've had: thin, but not skinny, crispy, but not too crunchy. Perfect. The chef, Eric, seriously knows what he's doing, and he's pretty much slinging all that fish all by himself back there at breakneck speed. Don't waste your money at Mama's and spend twice the amount on comparable food. Paia Fish Market is the place to go.
(5)
Ed L.

Paia is a neat little town up north and a great place for a pit stop on the way to Hana. The Paia Fish Market is pretty famous so I went to see what all the hype was about. After eating the fish tacos and Ono burger, I really did not find anything to be that special about it. The portions were very large with the sides of rice, slaw and fries so an order is usually enough to fill 2 normal people. The tacos were good and loaded with the Mahi Mahi. You could make 4 tacos out of the two they give you. Fish was fresh and the flavors were good but nothing surprising. The Ono burger was like an overcooked chicken breast, very firm and dry. Not to mention it is extremely bland, no seasoning or marinade. Although I don't blame Paia Fish Market for selling an expected lower grade fish, I do wonder why they don't spruce it up even if it is a simple sauce or seasoning blend. I would rather eat a Filet-o-fish at McDonald's than the Ono burger. I heard the fish and chips were excellent and regret not getting that instead. This place is packed so look out for seats before ordering.
(3)
Eddy C.

Additional 15% gratuity added to bill for ordering six plate or more is highway robbery. You stand in line to order, pickup food yourself, and bus yourself. For what is the gratuity?
(2)
Veronica G.

3.5 actually. Service kinda sucked but you're going for the food. We were recommended this place and if you've got about twenty mins to wait for food you won't be disappointed by the portions. So full. But don't expect a fancy place. Bench seating but we had some people at our table.
(3)
Danita M.

This place is so yummy!! I had the fish tacos which were very good, flavor was great and the portion was good. My friend had the mahi sautÃ©ed with garlic and butter which was amazing! The only downside is the lack of seating; we were lucky to grab a seat before our food was ready, but it gets very crowded. Still, this is a great place for some yummy seafood!!
(5)
Alli Q.

Came here on Sunday for early lunch and just beat the crowd! The ono fish tacos are yummy. I would recommend getting either fries or cajun rice as a side (the potatoes didn't have much taste). The Obama burger was just ehh so I would say that tacos are the best way to go! Order at the counter and wait for your number to be called.
(4)
Irem H.

Nice place. Ny husband had seafood salad with Oro and it was delicious. I had seafood pasta. For me, it was a hugeeee one! It could be shared. We also ordered fried calamaris. So we couldn't finish the calamari and pasta. But everything tasted good.
(5)
Joycelyn L.

Fish tacos tasted good, they were stuffed with fish and quite tasty. Onion rings were average but not super oily. Ono burger tasted good. I liked the tartar sauce it came with since it reminded me of In-N-Out burger's spread. I came here for lunch and suggest you get a table before you place your order. The place fills fast. Preferred the tacos over the burger since it was a lighter meal.
(4)
Bevo T.

Absolutely one of my favorite restaurants in all of HAWAII. It's simple and fresh! When in maui, i always come here and ALWAYS get the fish burger! I always walk in hoping that the fish of the day is opakaka (pink snapper i believe). It is a flaky white fish. mmMm. I get slightly disappointed when its not but i will then go with Ono. Everything about the fish burger is just yum! the fresh fish and the tartar sauce with lettuce and tomato, simple to perfection. The seafood pasta is something one will see another order and WISH they had ordered that. It tastes as good as it looks. sometimes needs a little more salt and pepper but that's just me. Warning you now, unless you have been out all day doing water sports and this is your first meal of the day, 1 order of this can feed a family! ok maybe not a family but two for sure. When we order this, we usually get the pasta and an appetizer like onion rings. If you don't eat here when you are in maui, you ARE missing out.
(5)
Suzanne M.

Love their fish! Love it! The coleslaw and pan fried potatoes can't be beat. We went here nearly every meal on our trip.
(5)
Patrick L.

This was my first stop when i landed in Maui. Very close to the Kahului Airport (OGG). The neighborhood has plenty of shops around. Kinda feels and looks like a locals area. The restaurant was packed when i got there. Long lines and better reserve your tables cause they go fast. Mahi Mahi Taco is the thing to get. $10 for two tacos. Its loaded with fresh Mahi Mahi. Reviewing the food right now makes me wish i was in maui right now to grab another MAHI MAHI TACO.
(5)
Marjolyn D.

My husband has been here before and we drove to Paia from Lahaina just so he could show me this cute surf town. He was telling me how good the fish was so of course, we had to have lunch here. He ordered the lunch platter and I had the mahi fish sandwich. it was super delicious. I was especially a fan of their potatoes - not sure what they put in them but they're SO delicious. I'd definitely come back again.
(4)
Mark C.

I loved this place. Fresh fish caught daily on delicious sandwiches? What's not to love. I had the Obama Burger and the Ahi Tuna Burger; both were great. This would be one of those kinds of places that would be on my weekly lunch rotation forever, if ya know, it wasn't in Maui.
(5)
AlohaKeAku A.

We eat here once a week now. Excellent value-good food
(4)
Dimitri S.

Solid island fare. I had the mahi mahi dinner plate with sauteed butter, garlic and lemon sauce drizzled on top. I was then asked, rice or potatoes, I replied, "what do you recommend?" She said I could could get some of each, PERFECT! The cold Widmer beer was the ideal accompaniment. My dining mates had the fish taco, Caesar Salad and Chicken Salad. Overall they were less impressed by their meals, but gotta say, if you're going to the Pa'ia Fish Market, get FISH! The cole slaw was a bit disappointing but the fish was well cooked and seasoned and very, very fresh. Be prepared to wait for a seat and hopefully people will clear out in time for your meal to be ready.
(4)
Monique R.

Was good - nothing really above average - shit I can't even remember what I had - that's how memorable it was...haha...I know the other half had the Mahi Mahi Burger - was ok - said he has had alot better.....worth a drop in though. Oh okay coming back to me know I had a Burrito of some sort - Beans, cheese rice etc - was ok - Mexican joint across the road was far better
(2)
Michael P.

Amazing seafood and other options...on the way to Hana. This place has some of the best seafood in the Islands. Be prepared to get a reservation and shop around some of the local stores before you get in...but when you do. Great servers are going to help you find a new dish that you will love.
(5)
Michael J.

Friendly seafood restaurant and pub with family-style seating and relaxed, casual atmosphere. I think it's a great choice for eating in Paia. It's centrally located, quick, and has a lot of very good food. I had the mahi burger which was one of the best mahi dishes I've ever had: deliciously seasoned and perfectly grilled. It is a little on the expensive side, especially for drinks. It also tends to get crowded so be prepared to wait for a seat. But, big crowds are usually a sign that the place has good food! I also like the setup: you go up and order when you're ready, then sit wherever you want.
(4)
Maria G.

I actually give this place a 2.5 *. To tell you the truth I was a bit disappointed after all the gleaming reviews and recommendations about this place. I tried out their fish plate lunch (Charbroiled Mahi) with fries and although it came out as a generous portion, the taste was nothing spectacular. Maybe it was an off day? Maybe I should have just gotten the mahi burger? Needless to say, for a $20 lunch dish, I expected more. Great ambience though and the salads looked fantastic. Not sure if I'll be making a return visit to this plae.
(3)
John L.

I give this place a big fat 'meh'. I was really not impressed. And that really disappointed me, As some rate this place the best. My Ono burger was overcooked, Almost as dry; the bun. I kind of liked the atmosphere, But it should have been more fun. The food seemed slapped together, Sashimi appetizer; not Hawaii fresh. Looking for good seafood in Maui? Paia Fish Market was not the best.
(2)
Eva D.

We did some ziplining in Haiku and decided to have a late lunch here. It was the best meal we had so far in Maui. My husband and I had the cajun cooked mahi with ceaser salad, my son had mahi as well, however sautÃ©ed in the butter and wine sauce with the cajun rice. We all loved it and if we weren't staying in the Kahana area, we would be back for more.
(5)
Joe S.

Rasta! This joint is fresh and straight up the real deal. RASTA!!!!!!!! Enjoy the woody decor, enjoy the island breeze sifting through the small shop. Get the Ono-Burger....the slaw and dill-mayo they put on this thing is so delicious, when your in the islands, you gotta eat the fish THE FISH, THE FISH, THE FISH, THE FIIIIIIIIIIIISSSSSSSSSSSSHHHHHHHH!!!!! Go here order up the fish sandwiches.....some beers a basket of golden fries and taste that fresh caught Ono.......you'll become converted once you go. I actually know people that were NOT fish people before coming here (sadly on the mainland we Fuck up fish) I took them here and well let's just say.....they're fish people now. Amazing food here, great service and awesome reggae beats as you swill beers.
(5)
Caroline L.

Eecks. We regretted eating here. I got the burger which was overcooked and salty w/pre-packaged cheddar cheese. The fish tacos were mediocre too, fish was dry. Coconut's fish taco was definitely better with ingredients that were much more fresh. The coleslaw here tasted like they just threw mayo on prepackaged salad. Yuck. It's also insanely loud in here.
(2)
Brandon V.

We payed $30 for two meals and waited 35 minutes to recieve it. You will be occupied though because during this time you will be making aqward eye contact with all eating their food as you wait to swoop up their seat the moment they get up. If you are not paying attention you will not get a seat in this cramped miserable "seat yourself" market. Once you find a place to eat your food you will likely have to clean that portion of the table yourself because the whole time I was there I did not see anyone picking up the tables. In all fairness the food wasnt near as offensive and if you happen to walk by and its not busy you might give it a try, otherwise give yourself a break, your on vacation and the food wasnt what you would write home about.
(1)
Lindsay A.

Again, this place depends on what time you hit it up. If you go when there is a rush you'll have a decent meal.. but who wants that when you can have the chance at a kickass one. Go before the dinner rush and after the lunch rush.. unless you can be the first for either. The cajun spicy fishburger... w The tiger sauce. DAMN!!! yes! really great. I did have it once and it was good, it was fine, but not as good as that first time. But it was really busy the second time. I also went and had the basket of prawns/shrimp. Really simple but delish, with the coleslaw. that is what makes it. see for yourself.
(4)
Marika K.

Nice casual place.. Service is nothing special but the food was good and pretty generous. We got the fried shrimp and fish tacos and both were good. I liked the fried shrimp a little more then the fish tacos.
(5)
Lanae R.

Not sure why I only just found out about this place 3 years ago but I'm glad I know now! You HAVE to get here on your next trip to Maui...they're in Pa'ia...super cute little town that's fun to poke around in. Fish burger is to die for...but we haven't had one bad menu item so it won't disappoint! ***Order line can get long...and it can be a strategy game finding open seating to accommodate your group...BUT TRUST ME WHEN I SAY IT'S WORTH IT!*** D-lish!
(5)
Steven N.

I love eating at Paia Fishmarket. The food is always fresh and the service is top notch. If there is a line it is because the food is excellent. When ever I have guest in town they always request a visit to the fish market. It is also a local favorite and meeting place for people from all over the island. So if your in Paia Maui, Paia Fish Market is a must.
(5)
Malish K.

The best restaurant on Maui! I go there every day after surfing Hookipa, as does the rest of the island because their fish is delicious. Get the garden salad with Grilled Mahi on top. Or try the Mahi burger. Seafood fetuccini is also delish and can feed a small family :)
(5)
Shalin P.

I'm not a big seafood person but had to try out Paia Fish Market based on the reviews. I ordered Fish Tacos, which I've never had before. And I gotta say, this was one of the best dishes I had during my entire Hawaii vacation. Such great flavor and so tasty. However, the side of rice that comes with it is very bland. I would skip the sides and get an extra taco. The place gets very crowded so the best plan is to look for someone finishing up their meal while you are waiting in line. For vegetarians, they do have a black bean quesadilla.
(5)
Randy P.

Great place for fish! We went there for the mahi mahi and were greatly satisfied with the portion, taste, service and atmosphere. People there are so laid back ... I mean really, it was crazy busy, but the people there were so nice. After that initial visit, we were going to try another fish place there in town (one that is on tv and highly publicized as the best) but decided to go back for round two .... definitely worth it ... and of course, we'll be back.
(5)
Eric J.

The Obama burger is quite simply the best fish sandwich in the planet! The food is awesome, though prepare yourself for the small town 'roadside' feeling. It's a lot of fun if you're looking for hearty seaside eating without white tablecloths and candles!
(5)
Masato I.

This is a good place to stop for lunch if you're near Paia! Went here twice on a weekend trip to Maui with the brother, his wife and their baby. We tried the mahimahi and ono burgers which both got everyone's endorsement. They grill the burgers and are flavored with what seems like garlic butter, salt and a hint of lemon. Fish is perfetly flaky and there is absolutely no fishiness so it seems super fresh. The fries are enough to make it a meal for 2 extra bucks, but they're nothing to yelp about... cut too short, fried too long and too crispy for my taste. The burgers also come with coleslaw which is mildly flavored so I can handle it since I'm not a huge "slaw" fan. I also tried the fish tacos which were not quite as good. It was prepared cajun style which just made it super salty. Served in double corn tortillas that were a bit dry, but I'll stop there, just stick with the burgers. It is a bit steep for what you get, but for Maui, I suppose this is a bargain. For the three of us, 50 bucks fed us each trip and that included the fries and a few beers. In case this is the only review you've read, have a friend stake out a table while you order, but one will open up within a few minutes. Also, please don't feed the hippies.
(4)
Ashley G.

I have to say after the 40 minute wait for our food I was totally bummed with my fish taco plate. Sure, I probably should have gotten the more popular fish n' chips, but I was feeling frisky and later regretted it. Had to scarf it down elbow to elbow with my visiting family (we took a day trip to Maui from Oahu) so we could make it back in time for our flight. Taco was nothing special and wasn't crazy about the base the cole slaw is made with (tartar sauce or just a whole lotta pickle and dill?) To us certainly not worth the hype OR the wait. Not to mention snottiness of the typical local patrons. Ridiculously rude, unwelcoming, and certainly treating everyone like they're tourists and that the locals (who clearly are transplants) own the joint. But I wasn't surprised--we ran into that all day. #Annoyed. Head over to the Mexican joint across the street. They too are on hawaii time and busy chatting it up with their friends to take your order but pretty good grub.
(2)
Michael S.

If you like fish, you MUST come here! It's really as simple as that! I had the Obamaburger which I believe is a Ono burger with cajun seasoning and a wasabi butter on top. Delicious... I could of used less wasabi, but really that was some good fish. Gf had the chowder and one fish taco which she could not finish. It was a good amount of food, but she was under the weather...otherwise, she would of completely finished it all. Loved the communal tables and locals eating there. Good stuff especially after doing a little shopping at the Dakine store!
(5)
Kristin K.

A little overrated for the price, I mean you are on an island where one must assume the fish is fresh and hasn't traveled too far. The salad topped with grilled fish looked the best and wish I would have ordered that...instead of the plate with 'cajun' rice and coleslaw...
(3)
Pete V.

Paia Fish Market is for you if.... 1 - You're not claustrophobic...and by that I don't mean shoulder to shoulder, I mean skin on skin!! This place gets really packed, really fast during lunch and people waiting in line or grabbing their food will inevitably bump into you 6-8 times during your meal. Me thinks the loyalists at this establishment actually get turned on by physical contact with strangers. 2- You don't mind waiting in long lines. The line was out the door the day we arrived, and although it moved steadily...we reached the counter in maybe just 10 min, finding a place to stand and wait after you've ordered is an entirely different story. My advice is to stand right next to the garbage can. That area is usually vacant. 3 - You love super fresh fish and cheap prices! I was shocked at how cheap this place is for the quality of seafood they deliver. I had the Mahi burger and it was a nice cut of Mahi steak, not over cooked, topped with a nice light tartar sauce. It tasted like they had just pulled the fish out of the Pacific ocean! Oh and not to forget the fish tacos were almost on the level of Wahoo's Fish Taco's (for those who are familiar with the California fish taco mecca). Bottom Line: Definitely worth the wait for some great, affordable fish. But is it worth being cramped and bumped while you enjoy your meal? Well, that's up to you to decide...
(4)
Dan L.

This was an awesome experience. Small town with an awesome small food joint that makes some really amazing fish tacos. Their slaw was solid and they served beer which was a plus. It's family style seating so you get what you get. 8 per table. We met some people from Cali who gave us their life story in like 10 mins due to the seating style. I enjoyed it, might not be everyone's cup o' tea. But the fish tacos...mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
(5)
Tim H.

Saw their fish tacos on an episode of The Best Things I Ever Ate. I tried their fish tacos. Very fresh and good, but nothing that special in my opinion. I also had the ono burger which was fresh and good as well. If in the Paia area, the Paia Fish Market is definitely worth checking out for a casual meal at under $15 per person. However, nothing great enough in my opinion to make a special trip here.
(4)
Martin S.

The line of tourists (myself included) stretches outside the door and spills onto the sidewalk. Why? Perfectly prepared fresh fish, huge portions piled with great sides. The line moves briskly as the kitchen staff whips up the plates. I can't believe that this place is humming along with what appears to be only 4 people--the cashier, the guy cleaning tables, and 2 guys cooking and serving behind the counter. They work quickly like a well-oiled machine. We get our plates and sit at long communal tables, everyone enjoying lively conversation over the good food. Aloha spirit fills this place!
(4)
Jules H.

sometimes it's hard to write reviews, especially for independents. here it goes: 1) chowder - not much of the "good stuff." the potato pieces were suspiciously similar in size to the french fries, just shorter. 2) charbroiled fish platter - your fish options are up close next to the cashier. stick with the most popular choices, and you will be happy.
(3)
Kristen S.

Paia Fish Market is a great place to grab lunch. The fish is what you come here for, obviously. Our family of four ordered 2 ono sandwiches, 1 mahi sandwich and 1 opah sandwich. All of them were cooked to order, cooked to perfection and served immediately. Or should I say, our number was called immediately ;). The sandwiches were served open-face on a bun covered in yummy coleslaw, slice of tomato and shredded cheese. For about $9 a sandwich, it's reasonable. The fish portions were big and all the fixings were fresh and delicious. We also ordered a couple beers and two baskets of fries, one with salt and one without (my mom is on a low-salt diet). We were pleasantly surprised that a small, bustling, No-frills eatery could not only accommodate her diet but also get it right. As a general note, the food here is not saturated in salt and doesn't compromise on flavor. A good thing! If you want fresh, grilled fish locally caught in Hawaiian waters and dont want to shell out the big bucks at Mama's Fish House, I would recommend coming here for a casual lunch. We didn't try it, but the fresh ahi sashimi looked really fresh and really good...same goes for the fish tacos! Be warned: Parking is abysmal, and the tables get crowded at lunchtime, but trust me it's all worth it. Try coming around 2pm or later to beat the crowds.
(4)
Mitzi D.

There are no amazing views and no white table cloths. You share a long bench with strangers you have never met. However, I would pick the fish at the Paia Fish Market over the overpriced experience at Mamas Fish House any day. The fresh fish selection is vast and when in Maui I would get whatever local catch of the day is on special. Its grilled to perfection! My FAVORITE items is the fried calamari. This is not your average tough, small tiny piece of unmentionable food. The calamari here is soft, big and meaty. Its so tender its absolutely amazing. I took my friends parents here and they said "they don't make calamari like this at home!". Yes, you have hippies here and all over Paia but who cares. You get a high quality piece of fish at a great price. Across the street for dessert is some Ono gelatto!
(4)
Leigh H.

Great fish tacos and fish burgers. Serves wine and beer. Great prices. Fun place to go for lunch and walk the quaint little town.
(5)
Janice F.

The first time I was here, I wasn't so impressed with the food. The second time however, the fish taco's were really quite good. Stuffed full with juicy, tasty fish and served with a dill tartar sauce, no complaints here. It is super busy at lunch time, line-ups out the door. I ended up getting there at about 4:30 pm without any lines. It is kind of dirty, people wipe down their own tables and the washroom is located outside the restaurant.
(4)
Kim R.

We had to go and try this Fish Market out - locals raved about it, and online ratings boasted it to be the best fish tacos they have ever had. I on the other hand did not find this to be true. It's so extremely busy and it's like you get an adrenaline to rush the second you sit down! There are rows of bench seats and tables, so you pretty much race to sit where there's an available opening. Before we ordered, it seemed it would have been better to get the meal to go due to the very crowded, and almost unbearably hot, seating area. The fish tacos were extremely underwhelming - we had better at the airport in Seattle on the way to Maui. We saw a review on, "The Best Thing I Ever Ate", and how amazing they tasted - and on Yelp and TripAdvisor, how juicy and succulent the fish was... I just didn't see the big deal. We also tried the deep fried shrimps, which were decent, but you only get 5-6 for around $9. I would suggest to try it for yourself - it seems to be a favourite among many - both locals and travellers. It just wasn't our favourite.
(2)
Jay B.

Was lookin for a good place to eat before we headed home from our vacay and remembered seeing the Paia Fish Market on our drive back to our place after we did the Haleakala Bike Tour; so I checked yelp and it seemed to get great reviews. So off we went before our flight...and I was so glad we came. I didn't even know they were featured on Food Network, so that's a bigger plus. The food was great...I got the Ono-Burger(you can pretty much burger any fish they have available), but the Ono-burger was awesome. GF had the fish tacos, I forgot what kind of fish it was tho, but it was amazing as well. it was fresh and very tasty. We were so full that we even saved half of our meals and brought it with us to the airport to eat as our in-flight meal. You get a lot of bang for your buck here. Service - The place is super crowded so you kindof have to have your party scope out and get a table while you order. Someone took my order when they brought it up, so they apologized profusely and quickly got another serving brought up. Wasn't their fault, but that's the trouble with number calling, esp when everyone's ordering the same thing. Atmosphere - Most people are friendly, but it's small and the tables are setup picnic style, so be prepared to share your table with other friendlies...or sometimes not so much; I ran into a few non-friendlies, but fortunately, we didn't have to sit with them. I just gave them the stink-eye and moved on. Parking - street parking all over, just gotta get lucky if you wanna park close :) For the price and value of the food, it's quite the treat on the tastebuds for a very affordable price :)
(4)
Courtney S.

Had the Obama fish burger. GREAT food. Ample seating. Order at the counter. Try the Coconut Brew too. Different and thick. Daughter had the chicken Caesar. Both huge portions. Loved this place. Surfboards as tables. Pretty sure they had a kids menu but can't guarantee. Loved it!
(4)
Angelica M.

A local friend of mine suggested this restaurant during my visit to Maui. I ordered the seared ahi burger with the expectation it would be good. It was the BEST fish burger I have ever had. Every one else in my party raved about their dishes. Three cheers for Pa'ia Fish Market!!!! The only down side is the limited seating, so when you arrive be on the lookout to immediately save a seat.
(5)
Leslie T.

Why 3 stars? It was good, but it IS just a hole-in-the-wall fast food place. My fish (from the fish and chips order) was very good and not greasy, but the coleslaw - flavorless, and the fries - meh. My husband had the fish tacos and he said they were good. They do have Kona Brewing Co.'s Longboard Lager, though, and it was nice and cold! It was also very crowded (which made it difficult to move any which way) and loud! Next time I will order a fish sando, as I heard - later - that they are yummy!
(3)
Valorie W.

My aunt, who lives in Kihei, introduced us to the Fish Market in 2009. The menu is simple, but the freshness and preparation of the fish is amazing. It gets crowded, so a bit of a wait to order isn't unusual. Also, seating is at shared picnic tables throughout the restaurant, so don't be surprised if you wind up bumping elbows with a complete stranger. I really enjoy the blackened ono, and my husband commented that the ahi was seared just right. We can't wait to visit when we're on Maui and will be back next week!
(4)
Ana C.

This is one of my fave spots to cruise for grinds when I'm on Maui. If I'm in a car and we drive through town, on the way upcountry, I always insist we stop and eat here. While it is considered somewhat of a tourist attraction, you will find just as many local surfers, beach bums, normal bums, artists and others, grubbing it up here at any given time, as you will fanny-pack and Hawaiian shirt wearing Haoles. The restaurant itself is small, but its high ceilings give it an airy feel and makes it seem much larger than it really is. The window-lined walls let the natural sunlight in, and because of this during the day this is a great place to come recoup after a long, hot, bright day on the beach. Get ready to wait in a long line and be sure to have your order ready when you get to the counter. You will find no waitresses or waiters at this restaurant; it is self-service at it's finest. I should also mention that there are no tables and chairs. The seating is comprised huge long lacquered wood picnic benches, which patrons are expected to share communally. Do not walk in this restaurant and try to "save a seat," especially if it's a local who is trying to find room at your table. Sharing is caring; that's the Maui way. Anything you might need in terms of napkins, utensils, or condiments sits in containers on the picnic tables. Now on to my fave part...the food! Before I go any further, I should probably mention that I order the same meal each and every time I go to the Paia Fish Market... MAHI MAHI BURGER FRIES DRINK (varies) While, I am partial to this meal, I have tried many other things on their menu because I am the kind of person who sees the food on the plate next to me and before the who's plate it is can take a bite, I'm asking to try what they have and sticking a fork into it at the same time. Rude, I know! But what can I say, I'm a sucker for seafood. Anyway, if you have the chance, or find yourself scanning the menu for something other then my fish burger, I have some recommendations for you. Fish Tacos Calamari Ono burger (firmer than Mahi Mahi) Chicken burger (if you aren't a fish fan) Fries (sooo good solo, or ad a side) Chicken Caeser Salad Now back to the Mahi Mahi burger...this tasty combo of flavors and textures perfectly blend together to create something truly unique. So unique, that I have never seen an attempt to replicate it (and I have been to many restaurants all over the world). Not to mention, it's the only fish burger in the world I've gone back to a restaurant to eat more than once. Ummm...did I mention it is incredibly filling as well? The burger is served open-face; half its contents piled on one side and half on the other. On one end, is the sesame seed adorned top of the bun (side note: the bun is BIG, but not too thick that the bread overpowers any other ingredient). Piled on top of the top (haaa) is perfectly seasoned dill coleslaw and some freshly cut slices of firm, but ripe tomato. Piled on the inside of the other half of the bun is a seasoned and skillfully grilled large piece of Mahi Mahi that is so juicy it shines when the light hits it. Last but not least, on top of the grilled fish is a little mound of a thinly shredded mix of cheddar and jack cheeses; always just starting to melt from sitting on top of the just grilled piece of Mahi Mahi. Now comes the fun part. Pick up one end of that burger and turn it over on top of the other. The last thing you should attempt, or even be concerned about, when eating here is neatness and manners. You are going to get messy. The laidback atmosphere not only condones this, it encourages the messiness. When you're done eating, you clear your own plates. In the far right had corner of the restaurant (if you're facing the cotter where you order) is a bus station where you leave any plates, utensils, or glassware you used, as well as trash bins to throw away any leftovers.
(5)
Laura A.

Always filled with locals, that says a lot! We had the fish tacos, We loved them! Wished we would have tried the onion rings they looked really tasty!
(4)
Rose R.

Judging by the out-the-door line every time I go here, I'd say everyone already knows this place is amazing! The fish is SO FRESH and so delicious. You literally can't go wrong ordering anything off the menu. Although I'd recommend going before 11:30 or after 2 to avoid the longer lines.
(5)
Vishal S.

Best Fish Tacos ever! Period.
(5)
Shirley D.

This review has been overdue for the last two years. The only reason I remembered to write about this was because we are headed back here in a couple of months and started searching for restaurants, my part of the vacation...hehe. I'm going to try and remember as much as I can, which is limited at this point. Anyways, here's my review on the restaurant. They serve great seafood that is fresh, clean and good portion at a great price. This is one of the restaurant you could get your food to go and enjoy eating it on the beach. I had ordered the mahi mahi with wild rice and cole slaw. The mahi mahi was delicious and you could taste the freshness (not fishy taste or smell). It's a bit pricey, but you are getting quality food. Yes, the fish taco - deliciously well made........OH BABY!!!!.....The best I had on the island. It so beats out Jaws (overrated). This restaurant is located in a cute little town before you go on your excursion to do the Road to Hana. This restaurant will quench your thirst for seafood and more. I'll update you guys, when I come back.
(5)
Amanda G.

Once again, this place did not disappoint! I actually saw their fish tacos on an episode of, "Best Thing I Ever Ate", so I had to try them when we stopped in here for lunch. My friend and I both loved them! They were by far the best fish tacos I've ever had. We also came back twice for dinner .Each time I had the grilled fish sandwich, and each time it was perfection:) Once I had ono, and once I had opah, both were remarkably fresh and totally enjoyable! We shared fries too, and they were as good as I remembered. I adore Paia town, and this place is my favorite restaurant on the island. I was very happy to see they are doing so well with both tourists and locals. Definitely a gem of a restaurant.
(5)
Trang H.

After finishing our food at the Paia fish market we immediately went on a search for another place to eat. We ordered their popular fish tacos and we're so excited to have some amazing food. Unfortunately we were dissappointed with their food. We couldn't even tell that we were eating fish. The meat could have pass for chicken. The taco as a whole was very bland and really had no taste at all. This would not be a place we would go back to.
(2)
Kimmy K.

It cracks me up that everyone says this place is so great. It's not fresh or tasty or even a fish market. I'm pretty sure they get their fish from Costco. When you see them grilling it up, it sure looks like the frozen fish you get out of bags from Costco. The flavor is bland and everything is just sad. I couldn't even eat all of my food it was so bad. Save your money and your taste buds and skip this place. There are much better places in Paia with FRESH fish that you can eat at.
(1)
Jason J.

Awesome fish tacos. I wasted my time on other places just for the sake of variety. Never again. No matter what kind of fish. Try 'em with the Tiger sauce on the tables. Parking is pretty tough, but just park in the city lot down the road and a couple blocks.
(4)
lisa a.

Oh Tracy K, thank you for your review. The seared Ahi burger was fantastic! Huge, juicy, perfectly seared deliciousness in a bun. We also tried the seafood chowder, $5 for a giant bowl of soup brimming with large chunks of various fish and shellfish. Park in public lot when you enter Paia, it's just down the block and probably easier than trying to find a spot on the street. Plus, with the ginormo portions you'll need at least a block of walking to recover afterwards.
(4)
Elle G.

The food is definitely 4 star. Very yummy and I've never been disappointed BUT... The seating is always a nightmare, so we don't eat there as often as we'd like. I still go there if I was just grabbing something to go, but usually we want someplace to sit down. Not saying they're doing anything wrong. There is limited space and I think they make the most of it. But for me, I don't like to face stress in a restaurant. I like to go somewhere and chill out, not deal with sweating grabbing a seat or two, having someone move into it while you get your food, dealing with someone else's trash on or under the table, and/or having to share a table with people you have to compete with vocally to have a conversation...literally bumping elbows at times. It's not too bad when it's not full, but in a crowd... nah.
(3)
Brian V.

Upon arriving at the airport, we read some reviews on my phone and decided to give the Paia Fish Market a try. We were lucky enough to get a close parking spot on a pretty busy day. We immediately noticed that this place had a decent-sized line (can be a little crowded inside) and the seating was limited (there are benches that you share with other people). Depending on your comfort level, that might be a positive or negative. My wife ordered the fish tacos and I ordered the fried fish. My wife said her fish tacos were the best she's ever had and my fried fish was also the best I ever had. After taking a few bites of each others food, we agreed that this place was amazing. Aside from a few super fancy romantic dinners, the Paia Fish Market was the best meal we had during our stay in Maui. We liked the food so much that we made a few trips and each time we loved the meal. At first, I thought the food was a little on the expensive side for this type of restaurant. But after a few days on Maui, I realized that it was actually pretty inexpensive in relation to everything else. If you want to eat great food in a relaxed environment, you should definitely try the Paia Fish Market. And if you are feeling frisky, don't be afraid to try a little tiger sauce with your fried fish and tarter sauce. It creates an electrifying combination!
(5)
Kat T.

This place is sooo ONO.. great fresh fish.. It's cute and friendly..just a little prices.. thought it would be a fancy place.. but it's almost like a hole in a wall but cleaner.. lol I really like my Mahi Mahi and chips. NOT fond of the dill tarter sauce. My husband had the shrimp and chips but wanted the rice.. He liked his food and said it was a fresh taste for his and mine... I also ordered the seafood chowder.. SORRY I've had better in Maine. This one tasted a little watery. (and for that this place gets 4 stars) To bad I didn't taste the fish taco.. next time..
(4)
Kiristen R.

Yes lawd! In the words of Tamar Braxton, this place is "thetruthdotcom". So good. This was the first place my hubs and I went on Maui and it was a nice "Aloha". I split the fish burger and the calamari/fried fish plate with my husband. The entire meal was good but the fish burger was probably the best I've ever had in my life. Juicy and well seasoned. I probably had 3 fish burgers the following week but none came close to the fish burger here. I almost want to fly back to Maui just to eat here. Other notables: -communal seating -a little pricey -bus your own tables Make sure to stop here when you're in Maui.
(5)
T C.

The fish tacos were really tasty. My husband ordered the quesadilla and loved it. Great place to grab lunch.
(5)
yelp karma u.

MMMM....My mouth is watering just thinking about thier Ono sandwich! We ordered the Obama Ono Sandwich which deserves a 5 star vote regardless of the eater's political affiliations! Hands down the best fish sandwich I've had to date. We also got a Mahi Fish & Chips which was decent but rather ho-hum. Fries (chips) on the side were amazing though and made up for the underwhelming fish pieces. Cute spot, love the vibe. With such amazing items on the menu don't bother with the Fish & Chips. Can't wait to go back!
(5)
Erika R.

OMG. This place is absolutely fantastic! When my husband and I first approached the counter to order, I was a bit shocked at the $18 price tag for a lunch plate. But let me reassure you -- it is sooo worth it! The cajun-style opakapaka was hands down the most delicious piece of fish I've eaten eh-ver. An important note regarding the value for the price -- the portion sizes are very generous! It was definitely at least 10 ounces, though this didn't stop me from totally cleaning my plate! And just to put things into perspective, I'm a pretty health-consious broad -- I track my daily caloric intake, keep to a strict diet... but the Paia Fish Market was absolutely worth my, ahem... overindulgence :) Make sure to get some of the coleslaw as well. Again, I normally avoid coleslaw, as gloppy mayonnaise is not my thing. But the coleslaw at this place was all about fresh dill and crunchy cabbage -- it was light and fresh and delish!
(5)
C.W. C.

This place rocks! We had the Obama burger (blackened Ono with a wasabi relish) and it was delicious. Great value with the freshest ingredients. I recommend going for an early or late lunch to avoid the mad crowds. We will be back!
(4)
Liz A.

I spent 7 weeks on Maui this summer and was on a mission to find the best fish tacos on the island..... And, well, after trying just about every place on the island that serves them, Paia Fish Market it the outstanding winner by a long shot! You get to choose the type of fish you want, how you want it prepared and whatever side you would like. It comes with cabbage, tomatoes and a lemony dill tartar sauce. The fish is SO fresh. Squeeze a little lemon and add some Tiger Sauce and you will be more than satisfied! The fries are also delicious - crispy and seasoned well! It's the type of place where you walk up to the counter, order and sit wherever there is an open table. It's always busy (for obvious reasons!) but the communal seating is very fun. You never know who you might be sitting next to! Lots of interesting people to meet in Paia town! Prices are very affordable and you can also order alcoholic beverages. If you are in Maui and looking for some SUPERIOR fish tacos - this is definitely the place to try!
(5)
Tommy C.

We got the tuna platter and the tuna fish burger. The platter was cooked in a butter white wine sauce. Sounded good but the fish was way over cooked and tough. It came with a bunch of sides. As for the burger, it was much better and tastier. But I still had much to desire after reading all the reviews. I didn't get a chance to try the tacos, but I wished I did since everyone else was ordering it. Maybe next time if there is one.
(3)
Angelo G.

Excellent fresh seafood!
(5)
Julie R.

After going halfway to Hana, we were ready to stop off for some lunch! We had recommendations for this place and Mama's Fish House. We met some locals who said to come here for sure over Mama's. We were glad we did. It was fresh, reasonable and local. We shared a plate of fish tacos. There were 2 kinds of fish. Both were juicy and tasty. Grilled Opa and Ono I believe. The tacos are loaded up, not anything skimpy. A plate of 2 is $12 but huge. You get your moneys worth with the fish for sure. On the side the coleslaw was the best I ever had. Super crunchy and delicious. The rice and beans were a filling addition to the plate too. These tacos were satisfying and the place offered low frills. The tables are community style. Most people keep to themselves and allow enough room where you feel you are eating alone anyway.
(4)
Yeelin T.

We stopped by around noon on our way to Haleakala. Boy, it was busy! We waited in line for over 10mins, and waited some more after we were seated. Speaking of seats, I wasn't a big fan of the cafeteria-style benches, but, for good food, whatever. My fiance had the fish and chips, and I had the Obama burger. Coming from Seattle, we are used to cod in fish and chips, so mahi mahi is a nice change. The fish was coated in a slightly spicy breadcrumb. Delicious! The Obama burger was made from Ono. It was a gamble. I have read reviews that Ono is a bland white fish so I was weary about how good this would be. The fish was a bit tough, and it really didn't taste very good on its own. However, when I took a bite of it with the burger (sauce and all), wow. It really came together! I was blown away. If you've never had Ono like me, try it!
(5)
John N.

the seafood pasta was good, only complaint was that the dish had only one scallop! the pasta was pretty good overall. the place is crowded, picnic style tables so be prepared to elbow up with your neighbor.
(3)
Rory L.

Stopped in here for a late lunch/early dinner as we were driving back from Hana. I got the fish tacos because of the rave reviews and it was what I was wanting. They weren't out of this world, but they were good. My wife got a salad and fried calamari, which were both good as well. Fun atmosphere - order at the counter, then wait for your number to be called. Tables are picnic-style with benches. Bathrooms are a short walk down the street and around the corner which is quirky, but it doesn't ruin the experience.Tables are picnic-style with benches.
(3)
Jethro C.

The fish tacos, fish burgers, and fish n chips were amazing here. The Paia Fish market is located along the main street of a cute little town, which is picturesque. Paia Fish Market is a perfect place for dinner after a day at Baldwin Beach, Haleakala crater, or the Road to Hana. There's something about the atmosphere of the restaurant that can't be put in words, but is characterized by the friendly staff and excitement of people lining up. The only drawback is that seats may be hard to find.
(5)
Baba G.

My wife and I decided to try this place based on the positive Yelp reviews, and since it was walking distance from our hotel. Talk about a let down! The fish and chips were MEDIOCRE- the mahi filets were overcooked and dry. ( dark brown in color ) . The chips were nothing special- frozen variety from Costco or whatever freezer section. The tartar sauce tasted like it was pre made and out of a bottle. overall disappointing. Here's a free tip to the owners or line cook (no chefs there): the fish in fish & chips need batter! and try thick fresh cut fries with sea salt. Sheesh they didn't even try. We also had an ono burger- a nice filet but very bland. just barely 3 stars. But at least it was better than the fish & chips- which isn't saying much. We shared a bowl of clam chowder- tasted like it was out of a can. Some yelpers said they were happy to eat here instead of Mama's Fish House. Do some research on Mama's and you'll find the comparison is like comparing Yugo to Mercedes. Janet Reno to Pamela Anderson. HP to Apple. you get the point- no comparison. I would only recommend Paia F.M if you are hungry after a night of drinking heavily.
(2)
Matthew A.

Here comes another review where I downgrade a restaurant that had been stellar. I regret having to give Paia Fish Market two stars but the quality of the food just wasn't there. Just horrible this time. We ordered the fried calamari appetizer and the sautÃ©ed Mahi lunch plate. The Calamari was close to burnt, tasteless and rubbery. The Mahi was overlooked, dry and brown. We usually order the Mahi sandwich so shame on me for deviating. My wife blamed me for setting her up for disappointment. Terrible food plus an old curmudgeon pitching a fit cuz I got my order in before him and his wife amounts to a not so good experience. After straightening him out, we left.
(2)
Karyn W.

ALWAYS a fan of the fish taco. We get the plate with 2 and share. there is enough. The salad with fish looks amazing, I am just stuck on the taco. Usually 4-5 fish choices of whatever is fresh. I am a fan. Go right before or after the lunch hour. This place gets crowded......
(5)
Sally L.

This place is pretty crowded and has shared picnic tables, but it's one of the cheaper places to eat on the whole island. Portions are huge and the food is pretty good. Bathroom is off-site and accessed with a key which I found to be a little off-putting, but it was reasonably clean. I would suggest getting to-go.
(4)
Francis K.

food- pretty good. the fish sandwich was good; not exceptional but decent...the fish platters are way overpriced. they are about twice the price of the sandwich but only a little larger portion. the fries are very average (especially since they charge you $2.50) service- this is where i was disappointed. we got there a few minutes before it opened and there was a small line. they let us in at 11am and when we approached the counter, the register clerk had a very smug attitude as she was finishing whatever she was doing (while the line was growing)....they didn't even look up to say hi or acknowledge any of the customers. the attitudes of many of the employees were similarly arrogant.
(3)
Steph H.

This Paia landmark right on the corner of Baldwin and Hana Hwy is popular with tourists and local alike, and rightly so. Fresh, hot and cheap, what more can you want? The place is small and only offers communal wooden picnic-style tables and benches for seating but I found it a charming, egalitarian experience--strangers rubbing elbows and sharing napkins while digging into the delicious food. It's a surprisingly large menu, but I'd heard their fish sandwiches were the thing to try, and when I saw the sign for their Obama Burger Special (Fresh Ono, Cajun-style, topped with homemade wasabi butter and fries), I had to get it! It was quite delicious, but I must admit that the fish was a tad on the dry side, kinda like a wahoo's fish taco. But I'm really splitting hairs, and my "dry" could be just someone's "well-done." I usually don't like well-done anything so it could just be me. Otherwise, it was delicious and the fries were quite good as well. My dining companions and I enjoyed it very much and I'd repeat given the chance.
(4)
carol a.

This place is an awesome value! We both got fish sandwiches and the fish couldn't be any fresher. For the price and the portion size, it's a great value. There is always a line and food is a little slow to come out, but it's so worth the wait!
(5)
Nadia B.

Definitely, definitely fresh food! We ordered fish tacos and mahimahi fish and chips... I never EVER had fish sticks like these... tasted like chicken, battered in amaziiinggggggg breading with was moist and spicy and with garlic.. I lovvvvvved it.... Fish tacos were also very good... two of us with one drink cost a total of $25... great lunch spot....!! and in a nice area too!
(4)
La L.

My husband didn't speak the entire time he ate his fish sandwich. I am pretty sure it was Ono. He was in complete awe. I think his eyes rolled back into his head. I'm not sure why some of the reviews are poor. Personally, I wouldn't eat a burrito at a place that's called Paia Fish Market. But that's just me. My "Obama" sandwich was good but not as good as his and he literally gave me the smallest bite you've ever seen. He was not willing to share. Go here and grind but go for the FISH. My husband still talks about his sandwich and benchmarks every other fish sandwich against the one he had here. It's just not a fair competition for the East Coast fish. They just don't stand a chance. I feel bad for them.
(5)
Tracy K.

The only fish Paia Fish Market will sashimi sear is Ahi, and you HAVE to try it. Because although their cooked Ono burger is fantastic, nothing beats a quality rare fish burger. Fresh, tender, moist filet generously and perfectly sliced to fit flat on a burger. $9.50 is all it takes to turn you into a Paia Fish Market fan. BF took a bite of my burger and immediately wished we could swap plates. Not today, dear.
(5)
Yorke W.

Surprised at how good my lunch was today at this restaurant. It was highly recommended but it is small and was very crowded. But the line moved along and our lunch was delicious. We had the fish burger with an Rader of French fries (small) . I definitely recommend for you to give it a try when you are in Paia!
(5)
ed b.

Walk across the street to Milagros's for better, fresher fish, table service and no flies and the same pricing. We had a variety of their dishes and they were all mediocre. This was the worst fish we had in 10 days on the island.
(2)
Stacey J.

Busy little place that we found on our honeymoon by using Yelp. The fish on my sandwich was excellent - juicy and tender. The fries however and even worse that In and Out fries - horrid. The chicken tacos were just OK. I would not go back again. Service was fast - not a lot of seating or parking. I thought is was overpriced for the food.
(3)
sonya h.

We had the mahi fish and chips and also a fish sandwich. Both were excellent. They are so popular so it's tough to find a place to sit. You have to stalk people and make them uncomfortable to they get up and leave. HAHA. I think most people will come here after they go to Hana. It's sooo good...I want to go back again.
(4)
Steve M.

Great fresh fish. Amazing actually. Went on a busy night after an exhausting trip to Hana and beyond. Cafeteria style seating. Prices are not cheap...think for me and my wife was about $60, but hey, I was in Hawaii paying for fresh fish that was caught in the am. I had an amazing filet of perfectly grilled and seasoned Opah and my wife had the Mahi. Large platter. Got the crispy fries and my little dipping sauce I created with soy sauce, ketchup, and Tiger Sauce was awesome! Yes, I would come back, and would probably get the same thing. Steve out.
(5)
Aaliya Y.

We went straight from the airport to Paia fish market because it is just that good! This establishment is small storefront with casual picnic bench seating. It is brimming with locals for good reason. I would recommend the obama burger (ahi tuna) and the cajun fish tacos! The fish is amazingly fresh and flavorful, perfectly seasoned and well frankly, has become the subject of many dreams. yum! Can't wait until our next trip to Maui. I will definitely be going back for some more fish tacos.
(4)
shopaholic v.

Had to drive BACK to Paia after our day long drive to Hana. J was diggin the menu with a wide range of fresh caught fish. He was very very happy with his Ono fish tacos and raved for days about their yumminess. I had a plate of Ahi Tuna w/fries and it was oh so deliciouso! A definite MUST try in the town of Paia! We can't wait to go back! Ambience - cute and kitschy, complete with large fish replicas and beach shack decor. Seating on communal benches led us to meet several transplanted locals (they went to windsurf and have stayed for 21 yrs!). Price: Very reasonable! Service: Self serve keeps it quick and cheap! Location: In the heart of Paia town. Easy walking from the free parking lot.
(5)
Shaun W.

Wow. Great food!!! Reasonable price. Order at the counter, it's up in no time. Best Ahi I had this trip and frankly....in along time. Worth the drive!
(5)
Colin H.

Tacos were bland, tortillas a bit like cardboard. Clam chowder was too thin and tasteless. The slaw was pretty refreshing though. This was my first foodstop in Maui, although the seafood seemed fresh - it wasn't cooked too well. The best thing at this place were the fries which were fried and seasoned almost perfectly. For the best fish tacos you have to go to Coconut's fish cafe in Kihei.
(2)
Dennis L.

Our resort recommended Paia Fish Market after hiking Twin Falls! Finding parking was a challenge but it was worth it to have the Fresh Fish Mahi Burger! The cajun spice is perfect. It's like fish getting grilled after it's caught. It proved to be a great place to go to after a physically challenging day. The ambiance has a very "surfer" feel since Paia is known as thee destination for windsurfing.
(4)
Maddie C.

Really yummy fish, any kind of fish, just get it grilled and you'll get it right. We came here twice during the week and here's what we got: 1. Opakapaka--light, flaky, sweet and delicious. Grilled PERFECTLY. Not too overdone, not underdone. Just amazing. 2. Opah (moonfish)--a little firmer than the Opakapaka, but still sweet. YUM. Again, perfectly cooked. 3. Mahi Mahi--best we had in Maui that week. 4. Ono--I'm not a big fan of ono (since it seems like boring white fish to me) but this one was cooked so perfectly that w/a touch of lemon, it was delish. The only downer here are the crazies (I'm looking at you large rude people from the mid- west) sniping tables and trying to squeeze us around in our seats WHILE we were eating, and trying to sit with us before we were done. Seating is communal, which means sadly you will have to get competitive when you're looking for seats, while you're eating (gotta watch your back for the crazies trying to steal your seat) and even getting out of your seat (some girl blocked me from getting out since she was trying to take my seat before I even got out of it, WITH MY TODDLER IN TOW. RUDE.) Smack down the crazies and you'll be fine. I can't believe some people actually think that their behavior is fine until you yell at them. The sides that come w/the grilled fish plate ain't nothing special, but whatever, it's all about the fish. If you don't fancy the sides (and the fish plate price tag), get the fish burger version. It's the same thing, without the fancy. And that cole slaw that comes with is actually pretty friggin good too.
(5)
Christina S.

My boyfriend and I recently ate at Paia Fish Market on our trip to Maui. I had read lots of good reviews, though some not so good in travel books, but still decided to put it on our to-do list. I was sadly disappointed with my meal. I got the fish tacos, and they were very bland, no taste at all really. The potatoes that came with it were great though. My boyfriend ordered a platter and that fish was better than mine, though for the price, it was not worth it in my opinion.
(3)
Karen T.

We stopped here on the way back from Hana and had the fish tacos and Obama burger. It was a really long wait but the Obama burger was really good.
(3)
Jyoti C.

AWESOMEEEEEEEE! A must must must try on your way to Hana or on your way back in Paia..a great place to have fresh fresh fish..amazing fish burgers...I want one now :(
(5)
Garry Y.

Fresh, fresh, fresh seafood. I had the fish and chips, yeah i know healthy food made unhealthy. The lines were long but they got the food out within 15 minutes, you order at the counter and wait for the food then wait for a table. You most times will have to share the picnic table with strangers but that makes it a fun experience. This is a must try place, also save room for dessert and have Ono Gelato across the street, make sure you look both ways as the traffic is crazy bad.
(5)
Amanda C.

I'm not a fan of seafood but I heard so much about this place and their fish tacos, I had to try some. They were fantastic! My daughter got the Mahi Mahi fish and chips and we all helped her eat them they were so good.
(4)
Jennifer L.

Their fish HAD NO TASTE and terribly OVERCOOKED The corner we sat down was dirty and SMELLY. Their restroom was disgusting.
(1)
Law Offices Of Louis J. Esbin E.

Heard great things! But, Fred's in Kihea and Kimo's in La'Haina had better, tastier and more generous fish tacos!
(1)
Cherish H.

Yum Yum Yum. This place is awesome. We ate here twice in the week. Not only is it situated in a unique little town with contrasting tourists and dreadlocked locals, but it is delicious food! Fish tacos, chicken tacos, & french fries were all amazing. The seafood pasta was filled to the brim with seafood, and the portions were huge. The food was all quite tasty. The cole slaw was unique, and a good unique that was. It was very tasty, with a tang and not mayo-y like most are. Going around 2PM or 8PM on a weekday proved to be great, we easily found seating in the cafeteria-type setting. Yummilicious Factor = A
(5)
Harish C.

It's right there at the Paia main intersection. It has good food in a low ambience place with picnic tables. It has fresh seafood and tacos. Just because the place looks like a dump with picnic tables doesn't mean the prices are low. They are high as well. There could be some wait time to get seats or to order food.
(4)
Rina C.

ordered the moon fish. supposed to be soft and moist according to the description but it's not. side dishes are not good either the seafood chowder is decent. bathroom is gross very disappointed. but Paia doesn't have many restaurant. ..............
(2)
M S.

Great atmosphere, fresh fish, excellent prices. My wife and I discovered this place by accident on our honeymoon and ended up going back several times. Would highly recomend!
(5)
Dusty B.

Was back on island for work. And, we drove way out of the way to nab one of these Mahi burgers. How are they so moist and delicious? The slaw on top definitely creates a unique flave profile too. I really love this spot and hope they keep it exactly the same for years to come.
(4)
Russ H.

True FRESH FISH with tremendous value. One of the best parts about this restaurant is that you can get a high quality meal at a reasonable price; yes, seafood is expensive, but there is nowhere else on the island where you can get seafood that is this consistently fresh at this price. If the line is long and you anticipate drinking more than one beer, suggest buying two and requesting that the cashier keep one on ice. They did this for me and it was quite a good idea!
(5)
Allison L.

Searching for a good meal before starting our trip to Hana - this place was perfect! I can't pick what was better - my fish tacos, or Mr. L's Obama burger! On our trip to Hawaii, we both fell in love with the fish Ono, which was the star of the Obama burger - blackened cajun seasoned, topped with wasabi butter and cooked perfectly. And fish tacos were excellent too - huge portions. I took some of the extra wasabi butter (extra butter?? a southern gal has never heard of this, but it's the blessing that comes to being married to a west coaster), from the ono burger and put it on my tacos and that was even better! That should be an option. Communal seating, condiments shared on the tables, order at the counter and pick up your food when your number is called --- perfect beachy ambiance!
(5)
Suzy F.

Paia is a great food destination on Maui. Paia Fish Market is the best place in Paia to get fish burgers and tacos. The restaurant is clearly popular, the food is served pretty quickly, and it's more reasonably priced than other places on Maui. My husband got the fish tacos, which he liked but didn't think were crave worthy or super remarkable (Coconuts Grille Fish Tacos are THE best on Maui based on what we sampled). I got a Mahi burger. I thought it was outstanding, and I was very happy with my order. I highly recommend the fish burgers! The fish portion is plentiful, cooked and seasoned to perfection. The onion rings were very good, large rings and large portions, but they weren't a culinary take on onion rings.
(4)
Dana S.

A perfect lunch spot to perch on a communal bench, flip thru the real estate guides, and enjoy some tasty fish while wishing you had a cool $2.5 mil to plunk down on a "beachfront plantation-style estate". The tacos were pretty good (I think I just prefer them baja style), the ahi burger was really good (remember to ask for it rare), and the fish and chips were fantastic. The portions are huuuge tho, so you might consider splitting.
(4)
Caligirl P.

Yum yum in the tum! Whether you are hanging in Paia for the day, passing through on the Road to Hana or just looking for fantastic seafood in Maui - without breaking the bank I might add - this is the place - counter order and food is up pretty quick to the delight of your palette : )) Great people watching too!
(5)
Todd B.

I just freakin' love this place! Easily my fav casual dining place on Maui. Very casual atmosphere with community tables; order at the counter. Amazing fish tacos (recommend getting them blackened with a split of home fries and cajun rice along with the slaw). Not the cheapest casual meal you'll find, but for the quantity and quality of food you'll get, you'll never beat it. Mix those tacos with an ice cold Big Swell IPA or a Coconut Porter and you'll be happy each and every time.
(5)
Gregory A.

Don't know what happened to my old review of this place from back in Feb. I had the special which was the Opah fish sandwich. Opah is my new favorite after eating that sandwich. I was even able to convince mt 2 girls to try it who do not like fish, and they loved it. Would drive any distance on Maui to go here. A little pricey but what isn't on Maui. Don't go expecting a quiet table to yourself as it is a family style shared table Fresh Fish Market eatery!
(5)
Midnight B.

So I just literally ate there a few hours ago and just got to my hotel room now and I am writing my review from here, that's how good it is I had a fish taco, everyone loved what they ate. Instead of spending an arm and a leg at Mama's Fish House I'd go here, seriously... Yes Mamas is good but its not that good to spend $50 something a plate. For fish??? ' Anyway, back to PFM, amazing food, amazing service, great variety. Its no wonder this place is packed. Go here
(5)
Jon-Rachel Y.

The only a two ways I like fish prepared is either raw or fried. But after visiting this establishment, I can add grilled to that list. This small joint in Paia on the corner of Baldwin and the Hana highway is place that should not be missed. Their colorful menu boasts plenty of local fish served in a several styles or you can have pasta, burgers, or other seafood items. There are about 6 tables and benches with condiments/utensils station at each table so find a spot quickly since the customer turn over can be quick. The decor is covered with fish pictures and flowers up front. At first, I had entree envy when I saw others ordered blackened fish, but the food we ordered was fresh, flavorful and satisfying. There is no parking so find the public parking lots either on Baldwin or Hana if there is no street parking. No restrooms, but the organic grocery store on Baldwin has them. What we ordered (~$20): - Ono burger - highly recommend - Fried shrimp - the tarter sauce and cocktail sauce was great - Use the Tiger sauce on the tables When we went: - Friday @ 12:00 Will we return: - yes
(5)
Arleen B.

A definite stop when on vacation in Maui every time we arrive. Great choices, only fresh fish, and some meats, island fare. Good prices, friendly and in a town great to visit and walk around.
(5)
Robin M.

Parking was a bit of a challenge, and when we arrived (7:30pm on a Monday) the place was packed, but an entire table cleared up as soon as we left. The tables are communal style so we grabbed two seats at the end. FYI, this place is really noisy when full. I had the fish tacos, hubby got a mahi burger and fries.
(4)
Sarah F.

Small little restaurant, super busy but worth every penny and the wait. My son ordered the fish n chips (please note he doesn't like fish n chips but he didn't see anything else he wanted) and he gobbled it all up and declared that he LOVED it! My husband and I had the grilled ahi tuna plate with fries and slaw and it was unbelievable. The fish was extremely fresh and cooked perfectly. The only sad part was that we were staying too far away to come back. If you love fish you will not be disappointed.
(5)
Marguerite A.

So de-le-sious! The food melts into your mouth! I love this place. We have been so lucky never have had to wait in any long lines. We have met some really nice people there! Prices are great! See ya in Feb.
(5)
Kevin T.

Heard about this place from "The Best Thing I Ever Ate" on the Food Network. We were heading back to the Mainland that day and took a slight detour to have lunch on our way to the Maui airport. The guy on the show recommended the Fish Tacos as The Best "Snack Food" he's ever eaten. While the Fish Tacos were delicious, it was the Blackened Mahi Mahi Fish Sandwich that was the standout. I still dream about it and will definitely make a trek there no matter where on the island of Maui I am staying. TIP: Lines can be long, so timing is everything. We fortunately got there about 15 minutes before they opened and were the first to order. There was a line out the door within a half hour of opening.
(5)
Gayla B.

Good food! Always busy, so probably not a good idea to bring a huge crowd in or other wise there will not be enough seating.
(4)
Lindsay L.

This is one of my favorite stops when I'm in Maui. Luckily, on this last trip I was able to have two lunches there and sample some new dishes. Every time I've been there, I always get the fish taco - because they are SO delicious! Obviously, this time I still got the fish taco, but I tried it with the plate dinner which included fries and cole slaw. Definately a repeater! The next lunch we shared the fish entree and it was delicately cooked and full of flavor. Thank you Paia Fish Market for taking such good care of us!
(4)
Kristy L.

Great fresh fish! We had the tacos and the fish & chips and they were both really good. The line can be crazy long, and you share communal picnic tables, but the experience and food were both worth it!
(4)
Alan L.

This place was packed and that's always a good sign. There are so many options that I wanted to keep coming back to try the other meals. I had the charbroiled fish and the plate was pretty big. The preparation was a little bland as it was just charbroiled fish probably with a little salt and pepper. But the fish tasted fresh. I'm just waiting until I can go back and try another dish.
(4)
Capt. Van Vliet H.

Love this place! Great for lunch and the fish is cooked just right and is always fresh. The atmosphere is breezy and makes you feel on vacation immediately. Love the owners and workers vibes too.
(5)
Eric S.

Best fish sandwich I had in Maui. Grilled Mahi-Mahi sandwich with coleslaw was awesome, as was the fish and chips. The line gets backed up quick and there is limited seating, otherwise, its a great place to visit if you're in Paia (which you should be for at least part of your trip). Prices are fair as well.
(4)
Fred K.

This place is great. We try to get here every time we go to Maui. Our favorite is the fish and chips. You have to get there early because they do run out - they're that good. When we arrived we were able to find a place to sit. Before we left, the line was out the door. The service is good to. We ordered 3 fish and chips and after we sat down and just before getting the order we noticed that only two were on the ticket. I went up to the counter and mentioned the mistake and they expressed the order. Of course, i think that the two orders would have easily fed the three of us. The down side to them being good is that the price has gone up over the years Supply and demand. We demand it and they supply it :)
(4)
Greg T.

Worth the wait and the $$$$. This isn't inexpensive, but it doesn't break the bank. Drinks are the exception, however. Seating is tough, so see about saving a spot or taking it to go and skipping the table.
(4)
Brad S.

Very good. Should have been easy to find, but google maps let me down, and took me a mile down Baldwin Dr, when it is right at the corner of Baldwin and Hana Hwy. It's about 10 minutes past the airport -- 15 minutes if the traffic is a little heavy. You order at the kitchen, I ordered an Ono Burger with fries and a Coke (about $15). Then fight for a seat at the communal picnic tables. I might have gotten the MahiMahi if I had it to do over again, though I'd had good Mahi the night before. The burger (a chargrilled fish sandwich) was excellent. The fries are nothing special, but have a little cajun seasoning on them to give them a touch of spice. A very good meal.
(4)
Dave Y.

Found it on Yelp while on the mainland...headed there straight off the plane (boy did we stick out)...Fish Tacos with a a Big Swell IPA...Awesome. more on a plate than you can eat and really good quality. before we headed to the west side of the island we had to stop back in for another round of fish tacos. After a few days on island we blended in. there are a handful of long tables that you share with others and each time we found conversation with our fellow diners. One even ran out to their car so they could give us their road to Hanna CD. Chill setting. nothing fancy. Just really good food and friendly people.
(5)
Jorgen M.

If you are in Maui and you are lucky enough to be staying in or around Paia, you have to go here. The Mai-Mai Fish sandwich is hands-down the best fish sandwich around. Served uber fresh with a great coleslaw ( call it coleslaw really does not do it justice) and in a great HI bread bun. Other dishes here to try are the Fish Tacos and of course Sashimi. The decor is rustic HI fish house and its always full...for good reason. A must go to place
(5)
T J.

Someone at work recommended trying this place out and I am glad that we did. We did arrive right at lunch time when there was a long line almost to the door, so try to go outside of that time as we waited 30 minutes for our food and there was nowhere to sit.
(4)
Triple C.

This place is always busy and there is a reason for that...great fish at good prices! It will be hard to find a better combination of the two! I had the Obama burger and while I am not a fan of his policies, the burger in his namesake could run for office and win! Cajun style ono that is huge! I am not sure how big but it felt like 10 ounces, far exceeding the radius of the hamburger bun that tried in vain to contain this beast of a fish filet! All this for 10 bucks! I have also had the mahi fish and chips. Excellent as well but wasn't a big fan of the fries. The fried potatoes are better in my opinion. The coleslaw was great too! I finished that and I rarely touch coleslaw! The seating may seem cramped as there is elbow to elbow seating on benches. I have to admit I was apprehensive at this arrangement bit I have been back several times and each time I always meet someone eating next to me who share the comraderie of enjoying the same delicious food! Makes it kinda fun!
(5)
Darron N.

Awesome fresh fish
(5)
Gwen M.

The locals love it. 'Nuff said? Seriously though, friends had Mahi mahi fish and chips and I had a great grilled mahi sandwich. YUM! Shared tables. Relaxed expectant atmosphere delivers with great food at very fair prices. My top pick for the trip. Loved it.
(5)
Kendra N.

While I worked on a full time basis (and especially after marrying a foodie), I got adjusted to "eating the good life". But then, grad school happened and so, eating the good life became eating on a budget. While in Maui, we were in the mood for some good local fish. Mama's Fish House was the popular recommendation but after seeing the average price per plate, we opted for the cheaper Paia Fish Market. Am I happy with the decision I made? Well, let's just say if I didn't believe in serendipity, I sure do now. Paia Fish Market is my M&M- my Maui MUST! It's just a 10-15 minutes away from the airport. Parking might be a challenge but there's a small lot up the street. Parking is free, by the way. We got the Ono fish Burger $8.50 and Fish Fajitas $15.95. I guess the Fish Fajitas was good but after eating the Ono fish burger, nothing I could have eaten would have even come close. The fillet was moist and not "fishy" tasting at all. Also, the burger is pretty huge, so with fries it's enough to feed my normal sized local hubby and me, small local Asian girl. It was pretty late at night, around 8 pm, but still slightly crowded. However, we didn't wait an unreasonable time for our food and luckily got the last table. I can just imagine if we arrived earlier, I might be writing a different review. So if you're planning to to eat here during the peak meal times, I would suggest ordering it to go and having an impromptu picnic somewhere. Unfortunately, since this first experience, I'm a devoted Ono fish burger eater so I can't comment on any of the other dishes... and to be honest, I probably never will be. Because if I'm in Maui and I only got enough room for one entree per meal then the Ono fish burger is what I'm eating.
(5)
Ana C.

This was a really great place to eat our last evening in Maui as we were slowly making our way back to the airport after exploring the road to Hana. I had their "Obama" burger which was a fish burger with wasabi on it. It was awesome! Portions are really generous, the beer on tap is good, the prices are great. Food came up pretty quickly and we enjoyed sharing our table (think picnic tables) with a local. Their local beef burgers are also really good, as that's what husband enjoyed. I would come back here for sure and enjoy another fish burger. They had tons of fresh fish available, too, at market prices, that you could have prepared different ways which I liked the idea of. They did not have a happy hour, though, but a lot of other places around do.
(4)
Chen C.

Simple charbroiled opakapaka, with rice and coleslaw. Very tasty fish, good rice, decent cole slaw. A little overpriced.
(4)
Anne S.

Ate here while vacationing in Maui. This was the best meal at the best price on our trip. The food is top notch, super fresh, and you can tell the locals hit this place up all the time. Lunch or Dinner. Get it.
(5)
Marcia K.

First time we had lunch, we loved it. Food was fresh, line was long, but it's the best fast food we've ever had! I always love getting something different than my husband so we can eat half and trade. Mahi Mahi Sandwich is delish, and the fish & chips are great! Bring your patience, and your appetite. This place is a MUST TRY.
(4)
Sunny B.

Is there a place where I can eat fish served by hippies?! Hells yeya! Super good fish cooked/served 5 ways. The sides are all fried and fatty so if you're in the mood try here for lunch. Beer and wine only. There is a yummy gelato place across the street to finish the meal sweetly.
(3)
Kathrin S.

Our zip line instructor told us this is the place to eat in Paia. We got there at 1:00pm and there was a long line to order your food but it was definitely worth the wait. I ordered the Ono burger and it was delicious. My husband ordered the fish tacos also delicious. Only downside is seating is scarce so one needs to waited in line to order and the other needs to stake out for a table.
(4)
Rachel P.

Eh. Fish tacos were overrated. No flavor and missing spice or cilantro or anything. Weirdly served with tartar. No need to return.
(2)
Sanam T.

All I can say about this place is WOW. The food was excellent. We ordered the fish sandwich and fish tacos. The both were great, but the fish tacos are the best I have ever had. This place is very casual and has a communal feel. I wish we had discovered this place earlier on our trip. I would have gone here more often. I would skip the other fancy restaurant and go directly to this place. You will love their food. There is something for everyone.
(5)
Angela C.

This was recommended to us by a local. They said that this is as good as (and cheaper than) the more famous "mama's fish house" if you're in the mood for fresh fish. Great ambiance. Fun, casual and fair prices. You order at the counter and have a seat at one of the long tables. You'll likely be sitting elbow to elbow with other folks. I didn't find it uncomfortable at all. It felt right in this little place.
(5)
Sasha R.

We happened by on the way to Hana, and went back again for takeout for the perfect pre-flight dinner. Fish. And. Chips. we tried other things, but that was the clear winner. oh, and the onion rings. and how.
(5)
Jason P.

Take a look at the menu and when you're ready, order by the counter and wait for your number to be called. Then grab a seat along any one of the ~7 wooden cafeteria-like tables. For lunch, I ordered the Mahi Fish and Chips ($11.95) which includes slaw, tarter, and French Fries. Three rectangular pieces of super-meaty (about 1" thick and 3" long) mahi mahi that is far from dry. The fish was perfectly fried making for an awesome fried fish, complimented with their homemade tartar sauce that was just out of this world. The crunchy cole slaw was plain with no distinguishable taste, almost tasting that of what it was, cabbage. The fries were also pretty good, but I just couldn't get enough of the mahi mahi deep fried to perfection. I also had a chance to try the Fish Taco (lunch) ($9.95), which is a corn tortilla with salsa, fresh lettuce, tomatoes and cheese. It is also complemented with the hand cut crunchy coleslaw, homemade tarter sauce, and a choice between Cajun rice or French Fries. This dish was somewhat very similar to mine except you received bits of fish tossed on a small 4" tortilla with the other fresh ingredients. For the price, I'd definitely go with the meaty Fish & Chips for a couple dollars more. A 16 oz. clear plastic cup that can be used at the soda machine will bring you down $1.75. The ambiance is cozy, with the bench tables back-to-back. Expect to share your table with other visitors to Maui or the locals. Share your experiences with one another, maybe ask for a few recommendations on places to check out.
(4)
Abby L.

We went here at the end of our trip, on the way to the airport, and we agreed that this was easily the best fish preparation we had the entire trip at a fraction of all the resort and chain dining. I had the Obama burger (blackened Ono with wasabi butter) - every bite was juicy and flavorful! My fiancÃ© had the mahi mahi fish tacos which he said was the best he ever had, and of course, we washed everything down with Maui brewing co beers. Well worth the side trip to the fun and eclectic city of Paia!
(4)
Boon K.

We love this place so much we kept coming back. They make the best ono burger I have ever had. I love the fish tacos too so I also almost want to get both. The wasabi butter on the burger is what makes it so go and they cook the fish just right. We got lucky and they had the sashimi available and it was so fresh and had a clean taste you didn't need soy sauce or wasabi, it was perfect plain. I think while we were only here for a week, we went at least 4 times.
(5)
Brandon L.

The place was popping and super good. The prices are reasonable for Maui and the atmosphere has a buzz to it. The Mahi Mahi fish and chips were nicely breaded and very moist. The garlic grilled upahkaka?? was awesome and the dipping sauce that they had was delish. The Obama burger with Ono was super good. Who would have thought shredded cheddar and swiss would work so well on the burger. Also the Cajun rub on the fish wasn't overpowering. You have to go here. Forget Coconuts, go to the real deal.
(5)
Tiffany Y.

I still have dreams about this place. The amazing cajun seared ahi steak was to die for. Never had anything like it since.
(5)
Diana Lyn Z.

Yum yum yum! Went here specifically to try the fish tacos because of the show "Best Thing I Ever Ate!" In addition to the fish tacos, we ordered the ono burger. I swear, it was the quietest meal we had. Everything was soooo good and we just scarfed everything down! The coleslaw was fresh. I loved the wasabi mayo that went with the burger. Added a nice amount of spice to the burger. Everything was just fresh and delicious and I definitely would come back here again. Next time, though, I do want to try the Obama burger!
(4)
D C.

Wow! This is just the word to describe the food here! It's simply delicious! We had the Ono and Mahi burgers. They are so tender and fresh. The flavor is just sensational! Thought the chowder would fail to deliver, but it was surprisingly good! One must also try the fish tacos. It's just as fresh and tasty as the burgers. The meat is so tender. This is certainly the place and perhaps the only place we would visit again for food in Maui!
(5)
Manong P.

This is the spot for fresh fish and good food. As good as it gets. Minus the ambiance, view, and presentation, this is better than Mama's Fish House. I ordered the Cajun style Ahi, which happened to be their catch of the day. Boy was it fresh. That thing was probably caught early morning and served at lunchtime. The seasoning was your standard Cajun seasoning, but what made it even better was the freshness of the tuna. Perfectly cooked, not overcooked like most seafood spots tend to do. Served over rice and it was quiet time for me. Service was excellent and they really do know their fish. If you have questions about what goes with what, the cashier will know and the cook in the back knows even more. He'll break it down to the smallest bit. I like how it's shared seating. Long table and benches, you sit with everybody else. it's a get in, get out type of spot. You don't sit there and chit chat after, there's a lot of folks waiting for a seat at the door. Prices here is very reasonable for the quality and quantity of food that you get. You can't miss this place. Corner of Hana Highway and Baldwin Ave, that's like their Hollywood and Highland.
(5)
Manu D.

I'm so glad we found out about the Paia Fish Market using Yelp!!! Definitely worth a stop if you're in Paia or on the road to Hana. The fish tacos were excellent: FRESH fish, quality greens and tomatoes, and their tartar sauce was excellent. One of my sons doesn't eat fish, so he ordered the cheeseburger. He was also very pleased. Also, the food was moderately priced but the portions were very good value for your money. Can't wait for our next trip to Maui and we'll definitely come back to this quality establishment.
(5)
Gracie L.

Two stars because my fish wasn't terrible, so those are for the cooks. But bad service because of the gal at the front counter- Laurie. We waited in line, and mind you we were the only ones in line, except for the young man in front of us whom Laurie took quite an interest in. We stood there while she talked and talked and totally ignored us. To wrap up this review Laurie didn't get a tip from us, and I shan't be returning.
(2)
Thao N.

We went for lunch after our visit to Hana and it was just eh. It wasn't bad but it was nothing to write home about. We ordered the fish taco which was, in my opinion, bland. We also ordered the Ono burger. My husband said that the fish was very flaky, which he loved, but again bland. They served it with coleslaw and to us it was a little too sour. I wouldn't go again just because there are so many other places we want to try.
(3)
qirk z.

Awesome mahi burger!! You get a very large slab of fish, soft bun, and tasty addons. Fries were disappointing. Wish I had another.
(4)
Sarah G.

Paia is a fun town to explore as a tourist and there are several restuarants to choose from. Our relatives recommended Paia Fish Market and I am glad they did. Fun, relaxed atmosphere. Great food. We both got a fish sandwich. Huge piece of fresh fish topped with yummy coleslaw on a toasted bun. The sandwich is a meal in itself but I can't pass up fries. The fries were good too. Next time I am in Maui, I am going back.
(5)
Tania G.

Ugh, this place was so not worth the money. One caveat, I did not try the fish tacos or burgers that everyone raves about. My goal was to have a caesar salad with some fresh fish. The ono was extremely dry with no taste. The cocktail dressing that came with it was just ok, nothing special. Caesar dressing was blah. All in all, felt like some garden variety caesar salad you'd buy in some third rate coffee shop in a hotel or prepackaged at the airport. Bland, bland, bland. Not something I'd pay $15 for again or stand in a long line for. Definitely not better or fresher than Mama's. Speaking of the line, its long & runs the middle of the joint. You are constantly having to move aside and getting jostled by other customers/employees. Yelp says yes for wheelchair accessible? Techinically, maybe but it would be really uncomfortable, I would take one look in there at that line & seating setup and roll right on by. I won't be back. Next time I am craving a good caesar salad with fish, you'll find me at Cafe O Lei at the Dunes. For good fish tacos, I'll head over to Lahaina, Leilani's at Whalers' Village.
(1)
Nancy G.

For the very first time in my whole life, I had two of the best foods I've ever tasted in one place. Fish tacos and onion rings. Yes, the fish tacos ARE as good as everyone says. Tons of fish loaded on top of the tortilla with lettuce, tomato and some sauce. The fish is grilled mahi mahi and you can tell it's super fresh. I can't really explain it properly, other than saying that it really is the best fish taco I've ever had. The Sweet Maui Onion Rings are fantastic as well. Sweeter than regular onion rings with a great crisp on the outside and soft and hot inside. This is a must try in my opinion because it just really is the best I've had ever. And I'm a girl who likes her onion rings. It's super casual here, you go up to the front and order your food, then find any space you can at the long tables.
(5)
Robert K.

Good for take out lunch only. Packed atmosphere with park benches to eat on which you share with other customers. Counter order your deep fried food and stand in a NYC subway car at 5 p.m. feel unless you can share a table. Prices are very high for mostly fried food, zero atmosphere and mobbed by tourists who dont know there are way way better places to eat a few feet up the road on Baldwin Ave like Mambos or Cafe des Amis
(2)
Suzanne R.

We stopped here on our way back from Hana, I didn't eat but my husband picked up the Grilled Ono fish plate, it came with cajun rice and coleslaw. He took it back to the hotel and sat alone enjoying everybite. He said it was very good and that he might go back during the week to get some more. He chose to give them four stars. Compared to a lot of the other places we ate at on our trip it was pretty darn good :)
(4)
Archie R.

Before I took my first bite. I don't care that food network came here and called these the best fish tacos around. I'm from California, we practically invented fish tacos, I refuse to believe that any... After first bite. I take it all back. These bastards are delicious. Basically you pick your fish and then you pick the style you want (grilled, Cajun, etc) and you pick your sides. I opted for the Mahi Cajun with rice and slaw. My only complaint is that you have to get the same style and the same fish if you get two tacos. No variety here. If you're staying in kapalua or kaanapali, make sure you stop here when you land before you make the drive. Parking sucks but this place is worth it. Surf.
(5)
Michelle N.

After the long road to Hana, a bite to eat (and a nap) is exactly what I need! From both word of mouth as well as Yelp, Paia Fish Market was a definite stop on the way back to the hotel! Honestly - the BEST mahi burger that I've ever had. Hands down. Granted, since I'm not too veggie friendly, mine was wiped pretty clean - but great nonetheless! They have huge benches to sit on so you get a pretty "homey" feel. The downside... it's a tad pricey - for the hubby and I, we spent close to $30... not what I expect for "fast-food-ish" places. But hey... if you're on vacation... F IT!
(4)
Richard B.

It is all about the fish. All of the fish is locally sourced and fresh off the boat. Very high quality. I love the mahi mahi fish tacos. Simply prepared, but ono in flavor.
(4)
Renee M.

Sorry Obama, in this case, you did not pick a winner my friend..... Oh let me count the disappointments with you, Paia Market: - You are wayyyy overpriced for your pseudo fresh fish, and underseasoned main courses like the seafood pasta, and veggie quesadilla. (My grandma who only cooks Chinese food, makes a better pasta and quesadilla enuff said) - Service is painfully slow, and rude (Just because Obama came by doesn't mean you get to slack on your Customer service to the people who made you popular) - Biggest Failure: Taste...to be known for the fish and chips, and fish dishes, both the fish and chips, fish tacos, and grilled mahi mahi were all Terrible (emphasize on the Terrible) Fish and chips were soggy not crisp, fish tacos tasted like 2 day old fish, and grilled mahi mahi was over cooked, so ended up tasting like I was chewing on a rubber eraser (as many of you learned in kindergarden this does not taste good) - Tables are communal style: So you end up sitting next to some questionable characters (questionable in the sense of, you wonder do these people ever hear of a shower and some soap) or if your really lucky, you end up next to a super touristy group who have young children who just think your food and drink are perfect homes for their fingers, and toys....Yippieeee If you are a person with little to no taste buds come here, otherwise, go somewhere else.....
(2)
Steve C.

Second best fish sandwich on Maui compared to Coconut's.
(4)
Michael L.

Paia Fish Market is fantastic. The fish is very fresh, and the sandwich accouterments are delicious. The crispy shoestring fries are great, too. The restaurant can be very busy, so when you first enter it can appear quite difficult to get a table. It does take a little while to get your food though, which should provide time to scout out a table.
(5)
Matt S.

A good place to grab a bite to eat on the road to Hana.
(4)
Kenn D.

The bomb, period. Thought about this place for a year! (we travel to Maui annually). Learned from the local's PFM is way better than Mamma's and its true, plus you save $20 a plate eating at Paia's. This is a must stop if you are in the area. Actually, we drive 40 minutes one way each year just to eat here.
(5)
Laura M.

The husband is probably going to kill me for saying this... but the Fish Market is just... ok. He has been raving to anyone who will listen about this spot for the past year, and finally took me to try it while we vacationed in Maui. This little spot was cute and had a very beachy vibe. We ordered the Obama Burger and fish tacos. The burger was pretty tasty, and the fries were good. I really liked the wasabi-butter. Something to try and recreate at home, for sure. The fish tacos were pretty meh. I had anticipated large chunks of fish (fried or grilled, I didn't care)... but the shredded up fish meat was definitely not what I had in mind. Just looking around, there were people who looked like they might have ordered better than we did. The plates of fish 'n chips, shrimp, and other sea creatures all looked awesome... but alas, that isn't what was on my plate. This is definitely a place worth trying, but I don't think it is quite as fantastic as the die-hards claim.
(3)
Bert B.

With every trip to Maui, we are evermore drawn to the Paia fish Market. this hippie-infused, dreadlocked eatery of dubious appearance proves to be the most remarkable, best source of fish tacos, calamari, Ono fish sandwiches and great chips (fries) anywhere on this planet. I cannot comment on fish tacos throughout the rest of the universe. One recommendation, since you will inevitably have to stand in line to place your order, grab a seat at one of the picnic benches immediately upon arriving and have someone i your party stand in line to order. Otherwise, you may get your food and find yourself without a lace to eat it. My final conclusion: fly to Paia Fish Market, and if you have time later, see Maui!
(5)
James C.

It was definitely a popular place. There was nowhere to sit so we got a to go order and waited, and waited, and waited. Definitely not a quick option. I ordered the fish tacos and kind of thought, "meh, had better". The fish was good but no real flavor. I also got a side of onion rings, and those rocked. My GF got a fish burger that she dug and some rather ordinary fries. I'd try it again and eat in just to see if I missed something.
(3)
Angela T.

A great, laidback casual place with a large variety of fish on the menu. The fish and chips were delicious. The fish seemed like it came right out of the hot oil. It was crispy, hot and oh-so scrumptious. The portions were all huge and the prices were very reasonable. It's a great place for kids too, as the bench seating provides ample room for all.
(4)
Connie C.

Best fish burger ever! Hopefully will back to Paia soon! ^-^
(5)
Rony H.

I went in and ordered the fish quesadilla lunch order that comes with their cole slaw and a choice of a side of cajun rice, rice&potatoes, red potatoes or french fries. I got the rice, and it was alright. Their cole slaw isn't the typical shredded cabbage version, it's squared cut and comes in this dill flavoring. The cabbage is crunchy enough with having just the right amount of flavor without it being watery. The quesadilla had cheese and refried beans within, which comes with a dill tartar sauce and goes really well with the fish. It tasted good, but I don't know if I'd order that again. Their picnic bench style tables are pretty sticky to sit on, so that caught my attention, but they have all the amenities you need on the table--napkins from costco, metal forks and spoons and this sweet and hot sauce, salt, etc. It was nice to sit next to a couple talking about their first nudist beach experience while we waited for our food. I'll have to try the shrimp fajitas next time.
(3)
Ian R.

This is my favorite place to eat in Paia. Actually, it is my favorite place to eat on the island. I absolutely love the Mahi Mahi Burgers, with a side of fries. What can I say that hasn't already been said? The fish is cooked to perfection. It is always moist. The fries are a perfect soft crispy golden brown. YUM! I hear the cheeseburgers are amazing as well, but I've never veered away from the Mahi Mahi burger. Maybe someday when I feel I need a beef fix I'll try the cheeseburger, until then I'm happy with my regular order. I also love the fact that the tables are set up family style, where everyone shares tables with each other. If there is an available spot at a table it is easy to scoot in with a friendly "is anyone sitting here?" or "can I sit here", or "can I join you". You get the drift.
(5)
Pete E.

This is a one of the Islands best places to get a meal. Very low key place that has long tables, wait your turn grab one, maybe expect to share it with a local or two. Get in line and order your food, they will bring it to the table. Everyone loved their taco's, or plate lunch but the best item was a special called the Obama fish burger, no idea if the President has every eaten here as I think he vacations on Oahu, but this fish burger comes coleslaw, tomato and a special wasabi butter sauce, and it is the best grind on the island. You can pick your fish Ono, Mahi or sometimes some other fresh catch. Get some fries and a cold beer, and your in heaven. Wear your shorts, tee shirt and slippers this place is casual. Your going to love the food, and the price. Go across the street for a shaved ice afterwards.
(5)
Jeff C.

The fish tacos were pretty good. Large portions and about $11 for lunch. It is worth checking out!
(4)
Paul K.

That was one good fish sand at Paia Fish Mkt. It's one of the best meals we had in Maui when we were there a couple of years ago. It was also one of the cheapest meals we had in Maui! The fish sandwiches were around $9-10. We read rave reviews in Lonely Planet so we decided to make a stop on the way to the Road to Hana. The place was crazy busy and we were lucky to have found a couple of open seating pretty quickly. There is a large menu of fish to choose from. I tried their Ono on the first visit and Mahi on the second. They were both fresh and fantastic. We also had a few beers which went really well with the sandwiches, fries and coleslaw. It's kind of out of the way from civilization and it would be quite a drive to come just to eat here, but we did drive for an hour just to eat here on our second visit. The place is very casual with picnic/park benches instead of tables and chairs. It looks like a bait shop and has a fish shack look If I am ever back in Maui, I will be making a stop here.
(5)
C. K.

So far my favorite lunch spot on Maui. It has great fish and chips, but when I'm at home I dream of their Mahi burger. Firm and savory with just the right mixture of cole slaw and a sweet bun. My wife gets the Ono burger, also great, the fish is a little more flakey. Wash it all down with a Bikini Blonde Lager an you've got a 5 star lunch. The Paia Fish Market seems to be equally popular with locals and tourists, so seating at the picnic style tables is at a premium. You will likely wind up bumping elbows with your neighbor, but for me that's all part of the charm.
(5)
nicky f.

It's all about the fresh fish at Paia Fish Market. Order at the counter and patiently wait for the deliciousness that is being prepared (with love) for you. I wish I had a plate of fish tacos or some of the fish and chips right now, yummmmy. We also ordered the sashimi, which we didn't like as much as Mala Tavern, but it was still good. You don't get to eat at your own private table, so be prepared so sit with other people, or get your food to go. Food Network has been here and this is one of Paia Fish Market's recipes foodnetwork.com/recipes/â€¦ Oh!...they have icy cold beer on tap (:
(4)
Jonathan W.

This place is VERY low-key. No assigned tables, just benches. Usually a busy line to place your order and then a scramble to grab a spot long enough to chow down. You get a pick of the fresh fish of the day, ahi, mahimahi, opakapake etc. Your options are really just the dinner plate (charbroiled fish, rice, and slaw) ours was FAR TOO well done, fish and chips, (the mahi-mahi was soft and moist) and fish burgers or tacos (both were adequate and seemed favored by the locals). It is a popular place likely because it is fresh fish done fast food style. It is large portioned and greasy. Don't expect a tenderly well prepared fish entree. Nevertheless, for a quick lunch and avoiding the resort prices, not a bad option.
(3)
Joseph H.

Just to be clear: My girlfriend and I ate here 10-12 times over the course of a couple of visits to Maui. She loves fish and doesn't like red meat. I like red meat and normally don't eat cooked fish. But we both agree that the fish burgers here are amazing. They're the only thing I've eaten at the Fish Market. I generally avoid salmon (boring, and not local) and mahi-mahi (just boring). Ono is also a potentially bland fish. There are normally 5-6 different types of fish available on a given day so you can skip those and get something a little more flavorful and less cliched. If you came in and got a fish burger and it sucked, you were probably profoundly unlucky, and I'm sad for you, because frankly these guys do a better job with fish -- on the whole -- than places that charge 2-3x as much in San Francisco. The cajun blackened done medium is amazing, although you may wind up with it cooked medium well or well, in which case it's potentially just good to great. I have no idea what the hamburgers and other items are like. I don't care either! Actually I don't think I've ever had a hamburger in Hawaii that wasn't from Burger King (the one in Kona used to be GOOD!), McDonalds, or W&M.
(5)
Lizi C.

Best Mahi Mahi burger in the world!
(5)
Mike G.

Last stop before we left Maui after a two week vacation. Lived up the the reviews. Fresh fish tacos, with a solid choice of sides and nice slaw. Located in the funky little town of Paia, a must stop while in Maui.
(5)
Christine R.

Fish tacos are good but not best on island. Overall, friendly service and kind of fun to sit in communal style setting.
(3)
Ibbs K.

I read about this place in my handy Maui Revealed book and had to try it when they mentioned the magic words "Fish & Chips". The fish was fresh, fries were addicting as always, and the house cole slaw was delicious! We paired it with a regular 'ol garden salad with house dressing and a local brew. If I'm ever back in Maui (please let that be soon... PLEASE!), I will definitely have a meal here again.
(4)
Elisabeth Z.

FISH BURGERS! We celebrated our road to Hana victory with fish burgers from this location on the direction of several Maui regulars and we were not disappointed. Fresh and flavorful fish, well prepared. The rest of the menu looked great but we were on a mission for our first fresh fish of the trip. Both the Ono and the Maui Maui versions were considered delicious and I would absolutely go back for another one!
(4)
K M.

Hands down, best eats on Maui!
(5)
Maryrose S.

Fish tacos!!! We were lucky to arrive at the Paia Fish Market during it's down time. I can see how this place can pack up quick. I left my fish order with the husband while I scouted out a place to sit. Easy enough. Our order came quickly and I dived in. Perfect! The fish was prepared just right and was indeed, one of the best I've had in Maui. And I love my fish tacos. I look forward to going back!
(4)
Jen D.

Went here on my last day in Hawaii, and had the best meal of my visit there. I had a salmon burger (they were out of their Ono), and it was the best combination of items with that perfect fish, slaw, bun, and possibly illegal substance of some kind that seemed pretty out of this world at the time. After reading the reviews, I'm kinda glad I did this instead of Mamas. It was cheap, fast, and absolutely put me in some happy place.
(5)
Mandy A.

I give them 3 but my husband wants to give them 4 maybe because he was super tired after driving to Hana and back.... We had MahiMahi Burgers with a gigantic order of fries and two beers. Later on, i noticed they served Maui Brewing co. beer but i had already gotten the Hefe (Maui brew is the best!!!) Seating sucks cause it is a Fast food slow place....or a Slow Fast Food..... so many people there....so it must be a big hit to people! They have long "family style" picnic tables so be sure to have your buddy (or hubby) sit and hold seats while you order. Burger was big....good but not great. Do like the sloppyness of them though....
(3)
Nina M.

Place was pretty crowded when we got there. The tables are set up family style so be prepared to buddy up with whatever group sits down next to you. Otherwise everything was great! Not a bad deal for the price. I had a burrito meal (comes with fries) and it was plenty for two meals. Would definitely go back if I found myself in the area again sometime soon!
(4)
Kalyn B.

Get the burger. Seriously. Don't mess with fish tacos. The burger here with the coleslaw on it is STUPID GOOD. Get it medium-rare, don't get it well-done! The beef is from the island, pastured; the grass is from volcanic soil. Forget cheese, the beef is too good to play with. I don't even know what their fish tacos taste like. They could be good. Who cares about fries, etc., get the burger here and you'll be happy.
(5)
Mike P.

PFM -- No Ka Oi! My last trip to Maui (4 years ago) I went 3-4 times in 10 days. This trip I made it twice and it still has the best fish on the island for the price. Personally I don't bother with a sandwich--my girlfriend and I split the lunch plate and we were both stuffed! You get rice/potatoes and an amazing coleslaw (I think it had allspice).
(4)
Jeremy L.

I'm actually not a big fan, but that's not so much because of the quality of food, but because I don't eat fish often. My friends find this place to be the best. It's very popular and there is limited seating, so that can be stressful at times. I give it 3 stars because, while I'm not a fish eater, it is still a good place to eat especially if you like fish.
(3)
J S.

I have never seen a place so rude to people with food allergies. My wife, who is allergic to gluten and dairy, asked for a couple small substitutions and got eye rolls, sighs and refusals. There wasn't a long line... I'm allergic to dairy and when I verified that the fish wouldn't be cooked in butter, the woman shouted, "FINE, NO BUTTER!" After we'd ordered, she shouted, "I have a really complicated order!" I could understand if they were busy or even a polite refusal. I've never had someone give me such a hard time for having a food allergy. Food was good, but not worth the abuse.
(1)
Colleen C.

Had heard this place was a must for fish tacos... not a big fish taco fan, but decided I could find something worth trying. I gotta tell you, I was totally thrown off by the self-serve atmosphere and having to scrounge for a seat at at table with strangers. As put off as I was, I'm always willing to overlook lack of luxury for good food. I ordered the seafood pasta, thinking there's no way this place could pull off a decent pasta dish, but I live in AZ so nothing excites me about tacos and fajitas. You all can talk all you want about your ono burgers and fish tacos, but I can't imagine anything beating the giant bowl of seafood pasta I got (at dinner, mind you). Flavorful sauce with lots of parmesan, big chunks of fish, meaty shrimp, and scallops that melted in my mouth like pure butter. I was so full about halfway through that I had to just pick out all the seafood... absolutely fantastic! Again, the service (what service there was) was rude, the crowd was bizarre, the seating was difficult, and the gas-station-style restroom was just sketchy. But I'd elect to eat the food from this place over fancy-schmancy, over-priced Mama's down the road any day.
(5)
Sonia K.

Fish tacos were amazing, rivals any socal spot, wish it was around the corner from me I would be there at least once... or twice a week! ;)
(5)
Marc C.

Wow, this spot had the absolute best fish burger I have ever tasted! Ono Burger: Fantastic. The buns were grilled, the burger was dressed with cole slaw, a slice of tomato, and some cheese. This of course was followed by a nice slice of Ono that was perfectly seasoned to perfection. Once I had some lemon drizzled on the dressings, I put it together and took my first bite. It all just came together well. The cole slaw just works so well to balance out the seasoning on the fish. And talk about the fish, it was firm and not overcooked. I could eat this by itself (which I probably will next time). The buns weren't over powering like at other hamburger places. Overall, fantastic burger and I highly recommend it even if you don't like fish sandwiches. Onion Rings: These were good, but they're the reason why I'm holding back from 5 stars. The onion was great, however they use way too much breading and some pieces just taste like breading with little sign of onion. The pieces that did have a good chunk of onion were great though, you could taste the sweet maui onion flavor that is unique to these rings.
(4)
Walerz B.

All in all, I can see why people would love this place. In general the seafood is fresh and tasty but maybe my taste was off. Fried calamari: crispy and thick. But I don't like calamari steaks, I prefer the rings and the tendrils. Plus, the tartar sauce had a bit too much dill for my liking. Mahi burger: I didn't get to taste it but my friend and sister said it was delicious Fried mahi mahi fish: thick chunks of fresh fried fish. The first chunk was too dry. Everything else was good. Taste-less so the tartar sauce (that I didn't care for) and ketchup had to make do. Seafood chowder: yum! Lot's of seafood. Everyone was friendly and this place was packed with both locals and tourists.
(3)
Sanjeet A.

Had the mahi fish and chips. They were awesome! My wife had the mahi burger and loved it. Will highly recommend and will go again.
(4)
Whitten G.

Typical fish market fare in a quaint Hawaiian town. Excellent Ono and MahiMahi sandwiches! Fish and chips also quite good. Rounding it out was a locally brewed draft beer. Helps everything go down nice! Yum!
(4)
Catrina G.

Servings are generous and quality is great! Went here once, and had to go back a few more times. Highly recommended!
(5)
Virak R.

I LOVE THIS PLACE! This is a GREAT place to stuff yourself with some fantastic fresh fish! Yummy! The atmosphere here is relaxed and very kid friendly. What do you expect in Hawaii right? If you can't find a way to relax here you have other issues. A must stop while in Maui!
(5)
John L.

It was ok. The fish on my plate was good but the rest feels like an afterthought, they're just there just because. Nice cool atmosphere but some people were really territorial with the communal tables. All and all it was ok. Thought it was overpriced.
(3)
Kris Marie D.

Go with the Mahi Mahi Burger and home fries with a Bikini Blonde Beer to wash it all down. Cafeteria style seating, so cozy up and make new friends.
(5)
Big Room Nine X.

The biggest surprise this year for us on our visit to Maui. On other yelpers recommendation we tried this place out. The bad ~ lot's of bums or people who look like bums in the area. Old (very old) towne. I wouldn't visit Paia when its dark. Small restaurant and eating area...you have to share cafeteria style tables with strangers. The good ~ Best fish tacos hands down! Fresh fish...very fresh. After the tacos I had to try something else so I ordered the Ono burger. Fresh fish again. This place is awesome. Great hole in the wall. I wouldn't recommend this place for someone who wants a nicer setting.
(5)
Brad P.

Absolutely fantastic! Seafood chowder is excellent! The Cajun ono is fantastic! It was worth the drive from Lahaina
(5)
Alexandra C.

I lived on Maui for the first eighteen years of my life. This is by far one of the best seafood restaurants on the island. The food is top notch and I, personally, love the atmosphere. However, there is a constant fight for seating and it's not what you would call "comfortable." The seating is basically cafeteria style, with huge tables and benches. That's not a negative for me, but it can be hard to get a place to sit at lunch rush. It's not necessarily cheap, but for the food you're getting, it's a deal. The only thing on the menu I'm not impressed with is the rice. It's kind of bland.
(5)
Phillip D.

Fish Tacos here are way over-rated. It tastes suspiciously similar to Rubio's fish tacos, but only larger. It might be good by island standards, but it's nowhere as good as LA Taco Trucks or Cactus in Berkeley (personal fave).
(3)
Gloria K.

We went to Paia Fish Market after our long, harrowing day trip on the Road to Hana and back. We were hun-ga-ry! We arrived during peak dinner hour, which meant the place was packed. The tables are cafeteria style, so don't be shy about squeezing in with strangers. Also, don't be tentative about snagging a seat when you spot one. We both ordered the Ono Fish burgers with a giant side of fries. The fries were standard fare, but we gobbled them up because we were so hungry from hiking. The burgers were very good. The coleslaw that comes on top was yummy. In my opinion the fish itself was a bit bland, and definitely needed seasoning, which is easily remedied with all the spices and sauces left on the dining tables. Overall it was a satisfying meal. Not mind blowing amazing, but we left happy.
(4)
Rachael T.

Oddly, although they exclusively use flash-frozen fish, which keep their prices congruous with their informal and busy interior, and is something I usually shun on a tropical island where fresh fish literally swims all around as a local harvest-able foodstuff, I prefer the fish burgers at Paia Fish Market to many similar provisions on Maui. Specifically, I will order a Cajun-style Ono burger which is presented as simple as they come on a standard bun with standard slaw, shredded cheese and a tomato slice. I love to pour the Tiger Sauce they have readily available at each communal picnic table all over my burger, a side of fries and a nice cold beer. It keeps me coming back again and again despite my typical snobbery of all things flash and frozen.
(3)
Jared E.

Saw this shop featured on "The Best Thing I Ever Ate" on the Food Network and decided we had to stop while visiting Maui. We were not disappointed. In our group we had seafood pasta and the fish tacos. It was all amazing. The fish tacos, were the best fish tacos I have ever had, period. We will be going back whenever we make it to Maui again.
(5)
Bob D.

Solid - you order and find your own table. Had grilled fish with rice and slaw. Everything was good to excellent - the slaw was yummy - I saw a lot of fish and chips being served which looked good. This is not a place to sit down and dine - order, eat good grub and on your way. For sure a repeat, yet, not a full dining experience of a sit down restaurant.
(4)
Sam K.

"Enough!" I shouted in my head. So, after weeks of my gf nagging to go try their spectacular fish tacos and shit, I gave in so I can say ... I told ya so. I grew up on maui, I know my cuisine, I know my fish and my gf was doubting me on my knowledge of places to eat in on my old stomping grounds ... ah come on! She said it's gotta be good if Food network went there and so we have to try it. I was like, trust me, locals don't even go there and if they do ... it's the retards that don't know what fresh really is. I don't know why they call it Pa'ia Fish market when they don't sell any fresh caught fish ... like all the other fish markets i've been too around the world... that's fail in itself. If you guys like to go to a chinese restaurant full of white people, then you'll love this crap! This is just an over hyped place that locals don't frequent unless they are starving ... except the haoles that don't know what fresh is nor how certain cuisines should taste. There has never been anything good food wise in Pa'ia and it's true until this day imo, wait, Mamas Fish house is about it if you wanna shell out some cash. Food: Tacos GF got the fish tacos and I stood there watching the "cook" throw fish on the grill ... twas not fresh. Anyhow, she got the 2 tacos and rice, potatoes and slaw. The only fresh taste I got was from the tomatoes and lettuce, fish was cold and super dry. I know how fresh mahi mahi should taste if it was caught that day and cooked... the mahi mahi was about a week old. The rice was horrible because it was even cooked ... it needed another 5-10min because I'm not a fan of crunchy rice. The potatoes were the worst I've had because it was soggy as fuck! If they were going for forgetting to smash the potatoes after dumping the water then they succeeded. The cole slaw should've been called a salad w/ light slaw dressing. Burger I got the "local grown beef" burger because I saw the not so fresh fish they were throwing on the grill and I wish I didn't. I've should've known not to get a beef anything because the pattie was probably months old. usually a burger would ooze some juiciness and have some flavor, well, this was so dry and bland that it was like eating a mcdonalds burger. This was the worse experience we've ever had and I can honestly say this is the worse food I've ever had on the Valley Isle ... this place is NOT GOOD. We spent $30 on nasty ass food yelpers honestly thought was good, I cry for people that can't cook and don't know how things should taste because you guys shouldn't be giving out reviews. I gave it a star because the tarter sauce was good.
(1)
Jenny K.

loved the fish!!! shared a two taco fish taco and a fish burger. fish burger came with skinny fries. the burger had tartar sauce, grilled fish, sliced tomato, coleslaw. fries came with tartar sauce. fish tacos were also tasty as it was the same kind of fish and coleslaw. i eat my fish taco faster than most people cuz i don't believe in putting it down. if you put it down, it gets all messy...might as well eat the whole thing...inhale...lol.. but i'll have to say that this place reminded me of my favorite fish taco place back in cali...lazy dog cafe. my fav is $3 cheaper w/bigger portion. but anyways, this is a good place to get a bite to eat. really wanted to try all the other stuff people were ordering around us. everything looked yummy!!
(4)
Ellen J.

3.5 On a cloudy day, we made the trek from Lahaina to the north area. Originally, we were headed to Geste Shrimp Truck, but they were unfortunately closed due to weather :( So, we headed to Paia to give the next most raved about restaurant a try! Be forewarned . . . parking in Paia is tight and the Paia Fish Market does not have its own parking lot. It is worth finding parking to spend time in this little town that has a flowerchild-like feel. I've digressed . . . The restaurant is typical Hawaiian aloha with a walk-up counter to place your order. The seats are communal picnic-style benches. On this particular busy day, it would have made sense for one of us to stand in line and one of us to grab a seat at one of the tables. The menu has a lot to offer -- various fish plates and sandwiches. If you order as a meal, it comes with a side of your choice. I was set to order the ono burger, but then as I reached the counter, I saw a sign that gave me other fish choices, so I picked the opakakpaka (Hawaiian pink snapper). My sandwich was delicious - the opakapaka cooked to perfection! It was a little overwhelmed by the big old bun (nothing special). Hubby had the fish (mahimahi) tacos. He agreed that my opakapaka burger was far superior to his tacos. The french fries were thin and crispy and an adequate accompaniment to both meals. My husband thought the cole slaw was bland. Would I drive out here on our next trip just to go to the Paia Fish Market - probably not - but if you're out that way - especially on your way to or from the road to Hana, it is definitely worth it!
(3)
Blythe Z.

FISH TACOS!!! So, good you will want more! Stopped in here after our Road to Hana day trip. I love this town it's a very sleepy beach town, with a good vibe. Seriously, take my word for it get the Fish Tacos - oh also their french fries were pretty tasty too! Prices were very reasonable. Fast service, with community style picnic table seating.
(4)
Sharon M.

Man, this place was crowded all the time. We came here at night---crowded (went to Flatbread across the street instead) Came right before lunch---crowded Came at late lunch--crowded Reading a few of the previous reviews, I can see that they're known for their Fish Tacos (thanks Food Network!). However, i did not have the fish tacos which is probably why I have an A-OK rating. I had the chowder and fish and chips. Not bad. Not the best I ever had. A little forgettable. Had a taste of my bf's Ono burger---now that was yummy (dammit, why didn't I order the Ono burger? Oh because I had a fish burger the day before) Anyway, the portions are freaking huge, the food was better than mediocre, the service was speedy. I'd probably go here again.
(3)
Tom B.

Great fish tacos, fish and chips was good. Limited beer selection and of course overpriced (it is Maui after all...). Recommended. Note: somehow this review didn't get posted from my iPhone, but went into a "drafts" folder that I didn't know about... which is why it's getting posted almost 6 months after the actual meal occurred.
(4)
Kimberly H.

This was my second time in Paia, but my first visit to the fish market. If I make it out to Maui in the future, this will definitely be a spot that I hit! The town itself is an experience ... within 20 minutes I had gotten my face painted by a lady who would not take no for an answer, walked passed a coffee shop who's tag line was "haven't had an orgasm today? come in ... we can help!", saw an intoxicated man yell threw a window at a very large Hawaiian man holding a newborn, "you are so big, and that baby is so small, that's soooo awesome" haha, and smelled more second hand weed than being at a Pink Floyd Experience concert. After all this, we were starved and decided to try the place with the line out the door! Now, this place during peak hours in not for the faint of heart. Heard numerous people complaining that there was no where to sit (it's family style long tables). These people were like vultures watching every person's move and as soon as someone so much as shifted their weight, the whole line turned to watch. I just wanted to try the food, and I would have been happy to sit on the street which is exactly why I ordered mine to go. I went with the Obama Burger: fresh ono, Cajun style; topped with homemade wasabi butter and a side of cajun rice. About the time our food came up a seat opened up and we took it. The fish was excellent! I could have done without the rest of the toppings though, there were too many competing flavors. Wasabi butter, Cajun seasoning, coleslaw, tomato, shredded cheese, and tartar sauce. Next time I will know what to omit. I was happy that for once this trip the menu said wasabi and they weren't shy about it. It was nasal clearing goodness. I ate fast because I'm short, and with that many people around you, I frankly got tired of being that close to people's crotches. Moral of the story: try this place!
(4)
Amanda L.

Best fish tacos in Maui! We got the Fish Taco Platter which comes with 2 soft tacos with your choice of fish, coleslaw, and a side. We got one platter with Ono and Fries and another with Mahimahi and cajun rice. The fish tacos were loaded with fresh fish and was perfect with the salsa and tartar sauce. Note: each taco is wrapped with two tortillas to capture all that goodness. The cajun rice wasn't very interesting at all - skip this and just go for the fries. The coleslaw was chunky because the lettuce isn't shredded but still tasty. PS parking is a hassle, esp since it's a small town.
(4)
Michael C.

Believe the hype! I originally saw this place on the Food Network when they were doing a show on the best fish tacos in America. So when I went to Maui I decided I would eat at this place. Since I don't give five stars too often I will go ahead and write about my experience: Walked into the restaurant with one goal in mind. Get fish taco. Eat it. Drink beer. Repeat until stomach is in pain. We started out with calamari and the first thing that I noticed was how flavorful the fried pieces of squidy goodness were. They weren't calamari rings/spidery pieces that I was used to - they almost tasted like chicken tenders - velly velly good. The tacos themselves were AWESOME. Two corn torts, diced fish, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes. Pure heaven. The two tacos were served on top of a bed of fries and slaw, and with a side of tartar sauce. Worth the wait, worth the visit, this place is legit. The people I went with got the fish and chips and the fish was so perfectly fried and fresh that I could feel my toes curl as I ate the pieces that my guests begrudgingly gave to me. So if you're looking for your own cloud in fish taco heaven make sure that you visit Paia Fish Market ASAP the next time you're in Maui.
(5)
T H.

Oh Renne M. Your review of the Island's WALMART says more about you, then your review of the Paia Fish Market.... "2. I'm cheap, and hate paying $10 bucks for a bottle of water, when I can get a case of 24 for $6.99 3. I get hungry about a zillion times a day, and need to have muchies on hand, walmart sells me munchies at a fraction of the local resort price." Just thought I'd put that out there.. As for me, Eating here 3 times in 4 days, because I could. I don't mind talking to locals and tourists. I don't spend time in WalMart while I'm visiting Maui. I try to give my money to local businesses exclusively, if possible. Thanks for the fast service, even at the mad lunch time crunch. The Ono burger, so amazing I needed it two more times. The great price for the Island and treating me great, even though I wasn't a local.
(4)
Amy C.

Absolutely delicious mahi sandwich. I will definitely go back every chance I get.
(5)
Steve M.

Great food, fast service, bad parking.
(4)
Des D.

A tad pricey, but then you are in Maui and this is fine dining. Food is excellent and has a very clean taste to it. Room is fantastic and our wait staff were also very much up to the mark.
(5)
Alicia L.

I won't even rate the food. We were here with three adults and 4 kids, ages 5-10. Ordered full (and full priced) meals for each if them. A 15% (just over $15.00 in our case) gratuity was added to the ticket because we are a group of 6 or more....bear in mind that you wait in line to place your own order and then your number is called so that you can come pick up your order at the counter. Family style seating means you share your table. You are handed paper cups for your drinks. And you bus your own table...Gratuity for what!!!????? Shame on you!!!!!!!!!
(1)
Helen Y.

1 star for being a local place vs tourist trap 1 star for the location (cute downtown paia surfer town) 1 star for the prices minus 2 stars for the mahi mahi lunch plate that gave me an allergic reaction of some sort! BF: hmm you look really flushed me: oh I wore blush today BF: silence (walking around downtown paia) me: my face feels really hot BF: yeah i think you might be sunburned me: look at my arms, they are all red! BF: look at your face too! me: (looking in mirror) OH MY GOD BF: yeah let's get you some sunscreen me: but i don't feel burned? i don't tan THAT easily not sure what to say but either i have a new allergy or the fish plate gave me some sort of food poisoning.
(3)
Ann S.

We wanted to love this place but in the end, it just didn't impress us like it has other reviewers. The fish and fries were average. Given how loud it is and our dislike of community bench seating, we wouldn't go back.
(2)
Alison B.

This is my favorite place in Maui, by a landslide. Get the Ono burger and or the Mahi Mahi Fish n Chips. Both are spectacular. The seating is a clusterfuck when it is busy. This is mostly due to rude people "saving" 4-5 seats when the other members of their party are like 20th in line to order. People need to chill and realize that if they just wait in the line, seats will open up by the time your food is ready!
(5)
Jan L.

I love fish so this is a must visit place for me everytime I come back to Maui...the prices are a bit on the high side for my normal budget but I made it my one eat out meal for the day at least once while I'm here. The servings are generous and the options are plentiful. Try the Mahi, Ahi or Ono in the taco, fish-n-chip or salads. If you haven't had Ono before, it a bit drier than Mahi when cooked but just as tasty. Mahi is my favorite and usually love it in the tacos or just plain grilled with rice and coleslaw. What makes them stand out is the freshness of every meal. I love the decor and the service is superb...very patient when asking questions without having you feel rushed. Paia town is enroute to Hana so if you get the chance, see if you can come by on your way back from this wonderful day trip...I love the chill atmosphere in this little town and if you're up for dessert, Ono Gelato is right across the street from this place...and for a bit of organic food shopping before your trip to Hana...go to Mana Foods is across the street too but a few shops down.
(5)
Kimberly C.

It was so good, I had to come back a second time. Found this little place on the corner on Yelp and after reading reviews, I figure it was a place I should try. When we first went there, it was quite cloudy and I was not too pleased on the parking situation. We drove up and down the street before finally deciding to park in a residential area, hoping that nothing would happen to our car. It was pretty crowded when we got there, and I was able to grab a seat for my boyfriend and I. They have tables and long benches to eat, so you kinda had to be quick to grab a seat. I ordered the mahi burger, cajun style and my boyfriend had the mahi plate, cooked with butter and white wine. OMG it was delicious. The fish was cooked perfectly, so moist and flaky. The second time we came back, we both ordered the mahi burger, cajun style. Less crowded this time, and the day was gorgeous. I guess everyone would rather be at the beach, but we were heading back to the airport this time so it was a perfect place to catch one more meal before our trip. Four stars, just because parking was not so great.
(4)
SFCAFOX S.

LOVE this place, probably the freshest best quality fish tacos at $5 each on the whole island of Maui. If you want something light, skip the entree plate which comes with rice or potatoes, etc and just order the fish tacos ala carte at $5 each, 1 was perfect for a light lunch. I think we are going to try them for dinner too. Definitely a "Best Of Maui" in my opinion.
(4)
Keith m.

Fish Tacos = Good Onion Rings = Good Ono Burger = To Die For... Best thing I've eaten that's been classified as a "burger"! This is a beautiful 1/2 pound slab of deliciously fresh-caught Ono right off of the charbroiler... fresher than most seafood plates served for $25+... This was $9 well-spent. If they had this Ono burger in LA, I would never need to eat beef or Father's Office again!
(5)
Jeff M.

A Haiku Review of Paia Fish Market: Had the fish tacos. Tasty lunch for the value. Authentic Maui.
(4)
Mike S.

I had ordered the Obama burger. The Obama burger is a grilled slab of Cajun Ono topped with wasabi butter, slaw, cheese and mayo and is too die for. One of my favorite meals while I was in Maui last time. The Obama burger is not on the regular menu and was offered as a special. My wife ordered the Mahi burger which was good. It comes grilled with a mild tasting cole slaw, lettuce , tomatoes, tarter sauce and cheese on a sesame bun. She liked it but wished she had the Obama burger after tasting mine. We also ordered the fish and chips for my son. They were good but nothing special. I can't talk about the fries just because they weren't that memorable (not bad but not worth remembering). The seating situation here is large communal picnic tables. I encountered people saving several seats while someone is up ordering the food. The place gets very busy and the tables become cramped due to the "table savers." One table saver save a whole table and only had three people with him. Moral of the story, if there is no seating don't be too nice and just sit down. Other than that... Very good food, prices a tad high. Burgers run about $8.50
(4)
Elizabeth K.

LOVE this spot - amazing fresh fish, large plates, reasonably priced, and fun casual atmosphere. You order at the front, grab a seat, and they'll call your number. The line looks intimidating but it moves fast and is well worth it. Plus Paia is such a cute town to walk around and enjoy after lunch.
(5)
Tara B.

The Paia Fish Market is OK. I ate the fish taco and felt unsatisfied after. They contained shredded/ground fish, cheese, lettuce and tomatoes...fairly boring, not flavorful at all. Milagros (across the street) has far better fish tacos (see my review). The french fries that accompanied the tacos were not that great. They have the taste of old cooking oil. Yuck. One nice touch was the coleslaw.
(2)
Randall F.

Walk in stare at the menu for 2 minutes noting the variety of seafood and fries Order from friendly lady Sit and wait for your number to be called Get food and enjoy the fresh fish Mahi Mahi and thin fries. Really a great spot in the heart of the town of Paia....seemed always crowded and food is piping hot when you pick it up at the cook's counter. If you are driving to Hana or Haleakala, stop by for lunch.
(4)
dave c.

Outstanding! The fish quesadilla was wonderful, the atmosphere very casual and relaxed. Large menu to choose from but service was quick. This is a seat yourself, carry your food to the table place. One of our favorite lunch stops on Maui.
(5)
Chris L.

After seeing this place on the Travel Channel (and I think the Food Network), I talked the group into heading to Paia to taste the famous fish tacos. I'm not sure if this is just an establishment struggling live up to the hype, but I was not impressed (and actually felt bad for dragging the group to Paia). The fish taco's were good...but not extraordinary. And at $12 for two tacos, they should be just that. Because for 1/2 the cost, I could get 3 fish tacos at Baja Fresh (and they have a salsa bar!). Now my dad ordered a cheeseburger (apparently made with local Maui beef)...and that looked amazing!
(3)
B D.

We stopped by this place after we landed at OGG airport, it's about a 10-15 minute drive. IT WAS SO WORTH IT. This was hands down one of the most memorable eats that we had while we were vacationing in Maui. The place definitely has a local vibe... "no shoes, no shirts, no worries!" We tried the Ono Burger and the Fish Tacos. LOVED THE ONO BURGER. SOOOOO PERFECTLY COOKED, IT FALLS APART IF NOT HANDLED GENTLY. TENDER & MOUTHWATERING. (not fried) I would probably pass on the Fish Tacos, they were good but not as memorable and mouthwatering. I don't think I'll be able to find a fish burger as good as here in LA.
(5)
Toni M.

That's 2.49, not 2.51. We had lunch here today after stopping at Mana Foods for tea. It was almost as crowded as last night but less noisy. I spotted a family getting up to go, so I moved into their place when they left. Alan ordered for us at the counter, fish and chips for him, calamari and chips for me. Both came w/ coleslaw and tartar sauce. I thought the fish and the calamari had been cooked too long. Both were too dark. Alan liked the coleslaw better than I did. The fries were undistinguished. I was sorry to have missed the seafood pasta that sounded so good last night, but it was too warm a day for it and my impression was that the dish was too big for lunch, although Alan saw one coming from the kitchen, so someone ordered it. The best part of lunch was the conversation w/ the nice young couple from Phoenix who shared our table. I doubt we'll be back.
(2)
nisha c.

Great local favorite with an attitude. Delicious, fish sandwiches. Casual picnic table seating. First come first serve.
(5)
David B.

On my first trip to Maui, I made a special trip to Pa'ia Fish Market on my last day in town (thank you Andrew Doughty). I had what was, up to that point, the best fish sammich I'd ever had -- or could even imagine. (Opah is where it's at, kids; accept no substitutes.) So on my most recent trip, it was the first place I hit. As usual, the place was crowded and slightly dirty, and the staff didn't really give a crap about me or any of the customers. Hey, it is a dive after all. But what bugged me was my second, less-than-magical experience with my bff (best fish forever) opah sammich. They take this beautiful, though smallish, piece of fresh opah, grill it to perfection, put it on a very tasty, fresh roll, and top it with... a half-dead lettuce leaf, a slice of under-ripe tomato, and -- the piece de resistance -- a handful of pre-grated cheese-like substance from a bag. Are you effing kidding me? For $10 -- and with such a beautiful piece of fish -- you couldn't be bothered to use decent vegetables and real (better yet -- no) cheese? It turns out there are lots of places on Maui that will sell you a fish sammich, and some of them are excellent. PFM, it was nice knowin' ya.
(2)
Jull Y.

Came here after reading Yelpers reviews'.... don't believe what every yelper says. it's a total tourist trap! fake local vibe.. the vibe is like a little more upscale wahoo fish taco joint in california. ok fine, i'm not being fair.... fish was indeed fresh, but WAY too over priced. fried shrimps were frozen. YUCK! if you can't make it here to eat, you're not missing out. OVERPRICED! and there are flies around the seating area. double YUCK!
(2)
Kim D.

This place is cool beans. The fish is always fresh and plentiful. It is our favorite place on Maui for fresh fish.
(5)
Su-Lynn T.

Paia Fish Market serves fresh fresh fish served in a variety of ways at a counter-type joint in the heart of Paia. You enter, you order at the counter, you get your receipt, you find a spot in the communal picnic type tables, and then when your number is called you pick up your food. Finding a seat at 3pm was kinda tough! I guess that is how popular the place is. The food was excellent though, we got the fish n chips with mahi mahi, which were super tender, only lightly dusted with cornmeal and deep fried served with thin cut fries. We also got the seafood salad with grilled ono, served on a large bed of mixed greens, a few poached shrimp, and papaya seed dressing (soo good). Ono, I realized, was probably not my favorite fish since it's a little meatier than than most, but I thought it was very fresh and well-prepared. Everything was good, fresh, and fast. It's a great stop for late lunch/dinner on the way back from the road to Hana. Prices were reasonable, although not terribly low for a take-out counter style restaurant but the quality of fish is worth it. Note that bathrooms are not directly on premises but you get a key to a stall that is around the corner in a parking lot, but it was clean. After eating a meal here you can stop by Aloha Shave Ice and/or Ono Gelato Co. for dessert, both in Paia.
(4)
Kathy P.

Believe the hype. This place is fantastic. On my way out of Maui, I decided to ease my tropical depression by stopping at the Pa'ia Fish House. It was 10:45, and there was already a line. Fifteen minutes later, the doors opened, and we moved en masse to the cash register to place our orders. I had the ono sandwich with fries and a Big Swell IPA (a local brew) with cole slaw and fries. It was everything I thought it would be and more. Ono is a dense white fish, and it was grilled to perfection right in front of my eyes. The fish was so fresh I almost imagined a pleading little voice - "PLEASE DON'T EAT ME!" - coming from between the bun. The fries were crispy and perfectly seasoned, and the selection of local beers was quite expansive. I love the laid back, picnic table vibe of this restaurant - it is how I imagine Maui 30 years ago before the invasions of celebrities, golf courses, and Japanese tourists. I will be back.
(5)
R T.

My friends and I really enjoyed eating at the Paia fish market on the north shore. Convenient location, tasty food, large portions, social. The tables are picnic-style and communal so it's easy to meet other travelers and strike up conversations. We met a few others this way. There is also a tasty gelato place right across the street called Ono Gelato. Our favorite dishes at the fish market where the fish burgers- particularly the ono fish and snapper- soft, juicy white fish with relish on top- no side dish required. Portions are big so think twice before ordering two main courses and two appetizers! Unless you have a fridge at your apartment/hotel. One nice thing to do- get a couple fish sandwiches to go and watch the pro windsurfers 5 minutes down the road at Ho'okipa beach. I have lived near Seattle in the Pacific Northwest, and I've had my share of fish and chips. The Mahi fish at the Paia Fish Market was best I've had, hands down. The chips were just ok. I wish I could go back soon and try some of the other fish on the menu.
(4)
Jennifer Y.

Simply yummy, cheap and kid friendly. $10. buys you a fresh fish lunch plate that is worth it. It is like an annual routine for me... I hit the bikini shop on the block and eat at this market for lunch! This town has become quite pricey for a once know little hippie town so when you find a good thing, it's a good thing!
(4)
debbie l.

Had to eat here after reading the Yelp reviews and we were not disappointed. We headed here on our last day before heading to the airport for our red-eye flight. We had fish and chips and it was delicious, the best we had this trip. The place was super crowded even at 2 in the afternoon, and it was really hot inside they have no a/c only fans, so we got our food to go and drove to a nearby park to eat. Plus they have cafeteria style seating which is not my thing especially in a hot, crowded restaurant. I'd love to hit this place when it's not so crowded and try some of the other menu items. Best fish at a reasonable price. Worth the drive to Paia.
(5)
Leslie F.

This is hands down my favorite place to eat on island!! Yes it's crowded. Yes you share tables but that's called atmosphere. This place is always hustling because the food is that good. I'm a huge fan of the Obama burger (Cajun ono sandwich with wasabi butter) So GOOD!!! The fries are worth the upgrade. I have friends that swear the fish taco's are the bomb. Worth a visit for an epic $10 fish sandwich.
(5)
Marisa R.

This place is not to be missed. The fish based meals are fresh, succulent, consistent, reasonably priced, filling and perfectly cooked. There are no words for how great this place is. The line cooks jam, cranking out one perfect meal after another. We ate there Every Single Day that we were in Maui. Not because we had to. Because we wanted to. Casual atmosphere - you will feel totally comfortable in your sand filled swim wear or a little dressed up for the evening. If you want to spend way too much money on a less satisfying meal to justify wearing a fancy outfit, go down the road to Mamas Fish House.
(5)
Craig M.

I got chicken taco's so maybe it is an unfair judgement..Was just ok. Restaraunt was cozy and folks were friendly and I liked the vibe so there is that!
(3)
Gina C.

My husband and I came here on our way to Road to Hana. My friend recommended this place and I'm so glad we tried it. The place is very casual and laid back. The restrooms are in the back and you have to use a key to get in. I didn't like that part. As for the food, I ordered 2 fish tacos. It came with a heaping pile of rice, potatoes, and slaw. The tacos were delicious! It was lightly breaded with a coleslaw topping. It was very filling. My husband ordered the grilled mahi mahi plate. It was also delicious! It also came with a generous portion with rice, potatoes, and slaw. We also had an order of fried shrimp which was also great! For lunch our meal was a little under $50. I thought it was a little pricy for lunch, but it was worth it. We arrived at 11:00AM when they opened and by the time we left, it was packed! Stop by this place before or after the Road to Hana. It is worth the drive!
(5)
Lisa A.

This place is so over priced for what you get which is zero service and a long line just to find a shared seat at a common picnic table. The staff is rude and they really have attitudes! I guess the prices are decent for the Island but the food is nothing to write home about. Freds in Kihei has MUCH better food for a LOT less and they treat you well and have tables you can sit at alone. I truly am sick and tired of getting gouged at this place so the last visit will be my last visit! I'll just go have drinks at Milagros..... This better not get filtered!!!!
(1)
Robyn W.

I went to the Paia Fish Market twice and had 2 dramatically different experiences, so I will average it out to 3 stars... Our first visit was for dinner - after being warned about the line ups, we were pleased to find that it wasn't that busy. The Hubs and I both got the mahi mahi fish and chips. It was fantastic. The fish was fresh and tender, with a light breading instead of a heavy beer batter and spiced nicely, the fries and slaw were also good. We even got half a table to ourselves! I don't know if we were just starved after our drive to (and from) Hana, but we both declared it the very best fish and chips we have ever had. It left such an impression that we went back the next day for lunch. I wish we had left well enough alone. Our second visit found the monumental lines that everyone talks about. It was long, and every table was packed, so we ordered more mahi mahi to go. Then we waited. We saw all the orders before us get called, then we saw several that ordered after us get called, and still we waited for fish and chips. When we finally got our food, we walked across the street to our hotel and dug in. Unfortunately, my fish was overcooked to the point of being burnt, leaving the fish inside dry. The fries were cold and the slaw was warm. I would go back the next time we visit the island because our first visit was so good, and just hope that lunch was an "off" day.
(3)
J M.

Fish so fresh you wonder why the $$$$ resorts can't do it this good. Also had Widmer Hefferweissen from Portland OR on tap. Everything on the menu looked good at this no-frills local fish winner.
(4)
H T.

while on my hike, some of the other tourists said they liked eating at paia fish market, and so did the hike guide. since a local likes it, i decided to try it for dinner after the hike. i got the cajun/blackened okapakada (or whatever it's called) sandwich for $9.50. it does not come w/ sides, but the sandwich has some slaw on it. you can pay $9 for ono or mahi mahi sandwiches but $9.50 for any other fish. order at the counter and find a seat. long communal tables invite chatter, so get to know the people around you.
(4)
Andrew P.

Kind of a pain dealing with parking in downtown Paia, but the mahi burger really was quite tasty. Perfectly cooked, moist and bursting with flavor. The fish market in Lahaina is almost as good, but just not quite there.
(4)
Jeff W.

Never a bad meal here. We eat here at least twice each time we come to Maui. Blackened mahi is really tasty.
(5)
Mary S.

I have a friend who often describes good food as the "best ever" or "soooo goood", but when it came to Paia Fish Market, he was so right. Fast, affordable, fresh. Definitely gets the job done. We roll in for a late lunch around 2:30 and the place is hopping. The food is so incredibly fresh. Mahi burger was amazing. Seasoned fries hit the spot. Located in an adorable area with plenty to do. Basically, it was the best ever, and everything I ate was soooo goood.
(5)
Kay W.

I love their fish burgers. I might just have to jump on a plane from Boston and come visit my aunt so I can have one... Soon
(5)
Kei ..

this place was recommended by foodnetwork guy fieri. this has the freshest fish & everything tastes great!! it's a little pricey, but for us well worth it especially on vacation. we had fish & chips, fish taco's, & blackened maui. service was fast . just grab a spot to eat before ordering your food. you share picnic benches to eat.
(5)
Jenny W.

The fish burger is just ok. The portion was large but the flavour was lacking. The fries on the other hand was really good. Maybe my expectations were too high but I was disappointed.
(3)
Todd H.

Who doesn't love fresh fish? (A rare thing here in Colorado) This place has it all! It can be busy at times, however it's really worth the wait. You wont regret it! YOU GUYS SERIOUSLY ROCK!
(4)
iPunchfish -.

The first restaurant I ate at when I traveled to Hawaii. The fish tacos are so fresh and tasty that I came back here again before we left. Their 2 fish taco platter with potatoes and rice with a Bikini Blonde is amazing.
(4)
Eri O.

Best fish tacos and fish quesadillas!! I'm so gald that a local told us about this place! I miss it already!! I would come to Maui just to eat the fish quesadilla again.
(5)
Y d.

Basically your best choice if you are in Paia unless you want to drive a bit to Mama's fish House.
(3)
Heather J.

Rustic long benches, open seating (if you can find a spot), sitting next to world class surfers/locals/and tourists-well not priceless but charming...the place will convert you to the fish burger.
(5)
Chuck C.

Great surprise. Someone in the car mentioned fish tacos, and we happened to be on our way toward Paia. Pulled up near Paia fish market, checked the menu, ka-ching. Fish tacos, and fish tacos extraordinaire. I want to check out of our condo near Lahaina so I can eat here everyday.
(5)
Mary L.

$12 for the fish taco lunch special. It came with 2 tacos, cabbage (I think?), rice, and potatoes. The tacos were fantastic, nothing else on the plate was worth eating.
(4)
JD L.

Can I give zero stars? Ugh. I hate that you Yelpers sent me here. FoodTV is not God. If you like fried crap and TGIF then maybe you might like this. I got the fish tacos and chose ahi. I was concerned as I watched oversized, piles of overfried gross food come out but i trusted my fellow yelpers. The tacos were uninspired, overcooked and flavorless, rice was inedible, worst cole slaw ever- I think it was just cabbage. How do you screw up cole slaw!?? The only redeeming things I can say is their tartar sauce is ok and their home fries are made with fresh potatoes (but still not great). Oh, I got 2 tacos and it cost me $14. One was $10, 2 were $13 and they added a dollar for the ahi without telling me. So, tacos were $3 and the other grossness on the plate was $7. I want to puke now. If you want a great fish sandwich, go to The Fish Market Maui in Lahaina and get the seared ahi sandwich. Then you tell me this place was good. Please. If you want a good fish taco, I go to Dia de Pesca in San Jose, CA. And the are $3.25 and they taste amazing. Or in Maui, even the David Paul ahi tacos at the bar are good. Excuse me, this PFM meal makes me so sick I feel for the first time that I have to go stick my finger down my throat now....
(1)
Jessica S.

delicious fish sandwich (burger) with fries. wished we had it twice there. i had ono, husband had mahi, both were amazing.
(4)
Matthew W.

After a big breakfast, I was not terribly hungry, so I went with the cheeseburger. It was tasty, with a Hawai'ian twist...the ubiquitous and messy cole slaw as a main topping. My friends had fish and chips (fries), which were made of Mahi Mahi. Had I known this ahead of time, I would have gone that route. The fish was pretty good for a fried lunch. Overall, this was a nice place for lunch, but it will likely be my only visit. Seating is hard and the place is noisy. There are other places in Pa'ia to visit too.
(3)
Denise Q.

Fish Tacos- bomb Mahi Burgers- bomb Fish and Chips- bomb It is all good! Does not disappoint.
(5)
Maggie M.

Two weeks in Maui we spent a Lot of $$ on just OK food. The last meal there we happened upon the Paia Fish Market. It was the best food and by far the most economical of all the restaurants we visited. The local flavor and family style seating was fun
(5)
Sung L.

I had the blackened Ono burger and it was over cooked and dry. To be fair, the place is always packed so I might have caught them on a bad day. The fish seemed fresh. Because it's so busy, it's also not a very comfortable place to eat. People order and hover over other people who are finishing up and swoop in to sit down at an uncleared table.
(2)
Jessica D.

3 words: Rare ahi burger. Sooo good. Make sure you order it rare or it will be well done. Best deal on the island for $9.50. I also recommend the bikini blonde beer and the fries!
(5)
Ms. A.

My husband and I visited this restaurant in Spring of 2011. It was awesome! I had been here before with a friend and remembered the atmosphere and food. The restaurant is a little bit of a mix of high and low. The food is very good and you eat on real plates with silverware. But you pick up your food from the counter and bus your own table. That's what I mean by a mix of high and low. That being said, just because you don't have a waiter taking your order, doesn't mean you can't have great service. The staff is expedient and they know their menu - it's a good thing, because the menu is pretty long! We went for lunch in the afternoon, and the place wasn't too crowded, but all of the tables were filled. The atmosphere is a little bit of a cafeteria style - but in a good way. You grab your food, find a seat, and grind 'em. I got the fish and chips and it was delicious - the fish was flaky and juicy and the batter was crispy. Everything was fresh and hot off the grill/oven. The smells are delicious, too! There's nothing like it with a nice cold beer! Oh, and their coleslaw is ono! I don't usually go for coleslaw but with the fish and chips it was fresh and delicious!
(5)
Douglas N.

I heard so many things about this place that I couldn't wait to give it a try. The first time I went in the line was to the door, so I came back later when it wasn't crowded. Service: I was the only person standing at the counter for at least a couple minutes looking around before someone finally came to the cash register. There was no greeting, no recommendations, nothing. I paid for my meal of Ono cajun style with fries and coleslaw $22, w/ tax and tip paid $26. Big mistake to tip. The tables were filthy, there's silverware at the table, but I had to go to 2 other tables trying to find napkins. When your meal is ready they just yell out your number and you go up to the counter to get it, even though I had seen the cash register person deliver meals to other patrons. No big deal, if the food is good I'm ok with it. Well after you're done with your meal you clear your own dishes next to the counter, so don't bother tipping. I can understand if you're busy but when I went in there were a few people standing around and no attempt to even wipe tables and restock them. And that didn't happen the whole time I was there. 1 star. Food: The ono was very fresh, I got it cajun style it was overspiced and not that great. If I do come back I'll try it sauteed. The fish wasn't overcooked, and since it was fresh it did flake. And they give you a good size of fish. Fries not spectacular (though you do get a lot of them), very generic. Coleslaw is iceberg lettuce and red cabbage with LOTS of mayo. That's pretty much all you taste, no dill, no tang, nothing. The only redeeming thing about this place was that the fish was super fresh. Atmosphere: Ok I guess. Probably better if you're a little drunk and swapping fishing stories. I'm all for hole in the walls, but like I said tables were absolutely filthy and none of the workers seemed to care. Verdict: WAY overpriced for what you get, I only ate the fish and some of the fries. Maybe it was a bad evening or they were cranky I have no idea because other ppl I talked to said great things about this place. Maybe next time I'll get a fish burger or something (which is around $10-12). I was just aghast at the lack of service and aloha. I felt more like a nuisance rather than a customer.
(2)
Craig D.

(4) ~ Overall Food & Service. My "Obama" Ono (Wahoo) Burger was the BEST fish Burger I ever had! My wife's fish tacos were pretty good too.
(4)
Susan T.

Before heading out to our villa in Kapalua from the airport, we decided to make a stop at Paia since it was not extremely far from the airport and we were starving.... this place is pretty busy with big tables and benches that you will probably have to share with random people, but like us they are all tourist and on vacation so everyone was in a good mood :) I had the obama burger (named after our president) and it was delicious! It was blackened fish ( i forget what kind) with wasabi and all the trimmings. The spice was a perfect blend and it makes me hungry just thinking about it. So I definitely recommend this place! The fish taco was good too but I totally recommend the Obama burger if they still have it!
(4)
Paula B.

Great and fresh!!! Good place for dinner on the way back from Hana! "Obama burger" = Excellent.... Also the yellow fin tuna dinner plate was HUGE! Very good!!!!!
(5)
Simon M.

Great simple FRESH fish served with fresh cold slaw and other sides. Great neighborhood atmosphere
(4)
Derrick S.

Very crowded for a very good reason! We went to this place 2 times when we were in Maui! Cannot recommend highly enough!
(5)
Ryan C.

Ambiance. Order from the counter, cafeteria style dining, and surrounded by "beach bums". There is no ambiance, nor should there be. This is as simple as it gets. Service. Nothing to say really, as that's not the point of this restaurant. Food. As fresh and as simple as it gets. It should be noted right away that Paia Fish Market gets its fish from the same source as Mama's Fish House, which is significantly more expensive. This is perfect "beach eats". You choose your fish, you choose from several cooking styles, and you enjoy your delicious, fresh, (relatively) affordable seafood. Go here. You will not regret it. This is where the locals eat and you should too.
(5)
Mark S.

I could write a long review of this place and point out the pros and cons, but I am really not into it that much. All I will say is this: good fresh fish, crappy service and tons of annoying, spatially-impaired tourists. Go to Coconuts in Kihei for fish as good, lower prices and fewer annoyances.
(3)
Tim P.

Fish Tacos! We are from San Diego and have serious fish taco talent to choose from - honestly the fish tacos at Paia Fish Market are the best I have ever had. Loved the portions, menu, and people were nice! Definately a must eat...
(5)
Monique C.

This place is good! love their fish and chips, some of the freshest fish eva! Not too greasy. Always packed- with sunscreen smelling tourists.. how exciting:-0 4 stars for real good food
(4)
Sarah R.

Great place to people watch and refuel after coming off the Road to Hana. The food wouldn't win any awards if eaten in a less atmospheric place, but don't let that get in your way of a great time. I had the fish tacos - which were HUGE - and are served with better than average french fries. Yummy!
(4)
Charles O.

Had the fish tacos and some beers after seeing the tacos highlighted by an Australian Dude on the show "the best thing I ever ate". Apparently the Aussie has never been to Baja California or Los Angeles, CA where many a fish taco have more flavor. The fish I'd have to say was amongst the freshest I've had. It was also grilled, which is unique. I prefer fried, which doesn't matter if it is super fresh or not. Where they dropped the ball was on what else is on the taco. Good...but not impressed.
(3)
Jake S.

First off Great place to have a sit down lunch. Second order their Ono Burger with a side of Cole Slaw. Their portions are big enough to feed about 3 people! I always end up taking home left overs of the massive portions they give. Great Place. Even Rachel Ray from the Food Network loves it!
(5)
Christopher B.

Another one of my rare 5 star places!! I just loved the Mahi Fish and Chips!!! I have been there about 5 times now and I have never had anything bad at all. Not going to bore you with a long review and just tell you to go try it out!! It is a little pricey but worth it because the quality is outstanding!! There is limited seating and i reccommend taking it to go and heading a mile down the road to Ho'okipa Beach Park and watch the wind surfers..
(5)
Gregg F.

Came for the fish tacos which were pretty good. I would say there are others who now rival these. The fish was chopped up too small so you start to lose the taste. We also had the fish sandwich very good! Portions are better than average. This one is more like 3.5 stars.
(4)
Denise H.

The fish was awesome here. The place does tend to get busy a lot so plan to wait for a seat. I had the fish tacos and sashimi platter. Both were excellent.
(5)
Jamie W.

I had 2 fish tacos with half cajun rice and half potatoes along with cole slaw - I think they called it a lunch plate. The fish tacos were DELICIOUS! I had a fish taco at Maui Taco the first evening I arrived here, and it isn't even close to as good tasting as the ones I had here at Pa'ia Fish Market. The potatoes had a nice dill seasoning and onions, giving them a good taste. The cajun rice wasn't any count - just get all potatoes, no rice needed. Cole slaw was decent. The tartar sauce has more dill - it seems to be a favorite spice here. That's fine with me because I like it. The soda fountain Diet Coke was only $1.50 and free refills were a great deal from what I've experienced so far on Maui. The folks working here are very kind and efficient. The table seating is pretty small, making it tough to elbow yourself some space to eat if it is busy. Sunday afternoon around 1:30pm on Labor Day Weekend found this place plenty busy. Worth the drive just for this fish shack!
(4)
Cindy J.

OMG. Generous portions of fresh fish. Cooked simply but perfectly. Reasonably priced to boot, how can you top that? Recommendations include fish tacos, blackened mahi mahi on caesar salad, and ahi tuna sandwich and nice options for kids who don't eat fish (cheese quesadilla and local beef burgers). We made a detour on our way to the airport for one final meal.
(5)
Amy O.

I get the same Ono Fish Burger every time. Sometimes I get a side order of fries or onion rings too. It's a lot of food and I'm always ridiculously stuffed when I leave there. It's just so tasty that I can't seem to stop when my tummy tells me to.
(5)
steve s.

Another 5 star review for this place. My wife and I were both pleased with this place. My only advice would be to go during the off hours. The seating there is pretty limited. Quality of Food - 4.5 stars Value - 5 stars Customer service - 4 stars
(5)
Joann s.

The owners of this restaurant are opening a sushi restaurant in the town i live in Haiku - during their construction in JUNE i drove to the post office - right next door - twice - no where else - got home and had a bug nail in my tire - had to get the tire replaced for $167 bucks - i only live 2 miles from where it happened and of course cannot PROVE i got the nail there but it makes sense. I politely sent two letters and spoke to the owners about this and asked them to at least SPLIT the cost with me as i am out of work. Their reply was "we are trying to open a restaurant here" - that was it - i for sure will never patronize either of their restaurants and will tell all my friends the same - this is MAUI for crying out loud - land of aloha - or so i thought.....Very very disappointing. Owners i dealt with were Yuri Soledade and DeWitt Lickle. They also said - well you cannot PROVE it - i said i realize that - just asking for you to help me out - nope.....
(1)
Jim C.

One of my favorite new finds on my recent trip to Maui. Awesomely fresh fish - great place for a fish sandwich. Where else in Hawaii can you get fish that tastes like it was just caught for $8.50 or $9.00? Fish sandwich ($8.50 for ono or mahi, $9 for other daily special fish) - simple, seasoned and cooked perfectly, and moist - 5 stars Caesar salad with fresh fish and jumbo shrimp w/cocktail sauce $13.95) - the fish was super and shrimp was suprisingly fresh - 5 stars The place itself is very casual and you'll find a combination of locals, surfers, and tourists. You order at the counter first and then find an open table. Don't expect a formal sit down service place. Bottom line: Super fresh and delicious fish that rivals many of the local restaurants like Mama's Fish House but at super prices. One of my new Maui faves.
(5)
Wa T.

I think they are good for the burgers and fried finger foods, such as the onion ring and calamari. Just had their fish n' chip. Nothing special about it. Still crowded after 1:30p, but started to clear out and had a table of 7.
(3)
Paula D.

Great food, great environment.... my first fish tacos and I'm hooked!
(5)
Jesse W.

1/26/08: Saturday night dinner at 6:30pm (rush hour) - we walked around 5pm and decided to grab dinner after walking around Paia (it was pretty quiet inside the restaurant) - when we returned, it was PACKED. Plenty of tourists and locals. Big chalkboard type menu loaded with fish prepared all different ways. Order at the counter and then start looking around for a table. Restaurant is setup with picnic bench style tables, first come first seated! We hovered over a couple pressing them to finish their meal - the meal took some 10 minutes to prepare (they call your number when finished) and by then, we were planted at a table. I ordered the fish pasta (huge plate of white sauce pasta (alittle watery) piled high with fish chuncks, scallops and shrimp. Others in the group tried the grilled fish sandwiches, yummy! Food was great- Self service (ordering and pickup of food) also means self cleaning - they request that you bring your used dishes to a bus boy station. Now, I tipped the staff when placing the order - I wonder what they did to earn that... hmm...
(5)
Anino X.

Upon advice from my cousin, my girlfriend and I visited Paia Fish Market shortly after we landed on Maui. We loved it so much we came back for lunch on the day we left. Everything was fresh and made to order. The first meal we tried out the fishburgers- ahi for her and mahi for me. The second time we stopped in, I tried the fish tacos and she had an ahi burger, cooked more rare than the first time. Just be sure to pop in on off-peak times. The place is tiny and Paia is a the last stop on the Hana drive, which is a popular tourist trip, so the little town does get crowded. There's only one parking lot to stop in, which is about 3 blocks away from the Paia Fish Market.
(5)
Giao T.

Average menu selection, but the food was delicious. Ordered the fish tacos and Mahi Mahi fish burger. Portions was generous. Cole slaw, rice and potatoes were equally good for the side dishes. Wait was kind of long and there's very limited seating. We had to share a long table with another family, but that wasn't bad. Price is okay considering the portions of each plate. Definitely a must try if visiting Maui; just be prepared to wait and probably share a table was other tourists.
(4)
HarryandJean A.

Excellent! We met some friends for lunch and all had the fish taco plate. The taco plate came with your choice of fresh fish and one side item. We all chose the mahi which was a lot of food at a reasonable price. We arrived there when they opened at 11:00 am and were glad we did because the picnic tables with bench seats fill up fast. They did not have a parking lot so we parked in the public lot a few blocks away. We will make it a point to eat here again when we return to Maui.
(4)
lauren m.

Delicious, fresh fish. Paia is such a weird place. This fish market is small, with wooden picnic tables. Grab a table space when you come in. The fish sandwich was awesome. The side portions are huge, so share with someone.
(5)
Jessica Y.

Lunch or dinner plates local fish, prepared your way love coleslaw, prices.
(5)
Elaine L.

Best Fish & Chips I've ever had in my life! Huge chunks of Mahi Mahi and not skimpy little pieces covered in breading. Their portions are huge from what I could observe off everyone's plate. Simple, fresh and a must try if you are stopping in Paia for your last gas up or food stock up before the drive to Hana.
(4)
Sonya T.

This place was a great value! Got the mahi fish burger and it was not only good but it has a huge piece of fish. I suggest getting a fish burger since the price is so good and you get Cole slaw and fries are 2 bucks more. A must on the way to Hana!
(5)
Fred E.

Good Burger and loved the Opah fish!
(5)
Tom W.

This place is a must on a visit to Maui. Consistently good food at 1/2 the price of other restaurants. My favorite is the mahi burger - light, buttery and flaky. Sashimi is excellent too.
(5)
Fred M.

I came here on my last day in MAui. I was very sad because I had just eaten a large meal at MAMAS FISH HOUSE (awesome) but still wanted to get a fish taco that I had been hearing so much about. I decided to go with my gut and rushed over there. I walked in to a very local atmosphere and a long line. Got a fish taco. It was freaking great. I immediately got my appetite back and devoured the taco.
(4)
Brian W.

Fish tacos. Wow. Wowwwww
(5)
Emma M.

Disappointing to say the least. Ordered Mahi mahi fish and chips. The fish was dry and overdone. The ceasar salad was overly salty with too much dressing. The calamari fish and chips my husband ordered was ok but nothing fabulous. This was one of our go to places during previous visits to Maui but this time around it was not up to par.. Not sure I'll return, certainly not during this visit
(2)
Beverly T.

This place is really good. I was shocked. We ordered the fish and chips with calamari. Both were excellent. The fish was not overbattered and the flavor was excellent. The fish was also cooked to perfection... moist and crispy on the outside. The fries, however were not fresh and as crispy as I would have liked. That's why there's one star missing. The cole slaw was also a little bland. I was expecting tough calamari, but it was really tender and delish! It came with sauce that had a little bit of wasabi root mixed into it, which was unique and very very pleasant. I actually enjoyed the calamari more than the fish, but both were very good. I hear the beer is pretty cheap here, but we get any.
(4)
Eric W.

Very good food in a funky local setting. I enjoyed my fish tacos, although I had had better on the Big Island. My wife really enjoyed her seafood pasta. They even have a decent selection of wines and the prices weren't too bad. It was a lot of fun sitting family-style at a large table with some locals. Most of the customers seemed to be locals. Lots of friendly alternative surfer types. Made me homesick for the Bay Area.
(4)
Catherine K.

YUM! So glad we stumbled upon this place. Everything here looked delicious, but we finally decided to try the fish tacos. They were exactly what we needed to fuel our hike. The portions here are ridiculously large so be prepared to share or take home extras. I wish they didn't serve such huge servings...people end up wasting so much.
(4)
Jason L.

So happy my wife and I found this place. We were walking around Paia after Twin Falls and stopped in for lunch. The place looked cool from the outside. After going in we sat at one of the communal tables. Went to the counter to order and had the Blackened Mahi Sandwich which was amazing. The fish was very fresh. Forget what my wife had but know it was awesome also. Loved the vibe and amazingly the food was even better. Can't recommend this place enough.
(5)
Dane K.

This place is great... Went here more than once. They have great fish sandwichs (Ono, Mahi, I think a few other options). Relatively inexpensive. Cooked and seasoned perfectly, the sauce they put on is nice. Onion rings were great, too. My mom left her camera here and someone was nice enough to return it to them. Dining indoors is kind of picnic tableish, no frills but very clean and actually pretty interesting.
(5)
Lydia B.

This place was suggested to us by a local. It offers very reasonably priced FRESH seafood. It's pretty casual and low key. Be ready to share a picnic table with some fun folks and a enjoy some fresh fish cooked to your desires and a glass of wine or beer.
(4)
Finola M.

This was our absolute favorite meal in Maui (worth 6 stars). We popped in, not really expecting much, seemed a little touristy. I had the "Obama" burger of Ono and my husband had fish tacos. I don't know what is in this stuff, it makes me drool just thinking about it, it was that good. Not cheap as far as burger joints go but 1. it's fish not meat so I would expect to pay more, 2. it's Maui, and 3. It's ridiculously good.
(5)
Sumail B.

OK, relative to Hawaii prices, this place is reallllyy well priced. They have a great selection of daily catches and the food is pretty damn well made. Amongst a variety of individuals, we had the chicken fajitas, salmon fajitas, fried shrimp and chips, and mahi and chips. All of them were delicious. The only reason why I cut down the review was because the lady at the counter taking our order was really really brusque and LITERALLY threw my change back at me. That is not OK. Period. Otherwise, I recommend the place. Customer service is a big selling point for me.
(3)
Steffie L.

It's a good place to grab a quick bite. Food there is affordable and comes in big portions.
(3)
Linda V.

definitely go here and skip Mama's when your'e on Maui. Can't wait to go back, and actually make it up the road to Hana.
(4)
M S.

Oh, this place was so good! Fish tacos were excellent :) Place is busy but fun. Fish was fresh and perfectly prepared. Highlight of our dining on Maui!
(5)
JN B.

Tried this place based on most of the good comments from other Yelpers. I would side with the other 3-star reviews. Overall comment: good but over-priced. We ordered two dishes: blackened salmon and seafood pasta, a side of home fries, and one drink=$50. The salmon was good. The seafood pasta was a little too thick and soggy - was expecting something a little lighter/olive oil based. We ordered home fries but got a skillet of sautÃ©ed seasoned potatoes chopped in small cubes. This is their version of home fries? I hope it was just a mistake. If you are in the area check it out, but don't go out of your way just to eat here. I understand that Maui is one of the most expensive places to eat, but I've had better dishes at Wahoo's Fish Tacos: larger portions, very reasonable prices. One last tip: If you are planning on going to Maui, be sure to bring a few re-usable shopping bags. None of the stores hand out plastic anymore.
(3)
Julia L.

The food here was good, but watch out for the stange pricing structure of the "dinners." Stick with a sandwich. Same exact fish and sides and portion size, just on a bun at half price.
(3)
Ryan H.

Great old hippie town next to some of the most famous windsurfing in the world. Stop in for their incredible ono tacos - fresh as can be!
(4)
Paul R.

What a great spot- fresh fish at extremly affordable prices. Order at the counter and I highly recommend the Ono Burger or the fish tacos. We had consecutives meals and best food for the buck on this island. Don't forget to check out their T-shirts.
(4)
Kim V.

Perfect post Hana Highway meal. Big, overstuffed fish tacos you can't pick up, great fries, and served in 10 minutes. The Ono burger is "ono." (delicious)
(5)
Marnie A.

This place was on the Food Network for having the best fish tacos so of course I had to check it out for myself. Parking is hard to come by and arrive early as the line can get long. The family style tables makes it fun as we love to chat and meet people. Great menu with way too many options. The fish tacos are great. They are probably the second best I've had...which is pretty darn good.
(4)
Bill S.

This might just be the best pizza on the planet. I'm not kidding. Make sure you stop here if you can, and if you do, try the Kalua Pig (Mopsys). Unbelievable.
(5)
Marie B.

If you're looking for a really good, fresh and clean seafood restaurant, this is the place to go to! The food was delicious! We ordered a seafood pasta dish and had their Ono Fish and Chips and everything was delicious!
(5)
Kev M.

More of a good super casual fast local fish, salad and burger place. Order at the counter. Sit wherever you want. You'll likely share a table, but it's cool, not weird. They'll shout your number which you won't hear the first time. Then you eat a super tasty Ono fish burger with onion rings and drink a Longboard lager. The fish tacos come on an enormous plate with potatoes and rice and Cole slaw. I enjoyed it. But it's super casual if you looking for a sit down waiter ordering meal, this isn't it.
(4)
BrokeDaMou F.

I always come here during my stays in Maui. And I always order the same thing, the Ono burger. The fish is a good sized piece that is thick and fits the bun for $9. A basket of fries is enough for two people. Seating is "communal" where 6-8 people each can fit in one of the 6 large tables. Don't forget to clear your own plates and place them in the bin.
(5)
L B.

This was my hubby's favorite restaurant in Maui before we went to Mama's. We got the fish quesadilla, Ono sandwich plate, plate with garlic butter fish, onion rings, and mahi mahi fish and chips for five adults and the bill came out to $88 before tip. The butter snapper fish was rich, buttery, soft and flaky, my hubby liked the fish & chips here more bc it was firmer and less battered, where I thought island chef's fish and chips were better bc they were softer and creamier, we were both not fans of the quesadilla - there was too much going on and not enough cheesiness, and the onion rings were crunchy but bit too dry for our liking. Overall, we would go again!
(5)
Thomas H.

I've been coming to Maui for over 20 years and stay on the north shore in a little community called Sprecklesville just a couple of clicks from Paia. Until someone can convince me otherwise the fresh Mahi on the Mahi burger at the Fishmarket is not only the best fish I have had on the islands, it is the best fish I have ever had anywhere, and that includes Mama's. Maybe the fact that it also is less than ten bucks adds to the allure. Send someone to the counter to order and then keep on the lookout for a seat by the windows that face Hana Hwy. Then you can have one of the best pieces of fish you can imagine while watching one of the best shows that you can and that is the parade of eclectic souls that transit the sidewalk outside Left to my own devices I would probably eat here 5 times a week, but fortunately others help me set limits . . . . . To date, for restaurants, this is my only 5 star recommendation.
(5)
Nick H.

I've had far better at many other places I ordered the fish tacos plate and there was certainly a lot more iceberg lettuce than fish! The whole plate was bland and I was not at all satisfied after the meal! For good fish on the cheap, I STRONGLY recommend heading over to Makawao and visiting a small trailer which has far better food! What a disappointment!
(1)
J K.

If you want a great local spot to enjoy fresh fish tacos, Mahi, Ono burgers this place is awesome! We stumbled upon this place on the way back from Hana- twin falls, and had to back a second day during our week long stay. If this place hasn't been featured on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives, they better film it here! The NY times has even written about this place. A+++
(5)
Charlene A.

After some shopping in Paia, we decided to try the Fish Market tacos. We got there just before the lunch rush, I can imagine it being hard to find a place to sit at the communal tables. The opakapaka and ono tacos were very fresh! They were served with cajun rice and coleslaw. A bit pricey for lunch, but worth tasting the freshness!
(4)
Jason C.

Was brought here by a very good friend on while killing time til my flight. I friggin love this place. I can't remember the name of the fish, it was opah or opah something, and it was hella good, man, I can still taste if fresh off the grill. My brother had the salmon, which was good, and my friend had the grilled ono, and that ono was the ONE. Washed it down with some local brew and I was hooked. My bro was flirtin with counter, which I found hilarious. I liked the feel of the place, real chill. Food was a lil pricey, but good nonetheless. Definitely plan on goin back the next time on the island.
(5)
Y R.

Best tasting fish sandwich I've had on Maui. Super casual...everybody sits at big picnic tables inside the restaurant...sometimes you've got to jockey for a spot. Great little place for a good bite while in Paia. Can't beat the Fish Market right after the beach. I usually only eat lunch here, but I've gotten the seafood pasta to-go once for dinner...rich!
(4)
Claude G.

Delicious! Try the obama burger, or the fish/chips. We go back to this place over and over and over.
(5)
Kim R.

Yum! Yum! If you are going to be on Maui you must stop into this place for some fish tacos. The tacos were so good and came with coleslaw and rice or fries. The tacos were about 12.95 for two, but were well worth it. I would definitely eat here again! Next time I want to try the Ono burger, it looked awesome!
(4)
Steve S.

The Mahi burger is delicious and the picnic table eating goes along with the whole hippie vibe that the city holds. Crowded, cool little shop. I will definitely be eating here again!
(5)
Jame N.

Drove from kaanapali to try this place based on all the great yelp reviews but suffice it to say I'd never do it again even though we r in Maui at least once or twice a year. Food was just ok. Had the mahi fish &chips and the fish was dry and over cooked. The Ono burger was a bit better but probably because of the cole slaw and tarter sauce that kept it moist. Portions r average size -definitely not 10 oz as some helpers have claimed! We r not big eaters and were just barely full...prices are fairly reasonsble though. probably the best option if you happen to be in the area otherwise, not worth the drive.
(2)
Tim F.

We stopped by after walking past several times to get a drink. We really weren't very hungry. As we ordered, the fish sandwich special (Obama "burger") sounded too interesting so we ordered. The fish was cooked to perfection and the fires were great!..IF you like seafood and are looking for a quick, very well prepared meal - I recommend stopping by. Friendly staff and great food. Paia is a great town with unique shops.
(4)
M I.

The Ono Burger was truly great. Very fresh and good size portion. My son had the Mahi Burger and really liked it. Wife had the burger which was also very good considering it's a fish market and my daughter had the chicken lunch plate which was also fine. My rating is based on the fish burgers which I'd easily go back again for. If you are near Paia and have a taste for a fast food style setting with a great piece of grilled fish, some mild but tasty coleslaw and some McD's like fries this is the place.
(5)
Krys G.

We've been to Maui twice now for extended vacations, staying at the Huelo Point Lookout (see review.) Although a good 20-minute drive from HPL, we ventured in to the Paia Fish Market 2-3 times a week for a beer and their absolutely mouth-watering, savory, crunchy, tasty, fabulous fish and chips. The best I've ever had. This place is a terrific stop if you're on your way to or from Hana, since it's a quick informal bite to eat with very reasonable prices. It is bar none the best place to eat in Paia. Even if you're staying on one of the opposite coasts (Lahaina, Kapalua, Wailea,) this place is worth the trek.
(5)
Esther T.

The Mahi fish and chips are amazing...the fish is sooo good. Paia was the perfect place to stop for lunch after navigating the north end of the island. There are great places to shop nearby, you can't miss the shops ladies!
(5)
Jay G.

Great blackened sashimi! Its an order at the counter / pick up at the counter type place. No waitresses, only about 8-10 tables in the place. Expect to share a table (really a picnic table and bench) with strangers. Worth it though, cuz the food is good.
(4)
Leigha T.

This would have been given 5 stars, but I had the worst stomach ache of my life time, and it could have really ruined my day, luckily for some reason I had some alkaseltzer and a bottle of water in my bag and I was okay. But, it was worth it! The food is crazy good! I had shrimp fajitas. Cool, spicy and I inhaled it, might be why the excruciating stomach ache. Get there EARLY! 11:30am was perfect, we were the last to get a seat before a big rush came in at noon. Even if you had to wait, I'd still go. Super cute town too. Fun place to explore.
(4)
MrSantaMonica K.

my favorite place to go on Maui! mahi and salmon are awesome!!! it's worth the drive, depending what part of Maui you are staying on... again just go!
(5)
Shane F.

My best find on Maui. Amazing.
(5)
Marline P.

This place is a gem. We had amazing fish here (burrito and sandwich). At first you might think, as we did, that a fish sandwich couldn't possibly be worth $10 but you would be wrong: it will be one of the best things you eat on Maui! The only thing that keeps this from being a 5 star is that we found a wire twist in the coleslaw. An oversight, but it could have been a huge problem if it had been swallowed or even gotten into the mouth which fortunately it hadn't.
(4)
Prettylilredhead H.

So good for what it is--very tasty fish -n chips. Sashimi was good as well. Fast and friendly. Gets really crowded at lunch time!!
(5)
S K.

we LOVED paia fish market! It meets up to all the hype. We had lunch here before heading out on the road to Hana, and we were glad that we did! It's a casual place for lunch/dinner that we'd love to go back to. best fish tacos ever! ono and mahi burgers were amazing even the fries were good :)
(5)
Kevin W.

Probably the best fish burger I ever had.... the fish is grill and very fresh on a bun. Choose the obama burger, its ono fish with cajun spice.
(5)
s f.

Last meal on Maui, and this was great. Fresh, diverse choices, fast, plentiful, items for non-fish eaters, great prices, efficient staff. Bathrooms are outside, and it's crowded. We will go back.
(4)
Chrissy W.

This is the best fish market that I've ever visited. The prices are extremely reasonable and the fish is just so good. Keep in mind, it is a fish market so the restaurant is extremely casual. There are wooden tables with bench seating and food is served on paper plates. We came with a large party, and everyone seemed extremely happy with their meals. Somebody in our party ordered the ono platter sauteed. It came in this great lemony garlic saute. You could see the bits of garlic on top of the fish. If you enjoy garlic, you should consider the sauteed style for your fish. I ordered their opah blackened with a side of cajun rice and coleslaw. It was heavenly... but maybe everything tastes a little better when you've have had a great beach day. I'm already itching to go back to Maui just to make a visit to this fish market.
(5)
Erin T.

Awesome casual restaurant in Paia! Wonderful fish and chicken tacos. Menu is a bit limited, but we were 100% satisfied with our dining experience. From what I can tell, the best casual place to dine in Paia (other than Mama's Fish House, which is more formal). Definitely give it a try if you're in the area (and stop in the adorable Paia Mercantile next door for unique/reasonably priced gift items)!
(5)
Susan M.

stopped here for lunch after visiting haleakala crater. we started with the ahi sashimi. nice fish, but a little boring. i think i'm more of a tartare kind of girl, but the quality of the fish was tops. i had the ono burger with fries, and it was pretty tasty! the bf had the fish and chips (made with mahi mahi) and that was delish. i couldn't stop eating some of his fish. the fries were good, although the staff wasn't necessarily the friendliest. it's counter service with communal tables, but there was more than enough room for everyone.
(5)
Tracy D.

At the recommendation of locals, my bf and I got the mahi-mahi burger and the ono burger-- both amazing! No fish burger on the mainland can hold a candle to these. The fish was incredibly fresh, the tartar sauce had fresh dill it it (none of that prepackaged processed crap for them here, thank you very much), the lettuce was crisp, tomato juicy, and bun perfectly toasted. We were sitting with another couple at a long wooden table-- the four of us got our food at approximately the same time, and for 15 minutes conversation ceased completely. btw-- for those of you heading to Hana, they do have a restroom, but it's around the corner and you have to ask for the key at the counter.
(4)
keri r.

got here at 11am (when they opened), and there was already a crowd forming. i can see why! i ordered the ono burger, which was amazing. the fish was cooked perfectly, and their tarter sauce is delicious. my mom ordered the fish taco plate, which was good as well. i will come back for sure when i'm in paia, but i will definitely want to come back when they open to avoid the crowds!
(5)
Cin S.

The ahi burger was the best and includes a big ol' slab of tender, fresh ahi. Fish tacos were also extremely tasty. Wish I didn't have to go all the way to Maui to eat there. :(
(5)
John G.

Two words: Fish tacos. Fabulous. Located in town of Paia, the last stop in civilization if you are heading out to Hana on the Hana Highway. Place is just like a general store. You can pick up some nice items to snack on for your long trip to Hana. Check it out. Basic, non-touristy place for sure.
(3)
Robert L.

Had the "fish burger" in this case grilled ono on a bun. My wife and I had to share it it was so big. Some may look at the place and think that it is a dump BUT the food is so fresh and terrific. The fish is better than Mamas at 1/4 the price. The communal tables are "intimate" so you will make new friends. We drove from Lahaina as part of a day trip but it would be worth the trip if this is the destination
(5)
Alejundro S.

Love this place. Every year we stop by. wanna eat healthy? Order the Seafood salad with favorite fish cajun style.
(5)
Sarah T.

This is possibly the best fish on the island. The fish burger is the best thing you can order, I recommend the Mahi Burger, it's flakey and perfect! the Coleslaw sauce they use in the burger is perfect, it's a tarter-type sauce with lettuce and it's what makes the fresh fish absolutley perfect. If you don't get a fish sandwich anything you order is great. They get fresh caught fish delivered daily, so you know you'll walk away with a great meal. Downsides: Kind of expensive, but thats what you get for fresh fish. The sandwiches don't come with anything, fries and drinks must be ordered sepereatly. They keep water cups next to the fountain soda if you'd like water. The seating is small and seats are hard to come by. I'd reccomend getting your meal to go and eating at the beach if possible. Also, the line is ALWAYS out the door. No matter what. For some reason tourists know this place is a great spot, or they are just too lazy to walk their damn asses somewhere else. OVERALL: BEST FISH BURGER YOU WILL HAVE IN YOUR LIFE.
(5)
Jun B.

Paia Fish Market has the perfect fish. Charbroiled ono and opah. Their fish is fresh and broiled perfectly. Pair it with either rice or fries or onion rings. This is undoubtedly a must-go place to eat when visiting Maui. Fresh fish can't get any better than Paia Fish Market.
(5)
christine c.

simple, fresh amazing food. we had ono because we only come across it rarely in the pac NW. it was tender and amazing. the rice and the coleslaw were perfect. not a single complaint about the food... family style seating. very interesting.
(5)
Jennifer K.

I'm a little sad I didn't eat these fish tacos everyone keeps talking about. I ate fish and chips. Nothing special, but decent. The restaurant is airy and bright, but the downside is that there were ants all over the table. This definitely distracted me from my food. I'll give it another shot though.
(3)
Katherine S.

I Love Paia Fish Market! It's a definite must try when you're in Paia. I could eat here twice a week if I wasn't worried about my waistline. They have the best fish burgers and fries!
(5)
Laurel B.

Excellent fish tacos and a terrific ahi burger. Just order a la carte, or order one dinner (with the accompaniments like cole slaw) and one a la carte entree because it's plenty o' food. Very fresh fish. Cold beer plus this lunch at Hookipa watching the windsurfers = a fine time for me.
(4)
David And Samantha K.

This was the first place I ate after moving to Maui, and the only place I make sure to squeeze into every visit when I return. The family style tables add to the aloha spirit of this place-- I always seems to strike up an interesting conversation while trying to squish the messy fish burgers in my mouth. I love the Ono burgers, although the Mahi ones are good too! And before eating here, I don't think I'd ever had coleslaw ON my fish sandwich, but now I feel that it's required. Be sure to stop here when you're on this side of the island. You won't regret it!
(4)
Jackie B.

Seriously, I thought I would like this place because of all the great reviews. But my fish - wasn't even fresh. (freezer burn sucks). This is a tourist trap! ohh well, live and learn
(2)
Todd S.

Awesome... best bang for the buck. For $15, you get a seafood lover's feast - great casual dining.
(5)
Marie H.

Thank you Yelp for pointing us to this awesome find - we attempted the Road to Hana and made it just past Twin Falls (the roads were too windy for our group) before deciding to head back. We wanted to stop for lunch and ended up at the Paia Fish Market - our timing was perfect, we got the last table before the crowds came - it's a smaller restaurant that definitely has that beach-y vibe to it and a very local feel with the bench/picnic style seating - and the people that work there were just awesome, friendly, informative, talk about sharing the aloha spirit! And the food... everyone in our group was impressed with whatever they ordered - even the grilled chicken that the kids had was probably the best grilled chicken breast ever - so moist and yummy! This was also where my husband discovered the Opakapaka - cooked to perfection! This is definitely on our list of go-to places on our next visit!
(5)
Steve M.

Remember, you are in Maui, the pace is slow, service is not exactly the name of the game - but the Fish Market is great. The fish tacos, the fish and chips, the burgers - all excellent. Seating is tight, but the atmosphere is fun. I took my 3 teens, we had a great time, and the pricing reasonable. If you are looking for a solid place for lunch or dinner, this is a great option. And on Maui, you need good options - there are not many....
(4)
alex b.

BEST fish and calamari in maui!!! Local shop that you will never forget! Big servings and great atmosphere! Eat here it's amazing!!!
(5)
Kevin R.

A brilliantly different spin on fish and chips.
(4)
Mrs. Val V.

One of my Favorites when visiting the island of Maui. The fish tacos are excellent, which may seem odd to our friends on the mainland. I too, thought the concept of fish and tacos were a bit strange. But after spending a weekend in this little bohemian town, my local maui friends Insisted I try them, Ive been a fan ever since. Matter of fact,everything on the menu is nothing short of Delicious. My twin daughters love the fried fIsh platter. Whats great about this place is, its very casual and local but the food is nowhere near what you would expect..dont let the casual surfer decor fool you... it far exceeded my expectations. I would highly recommend to anyone visiting to check this place out. Its been a favorite place of ours for the past 8 years and counting.
(5)
monkey p.

wow! the fish here tastes like it was just caught from the sea. i think this might be the best meal in maui. and the prices are unbelievable. everything is so good and so fresh it doesn't need any spices or sauces. i could eat here everyday.
(5)
Kitty S.

BEST CHARBROILED MAHI FISH BURGER EVER! We were here for dinner and it was super busy but we got our dinner within 15 mins. It's cafeteria style here -- you eat at long wooden tables with other people. We also ordered the fish tacos -- everything in them was good except...the fish, which was too dry. Too bad. Paia's a laid-back, bohemian town, kind of like Venice in CA. It's not really killer to park -- there's a large public parking lot about 2 blocks away.
(5)
Brian W.

Fuc*ing Awesome!
(5)
Jule K.

I wish this place is close to where I live! Fish was very fresh. The Cajun style is fantastic. Must go place.
(5)
River F.

Maui would not be Psychedelic Babylon without this place. After any sponge 'n surf session, just got paid or lei'd ; and, crater adventure, you're bond to have a nasty appetite. Once you're back on earth, Pa'ia Fish Market's got plenty of grease to tame those visions and calm those nerves. Come down off that unrealistic vegan head trip with some Opakapaka (red snapper) burger coleslaw and potato salad. This place keeps it simple and rustic. They can't mess this up! If you sit by the window long enough you might see almost anything. Park your hippie bus in the lot down by the shell station and walk up. Excellent fish tacos. Great fries! Put some lemon in your coke. Great spot to be taken out. You won't break the bank of your host and you'll still get fed.
(4)
roger w.

great food, but quite pricey (about $50 for 3 lunches) - would have given 4 stars but for the fact that when my 8 year old daughter asked to get a leaf of lettuce for her $9 cheeseburger (plus $2 for fries on the side) they asked for a quarter. YGBFSM! I was tempted to take that quarter from the tip I left in the jar. Frikken nickel and dime the haoles on already overpriced stuff. I really enjoyed the food here and am not disinclined to return, but honestly, Wahoo's in CA is better and half the price.
(3)
Y L.

We come here everytime we are in Maui. My big Obama burger (fish burger with wasabi mayo) was great. My kids got the seafood linguini and it was enough to feed a family of four (and it was delish!). My husband got the fajita plate and it disappeared from his plate so fast I couldn't even sneak a taste. Plus, is it just me or is Paia getting a nice makeover. They even have a Honolua Surf Co. store and a gelato store now.
(5)
John K.

I have to admit. I've resisted expanding my review because I hate waiting in line. I love stopped by on our way to Keanae or on the way back from Hana. One thing is certain the "lunch crowd" starts at 11 AM and extends past 1:30 PM. It's very popular with the locals. The old timers like to take their time contemplating a menu that hasn't changed in years. The there's the new brand of locals that are on New York City Lunch Hour Time... all the time. We go to Maui to mellow out and Paia Fish Market is a vital part of our vacation. Beware: If you head over to Paia between 3:30 PM and 6:00 PM that's "locals" rush hour. Also, there's considerable traffic in the morning, it's on the "Road to Hana"
(5)
E. M.

Definitely get the mahi-mahi burger!
(4)
K M.

I've been here many times and each year it is a simple, but yummy meal. It's a no frills restaurant where you order at a counter and they call your number. The tables are picnic tables inside and it can be hard to get a table during the busy time, so best to go off peak hours. Fish always taste fresh and they serve wine and beer. I recommend it for a nice casual meal with family or friends.
(5)
ellis g.

The mainstays of the menu revolves around fresh, local fish at good prices. They do fish all day long and they do it well. I've had the fish tacos, fish burger, and seafood salad. The salad was okay (basically a delicious fillet on top of a mediocre salad) but the tacos and burgers were delicious. Many types of fish to choose from, changes daily based on catch. Highly recomended for fresh seafood, fast and at a good price.
(4)
Moko S.

good food, but i'm not sure if this is extremely good in maui. a bit pricey but everything is so expensive in maui.
(4)
Kathryn M.

Good food. Good price. Nice employees. Good atmosphere.
(4)
Anna S.

If you are staying in Maui for a while then a trip to the small town of Paia shoud be something to do. While here of course, you have to try the Paia Fish market and yes it is always packed but worth the experience. I came with a big group so it was hard to find a place to sit and we all had to scatter ourselves throughout benches in the small restaurant. This place is not for people who are looking for a comfortable, peaceful, quiet, no rush meal. There are only benches with no back rests and once you are done, there is pressure to leave to make room for more people waiting for a place to sit. The food is good, the prices are average and the ambiance is casual and simple. Parking in Paia can be tough when it is busy.
(4)
m c.

On my 5th trip to Maui. At least I can say I tried this place. Shared the fish tacos...my tortilla shell was hard and dry while my husbands was soft! What's up with that? We also ordered the mahi fish and chips. They were good but not fantastic. The mahi mahi fish burger was much better than all the stuff we ordered. Moist. Nothing to write home about. Not a place I would seek out to eat at next time I come to Maui.
(2)
larry m.

Stumbled on the Paia Fish Market on the advice of our tour guide Thomas from Phil's Volcano Tours. I had the Opah blackened fish plate. It was fabulous. The fish was cooked to perfectly and the flavors of the blackened seasoning were not overpowering. We got there a little after 2:30 and the place was a little busy but the got our order to us pretty quickly. The eating area has a bunch of picnic style tables so if you're the friendly type, you can meet other tourists and locals. I'll be coming here again on my next trip to Maui.
(4)
Daniel T.

its hard to figure out what to order since there's so many ways you could get the fish... we just got the fish and chips and calamari and it was great! highly recommended
(5)
erica m.

We had read a lot of great reviews and were craving a tasty fish sandwich. We arrived at high noon on Saturday. Probably the busiest time of the week. The line was stretched the length of the cozy restaurant but moved at a decent pace. Seating is communal on picnic benches which allows for hearing interesting conversations amongst neighbors and stricking up small talk. We ordered the Mahi burger and the Ono burger and split one order of fries which were enough for two. A tasty Maui IPA was a great refresher. We preferred the Mahi over the Ono----the Mahi was a flaky, moist fish and the Ono was more firm and dry. The non-descript bun holds shredded cheese, coleslaw and tomato with a small amount of tarter sauce. IMO the sandwich was a little dry and could of used a little more sauce. Overall we thought the Mahi sandwich was good but not great. I wish I could give them 3 1/2 stars. Maybe were a little too critical but we had such high hopes from all the reviews. (It is hard to complain about wonderful Hawaiian fish we can't get on the mainland). Paia Fish Market is a good value for two fresh fish sandwiches ($30-35 with two beers). If we had to do it over again we would order the Mahi sandwich again with an order of fish and chips.
(3)
Carla M.

We tried the ono burger and the mahi burger...YUMMY. Seasoned french fries were really tasty too. Service was quick considering how crowded it was. It's always super busy, so you may have to wait a few minutes to find a seat, but it's well worth it.
(4)
rachel p.

This place was delicious! Would give it more stars if I could! The food is fresh, tasty and portions are generous! Will be making this a regular stop on our next maui trip! The mahi mahi fish and chips are a must! Extra juicy! Yum!
(5)
David E.

Delicious, succulent, extravagant. Simply the best and freshest fish sandwiches on the island. So what if I like hyperbole? Big whoop wanna fight about it?
(5)
Bay Area Truth Teller Z.

Maybe we caught them on a bad day, but my mahi mahi and chips were dry as a bone and not worth the price. They might as well have served me fish sticks. I wouldn't have known the difference. There is no bathroom, it seems very crowded all the time, and very unorganized. The worst part was the price. It was $30 for my boyfriend and I to eat lunch -- LUNCH? At a FAST FOOD place? Come on' Paia Fish Market. Thats ridiculous even for HI's higher cost of living standards. If the food was fabulous, I'd not complain, but it was not good at all.
(2)
merle s.

We stopped here after the Road to Hana, and we were so happy that we did. We had the ono burgers with fries, and it was so very delicious. Food was perfect and the price reasonable, portions were healthy. I did not leave even a little bit hungry. I would definitely return.
(5)
Mike G.

Probably the best fish tacos outside of the beach in Mexico where they bring the fish right off the boat. Great service from the counter person at lunch today. Very polite and patient. When you order the tacos, request the ahi as the fish. Its all good but hte ahi is awesome. There is a 1$ up charge for the ahi. Its a must visit on that side of the island.
(5)
Young H.

I am NOT a seafood seeker. We live in the Seattle area and have great exposure to good, very good seafood. But, I would not know it. I really wanted to try this place and we ate here twice in less than 24 hours. I had the fish tacos the first night and then fish and chips for lunch the next day. The fish was good, very good. My wife had a Ono Fish Garden Salad and it looked great as well. The tacos were excellent and the fried fish was really good. I think their tartar sauce is really good (is it made from scratch?). This place is packed so be patient. The service is quick and competent. The price is made more manageable because it is not a full service restaurant (you order at the counter and you pick up your order just a few feet from where you placed your order).
(3)
ryan h.

this place was great every time i had the pleasure of making it to this side of the island... their portion sizes are massive and they have a pretty decent selection of fish and sides and flavors... in busy season there is usually a pretty big wait and there is not a lot of seating, but once you make it through the wait i assure you it is well worth it!
(4)
Shay L.

What we ordered: fish tacos, mahi mahi fish n chips and fried calamari appetizer. On all 3 items the fish was so over-salted that it hurt our stomachs after eating. We were all so hungry we ate it anyway but would not be going back. Fish did not taste fresh, it tasted like it had been soaked in brine. Atmosphere was fine, service was friendly. Maybe it was an off day?
(2)
Michelle C.

This is a casual fish market type place; you go to a counter and you eat at communal tables. That said, our food was really great. Fresh Hawaiian fish and cole slaw with perfect fries. They have daily fish specials that are excellent. A review below panned the frozen shrimp...why would you order shrimp in Hawaii with all the fresh fish? Eat local. Best lunch we had in Maui.
(5)
Eugene L.

best dinner of the trip! opah fish was excellent. Seafood pasta was excellent! price is average. Cheaper than anything on the coast in west maui and way better. I would def come back.
(5)
Lauren F.

the paia fish market has been one of my greatest culinary loves for the past (how old am i again?) thirteen years. do i miss the weird decor and equally weird paia-ites that used to grace the market's interior? yes. do I kind of lament the fact that since the island's gotten busier it can be really hard to get a spot at one of the picnic tables and that tourists can be kind of jerks about letting you sit with them? sure. is it still worth the effort to drive to the other side of the island for their mahi fish and chips? abso-freakin-lutely. sitting down to a massive plate of dayboat mahi, thin-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw and a newcastle beer is one of the most incredible feelings man/womankind can experience, comparable only to the feeling one might get when winning the lottery or escaping a speeding ticket. locals probably already know all of this, though, so here are some tips for the tourists: 1. get there. now. 2. whatever you order, make sure you douse it properly in tiger sauce, found in the condiment caddies on every table. 3. if a shirtless/shoeless/wet kid needs a place to sit, scooch over. he's been surfing all day and he's hungry, too. 4. be kind to your busboy; help out and use the busbuckets in front of the fish counter. don't forget to recycle your bottles and cans. 5. drink it all in, 'cause there's no place like in on the mainland!
(5)
Henry W.

Fantatic seafood pasta and salad. The wife and I shared the salad and pasta and it was enoug for the both of us. The fish was fresh as can be and the sauce is to die for. both my wife and I agreed this was the best meal we had in Maui all week. Definitely will be back the next time in Maui.
(5)
A T.

Excellent food! Great atmosphere! This is a must while in Maui. Loved for the food here!
(4)
Karen D.

Expensive! Fish tacos and Fresh grilled fish, YUM! The only reason I give this 3 stars instead of 4 was because of the RUDE woman who took our order. There was no one behind us and she repeatedly said "ARE YOU READY" while rolling her eyes. We had questions since this was our first visit and she seemed annoyed with answering. Too bad, she kinda ruined the experience!
(3)
kirstin p.

Calling all fish lovers - this is the place to go when on Maui. Located on the corner of Baldwin Avenue and Hana Highway in the surfer town of Pa'ia, this 'hole in the wall' serves the most mouth-watering ("Broke 'da mout" as us locals say) fresh fish. All the fish is caught fresh daily and is prepared in a variety of styles - Fish Tacos are amazing, cajun style, fish burgers etc. etc. Seating is limited and is 'picnic table' style complete with cafeteria-style forks and knives in wooden holders. 'Regulars' include Maui residents Gabby Reece and her big-wave surfer husband Laird Hamilton.
(5)
Tommy K.

The best Fish Burgers around. The Obama Ono is the bomb if you like spicy. Mahi, Ahi, it is all good. Super friendly, clean, fresh and very casual. Enjoy!!!
(5)
Karine W.

I had read all the reviews, and decided we had to try it out, so we made it up to Paia on our last night in Hawaii. Truly, the fish just tastes amazing! Husband had the Mahi fish and chips, and I had the seafood pasta. The fish was SO wonderful, and my pasta was HUGE, with big pieces of fish and shrimp, and tasted amazing. It is definitely a place the locals hit, and was quite busy at 7pm on Saturday night, so we had to wait a few minutes for some open space at a table, but it was worth it. Crowded and busy, but definitely recommend checking it out.
(4)
Velma C.

I thought this place was fantastic. My friends and I went on the recommendation of a tour guide. It's a really laid-back casual place--you order at a counter and wait for your number to be called; at the counter is a small sign that lists that day's fresh fish; the tables are first-come, first-sit, and it's likely you'll share a long table with another party. It feels like a beach-side surf shack, which it kind of is. I actually went back a second time, I liked it so much. First time I had a dinner plate with ono, second time I got the seafood salad with salmon. I thought the portions were huge, and the pricing reasonable. It's a nice, chill place, no pretentions.
(5)
Tracy H.

The best fish and chips I have ever had!!!!! I could've eaten a double order. Three largish mouth-watering, perfectly seasoned and fried to perfection hunks of mahi mahi. The coleslaw on the side was also tasty. My hubby had the ono burger and it was also very good. My brother had the Obama burger and it was delicious. I'll be craving this all the way back to the mainland for sure.
(5)
josh D.

Food here was great. Stopped here on the way to Hana for lunch. Had the Ono (which means delicious). And the Ono was ONO! Place was the type you order from the counter and they call you when it is ready. There are about 10 tables that seat about 8-10 people each.
(5)
A K.

This is where the locals go for fresh fish. If you don't want to break the bank but still eat fresh, avoid Mama's and head for the Pa'ia Fish Market. The night we were there, they had Ono, Ahi and Mahi Mahi, the three most popular fishes in Hawaii. I had the Ono sauteed with garlic, lemon and butter with a side of potatoes and rice for $21.95. My friend had it fried Cajun style, which was also delicious. They gave me a huge chunk of fish. I could have probably shared it with my husband. Everyone sat in long wooden tables with benches and you go up, order your food and go up when your number is called. It's not a fancy place but casual and chill. It's a nice break from the resorts.
(5)
Hilary M.

The BESt! Worth the wait!!! Authentic fresh food! Had the fish tacos-Ono Cajun style! Delish!!! We will be back!
(5)
Kacie H.

This place is worth the wait. Actually the line was fast and the fish is so good! Amazing! I could eat here evwryday!!!!!
(5)
Naomi L.

Always super busy, very casual. Had fish n chips and was slightly bland, next time I want to try the fish tacos.
(4)
Cynthia A.

We returned for another delicious meal at the Paia Fish Market last night. There were 4 of us who enjoyed Opa and Ono. Two of the Opas were prepared Blackened and served with French Fries and Cole Slaw. The third Opa was grilled and the Ono sautÃ©ed with butter, white wine and garlic served on top of Home Fries. All of the entrees were prepared so that the fish was perfect - moist and flaky. The butter on the Ono had been browned and the garlic burned so that it took away from the delicacy of the fish. This restaurant is casual with picnic tables you wait for as they become available after you order your food in line. They have a wonderful assortment of beers and wines. Our table enjoyed 3 Bikini Blonds and a glass of Louis Latour Chardonnay. This is a must if you're near Paia!
(4)
S L.

Great lunch stop. Everything costs more on the island, but at this place you get what you pay for. The fish was fresh and speed of service was good. Nothing fancy here, you will be sharing a table with other customers. Really cool island vibe in a nice town.
(4)
Matt C.

HUGE portion size. For 1/4 the cost of a meal at Mama's you get 4x as much food here at the Paia Fish Market. On a street lined with overpriced apparel and artwork, this popular fish joint on the corner is a great deal. I had the blackened Mahi Mahi plate. The fish came out looking like a 16oz porterhouse steak, and was just as thick too. Fantastic blackened cajun rub, super fresh fish, and sitting on a bed of nicely done homestyle potatoes and rice. The cole slaw was even pretty tasty. I was very happy with my meal. Inside, the ambiance is beachy, with communal picnic table seating, lively music, and somewhat of a beach-themed TGIF tchotckes vibe. The counter where you order is much higher off the ground than normal, making it feel like you are ordering your fish straight from god, and it tastes like that too.
(4)
Nat W.

They have about 6 big tables inside and most likely you will have to share a table with other people. The tables are a little messy and typical ambiance of beach places. My mom and I shared a seafood salad with blacken mahi ($15). The portion was huge and the fish and vegetables were fresh, though they put too much salt and pepper. There are not too many dining options in Paia and I think this is one of a few restaurants with good average priced food. *Featured on "Best Thing I Ever Ate" Cooking Channel.
(4)
godfred l.

The wait was very long and unfortunately food was medicore. The main problem is that there is a moth or some bug in my chowder!!! An inch long bug with wings!!! How dirty can they be...totally disappointed
(1)
Scoob W.

Super busy. You stand in line to order and the whole time cross your finger and hope that there will be seating. Huge portions. Good food. But pricey for this type of restaurant.
(4)
Ellen C.

This is our second time visiting the Paia Fish Market, and even though the last time we were there was three years ago, we ended up ordering the same things: fish tacos for me and a grilled fish burger for my husband. The menu is simple, but you can change it up by ordering different types of fish. My husband had the grilled ono, and it was delicious as usual. I had one ono and one opah taco. Both were good, but I could have done without the cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes. ( I actually pulled those toppings off and added some coleslaw instead. Now THAT was good!) My taco plate came with the aforementioned coleslaw and also your choice of rice or potatoes. Sadly, they were out of the Cajun rice, so I had the homestyle potatoes, which were nothing special. Next time we're back in Maui, we will probably stop by the fish market again, but I think I'll get the fish burger. That's one tasty sandwich. And fresh to boot!
(4)
Kelly K.

This place is fantastic. Be prepared for a long line and having to fight for a seat, but it is worth it. My husband and I ate here for lunch on our way up to the road to Hana and we loved it so much that we ate there for dinner on our way back home. The fish and chicken tacos are amazing!
(5)
Bad News S.

Yeah the fish is good but . .. We went back here after several years, hungering what used to be very good fish sandwiches. The fish, Ono and Mahi Mahi, were pretty good but I seem to recall they offered a wider choice of how they prepared the fish. The buns sure have slipped in taste and quality. Fries and onion rings were just average, not what we remembered. Lines were long but everyone was polite and well behaved and moved out when they were finished. Noisey place as well. The food is good but I can't say it is as good as it seemed several years ago. Cash only. I'd recommend if you must try this place to go when there are fewer crowds like early lunch or after 2pm lunch. If you are in Paia, you could probably do a lot worse for food but we left feeling a bit disappointed. I understand they are finally setting up a second store in Kihei and we'd probably try it one of these days.
(3)
M C.

This place was REALLY good! From the minute we walked in we were greeted like family. It was so hard to decide what to order but we found a great solution: ordered the fish tacos & the Ahi sandwich and shared. Both were delicious but I think Ahi sandwich slightly one upped the tacos. The tacos had some really good rice & slaw you don't want to miss out on. ORDER BOTH!
(5)
Kim W.

the best fish tacos I have ever had. each year we come back to Maui we make the drive for these tacos. if you don't want to wait for a table, show up after lunchtime but well before the dinner crowd. if you are not starvin, a plate with two tacos can easily be shared. love this place
(5)
Wyatt B.

Maybe the best fish you will have on the island. It takes a minute for them to make your food, but it is well worth the wait.
(5)
Natalee B.

If you want a delicious seafood meal, this is the place! I have been here with my husband a few times, and each time we have had a great experience. We have tried the fish and chips, fish tacos, seafood pasta, seafood chowder, and the fish quesadilla. Each dish was so delicious, I don't think I could pick a favorite. Everything is priced reasonably and portions are large. The ambiance is great. Can't wait to go back!
(5)
Cindy M.

Went in here a little bit before lunch rush for some beer and tacos. We've just landed to Maui the night before and was excited to try some local fresh Hawaiian food. Turned out to be a disappointing experience. We ordered the two tacos plates (came with rice and coleslaw). I do have to say that the portion was big. Our rice portion was huge and we weren't even close to finishing it. Partly because it was dry and a bit under seasoned. The tacos are not very exciting either. The fish tasted blend and very small pieces in the sea of cabbage. Basically a self-service joint, grab your own utensils and get seated. There's about 10 long tables inside. Very nice beach vibe. Restroom is available outside the restaurant, grab the keys on the wall (if you are facing the cashier, it'll be on the rightmost wall).
(2)
Karen S.

YUM! Loved this place. We stayed in Paia for three days - and ate here everyday for lunch. The fish tacos were all I ate - but their fish sandwiches that my husband got were equally amazing. SO delicious - you really can't go wrong eating here. Try it out if you're in Paia. It's quick, pretty cheap and tasty!
(5)
Tony U.

We were looking for something without the fanfare of so many of the typical restaurants in Maui and we were so happy to have learned of Paia Fish Market! We enjoyed their Fried Calamari for our appetizer, it was so fresh and light. For our entree we had their Fish Tacos and Blackened Ono. We live in Southern Cal and have fish tacos almost weekly, these were unlike anything we have ever had! The flavors burst in your mouth and the fish was firm and very tasty. The Ono was blackened to perfection and when you cut into the Ono you could see how well prepared it was. I have never had "Blackened" as I did here, true perfection!
(5)
Nadia H.

The food here was our first stop on Maui, and the most scrumptious. Truly excellent, fresh, expertly seasoned fish. We got the fresh fish of the day with cajun seasoning. It was *AMAZING*. I don't say that lightly. Just the right amount of seasoning, tasted fresh, the right temperature (piping hot). The service left a lot to be desired. The lady taking the orders was brusque, totally unhelpful, and the cafeteria style dining was ok, but nothing to write home about. Definitely go for the food.
(4)
N K.

I had very high expectations going to this place. The fish tacos: good fish but majorly over-cooked and poorly seasoned and flavored. The Obama burger: really fresh fish and well seasoned- tastier than the fish tacos. Very very crowded and hard to find seating. Also, very loud inside and you constantly feel rushed. All in all, a very unpleasant atmosphere with above average food.
(3)
David P.

Great little place with great prices. Cheapest way to get as much Ono as you want and the tacos were amazing. The salad and fries were forgettable, but very busy and worth the wait
(4)
Anne M.

Oh my goodness!! This place rocks!! The food we ordered was simply divine! I ordered scrumptious seafood linguine and it was amazing. The hubs ordered fish tacos and I think they are better than Monkey Pod's. My son's fish quesadilla was really good as well. Food overall was great. It comes out fast and tasty. The place does get packed and it has a rather small dining area, given its large following. Other than that, I would say this restaurant is one of the best in the island. Not pretentious. Just good seafood. Plain and simple.
(4)
Virginia M.

"Would you like a side of pot with that?" We'll this place is goddamn amazing and so EVEN though it's pushing 600 reviews, and mine will be superfluous, I'm still posting it. Because: principle, and all that. This has become a must-do during our trips to Maui. Pa'ia is a trip, kind of a hipster-hippy-trendy-crafty mashup. The locals are awesome.. There's so much pot here it's unreal. Seriously, red eyes for days. But that doesn't matter, let's get to the fish.... So here's the short of it: big portions, super casual, fair prices, delicious fish. The long of it: we always order the fish sandwiches or the fish tacos (which are gluten free). They've never disappointed. They carry a variety of gluten free side dishes as well,: coleslaw, rice, potatoes. I don't recommend eating in if you're looking for a nice romantic dinner, it's cramped and hot and there are always flies... That's cause the doors are always open, cause the place is always packed. Most of the locals get their meals to-go. And that's a good idea. 2 fish tacos are about $14 with three sides, it's a ton of food. The fish salads are around that price as well. They serve beer and wine only, no full bar. This is a fabulous meal dressed in island vibes and small town charm, so leave your fancy-pants 5-star dining snootiness at home. Oh and don't actually ask for a side of pot...that won't go over well.
(5)
Gaurav H.

The best place in Maui for 1st class fish, Mama's fish house comes close but is very pricey. I really enjoyed the blackened Opakapaka with brown rice and fries that I had here. Also, the place has a great vibe and high energy. Was very crowded and me and my wife had to share a table with another family (with noisy kids!!), but all said and done, I wish I can go there for dinner every single night. Loved this place.
(5)
Rachelle K.

This place has the best fish burgers!!! Super laid back and amazing food!!! Must eat place in Kihei!
(5)
Sam F.

The seared ahi burger was THEE BEST! Nothing anywhere could compare. No joke! It was served with a heaping amount of potatoes. I highly recommend getting their Caesar salad. The prices were a bit high but what are you expecting for an AHI, which is fresh by the way and in Hawaii? The place is usually packed to the point where you cannot move and if you're planning to sit inside you better have amazing luck because it's almost impossible. My recommendation is to just grab it to go and eat it on the beautiful beach of paia bay.
(5)
Leonardo Z.

Cozy small place. Serves tasty fresh fish at reasonable prices compared to others around here. Good place to stop on the way to airport or on road to Hana. Also has variety of beer and wines. Not fancy but yummy!
(4)
Tina L.

I agree with more skeptical reviewers here. We had both Mahi mahi and Ono. Onion rings were delic but definitely not 30 minute wait delic. The fish was fresh but definitely not worth the hype. This is literally the last stop of civilization until Hana and I made fun of our dinner options in the jungle (literally one of two dinner spots and a handful of food truck lunch options) but even the mahi mahi prepared at Braddah Hutt (in a food truck) was prepared juicier and just better than Paia Fish Market, which overcooked both of my fish and made them taste like steak.
(3)
Mike F.

Spent the last day of vacation in Maui buzzing around Paia and landed here for some Fish Tacos. A little busy, will sit with strangers for sure, but the food is worth! For like $12 you get a couple of mahi mahi tacos on top of a crap load of fries/cajun rice and vinegar slaw. The tortillas were fresh and crispy, the fish flaky and soft, nice spices. If you're looking for fish tacos in Maui, you wont find a better place for the price.
(5)
Hara W.

A great place for dinner after the road to hana. Great bargains, excellently fresh seafood, and interesting local brews. I ordered mahi burger ($10) and bikini blonde for beer ($6). Plus, Paia is great town with loads of hippie local-conscious shops.
(4)
Xavier V.

We only had short time for lunch so we ordered some ahi sashimi and ono burgers to go and ate them while driving. Almost right away, we wished we ordered more. I don't normally eat fish but the sashimi literally was melting in my mouth and as fresh as it can be. The ono burger was... just really, really good. It definitely wasn't filet-o-fish. We'll definitely eat here again when back in Paia and highly recommend to anyone traveling there.
(4)
Susan S.

Fish from Costco is not my idea of fresh
(1)
Anellia I.

This is absolutely the best place to get delicious and fresh fish and seafood on Maui! I've had everything on their menu, but my absolute favorite is the opakapakapa fish burger with fries and coleslaw. It's so yum that I'm salivating as I'm typing this review. The fresh catch fish plate is also not to miss, especially if you're up for a bigger meal -- portions are huge and my husband and I always ended up sharing one meal and taking the other one home/to the beach. Seriously, this place is so delish that there were days when we'd hang out on Baldwin beach instead of any other nicer beach just to be closer to Paia Fish Market for lunch.
(5)
David O.

Amazingly Fresh!! Stopped here after a long hike for a grab to eat . Try their fish and chips or mahi dish. Yum! Casual in the center of Paia .
(5)
Diana M.

My bf and I tried the sashimi, calamari, shrimp cocktail appetizers . They were all spectacular . I had the Ono burger and my bf had fish tacos . We tried a few other good places for fish tacos on our vacation to Maui but these were the best.
(5)
Shaun G.

Freshest and best calamari I've ever had. Popular so it's cramped, but once you find a table and eat the food it's worth it. Paia is also a great city to walk around and this is located on the main road.
(5)
Teresa F.

Great fish available casual setting. Picnic tables for seating.
(4)
Troy P.

A lot of things contributed to the 5 star rating for Paia Fish Market. We cruised around the island and made our way into town towards supper time, after finally finding a parking spot we walked around to see what there was to see then looked for something to eat. Well, Paia Fish Market was bustling with activity, the line was literally out the door which was the first sign that this place must be good. The inside is tight and a little confusing for first timers but totally worth it. The tables on either side of the interior are long and allow for an aisle from the counter to the entrance, this is where the line forms. Communal dining is acceptable as the tables are so large only bigger groups can really fill one all the way up. You can't help but watch other people eat while you are in line and ask them with wide eyes, "Hey, whatcha got there?". There is a menu on the tables, above the register and at the very front by the entry door, basically what fish are available and how you want it served. I got the Opah Fish Tacos and it was an enormous portion, I'm a big guy and like generous amounts of food, and I can tell you I was smiling when it arrived. The fish was not deep fried but lightly seared or pan fried. They also came with potatoes, Cole slaw and some kind of homemade sauce. You get the local feeling while you're here although as you look around I think only tourists actually stay there to eat, I'm betting all the locals call in for takeout. Either way, try this place out and eat some fresh fish. You won't regret it.
(5)
Cristina M.

Yum! I ordered the seafood pasta, and my boyfriend ordered the mahi burger, which I also stole a couple of bites from. Although they forgot to put any mushrooms in mine, which the menu said it had and I love, it was still amazing! The portion was fairly large and very easily split-able. There were only about 3 scallops and 3 pieces of shrimp, but they were very generous with the amount of fish in there, and the sauce was amazing! If I would go there again I would order the mahi hamburger which my boyfriend did instead of the seafood pasta. Fish was very fresh!
(5)
Amanda L.

We were passing through and chose here over mamas fish house and we weren't disappointed! The dishes were fair priced and the fish was so tender! The onion rings were also quite delicious! My husband and I both recommend.
(5)
Holli H.

It was good. I would certainly go again, but it's not all the hype it's made out to be. They rotate their fish according to what's caught for the day, but it's rather expensive and you get huge portions. If you're just stopping by for lunch, be prepared for that. The bathroom situation leaves something to be desired. Otherwise, the food is yummy. I would recommend checking it out.
(4)
Jesika C.

I hate fish... But I had tried the mahi mahi tacos with slaw and Cajun rice. HOLY OFF THE WALL AMAZING! I love fish now. Whatever they put on that taco was perfectly balanced food love. Shout out to the chef. My husband had a grilled ahi sandwich with fries and he loves it. The only negative is that the tables are somewhat communal and u gotta grab a seat where u can. If you take a large group, be prepared to wait to sit together. The Food came out quickly and fast and the pretty girl that takes your order was super helpful and nice! They have someone in the dinning area constantly cleaning so it's never dirty. We sat beside locals who say they come to dine at least 2x a week! Super good food!!!!
(4)
Stephanie E.

Huge portions and good food.
(5)
Ramsha B.

I had greater expectations because of the reviews and stuff but I didn't really like their food. I ordered their salmon with Cajun rice and my husband got their quesadilla with seafood. The Cajun rice were kind of bland for me. My husband though his quesadilla was good but I didn't like that either. It is a small place and seems like its usually crowded so you got to share tables. They have an extensive menu so that's what some people might like.bi didn't see any restrooms so that's a minus. Over all its just at average restaurant.
(2)
Ali B.

We tried Paia Fish Market when we thought we were not hungry! But man, you should have seen me eating the fish! I think this was one of the best fish sandwiches I have ever tried. I recommend this place for light or heavy portions. You may try different variations of Ono fish if you are looking for a local delicious fish.
(4)
Katie B.

Our favorite meal on Maui! And pretty cheap too! We had the Ono burger with fries and fish tacos with Spanish rice. These tacos put the Coconuts fish tacos to shame - so good! I'd skip the rice and get fries, and Ono burger was awesome too! Highly recommend!
(5)
Rob E.

Small place that really has great food! Portions are very large so I recommend sharing if you can. My wife and I split the Ono lunch plate with Cajun rice and coleslaw. It was amazing! Fish was cooked well done and we ordered it blackened. Spices were very flavorful and exactly what I expect when ordering fish blackened. Portion was perfect for us to share. When you order fish you have several options for type of fish ie Ono, mahi mahi, monchoung etc and you also choose how it is prepared ie sautÃ©ed, blackened, etc. plus you have several options for sides! Small place but they have like 8 tables that seat six so you will probably share your table with others.
(5)
Lloyd J.

OVERALL: Okay food. DETAILS: Fish Tacos are okay. Fish was a bit hard perhaps over cooked. I had Cajon rice and fries on the side, again just okay. Fries were refried and hard. Fish Quesadilla not good. Tasted like refried beans overload. For the amount they charge is was not worth it.
(2)
Michelle G.

We had time to kill before checking in to the condo and since we were only 15 minutes away from Paia we decided to check this restaurant off our yelp dining list.This was our first meal after arriving in Maui and I must say that this charming little hippy town grabbed my heart. I loved that you share tables and could really capture the aloha spirit and begin to unwind after a long flight and the hustle and bustle of the airport crowds. I had the fish and chips, I usually never get fried fish but it looked so good that I couldn't resist. The fish was so delicate and tender and perfectly seasoned, a large portion of fries and coleslaw and I was in a food coma. My husband had the Obama burger and loved it as well. We stopped by here for dinner a few days later after the road to Hana and then again as our last meal on our way back to the airport. Needless to say we will be back on our next visit to Maui. If you like fish you have to try this fish market during your time in Maui.
(5)
Rj L.

Wow! Just really a good place to eat. Bench seating with other people but hey, that's the Aloha spirit!... Fish and chips (made with Mahi Mahi), seafood chowder, onion rings and a fish taco fir the two of us was waaaaay too much food ( which was a good thing). I'm always wary when traveling to get a couple small things on a plate and leave hungry! Not here! Prices were good and the quality was outstanding! Definitely recommend!!!
(5)
Natasha G.

This place seems to be THE place in Paia. We went on Saturday at 830pm and it was still packed. Order food at the counter, find a seat at the shared picnic tables, and wait for your number to be called. I had the ono burger with fries, and my husband had the mahimahi fish and chips. My ono burger was really tasty, but man its a mess to eat. Next time Id just order it as a plate instead of as a burger. The fries were good, had good seasoning. Hubby said the fish and chips were good... not the best hes ever had, but good. Especially enjoyed the tarter sauce. The price was good for the quality and freshness of the food.
(3)
Linda L.

Great stop on the way back from the road to Hana! We were starved but wanted to get off the curvy roads before nightfall. I had the burger. After all that hiking I was famished. My husband had the fish tacos and both were excellent. The price is right and the food was served quickly despite being very busy! Oh and I forgot to mention the onion rings. Yummy!
(5)
Yuan Y.

I don't usually write reviews because I read reviews, and if the experience is similar to what other reviewers described, I don't feel the need to repeat redundant messages. What I describe is a deviation from other reviewers. Ono dinner plate was big, fish was flaky but dry. Only had flavor on surface. The mahi of the mahi fish and chips was burned black on the outside, fish inside was edible. Not sure if that was intended. Overall felt like ate a gigantic chunk of flavorless and dry fish.
(2)
Tom S.

This is a basic restaurant where you walk up to the kitchen counter to order food, sit at picnic tables to eat. The fish dishes are tasty. The portion sizes are generous. The cleanliness factor (pretty low) was an issue for me. I left the place feeling pretty sticky. No restroom to wash up after a meal. I like the food, hate the dumpy ambience.
(3)
Sarah C.

OH my goodness, where do I start? So Paia Fish Market is located on the corner of Baldwin and Hana highway, very convenient. There is parking a bit further down Hana highway (if you are coming from Hana) in a big parking area on the left, or it will be on the right if you are coming from Kahului. The ambiance is rushed feeling, and there are tables to sit down at and eat, which is nice but we usually take it to go. The food is excellent! My favorite is the Ono burger with fries. The Ono is moist and flakey, and whatever they use to season it with is the bomb! I love their coleslaw and tarter sauce, there is just a unique tang to it. The staff is pretty friendly and our order comes out in like 5-10 mins. The prices are about $10 for a burger and $15 for entree. Pretty reasonable...for Maui. We always take friends and family visiting from the Mainland to Paia Fish Market,
(4)
Mark B.

I like fish fine, but would not consider myself a fish enthusiast. After asking a local for some recommendations on eating, they suggested we try the Paia Fish Market. It looked like a local mom and pop shop, so we decided to give it a shot. I've never had a fish burger before and honestly went in thinking fish had no business being on a bun. I ordered an Okapohana (something like that) burger. I was expecting it to be tolerable, but from the first bite absolutely had my mind blown. I could not believe how much flavor it had. Absolutely the best meal I had in my entire week in Hawaii. To be fair, my wife had fried fish and chips and hers tasted normal, so I'm certainly not trying to vouch for the entire menu, but the fish burger was delicious. If I hadn't been staying on the other side of the island, I probably would have gone again.
(5)
Andrea B.

In search of some killer fish and chips, thought Paia Fish Market would be a great place to try. Umm....a bit disappointed, but they were still okay. The Mahi fish was a bit dry and bland, had a decent batter, the fries were a bit salty, and the coleslaw was fresh and good. I liked the calamari much better and it was served with a pretty good tarter sauce. They do have a good variety on their menu, and for those none fish eaters they do have burgers! Service is fair, and the line is always through the entrance of the restaurant to the counter. Hard to get seating, especially for larger parties. Prices were okay. Parking as always is a challenge in Paia.
(3)
Edward Y.

Good quality fish, casual ambience, great happy attitudes from the staff. Prices are like maui style pricing tho (interpret how you wish). Enjoyed the meal, nothing to complain about but if I go back I'd try somewhere else before going back again.
(3)
Nick G.

I heard about this place from the show "The Best Thing I Ever Ate," and they said this was the place to go for some awesome Fish Tacos. So of course, I hopped on a plane to Maui to try them out... They didn't disappoint either. The place was very busy, as were we, so we just got the fish tacos, ate them standing up among a group of people waiting for a seat, and loved every second of it. The ingredients were all fresh and delicious. The tarter sauce may have been the best tarter sauce ever, and it all just went together perfectly. Bravo. Wish I'd of had more, next time! I highly recommend this place.
(5)
Sara H.

I had the fish quesadilla with Cajun rice. It was fabulous and the price was reasonable for Maui! Excellent quesadilla! I would recommend this restaurant in a second!
(5)
Staycie K.

Fantastic food every single time. I like to call my order in so that I don't have to wait in line and then wait for the food.
(5)
Justin A.

I ordered the fish quesadilla tacos. Yea I know who orders fish quesadillas? I do! I was craving fish and cheese and this was the only way to fix the craving I had. It was a lot of fish jam packed into the quesadilla.
(3)
April S.

One of my favorite places great prices Fish sandwich with Tiger sauce the best relaxed atmosphere you order and sit down and try the fries to
(5)
Kimthy D.

My husband and I shared the 2 taco plate and I was stuffed. Husband said it was his favorite fish tacos that we've had on the island. I really enjoyed it, the portion was big and we were content. Their system is very efficient making it easy to order and pick up your food. Too bad they don't sell fresh fish to cook on your own. We'll be back though!
(5)
Stuart T.

They are very rude and the food is just ok... actually their beans are canned so that is worse than just ok. I dont ever post 1 star reviews cause I dont belive that its fair... but I was so angry I almost broke my rule...but I resisted
(3)
Antonio A.

Amazing food! Inexpensive. Great stop!
(5)
Robert M.

Ono was grilled perfect. For an interesting vibe sit and enjoy at a community table both local & international customers.
(4)
Taylor Ann D.

What a great spot!! The veggie dinner was super bomb and the atmosphere was great! Will come back for sure. TAJ
(5)
R P.

This place was the surprise of the trip: the fish tacos were incredible. The place is packed, a testament to their great food. Spendy, but huge--huge--portions. If you're in Paia, this is the place to eat. Communal tables, serve yourself, long line to order, but worth it.
(5)
Day B.

I like the chicken sandwich better haha Fish and chips are a good option along with the calamari. They used to make a burger called the Obama burger- it was pretty good! If you ask they are pretty cool and will cook it up. Ask for extra wasabi butter! If you want a salad - the Caesar with fish is a good one. Seating is the only downside.
(4)
Mandana B.

AMAZING!!!! This place was one of the highlights of our Maui trip. I had the Obama burger with Ono, and it was sooooooooo good that I had to go back on our way to the airport for our final dinner! I loved the town and Paia and the style of the restaurant was very casual and relaxed. You have to go here if you are visiting Maui! Yummy for my tummy!! Tip - Have someone in your party grab a table while you are in like to order, they get really busy and seating is limited.
(5)
Linda G.

Excellent fish tacos the best I ever had! My husband has fish & chips and coleslaw he said were "excellent" It's casual dining self serve, family style picnic tables but longer.
(5)
Misty W.

This is our go to place as soon as we get off the plane. The fish is ALWAYS fresh. Try the blackened Ono burger. My only suggestion is for more seating somehow. But that would probably mean moving.
(5)
Jenna L.

Fish tacos! Yes please! Delicious and quick- but I worried a tad about the cleanliness of the place. I observed a young man wiping down the tables with a cloth and then wiping the floor with the cloth and then wiping a table with that same cloth. The place gets packed so you share a picnic table with strangers. The fish tacos were great and fresh tasting. Not the best we had on the island but very good and very filling. Affordable and yummy.
(3)
Hello K.

The fish tacos were AMAZING!!!! Probably one of the best on the island. The coleslaw was not good. They basically put tartar sauce on cabbage. I would still go back for the fish. :)
(3)
Lynn F.

I loved the food the people and the fish tacos. Good job. Abracos do amigo brasileiro Pedro do Brazil cafe me berkeley Ca. Successo amigo.obrigado
(5)
Lori I.

Fresh fish in a casual walk up to the register and pay kind of place. All entrees or combos were $10-$20 and were very filling. This place is very casual, and open from 11-9:30daily. No reservations taken...this is more like a drive in type of place, and if you don't want to shell out the big $$$$ to go to Mama's Fish house, check this place out. yelp.com/biz_photos/8P3Qâ€¦ 1. Park in lot somewhere down the street in Paia town. 2. Stand in line to order/pay. yelp.com/biz_photos/8P3Qâ€¦ 3. Sit on community picnic tables while you eat your food. 4. Bus your own dishes. 5. Bathroom key on wall (one stall each outside the back, not that clean but works) 6. FOOD Kids quesadilla - good Fish & chips - good Cajun rice - weird Potatoes - great Fries - good Ono sandwich - moist and large cut - good Fish tacos - grilled (not breaded) on coleslaw - pretty good Then after you're done, go across the street and have dessert at Ono Gelato.
(4)
Sarah W.

Really loved their fish tacos. Such a great, low-key lunch spot.
(4)
Greg P.

Phenomenal Fish Tacos!! My wife and I were starting to get frustrated because we were not finding good fish tacos on Maui. That was until we stopped at the Paia Fish Market for lunch. It's busy and for good reason, the food is excellent. We found a place to sit with no problem. The staff were friendly and accommodating. We ordered the mahi mahi fish tacos. The servings are huge. The fish tacos come with a choice of side. We got the roasted red potatoes which were delicious. A huge serving of their cole slaw comes automatically. It's perfectly seasoned without going overboard on the mayo. The fish tacos themselves were perfection. The generous portion mahi was perfectly seasoned and not overpeppered. It comes on two soft corn tortillas with melted cheese, salsa, fresh tomato and lettuce, and then a great tartar sauce. They did not last long in our hands. If you are searching for great fish tacos on Maui, look no further.
(5)
Stephanie L.

Great fish buried in mediocre carbs and sauce seems to be the theme here. Fish tacos: Mahi was a little overcooked, lettuce, tomato, CHEDDAR cheese?! Regular old packaged corn tortillas. No salsa, lots of sweet tartar sauce. Why do people like this? Burger: again why is there cheese on it? Bun is really soft so nothing holds together. Fish itself was great though. Everything comes with cole slaw that is doused in more tartar sauce. It's good tartar sauce, but when you have such good fish why are we doing these things to cover it up? If I were to go again I would probably just get a plate lunch or seafood salad so the fish can stand alone a little better.
(2)
Ali B.

Get the seafood pasta. It fed my boyfriend and I 2 meals each. INSANE huge portion. Also, I recommend buying a glass (or 2) of wine. The pours are also quite generous :D The service is friendly, the ambiance is relaxed, and the food is just damn good. Come eat, relax, and make a new friend while savoring your delicious seafood delight.
(5)
Kenny m.

Just finished a late lunch here and my Cajun Ono was over cooked. How you can sell fresh fish in Paia and not prepare it right is beyond me. Potatoes and Cajun rice were great. My girlfriend had sashimi and that was excellent. Work on your cooking skills guys and you'll always have a line out the door.
(2)
Mindy S.

We have eaten at The Fish Market twice and both times the fish TOP NOTCH !!! I grew up in South Florida and my father was a captain. Seafood was a regular staple food in our house so I was exposed to some of the best seafood in the world (grouper, snapper, cobia, wahoo, dolphin/mahi-mahi, shrimp, stone crab claws and native lobster. The Fish Market takes pride in their seafood, cooking fish perfectly and using the freshest fish there is. I had the fish sandwich using snapper (Ehu) without the bun (this is where the sandwich falls short...using store-bought white bread buns instead of some amazing local bakery bun) on a bed of lettuce w/ slice of tomato and shredded cheese (nothing special so I didn't eat that part). The fish was super mild w/ nice seasoning salt and grilled perfectly. I had the French fries which are rather addicting. Shoestring fries cooked right not oily and salted lightly My partner had the fish tacos and he LOVED them. He said my fish was better tasting but mine was more expensive and not competing w/ the other stuff that goes into making fish tacos. Our first visit I had the fish and chips and they were cooked perfectly and the breading was not your typical caked-on thick batter laden in oil from the deep fryer. The coating was a nice crumb breading and lightly seasoned. I totally enjoyed the fish. My partner had the fish tacos...so that is his preferred choice at this place. Fast paced market, not fancy, just bench tables that you can share with others (limited seating) and nice local art donning the walls. We enjoyed the local beer selection and as for the coleslaw goes (sides on most all meals) was hit and miss. I think they used the tarter sauce to dress the cabbage. The first time we at at Fish Market my slaw was dry so I wasn't impressed. The second visit the coleslaw was rather drenched in the sauce. A bit tart tasting. Not their best side item, but it was the fish I came for not the slaw. For the money it was a good choice and we will continue to visit if we return (hopefully the quality will remain and we get another chance to return to Maui).
(5)
Mark H.

Paia is a fun place to pop into while shopping. The restaurant is a walk up counter with limited seating. If you're with a large group, you may not get seating during peak periods. The Ahi and Mahi were excellent, but the cole slaw didn't hit the spot. The cajun rice was also a miss, but the fries were crispy and fresh. Tip: parking in the area can be a challenge, so if you see a spot in the general area, snag it.
(3)
Allison W.

This restaurant is a MUST if you are in Maui. Came here last night with my boyfriend. We ordered the mahi fish tacos and the cajun style fish dinner. IT WAS SO GOOD. We are going back today for lunch.
(5)
Maile K.

Way overrated..tourist trap.....frozen fish!?? Ha!! Location.. Location.. Location
(2)
Will T.

Great food. Usually a line but worth it. Order and wait for number and sit at table with other people unless you have a big group and can save a table. Fish tacos were amazing. Owen Wilson happened to be there that day.
(5)
Nancy Z.

This was the last place we ate at the conclusion of our business trip to Maui. What a delight. Be forewarned, though, parking is difficult and finding a place to sit...just as difficult. This place really packs them in. A small place with several "community" style tables. Each table seats about six comfortably. A co-worker and I each got a seafood chowder and shared a dinner-sized fish and chips. More than enough for two. The chowder was excellent. The fish and chips was also very good. The breading was a little dark, but it tasted really good. I like that they use a seasoned salt on their fries. The homemade coleslaw was yummy and perfectly dressed (not too much mayo). The leftovers were just as good the next day....or that's what my husband said :-)
(4)
Matthew S.

Usually crowded but worth the wait. We get "Obama Burgers" and onion rings. Our kids love the fish and chips. Our youngest (7 yr old) likes buttered pasta. We have eaten here many times and it is consistently good. Never a complaint.
(5)
Gregg J.

Wow!!! A bartender we met near our condo suggested we visit this place before we leave. It's a Community style place where you will end up sitting next to someone you might not know. At the counter persons suggestion we had the delicious shrimp cocktail. My wife and I split the fish fajitas (suggested previously on yelp). Oh my!! They were incredible! Definitely the best fish I have had during my 10 day trip to Hawaii (day 10 today, sadly). The tomatoe-Esque sauce is phenomenal! Thanks for making my last lunch here a memorable one!
(5)
Deanna B.

Best fish tacos! The whole family agrees this is one of our favorite places to grab a quick bite when in paia/haiku area. Even worth the drive if you are staying elsewhere in Maui.
(5)
Hui P.

Been coming here since I was a kid. Good food and laid back atmosphere. Had the seafood pasta special the last time and it rocked. Big enough to share with an appetizer of calamari, which also rocked. You will likely think that this place could use more seating, but this is a classic Paia joint which has survived years of change, so you gotta give them a break and adapt. Pull up a seat next to some strangers, smile, say aloha, and enjoy your fish burger!
(4)
Kevin H.

Oh man, I wish I had read about this spot a bit more, but it was a last minute dealio. Being a wandering gypsy that can fold into the" laid back no plans let things unfold as they may" vibe, I pulled into Mama's fish house about 215, thinking they were open for lunch until 330. Plenty of time. I thought. As I pulled into the jammed lot, the valet as he is about to park our car let me know that we just missed lunch by ten minutes. They were open but serving light appetizers and cocktails only, until dinner started at 430. Passed on that, and that is how we wound up here. Fish tacos. Love them. Excited at the prospect of choosing one of three fish of the day, having that fish char grilled and served up taco style. Here is where they lose me. Food came up, name called, first glance they looked pretty killer. Dressed nicely and all. The fish was minced. Believe it or not I get why they do this, it does stay all together like, say perhaps a ground beef taco would. It just seemed like a crime to take whatever fish you ordered with varying texture, and mince it to death. Did I enjoy them? You bet, as I was really hungry from early morning activities and the late lunch. I would however dig them a bit more if the fish was chopped up a bit less Looking to get back here and try something else perhaps..
(3)
Permahungry C.

Met somewhere here for lunch, and was so glad he suggested this spot. Might have been our favorite meal while on the island... And that's only partially because we thought it was so reasonably priced! Food - we had the fish burger, and lucky for us they had Opah that day. Uh, delicious and well worth the couple of dollar upgrade from the Ono... Perfectly cooked, great portion size, super yummy. Next time I might hold the cole slaw and tartar (or get them on the side) so I can really enjoy the fish itself... but that's just me... Hubs also got fries, which were yummy. Oh, and yes they have beer. ;) Service/Atmosphere - So you wait in line... you order at the counter... then you grab a seat at community tables. It's loud, it's crowded, but somehow it all ends up working out. By the time your number gets called and you get your food, a seat has opened up somewhere. It's casual, and fun. And honestly, surprisingly clean considering the chaos. In conclusion - if you're not looking for fancy pants sit down service, definitely go here. We enjoyed this way more than some much more expensive meals we had in Maui...
(5)
Eliot M.

Great dinner. If you are looking for a scenic view this is not your place. But you will pay an arm and leg for that view. The fish is the best on the island that I have had. It's got a really cool Hawaiian feel with open seating. Love ruins place
(4)
Jan-Marc E.

Great dishes here, small busy place, but once again: wow. We tried the calamares and a Fish burger, really yummy. This place is a perfect choice for a quick snack for a low price. Tasts amazing there so better check it out!
(4)
Andrea C.

The fish tacos and rice are always amazing. What a great place by and experience the delicious food!
(5)
Katherine M.

Paia Fish Market was one of the eating highlights of our Maui trip! It's a fun little eating adventure that is not to be missed. Paia is the perfect town to hang out in if you have time to kill before or after an OGG flight. And when you get off of the plane hungry for your first mahi mahi sandwich of the trip, Paia Fish Market is your answer. We tried the mahi mahi burger, ahi burger, and blackened sashimi. All were excellent. Don't freak out to find a spot as soon as you walk in, SOMETHING will open by the time you order and then get your food (10-15 min). RELAX, you're in Maui. It was really funny to watch people as they'd walk in and realize it's first come, first serve seating at large picnic tables. "Wait, honey, stand right there. Don't move. We won't have anywhere to sit, and it looks like the people you're standing a foot away from are almost done. Stare at their food. Make them uncomfortable. Maybe they'll leave sooner and we can sit there." Yeah, don't be THAT person.
(5)
M O.

After the road to Hana, this meal was great. Our party ordered fish n chips, shrimp n chips, fish tacos, mahi burger and calamari. Everything tasted great! Line up, order and then people watch! Paia is wonderful.
(5)
Leona S.

Really huge portions! We both got the fish and chicken taco plate. Came with two heaping portions of fish and chicken on a corn tortilla. It also came with cole slaw, a side of Cajun rice and home style potatoes and tartar sauce. The fish actually didn't have as much flavor as I thought it might have. It was grilled and shredded, which I didn't like too much. I would've rather had deep fried in a chunk or something. My hubby liked the potatoes which were grilled with onions. Savory. Tad on the pricey side, about $12 a plate. Communal seating.
(4)
Mallika A.

Based on the reviews of other Yelpers, we had the Ono and Mahi Mahi burgers both of which were bland and tasteless. Fries were good. This place is overhyped. Not worth standing in line.
(1)
Dana Z.

Ah Paia fish mart....... I have been eating here for over 30 years. Yup, 30 years. Amazing to think about that much longevity in a restaurant, and it has remained largely the same all these years. I first started eating there when I moved to Maui in 1989 and now eat there when ever I come back to visit Hawaii Nei. No visit is complete without a fish burger from this delicious place. Since I have tried almost everything on the menu, I would recommend the ono burger with fries, the fish tacos with ahi or the garden salad with the catch in the day. The garden salad with the fish is my newest love, it is a huge salad with a nice juicy piece of fish and a few shrimp. Get some extra tarter sauce to make it pop.I also recommend getting in line and have one of your party grab a seat or there might now be one when you get your order. They are fast at putting out the food here! Production done right, Thank you fish mart for always being there and always being good! Two thumbs up!
(5)
James P.

Great find! Get here early, but the line moves quickly. I had the Blackened Ono Burger with Wasabi Butter (Awesome!) Onion Rings (Good) & Fries (Tasted old?). So happy they take credit cards!
(4)
Andrew K.

Really fresh and delicious seafood in a casual environment. In particular, the mahi mahi salad and tuna sashimi were OUTSTANDING! I wish the bathrooms were inside, but you can't have it all.
(5)
Mimi C.

Delicious fish burger and tacos! This seems to be a hit with locals and tourists as it's super packed. a tip from locals -- the fish on the blackboard is great, but you'll want to go up front to their little whiteboard for the fresh catch of the day. :) We got the obama burger and it was customized to our liking. :) Be prepared for a 20 minute wait at peak hours -- just to order.
(4)
Sheila P.

Great place... I went here on a recommendation. The portions were generous and the fish was delicious. All at an affordable price!
(5)
Gem G.

Large portions at such reasonable prices! We ordered Mahi Mahi burger, Ahi Tuna burger and Mahi Mahi fish n chips and they tasted so fresh. Fish was bigger than the buns! Would highly recommend this place!
(5)
Amreena A.

Eat Ono burger, eat two! Then go watch the brave surfers conquer the waves. Come back, eat another Ono burger.
(4)
Seline m.

fresh fresh fish tacos. don't get fooled by the long lines, they are fast, but its not fast food, its fresh quality awesome food. ordered the fish taco plate and it was a lot of food for one person. It was probably the best food I had in maui
(5)
Ennie L.

Fish market in Paia is popular spot but on a hot day with s resto full of people it can get stuffy. Tables are first come first serve , the food is definitely good, probably one of the best places to eat downtown Paia, most of the locals highly recommend it. I got the fish tacos, super tasty and their rice is very good.
(5)
Vanessa F.

Maybe because it was raining, but I came here to pick up dinner at 7pm on Saturday and the restaurant wasn't even half full. Yay for me, I guess! The food here is pretty good. I ordered the seafood chowder and the seafood pasta. The chowder was really good. I thought the sauce on the seafood pasta was a little heavy, but it had a lot of good seafood in it and the portion size was really big, so definitely worth it. My other family members ordered the fish tacos and they loved them. They put a lot of fresh lettuce on it and the seafood was really fresh and cooked well. If you are staying nearby and it's busy, just order it to go and enjoy it at your pad.
(4)
Javi G.

a little bit on the pricey side...but OMG! totally worth it. Stop here for a mahi mahi burger and fries. There is a reason why this place is so packed. Enjoy your burger or other fish plate and be ready to order another one.
(5)
Jason D.

Great place for a variety of fish plates. Always good portions so bring your appetite. Always hit this place at least twice when in Maui.
(4)
Meghan H.

This place is chaos in a box. We arrived on a SATURDAY night around 7 and the place was ON WHEELS. People lined up almost out the door and very, very limited seating. They do this bench/picnic style seating which I don't dig. Don't get me wrong, I love making new friends, but wtf. You line up, order, and they call your number where you go and literally pick up your food from their window. Most places give you a little number to post at your table and someone drops off your food to you. My favourite part is they ask for a tip when you pay with credit card. I'm sorry, don't eat yellow snow? You don't do anything. That's not true, they handed me a cup for my pop. They also don't put up the food at the same time for people in groups of 4 or more. We watched two groups receive food very randomly. People ate and others sat and waited. Yeah, yeah I'm bitchin, I know. But guess what, 3 stars would've been 5 stars if this place wasn't like a monkey jungle gym 'cause the food was ammaaaaze ballllls. Like Amaze BALLS. We ordered the Seafood Pasta (about 18-19$) and shared it. IT was delicious. Perfectly cooked scallops, shrimp, and pieces of fish in a creamy white sauce poured over al dente fettucine noodles. You crazy bastards and your delicious food. If you're in Paia, come here, order, and get that food to go because it's delicious. Fish Market place, please expand and get some servers. But good work on the seafood pasta
(3)
Cole G.

Fish was good but they messed up our order pretty bad. Would try it again, but drove far to try this place.
(3)
Vic L.

Ate here last night. Very very cool setting for a restaurant, communal seating and shared condiments. The fried fish fingers were outstanding and the calamari was brilliant. The sashimi for me was just average which stops me giving 5 stars but I would 100% come back here. Loved it!
(4)
Shereen R.

After hiking at Haleakala, we decided to lunch in Paia. And what better place to grub at than at Paia Fish Market. The location is a bit small, and tables are communal. You place your order at the counter (after spending what could be 10-15 minutes perusing all of the menu items!), take a seat and possibly make some new friends. The lines can be ridiculously long but it's well worth the wait. The portions here are great. We ordered the ono burger which was really good, and the fish & chips which were awesome. Fresh, tasty food cooked well. Great way to appease your grumbling stomach.
(4)
Mia C.

It was raining last Saturday afternoon. And the best thing you can do in Maui while it rains is to check out a new restaurant. There was a huge line around 6pm. The lady who stood in front of me raved about their fish tacos. So I decided the mahi mahi fish tacos it is. I got the Cajun style and also ordered Cajun rice on the side instead of fries. I also saw several people ordering the mahi mahi fish and chips. So decided to go for that as out 2nd entree. Needless to say, the portions were big and the food was tasty and filling.
(5)
Maria A.

EXCELLENT. This is a little hole in the wall place in the beautiful town of Paia.. Nothing fancy, open seating, go the counter order and pick up your food to eat kind of place. Food is excellent. We had the charbroiled Mahi, Mahi, seafood chowder and fish tacos. All three items were superb.. You won't be disappointed.
(5)
MrTibs M.

Generic junk food even though it looks so Hawaiian authentic and a happening place. Most of the fish is not local caught and the fries aren't great. Really doesn't fit with the whole hippie thing. Had the mahi fish and the shrimp dinners (both frozen) and it costed us $20!
(1)
Jen N.

This place is a must go! If I knew how good it was, I would've eaten here every single day of my vacation. Best $12 I've ever spent! Do not miss out on the Mahi Burger or Fish and Chips.
(5)
Gail P.

The fresh fish here is second to none! You have a choice of fish and preparation. I had ono with Cajun seasoning. The portions were huge and cooked to perfection! Their coleslaw on the side was fresh and tasty. This is not a fancy place. But it fits in well with the hippie vibe of the town. Order at the counter and share a picnic style table. It was fun to eat with other travelers who, like us, have made Paia Fish Market a must do while visiting Maui.
(5)
Kurt L.

One of my favorite places in Maui! Delectable, FRESH fish for a low price. You can choose from a variety of fish, prepared a variety of different ways. Ahi, ono, mahimahi, salmon and several others! Charbroiled, Blackened, Cajun charbroiled, SautÃ©ed In Lemon Butter sauce, and others! The fish "burgers" are the best deal at around $10. A lunch plate will be a bit more food but will probably be twice as expensive. Parking is a little hard to find but if you have to park a little far away, you get to enjoy a pleasant walk, down a charming street, through a quaint town.
(5)
Craig T.

The Ono burger is the best item on the menu for only $10. This is a great place for lunch as many locals were there when we visited. Great spot on the way to the north shore of Maui or cheaper alternative to Mama's fish house. enjoy Craig T
(5)
Eric D.

Stopped here for lunch on the way back from Hana. Paia is a nice little town, and the Fish Market is a good place for lunch. Food took kind of a while, but it was busy, and worth the wait. Excellent fish tacos.
(4)
Renato H.

Food was good but way overrated by others, not worth the wait! Cook didn't seem happy to be working there, especially when I asked him how much longer I needed to wait for a simple fish taco after 25 minutes of wait, of course by then the rest of my orders were cold
(2)
Jennifer S.

Absolute must try! The fish is fantastic! Great lunch spot. Quick and easy! Communal tables so if you go there during prime time, takes a few minutes to get a seat, but well worth the wait.
(5)
Mary H.

We heard about this place from Food Network's Best Thing I Ever Ate and turns out that just about every Best of Maui restaurant list has Paia Fish Market on it too. It's in the hippy section of Maui, is super cazh and full of locals and tourists sharing tables. We ordered the Obama Burger (ono burger with wasabi butter) and the fish tacos which were the featured item on BTIEA. I have to say that the first bite of the fish taco was one of the best first bites I've ever had. A real surprise -- I mean, who thinks a fish taco is going to be that good?!? The taco was filled with big moist chunks of lightly-smoked fish and just the right ratio of lettuce to tomato, along with a tartar sauce. The Obama Burger was good but could have used more texture. The bread wasn't toasted so perhaps some coleslaw or a crispier lettuce would have helped. All-in-all, a must visit when you're in Maui.
(5)
Jeanne H.

Great fish sandwich! Fast service, clean, great music and lots of choices. Stopped in Paia for a quick bite and were pleasantly surprised! 6 oz of fresh Mahi Mahi almost could not finish it!
(4)
Crystal A.

We loved it so much that we went back there 3 times (once for a late lunch after we were done with Road to Hana, and another day for lunch and dinner in the same day). Worth every penny and the portions were huge. All the times that we ate there we had the fish tacos. The fish was fresh, and it comes with a side of red potatoes and red rice. I swear if we had the chance we would eat there more often. The next time that we're in Hawaii we'll head to Paia to try other items on the menu. You won't be disappointed.
(5)
Jodi P.

Dude the fish burger is what I always come for, juicy with coleslaw, so yummy . I actually just came from Rock and brews where I was so disappointed, hour wait for my food and the dish, the waiter recommended, was the most exspensive and totally plain. I guess that is what I deserve when I chose to go somewhere new even though I was craving paia fish market, lesson learned. Total disaster but now that I'm finally here and my order was ready in less than 6 min. My night is finally going well. Ordered in six minutes but only took two to maul.
(5)
Denni P.

Fresh fish don't be shy to share your picnic bench style table with others! Mahalo style. The mahi mahi burger was to die for, yes a bit greasy with all the fries but what you can do is order the burger without the bun to carb-down and not carb-out. Definitely will go back, this is a fantastic place. If I indulged more in fried foods I would be here all the time.
(4)
Donna T.

Crowded and busy but worth your wait. Have someone in your group grab a table as soon as you get there so by the time you have ordered, you'll have a place to sit and wait for your food. The mahi fish sandwich was very tasty as were the fish tacos; lots of fish. There were two beers on tap-Red Hook IPA and Hefeweizen; and Maui Brewery Company beer. Prices are reasonable and the ambiance is friendly. It was a fun stop on our way to watch the wind surfers.
(5)
Pam H.

Great fish tacos and slaw. Slaw had a wonderful light creamy dressing. Not over dressed. Love to come back and try the fish burgers and fish plates. It all looked and smelled good!
(4)
Jonathan A.

These are the best fish tacos you will ever taste. I am definitely coming back here next time I'm in Maui :)
(5)
Rushil R.

Great food but a little pricey. $22 for some fish coleslaw and fries? Luckily the food was worth the price. Their fish quesadillas were great as well
(4)
margaret w.

OBAMA burger and Ono burger- must try!! Tacos were good; Fish and chips were excellent. Long Lines but food was worth the wait.
(4)
Amy G.

Very crowded place with pretty good food. It takes a while to get the food and you will be sitting elbow distance right next to strangers while you wait and dine. We sat at the edge of a table and 5 minutes later this large group of elderly people sat down between us and another couple at the other corner of the table. They actually asked us to move just so they can sit with their friends, normally I wouldn't mind but they were rude about it. Needless to say we stayed at our seats and their friends squeezed right in. Too bad we can choose our neighbors. I had the pasta and he had the ono burger. I thought the pasta tasted great, the shrimp, fish and scallops tasted fresh but the sauce was just a bit overpowering. He really liked his burger too.
(4)
Kathy C.

I can see myself coming to Paia Fish Market more often if we stayed near Paia. Unfortunately, we were only there for one after and therefore, only got to enjoy it once. The place is small and cute with very laid back vibe. I got an ahi burger and it was very tasty. It was cooked through though, not sure if that was intentional and that I was suppose to specifically ask for seared. And since it was a take-out, I wasn't able to find out. But still did enjoyed it and would have returned if we had stayed in Paia.
(3)
Eric D.

This is an order at the counter and pickup your food establishment, but the price is affordable and the food is excellent. The feel of the restaurant fits this bohemian style town. Fish tacos were awesome!!! Quick service even though the place was hoppin busy. The crowd seemed to be enjoying their food equally well.
(4)
Keneke M.

Very pricey considering no food servers and you have to wait in line to order at a counter then if your lucky enough to get a seat you have to sit on a picnic bench table with strangers. Way too expensive for these accomodations!!!
(2)
Michael L.

We came here after visiting the 7 sacred pools. Got here right before closing time. We ordered the Ono burger with fish taco dinner, it was good stuff. The cook/owner gave us free rice and potatoes, I'm guessing it was because they were about to close.
(4)
B B.

I was very disappointed. Having finished up a long day of sightseeing, I saw the positive reviews for the Fish Market and decided to head over. Having never been here before, I asked the cashier what she recommended... in response she gave me the stink-eye and said "I don't know." Fine, I ordered the fish and chips, which looked good on Yelp. Next I sat down to wait for my food at the only open table, which was filthy. Nobody came to clean it by the time my food arrived, so I did it myself. Then for the grand finale... the fish was bland and unappetizing! The only reason this review isn't 1 star is that the chips (fries) were tasty... and it's never a good reflection on your restaurant when the only redeeming quality are its french fries. In all, poor service, disregard for cleanliness, mediocre fish, solid french fries. I won't be coming back.
(2)
mom w.

Very yummy mahi mahi fish burger!!! I was going to split with hubby but couldn't stop eating so most of it was gone but I did save one small bite for hubby but even from that one small bite, he couldn't stop raving about it too!
(5)
Al H.

Had the fried shrimp appetizer & the teriyaki chicken dinner platter (both VERY GOOD). Chicken was seasoned/grilled perfectly and potatoes and rice sides were very tasty (big full plate of food - very good value). Liked the fried shrimp app so much I had a second one for "dessert" before heading out. My girlfriend had the popular "Ono burger" and she said it was one of the best things she's eaten while visiting Maui ('nuff said there). Friendly staff, communal bench seating... Highly recommended and worth the wait (we went a bit later 8pmish and were able to order and sit without much of a wait at all). Go eat some food at this place!!!
(5)
Meagan B.

My favorite fish on island. The fish sandwiches with the crunchy coleslaw and fries. I could eat it every day! I used to live on island and would frequent here often. Now when I fly back, it's the first place I drive to when I get off the plane, and my last meal on island. There isn't air conditioning, but I love it. The windows and door are open, and there's usually a breeze. I think it adds to the experience. I miss you guys!
(5)
James T.

Food = 5 Price = 5 Experience = 5 The best dining in Paia... it's the easiest to find too.
(5)
Tami C.

Food is ok. Fish and chips over cooked. Chicken taco nothing special. Served with coleslaw that was tasteless. Given the crowds and line, I would suggest skipping this establishment.
(2)
Andres G.

Place is legit. Great food and great beer prices. If you're on a budget, hit this spot instead of mama's fish house.
(4)
Carl A.

The food here is pretty good. The portions are a nice size and it's tasty. The problem here (and it's the reason I won't be going back as a local) is the service. It's rude to the point you can't believe it just happened. Once I was put on hold when making a to-go order and found myself waiting for a quite a while (which in most cases is fine. I realize this place IS busy at times) until I eventually hung up realizing that I had been forgotten. The rub came when I called back. I remarked that I had called to place a to-go order a moment ago and just kind of got left hanging. Her response, without pause, was, "well, I get busy and I can't remember everything". You're not remembering everything, obviously. But you would be well-served to remember the reason you are at the job that employs you. That would be me, the hungry customer with money to spend who didn't spend it that night b/c of your not-even-the-least-bit-apologetic attitude. Two nights ago was it for me. I went in around six o'clock and to my surprise they weren't busy yet....clear path to the register. I walked right up as the cashier young lady was apparently writing down the nightly specials onto a white board. She looked up as I stood there ready to order and remarked that she would be right with me. Then without pause continued on with her vital task right on the counter in front of me. I stood there.....waiting as she didn't even glance up or acknowledge me further. It was an awkward period of time while I continued to wait. Then continued to wait some more. She was very detailed, you see. Changing the color of the pens for different specials before moving onto the next special and the next pen. To me this is poor customer service and frankly, rude. I'm here again trying to get some food from this place b/c it actually tastes pretty good once you manage to get your order in. And this young woman just has me stand there waiting while she finishes her art project. Let me advance the notion that perhaps tending to the person with money ready to order right in front of you is nominally more important than your special board. Being all, but done is one thing. But keeping me standing there.....well, it made me walk out of your place for the last time. I refuse to endorse that service culture.
(2)
Wendy C.

Just got back from Maui last night. Had to review this place... Stayed in Kaanapali Beach area and drove here on recommendation of a friend. Excellent! If you have a chance... Go! I had Cajun seasoned fish tacos (mahi mahi) and my husband had grilled Ono. My mouth is watering even now. The prices are very good considering the rest of Maui.
(5)
Michael S.

Great place right on the corner of the main streets. Easy hang out atmosphere. Plenty of fish and other choices. Local feel. I had the fish sandwich and it was the best meal I have had here on Maui. Friendly staff. Just get there before the rush as table seating is limited during busy times.
(5)
Arlene S.

The food was very good. Portions are large. My husband had the Ono fish sandwich. The fish was cooked to perfection. Very mild fishy taste. Chicken tacos were great as well. We'll definitely go back!
(5)
Tara H.

"Um, THAT is the lunch portion?" Yes, the lunch portions are a little overwhelming. But by the time you get your meal, you'll be thankful for the huge portions. I saw this place on the Food Network as a must try place while visiting. I wasn't sorry I went, and would gladly recommend it and visit again. It was a great way to cap of a shopping day in Paia! Yes, the lines can be daunting. The wait can be 15-20 minutes long. Though the delicious fish heaven delivered to you will make you forget the wait. My savory grilled fish tacos with salty shoe string fries were just what I had been waiting for. Top that off with an ice cold beer and you have a vacation paradise.
(4)
stacey c.

We came here because of the high reviews but it feels exactly like a Mexican fast food place with a little of every thing. We ordered the seafood pasta and for the price you would think it is better quality. The fish is dry. The sauce is heavy and salty. The soup salty as well. I think I need to trust my gut feeling. Yelp review should be half of the consideration.
(1)
Karlene D.

Always delicious fish & if you like onion rings they have the best. The chicken quesadillas were also outstanding. We always try to eat here when we're close by.
(5)
Rodney P.

Came here 3 times on vacation with friends. Obama burger was amazing! Fish tacos were phenomenal, my favorite was the fish and chips. Not to be missed on a Maui holiday!
(5)
Anna D.

I got suckered into getting the fish tacos.. and let me tell you, it was GOOD! The fish was super juicy and didn't have that gross fishy smell or taste. It was fresh and that's how all fish should be! There was a ton of foood so come with an appetite! My girlfriend and I decided to both eat there thinking we would have room for another dinner in a few hours.. UMMM, NO! That didn't happen. The place is also near a Paia Cafe so dont mistake it like we almost did. Thank god for yelp to have a photo cause if it wasn't for that we would've been eating at the wrong place!
(5)
Ivy T.

This place offers a variety of fishes and methods on how the fish is cooked. The ono is yummy sauteed in wine, butter and garlic. Their cajan rice compliments each fish entree and hand cut coleslaw really well. Portion size is big so it is better to share the entree.
(4)
Jack L.

We were early and there was no one in the restaurant yet. Someone told us to have a seat and someone will be by soon. A while later we found out that you have to order your food at the counter and there is no table service, as there were 3 other people in line by now which is totally cool. We order our food and it shows up 15 minutes later at the counter and the order number is called. The soup was ice cold, to the point I had to take it back and get it warmed up. Even then, it lacked taste and it was way too watery for a seafood chowder. Then I tried some of Darleen's seafood pasta and almost choked on it since it was so dry. Huge portions though, I wasn't impressed. Give me a little less food, make it a lot tastier and polish up your service for more of my money.
(2)
Wing Head Y.

If you're looking for fresh local fish prepared numerous ways this is your spot!! I ordered the blackened mahi dinner plate. I give this place
(4)
D K.

Good popular joint. Moderate prices ($11 fish and chips, $20 seafood pasta) but the fish is fresh and it tastes great. Seating is limited (5-6 picnic-table sized tables/benches. Park on the street or in the public lot across the street.
(4)
Faye B.

Wasn't quick enough to make a reservation at another restaurant so this ended up being our fallback. My husband and I just got finished doing the whole road to Hana and then some coming back up to Paia. So we decided we had to do a fish place on one of our last nights in Maui. I decided to go for the seafood pasta which was just okay. It had so much different seafood, but I just couldn't appreciate each kind. My husband oddly enough must have been all 'fished out' because he ordered a chicken quesadilla. Oddly enough the chicken was the bomb! The meat was so tender, juicy, and flavorful. At least one of the dishes was a hit, I was just disappointed that it wasn't the seafood one. Oh we'll, it was a good place to check out in the area.
(2)
J K.

Fabulous! Really fresh and lots of food. The line looks intimidating but this is a good sign its the place to be. You order off the wall menu check out the fish of the day. I had mahimahi over salad Loved it! The seating is limited best to get a seat and one of you in line to order. The town has little art shops along the way.
(4)
Arsham G.

Paia Fish Market in right on the corner of Baldwin and Hana Hwy. It's pretty highly rated but i found it to be nothing that special. I had a fish taco and an Ono burger. They weren't bad just average. It got crowded quickly so you will find yourself sharing a table with a few table which is fine. I found the bus boy didn't clean up fast enough after those people that left their plates behind. If you're in the area and want something to eat this place isn't a bad option, there are just better ones a small drive down the road.
(3)
Mark I.

What happened to all the cool metal fish that used to be hanging from the ceiling? And other cool funky artifacts? Kinda homogenized now. Guess things must change
(4)
Bach F.

Very good food on the way to Hana! Fish Tacos were as expected. Order a larger platter if you want a big piece of fish. Fish tacos are slim on the amount of fish.
(4)
Don F.

Awesome ono and mahi burgers are amazing. Whenever I visit Paia, this is where I come for quick service, great food and cold beer. MAHALO LOVE!
(4)
Brett G.

What a great concept. The fish tacos with rice were simply delicious. Other people in my party had the Ono dinner plate (divine) and Ono burger(yummy). Great prices, clean and efficient space. This spot is not a white table cloth restaurant but more a spot to grab a casual delicious bite of food. Quick service. You would be sorely to miss this wonderful local Hawaiian spot.
(4)
Jen W.

Came here twice! We always chose a fresh cooked fish option with a side. The slaw is great with dill! You may have to wait for a table or if getting it to go, to wait for your food but they cook to order so that is not surprise.
(4)
A K.

fish tacos...fish tacos...FISH TACOS. My husband and I went here for lunch one day per a recommendation one of our zipline instructors had given us during our trip. I am SO glad we took their advice. We walked around Paia for a bit, which I have to say, cute little town and the beach is nice to walk along. We decided to stop here for lunch after it died down a little (as it had been pretty busy during the lunch rush). We got tuna sashimi and fish tacos. First, before I get to the food, I want to say...the service here is great...it's laid back, so friendly, quick, and just awesome. Sometimes when I go to places where you order at the counter and find a place to sit yourself, I get overwhelmed...no worries here! The place is small, long tables, well-kept, awesome. Now, the food...I can't say enough good things. The tuna sashimi was so fresh and so delicious. It came on cabbage I think w/ some seaweed salad, wasabi, soy...incredible. We eat a lot of sushi and have eaten sushi many places...the sashimi here was pretty much perfect.. The fish tacos...wowowowowowow. I loved them. They are pretty big portions so trying to eat both (2 on a plate) was a little hard, but I just couldn't get enough. Each table has condiments like TIGER SAUCE and other things...awesome, awesome touch to the tacos...you HAVE to try this sauce. I was seriously in heaven during this lunch. If you're looking for an easy lunch, go here. This is for sure going to be one of my must-have spots when I go back to Maui. It's incredible.
(5)
Mayve B.

I found a roach in my fries. I will never eat here again. Do not eat here!!!! I talked to a friend to sells that them food and he said the kitchen is filthy. He wasn't surprised that I had a roach in my food.
(1)
Joseph H.

On our first day in Maui we drove to Paia from the airport. The fish market was the best place to unwind and really feel like you're in Maui! I highly recommend the food and drink selection. Its a small area maybe about 10 tables, but it is worth the wait if any. I had the calamari and chips. Can't complain. Thank you for starting my vacation off right. Aloha!
(5)
Stella A.

Best thing to try... Fish burgers! So delicious and fresh with the smoky grill taste leaving you satsified and happy. The seating is not always open because there are a lot of customers and its pretty noisy so just keep that in mind when you go.
(4)
Sheenae H.

I got the charbroiled opah plate with half cajun rice and half potatoes. Fresh, flavorful fish. Huge portions. The soda machine is very tall, and it's on a tall counter... I couldn't see into my cup to tell when it was getting full and nearly spilled on myself. Short people problems...
(4)
Melissa M.

Hands down the best fish and chips i've ever had. Good service, low key restaurant.
(5)
Andi F.

I had high expectations, but this fell short. First of all, I'm gluten free because I have to be not because it's trendy. I asked for a fish sandwich hold the bun. She asked coleslaw or side salad, I said slaw sounds good! She charged me $24 and my hubby got a fish and chips platter. Total $36. I sat down and realized everything on their menu was under $18. Why was I charged $24? I asked and was told because its special and you wanted slaw instead of salad and fish without the bun. Ummmm you asked which one I wanted and never ever mentioned it was more. And because I didn't get a bun I'm charged more than anything on the menu? My husband had way more food and his was like $12. Not going again for mediocre food and lousy attitudes. Total bait and switch if you ask me. Save your money, walk over to Flatbread where the staff is beyond nice and accommodating and the food is killer!
(2)
S S.

Best maui burger is what I purchased. Delicious. Everything was great! The place is packed for a reason. FRESH FISH, yum!
(5)
Mark F.

The Paia Fish Market was our "go to" choice on our last trip to Maui. We visited 4 times in a week and have shared positive reviews with several friends since. Maybe they were just having an off day this week. Our one visit resulted in likely the worst meal of the week. It may be that we chose some different items instead of the Obama Burger and fish and chips. Our first choice this week was the well regarded seafood pasta, along with a Mahi Burger. This week the pasta was bland, with a watery sauce. There were many fish chunks of variable levels of overdone-ness. The portion was huge, but we were not inclined to finish it. The Mahi burger was a disaster....overdone mahi on a cold white bun with little flavor other than a weak tomato, shredded lettuce and a bit of shredded cheese. Disappointment for sure...we will give it a go another time. Hopefully it was one off day.
(3)
Kayan H.

Fries were really good! Opakapaka fish burger with tiger sauce was really good as well, but you have to remember the tiger sauce (it's sitting on the table) otherwise, it's a bit bland. Ahi fish burger, this was our favorite of the two.
(3)
Patrick O.

This place was recommended to us by a local zip line guide. He said the fish was to die for. It really was. I had the fish quesadilla and my wife had the fish and chips. The quesadilla was so filling and had just enough Mexican flavor to be a quesadilla while still feeling like I was in Hawaii. The fish and chips had perfectly fried fish. Having grown up in Seattle where fish and chips is huge, my wife loved every bit of it. The fish was really juicy. The food came out quick and the atmosphere was buzzing. Having to sit at long picnic tables seemed bad at the start, but I met other people who came to Hawaii for vacation too.
(5)
Joanna F.

This was recommended to us at our hotel as soon as we checked in and we were ravenous, so we walked the 200 feet and got in line. There was a rather long line for lunch. The atmosphere is rowdy with communal tables. We decided to get it to go. I ordered the ono fish tacos, my husband ordered an ono burger and I got some tuna sashimi to split. The sashimi was ridiculously expensive, but the other two meals were fairly reasonably priced. The food we received was beautiful, but rather bland. My tacos were simply overcooked ono, lettuce and cheese that I could hardly taste. I added a little tartar sauce to give it some flavor. The sashimi was fresh but also rather bland (not that it's usually super flavorful). My husband really enjoyed his burger. Needless to say, we did not come back at all even though this was so conveniently located. I would probably come back in a pinch, but this seemed like the most touristy eatery in Paia with food that did not impress.
(3)
Natasha X.

My dad's friend recommended this place, so we had to try it. My parents both ordered the mahi burgers and loved them. I had the garden salad with grilled chicken, and it was delicious!!
(4)
Sophie C.

This is my third favorite place. Good fresh seafood, reasonably priced, and fast service (important since the place packs up!). Get the cajun style ono burger with dirty rice. Fish (batter was light and flavorful) and chips were also tasty. My newfound love is Tiger Sauce (a mixture of hot sauce plus sweet and sour) which I managed to put on anything and everything. Try it in the tartar sauce and dip the chips in it! Portions are large so definitely share as I was so full from my burger, it took me half the day to digest!
(4)
Kaya S.

PLEASE get a mahi burger (or an ono burger). SO GOOD. Unlike any sandwich I've ever had. The only issue I found is that the ADDRESS LISTED ON YELP IS WRONG. There is no 100 Baldwin St -- there's just an empty lot where it would be! The restaurant is at 100 Hana Highway, on the corner of Hana & Baldwin. Weirdly, on different parts of their website it's listed as 100 Baldwin and 100 Hana Highway. The confusion about where it was made it frustrating to get to, but the mahi burger definitely made it worth it.
(5)
Nancy B.

Long line that goes so quickly it's crazy...and WORTH it!!! The fish tacos are awesome, the fish and chips are perfect, the atmosphere is perfect, and the price is absolutely right. I love this place, love the breeze blowing through the dining room, love the community surf board seating, and I love the food! This is a MUST on Maui!
(5)
Rebecca F.

Fantastic fish options! The Obama burger and fish and chips were great. It is a pretty casual setting where you order first then squeeze into a long table with strangers but it is a suiting atmosphere. Expect a bit of a wait because the place is so popular among tourists and locals alike ( a good sign).
(5)
Betty N.

**NOT THE BEST FISH TACOS ON THE ISLAND** 1 Fish Taco = $9.95 2 Fish Tacos = $12.95 Being Asian, you know I ordered 2 fish tacos for $3 more. What was this. Lettuce instead of cole slaw? It looked like a *Taco Bell* version of a fish taco with the shredded lettuce and diced tomatoes on top. Very simple, maybe too simple. No zing or zang taste, even with the provided ranchy sauce and two shakes of the Tiger pepper sauce. Ordered the fries, too. Very meh. Seafood chowder was bit on the runny side. Not thick enough for this Mama Fish. Most reviewers have proclaimed that their fish tacos were the "best*. DISAGREED.
(3)
April C.

Always the best place to go in Paia, a little pricey but worth it! Its fabulous! Super fresh too....
(5)
Patricia G.

Great fried shrimp, Obama burger (which is a fish sandwich w/Wasabi dressing), blackened fish, rice. I've been there three times and I have a co-worker who eats there "all the time", LOLOL...You always run into other locals when you are there...peeps from Wailuku, Kihea, Lahaina.
(4)
Carly G.

AMAZING! I got the Cajun Ohono Fish dinner and it was perfectly seasoned, tender and flavorful. I opted for the fries but snuck a bite of the rice and would order it next time. The sauce that accompanies the fish was the perfect flavor to compliment the Cajun seasoning. Highly recommend.
(5)
Hion L.

During my trip to Maui, I would have to say that Paia Fish Market had the best fish burger of all of the places that we went to. I ordered the Obama fish burger which is comprised of Ono that is blackened and then topped with wasabi butter. Very delicious and not too much spice that it detracts from the fresh lightness of the fish. Mahi Mahi fish tacos were also pretty decent and very large. Not like the small size ones you get in CA, but rather large oversized portions with a ton of fish in it. The grated cheese was a bit odd, but tasty nevertheless The seating was a bit awkward since it is such a small place and it is communal style seating with long benches. At under $10 it represents a pretty good deal considering that many of the restaurants sell the same stuff for $14. The food is simple and straight to the point. Best Thing - Fish burger
(5)
Kasha W.

Exactly what we have been searching for. Just as impressive as the delicious fish tacos were the side dishes that came with them. Half potatoes, half Cajun rice, and a huge side of homemade coleslaw. High food quality and HUGE portions - even after a full day of swimming!
(5)
Uncle Fishbits Aeneas X.

Just go Just go Just go. That is all. Incredible food. It is a small type Phil's from Moss Landing - same concept. Line up and order amazing fresh fish and food prepared deliciously. Period. EAT IT. This is a the opposite end of Mama's - but if you still want amazing fish, fish n chips, chowders, even some pastas and other options, hit it up. It's a place to stop at least once during every trip. Thank you guys!
(5)
Dora T.

Very crowded but that always makes me rest assured that everything is fresh. We had mahi burger and fish fajitas. Although i would say the fish was maybe a little over cocked everything was delicious ! We would definitely go there again soon
(5)
R P.

Hands down the best food in Maui!!! Love the shrimp fajitas and shrimp scampi... Awesome fish tacos and calamari... Highly recommended... Will not disappoint...
(5)
John M.

A stop at the fish market is an essential part of your trip to Maui as they have the freshest fish. it isn't exactly a restaurant though as you order at the counter and save seats at long picnic tables next to strangers. My recommendation is not to get too much seasoning on your fish (ruins the point of fresh) and don't go expecting an upscale fine dining experience. I've only had good experiences but I wanted to give a fair warning for their unusual setup.
(4)
Scott D.

Good fish at a great price for Maui standards. They always have fresh Mahi and Ahi available among others as well. Cooked on the grill to perfection a must try when in Maui.
(4)
David B.

The freshest seafood around! It can be crowded most of the time, but it's worth the wait. Try any of the fish and chips combo, my favorite is the ono. Also plenty of seafood options. Again big portions, well worth your time and money.
(5)
C M.

Great mahi burgers after a long ride down the road to Hana. The fish was really flaky and moist. The dill slaw or whatever they put on it complimented the basic spiced fish not taking away from how fresh the fish tasted. The filet was so big that it split in half when taking the first bite only to still fit the hamburger sized bun with only half. The second half of just fish was good, but definitely tasted better with the tartar and slaw. The wait was a little long to get the food (the line moved fast) but we just happened to get stuck behind a to-go order of what looked like 12 plates.
(4)
Rachel H.

This was a great stop on our way back from the road to Hana! It's a small casual joint with only 8 picnic size tables but food comes out super fast. The Mahi fish & chips were great - meaty and not too breaded. And the tartar sauce is unique and delicious! It had some twist on flavor that I couldn't pinpoint but I loved every bite.
(5)
Tai M.

Fresh fish burger was delicious and melt in your mouth. I can see why there's always a line. Fish and chips were huge, and I've never seen fish fried they way they were here--lots of batter and crispy. Reasonably priced for what you get.
(4)
Lindsay O.

One star is for the rude lady behind the counter. The food was good but she decided how our fish should be cooked without asking. When we told her we did not tell her this she rudely said it could not be changed. This place used to be way better.
(1)
Marti L.

Go for the Ono Burger! Paia Fish Market was one of the 2 food stops before heading out to the beach. The Ono burger appealed to us and our instinct paid off. It was delicious! The thick cut of ono (wahoo fish) was cooked perfectly. Combined with coleslaw, tartar sauce, tomato and cheese, the burger was meaty, tasty and refreshing. Our poor burger never made it to the beach!
(4)
Angela W.

I got some Opah fish tacos with their red potato home fries which were rich and yummy. BF got the mahi fish and chips which I felt was a little dry but overall great lunch!
(4)
Mr J.

Just returned from a trip to Maui and Kauai. Was going to try this place anyway since Trip Advisor and Yelp had great things to say....Was not disappointed. Cool town with a surfer vibe. Ordered the fish dinner (choice of different types of fish and sides) It was the biggest slab of fish I ever saw on a plate.....very fresh - had it blackened and it was done superbly.The cool part is you have an option of many types of fish and how it is cooked....cajun, blackened, broiled etc....Two of us spent $65 for two dinners and 2 beers.....worth every penny even if you sit at a picnic table :-) For first timers, like I was, go to the ordering counter and look at the board to the left of the cash register, that will list what the fish options of the day are. We went after 8PM and had no wait (October)
(5)
Loreal G.

Im sure the Ono burger will bring us back to Paia fish market several times during our stay! I'm glad we were sent here on our first day, now we have a standard for Maui and its been set pretty darn high!!! Yay
(4)
Amanda L.

This was our first stop upon our arrival. I had the Mahi Mahi shrimp salad. Everything tasted great and was a great way to start off the week.
(4)
Joe T.

Based on the fist tacos. If you like "fish market" style fish tacos, maybe ok. If you are from So. Cal.... this is not what we are used to. OK fish with very sweet pickle based tartar sauce? Yuck. No real salsas in the joint, even on the table. Yuck. The "cajun" rice tasted like boxed rice a roni or something. The cole slaw was just cabbage with that sweet tartar sauce mixed in again. I yelped "fish tacos" in Maui hoping for some good ones, this was not it. I did see others with fist plates, etc. that looked ok. But I wont be back.
(2)
Johnny N.

Located in the center of Paia, this place has a lovely atmosphere. Great vibe, Great food, Great people! Seating is very limited so, good luck!
(5)
L H.

Had the most amazing cajun fish tacos here. We stopped at the fish market after an exhausting hike and it was perfect. I expected it to have some sort of market but its just a restaurant :) Zero complaints though-- order at a counter and try and find a seat. Don't go to the bathroom here, its terrifying but other than that the food is the freshest I've had on Maui. Will be coming back.
(5)
Amy T.

Two words... FISH TACOS. Not sure if it's because I was famished after hanging at the beach all day, but when I bit into the fish tacos, I was sold! The fish was fresh, juicy and flavorful. This is more of a casual restaurant where you buy your own food at the counter and share seats on a long bench. Napkins, utencils and condiments are all self served. Fish tacos and beer. Sigh.. memories!
(4)
Jennifer H.

REALLY don't get the hype. It's crowded, uncomfortable, expensive, and bad food. You have to get a key and go out back, next to the dumpsters, to wash your hands (and trust me, you don't feel cleaner after leaving the bathroom). Also, maybe you'll share a table with friendly people, or maybe, like us, a slightly hostile, OCD guy will sit down and start organizing the condiments. Next to the white guy with dreads who was hoarding the ketchup. Gives hippies a bad name. Our fish, mahi for $24, was waaay overcooked. That fish died in vain, it was dry, rubbery, and didn't have the promised "lemon butter" seasoning. Definitely spent at least 5 minutes too long on the heat. The fish taco, flavorless. Seriously. No salt, no grill char, nothing. Not even any salsa... just chopped tomatoes that weren't terribly ripe. No Cholula sauce or El Tapatio on the table to help it out either. The only thing decent that we ate there was: 1. the carrots, used as garnish. really, just a few shredded carrots but somehow, really sweet and delicious and I was so happy to put something tasty in my mouth at that point. 2. the blackened sashimi. I think it was just a piece of ahi rolled in some blackening spices. But since they didn't have to cook it, they didn't get to mess it up. The fish was fresh, I give you that. But we had a bbq at home a few days later that, by simply grilling the fish until it was done and NOT ANY LONGER, with a little salt, blew PFM out of the water.
(1)
Rachel S.

Normally I love this place! A real favorite, but today I asked for a seared ahi burger and it was cooked all the way through! Highly disappointed as this was a to go order.
(1)
Jeffrey M.

Love this place. We come to paia every year and paia fish market never disappointed us. Lunch today Mahi Mahi chargrilled with side fries. Delicious.
(4)
Cindy L.

Best meal I had on Maui!
(5)
Michelle V.

My husband and I always go to Flatbread when we arrive in Kahului. He doesn't eat fish and loves his pizza, so we go. Paia is a quick drive from the airport and after a 5 hour flight from San Francisco, we are hungry. Last week as we were walking to Flatbread we walked past the Paia Fish Market and my husband said something smells delicious. So we decided to drive there a week into our vacation and let me tell you, we will be back again (and again and again and again). I had the lunch plate with grilled mahi mahi, seasoned rice, and cole slaw. My husband had a grilled chicken burger. We both left happy, full and looking forward to having dinner there next week. It's a drive from Wailea, but as I said before, well worth it. 5 happy stars.
(5)
mark y.

had mahi burger ($10) and tacos ($13). preferred burger to the two taco plate, although I did like the red potatoes from the plate. I liked having a nice slice of fish versus the way the tacos have chopped up pieces of fish. I've been to this place and Coconut Fish Cafe, for some reason, they both chop up the fish for the fish tacos.
(4)
JoAnna G.

There are a bunch of good eats in Paia but I had my heart on checking this place out during lunch time. Best decision of my little foodie life! Menu is a little loco; there are tons of decisions to be made with a bunch of delicious fresh fish to decide on, and many options on how to prepare. After about 5 minutes of grazing and pulling apart the menu I knew what I wanted. Grubbed down on the fish plate: mahi mahi sautÃ©ed in lemon and butter on a bed of cajun rice and a side of slaw. Maybe it doesn't sound as incredible as it really is, but trust me, I was happy as a freaking clam. Seriously it was probably my favorite meal during my trip. The portions are huge! The mahi mahi was light, tender, and ridiculously delicious. mmmm... grilled perfectly. The cajun rice was the perfect compliment and even the slaw was really good. This place gets busy and the seating arrangements have you piled on long tables, cafeteria style next to some pretty interesting people, but I suppose it makes for a fun foodie adventure. The food does take a while to prepare but it comes out steaming hot and uber fresh so chill yourself out and appreciate this place for what it is. Worth every second of wait time to me. Fresh delicious fish prepared perfectly... My kind of place. :)
(5)
Suany W.

This place is crawling with weirdo hippies, but the fish tacos are legit! I'm not sure what type of fish they use, but it's fresh, non-fishy and flavorful. The fish is grilled, which I normally dislike (I prefer deep-fried), but the fish tacos here are the best I've ever had. Try it with Cajun rice! Warning: The tacos are HUGE, so only opt for two if you're really hungry. Otherwise, one should be plenty.
(4)
Bobby T.

This place hops! 5 PM, high dinner time, and we were able to get in, place our order, and find a place to sit with our toddler all with no problem. If you are looking for traditional table service, stay away from the fish market. Here you stand in line, place your order, and then wait for your number to be called. Use the time between ordering and eating wisely - find a place to sit. It's pretty easy. There are 4 or 5 largish picnic style tables for community seating. We chatted with several other couples while we waited and dined. There's nothing like sharing travel stories with others. The food is totally tasty and a good value, too. My wife had the Mahi Fish & Chips. I had blackened Ono. Everything was so good, and there was plenty of it. I can put the food away (some say I have a hollow leg), but I was overstuffed when I left. Yet I couldn't stop eating. Yeah. Next time we are on Maui, we'll definitely be stopping by Paia Fish Market!
(5)
Ceci S.

Great Mahi Mahi burgers!
(5)
Nikki H.

Rude service, huge portions. Don't know if it was the food from here or not, but soon after felt a bit sick to my stomach.
(2)
Feisty E.

Ok, we added a new favorite dish upon a couple of repeat visits... The seafood pasta!! Wow. Really so much more then you'd expect from a fast food fish joint. An enormous 2-person plate of shrimp and fish pieces in a gloppy, creamy white sauce over linguine. You have to try it... do NOT attempt to eat a whole thing alone however. Don't ask me how I know that. OTOH, a dish that was only so-so this time - the mahi tacos - the entrÃ©e size was mostly filler and carbs, with little fish. It was fine, just didn't make sense ($13 fish tacos vs $9 mahi burger... the latter wins, hands down). And the seasoning, lacked any sorts of flavor. Go for tacos elsewhere (Ohana Tacos in Honokowai, for one). I did learn to control my rage in waiting for a bench to open at Maui Fishmarket and now laugh at the others stressing over having to wait in line or splitting up a party. The line is terrifying and being a pot/hippie friendly place, Paian crowd is not always the best smelling bunch.... Still worth it!! Over the years, we've been maybe 10-12 times. Always pop in for last dinner on the way to OGG and just go crazy... Amazing quality for the price, hats off to you Fishmarket!
(5)
Teri T.

I've been to Paia several times and somehow missed this place. They serve about 4 kinds of fresh fish made to order: deep fried, Cajun, sautÃ©ed. Very delicious. I had mahi Cajun style with Cajun rice. They give a nice sized piece of fish on a bed of rice with cold slaw. Cold slaw was a little bland tho. No flavor. My husband had fish and chips. He also had mahi mahi sautÃ©ed in butter and garlic and a nice portion of French fries. It's a very busy place, but we easily found a table. You bus your own plates and utensils. They do have a busboy that keeps the tables really clean and replenishes the table forks, knives, and spoons. They also serve burgers, pasta, and salads.
(4)
Chris O.

Located on a busy corner in Paia this little gem does offer some tasty fish treats. My biggest issue with this place is atmosphere. It is tiny and offers communal picnic style seating. Its small and basically is always filled with tourists. Parking is a bear as parking in Paia is hard. Perhaps its me - but I prefer something a little different. That said, add two stars if you love seafood because to be fair the food is very good. I have deducted two stars due to what I have articulated herein. If you are not bothered by small and communal - go for it because the fish is fresh and worth it. Cheers......................
(2)
J T.

Seafood pasta was a little watery but filled with pieces of fish, shrimp, mussels, and creamy goodness! The shrimp and chips were the right amount of crunchiness and the sauces: cocktail and tartar, both of which were delightful. Only down side was they were out of blackened sashimi and I've heard that is a wonderful item, which I will try the next time I visit Paia Fish Market.
(4)
Amanda S.

Great casual spot for a meal. Place was busy and you have to be patient and grab a table but the fish was fresh and good. We got a sandwich but the entries looked large and tasty.
(4)
Kristin E.

My boyfriend and me went to the fish market everyday during our stay on Maui. We've tried nearly everything: Fish Tacos, Seafood Caesar Salad, Fish Burger, Chicken Burger, Fish Plate and Calamari and Chips. The food is delicious, I wish we had a place like this in Germany (and I'm from Hamburg so I live nearby the water...). Our fav fish was the Ahi, but we've tried Ono and Mahi Mahi as well and both were really good. They charboil the fish or you can have it sauteed (really nice) or cajun style. The home fries are also really really good! The place is always a bit crowded, but you have the chance to have a little conversation with your neighbour while waiting for your food because you sit together at long tables. I will definitely miss this place!
(5)
Jennifer D.

Quite possibly some of the BEST prepared fish on the island. The large portions, fresh fish, picnic tables, cute lunch buckets, and cool Paia breeze are the epitome of the perfect lunch in Maui! My family and I went on the recommendation of my uncle who lives in Makawao. He himself has never been, but several of his co-workers and friends mentioned this place to him and said the fish is superb. The girls at Lululemon across the street said that they liked the salads with fish too. Since my family has been trying to eat more fish and less red meat, Paia Fish Market was the place to go. When you step in, there is usually a line to order and very few seats available at the picnic tables. You should have one person hold down the fort at a table while the rest go up to the cashier to order. I had the fish plate lunch and I chose the salmon prepared in garlic, lemon, and butter. The consistency of the meat was flawless! I was drooling over ever bite I took. The butter made the fish even yummier of course. You get to choose potatoes, rice, or both! Of course I got both to get the best of both worlds. Your plate also comes with coleslaw. The fish plate is a little price for a lunch, running you about $18 bucks. Some of the other entrees aren't as much. We also tried the fish tacos and fish quesadilla. They usually come with a white fish, but my family upgraded to salmon for an extra buck. After trying all of the dishes, the fish plate was the winner for me. My brother liked his quesadilla because he is a cheese lover. We came back another time later in the week and I tried the Mahi Mahi fish plate to change it up. This time I tried the Charbroiled preparation and enjoyed the spice rub that they used the fish. But mahi mahi vs. salmon? Salmon FTW! Salmon has a softness that no other fish can compare to. If you ever find yourself in upcountry Maui then you should definitely plan for your lunch to be at the Paia Fish Market. Afterward check out the cute shops around the area too.
(5)
Daniel T.

I love this place!! Our first time to Maui and we were recommended to try this restaurant because of their fish tacos. So glad we did!! They were some of the best fish tacos I have had. I love the atmosphere with the tables and beach feeling. Located in the lovely town of Paia. Will definitely be back before heading back to CA.
(5)
Kali H.

Not sure why this gets such great reviews. I have eaten here on 3 separate occasions and at different times of the day and each time the service has been terrible. They act like they are doing you a favor by serving you. Twice they were out of an item but didn't inform us for over 10 minutes. I have had the blackened fish and it comes out drier then a saltine cracker! Yuck. So the next time I got it without the blackening and, again, dry dry dry. For someplace with "Fish Market" in the title you would think they would have better fish chefs. They also have a lot of wasted space with what looks like it was maybe going to be an actual fish market, there are display cases taking up the entire front of the ordering area. They look like crap and take up needed space. I don't waste my time or money here anymore.
(2)
Cherie T.

before we start our Road To Hana.. we stopped off at Paia Fish Market (thanks to Yelp). Each fish taco was about $4 something... i thought wow, that's pretty expensive for a small fish taco. So i decided on the combination plate for $13 which comes w/ 2 fish taco, cajun rice or red potatos, and cole slaw. Man, this plate is HUGE! and it looked mighty delicious. The two fish tacos were not as small as i thought. I took my first bite of my grilled mahi mahi taco.. OMG.. sooo fresh! so good! so delicious! the freshness of the lettuce and tomato and the fish.. the whole combination of flavor was just bursting in my mouth. I finished the two fish taco in a matter of seconds. instead of getting all cajun rice... i got half rice and half potatoes. Let me tell you this.. i wish i had just ordered 3 fish taco by itself rather than paying for the plate combination. The cajun rice.. wow, too much rosemary! that's all i can taste.. didn't like it. and the red potatoes were just meh - nothign special. But i do regret ordering the plate. i wish i had a 3rd fish taco. Service is fast, people are friendly. Parking, there's a free parking lot down the street, next to the Shell Gas station. If you're heading to Hana.. stop by at this place and treat your stomach to some delicious mahi mahi tacos.
(4)
Amy L.

Definitely tasty food, but it's just a bit on the pricey side. And seating is minimal. And there's a wait. Times visited: 1
(3)
Tomer S.

This is by far the best restaurant on the island. We made the way from Lahaina just to eat here after enjoying it so much the first time. The portions are huge, priced very reasonably and most importantly, delicious. I recommend the Charbroiled Ahi or Blackened Salmon with the side of potatoes, but I am sure everything on the menu is great. I will have to come back to explore the rest of the menu, there were so many options!
(5)
Sonali A.

Great little place with fresh fish tacos and Maui Brewing Co beer! Laid back and casual, perfect for our first dinner after landing in Maui!
(4)
Mike J.

this is the best fish you could ask for. One of our favorite places in Maui. The Ono burger is unbelievable. The calamari is excellent, the best I have ever had. there is a cheap parking lot across the street, we a dollar. Fish and chips was good too.
(5)
Leslie J.

Very disappointed!! We stopped here for dinner on the way home from our Hana excursion. Not welcoming. Lady at the register did not seem friendly at all. We ordered -2 fish tacos= $12.95. Fish was dry and overcooked. No flavor. We doused it in tarter sauce to give it a little flavor. The french fries were hard and tasted like old fries from earlier in the day that were refried. -fish quesadilla =$14.95 all we tasted was salsa. Again, fish was dry. -fountain drink= $2.61 for a medium sized cup. Ridiculous... Abosolutely ridiculous for a fountain drink
(2)
Marvin D.

Stumbled upon this place after a locals recommendation, wish I could find that couple and thank them again for introducing us to such a wonderful place. Everything is great there, ordered an Obama burgers, this burger is mind blowing freakin good. Trust me you don't need the cole slaw or any other stuff with it, just add a dash of like and savor the heavenly Cajun flavored coho! Very friendly staff and and overall great food.
(5)
Tori H.

Just as delicious as you would expect it to be, maybe even more. Suuuper packed family style seating so unless your ready to rub elbows with some strangers, you might wanna get it to go and eat by the beach. Personally I love strangers...and fish...and strangers who love fish so it works out
(4)
John F.

Ho-ly cow. This place is incredible. Without a doubt one of the best meals we had while in Maui. Hole in the wall, no frills, sit-on-a-bench seafood for a reasonable price. My fish tacos were fresh and the portion was enough to feed me for at least a day. I would recommend a particular dish, but everything looked so good. In a town full of expensive junk, Paia Fish Market is a delicious bargain. Do not miss it while in Paia! We will definitely be back here asap.
(5)
Steve M.

My favorite stand bye in maui. I live in Oahu and travel to Maui quite a bit. The endearing part of the Paia Fish Market IS the chaos, the picnic benches, the people and the FRESH ass fish. Its PERFECT for me. Its not a trip to Maui without a drop by to Fish Market in hippy town. The detractors arent GETTING it. Its the chaotic type of semi local semi tourist vibe with the lines and great food that make this place what it is... Man...Enjoy your life. Your experiences. Your fish....and settle down. You are in Hawaii!
(5)
Charlie B.

Loved it! Sort of made me wonder why I was paying an arm and a leg for amazing fresh fish for 9 days prior! It's nothing fancy inside, but the food was great. We had the taco dinner and the enchilada dinner after much deliberation. You sit at tables with other diners, which actually was fun, you can gawk at each others food and compare notes. I love how places like this that you dont' think too much about turn out to be some of the fondest memories of a trip and at a fraction of the price at fancy dinners in other spots. If I were back in Maui this would be on my must-return list to try the pasta and other fresh fish preps. If staying near Paia I think I could come back for multiple visits and work my way through the menu. Loved it!
(5)
Mercy P.

One of my favorite places to eat! That's the only place I eat burgers! Fish is always fresh!
(5)
Mark G.

We love the food here. Sizes are supersized large. Sharing is a good idea for moderate to light eaters. Food tasted fresh. Fast service. I am Vegan, and cheated on the Salmon burger and it was amazing tasting. Wish I ate the entire Salmon burger. If Salmon is on the menu, it was special dish and not normally on the menu. For the Vegan, I had a Veggie quesadilla (with no cheese) and it was perfect. My wife and daughter got the fish tacos and were both satisfied. My son, ate most of the salmon burger in seconds, but also ordered the seafood pasta. It is VERY RICH, and heavy dish. Very large size too. He couldn't finish it, even if he didn't eat the Salmon Burger. The richness is from the cream sauce. But he loved it! They have some great drink choices, including a gurana drink that is a natural energy natural caffeine drink. The atmosphere is picnic bench style sit down. Not enough tables for the number of people in line, so you may need to have your party sit while one or two order. Otherwise standing room only, or eat while walking the cute town. I was amazed for the fresh food how quickly it was prepared. The dishes do come out when ready, therefore at different times based on the meal orderred. But all our dishes arrived before those behind us. This is worth a trip to Paia just for the delicious meal. Parking is street parking. Careful of the limits as parking officers do give tickets. Visit the health food store up the street for dessert.
(4)
Lisa F.

We loved this place so much we came back for more! Fresh, delicious and huge portions. Not to be missed!
(5)
Margaret F.

Great lunch spot on the way back from Hana (we stayed overnight) in the little town of Paia. Looks like a lot of tourists and locals alike visit the fish market. Loved the fish taco - flaky and came with a ton of cole slaw and potatoes. The shrimp and chips were good, too. Should have tried the fish and chips instead. It does get busy so grab a seat in one of the communal picnic tables when you can, but people there finish their food pretty quickly anyway.
(4)
Dragana N.

This place is located in a cute town of Paia and is a perfect spot to stop by for a quick meal after a long day at the beach. We had their delicious coconut deep fried calamari as an appetizer and fish tacos paired with potatoes as a side. Both dishes were a total hit. The calamari was absolutely amazing and the best one I had so far. The tacos were quite big and loaded with so many ingredients, so its perfect for sharing. The only negative is that the tacos were placed on top of hot potatoes which made the tortilla soft and tacos a bit challenging to eat. But other than that it's really quite delicious. The place gets packed but the service is friendly and fast so you won't have to wait too long for your meal. It's a great spot to check out!
(4)
Sowmini S.

Strolling around the streets of Pa'ia is a very pleasant experience especially for art lovers, honeymooners and couples in general. While you forget everyone around you and yourself with admiration of their art or your beau ;) , you stomach rumbles and brings u back to reality. That's when u rush inside a super crowded place with good food called Pa'ia fish market. We ordered fish 'n' chips and waited for 15 starving minutes for food, but it was worth it.
(4)
Taylor B.

Been here twice this week and plan on going one more time before we leave! It's an awesome place to grab some melt in your mouth calamari or mahi fish and chips! Depending on the time of day the line can get pretty long but it goes quick and keep an eye out for people leaving because seating is pretty limited. Would definitely recommend while walking around all the shops in town!
(5)
Mitchell M.

I expected it to be slightly cheaper and was a bit disappointed with the Ahi sashimi. Other than that, I have no complaints and highly recommend this place. Of course, if you have ever stayed in Paia...you know your options are limited anyhow. Lol. We ate here a couple times, and the shrimp & chips was definitely are favorite. Good chips, and perfectly fried, meaty shrimp. The cocktail sauce had a nice kick which I liked as well. We also had the fish & chips which is made with mahi mahi. As you may be aware, mahi is a pretty substantial fish, so it was slightly heavier than the fish & chips I am accustomed to, but we enjoyed it all the same. The fish tacos are also very good...also made with mahi. They have a large selection of fresh fish with a large variety preparations. There are also seafood and pasta options, so I think it's safe to say just about everyone will find something here. It is almost always busy. We did lunch & dinner here. Dinner was early as we had just gotten off the beach, but expect lines at prime dinner times. There is not table service except they will bus your dishes for you. The place is two rows of communal picnic tables. You order at the front counter. I don't recall completely, but am pretty sure they do serve beer.
(4)
Dennis S.

Extremely popular, and for good reason. At 2:30 in the afternoon the place will still have a line out to the door. Seating is casual around up-scale picnic tables. Busy, busy, busy. We've had their fish sandwiches several times and think they're great. Very tasty and moist, not overcooked.It's a simple choice as far as we're concerned. Ono burger all the way. The sign is up for a Paia Fish Market to open in Kihei. Can't wait.
(5)
Matt G.

Great fish, super fresh. I ate the mahi fish and chips and the fish tacos. Very flakey fish and not over cooked. Local feel restaurant but very good food.
(5)
Andrew C.

Ono is always fresh and my favorite is the Obama burger served with wasabi butter. Love the local vibe.
(5)
Lisa A.

Not quite sure what to rave about. Tried the special of the day grilled fresh fish of the day choices were three. We picked the Mahi Mahi grilled and it was okay but it was much tastier at Saigon cafe in Kahalui. The sashimi which is an appetizer was good but not great. I don't think they know how to cut it right. The Cajun style rice is good but I should have ordered the fries to try. I guess it's better than other choices if you're in Paia.
(3)
Jimmy N.

I went around 7pm with my party of 6. Can be very crowded but luckily we grabbed a whole table...first come first serve. It is also open door to the outside so it's mainly cool air from the fans not AC. Waited in line for about 10 minutes and then another 10 minutes after we ordered. The mahi fish and chips were delicious! Best fried fish I've tried in Maui and the fries were crispy and salty enough. We also had the seafood pasta and calamari appetizer...both were delicious as well. Would recommend for a quick stop before heading to the airport. Only 4 stars cuz of the waiting in line
(4)
Sheila M.

Good food in a casual friendly environment. We ordered fish tacos and the Ono burger. The tacos were ok but the burger was great. Food came quickly and prices were reasonable for Maui.
(4)
Sophie L.

Fish tacos were pretty good. A tad on the bland side but huge portions and lots of fresh fish. It came with cole slaw and french fries. Wish I got to try the fish and chips.
(4)
Hector S.

Didn't love the place, didn't hate it. The fish sandwich was good. We shared and was fine and kept us from getting too hungry before dinner.
(3)
Shoshana S.

I got the Cajun seared Tuna and he got the Opah-both were a delight for the taste buds. One fish dinner would have been enough for us to share. The portions are enormous and the vibes were casual and easy. Loved it!!
(5)
Heather W.

Super fresh and reasonable- loved every bite of my mahi mahi sandwich. One star less for service- a bit snooty - but would definitely return for that sandwich again. Yum.
(4)
Jessi G.

This was by far the best meal and the best priced food that I had during my entire trip in Maui. I had the Cajun salmon dish and it was UNBELIEVABLE! The fish was super fresh and seasoned perfectly. I wish I found this place before the last day on my trip and I would have gone several more times. And Thank you Paia Fish Market for introducing me to Tiger Sauce!! yummmm
(5)
Linda T.

fish burger was bomb! I got the ono burger which comes with a grilled filet of ono in a very soft sesame bun, lettuce, tomato, cheese and sauce. it was simple, tasty and delicious. besides ono, you can get mahi burger. fish tacos are a mixture of ono and mahi and are filling and yums. comes with a side of cole slaw and choice of fries or home fries. this place gets packed during meal hours. line up to order and find any open spots to sit and dine.
(4)
Ro C.

Can't believe Mama's has a higher rating than Paia Fish Market. It was one of the most memorable meals on the island. My husband had the "snapper" with Cajun rub and I had the mahi mahi smothered in butter and garlic. The fries were soaked in the sauce making it a delightful treat! Their fresh coleslaw alone is worth going back for. Must try if you're in the area!
(5)
Zeb B.

Good casual food. Get there early - always a crowd.
(4)
Foodi E.

Fish caught that very morning is served gourmet style daily at unbelievably reasonable prices. In order to keep prices down, you place and pick up your order at a walk up counter, self serve your beverages and sit at community tables. Help them keep prices at bay by busing your trays as you would normally at a food court type place... The atmosphere is casual and crowded So if you're looking for a quiet more intimate tourist dining experience make reservations at an overrated and expensive Fish House on the island to enjoy half the portions that you would be served here. Just saying..,
(4)
Jorge G.

It just ok, my expectations were higher. I had the fish and chips and the Ono burger. The place is very simple which I am ok with, the staff was friendly but the food ehh...
(4)
Sean H.

Blah. For a "fish market" in Maui, you'd think they'd at least have some local items like poke or a selection of fresh local fish, and you'd also expect the fish to be fresh and prepared well. Not so much. Since the menu was lacking in good options, I got the fish and chips, which came out super overlooked and generally just bland. It took a lot of tartar sauce to overpower the heavy batter on the dried out mahi. Also, as others have noted, it's not the cheapest place. The portions are huge, which is nice (I guess), but the food isn't that great so I'm not sure an extra pound of rice or slaw justifies the higher cost. All in all, just seems like an average at best and somewhat touristy type of fish restaurant, with a really boring and overpriced menu. I'd pass.
(2)
Louis R.

I get fish tacos on every island in Hawaii and not necessarily from high-end restos. I prefer tacos from broke-down trucks and little mom and pop spots. I wasn't gonna deviate from this paradigm, in this old school town. So ono. So fresh. So local. Mahalo, uncle and auntie.
(5)
Melody H.

I can't come to Maui without a stop here. Their food is amazing. I love their taco and the fish and chips are yummy. I was so happy when they opened other locations but would still make the drive if they hadn't.
(5)
Jonathan M.

Great food and large size portions especially on the pasta and Mahi Fish & Chips.! Also ordered seafood chowder and the Ono sandwich which were very tasty, too. Service was fast. Dining area is small but you can always share a table with a stranger. The only reason why I didn't give 5 stars was because of the parking situation. This is located in the middle of the down town area so you may have to circle around a few times to find one. Other than that I'd recommend this place.
(4)
Heather B.

Had fish (mahi) and chips. The fish itself was amazing- caught that day! The breading was not the usual fish and chips batter. I didn't enjoy it. It was more like salty bread crumbs. Fries were cold. Coleslaw was very good. Not to saucey. My friend had a veggie quesadilla and said it was good..
(3)
Landon J.

I was not a huge fan! The rest of the family loved it. I had the fish (Mahimahi), the shrimp and chips as well the first time and the fish and chips and the fish tacos the second time. The were both "fine" to me, but I left feeling like it did not sit well in my stomach. I would rather have ate at different places (flat bread pizza across the street), but the family liked this place! The shrimp and chips were yummy and fish tacos were really good as well!
(3)
Geoff And Jenni G.

We quite liked this hole in the wall fish place in Paia... very relaxed, good food and well priced... the only complaint we had was our fish taco's were somewhat light on fish... I mean really light ... We may go back, just to see if it was a one-off or not... as it really was pretty good value for money and quite tasty!
(3)
Lizel Z.

Easy access casual food stop at the busy intersection in the middle of little Paia town.. Came here for lunch after searching for parking for 20+ minutes! Finally found a spot in a pay lot. :/ Walked in, ordered 2 fish tacos, 1 ono burger, and a beer (in a can?!). About 15 seconds after we sat down, the line grew to out the door!! Guess we came in at JUST the perfect time. :D The ono burger was definitely ONO!! The ono was fresh, sweet, and moist. Noms! The fish tacos were tasty, juicy, and cooked perfectly. MMMM! And the beer was the perfect complement to our seafood lunch! There were a group of surfer guys across the way from us, sitting at the table next to the windows. They had camera guys following their every move and catching every word of their conversation. This taping of what I'm guessing is a documentary or reality show may or may not have contributed to the super busy atmosphere of the restaurant.. but it was interesting to watch the "behind the scenes" in real life. Hope I'm not in the background stuffing my face or looking all awkward into the camera. LOL Anyway! There will probably be other tourists hovering around you when you're finishing up your meal. Share the aloha and offer them your seats if you know they're eyeing you.. and PLEASE bus your own table. :) We'll definitely come back for another ono meal next time we're in Maui!! Can't wait!!
(5)
Rayna J.

Coming back on from the road to Hana, there is the cutest little town of Paia! It's a must stoop at the Fish Market. My husband ordered the fish and chips while I decided to go with the Mahi Mahi Fish sandwich. Kinda unusual for me but I decided to try something different. WOW I am glad i did. A large cooked to perfection piece of mahi mahi on a sesame roll, layered with shredded cheese, tartar sauce and coleslaw. SURPRISED. I typically don't like tartar sauce or coleslaw but I fell in love. Just like many of the other yelp reviews, this is a WINNER!
(5)
Phil K.

Hip with great seafood to boot! One of the MUST VISIT food spots in Maui. Some of the best fish tacos that you'll ever have. The mahi burger was juicy and flavorful throughout and it was grilled to perfection. There are so many choices on the bright, colorful menu. Made it extremely difficult in narrowing down my choices. Decisions, decisions! Very busy so try grabbing a table before ordering!
(5)
ANJ A.

Pretty packed, grab your own sear, loved the Cajun style ono. Supposed to be better than Mama's Fish House.
(4)
Angie N.

This place runs like a well oiled machine! For as busy as they are, they always have a smile on their faces and the food is ready in a timely fashion. I love the picnic table setting inside. The food is consistently fresh and flavorful. Definitely a good choice for fresh fish in the North shore!
(5)
Lily G.

Paia is such a cute town with cute restaurants and shops and art galleries. We stopped here to grab dinner even though we were staying in Makena and we're so glad we did. The red snapper dinner plate was extremely tasty and cooked perfectly (we ordered it sauteed in butter). It was on a bed of slaw and we ordered it with the cajun rice. It's unlike what you'd imagine cajun rice to be. It's way more tasty and only enhanced by the tiger (hot) sauce they had at each table. I feel like a lot of restaurants here are hit or miss with its flavoring, in my opinion. But this place was a definite hit! It's not a large establishment. You line up and order at the counter, find an open spot, it's all family style bench seating, and wait for your number to be called. The fishes of the day are on a small white board at the register. So the only downside is that you can't see it if there's a lot of people in line until it's your turn up front. But the girl at the register did not mind being asked questions and didn't rush us at all. Also, their fountain soda is delicious because they pipe in chilled water in to the machine, which makes for a much tastier soda! We will definitely come back here next time we're in Maui!
(5)
Manjula S.

Out of the world and amazing food !! We had to wait around 30 mins for a table but it was totally worth it.Fish was so fresh and perfectly cooked.This place is a must visit when in Maui and make sure you come HUNGRY here, you will not be sorry !!!
(4)
Emily C.

Great fresh fish and generous sides in a family style space.
(4)
Jessica C.

Fish and chips- Mahi. Large pieces of Mahi on a bed of fries and coleslaw. Very generous with their fish portions. Fish was over fried, the seasoning was good but the outside of the fish was more chewy than crunchy, the fish itself over cooked, thus lacking in tenderness and flavor. Fries are generic. Coleslaw is fresh. Shrimp cocktail: large pieces of shrimp. Peel was still on and tasted as if it has been frozen. The shrimp tasted "pasty" instead of the firm texture that freshly cooked shrimp usually tastes like. I'd skip this touristy place. Eskimo Candy has way better fish and chips.
(2)
Eric N.

Fresh fish! I ordered the Mahi dinner cajun style and it was delicious. I was skeptical about the portion size for the price before I ordered, but to my relief, it was a nice large piece of fish. The cajun style was heavily seasoned, just how I like it. The coleslaw is homemade everyday (I noticed it has fresh dill in it-yum!), and the acidity/creamyness/texture is the perfect balance to your plate. I will go back for sure!
(5)
James N.

Came here with my friends when we decided to visit the area for some food and drinks. Stopped by here because my friend yelped it and wanted to give it a try. It was not what I was expecting. It's extremely casual and has a 'on the go' take on the food. The food here was edible but it was extremely forgettable. I don't remember anything I ate other than the fish and fries. The fries were really good and crispy. The fish wasn't anything great. We got like 3 different kinds of seasoning on the fishes too. I guess it's a good spot to go if you wanna grab a quick bite of fish and some good fries. 3 Stars.
(3)
Ariel L.

Stopped here for lunch after spending 3 days in Haleakala crater. Super crowded but pretty quick turnover so it wasn't that hard to find a spot at the shared picnic style tables. I had the Cajun rubbed mahi over salad. The fish was cooked perfectly but the spices recently really very strong. Came with some tasty cocktail/tartar sauces though. Papaya dressing is always a good choice for salad. My dad git the fish tacos. His only complaints were the home style potatoes that were a mix of over and under done. Large servings worth the cost, great casual place to stop for lunch.
(4)
Adrienne A.

You order, serve yourself and clean up after yourself. You can even do take out. Small place with limited seating but, definately worth the wait. We had the seafood pasta, fried calamari and onion rings. The seafood pasta was delicious and the portion was very generous. Couldn't believe the calamari was finger size, sweet and tender. The onion rings were crunchy and not oily. I'm sad that we discovered this place on our final night, my husband and I will definitely be back here next time we're on Maui.
(4)
Natalie W.

Great food, good prices. Had the Ono burger one day and he mahi burger the next. Good fries too. Would recommend if in the area. No complaints.
(5)
Mike L.

This was Okay food...nothing amazing; lots of locals. Was expensive for what it was. Sashimi was good; Ono sandwich was Good, nothing spectacular. Fries were overly salty to my taste.
(3)
Ron R.

Very good food and value. We had Fish tacos, chicken tacos, and fish & chips. We were hungry early (11:30am) so we missed the short line that formed later. We'll definitely return when in the area
(4)
Good A.

Road to Haha, Pit Stop, awesome for Blackened Mahi Mahi and Fish Sandwiches. Paia is a hippieish town, this place is in the main corner of town. Great little restaurant in Maui!!!!
(5)
Danielle B.

Looking for amazing food at reasonable prices!! Look no more!! The fish tacos here are amazing and come with the choice of a side. The fish is fresh!! We also ordered the Mahi fish sticks and they were also pretty good thou I highly recommend the tacos over them!! It is more like a casual fast joint but it is truly really good!!
(5)
Dan M.

This is for the NEW Paia Fish Market just opened today in Kihei. I drove by and saw it was open! Located in the Kalama Center across from the big whale in Kalama Park. I ordered the Cajun spiced Ono sandwich with fries. It was as good as driving to the North Shore. Service was excellent and everyone was friendly. Not bad for a opening night! Onolicious! Can't wait until tomorrow for lunch or dinner or both!
(5)
Carol L.

Now this was the fish I'd been searching for. The FISH LUNCH PLATE (choose a fish from the daily selection) comes with coleslaw and a choice of cajun rice, home fried potatoes or 1/2 of each. You can have the fish charbroiled, with cajun seasonings or sauteed. After the disappointing fish at Kihei Caffe, I was very much looking for redemption. The charbroiled ONO I had was excellent. And it was a hefty piece. The home fries were also really good. My friend had the FISH AND CHIPS. It looked more like fish sticks so not what he was expecting. It was okay, but I'd come for the charbroiled daily catch.
(5)
MICHAEL P.

-Best fish on the island with great price. Simple, fresh, clean, and worth the money. -Got the Opakapaka filet plate special, chowder, and 2 fish tacos. All very well seasoned and prepared. -Had to park at a lot about 2 blocks away and walk over. -Out of
(5)
Sean E.

Just another stop on our eating out list that was fantastic. Its worth the wait, in traffic and in line. Had the daily special "Obama" last time - blackened ono burger with wasabi mayo. This time we tried the fish and chicken tacos & the Cajun ono lunch plate with fries. Really fresh food, cooked great & exploding with flavor. Food network "Best Things I Ever Ate" rated them the best fish tacos and I guess we can't argue.
(5)
Robert W.

Found this place by mistake and it was the best mistake I made the entire trip. The fish sandwich was phenomenal, the calamari was the best I have ever eaten. If your on the road to Hana I recommend you eat here. I would also recommend you avoid the road to Hana or you will see said lunch again.
(5)
Brandon L.

Paia Fish Market is one heck of a seafood restaurant. When you first walk in, you already get a feeling that this place is chill and laid back. The menu is on top of the wall written with chalk, seating inside is more like a cafeteria style, and you can see the cooks working hard while you wait for your food. This place is packed during anytime of the day. We went there around 3PM and there was no seating at all. You have to watch for people leaving and claim that spot. If you have a big group, sitting next to each other might not be an option. I ordered the fish quesadilla and it came with rice and salad. The food was quite delicious. Paia Fish Market is known for it's huge portions. All of their entrees are piled high making a dome like shape. Parking is available along the street and it might be difficult to find a spot.
(4)
Jenny W.

2.5 stars Super disappointed with my meal here. In a trip filled with disappointing meals, this was the the most disappointing of them all. We got the sautÃ©ed Ono and ahi plates, which came with a good amount of rice/potatoes and coleslaw. The slices of fish were quite large but they were cooked too dry. Having had a delicious ahi sandwich at the fish market near Lahaina, I was extremely disappointed to find the entire ahi cooked through and made into a dry, not too appetizing slab of fish. The Ono was even more dry. Plus the fish tasted quite bland. The only redeeming factor was that at least the potatoes were really good. Not to mention that none of this was cheap. It was ~21 for the Ono and ~23 for the ahi, which was almost the price we paid for a much better meal (featuring similar fish) in Waikiki just a few days earlier.
(2)
Christine K.

Fair food. Personally feel like it is kind of expensive. Restaurant in Paia is hot. Outside seating is available in Kiehe which is nice. Friendly staff.
(3)
Roxy L.

This place is bomb.com ! Chill vibes, great prices, and good food! I usually get a piece of Mahi or Paka (Hawaiian snapper) grilled (sometimes with the garlic on it) and its always so fresh and tasty! Definitely a place you have to try when you are in Paia!
(5)
Sierra D.

I thought this place would live up to its reviews but it did not. I ordered a "chicken teriyaki" plate and the chicken tasted the cardboard box that it probably came out of. There was NO flavor what so ever, it was dry and just awful. Their "Cajun rice" is a joke and their coleslaw salad wasn't great either. Their fish tacos looked the best out of all their food I saw. Oh, and my whole family and I had upset stomachs after eating here! We were all pretty disappointed with this place.
(1)
Sandy G.

Love this little joint. While always busy, it is clean and efficient and the food is consistently tasty. Went back for the grilled Ono topping the organic Kula greens and enjoyed every bite! Don't forget to season with the Tiger Sauce if you like a little kick to your food (a bit sweet too)!
(5)
Stephen H.

Four-star food and 2-star price make for a 3-star overall rating. My lunch plate of sauteed salmon with half-half Cajun rice and home fried potatoes, and coleslaw was 4-star good. A generous piece of salmon was both seasoned and cooked almost perfectly for my taste. I did not get its hometown or pedigree, but I enjoyed it nonetheless. Really enjoyed it. I'd guess the salmon was farmed (vs. wild) for all its fatty goodness. I was expecting rather bland sides, but the rice and potatoes were tasty of and on their own. The coleslaw of coarsely chopped green and red cabbage too. All nicely complementary to the salmon. Here, diners are offered a variety of fish---mahimahi, ono, opah, ahi, monchong, opakapaka, salmon---prepared one of 4 ways---charbroiled, blackened, Cajun, or sauteed. This day, the mahimahi or ono lunch plates were $20.95. All other fish types were $23.95. With a one-size, refillable Coke ($2.50), and tax---$27.56. [gulp] Maui- and tourist- pricing. [sigh] Two stars. I'd come here again, but those prices made me hiccup.
(3)
Caroline K.

Had the mahi burger. Fish was fresh but overall the dish lacked flavor so I had to bump up the flavor with a ketchup/Tabasco mixture. Fries were good.
(2)
J D.

So ono! This place is great! Always busy, really fun casual vibe and great food. Order at the counter, and chill. A table will open up before your food is ready, I promise. The only way this doesn't work is when too many people sit before its their turn. The staff is friendly and patient! Will explain all the different types fish. We live up the street and this is a favorite for us!
(5)
Rohan P.

We came here for dinner, ordered blackened tilapia , Cesar salad and breaded shrimp. The tilapia was fresh and nicely cooked. The cole slaw served with the fish was the best I've ever had. Would definitely come back if I am in maui.
(5)
Courtney J.

The fresh fish burgers here are amazing! I went back a second time for another one. Get it with whatever is the fresh catch of the day. I had ono, and it was so good. They give you a large piece of fish. Then it's topped with slaw, a slice of tomato, and cheese. The only thing I don't like is that the cheese is shredded, so it seems to go everywhere when you pick it up to eat it. The second time we went back, we got a variation on this fish burger, the Obama burger with ono. This had a wasabi butter on the top and spices rubbed onto the fish. Fantastic! Full of flavor and such fresh, delicious, meaty fish. If they have this option when you go, definitely get it! The fish is the star of the restaurant of course, but I like to have some sides with my sandwich. The first time I split a basket of fries with my husband. They were your typical frozen shoestring fries. The second time we did the smart thing and split a basket of onion rings. Now they were really good! The portions here are really big, so come with a big appetite or share with a friend. This place seems to stay crowded, so you might have to share a picnic table with others, but we managed to find a seat okay like this. The food doesn't take too long to come out, so people seem to get in and out of there fairly quickly. If you're in Maui and love fresh fish, you really should check this place out!
(5)
Karen R.

Fresh and delicious! Tried Opah fish for the first time and it was amazing. Great atmosphere and even better fish!
(5)
Adam B.

Amazing fish-centric dishes in a fast casual setting. The sides leave a bit to be desired, but the fresh and local fish totally end up picking up the slack. Worth stopping by if you're in the area though not pilgrimage-worthy like Mama's. Mahi Fish & Chips: A very thin and lightly fried coating which means the inside of firm and fresh mahi-mahi really shone; definitely higher end than some generic white fish fry you'll find at a British pub. The chips were more like thin American fries rather than thick British chips, which would have been a better pairing. Absolutely loved the tartar sauce which had some sort of tangy dill note. Blackened Cajun Ahi Tuna: A bit pricier than the fish & chips, but worth it to have a local tuna steak as opposed to something shipped in frozen like we get back on the mainland. The cajun sear added a lot of complimentary flavor, but caused the interior to be gray instead of pink/red. Still amazing! Cajun Rice: Some flavor, but didn't overpower the fish. Red Potatoes: Texture made it seem a bit under cooked. Some mild flavoring, but not nearly as flavorful as a full on potato salad. Probably wouldn't get this again.
(4)
Kevin G.

My wife and I are in town for a week and are probably going here for our 3rd time tomorrow on the same trip. Flakey, melt in your mouth fish and chips, excellent chicken tacos and calamari to die for. Line can be long and seating is limited but worth it. Next time we come to Maui I want to book our stay as close as possible to Paia fish market! So good!
(5)
Dominique F.

Loveeed the fresh seafood! Would absolutely be back!
(5)
Chandler P.

This place was super crowded and it was war to find a table. I ended up ordering the fish and chips which were pretty good, but not the best I've ever had. My husband ordered a grilled filet which was very flavorful. I don't know if I would go there again.
(3)
Doug G.

We came here with a big appetite. We spent the day zip lining and hiking along paths on Hana highway. So the kids were starving. We had no idea how big the portions would be. There are no kid size portions or kids menu. Kids loved the food but they could have shared. 13 year old ate half a bowl of the seafood chowder. 10 year old ate half a quesadilla. 9 year old ate half a taco. Did I mention our kids were starving? The portions were gigantic. Wife had the fish and chips. Four large pieces of fish. Cooked just right. Couldn't waste the fresh fish so hardly touched the fries so the fish wouldn't go to waste. I had the 2 taco plate. Should have just had one taco. They came on a bed of potatoes and rice and cabbage. Both rice and potatoes were good. Wish I could have had more of the greens but I just couldn't eat it all. Overall great find. Delicious and super fresh. Food came out fast. Tough to find a table by yourself but that added to the fun of our day, to sit by people and make friends. Sat by a newlywed we had met at twin falls who had shared their walking stick and then met a local teacher. We just ordered too much food. Our first dinner on the island for a family of five for under $100.
(4)
Daura A.

Fresh as it gets! I am happy and very satisfied after I dine here! Healthy and fresh! And it's fish and sea food!!!!
(5)
Jeanie S.

Super casual, super busy, communal tables. Deliciously fresh fish. We had the fish tacos and the mahi-mahi burger. Very generous proportions. Everything on the plate was scrumptious. Highly recommended for a high quality, casual meal.
(4)
Mpunkt H.

Have known this place from 10 years ago when going there frequently and - as others say too - it still is the must stop in Paia. Had the Ono burger today with fries and loved it. It's simple setting and order at the counter suits the ambience and town of Paia perfectly. Never been disappointed.
(4)
David L.

Best fish and chips! Recommended by lady at the car rental counter. Place was packed at 3pm. We will be back! Reasonably priced and sell beer!
(5)
Jessi B.

Absolutely the best fresh fish restaurant with many options. They have my favorite fish everytime we eat there (at least once a week) which is Opah (hawaiian moon fish) light and flakey. There's family style seating so sometimes that's hard to find a seat but it's soo worth it. It's modestly priced. The food is always consistent. It's soo Ono!
(5)
Steven M.

Fresh fish, huge portions, rubbing elbows with the locals, reasonable prices -- what else could you want? We stayed across the street at the Pa'ia Inn for a week and ate here four times. The "Ono Burger" for 9 bucks is the best thing on the menu and a bargain. Sweet Maui onion rings were awesome. Ditto the $5 chowder -- a meal in itself. My advice is to share a salad and anything else, as the portions are massive.
(5)
Nomey T.

mmmmm... *drool* All I need are the Mahi burger and fries to boost my energy to get me to Hookipa to watch the surfers/windsurfers in action :) While quirk z. was disappointed, I LOVE their fries. Perfect in size and saltiness. The coleslaw and dill in the sandwiches are key. Can't wait for the next trip...
(5)
A W.

Yummy Fish Tacos! Be prepared for a drive from Kaanapali to Paia (~45min) but it was worth it, the fish was fresh and the portion sizes are huge.
(4)
Ian S.

Just can't be beat. I have been eating at this place since 2001, and it remains the best. I only get one thing: the Ahi fish burger with a side of fries. I add lots of Tiger Sauce to the burger. I put lots of malt vinegar on the fries and eat the fries with ketchup. By the end of the meal, everything has been mixed together, and it is just perfection! My wife/kids swear by the Mahi burgers, but I can't stay away from the Ahi! It is so good, I can never bring myself to try anything else! This is the first place i want to eat when i arrive in Maui, and the last place i want to eat.
(5)
A A.

Excellent, excellent, excellent. I love the informal style of this place. Just walk in, order your restaurant-quality meal, and have a seat while it's prepared. The fish was cooked perfectly and was absolutely HUGE - at least twice the size of any overpriced fish entree you order in a restaurant. One of the best places we ate at during our trip. Prices are very reasonable for the quality and amount of food you get.
(5)
Ibrahim A.

Best fish sandwich I have ever had. And I have had my share worldwide. Only wish there was more space to sit. The place in always packed and usually has a short wait. But worth it. The Obama burger is my favorite. Try it with half the Wasabi butter though!
(5)
CT L.

When you are a tourist on the road to Hana, this should be your "pit stop" for lunch. Although the restaurant's name contains the words "Fish Market", it is not a place to buy live fish. Pa'ia is an old country town with lotsa charm. This corner store has a casual, picnic table seating for hungry diners who are locals and tourists. However, if you are with a large group, it is EXTREMELY hard to find seating together during lunch time. Wolfing down the ONO BURGER and dipping the CALAMARI into the dill tartar sauce, I was eating like a SAVAGE. Washing it down with a cold bottle of beer also hit the spot! If you smell something salty next to you, do not be alarmed. It may be a Keanu-looking windsurfer, chomping on his meal. Pluses: + Fresh fish, like mahi mahi and red snapper, cooked in a variety of ways. My fave was cajun-style. + Generous portion with cole slaw sides. + Cheaper than Mama's down the street. Minuses: - A killer line during lunch hours. - Hard to park. - Long picnic tables to share with other groups. - Order and pay before you sit down. - Self-service - pick up your order at the counter and throw away your leftover at a bin. - Sounds ghetto - you gotta get a key to go the bathroom outside this place. Definitely a departure from resort dining. Tips: * Try the Obama Burger, fish and chips or fish tacos. Delish! * Skip the skinny fries and the pasta. * Go to ONO GELATO across the street for dessert.
(4)
Joanne C.

I waited to long to review this place, but as far as I can rememeber, we REALLY enjoyed the food! Fish was fresh, and the bench seating was different and enjoyable. This was the last place we went to eat before leaving Maui. It is just a few miles detour going towards OGG from Lahaina. You should definately try this place when in Paia!
(4)
Darika S.

Great maui fish sandwich. The fillet was grilled had coleslaw and was huge! Didn't need the fries that came with them. Hubby had the chicken tacos which came with potatoes and rice. A lot of food for the money. A lot of fantastic food for the money. I would chose this over Mama's fish restaurant for the flavor and price, not atmosphere.
(4)
David S.

Fun and inviting place, hard to get a table and almost no service ( you pick up your order at the window) but the food is excellent. I would have give 5 stars if the place had more seating.
(4)
Teresa K.

we stopped here for lunch after a tour was cancelled. we were by the airport so Paia was not far at all. both of us got the fish and chips, probably the best fried fish i've ever had. the people there were super friendly. not a lot of seating but the tables are long so you can ask someone to skootch over. proves my husband's theory that you find the best places on vacation by just stumbling onto them rather than making a res somewhere well known.
(4)
Patience K.

Crowded and full of locals- sooooooo good.
(5)
kenny h.

Food is good local style and large portions but dont feed the hippies
(3)
Kevin M.

Not to be missed! Not a fancy place at all, but a spot where you order at the counter and then find a table. Good brews, perfectly cooked fish on the "burger" and what my San Diego wife/bff said was the best fish taco she's ever had! Even the cole slaw rocked! Looked around and saw many happy eaters. I can't wait to go back!
(5)
Julie W.

Had the Mahi Fish & Chips and Shrimp & Chips for lunch. I would have given it 4 stars due to the LONG wait for our food--45minutes! But, it was worth the wait. The Shrimp batter was crispy and the Mahi was tender. Just be sure to go after the lunch crowd, otherwise you'll be waiting in a long line to order your food.
(5)
Karey R.

I can't believe I waited until the end of my trip to come here! What was I thinking? I had the cajun mahi burger. It was unbelievable! Any other place on the island is a waste, come here. My husband had the Ono burger, he was equally impressed. We parked at the first public lot (be careful with your valuables, we saw some broken glass in some spots). We walked down to Baldwin street and the fish market is on the corner. On the way back there is a cute little Hawaiian ice place across the street and down close to the parking lot, I suggest the mango =)
(5)
Joyce Y.

If/When I come back to Maui, this is probably one of the first place I'm going to go to and frequent! Mmmmm....Yummy fish tacos!! You can order one or two fish taco plates. I got one fish taco plate (I should've gotten two) for $10. The fish was nice and fresh and the taco was amazing! It comes with sides, but I don't remember what kind of sides. They also have lots of other dishes - fish burgers, fish and chips, fish tacos, etc. You line up and order at the counter and sit down. Then they call your number and you pick up your order. The place is crowded and seating is limited. It's a little pricey for one fish taco, but this place is a must to visit when in Maui!
(5)
J F.

Great food & atmosphere. Small portions.
(4)

Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.

Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.

Address : 100 Baldwin Ave,Ste A
Paia, HI, 96779
Phone (808) 579-8030
Website https://www.paiafishmarket.com/
Click To Get Directions

Opening Hours

Mon :11:00 am - 9:00pm

Specialities

Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : No
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Lunch
Parking : Street
Bike Parking : Yes
Wheelchair Accessible : Yes
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Loud
Alcohol : Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating : No
Wi-Fi : No
Has TV : No
Waiter Service : No
Caters : No

Claim Restaurant

WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES

Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online

Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.

Search Your Favourite Restaurants.

Paia Fish Market

100 Baldwin Ave,Ste A, Paia, HI, 96779

Paia Fish Market Menu

Burgers

Healthy Meal suggestions for

Burgers

Healthy Meal suggestions for CheckersRally

Burgers

Mimi N.

Corey S.

Sara F.

Keith K.

Alexandra A.

Monkiboi B.

Sally T.

Mike V.

Lulu L.

Billy V.

Kenn P.

Amar P.

Jean H.

David C.

LL A.

Michael K.

Ed U.

michelle m.

Mike L.

Steve N.

Nicholas S.

Cooking B.

Dave L.

Voice Of The People S.

Robin R.

Lan L.

Isaac H.

Alfred Y.

Chris L.

Jay T.

Beachy B.

Zhailah G.

Linda X.

Michele G.

Niclas C.

Julianna M.

TianChee S.

Janelle F.

Nory B.

Linda N.

Sasha R.

Kirsten C.

Adam T.

Josh G.

Angel W.

Laura I.

William H.

Jonathan B.

Leslie G.

Jade R.

Hue O.

Lynette D.

Kristin W.

Str8sixfan ..

Carol K.

Elfira d.

Emily R.

Francesca C.

Julie D.

Kirk S.

Loren B.

Ting L.

Keith L.

Sarah W.

David D.

Logie Z.

Laurel S.

Jessica S.

Tanya L.

Sheila B.

Julie M.