Teddy’s Bigger Burgers
335 Keawe St,Ste 221-222, Lahaina, HI, 96761
Teddy’s Bigger Burgers Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Lahaina for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Lahaina for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant cholesterol menu details.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
335 Keawe St,Ste 221-222
Lahaina, HI, 96761 - Phone (808) 661-9111
- Website https://www.teddysbiggerburgers.com/
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
- Mon :10:00 am - 9:00pm
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : No
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Accepts Bitcoin : No
Good For : Lunch
Parking : Private Lot
Bike Parking : Yes
Wheelchair Accessible : Yes
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Average
Outdoor Seating : Yes
Wi-Fi : Free
Has TV : No
Waiter Service : No
Drive-Thru : No
Caters : Yes
Categories
Burgers
Burger or Hamburger is savored as the most desired fast food meal in the United States. A hamburger is basically a sandwich prepared by stuffing ground meat patty, generally beef, between two slices of a bun cut in half. Hamburger is also famous for its seasoning. Most popular condiments used in hamburgers in the United States are mustard, mayonnaise, and ketchup. Besides ground meat patty, hamburgers are also stuffed with lettuce, onions, tomato slices, pickles, and cheese.
Hamburgers are also categorized into two types in the United States. Fast food hamburger and individual hamburgers served at restaurants are two basic types of burgers served in the United States. The individual hamburgers served at restaurants are prepared using everything including lettuce, onion, tomato, and sliced pickles as well as melted cheese on the patty or crumbled on top. American restaurants also serve veggie burgers for those who don't relish meat. Cheeseburgers are also hot favorite in the United States.
McDonalds is the most popular fast food burger restaurant serving different types of burgers in the United States. On the other hand, there are several restaurants such as Burger King are famous for serving the best hamburgers in the United States. Most burger restaurants in the United States often serve hamburgers with French fries and other condiments. If you have a liking for burgers in the United States, then you won't be disappointed. You can easily find the best burger restaurants in your city on our Restaurants Listings directory. Check the reviews and ratings of the top burger restaurants and savor yourself with the best hamburger in the city.
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
Ann S.
The lady who took our order was super friendly and their shakes were great while we waited for our order. We both got the teriyaki burger and I think we should've each gotten something different for our first time here. We weren't bowled over by that particular combo (I thought it came with pineapple but it didn't, I'd make sure to add it next time) but the burger on its own was really good. Fries were also good so as long as they're still around the next time we're back on the island, we'll be coming back!
(4)Rex M.
We've been here on Maui a month and were needing a burger fix. One of the guys that works at the place we're staying recommended Teddy's. It was on my "try" list but had forgotten about it. So we went around 1pm. Burgers hit the spot, french fries were fresh fried, onion rings were OK, doubt if I'll get them again. Total bill was 25$, a little high, but not too bad. Kinda reminds me of Five Guys in a good way they have more choices which is good.
(4)Carla L.
Good and very fresh! The buns disintegrate though. Also I had heard the milkshakes were great but they were out of chocolate and strawberry which is pretty odd
(4)J F.
First time ever to Teddy's Burgers. Incredible! We all loved it....best burger joint we have been to near Kaanapali.
(5)Lukas T.
This place is awesome. So awesome, in fact, that I am sitting in Teddy's again right now, the day after our first visit. My wife says she ate the best burger she's ever had and the topping choices are astounding. A must-try for burger lovers!
(5)Doc C.
Wonderful! Great service! Yummy!
(4)Dan S.
I heard that this was the place for great burgers and shakes. I have to agree. Also tried the onion rings and was pleasantly surprised. I will visit Teddy's every trip to Maui.
(5)Amanda A.
The best burger on Maui for sure! We go to Teddy's Bigger Burger at least once a month and love it every time! Yummmm :)
(5)Clarice K.
Went to Teddy's today, try to come here whenever I go to Lahaina. I love the food and the staff is very friendly. We had Hank today ( I think that was his name) he was super nice and told us all the specials. I had the pastrami sandwich which was really good and my friend had the loco moco burger an she said it was great. When you come here, come hungry! The portions are huge!
(5)Courtney S.
Burgers were delicious! Better than 5 guys or in and out. I'm from San Diego and I love in and out. Get the specialty burgers, you won't be disappointed. Service was good. As cheap as anything you are going to eat in Maui.
(5)Patricia R.
Great taste. Burgers are large. Good atmosphere
(5)Catherine M.
If you are craving a reasonably priced burger - go to this place! The food was really yummy (we had hawaiian style burgers). And the pineapple milkshake was to dye for!! I could have had so many more of those. I think this was our cheapest meal out while in Maui, and it was delicious
(5)Lisa D.
awesome burgers and great onion rings....our new fav burger joint :-)
(5)Paula G.
Found the Yelp deal and decided to give this place a try... feeding a family of 5 while on a Hawaiin vacation is tough, so we'll take the deal! Being tucked away in a shopping center, we wouldn't have stumbled upon it otherwise. Food: overall, a good burger and fries. Kids had the chicken nugget meals which they devoured. Coming from the Washington DC area, I don't think it stacks up to a Five Guys burger, but still good. Cost is certainly higher (but you're in Hawaii....), each meal was about $10 once you added on cheese. We had also stopped at Bubba's on Kauai and this place was defintely better. Service: For food alone, I would have gone with a three star, but the service of this place pushed it to a 4. Wow, I wasn't expecting this! Upon walking in, the cashier person proactively said hello and explained the menu to us. Our table was also promptly cleared and we were provided wet-naps to clean up. Place: cool hangout place... extremely clean.... A+ there! Not a bad place to stop..... and don't forget your Yelp deal!!!
(4)Bob K.
Had the University Burger & the Western Burger in two separate trips. The garlic fries are tasty!
(5)John P.
Great thick burgers, much better than the typical fast food burgers. Excellent environment and friendly staff. Priced for families.
(5)Hulda W.
Fries need to be crisper and fresher but the hamburgers rock. Friendly and helpful staff, clean and crisp environment and fun music. I like to order chili cheese style - it reminds me of Tommy's in LA. Shakes are really thick so you need a spoon or let it melt for a while before you use a straw.
(4)Mary M.
Just ate at Teddy's and I had the most wonderful turkey burger. I will definitely will go back
(4)Ssixty F.
good job teddy and rich. I loved my bigger burger with pastram and the wife said f@,&;n awesome with the bacado. very good service and clean. I highly reccomend! and the yelp coupon kicks butt thanks!
(5)Hulda S.
One of my fav new spots! All the kids working there are super curtious. The joint is amazingly clean! The food is really good and priced just right.
(5)Susie M.
Went here because of yelp's $12 for $20 deal for the first time; I was rather impressed with the quality and quantity of the food. I got a Maui burger (I think), and it was incredibly large. All ingredients were very fresh, the greens were actually green and crispy, not limpy as they sometimes are. The one complaint I had about their burgers is that their "secret sauce", which is good and similar but not thousand island exactly, is slightly overwhelming on the burger. If I was to go back, i'd probably order it with light sauce. Regardless, the 7oz was ginormous...I would suggest the 5oz is honestly enough food. Their fries were crispy and although there was somewhat of a wait on the food, it was clearly worth the wait. The decor wasn't anything special, very neon-colored, bright, reminds me of the California chain In-n-Out.
(4)Jeremy W.
I love yelp for helping me find spots like this! Awesome burgers and the shake was primo. I got an avocado, pepper jack, grilled mushroom, Ortega chile burger with a coconut shake and fries. Its worth it if it takes a day off my life!
(4)Ty S.
My friend introduced me to Teddy's a few months ago. As a rather frequent customer now, I can tell you that in my book, Teddy's has the best burgers on the entire island. Big, tasty, and the price is right. I have had the regular cheeseburger, the cajun burger, and the King of the Dojo... that one was pretty special. I usually get the monster double, which is two 5oz patties. (It may not sound like a lot, considering they offer double 9oz patties, but it leaves me feeling full with some left over) The burgers come out so hot and fresh here that I actually have to wait until it cools down a little bit before I can eat it. The buns are great, and in fact all of the ingredients all seem to be very fresh... no soggy lettuce, etc. The staff is great. Last time I was in around closing, they turned the fountain back on for me so that I could refill my soda before I left. The spirit of aloha is alive and well here. Eat at Teddy's... you will not regret it.
(5)Wendi R.
Searching for that all-elusive buger led us to Teddy's. Extremely friendly staff encouraged us to the counter. Had Teddie's burger (5oz) combo. Great burger! All the fixin's were fresh, local and plenty of them. Special sauce was mayo/mustardy drippy goodness. Fries were piping hot. Pros: Great burger. Meat excellent. Toppings fresh, local, yummy! Clean restaraunt, friendly and helpful staff. Cons: Slightly doughy bun, ended up only eating half. Chincy on the fries, would have loved a bigger portion. Overall: Great place for burger!
(4)Nathary R.
I live on Oahu and I have had Teddy's many times before, had Teddy's on my trip and it was amazing as always. The original burger is the way to go, if you get fries it's worth getting Cajun on them, making them spicy for .50 more. The avocado and bacon burger is amazing as well. Get your burger any way you like it, I guarantee it will be one of the best burgers you've had. Average meal combos are $10
(5)Paul L.
Friendly staff. burgers were nice and juicy. My daughter who is super picky loved the chicken nuggets. same meal on front street would have cost us 80. 5 of us came out to 45, 2 shakes included.
(5)jeff h.
I visited with my family. They are super nice people, best service I can say so far in Maui. We had wish sandwiches and they were very good. I have a difficult time finding so good food in mainland. I would strongly recommend .
(5)Marina M.
Great burgers. Very fresh. Good taste. Onion rings and fries were the best. Nice place.
(5)Chris P.
Pineapple and coconut milk shake is shake of the month and it is awesome. Sad to say, it is the best milk shake that I have ever had so far.
(5)Nolly Y.
pastrami sandwich with avocado was really good, juicy thin slices, on a moist bun. Aiea burger another winner. Blue cheese added to a juicy burger made it all the better!
(5)Garrett H.
Best burgers on Maui!
(5)Zac G.
Great western burger
(5)Lewis C.
It's usually hard to justify giving a burger joint 4 stars - but the great selection on the menu, along with tater tots offered (along with the usual fries and onion rings) and the sleeper selection - chili - tipped them over to a 4-star rating. First a suggestion - the smallest size burger is a very healthy size, so no need to upscale unless you are super hungry or if you are an 18-year old male - of which I had TWO in my party (Ryan and Joey). Every burger was delicious - the mushroom swiss was a big hit. The chili burger was so chock full of chili, we glommed some of it to make chili fries and chili tots. Shakes were made the right way on real shake spindles, not with a blender. All ingredients tasted fresh and the guy brought all our food to our table with a super friendly attitude. This place was REALLY GOOD. We'll be back for sure.
(4)Kenny L.
So yelpers are legit. The burgers here were amazing and literally caused me to finally create a login for yelp! My wife who is very hard to please already mentioned how she wanted to come here again before we take off. Expensive for burgers, but I felt I was getting for what I paid for. Thanks yelp! Other Maui reviews to come.
(5)Shelly H.
Great burger and sandwich shop in Lahaina. Will definitely be back on our next trip!
(4)Florenda G.
Just came by on a whim and found this place. The food was delicious and the portions were big. Definitely a place to bring the whole family. Very fun atmosphere and the staff was polite and very helpful.
(4)Tuan G.
Good place to eat that's reasonably priced and a step over other fast food joints. Burger was not overcooked like other burger joints and fries are crispy and not greasy. I would given this place 4 starts but they were gonna charge me extra for sauce that should have come with the burger. That kinda irked me.
(3)AlohaKeAku A.
Started out loving this place but we just can't do it any longer. We just can't handle the inconsistancy. Out of all the times we have eaten here and all the money we have spent in this restaurant, we deserve better. The burger is made either wrong, raw or too dry. The only consistancy is that it's going down hill fast. Any special requests screw up the kids that work here and they can't get it right. The owner tries to find other help but needs to invest his time into finding employees that can get an order right, a cook that knows how to make a burger and salads that can be eaten and not thrown in the trash for lack of taste. Putting more items on the menu only makes for more mistakes. There is too much to choose from and they can't get even the simple burger right. The salads are horrible. The ceasar salad consists of romaine lettuce in a plastic container, 1 oz of chicken (dry) and a package of ceasar dressing from Kens dressing. Are you kidding me? We are so disappointed. What a shame. We're done.
(1)Ed W.
Great place for a burger on this side of the island, especially with the Yelp deal! You really need to know how to order too, if you just order one of the their built burgers, you will be paying for all of the extras.
(5)A D.
Great hamburgers! The bun was fresh and delicious and the meat was tasty as well. I like that you can choose the size of your burger. My husband had a malt -- and you could actually taste the malt. Many places will give you a "malt" but the flavor is so subtle it's more like a milkshake. This place should give Cool Cat Cafe a run for their money -- they already have one advantage -- not having to deal with the challenge of Front Street Parking. It can get expensive though -- I ordered a specialty hamburger to go -- it was the small size but over $11.
(4)Janice Araki L.
Bacado burger is great. Wish they would steam the bun or had a better bun. Fries nice and crispy and hot. They have fat fries. Definitely coming back to try the different burger options.
(4)Ciaran C.
I tried Teddy's Bigger Burgers because there was a $20 for $12 coupon on Yelp. Glad I did - the 9oz bacado (baconn+avocado) burger was delicious. Would defo repeat.
(5)April G.
Food was great! Yelp deal was awesome....always appreciate saving some $$!
(4)Dan J.
Delicious burgers, fries and shakes. We were In Maui for a couple of weeks, and ate here several times. Easily the best burger I have had in Maui. It's a very casual place in a strip mall, great dor kids.
(5)Ben Y.
This place has the best burgers by far. That's saying a lot being from Chicago. The 5oz. terry is the best. Just the right amount of meat to bun ratio. Each bite is a juicy delight.
(5)Bean M.
STAY AWAY. Teddy's charges expensive sit-down restaurant prices for an average burger inside of a fast food joint located in a strip mall. You're better off down the street at any of the restaurants on the Lahaina boardwalk, which have better tasting burgers at comparable prices, bars, and the epic paradise scenery that is Maui's beaches. I can't understand why this place has ambitions to expand; they need to fix the numerous issues it has first. The price is too expensive, when I stacked two options onto my teri burger, I was already up to 13 bucks. For 13 bucks, there better be hot girls in hula skirts with a warm ocean breeze tickling my face (that's Cheeseburger in Paradise on the boardwalk, for those of you wondering). The decor is amazingly sparse and boring, I thought I was at hot dog on a stick. Every other sit-down restaurant on the planet has neat objects and posters to look at while you're waiting - here you get yellow, blue, and red tiles, with copious amounts of...wall to look at. My order was screwed up in two ways, I asked for no bun and got a bun, then I ordered grilled onions and did not get the grilled onions. The employees and chefs were nice enough to remedy that. The burger tasted fresh and was decent, but NOT oh-my-god-that-really-hits-the-right-button tasting. Carl's Juniors, Red Robbins, and In-And-Out generally have awesome burgers that push those buttons, and Teddy's has a long way to go on many fronts to match those big name players, along with the other smaller players on Maui like Cool Cat Cafe or Cheeseburger in Paradise. Pros: Friendly staff Clean No need to tip Not that crowded Lots of Parking (this location) Cons: Expensive Average tasting burger (less if you factor in price) Two order mistakes Cheap moist toilette (tore way too easily) Boring decor No napkin dispenser on half the tables (including mine, had to steal from another table) No bar No live music events No beach, no boardwalk No girls in hula skirts (seriously, it's supposed to be a 50s joint, make the women wear poodle skirts and the guys clean pressed cotton shirts and jeans....this place isn't even trying).
(1)Kafa G.
1st Time there... I loved it!! It was soo good!! But, kinda of expensive... but, it was worth it...bcuz, it was just good! You can pick the size of the oz. Patty... from, 5oz * 7oz * 9oz... then you Pick if you wanted.. a Combo $10.32....comes with a drink and French fries.... onion ring!... was the bomb!! You guys got to try it..
(5)Scott S.
The strawberry shake is awesome! Great burger joint especially for Maui. They have a really extensive list of specialty burgers. Even a crossfit burger (Paleo-ish I belive) for my wife.
(4)Ron S.
Tastes great! The burgers come in 5, 7 , and 9 oz patties depending on how hungry you are. We went during the lunch hour so they were getting a little slammed. He took them almost 20 minutes before we got our food but it was worth the wait!
(5)Rob P.
Wow, best burger I've eaten in what is the land of burgers.. Tastes awesome, great choices
(5)Glenn P.
Good burgers great service cool atmosphere. If your craving a burger on the Westside this is the place. But not the best burgers on the island in my opinion. That would be at Peggy Sues in Kihei.. Will be back here
(3)Paul T.
I had business on the West Side of Maui the other day and decided to give Teddy' Bigger Burgers a shot. My opinion is that if you dare open anything on this Island, you had better blow the competition out of the water. Teddy's came up short. I was expecting a big juicy burger. Mine was rather on the dry side. Fries were okay, but the stupid little cups I had to fill up with ketchup sucked! Put a Ketchup and Mustard bottle on each table. Outback, Ruby's, and Carl's Jr have much better burgers and plenty of condiments on the table. The one thing that sticks out from my experience is I noticed the owner/manager? (wearing black shirt) was sweating profusely, and every time he went into the open kitchen he would grab fries and eat them. I watched this several times, and frankly I was getting a little noxious. I get it now! Teddy's Bigger Burgers, not Teddy's BETTER Burgers. At least they are not lying. I don't think they will get a second shot from this local. I received an e-mail from the owner, and he related they took care of the EMPLOYEE who was grazing and sweaty. Kudo's to an owner who is proactive and who is sincere about caring for his customers. I will give Teddy's Bigger Burgers another shot, and another review sometime in the near future. Review update: It's been a while since I gave Teddy's a second shot. My daughter loves the Teddy's on Oahu, and she was on Island and wanted Teddy's. I must admit I had a great tasty burger, that I would eat again. Service was very friendly, and I left satisfied. I will be back, sooner this time.
(4)Jenn J.
5 for clean and service, but can't do overall beyond a 3 because the burgers were just that burgers - meat no flavor, we even had the Western burgers which had very little bbq sauce on them. It's just another burger joint, if on Holiday it's not worth wasting a meal on this place I'm sure you have one just like it at home. Sorry I really wanted to like this place, but it just wasn't what we expected.
(3)Julie L.
I love Teddy's Bigger Burgers. I had the plain grilled chicken breast sandwich and it was fantastic. The fries were seasoned just right. The staff was very welcoming and friendly. I would definitely go back!
(5)Kyle K.
We drove from Kihei to Lahaina to eat a awesome burger. This was my second time here and introduced Teddy's to a friend of mine and is now hooked! Not only was the food was top quality, but the service from the staff was excellent! Our cashier Joe recommended some new items on the menu and was great at checking up on us to see how everything was. We will coming back very soon and bringing in more friends to introduce them to this fine establishment you have in Lahaina!
(5)Anthony S.
Well we have been coming to Maui for over 25years and were ready for our Cheeseburger in Paradise. Went on yelp to read reviews and saw Teddy's, read reviews, so gave it a try. The burger was no better than Cheeseburger in Paradise and the onion rings get a B-. They tout old style burger joint but it was more like McDonald's decor. Everything was extra: cheese, malt powder in shake, grilled onions. And no beer! If you're looking for a Cheeseburger in Paradise go there as the burgers are not much different (neither have any seasoning) but the view and ambience is stellar!
(3)Kara N.
Yummy burgers!! Their fries are also tasty and you definitely have to try their shakes. It would have been 5 stars but the service was a tad slow, but the great food took my mind off it in the end.
(4)Jenny M.
Great burgers, sandwiches and MILKSHAKES!!! Just what Maui has been needing. Nice music too.
(4)Rhonda L.
Burgers were Delicious!! Good customer service...Very satisfied with our Yelp deal =)
(5)Susie S.
The woodenville burger was awesome! Can't wait to go back!
(5)Mark A.
My family and I visited during our vacation here in Maui. Away from the tourist places on Front Street and the Kaanapali beach front Teddy's really delivers on a Better burger and awesome shakes! This was the best burger place on Maui!
(5)Lindsay S.
Best burger I have ever had, what more is there to say?
(5)E B.
We're local and live just down the street but passed by Teddy's for several months before finally stopping in. I don't eat red meat but as soon as I saw the Teri Chicken I was sold. I LOVE Teri Chicken & could eat it every day. I've found that Koho's, Aloha Mixed Plate and Cool Cats to have some of the best Teri on the island - sweet Hawaiian Teri, not the sour Japanese Teri that the higher end resturants serve. I can now add Teddy's to my list of favs! Add a shake and some fries or tots and its a great meal. My husband loves burgers, fries and a malt or rootbeer float. He knows his meat and love Teddy's burgers - big, juicy and all the fixings. If it drips, then you know its good. It is a little pricey for a burger joint but its Lahaina plus you get what you pay for, IMHO. If you are a local you get an automatic Kam discount which is cool. They have a cool fast food meets vintage Hawaiian meets carhop, 50's diner feel to it. The last two times we have come in for dinner the place was hopping with locals and tourists alike. They have great customer service (the lady with the blonde hair is very chipper and nice), quick to make the food and are cool with all the little additions like when I'm specific that I only want bun, chicken, teri, cheese & bacon plus teri on the side. They serve Roselani Ice Cream for their shakes/malts & Roselani is the best there is. My husband likes their rootbeer floats and they fill the cup with a ton of ice cream that takes awhile to melt. He sometimes goes to refill the rootbeer 5 or 6 times during a meal and they never say a word about all the soda :) A great new spot for when we want some filling and tasty food, don't want to go far and don't have to get dressed nice.
(5)Jim E.
pretty good fish sandwhich - pretty expensive too - nothing over the top special but good - diner style
(2)Max E.
I had the absolutely amazing pastrami swiss burger, fries and a coconut + pineapple shake. My first time eating pastrami on a burger and it was just out-of-this-world delicious. Also, the service was unexpectedly good -- fast, attentive and friendly. Don't miss this place!
(5)C K.
Terrific burgers and awesome service! Luigi was exceptionally helpful and so was the other guy at the counter. Chocolate malt milkshake was nice and thick! Keep it up.
(4)Amy V.
Great Atmosphere, friendly staff and I love that they cook to order. Everything was hot and delicious. We had a child's chicken nugget meal (chicken tasted fresh and not processed) and two cheeseburgers with fries. The buns were soft and warm and it was well dressed. Only complaint, the hamburger was a little well done.. will ask for medium next trip :) The chocolate milkshake was AMAZING!
(4)Leo G.
The owner should go to California and try In-N-Out. The burgers here are big but they are also big on terrible flavor. The customer service was good but that alone does not merit an extra star. I have yet to find any meal that taste somewhat descent in Maui with the exception of McDonalds!
(1)Sue H.
We stumbled across this awesome burger joint, and so glad we did! My husband ordered the 7 oz blue cheese burger and he loved it. I kept to the original 5 oz and it was plenty big! The meat was flavorful and juicy, lettuce and tomato fresh and crisp. Nice and messy, just the way a burger should be....hence the hand wipes they provide to you. The price was right as well. The fries were delicious and cooked to the perfect crispness without over doing it. I would definitely try this place again. If only they had a location in OC!
(5)Austin D.
We've been coming to Maui for 25 years and this is the best burger we've had on the island! Cheeseburger in Paradise doesn't hold a candle. Great service as well!
(5)LeeAnn M.
Tater tots are great! I thought the BBQ sauce in my Western was a tad sweet. But it was still good. Also liked the garlic fries.
(4)Francelle L.
Came to eat here on a family vacation. It was about 8:30pm and all 7 of us trucked on in to all order a classic combo meal all of which has speical things on the burgers. We sat down and was told our milk shakes will be ready on the first "page" and then our food would be ready on the second "page". The first "page went off and it was actually our food. When we go this all of our burgers were just regular ones. Most of us all had bacon on the burgers. There was no Bacon and everything was wrong. So they kindly took our food back and corrected this. Once we got our corrected orders I bite into my burger to find it was still raw!!!! Not like a cook to order rear, but RAW all the way through. It wasnt just me who had a raw burger, almost half of them were. Some people in our group were bring nice and just ate what they could. We gave them back our orders, half eaten and got our money back. I will never eat there again.
(1)Justine S.
Love the cheese fries and onion rings! Friendly staff and comfortable place. Lahaina is lucky to get a Teddys!
(5)Willie G.
Simply put it good food good service worth your time and hard earned money.
(5)T W.
First timer. Good burger well made and juicy. Good fries. Staff could have been a little more friendly at the counter. Quick service, clean facility. I'll go back and try another flavor burger.
(4)Ken B.
Nothing like a good burger to get you rolling and this place has them. Staff was courteous, place was clean, and the burgers great. Good selection of burgers, my wife had the western and I had bacon blu. Wish I had read the reviews before going in, I would have tried a shake.
(5)holly v.
My husband and I were visiting Maui last week and my cousin & her husband, who live there, wanted to go to Teddy's for their vegetarian burger. We had regular burgers, my cousin, the veg burger, and her husb. the fish burger. We all were very pleased with what we ordered. The service was friendly and efficient, the burgers were juicy and big, and the fries were great. It is a bit more expensive than the fast-food burger places and the food took a little longer, but hey, they are not the usual fast-food joints. And everything on Maui is more expensive than even Honolulu, or the SF Bay Area where we live. The burgers were a nice change from the upscale, touristy places in Lahaina, even the more expensive burger place on Front St where we had eaten the previous night. (No, we don't regularly eat burgers, not even fast-food burgers.) We would definitely try Teddy's again, whether in Maui or elsewhere.
(4)Stuart C.
Burger combo for the large 9 oz. burger comes with a huge mound of crispy, well-seasoned fries. Stop me before I finish them all and go into a starch coma!
(5)Jamie Z.
First time in and wasn't sure what to get. Mark, the cashier at the counter, took the time and went way out of his way to insure we were happy with our meal. Cooks did a good job with order accuracy and timeliness. Normally not into fast food places much, but the price, friendliness, and quality I will go back. Kama'aina available as well as the ongoing ad in Maui Time
(4)Louise P.
We bought the Yelp Deal and loved these burgers!! Service was very good and the woman at the counter let me try lots of samples of sauces and fries. The burgers were SO juicy and all the toppings were delicious. They have tons of options for sauces, veggie toppings, eggs, etc. We'd go here all the time if we were locals!
(5)Good U.
Lots of options and add-ons to burgers. Juicy, tender burgers. Light casual atmosphere and service. You're going for the food. Go hungry.
(4)Marti W.
I don't know what the heck they put in their food but this is hands down the best burger/fries place that I know of. Maybe because it the food comes out immediately so it's really hot? I've only always gotten orders "to go" so I don't really know it as a sit down place. I like the spicy fries and the garlic fries. Also, I appreciate the little electronic devices that let you know your order is up. That way our minds are free to wander and not be continually focused on whether someone has called our number. I've tried the fancy stuff but in all honesty, a 5 oz regular (no cheese but yes on that sauce) with the lettuce/onion/tomato stuff is my favorite. That and the hot fries? Dang.
(5)Aniket D.
Yay! for the vegetarian options and the sauces. We liked the burgers and the grilled pineapple is great! Wao sauce and Fire sauce are the ones we loved.
(4)Clarice C.
One of the only places on Kaanapali to eat if you want a late meal that's not fast food and not waiter service. I'm in Hawaii..so I passed on the bun and the actual burger itself was really good. I added all the toppings that go on their western burger and it was super tasty. Also got tater tots (very good) and garlic fries. It's not ball park kind of garlic fries :( they just put garlic salt and garlic powder on normal fries so if you are expecting fresh garlic, you'll wanna pass. I'm sure the milkshakes are good too but my meal was probably already pushing 800+ calories so i had to pass. Would come back here next time i'm looking for a quick meal! Prices are reasonable for Hawaii standards!
(4)Sally M.
I'm always on the quest for the perfect burger, no matter what city I visit and after hearing for years that Maui has great burgers, I had to find out what the hype was all about. I read in a travel guide that Cool Cat Cafe had a good one, but when I walked by they had such an obnoxious cruise ship crowd, a long wait, and the most horrible singer belting out Cat Stevens at record-breaking volume that I never made it to the door. Searched online and found out about Teddy's and decided it was a good fit. My boyfriend and I both ordered the Lahaina burger which had pineapple, bacon, lettuce, tomato, jalapenos, and cheese served with their Super Sauce. I asked for it on the side since I hate drowned burgers. I put some on my burger but I ended up using it Belgian style by dipping my fries into it as it was a mayonnaise-based aioli. SO DELICIOUS. The burger was so fresh, the meat was excellent and the bun was perfect. They have 3 sizes. 5 oz., 7 oz., and 9 oz. I opted for the 7 oz. and it was just the perfect size for me. I have to mention that the service is top notch. I overheard some very unpleasant, curmudgeonly, elderly women sitting behind me endlessly complaining about their order and the owner offered them two free shakes to make up for any mistake. That's a class act. I really like small family businesses and this place was really nice all around. Prices were very fair and there is no need to worry about tipping and waiting to be seated. Nothing snooty, just great burgers. I will definitely eat here the next time I am in Lahaina.
(5)Christine S.
Tried this place and was pleased at what we found. Delicious burgers with great topping choices. The fries are to die for. I got the spicy fries-yummy. My son got the plantation fries and they were so good. My son's fries had so much pork on them and the sauce they were covered in was spicy and delicious. We also tried the garlic fries which were good too. I would recommend this place if you like five guys or in n out. Good comparison to both places.
(5)Brian S.
This is a really good burger. They'll cook it a true medium (slightly pink), which makes for a juicy burger. I would rate it 4.5 but you have to rate it to one significant figure (haha)! It's a good price and friendly staff. Price is reasonable for Maui.
(5)Todd P.
Delicious food and excellent service. Got the Lahaina burger and garlic fries. It's a pig out kind of place. Our burger had jalapeños, bacon, and pineapple. The garlic fries had tons of garlic and butter. They have malt vinegar if that's your type of thing.
(5)Veronica G.
Bacado burger and cheese fries... Feelin' fat and amazing. Super delicious!!!
(4)Pepper I.
Best value for a hamburger in Lahaina, I think. Walk-in and sit down style. The milk shakes are great. The food is outstanding, and the help is patient. We eat there every year, at least once, just to keep our Hawaii budget in line, and for a quick meal. Save a ton of money versus the Front Street Burger places and really enjoy the experieince.
(4)Dan N.
I love it. A sloppy juicy pastrami burger with Swiss. Good music and friendly service makes a great place to visit. I didn't get the special of the month but it had a hash brown patty on the burger aka spud burger. Might have to come back and try that one!
(5)J W.
Okay, I give in. Every single thing in Hawaii is expensive. BUT, there are some things that are pretty darn close to worth it. If a burger is what you're craving while in Maui, I'd recommend Teddy's. we tried several variations and all were tasty as burgers go. Fries, onion rings, shakes, none were bad. Still expensive, but on the mainland we have Fuddruckers, which is my all time favorite. Teddy's was a close second even considering the dollars and place. Family type atmosphere and parking is easy considering its in Lahaina. The shopping center has several stores worth a stroll to walk off the calories.
(4)Ryan D.
This is the best burger in Maui, possibly anywhere. I'm from CA so I'm accustomed to some good burgers (In-N-Out, 5Guys, TK Burger, The Counter) and this is probably the best I've had. It's freshness was above anything I've ever tried for a burger. I had to come in here while on my last vacation per the recommendation of a coworker (who's friends w/ the owner). Very friendly people work here and own the place. I had a regular cheeseburger (5oz) w/ cheese, bacon, and avocado for extras. OMG it was so fresh and delicious. I couldn't even finish the whole thing. My wife had the King of the Dojo - spicy cajun chicken, bbq sauce, a hashbrown patty, cheese, etc. It was pretty good, but not my style. I definitely recommend this as a stop during your next trip.
(5)Butch E.
Great cheeseburgers here! Great prices and really good service. Support these guys they try hard and care about your experience. Great price, quality and service. Can't beat it!
(4)Terri W.
The burgers were great, fun atmosphere and reasonably priced. You won't be disappointed by Teddy's.
(5)Naisa L.
So glad that we went here!! Food was delicious! Cajun burger with tots & a banana mac crunch milkshake!! The banana milkshake is limited so try it before its gone!! Definitely would recommend this to those going to Maui!
(5)R M.
The best burger I've ever had. Great theme. Nice service. Ableit, at Hawaii prices. This chain needs to invade the mainland.
(5)Joshua J.
This place has been our go-to-grub-spot in Maui due to consistency and professionalism of cooking and customer service. Me and my wife have frequented this place 2 days In a row and I love everything about them. Buns are soft, which is my pet peeve for any sandwich, and they cook it exactly how u order it. I definitely recommend this place for any meal.
(5)Joanne M.
Their burgers are AMAZING! I got the Lahaina burger with grilled pineapple, of course. It was so good, and I got to choose the size patty I wanted, which is a plus. They also have a "crossfit burger" for more conscious individuals. I got their "shake of the week" which was Rocky Road at the time and it was AWESOME. The guys are nice there and it's not a fast food place, so burgers will take longer than a drive-thru people! They are cooked when ordered, so just be patient, it is worth the extra 2 minutes! I would say this is at the top of my list next to Shake Shack and In & Out. But, I think I love Teddy's so much its #1 now because they have a more variety and BETTER toppings, hence the pineapple.
(5)Reid R.
Service is fast and friendly but that doesn't make up for the food. Their huge menu falls victim to the quantity quality balance. The sauces are cheap and bland, my girlfriends burger came with grainy hard avocado on a crumbly bun. neither of us were able to eat more than 2 bites before our burgers were in piles that we finished like burger salads. we've also ordered food to go and no more than 10 minutes later the bottom bun was like mashed potato.
(2)Sung K.
Reference point for east coasters. I personally liked it better than five guys, BGR, and elevation burgers. If you're craving a cheeseburger for not a whole lot of money you must eat here. Not to mention it will taste better than any burger you will pay a lot more for somewhere else.
(5)Carolyn H.
The Burgers were really good. It is the only reason why they are getting as many stars from me as they are. Stick with a single patty.. The double patty is too much food. Crime: Their cheese fries are made with cheese sauce and not quality cheddar cheese like you might expect. I ordered these thinking that a place with good reviews and focused on quality like this place knew what they were doing and I didn't even think they might do something as horrific as this. They should hang their head in shame for this, however, you the discerning customer can still enjoy their burgers, but stay away from the Cheese fries... they are hideous. Crime #2: You are in Hawaii, right? You are thinking I should get the Pineapple shake, because this is Hawaii, again, they know what they are doing with Pineapple, right? To summarize, their pineapple shake tasted queer. It tasted like they made it with vanilla bean ice cream and added a small amount of pineapple flavoring. The vanilla bean flavor dominated your taste buds and the pineapple flavor really didn't come through, but made the vanilla bean flavor taste weird. My family all passed it around trying to pass it off to each other trying to get rid of it. +$5 for a shake that nobody liked? More shame.... They need to get their act together and taste their own shakes... because I don't think they do. Teddy and whatever his partner is should come down off their pedestal and eat their own food, because I don't think they are. In some areas, they are just raking you the customer for large dollar amounts and not delivering on quality.
(2)Sergio A.
Food is DELICIOUS! Service is fast. A special kudos to the milkshake lady. The banana nut macadamia milkshake is worth the money. I had the 7 oz. burger, Lahaina style, with garlic fries. My wife had the 5 oz. burger, Bacado style, with spicy fries. Both burgers exceeded expectations. The place reminds me a little of Five Guys, except I would rather come here any day, hands down. The price is a little high, but you'll definitely pay less than you would at another burger joint, and get a much better burger; take advantage of their Yelp deal. It's located across the street from the Lahaina Cannery Mall. This is a must try while in Maui.
(5)Mark T.
Excellent hamburgers here! I had a green chile cheeseburger with pepper jack cheese and the flavor was top shelf. The bun is excellent as well. They grind their chuck roast and hand make the patties. The only thing they could have done better is cook it properly. I ordered medium and it was almost well done. It would have been little juicier if they had cooked it right. The fries are ok, but were a little chewy. Go here for the burgers. They are worth it.
(4)Jennifer F.
This is a solid 50s motif burger joint. Good for an open, relatively inexpensive place to take the kids and have a decent burger and fries. I had the veggie burger and loved it. The steak fries were good and they made a grilled cheese (off menu) for my picky eater son. Quick, friendly service.
(4)Bob G.
Awesome burgers, great seasoning and fresh ingredients. Try the Lahaina with pineapple and jalapeños. Fantastic flavors.
(5)Kelsey F.
I really liked this place! They have great burgers, yummy fries, and great sauces! Can't go wrong:)
(5)Marc R.
Customer service was awesome. Everyone was very friendly. I will definitely go back. Food was great too.
(5)Karen H.
Just wanted a quick cheap meal. The burger was nothing special, but I did like their tator tots. The milkshakes were ok too.
(3)Julie K.
You know, the food was fine. Just not fine enough to warrant the price. Even when using a Yelp deal to reduce the cost, it was still over $20 for two burgers, fries and shakes. The inside wasn't any better than a McDonalds. Yes, I would eat here again if I had a coupon or deal and I was shopping nearby, but I wouldn't go out of my way to do it. Most tourists who come to Maui are looking for some ambience, and this doesn't have any.
(3)Lorrie K.
Fantastic burgers, and so many ways to order them. I give them a 3 on atmosphere though since it looks like a circus more than retro with the blue, red and yellow decor. Black and white or black, red and white would look much bette plus the molded plastic seats remind me of McDonalds. It didn't bring down my overall grade much though, since they did such a good job on the burgers.
(4)May L.
Went last week for the first time and it was awesome! The food was great and the service was quick and friendly. Big portions and very reasonably priced, we used the yelp deal which was cheaper than the kama'aina discount. Can't wait to go back!
(5)Jason B.
Fantastic food - the only problem is deciding what to get! I ended up getting the 5oz combo meal with added cheese and pulled pork, delicious! The fries were nothing to write home about, next time I'm skipping the fries and drink and getting a bigger burger with more goodies!
(5)Geordi W.
If you are looking for a burger this is the place to go! Great 50's atmosphere and even better burgers!
(5)Lindsay M.
Great food at s great price. The shake was delicious and super thick. I can't wait to go back.
(5)Lou G.
Located near the Foodland, Teddy's is clean, well lit & the servers are courteous. Read about this place on Yelp and used the coupon purchased on Yelp. Enough about the surroundings, it's about the burgers . I had a 7 oz Bigger "Lahaina" burger, wife had a fish burger & chocolate shake, we shared fries. My burger was delicious. I have had burgers from Shake Shack in New York City, Five Guys Burgers & Fries and In-N-Out amongest many others that were less memorable. Teddy's is as good as any of those mentioned, if not better. On the night we went it was busy but not crowded. So nice not to fight crowds in Maui. Now for the cliche, it doesn't get any better for location or food, a cheeseburger in paradise.
(5)Tony M.
Great burger on maui. Excellent selection, almost too many. Food fresh and a good value. Service was also very good. They seem to want to please you. Can get "buy one combo, get second at 50% off" coupons in tourist mags. Makes 2 combos total less than $20. Don't think you'll be disappointed with any selection. 4 of us had 4 different, all pleased. If your visiting the island, don't miss.
(5)Angela N.
Awesome burgers! A must eat in Lahaina. We came from Los Angeles and Chicago to visit Maui and wanted a great burger. Teddy's Bigger Burgers has so many yummy choices so you can't go wrong! If you want a great tasting burger made fresh this is difinitely the place!
(5)Jen A.
Found this place by accident and so glad we did! They serve your typical burger, fries and shakes. I had the bacon blue cheese and it was cooked perfectly. Get the $20 for $12 through yelp for an awesome deal! I purchased mine while waiting in line and showed them my smart phone and the accepted :)
(5)Christy A.
Yum! Omg I wanted to walk out when I saw the cost of the food but I am so glad I didnt. I got the grilled chicken sandwich and husband got a burger. They were both delish! I was a little scared of the secret sauce so I got it on the side. Well I'm glad I did because not only did I use it on my sandwich but I dipped my fries in it. This was not the ordinary thousand island dressing secret sauce. It was fresh, sweet, tangy and yummy! I totally suggest you give this place a try. But do be prepared to wait a few minutes. This place cooks everything to order so it takes a while, however it is worth the wait.
(5)Matthew V.
Best burger my wife and I had in HI. Best service we had in any restaurant. I paid a little more than I had expected (pricing for the specialty burgers isn't clearly posted and can sneak up on you quickly - adding $4-6 to the regular price of the burger), but with the Yelp deal, everything balanced out. Apparently it's a chain based on the islands (with an additional location in both Tokyo and WA), but easily the best meal for the money we had all week. The only thing that kept this from being an epic experience was the lack of deep fried cheese curds on the menu.
(5)Melisaa B.
Fabulous burgers and great service! Highly recommend the Lahaina burger! This burger can't be beat!
(5)Leilani D.
I love their burgers! I usually get the bacon bleu cheese burger with cheese fries their staff is very friendly and helpful I also like their milkshakes so addicting!
(5)Anthony C.
I visited this place twice during my last visit to Maui and will definitely return on my next trip. It's so difficult to find reasonably priced food that is good on Maui and am happy that this place is there for a yummy lunch. I was impressed by the staff too - very friendly. And, the place is VERY clean - very important to me!!!
(5)Keith L.
Great spot for burgers and the usual sides but stick with Cool Cat Cafe if you want to wash your burger down with a brew or other adult beverage.
(4)Sadler W.
Great semi-retro burger joint! Looks like a fast food burger stand, but the burgers were cooked fresh (you could tell) and they had some cool and funky possibilities on the menu as well. I had the teri-burger, which was very good. Grab a Yelp deal and check them out!
(5)Sonya P.
I don't say this often but this was one of the best burgers I've ever had. Perfect topping combos like mushrooms and swiss teri available, fresh ingredients, generous amounts, and great portions. I wish I lived near this place. 5-stars for sure.
(5)Gary K.
If I could give this place 6 stars I would, you can tell that the owners really care for their business because the food is amazing!!
(5)James K.
I visited Teddy's Bigger Burger on a recent vacation to Maui. I've had all the well known burgers in Los Angeles (In-N-Out, Five Guys, Umami, Father's Office, The Counter, Plan Check, etc), and Teddy's ranks up there. In fact, I would rank Teddy's number 1 or 2 compared all the ones I've mentioned. The burger was flavorful and had the smokey taste you get when you grill it in your backyard. Excellent. Garlic fries were good too. Only complaint is that it takes a while for your order since they cook it when you order. Worth the wait though.
(5)T A.
Great place to have a burger. Big, Jucy burger with a nice atmosphere.
(4)Amanda H.
Good food, good service, clean place. Worth the money!
(5)Alison J.
Happy to find a good burger place in Lahaina, especially one that offers turkey burgers. Fast service, clean place. Our order was off a little (we never asked for the bacon that appeared on one of our burgers), but the burgers were generous in size, with nice soft buns, fresh crispy lettuce and tasty pickles. We will definitely add this to our meal rotation for our trips to Maui. It's a nice break from the pricey restaurants that abound here.
(4)Mari P.
Damm good juicy hamburgers in Maui. Wanted something semi-quick and casual since we were towing around two kiddies. The bread roll the hamburgers come in and french fries were awesome. I could have killed two hamburgers along with my diet coke (tee hee), these hamburgers just reminded me of grilling in the backyard. Check them out, staff is super nice, place is spacious and there is AC ya'll! Enjoy and then go take a dip in the beach.
(5)Joe R.
Great!!! That's all that needs to be sad about the food here.
(5)Super H.
A nice change of pace from sit down, fancy spots in Maui. A solid, greasy meal as well. 3 and a half stars but I'll round up because I got a great check-in deal.
(4)Manas A.
That was one large burger! With an egg on top. Like a loco moco, but sans rice. And some chili and spud on top to round it off. Go for it if you have the appetite. Or rather, make the appetite and then make sure to come here. P.S. Don't tell your cardiologist you were here.
(5)Lisa M.
The best juicy burger. Would eat there again.
(5)Garth H.
We really enjoyed Teddys. Burgers were very tasty, and yes they werent "medium" the first time, but we didi go back a second time and they were perfect. Not cheap, but by Hawaiian standards a decent value, and for sure not a disappointment. We'll be back, and after perusing their website, theyactually have a restaurant in our home area, Woodinville, WA.
(5)Garland R.
This is a great place to swing in for in and out style burger for a good price, I also like the location how it's tucked in a little off Front St.
(3)Kris H.
This was an extremely great burger place. So many choices, I think all eight of us chose something different. Their fries are perfect and their special hot sauce had the perfect amount of heat but did not over-power your tastebuds.
(5)Dave B.
The "bacado" was one of the best burgers I've ever had! The garlic fries and malts are also top-notch. Grab the Yelp deal and give it a try. You won't regret it.
(5)Lisa F.
Looks like a typical themed Burger joint but the burgers are something else! Large and juicy the onion rings were perfectly cooked. Good meal.
(4)Jason S.
Best burgers in Maui. We ate at every place from Lahaina to Kapalua and this was our favorite. Great service, great food, and great price. Server even have me a coupon to save me money on my order. Highly recommended.
(5)Julie B.
Very tastey! I don't eat beef so I go for turkey burgers, and these ones were delicious! It's so hard to find a good turkey burger, this one was tender and juicy. I got the Lahaina toppings, and regular fries. My friend got the Bacon me Crazy and we both loved it! I wanted to get a shake but they were almost six dollars which I just can't justify for a shake.
(5)MARK P.
Great burgers; friendly, efficient service. Loved the Bacado and Western burgers. One of the real few bargains in W. Maui with the Yelp deal. We would absolutely go again. I have an ocean view from my room, I don't need one with my burger.
(4)Kim G.
This was another "this place gets good reviews on Yelp, lets try it" We had been out an about enjoying Maui all day and just wanted to grab something semi-fast and not pay a fortune, and not have McDonalds. It's in a shopping center across from the Lahaina Cannery Mall, so fairly easy to get to. Its the kind of place that you order you food up at the counter and then they bring it to you and your table. There are four different sizes of burgers to choose from and then several topping/combo options. Their burgers all automatically come cooked medium-well unless you tell them otherwise. We each got the 7 oz. size which was plenty! I didn't even finish mine. I got the Bacado Burger...burger, bacon, cheese, and 1/2 of an avocado. The avocado is what sealed the deal for me, it was delicious! The bread that is used for the buns is really good too. Big, soft, fresh, and a light dusting of flour on the top bun. I had fries as a side, I'm not sure what the other side options are. For four combos we paid about $52 so not exactly an economy meal, but I will admit that is was a really good burger. You can tell the meat is pretty high quality, it just has that great taste.
(4)Dennis A.
5 adults, 6 kids. The service and all of the food was Great.
(5)Rachael H.
Horrible. The menu says the burgers are medium so I asked for them to be well done. I got one medium and one RAW!!! That was after a 25 minute wait. While I was waiting I watched tantrums by employees, food handing issues with the guy making the shake and some guy in a t shirt for the melting pot walking in off the street and going in the back and start cooking without even washing his hands-plus did he even work there? I called and went in the next day to get my money back ( it was a to go order) and the manager/owner was too busy to talk to me so another 15 minutes of waiting to get this taken care of by someone at the register.
(1)Raquel S.
Awesome burger joint!!!! They don't make ones like this anymore. Burgers,fries,onion rings,shakes and corn dogs my family loved all of it !!!! We are going back again before we leave!!
(5)Robert G.
Best burgers in the land and more. Eating there is a nostalgic experience with the 50's and 60's atmosphere, the oldies music and the great burgers. The basic #1 Combo is hard to beat. If you are a large eater they have a burger size to please you. Give it a try you will not be sorry.
(5)Rob S.
They live it up to their motto: "Reinventing the Burger Joint!" These guys serve your burgers, shakes, and sides any way you'd like: fully customizable. They live it up to their motto: "Reinventing the Burger Joint!"All their beef patties are hand-made, 100% ground chuck and not FROZEN. Though their main feature is burgers, these guys also offer crispy and grilled chicken sandwiches, turkey burgers, veggie burgers (it's not soy, it's full-on veg!), fried fish sandwiches, fish n' chips, chicken nuggets, grilled cheese, and corn dogs. I've eaten here a couple times with family and just on my own, and concocted a couple crazy burgers and sides like: Bacon and Blue Cheese onion rings, 5 oz. Patty and Veggie Patty, with Avo, Grilled Onions, Mushrooms, and Swiss Cheese in a single burger, and Srawberry Peanut Butter Shake (Tastes like PB&J!) Dragon Tots (Tots smothered in their Teriyaki, Special and Fire Sauce with a whole half of avocado on top!) Staff is Super friendly and very knowledgeable of their menu! If it's your first time, don't be shy to ask the guys up front! They know their stuff!
(5)Romarues R.
A different way to eat burgers, with a Hawaiian style ...I love this place. you should try this place and compare.
(4)Rick M.
GREAT burger with equally great service! I tried the TCB new featured burger. Teriyaki, cheese & lots of bacon! Yum!! You HAVE to try the garlic fries. The service is amazing for a "burger joint". (Sorry Teddy, this is not just a burger joint, but Top Burger in Hawaii the last 12 straight years!) they give EVERY patron a feedback review. They care about you and service is more like a restaurant. They constantly check your table for whatever you may need. I realize having a burger in Maui seems wrong given all the amazing local fare, but this IS local fare as well. You won't be disappointed!! We went 2 times in3 days! ENJOY :)
(5)Michael G.
Incredible pastrami
(4)calvin n.
The burger was good but don't eat the salad. we ended up throwing it away.
(3)Katie C.
Friendly counter people, very good food that is cheap and comes out quick! Love it!
(5)Sam G.
Got a lahaina style burger + garlic fries - was so good I'm getting another burger ...
(5)Winter M.
Great fast food burger. I got the bacado burger and it was a wonderful balance of juicy crispy savory creamy and charred. The price is incredibly reasonable for Maui especially with the yelp deal. Shakes are thick and not overly sweet. All together one of the better meals we have had on the island. Skip the overpiced burger joints on front street and come here.
(5)Jonathan S.
Awesome fun place. Great people who care what you think and about their burgers. Shakes are awesome!!!
(5)Matt M.
These burgers are the real deal. Awesome flavors, high quality ingredients, filling meal. The fries and rings are both great, if you have room for them after the monster burgers served to you! The "bigger" size at 7oz is very filling I'm bot sure if I could handle the biggest. They have one in Woodinville WA too so we will for sure check them out once we get home. Otherwise Teddy's will be one of our first stops when we return to Maui! This trip we tried Cool Cats as well as Honu for their burgers. Teddy's beats them all. Especially for the price you pay (Honu was very good but $18 for a burger is a little much, even if it is right on the water)
(5)A Y.
Great burgers and great service. A bit pricey for a fast food joint, but with the yelp deal = one happy customer.
(4)Brendan M.
This was my first visit to Teddy's and I was impressed. I ordered a Laihana burger, which in addition to the basics came with pineapple and jalapenos. The sweet and spicy combination was AMAZING. In addition, or particular note was there "secret sauce," which seems to be similar to Thousand Island, but they have made it there own by giving it a sweet taste - it was quite good. Also all of the ingredients were fresh and you could definitely taste it. Their fries were also very good. The burgers come in three sizes 5, 7, and 9 oz. I ordered the 7 oz burger and it was huge. I was starving so I did finish my burger/fries, but had I been at home as opposed to on vacation where I had not eaten since breakfast the 5 oz would probably have been more than enough. The prices were a little high - it cost $28 for two 7 oz burger combos. Although, if you buy the Yelp $12 for $20 coupon you can same some money. The food quality was similar to that of a sit down restaurant's burgers, which justifies the cost; however, the environment is that of a fast food restaurant - for which the same cost seems very expensive. The decor of the restaurant is obnoxiously bright red, yellow, and blue colored. It says it is 50's themed, but it does not really look it to me. That being said I went for the food NOT the decor. One complaint about there menu (on the wall) is it seems a bit disorganized and hard to follow. There is a sign on the wall with circles showing you how big the 5, 7, and 9 oz burger sizes, but I did not even see that until after I ordered. Also, the main menu gives you the cost of their burger combos for the original Teddy's burger, which is based on what size you order. However, there is also a side menu with a lot of different speciality burger options including the Laihana, but that one does not include any prices. When I ordered it the cost came to the same as the original Teddy's burger combo (7 oz size) - so I assume all burgers cost the same based on size? All in all it was a little confusing and pricey, but the burger made it worth if. If on Maui and you want a burger I definitely recommend Teddy's. They do accept credit card.
(4)daniel s.
I still love this place! I want a t-shirt. I can't wait till the location in kihei opens up.
(5)R W.
This was a great place to eat while we were on vacation! Kids loved the food and all the burger options were really good. We will be back next time we are on Maui.
(5)P H.
Having landed in Maui and found our hotel we were in desperate need of sustenance. As we entered Teddy's I felt guilty for not choosing local Hawaiian cuisine as our first meal, but tired and hungry we relented given the excellent reviews. I got the #3 Combo, Biggest Burger with large fries with a side of tots. Remember that feeling of guilt upon entering? Upon first bite the guilt left me! Into the ether it went! The food was excellent - the burger and their secret sauce delicious, the tots were cooked perfectly, and the fries? Sir! They were tasty seasoned fries! Thinking the experience could get no better, the staff made a pass and even asked how our experience was! This was a first for me at a fast food restaurant and one that was greatly appreciated. Add Teddy's to your Maui experience, you won't regret it.
(5)Vince M.
WOW! Their burgers were delicious. Guy at the counter gave us the run down on their menu, letting us know which was their most popular burgers. They also have TATER TOTS! Meat was nice and juicy, buns were perfect for the size of meat you get. They didn't get too soggy or anything. Tater tots were perfect. My girlfriend is not a big fan of beef, but she liked her burger. Hands down, the best burger I've ever had. Too bad it is in Hawaii! :(
(5)Eats Too Much F.
Best burger I've had on the West side of the island. If, Cool Cats wins 'Best Burger" next year I will firmly believe the voting is rigged. It's in a very Southern California plaza (no surprise, it was built by DR Horton) and is not on the water, but it is the best burger I've had on the West side ever since that place below the other restaurant as you enter Kaanapali closed. If you are getting tired of "Shoyu" this and "Teri" that and crave a great burger and fries, this is your place. The garlic fries rock!
(5)Daren N.
Best burger in Maui! I was suprised, and we took advantage of a yelp deal for checking in. Service was very good also, and seems employees like working there.
(5)Lovesto E.
Wow!!! Was I pleasantly surprised when we went here to eat. The place is very clean and the food was delicious! The burgers are homemade and tastes like it and the seasoning very good. The burger is cooked to order at your preferred doneness and you even have a choice of different types of fries. I had the 7 ounce combo with crispy fries and I must say, it was tasty! My wife had the buffalo chicken sandwich with spicy fries and she enjoyed every bite! They also have a kamaaina discount, which does make a difference. The service, although counter service, was also very good and the employees are very attentive and friendly. Hard to find good workers here, but it was very apparent these guys and gals, or at least this shift, took pride in their jobs. I even heard one of them apologizing and thanking a customer for telling them one of the tables needed to be wiped, despite the fact this lady could have sat at the many other, clean and unoccupied tables! I will definitely be back, many times, I'm sure.
(5)Lanie M.
We were cruising in Lahaina and decided to have some burgers. I was been here before and i heard so much good reviews from my friends who had been here. I ordered the Kailua burger combo , i was satisfied about the service, the burger was juicy , i loved the fries and the price was reasonable enough for a 5 oz burger .
(4)Doreen B.
This is the place that one that can satisfy a real burger craving. During my 2nd pregnancy - I only craved hamburgers. It was my mission to find a perfect burger but also a decent burger on each side of the island. This one takes the crown for best and best in the west. If you're a fan of the 5 Guys chain - this is a cut above with a little aloha to go with. My favorites: Lahaina Burger Makawao Burger Anything with their Onolicious sauce :) They offer Kamaaina rates upon request. If you're in a hurry, call in your order and chow down beach side. We haven't tried the shakes yet but hear they are delicious. Once you've had a 7 oz burger and fries to split, there isn't much room for a PB Shake ;)
(5)Jeri H.
This was on our list of places to try and we were NOT disappointed! Burgers were cooked perfectly! Onion rings- on point! Yes, we did wait approx 10min but the food was oh-so-good! Great place to recharge after an afternoon of snorkeling. The place was exceptionally clean! YAY!!! The staff was awesome. This place certainly knows how to dish ALOHA! Mahalo for a great lunch!
(4)Nani D.
Quite disappointed this time around. We come often and I've noticed the following: - large groups staff gets flustered and overwhelmed. Got my order mixed. - we ordered milk shakes with our meal and checked 3x's. An hour later we got a refund & an apology. (We checked twice prior to that stating they would make it). Did I mention they were busy?... What we did get: A warm welcome when we walked in the door. AND the other cashier asked how our night was going. For this they'll get another chance and hopefully a better review next time.
(3)Rainelle H.
The staff at the Lahaina Teddy's Bigger Burgers are always super friendly and my teri burger is always cooked to perfection. The only con is that it can get a little pricey depending how much add ons or what kind of combo you get. However, locals can get kamaaina discount when they show their HI ID. Scrumptious meal at a reasonable price served with ALOHA, how could you ask for more?
(5)Stephanie V.
Amazing as always!!! If you complain about this place it's probably bc you made yourself a crappy burger considering it's build it yourself! Great service, and great food!
(5)Lon H.
Teddy's is a nice change of pace while in Maui. When you're hungry for a burger, this is where I've gone on my last two trips. You can order whatever size and type of burger you like and you can make it a combo if you prefer. You can also order your fries extra crispy (which I do) or you can have garlic fries. The burgers are cooked medium or you can order them more well done if you like. Service has always been very good. The restaurant is clean and inviting.
(4)Jesse G.
For starters the bill was less than $15.00 for a 7 Oz Woodenville combo meal with upgraded garlic fries. This was our first time at Teddy's and we were very impressed. My wife and I split the burger in half and still had food left over. The wait for the food was about 10 minutes and the food was prepared very well. The service was friendly and informative with all our questions. Ruben the young gentlemen that took our order was top notch and helped us decide a great burger. Extremely tasty food, great service and reasonably priced for Maui.....eat here if you can you will not regret it.
(5)Lena H.
Best hamburger place on any island!! Pricey but worth every penny! Grilled pineapple is yummy!
(5)Mark G.
A very good reasonable meal for a family of 5. This is more than a burger joint, although for Burgers it was good. In addition to the burgers they also make a Mahi-Mahi burgers, veggie burgers, Vegan Burger, and salads. They were all good. Plus great fries, including garlic fries. Vegans and Vegetarians can eat well. The salad was actually great, and the Veggie burger was delicious. This is a causal local restaurant. In fact, if you are a "declared" local you get 10 percent off your bill. The locals fill the restaurant with the tourist. Our favorite burger is Joey's in Whalers village, but this is a very close tie or 2nd place for the Island. The menu is big and a tiny bit complicated, but our order taker was soooo nice and helpful that it went very smoothly. The drinks are mostly fountain drinks. The buns are Hawaiian buns, and they also serve grilled Pineapple and grilled Onions, which are yummy! We didn't order the shakes, but they looked great. Parking is easy as it is located in a strip mall. Because it is cooked fresh, once you order it can take about 10 mins for the food to be available for pick up, but worth the wait. It looks like a retro 1970's surfing burger joint, which is a fun atmosphere. Size is generous.
(4)Lizette A.
Had the 5 oz. Burger and (good portion) of fries. I ordered the spicy fries. It was their crispy fries with a zesty sprinkling of mild spice. It was all tasty! Big bang for your buck in Hawaii. The service was fast and friendly, almost just like my favorite In N Out at home. Most definitely a good addition to your food stops on Maui. The end.
(4)Andrea K.
So much to love here! I ordered a Lahaina Burger...bacon, jack cheese, jalapeños & pineapple on a sweet Hawaiian bun, spicy fries and a dreamcicle shake. The burger was cooked perfectly. The toppings were crisp and fresh. The fries were crispy at the ends and covered in seasoning salt. The dreamcicle shake was made with vanilla ice cream and Fanta...tasted like orange sherbet and cooled the flames from the jalapeños! The fam and I loved it and we consider ourselves to be burger connoisseurs being from TX ;-)
(5)Maria C.
A little pricier than your typical fast food burger joint, but the quality is MUCH better. My usual go-to burger is the Kailua -- 5 oz burger with teriyaki sauce, grilled onions, swiss cheese, & mushrooms. Yum! Service is usually great & friendly, but once in a while the wait after ordering seems longer than it should be. I also get their malt shakes, but one time it was just a regular milkshake vs. a malt which is an additional charge. They sometimes offer a discount coupon in local newspapers like the Maui Time and always offer a kama'aina discount. What really won my heart & left a good impression on me the last time was when they asked if I wanted to donate my kama'aina discount to Trucker Dukes (a Maui toddler diagnosed with stage 4 neuroblastoma). This was such a great way to get involved in the community and help a family in need of support. Awesome promotion that definitely increases a company's goodwill value!
(4)Marissa S.
I've had this place bookmarked on Yelp before coming to the island and after my Hawaiian Yelp buddy, Joe P. recommended this place, I was convinced this was not to be missed. No better time to eat a big, fat, juicy burger than after a swim in the beach. We soooo earned it! Teddy's is a local fast food joint that looks like a diner, Hawaiian style with colorful surf boards hanging on the walls. The guy behind the counter helped me through my ordering. I was being an annoying customer with too many questions that day...poor kid! It was his first day at work he said but he delivered like a pro. I was impressed. With his recommendations, here's what we got: ORIGINAL BURGER---A good 'ol American burger with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and cheese. Perfectly cooked beef patty that was oozing with juicy flavors. Love the potato bread bun used in all their burgers. It has the starch sticking to the roof of your mouth effect---my weakness when eating a burger. So good and easily my fave out of everything I had here. I got the 7oz patty but I think a 5oz would have sufficed. It's filling! LAHAINA STYLE BURGER---Sweet and spicy! This came with pineapple, bacon, swiss cheese, and jalapenos. I just had to get this, we were in Hawaii after all. Another great burger especially if you want some heat. Wonderful marriage of flavors from all the ingredients which I'm already a fan of individually. TERI BURGER---They make their own teriyaki sauce and the kid highly recommends it so I ordered this for my daughter with bacon, of course. The burger was missing bacon when served but they fixed that right away and brought it to our table in a jiffy. It was too one note for me in flavor but since bacon makes everything taste better, it worked out. GARLIC FRIES---Thick-cut and crispy fries drizzled with garlic, lots of it! We killed this basket and could probably kill a vampire with our garlic breaths as well. Plan to share between 2-3 people as a side. A pineapple milkshake would've been an awesome pairing but my daughter insisted on a ROOT BEER FLOAT to go with her combo. There was so much to go around with one order. They fill a cup with vanilla ice cream and you can do unlimited root beer refills. Sweet! Best part: $30 for everything! Big fan!
(4)Alex C.
Visiting from CA and I have to say this is one of the best burgers I've had in a long time. I ordered a bigger burger with pepper jack onion ring and fried egg and it was the best. Definitely recommend this place
(5)Horace S.
Ok, the place is fun like an old 70s fast food establishment. Music is great also. Can't get enough of Pretty Woman. Order the monster burger and fries with a creamsicle shake. The first place I left full. Great food!
(5)Enmeline V.
Love Teddy's Bigger Burgers!!! I first encountered them in Oahu years ago. When they opened the one on Maui, I was so happy and excited! Best burgers I've had ever! Can barely finish a 5oz burger though, which bums me out because I wanna finish off my fries with their awesome sauce! Try it! You'll be stuffed!
(5)John G.
Very good burgers. The buns are a little dry, but good nonetheless. The fries and chili cheese fries are excellent. Fast, friendly restaurant. Clean. I am sure we will be back.
(4)Joey T.
The best burger I had while in Maui. With all the hotel food and diners burgers are plentiful on the island. However finding a good one is definitely much harder said than done. I figured that out the hard way. Teddys has a cool decor in a nice center. Obviously the locals like it, and I believe they even charge them less than the tourists. They have three different size patties, and you can order the burger cooked to what you want. Lots of good toppings and choices to make the burger your own. They keep the customization high with their other menu options too. Shakes fries and onion rings all above average and good. My chief complaint is that our staff member who took our order was very, very, slow. He was also abrasive, and just messed our order up. We had to wait for a second round of burgers, which was not quick. Even with the unfortunate service, the burger still make up for it. Compared to everything else close by Teddys simply wins out.
(4)Joseph M.
It was ok..like others said I don't see what all the hypes about. The burger was bland and needed more seasoning. The only reason I'm giving 3 stars is because the portion size...but then again for the price I expected a bomb burger, I could make a better one at home. Would not recommend sorry
(3)Mike S.
Awesome food. Best burgers in Maui.
(5)Valeriy K.
Wow, those were great tasty burgers!!! Very satisfied!! The place was also really clean and the ppl were nice. They could be a little more generous on the fries tho.
(4)Lisa K.
My favorite thing was how customizable everything was. I had the no-bun option with lettuce instead, and blue cheese. The smallest burger size seemed quite sufficient unless you're pretty hungry. I found both the fries and the onion rings quite good. Our only problem was that the burgers were a bit too charred tasting, even when they weren't overly done, so I'm not sure if this can be modified.
(4)Vikéndios N.
Wow, it's been almost 3 years since I've eaten at Teddy's!? I'd stop in more often but I hardly come to the west side anymore. ATMOSPHERE: The place is still in great shape and is very clean. It's so reminiscent of In N Out with its similar colors and simple menu. FOOD: Combo #2 - Bigger combo with a 7 oz. patty. This is the perfect size for me. Opted for mushrooms, cheese, tomato, lettuce and special sauce. The patty was cooked nicely and was super tender and juicy, the bun soft, and the natural cut fries were thick, crispy and hot. SERVICE: Super friendly regardless of how busy and bustling the place was on a Sunday during lunch. It took about 10 minutes to get our food, but the wait was so well worth it because everything was fresh and hot. OVERALL: I'm totally a fan. Just the day before, I ate a Double Whopper from BK, and it was within 10-cents of Teddy's price and worlds different. I wish they'd open up shop in Kahului or Wailuku as there are 2 new malls going up!
(4)Bunker T.
Found Teddy's via Yelp after a day of snorkeling and it looked like a fast food spot. BUT... excellent burgers for both of us! Juicy, big, sloppy burger on a fantastic roll really hit the spot. Great food, great staff, great place.
(5)Kerrissa A.
The burgers are so juicy and perfectly crafted. The fries are hot and crispy. The restaurant is so clean they up keep it very well. The service is great. Specifically, my friends and I were really impressed with Shawn, he's very professional and provides great service. He seems like a hard worker who does the best that he can. Love those kind of people! Overall, super impressed and always come to teddys when in Lahaina.
(5)birdie o.
The decor is interesting and the location is easy to find! Was craving a good burger figured from the yelp reviews that it was good! Got a Hawaiian Kai burger which comes with pepper jack, bacon, avocado and pineapple! The inside smells good and very clean! Fresh and nice views of the mountains! They have everything that a usual diner would have and they have Tons of specialty burgers to choose from! They also have some weird combinations too! The people are cool, blan but cool. They also passed out wet napkins which is helpful cus they get messy! Over all definitely a good place to get that fatty oil in your system!
(4)Kayla S.
Great burger joint that definitely doesn't rob your wallet! So glad we decided to stop by for lunch! Friendly service, EXECELLENT burgers. Will for sure stop by on our next visit to Maui :)
(5)Kevin G.
Did this used to be a Chuck E Cheese? The decor is obnoxious and the burgers are middle of the road. They could be the frozen ones you buy from Costco! I don't want to knock it too bad because the staff was very nice and seemed like great employees.
(3)Chris F.
Wow really great burgers. Ask them to go though the menu with you if it is confusing. We are just visiting and they were very nice to go through the options with us. The pineapple. Is really great on any burger, I got Lahaina style and it was really good. If you like just a little spice I would go for that. Get it to go and take it to a beach park, or back to your resort breach and enjoy!!
(5)Steph G.
Oh boy, where do I begin? From start to finish, experience was overall quite unsatisfactory. When my love stepped up to the counter, he had to ask the kid (I believe his name was Noah) what a Teri Burger consisted of three times. Each time, he seemed to misunderstand and thought he was ordering it. Occurrence x3 all in a matter of a few minutes. We ordered a bocado burger and a western burger, not long after the rest of our group. Our total? $34 for 2 burger combos and 2 shakes. WTH? No, this is NOT a fancy burger joint. It looks more like a cheesy fast food restaurant, probably more cheesy looking than McD's. Poor fluorescent lighting, rainbow colored decorations, you get the picture. Imagine spending 30 bucks in a joint like that. Everyone else received their orders and were halfway done with their meals as we waited. I finally went up to ask and it turns out, the large girl behind the counter found it sitting without a number, getting nice and cold. Turns out Noah didn't do something correctly and that's why our food never came up. There's more. Get back to my table to find that the Bacado burger is not one at all. Gave it back to the same girl and said this is wrong, we ordered a bacado burger. She says, "oh ok a bacado burger got it." And then proceeds to ask me what's on it? I simply stated, "it's on your main menu board as one of your specials." Asked me same question again. WTH? Can she read? Or figure out where to get her information? She comes back to the table and asks me another question..."Are there mushrooms on the bacado burger?" ARE YOU KIDDING ME LADY?! Tip to the people who run this place: hire some workers who can actually figure out where to get the information they need rather than asking the customers a million times what's on the specials menu. That's just the stupidity that comes behind the counter at this joint. Let me tell you the food was less than mediocre for the price we paid. Patties seemed to have come from frozen, bun was dry and crumbly. You tell me if that's worth 30 bucks. It's not even an issue of poor service, more an issue of IQ with the staff. That in combination with the less than subpar burger equals a very low recommendation from me. Such a waste of money. I work hard for my money and would not waste a penny here again. Wish I could be reimbursed for this ridiculous "dining" experience. I am completely befuddled by the high ratings this place has. BUYER BEWARE.
(1)Lyn S.
The Kailua Burger is my fav! Henry n his staff has awesome customer service!
(5)K M.
If you want the best burgers in Maui come here. I took my wife here for her first Teddy's bigger burger experience and she loved it. Isaiah provided exceptional service, He took extra time to tell my wife about the featured burgers and the other menu selections. We will definitely come back next time we are in Maui.
(5)lisa m.
We love Teddy's!! It's our neighborhood burger joint & we love having it so close by so we can eat our favorite burgers anytime!! The owner Henry is a great guy! Very hospitable & always welcomes everyone as they come in! Thank you Henry & lisa
(5)Wendy B.
Food is so expensive in Maui and this place was a great value. Good burger, yummy tater tots and quick, so you can get back to your vacation fun.
(5)Vince L.
The eatery was a bit hard to find. I knew it was in the same plaza as Foodland and Barnes & Noble, but the the sign was really high, behind a tree, and in a strange font. As for the menu, it's a pretty simple menu with burgers and fries. The combos seem to be the best deal at $9.95 for a burger, fries and a drink. You can also build your own and get sandwiches. The burgers were cooked to your desired doneness. I think they can cut back on the salt for the fries though. You get a buzzer that vibrates when your meal is ready. What stood out about this location was the staff. They were friendly and even brought stuff to the table. Yes, it's a fast food joint, but please remember to leave a tip if you like the service.
(4)Maureen C.
I liked the burgers here, but they weren't wow. Although my boyfriend's was on the dry side, mine was perfectly juicy and very moist. Not sure why there would be such a big difference since the others in our party also got juicy patties. The onion rings and tots are amazing! Definitely get one of them. The onion doesn't just slide out with only batter left in your fingers, you can actually bite through the batter AND the onion, which I have never experienced before. The service was also really good. We ordered a float that they forgot about, but when we told them they gave us extra scoops of ice cream! Pro-tip: google maps apparently does not really know where this place is, it takes you to some small back-corner street. Look for the huge plaza and just turn in there haha.
(4)K B.
It was aighhht. Burgers were good and fries were better. Price is what makes this place attractive. Some days you just don't want to spend $50 for a meal for 2.5 ppl in Maui. Today's bill at Teddy's was $27.
(4)Maka V.
Burgers were okay. The bun feel apart after 3 bites. Tator tots were good. Hubby thought garlic fries were too garlicy but i liked them. Service was great.
(3)Ebby M.
We come here all the time, and think it is genuinely the best burger around. The fries are big, the shakes are killer, and it's probably the only place around to get jalapeno poppers. Their burgers of the month honestly scare me, but my husband gets them almost every time. If you're the adventurous sort, then that's the way to go! 4/5 stars because it's tougher on our pocketbook than we think it should be, and their tables are too small for our groups.
(4)Scott S.
Came here to get some dinner on the "cheap" at least on island standard. Recommend that anyone who comes here to get the buy one combo get the second for 50%. Both of us had the #1 combo. Burger was seasoned well but the fries did not taste fresh. Sauce on the burger was also good. Service was ok but one of the soda machines was broken and the other had too much carbonation. Again, make sure you get the coupon before you eat here.
(3)Stef N.
Love the burgers and secret sauce. Very clean. Workers are very friendly and helpful. They also offer discount with local ID.
(5)Lala K.
Teddy's Burgers is on my top five bestest burgers list. Everything you want in a burger Teddy's has... Whether it's a plain old fashion cheese burger or if you're they daring type and like to try different addons to your burger. They do have special burgers named after different Hawaiian cities. My go to burger is the Teri burger with Swiss with a side of garlic butter fries yum!! Aside from the delicious food, the restaurant itself is spacious and clean - great for huge groups and kids. And the staff is super friendly! I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a yummy burger!
(5)T W.
As a visitor to Maui, wasn't quite sure how good a hamburger joint would be in a strip center. Well, surprise surprise .... Food was great, service was great, restaurant was clean and staff was very friendly. Highly recommend this place. Had the Blue Wave Special which was hamburger, teriyaki sauce, bacon and blue cheese
(5)Amber K.
Great Tots!! My burger was okay, I couldn't get past the fact that my medium burger was well done. Maybe it was an off day. I'll be back, we'll see. The customer service was great and the restaurant was clean.
(4)David S.
People--The people behind the counter were very friendly and nice. Great experiences both times we visited. Milkshakes--they were awesome--suggest the haupia and the pina coloda. We went back a second time just for the shakes. Food--The hamburgers were good and I would have them again--they were not over the top delicious (maybe needs better seasoned meat) but it was a solid burger. The bun was too soft--should use a more substantial bun. Overall, nice experience--would go again and definitely get the milkshakes.
(4)Jess L.
Teddy's bigger burgers food is great. They cook it fresh and the employees are really nice. It has your standard style fast food restaurant dining room, nothing special. They give a local discount but it is pretty minimal. As usual it is pretty overpriced, even for Maui. I got a 7oz bacon cheeseburger and a small tator tot and it was over $13 even with my local discount. They charge for sauces if you want anything above and beyond ketchup or mustard. I will go back I'm sure but I don't frequent this burger joint because of the prices. Great burgers with a lot of topping choices.
(4)John W.
I'm going to make this one simple. This is probably the gourmet burger chain going. Being from NY, we've had them all - Shake Shack, Fatburger, Umami, Bareburger, Bobby's Burger Palace, American Roadside, Five Guys, Checkers, Sonic, and so on. But it was unanimous for me, my wife and two teenage sons - this place wins hands down over the others for their burgers and shakes. Did it take 10-15 mins to get our burgers, yes. But they were prepared and cooked to exactly what we asked for. Did the bun fall apart, yes. But we're in it for the meat and fixings, not the bread. The only things I'm knocking are the garlic fries and onion rings (we've had better from some of the places named above) and the price ($80 for the four of us -- this is a take-out burger joint, right?)
(4)Shauna L.
Friendly service, great burgers and fun music! My sweets and I both ordered burgers and shared some chili cheese fries. I got the kids burger and it was the perfect size for me. It had a really nice grilled flavor and was cooked perfectly. All the toppings were fresh and the buns were fresh too. Oh and I have to point out that I love grilled onions on a burger and these were by far the best cooked grilled onions I've had on a burger in forever. They sliced them nice and thick and didn't skimp at all. The chili cheese fries were also good. The small was the perfect size to split. I loved that they use cheese sauce instead of shredded cheese on the fries too. Kind of reminded me of steak n shake cheese sauce. They played oldies music which was a nice touch. We will be going back for sure.
(4)Lucy L.
Awesome place for a delicious burger. Portion is nice and big. Reminds me of Inn-n-Out and Five Guys. Definitely recommend it for cheap eats in the area. My Yelp deal made it even better.
(5)David P.
Great burger joint with totally casual atmosphere. Reasonable prices. I'd definitely go again.
(4)Karey R.
Oh we looooove Teddy's. The whole family loved everything there, the staff, the food quality, the cleanliness, everything was great. My favorite was the Hawaiian Style Burger. My daughter and son loved the milkshakes and kid's meals. Teddy's is the perfect place to go after spending all morning at the beach. All you have to do make the short drive up from Lahaina and you've got yourself a delicious meal for 1/4 of the price. I can't imagine why anyone would go to a tourist trap on Front St. when Teddy's Bigger Burger's is less that a 5 minute drive from there. It's seriously scrumptious.
(5)Tyler C.
Found this place by chance and decided to give it a shot. Really impressed with the food quality and service provided by the staff. Would recommend to anyone visiting Maui! Filling meals at decent prices. YUM.
(5)Jim S.
We spent all week eating at amazing restaurants. Had a craving for a burger. Stopped by this place and it absolutely rocked! Great shakes, garlic fries and burgers. Great price too for a family of 5. Highly recommend it!
(5)Min C.
Great food, great service, and friendly staff. I'm originally from SoCal, where there's a lot of good burger joints so I have been spoiled. So was craving a burger at lunch and decided to check out Teddy's because it had great reviews on yelp and I was not disappointed. I was ordering a custom burger but the cashier suggested I order one of the burgers that had the same toppings, nice of him to save me a little $. They give out wet naps to everyone, very thoughtful as the burgers are big and it can messy. If your hungry for a burger, definitely give them a try
(5)Mary P.
When I come back to the island this is the first place I go I always have a craving for Teddy's bigger burger. We have a home here in Maui and California I wish Teddy's was in California. We have recommended Teddy's to all of our friends that live here and the ones that come to visit no one has ever been disappointed. Thanks for a great Burger. Also the employees are very friendly. They go out of there way to make sure you're satisfied and have everything you need.
(5)Brook H.
We had just gotten off the Lana'i ferry and were looking for something simple to pick up before we headed back to Kihei. That's when Teddy's came up on our search for something tasty to eat. Oh boy did we make the right choice... First, the environment is cool. A mix of soda shop and 80's surf shop, it's a nice little place to grab a burger. The staff were friendly, even an hour before close, and made our food fresh and hot. Even when I later asked for a shake, while they were already cleaning up one of the machines for the night, they had no problem making it for me. Second, the food is awesome. The burgers are huge and they have so many awesome styles. Whatever you do, get their special sauce on it (which automatically comes that way unless you say differently). So many different cheeses, toppings, sauces, etc. I love the Waikiki, with cheddar, teriyaki, and "hashbrowns" (tater tots). The shakes? WOW. Using locally-made Maui ice cream, I couldn't stop downing mine. Pineapple shakes rock! So, if you're in Hawai`i and you see one of these places, STOP. Get some great burgers, tasty shakes, and enjoy the experience!
(4)Rebecca D.
My husband and I are visiting from Washington State for our anniversary and we stopped by Teddy's Bigger Burgers, absolutely amazing!! Our burgers tasted like we were at a backyard bbq. They were fast and friendly. Our food was fresh and hot. You must visit Teddy's if you come to Maui!
(5)Christian A.
Best burger spot on the island! Lots of menu choices that you cannot find anywhere else. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Takes a bit longer to get your food, but worth the wait IMO.
(4)Rocco P.
The Tater Tots are amazing!!!! I'd up it to 3.5 stars for the tots alone. I had the 5oz Cajun Burger with Teri sauce. The bun was delightful, soft and supple - almost a potato bread. The amount of meat seemed fine for as hungry as I was. Topping were a good choice although I was expecting the burger to be drenched with teri sauce as opposed to just having some as dressing swirled on top. I recommend. I'm a huge iced tea fan and was disappointed the tea was from a coke dispenser vs. fresh.
(3)Taylor S.
The best burger I have ever had! Every time I'm in Maui I have to stop in here a couple times a week! The staff is friendly and caring. They give you hand wipes before and after you eat. They have the best shakes (chocolate peanut butter is my fav) and burgers! It can get very crowded in here though!
(5)Jaime T.
Great service....delicious food at a really great price. They even give a good kamaaina discount. One of my favorite restaurants! Worth the drive from Kihei.
(5)Ally C.
Food is a little on the pricey side for burgers and shakes, but their service is prompt and friendly, and the food is good. We originally ordered ahead by phone and picked up so we could eat elsewhere. The food really hit the spot so a few days later we went back just for shakes. I especially liked the chocolate and peanut butter milkshake.
(4)Ania S.
We decided to come here 5 minutes to close since tropical storm Flossie caused our room service to be delayed. Lemme tell u. This place is Ahhhmmmmmmaaazzzzinnnnnnggg!!!! Hands down the most tasty, delicious, filling, juicy, perfectly cooked burger, ever. (And I'm from Chicago. We have a lot of good burger places ;) ) The service is awesome!! The guys took care of us with 5 minutes to close without an attitude or smirk that we walked in so late. thank you for a memorable meal on our Maui Honeymoon! This place is Diners, Drive ins and Dives material!!! My husband recommends "The Dude" with pulled pork....mmmmmm! And I had the red blue (bacon, frank's red hot, blue cheese) A plus too.....they have jalapeño poppers with cream cheese! I highly recommend Teddy's for a tasty and reasonably priced lunch or dinner or late night pig out :)
(5)Marcy U.
Simply one of the worst burgers I have ever eaten. First of all you get a choice of a small, medium, or large patty. However, there is only one size bun. My sad, dry, tasteless burger patty was lost in a huge, bun that would have not been so bad had they at least grilled it for a minute. As far as the staff goes, they were not overly friendly or helpful when I told them it was my first visit. I would have understood their aloofness had they been busy, which they were not, as I came in between the lunch and dinner rush at about 2:45pm. All I can say is that I'm glad I did not read the five star reviews beforehand or I would have been even more disappointed.
(1)Mariana L.
Stopped in on vacay After reading the reviews..I'm a sucker for a good burger with a local flare...this hit the spot! If you want a traditional burger or a burger with some hawaiian flavor than this is your place! I got the lahaina style burger with plantation fries (fries topped with pulled BBQ pork & cheese)..they got a variety of handmade milkshakes. Def reccomend this place, bomb..amazing!!
(5)Dustin W.
Best burger I've ever had. Would recommend to stop by for sure. Quick in and out burger joint, juicy, delicious, ......enough said.
(5)Rolly E.
I gave two stars on this mainly due to the person helping me at the counter. After he was done helping someone else he didn't ask me if I needed help he just looked at me. I walked up to him and he just looked at me without asking me what I wanted I started to place my order. I was still telling him what sandwich I wanted he saw a woman come in and started helping her taking her payment. She said your helping him first, and he said its ok your transaction is faster. WTF was that. He didn't even tell me anything I just told the lady its ok. And then he asked me what I wanted again? So I started telling him my burger and he asked me what size. I was like what sizes are there and he again stared at me like I should know the answer. So I had to skim on the menu board until I found out what he meant. And then after all said and done he almost forgot to give me my drink cause he looked at me and gave me the look of what am I still doing up there at the counter. Then when I got my food my upgraded tater tots were so overcooked that I had to throw it away. I have been to a lot of Teddys in Oahu, but this Teddys I won't come back again due to that guy that works in the front.
(2)Norman C.
Location B ( I wish it was located in Central Maui ) Service A+ ( Very frendly staff ) Menu A+ ( Decent selection ) Taste A+ ( Had the Double Bacon Cheese ) Drinks A+ ( Self serve no refill charge ) Fries C+ ( i prefer thicker fresh cut with skin ) 1st Visit A+ ( Sunday day ) 2nd Visit A+ ( Sunday day ) 3rd Visit D- ( Saturday early evening - Raw uncooked burger had to return, young cooks ) Waited extra long, no product offer or credit was issued. Overall A , Really great service and food accept for our 3rd visit. Still one of the best Burger joints in the State so far beating out Fat Burger.
(4)Lauren F.
The food was REALLY good. I think my boyfriend ordered a double bacon cheeseburger and a basket of onion rings. We were waiting for a while for the food and I must have thought it was longer only because I was soo hungry. The place wasn't very busy, but I was starting to wonder after the ticket time was about 25 minutes long. So I asked about our order. The employee said I'm sorry we don't have your ticket. I started to get worried. Thankfully they really snapped into action and gave us a delicious milkshake after a few minutes. I knew they had just made a mistake and got us an order of onion rings and the burger very quickly. I'm glad I mentioned something to them because it wasn't necessarily bad customer service, but a simple mistake. I appreciated that they made sure were happy up until we finished and left the restaurant.
(4)John M.
Teddy's is located in a newer shopping center next to Foodland across the highway from the Cannery/Safeway shopping center. Lots of free parking. It is modern, clean and the service was excellent. You order at the counter and pick up your order when it is ready. I had the 5 oz cheeseburger combo medium rare. Be sure to ask if you like other than medium well and the staff is happy to do your burger as you like it. Very generous order of fries and serve yourself drinks at a reasonable price by Lahaina standards. The cheeseburger was just the way I like it and I will definitely become a regular customer on my visits to Maui.
(5)K P.
Really good burgers! We were surprised for sure. I think for the money especially for being in HI, it was awesome. I ordered just the 5 oz original burger and it was about $6. My husband got the double patty 5 oz combo meal for $11.89. The prices are higher compared to other burger places, but worth it. Every place we've tried so far has been really really disappointing. So to come across this place is a huge plus! The bread is thick and good too. The patty was suppose to be medium but cooked a little longer so it was a tad dry. My husband loved his meal also. You can taste the charcoal flavor, which we love! The burgers were flavorful and NOT greasy!!! The fries were done perfectly too and not drenched in grease. Service was very good! Extremely friendly as soon as we walked in the door and up until we left. Very personable people. The place is really clean too. We have a lot of burger places back home in SD like In n Out, Smashburger, Burger Lounge, The Habit, Five Guys, and Hodad's. My point is Teddy's is just as good compared to those, but each place has it's own unique qualities.
(5)K M.
Ok, this is one case in which bigger is not always better. I got a little greedy and ordered a HUGE burger with all the fix-ins (pineapple, etc etc!). Although it was tasty, there was just too much meat and stuff in it that my taste buds didn't know what was going on. Overall pretty tasty, and the shake was yummy as well.
(3)Lawrence S.
This is one of the best burgers I have had on maui. I am a local and I have had burgers from lahaina to hana and this was one of the best. I had the burger with the cheddar green chilies , fried egg, bacon, and all the veggies with the fries. I was very suprised when we got our order. the burger was a meal on a bun and the burger was cooked to perfection. I am very happy I stopped in to have dinner here and I will definetly be back. all the other burgers they had up on the wall looked great so must go back and try and I hear there onion ring are really good. this was a 5 star meal without the 5 star price. just wish they would put one upcountry.
(5)MyKey D.
For me, burger was okay. I have had better. It's sad when you can say that you would rather have the burger from L & L. Maybe it was just me, but the burger I had was dry and tasteless. Loaded it with ketchup. Maybe need to go back and try again.
(3)Mike B.
Given that everything costs more in Hawaii, the value for the buck and the quality of the food is pretty darn good. For under $10, you get a great burger, fries and drink and that includes sales tax. We don't have sales tax from where I'm from. It is only 4.1667% which is amazing since have a second home in California where it is 8% + and in Europe a few times a year where GST is 18% +. Burger was cooked to order. Fries were very good. Service good too. They even came by your table and asked everyone to write a review (in house) so they are only looking for constructive feedback and ways to improve. I really liked that. I definitely would go back next time I'm in Maui.
(5)Jake B.
Awesome concept...simple burger, fries and shakes. Add all types of toppings and sauces to your burger or fries/tots. My only "complaint" was the garlic fries...they were drowned in oil and minced garlic and got soggy quick. Other than that, this is worth trying!!
(4)Marlon O.
So nice, we ate there twice! My wife and I stopped by here for lunch, and she knows how much I love burgers and fries. I ordered a green chili burger with pepper jack, and a fried egg, they called it the Ranchero Burger. My wife had a bacon avocado burger with a fried egg. Both were big portions for the price too. We also got an order of extra crispy fries. The fries were a medium cut, usually pretty soggy. These fries were crispy and a thicker cut. Amazing. Order the kona pie milkshake. I don't know of another place to get this.. Anywhere!! A must have with the burger and fries. Overall, one of the best burgers I've had in a while,
(5)Adriana N.
Mmmm!!! Their burgers are delicious :) Even the smallest size burger was too much for me! The fries are yummy! They have shakes but I didn't get to try one out this time.. hope they are tasty as well. If you are looking for a out of the norm burger joint, this is a place to go. The place was nice and clean, they have their own bathroom so that's always a plus :) They have good music on too!
(4)Craig T.
Not sure what the hype is about...maybe I just need to try the bigger special burgers. Had the Big Combo, nothing "great." The staff is fun and energetic which makes it a good experience.
(3)Jenny G.
I love this place! The burgers are amazing. Remind yourself it's called Teddy's BIGGER Burgers... They are quite enormous. (I'm guilty of ordering a child's size burger to make sure I have room for a shake. ) Service is very friendly. Staff often comes by and gives you wet wipes after you're done eating. Nice touch. Also, you can cruise the Lahaina Gateway Shopping Center when you're done. Burn off a couple of calories while buying some goodies!
(5)Eric M.
Great food and service. By far the best burgers in Maui.The onion rings are outstanding.
(5)Anna Y.
They make em big and they make em right. There is no shame in being a glutton here. They will make you a burger with as many toppings as you wish for. The fries are good, the onion rings are good, the toppings are what make it special. My only wish is that they warm up the bun entirely and not just the one half of each side. 10% kamaiana discount!
(4)John T.
Solid burgers- definitely not lighter fare! Happy friendly employees, and fat burgers! They have a giant selection of ways to make your burger, fries, onion rings, sodas, milkshakes. What more can u ask for in a burger? I go here at least once or twice a month. In Lahaina sometimes the lunch selection is not all that. Teddy's burgers always delivers a quality product.
(5)Christina W.
This place is so good! It's in a plaza that has a lot of chain restaurants, but definitely go here instead of the others! They offer Kama'aina discount too! I ordered a regular burger with cheese and everything on it...and wow...amazing! It's a classic american diner style burger with all the fixin's. The meat is cooked medium unless you say otherwise, but don't say otherwise! Our burgers were so moist (not bloody), and the grilled taste was really good! The only downside was the garlic fries. Being from the garlic capital of the world, I have a high expectation when I order garlic fries (chunks of garlic, parsley, etc), but these aren't spectacular. They're just fries with some garlic salt on them! All in all, a solid 4 stars for the amazing burgers!
(4)Susan W.
I honestly don't understand why this place has such high ratings. I walked in with a party of 6 and they told me it would take 45 minutes to get 6 burgers. We decided that was fine because of all the great reviews we had seen. After waiting for our food, we finally got 3 beef burgers, 2 veggie burgers, and one turkey burger. The beef burgers were not only dry but tasted like lighter fluid. The veggie burgers were literally black and were tasteless and although the turkey burger was juicy, it clearly came from a box. We spoke to the manager and she comped us the burnt veggie burger and gave us 2 free milkshakes which took another 10 minutes to make. I would never come back here.
(1)Rebekah B.
Self-serve old diner feeling with the tastiest burgers & milkshakes around. Everyone was extremely nice, welcoming, and accommodating. First words out of my husbands mouth receding his first bite was "This is the best burger I've ever had!" (The Lahaina burger) Somewhat pricey for a self serve joint, but think of it more as a premium self serve diner. Plus you're in a Maui, everything is a wee but more expensive.
(5)Ember D.
Really, really good!! ... My husband is a burger connoisseur who takes his burgers seriously. Me, on the other hand, who likes a burger here and there but by no means craves them, was quite happy. My husband ordered a "double monster combo" (double 9 oz. patty cheeseburger with fries and a drink). And I ordered a chicken sandwich with onion rings and a strawberry milkshake. Needless to say, my husband was in carnivore heaven and i was extremely pleased with my (seemingly simple) chicken sandwich. Their sauce is great, the onion rings were declared to be the best my husband had ever had and the strawberry milkshake was top notch! Not to mention the service was very pleasant. The young man who took our order was very patient with us newbies and even went around asking how everything was going and offered us much needed wet naps. This was our first day here and my husband said he would be very disappointed if he didn't come back at least 2 more times within the next week. The Yelp coupon was very helpful especially because between the two of us we somehow rang up a $30 bill. But that's just how much things cost here on the island.
(5)Al G.
Ordered the veggie burgers with spicy fries, we totally enjoyed the burgers and would definitely return to this place!
(4)Paw L.
It's a place I'd come back to. The place was clean and the staff very friendly. The food was awesome. While the fabled Big Kahuna burger doesn't exist, Teddy's come close. They'll cook it just the way you want it.
(5)Danny G.
Visited Teddy's while on vacation - so first time visitor. What struck me most - beyond the super tasty (and, huge!) burger, fries and shake - was the customer focused survey card that was presented to us during our visit. One question was (and, I'm paraphrasing here) "we care. does it show?" In short, it totally did. From the gent at the front counter, to the gent cleaning tables and collecting surveys - they were all stoked to be there, serving great burgers. Another question was (again, paraphrasing) "is there anything we don't serve that we should?" We rattled off suggestions - the first 4-5 of which we realized that they actually do serve those things. Minus points for us for being non-observant - bonus points for Teddy's for having all the suggestions covered!
(5)Greg L.
I had high hopes... I had a burger Hawaiian style. The sauces were perfect, but I finished those before I finished the burger. I was able to taste the burger minus the sauces and the burger was so dry. Maybe it was an off day i'm sure the reviews will balance out for these guys. The staff was very kind and the restaurant was extremely clean. You can tell these guys pay close attention to the details. Although I didn't get a chance to revisit before the close of my trip I look forward to future trips to Maui to see how they are progressing. I hear the Oahu location has won burger of the year awards. If Teddy's can stay on top of their game I hope next time I'm there i'm eating a "Best in Maui," burger. Thanks!
(3)Jade S.
Does not disappoint! It's so good every time. Will definitely be back whenever I'm in Maui
(5)Ronald S.
Teddy's is one of my favorite burger joints on Maui, I mean if I was in Vegas I'd be mauling at In N Out, but since I am not...and Teddy's is about 3 blocks from my abode, it's a 4 star rating man. The burgers are seasoned and cooked just right the way I like em...medium...and the buns soft, the veggies are fresh. When I'm hungry I'll do a double 5 with cheddar, no sauce sorry...not a fan of their sauce...but it's seasoned right so no need for that. Onion rings..a shake..can't beat it..I never had a complaint at Teddy's.
(4)Christine V.
This place is amazing and high quality. I think we ate there 3 times in one week. I know, my other half is a meat kinda guy and their milkshakes were da' bomb. Seriously. Not for atmosphere as much as for the delicious burgers. Given the alternative of a terrible burger with an ocean view, I'd just as soon pick up my Teddy Burger and drive to the beach. Yummm!
(5)Lars B.
Absolutely fantastic burgers - the flavor is out of this world. Staff is friendly - especially if they notice you've never been there before, as they will take as much time as you need to have the menu explained to you. Shakes are to die for, and fries are cooked to perfection. I only wish it was available in Iowa :(
(5)Matthew B.
If you're looking for a burger on Maui, this is the place to go. The burger was cooked just right. Juicy, seasoned, and full of flavor. The garlic fries were delicious, and the milkshakes are creamy and thick. There are a bunch of good burger choices on the menu. But if you don't find something to suit your mood, you can create your own. The prices are on par with similar joints on Maui.....about 10-15 bucks a person. The restaurant was clean and there is a bunch of seating available. Service was fast and the order was accurate.
(4)Mike L.
I was only able to come here once during my week vacation. I really liked the menu and all the specialty burgers. I ordered the Lahaina burger and it was ok, I really expected it to be great and it just wasn't. I really want to go back though and try all the other burgers because I know there has to be some great ones that I will like .
(3)Paul L.
Great selection of burgers. I was really happy with what I got and garlic fries were killer
(4)Amy G.
Good burgers, slow service. It took us a while to get our order even though it wasn't confusing. The questionnaire says you should be getting your food within 10-15 minutes and it took at least 20, we were the first ones there too. We had the #1 with pineapple and it tasted great so the wait was worth it in my book. I wouldn't compare it to in and out nor 5 guys, I would say it holds it's own.
(4)John G.
OMG. That's it - just O M G. I would move to Maui for many many reasons, but near the top of this list would be so that I could eat here as often as possible. Yes, I know that I would end up looking like Iz Kamakawiwoole (no disrespect at all intended to the man), but I would do it anyway. Picture your ideal burger joint. then picture being able to put just about anything you would want to your burger. Now double that and make it taste heavenly. That's Teddy's. Their avocado burger comes with half a freaking avocado on it - not just a couple anemic slices! Of course, I asked where the other half of the avocado was - but that's just me. Do yourself a favor and try this place out. I guarantee you will want to go back.
(5)Alia C.
I have had better....if you want a cheap decent burger go to teddies. Maybe we are picky burger eaters...maybe ask for extra "special sauce" on the side. Very good deal since you get a burger, fries, and drink under $10...we didn't try the shake maybe I would have rated higher.
(3)Shanel S.
Always a big fan of Teddy's. Wish they had the fried jalepeno's that they do in the Manoa store.
(4)Bruce C.
A very good chain restaurant, which we can use more here on Maui. I like this place for many reasons: quality, quantity, service, and consistency. When you walk up to the counter you can be sure that you're going to have a great meal the way you want it.
(5)Liz G.
Big, juicy burgers! Need I say more? I tried the one with avocado and had the cheese sauce on the side. The garlic butter fries were good too. Very yummy. If you're gonna eat a burger on Maui, this is the place to go.
(5)Leslie C.
This place was fantastic! Many different things on the menu. Hoping to go back before we head home:)
(5)Victoria L.
Sad to say that we just got garlic fries and they were a disappointment. They were just fries with seasoning. But my brother in law and family got burgers and loved them! Just was sad because I'm obsessed with garlic fries and that's what I was expecting.
(2)Scott S.
Very Tasty. Food was good, service was good. Ideally it's nice to have variety. I ordered way too much food (thanks yelp coupon). Big burger with pineapple, jalapenos, cheese and special sauce. Only gripe... They charge for extra sauces.
(4)John B.
Great tator tots and vanilla shake and corn dog was just ok. Will go back to try burgers
(4)Henry T.
It's a burger joint! Took my wife and kids here on 4/7/12 at about 7pm. I had the #3 combo which is a 9 oz burger patty. The wife had a #2 combo with a 7 oz patty and my kids split a #1 combo with a 5 oz patty. The combos come with fries and drinks. The burgers were good, nothing to be excited about but convenient if you want a backyard grilled burger with the backyard grilling. We barely got any of their burger sauce almost non-exsistent had I known I would have asked for extra sauce. Alot of food and the it's worth the price as the saying goes "you get what you pay for." The wife and kids enjoyed the fries, big ole thick cut fries and the quantity they give is enormous. I'd prefer a little more burger patty then fries so next time I'll get their combo #4 which is a 16 oz patty. Hey, it was my cheat day and it was well worth it. We'll definitely go back to try more of their menu.
(4)C C.
Good burgers, kind of messy. The pattys are just like you would make at home. Not the patty type that you buy frozen but the type you roll up handmake. Probably wouldn't go back
(3)John M.
This place was pretty decent but a little pricey for a casual burger joint. I actually had the fish and chips which were slightly overly breaded. It is a nice break from the usual Hawaiian cuisine when you're on Maui..and its not like there is an In-N-Out or Five Guys anywhere near by LOL Plenty of seating, clean and pretty quick considering the food is made to order. Its in a strip mall, so its not the easiet to spot.
(3)Mary S.
Great service & WOW, amazing portions. I had the 5 oz Bacon Me Crazy & I am having a hard time finishing it. Had the old school taters & used tge $12 for $20 deal & feel like we got a great deal & have way more than we can eat & it tasted great !! Highly recommend.
(4)Susan W.
Got the yelp $12 for $20 deal certificate as soon as I saw it knowing we were going to Maui in February. Also got one for Mom & Dad who we were meeting on Maui. We normally go for burgers at Red Robin so I will base my review on a comparison of the 2. Red Robin wins hand down in every category. I greatly prefer sitting down with a menu than standing & trying to read the menu while people line up behind me. And Teddys menu does not list the prices for half of their burgers & fries cost extra. Their pricing for a meal deal is no deal. And Red Robin has beer, wine & cocktails. The lighting was too bright & the primary color scheme made me feel like I was in kindergarten. In Teddys favor the onion rings were amazing!! Burger meat flavor was good but too raw for Moms liking. (she likes med rare steak too) Friendly workers & clean restaurant. The yelp deal did not cover our dinner. :( Had to fork over an extra $5. $20 at Red Robin would have covered both burgers but no beverage. I don't think I would go there again. If I was craving a burger I'd go to Moose McGillicuddys in Lahaina on burger night.
(3)Savan P.
Everything is just delicious. Veggie burger was appetizing and they have 4 varieties of fries. Milkshakes are made from hefty amounts of ice cream. Great combinations and they have plenty of add on ingredients.
(5)Reed F.
I figured it was about time for an update! We go maybe twice a month since I had something of an epiphany, this place is basically a fast food burger place done right. It costs maybe 10-20% more than the place with the clown but that 20% buys you more food and better quality food. If we get the urge for a burger we go here and not the clown shack. As a family of four we just ate, all had burgers (the kids had the kids cheeseburger meals, I had a 7oz teri the better half had a 7oz original with an extra, garlic butter fries and drinks for the adults plus 4 special sauces) and the total including Kama'aina discount was $32. $8 bucks a head and could have been cheaper. You can most definitely spend more if you want, you can even make it cheaper if you ditch the upgrades we had, but thats insanely good value for the quality. While you cannot do much about the quality of the soda, the milkshakes are an awesome alternative, the patties are made with real chuck (no ground up connective tissue \ ears \ hooves etc), shaped by hand. None of that dubious grey 'meat' you find elsewhere. I was bored and watched them make up some patties, it's basically the same as you do at home (ok I wish I could do it that well at home :)). The buns are perfect, not the plasticy tasting corn syrup bread that will last 20 years without going moldy but nice fresh bread. Honestly it left me wondering how on earth the fast food joints get away with charging so much considering the poor quality of the ingredients they use. One of the real tell tale signs is you walk away from here full for your $7-8 and you stay full, theres no wearing off of a sugar rush like at the grey burger places that leave you hungry a couple of hours later. This isn't a full service front street restaurant, it isn't trying to be one, nor is it a 99 cent menu place serving burgers made from parts of a cow even its mother wouldn't recognize. It is basically a fastish (as fast as cooked to order gets) food burger joint serving quality fresh food for a small and reasonable premium. Personally I consider it entirely worth it. For as long as it has been open I have experienced a consistent high level of product and service. The staff are great, seriously happy, friendly, efficient and it makes for a nice atmosphere. There is a constant variation on milkshakes and special burgers so you don't get bored. You can spend as little or as much as you want. If you order a lot of toppings then honestly, yes, it is going to cost more but if you go into the clown place can you get half an avacado on your burger or a huge serving of pulled pork, will it be cooked fresh or will it have sat there for 20 minutes? It's great to have a choice but I think some folks misunderstand what this place is trying to be. Besides longer opening hours (although I may be the only person craving a teddy burger at 1am), the only thing I would like to see is an option to use some more local ingredients, maybe some local organic veg (a nice thick slab of local tomato would be perfect) and Maui Beef. An extra buck or buck 50 for Maui grass fed beef would be worth it for me and I think it would fit with the brand, at least as an upgrade. Maybe a kimchee topping?
(5)Keoki R.
Great service and food ! We stop by at least once a week for the mahi burger with garlic butter fries . For dessert a strawberry shake that takes a little while to make but worth the wait !
(5)Christine I.
Oh Teddy's, you were a life saver the night we got into Maui. After a week of wedding activities on the Big Island we were ready to relax. Hubs needed some familiarity after me forcing him to try all the local food that I missed so dearly - saimin, portuguese sausage, poke, lau lau...gah, that's enough. He is a burger, steak and potato eater, so it took a lot out of him. I read through some reviews and saw "In 'n Out" as a comparison, oh do not be mistaken, this is much better than In 'n Out. The meat is fresh and cooked well and the combinations of flavors they have on the menu is outstanding. There is this butter garlic sauce they put on their fries that I can only imagine what God's tears taste like. They have three different sizes of burgers and we're glad we went with the "smallest" at 5oz, it was more than enough. I ordered the mushroom swiss combo, the Hubs ordered the teri burger that had a hash brown on top - he looked happier than he did at the alter. Thanks for kicking off a great honeymoon!
(5)Lee C.
The Cajun Burger here is in the Top 5 Best Burgers that have ever been in my mouth! Love the fries! Delish!
(5)Chris G.
I'm from CA, and I read an earlier review suggesting that IN-N-OUT has this place easily beat. Not so fast...yes, IN-N-OUT remains my barometer for tasty burgers, but Teddy's brings something different to the table (pun intended), and there is no shame in their burger. Teddy's is super friendly, walk in the door and you hear, "Welcome to Teddy's Burgers". The decor and vibe is a cross between Hot dog On A Stick (color scheme) and Johnny Rockets (old school diner). Whatever the case, it works. Their motto is that they don't make 'fast food', rather, they make food that is worth the wait, and it is! Every burger is fresh beef and hand packed that day, they make a R-E-A-L burger that you might have at a backyard BBQ, i.e. size and quality! You can pick from a variety of toppings, and also some predetermined scrumptious combinations (see the big board behind register). You can also choose the size of your patty, 5oz, 7oz, or 9oz. The 7oz will certainly satisfy your hunger, the 9oz will leave you full until your next meal, no question. On this stop I went for the medium prepared, 7oz Teri (Sweet BBQ glaze, lettuce, tomato, pickle & onion). So flippin' good! The bun is also fresh, with remnants of flour on the top. If you really want to go for the full experience, get the combo with fries, AND add a hand made ice cream shake. My wife and kids devoured the Combo #2 with bacon & bleu cheese. I was able to steal a bite myself, and this burger was AWESOME. As mentioned, the servers are salt of the Earth friendly, and the flavor is tasty. This is more of a burger experience than an IN-N-OUT, it will probably take 20+ minutes to place your order, get your food, and eat your hearty burger. Teddy's has a few locations, I've indulged myself at 3 locations and always been happy with my eating experience. In summation: big burger, big taste, venue with big personality.
(4)Howie Z.
The mahi burger was great!!! Must have the Plantation fries, with garlic butter. Bacado burger, one of the best. Listen to Mark, for the French fries and onion ring pairings.
(5)Michael O.
Food and service was awesome! Highly recommend! Try your burger Hawaiian style! Quite delicious!
(5)Brooke E.
Ya I can dig it
(4)Kristy N.
We came here twice while on vacation. The first time I got just a regular bacon cheeseburger and the hubby got the pastrami Swiss burger with a side of extra crunchy jalapeño cheesy fries. Everything disappeared in front of us within seconds, and I'm the type of girl who ALWAYS has leftovers. So good! The second time the hubby got his usual and I tried the Hawaii burger with add on bacon and cheese. And again with the side of jalapeño cheese fries. We will definitely come back here again on our next visit to Maui :)
(5)Danielle L.
Pretty good burgers and really great onion rings. We went there tonight looking for a quick and cheap meal; this was quick but not reasonably priced. The burgers were good. I got the Waikiki and my husband got the Bacon Me Crazy. He thoroughly enjoyed his and mine was okay. We both prefer Cheeseburger in Paradise for the money though.
(4)Jennifer S.
All the reviews sounded so promising and the pics looked good....but for us it wasn't that great. The onion rings were awful, tasted like some bad frozen grocery store version. My combo came with crispy fries. They tasted like no one changed the oil in the fryer in months. The burger seemed dry to me. To top it all off, it cost us $35 for 2 burger combos and an order of onion rings. Honestly I think carl's jr makes a much better burger.
(2)Shannon A.
I really like this place, burgers are nice and juicy, and the shakes are delicious and super thick (that's what she said), but I had to knock off a star for service. The employees there are all so sweet but it's just really, really slow. I'm here today on a Saturday, and they cannot keep up with the amount of people pouring through the door. I ordered two shakes 30 minutes ago and they still haven't gotten to my order yet (i asked and they said it would be up next). More shake makers please! But, I will still return.
(3)Russell C.
Maybe its just because we dont have very many good burger places here but i think this place is pretty darn good. It caters to everybody by having a great selection of things you can put on your burger. Came here the other day and ordered my usual University burger in the 9oz variety, comes with cheddar cheese hashbrown and spicy teriyaki sauce, then i decide to go crazy and i added pastrami and a side of butter garlic tots. Order comes up and i swear that when i went to pick it up i was gonna start eating at the counter. It looked amazing, then i bit into it, and started have Nirvana like trip that blew every part of my taste buds away. Sweet and savory, crunchy and soft and tender. It was amazing, they i got into the butter garlic tater tots which are drenced in melted butter, garlic and parsley. OMG i dunno if i was just really hungry or i found "my" go to meal. Great now im hungry !
(5)Nadia H.
I'm really not sure what the hub bub is about. My burger was blah. I'm wondering if this place is all about the toppings, and all this excitement is really just, "the massive combination of toppings that totally hid the flavor of the burger were so great!" I am not a tons-o-toppings gal, as some of my previous reviews have shared. So if you are, please move along, this review is not for you. If you, like me, like to enjoy the burger itself - this place did not deliver. Burger was not medium, it was definitely a dry-well-done. Nothing unique or flavorful about it. Onion rings were decently good.
(2)Taylor B.
Not quite sure what all the hype is about. It's a basic burger joint covered in contemporary colored seating and ceiling tiles making it look like a kids play house. Staff was friendly but it was a bit pricey for a plain cheeseburger and fries.
(2)Alessandra H.
Great burgers! Excellent service. Fast even though it was busy and late. Only tiny complaint is our burgers were a little on the rare side, but still delightful. We would go back. Affordable for Maui food.
(4)Meghana B.
This is one of the best burger joints I have come across so far. There are tons of choices for the burgers to suit all your palettes - spicy, sweet, rustic, old-fashioned... The patty is flavorful and succulent. I had the fish burger and that is something totally worth trying...
(4)Marty K.
I haven't sampled many burgers in Lahaina but the burger was cooked well and the price was acceptable for Maui. ($15 for a 9oz burger, Garlic fries and a drink). I ordered the Bacado burger. It needed double bacon and double cheese. If it's food you want, check it out. If it's a view and ambiance then keep looking. it's a 50's themed burger "joint". Tip: skip the garlic fries. I might try the plantation fries next time.
(3)Andrea S.
The original burger is good but the fries with garlic are even better and alone a reason to come here. In case your really want to punish yourself, go for the healthy crossfit burger, possibly after a training in the nearby box. Mahi Mahi is a good choice as well but nowhere close to the others.
(4)Bianca R.
Great burgers, ok fries. Try the Lahaina burger with teriyaki chicken, no aioli. Yum!
(4)David L.
The only thing better than the food was the staff. Great burger, great fries. So much better than Cool Cat Cafe.. not even close. Ask for double vegetables and double sauce and you'll never be disappointed. Offered senior discount without having to ask for it (must be all the grey) Couldn't give a higher recommendation, maybe even better than the double double from In & out David & Cheri
(5)Carolyn A.
The shakes and malts were good. The rest? Not so much. The burger was ok, the fries mediocre, and the big ole bun was stale. We kept asking about our shakes and was told they would bring them out to us. The high point was the shakes - which we finally got as we headed out the door.
(2)Anh T.
OMG these burgers are so good. Burgers are so delicious and I don't know what they did to their but it is so good. You can get the burgers in a multitude of sizes and the smallest one is sufficient for me. But the oscar goes to the garlic fries. I had a lot o garlic fries in my lifetime but I've never had garlic fries with garlic SO SWEET. I could have mistaken them for caramelized onions. Don't cheat yourself, treat yourself... with these fries. SERIOUSLY you won't regret it!
(5)Chalette H.
I changed my mind will go back.
(5)Trevor J.
I enjoyed the divey atmosphere and reminded me of a Johnny Rockets. The food was really good and I enjoyed the burger. The milkshake was something on a hot day that was a necessity. The only reason a star is deducted is due to the price of the burgers. The ratio of cost vs. enjoyment isn't worthy of a 5 star, but it definitely worth trying if you can put away a big burger.
(4)Cassandra D.
Been to Teddy's 3 TIMES! Loved their burgers&fries every single time! My first was located in Oahu and the other two visits were in Maui! Excellent burgers! The beef patties are so lean and perfectly cooked to however you like it! The sizes of pattoes go from 5-9 oz. I always get 7, just right for me. The Waikiki, University, and King of the Dojo burgers are OFF THE CHARTS. I think ALL of their burgers and sides are very good. YOU MUST COME HERE!
(5)Michael G.
Burgers are overcooked, why do you ask if medium is okay but then you go ahead and burn them? EXPENSIVE $8 for a 7 oz hamburger??? Great fries. $3.99 for 4 chicken nuggets.
(2)Lance T.
I'd eat at Teddy's, in fact I'd eat there all the time if they would change their burger buns. The bun is literally stopping me from eating there. I thought about ordering a burger and taking it home and putting it on my own bun bought from Safeway. At Least then the burger won't disintegrate in my hands while I'm trying to eat it. Shakes are good, fries are good, burgers cooked well, and the bun literally kills the deal! Change it or offer a better bun for more money and I'll come back.
(3)Kristie F.
Excellent food and service .we didn't mind paying a little extra for frest and fast food. After we walked across the plaza for icecream. Easy to find .
(5)David P.
I like that they read all about how 5 Guys works and their business model, but this falls way short in all regards. The grown-nearby ingredients and discount if you say you are local are nice, but after that its just hastily made, sloppy burgers with inconsistent toppings and shakes made from syrup. The employees don't help the ambience as they mumble what you hope is your order in a blank stare and go back to texting as soon as you pay. So sorry we interrupted them! I wish we had gone to Cheeseburgers In Paradise instead.
(2)Mari N.
I've always enjoyed taking the long drive from town to come to Lahaina specially for Teddy's Bigger Burgers but I'm extremely disappointed on my last visit this past time. I should have known upon entering that something was wrong. There was a long line (which is normal on any friday night) however, these customers were coming up to say their order was either wrong or worse - their burgers weren't fully cooked!! Decided to ignore that fact and stood in line. When it came to my turn, we weren't greeted with any greetings, not even a "hi, may I take your order?" Nothing. The guy just stared at us like aliens. Strike one. He didn't seem to know the menu at all and didn't correctly ring up my original order. It took 3 tries and another employee being in my opinion very rude to the customer - like I had made a mistake when I was making my order. Strike two. We sat down to wait for our food and changed from three different tables because while the tables were clean - the seats were greasy and the floors were filthy. Like the employees just wiped the contents from the table onto the floor. The food wasn't even at the table yet and I wanted to leave. Strike three, your out. My overall experience this time is disappointing and to make the drive out to Lahaina, I think I'll carefully choose next time. My chicken sandwich was the same - I enjoyed it. However, the burgers my family ordered were still red and bloody. Maybe management changed but I hope someone gets a handle on the situation because I've always enjoyed the food here at Teddy's, I'd hate to see a great business crumble from employee inattentiveness.
(2)Michael C.
Was hard to find the place since the signage was confusing and not clear plus google maps gives you incorrect directions. So we started off a little unhappy. The main menu is unclear what is on the burger and if you want one of the featured burgers, that menu is way off to the left and a bit confusing. The burgers were just average and the fries just ok. The onion rings were crispy but in my opinion too much batter and not much onion. The soda machine did not have any carbonation so yucky. Not sure why this place is 4 1/2 stars!! Really???
(1)Chris B.
Aside from the great prices, this place was delicious. Got a 7oz terry burger..... Nom nom!! I Love the customization, and the service is always friendly.
(4)Ling L.
I really wanted this place to be great! Service was great. The people seem to like working there. Fries- the best fries i have had on the island so far. fried to order and freshly cut with perfect thickness. Cajun burger -cajun flavoring of the meat was good. Just a slight kick. Sauce and toppings were also good but the meat should be the star of the burger and it was dry. Also they advertise this as sweet and spicy and i did not get much of the sweet. Since this is a burger joint i need to deduct points for dry meat. I'm willing to give the other burgers a try. And overall everything seemed fresh.
(3)Lisa W.
Good, fast service. Great flavor burgers, fries & shakes. 5 out of 5 stars all the way!
(5)Kathy S.
I've always loved Teddy's...I've been going to the one in Honolulu, and didn't know that there was one on Maui! Burgers are always juicy and tasty. We needed a light snack after a disappointing lunch at a nearby noodle place one day. When I found Teddy's nearby on Yelp, we headed straight for there! The original Burger with Cheese is always a good choice, but.. if you're hungry, go for the Monster Double Combo with bacon, mushroom, and jalapenos! Yum! The Garlic Tots are always a favorite, but the onion rings are really good too! Prices are decent, but beware, if you eat too much, you'll end up with the kanack-attack!
(5)Barrett F.
Delicious food and shakes, relaxed ambiance, and fresh food prepared quickly, without being fast food. Friendly workers, clean eating area, and enjoyable music. It's off the normal tourist path of lahaina and ka'anapali, and is a great gem.
(5)Brig V.
I know Cheeseburgers & so does Teddy's! They also know how to make you feel welcome. I was thrilled to find them tucked back off the local drag in Lahaina. Prices were reasonable and food was beyond fantastic. I ate there 2 days in a row and the staff was so helpful going out of their way to ensure the restaurant was clean and the customers were overly satisfied. Order a milkshake here! and of course a Cheeseburger.
(5)Dj P.
Our burgers were super dry. Not sure why they ask how you'd like your burger cooked because no matter what our order was...all of our burgers came out dry. Their buns are too big...not tasty. The best part were the tots..but how can you go wrong w/ those? Just fry them up!! Go grab a burger at Shark Pit Maui..for a juicy burger..and a better experience.
(2)Grace V.
Had the Lahaina burger combo with the garlic fries. Al were very good but I don't think it was worth $14. However I did enjoy it and the service was good.
(4)Don M.
After eating at restaurant after restaurant, I was craving a hamburger in a casual setting. I stumbled onto this place and got a great restaurant quality burger (if not better). They have six sizes of burgers (three size patties with the option of a single or a double). They also offer turkey burgers. Their specialty burgers are great. I had the Ranchero Burger and it was great. I would have prefered the fried egg to be runny, so if I make it back there, I will request it that way. I enjoyed this place so much, I stopped by again on the way to the airport and took it with me. Somehow I managed to eat it before I made it there. It was awesome. Visited December 2012
(5)Miko M.
over-rated and over-priced. I have no idea how this place has 4.5 stars! The only thing I can think of is that Maui must not have very many good burger places. I'm from SoCal and there are a lot of amazing burger options, so maybe this has something to do with my huge disappointment. What I did LIKE: I liked the variety of toppings and sauces available for the burgers. I had the cheese fries and they were pretty decent. (nothing amazing) My turkey burger was juicy and did have decent flavor. Why I was so disappointed: It's very over-priced for what your get and the quality. It's FAST FOOD...which would be ok, if the food was better. The actual beef burger was tasteless (according to my bf) The bun looks great in the picture.....but was just a cold white bun, not even toasted. If you are visiting Maui (like I was), skip this mediocre place and spend your money elsewhere. If you are from Maui and it's your only burger option, well....I feel bad for you...you should come visit Cali and experience In-n-out or Umami Burger or The Counter to name a few.
(2)Lars J.
The number 4 is HUGE! Large garlic fries are HUGE! It's not cheap. Were talking a $14 burger here. But it's worth it. The fries are perfectly crisp and the garlic isn't overpowering. Bottomless soda.
(5)Nate S.
Great little spot in west Maui. 50s themed burger joint. Very creative burgers or just your plain old hamburger. We had the pigskin burger and the Hawaiian style classic. The pigskin was a normal burger with pulled pork and a fire sauce on top. Not too spicy though. The Hawaiian style had pineapple and a teriyaki sauce. Both burger were very tasty. The beef itself was juicy and had a great beef taste. We upgraded to tater tots. Those were some of the best tater tots I have ever had. They were crispy but not overdone and had a wonderful seasoning. The place is a little pricey. $27 for two burgers, upgraded tots, and a milkshake. The service was wonderful. They were very knowledgeable about their menu items and very friendly to us. I definitely recommend.
(5)Sherwin A.
Staff seems to be friendly. Walked in and was asked if I've been there before. I said no and they explained the full menu. Burger options were unique and tasty. I got the Lahaina style burger with garlic fries and chocolate peanut butter milk shake. It was pretty expensive for a burger combo ($15) but I was on vacation so I didn't mind the price. I just wanted to try it out. I was satisfied with the meal. If I were to make a complaint, it would be that the burger can get wet, break apart, and get messy.
(4)Jim H.
It was ok. A little spendy for what we got. Of course looking at others' reviews I see there is a coupon I missed out on - ah well. We came in the evening when there wasn't much of a wait. I probably would have been annoyed if I had waited 40 mins like one of the other reviewers. I enjoyed Paradise and Cool Cat more. Interior was a lot like other fast food places.
(3)T. T.
Finally a decent veggie burger in Lahaina! Yes! The servers and cashiers were all super friendly and they were working hard to keep things moving. I appreciated the fact that the restaurant was relatively clean and bright. The burgers were great (both the beef and the veggie) except for the potato buns that kept falling apart. Next time I'm ordering the wheat bun. The onion rings were nice and crispy and my 2yr old loved having tater tots instead of fries. Brilliant! The garlic fries were the only miss in my book. They looked amazing, but tasted like sugar and butter with some crushed garlic. Ick. We'll be back again. Now to find that coupon everyone is talking about...
(4)Day B.
Best burger in Lahaina! Can't really say which burger is best because it's a toss up. The shakes are good, the fries are good and there's always good seats.
(5)Chris D.
Food was great and reasonably priced! Pros: prices are reasonable and meals are big enough for two to share! I had a chocolate shake (black and white) and it was delicious!!! The fries are also great and fresh. Cons: we had a crispy chicken sandwich and were not big fans of the mustard sauce on it.
(5)Tamra P.
A week long vacation included indulging in lots of Food Network. Yes, I was in Maui and should be doing lots of things other than watching TV but whatever. It's not my first time here and being a FT working mom with 2 under 2 having some time to watch any TV is a luxurious indulgence. So anyway.....it had me craving a juicy burger. While I really wanted to try somewhere new Teddy's had the best reviews for burgers in the area. Tried and true at home, I sent the hubby to pick up a Kailua burger with onion rings. Ooohhhh how delicious this was! I ordered it well done, light on the sauce (yes burger foodies I can feel you cringing) but that's how I like my burgers and despite the request it was still juicy perfection to me. A 5 oz burger and half the onion rings were plenty to have me satisfied. Hubby loved his selection as well, particularly the peanut butter shake. Glad to see the Maui Teddy's at least as good as the ones on Oahu!
(4)Mikihala M.
Excellent burgers for the price. So filling!! The nephews loved it! Adults loved it! Best shakes around!
(4)Brent W.
The food was meh, but we are in Hawaii. Extra stars for super nice staff. I got the plantation tots. They were short on the pulled pork and had a super spicy BBQ sauce. Others in our group got various burgers. Definitely pink in the middle. Most in our group did not finish their meals, but it was a fun atmosphere. Getting to the place google maps had us at a dead end in a residential area. This time apple maps is better.
(4)Madison H.
Wow these hamburgers were awesome! Would recommend the western burger and the Lahina burger! Very fresh and be prepared to be stuffed afterwards. The spicy fries and garlic fries were Devine as well. Awesome spot for a meal for lunch! Would highly recommend!!!
(5)Tim W.
After a day on the beach and in the sun, our Teddy's burger hit the spot. The burgers are huge so I didn't even attempt a bigger burger. The service was friendly and the place was clean. For the area the price was very reasonable, my burger combo was 10 bucks. Its a laid back atmosphere and a good place for families who just want the all-american burger.
(5)Mark P.
I'm in outside sales so I eat out a LOT! In fact, I am a burger connoisseur! This place serves one of the best burgers around. Probably ranks in my TOP 3 or 4 . Alex took our order and he was awesome. He was friendly, helpful, and enjoyable to talk with. Like I said, I eat out a lot and some places hire the most incredible idiots that won't even say "thank you" or engage you in conversation in any way. Or worse yet, they'll just grunt at you because they really don't want to be there. This place is clean, the people were great, the food was awesome AND they do a classic car show. I missed it, but anyplace that's into hot rods can't be ignored. On top of that, I didn't see one homeless dirtbag loitering around (unlike McDonald's) We're definitely going back! They run a top notch operation!
(5)Doug S.
I've been wanting to try this place as I am a burger aficionado. Having tried every burger place on Maui, I finally spent several days at home perfecting the burger the way I like them, including grinding my own beef and making my own buns. As expected, no one can come to close to my burger, so I do have a built in bias. LOL. Sadly, unless you know me and get a personal invite for my homemade burger and fries, you'll have to suffer and pay for a high priced premium burger at either Teddy's or Cool Cats. Burger lovers come in many shapes and sizes. Personally, I am partial to the burger cooked on a griddle and not too thick as I think it preserves the juiciness of the meat and gives the best meat to bun ratio. That being said, Teddy's is a charbroiled burger and for that style, they do it as good as anyone. I made the mistake of ordering the double when I should have ordered the single. I started pooping out about 3/4 of the way through. Don't get me wrong, it was good. I always stick with the traditional burger with cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and whatever house sauce that is offered. I ordered the regular fries (thick cut style) and they were good as well. IMHO, I believe this burger tops Cool Cat's burger, but of course it is a close toss up.
(5)Christine K.
Teddy's Bigger Burger's was my favorite place to eat during my stay in West Maui. I tried over five different restaurants near the resort area, and Teddy's was worth every buck. I ordered the 5 oz burger and customized it. The burger comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, and their special sauce, but I added grilled onions and jalepenos. It was perfect! The patty was not dry and cooked nicely. My boyfriend was starving and ordered the 7 oz, but I think the 5 oz burger will satisfy most. This place is a lot cheaper than other restaurants that I checked out like Hula Grill and Kimo's, but the food is up to par. Definitely worth the try!
(4)M C.
Dude...where are the burgers??? I visited this past Monday and was told that their grill was out of service, so only fried foods were being offered. What kind of burger place has only one grill and has to stop making their signature item when it has a malfunction? The family wound up getting very overpriced chicken sandwiches and average fries, but only after a 20+ minute wait after we had ordered. Apparently, the staff at this location are very slow and don't know how to prioritize orders. People who came in after us were served 5-10 minutes before us with their food. I had to go up to the counter to ask what was up with the long wait and I can't remember the last time I had to do that at any dining establishment (and they didn't even have burgers...you don't fry food for over 20 minutes, so not sure what the people in the kitchen were up to). The staff was apologetic and asked us to call prior to coming in next time to see if their grill was working and if they were serving burgers. Needless to say, I wasn't going to give them my business for another overpriced meal after the insanely slow service. It's a shame because I had really wanted to try their burgers, but tourists can't waste time revisiting a food joint on precious vacation time after such a poor first impression.
(1)G. M.
This is a LOVE HATE relationship for me. My weakness is really good burgers, and they have nailed it here. I try to limit myself to once every couple of months. If weight or health were not important to me...I'd be here all the time.
(5)J D.
Great burgers. Need some time to figure how to order. Build to order is the best way. You can upgrade your soda to a shake but they don't really tell you that upfront. Clean sitting area. Burgers can be burnt so order to taste. By default it's well done and charred. Great place after all is done. No beer.
(4)Artemis I.
I tried the original burger with cheese. Big fan!! It was delicious!! I want another one! The milkshake however, tasted a bit too much like just ice cream and the consistency was more like ice cream than a milkshake. Nonetheless, I will be back here!! I want to try all the burgers!
(4)Brandon Y.
Ordered two burgers, 5 oz and 7 oz. Waited a long time to get order. Both burgers were served very rare. Bloody rare. So rare that the buns were soaking up the red bloody liquid. Asked staff to cook burger a bit longer. Waited another 15 minutes to get burger. I would never come back here again. Worst burger i've had in a long time.
(1)Karen S.
Wow! This place lived up to it's reviews. My hamburger was rare enough to moo. My garlic fries were piled high with garlic and dripping with butter. My chocolate milkshake was one of the very best I have ever had. My nutritionist would not be happy about my calorie intake, but I enjoyed my meal to the last morsel. Excellent!
(5)Phung H.
The Mahi Burger is soo good! Gotta get the special sauce. Fries are crispy and thick! Highly recommend!
(5)Lilian S.
UPDATE: I just went back to Teddy's to give it one more chance and they got my order right! Finally! Also, my burger was delicious. The owner wrote me back and apologized for the wrong order incidents. I'm glad such a caring person owns this Maui restaurant. 5 stars! I'm officially finished going to THIS Teddy's Bigger Burger. The past three times I've visited this restaurant, the cooks got my order wrong! I have come to the conclusion that this was not a mistake made by the person taking my order because he put in my order correctly on the register (therefore my receipt). The cooks are continuously talking amongst one another, incredibly slow, and did not get the orders correct. I was contemplating taking my order back, but I feared my next burger would have more than what I asked for on it. I ordered an original with cheese, sauce, and grilled onions. The burger I received was an original with sauce. Therefore, I paid extra for items I did not receive on my burger. I'm disappointed because I truly enjoy these burgers on Oahu (I just moved back to Maui). I guess I'll have to find another burger joint.
(5)Andrea C.
Wow, the burgers at Teddy's are really amazing. what a super great find. I will visit this place every time I'm in Hawaii!
(5)Evan F.
Really thick, juicy burgers. I especially like the potato bun. I'm not the biggest fan of their fries, but I do like their tater tots. Plus, if you happen to be from or live in Hawaii, you get a kama'aina discount, which helps since it can be pricey.
(4)Cid H.
A decent burger, but don't come in with high expectations. It's your basic Five Guys clone, with the added twist of a few local-style specialty burgers. I ordered one of the spicier burger options (pepper jack cheese and grilled hot pepper), and it was okay. The fries were also...okay. The burgers themselves were slightly dry, and they were cooked medium when I asked for medium-well. Again, it's an okay burger joint if you're looking for standard burger fare. And since the restaurant itself is colorful and "fun," I imagine younger kids would probably like it. But I'm not seven and I was hoping for something a little better.
(3)Joshua O.
I must say. "Mighty Tasty" its hard to f up a burger. Ive seen it done before. This place is definitely not one of those places. I had the 5oz western burger, comes with a drink and fries. Mmmm... Fat boy delight. The wife had the mahi fish & chips. Pretty bomb. The lady ringing us up. Vicky. Good spirited gal. Very friendly and helpful. She recommended the pumpkin shake. The best I ever tasted. I will be back. Most definitely.
(5)Rob K.
The burger is bigger, and better, than anything else you will find in Lahaina. Great value too! Definitely coming back on my next visit.
(5)Sep G.
This place would be a go to if I lived on this beautiful island!!! Clean, good food, fresh ingredients and great service. Try the crispy chicken sandwich, if your not in to burgers as my wife can be picky at times. Defiantly try the onion rings(soooo good) and the burgers are tasty and fresh. Great casual quick burger joint on the island!! Mahalo!
(5)Paul H.
Found Teddy's in a little strip mall across the street from the Lahaina Cannery Mall when looking for a place to grab a good burger for lunch while vacationing in Kaanapali. Had their original burger combo with cheese. The place reminded me of an In 'N Out or a Five Guys with their small menu and ordering system. The burgers were cooked to order and took a little over five minutes to come out. Burger had great flavor and was hot and juicy. The fries were nice and crisp and not greasy at all. Definitely worthy of the good reviews they've received.
(4)Eugene S.
Just ok. Super expensive and slow. Probably would not return. Burgers were good, but no better than any other typical burger joint. Our 4 burgers came out well done. The menu says they'll be medium. Strawberry and chocolate shakes were good. The fries were acceptable. The biggest knock is the values. Two combos plus two burgers and two shakes was +$50. I need a better meal for $13 per person.
(3)Bryce F.
Based on other reviews, I had high expectations. I found the service to be outstanding, and the restaurant to be clean, etc. but I did not find the burger to be particularly special. It was large, and everything was fine, just not comparable to a Fuddruckers or similar, in my opinion.
(3)Shirley N.
What a great burger. Three different size offerings = 5,7, or 9 oz. Served on a toasted egg burger bun. We first were exposed to Teddy's on Oahu last week. But we only ordered fries and the dreamsicle shake. Then I was flipping through a free Maui dining brochure last night and saw the ad for Teddy's here in Lahaina. The four of us were ready for a juicy burger. So many toppings to select from, but I went with a cheddar cheeseburger with grilled onions and a soda. Hubby got a bacon cheeseburger and a chocolate shake. The shakes are great. Pure ice cream and extra thick. Great juicy ground chuck meat party. Dressed with special sauce, lettuce, tomato, and pickles. Reminds me somewhat of In N Out back home. Be prepared to use tons of paper napkins. They'll even come by to give you an alcohol wipe for your fingers. And a survey card if you choose to complete about the customer service provided. On it, there's a mention of their turnaround time of 10-15 minutes from ordering to cooking to your table since the burgers are cooked to order. You're given a pager. Find a table and when your pager flashes, your order is ready. It's worth the wait for an quality burger.
(4)Amanda C.
If you're tired of eating light, Teddy's Bigger Burgers has exactly what you're looking for. Giant portions, creative burgers, sinful cheese fries, and awesome customer service await you. Seriously, the people who work here are so friendly and helpful... they happily explained menu options and walked me through which burger to try. Considering the glowing reviews, I expected slightly better tasting food. The burger was a little too done for my taste and although my cheeseburger had half an avocado on it, the avocado wasn't really ripe making it significantly less delicious. But they get serious kudos for not skimping on ingredients, which is all too common especially in the more touristy parts of Maui. If you're visiting the island and looking for a one-of-a-kind experience, feel free to skip Teddy's. But if you're in Maui and looking for a quality fast food option, Teddy's is a great choice.
(3)Yane Y.
Really, 3.5 stars. As someone mentioned, it reminds me a lot of Five Guys (except overpriced Five Guys). My husband and I ordered a burger each with fries and a drink and it cost $30. For two burger combos, I think $30 is way too expensive! Unless it's a burger that is out of this world!!! I don't think it's reasonable at all. I ordered a cheeseburger and it was fine, but nothing amazing. =) The meat was cooked well and juicy, so definitely gotta give props for that. But the meat and spices didn't jump out at me. Also, my husband ordered a special with onion rings and special sauce in it (sorry I cannot remember the name!!! which is why I need to write these names down while I'm there) ... it also was not worth $11 (w/o fries and drink). Definitely clean with two fountain machines but just overpriced!!!
(3)Kellie S.
I went to Teddy's last week while on vacation and their burgers were great! The special sauce added a little something extra. The tots were extra crispy (which I love) and the garlic fries were amazing! The menu had so many options, but the staff was very helpful and steered us in the right direction. I really regretted that I could only eat here once. It was that good.
(5)Fred G.
Was here in 2/14 and the burgers, service etc were great. This time everything was great except for the burgers. They were well done and dry, garlic fries mediocre. Cheeseburger in paradise a better option
(2)Allen W.
Waited 30 minutes for a 9oz burger and fries Ridiculous! First time trying in Maui. Burger was ok though
(1)Annie W.
You can't go wrong with Teddy's when you're craving for a good burger. It's fairly new here and they even offer kama'aina rates, plus they accept the iDcard. I'm glad they were open late, because finding cheap eats in Maui during a short stay can be a bit tough. I usually stick with the chicken sandwiches and it always delivers. Perfectly cooked to perfection over those potatoes buns and that secret sauce that oozes out with each bite. It definitely satisfies my craving for something semi healthy and most definitely delicious. The service was great, the place was nice, bright and clean.
(4)Zack G.
This place was awesome. Wife had a burger Cajun style and I had the crispy chicken sambo. We split spicy fries. More than enough food, you don't need your own combo meals. We loved the food, nothing but good things to say. I added avocado and onion rings to my chicken and it was lights out. Friendly staff, but the food to a while to come out. Not a "fast food" joint if that's what you're looking for. Worth the wait. Good prices, we were both stuffed for $20.
(5)Lance N.
I don't know how anyone could be disappointed with this place. The Lahaina burger is awesome. The shakes awesome and the fries are amazing. Good atmosphere. Cheap grub Good times
(5)Lexie V.
I LOVE Teddy's. When i used to live in Hawaii, this was my favorite place for a burger. Teddy's is Hawaii's own burger chain and it's a damn shame it's not on the mainland because it blows all of our burger chains away. First, their burgers are always freshly prepared. Second, they are HUGE and there is a crazy variety of possible toppings, including jalapeno poppers (uh, yum!). Their fries are great, and oh, and did I mention they make the best super thick shakes ever? And they have about 15 different flavors, my personal favorite being the creamsicle one. This is the first place I beelined to when our plane landed in Maui. My vegetarian bf had never been and he was blown away by his veggie burger too and wanted to go back during our trip to eat it one more time. Awesome, fresh made-to-order food, polite staff, clean restaurant. What's not to love?
(5)Virginia B.
Husband and I went for lunch on 11-5-2014...both ordered the original 5 oz cooked medium. Order came cooked well. They don't toast your buns which I prefer. I'd rate this an ok, nothing to rave about.
(3)Ron W.
The thing I like best (besides the Burger) is that the entire staff seems to be really happy doing what they do & they make ME FEEL like they actually care that I'm happy with my food & service. Thanx Teddy! Now, if I only had room for a shake
(5)Stephani G.
Very good original burger. The bun is a giant potato, not my fav. The fries are plain unless you pay to upgrade. The grilled onions were not worth the $0.60 upgrade. The best part was the seasoning of the burger and the strawberry shake which added on one star in and of itself. Be prepared to wait for your food, very tasy food. Good prices too. Don't be cheap about upgrading the combo to a shake, the strawberry was delish!
(4)Dena H.
The burgers are excellent! There are a lot of options on the menu but talk to the workers there, they'll help you decide what to get. The garlic fries were so yummy!
(5)Ethan S.
This place is SO. GOOD. One of the highest quality burgers I've ever had. Pigskin Classic (patty not overcooked, lots of pulled pork (not fatty) and delicious bacon. A highlight: The side of tots layered with pulled pork, melted cheese and fire sauce (which, btw, isn't too spicy).
(5)Veronica J.
Decent burgers and chicken sandwich. They do give local people a discount. One burger combination is around 12 dollars. Place get busy at lunch time but service is fast.
(3)Anthony N.
This place makes a solid buger and fries. The portions are just right. The burgers seemed huge to me. The flavor was spot on. The only reason I didn't rate this five stars was that from the time we ordered to the time we received our food was a little long(20 min). But other than that this place is great.
(4)Maya S.
A must stop if you love a good burger, garlic fries, and TOTS!!! Go, just go. Family friendly, and in the grand scheme of one of the priciest locations, not a bad deal. You can even get the "biggest burgers" and split them! The shakes looked great but we were too full to try them. My fifteen year old would have eaten there every day if we would have let him!
(5)Mark C.
Good burgers! Consistent and people that helped us each time we've been there are very nice! Good for families! Will continue going there,
(5)Carol L.
Yum! This is a fun, bright, clean burger joint. The burger options were varied and could be customized any which way. I had their "Debbie" burger (named after a customer) that had bacon, pepper jack, avocado, and tons of jalapenos. It was great! The fries were really good, but I enjoyed the tots more. My son had a corn dog and it was also really good. We all shared a chocolate peanut butter shake and it was spoon thick and yummy. This was a NOT fast food burger joint that, if I lived there, would be in my rotation. The only negative was that the employee managed to get both my and my husband's order wrong (not sure how) but they fixed it right away with an apology. It was all good.
(5)Steve S.
Outstanding original monster burger (2) 5oz patty and cheese and all the fixings on a great bun! Shakes are sure thick and choice of chocolate ,vanilla, strawberry, peanut butter or mix your kind. When u come to Maui this place is must for any burger maniac!
(5)Maria G.
Yelp directions won't get you there. It's in the back of the Lahaina Gateway shopping center, across the highway from Longs. Start with a simple Big Burger combo. 5oz burger, fries and a drink for about $11. I don't even think it needs cheese. I tried a few different combos including the western bacon cheese but it was not as good as the basic burger. My husband had the veggie burger with avo and it was half an avocado! The special sauce is so good and really sets this burger apart. Then again, the bun, pickles and everything else do too. I'm hoping they open one here in San Francisco where there are more than enough burger places but none as good as Teddy's.
(5)Matt W.
Oh man....the burgers here are delicious. I would pound a second, but I can't because I'm stuffed from the first. I'll be dreaming about this place tonight.
(5)DH S.
Big fan of Teddy's on Maui. We try to stop by every trip out to the island. You can taste the quality in the burgers. Always full of locals when we've stopped in. My little boys (5 & 2) both love their cheeseburgers. I'm a fan of Islands Hawaiian so of course I opt for the Hawaiian style, which doesn't dissapoint.
(4)Stephanie V.
Food-gasmic!!!!! Best burgers and shakes I've ever had!!!!! If these burgers had babies ... I call dibs...
(5)Mike D.
Yelping Hawaiian eateries can be hit or miss. We've been burned more than a few times by highly rated restaurants only to find ok at best food. Maybe it'd the diversity of tourism and tastes / expectations or maybe it's just by comparison. That being said Teddy's is pretty solid. Good burgers at an affordable price ( which puts it amongst rare company in Maui). My only criticism is that they often overlook the details. If you make any sort of special order, like "no onions" just be sure to check before you leave the restaurant.
(4)Simeko C.
This was a great place to grab a burger. The portions were big and the food was tasty. I would recommend eating here for a reasonable price good meal.
(4)Jennifer M.
Don't bother. It wasn't very clean and the food was ok.
(2)Adam V.
I got the Lahaina style burger which was very good! Super big burger but not too big to eat in a relatively organized and clean fashion. I also got the plantation fries which were fries covered in kalua pork, BBQ, onions, and cheese!!! Very impressed with the food here.
(4)Maksim B.
Great burger joint! Better than in and out. Totally worth trying, get the lahaina style burger.
(5)Gibb F.
As soon as I walked in I knew it was going to be good. The bright menu had an outrageous selection of great food. The baconner burger (not sure exactly what it was called) had double bacon, double cheese and grilled onions. Everything I wanted added to my normal cheese burger. The selection of three different size burger patties made it even better, the medium size 7oz was more than enough for me. From there I decided to roll with onion rings, despite the vast selection of specialty sides (garlic fries, chili cheese fries, etc.). My wife chose to get the special, pulled pork and BBQ sauce over top of perfectly cooked tater tots. After being helped by the great staff we took our seats and within 7 minutes our food was sitting on our table ready to go. As soon as I saw the burger cooked medium with grilled onions and melted cheese oozing out I knew I was in for a treat. I bit in and was very much amazed by the tasty burger with the specialty sauce. I then looked to my onion rings which were also beyond what I expected (onion rings always seem to be hit or miss). They were just the perfect blend of batter and onion and the best thing I could have asked for to go with my burger. The only problem was once I'd finished my burger there were a lot more onion rings I couldn't eat left on my plate. I also got a few bites of my wife's pulled pork tots, which had a bit of spice that I loved, although she's never been much of one for spicy things so she ended up leaving with a bad stomach ache. The icing on the cake was that on the little review card they give you to fill out (if you want to) they had a question that asks what you'd have on the menu if you owned the place. Suddenly I knew where the vast array of menu items had come from. All in all it was a great experience with great food. Not the best burger I've ever had, but it's definitely in the top ten. Hopefully next time my wife can make it out feeling a bit better!
(4)Kevin J.
burger was really good...and the service was great! would come back....if i went back to hawaii..
(5)Carolyn A.
Teddy's was pretty good. Great flavour, very friendly staff. My only gripe was there was a bit too much sauce and onions for my liking. Would definitely have again though
(4)debbie l.
The burgers were tasty and I liked the bun it held up well to the juicy burger. The onion rings were good as were the fries. My burger had a small part that was really pink which i didnt eat. I'd say its a little better than In and Out and way pricier. Everything is an up-charge so your $9 burger combo is really $14 or more. Not even close to Fuddruckers burgers. I like Cool Cats better burger and atmosphere and is not as expensive. Overall pretty good for a chain but $27 for two burgers. I expect a much different kind of burger for that price.
(4)Paul P.
Best burger in Maui! Better than Cool Cats and better priced. I had the Teri Hawaiian Burger with Cajan Fries. Also added avocado to the burger. Everything was awesome. Clean restaurant and friendly staff.
(5)Michael T.
My wife and I eat here each time we travel to Maui. The burgers are huge and the shakes are amazing! Great food, friendly staff, and great prices for the area....highly recommended!
(5)Keith H.
This was a great find to get a great burger - thanks to a Yelp deal. My wife and I appreciated the different patty size choices and the many ways to customize our burgers. Lots of fries, on future orders, my wife and I will share those. Great malt as well. Next time I am in Maui, I will definitely be getting a meal or two here. I saw on their website that they have several locations on the Islands and also near me in Woodinville, Washington. I'll have to try it, it would be wonderful if it is as good, - if not I'll just have another excuse to head back to the islands.
(5)Chris P.
Both my girlfriend and I agreed that this was hands down the best burger we had both ever had. I'm a huge burger guy and she's not into burgers at all. I let her have a bite of my burger and she completely regretted not getting one. The burger was just juicy, perfectly cooked, and amazing.
(5)Daniel P.
What an amazing burger! This sandwich was huge! Got the monster 9oz double patty! Wow!!! Also got the fries and onion rings both were great and the fries were fresh cut. Vicki was my cashier, super friendly and had a nice chat with her while ordering. For my first time there she was very helpful and walked me through the process. The only bad thing was hard to find the place. Palm trees outside block the sign. But go! Find it! Worth it! Delicious!!
(5)Gina M.
Great burgers...cooked to order. We had the Hawaiian, Bacon and Blue, Bacado and Kailua. All were great. Shakes were awesome...not too thick. Very casual atmosphere.
(5)Jennilee M.
THE BEST burger on Maui - hands down! I've ate at the Teddy's in Waikiki, and for some reason this Teddy's tastes so much better. The burger that I usually get is the blue cheese burger - so 'ono!! I also tried their western burger which is really good, a bit messy but so good. Their special sauce that they put on their burgers is ah-may-zing. Even their fries are good! Definitely a spot to hit up everytime we go to Lahaina.
(5)Tracey G.
Came in here during vacation in Maui. Burgers were okay, I like that they serve fish and chicken sandwiches :)
(3)Michael T.
Try the #1 Combo with Teriyaki Sauce It is Great. They have Great Food and Great Service. Really enjoyed ourselves here.
(5)Michael L.
I tried out TBB's due to a Yelp deal coupon and was glad that I did. It was similar to Five Guys Burger joint due to the way you can customize your order, however, the options they had were endless. I had a insanely big and complex Hawaiian themed burger and it was delicious. The price wasn't cheap but on Hawaii you have to expect things to be a little bit more costly. I would say it was very nice value though. If you're looking for a differing dining option on the island, or just love burgers, I would highly recommend it. Pros: great service, unique burger options, great fries and sides (my wife loved her chocolate shake), and very filling.
(5)Rachel A.
Not only are the burgers & shakes delicious (especially the Kailua & Bacado), the reason a burger joint is 5 stars instead of 4 is their location. The fact that you don't have to go to Front St or Kaanapali for a good meal deserves an extra star!
(5)Armando A.
Kinda funny that I go all the way to Maui and end up at a burger joint, but there you go. We get there and it's in a suburban looking strip mall and looks like it's part of a chain which I usually stay away from. However, it was at the end of a long day and we were not about to go searching elsewhere. At any rate, the burger were VERY good. The shake I had was excellent too. I don't remember the name of it but the flavor was like one of those push ups I had when I was a kid. Not much on vibe but the food was worth the trip.
(4)Angie T.
Yum, YUM and YUM! We came to Teddy's after sunbathing on the beach. There's always something about swimming and sunbathing that makes you really hungry. I ordered the 5 oz burger and cheese fries. My husband ordered the plantation fries and they were amazing! I personally do not prefer to eat pork but the shredded pork on the fries was tender, juicy and delicious. The prices weren't horrible and the food was bomb. We were with some locals so we got the kamaaina discount~ Woohoo! Bottom line- if you are hungry and in Lahaina you must go to Teddy's.
(5)Ray M.
Excellent burger and chicken sandwiches. The burgers are very juicy; a 5 oz. is filling. My wife's Cajun chicken sandwich had the right level of spices; she said up that she could taste the spices, and that most times at other places the level of spice is too weak. The tots tasted fantastic. Too bad they are not in California.
(5)Corky B.
I had the turkey burger with pineapple. Came with the standard burger sauce. The sauce is sweet enough that I don't think there is a need to order the teriyaki version of the burgers they offer. Turkey burger was good, though slightly undercooked. Quality of bread and veggies was good. Onions were very thinly sliced. Had a vanilla milkshake. Very thick, and they brought it out right to my table. Better service than I expected from a fast food vendor in a shopping center. They have a lot of specialty sides, like tots covered in things like pork, cheese, onions, that are not easy to see on the menu. They have pictures around the restaurant showing some of the special items they serve. There are enough wacky things they offer that it would be worth re-visiting if only to try them out.
(4)Mike C.
Teddy's was one of my favorite burger joints when I lived on Oahu, and it's one of the places I sorely missed after I moved back to Maui in 2009. I was so excited when i heard they were finally opening a location on Maui, and they didn't disappoint. Try the western burger for something a little tangy, or the bacado if you like a California style burger. No matter what you get, it's gonna be a delicious burger!
(5)Nick R.
My wife and I were hungry and we asked one of the local merchants in old Lahaina where's a good place to eat for the money. She recommened Teddy's because you get a typical combo meal i.e. burger, fries, and a drink for around $10. She said the burgers were very good. I love my burgers and I know a good burger when I have one. Teddy's Burgers is one of my favorite burger joints to eat now. The burgers had a lot of flavor on fresh (or what seemed fresh) hamburger buns. The hamburgers are definitely top notch, and the meat is also fresh, not frozen like a lot of other places. Whenever I'm in Maui, eating at Teddy's is a must. The service is great and the wait isn't long. Pound for pound worth every penny.
(5)J X.
I'm very impressed with the high level of customer satisfaction that the owner and his wife emphasize. They will go out of their way to make sure your experience goes above and beyond "mediocre," because that is not good enough for them. They have cute review cards that are optional for you to fill out because the owners actually care about your feedback so they can continue making their restaurant even better! They have a lot of interesting variety of burgers, and teryaki is wonderful on almost everything I've now realized! :)
(5)Shawn P.
Burgers were amazing, atmosphere was great. Definitely would recommend this place as a nice, reasonably priced, option for tourists and locals.
(4)Julio M.
Teddy's is located in the main mall in Lahaina (resort area in western side of Maui). Foodie- wise Maui has been somewhat of a disappointment.... We order a burger with pineapple and a fried egg, grilled chicken w cajun spices, tater tots w avocado and a coconut-pineapple shake. Total Bill $28.26 My burger benchmarks are: In-n-out, Fat Burger, The York, father 's Office, Five Guys, and TK Burger. All good, except this is a different animal - its a fusion burger place. This place seems to have elements of each: the fried egg and 50s feel of Fat Burger, the bun and grilled chicken and veggie patty options of TK Burger. No place competes with the King: In-N-Out on a value basis. If I had $2 for a meal it would be In-N-Out. But a salad at Safeway costs $8 - so $28 for a orgasmic burger meal in Maui is a veritable steal. They have huge meat portions 5 7 or 9 oz . And as many topping options as Five Guys. My lady friend was in rapture with the tots with avocado - she was scheming how to bring them back on the plane. Napoleon Dynamite would be jealous. Totally awesome shake - we had a custom build: pineapple coconut. They Really make it your way, especially if it Includes pineapple, jalapeños, onion rings, teriyaki,....Mahalo. The decor is the only I can find as a negative: yellow, blue, and red. One of the owners totally had a hard on for some girl at HotDog on a Stick when he was younger. It's a must stop when in Maui!
(5)J T.
Had the mahi mahi burger yesterday, blackened style. It was spot on and the addition of jalapeños added just the right amount of spice for my taste. Their "special sauce" was a nice touch as well. Overall, a great choice after spending all day in the sun.
(5)Abra S.
Maybe for Maui this place has great burgers but compared to the rest, this place is ok. My burger was good but nothing that stands out and I will prob not go back. My girl and I came here since it had good reviews on yelp and since the locals raved about it, but we weren't impressed. Would recommend if you want a decent burger but nothing special.
(3)Andre E.
Well I must say my first Turkey Burger in Maui was a HUGE success just like the burger was. The burger tasted great.....just like it came right off the grill....fresh toppings...potato bun....and I had a small drink.....which is really the size of a medium. We got a great deal here on yelp for this establishment as well....we paid only 12 bucks for 20 worth of food. The only reason I gave this place 4 stars instead of 5 was because the fries were just average.....and they overdue it a bit on the condiments so make sure to tell them to go easy on those if you don't want it getting all over your hands or clothes....LOL. Despite the fact that the food is made to order....we got our food fairly quickly. I highly recommend this location if your looking for a good burger. Eat, Drink, and Be Merry my Friend!!!!!
(4)Pualani T.
This was my first visit, clean establishment, friendly and helpful employees and great burgers. Their special sauce is great had it on the side and used also as a dip for the fries. Fries are plentiful one order can be shared by two. Will be back when I'm back in Lahaina.
(5)Amy B.
Great choices for every type of burger you can think of!
(4)Paul D.
Great tasting hamburgers and a better value than Cheeseburgers in Paradise and Cool Cat Cafe. Friendly helpful staff. Onion rings can use some work - overbreaded and undercooked.
(5)Evan S.
Although I wasn't too happy with my visit, the management at Teddy's contacted me because of my yelp review to offer an explanation, corrective actions for their restaurant, and a refund (since I left the island). Customer service goes a LONG way for me and I really appreciated the sincere response and offer of reimbursement. Teddy's is a class act and I'm sure this place will become one of the most popular places on the island. Good luck Teddy's!
(4)Stacie W.
Go! Great burgers!!
(5)Shakira E.
Hot and Juicy Burgers, great fries all made to order! This is a great addition to Lahaina it seems like this place was missing from the usual food offerings. My husband said they have a nice Juicy Turkey burger I had the beef burger and it was delicious the toppings were fresh. If you are dining in you have unlimited soft drinks at the ready lastly the fries were just ok; but who can complain too much when you are eating a burger in paradise,,,,,
(4)Jordan H.
The atmosphere is fun, the burgers are amazing, the staff is awesome. They always seem to be adding an inventive new burger to the menu. Prices are a little high, but that's everywhere on Maui. We love this place.
(4)Faith T.
Huge portions! Amazing choices. Friendly staff. We heard Teddy's was great but it really is. I would have given them 5 stars but the fish sandwich was soggy...not the bun just the fish.
(4)Kirk W.
I was browsing Yelp for food recommendations when I saw a coupon pop up for Teddy's Bigger Burgers. I knew my wife and I would be there for a full week, so figured we would be able to find time to use a coupon and went ahead and bought it. VERY happy with the purchase now that we've used it. The store was moderately busy as 12:30pm (got more crowded near 1pm), but we didn't have to wait to order and the food came out quickly. I don't eat a lot of beef, so I was excited to see turkey is an option with any of their burgers. I got the Halloween special "Jalaween" - burger, onion rings, jalapeno's, pepper jack cheese and their regular toppings. Turkey patty was great and didn't dry out. We were splitting items since we couldn't decide what to get, the manager was nice enough to take the burger in the back and slice it in half for us. My wife got the fish & chips and we were equally impressed with that. Three pretty big pieces of fish and a big basket of fries. The fish comes out with Tartar sauce and Vinegar, depending on your tastes. Also of note, they have Coke products vs. Pepsi. I'm a big Diet Coke drinker so that was a pleasant surprise. Definitely recommend checking Teddy's out.
(5)Marcus C.
Had the Kailua Burger. Tasty and Juicy!!!
(4)Jeremy T.
Accidentally found this place on our way to our hotel from the airport. The quality of the food was really good. I had both the chicken burger and cheese burger which came with their special house sauce. The standout item on the menu are the shakes. Even plain ol vanilla was pretty good. I would even go out on a limb and say that the food is better than "Cheeseburger in Paradise" We went here a few times during our stay in Maui. Wished it was here a during our past visits to Maui =).
(4)Angie I.
Teddy's when are you coming to my neighborhood?!? Oh how I crave the delish burgers, tots and of course those milk shakes! YES, those milk shakes bring me to the yard!! BTW...what do they do to those cows to make them taste so good....must be lots of lovin' cuz the burgers give you lots of loving when you eat them! =) Burgers = 9 Tots = 8 Milk Shakes (coconut and the pineapple) = 10 We ate at Teddy's several times during our stay in Maui and it was love at first bite! I can't imagine how I can go back to eating In-N-Out, Five Guys or anything else that could compare to the fun fast food I discovered in Lahaina. We will def be back soon!
(5)John B.
A real hamburger, fries and shake. Don't go anywhere else in the Lahaina area for a burger or a shake or you will be getting something other than the best the area has to offer. This is where the locals go. The staff is extremely helpful and friendly. The atmosphere is very clean and cheerful. You place your order at the counter and they bring your food to you On a scale of 1 - 10 I'd give the burger an 8, the fries a 7 and the shake a 10. Probably the best hamburger for the price in Maui and the best shake anywhere. Try the root beer shake.
(4)Adri A.
Teddys is truly the IN and OUT burger of Hawaii! The meat is juicy and smoky charred and the sauce is O SO GOOD secretness.. " not ur avg thousand island dressing" lol .. Its a solid fast food burger and worth every penny and minute that u would wait at the famous Cali chain... If i am being painfully picky, I will say that the Oahu locations have the customer service BEAT! they offer the little wet napkins and are genuinely happy about you stopping by. .. as you can see MY "BEEF" is not with this burger but rather, with the service... so definitely come by and get THE BEST FAST FOOD BURGER YOU CAN HAVE IN MAUI!
(4)Sydney W.
Very yummy, esp. with the Yelp deal!! DH ordered a regular burger; I had the veggie burger. Both tasty. Milkshake was thick and delicious. Worth a try!
(4)Bean M.
STAY AWAY. Teddy's charges expensive sit-down restaurant prices for an average burger inside of a fast food joint located in a strip mall. You're better off down the street at any of the restaurants on the Lahaina boardwalk, which have better tasting burgers at comparable prices, bars, and the epic paradise scenery that is Maui's beaches. I can't understand why this place has ambitions to expand; they need to fix the numerous issues it has first. The price is too expensive, when I stacked two options onto my teri burger, I was already up to 13 bucks. For 13 bucks, there better be hot girls in hula skirts with a warm ocean breeze tickling my face (that's Cheeseburger in Paradise on the boardwalk, for those of you wondering). The decor is amazingly sparse and boring, I thought I was at hot dog on a stick. Every other sit-down restaurant on the planet has neat objects and posters to look at while you're waiting - here you get yellow, blue, and red tiles, with copious amounts of...wall to look at. My order was screwed up in two ways, I asked for no bun and got a bun, then I ordered grilled onions and did not get the grilled onions. The employees and chefs were nice enough to remedy that. The burger tasted fresh and was decent, but NOT oh-my-god-that-really-hits-the-right-button tasting. Carl's Juniors, Red Robbins, and In-And-Out generally have awesome burgers that push those buttons, and Teddy's has a long way to go on many fronts to match those big name players, along with the other smaller players on Maui like Cool Cat Cafe or Cheeseburger in Paradise. Pros: Friendly staff Clean No need to tip Not that crowded Lots of Parking (this location) Cons: Expensive Average tasting burger (less if you factor in price) Two order mistakes Cheap moist toilette (tore way too easily) Boring decor No napkin dispenser on half the tables (including mine, had to steal from another table) No bar No live music events No beach, no boardwalk No girls in hula skirts (seriously, it's supposed to be a 50s joint, make the women wear poodle skirts and the guys clean pressed cotton shirts and jeans....this place isn't even trying).
(1)Kafa G.
1st Time there... I loved it!! It was soo good!! But, kinda of expensive... but, it was worth it...bcuz, it was just good! You can pick the size of the oz. Patty... from, 5oz * 7oz * 9oz... then you Pick if you wanted.. a Combo $10.32....comes with a drink and French fries.... onion ring!... was the bomb!! You guys got to try it..
(5)Scott S.
The strawberry shake is awesome! Great burger joint especially for Maui. They have a really extensive list of specialty burgers. Even a crossfit burger (Paleo-ish I belive) for my wife.
(4)Ron S.
Tastes great! The burgers come in 5, 7 , and 9 oz patties depending on how hungry you are. We went during the lunch hour so they were getting a little slammed. He took them almost 20 minutes before we got our food but it was worth the wait!
(5)Rob P.
Wow, best burger I've eaten in what is the land of burgers.. Tastes awesome, great choices
(5)Glenn P.
Good burgers great service cool atmosphere. If your craving a burger on the Westside this is the place. But not the best burgers on the island in my opinion. That would be at Peggy Sues in Kihei.. Will be back here
(3)Jenny M.
Great burgers, sandwiches and MILKSHAKES!!! Just what Maui has been needing. Nice music too.
(4)Rhonda L.
Burgers were Delicious!! Good customer service...Very satisfied with our Yelp deal =)
(5)Susie S.
The woodenville burger was awesome! Can't wait to go back!
(5)Mark A.
My family and I visited during our vacation here in Maui. Away from the tourist places on Front Street and the Kaanapali beach front Teddy's really delivers on a Better burger and awesome shakes! This was the best burger place on Maui!
(5)Lindsay S.
Best burger I have ever had, what more is there to say?
(5)E B.
We're local and live just down the street but passed by Teddy's for several months before finally stopping in. I don't eat red meat but as soon as I saw the Teri Chicken I was sold. I LOVE Teri Chicken & could eat it every day. I've found that Koho's, Aloha Mixed Plate and Cool Cats to have some of the best Teri on the island - sweet Hawaiian Teri, not the sour Japanese Teri that the higher end resturants serve. I can now add Teddy's to my list of favs! Add a shake and some fries or tots and its a great meal. My husband loves burgers, fries and a malt or rootbeer float. He knows his meat and love Teddy's burgers - big, juicy and all the fixings. If it drips, then you know its good. It is a little pricey for a burger joint but its Lahaina plus you get what you pay for, IMHO. If you are a local you get an automatic Kam discount which is cool. They have a cool fast food meets vintage Hawaiian meets carhop, 50's diner feel to it. The last two times we have come in for dinner the place was hopping with locals and tourists alike. They have great customer service (the lady with the blonde hair is very chipper and nice), quick to make the food and are cool with all the little additions like when I'm specific that I only want bun, chicken, teri, cheese & bacon plus teri on the side. They serve Roselani Ice Cream for their shakes/malts & Roselani is the best there is. My husband likes their rootbeer floats and they fill the cup with a ton of ice cream that takes awhile to melt. He sometimes goes to refill the rootbeer 5 or 6 times during a meal and they never say a word about all the soda :) A great new spot for when we want some filling and tasty food, don't want to go far and don't have to get dressed nice.
(5)Jim E.
pretty good fish sandwhich - pretty expensive too - nothing over the top special but good - diner style
(2)Max E.
I had the absolutely amazing pastrami swiss burger, fries and a coconut + pineapple shake. My first time eating pastrami on a burger and it was just out-of-this-world delicious. Also, the service was unexpectedly good -- fast, attentive and friendly. Don't miss this place!
(5)C K.
Terrific burgers and awesome service! Luigi was exceptionally helpful and so was the other guy at the counter. Chocolate malt milkshake was nice and thick! Keep it up.
(4)Amy V.
Great Atmosphere, friendly staff and I love that they cook to order. Everything was hot and delicious. We had a child's chicken nugget meal (chicken tasted fresh and not processed) and two cheeseburgers with fries. The buns were soft and warm and it was well dressed. Only complaint, the hamburger was a little well done.. will ask for medium next trip :) The chocolate milkshake was AMAZING!
(4)Leo G.
The owner should go to California and try In-N-Out. The burgers here are big but they are also big on terrible flavor. The customer service was good but that alone does not merit an extra star. I have yet to find any meal that taste somewhat descent in Maui with the exception of McDonalds!
(1)Sue H.
We stumbled across this awesome burger joint, and so glad we did! My husband ordered the 7 oz blue cheese burger and he loved it. I kept to the original 5 oz and it was plenty big! The meat was flavorful and juicy, lettuce and tomato fresh and crisp. Nice and messy, just the way a burger should be....hence the hand wipes they provide to you. The price was right as well. The fries were delicious and cooked to the perfect crispness without over doing it. I would definitely try this place again. If only they had a location in OC!
(5)Austin D.
We've been coming to Maui for 25 years and this is the best burger we've had on the island! Cheeseburger in Paradise doesn't hold a candle. Great service as well!
(5)LeeAnn M.
Tater tots are great! I thought the BBQ sauce in my Western was a tad sweet. But it was still good. Also liked the garlic fries.
(4)Francelle L.
Came to eat here on a family vacation. It was about 8:30pm and all 7 of us trucked on in to all order a classic combo meal all of which has speical things on the burgers. We sat down and was told our milk shakes will be ready on the first "page" and then our food would be ready on the second "page". The first "page went off and it was actually our food. When we go this all of our burgers were just regular ones. Most of us all had bacon on the burgers. There was no Bacon and everything was wrong. So they kindly took our food back and corrected this. Once we got our corrected orders I bite into my burger to find it was still raw!!!! Not like a cook to order rear, but RAW all the way through. It wasnt just me who had a raw burger, almost half of them were. Some people in our group were bring nice and just ate what they could. We gave them back our orders, half eaten and got our money back. I will never eat there again.
(1)Justine S.
Love the cheese fries and onion rings! Friendly staff and comfortable place. Lahaina is lucky to get a Teddys!
(5)Willie G.
Simply put it good food good service worth your time and hard earned money.
(5)T W.
First timer. Good burger well made and juicy. Good fries. Staff could have been a little more friendly at the counter. Quick service, clean facility. I'll go back and try another flavor burger.
(4)Ken B.
Nothing like a good burger to get you rolling and this place has them. Staff was courteous, place was clean, and the burgers great. Good selection of burgers, my wife had the western and I had bacon blu. Wish I had read the reviews before going in, I would have tried a shake.
(5)holly v.
My husband and I were visiting Maui last week and my cousin & her husband, who live there, wanted to go to Teddy's for their vegetarian burger. We had regular burgers, my cousin, the veg burger, and her husb. the fish burger. We all were very pleased with what we ordered. The service was friendly and efficient, the burgers were juicy and big, and the fries were great. It is a bit more expensive than the fast-food burger places and the food took a little longer, but hey, they are not the usual fast-food joints. And everything on Maui is more expensive than even Honolulu, or the SF Bay Area where we live. The burgers were a nice change from the upscale, touristy places in Lahaina, even the more expensive burger place on Front St where we had eaten the previous night. (No, we don't regularly eat burgers, not even fast-food burgers.) We would definitely try Teddy's again, whether in Maui or elsewhere.
(4)Dan J.
Delicious burgers, fries and shakes. We were In Maui for a couple of weeks, and ate here several times. Easily the best burger I have had in Maui. It's a very casual place in a strip mall, great dor kids.
(5)Ben Y.
This place has the best burgers by far. That's saying a lot being from Chicago. The 5oz. terry is the best. Just the right amount of meat to bun ratio. Each bite is a juicy delight.
(5)Paul T.
I had business on the West Side of Maui the other day and decided to give Teddy' Bigger Burgers a shot. My opinion is that if you dare open anything on this Island, you had better blow the competition out of the water. Teddy's came up short. I was expecting a big juicy burger. Mine was rather on the dry side. Fries were okay, but the stupid little cups I had to fill up with ketchup sucked! Put a Ketchup and Mustard bottle on each table. Outback, Ruby's, and Carl's Jr have much better burgers and plenty of condiments on the table. The one thing that sticks out from my experience is I noticed the owner/manager? (wearing black shirt) was sweating profusely, and every time he went into the open kitchen he would grab fries and eat them. I watched this several times, and frankly I was getting a little noxious. I get it now! Teddy's Bigger Burgers, not Teddy's BETTER Burgers. At least they are not lying. I don't think they will get a second shot from this local. I received an e-mail from the owner, and he related they took care of the EMPLOYEE who was grazing and sweaty. Kudo's to an owner who is proactive and who is sincere about caring for his customers. I will give Teddy's Bigger Burgers another shot, and another review sometime in the near future. Review update: It's been a while since I gave Teddy's a second shot. My daughter loves the Teddy's on Oahu, and she was on Island and wanted Teddy's. I must admit I had a great tasty burger, that I would eat again. Service was very friendly, and I left satisfied. I will be back, sooner this time.
(4)Jenn J.
5 for clean and service, but can't do overall beyond a 3 because the burgers were just that burgers - meat no flavor, we even had the Western burgers which had very little bbq sauce on them. It's just another burger joint, if on Holiday it's not worth wasting a meal on this place I'm sure you have one just like it at home. Sorry I really wanted to like this place, but it just wasn't what we expected.
(3)Julie L.
I love Teddy's Bigger Burgers. I had the plain grilled chicken breast sandwich and it was fantastic. The fries were seasoned just right. The staff was very welcoming and friendly. I would definitely go back!
(5)Kyle K.
We drove from Kihei to Lahaina to eat a awesome burger. This was my second time here and introduced Teddy's to a friend of mine and is now hooked! Not only was the food was top quality, but the service from the staff was excellent! Our cashier Joe recommended some new items on the menu and was great at checking up on us to see how everything was. We will coming back very soon and bringing in more friends to introduce them to this fine establishment you have in Lahaina!
(5)Anthony S.
Well we have been coming to Maui for over 25years and were ready for our Cheeseburger in Paradise. Went on yelp to read reviews and saw Teddy's, read reviews, so gave it a try. The burger was no better than Cheeseburger in Paradise and the onion rings get a B-. They tout old style burger joint but it was more like McDonald's decor. Everything was extra: cheese, malt powder in shake, grilled onions. And no beer! If you're looking for a Cheeseburger in Paradise go there as the burgers are not much different (neither have any seasoning) but the view and ambience is stellar!
(3)Florenda G.
Just came by on a whim and found this place. The food was delicious and the portions were big. Definitely a place to bring the whole family. Very fun atmosphere and the staff was polite and very helpful.
(4)Tuan G.
Good place to eat that's reasonably priced and a step over other fast food joints. Burger was not overcooked like other burger joints and fries are crispy and not greasy. I would given this place 4 starts but they were gonna charge me extra for sauce that should have come with the burger. That kinda irked me.
(3)Nani D.
Quite disappointed this time around. We come often and I've noticed the following: - large groups staff gets flustered and overwhelmed. Got my order mixed. - we ordered milk shakes with our meal and checked 3x's. An hour later we got a refund & an apology. (We checked twice prior to that stating they would make it). Did I mention they were busy?... What we did get: A warm welcome when we walked in the door. AND the other cashier asked how our night was going. For this they'll get another chance and hopefully a better review next time.
(3)Rainelle H.
The staff at the Lahaina Teddy's Bigger Burgers are always super friendly and my teri burger is always cooked to perfection. The only con is that it can get a little pricey depending how much add ons or what kind of combo you get. However, locals can get kamaaina discount when they show their HI ID. Scrumptious meal at a reasonable price served with ALOHA, how could you ask for more?
(5)Stephanie V.
Amazing as always!!! If you complain about this place it's probably bc you made yourself a crappy burger considering it's build it yourself! Great service, and great food!
(5)Lon H.
Teddy's is a nice change of pace while in Maui. When you're hungry for a burger, this is where I've gone on my last two trips. You can order whatever size and type of burger you like and you can make it a combo if you prefer. You can also order your fries extra crispy (which I do) or you can have garlic fries. The burgers are cooked medium or you can order them more well done if you like. Service has always been very good. The restaurant is clean and inviting.
(4)Jesse G.
For starters the bill was less than $15.00 for a 7 Oz Woodenville combo meal with upgraded garlic fries. This was our first time at Teddy's and we were very impressed. My wife and I split the burger in half and still had food left over. The wait for the food was about 10 minutes and the food was prepared very well. The service was friendly and informative with all our questions. Ruben the young gentlemen that took our order was top notch and helped us decide a great burger. Extremely tasty food, great service and reasonably priced for Maui.....eat here if you can you will not regret it.
(5)Lena H.
Best hamburger place on any island!! Pricey but worth every penny! Grilled pineapple is yummy!
(5)Mark G.
A very good reasonable meal for a family of 5. This is more than a burger joint, although for Burgers it was good. In addition to the burgers they also make a Mahi-Mahi burgers, veggie burgers, Vegan Burger, and salads. They were all good. Plus great fries, including garlic fries. Vegans and Vegetarians can eat well. The salad was actually great, and the Veggie burger was delicious. This is a causal local restaurant. In fact, if you are a "declared" local you get 10 percent off your bill. The locals fill the restaurant with the tourist. Our favorite burger is Joey's in Whalers village, but this is a very close tie or 2nd place for the Island. The menu is big and a tiny bit complicated, but our order taker was soooo nice and helpful that it went very smoothly. The drinks are mostly fountain drinks. The buns are Hawaiian buns, and they also serve grilled Pineapple and grilled Onions, which are yummy! We didn't order the shakes, but they looked great. Parking is easy as it is located in a strip mall. Because it is cooked fresh, once you order it can take about 10 mins for the food to be available for pick up, but worth the wait. It looks like a retro 1970's surfing burger joint, which is a fun atmosphere. Size is generous.
(4)Lizette A.
Had the 5 oz. Burger and (good portion) of fries. I ordered the spicy fries. It was their crispy fries with a zesty sprinkling of mild spice. It was all tasty! Big bang for your buck in Hawaii. The service was fast and friendly, almost just like my favorite In N Out at home. Most definitely a good addition to your food stops on Maui. The end.
(4)Andrea K.
So much to love here! I ordered a Lahaina Burger...bacon, jack cheese, jalapeños & pineapple on a sweet Hawaiian bun, spicy fries and a dreamcicle shake. The burger was cooked perfectly. The toppings were crisp and fresh. The fries were crispy at the ends and covered in seasoning salt. The dreamcicle shake was made with vanilla ice cream and Fanta...tasted like orange sherbet and cooled the flames from the jalapeños! The fam and I loved it and we consider ourselves to be burger connoisseurs being from TX ;-)
(5)Maria C.
A little pricier than your typical fast food burger joint, but the quality is MUCH better. My usual go-to burger is the Kailua -- 5 oz burger with teriyaki sauce, grilled onions, swiss cheese, & mushrooms. Yum! Service is usually great & friendly, but once in a while the wait after ordering seems longer than it should be. I also get their malt shakes, but one time it was just a regular milkshake vs. a malt which is an additional charge. They sometimes offer a discount coupon in local newspapers like the Maui Time and always offer a kama'aina discount. What really won my heart & left a good impression on me the last time was when they asked if I wanted to donate my kama'aina discount to Trucker Dukes (a Maui toddler diagnosed with stage 4 neuroblastoma). This was such a great way to get involved in the community and help a family in need of support. Awesome promotion that definitely increases a company's goodwill value!
(4)Kerrissa A.
The burgers are so juicy and perfectly crafted. The fries are hot and crispy. The restaurant is so clean they up keep it very well. The service is great. Specifically, my friends and I were really impressed with Shawn, he's very professional and provides great service. He seems like a hard worker who does the best that he can. Love those kind of people! Overall, super impressed and always come to teddys when in Lahaina.
(5)birdie o.
The decor is interesting and the location is easy to find! Was craving a good burger figured from the yelp reviews that it was good! Got a Hawaiian Kai burger which comes with pepper jack, bacon, avocado and pineapple! The inside smells good and very clean! Fresh and nice views of the mountains! They have everything that a usual diner would have and they have Tons of specialty burgers to choose from! They also have some weird combinations too! The people are cool, blan but cool. They also passed out wet napkins which is helpful cus they get messy! Over all definitely a good place to get that fatty oil in your system!
(4)Marissa S.
I've had this place bookmarked on Yelp before coming to the island and after my Hawaiian Yelp buddy, Joe P. recommended this place, I was convinced this was not to be missed. No better time to eat a big, fat, juicy burger than after a swim in the beach. We soooo earned it! Teddy's is a local fast food joint that looks like a diner, Hawaiian style with colorful surf boards hanging on the walls. The guy behind the counter helped me through my ordering. I was being an annoying customer with too many questions that day...poor kid! It was his first day at work he said but he delivered like a pro. I was impressed. With his recommendations, here's what we got: ORIGINAL BURGER---A good 'ol American burger with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and cheese. Perfectly cooked beef patty that was oozing with juicy flavors. Love the potato bread bun used in all their burgers. It has the starch sticking to the roof of your mouth effect---my weakness when eating a burger. So good and easily my fave out of everything I had here. I got the 7oz patty but I think a 5oz would have sufficed. It's filling! LAHAINA STYLE BURGER---Sweet and spicy! This came with pineapple, bacon, swiss cheese, and jalapenos. I just had to get this, we were in Hawaii after all. Another great burger especially if you want some heat. Wonderful marriage of flavors from all the ingredients which I'm already a fan of individually. TERI BURGER---They make their own teriyaki sauce and the kid highly recommends it so I ordered this for my daughter with bacon, of course. The burger was missing bacon when served but they fixed that right away and brought it to our table in a jiffy. It was too one note for me in flavor but since bacon makes everything taste better, it worked out. GARLIC FRIES---Thick-cut and crispy fries drizzled with garlic, lots of it! We killed this basket and could probably kill a vampire with our garlic breaths as well. Plan to share between 2-3 people as a side. A pineapple milkshake would've been an awesome pairing but my daughter insisted on a ROOT BEER FLOAT to go with her combo. There was so much to go around with one order. They fill a cup with vanilla ice cream and you can do unlimited root beer refills. Sweet! Best part: $30 for everything! Big fan!
(4)Alex C.
Visiting from CA and I have to say this is one of the best burgers I've had in a long time. I ordered a bigger burger with pepper jack onion ring and fried egg and it was the best. Definitely recommend this place
(5)Horace S.
Ok, the place is fun like an old 70s fast food establishment. Music is great also. Can't get enough of Pretty Woman. Order the monster burger and fries with a creamsicle shake. The first place I left full. Great food!
(5)Enmeline V.
Love Teddy's Bigger Burgers!!! I first encountered them in Oahu years ago. When they opened the one on Maui, I was so happy and excited! Best burgers I've had ever! Can barely finish a 5oz burger though, which bums me out because I wanna finish off my fries with their awesome sauce! Try it! You'll be stuffed!
(5)John G.
Very good burgers. The buns are a little dry, but good nonetheless. The fries and chili cheese fries are excellent. Fast, friendly restaurant. Clean. I am sure we will be back.
(4)Joey T.
The best burger I had while in Maui. With all the hotel food and diners burgers are plentiful on the island. However finding a good one is definitely much harder said than done. I figured that out the hard way. Teddys has a cool decor in a nice center. Obviously the locals like it, and I believe they even charge them less than the tourists. They have three different size patties, and you can order the burger cooked to what you want. Lots of good toppings and choices to make the burger your own. They keep the customization high with their other menu options too. Shakes fries and onion rings all above average and good. My chief complaint is that our staff member who took our order was very, very, slow. He was also abrasive, and just messed our order up. We had to wait for a second round of burgers, which was not quick. Even with the unfortunate service, the burger still make up for it. Compared to everything else close by Teddys simply wins out.
(4)Joseph M.
It was ok..like others said I don't see what all the hypes about. The burger was bland and needed more seasoning. The only reason I'm giving 3 stars is because the portion size...but then again for the price I expected a bomb burger, I could make a better one at home. Would not recommend sorry
(3)Mike S.
Awesome food. Best burgers in Maui.
(5)Valeriy K.
Wow, those were great tasty burgers!!! Very satisfied!! The place was also really clean and the ppl were nice. They could be a little more generous on the fries tho.
(4)Lisa K.
My favorite thing was how customizable everything was. I had the no-bun option with lettuce instead, and blue cheese. The smallest burger size seemed quite sufficient unless you're pretty hungry. I found both the fries and the onion rings quite good. Our only problem was that the burgers were a bit too charred tasting, even when they weren't overly done, so I'm not sure if this can be modified.
(4)Vikéndios N.
Wow, it's been almost 3 years since I've eaten at Teddy's!? I'd stop in more often but I hardly come to the west side anymore. ATMOSPHERE: The place is still in great shape and is very clean. It's so reminiscent of In N Out with its similar colors and simple menu. FOOD: Combo #2 - Bigger combo with a 7 oz. patty. This is the perfect size for me. Opted for mushrooms, cheese, tomato, lettuce and special sauce. The patty was cooked nicely and was super tender and juicy, the bun soft, and the natural cut fries were thick, crispy and hot. SERVICE: Super friendly regardless of how busy and bustling the place was on a Sunday during lunch. It took about 10 minutes to get our food, but the wait was so well worth it because everything was fresh and hot. OVERALL: I'm totally a fan. Just the day before, I ate a Double Whopper from BK, and it was within 10-cents of Teddy's price and worlds different. I wish they'd open up shop in Kahului or Wailuku as there are 2 new malls going up!
(4)Bunker T.
Found Teddy's via Yelp after a day of snorkeling and it looked like a fast food spot. BUT... excellent burgers for both of us! Juicy, big, sloppy burger on a fantastic roll really hit the spot. Great food, great staff, great place.
(5)Steph G.
Oh boy, where do I begin? From start to finish, experience was overall quite unsatisfactory. When my love stepped up to the counter, he had to ask the kid (I believe his name was Noah) what a Teri Burger consisted of three times. Each time, he seemed to misunderstand and thought he was ordering it. Occurrence x3 all in a matter of a few minutes. We ordered a bocado burger and a western burger, not long after the rest of our group. Our total? $34 for 2 burger combos and 2 shakes. WTH? No, this is NOT a fancy burger joint. It looks more like a cheesy fast food restaurant, probably more cheesy looking than McD's. Poor fluorescent lighting, rainbow colored decorations, you get the picture. Imagine spending 30 bucks in a joint like that. Everyone else received their orders and were halfway done with their meals as we waited. I finally went up to ask and it turns out, the large girl behind the counter found it sitting without a number, getting nice and cold. Turns out Noah didn't do something correctly and that's why our food never came up. There's more. Get back to my table to find that the Bacado burger is not one at all. Gave it back to the same girl and said this is wrong, we ordered a bacado burger. She says, "oh ok a bacado burger got it." And then proceeds to ask me what's on it? I simply stated, "it's on your main menu board as one of your specials." Asked me same question again. WTH? Can she read? Or figure out where to get her information? She comes back to the table and asks me another question..."Are there mushrooms on the bacado burger?" ARE YOU KIDDING ME LADY?! Tip to the people who run this place: hire some workers who can actually figure out where to get the information they need rather than asking the customers a million times what's on the specials menu. That's just the stupidity that comes behind the counter at this joint. Let me tell you the food was less than mediocre for the price we paid. Patties seemed to have come from frozen, bun was dry and crumbly. You tell me if that's worth 30 bucks. It's not even an issue of poor service, more an issue of IQ with the staff. That in combination with the less than subpar burger equals a very low recommendation from me. Such a waste of money. I work hard for my money and would not waste a penny here again. Wish I could be reimbursed for this ridiculous "dining" experience. I am completely befuddled by the high ratings this place has. BUYER BEWARE.
(1)Lyn S.
The Kailua Burger is my fav! Henry n his staff has awesome customer service!
(5)K M.
If you want the best burgers in Maui come here. I took my wife here for her first Teddy's bigger burger experience and she loved it. Isaiah provided exceptional service, He took extra time to tell my wife about the featured burgers and the other menu selections. We will definitely come back next time we are in Maui.
(5)lisa m.
We love Teddy's!! It's our neighborhood burger joint & we love having it so close by so we can eat our favorite burgers anytime!! The owner Henry is a great guy! Very hospitable & always welcomes everyone as they come in! Thank you Henry & lisa
(5)Wendy B.
Food is so expensive in Maui and this place was a great value. Good burger, yummy tater tots and quick, so you can get back to your vacation fun.
(5)Kayla S.
Great burger joint that definitely doesn't rob your wallet! So glad we decided to stop by for lunch! Friendly service, EXECELLENT burgers. Will for sure stop by on our next visit to Maui :)
(5)Kevin G.
Did this used to be a Chuck E Cheese? The decor is obnoxious and the burgers are middle of the road. They could be the frozen ones you buy from Costco! I don't want to knock it too bad because the staff was very nice and seemed like great employees.
(3)Chris F.
Wow really great burgers. Ask them to go though the menu with you if it is confusing. We are just visiting and they were very nice to go through the options with us. The pineapple. Is really great on any burger, I got Lahaina style and it was really good. If you like just a little spice I would go for that. Get it to go and take it to a beach park, or back to your resort breach and enjoy!!
(5)Vince L.
The eatery was a bit hard to find. I knew it was in the same plaza as Foodland and Barnes & Noble, but the the sign was really high, behind a tree, and in a strange font. As for the menu, it's a pretty simple menu with burgers and fries. The combos seem to be the best deal at $9.95 for a burger, fries and a drink. You can also build your own and get sandwiches. The burgers were cooked to your desired doneness. I think they can cut back on the salt for the fries though. You get a buzzer that vibrates when your meal is ready. What stood out about this location was the staff. They were friendly and even brought stuff to the table. Yes, it's a fast food joint, but please remember to leave a tip if you like the service.
(4)Maureen C.
I liked the burgers here, but they weren't wow. Although my boyfriend's was on the dry side, mine was perfectly juicy and very moist. Not sure why there would be such a big difference since the others in our party also got juicy patties. The onion rings and tots are amazing! Definitely get one of them. The onion doesn't just slide out with only batter left in your fingers, you can actually bite through the batter AND the onion, which I have never experienced before. The service was also really good. We ordered a float that they forgot about, but when we told them they gave us extra scoops of ice cream! Pro-tip: google maps apparently does not really know where this place is, it takes you to some small back-corner street. Look for the huge plaza and just turn in there haha.
(4)K B.
It was aighhht. Burgers were good and fries were better. Price is what makes this place attractive. Some days you just don't want to spend $50 for a meal for 2.5 ppl in Maui. Today's bill at Teddy's was $27.
(4)Maka V.
Burgers were okay. The bun feel apart after 3 bites. Tator tots were good. Hubby thought garlic fries were too garlicy but i liked them. Service was great.
(3)Ebby M.
We come here all the time, and think it is genuinely the best burger around. The fries are big, the shakes are killer, and it's probably the only place around to get jalapeno poppers. Their burgers of the month honestly scare me, but my husband gets them almost every time. If you're the adventurous sort, then that's the way to go! 4/5 stars because it's tougher on our pocketbook than we think it should be, and their tables are too small for our groups.
(4)Scott S.
Came here to get some dinner on the "cheap" at least on island standard. Recommend that anyone who comes here to get the buy one combo get the second for 50%. Both of us had the #1 combo. Burger was seasoned well but the fries did not taste fresh. Sauce on the burger was also good. Service was ok but one of the soda machines was broken and the other had too much carbonation. Again, make sure you get the coupon before you eat here.
(3)Stef N.
Love the burgers and secret sauce. Very clean. Workers are very friendly and helpful. They also offer discount with local ID.
(5)Lala K.
Teddy's Burgers is on my top five bestest burgers list. Everything you want in a burger Teddy's has... Whether it's a plain old fashion cheese burger or if you're they daring type and like to try different addons to your burger. They do have special burgers named after different Hawaiian cities. My go to burger is the Teri burger with Swiss with a side of garlic butter fries yum!! Aside from the delicious food, the restaurant itself is spacious and clean - great for huge groups and kids. And the staff is super friendly! I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a yummy burger!
(5)T W.
As a visitor to Maui, wasn't quite sure how good a hamburger joint would be in a strip center. Well, surprise surprise .... Food was great, service was great, restaurant was clean and staff was very friendly. Highly recommend this place. Had the Blue Wave Special which was hamburger, teriyaki sauce, bacon and blue cheese
(5)Amber K.
Great Tots!! My burger was okay, I couldn't get past the fact that my medium burger was well done. Maybe it was an off day. I'll be back, we'll see. The customer service was great and the restaurant was clean.
(4)Brooke E.
Ya I can dig it
(4)Kristy N.
We came here twice while on vacation. The first time I got just a regular bacon cheeseburger and the hubby got the pastrami Swiss burger with a side of extra crunchy jalapeño cheesy fries. Everything disappeared in front of us within seconds, and I'm the type of girl who ALWAYS has leftovers. So good! The second time the hubby got his usual and I tried the Hawaii burger with add on bacon and cheese. And again with the side of jalapeño cheese fries. We will definitely come back here again on our next visit to Maui :)
(5)Danielle L.
Pretty good burgers and really great onion rings. We went there tonight looking for a quick and cheap meal; this was quick but not reasonably priced. The burgers were good. I got the Waikiki and my husband got the Bacon Me Crazy. He thoroughly enjoyed his and mine was okay. We both prefer Cheeseburger in Paradise for the money though.
(4)Jennifer S.
All the reviews sounded so promising and the pics looked good....but for us it wasn't that great. The onion rings were awful, tasted like some bad frozen grocery store version. My combo came with crispy fries. They tasted like no one changed the oil in the fryer in months. The burger seemed dry to me. To top it all off, it cost us $35 for 2 burger combos and an order of onion rings. Honestly I think carl's jr makes a much better burger.
(2)Shannon A.
I really like this place, burgers are nice and juicy, and the shakes are delicious and super thick (that's what she said), but I had to knock off a star for service. The employees there are all so sweet but it's just really, really slow. I'm here today on a Saturday, and they cannot keep up with the amount of people pouring through the door. I ordered two shakes 30 minutes ago and they still haven't gotten to my order yet (i asked and they said it would be up next). More shake makers please! But, I will still return.
(3)Russell C.
Maybe its just because we dont have very many good burger places here but i think this place is pretty darn good. It caters to everybody by having a great selection of things you can put on your burger. Came here the other day and ordered my usual University burger in the 9oz variety, comes with cheddar cheese hashbrown and spicy teriyaki sauce, then i decide to go crazy and i added pastrami and a side of butter garlic tots. Order comes up and i swear that when i went to pick it up i was gonna start eating at the counter. It looked amazing, then i bit into it, and started have Nirvana like trip that blew every part of my taste buds away. Sweet and savory, crunchy and soft and tender. It was amazing, they i got into the butter garlic tater tots which are drenced in melted butter, garlic and parsley. OMG i dunno if i was just really hungry or i found "my" go to meal. Great now im hungry !
(5)Nadia H.
I'm really not sure what the hub bub is about. My burger was blah. I'm wondering if this place is all about the toppings, and all this excitement is really just, "the massive combination of toppings that totally hid the flavor of the burger were so great!" I am not a tons-o-toppings gal, as some of my previous reviews have shared. So if you are, please move along, this review is not for you. If you, like me, like to enjoy the burger itself - this place did not deliver. Burger was not medium, it was definitely a dry-well-done. Nothing unique or flavorful about it. Onion rings were decently good.
(2)Taylor B.
Not quite sure what all the hype is about. It's a basic burger joint covered in contemporary colored seating and ceiling tiles making it look like a kids play house. Staff was friendly but it was a bit pricey for a plain cheeseburger and fries.
(2)Doreen B.
This is the place that one that can satisfy a real burger craving. During my 2nd pregnancy - I only craved hamburgers. It was my mission to find a perfect burger but also a decent burger on each side of the island. This one takes the crown for best and best in the west. If you're a fan of the 5 Guys chain - this is a cut above with a little aloha to go with. My favorites: Lahaina Burger Makawao Burger Anything with their Onolicious sauce :) They offer Kamaaina rates upon request. If you're in a hurry, call in your order and chow down beach side. We haven't tried the shakes yet but hear they are delicious. Once you've had a 7 oz burger and fries to split, there isn't much room for a PB Shake ;)
(5)Jeri H.
This was on our list of places to try and we were NOT disappointed! Burgers were cooked perfectly! Onion rings- on point! Yes, we did wait approx 10min but the food was oh-so-good! Great place to recharge after an afternoon of snorkeling. The place was exceptionally clean! YAY!!! The staff was awesome. This place certainly knows how to dish ALOHA! Mahalo for a great lunch!
(4)Cassandra D.
Been to Teddy's 3 TIMES! Loved their burgers&fries every single time! My first was located in Oahu and the other two visits were in Maui! Excellent burgers! The beef patties are so lean and perfectly cooked to however you like it! The sizes of pattoes go from 5-9 oz. I always get 7, just right for me. The Waikiki, University, and King of the Dojo burgers are OFF THE CHARTS. I think ALL of their burgers and sides are very good. YOU MUST COME HERE!
(5)Michael G.
Burgers are overcooked, why do you ask if medium is okay but then you go ahead and burn them? EXPENSIVE $8 for a 7 oz hamburger??? Great fries. $3.99 for 4 chicken nuggets.
(2)Lance T.
I'd eat at Teddy's, in fact I'd eat there all the time if they would change their burger buns. The bun is literally stopping me from eating there. I thought about ordering a burger and taking it home and putting it on my own bun bought from Safeway. At Least then the burger won't disintegrate in my hands while I'm trying to eat it. Shakes are good, fries are good, burgers cooked well, and the bun literally kills the deal! Change it or offer a better bun for more money and I'll come back.
(3)Kristie F.
Excellent food and service .we didn't mind paying a little extra for frest and fast food. After we walked across the plaza for icecream. Easy to find .
(5)David P.
I like that they read all about how 5 Guys works and their business model, but this falls way short in all regards. The grown-nearby ingredients and discount if you say you are local are nice, but after that its just hastily made, sloppy burgers with inconsistent toppings and shakes made from syrup. The employees don't help the ambience as they mumble what you hope is your order in a blank stare and go back to texting as soon as you pay. So sorry we interrupted them! I wish we had gone to Cheeseburgers In Paradise instead.
(2)Mari N.
I've always enjoyed taking the long drive from town to come to Lahaina specially for Teddy's Bigger Burgers but I'm extremely disappointed on my last visit this past time. I should have known upon entering that something was wrong. There was a long line (which is normal on any friday night) however, these customers were coming up to say their order was either wrong or worse - their burgers weren't fully cooked!! Decided to ignore that fact and stood in line. When it came to my turn, we weren't greeted with any greetings, not even a "hi, may I take your order?" Nothing. The guy just stared at us like aliens. Strike one. He didn't seem to know the menu at all and didn't correctly ring up my original order. It took 3 tries and another employee being in my opinion very rude to the customer - like I had made a mistake when I was making my order. Strike two. We sat down to wait for our food and changed from three different tables because while the tables were clean - the seats were greasy and the floors were filthy. Like the employees just wiped the contents from the table onto the floor. The food wasn't even at the table yet and I wanted to leave. Strike three, your out. My overall experience this time is disappointing and to make the drive out to Lahaina, I think I'll carefully choose next time. My chicken sandwich was the same - I enjoyed it. However, the burgers my family ordered were still red and bloody. Maybe management changed but I hope someone gets a handle on the situation because I've always enjoyed the food here at Teddy's, I'd hate to see a great business crumble from employee inattentiveness.
(2)Michael C.
Was hard to find the place since the signage was confusing and not clear plus google maps gives you incorrect directions. So we started off a little unhappy. The main menu is unclear what is on the burger and if you want one of the featured burgers, that menu is way off to the left and a bit confusing. The burgers were just average and the fries just ok. The onion rings were crispy but in my opinion too much batter and not much onion. The soda machine did not have any carbonation so yucky. Not sure why this place is 4 1/2 stars!! Really???
(1)Chris B.
Aside from the great prices, this place was delicious. Got a 7oz terry burger..... Nom nom!! I Love the customization, and the service is always friendly.
(4)Ling L.
I really wanted this place to be great! Service was great. The people seem to like working there. Fries- the best fries i have had on the island so far. fried to order and freshly cut with perfect thickness. Cajun burger -cajun flavoring of the meat was good. Just a slight kick. Sauce and toppings were also good but the meat should be the star of the burger and it was dry. Also they advertise this as sweet and spicy and i did not get much of the sweet. Since this is a burger joint i need to deduct points for dry meat. I'm willing to give the other burgers a try. And overall everything seemed fresh.
(3)Lisa W.
Good, fast service. Great flavor burgers, fries & shakes. 5 out of 5 stars all the way!
(5)Kathy S.
I've always loved Teddy's...I've been going to the one in Honolulu, and didn't know that there was one on Maui! Burgers are always juicy and tasty. We needed a light snack after a disappointing lunch at a nearby noodle place one day. When I found Teddy's nearby on Yelp, we headed straight for there! The original Burger with Cheese is always a good choice, but.. if you're hungry, go for the Monster Double Combo with bacon, mushroom, and jalapenos! Yum! The Garlic Tots are always a favorite, but the onion rings are really good too! Prices are decent, but beware, if you eat too much, you'll end up with the kanack-attack!
(5)Barrett F.
Delicious food and shakes, relaxed ambiance, and fresh food prepared quickly, without being fast food. Friendly workers, clean eating area, and enjoyable music. It's off the normal tourist path of lahaina and ka'anapali, and is a great gem.
(5)Brig V.
I know Cheeseburgers & so does Teddy's! They also know how to make you feel welcome. I was thrilled to find them tucked back off the local drag in Lahaina. Prices were reasonable and food was beyond fantastic. I ate there 2 days in a row and the staff was so helpful going out of their way to ensure the restaurant was clean and the customers were overly satisfied. Order a milkshake here! and of course a Cheeseburger.
(5)Dj P.
Our burgers were super dry. Not sure why they ask how you'd like your burger cooked because no matter what our order was...all of our burgers came out dry. Their buns are too big...not tasty. The best part were the tots..but how can you go wrong w/ those? Just fry them up!! Go grab a burger at Shark Pit Maui..for a juicy burger..and a better experience.
(2)Grace V.
Had the Lahaina burger combo with the garlic fries. Al were very good but I don't think it was worth $14. However I did enjoy it and the service was good.
(4)Don M.
After eating at restaurant after restaurant, I was craving a hamburger in a casual setting. I stumbled onto this place and got a great restaurant quality burger (if not better). They have six sizes of burgers (three size patties with the option of a single or a double). They also offer turkey burgers. Their specialty burgers are great. I had the Ranchero Burger and it was great. I would have prefered the fried egg to be runny, so if I make it back there, I will request it that way. I enjoyed this place so much, I stopped by again on the way to the airport and took it with me. Somehow I managed to eat it before I made it there. It was awesome. Visited December 2012
(5)Miko M.
over-rated and over-priced. I have no idea how this place has 4.5 stars! The only thing I can think of is that Maui must not have very many good burger places. I'm from SoCal and there are a lot of amazing burger options, so maybe this has something to do with my huge disappointment. What I did LIKE: I liked the variety of toppings and sauces available for the burgers. I had the cheese fries and they were pretty decent. (nothing amazing) My turkey burger was juicy and did have decent flavor. Why I was so disappointed: It's very over-priced for what your get and the quality. It's FAST FOOD...which would be ok, if the food was better. The actual beef burger was tasteless (according to my bf) The bun looks great in the picture.....but was just a cold white bun, not even toasted. If you are visiting Maui (like I was), skip this mediocre place and spend your money elsewhere. If you are from Maui and it's your only burger option, well....I feel bad for you...you should come visit Cali and experience In-n-out or Umami Burger or The Counter to name a few.
(2)Lars J.
The number 4 is HUGE! Large garlic fries are HUGE! It's not cheap. Were talking a $14 burger here. But it's worth it. The fries are perfectly crisp and the garlic isn't overpowering. Bottomless soda.
(5)Nate S.
Great little spot in west Maui. 50s themed burger joint. Very creative burgers or just your plain old hamburger. We had the pigskin burger and the Hawaiian style classic. The pigskin was a normal burger with pulled pork and a fire sauce on top. Not too spicy though. The Hawaiian style had pineapple and a teriyaki sauce. Both burger were very tasty. The beef itself was juicy and had a great beef taste. We upgraded to tater tots. Those were some of the best tater tots I have ever had. They were crispy but not overdone and had a wonderful seasoning. The place is a little pricey. $27 for two burgers, upgraded tots, and a milkshake. The service was wonderful. They were very knowledgeable about their menu items and very friendly to us. I definitely recommend.
(5)Sherwin A.
Staff seems to be friendly. Walked in and was asked if I've been there before. I said no and they explained the full menu. Burger options were unique and tasty. I got the Lahaina style burger with garlic fries and chocolate peanut butter milk shake. It was pretty expensive for a burger combo ($15) but I was on vacation so I didn't mind the price. I just wanted to try it out. I was satisfied with the meal. If I were to make a complaint, it would be that the burger can get wet, break apart, and get messy.
(4)Jim H.
It was ok. A little spendy for what we got. Of course looking at others' reviews I see there is a coupon I missed out on - ah well. We came in the evening when there wasn't much of a wait. I probably would have been annoyed if I had waited 40 mins like one of the other reviewers. I enjoyed Paradise and Cool Cat more. Interior was a lot like other fast food places.
(3)T. T.
Finally a decent veggie burger in Lahaina! Yes! The servers and cashiers were all super friendly and they were working hard to keep things moving. I appreciated the fact that the restaurant was relatively clean and bright. The burgers were great (both the beef and the veggie) except for the potato buns that kept falling apart. Next time I'm ordering the wheat bun. The onion rings were nice and crispy and my 2yr old loved having tater tots instead of fries. Brilliant! The garlic fries were the only miss in my book. They looked amazing, but tasted like sugar and butter with some crushed garlic. Ick. We'll be back again. Now to find that coupon everyone is talking about...
(4)Day B.
Best burger in Lahaina! Can't really say which burger is best because it's a toss up. The shakes are good, the fries are good and there's always good seats.
(5)Chris D.
Food was great and reasonably priced! Pros: prices are reasonable and meals are big enough for two to share! I had a chocolate shake (black and white) and it was delicious!!! The fries are also great and fresh. Cons: we had a crispy chicken sandwich and were not big fans of the mustard sauce on it.
(5)Tamra P.
A week long vacation included indulging in lots of Food Network. Yes, I was in Maui and should be doing lots of things other than watching TV but whatever. It's not my first time here and being a FT working mom with 2 under 2 having some time to watch any TV is a luxurious indulgence. So anyway.....it had me craving a juicy burger. While I really wanted to try somewhere new Teddy's had the best reviews for burgers in the area. Tried and true at home, I sent the hubby to pick up a Kailua burger with onion rings. Ooohhhh how delicious this was! I ordered it well done, light on the sauce (yes burger foodies I can feel you cringing) but that's how I like my burgers and despite the request it was still juicy perfection to me. A 5 oz burger and half the onion rings were plenty to have me satisfied. Hubby loved his selection as well, particularly the peanut butter shake. Glad to see the Maui Teddy's at least as good as the ones on Oahu!
(4)Mikihala M.
Excellent burgers for the price. So filling!! The nephews loved it! Adults loved it! Best shakes around!
(4)Brent W.
The food was meh, but we are in Hawaii. Extra stars for super nice staff. I got the plantation tots. They were short on the pulled pork and had a super spicy BBQ sauce. Others in our group got various burgers. Definitely pink in the middle. Most in our group did not finish their meals, but it was a fun atmosphere. Getting to the place google maps had us at a dead end in a residential area. This time apple maps is better.
(4)Madison H.
Wow these hamburgers were awesome! Would recommend the western burger and the Lahina burger! Very fresh and be prepared to be stuffed afterwards. The spicy fries and garlic fries were Devine as well. Awesome spot for a meal for lunch! Would highly recommend!!!
(5)Tim W.
After a day on the beach and in the sun, our Teddy's burger hit the spot. The burgers are huge so I didn't even attempt a bigger burger. The service was friendly and the place was clean. For the area the price was very reasonable, my burger combo was 10 bucks. Its a laid back atmosphere and a good place for families who just want the all-american burger.
(5)Mark P.
I'm in outside sales so I eat out a LOT! In fact, I am a burger connoisseur! This place serves one of the best burgers around. Probably ranks in my TOP 3 or 4 . Alex took our order and he was awesome. He was friendly, helpful, and enjoyable to talk with. Like I said, I eat out a lot and some places hire the most incredible idiots that won't even say "thank you" or engage you in conversation in any way. Or worse yet, they'll just grunt at you because they really don't want to be there. This place is clean, the people were great, the food was awesome AND they do a classic car show. I missed it, but anyplace that's into hot rods can't be ignored. On top of that, I didn't see one homeless dirtbag loitering around (unlike McDonald's) We're definitely going back! They run a top notch operation!
(5)Doug S.
I've been wanting to try this place as I am a burger aficionado. Having tried every burger place on Maui, I finally spent several days at home perfecting the burger the way I like them, including grinding my own beef and making my own buns. As expected, no one can come to close to my burger, so I do have a built in bias. LOL. Sadly, unless you know me and get a personal invite for my homemade burger and fries, you'll have to suffer and pay for a high priced premium burger at either Teddy's or Cool Cats. Burger lovers come in many shapes and sizes. Personally, I am partial to the burger cooked on a griddle and not too thick as I think it preserves the juiciness of the meat and gives the best meat to bun ratio. That being said, Teddy's is a charbroiled burger and for that style, they do it as good as anyone. I made the mistake of ordering the double when I should have ordered the single. I started pooping out about 3/4 of the way through. Don't get me wrong, it was good. I always stick with the traditional burger with cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and whatever house sauce that is offered. I ordered the regular fries (thick cut style) and they were good as well. IMHO, I believe this burger tops Cool Cat's burger, but of course it is a close toss up.
(5)Christine K.
Teddy's Bigger Burger's was my favorite place to eat during my stay in West Maui. I tried over five different restaurants near the resort area, and Teddy's was worth every buck. I ordered the 5 oz burger and customized it. The burger comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, and their special sauce, but I added grilled onions and jalepenos. It was perfect! The patty was not dry and cooked nicely. My boyfriend was starving and ordered the 7 oz, but I think the 5 oz burger will satisfy most. This place is a lot cheaper than other restaurants that I checked out like Hula Grill and Kimo's, but the food is up to par. Definitely worth the try!
(4)M C.
Dude...where are the burgers??? I visited this past Monday and was told that their grill was out of service, so only fried foods were being offered. What kind of burger place has only one grill and has to stop making their signature item when it has a malfunction? The family wound up getting very overpriced chicken sandwiches and average fries, but only after a 20+ minute wait after we had ordered. Apparently, the staff at this location are very slow and don't know how to prioritize orders. People who came in after us were served 5-10 minutes before us with their food. I had to go up to the counter to ask what was up with the long wait and I can't remember the last time I had to do that at any dining establishment (and they didn't even have burgers...you don't fry food for over 20 minutes, so not sure what the people in the kitchen were up to). The staff was apologetic and asked us to call prior to coming in next time to see if their grill was working and if they were serving burgers. Needless to say, I wasn't going to give them my business for another overpriced meal after the insanely slow service. It's a shame because I had really wanted to try their burgers, but tourists can't waste time revisiting a food joint on precious vacation time after such a poor first impression.
(1)G. M.
This is a LOVE HATE relationship for me. My weakness is really good burgers, and they have nailed it here. I try to limit myself to once every couple of months. If weight or health were not important to me...I'd be here all the time.
(5)J D.
Great burgers. Need some time to figure how to order. Build to order is the best way. You can upgrade your soda to a shake but they don't really tell you that upfront. Clean sitting area. Burgers can be burnt so order to taste. By default it's well done and charred. Great place after all is done. No beer.
(4)Artemis I.
I tried the original burger with cheese. Big fan!! It was delicious!! I want another one! The milkshake however, tasted a bit too much like just ice cream and the consistency was more like ice cream than a milkshake. Nonetheless, I will be back here!! I want to try all the burgers!
(4)Brandon Y.
Ordered two burgers, 5 oz and 7 oz. Waited a long time to get order. Both burgers were served very rare. Bloody rare. So rare that the buns were soaking up the red bloody liquid. Asked staff to cook burger a bit longer. Waited another 15 minutes to get burger. I would never come back here again. Worst burger i've had in a long time.
(1)Karen S.
Wow! This place lived up to it's reviews. My hamburger was rare enough to moo. My garlic fries were piled high with garlic and dripping with butter. My chocolate milkshake was one of the very best I have ever had. My nutritionist would not be happy about my calorie intake, but I enjoyed my meal to the last morsel. Excellent!
(5)Phung H.
The Mahi Burger is soo good! Gotta get the special sauce. Fries are crispy and thick! Highly recommend!
(5)Lilian S.
UPDATE: I just went back to Teddy's to give it one more chance and they got my order right! Finally! Also, my burger was delicious. The owner wrote me back and apologized for the wrong order incidents. I'm glad such a caring person owns this Maui restaurant. 5 stars! I'm officially finished going to THIS Teddy's Bigger Burger. The past three times I've visited this restaurant, the cooks got my order wrong! I have come to the conclusion that this was not a mistake made by the person taking my order because he put in my order correctly on the register (therefore my receipt). The cooks are continuously talking amongst one another, incredibly slow, and did not get the orders correct. I was contemplating taking my order back, but I feared my next burger would have more than what I asked for on it. I ordered an original with cheese, sauce, and grilled onions. The burger I received was an original with sauce. Therefore, I paid extra for items I did not receive on my burger. I'm disappointed because I truly enjoy these burgers on Oahu (I just moved back to Maui). I guess I'll have to find another burger joint.
(5)Andrea C.
Wow, the burgers at Teddy's are really amazing. what a super great find. I will visit this place every time I'm in Hawaii!
(5)Evan F.
Really thick, juicy burgers. I especially like the potato bun. I'm not the biggest fan of their fries, but I do like their tater tots. Plus, if you happen to be from or live in Hawaii, you get a kama'aina discount, which helps since it can be pricey.
(4)Cid H.
A decent burger, but don't come in with high expectations. It's your basic Five Guys clone, with the added twist of a few local-style specialty burgers. I ordered one of the spicier burger options (pepper jack cheese and grilled hot pepper), and it was okay. The fries were also...okay. The burgers themselves were slightly dry, and they were cooked medium when I asked for medium-well. Again, it's an okay burger joint if you're looking for standard burger fare. And since the restaurant itself is colorful and "fun," I imagine younger kids would probably like it. But I'm not seven and I was hoping for something a little better.
(3)Joshua O.
I must say. "Mighty Tasty" its hard to f up a burger. Ive seen it done before. This place is definitely not one of those places. I had the 5oz western burger, comes with a drink and fries. Mmmm... Fat boy delight. The wife had the mahi fish & chips. Pretty bomb. The lady ringing us up. Vicky. Good spirited gal. Very friendly and helpful. She recommended the pumpkin shake. The best I ever tasted. I will be back. Most definitely.
(5)Rob K.
The burger is bigger, and better, than anything else you will find in Lahaina. Great value too! Definitely coming back on my next visit.
(5)Sep G.
This place would be a go to if I lived on this beautiful island!!! Clean, good food, fresh ingredients and great service. Try the crispy chicken sandwich, if your not in to burgers as my wife can be picky at times. Defiantly try the onion rings(soooo good) and the burgers are tasty and fresh. Great casual quick burger joint on the island!! Mahalo!
(5)Paul H.
Found Teddy's in a little strip mall across the street from the Lahaina Cannery Mall when looking for a place to grab a good burger for lunch while vacationing in Kaanapali. Had their original burger combo with cheese. The place reminded me of an In 'N Out or a Five Guys with their small menu and ordering system. The burgers were cooked to order and took a little over five minutes to come out. Burger had great flavor and was hot and juicy. The fries were nice and crisp and not greasy at all. Definitely worthy of the good reviews they've received.
(4)Eugene S.
Just ok. Super expensive and slow. Probably would not return. Burgers were good, but no better than any other typical burger joint. Our 4 burgers came out well done. The menu says they'll be medium. Strawberry and chocolate shakes were good. The fries were acceptable. The biggest knock is the values. Two combos plus two burgers and two shakes was +$50. I need a better meal for $13 per person.
(3)Bryce F.
Based on other reviews, I had high expectations. I found the service to be outstanding, and the restaurant to be clean, etc. but I did not find the burger to be particularly special. It was large, and everything was fine, just not comparable to a Fuddruckers or similar, in my opinion.
(3)Shirley N.
What a great burger. Three different size offerings = 5,7, or 9 oz. Served on a toasted egg burger bun. We first were exposed to Teddy's on Oahu last week. But we only ordered fries and the dreamsicle shake. Then I was flipping through a free Maui dining brochure last night and saw the ad for Teddy's here in Lahaina. The four of us were ready for a juicy burger. So many toppings to select from, but I went with a cheddar cheeseburger with grilled onions and a soda. Hubby got a bacon cheeseburger and a chocolate shake. The shakes are great. Pure ice cream and extra thick. Great juicy ground chuck meat party. Dressed with special sauce, lettuce, tomato, and pickles. Reminds me somewhat of In N Out back home. Be prepared to use tons of paper napkins. They'll even come by to give you an alcohol wipe for your fingers. And a survey card if you choose to complete about the customer service provided. On it, there's a mention of their turnaround time of 10-15 minutes from ordering to cooking to your table since the burgers are cooked to order. You're given a pager. Find a table and when your pager flashes, your order is ready. It's worth the wait for an quality burger.
(4)Alessandra H.
Great burgers! Excellent service. Fast even though it was busy and late. Only tiny complaint is our burgers were a little on the rare side, but still delightful. We would go back. Affordable for Maui food.
(4)Meghana B.
This is one of the best burger joints I have come across so far. There are tons of choices for the burgers to suit all your palettes - spicy, sweet, rustic, old-fashioned... The patty is flavorful and succulent. I had the fish burger and that is something totally worth trying...
(4)Marty K.
I haven't sampled many burgers in Lahaina but the burger was cooked well and the price was acceptable for Maui. ($15 for a 9oz burger, Garlic fries and a drink). I ordered the Bacado burger. It needed double bacon and double cheese. If it's food you want, check it out. If it's a view and ambiance then keep looking. it's a 50's themed burger "joint". Tip: skip the garlic fries. I might try the plantation fries next time.
(3)Andrea S.
The original burger is good but the fries with garlic are even better and alone a reason to come here. In case your really want to punish yourself, go for the healthy crossfit burger, possibly after a training in the nearby box. Mahi Mahi is a good choice as well but nowhere close to the others.
(4)Bianca R.
Great burgers, ok fries. Try the Lahaina burger with teriyaki chicken, no aioli. Yum!
(4)David L.
The only thing better than the food was the staff. Great burger, great fries. So much better than Cool Cat Cafe.. not even close. Ask for double vegetables and double sauce and you'll never be disappointed. Offered senior discount without having to ask for it (must be all the grey) Couldn't give a higher recommendation, maybe even better than the double double from In & out David & Cheri
(5)Carolyn A.
The shakes and malts were good. The rest? Not so much. The burger was ok, the fries mediocre, and the big ole bun was stale. We kept asking about our shakes and was told they would bring them out to us. The high point was the shakes - which we finally got as we headed out the door.
(2)Anh T.
OMG these burgers are so good. Burgers are so delicious and I don't know what they did to their but it is so good. You can get the burgers in a multitude of sizes and the smallest one is sufficient for me. But the oscar goes to the garlic fries. I had a lot o garlic fries in my lifetime but I've never had garlic fries with garlic SO SWEET. I could have mistaken them for caramelized onions. Don't cheat yourself, treat yourself... with these fries. SERIOUSLY you won't regret it!
(5)Chalette H.
I changed my mind will go back.
(5)Trevor J.
I enjoyed the divey atmosphere and reminded me of a Johnny Rockets. The food was really good and I enjoyed the burger. The milkshake was something on a hot day that was a necessity. The only reason a star is deducted is due to the price of the burgers. The ratio of cost vs. enjoyment isn't worthy of a 5 star, but it definitely worth trying if you can put away a big burger.
(4)Lexie V.
I LOVE Teddy's. When i used to live in Hawaii, this was my favorite place for a burger. Teddy's is Hawaii's own burger chain and it's a damn shame it's not on the mainland because it blows all of our burger chains away. First, their burgers are always freshly prepared. Second, they are HUGE and there is a crazy variety of possible toppings, including jalapeno poppers (uh, yum!). Their fries are great, and oh, and did I mention they make the best super thick shakes ever? And they have about 15 different flavors, my personal favorite being the creamsicle one. This is the first place I beelined to when our plane landed in Maui. My vegetarian bf had never been and he was blown away by his veggie burger too and wanted to go back during our trip to eat it one more time. Awesome, fresh made-to-order food, polite staff, clean restaurant. What's not to love?
(5)Virginia B.
Husband and I went for lunch on 11-5-2014...both ordered the original 5 oz cooked medium. Order came cooked well. They don't toast your buns which I prefer. I'd rate this an ok, nothing to rave about.
(3)Ron W.
The thing I like best (besides the Burger) is that the entire staff seems to be really happy doing what they do & they make ME FEEL like they actually care that I'm happy with my food & service. Thanx Teddy! Now, if I only had room for a shake
(5)Stephani G.
Very good original burger. The bun is a giant potato, not my fav. The fries are plain unless you pay to upgrade. The grilled onions were not worth the $0.60 upgrade. The best part was the seasoning of the burger and the strawberry shake which added on one star in and of itself. Be prepared to wait for your food, very tasy food. Good prices too. Don't be cheap about upgrading the combo to a shake, the strawberry was delish!
(4)Dena H.
The burgers are excellent! There are a lot of options on the menu but talk to the workers there, they'll help you decide what to get. The garlic fries were so yummy!
(5)Ethan S.
This place is SO. GOOD. One of the highest quality burgers I've ever had. Pigskin Classic (patty not overcooked, lots of pulled pork (not fatty) and delicious bacon. A highlight: The side of tots layered with pulled pork, melted cheese and fire sauce (which, btw, isn't too spicy).
(5)Veronica J.
Decent burgers and chicken sandwich. They do give local people a discount. One burger combination is around 12 dollars. Place get busy at lunch time but service is fast.
(3)Anthony N.
This place makes a solid buger and fries. The portions are just right. The burgers seemed huge to me. The flavor was spot on. The only reason I didn't rate this five stars was that from the time we ordered to the time we received our food was a little long(20 min). But other than that this place is great.
(4)Maya S.
A must stop if you love a good burger, garlic fries, and TOTS!!! Go, just go. Family friendly, and in the grand scheme of one of the priciest locations, not a bad deal. You can even get the "biggest burgers" and split them! The shakes looked great but we were too full to try them. My fifteen year old would have eaten there every day if we would have let him!
(5)Mark C.
Good burgers! Consistent and people that helped us each time we've been there are very nice! Good for families! Will continue going there,
(5)Carol L.
Yum! This is a fun, bright, clean burger joint. The burger options were varied and could be customized any which way. I had their "Debbie" burger (named after a customer) that had bacon, pepper jack, avocado, and tons of jalapenos. It was great! The fries were really good, but I enjoyed the tots more. My son had a corn dog and it was also really good. We all shared a chocolate peanut butter shake and it was spoon thick and yummy. This was a NOT fast food burger joint that, if I lived there, would be in my rotation. The only negative was that the employee managed to get both my and my husband's order wrong (not sure how) but they fixed it right away with an apology. It was all good.
(5)Steve S.
Outstanding original monster burger (2) 5oz patty and cheese and all the fixings on a great bun! Shakes are sure thick and choice of chocolate ,vanilla, strawberry, peanut butter or mix your kind. When u come to Maui this place is must for any burger maniac!
(5)Maria G.
Yelp directions won't get you there. It's in the back of the Lahaina Gateway shopping center, across the highway from Longs. Start with a simple Big Burger combo. 5oz burger, fries and a drink for about $11. I don't even think it needs cheese. I tried a few different combos including the western bacon cheese but it was not as good as the basic burger. My husband had the veggie burger with avo and it was half an avocado! The special sauce is so good and really sets this burger apart. Then again, the bun, pickles and everything else do too. I'm hoping they open one here in San Francisco where there are more than enough burger places but none as good as Teddy's.
(5)Matt W.
Oh man....the burgers here are delicious. I would pound a second, but I can't because I'm stuffed from the first. I'll be dreaming about this place tonight.
(5)DH S.
Big fan of Teddy's on Maui. We try to stop by every trip out to the island. You can taste the quality in the burgers. Always full of locals when we've stopped in. My little boys (5 & 2) both love their cheeseburgers. I'm a fan of Islands Hawaiian so of course I opt for the Hawaiian style, which doesn't dissapoint.
(4)David S.
People--The people behind the counter were very friendly and nice. Great experiences both times we visited. Milkshakes--they were awesome--suggest the haupia and the pina coloda. We went back a second time just for the shakes. Food--The hamburgers were good and I would have them again--they were not over the top delicious (maybe needs better seasoned meat) but it was a solid burger. The bun was too soft--should use a more substantial bun. Overall, nice experience--would go again and definitely get the milkshakes.
(4)Jess L.
Teddy's bigger burgers food is great. They cook it fresh and the employees are really nice. It has your standard style fast food restaurant dining room, nothing special. They give a local discount but it is pretty minimal. As usual it is pretty overpriced, even for Maui. I got a 7oz bacon cheeseburger and a small tator tot and it was over $13 even with my local discount. They charge for sauces if you want anything above and beyond ketchup or mustard. I will go back I'm sure but I don't frequent this burger joint because of the prices. Great burgers with a lot of topping choices.
(4)John W.
I'm going to make this one simple. This is probably the gourmet burger chain going. Being from NY, we've had them all - Shake Shack, Fatburger, Umami, Bareburger, Bobby's Burger Palace, American Roadside, Five Guys, Checkers, Sonic, and so on. But it was unanimous for me, my wife and two teenage sons - this place wins hands down over the others for their burgers and shakes. Did it take 10-15 mins to get our burgers, yes. But they were prepared and cooked to exactly what we asked for. Did the bun fall apart, yes. But we're in it for the meat and fixings, not the bread. The only things I'm knocking are the garlic fries and onion rings (we've had better from some of the places named above) and the price ($80 for the four of us -- this is a take-out burger joint, right?)
(4)Shauna L.
Friendly service, great burgers and fun music! My sweets and I both ordered burgers and shared some chili cheese fries. I got the kids burger and it was the perfect size for me. It had a really nice grilled flavor and was cooked perfectly. All the toppings were fresh and the buns were fresh too. Oh and I have to point out that I love grilled onions on a burger and these were by far the best cooked grilled onions I've had on a burger in forever. They sliced them nice and thick and didn't skimp at all. The chili cheese fries were also good. The small was the perfect size to split. I loved that they use cheese sauce instead of shredded cheese on the fries too. Kind of reminded me of steak n shake cheese sauce. They played oldies music which was a nice touch. We will be going back for sure.
(4)Lucy L.
Awesome place for a delicious burger. Portion is nice and big. Reminds me of Inn-n-Out and Five Guys. Definitely recommend it for cheap eats in the area. My Yelp deal made it even better.
(5)David P.
Great burger joint with totally casual atmosphere. Reasonable prices. I'd definitely go again.
(4)Karey R.
Oh we looooove Teddy's. The whole family loved everything there, the staff, the food quality, the cleanliness, everything was great. My favorite was the Hawaiian Style Burger. My daughter and son loved the milkshakes and kid's meals. Teddy's is the perfect place to go after spending all morning at the beach. All you have to do make the short drive up from Lahaina and you've got yourself a delicious meal for 1/4 of the price. I can't imagine why anyone would go to a tourist trap on Front St. when Teddy's Bigger Burger's is less that a 5 minute drive from there. It's seriously scrumptious.
(5)Tyler C.
Found this place by chance and decided to give it a shot. Really impressed with the food quality and service provided by the staff. Would recommend to anyone visiting Maui! Filling meals at decent prices. YUM.
(5)Jim S.
We spent all week eating at amazing restaurants. Had a craving for a burger. Stopped by this place and it absolutely rocked! Great shakes, garlic fries and burgers. Great price too for a family of 5. Highly recommend it!
(5)Min C.
Great food, great service, and friendly staff. I'm originally from SoCal, where there's a lot of good burger joints so I have been spoiled. So was craving a burger at lunch and decided to check out Teddy's because it had great reviews on yelp and I was not disappointed. I was ordering a custom burger but the cashier suggested I order one of the burgers that had the same toppings, nice of him to save me a little $. They give out wet naps to everyone, very thoughtful as the burgers are big and it can messy. If your hungry for a burger, definitely give them a try
(5)Mary P.
When I come back to the island this is the first place I go I always have a craving for Teddy's bigger burger. We have a home here in Maui and California I wish Teddy's was in California. We have recommended Teddy's to all of our friends that live here and the ones that come to visit no one has ever been disappointed. Thanks for a great Burger. Also the employees are very friendly. They go out of there way to make sure you're satisfied and have everything you need.
(5)Brook H.
We had just gotten off the Lana'i ferry and were looking for something simple to pick up before we headed back to Kihei. That's when Teddy's came up on our search for something tasty to eat. Oh boy did we make the right choice... First, the environment is cool. A mix of soda shop and 80's surf shop, it's a nice little place to grab a burger. The staff were friendly, even an hour before close, and made our food fresh and hot. Even when I later asked for a shake, while they were already cleaning up one of the machines for the night, they had no problem making it for me. Second, the food is awesome. The burgers are huge and they have so many awesome styles. Whatever you do, get their special sauce on it (which automatically comes that way unless you say differently). So many different cheeses, toppings, sauces, etc. I love the Waikiki, with cheddar, teriyaki, and "hashbrowns" (tater tots). The shakes? WOW. Using locally-made Maui ice cream, I couldn't stop downing mine. Pineapple shakes rock! So, if you're in Hawai`i and you see one of these places, STOP. Get some great burgers, tasty shakes, and enjoy the experience!
(4)Rebecca D.
My husband and I are visiting from Washington State for our anniversary and we stopped by Teddy's Bigger Burgers, absolutely amazing!! Our burgers tasted like we were at a backyard bbq. They were fast and friendly. Our food was fresh and hot. You must visit Teddy's if you come to Maui!
(5)Christian A.
Best burger spot on the island! Lots of menu choices that you cannot find anywhere else. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Takes a bit longer to get your food, but worth the wait IMO.
(4)Rocco P.
The Tater Tots are amazing!!!! I'd up it to 3.5 stars for the tots alone. I had the 5oz Cajun Burger with Teri sauce. The bun was delightful, soft and supple - almost a potato bread. The amount of meat seemed fine for as hungry as I was. Topping were a good choice although I was expecting the burger to be drenched with teri sauce as opposed to just having some as dressing swirled on top. I recommend. I'm a huge iced tea fan and was disappointed the tea was from a coke dispenser vs. fresh.
(3)Taylor S.
The best burger I have ever had! Every time I'm in Maui I have to stop in here a couple times a week! The staff is friendly and caring. They give you hand wipes before and after you eat. They have the best shakes (chocolate peanut butter is my fav) and burgers! It can get very crowded in here though!
(5)Jaime T.
Great service....delicious food at a really great price. They even give a good kamaaina discount. One of my favorite restaurants! Worth the drive from Kihei.
(5)Ally C.
Food is a little on the pricey side for burgers and shakes, but their service is prompt and friendly, and the food is good. We originally ordered ahead by phone and picked up so we could eat elsewhere. The food really hit the spot so a few days later we went back just for shakes. I especially liked the chocolate and peanut butter milkshake.
(4)Ania S.
We decided to come here 5 minutes to close since tropical storm Flossie caused our room service to be delayed. Lemme tell u. This place is Ahhhmmmmmmaaazzzzinnnnnnggg!!!! Hands down the most tasty, delicious, filling, juicy, perfectly cooked burger, ever. (And I'm from Chicago. We have a lot of good burger places ;) ) The service is awesome!! The guys took care of us with 5 minutes to close without an attitude or smirk that we walked in so late. thank you for a memorable meal on our Maui Honeymoon! This place is Diners, Drive ins and Dives material!!! My husband recommends "The Dude" with pulled pork....mmmmmm! And I had the red blue (bacon, frank's red hot, blue cheese) A plus too.....they have jalapeño poppers with cream cheese! I highly recommend Teddy's for a tasty and reasonably priced lunch or dinner or late night pig out :)
(5)Marcy U.
Simply one of the worst burgers I have ever eaten. First of all you get a choice of a small, medium, or large patty. However, there is only one size bun. My sad, dry, tasteless burger patty was lost in a huge, bun that would have not been so bad had they at least grilled it for a minute. As far as the staff goes, they were not overly friendly or helpful when I told them it was my first visit. I would have understood their aloofness had they been busy, which they were not, as I came in between the lunch and dinner rush at about 2:45pm. All I can say is that I'm glad I did not read the five star reviews beforehand or I would have been even more disappointed.
(1)Mariana L.
Stopped in on vacay After reading the reviews..I'm a sucker for a good burger with a local flare...this hit the spot! If you want a traditional burger or a burger with some hawaiian flavor than this is your place! I got the lahaina style burger with plantation fries (fries topped with pulled BBQ pork & cheese)..they got a variety of handmade milkshakes. Def reccomend this place, bomb..amazing!!
(5)Dustin W.
Best burger I've ever had. Would recommend to stop by for sure. Quick in and out burger joint, juicy, delicious, ......enough said.
(5)Rolly E.
I gave two stars on this mainly due to the person helping me at the counter. After he was done helping someone else he didn't ask me if I needed help he just looked at me. I walked up to him and he just looked at me without asking me what I wanted I started to place my order. I was still telling him what sandwich I wanted he saw a woman come in and started helping her taking her payment. She said your helping him first, and he said its ok your transaction is faster. WTF was that. He didn't even tell me anything I just told the lady its ok. And then he asked me what I wanted again? So I started telling him my burger and he asked me what size. I was like what sizes are there and he again stared at me like I should know the answer. So I had to skim on the menu board until I found out what he meant. And then after all said and done he almost forgot to give me my drink cause he looked at me and gave me the look of what am I still doing up there at the counter. Then when I got my food my upgraded tater tots were so overcooked that I had to throw it away. I have been to a lot of Teddys in Oahu, but this Teddys I won't come back again due to that guy that works in the front.
(2)Norman C.
Location B ( I wish it was located in Central Maui ) Service A+ ( Very frendly staff ) Menu A+ ( Decent selection ) Taste A+ ( Had the Double Bacon Cheese ) Drinks A+ ( Self serve no refill charge ) Fries C+ ( i prefer thicker fresh cut with skin ) 1st Visit A+ ( Sunday day ) 2nd Visit A+ ( Sunday day ) 3rd Visit D- ( Saturday early evening - Raw uncooked burger had to return, young cooks ) Waited extra long, no product offer or credit was issued. Overall A , Really great service and food accept for our 3rd visit. Still one of the best Burger joints in the State so far beating out Fat Burger.
(4)Lauren F.
The food was REALLY good. I think my boyfriend ordered a double bacon cheeseburger and a basket of onion rings. We were waiting for a while for the food and I must have thought it was longer only because I was soo hungry. The place wasn't very busy, but I was starting to wonder after the ticket time was about 25 minutes long. So I asked about our order. The employee said I'm sorry we don't have your ticket. I started to get worried. Thankfully they really snapped into action and gave us a delicious milkshake after a few minutes. I knew they had just made a mistake and got us an order of onion rings and the burger very quickly. I'm glad I mentioned something to them because it wasn't necessarily bad customer service, but a simple mistake. I appreciated that they made sure were happy up until we finished and left the restaurant.
(4)Amanda C.
If you're tired of eating light, Teddy's Bigger Burgers has exactly what you're looking for. Giant portions, creative burgers, sinful cheese fries, and awesome customer service await you. Seriously, the people who work here are so friendly and helpful... they happily explained menu options and walked me through which burger to try. Considering the glowing reviews, I expected slightly better tasting food. The burger was a little too done for my taste and although my cheeseburger had half an avocado on it, the avocado wasn't really ripe making it significantly less delicious. But they get serious kudos for not skimping on ingredients, which is all too common especially in the more touristy parts of Maui. If you're visiting the island and looking for a one-of-a-kind experience, feel free to skip Teddy's. But if you're in Maui and looking for a quality fast food option, Teddy's is a great choice.
(3)Yane Y.
Really, 3.5 stars. As someone mentioned, it reminds me a lot of Five Guys (except overpriced Five Guys). My husband and I ordered a burger each with fries and a drink and it cost $30. For two burger combos, I think $30 is way too expensive! Unless it's a burger that is out of this world!!! I don't think it's reasonable at all. I ordered a cheeseburger and it was fine, but nothing amazing. =) The meat was cooked well and juicy, so definitely gotta give props for that. But the meat and spices didn't jump out at me. Also, my husband ordered a special with onion rings and special sauce in it (sorry I cannot remember the name!!! which is why I need to write these names down while I'm there) ... it also was not worth $11 (w/o fries and drink). Definitely clean with two fountain machines but just overpriced!!!
(3)Kellie S.
I went to Teddy's last week while on vacation and their burgers were great! The special sauce added a little something extra. The tots were extra crispy (which I love) and the garlic fries were amazing! The menu had so many options, but the staff was very helpful and steered us in the right direction. I really regretted that I could only eat here once. It was that good.
(5)Fred G.
Was here in 2/14 and the burgers, service etc were great. This time everything was great except for the burgers. They were well done and dry, garlic fries mediocre. Cheeseburger in paradise a better option
(2)Allen W.
Waited 30 minutes for a 9oz burger and fries Ridiculous! First time trying in Maui. Burger was ok though
(1)Annie W.
You can't go wrong with Teddy's when you're craving for a good burger. It's fairly new here and they even offer kama'aina rates, plus they accept the iDcard. I'm glad they were open late, because finding cheap eats in Maui during a short stay can be a bit tough. I usually stick with the chicken sandwiches and it always delivers. Perfectly cooked to perfection over those potatoes buns and that secret sauce that oozes out with each bite. It definitely satisfies my craving for something semi healthy and most definitely delicious. The service was great, the place was nice, bright and clean.
(4)Zack G.
This place was awesome. Wife had a burger Cajun style and I had the crispy chicken sambo. We split spicy fries. More than enough food, you don't need your own combo meals. We loved the food, nothing but good things to say. I added avocado and onion rings to my chicken and it was lights out. Friendly staff, but the food to a while to come out. Not a "fast food" joint if that's what you're looking for. Worth the wait. Good prices, we were both stuffed for $20.
(5)Lance N.
I don't know how anyone could be disappointed with this place. The Lahaina burger is awesome. The shakes awesome and the fries are amazing. Good atmosphere. Cheap grub Good times
(5)John M.
Teddy's is located in a newer shopping center next to Foodland across the highway from the Cannery/Safeway shopping center. Lots of free parking. It is modern, clean and the service was excellent. You order at the counter and pick up your order when it is ready. I had the 5 oz cheeseburger combo medium rare. Be sure to ask if you like other than medium well and the staff is happy to do your burger as you like it. Very generous order of fries and serve yourself drinks at a reasonable price by Lahaina standards. The cheeseburger was just the way I like it and I will definitely become a regular customer on my visits to Maui.
(5)K P.
Really good burgers! We were surprised for sure. I think for the money especially for being in HI, it was awesome. I ordered just the 5 oz original burger and it was about $6. My husband got the double patty 5 oz combo meal for $11.89. The prices are higher compared to other burger places, but worth it. Every place we've tried so far has been really really disappointing. So to come across this place is a huge plus! The bread is thick and good too. The patty was suppose to be medium but cooked a little longer so it was a tad dry. My husband loved his meal also. You can taste the charcoal flavor, which we love! The burgers were flavorful and NOT greasy!!! The fries were done perfectly too and not drenched in grease. Service was very good! Extremely friendly as soon as we walked in the door and up until we left. Very personable people. The place is really clean too. We have a lot of burger places back home in SD like In n Out, Smashburger, Burger Lounge, The Habit, Five Guys, and Hodad's. My point is Teddy's is just as good compared to those, but each place has it's own unique qualities.
(5)K M.
Ok, this is one case in which bigger is not always better. I got a little greedy and ordered a HUGE burger with all the fix-ins (pineapple, etc etc!). Although it was tasty, there was just too much meat and stuff in it that my taste buds didn't know what was going on. Overall pretty tasty, and the shake was yummy as well.
(3)Lawrence S.
This is one of the best burgers I have had on maui. I am a local and I have had burgers from lahaina to hana and this was one of the best. I had the burger with the cheddar green chilies , fried egg, bacon, and all the veggies with the fries. I was very suprised when we got our order. the burger was a meal on a bun and the burger was cooked to perfection. I am very happy I stopped in to have dinner here and I will definetly be back. all the other burgers they had up on the wall looked great so must go back and try and I hear there onion ring are really good. this was a 5 star meal without the 5 star price. just wish they would put one upcountry.
(5)MyKey D.
For me, burger was okay. I have had better. It's sad when you can say that you would rather have the burger from L & L. Maybe it was just me, but the burger I had was dry and tasteless. Loaded it with ketchup. Maybe need to go back and try again.
(3)Mike B.
Given that everything costs more in Hawaii, the value for the buck and the quality of the food is pretty darn good. For under $10, you get a great burger, fries and drink and that includes sales tax. We don't have sales tax from where I'm from. It is only 4.1667% which is amazing since have a second home in California where it is 8% + and in Europe a few times a year where GST is 18% +. Burger was cooked to order. Fries were very good. Service good too. They even came by your table and asked everyone to write a review (in house) so they are only looking for constructive feedback and ways to improve. I really liked that. I definitely would go back next time I'm in Maui.
(5)Jake B.
Awesome concept...simple burger, fries and shakes. Add all types of toppings and sauces to your burger or fries/tots. My only "complaint" was the garlic fries...they were drowned in oil and minced garlic and got soggy quick. Other than that, this is worth trying!!
(4)Marlon O.
So nice, we ate there twice! My wife and I stopped by here for lunch, and she knows how much I love burgers and fries. I ordered a green chili burger with pepper jack, and a fried egg, they called it the Ranchero Burger. My wife had a bacon avocado burger with a fried egg. Both were big portions for the price too. We also got an order of extra crispy fries. The fries were a medium cut, usually pretty soggy. These fries were crispy and a thicker cut. Amazing. Order the kona pie milkshake. I don't know of another place to get this.. Anywhere!! A must have with the burger and fries. Overall, one of the best burgers I've had in a while,
(5)Adriana N.
Mmmm!!! Their burgers are delicious :) Even the smallest size burger was too much for me! The fries are yummy! They have shakes but I didn't get to try one out this time.. hope they are tasty as well. If you are looking for a out of the norm burger joint, this is a place to go. The place was nice and clean, they have their own bathroom so that's always a plus :) They have good music on too!
(4)Craig T.
Not sure what the hype is about...maybe I just need to try the bigger special burgers. Had the Big Combo, nothing "great." The staff is fun and energetic which makes it a good experience.
(3)Jenny G.
I love this place! The burgers are amazing. Remind yourself it's called Teddy's BIGGER Burgers... They are quite enormous. (I'm guilty of ordering a child's size burger to make sure I have room for a shake. ) Service is very friendly. Staff often comes by and gives you wet wipes after you're done eating. Nice touch. Also, you can cruise the Lahaina Gateway Shopping Center when you're done. Burn off a couple of calories while buying some goodies!
(5)Eric M.
Great food and service. By far the best burgers in Maui.The onion rings are outstanding.
(5)Anna Y.
They make em big and they make em right. There is no shame in being a glutton here. They will make you a burger with as many toppings as you wish for. The fries are good, the onion rings are good, the toppings are what make it special. My only wish is that they warm up the bun entirely and not just the one half of each side. 10% kamaiana discount!
(4)John T.
Solid burgers- definitely not lighter fare! Happy friendly employees, and fat burgers! They have a giant selection of ways to make your burger, fries, onion rings, sodas, milkshakes. What more can u ask for in a burger? I go here at least once or twice a month. In Lahaina sometimes the lunch selection is not all that. Teddy's burgers always delivers a quality product.
(5)Christina W.
This place is so good! It's in a plaza that has a lot of chain restaurants, but definitely go here instead of the others! They offer Kama'aina discount too! I ordered a regular burger with cheese and everything on it...and wow...amazing! It's a classic american diner style burger with all the fixin's. The meat is cooked medium unless you say otherwise, but don't say otherwise! Our burgers were so moist (not bloody), and the grilled taste was really good! The only downside was the garlic fries. Being from the garlic capital of the world, I have a high expectation when I order garlic fries (chunks of garlic, parsley, etc), but these aren't spectacular. They're just fries with some garlic salt on them! All in all, a solid 4 stars for the amazing burgers!
(4)Susan W.
I honestly don't understand why this place has such high ratings. I walked in with a party of 6 and they told me it would take 45 minutes to get 6 burgers. We decided that was fine because of all the great reviews we had seen. After waiting for our food, we finally got 3 beef burgers, 2 veggie burgers, and one turkey burger. The beef burgers were not only dry but tasted like lighter fluid. The veggie burgers were literally black and were tasteless and although the turkey burger was juicy, it clearly came from a box. We spoke to the manager and she comped us the burnt veggie burger and gave us 2 free milkshakes which took another 10 minutes to make. I would never come back here.
(1)Rebekah B.
Self-serve old diner feeling with the tastiest burgers & milkshakes around. Everyone was extremely nice, welcoming, and accommodating. First words out of my husbands mouth receding his first bite was "This is the best burger I've ever had!" (The Lahaina burger) Somewhat pricey for a self serve joint, but think of it more as a premium self serve diner. Plus you're in a Maui, everything is a wee but more expensive.
(5)Ember D.
Really, really good!! ... My husband is a burger connoisseur who takes his burgers seriously. Me, on the other hand, who likes a burger here and there but by no means craves them, was quite happy. My husband ordered a "double monster combo" (double 9 oz. patty cheeseburger with fries and a drink). And I ordered a chicken sandwich with onion rings and a strawberry milkshake. Needless to say, my husband was in carnivore heaven and i was extremely pleased with my (seemingly simple) chicken sandwich. Their sauce is great, the onion rings were declared to be the best my husband had ever had and the strawberry milkshake was top notch! Not to mention the service was very pleasant. The young man who took our order was very patient with us newbies and even went around asking how everything was going and offered us much needed wet naps. This was our first day here and my husband said he would be very disappointed if he didn't come back at least 2 more times within the next week. The Yelp coupon was very helpful especially because between the two of us we somehow rang up a $30 bill. But that's just how much things cost here on the island.
(5)Al G.
Ordered the veggie burgers with spicy fries, we totally enjoyed the burgers and would definitely return to this place!
(4)Paw L.
It's a place I'd come back to. The place was clean and the staff very friendly. The food was awesome. While the fabled Big Kahuna burger doesn't exist, Teddy's come close. They'll cook it just the way you want it.
(5)Matthew B.
If you're looking for a burger on Maui, this is the place to go. The burger was cooked just right. Juicy, seasoned, and full of flavor. The garlic fries were delicious, and the milkshakes are creamy and thick. There are a bunch of good burger choices on the menu. But if you don't find something to suit your mood, you can create your own. The prices are on par with similar joints on Maui.....about 10-15 bucks a person. The restaurant was clean and there is a bunch of seating available. Service was fast and the order was accurate.
(4)Danny G.
Visited Teddy's while on vacation - so first time visitor. What struck me most - beyond the super tasty (and, huge!) burger, fries and shake - was the customer focused survey card that was presented to us during our visit. One question was (and, I'm paraphrasing here) "we care. does it show?" In short, it totally did. From the gent at the front counter, to the gent cleaning tables and collecting surveys - they were all stoked to be there, serving great burgers. Another question was (again, paraphrasing) "is there anything we don't serve that we should?" We rattled off suggestions - the first 4-5 of which we realized that they actually do serve those things. Minus points for us for being non-observant - bonus points for Teddy's for having all the suggestions covered!
(5)Greg L.
I had high hopes... I had a burger Hawaiian style. The sauces were perfect, but I finished those before I finished the burger. I was able to taste the burger minus the sauces and the burger was so dry. Maybe it was an off day i'm sure the reviews will balance out for these guys. The staff was very kind and the restaurant was extremely clean. You can tell these guys pay close attention to the details. Although I didn't get a chance to revisit before the close of my trip I look forward to future trips to Maui to see how they are progressing. I hear the Oahu location has won burger of the year awards. If Teddy's can stay on top of their game I hope next time I'm there i'm eating a "Best in Maui," burger. Thanks!
(3)Jade S.
Does not disappoint! It's so good every time. Will definitely be back whenever I'm in Maui
(5)Ronald S.
Teddy's is one of my favorite burger joints on Maui, I mean if I was in Vegas I'd be mauling at In N Out, but since I am not...and Teddy's is about 3 blocks from my abode, it's a 4 star rating man. The burgers are seasoned and cooked just right the way I like em...medium...and the buns soft, the veggies are fresh. When I'm hungry I'll do a double 5 with cheddar, no sauce sorry...not a fan of their sauce...but it's seasoned right so no need for that. Onion rings..a shake..can't beat it..I never had a complaint at Teddy's.
(4)Christine V.
This place is amazing and high quality. I think we ate there 3 times in one week. I know, my other half is a meat kinda guy and their milkshakes were da' bomb. Seriously. Not for atmosphere as much as for the delicious burgers. Given the alternative of a terrible burger with an ocean view, I'd just as soon pick up my Teddy Burger and drive to the beach. Yummm!
(5)Lars B.
Absolutely fantastic burgers - the flavor is out of this world. Staff is friendly - especially if they notice you've never been there before, as they will take as much time as you need to have the menu explained to you. Shakes are to die for, and fries are cooked to perfection. I only wish it was available in Iowa :(
(5)Mike L.
I was only able to come here once during my week vacation. I really liked the menu and all the specialty burgers. I ordered the Lahaina burger and it was ok, I really expected it to be great and it just wasn't. I really want to go back though and try all the other burgers because I know there has to be some great ones that I will like .
(3)Paul L.
Great selection of burgers. I was really happy with what I got and garlic fries were killer
(4)Amy G.
Good burgers, slow service. It took us a while to get our order even though it wasn't confusing. The questionnaire says you should be getting your food within 10-15 minutes and it took at least 20, we were the first ones there too. We had the #1 with pineapple and it tasted great so the wait was worth it in my book. I wouldn't compare it to in and out nor 5 guys, I would say it holds it's own.
(4)John G.
OMG. That's it - just O M G. I would move to Maui for many many reasons, but near the top of this list would be so that I could eat here as often as possible. Yes, I know that I would end up looking like Iz Kamakawiwoole (no disrespect at all intended to the man), but I would do it anyway. Picture your ideal burger joint. then picture being able to put just about anything you would want to your burger. Now double that and make it taste heavenly. That's Teddy's. Their avocado burger comes with half a freaking avocado on it - not just a couple anemic slices! Of course, I asked where the other half of the avocado was - but that's just me. Do yourself a favor and try this place out. I guarantee you will want to go back.
(5)Alia C.
I have had better....if you want a cheap decent burger go to teddies. Maybe we are picky burger eaters...maybe ask for extra "special sauce" on the side. Very good deal since you get a burger, fries, and drink under $10...we didn't try the shake maybe I would have rated higher.
(3)Shanel S.
Always a big fan of Teddy's. Wish they had the fried jalepeno's that they do in the Manoa store.
(4)Bruce C.
A very good chain restaurant, which we can use more here on Maui. I like this place for many reasons: quality, quantity, service, and consistency. When you walk up to the counter you can be sure that you're going to have a great meal the way you want it.
(5)Liz G.
Big, juicy burgers! Need I say more? I tried the one with avocado and had the cheese sauce on the side. The garlic butter fries were good too. Very yummy. If you're gonna eat a burger on Maui, this is the place to go.
(5)Leslie C.
This place was fantastic! Many different things on the menu. Hoping to go back before we head home:)
(5)Victoria L.
Sad to say that we just got garlic fries and they were a disappointment. They were just fries with seasoning. But my brother in law and family got burgers and loved them! Just was sad because I'm obsessed with garlic fries and that's what I was expecting.
(2)Scott S.
Very Tasty. Food was good, service was good. Ideally it's nice to have variety. I ordered way too much food (thanks yelp coupon). Big burger with pineapple, jalapenos, cheese and special sauce. Only gripe... They charge for extra sauces.
(4)John B.
Great tator tots and vanilla shake and corn dog was just ok. Will go back to try burgers
(4)Henry T.
It's a burger joint! Took my wife and kids here on 4/7/12 at about 7pm. I had the #3 combo which is a 9 oz burger patty. The wife had a #2 combo with a 7 oz patty and my kids split a #1 combo with a 5 oz patty. The combos come with fries and drinks. The burgers were good, nothing to be excited about but convenient if you want a backyard grilled burger with the backyard grilling. We barely got any of their burger sauce almost non-exsistent had I known I would have asked for extra sauce. Alot of food and the it's worth the price as the saying goes "you get what you pay for." The wife and kids enjoyed the fries, big ole thick cut fries and the quantity they give is enormous. I'd prefer a little more burger patty then fries so next time I'll get their combo #4 which is a 16 oz patty. Hey, it was my cheat day and it was well worth it. We'll definitely go back to try more of their menu.
(4)Chris G.
I'm from CA, and I read an earlier review suggesting that IN-N-OUT has this place easily beat. Not so fast...yes, IN-N-OUT remains my barometer for tasty burgers, but Teddy's brings something different to the table (pun intended), and there is no shame in their burger. Teddy's is super friendly, walk in the door and you hear, "Welcome to Teddy's Burgers". The decor and vibe is a cross between Hot dog On A Stick (color scheme) and Johnny Rockets (old school diner). Whatever the case, it works. Their motto is that they don't make 'fast food', rather, they make food that is worth the wait, and it is! Every burger is fresh beef and hand packed that day, they make a R-E-A-L burger that you might have at a backyard BBQ, i.e. size and quality! You can pick from a variety of toppings, and also some predetermined scrumptious combinations (see the big board behind register). You can also choose the size of your patty, 5oz, 7oz, or 9oz. The 7oz will certainly satisfy your hunger, the 9oz will leave you full until your next meal, no question. On this stop I went for the medium prepared, 7oz Teri (Sweet BBQ glaze, lettuce, tomato, pickle & onion). So flippin' good! The bun is also fresh, with remnants of flour on the top. If you really want to go for the full experience, get the combo with fries, AND add a hand made ice cream shake. My wife and kids devoured the Combo #2 with bacon & bleu cheese. I was able to steal a bite myself, and this burger was AWESOME. As mentioned, the servers are salt of the Earth friendly, and the flavor is tasty. This is more of a burger experience than an IN-N-OUT, it will probably take 20+ minutes to place your order, get your food, and eat your hearty burger. Teddy's has a few locations, I've indulged myself at 3 locations and always been happy with my eating experience. In summation: big burger, big taste, venue with big personality.
(4)Howie Z.
The mahi burger was great!!! Must have the Plantation fries, with garlic butter. Bacado burger, one of the best. Listen to Mark, for the French fries and onion ring pairings.
(5)Michael O.
Food and service was awesome! Highly recommend! Try your burger Hawaiian style! Quite delicious!
(5)Stuart C.
Burger combo for the large 9 oz. burger comes with a huge mound of crispy, well-seasoned fries. Stop me before I finish them all and go into a starch coma!
(5)Jamie Z.
First time in and wasn't sure what to get. Mark, the cashier at the counter, took the time and went way out of his way to insure we were happy with our meal. Cooks did a good job with order accuracy and timeliness. Normally not into fast food places much, but the price, friendliness, and quality I will go back. Kama'aina available as well as the ongoing ad in Maui Time
(4)Louise P.
We bought the Yelp Deal and loved these burgers!! Service was very good and the woman at the counter let me try lots of samples of sauces and fries. The burgers were SO juicy and all the toppings were delicious. They have tons of options for sauces, veggie toppings, eggs, etc. We'd go here all the time if we were locals!
(5)Good U.
Lots of options and add-ons to burgers. Juicy, tender burgers. Light casual atmosphere and service. You're going for the food. Go hungry.
(4)Marti W.
I don't know what the heck they put in their food but this is hands down the best burger/fries place that I know of. Maybe because it the food comes out immediately so it's really hot? I've only always gotten orders "to go" so I don't really know it as a sit down place. I like the spicy fries and the garlic fries. Also, I appreciate the little electronic devices that let you know your order is up. That way our minds are free to wander and not be continually focused on whether someone has called our number. I've tried the fancy stuff but in all honesty, a 5 oz regular (no cheese but yes on that sauce) with the lettuce/onion/tomato stuff is my favorite. That and the hot fries? Dang.
(5)Aniket D.
Yay! for the vegetarian options and the sauces. We liked the burgers and the grilled pineapple is great! Wao sauce and Fire sauce are the ones we loved.
(4)Clarice C.
One of the only places on Kaanapali to eat if you want a late meal that's not fast food and not waiter service. I'm in Hawaii..so I passed on the bun and the actual burger itself was really good. I added all the toppings that go on their western burger and it was super tasty. Also got tater tots (very good) and garlic fries. It's not ball park kind of garlic fries :( they just put garlic salt and garlic powder on normal fries so if you are expecting fresh garlic, you'll wanna pass. I'm sure the milkshakes are good too but my meal was probably already pushing 800+ calories so i had to pass. Would come back here next time i'm looking for a quick meal! Prices are reasonable for Hawaii standards!
(4)Sally M.
I'm always on the quest for the perfect burger, no matter what city I visit and after hearing for years that Maui has great burgers, I had to find out what the hype was all about. I read in a travel guide that Cool Cat Cafe had a good one, but when I walked by they had such an obnoxious cruise ship crowd, a long wait, and the most horrible singer belting out Cat Stevens at record-breaking volume that I never made it to the door. Searched online and found out about Teddy's and decided it was a good fit. My boyfriend and I both ordered the Lahaina burger which had pineapple, bacon, lettuce, tomato, jalapenos, and cheese served with their Super Sauce. I asked for it on the side since I hate drowned burgers. I put some on my burger but I ended up using it Belgian style by dipping my fries into it as it was a mayonnaise-based aioli. SO DELICIOUS. The burger was so fresh, the meat was excellent and the bun was perfect. They have 3 sizes. 5 oz., 7 oz., and 9 oz. I opted for the 7 oz. and it was just the perfect size for me. I have to mention that the service is top notch. I overheard some very unpleasant, curmudgeonly, elderly women sitting behind me endlessly complaining about their order and the owner offered them two free shakes to make up for any mistake. That's a class act. I really like small family businesses and this place was really nice all around. Prices were very fair and there is no need to worry about tipping and waiting to be seated. Nothing snooty, just great burgers. I will definitely eat here the next time I am in Lahaina.
(5)Christine S.
Tried this place and was pleased at what we found. Delicious burgers with great topping choices. The fries are to die for. I got the spicy fries-yummy. My son got the plantation fries and they were so good. My son's fries had so much pork on them and the sauce they were covered in was spicy and delicious. We also tried the garlic fries which were good too. I would recommend this place if you like five guys or in n out. Good comparison to both places.
(5)Brian S.
This is a really good burger. They'll cook it a true medium (slightly pink), which makes for a juicy burger. I would rate it 4.5 but you have to rate it to one significant figure (haha)! It's a good price and friendly staff. Price is reasonable for Maui.
(5)Todd P.
Delicious food and excellent service. Got the Lahaina burger and garlic fries. It's a pig out kind of place. Our burger had jalapeños, bacon, and pineapple. The garlic fries had tons of garlic and butter. They have malt vinegar if that's your type of thing.
(5)Veronica G.
Bacado burger and cheese fries... Feelin' fat and amazing. Super delicious!!!
(4)Pepper I.
Best value for a hamburger in Lahaina, I think. Walk-in and sit down style. The milk shakes are great. The food is outstanding, and the help is patient. We eat there every year, at least once, just to keep our Hawaii budget in line, and for a quick meal. Save a ton of money versus the Front Street Burger places and really enjoy the experieince.
(4)Dan N.
I love it. A sloppy juicy pastrami burger with Swiss. Good music and friendly service makes a great place to visit. I didn't get the special of the month but it had a hash brown patty on the burger aka spud burger. Might have to come back and try that one!
(5)J W.
Okay, I give in. Every single thing in Hawaii is expensive. BUT, there are some things that are pretty darn close to worth it. If a burger is what you're craving while in Maui, I'd recommend Teddy's. we tried several variations and all were tasty as burgers go. Fries, onion rings, shakes, none were bad. Still expensive, but on the mainland we have Fuddruckers, which is my all time favorite. Teddy's was a close second even considering the dollars and place. Family type atmosphere and parking is easy considering its in Lahaina. The shopping center has several stores worth a stroll to walk off the calories.
(4)Ryan D.
This is the best burger in Maui, possibly anywhere. I'm from CA so I'm accustomed to some good burgers (In-N-Out, 5Guys, TK Burger, The Counter) and this is probably the best I've had. It's freshness was above anything I've ever tried for a burger. I had to come in here while on my last vacation per the recommendation of a coworker (who's friends w/ the owner). Very friendly people work here and own the place. I had a regular cheeseburger (5oz) w/ cheese, bacon, and avocado for extras. OMG it was so fresh and delicious. I couldn't even finish the whole thing. My wife had the King of the Dojo - spicy cajun chicken, bbq sauce, a hashbrown patty, cheese, etc. It was pretty good, but not my style. I definitely recommend this as a stop during your next trip.
(5)Butch E.
Great cheeseburgers here! Great prices and really good service. Support these guys they try hard and care about your experience. Great price, quality and service. Can't beat it!
(4)Terri W.
The burgers were great, fun atmosphere and reasonably priced. You won't be disappointed by Teddy's.
(5)Naisa L.
So glad that we went here!! Food was delicious! Cajun burger with tots & a banana mac crunch milkshake!! The banana milkshake is limited so try it before its gone!! Definitely would recommend this to those going to Maui!
(5)R M.
The best burger I've ever had. Great theme. Nice service. Ableit, at Hawaii prices. This chain needs to invade the mainland.
(5)Joshua J.
This place has been our go-to-grub-spot in Maui due to consistency and professionalism of cooking and customer service. Me and my wife have frequented this place 2 days In a row and I love everything about them. Buns are soft, which is my pet peeve for any sandwich, and they cook it exactly how u order it. I definitely recommend this place for any meal.
(5)Joanne M.
Their burgers are AMAZING! I got the Lahaina burger with grilled pineapple, of course. It was so good, and I got to choose the size patty I wanted, which is a plus. They also have a "crossfit burger" for more conscious individuals. I got their "shake of the week" which was Rocky Road at the time and it was AWESOME. The guys are nice there and it's not a fast food place, so burgers will take longer than a drive-thru people! They are cooked when ordered, so just be patient, it is worth the extra 2 minutes! I would say this is at the top of my list next to Shake Shack and In & Out. But, I think I love Teddy's so much its #1 now because they have a more variety and BETTER toppings, hence the pineapple.
(5)Reid R.
Service is fast and friendly but that doesn't make up for the food. Their huge menu falls victim to the quantity quality balance. The sauces are cheap and bland, my girlfriends burger came with grainy hard avocado on a crumbly bun. neither of us were able to eat more than 2 bites before our burgers were in piles that we finished like burger salads. we've also ordered food to go and no more than 10 minutes later the bottom bun was like mashed potato.
(2)Sung K.
Reference point for east coasters. I personally liked it better than five guys, BGR, and elevation burgers. If you're craving a cheeseburger for not a whole lot of money you must eat here. Not to mention it will taste better than any burger you will pay a lot more for somewhere else.
(5)Carolyn H.
The Burgers were really good. It is the only reason why they are getting as many stars from me as they are. Stick with a single patty.. The double patty is too much food. Crime: Their cheese fries are made with cheese sauce and not quality cheddar cheese like you might expect. I ordered these thinking that a place with good reviews and focused on quality like this place knew what they were doing and I didn't even think they might do something as horrific as this. They should hang their head in shame for this, however, you the discerning customer can still enjoy their burgers, but stay away from the Cheese fries... they are hideous. Crime #2: You are in Hawaii, right? You are thinking I should get the Pineapple shake, because this is Hawaii, again, they know what they are doing with Pineapple, right? To summarize, their pineapple shake tasted queer. It tasted like they made it with vanilla bean ice cream and added a small amount of pineapple flavoring. The vanilla bean flavor dominated your taste buds and the pineapple flavor really didn't come through, but made the vanilla bean flavor taste weird. My family all passed it around trying to pass it off to each other trying to get rid of it. +$5 for a shake that nobody liked? More shame.... They need to get their act together and taste their own shakes... because I don't think they do. Teddy and whatever his partner is should come down off their pedestal and eat their own food, because I don't think they are. In some areas, they are just raking you the customer for large dollar amounts and not delivering on quality.
(2)Sergio A.
Food is DELICIOUS! Service is fast. A special kudos to the milkshake lady. The banana nut macadamia milkshake is worth the money. I had the 7 oz. burger, Lahaina style, with garlic fries. My wife had the 5 oz. burger, Bacado style, with spicy fries. Both burgers exceeded expectations. The place reminds me a little of Five Guys, except I would rather come here any day, hands down. The price is a little high, but you'll definitely pay less than you would at another burger joint, and get a much better burger; take advantage of their Yelp deal. It's located across the street from the Lahaina Cannery Mall. This is a must try while in Maui.
(5)Mark T.
Excellent hamburgers here! I had a green chile cheeseburger with pepper jack cheese and the flavor was top shelf. The bun is excellent as well. They grind their chuck roast and hand make the patties. The only thing they could have done better is cook it properly. I ordered medium and it was almost well done. It would have been little juicier if they had cooked it right. The fries are ok, but were a little chewy. Go here for the burgers. They are worth it.
(4)Jennifer F.
This is a solid 50s motif burger joint. Good for an open, relatively inexpensive place to take the kids and have a decent burger and fries. I had the veggie burger and loved it. The steak fries were good and they made a grilled cheese (off menu) for my picky eater son. Quick, friendly service.
(4)Stephanie V.
Food-gasmic!!!!! Best burgers and shakes I've ever had!!!!! If these burgers had babies ... I call dibs...
(5)Mike D.
Yelping Hawaiian eateries can be hit or miss. We've been burned more than a few times by highly rated restaurants only to find ok at best food. Maybe it'd the diversity of tourism and tastes / expectations or maybe it's just by comparison. That being said Teddy's is pretty solid. Good burgers at an affordable price ( which puts it amongst rare company in Maui). My only criticism is that they often overlook the details. If you make any sort of special order, like "no onions" just be sure to check before you leave the restaurant.
(4)Simeko C.
This was a great place to grab a burger. The portions were big and the food was tasty. I would recommend eating here for a reasonable price good meal.
(4)Jennifer M.
Don't bother. It wasn't very clean and the food was ok.
(2)Adam V.
I got the Lahaina style burger which was very good! Super big burger but not too big to eat in a relatively organized and clean fashion. I also got the plantation fries which were fries covered in kalua pork, BBQ, onions, and cheese!!! Very impressed with the food here.
(4)Maksim B.
Great burger joint! Better than in and out. Totally worth trying, get the lahaina style burger.
(5)Gibb F.
As soon as I walked in I knew it was going to be good. The bright menu had an outrageous selection of great food. The baconner burger (not sure exactly what it was called) had double bacon, double cheese and grilled onions. Everything I wanted added to my normal cheese burger. The selection of three different size burger patties made it even better, the medium size 7oz was more than enough for me. From there I decided to roll with onion rings, despite the vast selection of specialty sides (garlic fries, chili cheese fries, etc.). My wife chose to get the special, pulled pork and BBQ sauce over top of perfectly cooked tater tots. After being helped by the great staff we took our seats and within 7 minutes our food was sitting on our table ready to go. As soon as I saw the burger cooked medium with grilled onions and melted cheese oozing out I knew I was in for a treat. I bit in and was very much amazed by the tasty burger with the specialty sauce. I then looked to my onion rings which were also beyond what I expected (onion rings always seem to be hit or miss). They were just the perfect blend of batter and onion and the best thing I could have asked for to go with my burger. The only problem was once I'd finished my burger there were a lot more onion rings I couldn't eat left on my plate. I also got a few bites of my wife's pulled pork tots, which had a bit of spice that I loved, although she's never been much of one for spicy things so she ended up leaving with a bad stomach ache. The icing on the cake was that on the little review card they give you to fill out (if you want to) they had a question that asks what you'd have on the menu if you owned the place. Suddenly I knew where the vast array of menu items had come from. All in all it was a great experience with great food. Not the best burger I've ever had, but it's definitely in the top ten. Hopefully next time my wife can make it out feeling a bit better!
(4)Kevin J.
burger was really good...and the service was great! would come back....if i went back to hawaii..
(5)Carolyn A.
Teddy's was pretty good. Great flavour, very friendly staff. My only gripe was there was a bit too much sauce and onions for my liking. Would definitely have again though
(4)debbie l.
The burgers were tasty and I liked the bun it held up well to the juicy burger. The onion rings were good as were the fries. My burger had a small part that was really pink which i didnt eat. I'd say its a little better than In and Out and way pricier. Everything is an up-charge so your $9 burger combo is really $14 or more. Not even close to Fuddruckers burgers. I like Cool Cats better burger and atmosphere and is not as expensive. Overall pretty good for a chain but $27 for two burgers. I expect a much different kind of burger for that price.
(4)Paul P.
Best burger in Maui! Better than Cool Cats and better priced. I had the Teri Hawaiian Burger with Cajan Fries. Also added avocado to the burger. Everything was awesome. Clean restaurant and friendly staff.
(5)Michael T.
My wife and I eat here each time we travel to Maui. The burgers are huge and the shakes are amazing! Great food, friendly staff, and great prices for the area....highly recommended!
(5)Keith H.
This was a great find to get a great burger - thanks to a Yelp deal. My wife and I appreciated the different patty size choices and the many ways to customize our burgers. Lots of fries, on future orders, my wife and I will share those. Great malt as well. Next time I am in Maui, I will definitely be getting a meal or two here. I saw on their website that they have several locations on the Islands and also near me in Woodinville, Washington. I'll have to try it, it would be wonderful if it is as good, - if not I'll just have another excuse to head back to the islands.
(5)Chris P.
Both my girlfriend and I agreed that this was hands down the best burger we had both ever had. I'm a huge burger guy and she's not into burgers at all. I let her have a bite of my burger and she completely regretted not getting one. The burger was just juicy, perfectly cooked, and amazing.
(5)Daniel P.
What an amazing burger! This sandwich was huge! Got the monster 9oz double patty! Wow!!! Also got the fries and onion rings both were great and the fries were fresh cut. Vicki was my cashier, super friendly and had a nice chat with her while ordering. For my first time there she was very helpful and walked me through the process. The only bad thing was hard to find the place. Palm trees outside block the sign. But go! Find it! Worth it! Delicious!!
(5)Gina M.
Great burgers...cooked to order. We had the Hawaiian, Bacon and Blue, Bacado and Kailua. All were great. Shakes were awesome...not too thick. Very casual atmosphere.
(5)Jennilee M.
THE BEST burger on Maui - hands down! I've ate at the Teddy's in Waikiki, and for some reason this Teddy's tastes so much better. The burger that I usually get is the blue cheese burger - so 'ono!! I also tried their western burger which is really good, a bit messy but so good. Their special sauce that they put on their burgers is ah-may-zing. Even their fries are good! Definitely a spot to hit up everytime we go to Lahaina.
(5)Tracey G.
Came in here during vacation in Maui. Burgers were okay, I like that they serve fish and chicken sandwiches :)
(3)Michael T.
Try the #1 Combo with Teriyaki Sauce It is Great. They have Great Food and Great Service. Really enjoyed ourselves here.
(5)C C.
Good burgers, kind of messy. The pattys are just like you would make at home. Not the patty type that you buy frozen but the type you roll up handmake. Probably wouldn't go back
(3)John M.
This place was pretty decent but a little pricey for a casual burger joint. I actually had the fish and chips which were slightly overly breaded. It is a nice break from the usual Hawaiian cuisine when you're on Maui..and its not like there is an In-N-Out or Five Guys anywhere near by LOL Plenty of seating, clean and pretty quick considering the food is made to order. Its in a strip mall, so its not the easiet to spot.
(3)Mary S.
Great service & WOW, amazing portions. I had the 5 oz Bacon Me Crazy & I am having a hard time finishing it. Had the old school taters & used tge $12 for $20 deal & feel like we got a great deal & have way more than we can eat & it tasted great !! Highly recommend.
(4)Susan W.
Got the yelp $12 for $20 deal certificate as soon as I saw it knowing we were going to Maui in February. Also got one for Mom & Dad who we were meeting on Maui. We normally go for burgers at Red Robin so I will base my review on a comparison of the 2. Red Robin wins hand down in every category. I greatly prefer sitting down with a menu than standing & trying to read the menu while people line up behind me. And Teddys menu does not list the prices for half of their burgers & fries cost extra. Their pricing for a meal deal is no deal. And Red Robin has beer, wine & cocktails. The lighting was too bright & the primary color scheme made me feel like I was in kindergarten. In Teddys favor the onion rings were amazing!! Burger meat flavor was good but too raw for Moms liking. (she likes med rare steak too) Friendly workers & clean restaurant. The yelp deal did not cover our dinner. :( Had to fork over an extra $5. $20 at Red Robin would have covered both burgers but no beverage. I don't think I would go there again. If I was craving a burger I'd go to Moose McGillicuddys in Lahaina on burger night.
(3)Savan P.
Everything is just delicious. Veggie burger was appetizing and they have 4 varieties of fries. Milkshakes are made from hefty amounts of ice cream. Great combinations and they have plenty of add on ingredients.
(5)Adri A.
Teddys is truly the IN and OUT burger of Hawaii! The meat is juicy and smoky charred and the sauce is O SO GOOD secretness.. " not ur avg thousand island dressing" lol .. Its a solid fast food burger and worth every penny and minute that u would wait at the famous Cali chain... If i am being painfully picky, I will say that the Oahu locations have the customer service BEAT! they offer the little wet napkins and are genuinely happy about you stopping by. .. as you can see MY "BEEF" is not with this burger but rather, with the service... so definitely come by and get THE BEST FAST FOOD BURGER YOU CAN HAVE IN MAUI!
(4)Sydney W.
Very yummy, esp. with the Yelp deal!! DH ordered a regular burger; I had the veggie burger. Both tasty. Milkshake was thick and delicious. Worth a try!
(4)Garland R.
This is a great place to swing in for in and out style burger for a good price, I also like the location how it's tucked in a little off Front St.
(3)Reed F.
I figured it was about time for an update! We go maybe twice a month since I had something of an epiphany, this place is basically a fast food burger place done right. It costs maybe 10-20% more than the place with the clown but that 20% buys you more food and better quality food. If we get the urge for a burger we go here and not the clown shack. As a family of four we just ate, all had burgers (the kids had the kids cheeseburger meals, I had a 7oz teri the better half had a 7oz original with an extra, garlic butter fries and drinks for the adults plus 4 special sauces) and the total including Kama'aina discount was $32. $8 bucks a head and could have been cheaper. You can most definitely spend more if you want, you can even make it cheaper if you ditch the upgrades we had, but thats insanely good value for the quality. While you cannot do much about the quality of the soda, the milkshakes are an awesome alternative, the patties are made with real chuck (no ground up connective tissue \ ears \ hooves etc), shaped by hand. None of that dubious grey 'meat' you find elsewhere. I was bored and watched them make up some patties, it's basically the same as you do at home (ok I wish I could do it that well at home :)). The buns are perfect, not the plasticy tasting corn syrup bread that will last 20 years without going moldy but nice fresh bread. Honestly it left me wondering how on earth the fast food joints get away with charging so much considering the poor quality of the ingredients they use. One of the real tell tale signs is you walk away from here full for your $7-8 and you stay full, theres no wearing off of a sugar rush like at the grey burger places that leave you hungry a couple of hours later. This isn't a full service front street restaurant, it isn't trying to be one, nor is it a 99 cent menu place serving burgers made from parts of a cow even its mother wouldn't recognize. It is basically a fastish (as fast as cooked to order gets) food burger joint serving quality fresh food for a small and reasonable premium. Personally I consider it entirely worth it. For as long as it has been open I have experienced a consistent high level of product and service. The staff are great, seriously happy, friendly, efficient and it makes for a nice atmosphere. There is a constant variation on milkshakes and special burgers so you don't get bored. You can spend as little or as much as you want. If you order a lot of toppings then honestly, yes, it is going to cost more but if you go into the clown place can you get half an avacado on your burger or a huge serving of pulled pork, will it be cooked fresh or will it have sat there for 20 minutes? It's great to have a choice but I think some folks misunderstand what this place is trying to be. Besides longer opening hours (although I may be the only person craving a teddy burger at 1am), the only thing I would like to see is an option to use some more local ingredients, maybe some local organic veg (a nice thick slab of local tomato would be perfect) and Maui Beef. An extra buck or buck 50 for Maui grass fed beef would be worth it for me and I think it would fit with the brand, at least as an upgrade. Maybe a kimchee topping?
(5)Keoki R.
Great service and food ! We stop by at least once a week for the mahi burger with garlic butter fries . For dessert a strawberry shake that takes a little while to make but worth the wait !
(5)Christine I.
Oh Teddy's, you were a life saver the night we got into Maui. After a week of wedding activities on the Big Island we were ready to relax. Hubs needed some familiarity after me forcing him to try all the local food that I missed so dearly - saimin, portuguese sausage, poke, lau lau...gah, that's enough. He is a burger, steak and potato eater, so it took a lot out of him. I read through some reviews and saw "In 'n Out" as a comparison, oh do not be mistaken, this is much better than In 'n Out. The meat is fresh and cooked well and the combinations of flavors they have on the menu is outstanding. There is this butter garlic sauce they put on their fries that I can only imagine what God's tears taste like. They have three different sizes of burgers and we're glad we went with the "smallest" at 5oz, it was more than enough. I ordered the mushroom swiss combo, the Hubs ordered the teri burger that had a hash brown on top - he looked happier than he did at the alter. Thanks for kicking off a great honeymoon!
(5)Lee C.
The Cajun Burger here is in the Top 5 Best Burgers that have ever been in my mouth! Love the fries! Delish!
(5)Julio M.
Teddy's is located in the main mall in Lahaina (resort area in western side of Maui). Foodie- wise Maui has been somewhat of a disappointment.... We order a burger with pineapple and a fried egg, grilled chicken w cajun spices, tater tots w avocado and a coconut-pineapple shake. Total Bill $28.26 My burger benchmarks are: In-n-out, Fat Burger, The York, father 's Office, Five Guys, and TK Burger. All good, except this is a different animal - its a fusion burger place. This place seems to have elements of each: the fried egg and 50s feel of Fat Burger, the bun and grilled chicken and veggie patty options of TK Burger. No place competes with the King: In-N-Out on a value basis. If I had $2 for a meal it would be In-N-Out. But a salad at Safeway costs $8 - so $28 for a orgasmic burger meal in Maui is a veritable steal. They have huge meat portions 5 7 or 9 oz . And as many topping options as Five Guys. My lady friend was in rapture with the tots with avocado - she was scheming how to bring them back on the plane. Napoleon Dynamite would be jealous. Totally awesome shake - we had a custom build: pineapple coconut. They Really make it your way, especially if it Includes pineapple, jalapeños, onion rings, teriyaki,....Mahalo. The decor is the only I can find as a negative: yellow, blue, and red. One of the owners totally had a hard on for some girl at HotDog on a Stick when he was younger. It's a must stop when in Maui!
(5)J T.
Had the mahi mahi burger yesterday, blackened style. It was spot on and the addition of jalapeños added just the right amount of spice for my taste. Their "special sauce" was a nice touch as well. Overall, a great choice after spending all day in the sun.
(5)Abra S.
Maybe for Maui this place has great burgers but compared to the rest, this place is ok. My burger was good but nothing that stands out and I will prob not go back. My girl and I came here since it had good reviews on yelp and since the locals raved about it, but we weren't impressed. Would recommend if you want a decent burger but nothing special.
(3)Andre E.
Well I must say my first Turkey Burger in Maui was a HUGE success just like the burger was. The burger tasted great.....just like it came right off the grill....fresh toppings...potato bun....and I had a small drink.....which is really the size of a medium. We got a great deal here on yelp for this establishment as well....we paid only 12 bucks for 20 worth of food. The only reason I gave this place 4 stars instead of 5 was because the fries were just average.....and they overdue it a bit on the condiments so make sure to tell them to go easy on those if you don't want it getting all over your hands or clothes....LOL. Despite the fact that the food is made to order....we got our food fairly quickly. I highly recommend this location if your looking for a good burger. Eat, Drink, and Be Merry my Friend!!!!!
(4)Pualani T.
This was my first visit, clean establishment, friendly and helpful employees and great burgers. Their special sauce is great had it on the side and used also as a dip for the fries. Fries are plentiful one order can be shared by two. Will be back when I'm back in Lahaina.
(5)Amy B.
Great choices for every type of burger you can think of!
(4)Paul D.
Great tasting hamburgers and a better value than Cheeseburgers in Paradise and Cool Cat Cafe. Friendly helpful staff. Onion rings can use some work - overbreaded and undercooked.
(5)Evan S.
Although I wasn't too happy with my visit, the management at Teddy's contacted me because of my yelp review to offer an explanation, corrective actions for their restaurant, and a refund (since I left the island). Customer service goes a LONG way for me and I really appreciated the sincere response and offer of reimbursement. Teddy's is a class act and I'm sure this place will become one of the most popular places on the island. Good luck Teddy's!
(4)Stacie W.
Go! Great burgers!!
(5)Shakira E.
Hot and Juicy Burgers, great fries all made to order! This is a great addition to Lahaina it seems like this place was missing from the usual food offerings. My husband said they have a nice Juicy Turkey burger I had the beef burger and it was delicious the toppings were fresh. If you are dining in you have unlimited soft drinks at the ready lastly the fries were just ok; but who can complain too much when you are eating a burger in paradise,,,,,
(4)Jordan H.
The atmosphere is fun, the burgers are amazing, the staff is awesome. They always seem to be adding an inventive new burger to the menu. Prices are a little high, but that's everywhere on Maui. We love this place.
(4)Faith T.
Huge portions! Amazing choices. Friendly staff. We heard Teddy's was great but it really is. I would have given them 5 stars but the fish sandwich was soggy...not the bun just the fish.
(4)Kirk W.
I was browsing Yelp for food recommendations when I saw a coupon pop up for Teddy's Bigger Burgers. I knew my wife and I would be there for a full week, so figured we would be able to find time to use a coupon and went ahead and bought it. VERY happy with the purchase now that we've used it. The store was moderately busy as 12:30pm (got more crowded near 1pm), but we didn't have to wait to order and the food came out quickly. I don't eat a lot of beef, so I was excited to see turkey is an option with any of their burgers. I got the Halloween special "Jalaween" - burger, onion rings, jalapeno's, pepper jack cheese and their regular toppings. Turkey patty was great and didn't dry out. We were splitting items since we couldn't decide what to get, the manager was nice enough to take the burger in the back and slice it in half for us. My wife got the fish & chips and we were equally impressed with that. Three pretty big pieces of fish and a big basket of fries. The fish comes out with Tartar sauce and Vinegar, depending on your tastes. Also of note, they have Coke products vs. Pepsi. I'm a big Diet Coke drinker so that was a pleasant surprise. Definitely recommend checking Teddy's out.
(5)Marcus C.
Had the Kailua Burger. Tasty and Juicy!!!
(4)Jeremy T.
Accidentally found this place on our way to our hotel from the airport. The quality of the food was really good. I had both the chicken burger and cheese burger which came with their special house sauce. The standout item on the menu are the shakes. Even plain ol vanilla was pretty good. I would even go out on a limb and say that the food is better than "Cheeseburger in Paradise" We went here a few times during our stay in Maui. Wished it was here a during our past visits to Maui =).
(4)Angie I.
Teddy's when are you coming to my neighborhood?!? Oh how I crave the delish burgers, tots and of course those milk shakes! YES, those milk shakes bring me to the yard!! BTW...what do they do to those cows to make them taste so good....must be lots of lovin' cuz the burgers give you lots of loving when you eat them! =) Burgers = 9 Tots = 8 Milk Shakes (coconut and the pineapple) = 10 We ate at Teddy's several times during our stay in Maui and it was love at first bite! I can't imagine how I can go back to eating In-N-Out, Five Guys or anything else that could compare to the fun fast food I discovered in Lahaina. We will def be back soon!
(5)John B.
A real hamburger, fries and shake. Don't go anywhere else in the Lahaina area for a burger or a shake or you will be getting something other than the best the area has to offer. This is where the locals go. The staff is extremely helpful and friendly. The atmosphere is very clean and cheerful. You place your order at the counter and they bring your food to you On a scale of 1 - 10 I'd give the burger an 8, the fries a 7 and the shake a 10. Probably the best hamburger for the price in Maui and the best shake anywhere. Try the root beer shake.
(4)Kris H.
This was an extremely great burger place. So many choices, I think all eight of us chose something different. Their fries are perfect and their special hot sauce had the perfect amount of heat but did not over-power your tastebuds.
(5)Dave B.
The "bacado" was one of the best burgers I've ever had! The garlic fries and malts are also top-notch. Grab the Yelp deal and give it a try. You won't regret it.
(5)Lisa F.
Looks like a typical themed Burger joint but the burgers are something else! Large and juicy the onion rings were perfectly cooked. Good meal.
(4)Jason S.
Best burgers in Maui. We ate at every place from Lahaina to Kapalua and this was our favorite. Great service, great food, and great price. Server even have me a coupon to save me money on my order. Highly recommended.
(5)Julie B.
Very tastey! I don't eat beef so I go for turkey burgers, and these ones were delicious! It's so hard to find a good turkey burger, this one was tender and juicy. I got the Lahaina toppings, and regular fries. My friend got the Bacon me Crazy and we both loved it! I wanted to get a shake but they were almost six dollars which I just can't justify for a shake.
(5)MARK P.
Great burgers; friendly, efficient service. Loved the Bacado and Western burgers. One of the real few bargains in W. Maui with the Yelp deal. We would absolutely go again. I have an ocean view from my room, I don't need one with my burger.
(4)Kim G.
This was another "this place gets good reviews on Yelp, lets try it" We had been out an about enjoying Maui all day and just wanted to grab something semi-fast and not pay a fortune, and not have McDonalds. It's in a shopping center across from the Lahaina Cannery Mall, so fairly easy to get to. Its the kind of place that you order you food up at the counter and then they bring it to you and your table. There are four different sizes of burgers to choose from and then several topping/combo options. Their burgers all automatically come cooked medium-well unless you tell them otherwise. We each got the 7 oz. size which was plenty! I didn't even finish mine. I got the Bacado Burger...burger, bacon, cheese, and 1/2 of an avocado. The avocado is what sealed the deal for me, it was delicious! The bread that is used for the buns is really good too. Big, soft, fresh, and a light dusting of flour on the top bun. I had fries as a side, I'm not sure what the other side options are. For four combos we paid about $52 so not exactly an economy meal, but I will admit that is was a really good burger. You can tell the meat is pretty high quality, it just has that great taste.
(4)Dennis A.
5 adults, 6 kids. The service and all of the food was Great.
(5)Rachael H.
Horrible. The menu says the burgers are medium so I asked for them to be well done. I got one medium and one RAW!!! That was after a 25 minute wait. While I was waiting I watched tantrums by employees, food handing issues with the guy making the shake and some guy in a t shirt for the melting pot walking in off the street and going in the back and start cooking without even washing his hands-plus did he even work there? I called and went in the next day to get my money back ( it was a to go order) and the manager/owner was too busy to talk to me so another 15 minutes of waiting to get this taken care of by someone at the register.
(1)Raquel S.
Awesome burger joint!!!! They don't make ones like this anymore. Burgers,fries,onion rings,shakes and corn dogs my family loved all of it !!!! We are going back again before we leave!!
(5)Robert G.
Best burgers in the land and more. Eating there is a nostalgic experience with the 50's and 60's atmosphere, the oldies music and the great burgers. The basic #1 Combo is hard to beat. If you are a large eater they have a burger size to please you. Give it a try you will not be sorry.
(5)Rob S.
They live it up to their motto: "Reinventing the Burger Joint!" These guys serve your burgers, shakes, and sides any way you'd like: fully customizable. They live it up to their motto: "Reinventing the Burger Joint!"All their beef patties are hand-made, 100% ground chuck and not FROZEN. Though their main feature is burgers, these guys also offer crispy and grilled chicken sandwiches, turkey burgers, veggie burgers (it's not soy, it's full-on veg!), fried fish sandwiches, fish n' chips, chicken nuggets, grilled cheese, and corn dogs. I've eaten here a couple times with family and just on my own, and concocted a couple crazy burgers and sides like: Bacon and Blue Cheese onion rings, 5 oz. Patty and Veggie Patty, with Avo, Grilled Onions, Mushrooms, and Swiss Cheese in a single burger, and Srawberry Peanut Butter Shake (Tastes like PB&J!) Dragon Tots (Tots smothered in their Teriyaki, Special and Fire Sauce with a whole half of avocado on top!) Staff is Super friendly and very knowledgeable of their menu! If it's your first time, don't be shy to ask the guys up front! They know their stuff!
(5)Romarues R.
A different way to eat burgers, with a Hawaiian style ...I love this place. you should try this place and compare.
(4)Rick M.
GREAT burger with equally great service! I tried the TCB new featured burger. Teriyaki, cheese & lots of bacon! Yum!! You HAVE to try the garlic fries. The service is amazing for a "burger joint". (Sorry Teddy, this is not just a burger joint, but Top Burger in Hawaii the last 12 straight years!) they give EVERY patron a feedback review. They care about you and service is more like a restaurant. They constantly check your table for whatever you may need. I realize having a burger in Maui seems wrong given all the amazing local fare, but this IS local fare as well. You won't be disappointed!! We went 2 times in3 days! ENJOY :)
(5)Michael G.
Incredible pastrami
(4)calvin n.
The burger was good but don't eat the salad. we ended up throwing it away.
(3)Katie C.
Friendly counter people, very good food that is cheap and comes out quick! Love it!
(5)Sam G.
Got a lahaina style burger + garlic fries - was so good I'm getting another burger ...
(5)Winter M.
Great fast food burger. I got the bacado burger and it was a wonderful balance of juicy crispy savory creamy and charred. The price is incredibly reasonable for Maui especially with the yelp deal. Shakes are thick and not overly sweet. All together one of the better meals we have had on the island. Skip the overpiced burger joints on front street and come here.
(5)Jonathan S.
Awesome fun place. Great people who care what you think and about their burgers. Shakes are awesome!!!
(5)Matt M.
These burgers are the real deal. Awesome flavors, high quality ingredients, filling meal. The fries and rings are both great, if you have room for them after the monster burgers served to you! The "bigger" size at 7oz is very filling I'm bot sure if I could handle the biggest. They have one in Woodinville WA too so we will for sure check them out once we get home. Otherwise Teddy's will be one of our first stops when we return to Maui! This trip we tried Cool Cats as well as Honu for their burgers. Teddy's beats them all. Especially for the price you pay (Honu was very good but $18 for a burger is a little much, even if it is right on the water)
(5)A Y.
Great burgers and great service. A bit pricey for a fast food joint, but with the yelp deal = one happy customer.
(4)Vince M.
WOW! Their burgers were delicious. Guy at the counter gave us the run down on their menu, letting us know which was their most popular burgers. They also have TATER TOTS! Meat was nice and juicy, buns were perfect for the size of meat you get. They didn't get too soggy or anything. Tater tots were perfect. My girlfriend is not a big fan of beef, but she liked her burger. Hands down, the best burger I've ever had. Too bad it is in Hawaii! :(
(5)Eats Too Much F.
Best burger I've had on the West side of the island. If, Cool Cats wins 'Best Burger" next year I will firmly believe the voting is rigged. It's in a very Southern California plaza (no surprise, it was built by DR Horton) and is not on the water, but it is the best burger I've had on the West side ever since that place below the other restaurant as you enter Kaanapali closed. If you are getting tired of "Shoyu" this and "Teri" that and crave a great burger and fries, this is your place. The garlic fries rock!
(5)Daren N.
Best burger in Maui! I was suprised, and we took advantage of a yelp deal for checking in. Service was very good also, and seems employees like working there.
(5)Brendan M.
This was my first visit to Teddy's and I was impressed. I ordered a Laihana burger, which in addition to the basics came with pineapple and jalapenos. The sweet and spicy combination was AMAZING. In addition, or particular note was there "secret sauce," which seems to be similar to Thousand Island, but they have made it there own by giving it a sweet taste - it was quite good. Also all of the ingredients were fresh and you could definitely taste it. Their fries were also very good. The burgers come in three sizes 5, 7, and 9 oz. I ordered the 7 oz burger and it was huge. I was starving so I did finish my burger/fries, but had I been at home as opposed to on vacation where I had not eaten since breakfast the 5 oz would probably have been more than enough. The prices were a little high - it cost $28 for two 7 oz burger combos. Although, if you buy the Yelp $12 for $20 coupon you can same some money. The food quality was similar to that of a sit down restaurant's burgers, which justifies the cost; however, the environment is that of a fast food restaurant - for which the same cost seems very expensive. The decor of the restaurant is obnoxiously bright red, yellow, and blue colored. It says it is 50's themed, but it does not really look it to me. That being said I went for the food NOT the decor. One complaint about there menu (on the wall) is it seems a bit disorganized and hard to follow. There is a sign on the wall with circles showing you how big the 5, 7, and 9 oz burger sizes, but I did not even see that until after I ordered. Also, the main menu gives you the cost of their burger combos for the original Teddy's burger, which is based on what size you order. However, there is also a side menu with a lot of different speciality burger options including the Laihana, but that one does not include any prices. When I ordered it the cost came to the same as the original Teddy's burger combo (7 oz size) - so I assume all burgers cost the same based on size? All in all it was a little confusing and pricey, but the burger made it worth if. If on Maui and you want a burger I definitely recommend Teddy's. They do accept credit card.
(4)daniel s.
I still love this place! I want a t-shirt. I can't wait till the location in kihei opens up.
(5)R W.
This was a great place to eat while we were on vacation! Kids loved the food and all the burger options were really good. We will be back next time we are on Maui.
(5)P H.
Having landed in Maui and found our hotel we were in desperate need of sustenance. As we entered Teddy's I felt guilty for not choosing local Hawaiian cuisine as our first meal, but tired and hungry we relented given the excellent reviews. I got the #3 Combo, Biggest Burger with large fries with a side of tots. Remember that feeling of guilt upon entering? Upon first bite the guilt left me! Into the ether it went! The food was excellent - the burger and their secret sauce delicious, the tots were cooked perfectly, and the fries? Sir! They were tasty seasoned fries! Thinking the experience could get no better, the staff made a pass and even asked how our experience was! This was a first for me at a fast food restaurant and one that was greatly appreciated. Add Teddy's to your Maui experience, you won't regret it.
(5)Lovesto E.
Wow!!! Was I pleasantly surprised when we went here to eat. The place is very clean and the food was delicious! The burgers are homemade and tastes like it and the seasoning very good. The burger is cooked to order at your preferred doneness and you even have a choice of different types of fries. I had the 7 ounce combo with crispy fries and I must say, it was tasty! My wife had the buffalo chicken sandwich with spicy fries and she enjoyed every bite! They also have a kamaaina discount, which does make a difference. The service, although counter service, was also very good and the employees are very attentive and friendly. Hard to find good workers here, but it was very apparent these guys and gals, or at least this shift, took pride in their jobs. I even heard one of them apologizing and thanking a customer for telling them one of the tables needed to be wiped, despite the fact this lady could have sat at the many other, clean and unoccupied tables! I will definitely be back, many times, I'm sure.
(5)Michael L.
I tried out TBB's due to a Yelp deal coupon and was glad that I did. It was similar to Five Guys Burger joint due to the way you can customize your order, however, the options they had were endless. I had a insanely big and complex Hawaiian themed burger and it was delicious. The price wasn't cheap but on Hawaii you have to expect things to be a little bit more costly. I would say it was very nice value though. If you're looking for a differing dining option on the island, or just love burgers, I would highly recommend it. Pros: great service, unique burger options, great fries and sides (my wife loved her chocolate shake), and very filling.
(5)Rachel A.
Not only are the burgers & shakes delicious (especially the Kailua & Bacado), the reason a burger joint is 5 stars instead of 4 is their location. The fact that you don't have to go to Front St or Kaanapali for a good meal deserves an extra star!
(5)Armando A.
Kinda funny that I go all the way to Maui and end up at a burger joint, but there you go. We get there and it's in a suburban looking strip mall and looks like it's part of a chain which I usually stay away from. However, it was at the end of a long day and we were not about to go searching elsewhere. At any rate, the burger were VERY good. The shake I had was excellent too. I don't remember the name of it but the flavor was like one of those push ups I had when I was a kid. Not much on vibe but the food was worth the trip.
(4)Angie T.
Yum, YUM and YUM! We came to Teddy's after sunbathing on the beach. There's always something about swimming and sunbathing that makes you really hungry. I ordered the 5 oz burger and cheese fries. My husband ordered the plantation fries and they were amazing! I personally do not prefer to eat pork but the shredded pork on the fries was tender, juicy and delicious. The prices weren't horrible and the food was bomb. We were with some locals so we got the kamaaina discount~ Woohoo! Bottom line- if you are hungry and in Lahaina you must go to Teddy's.
(5)Ray M.
Excellent burger and chicken sandwiches. The burgers are very juicy; a 5 oz. is filling. My wife's Cajun chicken sandwich had the right level of spices; she said up that she could taste the spices, and that most times at other places the level of spice is too weak. The tots tasted fantastic. Too bad they are not in California.
(5)Corky B.
I had the turkey burger with pineapple. Came with the standard burger sauce. The sauce is sweet enough that I don't think there is a need to order the teriyaki version of the burgers they offer. Turkey burger was good, though slightly undercooked. Quality of bread and veggies was good. Onions were very thinly sliced. Had a vanilla milkshake. Very thick, and they brought it out right to my table. Better service than I expected from a fast food vendor in a shopping center. They have a lot of specialty sides, like tots covered in things like pork, cheese, onions, that are not easy to see on the menu. They have pictures around the restaurant showing some of the special items they serve. There are enough wacky things they offer that it would be worth re-visiting if only to try them out.
(4)Mike C.
Teddy's was one of my favorite burger joints when I lived on Oahu, and it's one of the places I sorely missed after I moved back to Maui in 2009. I was so excited when i heard they were finally opening a location on Maui, and they didn't disappoint. Try the western burger for something a little tangy, or the bacado if you like a California style burger. No matter what you get, it's gonna be a delicious burger!
(5)Nick R.
My wife and I were hungry and we asked one of the local merchants in old Lahaina where's a good place to eat for the money. She recommened Teddy's because you get a typical combo meal i.e. burger, fries, and a drink for around $10. She said the burgers were very good. I love my burgers and I know a good burger when I have one. Teddy's Burgers is one of my favorite burger joints to eat now. The burgers had a lot of flavor on fresh (or what seemed fresh) hamburger buns. The hamburgers are definitely top notch, and the meat is also fresh, not frozen like a lot of other places. Whenever I'm in Maui, eating at Teddy's is a must. The service is great and the wait isn't long. Pound for pound worth every penny.
(5)J X.
I'm very impressed with the high level of customer satisfaction that the owner and his wife emphasize. They will go out of their way to make sure your experience goes above and beyond "mediocre," because that is not good enough for them. They have cute review cards that are optional for you to fill out because the owners actually care about your feedback so they can continue making their restaurant even better! They have a lot of interesting variety of burgers, and teryaki is wonderful on almost everything I've now realized! :)
(5)Shawn P.
Burgers were amazing, atmosphere was great. Definitely would recommend this place as a nice, reasonably priced, option for tourists and locals.
(4)Bob G.
Awesome burgers, great seasoning and fresh ingredients. Try the Lahaina with pineapple and jalapeños. Fantastic flavors.
(5)Kelsey F.
I really liked this place! They have great burgers, yummy fries, and great sauces! Can't go wrong:)
(5)Marc R.
Customer service was awesome. Everyone was very friendly. I will definitely go back. Food was great too.
(5)Karen H.
Just wanted a quick cheap meal. The burger was nothing special, but I did like their tator tots. The milkshakes were ok too.
(3)Julie K.
You know, the food was fine. Just not fine enough to warrant the price. Even when using a Yelp deal to reduce the cost, it was still over $20 for two burgers, fries and shakes. The inside wasn't any better than a McDonalds. Yes, I would eat here again if I had a coupon or deal and I was shopping nearby, but I wouldn't go out of my way to do it. Most tourists who come to Maui are looking for some ambience, and this doesn't have any.
(3)Lorrie K.
Fantastic burgers, and so many ways to order them. I give them a 3 on atmosphere though since it looks like a circus more than retro with the blue, red and yellow decor. Black and white or black, red and white would look much bette plus the molded plastic seats remind me of McDonalds. It didn't bring down my overall grade much though, since they did such a good job on the burgers.
(4)May L.
Went last week for the first time and it was awesome! The food was great and the service was quick and friendly. Big portions and very reasonably priced, we used the yelp deal which was cheaper than the kama'aina discount. Can't wait to go back!
(5)Jason B.
Fantastic food - the only problem is deciding what to get! I ended up getting the 5oz combo meal with added cheese and pulled pork, delicious! The fries were nothing to write home about, next time I'm skipping the fries and drink and getting a bigger burger with more goodies!
(5)Geordi W.
If you are looking for a burger this is the place to go! Great 50's atmosphere and even better burgers!
(5)Lindsay M.
Great food at s great price. The shake was delicious and super thick. I can't wait to go back.
(5)Lou G.
Located near the Foodland, Teddy's is clean, well lit & the servers are courteous. Read about this place on Yelp and used the coupon purchased on Yelp. Enough about the surroundings, it's about the burgers . I had a 7 oz Bigger "Lahaina" burger, wife had a fish burger & chocolate shake, we shared fries. My burger was delicious. I have had burgers from Shake Shack in New York City, Five Guys Burgers & Fries and In-N-Out amongest many others that were less memorable. Teddy's is as good as any of those mentioned, if not better. On the night we went it was busy but not crowded. So nice not to fight crowds in Maui. Now for the cliche, it doesn't get any better for location or food, a cheeseburger in paradise.
(5)Tony M.
Great burger on maui. Excellent selection, almost too many. Food fresh and a good value. Service was also very good. They seem to want to please you. Can get "buy one combo, get second at 50% off" coupons in tourist mags. Makes 2 combos total less than $20. Don't think you'll be disappointed with any selection. 4 of us had 4 different, all pleased. If your visiting the island, don't miss.
(5)Angela N.
Awesome burgers! A must eat in Lahaina. We came from Los Angeles and Chicago to visit Maui and wanted a great burger. Teddy's Bigger Burgers has so many yummy choices so you can't go wrong! If you want a great tasting burger made fresh this is difinitely the place!
(5)Jen A.
Found this place by accident and so glad we did! They serve your typical burger, fries and shakes. I had the bacon blue cheese and it was cooked perfectly. Get the $20 for $12 through yelp for an awesome deal! I purchased mine while waiting in line and showed them my smart phone and the accepted :)
(5)Christy A.
Yum! Omg I wanted to walk out when I saw the cost of the food but I am so glad I didnt. I got the grilled chicken sandwich and husband got a burger. They were both delish! I was a little scared of the secret sauce so I got it on the side. Well I'm glad I did because not only did I use it on my sandwich but I dipped my fries in it. This was not the ordinary thousand island dressing secret sauce. It was fresh, sweet, tangy and yummy! I totally suggest you give this place a try. But do be prepared to wait a few minutes. This place cooks everything to order so it takes a while, however it is worth the wait.
(5)Matthew V.
Best burger my wife and I had in HI. Best service we had in any restaurant. I paid a little more than I had expected (pricing for the specialty burgers isn't clearly posted and can sneak up on you quickly - adding $4-6 to the regular price of the burger), but with the Yelp deal, everything balanced out. Apparently it's a chain based on the islands (with an additional location in both Tokyo and WA), but easily the best meal for the money we had all week. The only thing that kept this from being an epic experience was the lack of deep fried cheese curds on the menu.
(5)Melisaa B.
Fabulous burgers and great service! Highly recommend the Lahaina burger! This burger can't be beat!
(5)Leilani D.
I love their burgers! I usually get the bacon bleu cheese burger with cheese fries their staff is very friendly and helpful I also like their milkshakes so addicting!
(5)Anthony C.
I visited this place twice during my last visit to Maui and will definitely return on my next trip. It's so difficult to find reasonably priced food that is good on Maui and am happy that this place is there for a yummy lunch. I was impressed by the staff too - very friendly. And, the place is VERY clean - very important to me!!!
(5)Keith L.
Great spot for burgers and the usual sides but stick with Cool Cat Cafe if you want to wash your burger down with a brew or other adult beverage.
(4)Sadler W.
Great semi-retro burger joint! Looks like a fast food burger stand, but the burgers were cooked fresh (you could tell) and they had some cool and funky possibilities on the menu as well. I had the teri-burger, which was very good. Grab a Yelp deal and check them out!
(5)Sonya P.
I don't say this often but this was one of the best burgers I've ever had. Perfect topping combos like mushrooms and swiss teri available, fresh ingredients, generous amounts, and great portions. I wish I lived near this place. 5-stars for sure.
(5)Gary K.
If I could give this place 6 stars I would, you can tell that the owners really care for their business because the food is amazing!!
(5)James K.
I visited Teddy's Bigger Burger on a recent vacation to Maui. I've had all the well known burgers in Los Angeles (In-N-Out, Five Guys, Umami, Father's Office, The Counter, Plan Check, etc), and Teddy's ranks up there. In fact, I would rank Teddy's number 1 or 2 compared all the ones I've mentioned. The burger was flavorful and had the smokey taste you get when you grill it in your backyard. Excellent. Garlic fries were good too. Only complaint is that it takes a while for your order since they cook it when you order. Worth the wait though.
(5)T A.
Great place to have a burger. Big, Jucy burger with a nice atmosphere.
(4)Amanda H.
Good food, good service, clean place. Worth the money!
(5)Alison J.
Happy to find a good burger place in Lahaina, especially one that offers turkey burgers. Fast service, clean place. Our order was off a little (we never asked for the bacon that appeared on one of our burgers), but the burgers were generous in size, with nice soft buns, fresh crispy lettuce and tasty pickles. We will definitely add this to our meal rotation for our trips to Maui. It's a nice break from the pricey restaurants that abound here.
(4)Mari P.
Damm good juicy hamburgers in Maui. Wanted something semi-quick and casual since we were towing around two kiddies. The bread roll the hamburgers come in and french fries were awesome. I could have killed two hamburgers along with my diet coke (tee hee), these hamburgers just reminded me of grilling in the backyard. Check them out, staff is super nice, place is spacious and there is AC ya'll! Enjoy and then go take a dip in the beach.
(5)Joe R.
Great!!! That's all that needs to be sad about the food here.
(5)Super H.
A nice change of pace from sit down, fancy spots in Maui. A solid, greasy meal as well. 3 and a half stars but I'll round up because I got a great check-in deal.
(4)Manas A.
That was one large burger! With an egg on top. Like a loco moco, but sans rice. And some chili and spud on top to round it off. Go for it if you have the appetite. Or rather, make the appetite and then make sure to come here. P.S. Don't tell your cardiologist you were here.
(5)Lisa M.
The best juicy burger. Would eat there again.
(5)Garth H.
We really enjoyed Teddys. Burgers were very tasty, and yes they werent "medium" the first time, but we didi go back a second time and they were perfect. Not cheap, but by Hawaiian standards a decent value, and for sure not a disappointment. We'll be back, and after perusing their website, theyactually have a restaurant in our home area, Woodinville, WA.
(5)Ann S.
The lady who took our order was super friendly and their shakes were great while we waited for our order. We both got the teriyaki burger and I think we should've each gotten something different for our first time here. We weren't bowled over by that particular combo (I thought it came with pineapple but it didn't, I'd make sure to add it next time) but the burger on its own was really good. Fries were also good so as long as they're still around the next time we're back on the island, we'll be coming back!
(4)Rex M.
We've been here on Maui a month and were needing a burger fix. One of the guys that works at the place we're staying recommended Teddy's. It was on my "try" list but had forgotten about it. So we went around 1pm. Burgers hit the spot, french fries were fresh fried, onion rings were OK, doubt if I'll get them again. Total bill was 25$, a little high, but not too bad. Kinda reminds me of Five Guys in a good way they have more choices which is good.
(4)Carla L.
Good and very fresh! The buns disintegrate though. Also I had heard the milkshakes were great but they were out of chocolate and strawberry which is pretty odd
(4)J F.
First time ever to Teddy's Burgers. Incredible! We all loved it....best burger joint we have been to near Kaanapali.
(5)Lukas T.
This place is awesome. So awesome, in fact, that I am sitting in Teddy's again right now, the day after our first visit. My wife says she ate the best burger she's ever had and the topping choices are astounding. A must-try for burger lovers!
(5)Doc C.
Wonderful! Great service! Yummy!
(4)Dan S.
I heard that this was the place for great burgers and shakes. I have to agree. Also tried the onion rings and was pleasantly surprised. I will visit Teddy's every trip to Maui.
(5)Lanie M.
We were cruising in Lahaina and decided to have some burgers. I was been here before and i heard so much good reviews from my friends who had been here. I ordered the Kailua burger combo , i was satisfied about the service, the burger was juicy , i loved the fries and the price was reasonable enough for a 5 oz burger .
(4)Amanda A.
The best burger on Maui for sure! We go to Teddy's Bigger Burger at least once a month and love it every time! Yummmm :)
(5)Clarice K.
Went to Teddy's today, try to come here whenever I go to Lahaina. I love the food and the staff is very friendly. We had Hank today ( I think that was his name) he was super nice and told us all the specials. I had the pastrami sandwich which was really good and my friend had the loco moco burger an she said it was great. When you come here, come hungry! The portions are huge!
(5)Courtney S.
Burgers were delicious! Better than 5 guys or in and out. I'm from San Diego and I love in and out. Get the specialty burgers, you won't be disappointed. Service was good. As cheap as anything you are going to eat in Maui.
(5)Patricia R.
Great taste. Burgers are large. Good atmosphere
(5)Catherine M.
If you are craving a reasonably priced burger - go to this place! The food was really yummy (we had hawaiian style burgers). And the pineapple milkshake was to dye for!! I could have had so many more of those. I think this was our cheapest meal out while in Maui, and it was delicious
(5)Lisa D.
awesome burgers and great onion rings....our new fav burger joint :-)
(5)Paula G.
Found the Yelp deal and decided to give this place a try... feeding a family of 5 while on a Hawaiin vacation is tough, so we'll take the deal! Being tucked away in a shopping center, we wouldn't have stumbled upon it otherwise. Food: overall, a good burger and fries. Kids had the chicken nugget meals which they devoured. Coming from the Washington DC area, I don't think it stacks up to a Five Guys burger, but still good. Cost is certainly higher (but you're in Hawaii....), each meal was about $10 once you added on cheese. We had also stopped at Bubba's on Kauai and this place was defintely better. Service: For food alone, I would have gone with a three star, but the service of this place pushed it to a 4. Wow, I wasn't expecting this! Upon walking in, the cashier person proactively said hello and explained the menu to us. Our table was also promptly cleared and we were provided wet-naps to clean up. Place: cool hangout place... extremely clean.... A+ there! Not a bad place to stop..... and don't forget your Yelp deal!!!
(4)Bob K.
Had the University Burger & the Western Burger in two separate trips. The garlic fries are tasty!
(5)John P.
Great thick burgers, much better than the typical fast food burgers. Excellent environment and friendly staff. Priced for families.
(5)Hulda W.
Fries need to be crisper and fresher but the hamburgers rock. Friendly and helpful staff, clean and crisp environment and fun music. I like to order chili cheese style - it reminds me of Tommy's in LA. Shakes are really thick so you need a spoon or let it melt for a while before you use a straw.
(4)Mary M.
Just ate at Teddy's and I had the most wonderful turkey burger. I will definitely will go back
(4)Ssixty F.
good job teddy and rich. I loved my bigger burger with pastram and the wife said f@,&;n awesome with the bacado. very good service and clean. I highly reccomend! and the yelp coupon kicks butt thanks!
(5)Hulda S.
One of my fav new spots! All the kids working there are super curtious. The joint is amazingly clean! The food is really good and priced just right.
(5)Susie M.
Went here because of yelp's $12 for $20 deal for the first time; I was rather impressed with the quality and quantity of the food. I got a Maui burger (I think), and it was incredibly large. All ingredients were very fresh, the greens were actually green and crispy, not limpy as they sometimes are. The one complaint I had about their burgers is that their "secret sauce", which is good and similar but not thousand island exactly, is slightly overwhelming on the burger. If I was to go back, i'd probably order it with light sauce. Regardless, the 7oz was ginormous...I would suggest the 5oz is honestly enough food. Their fries were crispy and although there was somewhat of a wait on the food, it was clearly worth the wait. The decor wasn't anything special, very neon-colored, bright, reminds me of the California chain In-n-Out.
(4)Jeremy W.
I love yelp for helping me find spots like this! Awesome burgers and the shake was primo. I got an avocado, pepper jack, grilled mushroom, Ortega chile burger with a coconut shake and fries. Its worth it if it takes a day off my life!
(4)Ty S.
My friend introduced me to Teddy's a few months ago. As a rather frequent customer now, I can tell you that in my book, Teddy's has the best burgers on the entire island. Big, tasty, and the price is right. I have had the regular cheeseburger, the cajun burger, and the King of the Dojo... that one was pretty special. I usually get the monster double, which is two 5oz patties. (It may not sound like a lot, considering they offer double 9oz patties, but it leaves me feeling full with some left over) The burgers come out so hot and fresh here that I actually have to wait until it cools down a little bit before I can eat it. The buns are great, and in fact all of the ingredients all seem to be very fresh... no soggy lettuce, etc. The staff is great. Last time I was in around closing, they turned the fountain back on for me so that I could refill my soda before I left. The spirit of aloha is alive and well here. Eat at Teddy's... you will not regret it.
(5)Wendi R.
Searching for that all-elusive buger led us to Teddy's. Extremely friendly staff encouraged us to the counter. Had Teddie's burger (5oz) combo. Great burger! All the fixin's were fresh, local and plenty of them. Special sauce was mayo/mustardy drippy goodness. Fries were piping hot. Pros: Great burger. Meat excellent. Toppings fresh, local, yummy! Clean restaraunt, friendly and helpful staff. Cons: Slightly doughy bun, ended up only eating half. Chincy on the fries, would have loved a bigger portion. Overall: Great place for burger!
(4)Nathary R.
I live on Oahu and I have had Teddy's many times before, had Teddy's on my trip and it was amazing as always. The original burger is the way to go, if you get fries it's worth getting Cajun on them, making them spicy for .50 more. The avocado and bacon burger is amazing as well. Get your burger any way you like it, I guarantee it will be one of the best burgers you've had. Average meal combos are $10
(5)Paul L.
Friendly staff. burgers were nice and juicy. My daughter who is super picky loved the chicken nuggets. same meal on front street would have cost us 80. 5 of us came out to 45, 2 shakes included.
(5)jeff h.
I visited with my family. They are super nice people, best service I can say so far in Maui. We had wish sandwiches and they were very good. I have a difficult time finding so good food in mainland. I would strongly recommend .
(5)Marina M.
Great burgers. Very fresh. Good taste. Onion rings and fries were the best. Nice place.
(5)Chris P.
Pineapple and coconut milk shake is shake of the month and it is awesome. Sad to say, it is the best milk shake that I have ever had so far.
(5)Nolly Y.
pastrami sandwich with avocado was really good, juicy thin slices, on a moist bun. Aiea burger another winner. Blue cheese added to a juicy burger made it all the better!
(5)Garrett H.
Best burgers on Maui!
(5)Zac G.
Great western burger
(5)Lewis C.
It's usually hard to justify giving a burger joint 4 stars - but the great selection on the menu, along with tater tots offered (along with the usual fries and onion rings) and the sleeper selection - chili - tipped them over to a 4-star rating. First a suggestion - the smallest size burger is a very healthy size, so no need to upscale unless you are super hungry or if you are an 18-year old male - of which I had TWO in my party (Ryan and Joey). Every burger was delicious - the mushroom swiss was a big hit. The chili burger was so chock full of chili, we glommed some of it to make chili fries and chili tots. Shakes were made the right way on real shake spindles, not with a blender. All ingredients tasted fresh and the guy brought all our food to our table with a super friendly attitude. This place was REALLY GOOD. We'll be back for sure.
(4)Kenny L.
So yelpers are legit. The burgers here were amazing and literally caused me to finally create a login for yelp! My wife who is very hard to please already mentioned how she wanted to come here again before we take off. Expensive for burgers, but I felt I was getting for what I paid for. Thanks yelp! Other Maui reviews to come.
(5)Shelly H.
Great burger and sandwich shop in Lahaina. Will definitely be back on our next trip!
(4)AlohaKeAku A.
Started out loving this place but we just can't do it any longer. We just can't handle the inconsistancy. Out of all the times we have eaten here and all the money we have spent in this restaurant, we deserve better. The burger is made either wrong, raw or too dry. The only consistancy is that it's going down hill fast. Any special requests screw up the kids that work here and they can't get it right. The owner tries to find other help but needs to invest his time into finding employees that can get an order right, a cook that knows how to make a burger and salads that can be eaten and not thrown in the trash for lack of taste. Putting more items on the menu only makes for more mistakes. There is too much to choose from and they can't get even the simple burger right. The salads are horrible. The ceasar salad consists of romaine lettuce in a plastic container, 1 oz of chicken (dry) and a package of ceasar dressing from Kens dressing. Are you kidding me? We are so disappointed. What a shame. We're done.
(1)Ed W.
Great place for a burger on this side of the island, especially with the Yelp deal! You really need to know how to order too, if you just order one of the their built burgers, you will be paying for all of the extras.
(5)A D.
Great hamburgers! The bun was fresh and delicious and the meat was tasty as well. I like that you can choose the size of your burger. My husband had a malt -- and you could actually taste the malt. Many places will give you a "malt" but the flavor is so subtle it's more like a milkshake. This place should give Cool Cat Cafe a run for their money -- they already have one advantage -- not having to deal with the challenge of Front Street Parking. It can get expensive though -- I ordered a specialty hamburger to go -- it was the small size but over $11.
(4)Janice Araki L.
Bacado burger is great. Wish they would steam the bun or had a better bun. Fries nice and crispy and hot. They have fat fries. Definitely coming back to try the different burger options.
(4)Ciaran C.
I tried Teddy's Bigger Burgers because there was a $20 for $12 coupon on Yelp. Glad I did - the 9oz bacado (baconn+avocado) burger was delicious. Would defo repeat.
(5)April G.
Food was great! Yelp deal was awesome....always appreciate saving some $$!
(4)Kara N.
Yummy burgers!! Their fries are also tasty and you definitely have to try their shakes. It would have been 5 stars but the service was a tad slow, but the great food took my mind off it in the end.
(4)