Sharky’s Seagrill

2519 Gulf Dr N
Anna Maria Island, 34217
Reviews:
Well ..... The food was ok. It was definitely bland though. It is rated way too high in my opinion. 2 adults and 2 kids .... Waiting on the bill now.... I feel certain I will feel MEH... YEP .. Feeling meh about cost verses food.
Completely random visit, it was the fifth place on the right and that was our criteria. Mussels we're good, especially the sauce. Crab cakes we're good, meaty, but not lumpy, like MD style. Friendly staff. Smaller place, but good mix of couples and families. Open after 4pm.
We showed up without reservations. When we arrived it wasn't busy, thankfully. I can only imagine that during high tourist season that you would need them as this place is not very big. We were seated immediately and the waitress, Donna, showed up acknowledged us and arrived at our table short thereafter. Service throughout the evening was stellar. There was an issue with my fish dish that I ordered being a little raw in the middle. She apologized and offered a dessert in it's place, there was no hesitation. We decided to split the Crab Stuffed Tilapia and the Seafood Sorrento, although we could have just ordered one and shared that dish. We added a small salad, however there was nothing small about this salad. Nice variety of fresh veggies and a peppercorn ranch dressing. The Long Fin Tilapia with blue crab stuff and lemon buerre blanc was wonderful and very large. I think the largest piece of tilapia that I've ever seen. The crab stuffing was nice and didn't have a lot of filler. The Seafood Sorrento was a huge portion as well. It contained shrimp, clams, squid, mussels and fish served over pasta in a cream or marinara sauce. We opted for the cream sauce. I don't think you could go wrong with any of the dishes on the menu. If you want good service ask for Donna, she'll take very good care of you during your meal.

(941) 779-9151

Seafood, American (New), Steakhouses

Store is open now

Slim’s Place

9701 Gulf Dr
Anna Maria Island, 34217
Reviews:
No review available for this restaurant

(941) 567-4056

Sports Bars, American (Traditional)

Store is open now