I've eaten their food three times. Two times I've eaten there and once had a pizza delivered. What was funny is the guy taking my pizza order told me the price and stopped talking. I was waiting for him to ask me my cc info. I think he thought I was balking at the price because he told me, "You realize our pizzas are not the $5 kind?" I laughed and said I don't eat $5 pizzas! He got a kick out of that and the pie was delivered warm and tasty! I was a bachelor that weekend and the large lasted me both Saturday and Sunday. Nothing like pizza for breakfast baby! Both times I visited there the food was really good. The first time I had the chicken Marsala and loved it. The second time I had the lasagne with meat sauce and my wife had the chicken cacciatore. She ate everything on her plate and loved it. I got full on half of the lasagne and had the other half for lunch the next day. Both times the lasagne was delicious. We live close by so we'll be going back again for sure. My wife and I aren't really into hearing cover music when we eat, we like to talk. The only thing I haven't appreciated about the place was the Elvis impersonator singing when we went on a Saturday night. Good singer but everything he sang was in the Elvis style...George Straight in an Elvis style...not for me thank you. Of course I did tip the gentleman because he has talent. We are looking forward to the weather cooling so we can sit either inside or out, where ever the singer is not.
(5)
Amanda A.
I am originally from NYC and moved to Arizona close to 2 years ago. I found out about this place from a random New Yorker I met. To say the least, this place is amazing. I go to Brooklyn V's all the time. I feel a price of home and nostalgia when I walk in. I spent about a year and a half trying to find good NY pizza and did not find it, until I went to Brooklyn V's. I won't eat any other pizza, except for theirs. Not only do they have great pizza, they offer amazing pasta dishes, desserts, and their staff is the greatest. I will always be a New Yorker and their food makes me miss/appreciate the NY style of food.
(5)
Mark L.
We celebrated my daughter's first birthday here last night and could not have been more impressed. My wife reserved a table for our party and the staff was not only accommodating, but went above and beyond by decorating our table with balloons, birthday napkins and even had a special candle for the cake. The food was phenomenal. My party tried garlic knots, spaghetti and pizza. Everything tasted delicious and the pizza was excellent. Cheese, sauce, garlic, pepperoni, spinach and dough all came together perfectly. Beer and wine were very reasonably priced and the live music completed the night. The staff was very attentive to our needs and I cannot say enough about how welcomed they made all of us feel. This is a family owned business that shows tremendous pride in quality and preparation of food and care for their patrons. A big thank you to the entire staff at Brooklyn V's for making my daughter's first birthday one that we will never forget.
(5)
Danielle C.
Great service!! Great food!! It's been difficult finding Stromboli in Arizona but Brooklyn V's do it and they do it right!!! I had the Stromboli with sausage, pepperoni and meatballs! They did not skimp out on meat or cheese!!! It was oozing cheese!!! So delicious!! We will be back to try the pizzas and pastas which all look amazing! Everyone was super friendly and made us feel welcome. I even saw the owner come out and shake hands with patrons. This is why it's so important to support local businesses especially when they are as worthy as this one!!! Can't wait to go back!!
(5)
Lori E.
I am from ny and i have to say this place has the best pizza and calzones I havent had anything elst tho
(5)
Donna B.
This place has quickly become my favorite local joint to get food! I love the food and the chance to get out of my house and sit down somewhere else with TV, a drink, and Italian food. My favorite dishes are the Chicken Marsala and the chicken and mozzarella (add mushrooms) calzone. The garlic knot appetizers are addictive! They come with a side of homemade marinara and are to die for. The bruschetta is pretty good. The chicken parm here is also very well done. Though I haven't tried it yet, their pizza seems to be very popular. The service is usually pretty good. Anna is the best!! Also, they deliver!! They have TVs, booths, tables, and outside seating. The tables in the middle can accommodate small groups.
(5)
April G.
We ordered and picked up our food. The phone was picked up promptly and the lady that was taking the order was very nice and informative. We ordered the Bianco pizza, stuffed shells and cannolis. Our order was ready in 20min. The lady at the counter was very friendly and quick to grab our food. The food was about $30 which isn't to bad. The pizza was awesome! It has fresh ingredients and the mozzarella was soooo good!!! The stuffed shells were seasoned wonderfully with some really tasty marinara. Lastly the cannolis tasted like my grandmothers which is saying a lot in a great way. :) They had chocolate chips with a slightly sweet ricotta filling. Other places tend to make these to sweet which ruins them. You have to have the right balance of sweetness, crunch and creaminess from the ricotta. Soooo this place gets a thumbs up!! Yum!
(5)
Robert G.
Went there first time with my sons and the pizza is outstanding! The only issue is we did not feel welcome, the service is excellent but the manager that day made visits to the other tables except ours, that i think is Not good buisness or good management! What am i? Chopped liver Lost my business and was planning to my it my regular pizza place,NOT NOW!
Had spaghetti meatballs and vodka penne comparable to las Vegas quality pastas five stars!
(5)
Matthew G.
I was really excited walking in and hearing all the accents and such, but if this is New York pizza, I'd rather stick with Arizona. Pizza was not terrible, but the sauce was way too watery. Everything slid off of our pizza. They also seemed to be big on the oil as well. Both the pizza and knots had excessive amounts of oil. The service was great and the staff was friendly, which is why I say 3 stars. Would I return? No. Not with all the great choices in the area. $28 for a med pizza, knots, and drink.
(3)
Mark B.
First of all, when you're here, you're family. The hospitality here is unparalleled. When time permits, Vito, the owner, and the crew will be sure to stop by, introduce themselves and drop a friendly hello. It's so nice to come to such a wonderful Italian restaurant and have authentic cuisine. Vito definitely takes pride in his work and the staff delivers. When you come, request Desiree and tell her Mark and Cristina recommended her. Enjoy the amazing food and ambiance. Support your local Italianos and enjoy what Vito and his staff is proud to serve you! Till next time, ciao!
(5)
BARRY B.
You search for a real New York pizza, especially if you come from Brooklyn. This place comes thisclose. Vito has the "touch". The pizza is delicious. Their marinara is wonderful and the garlic knots are like Brooklyn's best. It was also amazing that there were a lot of N.Y. ex-pats the evening we were there.
(4)
Alia K.
Wanted to try a new place for lunch and found a gem. Not only did I have a great experience, but the food was amazing too. Bob and Desiree are the sweetest people and helped me custom my lunch order. A very pleasant and clean environment. I'll definitely be coming back.
(5)
Tyler S.
Was enjoying a night of swimming in the 100+ degree weather and wanted something good, quick and delivered to our door. Brooklyn V's fit the bill! Food was delivered under the estimated time and was piping hot. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, chicken stromboli and honey bbq wings and all were amazing! Will definitely order again.
(5)
Travis L.
Great chicken parm. tonight, they forgot my side Caesar though. I gave five stars on my first review.
(3)
Harvey S.
A friend wanted to try this place, being that it's local and they have a doo-wap group performing...at least this Saturday. We had brushetta and garlic knots for the table. The brushetta had plenty of fresh tomatoes and basil, among other things. The garlic knots had minced garlic butter...more flavorful than garlic butter with powder. The margherita pizza was very flavorful...it had chopped tomatoes and a crust crispy and NY-style...thinner, but not too thin. And the musical group was really fun, but does not allow for good conversation if you're sitting nearby. The waitstaff was good natured and stopped by enough to check up on us, refill drinks, despite being a busy night. Recommended.
(4)
Val M.
I looooove this place. Food is always delicious, service is great, and always very quick/reliable with delivery. Highly recommended!
(5)
Tamara R.
Really glad I read the reviews on the buffalo chicken pizza and ordered it because that was delicious! Two pizzas and a 6 piece garlic knots was really quite expensive to have delivered though. Otherwise I'd give it a full 5. Really tasty food though!
(4)
Becky C.
I am astounded at the quality of this "hole in the wall" find. Between a smoke shop and a cleaners, Brooklyn V's has blown me away. Pizza shop? No, this is a Brooklyn restaurant in the heart of Mesa, AZ. I had spaghetti in clam sauce. Where do I begin? The pasta was al dente. That's the first step to proving you care a bit about your food. Next is tender clams, a TON of them, in a perfect sauce, mild with a hint of wine and garlic, sprinkled with parm and served with crusty Italian bread, baked locally and only sold to a choice few restaurants. It absorbs the sauce perfectly, melting in the buttery, garlicky goodness. There are only a few beers on tap. I had the Shock Rock Belgian White, a perfect compliment to the light sauce and simple meal. I was sent here by a local, the guy at Stamps Automotive, while they work on my car. I cannot thank him enough.
(5)
MikeNikki G.
Great food and great service. Kid friendly, but food is grown-up worthy. We will definitely be back.
(5)
Scott C.
Amazing food - Amazing owners and staff! Atmosphere is "Cheers" like. If you are considering trying but unsure - have no fear - You will not be disappointed!!
(5)
Nick B.
First timer and not bad def worth trying. Tried the eggplant and pizza very delicious...
(5)
Brandon B.
The service here is phenomenal. The entire staff makes you feel like you're a part of their family. I recommend you make your way here. I've been 5 times in the last 2 weeks. thank you for providing the best service in the Gilbert area. Furthermore the Pizza is AMAZING!!! You can't find pizza this good unless you're in Brooklyn!
(5)
Kim L.
My new favorite pizza place! We ordered for pickup through online app (which made it very easy) and was ready in exactly 20mins. Staff was friendly and place was clean. The ONLY reason I am not giving 5 stars is because of their limited specialty pizza choices. There are 8 very different specialty choices, all of which had 3 toppings or less, so if you like alot of toppings you'd pay extra per topping. We ordered the 3 meat pizza and added olives for my toddler for extra $2 but there wasn't much olives at all considering the extra topping fee. So if you wanted a typical "supreme" style pizza with meats and veggies, you'd pay close to $20-25 which is a lot for a 14in pizza.
(4)
Dan A.
Wow! I popped in for lunch on a Tuesday and was kindly greeted by Bob, one of the owners. I sat down for lunch and thought I'd give their pizza and Stromboli a try. The pizza was good. I'm from NJ, and I was very impressed. It's on par with some of the other NY style pizza places in Gilbert. The Stromboli, though... Out of this world. I saw how big it was and I figured I'd get through half after a slice of pizza, but I couldn't leave any of it. The dough was flavorful, crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. There was a ton of cheese! One of the best I ever had and it's made from scratch, so it takes about 20min of you just walk in. Absolutely worth it! Thanks Bob for a great experience! I know where I'm going for my pizza fix from now on!
(5)
Mike S.
Everything here is amazing. Garlic Knotts. Chicken Marsala, and the pizza is top notch. I am an east coast pizza snob and this pizza is LEGIT! !!! Come and try this place you won't be disappointed.
(5)
Mike D.
Maybe I'm a pizza snob.....been eating it for over 25 years now......thought I would try something new.....I have my five or so great places.......I get a pie once if not twice a week.....read some reviews on yelp, thought I would give this place a try.....made the mistake of not going to their website.....ordered off of yelp.....35 bones for a pizza and 6 wings and a couple of knots........so not worth it.....wings were dry.....the sausage on pizza looked liked chopped up hot dogs.....I'm not one to complain on food....but when I'm dropping almost 40 bills on a pizza and six wings I better have a great experience.....I'd take a little ceaser hot and ready any day over this.....I try and support local mom and pop shops....but when a pizza costs almost half a C note.....your not reaching out to your mom and pop customers
(1)
Andrew O.
Margherita pizza. Great crust, crunchy yet chewy. Sauce has a nice sweetness to it. They also do a frequent flyer type program as well.
(5)
Sara E.
$18 for a medium margarita pizza? This better blow my mind. Unfortunately, it was just "good". I would have given it 4 stars if it was appropriately priced.
(3)
Samantha G.
This was our first time at Brooklyn V's. We had the garlic knots, sausage, meatball, and pepperoni stromboli, and sausage and peppers hero. The stromboli was amazing! Other reviews have shown that is was more bread and small amount of meat, which was not the case! We will definately be back!
(5)
Bryan M.
Everything is fresh! I was first pleased at how good the ranch dressing was, light, not heavy. I ordered pizza, which was great, but immediately thought the baked ziti looked so good...I'll be back! The price is super for the quality and I'd recommend anyone that likes New York style pizza give this place a try.
(5)
David H.
Exceptional pizza- I especially enjoyed the margherita pizza. I added garlic to it, which ended up being a good choice. The garlic knots are great, and the desserts are homemade and really, really good. Had the cannoli and the tiramisu. Also, incredibly good, friendly service. :-)
(4)
John M.
This is a local mom & pop that you could easily mistake for a chain restaurant once you go inside. For now, its the one and only.:) It strikes an expertly crafted balance between the look of a fine dining establishment and a lounge, all while providing the comfort and ease of a fast casual restaurant. There are nice marble counters at the bar, where you can relax and order a beer or a glass of wine, and an outdoor patio with comfortable seating you could easily spend hours in. What's more, is that there is often live music on Saturdays, which is another plus, and their events makes it a great place for families, couples, and friends hanging out. In my opinion, you get more than what you pay for. They use authentic Sicilian recipes and make a mind blowing Antipasto salad. This is because of how particular they are here about the quality of their ingredients. Everyone that I have taken here has really enjoyed their food. I'm pretty sure you will too.
(5)
Christopher T.
Amazingly great food. Owner is super nice and friendly. Good prices and very clean inside and out. Taste flavor everything absolutely amazing. First time here found my new home for pizza definitely won't go anywhere else now. If your ever in Gilbert Arizona don't pass up this place without stopping in and grabbing something to eat. Thanks for the great food experience and service.
(5)
J P.
There are places that sell pizza and places that sell a pizza like substance (Pizza Hut, Domino's, etc). I would put Brooklyn V's in the category that sell pizza. Started off with the garlic knots. They were very good and the marinara sauce that was served with it was good also. Ordered the 14" white pizza and added pepperoni, onion and garlic. The crust on the pizza was light and crunchy...so that was a good thing. The pizza itself was a tad soupy but good never the less. As it turned out, after the garlic knots (small order) the pizza was more than enough for two with leftovers to go home. From a price perspective the price was a tad high when compared to a place that sells pizza like substance On the other hand it was competitive with places that sell pizza. So if price versus quality is an issue than a place that sells pizza like substance may be more in order.
(4)
Mark W.
Great lunch special. The sell slices. It's my go to pizza place now. Prices are good. Pizza is good. Service is good. What more do you want. So tired of chain delvery pizza. Good pizza with a mom and pop feal. Place gets packed at night. I recommend it. Kinda place makes you feal like a regular the first time your there. They also have a small patio.
(5)
Aysia D.
Service was a little slow. I like how family is involved. My pasta noodles were under cooked but it was still good.
(4)
Lauren H.
Absolutely love this place! Their Margherita pizza is to die for, as well as their bruschetta (you can taste the fresh basil!). You can't go wrong with their hot wings either. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. We tend to order delivery from here and have never been disappointed.
(5)
Leeda R.
The food is some of the best Italian food I've had! Great staff very friendly. Jenna waited on us and we loved her! My philly born and bread Italian husband said the food took him back home. I highly recommend this place
(5)
Tawnee S.
Service is great! We walked in got seated right away and ordered drinks. Very personal pizza hall. Pizza is delish..they have kick ass crust and I believe a homemade sausage that was mild and tastes yummy. Usually never order sausage and we've had it 3 times. Service was great, checked on us, filled drinks promply. Very enjoyable dinner on a tired Friday night.Ty
(5)
Ryan C.
May give it another shot for lunch, but will not be getting delivery again. Ordered through Grubhub, and it took almost 2 hours to arrive. Pizza was cold and tasted like Grocery store pizza. Meatballs were good. Wings were meh.
(2)
David P.
Really awesome pasta dishes, I love the fact they don't use sausage in every dish. Wished they had garlic bread as a side. Pizza is good, wife likes it a lot more than I do, probably wouldn't order it if not for her. Side salads are pricey but entrees will leave you enough for lunch the next day and are priced right. Nothing fancy , real casual but yummy.
(4)
Alma B.
I am not from New York, I have never been to New York. I have no expectations for pizza based on my old New York neighborhood or from childhood memories. Growing up in Mexico, pizza choices in the small town of Agua Prieta were somewhat limited to a couple of restaurants that served pies that had one thing in common to New York style pizza, the shape was round. Hungry last night, after a very stressful day at work, we wanted some food to be delivered to us. We wanted to be able to order it without hassle and we wanted it delivered fast. Demanding, I know. In this area ,Brooklyn V's Pizza delivered. I ordered it online, in a very easy to use website, they delivered it to my home and took about 45 minutes, which is a great time on a friday night. The pizza we ordered was the buffalo chicken pizza, not a very traditional pie, but I had been wanting to try it. The cost for an 18" pie was $20.00, a little on the expensive side. I was hoping for a delicious pizza, and I am not going to lie, the dough had very good flavor, but that was it. The chicken was extremely salty, to the point that we had to take it off the pizza, which wasn't a big task because there hardly was any chicken on the pizza to begin with, and the worst is the chicken was way too dry, and it hardly had any buffalo sauce in it. So I wasn't too pleased with this pie, but I am sure if I stick to a classic next time, they will do better in this department. We also ordered a cheese calzone with bacon and their garlic knots and those were the highlight of our meal. The calzone was filled with lots of cheese and bacon and tasted delicious. The garlic knots and the accompanying marinara sauce were so delicious we were fighting over them. I would definitely go back to Brooklyn V's pizza and probably eat in and order a more traditional pie or something else off the menu. For a pizza, a calzone and the order of knots I spent $45.00 including delivery and tip.
(3)
Sandra D.
Well, I have been enjoying eating at Brooklyn V's for over a year. Guess what? Nothing has changed except, they are busier, and rightly so. Great food, value and service draws people in. Their food is so consistently delicious! No greasy cheap ingredients here. The pizza ranges from $12.00-14.00 for a cheese. Combos are available between $15.00-$20.00 based on size and number of ingredients. Their wings are just outstanding. Big meaty bones. more baked than fried and so yummy. Ladies, enjoy a glass of wine. Good deals for white or red with no nasty after affects from those cheap wines so many places serve. Their standard is comparable to Kendall or the like. Oh, I almost forgot the perks, good entertainment with text notification and points towards free food. You should give them a try. You won't go home broke, hungry or disappointed, but you could leave with leftovers due to their generous portions. Good decision.
(5)
J F.
First off we had the garlic knots. They were SO DAMN GOOD. Perfect balance of crispy outside with soft gooey insides and not overly garlic'd. The sauce was made fresh in house and had great flavor. We ordered 12 - 6 would be enough for most people as they are larger than I expected them to be. None survived though :) Excellent pizza. Tried the margherita and was very impressed. The basil was super fresh, as were the tomatoes and it had clumps of gooey real mozzarella. The crust was perfect. If you like NY pizza this is the closest I've found it in AZ. The pepperoni was also very good. Not too greasy with nice flavor. Also, you can order by the slice and it still comes fresh so that was great for lunch. For dessert the Snickers pie was amazing. It was not too sweet which is often something I dislike in those types of pie. The owner, Vito, came over and chatted with us for a bit which was a nice touch and our server Nadine was super friendly and attentive. Dining room and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely be back to try other things off the menu. Hands down crushes Casanova Bros.
(5)
Randi S.
Yep we indeed came back for dinner. We had the v's 3 meat pizza. Best pizza I have ever had!!! Still wonderful service. Still relaxing and calming atmosphere. Definitely my favorite restaurant hands down!
(5)
Sean S.
FANTASTIC!!! This is a great little find. tucked in the corner, real mom/pop feel. The bread knots were a fun appetizer (amazingly priced) and my family enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. the red sauces were fantastic!! Vito himself even came out and chatted with us for a few. Nice atmosphere, great food, great price. You've got a customer here!!! We'll be back!!
(5)
Don S.
Great, friendly service and the pizza's very good. Definitely worth checking out.
(4)
Chuck M.
So far ????? It's been a wait for a pickup order --- longest minute ever and seems very disorganized at the cash register--- after 43 minutes still waiting. Wait staff did offer water while we waited but still waiting on that --- pick up order/service is horrendous
(3)
Jake A.
Just moved into neighborhood and been trying pizza and wings from places within delivery of my house. The delivery was fast and order was easy to place and pay for. Food was just ok. Nothing to get excited about. Little too expensive for just another pizza place. Will not be going back.
(2)
Nadine H.
Amazing food and quality service. The atmosphere is great and the service is phenomenal. The restaurant is fairly new (opened about a year ago) and the staff really makes you feel at home. I'm originally from New York myself, and I absolutely love Brooklyn V's, it makes me homesick in the best kind of way! I've tried all of their pizzas, a few of their dinners and all of their strombolis. The food is incredible. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to ANYONE! I recommend the garlic knots as an appetizer for all first time customers, not only are they a great price, but they are just unbeatable! 5 out of 5 stars, always.
(5)
Jim P.
When's the last time you encountered a wine list in a pizza joint? These guys love what they do and do it very well. Seriously fresh ingredients in their menu are prepared and served by a dedicated, friendly staff that know how to do good food. A family friendly atmosphere that is a pleasant step away from the typical chain store pizza place we so often settle for. Great food, good price , convenient location. My new favorite pizza restaurant in Arizona.
(4)
Nick R.
First the food is really good, the food alone is a 5 for me and the staff is very nice. The downsides are they had live music inside (not something I'm looking for in Italian restaurant) so we had to sit outside. The cheap Home Depot patio furniture made the situation awkward. All and all the downsides are an easy fix, and I will be going back.
(3)
Jennifer E.
This place is delicious! My favs are the pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and spaghetti with meat sauce! If You haven't tried Brooklyn V's, you're missing out!
(5)
RillaAnn J.
Been to Brooklyn V's several times since they've open, my complaint isn't the food... Last night my husband tried to order a pizza for take out. It was 845, they close at 9. The young female on the phone stated that they didn't want to make our pizza since they were closing... Wow. Great customer service. We normally aren't those ppl that order for right before close, but we are moving away from the area and that would have been our last time there. Thanks for the great memory.
(1)
Andrea D.
I stopped in here after getting my nails done. I wish I would have tried this place sooner. Not only was the customer service fantastic, the food is amazing! I got an anti-pasto salad, the ingredients are fresh and very flavorful.
(5)
Max K.
This restaurant is a very pleasant surprise to walk into. With it being kind of tucked in the corner of a shopping center that hasn't seemed to have much success, you would just be expecting a cheap pizza place that doesn't serve much more than average pizza and maybe some wings. Brooklyn V's offers a very pleasant, homey feel when you walk inside and the staff is very friendly. They are very grateful for your business and deliver a menu and quality of food that makes you want to come back for more. Within the last week or two I have already eaten here twice and nothing has yet to disappoint. Portions are extremely generous and the quality of food is something you would expect at a restaurant charging a steeper price. For my first visit, me and my girlfriend split a 12 or 14 inch pizza (can't remember the exact size, but not the largest size) and a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad had just the right amount of dressing and tasted about as good as a Caesar salad can get. It was also served on a chilled plate, which added a nice touch. The size of the salad was quite large and could probably feed at least 3 as an appetizer before the meal. The pizza came out a few minutes later and was quite delicious. A NY style pie that had the right amount of crispness to it, which is tough to come across. Most NY style pizzas are pretty flimsy, but Vito seems to have a great recipe. I am a stickler on Pizza and this easily satisfied me. About as good as I could expect out of a pizza that wasn't cooked in a wood fired brick oven. During my second visit I decided to venture out and try the Bow tie pasta with pesto sauce. I am not a huge pasta person but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and portion size once again. During this visit, we also decided to try Vito's cannolis and that was an EXCELLENT choice. The cannolis were superb and I have been craving them ever since. I would give Brooklyn V's a 4 1/2 star rating if that were possible on yelp. The only things I wish differently would be that the plates were maybe a dollar or two cheaper ($10 for a pasta plate, I think the salad was somewhere between $5.50-7 and then a 1-topping 12 or 14 inch pizza was $16) and I think the speed of service will improve with experience. Overall, Brooklyn V's provides a much higher quality of food and service than you would expect out of a place tucked back in the corner of a Goodwill shopping center, next to a smoke shop. I have encouraged others to try it and the one family that did was very happy, so I hope others enjoy it as well.
(5)
Henry D.
I accidently stumbled upon Brooklyn V's last night. I was headed to another pizza place to try for the first time but it was closed. I decided to get a slice and a salad. They get points for offering a slice right off the bat. 1. The crust was perfect, very true to the Brooklyn way. Flavorful. A+ 2. The sauce was very nice, I do like a little more sauce, but it was quality. A+ 3. Ingredients - Sausage- A. Roasted Pepper- A+. Eggplant- A. (It was very good, however it was tossed in tasty bread crumbs, but I do prefer the eggplant without the crumbs.) 4. Salad - I ordered a simple dinner salad with Ceasar dressing. Lettuce was a mix of greens and Romajne. Very crisp and fresh. Ceasar Dressing- A+ 5. Service- I can't comment too much as I was a carry out, but the young lady who took my order was very nice, I didn't ask, but she brought me a glass of water while I waited and that always gets points. She knew the menu well when I was deciding on my order and possible future orders. I will be back to dine in for sure.
(4)
Andrew D.
These guys get five stars from me not just because owner is from newyork like myself but the pizza is the best in Arizona. I have found so far especially the buffalo chicken pizza. Great job guys keep it up!
(5)
Kristen P.
Phenom eats, seriously! The service is amazing, our favorite server is Anna. She's always there to greet us with a big, family-sized smile and makes sure that everyone is receiving equal care (never sits on her rump, just making sure that everyone is getting the best service!) The food, now THERE is something to BRAG about! My favorite thing to eat so far is the White Eggplant Pizza. This gastronomical concept is so far out of my comfort zone, I didn't know if I was married to an Italian long enough, Glory Be! 13 Years and I was eating eggplant like a pro!. I'm here to tell you it is THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD! We're attempting to hit everything on the menu, so far we've dabbled with Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parmesan, Lasagna, Bruschetta, Baked Ziti, Stuffed Shells, and meatballs and every single thing has been extraordinary in flavor and quality! We have never been disappointed. Try this place, your taste buds will thank you! Oh and don't forget to sign up for the loyalty program, those points add up QUICKLY! Ignore those people that have left unsavory comments. Look at those accounts, one of them ONLY seems to YELP negative reviews and use foul language, really? Do you trust that kind of poppycock, I don't, I let the Cannoli cream talk for themselves?)
(5)
Jay J.
Great pizza and great place to bring a group Came here after church had 2 14" pizzas the 3 v's meat pizza and a all cheese Bianca pizza both were great we also had some garlic knots for starters very cheap and very good Loved the setting and the staff, nice open kitchen so you can watch your pizza an food being made The Owner coming and welcoming us and checking on our food was a nice touch too Will definitely be coming back
(5)
Cat K.
We moved from NYC 3.5 years ago and could not find authentic pizza, not to mention cannolis. I found Brooklyn Vs on here (yelp) and due to the great reviews decided to try.... YUM YUM YUM. We had the white eggplant pizza, margherita pizza and garlic knots ALL DELICIOUS. As we were getting ready to leave Vito the owner came over and said hello. We told him we could not find good cannolis anywhere, even though we had paid our bill he brought us a few cannolis for us to try... How thoughtful! We will definitely be back to try other things on the menu
(5)
Janelle R.
Love this place. I've been three times, once for pizza, then penne in vodka sauce, and most recently spaghetti with meat sauce. Absolutely everything is made fresh and I can taste every bit of it! The sauces are fantastic. Next time I'm trying the pesto. I don't even like pesto, but that's how much I enjoy the food here. The service is great too. Very friendly and warm staff. Feels like home.
(5)
Robert J.
First time ordering. We had a pizza (half V's 3 meat/half bianco) wings and garlic knots and everything was really good. We will order again for sure!
(5)
Sara S.
All I can can say is wow! This is my first time ordering from here and I ordered via grubhub and after reading reviews on yelp I thought my food would be ridiculously late. Turns out it was 20 minutes early! I ordered the stuffed shells, caprese salad and 2 meatballs. It came with 4 stuffed shells which in and of itself a hearty meal. The caprese salad was not terrible but would have liked to seen riper tomatoes and a tad more salt. The meatballs tasted like they had worshester sauce which is totally not necessary but the sauce they were in was yummy. Back to the shells, everything about it was great! My food arrived piping hot and early! Also their mix of Dr Pepper was on point tonight! I will definitely be ordering from here again!
(5)
Shanna G.
Yummy yummy so yummy I love this place. Being from New York, I'm a total pizza snob. I just happened on this place when I was getting my nails done one day and it blew my mind. Reminds me of home. I want to try other menu items but the pizza is just too good to not eat.
(5)
Matt B.
There have been a few pizza places in this suite over the years, I tried them all but never went back after trying them out once or twice (and I live pretty much right across the street). Love the food here, owners and servers are very nice and bend over backwards to give you what you want. I've brought friends here and they've enjoyed the food and atmosphere as well!!!
(5)
Darius L.
Very Tasty. Way way better than Casa Nova Brothers!!!! Yuk. Guys Keep up the good work. I'll keep coming back if you stay consistent. A little tucked back had to drive around to find you, but pleased I didn't give up the search. If you guys are from New York bring more of that NY goodness out here. Very Very good.!!!!
(4)
Sara O.
We LOVE Brooklyn V's. We come here at least once a week. The food is amazing and the service is great. They have added some new girls so be patient, the food is worth the wait anyway. We pretty much have the menu memorized and I haven't eaten anything I haven't liked yet. They are also apart of a great rewards program where you can build up points and earn free food!
(5)
Kelly G.
Just stumbled upon this place and so happy I did! The pizza was delicious! The atmosphere was family friendly and the place was very clean. I look forward to trying more things on the menu!
(4)
Kristine R.
Delicious! We moved from NYC 2 1/2 years ago and have been to many pizzerias where we have been told it's just like NY pizza and each have fallen short. My husband found this place on Yelp and OMG this is it. Cheese pizza reminds us of back home. We went back today with his brother and family and we ate and ate and ate. Cheese pizza, V3 pizza, eggplant pizza and the bianco pizza--- yum yum yum! The mini zeppolis and cannolis are delish. We are definitely going back to try the calzones and pasta dishes. It's a 20 min drive from home and so worth it.
(5)
Heidi H.
Best eggplant Parmesan by far! We've tried the gambit of eggplant parm at other Italian restaurants here in the valley and nothing compares to Brooklyn Vs!!
(4)
Thomas G.
The garlic knots are to die for and the eggplant pizza is freaking amazing. The owners Bob and Vito go out of their way to make you feel welcome and these guys do a ton of fundraisers to give back to their local community.
(5)
Julie F.
Not a bad place to get take out from. If you are looking for real NY pizza and pasta this is the place for you!
(3)
Marissa D.
Absolutely delicious. I couldn't stop eating! I was so full yet it was just so good. Found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try. We are pretty faithful to our regular pizza place but I am so glad we tried this place. My husband and I ordered the stuffed shells and a pepperoni pizza to share. The stuffed shells were definitely some of the best I've ever had! Everything about the food was good. We ordered over Yelp and picked it up with no problems. Definitely will be coming back often.
(5)
Kelly V.
This place is incredible - GREAT food, great service - we will definitely be back!
(5)
Steve B.
Got takeout on Saturday Night (9/27). It was our first time ordering from them, so we decided to order a cheese pizza. In my opinion, the true litmus test for any pizza is getting the pizza in it 's purest form, plain cheese. Well, Brooklyn V's passed this test with flying colors. The sauce had great flavor and the crust had the right amount of crispness and chewiness. We strive to support only locally owned restaurants, not chains. I love that this place is 2 minutes from our house. We'll be back!
(5)
Nawaf H.
Seriously!!! I mean this place got 4.5 stars ! Worst pizza i ever tried , nothing special at all , i ordered for home delivery and got my order after 75 minutes cold , the the pizza tastes horrible . First time and never again
(1)
Wilfredo A.
Great service, great pizza, but excellent pasta. It's a weekly tradition for me and my family to grab a meal from here whether it's to go or dinning in. Please don't pass on the knots, spaghetti, baked ziti, wings, or the old classic pepperoni pizza. For those who like a different ambiance make a trip out on Friday or Saturday night. Live music!!! Need I say more???
(5)
Cody M.
Our party of 4 ordered the chicken fettuccine alfredo, spaghetti with meat sauce along with a large pizza. Everything was great. I get fettuccine just about everywhere I go and theirs was some of the best. Pizza had a great thin and crispy crust. Great stuff.
(5)
Steve C.
New York style thin crust....not even close!! They claim if it's under a 1/2 inch, that's New York style thin crust. And it's chewy! It should be a 1/4 inch and crispy....nice try guys, but no thanks. The sauce is too sweet, I think they are trying to cover up the lack of knowledge on how to make a New York style thin crust.
(1)
Cory D.
Tale of two restaurants. Last week we ordered from Brooklyn V 's and it was fantastic all around, we ordered in the afternoon. Tonight we ordered and it was completely opposite so greesy we could not even finish it, we also ordered wings and they were less then average too. Super disappointed especially after our first experience. Way over priced for the quality and lack of attention to detail.
(2)
Noelle K.
OMG! THIS IS THE PLACE for an authentic NY Italian meal!!!! My man decided on a whim that I was going to try a new place after he had tried it for lunch. He said he couldn't wait to take me to Brooklyn V's. I am a very picky eater and I am not a fan of chains so I was really happy to support a small business that really knows its business! We started with these little bread things they call garlic knots that come with marinara YUM! This was starting out fantastic. You can tell a lot from the marinara, ya know ;) We each ordered a Stromboli and they were to die for! I could have cut it lengthwise and just crawled in, they do kinda look like sleeping bags. You know when you taste something so good the world just kinda stops spinning? Yeah......Oh sorry! We took a tiramisu home to split for later. The waitress said it was heaven in a box. I haven't had too much luck with tiramisu here in AZ so I wasn't too excited. A couple hours later her words were still echoing in my head and I just had to taste it. Fireworks shot off! The band started playing and suddenly I was in Italy! Reluctantly I put the other half (well almost half, he he) back in the fridge for my man. The liquor license is coming folks!
(5)
Danny A.
This is the real deal.Born and raised ny'er here and this is as good as it gets in the east valley.Now if they sold slices over the counter without the wait service,and Sicilian pies,it'd be like I was back home.Forget Casanova,they would be closed down in 6 months if they were back east.No comparison.
(5)
Jim W.
A very Friendly staff. Everything tasted scratch made. From the Fresh cut romaine, cherry tomatoes, the touch of black olive slices and a bit of red onion in the house salad, to the DELICIOUS chicken fettuccine Alfredo. I've never had so much tasty Alfredo sauce in one bowl of fresh made pasta. The bread that came with the meal was melt in your mouth, just out of the oven, fresh baked too. This cozy family place is one you should try.
(5)
Kimberly C.
Visited last night for dinner with friends. Our party of 4 split a large 18" pepperoni pizza and an order of 12 garlic knots. The food was EXCELLENT! I think the dough/crust MAKES the pizza and Brooklyn V's has it down pat. This space has been occupied by a few pizza joints since I've lived in the area and I've never been too impressed - but I'll definitely be back to Brooklyn V's. Other +'s: *Cannoli's - Very good! *Iced Tea - Fresh! *Friendly staff *Nice family/owners that took the time to say hello and welcome us to their establishment.
(5)
Reco J.
Let me tell you something and you would be wise to listen!! Since I moved to AZ I have searched for real good back east Italian food that did not require me to drive and sit down at a table. Brooklyn V's is a Blessing, I love there eggplant, and pizza and OMG! The cannoli is straight off the boat. Plus I can order online and it gets to my house in less than 20 mins and hot. Thank you for being you! Reco
(5)
Kaitlyn S.
I arrived at this establishment on a Friday around 7:30pm. Overall I was pretty impressed with the food, in which me and a group had ordered a large white pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was excellent and is comparable to somewhere such as Gilbert Pizza. However, the down side to this restaurant is the service. Every time I have made a visit here I have waited quite a bit of time to receive r any service. Expect to wait and plan your time accordingly, inside is a little cramped but this place makes you feel at home.
(3)
David F.
Great food, staff and atmosphere! We had our local lunch club here and it was great! I would recommend everyone to try the ziti as well as the pizza!
(5)
Christina L.
Great food, great customer service. We are from NY and really are thrilled to have amazing pizza and cannoli in Gilbert! Will be back again for sure.
(5)
Darlene c.
Can't eat pizza anywhere else now !!! Close my eyes and feel like in Brooklyn eating Bay Pizza by train in Sheepshead Bay.. and their sauce is delicious. ...and they leave the the bubbled pockets of dough and don't pop them like other places!! Cannoli's perfectly sweet, garlic knots w/fresh chopped garlic perfectly crisp on outside and yummy on inside!! This is my only place for Italian food now.. and owner is friendly as is waitstaff.. Enjoy the food every time I come here, it is worth the trip no matter how far..
(5)
Kelly G.
I like to say that this is a hidden gem in Gilbert. I dont usually like Italian food but this was authentic and home grown. It was the best experience I have had and it was so cute and quaint. I could take my kids and they enjoyed it also. The owner is really friendly and good people.
(5)
Joe A.
Very friendly restaurant, fast service and the food was absolutely fantastic. Had an ice cold beer to start, pizza was totally East coast and the ricotta shells with meat sauce. Bob served, Vito prepared and I wouldn't have known that if they weren't so friendly. I will be back!!
(5)
Ray N.
Love this place. Love their food.As authentic to NY Italian as it gets here in Az. Very nice, cozy atmosphere with great service from our waitress Allora. We were a party of 12 last night and everyone was raving about their dishes. The cheese pizza here is superb : perfect crust, great sauce and just the right mix of cheese. Eggplant parm was the best I have had in years and their calzones are amazing. Cooked just right and everything blended well. My experience in Az with other restaurants trying to make Calzones has been so so with most just throwing the stuff in hoping it gels. The owner Vito has been doing this for 30 years and certainly brings that and more to this awesome place. My new favorite place in Gilbert.
(5)
Gordon G.
We had Spaghetti and Meat Sauce and Zita. The Meat Sauce was one of the best we ever had. The music was "Sinatra/Martin" and it felt like we belonged. Great place to eat, food was excellent.
(5)
Andy L.
Placed a rather simple pick up order-small pepperoni pizza. I was not told a price on the phone, I figured it would be in the 10 dollar range. Lesson learned, never assume anything! When i got there, I paid over 15$, which, I'm sorry is EXCESSIVE! They need to sprinkle gold or something on there to make it worth the money at that price. Either way, I paid since I did order it and figured if it was a really good pizza it was worth it. Needless to say I was further disappointed when I got home and started eating it-now, I don't have extremely high standards when it comes to pizza-I love dominos, pizza hut, you name it-but the sauce was bland and had no taste to it. I lived in Boston for many years and have visited NYC many times; believe me when I tell you, this place has nothing, and I mean NOTHING in common with NY pizza. I was disappointed and won't be back.
(1)
Mike K.
We ordered 2 stromboli's, thinking we were getting NY style stromboli's, but what we got were 2 loaves of bread with a little bit of filling. For starters, ANY time I've ever ordered a stromboli, much less 2 of them, it has had to come out in a pizza box due to the size of them. But when 2 of them came out together fitting on ONE paper plate, I was already highly disappointed considering the $22 price tag. Once getting home and beginning to slice them up, the first 2 inches of the end was all bread, and as we started getting in through the rest of it, the crust of it was so think and breadlike, there was no room for filling. I've attached some photos to showcase the size and filling. Past all that, taste was only... ehh. The Eggplant parm stromboli was very bland and sausage and meatball stromboli was mediocre at best. I never leave bad feedback on these kinds of sites, but this one we felt needed to be addressed. Just know what you're getting when you order a "stromboli" there.
(1)
Tami C.
Being from the East Coast, it is hard to find an authentic New York pizza in AZ. Brooklyn V's is FANTASTIC!!!! Takes me back home.... The crust is fantastic with just the right amount of cheese. We've been here several times but haven't ordered anything other than pizza yet. Based on the other reviews, trying the Stromboli next. Check this place out, you won't be sorry!
(5)
Kristin H.
I got the lunch special, 2 slices and a soda for $5.75. I think it's a great deal and the pizza was delicious. I'm picky when it comes to my pizza crust and they didn't burn it which was great. Sometimes places that have thinner crust blacken their pizza before it comes to the table but it arrived hot and the perfect crispiness. This place is tucked away in a strip mall, but it doesn't take away from the great prices and good food.
(4)
Dan A.
Just tried Brooklyn's based on Yelp reviews. Pizza is outstanding. Will definitely be back. Upon entering this place you can tell right away this is a family run establishment. Very genuinely friendly staff. I noticed the other patrons and there were smiles at every table. Next time, I'm going for the sausage and peppers hero. It looks amazingly delicious.
(4)
Emily B.
We had some amazingly fresh bruschetta here as well as some very richly flavored lasagna, garlic knots and cannolis. We had excellent service and our server was very attentive. Additionally she and the other staff were so passionate about their food and the restaurant that it was contagious. We were truly blown away by this place! The food beat out some of the street crap I had in Rome over the summer!
(5)
Annette A.
Finally found REAL NY style pizza in the East Valley! The pizza Margherita and Eggplant parmesan Hero were delicious! The owners were very friendly and made us feel very welcome. New Yorkers you gotta come here!
(5)
Mike S.
I tried this place today, and I was impressed. I had the 2 pizza slice & drink lunch special. The margherita pizza was fantastic. The crust was thin & crispy, which I usually don't like because other pizzerias either make it too hard or too limp. This crust was incredible. They also have delivery service. I will not order chain pizza again.
(4)
Hanna F.
Well, once again I tried it for chance. Still the rude son of a bitch New Yorkers with extremely high prices for the shit they serve. Let me tell you, GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT.
(1)
Julie S.
So good!!! Real east coast Italiano!!! Some favorites - eggplant parm - very authentic, thinly sliced!! Ask for Desiree - awesome waitress with good recommendations.
(5)
Anne J.
A most go to place!!! You can taste the freshness, you can tell they make the dough daily. Amazing
(5)
Maria N.
Went to Brooklyn V's last night for dinner for the first time with my family. I was intrigued because they were from Staten Island so I figured they knew good pizza. It is hard to find a good "pie" out in AZ. The restaurant did not disappoint. We had the Margherita and the White Eggplant Pizza's. They we amazing. The dough was light and thin. The sauce was perfect. Not to thick and acidic. The eggplant pizza is a must. I can't wait to go back again and try the dinner selections. The staff was so friendly. It actually felt like a "family". Highly recommended. They deliver and cater also!
(5)
Sue L.
Very good pizza, delivered on time! I ordered garlic knots because of someone else's recommendation. The dipping sauce is excellent. The knots need more garlic.
(4)
Rachael W.
Pizza was average for New York style. Delivery was pretty quick but the pizza was cold and way over-priced. 25 dollars for one pizza is a little ridiculous.
(3)
Vanessa J.
my husband and I visited here as a recommendation from our neighbor. Had the pizza the first time it was excellent. Took the family there for a second trip had the Stromboli and the shells. Food and service was again excellent. Waitress even gave our granddaughter her own special treat. Will definitely visit again
(4)
Julie B.
Brooklyn V's opened 3 weeks ago and is having typical start-up issues with a new young staff. But, that's the only area that needs improvement! I wanted to try Brooklyn V's because as I was sitting at the stop light at Lindsey and Warner - the most wonderful pizza aroma drifted across the intersection. I told my husband, based on the aroma alone we needed to try this place. The FOOD IS WONDERFUL and definitely lived up to the tantalizing aroma! We ordered house salads and the Sausage and Pepper Stromboli. We didn't receive the Stromboli we ordered, however we kept the dish brought because the crust was so crispy and light, the cheese was perfectly stringy and gooey, and the combination of meats inside tender and tasty. Paired with their marinara sauce, we couldn't send it back - it was that good! One of the owners stopped by to check on our dinner. When we let her know what happened, she "comped" us Cannolis for dessert. The plate was chilled and the presentation was something I would have expected from a more upper end restaurant. We are so glad to have Brooklyn V's in our neighborhood and within walking distance! We'll be returning again and again to try the other items on the menu - which we expect will be equally flavorful.
(4)
Joyce S.
Very low key, but nice server, great food (huge portions) and just satisfied my pasta craving. Only wish they had beer.......
(3)
Robert G.
I've eaten their food three times. Two times I've eaten there and once had a pizza delivered. What was funny is the guy taking my pizza order told me the price and stopped talking. I was waiting for him to ask me my cc info. I think he thought I was balking at the price because he told me, "You realize our pizzas are not the $5 kind?" I laughed and said I don't eat $5 pizzas! He got a kick out of that and the pie was delivered warm and tasty! I was a bachelor that weekend and the large lasted me both Saturday and Sunday. Nothing like pizza for breakfast baby! Both times I visited there the food was really good. The first time I had the chicken Marsala and loved it. The second time I had the lasagne with meat sauce and my wife had the chicken cacciatore. She ate everything on her plate and loved it. I got full on half of the lasagne and had the other half for lunch the next day. Both times the lasagne was delicious. We live close by so we'll be going back again for sure. My wife and I aren't really into hearing cover music when we eat, we like to talk. The only thing I haven't appreciated about the place was the Elvis impersonator singing when we went on a Saturday night. Good singer but everything he sang was in the Elvis style...George Straight in an Elvis style...not for me thank you. Of course I did tip the gentleman because he has talent. We are looking forward to the weather cooling so we can sit either inside or out, where ever the singer is not.
(5)
Amanda A.
I am originally from NYC and moved to Arizona close to 2 years ago. I found out about this place from a random New Yorker I met. To say the least, this place is amazing. I go to Brooklyn V's all the time. I feel a price of home and nostalgia when I walk in. I spent about a year and a half trying to find good NY pizza and did not find it, until I went to Brooklyn V's. I won't eat any other pizza, except for theirs. Not only do they have great pizza, they offer amazing pasta dishes, desserts, and their staff is the greatest. I will always be a New Yorker and their food makes me miss/appreciate the NY style of food.
(5)
Mark L.
We celebrated my daughter's first birthday here last night and could not have been more impressed. My wife reserved a table for our party and the staff was not only accommodating, but went above and beyond by decorating our table with balloons, birthday napkins and even had a special candle for the cake. The food was phenomenal. My party tried garlic knots, spaghetti and pizza. Everything tasted delicious and the pizza was excellent. Cheese, sauce, garlic, pepperoni, spinach and dough all came together perfectly. Beer and wine were very reasonably priced and the live music completed the night. The staff was very attentive to our needs and I cannot say enough about how welcomed they made all of us feel. This is a family owned business that shows tremendous pride in quality and preparation of food and care for their patrons. A big thank you to the entire staff at Brooklyn V's for making my daughter's first birthday one that we will never forget.
(5)
Danielle C.
Great service!! Great food!! It's been difficult finding Stromboli in Arizona but Brooklyn V's do it and they do it right!!! I had the Stromboli with sausage, pepperoni and meatballs! They did not skimp out on meat or cheese!!! It was oozing cheese!!! So delicious!! We will be back to try the pizzas and pastas which all look amazing! Everyone was super friendly and made us feel welcome. I even saw the owner come out and shake hands with patrons. This is why it's so important to support local businesses especially when they are as worthy as this one!!! Can't wait to go back!!
(5)
Tom A.
Great people and food . Everything we tried is good. We happen to like the white pizza.
(5)
Lori E.
I am from ny and i have to say this place has the best pizza and calzones I havent had anything elst tho
(5)
Donna B.
This place has quickly become my favorite local joint to get food! I love the food and the chance to get out of my house and sit down somewhere else with TV, a drink, and Italian food. My favorite dishes are the Chicken Marsala and the chicken and mozzarella (add mushrooms) calzone. The garlic knot appetizers are addictive! They come with a side of homemade marinara and are to die for. The bruschetta is pretty good. The chicken parm here is also very well done. Though I haven't tried it yet, their pizza seems to be very popular. The service is usually pretty good. Anna is the best!! Also, they deliver!! They have TVs, booths, tables, and outside seating. The tables in the middle can accommodate small groups.
(5)
April G.
We ordered and picked up our food. The phone was picked up promptly and the lady that was taking the order was very nice and informative. We ordered the Bianco pizza, stuffed shells and cannolis. Our order was ready in 20min. The lady at the counter was very friendly and quick to grab our food. The food was about $30 which isn't to bad. The pizza was awesome! It has fresh ingredients and the mozzarella was soooo good!!! The stuffed shells were seasoned wonderfully with some really tasty marinara. Lastly the cannolis tasted like my grandmothers which is saying a lot in a great way. :) They had chocolate chips with a slightly sweet ricotta filling. Other places tend to make these to sweet which ruins them. You have to have the right balance of sweetness, crunch and creaminess from the ricotta. Soooo this place gets a thumbs up!! Yum!
(5)
Robert G.
Went there first time with my sons and the pizza is outstanding! The only issue is we did not feel welcome, the service is excellent but the manager that day made visits to the other tables except ours, that i think is Not good buisness or good management! What am i? Chopped liver Lost my business and was planning to my it my regular pizza place,NOT NOW!
(3)
kim s.
Had spaghetti meatballs and vodka penne comparable to las Vegas quality pastas five stars!
(5)
Don S.
Great, friendly service and the pizza's very good. Definitely worth checking out.
I was really excited walking in and hearing all the accents and such, but if this is New York pizza, I'd rather stick with Arizona. Pizza was not terrible, but the sauce was way too watery. Everything slid off of our pizza. They also seemed to be big on the oil as well. Both the pizza and knots had excessive amounts of oil. The service was great and the staff was friendly, which is why I say 3 stars. Would I return? No. Not with all the great choices in the area. $28 for a med pizza, knots, and drink.
(3)
Mark B.
First of all, when you're here, you're family. The hospitality here is unparalleled. When time permits, Vito, the owner, and the crew will be sure to stop by, introduce themselves and drop a friendly hello. It's so nice to come to such a wonderful Italian restaurant and have authentic cuisine. Vito definitely takes pride in his work and the staff delivers. When you come, request Desiree and tell her Mark and Cristina recommended her. Enjoy the amazing food and ambiance. Support your local Italianos and enjoy what Vito and his staff is proud to serve you! Till next time, ciao!
(5)
BARRY B.
You search for a real New York pizza, especially if you come from Brooklyn. This place comes thisclose. Vito has the "touch". The pizza is delicious. Their marinara is wonderful and the garlic knots are like Brooklyn's best. It was also amazing that there were a lot of N.Y. ex-pats the evening we were there.
(4)
Alia K.
Wanted to try a new place for lunch and found a gem. Not only did I have a great experience, but the food was amazing too. Bob and Desiree are the sweetest people and helped me custom my lunch order. A very pleasant and clean environment. I'll definitely be coming back.
(5)
Harvey S.
A friend wanted to try this place, being that it's local and they have a doo-wap group performing...at least this Saturday. We had brushetta and garlic knots for the table. The brushetta had plenty of fresh tomatoes and basil, among other things. The garlic knots had minced garlic butter...more flavorful than garlic butter with powder. The margherita pizza was very flavorful...it had chopped tomatoes and a crust crispy and NY-style...thinner, but not too thin. And the musical group was really fun, but does not allow for good conversation if you're sitting nearby. The waitstaff was good natured and stopped by enough to check up on us, refill drinks, despite being a busy night. Recommended.
(4)
Val M.
I looooove this place. Food is always delicious, service is great, and always very quick/reliable with delivery. Highly recommended!
(5)
Travis L.
Great chicken parm. tonight, they forgot my side Caesar though. I gave five stars on my first review.
(3)
MikeNikki G.
Great food and great service. Kid friendly, but food is grown-up worthy. We will definitely be back.
(5)
Tyler S.
Was enjoying a night of swimming in the 100+ degree weather and wanted something good, quick and delivered to our door. Brooklyn V's fit the bill! Food was delivered under the estimated time and was piping hot. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, chicken stromboli and honey bbq wings and all were amazing! Will definitely order again.
(5)
Tamara R.
Really glad I read the reviews on the buffalo chicken pizza and ordered it because that was delicious! Two pizzas and a 6 piece garlic knots was really quite expensive to have delivered though. Otherwise I'd give it a full 5. Really tasty food though!
(4)
Becky C.
I am astounded at the quality of this "hole in the wall" find. Between a smoke shop and a cleaners, Brooklyn V's has blown me away. Pizza shop? No, this is a Brooklyn restaurant in the heart of Mesa, AZ. I had spaghetti in clam sauce. Where do I begin? The pasta was al dente. That's the first step to proving you care a bit about your food. Next is tender clams, a TON of them, in a perfect sauce, mild with a hint of wine and garlic, sprinkled with parm and served with crusty Italian bread, baked locally and only sold to a choice few restaurants. It absorbs the sauce perfectly, melting in the buttery, garlicky goodness. There are only a few beers on tap. I had the Shock Rock Belgian White, a perfect compliment to the light sauce and simple meal. I was sent here by a local, the guy at Stamps Automotive, while they work on my car. I cannot thank him enough.
(5)
Scott C.
Amazing food - Amazing owners and staff! Atmosphere is "Cheers" like. If you are considering trying but unsure - have no fear - You will not be disappointed!!
(5)
Nick B.
First timer and not bad def worth trying. Tried the eggplant and pizza very delicious...
(5)
Brandon B.
The service here is phenomenal. The entire staff makes you feel like you're a part of their family. I recommend you make your way here. I've been 5 times in the last 2 weeks. thank you for providing the best service in the Gilbert area. Furthermore the Pizza is AMAZING!!! You can't find pizza this good unless you're in Brooklyn!
(5)
Dan A.
Wow! I popped in for lunch on a Tuesday and was kindly greeted by Bob, one of the owners. I sat down for lunch and thought I'd give their pizza and Stromboli a try. The pizza was good. I'm from NJ, and I was very impressed. It's on par with some of the other NY style pizza places in Gilbert. The Stromboli, though... Out of this world. I saw how big it was and I figured I'd get through half after a slice of pizza, but I couldn't leave any of it. The dough was flavorful, crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. There was a ton of cheese! One of the best I ever had and it's made from scratch, so it takes about 20min of you just walk in. Absolutely worth it! Thanks Bob for a great experience! I know where I'm going for my pizza fix from now on!
(5)
Mike S.
Everything here is amazing. Garlic Knotts. Chicken Marsala, and the pizza is top notch. I am an east coast pizza snob and this pizza is LEGIT! !!! Come and try this place you won't be disappointed.
(5)
Mike D.
Maybe I'm a pizza snob.....been eating it for over 25 years now......thought I would try something new.....I have my five or so great places.......I get a pie once if not twice a week.....read some reviews on yelp, thought I would give this place a try.....made the mistake of not going to their website.....ordered off of yelp.....35 bones for a pizza and 6 wings and a couple of knots........so not worth it.....wings were dry.....the sausage on pizza looked liked chopped up hot dogs.....I'm not one to complain on food....but when I'm dropping almost 40 bills on a pizza and six wings I better have a great experience.....I'd take a little ceaser hot and ready any day over this.....I try and support local mom and pop shops....but when a pizza costs almost half a C note.....your not reaching out to your mom and pop customers
(1)
Andrew O.
Margherita pizza. Great crust, crunchy yet chewy. Sauce has a nice sweetness to it. They also do a frequent flyer type program as well.
(5)
Sara E.
$18 for a medium margarita pizza? This better blow my mind. Unfortunately, it was just "good". I would have given it 4 stars if it was appropriately priced.
(3)
Samantha G.
This was our first time at Brooklyn V's. We had the garlic knots, sausage, meatball, and pepperoni stromboli, and sausage and peppers hero. The stromboli was amazing! Other reviews have shown that is was more bread and small amount of meat, which was not the case! We will definately be back!
(5)
John M.
This is a local mom & pop that you could easily mistake for a chain restaurant once you go inside. For now, its the one and only.:) It strikes an expertly crafted balance between the look of a fine dining establishment and a lounge, all while providing the comfort and ease of a fast casual restaurant. There are nice marble counters at the bar, where you can relax and order a beer or a glass of wine, and an outdoor patio with comfortable seating you could easily spend hours in. What's more, is that there is often live music on Saturdays, which is another plus, and their events makes it a great place for families, couples, and friends hanging out. In my opinion, you get more than what you pay for. They use authentic Sicilian recipes and make a mind blowing Antipasto salad. This is because of how particular they are here about the quality of their ingredients. Everyone that I have taken here has really enjoyed their food. I'm pretty sure you will too.
(5)
Christopher T.
Amazingly great food. Owner is super nice and friendly. Good prices and very clean inside and out. Taste flavor everything absolutely amazing. First time here found my new home for pizza definitely won't go anywhere else now. If your ever in Gilbert Arizona don't pass up this place without stopping in and grabbing something to eat. Thanks for the great food experience and service.
(5)
J P.
There are places that sell pizza and places that sell a pizza like substance (Pizza Hut, Domino's, etc). I would put Brooklyn V's in the category that sell pizza. Started off with the garlic knots. They were very good and the marinara sauce that was served with it was good also. Ordered the 14" white pizza and added pepperoni, onion and garlic. The crust on the pizza was light and crunchy...so that was a good thing. The pizza itself was a tad soupy but good never the less. As it turned out, after the garlic knots (small order) the pizza was more than enough for two with leftovers to go home. From a price perspective the price was a tad high when compared to a place that sells pizza like substance On the other hand it was competitive with places that sell pizza. So if price versus quality is an issue than a place that sells pizza like substance may be more in order.
(4)
Mark W.
Great lunch special. The sell slices. It's my go to pizza place now. Prices are good. Pizza is good. Service is good. What more do you want. So tired of chain delvery pizza. Good pizza with a mom and pop feal. Place gets packed at night. I recommend it. Kinda place makes you feal like a regular the first time your there. They also have a small patio.
(5)
Aysia D.
Service was a little slow. I like how family is involved. My pasta noodles were under cooked but it was still good.
(4)
Bryan M.
Everything is fresh! I was first pleased at how good the ranch dressing was, light, not heavy. I ordered pizza, which was great, but immediately thought the baked ziti looked so good...I'll be back! The price is super for the quality and I'd recommend anyone that likes New York style pizza give this place a try.
(5)
Lauren H.
Absolutely love this place! Their Margherita pizza is to die for, as well as their bruschetta (you can taste the fresh basil!). You can't go wrong with their hot wings either. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. We tend to order delivery from here and have never been disappointed.
(5)
David H.
Exceptional pizza- I especially enjoyed the margherita pizza. I added garlic to it, which ended up being a good choice. The garlic knots are great, and the desserts are homemade and really, really good. Had the cannoli and the tiramisu. Also, incredibly good, friendly service. :-)
(4)
Leeda R.
The food is some of the best Italian food I've had! Great staff very friendly. Jenna waited on us and we loved her! My philly born and bread Italian husband said the food took him back home. I highly recommend this place
(5)
Tawnee S.
Service is great! We walked in got seated right away and ordered drinks. Very personal pizza hall. Pizza is delish..they have kick ass crust and I believe a homemade sausage that was mild and tastes yummy. Usually never order sausage and we've had it 3 times. Service was great, checked on us, filled drinks promply. Very enjoyable dinner on a tired Friday night.Ty
(5)
David P.
Really awesome pasta dishes, I love the fact they don't use sausage in every dish. Wished they had garlic bread as a side. Pizza is good, wife likes it a lot more than I do, probably wouldn't order it if not for her. Side salads are pricey but entrees will leave you enough for lunch the next day and are priced right. Nothing fancy , real casual but yummy.
(4)
Ryan C.
May give it another shot for lunch, but will not be getting delivery again. Ordered through Grubhub, and it took almost 2 hours to arrive. Pizza was cold and tasted like Grocery store pizza. Meatballs were good. Wings were meh.
(2)
Alma B.
I am not from New York, I have never been to New York. I have no expectations for pizza based on my old New York neighborhood or from childhood memories. Growing up in Mexico, pizza choices in the small town of Agua Prieta were somewhat limited to a couple of restaurants that served pies that had one thing in common to New York style pizza, the shape was round. Hungry last night, after a very stressful day at work, we wanted some food to be delivered to us. We wanted to be able to order it without hassle and we wanted it delivered fast. Demanding, I know. In this area ,Brooklyn V's Pizza delivered. I ordered it online, in a very easy to use website, they delivered it to my home and took about 45 minutes, which is a great time on a friday night. The pizza we ordered was the buffalo chicken pizza, not a very traditional pie, but I had been wanting to try it. The cost for an 18" pie was $20.00, a little on the expensive side. I was hoping for a delicious pizza, and I am not going to lie, the dough had very good flavor, but that was it. The chicken was extremely salty, to the point that we had to take it off the pizza, which wasn't a big task because there hardly was any chicken on the pizza to begin with, and the worst is the chicken was way too dry, and it hardly had any buffalo sauce in it. So I wasn't too pleased with this pie, but I am sure if I stick to a classic next time, they will do better in this department. We also ordered a cheese calzone with bacon and their garlic knots and those were the highlight of our meal. The calzone was filled with lots of cheese and bacon and tasted delicious. The garlic knots and the accompanying marinara sauce were so delicious we were fighting over them. I would definitely go back to Brooklyn V's pizza and probably eat in and order a more traditional pie or something else off the menu. For a pizza, a calzone and the order of knots I spent $45.00 including delivery and tip.
(3)
Chuck M.
So far ????? It's been a wait for a pickup order --- longest minute ever and seems very disorganized at the cash register--- after 43 minutes still waiting. Wait staff did offer water while we waited but still waiting on that --- pick up order/service is horrendous
(3)
Jake A.
Just moved into neighborhood and been trying pizza and wings from places within delivery of my house. The delivery was fast and order was easy to place and pay for. Food was just ok. Nothing to get excited about. Little too expensive for just another pizza place. Will not be going back.
(2)
J F.
First off we had the garlic knots. They were SO DAMN GOOD. Perfect balance of crispy outside with soft gooey insides and not overly garlic'd. The sauce was made fresh in house and had great flavor. We ordered 12 - 6 would be enough for most people as they are larger than I expected them to be. None survived though :) Excellent pizza. Tried the margherita and was very impressed. The basil was super fresh, as were the tomatoes and it had clumps of gooey real mozzarella. The crust was perfect. If you like NY pizza this is the closest I've found it in AZ. The pepperoni was also very good. Not too greasy with nice flavor. Also, you can order by the slice and it still comes fresh so that was great for lunch. For dessert the Snickers pie was amazing. It was not too sweet which is often something I dislike in those types of pie. The owner, Vito, came over and chatted with us for a bit which was a nice touch and our server Nadine was super friendly and attentive. Dining room and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely be back to try other things off the menu. Hands down crushes Casanova Bros.
(5)
Kim L.
My new favorite pizza place! We ordered for pickup through online app (which made it very easy) and was ready in exactly 20mins. Staff was friendly and place was clean. The ONLY reason I am not giving 5 stars is because of their limited specialty pizza choices. There are 8 very different specialty choices, all of which had 3 toppings or less, so if you like alot of toppings you'd pay extra per topping. We ordered the 3 meat pizza and added olives for my toddler for extra $2 but there wasn't much olives at all considering the extra topping fee. So if you wanted a typical "supreme" style pizza with meats and veggies, you'd pay close to $20-25 which is a lot for a 14in pizza.
(4)
Sean S.
FANTASTIC!!! This is a great little find. tucked in the corner, real mom/pop feel. The bread knots were a fun appetizer (amazingly priced) and my family enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. the red sauces were fantastic!! Vito himself even came out and chatted with us for a few. Nice atmosphere, great food, great price. You've got a customer here!!! We'll be back!!
(5)
Randi S.
Yep we indeed came back for dinner. We had the v's 3 meat pizza. Best pizza I have ever had!!! Still wonderful service. Still relaxing and calming atmosphere. Definitely my favorite restaurant hands down!
(5)
Sandra D.
Well, I have been enjoying eating at Brooklyn V's for over a year. Guess what? Nothing has changed except, they are busier, and rightly so. Great food, value and service draws people in. Their food is so consistently delicious! No greasy cheap ingredients here. The pizza ranges from $12.00-14.00 for a cheese. Combos are available between $15.00-$20.00 based on size and number of ingredients. Their wings are just outstanding. Big meaty bones. more baked than fried and so yummy. Ladies, enjoy a glass of wine. Good deals for white or red with no nasty after affects from those cheap wines so many places serve. Their standard is comparable to Kendall or the like. Oh, I almost forgot the perks, good entertainment with text notification and points towards free food. You should give them a try. You won't go home broke, hungry or disappointed, but you could leave with leftovers due to their generous portions. Good decision.
(5)
Nadine H.
Amazing food and quality service. The atmosphere is great and the service is phenomenal. The restaurant is fairly new (opened about a year ago) and the staff really makes you feel at home. I'm originally from New York myself, and I absolutely love Brooklyn V's, it makes me homesick in the best kind of way! I've tried all of their pizzas, a few of their dinners and all of their strombolis. The food is incredible. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to ANYONE! I recommend the garlic knots as an appetizer for all first time customers, not only are they a great price, but they are just unbeatable! 5 out of 5 stars, always.
(5)
Jim P.
When's the last time you encountered a wine list in a pizza joint? These guys love what they do and do it very well. Seriously fresh ingredients in their menu are prepared and served by a dedicated, friendly staff that know how to do good food. A family friendly atmosphere that is a pleasant step away from the typical chain store pizza place we so often settle for. Great food, good price , convenient location. My new favorite pizza restaurant in Arizona.
(4)
Nick R.
First the food is really good, the food alone is a 5 for me and the staff is very nice. The downsides are they had live music inside (not something I'm looking for in Italian restaurant) so we had to sit outside. The cheap Home Depot patio furniture made the situation awkward. All and all the downsides are an easy fix, and I will be going back.
(3)
Jennifer E.
This place is delicious! My favs are the pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and spaghetti with meat sauce! If You haven't tried Brooklyn V's, you're missing out!
(5)
RillaAnn J.
Been to Brooklyn V's several times since they've open, my complaint isn't the food... Last night my husband tried to order a pizza for take out. It was 845, they close at 9. The young female on the phone stated that they didn't want to make our pizza since they were closing... Wow. Great customer service. We normally aren't those ppl that order for right before close, but we are moving away from the area and that would have been our last time there. Thanks for the great memory.
(1)
Andrea D.
I stopped in here after getting my nails done. I wish I would have tried this place sooner. Not only was the customer service fantastic, the food is amazing! I got an anti-pasto salad, the ingredients are fresh and very flavorful.
(5)
Andrew D.
These guys get five stars from me not just because owner is from newyork like myself but the pizza is the best in Arizona. I have found so far especially the buffalo chicken pizza. Great job guys keep it up!
(5)
Max K.
This restaurant is a very pleasant surprise to walk into. With it being kind of tucked in the corner of a shopping center that hasn't seemed to have much success, you would just be expecting a cheap pizza place that doesn't serve much more than average pizza and maybe some wings. Brooklyn V's offers a very pleasant, homey feel when you walk inside and the staff is very friendly. They are very grateful for your business and deliver a menu and quality of food that makes you want to come back for more. Within the last week or two I have already eaten here twice and nothing has yet to disappoint. Portions are extremely generous and the quality of food is something you would expect at a restaurant charging a steeper price. For my first visit, me and my girlfriend split a 12 or 14 inch pizza (can't remember the exact size, but not the largest size) and a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad had just the right amount of dressing and tasted about as good as a Caesar salad can get. It was also served on a chilled plate, which added a nice touch. The size of the salad was quite large and could probably feed at least 3 as an appetizer before the meal. The pizza came out a few minutes later and was quite delicious. A NY style pie that had the right amount of crispness to it, which is tough to come across. Most NY style pizzas are pretty flimsy, but Vito seems to have a great recipe. I am a stickler on Pizza and this easily satisfied me. About as good as I could expect out of a pizza that wasn't cooked in a wood fired brick oven. During my second visit I decided to venture out and try the Bow tie pasta with pesto sauce. I am not a huge pasta person but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and portion size once again. During this visit, we also decided to try Vito's cannolis and that was an EXCELLENT choice. The cannolis were superb and I have been craving them ever since. I would give Brooklyn V's a 4 1/2 star rating if that were possible on yelp. The only things I wish differently would be that the plates were maybe a dollar or two cheaper ($10 for a pasta plate, I think the salad was somewhere between $5.50-7 and then a 1-topping 12 or 14 inch pizza was $16) and I think the speed of service will improve with experience. Overall, Brooklyn V's provides a much higher quality of food and service than you would expect out of a place tucked back in the corner of a Goodwill shopping center, next to a smoke shop. I have encouraged others to try it and the one family that did was very happy, so I hope others enjoy it as well.
(5)
Henry D.
I accidently stumbled upon Brooklyn V's last night. I was headed to another pizza place to try for the first time but it was closed. I decided to get a slice and a salad. They get points for offering a slice right off the bat. 1. The crust was perfect, very true to the Brooklyn way. Flavorful. A+ 2. The sauce was very nice, I do like a little more sauce, but it was quality. A+ 3. Ingredients - Sausage- A. Roasted Pepper- A+. Eggplant- A. (It was very good, however it was tossed in tasty bread crumbs, but I do prefer the eggplant without the crumbs.) 4. Salad - I ordered a simple dinner salad with Ceasar dressing. Lettuce was a mix of greens and Romajne. Very crisp and fresh. Ceasar Dressing- A+ 5. Service- I can't comment too much as I was a carry out, but the young lady who took my order was very nice, I didn't ask, but she brought me a glass of water while I waited and that always gets points. She knew the menu well when I was deciding on my order and possible future orders. I will be back to dine in for sure.
(4)
Kristen P.
Phenom eats, seriously! The service is amazing, our favorite server is Anna. She's always there to greet us with a big, family-sized smile and makes sure that everyone is receiving equal care (never sits on her rump, just making sure that everyone is getting the best service!) The food, now THERE is something to BRAG about! My favorite thing to eat so far is the White Eggplant Pizza. This gastronomical concept is so far out of my comfort zone, I didn't know if I was married to an Italian long enough, Glory Be! 13 Years and I was eating eggplant like a pro!. I'm here to tell you it is THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD! We're attempting to hit everything on the menu, so far we've dabbled with Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parmesan, Lasagna, Bruschetta, Baked Ziti, Stuffed Shells, and meatballs and every single thing has been extraordinary in flavor and quality! We have never been disappointed. Try this place, your taste buds will thank you! Oh and don't forget to sign up for the loyalty program, those points add up QUICKLY! Ignore those people that have left unsavory comments. Look at those accounts, one of them ONLY seems to YELP negative reviews and use foul language, really? Do you trust that kind of poppycock, I don't, I let the Cannoli cream talk for themselves?)
(5)
Cat K.
We moved from NYC 3.5 years ago and could not find authentic pizza, not to mention cannolis. I found Brooklyn Vs on here (yelp) and due to the great reviews decided to try.... YUM YUM YUM. We had the white eggplant pizza, margherita pizza and garlic knots ALL DELICIOUS. As we were getting ready to leave Vito the owner came over and said hello. We told him we could not find good cannolis anywhere, even though we had paid our bill he brought us a few cannolis for us to try... How thoughtful! We will definitely be back to try other things on the menu
(5)
Jay J.
Great pizza and great place to bring a group Came here after church had 2 14" pizzas the 3 v's meat pizza and a all cheese Bianca pizza both were great we also had some garlic knots for starters very cheap and very good Loved the setting and the staff, nice open kitchen so you can watch your pizza an food being made The Owner coming and welcoming us and checking on our food was a nice touch too Will definitely be coming back
(5)
Janelle R.
Love this place. I've been three times, once for pizza, then penne in vodka sauce, and most recently spaghetti with meat sauce. Absolutely everything is made fresh and I can taste every bit of it! The sauces are fantastic. Next time I'm trying the pesto. I don't even like pesto, but that's how much I enjoy the food here. The service is great too. Very friendly and warm staff. Feels like home.
(5)
Robert J.
First time ordering. We had a pizza (half V's 3 meat/half bianco) wings and garlic knots and everything was really good. We will order again for sure!
(5)
Shanna G.
Yummy yummy so yummy I love this place. Being from New York, I'm a total pizza snob. I just happened on this place when I was getting my nails done one day and it blew my mind. Reminds me of home. I want to try other menu items but the pizza is just too good to not eat.
(5)
Darius L.
Very Tasty. Way way better than Casa Nova Brothers!!!! Yuk. Guys Keep up the good work. I'll keep coming back if you stay consistent. A little tucked back had to drive around to find you, but pleased I didn't give up the search. If you guys are from New York bring more of that NY goodness out here. Very Very good.!!!!
(4)
Sara S.
All I can can say is wow! This is my first time ordering from here and I ordered via grubhub and after reading reviews on yelp I thought my food would be ridiculously late. Turns out it was 20 minutes early! I ordered the stuffed shells, caprese salad and 2 meatballs. It came with 4 stuffed shells which in and of itself a hearty meal. The caprese salad was not terrible but would have liked to seen riper tomatoes and a tad more salt. The meatballs tasted like they had worshester sauce which is totally not necessary but the sauce they were in was yummy. Back to the shells, everything about it was great! My food arrived piping hot and early! Also their mix of Dr Pepper was on point tonight! I will definitely be ordering from here again!
(5)
Matt B.
There have been a few pizza places in this suite over the years, I tried them all but never went back after trying them out once or twice (and I live pretty much right across the street). Love the food here, owners and servers are very nice and bend over backwards to give you what you want. I've brought friends here and they've enjoyed the food and atmosphere as well!!!
(5)
Sara O.
We LOVE Brooklyn V's. We come here at least once a week. The food is amazing and the service is great. They have added some new girls so be patient, the food is worth the wait anyway. We pretty much have the menu memorized and I haven't eaten anything I haven't liked yet. They are also apart of a great rewards program where you can build up points and earn free food!
(5)
Kristine R.
Delicious! We moved from NYC 2 1/2 years ago and have been to many pizzerias where we have been told it's just like NY pizza and each have fallen short. My husband found this place on Yelp and OMG this is it. Cheese pizza reminds us of back home. We went back today with his brother and family and we ate and ate and ate. Cheese pizza, V3 pizza, eggplant pizza and the bianco pizza--- yum yum yum! The mini zeppolis and cannolis are delish. We are definitely going back to try the calzones and pasta dishes. It's a 20 min drive from home and so worth it.
(5)
Heidi H.
Best eggplant Parmesan by far! We've tried the gambit of eggplant parm at other Italian restaurants here in the valley and nothing compares to Brooklyn Vs!!
(4)
Thomas G.
The garlic knots are to die for and the eggplant pizza is freaking amazing. The owners Bob and Vito go out of their way to make you feel welcome and these guys do a ton of fundraisers to give back to their local community.
(5)
Julie F.
Not a bad place to get take out from. If you are looking for real NY pizza and pasta this is the place for you!
(3)
Kelly G.
Just stumbled upon this place and so happy I did! The pizza was delicious! The atmosphere was family friendly and the place was very clean. I look forward to trying more things on the menu!
(4)
Marissa D.
Absolutely delicious. I couldn't stop eating! I was so full yet it was just so good. Found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try. We are pretty faithful to our regular pizza place but I am so glad we tried this place. My husband and I ordered the stuffed shells and a pepperoni pizza to share. The stuffed shells were definitely some of the best I've ever had! Everything about the food was good. We ordered over Yelp and picked it up with no problems. Definitely will be coming back often.
(5)
Kelly V.
This place is incredible - GREAT food, great service - we will definitely be back!
(5)
Steve B.
Got takeout on Saturday Night (9/27). It was our first time ordering from them, so we decided to order a cheese pizza. In my opinion, the true litmus test for any pizza is getting the pizza in it 's purest form, plain cheese. Well, Brooklyn V's passed this test with flying colors. The sauce had great flavor and the crust had the right amount of crispness and chewiness. We strive to support only locally owned restaurants, not chains. I love that this place is 2 minutes from our house. We'll be back!
(5)
Nawaf H.
Seriously!!! I mean this place got 4.5 stars ! Worst pizza i ever tried , nothing special at all , i ordered for home delivery and got my order after 75 minutes cold , the the pizza tastes horrible . First time and never again
(1)
Wilfredo A.
Great service, great pizza, but excellent pasta. It's a weekly tradition for me and my family to grab a meal from here whether it's to go or dinning in. Please don't pass on the knots, spaghetti, baked ziti, wings, or the old classic pepperoni pizza. For those who like a different ambiance make a trip out on Friday or Saturday night. Live music!!! Need I say more???
(5)
Cory D.
Tale of two restaurants. Last week we ordered from Brooklyn V 's and it was fantastic all around, we ordered in the afternoon. Tonight we ordered and it was completely opposite so greesy we could not even finish it, we also ordered wings and they were less then average too. Super disappointed especially after our first experience. Way over priced for the quality and lack of attention to detail.
(2)
Cody M.
Our party of 4 ordered the chicken fettuccine alfredo, spaghetti with meat sauce along with a large pizza. Everything was great. I get fettuccine just about everywhere I go and theirs was some of the best. Pizza had a great thin and crispy crust. Great stuff.
(5)
Steve C.
New York style thin crust....not even close!! They claim if it's under a 1/2 inch, that's New York style thin crust. And it's chewy! It should be a 1/4 inch and crispy....nice try guys, but no thanks. The sauce is too sweet, I think they are trying to cover up the lack of knowledge on how to make a New York style thin crust.
(1)
Noelle K.
OMG! THIS IS THE PLACE for an authentic NY Italian meal!!!! My man decided on a whim that I was going to try a new place after he had tried it for lunch. He said he couldn't wait to take me to Brooklyn V's. I am a very picky eater and I am not a fan of chains so I was really happy to support a small business that really knows its business! We started with these little bread things they call garlic knots that come with marinara YUM! This was starting out fantastic. You can tell a lot from the marinara, ya know ;) We each ordered a Stromboli and they were to die for! I could have cut it lengthwise and just crawled in, they do kinda look like sleeping bags. You know when you taste something so good the world just kinda stops spinning? Yeah......Oh sorry! We took a tiramisu home to split for later. The waitress said it was heaven in a box. I haven't had too much luck with tiramisu here in AZ so I wasn't too excited. A couple hours later her words were still echoing in my head and I just had to taste it. Fireworks shot off! The band started playing and suddenly I was in Italy! Reluctantly I put the other half (well almost half, he he) back in the fridge for my man. The liquor license is coming folks!
(5)
Danny A.
This is the real deal.Born and raised ny'er here and this is as good as it gets in the east valley.Now if they sold slices over the counter without the wait service,and Sicilian pies,it'd be like I was back home.Forget Casanova,they would be closed down in 6 months if they were back east.No comparison.
(5)
Jim W.
A very Friendly staff. Everything tasted scratch made. From the Fresh cut romaine, cherry tomatoes, the touch of black olive slices and a bit of red onion in the house salad, to the DELICIOUS chicken fettuccine Alfredo. I've never had so much tasty Alfredo sauce in one bowl of fresh made pasta. The bread that came with the meal was melt in your mouth, just out of the oven, fresh baked too. This cozy family place is one you should try.
(5)
Kimberly C.
Visited last night for dinner with friends. Our party of 4 split a large 18" pepperoni pizza and an order of 12 garlic knots. The food was EXCELLENT! I think the dough/crust MAKES the pizza and Brooklyn V's has it down pat. This space has been occupied by a few pizza joints since I've lived in the area and I've never been too impressed - but I'll definitely be back to Brooklyn V's. Other +'s: *Cannoli's - Very good! *Iced Tea - Fresh! *Friendly staff *Nice family/owners that took the time to say hello and welcome us to their establishment.
(5)
Reco J.
Let me tell you something and you would be wise to listen!! Since I moved to AZ I have searched for real good back east Italian food that did not require me to drive and sit down at a table. Brooklyn V's is a Blessing, I love there eggplant, and pizza and OMG! The cannoli is straight off the boat. Plus I can order online and it gets to my house in less than 20 mins and hot. Thank you for being you! Reco
(5)
Kaitlyn S.
I arrived at this establishment on a Friday around 7:30pm. Overall I was pretty impressed with the food, in which me and a group had ordered a large white pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was excellent and is comparable to somewhere such as Gilbert Pizza. However, the down side to this restaurant is the service. Every time I have made a visit here I have waited quite a bit of time to receive r any service. Expect to wait and plan your time accordingly, inside is a little cramped but this place makes you feel at home.
(3)
David F.
Great food, staff and atmosphere! We had our local lunch club here and it was great! I would recommend everyone to try the ziti as well as the pizza!
(5)
Christina L.
Great food, great customer service. We are from NY and really are thrilled to have amazing pizza and cannoli in Gilbert! Will be back again for sure.
(5)
Darlene c.
Can't eat pizza anywhere else now !!! Close my eyes and feel like in Brooklyn eating Bay Pizza by train in Sheepshead Bay.. and their sauce is delicious. ...and they leave the the bubbled pockets of dough and don't pop them like other places!! Cannoli's perfectly sweet, garlic knots w/fresh chopped garlic perfectly crisp on outside and yummy on inside!! This is my only place for Italian food now.. and owner is friendly as is waitstaff.. Enjoy the food every time I come here, it is worth the trip no matter how far..
(5)
Kelly G.
I like to say that this is a hidden gem in Gilbert. I dont usually like Italian food but this was authentic and home grown. It was the best experience I have had and it was so cute and quaint. I could take my kids and they enjoyed it also. The owner is really friendly and good people.
(5)
Joe A.
Very friendly restaurant, fast service and the food was absolutely fantastic. Had an ice cold beer to start, pizza was totally East coast and the ricotta shells with meat sauce. Bob served, Vito prepared and I wouldn't have known that if they weren't so friendly. I will be back!!
(5)
Ray N.
Love this place. Love their food.As authentic to NY Italian as it gets here in Az. Very nice, cozy atmosphere with great service from our waitress Allora. We were a party of 12 last night and everyone was raving about their dishes. The cheese pizza here is superb : perfect crust, great sauce and just the right mix of cheese. Eggplant parm was the best I have had in years and their calzones are amazing. Cooked just right and everything blended well. My experience in Az with other restaurants trying to make Calzones has been so so with most just throwing the stuff in hoping it gels. The owner Vito has been doing this for 30 years and certainly brings that and more to this awesome place. My new favorite place in Gilbert.
(5)
Gordon G.
We had Spaghetti and Meat Sauce and Zita. The Meat Sauce was one of the best we ever had. The music was "Sinatra/Martin" and it felt like we belonged. Great place to eat, food was excellent.
(5)
Andy L.
Placed a rather simple pick up order-small pepperoni pizza. I was not told a price on the phone, I figured it would be in the 10 dollar range. Lesson learned, never assume anything! When i got there, I paid over 15$, which, I'm sorry is EXCESSIVE! They need to sprinkle gold or something on there to make it worth the money at that price. Either way, I paid since I did order it and figured if it was a really good pizza it was worth it. Needless to say I was further disappointed when I got home and started eating it-now, I don't have extremely high standards when it comes to pizza-I love dominos, pizza hut, you name it-but the sauce was bland and had no taste to it. I lived in Boston for many years and have visited NYC many times; believe me when I tell you, this place has nothing, and I mean NOTHING in common with NY pizza. I was disappointed and won't be back.
(1)
Mike K.
We ordered 2 stromboli's, thinking we were getting NY style stromboli's, but what we got were 2 loaves of bread with a little bit of filling. For starters, ANY time I've ever ordered a stromboli, much less 2 of them, it has had to come out in a pizza box due to the size of them. But when 2 of them came out together fitting on ONE paper plate, I was already highly disappointed considering the $22 price tag. Once getting home and beginning to slice them up, the first 2 inches of the end was all bread, and as we started getting in through the rest of it, the crust of it was so think and breadlike, there was no room for filling. I've attached some photos to showcase the size and filling. Past all that, taste was only... ehh. The Eggplant parm stromboli was very bland and sausage and meatball stromboli was mediocre at best. I never leave bad feedback on these kinds of sites, but this one we felt needed to be addressed. Just know what you're getting when you order a "stromboli" there.
(1)
Tami C.
Being from the East Coast, it is hard to find an authentic New York pizza in AZ. Brooklyn V's is FANTASTIC!!!! Takes me back home.... The crust is fantastic with just the right amount of cheese. We've been here several times but haven't ordered anything other than pizza yet. Based on the other reviews, trying the Stromboli next. Check this place out, you won't be sorry!
(5)
Kristin H.
I got the lunch special, 2 slices and a soda for $5.75. I think it's a great deal and the pizza was delicious. I'm picky when it comes to my pizza crust and they didn't burn it which was great. Sometimes places that have thinner crust blacken their pizza before it comes to the table but it arrived hot and the perfect crispiness. This place is tucked away in a strip mall, but it doesn't take away from the great prices and good food.
(4)
Dan A.
Just tried Brooklyn's based on Yelp reviews. Pizza is outstanding. Will definitely be back. Upon entering this place you can tell right away this is a family run establishment. Very genuinely friendly staff. I noticed the other patrons and there were smiles at every table. Next time, I'm going for the sausage and peppers hero. It looks amazingly delicious.
(4)
Emily B.
We had some amazingly fresh bruschetta here as well as some very richly flavored lasagna, garlic knots and cannolis. We had excellent service and our server was very attentive. Additionally she and the other staff were so passionate about their food and the restaurant that it was contagious. We were truly blown away by this place! The food beat out some of the street crap I had in Rome over the summer!
(5)
Annette A.
Finally found REAL NY style pizza in the East Valley! The pizza Margherita and Eggplant parmesan Hero were delicious! The owners were very friendly and made us feel very welcome. New Yorkers you gotta come here!
(5)
Mike S.
I tried this place today, and I was impressed. I had the 2 pizza slice & drink lunch special. The margherita pizza was fantastic. The crust was thin & crispy, which I usually don't like because other pizzerias either make it too hard or too limp. This crust was incredible. They also have delivery service. I will not order chain pizza again.
(4)
Hanna F.
Well, once again I tried it for chance. Still the rude son of a bitch New Yorkers with extremely high prices for the shit they serve. Let me tell you, GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT.
(1)
Julie S.
So good!!! Real east coast Italiano!!! Some favorites - eggplant parm - very authentic, thinly sliced!! Ask for Desiree - awesome waitress with good recommendations.
(5)
Anne J.
A most go to place!!! You can taste the freshness, you can tell they make the dough daily. Amazing
(5)
Maria N.
Went to Brooklyn V's last night for dinner for the first time with my family. I was intrigued because they were from Staten Island so I figured they knew good pizza. It is hard to find a good "pie" out in AZ. The restaurant did not disappoint. We had the Margherita and the White Eggplant Pizza's. They we amazing. The dough was light and thin. The sauce was perfect. Not to thick and acidic. The eggplant pizza is a must. I can't wait to go back again and try the dinner selections. The staff was so friendly. It actually felt like a "family". Highly recommended. They deliver and cater also!
(5)
Sue L.
Very good pizza, delivered on time! I ordered garlic knots because of someone else's recommendation. The dipping sauce is excellent. The knots need more garlic.
(4)
Rachael W.
Pizza was average for New York style. Delivery was pretty quick but the pizza was cold and way over-priced. 25 dollars for one pizza is a little ridiculous.
(3)
Vanessa J.
my husband and I visited here as a recommendation from our neighbor. Had the pizza the first time it was excellent. Took the family there for a second trip had the Stromboli and the shells. Food and service was again excellent. Waitress even gave our granddaughter her own special treat. Will definitely visit again
(4)
Julie B.
Brooklyn V's opened 3 weeks ago and is having typical start-up issues with a new young staff. But, that's the only area that needs improvement! I wanted to try Brooklyn V's because as I was sitting at the stop light at Lindsey and Warner - the most wonderful pizza aroma drifted across the intersection. I told my husband, based on the aroma alone we needed to try this place. The FOOD IS WONDERFUL and definitely lived up to the tantalizing aroma! We ordered house salads and the Sausage and Pepper Stromboli. We didn't receive the Stromboli we ordered, however we kept the dish brought because the crust was so crispy and light, the cheese was perfectly stringy and gooey, and the combination of meats inside tender and tasty. Paired with their marinara sauce, we couldn't send it back - it was that good! One of the owners stopped by to check on our dinner. When we let her know what happened, she "comped" us Cannolis for dessert. The plate was chilled and the presentation was something I would have expected from a more upper end restaurant. We are so glad to have Brooklyn V's in our neighborhood and within walking distance! We'll be returning again and again to try the other items on the menu - which we expect will be equally flavorful.
(4)
Joyce S.
Very low key, but nice server, great food (huge portions) and just satisfied my pasta craving. Only wish they had beer.......
(3)
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
Address :894 E Warner Rd,Ste 101
Gilbert, AZ, 85296
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : Yes Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Lunch Parking : Private Lot Bike Parking : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : Beer & Wine Only Outdoor Seating : Yes Wi-Fi : No Has TV : Yes Waiter Service : Yes Caters : Yes
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
Italian Cuisine
The immense popularity of Italian cuisine globally isn't unknown. You can find an Italian Pizzeria around every corner of almost every city in the United States. Not to forget that in every house, people enjoy mac and cheese as comfort food. But it would be wrong to believe that Italian food starts with pizza and ends with good pasta as this Mediterranean country has much more to offer other than these two dishes. In Italian Cuisine, there is a high use of fresh tomatoes, all kinds of herbs, great quality of cheese, all types of meat, seafood and fresh handmade pasta. Many find it hard to believe that Italians have been making noodles long back.
Italian and Greek cuisines are always mistaken to be same, but they are poles apart. The primary difference between the two cuisines is the use of cheese in most of the Italian dishes. Italians love to cultivate their own cheese and process them as per their food requirement. It is believed that some cheese is so expensive that cheese producers secure them in lockers.
If you are bored eating the same old pasta or pizza, you can try some of the authentic Italian dishes like Risotto, Polenta, Ribollita, Lasagna, Fiorentina Steak, Bottarga, Ossobuco, Carbonara, Focaccia, Arancini and Supplì. Another item which Italians love to relish every morning is a good cup of Italian Coffee. Once you taste a freshly brewed cup of Italian Coffee, you might not visit Starbucks ever again. Authentic Italian food is made with heart and soul, so go find a restaurant where you can relish Italian cuisine in your city.
Robert G.
I've eaten their food three times. Two times I've eaten there and once had a pizza delivered. What was funny is the guy taking my pizza order told me the price and stopped talking. I was waiting for him to ask me my cc info. I think he thought I was balking at the price because he told me, "You realize our pizzas are not the $5 kind?" I laughed and said I don't eat $5 pizzas! He got a kick out of that and the pie was delivered warm and tasty! I was a bachelor that weekend and the large lasted me both Saturday and Sunday. Nothing like pizza for breakfast baby! Both times I visited there the food was really good. The first time I had the chicken Marsala and loved it. The second time I had the lasagne with meat sauce and my wife had the chicken cacciatore. She ate everything on her plate and loved it. I got full on half of the lasagne and had the other half for lunch the next day. Both times the lasagne was delicious. We live close by so we'll be going back again for sure. My wife and I aren't really into hearing cover music when we eat, we like to talk. The only thing I haven't appreciated about the place was the Elvis impersonator singing when we went on a Saturday night. Good singer but everything he sang was in the Elvis style...George Straight in an Elvis style...not for me thank you. Of course I did tip the gentleman because he has talent. We are looking forward to the weather cooling so we can sit either inside or out, where ever the singer is not.
(5)Amanda A.
I am originally from NYC and moved to Arizona close to 2 years ago. I found out about this place from a random New Yorker I met. To say the least, this place is amazing. I go to Brooklyn V's all the time. I feel a price of home and nostalgia when I walk in. I spent about a year and a half trying to find good NY pizza and did not find it, until I went to Brooklyn V's. I won't eat any other pizza, except for theirs. Not only do they have great pizza, they offer amazing pasta dishes, desserts, and their staff is the greatest. I will always be a New Yorker and their food makes me miss/appreciate the NY style of food.
(5)Mark L.
We celebrated my daughter's first birthday here last night and could not have been more impressed. My wife reserved a table for our party and the staff was not only accommodating, but went above and beyond by decorating our table with balloons, birthday napkins and even had a special candle for the cake. The food was phenomenal. My party tried garlic knots, spaghetti and pizza. Everything tasted delicious and the pizza was excellent. Cheese, sauce, garlic, pepperoni, spinach and dough all came together perfectly. Beer and wine were very reasonably priced and the live music completed the night. The staff was very attentive to our needs and I cannot say enough about how welcomed they made all of us feel. This is a family owned business that shows tremendous pride in quality and preparation of food and care for their patrons. A big thank you to the entire staff at Brooklyn V's for making my daughter's first birthday one that we will never forget.
(5)Danielle C.
Great service!! Great food!! It's been difficult finding Stromboli in Arizona but Brooklyn V's do it and they do it right!!! I had the Stromboli with sausage, pepperoni and meatballs! They did not skimp out on meat or cheese!!! It was oozing cheese!!! So delicious!! We will be back to try the pizzas and pastas which all look amazing! Everyone was super friendly and made us feel welcome. I even saw the owner come out and shake hands with patrons. This is why it's so important to support local businesses especially when they are as worthy as this one!!! Can't wait to go back!!
(5)Lori E.
I am from ny and i have to say this place has the best pizza and calzones I havent had anything elst tho
(5)Donna B.
This place has quickly become my favorite local joint to get food! I love the food and the chance to get out of my house and sit down somewhere else with TV, a drink, and Italian food. My favorite dishes are the Chicken Marsala and the chicken and mozzarella (add mushrooms) calzone. The garlic knot appetizers are addictive! They come with a side of homemade marinara and are to die for. The bruschetta is pretty good. The chicken parm here is also very well done. Though I haven't tried it yet, their pizza seems to be very popular. The service is usually pretty good. Anna is the best!! Also, they deliver!! They have TVs, booths, tables, and outside seating. The tables in the middle can accommodate small groups.
(5)April G.
We ordered and picked up our food. The phone was picked up promptly and the lady that was taking the order was very nice and informative. We ordered the Bianco pizza, stuffed shells and cannolis. Our order was ready in 20min. The lady at the counter was very friendly and quick to grab our food. The food was about $30 which isn't to bad. The pizza was awesome! It has fresh ingredients and the mozzarella was soooo good!!! The stuffed shells were seasoned wonderfully with some really tasty marinara. Lastly the cannolis tasted like my grandmothers which is saying a lot in a great way. :) They had chocolate chips with a slightly sweet ricotta filling. Other places tend to make these to sweet which ruins them. You have to have the right balance of sweetness, crunch and creaminess from the ricotta. Soooo this place gets a thumbs up!! Yum!
(5)Robert G.
Went there first time with my sons and the pizza is outstanding! The only issue is we did not feel welcome, the service is excellent but the manager that day made visits to the other tables except ours, that i think is Not good buisness or good management! What am i? Chopped liver Lost my business and was planning to my it my regular pizza place,NOT NOW!
(3)Raymond D.
Ordered an eggplant parm hero and side order of meatballs. Both were solid. Meatballs could have been a bit bigger but other then that they were tasty. Being it was my first visit there and I wanted to add on a slice to my order ,Desireé set me up with a free slice of pizza while I waited for my take out order. I can say it definitely holds up to Long Island pizza. I will be back for sure.
(5)kim s.
Had spaghetti meatballs and vodka penne comparable to las Vegas quality pastas five stars!
(5)Matthew G.
I was really excited walking in and hearing all the accents and such, but if this is New York pizza, I'd rather stick with Arizona. Pizza was not terrible, but the sauce was way too watery. Everything slid off of our pizza. They also seemed to be big on the oil as well. Both the pizza and knots had excessive amounts of oil. The service was great and the staff was friendly, which is why I say 3 stars. Would I return? No. Not with all the great choices in the area. $28 for a med pizza, knots, and drink.
(3)Mark B.
First of all, when you're here, you're family. The hospitality here is unparalleled. When time permits, Vito, the owner, and the crew will be sure to stop by, introduce themselves and drop a friendly hello. It's so nice to come to such a wonderful Italian restaurant and have authentic cuisine. Vito definitely takes pride in his work and the staff delivers. When you come, request Desiree and tell her Mark and Cristina recommended her. Enjoy the amazing food and ambiance. Support your local Italianos and enjoy what Vito and his staff is proud to serve you! Till next time, ciao!
(5)BARRY B.
You search for a real New York pizza, especially if you come from Brooklyn. This place comes thisclose. Vito has the "touch". The pizza is delicious. Their marinara is wonderful and the garlic knots are like Brooklyn's best. It was also amazing that there were a lot of N.Y. ex-pats the evening we were there.
(4)Alia K.
Wanted to try a new place for lunch and found a gem. Not only did I have a great experience, but the food was amazing too. Bob and Desiree are the sweetest people and helped me custom my lunch order. A very pleasant and clean environment. I'll definitely be coming back.
(5)Tyler S.
Was enjoying a night of swimming in the 100+ degree weather and wanted something good, quick and delivered to our door. Brooklyn V's fit the bill! Food was delivered under the estimated time and was piping hot. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, chicken stromboli and honey bbq wings and all were amazing! Will definitely order again.
(5)Travis L.
Great chicken parm. tonight, they forgot my side Caesar though. I gave five stars on my first review.
(3)Harvey S.
A friend wanted to try this place, being that it's local and they have a doo-wap group performing...at least this Saturday. We had brushetta and garlic knots for the table. The brushetta had plenty of fresh tomatoes and basil, among other things. The garlic knots had minced garlic butter...more flavorful than garlic butter with powder. The margherita pizza was very flavorful...it had chopped tomatoes and a crust crispy and NY-style...thinner, but not too thin. And the musical group was really fun, but does not allow for good conversation if you're sitting nearby. The waitstaff was good natured and stopped by enough to check up on us, refill drinks, despite being a busy night. Recommended.
(4)Val M.
I looooove this place. Food is always delicious, service is great, and always very quick/reliable with delivery. Highly recommended!
(5)Tamara R.
Really glad I read the reviews on the buffalo chicken pizza and ordered it because that was delicious! Two pizzas and a 6 piece garlic knots was really quite expensive to have delivered though. Otherwise I'd give it a full 5. Really tasty food though!
(4)Becky C.
I am astounded at the quality of this "hole in the wall" find. Between a smoke shop and a cleaners, Brooklyn V's has blown me away. Pizza shop? No, this is a Brooklyn restaurant in the heart of Mesa, AZ. I had spaghetti in clam sauce. Where do I begin? The pasta was al dente. That's the first step to proving you care a bit about your food. Next is tender clams, a TON of them, in a perfect sauce, mild with a hint of wine and garlic, sprinkled with parm and served with crusty Italian bread, baked locally and only sold to a choice few restaurants. It absorbs the sauce perfectly, melting in the buttery, garlicky goodness. There are only a few beers on tap. I had the Shock Rock Belgian White, a perfect compliment to the light sauce and simple meal. I was sent here by a local, the guy at Stamps Automotive, while they work on my car. I cannot thank him enough.
(5)MikeNikki G.
Great food and great service. Kid friendly, but food is grown-up worthy. We will definitely be back.
(5)Scott C.
Amazing food - Amazing owners and staff! Atmosphere is "Cheers" like. If you are considering trying but unsure - have no fear - You will not be disappointed!!
(5)Nick B.
First timer and not bad def worth trying. Tried the eggplant and pizza very delicious...
(5)Brandon B.
The service here is phenomenal. The entire staff makes you feel like you're a part of their family. I recommend you make your way here. I've been 5 times in the last 2 weeks. thank you for providing the best service in the Gilbert area. Furthermore the Pizza is AMAZING!!! You can't find pizza this good unless you're in Brooklyn!
(5)Kim L.
My new favorite pizza place! We ordered for pickup through online app (which made it very easy) and was ready in exactly 20mins. Staff was friendly and place was clean. The ONLY reason I am not giving 5 stars is because of their limited specialty pizza choices. There are 8 very different specialty choices, all of which had 3 toppings or less, so if you like alot of toppings you'd pay extra per topping. We ordered the 3 meat pizza and added olives for my toddler for extra $2 but there wasn't much olives at all considering the extra topping fee. So if you wanted a typical "supreme" style pizza with meats and veggies, you'd pay close to $20-25 which is a lot for a 14in pizza.
(4)Dan A.
Wow! I popped in for lunch on a Tuesday and was kindly greeted by Bob, one of the owners. I sat down for lunch and thought I'd give their pizza and Stromboli a try. The pizza was good. I'm from NJ, and I was very impressed. It's on par with some of the other NY style pizza places in Gilbert. The Stromboli, though... Out of this world. I saw how big it was and I figured I'd get through half after a slice of pizza, but I couldn't leave any of it. The dough was flavorful, crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. There was a ton of cheese! One of the best I ever had and it's made from scratch, so it takes about 20min of you just walk in. Absolutely worth it! Thanks Bob for a great experience! I know where I'm going for my pizza fix from now on!
(5)Mike S.
Everything here is amazing. Garlic Knotts. Chicken Marsala, and the pizza is top notch. I am an east coast pizza snob and this pizza is LEGIT! !!! Come and try this place you won't be disappointed.
(5)Mike D.
Maybe I'm a pizza snob.....been eating it for over 25 years now......thought I would try something new.....I have my five or so great places.......I get a pie once if not twice a week.....read some reviews on yelp, thought I would give this place a try.....made the mistake of not going to their website.....ordered off of yelp.....35 bones for a pizza and 6 wings and a couple of knots........so not worth it.....wings were dry.....the sausage on pizza looked liked chopped up hot dogs.....I'm not one to complain on food....but when I'm dropping almost 40 bills on a pizza and six wings I better have a great experience.....I'd take a little ceaser hot and ready any day over this.....I try and support local mom and pop shops....but when a pizza costs almost half a C note.....your not reaching out to your mom and pop customers
(1)Andrew O.
Margherita pizza. Great crust, crunchy yet chewy. Sauce has a nice sweetness to it. They also do a frequent flyer type program as well.
(5)Sara E.
$18 for a medium margarita pizza? This better blow my mind. Unfortunately, it was just "good". I would have given it 4 stars if it was appropriately priced.
(3)Samantha G.
This was our first time at Brooklyn V's. We had the garlic knots, sausage, meatball, and pepperoni stromboli, and sausage and peppers hero. The stromboli was amazing! Other reviews have shown that is was more bread and small amount of meat, which was not the case! We will definately be back!
(5)Bryan M.
Everything is fresh! I was first pleased at how good the ranch dressing was, light, not heavy. I ordered pizza, which was great, but immediately thought the baked ziti looked so good...I'll be back! The price is super for the quality and I'd recommend anyone that likes New York style pizza give this place a try.
(5)David H.
Exceptional pizza- I especially enjoyed the margherita pizza. I added garlic to it, which ended up being a good choice. The garlic knots are great, and the desserts are homemade and really, really good. Had the cannoli and the tiramisu. Also, incredibly good, friendly service. :-)
(4)John M.
This is a local mom & pop that you could easily mistake for a chain restaurant once you go inside. For now, its the one and only.:) It strikes an expertly crafted balance between the look of a fine dining establishment and a lounge, all while providing the comfort and ease of a fast casual restaurant. There are nice marble counters at the bar, where you can relax and order a beer or a glass of wine, and an outdoor patio with comfortable seating you could easily spend hours in. What's more, is that there is often live music on Saturdays, which is another plus, and their events makes it a great place for families, couples, and friends hanging out. In my opinion, you get more than what you pay for. They use authentic Sicilian recipes and make a mind blowing Antipasto salad. This is because of how particular they are here about the quality of their ingredients. Everyone that I have taken here has really enjoyed their food. I'm pretty sure you will too.
(5)Christopher T.
Amazingly great food. Owner is super nice and friendly. Good prices and very clean inside and out. Taste flavor everything absolutely amazing. First time here found my new home for pizza definitely won't go anywhere else now. If your ever in Gilbert Arizona don't pass up this place without stopping in and grabbing something to eat. Thanks for the great food experience and service.
(5)J P.
There are places that sell pizza and places that sell a pizza like substance (Pizza Hut, Domino's, etc). I would put Brooklyn V's in the category that sell pizza. Started off with the garlic knots. They were very good and the marinara sauce that was served with it was good also. Ordered the 14" white pizza and added pepperoni, onion and garlic. The crust on the pizza was light and crunchy...so that was a good thing. The pizza itself was a tad soupy but good never the less. As it turned out, after the garlic knots (small order) the pizza was more than enough for two with leftovers to go home. From a price perspective the price was a tad high when compared to a place that sells pizza like substance On the other hand it was competitive with places that sell pizza. So if price versus quality is an issue than a place that sells pizza like substance may be more in order.
(4)Mark W.
Great lunch special. The sell slices. It's my go to pizza place now. Prices are good. Pizza is good. Service is good. What more do you want. So tired of chain delvery pizza. Good pizza with a mom and pop feal. Place gets packed at night. I recommend it. Kinda place makes you feal like a regular the first time your there. They also have a small patio.
(5)Aysia D.
Service was a little slow. I like how family is involved. My pasta noodles were under cooked but it was still good.
(4)Lauren H.
Absolutely love this place! Their Margherita pizza is to die for, as well as their bruschetta (you can taste the fresh basil!). You can't go wrong with their hot wings either. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. We tend to order delivery from here and have never been disappointed.
(5)Leeda R.
The food is some of the best Italian food I've had! Great staff very friendly. Jenna waited on us and we loved her! My philly born and bread Italian husband said the food took him back home. I highly recommend this place
(5)Tawnee S.
Service is great! We walked in got seated right away and ordered drinks. Very personal pizza hall. Pizza is delish..they have kick ass crust and I believe a homemade sausage that was mild and tastes yummy. Usually never order sausage and we've had it 3 times. Service was great, checked on us, filled drinks promply. Very enjoyable dinner on a tired Friday night.Ty
(5)Ryan C.
May give it another shot for lunch, but will not be getting delivery again. Ordered through Grubhub, and it took almost 2 hours to arrive. Pizza was cold and tasted like Grocery store pizza. Meatballs were good. Wings were meh.
(2)David P.
Really awesome pasta dishes, I love the fact they don't use sausage in every dish. Wished they had garlic bread as a side. Pizza is good, wife likes it a lot more than I do, probably wouldn't order it if not for her. Side salads are pricey but entrees will leave you enough for lunch the next day and are priced right. Nothing fancy , real casual but yummy.
(4)Alma B.
I am not from New York, I have never been to New York. I have no expectations for pizza based on my old New York neighborhood or from childhood memories. Growing up in Mexico, pizza choices in the small town of Agua Prieta were somewhat limited to a couple of restaurants that served pies that had one thing in common to New York style pizza, the shape was round. Hungry last night, after a very stressful day at work, we wanted some food to be delivered to us. We wanted to be able to order it without hassle and we wanted it delivered fast. Demanding, I know. In this area ,Brooklyn V's Pizza delivered. I ordered it online, in a very easy to use website, they delivered it to my home and took about 45 minutes, which is a great time on a friday night. The pizza we ordered was the buffalo chicken pizza, not a very traditional pie, but I had been wanting to try it. The cost for an 18" pie was $20.00, a little on the expensive side. I was hoping for a delicious pizza, and I am not going to lie, the dough had very good flavor, but that was it. The chicken was extremely salty, to the point that we had to take it off the pizza, which wasn't a big task because there hardly was any chicken on the pizza to begin with, and the worst is the chicken was way too dry, and it hardly had any buffalo sauce in it. So I wasn't too pleased with this pie, but I am sure if I stick to a classic next time, they will do better in this department. We also ordered a cheese calzone with bacon and their garlic knots and those were the highlight of our meal. The calzone was filled with lots of cheese and bacon and tasted delicious. The garlic knots and the accompanying marinara sauce were so delicious we were fighting over them. I would definitely go back to Brooklyn V's pizza and probably eat in and order a more traditional pie or something else off the menu. For a pizza, a calzone and the order of knots I spent $45.00 including delivery and tip.
(3)Sandra D.
Well, I have been enjoying eating at Brooklyn V's for over a year. Guess what? Nothing has changed except, they are busier, and rightly so. Great food, value and service draws people in. Their food is so consistently delicious! No greasy cheap ingredients here. The pizza ranges from $12.00-14.00 for a cheese. Combos are available between $15.00-$20.00 based on size and number of ingredients. Their wings are just outstanding. Big meaty bones. more baked than fried and so yummy. Ladies, enjoy a glass of wine. Good deals for white or red with no nasty after affects from those cheap wines so many places serve. Their standard is comparable to Kendall or the like. Oh, I almost forgot the perks, good entertainment with text notification and points towards free food. You should give them a try. You won't go home broke, hungry or disappointed, but you could leave with leftovers due to their generous portions. Good decision.
(5)J F.
First off we had the garlic knots. They were SO DAMN GOOD. Perfect balance of crispy outside with soft gooey insides and not overly garlic'd. The sauce was made fresh in house and had great flavor. We ordered 12 - 6 would be enough for most people as they are larger than I expected them to be. None survived though :) Excellent pizza. Tried the margherita and was very impressed. The basil was super fresh, as were the tomatoes and it had clumps of gooey real mozzarella. The crust was perfect. If you like NY pizza this is the closest I've found it in AZ. The pepperoni was also very good. Not too greasy with nice flavor. Also, you can order by the slice and it still comes fresh so that was great for lunch. For dessert the Snickers pie was amazing. It was not too sweet which is often something I dislike in those types of pie. The owner, Vito, came over and chatted with us for a bit which was a nice touch and our server Nadine was super friendly and attentive. Dining room and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely be back to try other things off the menu. Hands down crushes Casanova Bros.
(5)Randi S.
Yep we indeed came back for dinner. We had the v's 3 meat pizza. Best pizza I have ever had!!! Still wonderful service. Still relaxing and calming atmosphere. Definitely my favorite restaurant hands down!
(5)Sean S.
FANTASTIC!!! This is a great little find. tucked in the corner, real mom/pop feel. The bread knots were a fun appetizer (amazingly priced) and my family enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. the red sauces were fantastic!! Vito himself even came out and chatted with us for a few. Nice atmosphere, great food, great price. You've got a customer here!!! We'll be back!!
(5)Don S.
Great, friendly service and the pizza's very good. Definitely worth checking out.
(4)Chuck M.
So far ????? It's been a wait for a pickup order --- longest minute ever and seems very disorganized at the cash register--- after 43 minutes still waiting. Wait staff did offer water while we waited but still waiting on that --- pick up order/service is horrendous
(3)Jake A.
Just moved into neighborhood and been trying pizza and wings from places within delivery of my house. The delivery was fast and order was easy to place and pay for. Food was just ok. Nothing to get excited about. Little too expensive for just another pizza place. Will not be going back.
(2)Nadine H.
Amazing food and quality service. The atmosphere is great and the service is phenomenal. The restaurant is fairly new (opened about a year ago) and the staff really makes you feel at home. I'm originally from New York myself, and I absolutely love Brooklyn V's, it makes me homesick in the best kind of way! I've tried all of their pizzas, a few of their dinners and all of their strombolis. The food is incredible. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to ANYONE! I recommend the garlic knots as an appetizer for all first time customers, not only are they a great price, but they are just unbeatable! 5 out of 5 stars, always.
(5)Jim P.
When's the last time you encountered a wine list in a pizza joint? These guys love what they do and do it very well. Seriously fresh ingredients in their menu are prepared and served by a dedicated, friendly staff that know how to do good food. A family friendly atmosphere that is a pleasant step away from the typical chain store pizza place we so often settle for. Great food, good price , convenient location. My new favorite pizza restaurant in Arizona.
(4)Nick R.
First the food is really good, the food alone is a 5 for me and the staff is very nice. The downsides are they had live music inside (not something I'm looking for in Italian restaurant) so we had to sit outside. The cheap Home Depot patio furniture made the situation awkward. All and all the downsides are an easy fix, and I will be going back.
(3)Jennifer E.
This place is delicious! My favs are the pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and spaghetti with meat sauce! If You haven't tried Brooklyn V's, you're missing out!
(5)RillaAnn J.
Been to Brooklyn V's several times since they've open, my complaint isn't the food... Last night my husband tried to order a pizza for take out. It was 845, they close at 9. The young female on the phone stated that they didn't want to make our pizza since they were closing... Wow. Great customer service. We normally aren't those ppl that order for right before close, but we are moving away from the area and that would have been our last time there. Thanks for the great memory.
(1)Andrea D.
I stopped in here after getting my nails done. I wish I would have tried this place sooner. Not only was the customer service fantastic, the food is amazing! I got an anti-pasto salad, the ingredients are fresh and very flavorful.
(5)Max K.
This restaurant is a very pleasant surprise to walk into. With it being kind of tucked in the corner of a shopping center that hasn't seemed to have much success, you would just be expecting a cheap pizza place that doesn't serve much more than average pizza and maybe some wings. Brooklyn V's offers a very pleasant, homey feel when you walk inside and the staff is very friendly. They are very grateful for your business and deliver a menu and quality of food that makes you want to come back for more. Within the last week or two I have already eaten here twice and nothing has yet to disappoint. Portions are extremely generous and the quality of food is something you would expect at a restaurant charging a steeper price. For my first visit, me and my girlfriend split a 12 or 14 inch pizza (can't remember the exact size, but not the largest size) and a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad had just the right amount of dressing and tasted about as good as a Caesar salad can get. It was also served on a chilled plate, which added a nice touch. The size of the salad was quite large and could probably feed at least 3 as an appetizer before the meal. The pizza came out a few minutes later and was quite delicious. A NY style pie that had the right amount of crispness to it, which is tough to come across. Most NY style pizzas are pretty flimsy, but Vito seems to have a great recipe. I am a stickler on Pizza and this easily satisfied me. About as good as I could expect out of a pizza that wasn't cooked in a wood fired brick oven. During my second visit I decided to venture out and try the Bow tie pasta with pesto sauce. I am not a huge pasta person but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and portion size once again. During this visit, we also decided to try Vito's cannolis and that was an EXCELLENT choice. The cannolis were superb and I have been craving them ever since. I would give Brooklyn V's a 4 1/2 star rating if that were possible on yelp. The only things I wish differently would be that the plates were maybe a dollar or two cheaper ($10 for a pasta plate, I think the salad was somewhere between $5.50-7 and then a 1-topping 12 or 14 inch pizza was $16) and I think the speed of service will improve with experience. Overall, Brooklyn V's provides a much higher quality of food and service than you would expect out of a place tucked back in the corner of a Goodwill shopping center, next to a smoke shop. I have encouraged others to try it and the one family that did was very happy, so I hope others enjoy it as well.
(5)Henry D.
I accidently stumbled upon Brooklyn V's last night. I was headed to another pizza place to try for the first time but it was closed. I decided to get a slice and a salad. They get points for offering a slice right off the bat. 1. The crust was perfect, very true to the Brooklyn way. Flavorful. A+ 2. The sauce was very nice, I do like a little more sauce, but it was quality. A+ 3. Ingredients - Sausage- A. Roasted Pepper- A+. Eggplant- A. (It was very good, however it was tossed in tasty bread crumbs, but I do prefer the eggplant without the crumbs.) 4. Salad - I ordered a simple dinner salad with Ceasar dressing. Lettuce was a mix of greens and Romajne. Very crisp and fresh. Ceasar Dressing- A+ 5. Service- I can't comment too much as I was a carry out, but the young lady who took my order was very nice, I didn't ask, but she brought me a glass of water while I waited and that always gets points. She knew the menu well when I was deciding on my order and possible future orders. I will be back to dine in for sure.
(4)Andrew D.
These guys get five stars from me not just because owner is from newyork like myself but the pizza is the best in Arizona. I have found so far especially the buffalo chicken pizza. Great job guys keep it up!
(5)Kristen P.
Phenom eats, seriously! The service is amazing, our favorite server is Anna. She's always there to greet us with a big, family-sized smile and makes sure that everyone is receiving equal care (never sits on her rump, just making sure that everyone is getting the best service!) The food, now THERE is something to BRAG about! My favorite thing to eat so far is the White Eggplant Pizza. This gastronomical concept is so far out of my comfort zone, I didn't know if I was married to an Italian long enough, Glory Be! 13 Years and I was eating eggplant like a pro!. I'm here to tell you it is THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD! We're attempting to hit everything on the menu, so far we've dabbled with Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parmesan, Lasagna, Bruschetta, Baked Ziti, Stuffed Shells, and meatballs and every single thing has been extraordinary in flavor and quality! We have never been disappointed. Try this place, your taste buds will thank you! Oh and don't forget to sign up for the loyalty program, those points add up QUICKLY! Ignore those people that have left unsavory comments. Look at those accounts, one of them ONLY seems to YELP negative reviews and use foul language, really? Do you trust that kind of poppycock, I don't, I let the Cannoli cream talk for themselves?)
(5)Jay J.
Great pizza and great place to bring a group Came here after church had 2 14" pizzas the 3 v's meat pizza and a all cheese Bianca pizza both were great we also had some garlic knots for starters very cheap and very good Loved the setting and the staff, nice open kitchen so you can watch your pizza an food being made The Owner coming and welcoming us and checking on our food was a nice touch too Will definitely be coming back
(5)Cat K.
We moved from NYC 3.5 years ago and could not find authentic pizza, not to mention cannolis. I found Brooklyn Vs on here (yelp) and due to the great reviews decided to try.... YUM YUM YUM. We had the white eggplant pizza, margherita pizza and garlic knots ALL DELICIOUS. As we were getting ready to leave Vito the owner came over and said hello. We told him we could not find good cannolis anywhere, even though we had paid our bill he brought us a few cannolis for us to try... How thoughtful! We will definitely be back to try other things on the menu
(5)Janelle R.
Love this place. I've been three times, once for pizza, then penne in vodka sauce, and most recently spaghetti with meat sauce. Absolutely everything is made fresh and I can taste every bit of it! The sauces are fantastic. Next time I'm trying the pesto. I don't even like pesto, but that's how much I enjoy the food here. The service is great too. Very friendly and warm staff. Feels like home.
(5)Robert J.
First time ordering. We had a pizza (half V's 3 meat/half bianco) wings and garlic knots and everything was really good. We will order again for sure!
(5)Sara S.
All I can can say is wow! This is my first time ordering from here and I ordered via grubhub and after reading reviews on yelp I thought my food would be ridiculously late. Turns out it was 20 minutes early! I ordered the stuffed shells, caprese salad and 2 meatballs. It came with 4 stuffed shells which in and of itself a hearty meal. The caprese salad was not terrible but would have liked to seen riper tomatoes and a tad more salt. The meatballs tasted like they had worshester sauce which is totally not necessary but the sauce they were in was yummy. Back to the shells, everything about it was great! My food arrived piping hot and early! Also their mix of Dr Pepper was on point tonight! I will definitely be ordering from here again!
(5)Shanna G.
Yummy yummy so yummy I love this place. Being from New York, I'm a total pizza snob. I just happened on this place when I was getting my nails done one day and it blew my mind. Reminds me of home. I want to try other menu items but the pizza is just too good to not eat.
(5)Matt B.
There have been a few pizza places in this suite over the years, I tried them all but never went back after trying them out once or twice (and I live pretty much right across the street). Love the food here, owners and servers are very nice and bend over backwards to give you what you want. I've brought friends here and they've enjoyed the food and atmosphere as well!!!
(5)Darius L.
Very Tasty. Way way better than Casa Nova Brothers!!!! Yuk. Guys Keep up the good work. I'll keep coming back if you stay consistent. A little tucked back had to drive around to find you, but pleased I didn't give up the search. If you guys are from New York bring more of that NY goodness out here. Very Very good.!!!!
(4)Sara O.
We LOVE Brooklyn V's. We come here at least once a week. The food is amazing and the service is great. They have added some new girls so be patient, the food is worth the wait anyway. We pretty much have the menu memorized and I haven't eaten anything I haven't liked yet. They are also apart of a great rewards program where you can build up points and earn free food!
(5)Kelly G.
Just stumbled upon this place and so happy I did! The pizza was delicious! The atmosphere was family friendly and the place was very clean. I look forward to trying more things on the menu!
(4)Kristine R.
Delicious! We moved from NYC 2 1/2 years ago and have been to many pizzerias where we have been told it's just like NY pizza and each have fallen short. My husband found this place on Yelp and OMG this is it. Cheese pizza reminds us of back home. We went back today with his brother and family and we ate and ate and ate. Cheese pizza, V3 pizza, eggplant pizza and the bianco pizza--- yum yum yum! The mini zeppolis and cannolis are delish. We are definitely going back to try the calzones and pasta dishes. It's a 20 min drive from home and so worth it.
(5)Heidi H.
Best eggplant Parmesan by far! We've tried the gambit of eggplant parm at other Italian restaurants here in the valley and nothing compares to Brooklyn Vs!!
(4)Thomas G.
The garlic knots are to die for and the eggplant pizza is freaking amazing. The owners Bob and Vito go out of their way to make you feel welcome and these guys do a ton of fundraisers to give back to their local community.
(5)Julie F.
Not a bad place to get take out from. If you are looking for real NY pizza and pasta this is the place for you!
(3)Marissa D.
Absolutely delicious. I couldn't stop eating! I was so full yet it was just so good. Found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try. We are pretty faithful to our regular pizza place but I am so glad we tried this place. My husband and I ordered the stuffed shells and a pepperoni pizza to share. The stuffed shells were definitely some of the best I've ever had! Everything about the food was good. We ordered over Yelp and picked it up with no problems. Definitely will be coming back often.
(5)Kelly V.
This place is incredible - GREAT food, great service - we will definitely be back!
(5)Steve B.
Got takeout on Saturday Night (9/27). It was our first time ordering from them, so we decided to order a cheese pizza. In my opinion, the true litmus test for any pizza is getting the pizza in it 's purest form, plain cheese. Well, Brooklyn V's passed this test with flying colors. The sauce had great flavor and the crust had the right amount of crispness and chewiness. We strive to support only locally owned restaurants, not chains. I love that this place is 2 minutes from our house. We'll be back!
(5)Nawaf H.
Seriously!!! I mean this place got 4.5 stars ! Worst pizza i ever tried , nothing special at all , i ordered for home delivery and got my order after 75 minutes cold , the the pizza tastes horrible . First time and never again
(1)Wilfredo A.
Great service, great pizza, but excellent pasta. It's a weekly tradition for me and my family to grab a meal from here whether it's to go or dinning in. Please don't pass on the knots, spaghetti, baked ziti, wings, or the old classic pepperoni pizza. For those who like a different ambiance make a trip out on Friday or Saturday night. Live music!!! Need I say more???
(5)Cody M.
Our party of 4 ordered the chicken fettuccine alfredo, spaghetti with meat sauce along with a large pizza. Everything was great. I get fettuccine just about everywhere I go and theirs was some of the best. Pizza had a great thin and crispy crust. Great stuff.
(5)Steve C.
New York style thin crust....not even close!! They claim if it's under a 1/2 inch, that's New York style thin crust. And it's chewy! It should be a 1/4 inch and crispy....nice try guys, but no thanks. The sauce is too sweet, I think they are trying to cover up the lack of knowledge on how to make a New York style thin crust.
(1)Cory D.
Tale of two restaurants. Last week we ordered from Brooklyn V 's and it was fantastic all around, we ordered in the afternoon. Tonight we ordered and it was completely opposite so greesy we could not even finish it, we also ordered wings and they were less then average too. Super disappointed especially after our first experience. Way over priced for the quality and lack of attention to detail.
(2)Noelle K.
OMG! THIS IS THE PLACE for an authentic NY Italian meal!!!! My man decided on a whim that I was going to try a new place after he had tried it for lunch. He said he couldn't wait to take me to Brooklyn V's. I am a very picky eater and I am not a fan of chains so I was really happy to support a small business that really knows its business! We started with these little bread things they call garlic knots that come with marinara YUM! This was starting out fantastic. You can tell a lot from the marinara, ya know ;) We each ordered a Stromboli and they were to die for! I could have cut it lengthwise and just crawled in, they do kinda look like sleeping bags. You know when you taste something so good the world just kinda stops spinning? Yeah......Oh sorry! We took a tiramisu home to split for later. The waitress said it was heaven in a box. I haven't had too much luck with tiramisu here in AZ so I wasn't too excited. A couple hours later her words were still echoing in my head and I just had to taste it. Fireworks shot off! The band started playing and suddenly I was in Italy! Reluctantly I put the other half (well almost half, he he) back in the fridge for my man. The liquor license is coming folks!
(5)Danny A.
This is the real deal.Born and raised ny'er here and this is as good as it gets in the east valley.Now if they sold slices over the counter without the wait service,and Sicilian pies,it'd be like I was back home.Forget Casanova,they would be closed down in 6 months if they were back east.No comparison.
(5)Jim W.
A very Friendly staff. Everything tasted scratch made. From the Fresh cut romaine, cherry tomatoes, the touch of black olive slices and a bit of red onion in the house salad, to the DELICIOUS chicken fettuccine Alfredo. I've never had so much tasty Alfredo sauce in one bowl of fresh made pasta. The bread that came with the meal was melt in your mouth, just out of the oven, fresh baked too. This cozy family place is one you should try.
(5)Kimberly C.
Visited last night for dinner with friends. Our party of 4 split a large 18" pepperoni pizza and an order of 12 garlic knots. The food was EXCELLENT! I think the dough/crust MAKES the pizza and Brooklyn V's has it down pat. This space has been occupied by a few pizza joints since I've lived in the area and I've never been too impressed - but I'll definitely be back to Brooklyn V's. Other +'s: *Cannoli's - Very good! *Iced Tea - Fresh! *Friendly staff *Nice family/owners that took the time to say hello and welcome us to their establishment.
(5)Reco J.
Let me tell you something and you would be wise to listen!! Since I moved to AZ I have searched for real good back east Italian food that did not require me to drive and sit down at a table. Brooklyn V's is a Blessing, I love there eggplant, and pizza and OMG! The cannoli is straight off the boat. Plus I can order online and it gets to my house in less than 20 mins and hot. Thank you for being you! Reco
(5)Kaitlyn S.
I arrived at this establishment on a Friday around 7:30pm. Overall I was pretty impressed with the food, in which me and a group had ordered a large white pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was excellent and is comparable to somewhere such as Gilbert Pizza. However, the down side to this restaurant is the service. Every time I have made a visit here I have waited quite a bit of time to receive r any service. Expect to wait and plan your time accordingly, inside is a little cramped but this place makes you feel at home.
(3)David F.
Great food, staff and atmosphere! We had our local lunch club here and it was great! I would recommend everyone to try the ziti as well as the pizza!
(5)Christina L.
Great food, great customer service. We are from NY and really are thrilled to have amazing pizza and cannoli in Gilbert! Will be back again for sure.
(5)Darlene c.
Can't eat pizza anywhere else now !!! Close my eyes and feel like in Brooklyn eating Bay Pizza by train in Sheepshead Bay.. and their sauce is delicious. ...and they leave the the bubbled pockets of dough and don't pop them like other places!! Cannoli's perfectly sweet, garlic knots w/fresh chopped garlic perfectly crisp on outside and yummy on inside!! This is my only place for Italian food now.. and owner is friendly as is waitstaff.. Enjoy the food every time I come here, it is worth the trip no matter how far..
(5)Kelly G.
I like to say that this is a hidden gem in Gilbert. I dont usually like Italian food but this was authentic and home grown. It was the best experience I have had and it was so cute and quaint. I could take my kids and they enjoyed it also. The owner is really friendly and good people.
(5)Joe A.
Very friendly restaurant, fast service and the food was absolutely fantastic. Had an ice cold beer to start, pizza was totally East coast and the ricotta shells with meat sauce. Bob served, Vito prepared and I wouldn't have known that if they weren't so friendly. I will be back!!
(5)Ray N.
Love this place. Love their food.As authentic to NY Italian as it gets here in Az. Very nice, cozy atmosphere with great service from our waitress Allora. We were a party of 12 last night and everyone was raving about their dishes. The cheese pizza here is superb : perfect crust, great sauce and just the right mix of cheese. Eggplant parm was the best I have had in years and their calzones are amazing. Cooked just right and everything blended well. My experience in Az with other restaurants trying to make Calzones has been so so with most just throwing the stuff in hoping it gels. The owner Vito has been doing this for 30 years and certainly brings that and more to this awesome place. My new favorite place in Gilbert.
(5)Gordon G.
We had Spaghetti and Meat Sauce and Zita. The Meat Sauce was one of the best we ever had. The music was "Sinatra/Martin" and it felt like we belonged. Great place to eat, food was excellent.
(5)Andy L.
Placed a rather simple pick up order-small pepperoni pizza. I was not told a price on the phone, I figured it would be in the 10 dollar range. Lesson learned, never assume anything! When i got there, I paid over 15$, which, I'm sorry is EXCESSIVE! They need to sprinkle gold or something on there to make it worth the money at that price. Either way, I paid since I did order it and figured if it was a really good pizza it was worth it. Needless to say I was further disappointed when I got home and started eating it-now, I don't have extremely high standards when it comes to pizza-I love dominos, pizza hut, you name it-but the sauce was bland and had no taste to it. I lived in Boston for many years and have visited NYC many times; believe me when I tell you, this place has nothing, and I mean NOTHING in common with NY pizza. I was disappointed and won't be back.
(1)Mike K.
We ordered 2 stromboli's, thinking we were getting NY style stromboli's, but what we got were 2 loaves of bread with a little bit of filling. For starters, ANY time I've ever ordered a stromboli, much less 2 of them, it has had to come out in a pizza box due to the size of them. But when 2 of them came out together fitting on ONE paper plate, I was already highly disappointed considering the $22 price tag. Once getting home and beginning to slice them up, the first 2 inches of the end was all bread, and as we started getting in through the rest of it, the crust of it was so think and breadlike, there was no room for filling. I've attached some photos to showcase the size and filling. Past all that, taste was only... ehh. The Eggplant parm stromboli was very bland and sausage and meatball stromboli was mediocre at best. I never leave bad feedback on these kinds of sites, but this one we felt needed to be addressed. Just know what you're getting when you order a "stromboli" there.
(1)Tami C.
Being from the East Coast, it is hard to find an authentic New York pizza in AZ. Brooklyn V's is FANTASTIC!!!! Takes me back home.... The crust is fantastic with just the right amount of cheese. We've been here several times but haven't ordered anything other than pizza yet. Based on the other reviews, trying the Stromboli next. Check this place out, you won't be sorry!
(5)Kristin H.
I got the lunch special, 2 slices and a soda for $5.75. I think it's a great deal and the pizza was delicious. I'm picky when it comes to my pizza crust and they didn't burn it which was great. Sometimes places that have thinner crust blacken their pizza before it comes to the table but it arrived hot and the perfect crispiness. This place is tucked away in a strip mall, but it doesn't take away from the great prices and good food.
(4)Dan A.
Just tried Brooklyn's based on Yelp reviews. Pizza is outstanding. Will definitely be back. Upon entering this place you can tell right away this is a family run establishment. Very genuinely friendly staff. I noticed the other patrons and there were smiles at every table. Next time, I'm going for the sausage and peppers hero. It looks amazingly delicious.
(4)Emily B.
We had some amazingly fresh bruschetta here as well as some very richly flavored lasagna, garlic knots and cannolis. We had excellent service and our server was very attentive. Additionally she and the other staff were so passionate about their food and the restaurant that it was contagious. We were truly blown away by this place! The food beat out some of the street crap I had in Rome over the summer!
(5)Annette A.
Finally found REAL NY style pizza in the East Valley! The pizza Margherita and Eggplant parmesan Hero were delicious! The owners were very friendly and made us feel very welcome. New Yorkers you gotta come here!
(5)Mike S.
I tried this place today, and I was impressed. I had the 2 pizza slice & drink lunch special. The margherita pizza was fantastic. The crust was thin & crispy, which I usually don't like because other pizzerias either make it too hard or too limp. This crust was incredible. They also have delivery service. I will not order chain pizza again.
(4)Hanna F.
Well, once again I tried it for chance. Still the rude son of a bitch New Yorkers with extremely high prices for the shit they serve. Let me tell you, GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT.
(1)Julie S.
So good!!! Real east coast Italiano!!! Some favorites - eggplant parm - very authentic, thinly sliced!! Ask for Desiree - awesome waitress with good recommendations.
(5)Anne J.
A most go to place!!! You can taste the freshness, you can tell they make the dough daily. Amazing
(5)Maria N.
Went to Brooklyn V's last night for dinner for the first time with my family. I was intrigued because they were from Staten Island so I figured they knew good pizza. It is hard to find a good "pie" out in AZ. The restaurant did not disappoint. We had the Margherita and the White Eggplant Pizza's. They we amazing. The dough was light and thin. The sauce was perfect. Not to thick and acidic. The eggplant pizza is a must. I can't wait to go back again and try the dinner selections. The staff was so friendly. It actually felt like a "family". Highly recommended. They deliver and cater also!
(5)Sue L.
Very good pizza, delivered on time! I ordered garlic knots because of someone else's recommendation. The dipping sauce is excellent. The knots need more garlic.
(4)Rachael W.
Pizza was average for New York style. Delivery was pretty quick but the pizza was cold and way over-priced. 25 dollars for one pizza is a little ridiculous.
(3)Vanessa J.
my husband and I visited here as a recommendation from our neighbor. Had the pizza the first time it was excellent. Took the family there for a second trip had the Stromboli and the shells. Food and service was again excellent. Waitress even gave our granddaughter her own special treat. Will definitely visit again
(4)Julie B.
Brooklyn V's opened 3 weeks ago and is having typical start-up issues with a new young staff. But, that's the only area that needs improvement! I wanted to try Brooklyn V's because as I was sitting at the stop light at Lindsey and Warner - the most wonderful pizza aroma drifted across the intersection. I told my husband, based on the aroma alone we needed to try this place. The FOOD IS WONDERFUL and definitely lived up to the tantalizing aroma! We ordered house salads and the Sausage and Pepper Stromboli. We didn't receive the Stromboli we ordered, however we kept the dish brought because the crust was so crispy and light, the cheese was perfectly stringy and gooey, and the combination of meats inside tender and tasty. Paired with their marinara sauce, we couldn't send it back - it was that good! One of the owners stopped by to check on our dinner. When we let her know what happened, she "comped" us Cannolis for dessert. The plate was chilled and the presentation was something I would have expected from a more upper end restaurant. We are so glad to have Brooklyn V's in our neighborhood and within walking distance! We'll be returning again and again to try the other items on the menu - which we expect will be equally flavorful.
(4)Joyce S.
Very low key, but nice server, great food (huge portions) and just satisfied my pasta craving. Only wish they had beer.......
(3)Robert G.
I've eaten their food three times. Two times I've eaten there and once had a pizza delivered. What was funny is the guy taking my pizza order told me the price and stopped talking. I was waiting for him to ask me my cc info. I think he thought I was balking at the price because he told me, "You realize our pizzas are not the $5 kind?" I laughed and said I don't eat $5 pizzas! He got a kick out of that and the pie was delivered warm and tasty! I was a bachelor that weekend and the large lasted me both Saturday and Sunday. Nothing like pizza for breakfast baby! Both times I visited there the food was really good. The first time I had the chicken Marsala and loved it. The second time I had the lasagne with meat sauce and my wife had the chicken cacciatore. She ate everything on her plate and loved it. I got full on half of the lasagne and had the other half for lunch the next day. Both times the lasagne was delicious. We live close by so we'll be going back again for sure. My wife and I aren't really into hearing cover music when we eat, we like to talk. The only thing I haven't appreciated about the place was the Elvis impersonator singing when we went on a Saturday night. Good singer but everything he sang was in the Elvis style...George Straight in an Elvis style...not for me thank you. Of course I did tip the gentleman because he has talent. We are looking forward to the weather cooling so we can sit either inside or out, where ever the singer is not.
(5)Amanda A.
I am originally from NYC and moved to Arizona close to 2 years ago. I found out about this place from a random New Yorker I met. To say the least, this place is amazing. I go to Brooklyn V's all the time. I feel a price of home and nostalgia when I walk in. I spent about a year and a half trying to find good NY pizza and did not find it, until I went to Brooklyn V's. I won't eat any other pizza, except for theirs. Not only do they have great pizza, they offer amazing pasta dishes, desserts, and their staff is the greatest. I will always be a New Yorker and their food makes me miss/appreciate the NY style of food.
(5)Mark L.
We celebrated my daughter's first birthday here last night and could not have been more impressed. My wife reserved a table for our party and the staff was not only accommodating, but went above and beyond by decorating our table with balloons, birthday napkins and even had a special candle for the cake. The food was phenomenal. My party tried garlic knots, spaghetti and pizza. Everything tasted delicious and the pizza was excellent. Cheese, sauce, garlic, pepperoni, spinach and dough all came together perfectly. Beer and wine were very reasonably priced and the live music completed the night. The staff was very attentive to our needs and I cannot say enough about how welcomed they made all of us feel. This is a family owned business that shows tremendous pride in quality and preparation of food and care for their patrons. A big thank you to the entire staff at Brooklyn V's for making my daughter's first birthday one that we will never forget.
(5)Danielle C.
Great service!! Great food!! It's been difficult finding Stromboli in Arizona but Brooklyn V's do it and they do it right!!! I had the Stromboli with sausage, pepperoni and meatballs! They did not skimp out on meat or cheese!!! It was oozing cheese!!! So delicious!! We will be back to try the pizzas and pastas which all look amazing! Everyone was super friendly and made us feel welcome. I even saw the owner come out and shake hands with patrons. This is why it's so important to support local businesses especially when they are as worthy as this one!!! Can't wait to go back!!
(5)Tom A.
Great people and food . Everything we tried is good. We happen to like the white pizza.
(5)Lori E.
I am from ny and i have to say this place has the best pizza and calzones I havent had anything elst tho
(5)Donna B.
This place has quickly become my favorite local joint to get food! I love the food and the chance to get out of my house and sit down somewhere else with TV, a drink, and Italian food. My favorite dishes are the Chicken Marsala and the chicken and mozzarella (add mushrooms) calzone. The garlic knot appetizers are addictive! They come with a side of homemade marinara and are to die for. The bruschetta is pretty good. The chicken parm here is also very well done. Though I haven't tried it yet, their pizza seems to be very popular. The service is usually pretty good. Anna is the best!! Also, they deliver!! They have TVs, booths, tables, and outside seating. The tables in the middle can accommodate small groups.
(5)April G.
We ordered and picked up our food. The phone was picked up promptly and the lady that was taking the order was very nice and informative. We ordered the Bianco pizza, stuffed shells and cannolis. Our order was ready in 20min. The lady at the counter was very friendly and quick to grab our food. The food was about $30 which isn't to bad. The pizza was awesome! It has fresh ingredients and the mozzarella was soooo good!!! The stuffed shells were seasoned wonderfully with some really tasty marinara. Lastly the cannolis tasted like my grandmothers which is saying a lot in a great way. :) They had chocolate chips with a slightly sweet ricotta filling. Other places tend to make these to sweet which ruins them. You have to have the right balance of sweetness, crunch and creaminess from the ricotta. Soooo this place gets a thumbs up!! Yum!
(5)Robert G.
Went there first time with my sons and the pizza is outstanding! The only issue is we did not feel welcome, the service is excellent but the manager that day made visits to the other tables except ours, that i think is Not good buisness or good management! What am i? Chopped liver Lost my business and was planning to my it my regular pizza place,NOT NOW!
(3)kim s.
Had spaghetti meatballs and vodka penne comparable to las Vegas quality pastas five stars!
(5)Don S.
Great, friendly service and the pizza's very good. Definitely worth checking out.
(4)Raymond D.
Ordered an eggplant parm hero and side order of meatballs. Both were solid. Meatballs could have been a bit bigger but other then that they were tasty. Being it was my first visit there and I wanted to add on a slice to my order ,Desireé set me up with a free slice of pizza while I waited for my take out order. I can say it definitely holds up to Long Island pizza. I will be back for sure.
(5)Matthew G.
I was really excited walking in and hearing all the accents and such, but if this is New York pizza, I'd rather stick with Arizona. Pizza was not terrible, but the sauce was way too watery. Everything slid off of our pizza. They also seemed to be big on the oil as well. Both the pizza and knots had excessive amounts of oil. The service was great and the staff was friendly, which is why I say 3 stars. Would I return? No. Not with all the great choices in the area. $28 for a med pizza, knots, and drink.
(3)Mark B.
First of all, when you're here, you're family. The hospitality here is unparalleled. When time permits, Vito, the owner, and the crew will be sure to stop by, introduce themselves and drop a friendly hello. It's so nice to come to such a wonderful Italian restaurant and have authentic cuisine. Vito definitely takes pride in his work and the staff delivers. When you come, request Desiree and tell her Mark and Cristina recommended her. Enjoy the amazing food and ambiance. Support your local Italianos and enjoy what Vito and his staff is proud to serve you! Till next time, ciao!
(5)BARRY B.
You search for a real New York pizza, especially if you come from Brooklyn. This place comes thisclose. Vito has the "touch". The pizza is delicious. Their marinara is wonderful and the garlic knots are like Brooklyn's best. It was also amazing that there were a lot of N.Y. ex-pats the evening we were there.
(4)Alia K.
Wanted to try a new place for lunch and found a gem. Not only did I have a great experience, but the food was amazing too. Bob and Desiree are the sweetest people and helped me custom my lunch order. A very pleasant and clean environment. I'll definitely be coming back.
(5)Harvey S.
A friend wanted to try this place, being that it's local and they have a doo-wap group performing...at least this Saturday. We had brushetta and garlic knots for the table. The brushetta had plenty of fresh tomatoes and basil, among other things. The garlic knots had minced garlic butter...more flavorful than garlic butter with powder. The margherita pizza was very flavorful...it had chopped tomatoes and a crust crispy and NY-style...thinner, but not too thin. And the musical group was really fun, but does not allow for good conversation if you're sitting nearby. The waitstaff was good natured and stopped by enough to check up on us, refill drinks, despite being a busy night. Recommended.
(4)Val M.
I looooove this place. Food is always delicious, service is great, and always very quick/reliable with delivery. Highly recommended!
(5)Travis L.
Great chicken parm. tonight, they forgot my side Caesar though. I gave five stars on my first review.
(3)MikeNikki G.
Great food and great service. Kid friendly, but food is grown-up worthy. We will definitely be back.
(5)Tyler S.
Was enjoying a night of swimming in the 100+ degree weather and wanted something good, quick and delivered to our door. Brooklyn V's fit the bill! Food was delivered under the estimated time and was piping hot. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, chicken stromboli and honey bbq wings and all were amazing! Will definitely order again.
(5)Tamara R.
Really glad I read the reviews on the buffalo chicken pizza and ordered it because that was delicious! Two pizzas and a 6 piece garlic knots was really quite expensive to have delivered though. Otherwise I'd give it a full 5. Really tasty food though!
(4)Becky C.
I am astounded at the quality of this "hole in the wall" find. Between a smoke shop and a cleaners, Brooklyn V's has blown me away. Pizza shop? No, this is a Brooklyn restaurant in the heart of Mesa, AZ. I had spaghetti in clam sauce. Where do I begin? The pasta was al dente. That's the first step to proving you care a bit about your food. Next is tender clams, a TON of them, in a perfect sauce, mild with a hint of wine and garlic, sprinkled with parm and served with crusty Italian bread, baked locally and only sold to a choice few restaurants. It absorbs the sauce perfectly, melting in the buttery, garlicky goodness. There are only a few beers on tap. I had the Shock Rock Belgian White, a perfect compliment to the light sauce and simple meal. I was sent here by a local, the guy at Stamps Automotive, while they work on my car. I cannot thank him enough.
(5)Scott C.
Amazing food - Amazing owners and staff! Atmosphere is "Cheers" like. If you are considering trying but unsure - have no fear - You will not be disappointed!!
(5)Nick B.
First timer and not bad def worth trying. Tried the eggplant and pizza very delicious...
(5)Brandon B.
The service here is phenomenal. The entire staff makes you feel like you're a part of their family. I recommend you make your way here. I've been 5 times in the last 2 weeks. thank you for providing the best service in the Gilbert area. Furthermore the Pizza is AMAZING!!! You can't find pizza this good unless you're in Brooklyn!
(5)Dan A.
Wow! I popped in for lunch on a Tuesday and was kindly greeted by Bob, one of the owners. I sat down for lunch and thought I'd give their pizza and Stromboli a try. The pizza was good. I'm from NJ, and I was very impressed. It's on par with some of the other NY style pizza places in Gilbert. The Stromboli, though... Out of this world. I saw how big it was and I figured I'd get through half after a slice of pizza, but I couldn't leave any of it. The dough was flavorful, crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. There was a ton of cheese! One of the best I ever had and it's made from scratch, so it takes about 20min of you just walk in. Absolutely worth it! Thanks Bob for a great experience! I know where I'm going for my pizza fix from now on!
(5)Mike S.
Everything here is amazing. Garlic Knotts. Chicken Marsala, and the pizza is top notch. I am an east coast pizza snob and this pizza is LEGIT! !!! Come and try this place you won't be disappointed.
(5)Mike D.
Maybe I'm a pizza snob.....been eating it for over 25 years now......thought I would try something new.....I have my five or so great places.......I get a pie once if not twice a week.....read some reviews on yelp, thought I would give this place a try.....made the mistake of not going to their website.....ordered off of yelp.....35 bones for a pizza and 6 wings and a couple of knots........so not worth it.....wings were dry.....the sausage on pizza looked liked chopped up hot dogs.....I'm not one to complain on food....but when I'm dropping almost 40 bills on a pizza and six wings I better have a great experience.....I'd take a little ceaser hot and ready any day over this.....I try and support local mom and pop shops....but when a pizza costs almost half a C note.....your not reaching out to your mom and pop customers
(1)Andrew O.
Margherita pizza. Great crust, crunchy yet chewy. Sauce has a nice sweetness to it. They also do a frequent flyer type program as well.
(5)Sara E.
$18 for a medium margarita pizza? This better blow my mind. Unfortunately, it was just "good". I would have given it 4 stars if it was appropriately priced.
(3)Samantha G.
This was our first time at Brooklyn V's. We had the garlic knots, sausage, meatball, and pepperoni stromboli, and sausage and peppers hero. The stromboli was amazing! Other reviews have shown that is was more bread and small amount of meat, which was not the case! We will definately be back!
(5)John M.
This is a local mom & pop that you could easily mistake for a chain restaurant once you go inside. For now, its the one and only.:) It strikes an expertly crafted balance between the look of a fine dining establishment and a lounge, all while providing the comfort and ease of a fast casual restaurant. There are nice marble counters at the bar, where you can relax and order a beer or a glass of wine, and an outdoor patio with comfortable seating you could easily spend hours in. What's more, is that there is often live music on Saturdays, which is another plus, and their events makes it a great place for families, couples, and friends hanging out. In my opinion, you get more than what you pay for. They use authentic Sicilian recipes and make a mind blowing Antipasto salad. This is because of how particular they are here about the quality of their ingredients. Everyone that I have taken here has really enjoyed their food. I'm pretty sure you will too.
(5)Christopher T.
Amazingly great food. Owner is super nice and friendly. Good prices and very clean inside and out. Taste flavor everything absolutely amazing. First time here found my new home for pizza definitely won't go anywhere else now. If your ever in Gilbert Arizona don't pass up this place without stopping in and grabbing something to eat. Thanks for the great food experience and service.
(5)J P.
There are places that sell pizza and places that sell a pizza like substance (Pizza Hut, Domino's, etc). I would put Brooklyn V's in the category that sell pizza. Started off with the garlic knots. They were very good and the marinara sauce that was served with it was good also. Ordered the 14" white pizza and added pepperoni, onion and garlic. The crust on the pizza was light and crunchy...so that was a good thing. The pizza itself was a tad soupy but good never the less. As it turned out, after the garlic knots (small order) the pizza was more than enough for two with leftovers to go home. From a price perspective the price was a tad high when compared to a place that sells pizza like substance On the other hand it was competitive with places that sell pizza. So if price versus quality is an issue than a place that sells pizza like substance may be more in order.
(4)Mark W.
Great lunch special. The sell slices. It's my go to pizza place now. Prices are good. Pizza is good. Service is good. What more do you want. So tired of chain delvery pizza. Good pizza with a mom and pop feal. Place gets packed at night. I recommend it. Kinda place makes you feal like a regular the first time your there. They also have a small patio.
(5)Aysia D.
Service was a little slow. I like how family is involved. My pasta noodles were under cooked but it was still good.
(4)Bryan M.
Everything is fresh! I was first pleased at how good the ranch dressing was, light, not heavy. I ordered pizza, which was great, but immediately thought the baked ziti looked so good...I'll be back! The price is super for the quality and I'd recommend anyone that likes New York style pizza give this place a try.
(5)Lauren H.
Absolutely love this place! Their Margherita pizza is to die for, as well as their bruschetta (you can taste the fresh basil!). You can't go wrong with their hot wings either. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. We tend to order delivery from here and have never been disappointed.
(5)David H.
Exceptional pizza- I especially enjoyed the margherita pizza. I added garlic to it, which ended up being a good choice. The garlic knots are great, and the desserts are homemade and really, really good. Had the cannoli and the tiramisu. Also, incredibly good, friendly service. :-)
(4)Leeda R.
The food is some of the best Italian food I've had! Great staff very friendly. Jenna waited on us and we loved her! My philly born and bread Italian husband said the food took him back home. I highly recommend this place
(5)Tawnee S.
Service is great! We walked in got seated right away and ordered drinks. Very personal pizza hall. Pizza is delish..they have kick ass crust and I believe a homemade sausage that was mild and tastes yummy. Usually never order sausage and we've had it 3 times. Service was great, checked on us, filled drinks promply. Very enjoyable dinner on a tired Friday night.Ty
(5)David P.
Really awesome pasta dishes, I love the fact they don't use sausage in every dish. Wished they had garlic bread as a side. Pizza is good, wife likes it a lot more than I do, probably wouldn't order it if not for her. Side salads are pricey but entrees will leave you enough for lunch the next day and are priced right. Nothing fancy , real casual but yummy.
(4)Ryan C.
May give it another shot for lunch, but will not be getting delivery again. Ordered through Grubhub, and it took almost 2 hours to arrive. Pizza was cold and tasted like Grocery store pizza. Meatballs were good. Wings were meh.
(2)Alma B.
I am not from New York, I have never been to New York. I have no expectations for pizza based on my old New York neighborhood or from childhood memories. Growing up in Mexico, pizza choices in the small town of Agua Prieta were somewhat limited to a couple of restaurants that served pies that had one thing in common to New York style pizza, the shape was round. Hungry last night, after a very stressful day at work, we wanted some food to be delivered to us. We wanted to be able to order it without hassle and we wanted it delivered fast. Demanding, I know. In this area ,Brooklyn V's Pizza delivered. I ordered it online, in a very easy to use website, they delivered it to my home and took about 45 minutes, which is a great time on a friday night. The pizza we ordered was the buffalo chicken pizza, not a very traditional pie, but I had been wanting to try it. The cost for an 18" pie was $20.00, a little on the expensive side. I was hoping for a delicious pizza, and I am not going to lie, the dough had very good flavor, but that was it. The chicken was extremely salty, to the point that we had to take it off the pizza, which wasn't a big task because there hardly was any chicken on the pizza to begin with, and the worst is the chicken was way too dry, and it hardly had any buffalo sauce in it. So I wasn't too pleased with this pie, but I am sure if I stick to a classic next time, they will do better in this department. We also ordered a cheese calzone with bacon and their garlic knots and those were the highlight of our meal. The calzone was filled with lots of cheese and bacon and tasted delicious. The garlic knots and the accompanying marinara sauce were so delicious we were fighting over them. I would definitely go back to Brooklyn V's pizza and probably eat in and order a more traditional pie or something else off the menu. For a pizza, a calzone and the order of knots I spent $45.00 including delivery and tip.
(3)Chuck M.
So far ????? It's been a wait for a pickup order --- longest minute ever and seems very disorganized at the cash register--- after 43 minutes still waiting. Wait staff did offer water while we waited but still waiting on that --- pick up order/service is horrendous
(3)Jake A.
Just moved into neighborhood and been trying pizza and wings from places within delivery of my house. The delivery was fast and order was easy to place and pay for. Food was just ok. Nothing to get excited about. Little too expensive for just another pizza place. Will not be going back.
(2)J F.
First off we had the garlic knots. They were SO DAMN GOOD. Perfect balance of crispy outside with soft gooey insides and not overly garlic'd. The sauce was made fresh in house and had great flavor. We ordered 12 - 6 would be enough for most people as they are larger than I expected them to be. None survived though :) Excellent pizza. Tried the margherita and was very impressed. The basil was super fresh, as were the tomatoes and it had clumps of gooey real mozzarella. The crust was perfect. If you like NY pizza this is the closest I've found it in AZ. The pepperoni was also very good. Not too greasy with nice flavor. Also, you can order by the slice and it still comes fresh so that was great for lunch. For dessert the Snickers pie was amazing. It was not too sweet which is often something I dislike in those types of pie. The owner, Vito, came over and chatted with us for a bit which was a nice touch and our server Nadine was super friendly and attentive. Dining room and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely be back to try other things off the menu. Hands down crushes Casanova Bros.
(5)Kim L.
My new favorite pizza place! We ordered for pickup through online app (which made it very easy) and was ready in exactly 20mins. Staff was friendly and place was clean. The ONLY reason I am not giving 5 stars is because of their limited specialty pizza choices. There are 8 very different specialty choices, all of which had 3 toppings or less, so if you like alot of toppings you'd pay extra per topping. We ordered the 3 meat pizza and added olives for my toddler for extra $2 but there wasn't much olives at all considering the extra topping fee. So if you wanted a typical "supreme" style pizza with meats and veggies, you'd pay close to $20-25 which is a lot for a 14in pizza.
(4)Sean S.
FANTASTIC!!! This is a great little find. tucked in the corner, real mom/pop feel. The bread knots were a fun appetizer (amazingly priced) and my family enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. the red sauces were fantastic!! Vito himself even came out and chatted with us for a few. Nice atmosphere, great food, great price. You've got a customer here!!! We'll be back!!
(5)Randi S.
Yep we indeed came back for dinner. We had the v's 3 meat pizza. Best pizza I have ever had!!! Still wonderful service. Still relaxing and calming atmosphere. Definitely my favorite restaurant hands down!
(5)Sandra D.
Well, I have been enjoying eating at Brooklyn V's for over a year. Guess what? Nothing has changed except, they are busier, and rightly so. Great food, value and service draws people in. Their food is so consistently delicious! No greasy cheap ingredients here. The pizza ranges from $12.00-14.00 for a cheese. Combos are available between $15.00-$20.00 based on size and number of ingredients. Their wings are just outstanding. Big meaty bones. more baked than fried and so yummy. Ladies, enjoy a glass of wine. Good deals for white or red with no nasty after affects from those cheap wines so many places serve. Their standard is comparable to Kendall or the like. Oh, I almost forgot the perks, good entertainment with text notification and points towards free food. You should give them a try. You won't go home broke, hungry or disappointed, but you could leave with leftovers due to their generous portions. Good decision.
(5)Nadine H.
Amazing food and quality service. The atmosphere is great and the service is phenomenal. The restaurant is fairly new (opened about a year ago) and the staff really makes you feel at home. I'm originally from New York myself, and I absolutely love Brooklyn V's, it makes me homesick in the best kind of way! I've tried all of their pizzas, a few of their dinners and all of their strombolis. The food is incredible. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to ANYONE! I recommend the garlic knots as an appetizer for all first time customers, not only are they a great price, but they are just unbeatable! 5 out of 5 stars, always.
(5)Jim P.
When's the last time you encountered a wine list in a pizza joint? These guys love what they do and do it very well. Seriously fresh ingredients in their menu are prepared and served by a dedicated, friendly staff that know how to do good food. A family friendly atmosphere that is a pleasant step away from the typical chain store pizza place we so often settle for. Great food, good price , convenient location. My new favorite pizza restaurant in Arizona.
(4)Nick R.
First the food is really good, the food alone is a 5 for me and the staff is very nice. The downsides are they had live music inside (not something I'm looking for in Italian restaurant) so we had to sit outside. The cheap Home Depot patio furniture made the situation awkward. All and all the downsides are an easy fix, and I will be going back.
(3)Jennifer E.
This place is delicious! My favs are the pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and spaghetti with meat sauce! If You haven't tried Brooklyn V's, you're missing out!
(5)RillaAnn J.
Been to Brooklyn V's several times since they've open, my complaint isn't the food... Last night my husband tried to order a pizza for take out. It was 845, they close at 9. The young female on the phone stated that they didn't want to make our pizza since they were closing... Wow. Great customer service. We normally aren't those ppl that order for right before close, but we are moving away from the area and that would have been our last time there. Thanks for the great memory.
(1)Andrea D.
I stopped in here after getting my nails done. I wish I would have tried this place sooner. Not only was the customer service fantastic, the food is amazing! I got an anti-pasto salad, the ingredients are fresh and very flavorful.
(5)Andrew D.
These guys get five stars from me not just because owner is from newyork like myself but the pizza is the best in Arizona. I have found so far especially the buffalo chicken pizza. Great job guys keep it up!
(5)Max K.
This restaurant is a very pleasant surprise to walk into. With it being kind of tucked in the corner of a shopping center that hasn't seemed to have much success, you would just be expecting a cheap pizza place that doesn't serve much more than average pizza and maybe some wings. Brooklyn V's offers a very pleasant, homey feel when you walk inside and the staff is very friendly. They are very grateful for your business and deliver a menu and quality of food that makes you want to come back for more. Within the last week or two I have already eaten here twice and nothing has yet to disappoint. Portions are extremely generous and the quality of food is something you would expect at a restaurant charging a steeper price. For my first visit, me and my girlfriend split a 12 or 14 inch pizza (can't remember the exact size, but not the largest size) and a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad had just the right amount of dressing and tasted about as good as a Caesar salad can get. It was also served on a chilled plate, which added a nice touch. The size of the salad was quite large and could probably feed at least 3 as an appetizer before the meal. The pizza came out a few minutes later and was quite delicious. A NY style pie that had the right amount of crispness to it, which is tough to come across. Most NY style pizzas are pretty flimsy, but Vito seems to have a great recipe. I am a stickler on Pizza and this easily satisfied me. About as good as I could expect out of a pizza that wasn't cooked in a wood fired brick oven. During my second visit I decided to venture out and try the Bow tie pasta with pesto sauce. I am not a huge pasta person but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and portion size once again. During this visit, we also decided to try Vito's cannolis and that was an EXCELLENT choice. The cannolis were superb and I have been craving them ever since. I would give Brooklyn V's a 4 1/2 star rating if that were possible on yelp. The only things I wish differently would be that the plates were maybe a dollar or two cheaper ($10 for a pasta plate, I think the salad was somewhere between $5.50-7 and then a 1-topping 12 or 14 inch pizza was $16) and I think the speed of service will improve with experience. Overall, Brooklyn V's provides a much higher quality of food and service than you would expect out of a place tucked back in the corner of a Goodwill shopping center, next to a smoke shop. I have encouraged others to try it and the one family that did was very happy, so I hope others enjoy it as well.
(5)Henry D.
I accidently stumbled upon Brooklyn V's last night. I was headed to another pizza place to try for the first time but it was closed. I decided to get a slice and a salad. They get points for offering a slice right off the bat. 1. The crust was perfect, very true to the Brooklyn way. Flavorful. A+ 2. The sauce was very nice, I do like a little more sauce, but it was quality. A+ 3. Ingredients - Sausage- A. Roasted Pepper- A+. Eggplant- A. (It was very good, however it was tossed in tasty bread crumbs, but I do prefer the eggplant without the crumbs.) 4. Salad - I ordered a simple dinner salad with Ceasar dressing. Lettuce was a mix of greens and Romajne. Very crisp and fresh. Ceasar Dressing- A+ 5. Service- I can't comment too much as I was a carry out, but the young lady who took my order was very nice, I didn't ask, but she brought me a glass of water while I waited and that always gets points. She knew the menu well when I was deciding on my order and possible future orders. I will be back to dine in for sure.
(4)Kristen P.
Phenom eats, seriously! The service is amazing, our favorite server is Anna. She's always there to greet us with a big, family-sized smile and makes sure that everyone is receiving equal care (never sits on her rump, just making sure that everyone is getting the best service!) The food, now THERE is something to BRAG about! My favorite thing to eat so far is the White Eggplant Pizza. This gastronomical concept is so far out of my comfort zone, I didn't know if I was married to an Italian long enough, Glory Be! 13 Years and I was eating eggplant like a pro!. I'm here to tell you it is THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD! We're attempting to hit everything on the menu, so far we've dabbled with Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parmesan, Lasagna, Bruschetta, Baked Ziti, Stuffed Shells, and meatballs and every single thing has been extraordinary in flavor and quality! We have never been disappointed. Try this place, your taste buds will thank you! Oh and don't forget to sign up for the loyalty program, those points add up QUICKLY! Ignore those people that have left unsavory comments. Look at those accounts, one of them ONLY seems to YELP negative reviews and use foul language, really? Do you trust that kind of poppycock, I don't, I let the Cannoli cream talk for themselves?)
(5)Cat K.
We moved from NYC 3.5 years ago and could not find authentic pizza, not to mention cannolis. I found Brooklyn Vs on here (yelp) and due to the great reviews decided to try.... YUM YUM YUM. We had the white eggplant pizza, margherita pizza and garlic knots ALL DELICIOUS. As we were getting ready to leave Vito the owner came over and said hello. We told him we could not find good cannolis anywhere, even though we had paid our bill he brought us a few cannolis for us to try... How thoughtful! We will definitely be back to try other things on the menu
(5)Jay J.
Great pizza and great place to bring a group Came here after church had 2 14" pizzas the 3 v's meat pizza and a all cheese Bianca pizza both were great we also had some garlic knots for starters very cheap and very good Loved the setting and the staff, nice open kitchen so you can watch your pizza an food being made The Owner coming and welcoming us and checking on our food was a nice touch too Will definitely be coming back
(5)Janelle R.
Love this place. I've been three times, once for pizza, then penne in vodka sauce, and most recently spaghetti with meat sauce. Absolutely everything is made fresh and I can taste every bit of it! The sauces are fantastic. Next time I'm trying the pesto. I don't even like pesto, but that's how much I enjoy the food here. The service is great too. Very friendly and warm staff. Feels like home.
(5)Robert J.
First time ordering. We had a pizza (half V's 3 meat/half bianco) wings and garlic knots and everything was really good. We will order again for sure!
(5)Shanna G.
Yummy yummy so yummy I love this place. Being from New York, I'm a total pizza snob. I just happened on this place when I was getting my nails done one day and it blew my mind. Reminds me of home. I want to try other menu items but the pizza is just too good to not eat.
(5)Darius L.
Very Tasty. Way way better than Casa Nova Brothers!!!! Yuk. Guys Keep up the good work. I'll keep coming back if you stay consistent. A little tucked back had to drive around to find you, but pleased I didn't give up the search. If you guys are from New York bring more of that NY goodness out here. Very Very good.!!!!
(4)Sara S.
All I can can say is wow! This is my first time ordering from here and I ordered via grubhub and after reading reviews on yelp I thought my food would be ridiculously late. Turns out it was 20 minutes early! I ordered the stuffed shells, caprese salad and 2 meatballs. It came with 4 stuffed shells which in and of itself a hearty meal. The caprese salad was not terrible but would have liked to seen riper tomatoes and a tad more salt. The meatballs tasted like they had worshester sauce which is totally not necessary but the sauce they were in was yummy. Back to the shells, everything about it was great! My food arrived piping hot and early! Also their mix of Dr Pepper was on point tonight! I will definitely be ordering from here again!
(5)Matt B.
There have been a few pizza places in this suite over the years, I tried them all but never went back after trying them out once or twice (and I live pretty much right across the street). Love the food here, owners and servers are very nice and bend over backwards to give you what you want. I've brought friends here and they've enjoyed the food and atmosphere as well!!!
(5)Sara O.
We LOVE Brooklyn V's. We come here at least once a week. The food is amazing and the service is great. They have added some new girls so be patient, the food is worth the wait anyway. We pretty much have the menu memorized and I haven't eaten anything I haven't liked yet. They are also apart of a great rewards program where you can build up points and earn free food!
(5)Kristine R.
Delicious! We moved from NYC 2 1/2 years ago and have been to many pizzerias where we have been told it's just like NY pizza and each have fallen short. My husband found this place on Yelp and OMG this is it. Cheese pizza reminds us of back home. We went back today with his brother and family and we ate and ate and ate. Cheese pizza, V3 pizza, eggplant pizza and the bianco pizza--- yum yum yum! The mini zeppolis and cannolis are delish. We are definitely going back to try the calzones and pasta dishes. It's a 20 min drive from home and so worth it.
(5)Heidi H.
Best eggplant Parmesan by far! We've tried the gambit of eggplant parm at other Italian restaurants here in the valley and nothing compares to Brooklyn Vs!!
(4)Thomas G.
The garlic knots are to die for and the eggplant pizza is freaking amazing. The owners Bob and Vito go out of their way to make you feel welcome and these guys do a ton of fundraisers to give back to their local community.
(5)Julie F.
Not a bad place to get take out from. If you are looking for real NY pizza and pasta this is the place for you!
(3)Kelly G.
Just stumbled upon this place and so happy I did! The pizza was delicious! The atmosphere was family friendly and the place was very clean. I look forward to trying more things on the menu!
(4)Marissa D.
Absolutely delicious. I couldn't stop eating! I was so full yet it was just so good. Found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try. We are pretty faithful to our regular pizza place but I am so glad we tried this place. My husband and I ordered the stuffed shells and a pepperoni pizza to share. The stuffed shells were definitely some of the best I've ever had! Everything about the food was good. We ordered over Yelp and picked it up with no problems. Definitely will be coming back often.
(5)Kelly V.
This place is incredible - GREAT food, great service - we will definitely be back!
(5)Steve B.
Got takeout on Saturday Night (9/27). It was our first time ordering from them, so we decided to order a cheese pizza. In my opinion, the true litmus test for any pizza is getting the pizza in it 's purest form, plain cheese. Well, Brooklyn V's passed this test with flying colors. The sauce had great flavor and the crust had the right amount of crispness and chewiness. We strive to support only locally owned restaurants, not chains. I love that this place is 2 minutes from our house. We'll be back!
(5)Nawaf H.
Seriously!!! I mean this place got 4.5 stars ! Worst pizza i ever tried , nothing special at all , i ordered for home delivery and got my order after 75 minutes cold , the the pizza tastes horrible . First time and never again
(1)Wilfredo A.
Great service, great pizza, but excellent pasta. It's a weekly tradition for me and my family to grab a meal from here whether it's to go or dinning in. Please don't pass on the knots, spaghetti, baked ziti, wings, or the old classic pepperoni pizza. For those who like a different ambiance make a trip out on Friday or Saturday night. Live music!!! Need I say more???
(5)Cory D.
Tale of two restaurants. Last week we ordered from Brooklyn V 's and it was fantastic all around, we ordered in the afternoon. Tonight we ordered and it was completely opposite so greesy we could not even finish it, we also ordered wings and they were less then average too. Super disappointed especially after our first experience. Way over priced for the quality and lack of attention to detail.
(2)Cody M.
Our party of 4 ordered the chicken fettuccine alfredo, spaghetti with meat sauce along with a large pizza. Everything was great. I get fettuccine just about everywhere I go and theirs was some of the best. Pizza had a great thin and crispy crust. Great stuff.
(5)Steve C.
New York style thin crust....not even close!! They claim if it's under a 1/2 inch, that's New York style thin crust. And it's chewy! It should be a 1/4 inch and crispy....nice try guys, but no thanks. The sauce is too sweet, I think they are trying to cover up the lack of knowledge on how to make a New York style thin crust.
(1)Noelle K.
OMG! THIS IS THE PLACE for an authentic NY Italian meal!!!! My man decided on a whim that I was going to try a new place after he had tried it for lunch. He said he couldn't wait to take me to Brooklyn V's. I am a very picky eater and I am not a fan of chains so I was really happy to support a small business that really knows its business! We started with these little bread things they call garlic knots that come with marinara YUM! This was starting out fantastic. You can tell a lot from the marinara, ya know ;) We each ordered a Stromboli and they were to die for! I could have cut it lengthwise and just crawled in, they do kinda look like sleeping bags. You know when you taste something so good the world just kinda stops spinning? Yeah......Oh sorry! We took a tiramisu home to split for later. The waitress said it was heaven in a box. I haven't had too much luck with tiramisu here in AZ so I wasn't too excited. A couple hours later her words were still echoing in my head and I just had to taste it. Fireworks shot off! The band started playing and suddenly I was in Italy! Reluctantly I put the other half (well almost half, he he) back in the fridge for my man. The liquor license is coming folks!
(5)Danny A.
This is the real deal.Born and raised ny'er here and this is as good as it gets in the east valley.Now if they sold slices over the counter without the wait service,and Sicilian pies,it'd be like I was back home.Forget Casanova,they would be closed down in 6 months if they were back east.No comparison.
(5)Jim W.
A very Friendly staff. Everything tasted scratch made. From the Fresh cut romaine, cherry tomatoes, the touch of black olive slices and a bit of red onion in the house salad, to the DELICIOUS chicken fettuccine Alfredo. I've never had so much tasty Alfredo sauce in one bowl of fresh made pasta. The bread that came with the meal was melt in your mouth, just out of the oven, fresh baked too. This cozy family place is one you should try.
(5)Kimberly C.
Visited last night for dinner with friends. Our party of 4 split a large 18" pepperoni pizza and an order of 12 garlic knots. The food was EXCELLENT! I think the dough/crust MAKES the pizza and Brooklyn V's has it down pat. This space has been occupied by a few pizza joints since I've lived in the area and I've never been too impressed - but I'll definitely be back to Brooklyn V's. Other +'s: *Cannoli's - Very good! *Iced Tea - Fresh! *Friendly staff *Nice family/owners that took the time to say hello and welcome us to their establishment.
(5)Reco J.
Let me tell you something and you would be wise to listen!! Since I moved to AZ I have searched for real good back east Italian food that did not require me to drive and sit down at a table. Brooklyn V's is a Blessing, I love there eggplant, and pizza and OMG! The cannoli is straight off the boat. Plus I can order online and it gets to my house in less than 20 mins and hot. Thank you for being you! Reco
(5)Kaitlyn S.
I arrived at this establishment on a Friday around 7:30pm. Overall I was pretty impressed with the food, in which me and a group had ordered a large white pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was excellent and is comparable to somewhere such as Gilbert Pizza. However, the down side to this restaurant is the service. Every time I have made a visit here I have waited quite a bit of time to receive r any service. Expect to wait and plan your time accordingly, inside is a little cramped but this place makes you feel at home.
(3)David F.
Great food, staff and atmosphere! We had our local lunch club here and it was great! I would recommend everyone to try the ziti as well as the pizza!
(5)Christina L.
Great food, great customer service. We are from NY and really are thrilled to have amazing pizza and cannoli in Gilbert! Will be back again for sure.
(5)Darlene c.
Can't eat pizza anywhere else now !!! Close my eyes and feel like in Brooklyn eating Bay Pizza by train in Sheepshead Bay.. and their sauce is delicious. ...and they leave the the bubbled pockets of dough and don't pop them like other places!! Cannoli's perfectly sweet, garlic knots w/fresh chopped garlic perfectly crisp on outside and yummy on inside!! This is my only place for Italian food now.. and owner is friendly as is waitstaff.. Enjoy the food every time I come here, it is worth the trip no matter how far..
(5)Kelly G.
I like to say that this is a hidden gem in Gilbert. I dont usually like Italian food but this was authentic and home grown. It was the best experience I have had and it was so cute and quaint. I could take my kids and they enjoyed it also. The owner is really friendly and good people.
(5)Joe A.
Very friendly restaurant, fast service and the food was absolutely fantastic. Had an ice cold beer to start, pizza was totally East coast and the ricotta shells with meat sauce. Bob served, Vito prepared and I wouldn't have known that if they weren't so friendly. I will be back!!
(5)Ray N.
Love this place. Love their food.As authentic to NY Italian as it gets here in Az. Very nice, cozy atmosphere with great service from our waitress Allora. We were a party of 12 last night and everyone was raving about their dishes. The cheese pizza here is superb : perfect crust, great sauce and just the right mix of cheese. Eggplant parm was the best I have had in years and their calzones are amazing. Cooked just right and everything blended well. My experience in Az with other restaurants trying to make Calzones has been so so with most just throwing the stuff in hoping it gels. The owner Vito has been doing this for 30 years and certainly brings that and more to this awesome place. My new favorite place in Gilbert.
(5)Gordon G.
We had Spaghetti and Meat Sauce and Zita. The Meat Sauce was one of the best we ever had. The music was "Sinatra/Martin" and it felt like we belonged. Great place to eat, food was excellent.
(5)Andy L.
Placed a rather simple pick up order-small pepperoni pizza. I was not told a price on the phone, I figured it would be in the 10 dollar range. Lesson learned, never assume anything! When i got there, I paid over 15$, which, I'm sorry is EXCESSIVE! They need to sprinkle gold or something on there to make it worth the money at that price. Either way, I paid since I did order it and figured if it was a really good pizza it was worth it. Needless to say I was further disappointed when I got home and started eating it-now, I don't have extremely high standards when it comes to pizza-I love dominos, pizza hut, you name it-but the sauce was bland and had no taste to it. I lived in Boston for many years and have visited NYC many times; believe me when I tell you, this place has nothing, and I mean NOTHING in common with NY pizza. I was disappointed and won't be back.
(1)Mike K.
We ordered 2 stromboli's, thinking we were getting NY style stromboli's, but what we got were 2 loaves of bread with a little bit of filling. For starters, ANY time I've ever ordered a stromboli, much less 2 of them, it has had to come out in a pizza box due to the size of them. But when 2 of them came out together fitting on ONE paper plate, I was already highly disappointed considering the $22 price tag. Once getting home and beginning to slice them up, the first 2 inches of the end was all bread, and as we started getting in through the rest of it, the crust of it was so think and breadlike, there was no room for filling. I've attached some photos to showcase the size and filling. Past all that, taste was only... ehh. The Eggplant parm stromboli was very bland and sausage and meatball stromboli was mediocre at best. I never leave bad feedback on these kinds of sites, but this one we felt needed to be addressed. Just know what you're getting when you order a "stromboli" there.
(1)Tami C.
Being from the East Coast, it is hard to find an authentic New York pizza in AZ. Brooklyn V's is FANTASTIC!!!! Takes me back home.... The crust is fantastic with just the right amount of cheese. We've been here several times but haven't ordered anything other than pizza yet. Based on the other reviews, trying the Stromboli next. Check this place out, you won't be sorry!
(5)Kristin H.
I got the lunch special, 2 slices and a soda for $5.75. I think it's a great deal and the pizza was delicious. I'm picky when it comes to my pizza crust and they didn't burn it which was great. Sometimes places that have thinner crust blacken their pizza before it comes to the table but it arrived hot and the perfect crispiness. This place is tucked away in a strip mall, but it doesn't take away from the great prices and good food.
(4)Dan A.
Just tried Brooklyn's based on Yelp reviews. Pizza is outstanding. Will definitely be back. Upon entering this place you can tell right away this is a family run establishment. Very genuinely friendly staff. I noticed the other patrons and there were smiles at every table. Next time, I'm going for the sausage and peppers hero. It looks amazingly delicious.
(4)Emily B.
We had some amazingly fresh bruschetta here as well as some very richly flavored lasagna, garlic knots and cannolis. We had excellent service and our server was very attentive. Additionally she and the other staff were so passionate about their food and the restaurant that it was contagious. We were truly blown away by this place! The food beat out some of the street crap I had in Rome over the summer!
(5)Annette A.
Finally found REAL NY style pizza in the East Valley! The pizza Margherita and Eggplant parmesan Hero were delicious! The owners were very friendly and made us feel very welcome. New Yorkers you gotta come here!
(5)Mike S.
I tried this place today, and I was impressed. I had the 2 pizza slice & drink lunch special. The margherita pizza was fantastic. The crust was thin & crispy, which I usually don't like because other pizzerias either make it too hard or too limp. This crust was incredible. They also have delivery service. I will not order chain pizza again.
(4)Hanna F.
Well, once again I tried it for chance. Still the rude son of a bitch New Yorkers with extremely high prices for the shit they serve. Let me tell you, GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT.
(1)Julie S.
So good!!! Real east coast Italiano!!! Some favorites - eggplant parm - very authentic, thinly sliced!! Ask for Desiree - awesome waitress with good recommendations.
(5)Anne J.
A most go to place!!! You can taste the freshness, you can tell they make the dough daily. Amazing
(5)Maria N.
Went to Brooklyn V's last night for dinner for the first time with my family. I was intrigued because they were from Staten Island so I figured they knew good pizza. It is hard to find a good "pie" out in AZ. The restaurant did not disappoint. We had the Margherita and the White Eggplant Pizza's. They we amazing. The dough was light and thin. The sauce was perfect. Not to thick and acidic. The eggplant pizza is a must. I can't wait to go back again and try the dinner selections. The staff was so friendly. It actually felt like a "family". Highly recommended. They deliver and cater also!
(5)Sue L.
Very good pizza, delivered on time! I ordered garlic knots because of someone else's recommendation. The dipping sauce is excellent. The knots need more garlic.
(4)Rachael W.
Pizza was average for New York style. Delivery was pretty quick but the pizza was cold and way over-priced. 25 dollars for one pizza is a little ridiculous.
(3)Vanessa J.
my husband and I visited here as a recommendation from our neighbor. Had the pizza the first time it was excellent. Took the family there for a second trip had the Stromboli and the shells. Food and service was again excellent. Waitress even gave our granddaughter her own special treat. Will definitely visit again
(4)Julie B.
Brooklyn V's opened 3 weeks ago and is having typical start-up issues with a new young staff. But, that's the only area that needs improvement! I wanted to try Brooklyn V's because as I was sitting at the stop light at Lindsey and Warner - the most wonderful pizza aroma drifted across the intersection. I told my husband, based on the aroma alone we needed to try this place. The FOOD IS WONDERFUL and definitely lived up to the tantalizing aroma! We ordered house salads and the Sausage and Pepper Stromboli. We didn't receive the Stromboli we ordered, however we kept the dish brought because the crust was so crispy and light, the cheese was perfectly stringy and gooey, and the combination of meats inside tender and tasty. Paired with their marinara sauce, we couldn't send it back - it was that good! One of the owners stopped by to check on our dinner. When we let her know what happened, she "comped" us Cannolis for dessert. The plate was chilled and the presentation was something I would have expected from a more upper end restaurant. We are so glad to have Brooklyn V's in our neighborhood and within walking distance! We'll be returning again and again to try the other items on the menu - which we expect will be equally flavorful.
(4)Joyce S.
Very low key, but nice server, great food (huge portions) and just satisfied my pasta craving. Only wish they had beer.......
(3)