Awesome pizza, just awesome pizza! It's in the sauce!
(5)
Steve P.
I love pizza and sometimes I just want to try something different. Some friends of ours introduced us to Romeo's a couple of years ago and I remembered enjoying. So my family and I were driving down Hamilton Rd. recently and thinking about pizza. There are plenty of options in the Gahanna/New Albany area, but we settled on Romeo's and I'm sure glad we did. I called to order and the manager gave me several choices of sauce that I could have on my pizza. Good news already - variety! Since my family prefers cheese pizza, we decided to vary it up on sauce. We ordered two large cheese pizzas - one with zesty marinara and one with their "regular" which is a sweet sauce. The zesty marina was decent and taste like tomato-y sauce, more of a non-processed or homemade feel to it. So if you like that sort of thing, this is your sauce. I thought this sauce was decent. The "regular" sauce was GREAT. Sweet and delicious, it really hit the spot for my pizza craving. My wife and I both decided that is the sauce we will order again and we will be ordering again! When I called, I asked if they have cheesy garlic bread and maybe the manager misunderstood me, but he described a sub bun type of bread that they bake cheese over top of, which is not what I was looking for. We didn't order any for that reason. However, I was given an advertisement when I picked up my pizza and a cheese bread (like a pizza with garlic butter instead of sauce) was described. THAT's what I was looking for, so I will be ordering that next time to go with my pizza. The manager was really nice when I picked up my pizza. I told him I had never been in before and was willing to answer all of my questions. He even told me to check out the Maxtown Rd. location when I'm up that way (because I live equidistant from both locations) Definitely recommended if you're looking for good traditional pizza. Nothing fancy here, just all the right stuff!
(4)
Danielle A.
Romeo's has become my new favorite since discovering them at Slice of Columbus last summer. The sauce is sweeter than others, but I find it delicious. I've never tried their specialty pizzas. I always either top my pies with pepperoni or olives and banana peppers. The only thing I recommend that you avoid is the mushrooms. They taste ok but look like they come from a can ( and we eat with our eyes before our mouths). The service has been fast and friendly every time I've ordered. Because this location is in a plaza, parking is a breeze. As already mentioned by others, they have a limited delivery area, so be prepared for pick up. I will be back--probably on Friday.
(4)
Lani B.
5 stars for the excellent delivery service. 4 stars for the pizza. Really good pizza. If you want spicy sauce, this is not the place for you. I am from Cali and this is not like my beloved Round Table Pizza. But, I highly recommend it. The sauce is sweet and gooey. Lots of great varieties of pizza on the menu.
(5)
John A.
The description makes no culinary sense to me, but The Great Ranch & Potato pizza is unique and addictive. I don't particularly like sausage, I don't think of potatoes as a pizza ingredient, and I much prefer tomato based sauce. Yet this concoction has to be tried to be believed. I sampled it at Slice of Columbus last year and have been hooked. The others we have tried from Romeos have not been special, but do yourself a favor and try The Great Ranch and Potato pizza.
(4)
Lenny H.
The pizza is good, but the prices are too high and the customer service standard is too low. If I'm paying $18 bucks for a pizza, the least you could do would be courteous. We've ordered from this location several times in the past, and I get the sense that they think they're doing me a favor. One time we called and asked if there were any specials (no) and receive on the box lid, a coupon for what we just ordered. We would have saved 3 or 4 dollars. Most pizza places have specials on multi-topping pies. I'm not interested in the a-hole attitude or the high prices. I like the pizza, but not enough to deal with the rest of the "experience." I'll pass or head to Jet's down the street. I'm sure other locations are fine
(1)
David M.
I can't figure out what everyone likes about their Pizza. No better than Papa John's. And actually I guess I'd have to say Papa John's is better.
(2)
Brian S.
For our first pizza from Romeo's Pizza, we got the basic large pepperoni, typical crust with their Original Pizza sauce. Overall, the pizza wasn't that bad, not the greatest pizza I have ever eaten, but not certainly the worse. The crust seemed pretty similar to Fox's Pizza Den or what Dominos was many years ago. The thing that stood out to the most is that the sauce was extremely sweet, more than any other pie I could remember. Seemed very similar to Pizza Cottage's sauce and really isn't my cup o tea. I will certainly try them again, maybe trying one of their other pizza sauces that are avalaible.
(3)
Casey B.
Sauce is way too sweet. Crust was overlooked and prices were too high. Don't think we will get again.
(2)
becca p.
My latest pizza obsession, it is simply AMAZING! The sauce is sweet and different from your typical pizza. Definitely a must try!
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : Yes Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Outdoor Seating : No Has TV : No Waiter Service : No
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
Patrick R.
Awesome pizza, just awesome pizza! It's in the sauce!
(5)Steve P.
I love pizza and sometimes I just want to try something different. Some friends of ours introduced us to Romeo's a couple of years ago and I remembered enjoying. So my family and I were driving down Hamilton Rd. recently and thinking about pizza. There are plenty of options in the Gahanna/New Albany area, but we settled on Romeo's and I'm sure glad we did. I called to order and the manager gave me several choices of sauce that I could have on my pizza. Good news already - variety! Since my family prefers cheese pizza, we decided to vary it up on sauce. We ordered two large cheese pizzas - one with zesty marinara and one with their "regular" which is a sweet sauce. The zesty marina was decent and taste like tomato-y sauce, more of a non-processed or homemade feel to it. So if you like that sort of thing, this is your sauce. I thought this sauce was decent. The "regular" sauce was GREAT. Sweet and delicious, it really hit the spot for my pizza craving. My wife and I both decided that is the sauce we will order again and we will be ordering again! When I called, I asked if they have cheesy garlic bread and maybe the manager misunderstood me, but he described a sub bun type of bread that they bake cheese over top of, which is not what I was looking for. We didn't order any for that reason. However, I was given an advertisement when I picked up my pizza and a cheese bread (like a pizza with garlic butter instead of sauce) was described. THAT's what I was looking for, so I will be ordering that next time to go with my pizza. The manager was really nice when I picked up my pizza. I told him I had never been in before and was willing to answer all of my questions. He even told me to check out the Maxtown Rd. location when I'm up that way (because I live equidistant from both locations) Definitely recommended if you're looking for good traditional pizza. Nothing fancy here, just all the right stuff!
(4)Danielle A.
Romeo's has become my new favorite since discovering them at Slice of Columbus last summer. The sauce is sweeter than others, but I find it delicious. I've never tried their specialty pizzas. I always either top my pies with pepperoni or olives and banana peppers. The only thing I recommend that you avoid is the mushrooms. They taste ok but look like they come from a can ( and we eat with our eyes before our mouths). The service has been fast and friendly every time I've ordered. Because this location is in a plaza, parking is a breeze. As already mentioned by others, they have a limited delivery area, so be prepared for pick up. I will be back--probably on Friday.
(4)Lani B.
5 stars for the excellent delivery service. 4 stars for the pizza. Really good pizza. If you want spicy sauce, this is not the place for you. I am from Cali and this is not like my beloved Round Table Pizza. But, I highly recommend it. The sauce is sweet and gooey. Lots of great varieties of pizza on the menu.
(5)John A.
The description makes no culinary sense to me, but The Great Ranch & Potato pizza is unique and addictive. I don't particularly like sausage, I don't think of potatoes as a pizza ingredient, and I much prefer tomato based sauce. Yet this concoction has to be tried to be believed. I sampled it at Slice of Columbus last year and have been hooked. The others we have tried from Romeos have not been special, but do yourself a favor and try The Great Ranch and Potato pizza.
(4)Lenny H.
The pizza is good, but the prices are too high and the customer service standard is too low. If I'm paying $18 bucks for a pizza, the least you could do would be courteous. We've ordered from this location several times in the past, and I get the sense that they think they're doing me a favor. One time we called and asked if there were any specials (no) and receive on the box lid, a coupon for what we just ordered. We would have saved 3 or 4 dollars. Most pizza places have specials on multi-topping pies. I'm not interested in the a-hole attitude or the high prices. I like the pizza, but not enough to deal with the rest of the "experience." I'll pass or head to Jet's down the street. I'm sure other locations are fine
(1)David M.
I can't figure out what everyone likes about their Pizza. No better than Papa John's. And actually I guess I'd have to say Papa John's is better.
(2)Brian S.
For our first pizza from Romeo's Pizza, we got the basic large pepperoni, typical crust with their Original Pizza sauce. Overall, the pizza wasn't that bad, not the greatest pizza I have ever eaten, but not certainly the worse. The crust seemed pretty similar to Fox's Pizza Den or what Dominos was many years ago. The thing that stood out to the most is that the sauce was extremely sweet, more than any other pie I could remember. Seemed very similar to Pizza Cottage's sauce and really isn't my cup o tea. I will certainly try them again, maybe trying one of their other pizza sauces that are avalaible.
(3)Casey B.
Sauce is way too sweet. Crust was overlooked and prices were too high. Don't think we will get again.
(2)becca p.
My latest pizza obsession, it is simply AMAZING! The sauce is sweet and different from your typical pizza. Definitely a must try!
(5)Joe L.
did not like AT ALL
(1)